OversightArchive
All jurisdictions

Independent · Anonymous · Built on public records

Public business belongs to the public.

Oversight Archive collects official records from local and state governments, reads them against the rules officials must follow, and publishes what they show. Every claim links to the record and page it comes from.

Jurisdictions
1
Findings
31
Records posted
137
Meetings indexed
546
About Who we are and how we work Where our records come from, how findings are graded, and how to check a file yourself. The cases and research behind the site are in The full story. About Oversight Archive →

Why every taxpayer should care

More numbers, with sources →

89%

of Americans say corruption is widespread in government, a record high, including 83% of Republicans, 91% of Democrats and 90% of independents.Gallup, 2026

Half

as many local officials convicted of federal corruption crimes as a decade ago: 121 in 2023, down from 252 in 2014. Less is caught by prosecutors, so more depends on people checking the records.U.S. Justice Department

47%

of fraud cases inside government organizations happened at the local level, more than at the state (23%) or national (29%) level. More than half involved corruption: bribery, conflicts of interest or kickbacks.Fraud examiners (ACFE), 2024

44%

of fraud in government is first uncovered by a tip, more than by audits or any other method, and more than half of all tips come from employees. That is why our tip line is anonymous.ACFE, 2024, 2026

Bars show each topic's findings by grade: Documented Indicated Open question · What the grades mean

Executive Pay & Leave

How senior officials' pay, leave sell-backs, deferred compensation, stipends and retention payments are set, and who authorizes them.

12 findings · 39 records

12 documented

Open Meetings

Votes, executive sessions and open meeting laws: what governing bodies decide in public and what they don't.

3 findings · 17 records

3 indicated

Public Records Compliance

How agencies answer public records requests: deadlines, denials, missing records and identity challenges.

8 findings · 45 records

4 documented · 4 indicated

Financial Transparency

Whether residents can see how public money is spent: payment lists, credit card reports, budgets, financial reports and audits.

2 findings · 11 records

2 documented

Contracts & Ethics

Procurement, consultants, and conflicts of interest in votes on contracts.

2 findings · 12 records

2 documented

Workplace Conduct & HR Independence

How public employers handle harassment, retaliation and complaints, and whether people who report problems can reach someone outside the chain of command they're reporting about.

3 findings · 13 records

3 documented

Conflicts With State Law

Local ordinances, resolutions, policies and council actions that conflict with state law. Cities may only adopt rules that are not in conflict with the general laws of the state (Idaho Constitution art. XII, sec. 2; I.C. 50-302); where they conflict, state law controls.

0 findings · 0 records

Federal Questions

Whether federal money or federal limits are involved. Open questions are listed with the records that would settle them.

1 finding · 3 records

1 open question

Documented findings

All 31 findings →
Twin Falls, Idaho E-01Documented

Vacation sell-back cap "lifted" for the City Manager by Mayor letter; no Council vote located

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law

Public moneyUnequal treatmentHidden decisions

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · State law · 11 exhibits

Twin Falls, Idaho E-02Documented

Over-cap sell-backs 2016-2021, made before the required regular vacation was used, with no authority located

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law

Public moneyUnequal treatment

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · State law · 8 exhibits

Twin Falls, Idaho E-03Documented

City Manager raises 2016-2025 set outside any located open-session vote

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state law

Hidden decisionsPublic money

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · State law · 16 exhibits

Twin Falls, Idaho E-04Documented

Employer retirement and deferred compensation paid before it appears in any Council-approved document

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law

Public moneyHidden decisions

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · State law · Federal · 8 exhibits

Twin Falls, Idaho E-07Documented

Contract amendment procedure not followed (single-signature letters)

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract

Hidden decisionsPublic money

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · 4 exhibits

Twin Falls, Idaho E-08Documented

$2,500 Deputy City Manager stipend described as Council-authorized; no vote located

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state law

Hidden decisionsPublic money

Executive Pay & Leave · State law · 10 exhibits

How to read a finding

  • Documented The agency's own records show it directly.
  • Indicated Consistent records strongly suggest it, but a key record is still missing.
  • Open question A gap that needs records before anyone draws a conclusion.

Every finding also names the rule at stake (federal law, state law, state ethics law, or the City Code, City policy and contracts) and why it matters (how the labels work).

Every finding says which rule the records show was not followed and why it matters. Before publishing, we test the innocent explanations against the records. Missing records can clear people as easily as they can implicate them.

Latest on the timeline

  1. The City website's site map lists no accounts payable, check register, monthly financial report or financial dashboard. Its Finance links are the City Budget, the Master Fee Schedule and building permit fees. · Twin Falls, Idaho
  2. Three days after denying it holds copies of records requests, the City delivers 1,183 of them (#5162), three hours after writing that it would take IT "days" and "a large charge" · Twin Falls, Idaho
  3. Request #5061 for copies of records requests denied: "not a record that is held" · Twin Falls, Idaho
  4. Request #4953 denied for "non-compliance with 74-102(4)"; City Attorney questions the requester's identity · Twin Falls, Idaho
  5. Request #4940 passes 10 working days with no response: deemed denied by law · Twin Falls, Idaho
  6. $900,000 change order with Suburban Construction; Council Member Pierce makes the motion, 6-0 · Twin Falls, Idaho

Full timeline →