OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

Findings: Twin Falls, Idaho

31 numbered findings, each tied to the records that support it, the rule it is measured against, and the explanation the agency could give.

E-25Documented

Mayor (later Council Member) Pierce acted on seven Suburban Construction items after stating on the record that she does accounting for the firm; no later recusal or disclosure is recorded

Rule at stake: Possibly federal law

Conflict of interestPublic money

Contracts & Ethics · Local policy · State law · Federal · 8 exhibits

E-11Documented

2015 City Manager Service Agreement exists but was not produced to PRR #4869

Rule at stake: State law

Records access

Public Records Compliance · State law · 4 exhibits

E-12Documented

PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor "proprietary"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement

Rule at stake: State law

Records accessHidden decisions

Public Records Compliance · 10 exhibits

E-13Documented

City twice said it does not hold copies of records requests, then produced 1,183 of them three days later

Rule at stake: State law

Records accessUnequal treatment

Public Records Compliance · 9 exhibits

E-20Documented

Request #4940 unanswered for more than 20 working days - deemed denied by law

Rule at stake: State law

Records accessWasted time

Public Records Compliance · State law · 2 exhibits

E-14Indicated

PRR #4814/#4940: Finance request answered with HR payroll registers; AP reimbursements not produced

Rule at stake: State law

Financial transparencyPublic moneyRecords access

Public Records Compliance · 12 exhibits

E-21Indicated

Three requests for leave and sell-back records denied within 16 to 69 minutes, with an instruction to stop asking

Rule at stake: State law

Records access

Public Records Compliance · 6 exhibits

E-03Documented

City Manager raises 2016-2025: all but one set outside any located open-session vote

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state law

Hidden decisionsPublic money

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · State law · 16 exhibits

E-08Documented

$2,500 Deputy City Manager stipend described as Council-authorized; no vote located

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state law

Hidden decisionsPublic money

Executive Pay & Leave · State law · 10 exhibits

E-36Documented

Departments spent more than the Council appropriated in each of fiscal years 2022 to 2025, including the Council's own budget three years running; the audit note that used to disclose this stopped appearing in 2022

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state law

Public moneyFinancial transparency

Executive Pay & Leave · State law · 0 exhibits

E-05Indicated

Pay directions follow "evaluation" executive sessions (2018-2025)

Rule at stake: Possibly state law

Hidden decisions

Open Meetings · State law · 15 exhibits

E-06Indicated

The "performance review committee" was publicly created once (2014) and never again

Rule at stake: Possibly state law

Hidden decisions

Open Meetings · State law · 8 exhibits

E-15Indicated

PRR #4953 denial turned on requester identity/residency (legally mixed)

Rule at stake: Possibly state law

Unequal treatmentRecords access

Public Records Compliance · 4 exhibits

E-17Indicated

Closed sessions added to the agenda after the meeting began, at the City Manager's request, with no reason recorded (three times in 2017)

Rule at stake: Possibly state law

Hidden decisions

Open Meetings · State law · 1 exhibit

E-22Indicated

The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others

Rule at stake: Possibly state law

Unequal treatmentRecords access

Public Records Compliance · 23 exhibits

E-01Documented

Mayor's letter lifted the vacation sell-back cap for the City Manager; no Council vote located

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law

Public moneyUnequal treatmentHidden decisions

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · State law · 11 exhibits

E-02Documented

Over-cap sell-backs 2016-2021, made before the required regular vacation was used, with no authority located

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law

Public moneyUnequal treatment

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · State law · 8 exhibits

E-04Documented

Employer retirement and deferred compensation paid before it appears in any Council-approved document

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract; possibly state ethics law

Public moneyHidden decisions

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · State law · Federal · 8 exhibits

E-07Documented

Pay changes made by letters signed by one person, not the signed amendment the agreement requires

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract

Hidden decisionsPublic money

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · 4 exhibits

E-23Documented

Deputy City Manager sold vacation twice in fiscal year 2024

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract

Public moneyUnequal treatment

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · 2 exhibits

E-31Documented

The Council promised in 2013-2014 to post accounts payable, monthly financial reports and a financial dashboard on the City website. None is posted, and no record shows the promise was withdrawn.

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract

Financial transparencyRecords accessHidden decisionsPublic money

Financial Transparency · Local policy · State law · 14 exhibits

E-32Documented

The Council approves the City's credit card spending every month, but the report it approves is not in the public meeting packet.

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract

Financial transparencyRecords accessPublic money

Financial Transparency · State law · 4 exhibits

E-35Documented

A Veterans Day holiday was paid on top of a full 80 hours of regular pay for the City Manager in November 2024; no reversal appears in his payroll register through May 2026

Rule at stake: City code, policy or contract

Public money

Executive Pay & Leave · 2 exhibits

E-24Documented

Executive leave: a paid-leave benefit for the leadership team that appears in individual agreements but in no Employee Handbook

Rule at stake: Possibly City code, policy or contract

Unequal treatmentHidden decisions

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · 5 exhibits

E-26Documented

A Deputy City Manager submitted and then approved, as both "City Manager" and HR, pay changes for an employee she supervises

Rule at stake: Possibly City code, policy or contract

Hidden decisionsPublic money

Workplace Conduct & HR Independence · Local policy · 5 exhibits

E-09Documented

The City Manager took part in the Council-approved Employee Retention Program and the citywide one-time payouts, as his agreement extends employee benefits to him (context)

Rule at stake: Context

Executive Pay & Leave · 8 exhibits

E-10Documented

Handbook changes were delegated to the City Manager in 2018 (explains the 160->200 hr cap change)

Rule at stake: Context

Hidden decisions

Executive Pay & Leave · Local policy · 2 exhibits

E-18Documented

The City budgeted $65,000 for a compensation study and told the Council it would keep pay market competitive. Results existed by March 2026 and were shared with executives as confidential; none appears in any Council record

Rule at stake: Open question

Records accessPublic moneyFinancial transparency

Contracts & Ethics · 5 exhibits

E-27Documented

In Dec 2021 the City Manager set the Deputy City Manager salaries as a percentage "variance" from his own pay; his later raises did not carry that link forward (context)

Rule at stake: Context

Conflict of interest

Workplace Conduct & HR Independence · 4 exhibits

E-28Documented

A former council member's hire as Economic Development Director was handled in public; his HR records list a 2012 hire date

Rule at stake: Context

Workplace Conduct & HR Independence · 8 exhibits

E-19Open question

Deferred compensation amount vs. IRS annual limits (question only)

Rule at stake: Open question

Public money

Federal Questions · Federal · 3 exhibits