E-26 Documented · A (form approval history) / C (whether the City Manager delegated the step)
A Deputy City Manager submitted and then approved, as both "City Manager" and HR, pay changes for an employee she supervises
Rule at stake: Possibly City code, policy or contract how findings are ranked
City of Twin Falls · Policy / internal control (handbook special-arrangement clause; approval steps)
Why it matters
Separation of duties means the person asking for a pay change isn't the person approving it. When one person signs as requester, City Manager and HR, there is no check at all.
What the records show
Employee Status Change records for the HR Director (supervisor listed: Deputy City Manager Scott). Oct 2, 2023 (promotion to Acting HR Director, grade 11 to 17, $54.60/hr): "Submit by Gretchen Scott" 9:42:54 AM; "City Manager Approves by Gretchen Scott" 9:43:35 AM; "HR Approves by Gretchen Scott" 9:44:11 AM (77 seconds in all). Oct 31, 2025 (raise to $73.00/hr, "105% of market in grade 17 for completing 7 years"): submit 10:00:44 AM, City Manager approval 10:05:41 AM, HR approval 10:06:16 AM, all by Gretchen Scott. By contrast, the City Manager himself approved the City Manager step on Scott's own promotion (Dec 14, 2021) and on the HR Director's Dec 2023 promotion, and a different HR employee approved the HR step on two of the Economic Development Director's 2023 forms (Feb and Apr 2023). Hourly-rate history: $37.74 (Oct 13, 2023), $54.60 (Oct 27, 2023), $65.51 (Dec 22, 2023) - [Deduction] a 73.6% increase in about ten weeks, through two promotions.
Rule it is measured against
Every handbook since 2021: no one other than the City Manager may provide special arrangements on terms of employment, and they must be in writing. The status-change form has a separate City Manager approval step ("City Manager Approves" in its action history). [Deduction] When the submitter completes the City Manager and HR steps herself, the form loses the independent review those steps exist to provide. The City's written Financial Policies apply the same principle elsewhere: utility staff may not "open, close or enter any activity to their own account(s)" (Policy VII-c), cash handling requires "Segregation of duties - authorization, recordation, custodian functions, and reconciliation" (Policy III-c), and each senior staff member is responsible for seeing that internal control procedures are followed in their department (Policy I-c). [Our reading] A pay form approved at every step by the person who submitted it falls short of the separation the City requires of its clerks. The accounting manual the City posts with those policies: "One person should not be able to authorize a transaction, record the transaction in accounting records and maintain custody of the assets resulting from the transaction" (p82).
What would change this finding
The October 2023 pay itself matches a City Manager letter (EX-A28). This finding would change if the City Manager had delegated his approval step to the Deputy City Manager in writing before October 2023.
We aren't alleging that anyone acted in bad faith. A record made at the time could explain what's shown here. If the agency holds one that it didn't produce in answer to an earlier request, it can still release it, and we'll update this finding. A record made now carries today's date.
Records
- EX-A24 Executive status changes and offer letters 2020-2025 · PRR #4729 ↓
- EX-A26 History of hourly rates (spreadsheet) · PRR #4729 ↓
- EX-A28 2023-10-02 City Manager letter installing Acting HR Director (grade 17, $4,368 biweekly) · PRR #4729 ↓
- EX-A29 2023-12-01 City Manager promotional letter - HR Director (five years of service credited) · PRR #4729 ↓
- EX-B39 2023-12-04 minutes - Council confirms HR Director appointment 7-0 · Council minutes ↓
One file with a plain-text summary of this finding (what the records show, the rule, what we checked, what would change it), 5 records, their SHA-256 fingerprints (checked in your browser as the zip is made) and where each record came from.
Records asked for
Requests already made that bear on this finding:
- Request #4729: ELT compensation records FY21-FY26 (filed 2026-08 (approx.)). Produced HR documents
More records that could explain this finding, show that it was authorized, or change it have been identified, and requests for them are planned. Each is listed here once it is filed.
A complete answer depends on the agency responding to these requests as the Idaho Public Records Act requires.
How to read this finding
This page states what the records obtained so far show and the rule they are measured against. Its grade says how firmly the records show it, "Rule at stake" says what kind of rule is involved, and the labels under "Why it matters" say who bears the cost (more on the three labels). It is not an accusation, not a legal conclusion and not the whole story. A record we don't have could explain what is shown here or add to it, and we update a finding when new records arrive. Citations to a recording link to that moment in the audio. Transcripts and the searchable text of scanned documents are made by software, so listen or open the file before you quote. If this finding concerns you, ask the governing body to answer it in public, or ask an office with the authority to investigate.
Tell the City Council
The City Council answers to residents, and you don't have to attend a meeting to be heard. Send a written comment through the City's own public comment form, or write to members directly (addresses on the City's site). Point them to this finding and its records so they can check for themselves.
A starting point to put in your own words
I'm writing about a matter shown in the City's own records: A Deputy City Manager submitted and then approved, as both "City Manager" and HR, pay changes for an employee she supervises (Oversight Archive E-26). The records are at https://oversightarchive.org/twin-falls-id/findings/e-26/. I'm asking the City Council to [explain in an open meeting how this was decided / place it on a public agenda / tell residents which policy applies].
This is not anonymous. Comments sent to the City become public records. They can be shared in a meeting packet and released to anyone who asks, and the form may ask for your name and address. If you'd rather not be identified, use our tip line instead.
Who to contact: the City staff directory published by the City of Twin Falls. The City's own list of departments and staff, with phone numbers and email addresses. It isn't dated and may be out of date in places, so confirm with the office before relying on a name or title.
The City Council can act only on items on a posted agenda (upcoming meetings), so asking for a matter to be placed on one is often the most useful request. Your own words carry more weight than a copied letter. Stick to what the records show. More ways to take part: Make a difference.