Records requests: faults found
How Twin Falls handles public records requests, and where it falls short of state law
Idaho's Public Records Act says what a denial must contain, sets deadlines, and requires an agency to release the parts of a record that aren't exempt. It also sets one standard for every request. Below, each requirement is quoted or closely paraphrased from the statute and set against what happened. Last comes how to file a request so these problems can't stall it.
Filing a request with Twin Falls? State law says every request "shall" include the items below. The City's form doesn't ask for the last one, so add it yourself.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 4)
Open source · All sources
- your name, mailing address, email and phone
- a written declaration, under oath, of whether you're an Idaho residentIdaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 4)
Open source · All sourcesIdaho Code § 9-1406: a declaration under penalty of perjury has the same effect as a sworn statement
Open source · All sources
The City has denied requests under this rule, giving the name and address, or doubts about who the requester is, as the reason.Finding E-22: The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others
Open source · All sources How to file · Residency declaration (PDF, sign on screen)
The short version
- The City applies the requester rules to some requests and not others, and its own form doesn't ask for everything it has denied requests over. The same incomplete details were accepted on one request and grounds for denial on the next.Finding E-22: The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others
Open source · All sources - Denial notices leave out what the law says they must contain: a statement about attorney review and, in several cases, the right to appeal.Finding E-12: PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor "proprietary"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement
Open source · All sourcesFinding E-21: Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking
Open source · All sources - One request got an extension notice and then nothing, which the law treats as a denial.Finding E-20: Request #4940 unanswered for more than 20 working days - deemed denied by law
Open source · All sources - Records were left out of responses without a denial, and exempt personal information was released.Finding E-11: 2015 City Manager Service Agreement exists but was not produced to PRR #4869
Open source · All sourcesFinding E-14: PRR #4814/#4940: Finance request answered with HR payroll registers; AP reimbursements not produced
Open source · All sourcesEX-A24: Executive status changes and offer letters 2020-2025
Open source · All sources
Faults found
| What the law requires | What happened |
|---|---|
| One standard for every request. Every person has a right to examine public records.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 1) Open source · All sources Since July 1, 2025, a request "shall" provide the requester's name, mailing address, email address, telephone number, and a written declaration "attesting or affirming under oath" whether the requester is an Idaho resident.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 4) Open source · All sources The statute makes no exceptions. It doesn't say what an agency must do with a request that leaves something out. |
The City's records page says every request "must include this form, pursuant to City policy."City of Twin Falls, Make a Public Records Request (tfid.org) Open source · All sources The form requires a street address, city, state, ZIP code, phone number and email along with the name. It has no place at all for the residency declaration.City of Twin Falls online public records request form (forms.tfid.org) Open source · All sourcesFinding E-22: The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others Open source · All sources Request #3946 came in on that form with every item the form requires, street address and phone included.EX-C01-12: Requester's copy of the submitted request form (May 31, 2026) Open source · All sources It had no residency declaration, because the form doesn't ask for one, and the City worked on it from May into September without raising that.Finding E-22: The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others Open source · All sources The copies of submitted forms that the City saves, and released to us, leave out the street address and phone on every request: the fields are blank, or on #3946 missing altogether, though the requester's copy of that same submission shows both filled in. Those copies don't show what a requester actually entered.EX-C01-1: Request form Open source · All sourcesEX-C02-1: Request form Open source · All sourcesEX-C01-12: Requester's copy of the submitted request form (May 31, 2026) Open source · All sources On Sept 24, 2026 the City denied the same requester's next request, filed the same way, "for failure to comply with Idaho Code 74-102(4)," the requirement "to state the requestor's name and address."Finding E-22: The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others Open source · All sources That request also gave a name, mailing address, email and phone on the form, which requires them; the City's saved copy shows the address field blank. What it lacked was the residency declaration, which the denial didn't mention.EX-C02-1: Request form Open source · All sourcesEX-C02-2: Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments) Open source · All sources Other requests, also filed without a sworn declaration, were processed, or denied on other grounds.Finding E-20: Request #4940 unanswered for more than 20 working days - deemed denied by law Open source · All sourcesFinding E-21: Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking Open source · All sources The statute holds every request to the same standard. The City has enforced it on some requests and not others.Finding E-22: The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others Open source · All sources The law lets the City insist on all five items. If it does, its form should ask for all five and refuse a request that leaves one out, rather than accepting the request and denying it later. |
| Requests by email. "A request for public records and delivery of the public records may be made by electronic mail." An agency "may require" that a request be in writing and describe the records sought.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 4) Open source · All sources |
The City's page says its own form is required "pursuant to City policy."City of Twin Falls, Make a Public Records Request (tfid.org) Open source · All sources The statute allows a request by email and doesn't mention an agency form. It doesn't say outright that an agency can't require one either. |
| What a denial notice must say. A denial or partial denial must be in writing. The notice "shall state" either that the agency's attorney reviewed the request, or that the agency had the chance to consult an attorney and chose not to. It must also "indicate the statutory authority for the denial" and "indicate clearly" the right to appeal and the time limit.Idaho Code § 74-103 (subsections 4-5) Open source · All sources The Attorney General's view is that the only legitimate reason not to consult an attorney is that the exemption is clear, and the denial letter should say so.EX-D01: Idaho AG Public Records Law Manual (Question 30) Open source · All sources |
Three denials of requests for executives' leave records each said only that the records "are exempt from production under Idaho Code Section 74-106(1)." That cites a statute, but none of the three says anything about attorney review or the right to appeal. The third added, "Per our City Attorney, please stop requesting the same information."Finding E-21: Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking Open source · All sources The Sept 24 denial cited 74-102(4) with no attorney statement and no appeal rights.Finding E-22: The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others Open source · All sources The #3946 completion notice gave appeal rights but didn't say anything had been withheld. The statute behind the withholding came later, in a Deputy Clerk's email.Finding E-12: PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor "proprietary"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement Open source · All sources |
| Silence is a denial. For an Idaho resident, an agency "shall either grant or deny" within 3 working days. If it needs longer, it must say so in writing and provide the records within 10 working days of the request. For a non-resident, the limits are 21 days, or 35 days with a written notice. If the agency "fails to respond within the time allotted," the request "shall be deemed to be denied."Idaho Code § 74-103 (subsections 2-3) Open source · All sources |
Request #4940 was filed Oct 5, 2026. The City sent an extension notice the next day, then nothing: no records, no denial, and no reply to five follow-ups. As of Nov 10, 2026 it was past both the resident limit (10 working days) and the non-resident limit (35 days).Finding E-20: Request #4940 unanswered for more than 20 working days - deemed denied by law Open source · All sources |
| Release what isn't exempt. When a record holds both exempt and nonexempt material, the agency "shall" separate them and make the nonexempt material available.Idaho Code § 74-112 Open source · All sources The trade-secret exemption covers information that both gets independent economic value from not being generally known and is kept secret by reasonable efforts.Idaho Code § 74-107 (subsection 1) Open source · All sources Nothing in the statute exempts material just because a vendor calls it "proprietary." |
On #3946, 109 of 117 items were withheld under 74-107(1). Staff wrote that the City Attorney "agreed that proprietary information is excluded from the public records act," that they "didn't know enough about the project to differentiate" HUB's material from the City's, and that Human Resources "worked with our agent from HUB" to decide what to release.Finding E-12: PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor "proprietary"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement Open source · All sources The City's own emails and data aren't the vendor's trade secrets. |
| Every responsive record, released or denied. Every person has a right to examine public records, and a denial or partial denial must be in writing.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 1) Open source · All sourcesIdaho Code § 74-103 (subsection 4) Open source · All sources |
A request for every version of the City Manager's agreement didn't produce the 2015 agreement the Council approved in public. The City neither denied it nor said it no longer had it.Finding E-11: 2015 City Manager Service Agreement exists but was not produced to PRR #4869 Open source · All sources The City said travel reimbursements "will therefore appear on separate reports," then neither provided those reports nor denied them.Finding E-14: PRR #4814/#4940: Finance request answered with HR payroll registers; AP reimbursements not produced Open source · All sources |
| What counts as a public record. Any writing about the public's business that the agency prepares, owns, uses or retains.Idaho Code § 74-101 (subsection 13) Open source · All sources |
The City twice denied a request for copies of past records requests as "not a record that is held." Three days later it produced 1,183 of them, with no fee.Finding E-13: City twice said it does not hold copies of records requests, then produced 1,183 of them three days later Open source · All sources |
| Personal information stays private. An employee's home address and telephone number "shall not be disclosed to the public without the employee's or applicant's written consent."Idaho Code § 74-106 (subsection 1) Open source · All sources |
In answering request #4729, the City released executives' offer letters and status-change forms that show their home street addresses. Nothing in the response shows the employees' consent.EX-A24: Executive status changes and offer letters 2020-2025 Open source · All sources This is the same section the City cited three times to deny requests for leave records.Finding E-21: Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking Open source · All sources Before posting, we blacked out home addresses, personal phone numbers and personal email addresses. Names, titles and pay stay readable, because the law makes them public. |
Checked, and not counted as faults on their own
- The form's gaps by themselves. The law puts the duty to include the five items on the person making the request ("A request shall also provide ..."), not on the agency's form. The form becomes a problem when the City denies requests over what the form never asked for, as above.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 4)
Open source · All sources - Denying leave and hours-worked records. The personnel section makes public an employee's "gross salary and salary history, including bonuses, severance packages, other compensation," along with a few other items. Leave usage and hours worked aren't on that list, so the denials have a plausible legal basis. Sell-back payments are compensation, and they appear in the payroll registers the City did release. We count only how the denials were written.Idaho Code § 74-106 (subsection 1)
Open source · All sourcesFinding E-21: Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking
Open source · All sources - How long #3946 took. Records came 31 days after filing. That's past the resident limit, but the request had no residency declaration, so the non-resident limit (35 days) may apply. The City also says it was waiting for the requester to agree to an attorney-review fee, and the law lets an agency require payment in advance.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 12)
Open source · All sourcesFinding E-12: PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor "proprietary"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement
Open source · All sources - Questions about who a requester is. The law cuts both ways here. A custodian "shall make no inquiry" of a requester except for listed reasons. Verifying identity is allowed only "in accordance with section 74-113," the section on people asking for records about themselves. But 74-102(4) also requires every request to include the requester's contact details and a residency declaration. Asking for those is asking for what the law already requires, even though the City's own form doesn't collect all of it.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsections 4-5)
Open source · All sourcesIdaho Code § 74-113
Open source · All sourcesFinding E-15: PRR #4953 denial turned on requester identity/residency (legally mixed)
Open source · All sources
Being watched: in-person pickup for a few documents (#5290)
Request #5290, filed Nov 18, 2026, asked for every version of the City Manager's employment agreement since October 2014, any written amendments, and the new City Attorney's agreement, as electronic copies by email.EX-C14-1: Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 18, 2026)
Open source · All sources The City's request form says, "Requested records will be provided electronically."EX-C14-1: Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 18, 2026)
Open source · All sources That afternoon a Deputy City Clerk wrote that the City Attorney had reviewed the request and the City would grant access, but "due to the substantial volume of records requested, the documents will be made available for in-person pickup at the City Clerk's Office." No date was given.EX-C14-2: Correspondence with the City, Nov 18-19 2026 - pickup only, then a sworn declaration
Open source · All sources
- What the law says. "A request for public records and delivery of the public records may be made by electronic mail," and nothing in the law prevents an agency from providing electronic copies.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsections 4, 15)
Open source · All sources The law doesn't say outright that an agency must email records, so we don't count this as a fault yet. - The size. The request names a handful of contract documents. The City has emailed far larger responses, including 1,183 records requests in one response, at no fee.Finding E-13: City twice said it does not hold copies of records requests, then produced 1,183 of them three days later
Open source · All sources - The effect. Pickup-only means anyone who doesn't live near City Hall has to travel to collect a few documents the City could send by email, as its own form promises.
- When it becomes a fault. If the City holds to pickup-only without a written reason the law supports, or doesn't provide the records within 3 working days (10 with written notice).Idaho Code § 74-103 (subsections 2-4)
Open source · All sources We'll update this section either way.
Request #3946: what was released, and what the City said
This request asked for records, including internal email, about the City's compensation market analysis. The City released 8 of 117 items on July 1, 2026. The completion notice gave appeal rights but didn't say anything had been withheld. On July 13 a Deputy Clerk wrote that the other 109 were "statutorily excluded from release by Idaho Code Section 74-107(1)," the trade-secret exemption, after the City Attorney "agreed that proprietary information is excluded."Finding E-12: PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor "proprietary"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement
Open source · All sources Whether the City's records systems show what happened to the responsive records between collection and release is the subject of a pending records request.
How to file so a request can't be stalled
The short version is below. The full Idaho guide covers costs, exemptions and appeals step by step.
- Say plainly that it's a public records request, and send it to the records custodian the City names on its public records page.City of Twin Falls, Make a Public Records Request (tfid.org)
Open source · All sources The law says a request "must clearly indicate that it is a public records request," and an agency has no obligation to answer one that doesn't, or that isn't sent to the custodian.Idaho Code § 74-103 (subsection 1)
Open source · All sources Opening with "Public records request under the Idaho Public Records Act, Idaho Code 74-101 et seq." covers it. - Include everything the law requires, even where the City's form doesn't ask: name, mailing address, email, phone, and the residency declaration.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 4)
Open source · All sources Our fillable declaration uses the wording Idaho law accepts in place of a sworn statement, so no notary is needed.Idaho Code § 9-1406: a declaration under penalty of perjury has the same effect as a sworn statement
Open source · All sources A drawn or typed signature ("/s/ Your Name") counts as a signature under Idaho's electronic signature law.Idaho Code § 28-50-107: an electronic signature satisfies a law requiring a signature
Open source · All sources Or paste the text version into your email. - Be specific: describe the records in enough detail that the City can find them "with reasonable effort," including a date range.Idaho Code § 74-102 (subsection 4)
Open source · All sources - Track the deadlines. For an Idaho resident, the City must grant or deny within 3 working days, or, after a written notice that it needs more time, provide the records within 10 working days of the request. For non-residents it's 21 days, or 35 with notice. No answer in time is a denial.Idaho Code § 74-103 (subsections 2-3)
Open source · All sources - Check every denial for three things: the statutory authority, a statement about attorney review, and your right to appeal with its time limit. If any is missing, say so in writing.Idaho Code § 74-103 (subsections 4-5)
Open source · All sources - Appeal if needed. You can petition the district court in the county where the records are. The deadline is 180 days from the date the denial notice was mailed. The AG reads a deemed denial as starting the same clock.Idaho Code § 74-115
Open source · All sourcesEX-D01: Idaho AG Public Records Law Manual (Question 27)
Open source · All sources The court awards costs and attorney fees to the winning side if it finds the refusal, or the request, was "frivolously pursued."Idaho Code § 74-116 (subsection 2)
Open source · All sources An official who "deliberately and in bad faith improperly refused a legitimate request" can be fined up to $1,000.Idaho Code § 74-117
Open source · All sources - Send us what you get. Your request, the City's replies and the records help document how the City responds. Submit them here.
Quoted phrases are from Idaho Code Title 74, chapter 1, as amended through 2026. The linked statutes are the official text. This is not legal advice.
Sources
Numbers in the text open a note with a link. State law links go to the official text, which always shows the law currently in force.
- Idaho Code § 74-102
- Idaho Code § 9-1406: a declaration under penalty of perjury has the same effect as a sworn statement
- Finding E-22: The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others
- Finding E-12: PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor "proprietary"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement
- Finding E-21: Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking
- Finding E-20: Request #4940 unanswered for more than 20 working days - deemed denied by law
- Finding E-11: 2015 City Manager Service Agreement exists but was not produced to PRR #4869
- Finding E-14: PRR #4814/#4940: Finance request answered with HR payroll registers; AP reimbursements not produced
- EX-A24: Executive status changes and offer letters 2020-2025
- City of Twin Falls, Make a Public Records Request (tfid.org)
- City of Twin Falls online public records request form (forms.tfid.org)
- EX-C01-12: Requester's copy of the submitted request form (May 31, 2026)
- EX-C01-1: Request form
- EX-C02-1: Request form
- EX-C02-2: Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)
- Idaho Code § 74-103
- EX-D01: Idaho AG Public Records Law Manual
- Idaho Code § 74-112
- Idaho Code § 74-107
- Idaho Code § 74-101
- Finding E-13: City twice said it does not hold copies of records requests, then produced 1,183 of them three days later
- Idaho Code § 74-106
- Idaho Code § 74-113
- Finding E-15: PRR #4953 denial turned on requester identity/residency (legally mixed)
- EX-C14-1: Requester's copy of the submitted request form (Nov 18, 2026)
- EX-C14-2: Correspondence with the City, Nov 18-19 2026 - pickup only, then a sworn declaration
- Idaho Code § 28-50-107: an electronic signature satisfies a law requiring a signature
- Idaho Code § 74-115
- Idaho Code § 74-116
- Idaho Code § 74-117