OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

Who holds what power

Council, mayor and city manager in Twin Falls: who can do what, and what binds them

Twin Falls has a council-manager government. Voters elect the council. The council picks a mayor from among its own members and hires a city manager to run the City day to day. This page sets out what each office may do, which laws and policies bind it, and the exceptions the records show.

The short version

  • The council decides. It passes ordinances and the budget, sets policy, and hires and can remove the city manager.Idaho Code § 50-811
    Open source · All sources
    It can act only in a properly noticed open meeting.Idaho Code § 74-203
    Open source · All sources
  • The mayor presides. The mayor is a council member chosen by the council.Idaho Code § 50-809
    Open source · All sources
    The mayor runs meetings and votes, but has no veto and no administrative powers.Idaho Code § 50-810
    Open source · All sources
  • The city manager runs the City. The manager is the administrative head of city government, serves at the pleasure of a council majority, and carries out the council's ordinances and policies.Idaho Code § 50-811
    Open source · All sources
  • Everyone is bound by state law. City ordinances, resolutions and policies can't conflict with state law. Where they do, state law controls.Idaho Constitution, Article XII, Section 2: local regulations must not conflict with general law
    Open source · All sources
    Idaho Code § 50-302
    Open source · All sources
  • The City Code says the same. The City's own ordinances repeat these limits: the council works through the manager, and the mayor has no administrative powers.Twin Falls City Code 1-2-3: City manager (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)
    Open source · All sources
    Twin Falls City Code 1-2-1: Mayor (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)
    Open source · All sources
    The code is published online, current through Ordinance 2026-007 (June 22, 2026).Twin Falls City Code, published online by American Legal Publishing for the City (current through Ord. 2026-007, June 22, 2026)
    Open source · All sources

City council

What it can do

  • Exercise the City's powers under state law: ordinances and resolutions,Idaho Code § 50-302
    Open source · All sources
    and the budget and appropriations.Idaho Code § 50-1002
    Open source · All sources
  • Appoint the city manager, and remove the manager by majority vote at any time.Idaho Code § 50-811
    Open source · All sources
    Confirm the manager's appointments of department heads.Idaho Code § 50-808
    Open source · All sources
    The City Code lists them: the deputy city managers, chief financial officer, police chief, fire chief, city engineer, public works director, economic development director (added in 2022) and human resource director.Twin Falls City Code 1-2-4: Department heads (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015; amd. Ord. 2022-013, 7-18-2022)
    Open source · All sources
    Finding E-28: A former council member's hire as Economic Development Director was handled in public; his HR records list a 2012 hire date
    Open source · All sources
  • Set the city manager's pay and terms by contract. Twin Falls' agreements say changes must be in writing and signed by the parties, and that the City's personnel rules apply to the manager unless the agreement says otherwise.EX-A12: City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed) (secs. 2, 8)
    Open source · All sources
  • Approve payments to vendors. The Financial Policies reserve this to the council; the mayor may approve time-sensitive payments only when the council has specifically authorized it.City of Twin Falls Citywide Financial Policies (tfid.org)
    Open source · All sources

What binds it

  • Open meetings.
    • Decisions happen only in meetings that are noticed in advance, with an agenda that marks action items, and minutes are kept.Idaho Code § 74-204
      Open source · All sources
      Idaho Code § 74-205
      Open source · All sources
    • Since July 1, 2026, anyone attending may record an open meeting.House Bill 894 (2026): the public may record open meetings; effective July 1, 2026
      Open source · All sources
  • Executive sessions are closed discussions, allowed only for specific listed reasons, and no final action may be taken in one.Idaho Code § 74-206
    Open source · All sources
  • Committees count too. A committee the council creates with authority to decide or recommend is itself a governing body. It needs notice, open meetings and minutes.EX-D02: Idaho AG Open Meeting Law Manual (Questions 3-4)
    Open source · All sources
  • Hands off administration. Council members deal with City administration only through the city manager, except to ask questions. Neither the council nor any member "shall give orders to any subordinates of the city manager."Twin Falls City Code 1-2-3: City manager (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)
    Open source · All sources
  • Conflicts of interest. A member must disclose a conflict before taking official action on the matter.Idaho Code § 74-404
    Open source · All sources
    A conflict includes a private financial benefit to a business the member is associated with.Idaho Code § 74-403
    Open source · All sources

Mayor

  • Chosen by the council from its own members after each election, for a two-year term.Idaho Code § 50-809
    Open source · All sources
  • Presides and votes on everything before the council, but has no veto.Idaho Code § 50-810
    Open source · All sources
    The mayor's other duties are only those the council assigns.Twin Falls City Code 1-2-1: Mayor (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)
    Open source · All sources
  • Ceremonial head of the City. The mayor may sign contracts and legal papers by title, but state law and the City Code both say that signature does not give the mayor administrative powers.Idaho Code § 50-810
    Open source · All sources
    Twin Falls City Code 1-2-1: Mayor (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)
    Open source · All sources
    Administrative powers belong to the city manager.Idaho Code § 50-811
    Open source · All sources
  • Payments. The mayor may approve time-sensitive payments only when the council has specifically authorized it.City of Twin Falls Citywide Financial Policies (tfid.org)
    Open source · All sources

City manager

What the manager can do

  • Generally supervise the City's business, and see that its ordinances and policies are "complied with and faithfully executed."Idaho Code § 50-811
    Open source · All sources
  • Appoint department heads (the council confirms them) and prepare the tentative budget.Idaho Code § 50-811
    Open source · All sources
    Idaho Code § 50-808
    Open source · All sources
    The City describes the manager as its chief administrative officer, "responsible to the Twin Falls City Council."City of Twin Falls, City Manager Department page (tfid.org)
    Open source · All sources
  • Emergency powers. Since 2020 the City Code lets the manager issue public health emergency orders, most of them only with a council vote. During such an emergency the manager may also suspend non-essential services and "waive such internal rules, regulations and procedures as deemed necessary to protect the health and welfare of City employees." A council majority can override anything the manager does under these powers.Twin Falls City Code 1-5-5: Public health emergency orders (Ord. 2020-007, 4-6-2020)
    Open source · All sources
    Twin Falls City Code 1-5-8: Suspension and waiver of certain city services, ordinances, and policies and procedures (Ord. 2020-007, 4-6-2020)
    Open source · All sources
    Twin Falls City Code 1-5-6: Process for enacting public health emergency orders (Ord. 2020-007, 4-6-2020) (subsection D)
    Open source · All sources
  • Set employee rules. In 2018 the council repealed the resolution that set personnel rules and authorized the city manager to implement an employee handbook.EX-B05: 2018-10-29 minutes - Resolution 2018-012 (handbook delegated to City Manager)
    Open source · All sources
    Finding E-10: Handbook changes were delegated to the City Manager in 2018 (explains the 160->200 hr cap change)
    Open source · All sources
    Since 2021 the handbook says no one but the city manager may make special arrangements on terms of employment.Finding E-10: Handbook changes were delegated to the City Manager in 2018 (explains the 160->200 hr cap change)
    Open source · All sources

What binds the manager

  • The council's ordinances, budget and policies, which the manager must carry out.Idaho Code § 50-811
    Open source · All sources
    Spending can't exceed what the council appropriated without the manager's recommendation and council action. Adding positions beyond the approved count, or using fund balance, needs a council vote.City of Twin Falls Citywide Financial Policies (tfid.org)
    Open source · All sources
  • The manager's own contract.
    • Changes must be in writing and signed by the parties.EX-A12: City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed) (sec. 2)
      Open source · All sources
    • Salary adjustments are tied to the budget process.EX-A12: City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed) (sec. 3)
      Open source · All sources
    • The City's personnel rules apply to the manager unless the agreement says otherwise.EX-A12: City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed) (sec. 8)
      Open source · All sources
  • No personal benefit from public funds without specific authorization. State law bars any public servant from using public funds or property for personal financial benefit unless the governmental entity specifically authorizes it.Idaho Code § 18-1359
    Open source · All sources
  • Conflicts of interest apply to the manager the same as to council members.Idaho Code § 74-404
    Open source · All sources

Where the records show the rules were bent

Each row sets the rule beside what the records show. The finding behind each row explains the evidence and its limits.

The ruleWhat the records show
Employees may sell back at most 40 hours of vacation a year, and the City Manager's contract can be changed only in writing signed by the parties.Finding E-01: Mayor's letter lifted the vacation sell-back cap for the City Manager; no Council vote located
Open source · All sources
A letter signed by the mayor alone lifted the cap for the City Manager. No council vote appears, and four 100-hour sales followed.Finding E-01: Mayor's letter lifted the vacation sell-back cap for the City Manager; no Council vote located
Open source · All sources
EX-A01: 2022-12-08 Mayor letter lifting City Manager sell-back limit, with HR emails
Open source · All sources
The mayor has no administrative powers under state law.Idaho Code § 50-810
Open source · All sources
No council member may give orders to the city manager's staff.Twin Falls City Code 1-2-3: City manager (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)
Open source · All sources
The mayor's pay letters to the City Manager in 2022 and 2025 say, "I am directing the Human Resources staff to make the following compensation adjustments."EX-A07: Compensation memo, fiscal year 2023
Open source · All sources
EX-A09: 2025 compensation letter signed by the Mayor
Open source · All sources
Finding E-03: City Manager raises 2016-2025: all but one set outside any located open-session vote
Open source · All sources
Contract changes in writing, signed by the parties.EX-A12: City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed) (sec. 2)
Open source · All sources
Pay changes were made by single-signature letters.Finding E-07: Pay changes made by letters signed by one person, not the signed amendment the agreement requires
Open source · All sources
Employer deferred compensation was added by email years before it appeared in a council-approved document.Finding E-04: Employer retirement and deferred compensation paid before it appears in any Council-approved document
Open source · All sources
Committees with authority must meet openly, with notice and minutes.EX-D02: Idaho AG Open Meeting Law Manual (Questions 3-4)
Open source · All sources
The council created a City Manager evaluation committee once, in 2014, with three members. All three had left the council by January 2022. Later pay letters cite "the performance review committee," and no later vote, membership or minutes for it appear.Finding E-06: The "performance review committee" was publicly created once (2014) and never again
Open source · All sources
EX-B01: 2014-09-02 minutes - Council creates City Manager evaluation committee (excerpt)
Open source · All sources
The council acts only by vote in an open meeting.Idaho Code § 74-203
Open source · All sources
A $2,500 stipend was described as council-authorized. No vote appears in the minutes before it was paid.Finding E-08: $2,500 Deputy City Manager stipend described as Council-authorized; no vote located
Open source · All sources
Disclose a conflict before acting.Idaho Code § 74-404
Open source · All sources
The City Manager co-proposed the retention program and later enrolled in it.Finding E-09: The City Manager took part in the Council-approved Employee Retention Program and the citywide one-time payouts, as his agreement extends employee benefits to him (context)
Open source · All sources
A council member disclosed doing accounting for a contractor once, then acted on its items without a recorded recusal.Finding E-25: Mayor (later Council Member) Pierce acted on seven Suburban Construction items after stating on the record that she does accounting for the firm; no later recusal or disclosure is recorded
Open source · All sources
Agenda items added during a meeting need a motion stating the good-faith reason they weren't on the posted agenda (current law).Idaho Code § 74-204
Open source · All sources
An evaluation session was added mid-meeting at the City Manager's request, with no reason recorded.Finding E-17: Closed sessions added to the agenda after the meeting began, at the City Manager's request, with no reason recorded (three times in 2017)
Open source · All sources

"No vote appears" means none appears in the records we hold. If a record shows otherwise, we'll correct this page.

Sources

Numbers in the text open a note with a link. State law links go to the official text, which always shows the law currently in force.

  1. Idaho Code § 50-811
  2. Idaho Code § 74-203
  3. Idaho Code § 50-809
  4. Idaho Code § 50-810
  5. Idaho Constitution, Article XII, Section 2: local regulations must not conflict with general law
  6. Idaho Code § 50-302
  7. Twin Falls City Code 1-2-3: City manager (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)
  8. Twin Falls City Code 1-2-1: Mayor (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015)
  9. Twin Falls City Code, published online by American Legal Publishing for the City (current through Ord. 2026-007, June 22, 2026)
  10. Idaho Code § 50-1002
  11. Idaho Code § 50-808
  12. Twin Falls City Code 1-2-4: Department heads (Ord. 3106, 10-5-2015; amd. Ord. 2022-013, 7-18-2022)
  13. Finding E-28: A former council member's hire as Economic Development Director was handled in public; his HR records list a 2012 hire date
  14. EX-A12: City Manager Service Agreement, 2024 (signed)
  15. City of Twin Falls Citywide Financial Policies (tfid.org)
  16. Idaho Code § 74-204
  17. Idaho Code § 74-205
  18. House Bill 894 (2026): the public may record open meetings; effective July 1, 2026
  19. Idaho Code § 74-206
  20. EX-D02: Idaho AG Open Meeting Law Manual
  21. Idaho Code § 74-404
  22. Idaho Code § 74-403
  23. City of Twin Falls, City Manager Department page (tfid.org)
  24. Twin Falls City Code 1-5-5: Public health emergency orders (Ord. 2020-007, 4-6-2020)
  25. Twin Falls City Code 1-5-8: Suspension and waiver of certain city services, ordinances, and policies and procedures (Ord. 2020-007, 4-6-2020)
  26. Twin Falls City Code 1-5-6: Process for enacting public health emergency orders (Ord. 2020-007, 4-6-2020)
  27. EX-B05: 2018-10-29 minutes - Resolution 2018-012 (handbook delegated to City Manager)
  28. Finding E-10: Handbook changes were delegated to the City Manager in 2018 (explains the 160->200 hr cap change)
  29. Idaho Code § 18-1359
  30. Finding E-01: Mayor's letter lifted the vacation sell-back cap for the City Manager; no Council vote located
  31. EX-A01: 2022-12-08 Mayor letter lifting City Manager sell-back limit, with HR emails
  32. EX-A07: Compensation memo, fiscal year 2023
  33. EX-A09: 2025 compensation letter signed by the Mayor
  34. Finding E-03: City Manager raises 2016-2025: all but one set outside any located open-session vote
  35. Finding E-07: Pay changes made by letters signed by one person, not the signed amendment the agreement requires
  36. Finding E-04: Employer retirement and deferred compensation paid before it appears in any Council-approved document
  37. Finding E-06: The "performance review committee" was publicly created once (2014) and never again
  38. EX-B01: 2014-09-02 minutes - Council creates City Manager evaluation committee (excerpt)
  39. Finding E-08: $2,500 Deputy City Manager stipend described as Council-authorized; no vote located
  40. Finding E-09: The City Manager took part in the Council-approved Employee Retention Program and the citywide one-time payouts, as his agreement extends employee benefits to him (context)
  41. Finding E-25: Mayor (later Council Member) Pierce acted on seven Suburban Construction items after stating on the record that she does accounting for the firm; no later recusal or disclosure is recorded
  42. Finding E-17: Closed sessions added to the agenda after the meeting began, at the City Manager's request, with no reason recorded (three times in 2017)