OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

EX-D02

Idaho AG Open Meeting Law Manual

City of Twin Falls

View the document here · 44 pages

Record date
Not dated
Source
Public (Idaho AG)
Record type
State Law and Attorney General Manuals
Pages used
all (44)
Supports findings
Reference material

Chain of custody

  1. Obtained. Published by the Idaho Attorney General at ag.idaho.gov.
  2. As received. SHA-256 of the file exactly as the agency released it:
    d41729e7eb2725151e7f50a4c02eeec86a398ba3abb7a9e20da3ac8cf9cfe046
  3. Changes for posting.
    • Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed
  4. Posted copy. SHA-256 of the file you download here, checked against our index on every build:
    6bf4bbb42dc1dd102bf359e5d243de8304aec2df18f904edf3aadc7ff39fd27a

The original as received is kept unaltered. Anyone holding the agency's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. How to verify a file · Chain of custody for every record (CSV)

Document text (read by machine for search, and often imperfect for scans and handwriting; the file is the record)
Office of the 
Attorney General 
Idaho 
Open Meeting Law 
Manual 
Idaho Code §§ 74-201 through 74-208 
July 2026 
RAÚL R. LABRADOR 
Attorney General 
700 West Jefferson Street 
Boise, ID 83702 
www.ag.idaho.gov 
 

State of Idaho 
Office of Attorney General 
Raúl R. Labrador 
INTRODUCTION 
Open and honest government is fundamental to a free society. The 
Idaho Legislature formalized our state’s commitment to open government 
by enacting the Idaho Open Meeting Law in 1974. The Open Meeting 
Law cod ifies a simple , but fundamental , Idaho value: The public’s 
business ought to be done in public. 
One of my duties as Attorney General is to ensure that state agencies 
and officials comply with the Idaho Open Meeting Law. The 44 elected 
county prosecuting attorneys have the same duty with regard to agencies 
and officials of local government. 
My office is committed to assisting Idaho’s state and local officials in 
complying with their obligation under this law. Toward that end, my 
office regularly conducts training sessions for state and local officials 
throughout Idaho. 
The Office of the Attorney General has prepared this updated manual 
for your use and reference. Its purpose is to inform government agencies 
of their obligations, and citizens of their rights, under Idaho’s Open 
Meeting Law. 
Sincerely, 
RAÚL R. LABRADOR 
Attorney General 
 

Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
 
TABLE OF CONTENTS 
POLICY CONSIDERATIONS UNDERLYING THE OPEN 
MEETING LAW ................................................................................ 1 
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ............................................................ 2 
PUBLIC BODIES OR AGENCIES COVERED BY THE OPEN MEETING 
LAW ............................................................................................... 2 
CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS (501C(3)) AND HOMEOWNER’S 
ASSOCIATIONS ............................................................................... 5 
PUBLIC ACTIONS OR ACTIVITIES COVERED BY THE OPEN 
MEETING LAW ............................................................................... 6 
PROCEDURAL REQUIREMENTS OF THE OPEN MEETING LAW .............. 10 
SPECIFIC STATUTORY EXEMPTIONS: EXECUTIVE SESSIONS ............... 17 
PENALTIES FOR NONCOMPLIANCE ..................................................... 20 
THE STATUTE .....................................................................................23 
SUMMARY OF DECISIONS INTERPRETING THE IDAHO 
OPEN MEETING STATUTE ..........................................................33 
REPORTED DECISIONS ........................................................................ 33 
UNREPORTED DECISIONS ................................................................... 35 
ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE ANALYSES........................................ 35 
OPEN MEETING LAW CHECKLIST ..............................................36 
REGULAR MEETINGS .......................................................................... 36 
SPECIAL MEETINGS ............................................................................ 37 
EXECUTIVE SESSIONS ......................................................................... 38 
SAMPLE FORMS .................................................................................39 
EXECUTIVE SESSION MOTION AND ORDER ........................................ 39 
MOTION AND ORDER TO AMEND AGENDA ......................................... 40 
CURING PROCESS – IDAHO CODE § 74-208(7) ...........................41 
 
1 
POLICY CONSIDERATIONS UNDERLYING THE OPEN 
MEETING LAW 
The Idaho Open Meeting Law 1 was designed to ensure transparency 
of the legislative and administrative processes within state and local 
governments. The L egislature articulated this po licy in the Act’s first 
section: 
The people of the state of Idaho in creating the 
instruments of government that serve them, do not yield 
their sovereignty to the agencies so created. Therefore, 
the legislature finds and declares that it is the policy of 
this state that the formation of public policy is public 
business and shall not be conducted in secret.2 
Open meetings offer the public a chance to observe the way their 
government operates and to influence their government in positive and 
important ways. Closed meetings often can lead to distrust of 
governmental decisions and acts. 
Those who conduct meetings must remember this policy above all 
when deciding whether a meeting should be open. If a meeting is closed, 
there must be a compelling reason, supported by the statute itself, or by 
subsequent court rulings. 
Remember, when in doubt, open the meeting. 
 
 
1 Idaho Code §§ 74-201 to 74-208. 
2 Id. at § 74-201. 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
2 
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS 
PUBLIC BODIES OR AGENCIES COVERED BY THE OPEN 
MEETING LAW 
Question No. 1: What public bodies or agencies are subject to the 
Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: The Open Meeting Law provides: “ [A]ll meetings of a 
governing body of a public agency shall be open to the public and all 
persons shall be permitted to attend any meeting except as otherwise 
provided by this act. . . .”3 “Governing body” is defined to mean the 
members of any public agency “with the authority to make decisions 
for or recommendations to a public agency regarding any matter.” 4 
“Public agency” is defined to encompass various categories of 
governmental entities and subdivisions at all levels of government. 5 
The governing bodies of public agencies that are created by or 
pursuant to statute, as well as public agencies that are created by the 
Idaho Constitution, are subject to the Open Meeting Law. 6 The only 
public agencies that are statutorily exempt from the Open Meeting 
Law are the courts and their agencies and divisions, the judicial 
council and the district magistrates commission.7 Deliberations of the 
Board of Tax Appeals, the Public Utilities Commission and the 
Industrial Commission, in a fully submitted contested case 
proceeding, are also exempted from the requirement that they take 
place in an open public meeting.8 
Question No. 2: Does the Open Meeting Law apply to a public agency 
headed by a single individual as contrasted with a multi -member 
body? 
Answer: No. Section 74-202(5) defines a governing body to mean 
“the members of any public agency that consists of two (2) or more 
members, with the authority to make decisions for or 
recommendations to a public agency regarding any matter.” 
(Emphasis added.) By definition, the Open Meeting Law applies only 
to a governing body which consists of two or more members and thus 
 
3 Idaho Code § 74-203(1) (emphasis added). 
4 Idaho Code § 74-202(5). 
5 Idaho Code § 74-202(4). 
6 Attorney General Opinion No. 77-30, 1977 Idaho Att’y Gen. Ann. Rpt. 180. 
7 Idaho Code § 74-202(4)(a). 
8 Idaho Code § 74-203. 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
3 
does not apply to a public agency headed by a single individual. 
This also extends to employees of a public agency headed by a 
single individual; meetings held by employees of a department headed 
by a single individual (or multiple parties, for that matter) do not have 
to be open to the public. An illustrative example of this principle arose 
in the 2008 case of Safe Air For Everyone v. Idaho State Dep’t of 
Agriculture.9 There, the Idaho State Department of Agriculture 
(ISDA) invited representatives from federal, state, and tribal agencies 
to a meeting to discuss issues surrounding crop residue burning. The 
meeting was closed to the public. Several employees of the ISDA 
attended the meeting, but the director did not. 
An environmental group sued the ISDA, arguing that the 
employees’ participation in the meeting constituted a violation of the 
Open Meeting Law because the director had delegated decision -
making authority to the employees, thus making the employees a 
“governing body.” The Supreme Court disagreed, stating that: 
By definition, a ‘governing body’ [under the Act] 
must have ‘the authority to make decisions for or 
recommendations to a public agency regarding any 
matter.’ The employees do not have ‘the authority’ 
to make decisions for or recommendations to the 
ISDA. Any decision they make can be 
countermanded by a supervisor, and their 
supervisor can likewise deny them permission to 
make recommendations. . . . [ T]he authority to 
make decisions for an agency or recommendations 
to an agency must be statutorily based.10 
Of course, it should be noted that under the Idaho Administrative 
Procedure Act (IDAPA) various state agencies must hold open public 
meetings when they adopt rules or when they determine certain 
contested cases. 11 The open public meeting requirements of the 
IDAPA apply regardless of whether the public agency is headed by a 
single individual or by a multi-member body. 
 
9 145 Idaho 164, 177 P.3d 378 (2008). 
10 Id. at 168, 177 P.3d at 382. 
11 Idaho Code §§ 67-5201 to 67-5292. 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
4 
Question No. 3: When is a subagency of a public agency subject to the 
Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: A subagency of a public agency is subject to the Open 
Meeting Law if the subagency itself “is created by or pursuant to 
statute or executive order of the governor , ordinance or other 
legislative act.”12 In Cathcart v. Anderson, the Washington Supreme 
Court interpreted a Washington statute similar to section 74-
202(4)(d). The court held that, under the language “created by or 
pursuant to,” it is not necessary that a statute, ordinance or other 
legislative act expressly create a subagency so long as there is an 
enabling provision which allows that subagency to come into 
existence at some future time. 
Question No. 4: Are advisory committees, boards and commissions 
subject to the Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: The Open Meeting Law defines “public agency” to include 
“any subagency of a public agency which is created by or pursuant to 
statute or executive order of the governor , ordinance, or other 
legislative act,”13 and “governing body” to include any body “with the 
authority to make decisions for or recommendations to a public 
agency regarding any matter.” 14 Thus, advisory committees, boards 
and commissions are subject to the Open Meeting Law if the body is 
created by or pursuant to statute, ordinance, or other legislative act 
and if the body has authority to make recommendations to a public 
agency. 
In contrast, an administrative committee, board or commission is 
not subject to the Open Meeting Law if it is not entrusted with the 
formation of public policy, but merely carries out the public policy 
established by a governing body, and if its activities do not constitute 
the making of “decisions for or recommendations to” a public 
agency.15 Likewise, the Open Meeting Law does not apply to 
voluntary, internal staff meetings if the group is not created by or 
pursuant to statute, ordinance or other legislative act, even though the 
 
12 Idaho Code § 74-202(4)(d); Cathcart v. Anderson, 85 Wash. 2d 102, 530 P.2d 
313 (1975); Attorney General Opinion No. 7-75, 1975 Idaho Att’y Gen. Ann. 
Rpt. 22. 
13 Idaho Code § 74-202(4)(d). 
14 Idaho Code § 74-202(5) (emphasis added). 
15 Idaho Water Resources Board v. Kramer, 97 Idaho 535, 572, 548 P.2d 45, 72 
(1976). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
5 
discussions may lead to recommendations to the governing b ody.16 
Generally, however, if you are ever unsure of whether a meeting 
should be open, it is this O ffice’s recommendation to err on the side 
of opening the meeting. 
Question No. 5: Does the Open Meeting Law apply to the governor? 
Answer: The Open Meeting Law has no application to the governor 
when he is acting in his official executive capacity, since the Open 
Meeting Law does not apply to a public agency headed by a single 
individual. 
CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS (501C(3)) AND 
HOMEOWNER’S ASSOCIATIONS 
Question No. 6: Do charitable organizations have to comply with the 
Idaho Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: The Open Meeting L aw appl ies only to governmental 
entities. Typically , charitable organizations are private. Generally , 
nonprofit organizations are governed by their chartering documents 
and bylaws. Additionally, t itle 30, c hapter 3 of the Idaho Code , 
provides the legal foundation for Idaho nonprofits. Consult the 
chartering documents, bylaws and Idaho Code , title 30, chapter 3, to 
determine the requirements of corporate records and meetings. 
Question No. 7: Do homeowner’s associations have to comply with the 
Idaho Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: No. The Open Meeting Law applies only to governmental 
entities. Homeowner ’s associations are private entities. 
Homeowner’s associations are generally governed by agreements 
between the members and the association and their bylaws. Members 
should consult their association documents and bylaws to determine 
the association rules for meetings. 
 
16 See Safe Air For Everyone v. Idaho State Dep’t of Agriculture, 145 Idaho 164, 
177 P.3d 378 (2008); People v. Carlson, 328 N.E.2d 675 (Ill. App. Ct. 1975); 
Bennett v. Warden, 333 So.2d 97 (Fla. 1976). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
6 
PUBLIC ACTIONS OR ACTIVITIES COVERED BY THE OPEN 
MEETING LAW 
Question No. 8: What constitutes a meeting under the Open Meeting 
Law? 
Answer: The Open Meeting Law defines “meeting” to mean “the 
convening of a governing body of a public agency to make a decision 
or to deliberate toward a decision on any matter.” 17 “Decision” is 
then defined to include “any determination, action, vote or final 
disposition upon a motion, proposal, resolution, order, ordinance or 
measure on which a vote of a governing body is required, at any 
meeting at which a quorum is present. . . .”18 
The term “deliberation” is also a defined term and means “the 
receipt or exchange of information or opinion relating to a decision, 
but shall not include informal or impromptu discussions of a general 
nature that do not specifically relate to a matter then pending before 
the public agency for decision.”19 Note that this does not require any 
discussion or preliminary decision making. Even the receipt of 
information relating to a “decision” —i.e., a measure on which the 
governing body will have to vote —amounts to deliberation, and 
therefore triggers the definition and requirements of a “meeting” 
under the Open Meeting Law. 
Question No. 9 : Does the term “meeting” include such things as 
informal gatherings, briefing sessions, informal discussions, 
attendance at social functions, etc.? 
Answer: As noted above, a “meeting” is the convening of a 
governing body to make a decision or deliberate toward a decision. 
Additionally, a quorum must be present.20 
The California Court of Appeals discussed the dual facets of 
deliberation and action in Sacramento Newspaper Guild v. 
Sacramento County Board of Supervisors: 
 
17 Idaho Code § 74-202(6) (emphasis added). 
18 Idaho Code § 74-202(1) (emphasis added). 
19 Idaho Code § 74-202(2). 
20 Idaho Water Resources Board v. Kramer, 97 Idaho 535, 571, 548 P.2d 45, 71 
(1976). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
7 
It [ California’s open meeting law] declares the 
law’s intent that deliberation as well as action 
occur openly and publicly. Recognition of 
deliberation and action as dual components of the 
collective decision -making process brings 
awareness that the meeting concept cannot be split 
off and confined to one component only, but rather 
comprehends both and either. To “deliberate” is to 
examine, weigh and reflect upon the reasons for or 
against the choice . . . . Deliberation thus connotes 
not only collective discussion, but the collective 
acquisition and exchange of facts preliminary to 
the ultimate decision.21 
The California court then reasoned and ruled: 
An informal conference or caucus permits 
crystallization of secret decisions to a point just 
short of ceremonial acceptance. There is rarely any 
purpose to a non -public pre -meeting conference 
except to conduct some part of the decisional 
process behind closed doors. Only by embracing 
the collective inquiry in discussion stages, as well 
as the ultimate step of official action, can an open 
meeting regulation frustrate these evasive devices. 
As operative criteria, formality and informality are 
alien to the law’s design, exposing it to the very 
evasions it was designed to prevent. Construed in 
light of the Brown Act’s objectives, the term 
“meeting” extends to informal sessions or 
conferences of board members designed for the 
discussion of public business.22 
A similar result was reached by the Florida Supreme Court in the 
case of City of Miami v. Berns wherein the Florida court ruled that 
public officials violate Florida’s open meeting law when they meet 
privately or secretly and transact or agree to transact public business 
at a future time in a certain manner. 23 The Florida court went on to 
 
21 Sacramento Newspaper Guild v. Sacramento County Bd. of Supervisors, 69 
Cal. Rptr. 480, 485 (Cal. Ct. App. 1968). 
22 Id. at 487. 
23 City of Miami v. Berns, 245 So.2d 38 (Fla. 1971). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
8 
state that, regardless of whether a meeting or gathering is formal or 
informal, “[i]t is the law’s intent that any meeting, relating to any 
matter on which foreseeable action will be taken, occur openly and 
publicly.”24 
The same considerations must be applied with respect to the 
Idaho Open Meeting Law. Therefore, it is the opinion of the Attorney 
General that the provisions of the Open Meeting Law must be 
complied with whenever a quorum of the members of the governing 
body of a public agency meets to decide or deliberate on matters 
which are within the ambit of official business. Those meetings can 
be formal, informal, or social. So long as a quorum is present and the 
intent is to deliberate or make a decision, then the meeting must be 
open. 
The requirement that the Open Meeting Law be complied with 
whenever a quorum of a governing body meets to deliberate or to 
make a decision should not be evaded by holding smaller meetings 
with less than a quorum present or by having a go- between contact 
each of the governing body members to ascertain his/her sentiment. 
Question No. 10: Since any meeting of two county commissioners 
constitutes a quorum under Idaho law, are county commissioners 
prohibited from having any contact with each other outside of a duly 
organized open meeting? 
Answer: While it is the opinion of the Attorney General that the Open 
Meeting Law must be complied with whenever a quorum of the 
members of a governing body of a public agency meet to decide or 
deliberate on matters which are within the am bit of official business, 
this Office does not believe that the Legislature intended for the Open 
Meeting Law to act as a bar to all communications between individual 
county commissioners outside of open meetings. 
Question No. 11: Are adjudicatory deliberations exempt from the 
Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: Only for those agencies expressly exempted. The Open 
Meeting Law excludes the deliberations of certain agencies (the Board 
of Tax Appeals, the Public Utilities Commission and the Industrial 
 
24 Id. at 41; see also Canney v. Bd. of Pub. Instruction of Alachua Cnty, 278 
So.2d 260 (Fla. 1973); Bd. of Pub. Instruction of Broward Cnty v. Doran, 224 
So.2d 693 (Fla. 1969). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
9 
Commission), in fully submitted adjudicatory proceedings, from the 
requirement of open public meeting.25 In creating this exemption for 
adjudicatory deliberations by only these three agencies, it appears the 
Legislature intended that non -adjudicatory deliberations at these 
agencies, and all deliberations at all other agencies —i.e., except for 
the above-described informal or impromptu discussions of a general 
nature—must be conducted in a public meeting. Of course, the 
subject matter under adjudication may be separately identified under 
the Open Meeting Law as justifying a closed executive session. 
Question No. 1 2: Can I still address questions and comments to a 
commissioner or board member individually related to a pending 
matter? 
Answer: In other words, as representatives, can I still contact 
members of a governing body with unsolicited “information or 
opinion relating to a decision” that is pending before the public 
agency?26 The Idaho Supreme Court has addressed this specific 
question. 
In Idaho Historic Preservation Council v. City Council of Boise , 
a divided Court overturned a Boise City Council decision that allowed 
a corporation to demolish a building in Boise. 27 In reviewing an 
appeal from the City’s Preservation Commission, members of the City 
Council stated at the public [open] meeting that they had received 
numerous telephone calls concerning the issue. Although the Court 
framed the issue in terms of due process, it may also raise open 
meeting questions. 
In overturning the City’s decision, the Court stated: 
[W]hen a governing body sits in a quasi -judicial 
capacity, it must confine its decision to the record 
produced at the public hearing, and that failing to 
do so violates procedural due process of law. This 
Court has also observed that when a governing 
body deviates from the public record, it essentially 
conducts a second fact -gathering session without 
proper notice, a clear violation of due process. 
 
25 Idaho Code § 74-203(2). 
26 Idaho Code § 74-202(2). 
27 Idaho Historic Pres. Council v. City Council of Boise, 134 Idaho 651, 8 P.3d 
646 (2000). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
10 
Since the substance of the telephone calls received 
by the members of the City Council was not 
recorded or disclosed at the public hearing, the 
Commission had no opportunity to rebut any 
evidence or arguments the City Council may have 
received from the callers. 
Id. at 654, 8 P.3d at 649 (internal citations omitted). 
The Court concluded: 
This decision does not hold the City Council to a 
standard of judicial disinterestedness. As explained 
above, members of the City Council are free to take 
phone calls from concerned citizens and listen to 
their opinions and arguments prior to a quasi -
judicial proceeding. In order to satisfy due process, 
however, the identity of the callers must be 
disclosed, as well as a general description of what 
each caller said.28 
Therefore, in the event that unsolicited information is received 
and considered by a governing board member, the appropriate action 
is to disclose the source of the information and the substance of the 
information so that it may be included within the public record. In 
sum, any information that you wish to use to form the basis of your 
decision must be made a part of the public record. 
PROCEDURAL REQUIREMENTS OF THE OPEN MEETING 
LAW 
Question No. 13: Can video and audio recordings of public meetings 
be made? 
Answer: Yes. Open public meetings can be recorded by audio, video, 
or photographs by electronic, digital, or other means and a governing 
body shall not prohibit or unreasonably restrict recording of a 
meeting.29 
 
28 Id. at 656, 8 P.3d at 651. 
29 Idaho Code § 74-203(6). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
11 
Question No. 1 4: What are the notice requirements of the Open 
Meeting Law? 
Answer: The Open Meeting Law requires two types of notice: (1) 
meeting notice and (2) agenda notice. The notice requirements are 
satisfied by posting meeting notices and agendas in a prominent place 
at the principal office of the public agency, or, if no such office exists, 
at the building where the meeting is to be held. The notice for 
meetings and agendas shall also be posted electronically if the entity 
maintains an online presence through a website or a social media 
platform. The Open Meeting Law does not require publication of the 
notice in a newspaper or advertisement. However, other statutes 
governing particular entities may require publication of notice. 
The Open Meeting Law also requires that notice be posted at 
specific minimum times prior to the meeting. These times vary, 
depending on the type of meeting being held. The notice of an 
executive session must state the authorizing provision of law. 
Question No. 15: What are the notice and agenda requirements for a 
regular meeting? 
Answer: For “regular meetings,” the Open Meeting Law requires no 
less than a five (5) calendar day meeting notice and a forty-eight (48) 
hour agenda notice, unless otherwise provided by statute. 30 Any 
public agency that holds meetings at regular intervals at least once per 
calendar month, which are scheduled in advance over the course of 
the year , may satisfy this notice requirement by posting meeting 
notices at least once each year of its regular meeting schedule. 
Agenda notice must still be posted at least 48 hours before the 
meeting. 
Question No. 16: What are the notice and agenda requirements for a 
special meeting or executive session only meeting? 
Answer: For “ special meetings ,” or when only an “ executive 
session” will be held , meeting and agenda notice must be posted at 
least twenty-four (24) hours before the meeting, unless an emergency 
exists. An emergency is a situation which involves injury or damage 
to persons or property, or immediate financial loss, or the likelihood 
of such injury, damage or loss, when the notice requirements of the 
section would make such notice impractical, or increase the likelihood 
 
30 Idaho Code § 74-204. 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
12 
or severity of such injury, damage or loss, and the reason for the 
emergency is stated at the outset of the meeting. This notice and an 
accompanying agenda must be given by the secretary or other 
designee of each public agency to any representative of the news 
media who has requested notification of such meetings and the 
secretary must make a good faith effort to provide such advance 
notification to them of the time and place of each meeting.31 
Question No. 17: What must an agenda contain? 
Answer: What constitutes an “agenda” to satisfy the posting 
requirement is not set forth in the Open Meeting Law. However, an 
“agenda” is defined in Black’s Law Dictionary (9th ed.) as a “list of 
things to be done, as items to be considered at a meeting, [usually] 
arranged in order of consideration.” The agenda notice requirement 
is not satisfied by merely posting a weekly schedule of the governing 
board which sets forth the time, place of the meetings, and who is 
participating. Rather, the notice must specifically set forth the 
purpose of the meeting and “items of business.” Agenda items should 
be listed with specificity and not buried in catchall categories such as 
“director’s report.” An agenda item that requires a vote shall be 
identified on the agenda as an “action item” to provide notice that 
action may be taken on that item. Identifying an item as an action 
item on the agenda does not require a vote to be taken on that item. 
Multiple agenda items may be grouped together and voted upon as a 
single action item known as a consent agenda, so long as they are not 
ordinances, fee resolutions, or items requiring more than a simple 
majority vote.32 
Question No. 18: May an agenda be amended after posting? 
Answer: Yes. The procedure depends on when the agenda is 
amended. 
More than 48 hours before the start of a meeting (or more than 24 
hours before a special meeting), the agenda may be amended simply 
by posting a new agenda. 
Less than 48 hours before the meeting (or less than 24 hours 
before a special meeting), but before the meeting has started, the 
agenda may be amended by: (1) posting the new agenda, and (2) 
 
31 Idaho Code § 74-204(2) and (3). 
32 Idaho Code § 74-204(4). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
13 
making and passing a motion at the meeting to amend the original 
agenda and stating the good faith reason the new items were not 
included in the original agenda notice. 
After commencement of the meeting, the agenda may be 
amended to accommodate unforeseen issues, provided that: (1) there 
is a motion made that states the good faith reason the new item was 
not on the original agenda, and (2) the motion to amend is adopted by 
the governing body. Final action may not be taken on an agenda item 
added after the start of the meeting unless an emergency is declared 
necessitating action at that meeting. The declaration and justification 
shall be reflected in the minutes. 
To sum up, amending an agenda during a meeting or less than 48 
hours before the start of a meeting (24 hours for a special meeting) 
requires: (1) a motion, (2) a good faith reason why the item was not 
included in the original agenda, (3) a vote adopting the amended 
agenda, and (4) a record of the motion and vote in the minutes of the 
meeting. 
Question No. 19: May qualifications or restrictions be placed on the 
public’s attendance at an open meeting? 
Answer: A public agency may adopt reasonable rules and regulations 
to ensure the orderly conduct of a public meeting and to ensure orderly 
behavior on the part of those persons attending the meeting. In 
Nevens v. City of Chino, a California appellate court nullified a city 
council measure, which prohibited the use of any tape recorders at city 
council proceedings.33 While acknowledging that the city council had 
an absolute right to adopt and enforce rules and regulations necessary 
to protect its public meetings, the court held that the rule prohibiting 
tape recorders was too arbitrary, capricious, restrictive and 
unreasonable. A similar holding might be reached if a governing body 
prohibits the use of cameras if their presence is not in fact disruptive 
of the conduct of the meeting. 
Another limitation is that the body cannot make it practically 
impossible for the public to be present at a meeting. For example, in 
Noble v. Kootenai County, a board of commissioners conducted a site 
visit to a proposed subdivision. When arriving at the site, the board 
intentionally avoided a group that was gathered near the entrance to 
the site location and conducted its site visit outside the group’s 
 
33 Nevens v. City of Chino, 44 Cal. Rptr. 50 (Cal. Ct. App. 1965). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
14 
hearing. The court held that this was a violation, stating that “Idaho’s 
open meeting laws are designed to allow the public to be present 
during agency hearings. At the very least this means that the public 
must be permitted to get close enough to the hearing body to hear what 
is being said.”34 
In any event, the governing standard is the reasonableness of the 
rules and regulations. Use of a timed agenda, “heavy gavel” and/or 
compliance with Robert’s Rules of Order or some other procedural 
guideline may serve to facilitate the orderly conduct of a public 
meeting. 
Question No. 20: Does the Open Meeting Law require the governing 
body of a public agency to accept public comments and testimony 
during meetings? 
Answer: No. While other statutes, such as the Local Planning Act, 
may require the solicitation of public comments, the Open Meeting 
Law does not expressly require the opportunity for public comment.35 
Question No. 21: May the members of a governing body vote by secret 
ballot at an open meeting? 
Answer: No decision at any meeting of a governing body of a public 
agency may be made by secret ballot.36 
Question No. 2 2: If a voice vote is used, must the minutes of the 
meeting reflect the vote of each member of a governing body by name? 
Answer: If a voice vote is taken, the minutes of the meeting must 
reflect the results of all votes, but the minutes need not indicate how 
each member voted, unless a member of the governing body requests 
such an indication.37 
 
 
34 Noble v. Kootenai County, 148 Idaho 937, 943, 231 P.3d 1034, 1040 (2010) 
(internal citations omitted). 
35 See Coalition for Responsible Government v. Bonner County, First Judicial 
District, Bonner County Case No. CV-97-00107 (May 15, 1997) (on file with the 
Office of the Attorney General). 
36 Idaho Code § 74-203(1). 
37 Idaho Code § 74-205(1)(c). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
15 
Question No. 23: May a vote be conducted by written ballots? 
Answer: A vote may be conducted by written ballot, but written 
ballots would not comply with the Open Meeting Law unless the 
ballots are made available to the public on request and unless the 
members casting the ballots are identifiable by signature or other 
discernible means. 38 The reason identification of the vote of 
individual members is treated differently between voice votes and 
votes by written ballot is that, with respect to voice votes, members of 
the public in attendance can readily ascertain the vote of individual 
members of the governing body. In contrast, a vote by written ballot 
is tantamount to a secret vote, unless such ballot is signed or identifies 
the name of the voting member. 
Question No. 2 4: What types of records must be maintained under 
the Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: The Open Meeting Law requires that the governing body of 
a public agency must provide for the taking of written minutes of all 
of its meetings, but it is not necessary to make a full transcript or 
recording of the meeting, except as otherwise provided by law. 39 
These minutes are public records and must be made available to the 
general public within a reasonable time after the meeting. The 
minutes must include, at a minimum, the following information: 
(a) All members of the governing body present; 
(b) All motions, resolutions, orders, or ordinances proposed 
and their disposition; 
(c) The results of all votes and, upon the request of a 
member of the governing body, the vote of each member by 
name. 
Other statutes may provide more specific requirements for particular 
entities. 
In addition, section 74-205(2) provides that minutes of executive 
sessions must be kept, but they need contain only sufficient detail to 
identify the purpose and topic of the executive session and do not need 
to include the disclosure of material or matters that compromise the 
 
38 Attorney General Opinion No. 77-13, 1977 Idaho Att’y Gen. Ann. Rpt. 115. 
39 Idaho Code § 74-205(1). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
16 
purpose of the executive session. The minutes pertaining to the 
executive session, however, must include a reference to the specific 
statutory subsection authorizing the session. 
Question No. 2 5: Are there any prohibitions on where a public 
meeting may be held? 
Answer: Yes. Section 74-203(3) specifically provides: “A governing 
body shall not hold a meeting at any place where discrimination on 
the basis of race, creed, color, sex, age or national origin is practiced.” 
Thus, for example, a public meeting may not be held at a private club 
if the private club excludes women from membership, even if women 
are allowed entrance for the purpose of attending the meeting. 
Question No. 2 6: Does the Open Meeting Law permit holding a 
meeting by telephone conference call? 
Answer: Yes. The Open Meeting Law specifically authorizes the 
holding of a meeting by telephone conference call. However, at least 
one member of the governing body or the director or chief 
administrative officer must be physically present at the meeting 
location designated in the meeting notice .40 Additionally, the 
communications among the members of the governing body must be 
audible to all persons attending the meeting. Care should also be taken 
to ensure that votes are not made in such a way to permit an illegal 
secret ballot or vote. 
Question No. 2 7: Are discussions conducted via telephones, 
computers, cell phones (including texting) or other electronic means 
exempted from the Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: As discussed in this manual, the Open Meeting Law applies 
to the deliberations and discussions between two or more members of 
a board or commission on some matter which foreseeably will come 
before that board or commission for action. The use of a telephone to 
conduct such discussions does not remove the conversation from the 
requirements of the Open Meeting Law. 
Similarly, members of a public board may not use computers or 
texting to conduct private conversations among themselves about 
board business. A one-way e-mail or text communication from one 
city council member to another, when it does not result in the 
 
40 Idaho Code § 74-203(5). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
17 
exchange of council members’ comments or responses on subjects 
requiring council action, does not constitute a meeting subject to the 
Open Meeting Law; however, such e-mail or text communications are 
public records and must be maintained by the records custodian for 
public inspection and copying. 
SPECIFIC STATUTORY EXEMPTIONS: EXECUTIVE SESSIONS 
Question No. 2 8: What types of meetings may be closed under the 
Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: A closed meeting—that is, an “executive session”—may be 
held for the reasons listed in § 74-206(1): 
(a) To consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff 
member or individual agent, wherein the respective qualities of 
individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy 
or need. This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an 
elective office or deliberations about staffing needs in general; 
(b) To consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of, 
or to hear complaints or charges brought against, a public officer, 
employee, staff member or individual agent , or public school 
student; 
(c) To acquire an interest in real property not owned by a 
public agency; 
(d) To consider records that are exempt from disclosure as 
provided in chapter 1, title 74, Idaho Code; 
(e) To consider preliminary negotiations involving matters 
of trade or commerce in which the governing body is in 
competition with governing bodies in other states or nations; 
(f) To communicate with legal counsel for the public 
agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for 
pending litigation, or controversies not yet being litigated but 
imminently likely to be litigated. The mere presence of legal 
counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement; 
(g) By the commission of pardons and parole, as provided 
by law; 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
18 
(h) By the custody review board of the Idaho department of 
juvenile corrections, as provided by law; or 
(i) To engage in communications with a representative of 
the public agency’s risk manager or insurance provider to discuss 
the adjustment of a pending claim or prevention of a claim 
imminently likely to be filed. The mere presence of a 
representative of the public agency’s risk manager or insurance 
provider at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement. 
(j) To consider labor contract matters authorized under 
section 74-206A(1)(a) and (b), Idaho Code. 
This provision enumerates specific and not general statutory 
exemptions to the requirement of conducting an open meeting. It is 
the Attorney General’s opinion that a public agency cannot conduct 
an executive session to consider general personnel matters, but can 
only meet in executive session to consider those specifically 
enumerated personnel matters found at section 74-206(1)(a) and (b); 
that is, “to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member or 
individual agent” or “to consider the evaluation, dismissal or 
disciplining of, or to hear complaints or charges brought against, a 
public officer, employee, staff member, individual agent or public 
school student.” Additionally, Idaho Code section 74-206(2) 
specifically directs that the exceptions be construed narrowly. No 
entity should try to “shoehorn” an issue into an executive session 
exception. 
An executive session may be held to consider acquiring an 
interest in real property that is not owned by a public agency. 
However, an executive session cannot be held for the purpose of 
acquiring an interest in real property owned by a public agency.41 
It should be noted that the Open Meeting Law establishes 
circumstances where executive sessions are permissible. In other 
words, the act authorizes, but does not require, closed meetings. In 
addition, even though certain enumerated matters may be 
“considered” in an executive session, it must be emphasized that: 
 
41 Attorney General Opinion No. 81-15, 1981 Idaho Att’y Gen. Ann. Rpt. 161. 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
19 
“[N]o executive session may be held for the purpose of taking any 
final action or making any final decision.”42 
It is imp ortant to remember that section 74 -206(1) sets forth 
specific procedural steps to be followed to have a valid executive 
session. Failure to do so will invalidate any action taken as a result 
of the executive session. Additionally, it may subject the board 
members to liability for those actions. Procedurally, the presiding 
officer must identify the specific authorization under the Open 
Meeting Law for the holding of an executive session and at least a 
two-thirds (⅔) vote in favor of the executive session must be recorded 
in the minutes of the meeting by individual vote. 
Question No. 2 9: What procedure must be followed before an 
executive session, closed to the public, may be held? 
Answer: It must be noted that executive sessions take place only at 
meetings. Before any executive session may be held, there must be a 
valid open meeting and a vote to hold an executive session. Every 
such “meeting” must satisfy the Open Meeting Law’s notice and 
agenda requirements.43 If the governing body of a public agency then 
wishes to consider matters which may legally be considered in a 
closed meeting, an executive session may be held if two-thirds (⅔) of 
the members vote to hold an executive session. Prior to such vote, the 
presiding officer must identify the authoriz ation under the Open 
Meeting Law for the holding of an executive session. Then, when the 
vote is taken, the individual vote of each member of the governing 
body must be recorded in the minutes.44 
Question No. 30: May legal counsel meet privately with the governing 
body of a public agency to discuss threatened or pending litigation? 
Answer: Yes. Section 74-206(f) expressly provides that an executive 
session may be held “[t]o communicate with legal counsel for the 
public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options 
for pending litigation, or controversies not yet being litigated but 
imminently likely to be litigated.” 
 
42 Idaho Code § 74-206(3); Attorney General Opinion No. 77-44, 1977 Idaho 
Att’y Gen. Ann. Rpt. 226; Attorney General Opinion No. 81-15, 1981 Idaho 
Att’y Gen. Ann. Rpt. 161. 
43 Idaho Code § 74-204. 
44 Idaho Code § 74-206(1). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
20 
Question No. 3 1: Must the governing body’s attorney be present 
during an executive session? 
Answer: Generally, the governing body’s attorney need not be 
present when the governing body meets in executive session. An 
exception is an executive session authorized under Idaho Code section 
74-206(1)(f): “To communicate with legal counsel for the public 
agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for 
pending litigation, or controversies not yet being litigated but 
imminently likely to be litigated. The mere presence of legal counsel 
at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.” (Of course, 
the attorney’s “presence” may be facilitated via a telecommunications 
device.) An executive session under this subsection is solely for the 
purpose of communicating with legal counsel on pending or probable 
litigation. 
Question No. 32: If a more specific statute requires open meetings and 
has no provision for executive sessions, is the executive session 
provision of the Open Meeting Law still applicable? 
Answer: Yes. The executive session provision takes precedence over 
other statutes that may apply to a particular entity. Thus, even if a 
statute requires all meetings of a governing body to be open, executive 
sessions may still be held.45 
PENALTIES FOR NONCOMPLIANCE 
Question No. 3 3: What is the validity of action taken in violation of 
the Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: If an action, or any deliberation or decision making that 
leads to an action, occurs at any meeting that fails to comply with the 
provisions of the Open Meeting Law, such an action may be declared 
null and void by a court.46 
Any member of the governing body taking such an action, who 
participates in any such deliberation, decision making, or meeting, is 
subject to a civil penalty not to exceed two hundred fifty dollars 
($250).47 The maximum civil penalty for a subsequent violation is 
 
45 Nelson v. Boundary County, 109 Idaho 205, 706 P.2d 94 (Ct. App. 1985). 
46 Idaho Code § 74-208(1). 
47 Idaho Code § 74-208(2). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
21 
two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500).48 
Any governing body member who knowingly violates a provision 
of the Open Meeting Law is subject to a civil penalty of not more than 
one thousand five hundred dollars ($1,500).49 
It is the opinion of the Attorney General that the Idaho Legislature 
intended that such fines be paid by the individual member of the 
governing body, not the governing body itself. 
Question No. 34: Who enforces the Open Meeting Law? 
Answer: The Attorney General enforce s the Open Meeting Law in 
relation to the public agencies of state government . County 
prosecuting attorneys enforce the Open Meeting Law in relation to the 
local public agencies within their respective jurisdictions.50 
Any person affected by a violation of the Open Meeting Law is 
entitled to bring a lawsuit in the magistrates’ division of the county in 
which the public agency normally meets for the purpose of requiring 
compliance with the provisions of the Open Meeting Law. The 
lawsuit would ask the court to declare any improper actions void and 
to enjoin the governing body from violating the Open Meeting Law in 
the future. Such a lawsuit must be commenced within thirty (30) days 
of the time of the decision or action that results, in whole or in part, 
from a meeting that failed to comply with the provisions of the Open 
Meeting Law. Any o ther lawsuit must be commenced within one 
hundred eighty (180) days of the time of the violation.51 
Question No. 3 5: If there is a violation of the Open Meeting Law at 
an early stage in the process, will all subsequent actions be null and 
void? 
Answer: Yes. Section 74-208(1) clearly indicates that an action or 
any deliberation or decision making that leads to an action, which 
occurs at any meeting not in compliance with the provisions of the 
Open Meeting Law, will be null and void. The 1992 L egislature 
added the “deliberation or decision making that leads to an action” 
language to the provisions of section 74- 208(1). This language 
 
48 Idaho Code § 74-208(4). 
49 Idaho Code § 74-208(3). 
50 Idaho Code § 74-208(5). 
51 Idaho Code § 74-208(6). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
22 
clarifies the consequences of a violation under the previous 
requirement. 
The Idaho Supreme Court has held that the procedure for voiding 
actions taken in violation of the Open Meeting Law must be read 
literally. Thus, any action may not be declared void if it is not 
challenged within the thirty-day time limit established by section 74-
208(6).52 
Question No. 36: If a violation of the Open Meeting Law occurs, what 
can a governing body do to correct the error? 
Answer: The governing body should follow the steps outlined in 
Idaho Code § 74-208(7) to “cure” the violation. A violation is cured 
by repealing any action taken at an illegal meeting or disregarding 
deliberations made in violation of the Open Meeting Law. Should it 
choose to, a governing body may, in a properly noticed meeting, 
repeat the deliberation or decision that occurred at the illegal meeting. 
Question No. 3 7: Are members of the governing body of a public 
agency criminally liable for violations of the Open Meeting Law in 
which they knowingly participate? 
Answer: The Open Meeting Law specifically provides civil 
monetary penalties for violations. The Open Meeting Law does not 
provide for criminal liability. 
Question No. 3 8: Do school boards have to comply with the Open 
Meeting Law? 
Answer: Yes. Each school district is governed by a board of trustees 
or “board”53 and a ll school districts in Idaho, including specially 
chartered school districts, are under the supervision and control of the 
State B oard of Education. 54 State boards and s chool districts are 
defined in the Open Meeting Law as a “public agency,”55 and as such, 
are subject to the Open Meeting Laws.56 
 
52 Petersen v. Franklin County, 130 Idaho 176, 938 P.2d 1214 (1997). 
53 Idaho Code § 33-501. 
54 Idaho Code § 33-101. 
55 Idaho Code §§ 74-202(4)(a) and 74-202(4)(c). 
56 Idaho Code § 74-203(1). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
23 
THE STATUTE 
(Idaho Code §§ 74-201 to 74-208) 
74-201. Formation of public policy at open meetings. The people of 
the state of Idaho in creating the instruments of government that serve 
them, do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies so created. Therefore, 
the legislature finds and declares that it is the policy of this state that the 
formation of public policy is public business and shall not be conducted in 
secret. 
74-202. Open public meetings – Definitions. As used in this chapter: 
(1) “Decision” means any determination, action, vote or final 
disposition upon a motion, proposal, resolution, order, ordinance or 
measure on which a vote of a governing body is required, at any meeting 
at which a quorum is present, but shall not include those ministerial or 
administrative actions necessary to carry out a decision previously adopted 
in a meeting held in compliance with this chapter. 
(2) “Deliberation” means the receipt or exchange of information or 
opinion relating to a decision, but shall not include informal or impromptu 
discussions of a general nature that do not specifically relate to a matter 
then pending before the public agency for decision. 
(3) “Executive session” means any meeting or part of a meeting of 
a governing body that is closed to any persons for deliberation on certain 
matters. 
(4) “Public agency” means: 
(a) Any state board, committee, council, commission, 
department, authority, educational institution or other state 
agency created by or pursuant to statute or executive order of the 
governor, other than courts and their agencies and divisions, and 
the judicial council, and the district magistrates commission; 
(b) Any regional board, commission, department or 
authority created by or pursuant to statute; 
(c) Any county, city, school district, special district, or other 
municipal corporation or political subdivision of the state of 
Idaho; 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
24 
(d) Any subagency of a public agency created by or 
pursuant to statute or executive order of the governor, ordinance, 
or other legislative act; and 
(e) Notwithstanding the language of this subsection, the 
cybersecurity task force or a committee awarding the Idaho medal 
of achievement shall not constitute a public agency. 
(5) “Governing body” means the members of any public agency 
that consists of two (2) or more members, with the authority to make 
decisions for or recommendations to a public agency regarding any matter. 
(6) “Meeting” means the convening of a governing body of a public 
agency to make a decision or to deliberate toward a decision on any matter. 
(a) “Regular meeting” means the convening of a governing 
body of a public agency on the date fixed by law or rule, to 
conduct the business of the agency. 
(b) “Special meeting” is a convening of the governing body 
of a public agency pursuant to a special call for the conduct of 
business as specified in the call. 
74-203. Governing bodies – Requirement for open public meetings. 
(1) Except as provided below, all meetings of a governing body of 
a public agency shall be open to the public and all persons shall be 
permitted to attend any meeting except as otherwise provided by this act. 
No decision at a meeting of a governing body of a public agency shall be 
made by secret ballot. 
(2) Deliberations of the board of tax appeals created in chapter 38, 
title 63, Idaho Code, the public utilities commission and the industrial 
commission in a fully submitted adjudicatory proceeding in which 
hearings, if any are required, have been completed, and in which the legal 
rights, duties or privileges of a party are to be determined are not required 
by this act to take place in a meeting open to the public. Such deliberations 
may, however, be made and/or conducted in a public meeting at the 
discretion of the agency. 
(3) Meetings of the Idaho life and health insurance guaranty 
association established under chapter 43, title 41, Idaho Code, the Idaho 
insurance guaranty association established under chapter 36, title 41, Idaho 
Code, and the surplus line association approved by the director of the Idaho 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
25 
department of insurance as authorized under chapter 12, title 41, Idaho 
Code, are not required by this act to take place in a meeting open to the 
public. 
(4) A governing body shall not hold a meeting at any place where 
discrimination on the basis of race, creed, color, sex, age or national origin 
is practiced. 
(5) All meetings may be conducted using telecommunications 
devices which enable all members of a governing body participating in the 
meeting to communicate with each other. Such devices may include, but 
are not limited to, telephone or video conferencing devic es and similar 
communications equipment. Participation by a member of the governing 
body through telecommunications devices shall constitute presence in 
person by such member at the meeting; provided however, that at least one 
(1) member of the governing body, or the director of the public agency, or 
the chief administrative officer of the public agency shall be physically 
present at the location designated in the meeting notice, as required under 
section 74-204, Idaho Code, to ensure that the public may attend such 
meeting in person. The communications among members of a governing 
body must be audible to the public attending the meeting in person and the 
members of the governing body. 
(6) Except as otherwise provided in this subsection, no person 
attending open public meetings shall be prevented or prohibited from 
recording such meetings. For purposes of this subsection, “recording” 
means the capturing of audio, video, or photographs by electronic, digital, 
or other means. A governing body may take measures to ensure the orderly 
conduct of its open public meetings but shall not prohibit or unreasonably 
restrict recording as provided under this subsection. No person shall be 
removed or excluded from meetings for recording pursuant to the 
provisions of this subsection. The provisions of this subsection shall not 
apply to: 
(a) Executive sessions; 
(b) Any meetings or hearings in a facility owned or operated 
by the Idaho department of correction; 
(c) Any meetings or hearings in a facility owned or operated 
by the Idaho department of juvenile corrections; or 
(d) Any meetings or hearings conducted by the Idaho 
commission of pardons and parole. 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
26 
74-204. Notice of meetings – Agendas. 
(1) Regular meetings. No less than a five (5) calendar day meeting 
notice and a forty -eight (48) hour agenda notice shall be given unless 
otherwise provided by statute. Provided however, that any public agency 
that holds meetings at regular intervals of at least once per calendar month 
scheduled in advance over the course of the year may satisfy this meeting 
notice by giving meeting notices at least once each year of its regular 
meeting schedule. The notice requirement for meetings and agendas shall 
be satisfied by posting such notices and agendas in a prominent place at 
the principal office of the public agency or, if no such office exists, at the 
building where the meeting is to be held. The notice for meetings and 
agendas shall also be posted electronically if the entity maintains an online 
presence through a website or a social media platform. 
(2) Special meetings. No special meeting shall be held without at 
least a twenty -four (24) hour meeting and agenda notice, unless an 
emergency exists. An emergency is a situation involving injury or damage 
to persons or property, or immediate financial loss, or the likelihood o f 
such injury, damage or loss, when the notice requirements of this section 
would make such notice impracticable or increase the likelihood or 
severity of such injury, damage or loss, and the reason for the emergency 
is stated at the outset of the meeting. The notice required under this section 
shall include at a minimum the meeting date, time, place and name of the 
public agency calling for the meeting. The secretary or other designee of 
each public agency shall maintain a list of the news media requesting 
notification of meetings and shall make a good faith effort to provide 
advance notification to them of the time and place of each meeting. 
(3) Executive sessions. If only an executive session will be held, a 
twenty-four (24) hour meeting and agenda notice shall be given according 
to the notice provisions stated in subsection (2) of this section and shall 
state the reason and the specific provision of law authorizing the executive 
session. 
(4) An agenda shall be required for each meeting. The agenda shall 
be posted in the same manner as the notice of the meeting. An agenda may 
be amended, provided that a good faith effort is made to include, in the 
original agenda notice, all items known to be probable items of discussion. 
An agenda item that requires a vote shall be identified on the agenda as an 
“action item” to provide notice that action may be taken on that item. 
Multiple agenda items may be grouped together and voted upon as a single 
action item known as a consent agenda, provided the agenda items are not 
ordinances, fee resolutions, or items requiring more than a simple majority 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
27 
of the members present. During the meeting, if any member of the 
governing body requests an item or items be removed from the consent 
agenda, such item or items shall, prior to the vote on the consent agenda, 
be removed from the consent agenda and considered as a separate action 
for discussion and vote. Identifying an item as an action item on the agenda 
does not require a vote to be taken on that item. 
(a) If an amendment to an agenda is made after an agenda 
has been posted but forty- eight (48) hours or more prior to the 
start of a regular meeting, or twenty-four (24) hours or more prior 
to the start of a special meeting, then the agenda is amended upon 
the posting of the amended agenda. 
(b) If an amendment to an agenda is proposed after an 
agenda has been posted and less than forty-eight (48) hours prior 
to a regular meeting or less than twenty-four (24) hours prior to a 
special meeting but prior to the start of the meeting, the proposed 
amended agenda shall be posted but shall not become effective 
until a motion is made at the meeting and the governing body 
votes to amend the agenda. 
(c) An agenda may be amended after the start of a meeting 
upon a motion that states the reason for the amendment and states 
the good faith reason the agenda item was not included in the 
original agenda posting. Final action may not be taken on an 
agenda item added after the start of a meeting unless an 
emergency is declared necessitating action at that meeting. The 
declaration and justification shall be reflected in the minutes. 
74-205. Written minutes of meetings. 
(1) The governing body of a public agency shall provide for the 
taking of written minutes of all its meetings. Neither a full transcript nor a 
recording of the meeting is required, except as otherwise provided by law. 
All minutes shall be available to the public within a reasonable time after 
the meeting, and shall include at least the following information: 
(a) All members of the governing body present; 
(b) All motions, resolutions, orders, or ordinances proposed 
and their disposition; 
(c) The results of all votes, and upon the request of a 
member, the vote of each member, by name. 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
28 
(2) Minutes pertaining to executive sessions. Minutes pertaining 
to an executive session shall include a reference to the specific statutory 
subsection authorizing the executive session and shall also provide 
sufficient detail to identify the purpose and topic of the executive session 
but shall not contain information sufficient to compromise the purpose of 
going into executive session. 
74-206. Executive sessions – When authorized. 
(1) An executive session at which members of the public are 
excluded may be held, but only for the purposes and only in the manner 
set forth in this section. The motion to go into executive session shall 
identify the specific subsections of this section that authorize the executive 
session. There shall be a roll call vote on the motion and the vote shall be 
recorded in the minutes. An executive session shall be authorized by a two-
thirds (⅔) vote of the governing body. An executive session may be held: 
(a) To consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff 
member or individual agent, wherein the respective qualities of 
individuals are to be evaluated in order to fill a particular vacancy 
or need. This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy in an 
elective office or deliberations about staffing needs in general; 
(b) To consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of, 
or to hear complaints or charges brought against, a public officer, 
employee, staff member or individual agent, or public school 
student; 
(c) To acquire an interest in real property which is not 
owned by a public agency; 
(d) To consider records that are exempt from disclosure as 
provided in chapter 1, title 74, Idaho Code; 
(e) To consider preliminary negotiations involving matters 
of trade or commerce in which the governing body is in 
competition with governing bodies in other states or nations; 
(f) To communicate with legal counsel for the public 
agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for 
pending litigation, or controversies not yet being litigated but 
imminently likely to be litigated. The mere presence of legal 
counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement; 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
29 
(g) By the commission of pardons and parole, as provided 
by law; 
(h) By the custody review board of the Idaho department of 
juvenile corrections, as provided by law; 
(i) To engage in communications with a repre sentative of 
the public agency’s risk manager or insurance provider to discuss 
the adjustment of a pending claim or prevention of a claim 
imminently likely to be filed. The mere presence of a 
representative of the public agency’ s risk manager or insurance 
provider at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement; 
or 
(j) To consider labor contract matters authorized under 
section 74-206 (1)(a) and (b), Idaho Code. 
(2) The exceptions to the general policy in favor of open meetings 
stated in this section shall be narrowly construed. It shall be a violation of 
this chapter to change the subject within the executive session to one not 
identified within the motion to enter the executive session or to any topic 
for which an executive session is not provided. 
(3) No executive session may be held for the purpose of taking any 
final action or making any final decision. 
(4) If the governing board of a public school district, charter 
district, or public charter school has vacancies such that fewer than two -
thirds (2/3) of board members have been seated, then the board may enter 
into executive session on a simple roll majority vote. 
74-206A. Negotiations in open session. 
(1) All negotiations between a governing body and a labor 
organization shall be in open session and shall be available for the public 
to attend. This requirement also applies to negotiations between the 
governing bo dy’s designated representatives and representatives of the 
labor organization. This requirement shall also apply to meetings with any 
labor negotiation arbitrators, fact finders, mediators or similar labor 
dispute meeting facilitators when meeting with both parties to the 
negotiation at the same time . Provided, however, a governing bo dy or its 
designated representatives may hold an executive session for the specific 
purpose of: 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
30 
(a) Deliberating on a labor contract offer or to formulate a 
counteroffer; or 
(b) Receiving information about a specific employee, when 
the information has a direct bearing on the issues being negotiated 
and a reasonable person would conclude that the release of that 
information would violate that employee’s right to privacy. 
(2) All documentation exchanged between the parties during 
negotiations, including all offers, counteroffers and meeting minutes, shall 
be subject to public writings disclosure laws. 
(3) Any other provision of law notwithstanding, including any 
other provisions to the contrary in sections 33- 402 and 74- 204, Idaho 
Code, the governing body shall post notice of all negotiation sessions at 
the earliest possible time practicable. This shall be done by the governing 
body by immediately posting notice of the negotiation session on the front 
page of its official website. If time permits, the governing body shall also 
post notice within twenty -four (24) hours at its regular meeting physical 
posting locations. 
(4) Public testimony, if any, shall be posted as an agenda item. 
74-207. Open legislative meetings required. All meetings of any 
standing, special or select committee of either house of the legislature of 
the state of Idaho shall be open to the public at all times, except in 
extraordinary circumstances as provided specifically in the rules of 
procedure in either house, and any person may attend any meeting of a 
standing, special or select committee, but may participate in the committee 
only with the approval of the committee itself. 
74-208. Violations. 
(1) If an action, or any deliberation or decision making that leads 
to an action, occurs at any meeting which fails to comply with the 
provisions of this chapter, such action shall be null and void. 
(2) Any member of the governing body governed by the provisions 
of this chapter, who conducts or participates in a meeting which violates 
the provisions of this act shall be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed 
two hundred fifty dollars ($250). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
31 
(3) Any member of a governing body who knowingly violates the 
provisions of this chapter shall be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed 
one thousand five hundred dollars ($1,500). 
(4) Any member of a governing body who knowingly violates any 
provision of this chapter and who has previously admitted to committing 
or has been previously determined to have committed a violation pursuant 
to subsection (3) of this section within the twelve (12) months preceding 
this subsequent violation shall be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed 
two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500). 
(5) The attorney general shall have the duty to enforce this chapter 
in relation to public agencies of state government, and the prosecuting 
attorneys of the various counties shall have the duty to enforce this act in 
relation to local public agencies within their respective jurisdictions. In the 
event that there is reason to believe that a violation of the provisions of this 
act has been committed by members of a board of county commissioners 
or, for any other reason a county prosecuting attorney is deemed 
disqualified from proceeding to enforce this act, the prosecuting attorney 
or board of county commissioners shall seek to have a special prosecutor 
appointed for that purpose as provided in section 31-2603, Idaho Code. 
(6) Any person affected by a violation of the provisions of this 
chapter may commence a civil action in the magistrate division of the 
district court of the county in which the public agency ordinarily meets, 
for the purpose of requiring compliance with provisions of this act. No 
private action brought pursuant to this subsection shall result in the 
assessment of a civil penalty against any member of a public agency and 
there shall be no private right of action for damages arising out of any 
violation of the provisions of this chapter. Any suit brought for the purpose 
of having an action declared or determined to be null and void pursuant to 
subsection (1) of this section shall be commenced within thirty (30) days 
of the time of the decision or action that results, in whole or in part, from 
a meeting that failed to comply with the provisions of this act. Any other 
suit brought under the provisions of this section shall be commenced 
within one hundred eighty (180) days of the time of the violation or alleged 
violation of the provisions of this act. 
(7) [Curing a violation.] 
(a) A violation may be cured by a public agency upon: 
(i) The agency’s self-recognition of a violation; or 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
32 
(ii) Receipt by the secretary or clerk of the public 
agency of written notice of an alleged violation. A 
complaint filed and served upon the public agency may 
be substituted for other forms of written notice. Upon 
notice of an alleged open meeting violation, the 
governing body shall have fourteen (14) days to respond 
publicly and either acknowledge the open meeting 
violation and state an intent to cure the violation or state 
that the public agency has determined that no violation 
has occurred and that no cure is necessary. Failure to 
respond shall be treated as a denial of any violation for 
purposes of proceeding with any enforcement action. 
(b) Following the public agency’ s acknowledgment of a 
violation pursuant to paragraph (a)(i) or (a)(ii) of this subsection, 
the public agency shall have fourteen (14) days to cure the 
violation by declaring that all actions taken at or resulting from 
the meeting in violation of this act void. 
(c) All enforcement actions shall be stayed during the 
response and cure period but may recommence at the discretion 
of the complainant after the cure period has expired. 
(d) A cure as provided in this section shall act as a bar to the 
imposition of the civil penalty provided in subsection (2) of this 
section. A cure of a violation as provided in subsection (7)(a)(i) 
of this section shall act as a bar to the imposition of any civil 
penalty provided in subsection (4) of this section. 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
33 
SUMMARY OF DECISIONS INTERPRETING THE IDAHO 
OPEN MEETING STATUTE 
IDAHO ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE 
REPORTED DECISIONS 
1. Petersen v. Franklin County, 130 Idaho 176, 938 P.2d 1214 (1997) 
(actions that violate Open Meeting Law that are not challenged 
within the time limit established by Idaho Code § 67 -2347(4) are 
not void). 
2. Student Loan Fund of Idaho, Inc. v. Payette County, 125 Idaho 824, 
875 P.2d 236 (Ct. App. 1994) (merely alleging violation of Open 
Meeting Law, without additionally alleging a specific “palpable 
injury,” is insufficient to confer standing). 
3. Gardner v. Evans , 110 Idaho 925, 719 P.2d 1185 (1986) (an 
aggrieved party will not prevail in a claim for improper notice under 
the Open Meeting Law when they cannot demonstrate any 
disadvantage stemming from the deficient notice). 
4. Nelson v. Boundary County, 109 Idaho 205, 706 P.2d 94 (Ct. App. 
1985) (Open Meeting Law’s provisions authorizing executive 
sessions preempt Idaho Code § 31- 713’s requirement that all 
meetings of county commissioners must be public). 
5. Gardner v. School Dist. No. 55, 108 Idaho 434, 700 P.2d 56 (1985). 
6. Baker v. Ind. School Dist. of Emmett, 107 Idaho 608, 691 P.2d 1223 
(1984). 
7. State v. City of Hailey, 102 Idaho 511, 633 P.2d 576 (1981). 
8. Idaho Water Resources Board v. Kramer , 97 Idaho 535, 548 P.2d 
35 (1976). 
9. Nelson v. Boundary County, 109 Idaho 205, 706 P.2d 94 (Ct. App. 
1985). 
10. Idaho Historic Preservation Council v. City Council of Boise , 134 
Idaho 651, 8 P.3d 646 (2000). 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
34 
11. Farrell v. Lemhi County Board of Commissioners, 138 Idaho 378; 
64 P.3d 304 (2002). 
12. State v. Yzaguirre, 144 Idaho 471, 163 P.3d 1183 (2007). 
13. Safe Air For Everyo ne v. Idaho State Dep’t. of Agri ., 145 Idaho 
164, 177 P.3d 378 (2008). 
14. City of McCall v. Buxton, 146 Idaho 656, 201 P.3d 629 (2009). 
15. Idaho Press Club, Inc. v. State Legislature of the State, 142 Idaho 
640, 132 P.3d 397 (2006). 
16. Fox v. Estep, 118 Idaho 454, 797 P.2d 854 (1990). 
17. Acheson v. Klauser , 139 Idaho 156, 75 P.3d 210 (Idaho Ct. App. 
2003). 
18. Noble v. Kootenai County ex rel. Kootenai County Bd. of 
Comm’rs, 148 Idaho 937, 231 P.3d 1034 (2010), reh’g denied (May 
19, 2010). 
 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
35 
UNREPORTED DECISIONS 
(On File with the Office of Attorney General) 
1. Coalition for Responsible Government v. Bonner County, First 
Judicial District, No. CV-97-00107 (1997) 
2. State v. Thorne, et al.; Idaho Fourth Judicial District No. 3L-97763 
(1994). 
3. Playfair v. S. Lemhi Sch. Dist. 292 Bd. of Trustees , CIV. 09-375, 
2010 WL 1138958 (D. Idaho Mar. 20, 2010). 
4. Kline v. Power County Board of Commissioners , Idaho Sixth 
Judicial District No. CV-2011-0248 & CV-2011-0279 (2012). 
ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE ANALYSES 
1. Attorney General Opinion No. 08 -3, 2008 Idaho Att’y Gen. Ann. 
Rpt. 42, 2008 WL 4360202. 
2. Attorney General Opinion 85 -9, 1985 Idaho Att’y Gen. Ann. Rpt. 
50, (December 31, 1985) 1985 WL 167852. 
3. Attorney General Opinion 89 -7, 1989 Idaho Att’y Gen. Ann. Rpt. 
61, 1989 WL 4084. 
 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
36 
State of Idaho 
Office of the Attorney General 
OPEN MEETING LAW CHECKLIST 
Regular Meetings 
Meeting Date and Time: _____________________________________________ 
Meeting Location: _________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________ 
 [Idaho Code § 74-203(4) and (5)] 
 
Before Meeting 
 Meeting Notice posted 5 or more calendar days prior to the meeting date. 
 [Idaho Code § 74-204(1)] 
 Agenda Notice posted at least 48 hours prior to the meeting. 
 [Idaho Code § 74-204(1)] 
 Posting of Amended Agenda [Idaho Code § 74-204(4)] 
 
During Meeting 
 First: Any agenda amendments? [Idaho Code § 74-204(4)(b) and (c)] 
 Secretary or other person appointed to take minutes. 
 [Idaho Code § 74-205(1)] 
 
After Meeting 
 Minutes available to the public within a reasonable time after the meeting. 
 [Idaho Code § 74-205(1)] 
 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
37 
State of Idaho 
Office of the Attorney General 
OPEN MEETING LAW CHECKLIST 
Special Meetings 
Meeting Date and Time: _____________________________________________ 
Meeting Location: _________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________ 
 [Idaho Code § 74-203(4) and (5)] 
 
Before Meeting 
 Meeting and Agenda Notice posted at least 24 hours prior to the meeting. 
[Idaho Code § 74-204(2)] 
 Notification provided to the news media. [Idaho Code § 74-204(2)] 
 Posting of Amended Agenda [Idaho Code § 74-204(4)] 
 
During Meeting 
 First: Any agenda amendments? [Idaho Code § 74-204(4)(b) and (c)] 
 Secretary or other person appointed to take minutes. 
 [Idaho Code § 74-205(1)] 
 
After Meeting 
 Minutes available to the public within a reasonable time after the meeting. 
 [Idaho Code § 74-205(1)] 
 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
38 
State of Idaho 
Office of the Attorney General 
OPEN MEETING LAW CHECKLIST 
Executive Sessions 
Session Date and Time: _____________________________________________ 
Session Location: _________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________ 
 [Idaho Code § 74-203(4) and (5)] 
 
Executive Session Only 
 Meeting and Agenda Notice posted at least 24 hours prior to the session. 
[Idaho Code § 74-204(3)] 
 Posting of Amended Agenda [Idaho Code § 74-204(4)] 
 
Executive Session During Regular or Special Meeting 
 Motion to enter Executive Session to discuss one of the exemptions listed 
in Idaho Code § 74-206. 
 ⅔ vote to enter Executive Session reflected in regular/special meeting 
minutes. [Idaho Code § 74-206(1)] 
 
During Session 
 First: Any agenda amendments? [Idaho Code § 74-204(4)(b) and (c)] 
 Secretary or other person appointed to take minutes. 
 [Idaho Code § 74-205(1)] 
 
After Session 
 Minutes must reference statutory subsection authorizing executive session 
and identify purpose and topic of session. [Idaho Code § 74-205(2)] 
 Minutes available to the public within a reasonable time after the meeting. 
 [Idaho Code § 74-205(1)] 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
39 
>> SAMPLE FORM << 
Public Agency: ________________________________________________ , Idaho 
 (name of county, city, district, etc.) 
Governing Body: ___________________________________________________ 
 (i.e., “Board of County Commissioners”, “City Council”, etc.) 
Meeting Date, Time and Location: ______________________________________ 
EXECUTIVE SESSION MOTION AND ORDER 
 _________________________ (print name), ___________________ (print title), 
MOVES THAT THE BOARD, PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-206, CONVENE 
IN EXECUTIVE SESSION TO: (identify one or more of the following) 
 Consider personnel matters [Idaho Code § 74-206(1)(a) & (b)] 
 Deliberate regarding an acquisition of an interest in real property [Idaho Code § 
74-206(1)(c)] 
 Consider records that are exempt from public disclosure [Idaho Code § 74-
206(1)(d)] 
 Consider preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade or commerce in 
which this governing body is in competition with another governing body [Idaho 
Code § 74-206(1)(e)] 
 Communicate with legal counsel regarding pending/imminently-likely litigation 
[Idaho Code § 74-206(1)(f)] 
 Communicate with risk manager/insurer regarding pending/imminently-likely 
claims [Idaho Code § 74-206(1)(i)] 
 
Purpose/Topic summary (required): ____________________________________ 
AND THE VOTE TO DO SO BY ROLL CALL. 
CONVENE AT: ____________________ ADJOURN AT: __________________ 
 YES NO ABSTAIN 
 _____________________________ , Chair ______ ______ _____ 
 (print name) 
 _____________________________ , Member ______ ______ _____ 
 (print name) 
 _____________________________ , Member ______ ______ _____ 
 (print name) 
Clerk/Deputy Clerk: _________________________________________________ 
 (Signature) 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
40 
>> SAMPLE FORM << 
Public Agency: ________________________________________________ , Idaho 
 (name of county, city, district, etc.) 
Governing Body: ___________________________________________________ 
 (i.e., “Board of County Commissioners”, “City Council”, etc.) 
Meeting Date, Time and Location: ______________________________________ 
MOTION AND ORDER TO AMEND AGENDA 
(less than 48 hours before regular meeting or 24 hours before special meeting) 
 _________________________ (print name), ___________________ (print title), 
MOVES THAT THIS GOVERNING BODY, PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-204, 
AMEND THE AGENDA FOR THIS MEETING AS FOLLOWS: 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
Good faith reason item not included in posted agenda (required): 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
 _________________________________________________________________ 
 YES NO ABSTAIN 
 _____________________________ , Chair ______ ______ _____ 
 (print name) 
 _____________________________ , Member ______ ______ _____ 
 (print name) 
 _____________________________ , Member ______ ______ _____ 
 (print name) 
Clerk/Deputy Clerk: _________________________________________________ 
 (Signature) 
Idaho Open Meeting Law Manual 
 
 
41 
Curing Process – Idaho Code § 74-208(7)