City Council meeting
Monday, July 18, 2022
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: c,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:02:16 Are you guys ready?
0:02:18 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the July 18, 2022 City Council meeting.
0:02:26 I want to confirm we have a quorum.
0:02:27 We have six members present in chambers and Councilman Hawkins is excused tonight.
0:02:35 The first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:02:38 If you wish to join me, please rise.
0:02:41 Acclamations tonight, so we'll move right on to the consent calendar
0:03:14 Thank you, it's a second
0:03:18 I'm a motion by chris for read second by chon bierger to
0:03:22 Approve the consent calendar as written
0:03:26 Aaron rocov. Oh, please mayor pierce. Yes. Nice. Mary. Yes
0:03:32 Sean bierger. Yes. Nikki boyd. Yes. Jason brown. Yes. That's your color. Yes. Thank you motion passes
0:03:40 If you were here for the final plan for Washington Fire Station subdivision, the Twin Falls Library
0:03:48 Read and Treat, Arm Bureau Magic Valley District Picnic and a Bench Donation on Canyon Room
0:03:56 Trail, we've approved all those and you're welcome to stay or you can, next item on the
0:04:03 agenda is a presentation under items of consideration, HIDO Power Presentation of Energy Efficiency
0:04:11 Incentive check to the city of Munfals, and we have our staff engineer, Lee Glesman.
0:04:17 Welcome, Lee.
0:04:18 Good evening, Mayor and Council.
0:04:20 I'd hope Power has an Energy Incentive program that whenever you construct a project that
0:04:29 utilizes energy efficiency, that they will actually provide incentive checks.
0:04:34 A city of Twin Falls built the PRI P.I. station a couple of years ago.
0:04:40 incentive for that is 21,579 dollars. We're saving about 119,000 kilowatt
0:04:47 hours a year. I'm sad. I've worked and said it was about 8,000 dollars of actual energy savings from Chris.
0:04:56 Chris, did you? This is Chris Bell with Idaho Power and wealth since.
0:05:14 And we have a check. Awesome. Thank you.
0:06:11 So, we've had our programs for a few years now.
0:06:14 When I was going back and looking at the history of the City of Twin Falls
0:06:18 and it looks like you guys have saved about a little over 8 million kilowatt hours
0:06:22 with incentives for animal power and we've given about 865,000 dollars to the city.
0:06:28 Oh, thank you for using our programs. It's nice to see that the Tax Fairs of Guelker
0:06:34 represented you guys are being efficient with the dollars that you have.
0:06:38 So thank you so much. Thank you very much. Thank you Lee.
0:06:44 Okay. Yes, please. In fact, the drive-thru is still open if you want. Okay, so the next item on the agenda is an action item.
0:06:55 A request to amend city code 1-2-4 to add the economic development director to the list of department heads. Sean Berger.
0:07:06 Thank you, Mayor.
0:07:07 So before the Council addresses this item,
0:07:10 I would like to disclose that I have a real
0:07:15 or potential conflict of interest related to this item
0:07:20 because my official action may result in steps toward
0:07:25 private benefit to me in the future.
0:07:27 As if this item moves forward,
0:07:30 this is a position that I think I would consider applying
0:07:33 for so I'm gonna step down through this discussion
0:07:35 Go ahead, Mitch.
0:07:40 As you know, Council, we have had a vacant position at the economic development director for about a year and a half now.
0:07:47 Travis has been doing double duty for too long.
0:07:52 We've been thinking about how this position might fit with a bigger restructure kind of concept that we've been going through.
0:08:01 It's taken us a little time to get to this point, but we're ready to move forward tonight.
0:08:05 tonight. And so what you have in front of you is a very easy, quick, simple code of it
0:08:11 writing three words to the city code. There's a section in chapter, title one, chapter two,
0:08:17 section four, that basically lists out the titles of the department heads of the city.
0:08:23 And those department heads are the ones that Travis will appoint and that the council will
0:08:28 confirm the appointment of. Use of the members of the executive leadership team. Use of the
0:08:32 folks that can obligate the city to do certain things, pay bills and those kinds of things.
0:08:39 And so what we're proposing to do is add the economic development director to that list
0:08:43 of department heads.
0:08:44 So it's very simple, ordinance amendment, but the impact of it I think is a little bit bigger
0:08:50 than that and it's probably we're talking about a little bit.
0:08:52 So we would propose to recruit a new economic development director, elevate that position a
0:09:00 little bit become part of the executive leadership team. We also would like for
0:09:05 this position to kind of be the spearhead for our prosperous community focus
0:09:10 area in this strategic plan and so we're talking about lumping that position
0:09:14 together with the airport which is another big component of prosperous
0:09:17 community. We think that's a good move we think it'll elevate the maybe the
0:09:22 importance of or at least the feelings about the airport and how it really is a
0:09:26 a significant part of our economic development strategies.
0:09:31 And so this is a big change in its impact,
0:09:34 but it's a little minor change in the wording of the code.
0:09:37 And so basically that's where we're at tonight.
0:09:40 If the council approves this ordinance tonight,
0:09:44 we will then post for the recruitment very soon,
0:09:47 if not tomorrow, very soon after that.
0:09:50 And also it is an ordinance, and so if you want to adopt it tonight,
0:09:54 to put it on third and final and the rules that whole business.
0:09:57 And there's an ordinance that's in the packet. I believe it's 2022-1013.
0:10:02 I'm able to answer your questions if you have any questions. Any questions for
0:10:09 Mitch Street? Any questions I just want to thank
0:10:17 City staff for working on this. This has been something that we've been
0:10:20 missing for quite some time. Portions of this in the past
0:10:26 areas and so making sure taking the time to get it right, especially with the new
0:10:34 organization that we're trying to establish here within the city. So thank
0:10:39 you for doing that. I appreciate that to everybody that's worked on this and made
0:10:43 sure that we get it right. You mentioned something that I probably should have
0:10:47 mentioned in my presentation and that is that the stuff that is currently
0:10:49 belonging to that position will stay with that position. So there'll be that
0:10:53 coming developed director for the city, also will act as the executive director
0:10:57 for their renewal agency, as long as that contract with their renewal agency stays in effect.
0:11:01 So all those duties will stay right through with them, plus a few more.
0:11:05 So that's all right.
0:11:10 There, I move that we suspend the rules and place ordinance 2022-013 on 3rd and final by title only.
0:11:19 Thank you. Do I have a second?
0:11:21 Second.
0:11:22 Thank you. Motion by Christopher Reed.
0:11:24 Seconded by Jason Brown to put, um, ordinance 2022 dash 013 on third and final reading by title only and suspend the rules.
0:11:35 Aaron Roll, call vote please.
0:11:38 Vice mayor, read yes.
0:11:40 John America, you just have to say his name.
0:11:46 Sorry.
0:11:48 Thank you, boy.
0:11:50 Jason Brown.
0:11:51 Yes.
0:11:52 Spencer Keller.
0:11:53 Yes.
0:11:53 Mayor Parris, yes. Motion passes 5-0. Okay, so I will read the ordinance,
0:12:01 that ordinance number 2022-013, an ordinance of the City Council of the City
0:12:08 of Twin Falls, Idaho amending section 4, chapter 2, title 1 of the Twin Falls
0:12:14 City Code, adding economic development director as a department of a motion.
0:12:22 So moved to approve ordinance so I move that we approve ordinance 2022 dash 0 1 3
0:12:40 Thank you.
0:12:43 Second.
0:12:44 Motion by Spencer color seconded by Jason Brown to adopt ordinance 2022 dash 0 1 3
0:12:53 Aaron Rohe called vote please.
0:12:56 Nikki Boyd.
0:12:57 Yes.
0:12:58 Jason Brown.
0:12:59 Yes.
0:13:00 Yes, Mayor Pierce. Yes, I'm married. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 5 to 0
0:13:07 Thank you, Mitch
0:13:12 Next item on the agenda is another presentation
0:13:17 update on
0:13:18 public transportation in Twin Falls
0:13:21 We have Mandy Thompson assistant to the city manager. Welcome, Mandy. Thank you. Good evening, mayor and council
0:13:29 I wanted to come and have a conversation with you tonight
0:13:33 I was going to have a PowerPoint and then I told Mitch I started on it and I felt like
0:13:37 I was getting in the weeds and I was so we're going to start with a real basic conversation
0:13:42 and my hope is that I can come back in the weeks and months to come with some updates
0:13:47 on progress should you all be okay with this moving forward.
0:13:52 So a little background.
0:13:54 I've been up here talking about public transportation since I started with the city nine years ago.
0:14:00 So Sean is the only one here that can remember, but it's been a conversation that we've been
0:14:05 having.
0:14:06 We've been preparing for that eventual cresting over 50,000 in population, and what that means.
0:14:12 And so we're there.
0:14:14 All the estimates tell us we're well over 50,000.
0:14:17 And so now we're kind of in this waiting game, waiting for the 2020 Census to be certified,
0:14:22 which we anticipate will probably be in January.
0:14:25 And then we have a little bit of leeway because we get to then go through the process of forming the MPO and getting our ducks in a row.
0:14:33 But there are some developments that you may or may not be aware of that I wanted to come and have a conversation with you tonight.
0:14:41 So since 1979, Trans-Hore has been operating through the College of Southern Idaho with the public transportation system here in Twin Falls.
0:14:48 CSIS served as its fiscal agent, and when asked, I think the history of how that happened,
0:14:55 they really looked at it as a community service, transformed into somewhere to land, and at
0:15:00 the time that was when the college was taking on a lot of those organizations that they were
0:15:04 sort of fostering under the CSI umbrella.
0:15:07 Transforters of demand, response system, so essentially you have to call 24 hours in
0:15:11 advance, so you arrange your ride, someone comes to pick them up in one of those buses,
0:15:16 And they take you to your ride and then also home again.
0:15:22 It has served our community for all of these years.
0:15:26 There have been times in 2015.
0:15:30 They had a high of over 40,000 rides provided in a year and have been struggling over the
0:15:39 last probably six or seven years with the required match.
0:15:44 They get their funding through the state, which the state is a pass through, the state
0:15:48 gets the funding from the federal government, but it's 5311 rural transportation funds.
0:15:54 And as some of their sources of match have gone away, they have struggled to fully take
0:16:02 advantage of the funding that they received through the Department of Earth through I-TD
0:16:08 and the Federal Transportation Authority.
0:16:11 We've had conversations with them for several years about our intentions of what we envisioned
0:16:16 public transportation to look like.
0:16:19 Back in 2016, we commissioned a study that was paid for by the state to look at transit
0:16:26 and some of the things that we could do in the interim as we were preparing for where
0:16:31 we are today.
0:16:32 And those were things like increasing our density, really thinking about public transportation
0:16:39 from not only the user of the bus, but a pedestrian,
0:16:42 because everyone that uses a transportation
0:16:44 is also a pedestrian, and that gave us
0:16:46 a myriad of things that we could do,
0:16:48 work on things within our code,
0:16:50 which I know that some of those things
0:16:51 were actually included in our complimentary, right?
0:16:56 So we have been taking little steps a long way.
0:17:00 Then in 2019, we went back to IITD
0:17:05 and with some concerns about the eventual 50,000 in designation and really trying to understand
0:17:13 what our options were.
0:17:16 So they went ahead and paid for an additional study by an organization out of the one of
0:17:24 the San Francisco University, it's called the Western Transportation Institute.
0:17:28 So what that group did was really take a very close look at what transportation, oh transportation
0:17:33 currently look like at the time in Twin Falls, and some of the options for the future. So kind
0:17:39 of back to transfer. In the way that it was operating, again, it was a demand response,
0:17:45 there were no fixed routes, and it was really serving specific clientele essentially it's
0:17:52 disabled and elderly in our community. The services would run on weekdays only, and like
0:17:58 like I said, require an appointment and a lot of pre-planning in order to take advantage
0:18:04 of the service.
0:18:08 They've really, like I said, struggled with their funding as well as ridership to the point
0:18:14 where they've dropped to, they're right around 600 rides a month, so they're more than, you
0:18:22 know, they're less than half of where they were at that peak and so they're definitely
0:18:26 kind of seeing that with the inability to provide that full match that was a struggle as well.
0:18:32 So the funding cycle for transfer was on a two-year cycle. So they would apply for it in the middle of a two-year cycle
0:18:41 for the like following two years. So last fall in 2021 they were in the middle of a two-year funding cycle
0:18:48 and they had to make the decision by being CSI whether or not they were going to apply for another two-year grant
0:18:54 through about 53 11 world transportation funds.
0:18:57 We had a lot of conversations with I.T.D.
0:18:59 because we were unclear if they could utilize funds,
0:19:02 if they were given those funds,
0:19:04 but then Twin Falls was designated small urban,
0:19:07 if they even legally could use those funds.
0:19:11 We were just in this very special situation
0:19:14 and no one could ever really give us a very clear answer.
0:19:17 And so, the clearest answer was
0:19:20 is they could not transfer funds.
0:19:22 funds. So once they were awarded to CSI to operate transfer, they couldn't transfer those
0:19:27 to the City of Twin Falls. And so CSI made the decision to not reapply, which means that
0:19:34 they would finish out that second year of funding, which we're getting close to. And
0:19:40 when we're starting to receive communications in the City Manager's Office, and you may
0:19:44 or may not have had individuals, residents of the City, come to you with their concerns,
0:19:51 but transfer will cease operations on September 30th.
0:19:55 You might wonder why I'm only just coming to you in July having known this for a while.
0:20:00 But one of the reasons is because, well, one, we just really weren't unclear what solution we were to even be ready to propose.
0:20:07 And two, we've been working and staying in really close connection with I-T-D's public transportation division.
0:20:16 And they requested that we wait because they were in the process of setting up a whole new
0:20:25 public transit system in Idaho Falls.
0:20:27 So if you go back a few years, in 2015, or excuse me, in 2019, the public transportation
0:20:35 system in Idaho Falls went bankrupt and closed their doors.
0:20:39 They were running a fixed route system, and when you looked at it on a map, it looked like
0:20:43 it was all inclusive.
0:20:44 But that was a single line with two or three buses, and it was not utilized at all.
0:20:52 And they eventually had to close their doors.
0:20:54 So I did these public transportation division came in and worked with them to come up with
0:20:59 a new system.
0:21:00 And so they asked that Twin Falls give them a bit to figure out what they were going to propose
0:21:05 in Idaho Falls because the way that Idaho Falls is spread out is fairly similar to the
0:21:12 as far as just sort of not there's not a corridor that makes it easy, like it does up it for mountain rides up in the Hailey area.
0:21:21 And so in mid-June I received a phone call and have had several conversations with Rundran and Summer for Hershel from the public-transfit division about what they've launched in Idaho Falls, and that is a micro-transit system.
0:21:42 And so what I'm coming here to speak with you about tonight is options that we have going forward here in Twin Falls.
0:21:51 And I don't want to get into the weeds and go into a lot of detail, but one of the things that I provided to you in your packet was that study that Western Transit Institute conducted in POC Forward to us last year.
0:22:03 And a few of the key findings were that one, the use of
0:22:08 transformers was declining rapidly while the cost of their
0:22:12 service was increasing.
0:22:14 A traditional fixed route system in Twin Falls would not be
0:22:17 effective and we would likely have empty buses driving around
0:22:20 Twin Falls and that we needed to have something that was
0:22:23 convenient, innovative, and reliable.
0:22:27 Anything okay, well, we can't have buses, so what does that
0:22:30 third option mean?
0:22:31 And so what they put forward to us and what they suggested was
0:22:34 this idea of microtransit.
0:22:36 So really, this is an approach to public transportation
0:22:39 that's based upon the specific service area.
0:22:43 So we have a very defined service area.
0:22:46 Set service hours that are characterized
0:22:49 by whatever we deem important,
0:22:51 whether it's helping people get to work,
0:22:53 helping people get to the hospital,
0:22:55 the doctor's appointments,
0:22:57 shop grocery shopping.
0:22:59 There's a lot of flexibility in it.
0:23:01 Typically, the services are accessible by an app on a smartphone or a computer, and you
0:23:10 have operations, you contract with the company to do all the scheduling and dispatching, and
0:23:16 they rely on licensed technology platforms in which to provide that service, and so essentially
0:23:24 you would put out an RFP to find a provider that could operate a system in Idaho Falls
0:23:32 similar to what they're operating in, excuse me, in Twin Falls is similar to what they're
0:23:37 operating in Idaho Falls.
0:23:39 So really in very simple terms it's kind of thinking of it like the Lyft or Uber of public
0:23:47 transportation.
0:23:48 ITD has come to the City of Twin Falls with the opportunity to fund, fully fund, a pilot
0:24:00 program for the City of Twin Falls.
0:24:03 There were CARES dollars allocated to our region that have not been utilized, and then
0:24:09 there's additional CARES dollars that were allocated to the state.
0:24:12 Not all of those have been utilized.
0:24:14 And so we have an opportunity to design a pilot program that we can fund with these dollars
0:24:21 and see how a micro-transit system carefully designed would function and be received in
0:24:29 Twin Falls.
0:24:32 With fully the intention of whatever we design is something that would be sustainable into
0:24:37 the future budget-wise.
0:24:38 So what I'm hoping to have a conversation about tonight is whether you're in support of
0:24:47 moving forward with a conversation with ITD and starting to see what that would look like
0:24:52 in Twin Falls and working on some public outreach because we're gonna have to do a decent amount
0:24:56 of that too as a part of utilizing the care dollars that they're offering from the state.
0:25:04 It's a great opportunity with little or no cost to the city and again I think it's a great
0:25:09 solution that's being utilized throughout the country for communities like Twin Falls that are
0:25:15 They're just not large enough and don't have the budget, you know, the funding available
0:25:20 to support fixed route systems that would be utilized and that would really serve the community.
0:25:28 So something like micro transit.
0:25:31 And the great thing is you can really put anything into the service contract with the
0:25:36 vendor that you want so we could write in the use of vouchers so that individuals can
0:25:42 and continue to use Medicaid vouchers.
0:25:44 Individuals can continue to use vouchers from like IBC and Link.
0:25:52 So we have these really great partners that have these vouchers that provide to people
0:25:57 to use public transportation, and we can allow them to continue to use this in a new format.
0:26:03 So we can see if you have any questions.
0:26:06 I actually just heard a story on the radio yesterday about a community of very similar
0:26:20 pro fixed route systems, lapsed through their buses and storage and gave it a shot and it's
0:26:27 been very successful there and they said again it's serving a lot of the very underserved
0:26:33 part of the community, people trying to get to edit appointments, people trying to get
0:26:37 to a point of transportation so I think it's certainly worthy of pursuing particularly
0:26:45 there are some partnership funds available on the state level. A question I would have is when they're talking about, I appreciate that we're trying to deal with a public transportation system, the City of Twin Falls, that's our role here. Are there opportunities potentially with
0:27:05 Yes, and we actually had that conversation because I was thinking along the lines of
0:27:26 the MPO and all that, but a camp leader can't really be a part of that.
0:27:31 So yes, you don't have to have another sponsor, like you win because, clearly, Twin Falls
0:27:35 is not going to operate a system outside of our corporate boundaries, but it's happening
0:27:39 in idle falls.
0:27:40 So I don't lose this familiar with idle falls, but idle falls has grown into its neighbor
0:27:45 and so you go through that area kind of southeast corner of Ammon or vital falls into Ammon and there's no, you know, you know, when you've left one connected to the other, but the buses are geofence so they don't go beyond a certain point.
0:27:59 So there's been a lot of pressure on the Ammon City Council to essentially tack on services to what they're operating in the program so that they can have the buses come into their community as well.
0:28:13 And they're just kind of small, I mean, I'll bring you a tremendous amount more information
0:28:19 that, you know, you lease the buses through, again, through the contractor, and they're
0:28:23 just kind of like a small van, some of them are paratransit, so that they can transport
0:28:28 individuals with disabilities.
0:28:30 Several of the ones, not all of them, also have a bike rack on it, so individuals can,
0:28:35 you know, utilize their bikes if they want to get to a certain point, and then use their
0:28:39 bikes from, you know, a point on.
0:28:40 So, and it's a fixed amount, so there's some revenue generation apart of it, so I don't
0:28:44 think I'll just chose three dollars, you know, it's really up to the community how much they
0:28:50 want to charge, what limitations that they place on it, but there's actually, I got really
0:28:55 excited for the first time ever talking about published transportation because it's normally
0:28:59 just, it's a weight on your shoulders that you don't want to even consider.
0:29:03 Right, that's our cover.
0:29:07 Thanks for bringing this idea.
0:29:08 This idea, if we have to test the waters, I'd much rather do it on somebody else's dollars
0:29:12 than ours.
0:29:13 I do have a question, and if you don't feel like you should answer the knife, you won't
0:29:17 wait until you come back next time.
0:29:19 So my understanding is, once the census is finally certified, we become an urban area,
0:29:25 so CSI is no longer eligible for the rural grant, so the city would be eligible for the
0:29:32 urban grant.
0:29:34 But the downside is we have to still come up with 50% of that cost, whether it's mayors or directly subsidized by the city or whatever.
0:29:43 So the idea now is we kind of test the waters, see what's practical, see what actually provides the service to people, and doesn't just be a money pit.
0:29:52 Right, and the way Idaho Falls has done it is they started low, they started kind of on the small side, and they actually are finding other, they're planning on adding services.
0:30:01 So what I'd like to do is give them about quarter to get some time under their belts and then bring those numbers back to you along with an actual proposal of what we'd like to write into an RFP.
0:30:14 But what I would like to do is whatever we utilize and care dollars, think of it as that would be our total budget and then how much could we afford to come up with that 50% whether that again is money out of our budget,
0:30:30 whether that's council directed capital, whether that's funds when the urban or no district
0:30:36 town closes or amfares.
0:30:38 I mean, there's a lot of different things you can bring on sponsors, but we can get the
0:30:43 business community involved, in fact, they're wrapping two of the buses in Idaho Falls, and
0:30:47 they have this kind of sponsorship associated with that.
0:30:51 And then you could add, like, the Vampool concept, which those are being two communities
0:30:58 in Washington state, they don't even fund their vampables.
0:31:02 The vampables are funded by private industry,
0:31:04 but they're managed by that same contract.
0:31:08 That's what it's saying.
0:31:09 Chris Ferri, can you talk about the timeline again?
0:31:11 You mentioned that transport is done at the end of September.
0:31:16 Yes.
0:31:16 So what does the timeline look for us?
0:31:19 So we started tomorrow.
0:31:21 We probably wouldn't have found something on the road
0:31:23 until January.
0:31:24 So I fully recognize that there will be an interruption
0:31:28 of service for individuals, and unfortunately, if we couldn't really have a pretty crunch
0:31:34 timeline to do all of the public outreach that we, and again, I did, I've waited on their
0:31:42 request, which I think was good because they came to the table with money, they being ITD,
0:31:49 but it will result in a disruption in services for individuals that utilize transporters.
0:31:54 Now, like I said, they're averaging about 600 drives a month.
0:31:59 They no longer track individual right or independent passenger numbers.
0:32:06 So I don't know if those 600 rights are like 300 people going back and forth or if it's
0:32:11 50.
0:32:12 I mean like we don't have a number to tell you how many residents in Twin Falls are relying
0:32:16 on transport right now.
0:32:18 It's relatively small but I don't want to diminish the fact that there are P.R.
0:32:21 people that are utilizing that.
0:32:22 So the sooner we can get working with I.T.D. to get something before you to go through
0:32:28 and RFP process the best, the better.
0:32:33 So.
0:32:34 And I would say from a communications perspective,
0:32:36 but you already spoke about that we're
0:32:37 going to need to have some good outreach,
0:32:40 also much we have good partners in the community,
0:32:42 and so ways that we can connect through
0:32:44 to those services that are not currently using to help.
0:32:49 The thing I just wanted to mention is for food for thought,
0:32:53 the story I heard on the wrist at this community,
0:32:57 not based, but also had a call center.
0:33:00 Yes, I get to smash center.
0:33:02 Yes.
0:33:02 and so while I appreciate technology and all the great things it does, it also tends to train to serve.
0:33:15 Yes, but I've got a nice difference between how transfer operates now as transfer requires a 24-hour notice.
0:33:21 So, I mean, some of the early numbers that are getting out of vital falls is the average weight times like 13 minutes.
0:33:27 No.
0:33:28 Yeah, in your home or wherever it is that you're at where you're ready to get it right.
0:33:32 this is great because that was the one the thing I first thought of giving all the
0:33:38 back-knead these the most some of the seniors they do things on their fun to do
0:33:46 but I personally know if it's it's really scary to think that they could be in
0:33:52 trouble and not make them and so they do they're not using a computer either so
0:34:03 that's that's really good that there would be a yeah and those are all things
0:34:15 that you can write into the RFP
0:34:25 and that there's several other partners.
0:34:27 Not to do these, they've come and received funds from M.P.O.G.
0:34:31 that I think might be outside of their scope
0:34:35 but they're not profit.
0:34:36 I don't want to leave 600 individuals potentially.
0:34:40 It might be less, it might be more whatever it is,
0:34:43 especially as we're going to be hitting winter
0:34:46 during that period, the ability to get to go.
0:34:49 So maybe reaching out to them during their citizens.
0:34:57 Yes, and Transfor, Jim Boehm, who's now operating
0:35:00 and who's the director at Transfor,
0:35:01 is more than willing to work with the city.
0:35:04 In fact, has offered his services to help in this process
0:35:07 and this transition process.
0:35:09 So I'm hopeful that just through a transfer,
0:35:12 we can do some public outreach to those individuals
0:35:16 that are users of the system right now
0:35:18 and come up with some stop-gap solutions for them.
0:35:21 Anybody else today?
0:35:27 So I think you mentioned it a little bit.
0:35:30 The question one of the questions I had was this.
0:35:33 So it sounds like there would be still buses
0:35:37 around the buses wouldn't go away.
0:35:38 So the contract would bring buses in and run or how, what, uh...
0:35:44 Yeah, I mean, they're gonna be smaller than what transfer operates, okay?
0:35:47 And we'll have much more modern.
0:35:49 Yeah, and we get to choose how many based upon the amount of service we're willing to provide.
0:35:54 So like I said, I don't know if it has, I think, six vehicles.
0:35:57 So they have three forks.
0:36:00 before kind of the comic is small but it's I think smaller than like a sprinter
0:36:07 but and all four of those are equipped with paratransitists so that they can
0:36:13 utilize them so individuals that are disabled can utilize that service then
0:36:17 they have like an event and then they have a exam you have choices and options
0:36:22 they dictate they dictate whoever that profile looks like if they need a certain
0:36:27 And there is kind of written into the algorithm that these companies, there are several that
0:36:35 offer the services across the country, and written into the algorithm are shared rights.
0:36:39 So if you've got people who are on a shared route, then you'll share a right.
0:36:44 So in those larger vans, if you've got somebody, you know, five or six blocks away, they'll
0:36:50 pick them up or take them home, type of a situation.
0:36:55 And then again, too, if you've got a group of six people that are all going to the same place,
0:37:01 and you put that in, then it's kind of like lift or they'll sound the appropriate vehicle to pick that map.
0:37:10 A lesson learned in Idol Falls is they were, they just went with $3, right?
0:37:14 And it was $3 for one person or it was $3 for six people.
0:37:17 And they are regretful of that decision and are likely going to in the next funding cycle,
0:37:23 to change that to a per person cost, but still I think that we get the flexibility to decide
0:37:31 what that would look like.
0:37:32 It's $5 for the first writer and two for every additional, so.
0:37:36 We get to learn some of those pitfalls and maybe I know it's all-
0:37:39 And there are some lessons learned.
0:37:40 The voucher system that I spoke of, they didn't think about that.
0:37:43 And when I asked them, they were like, oh, we should have done that.
0:37:48 So it's kind of nice to learn from other communities.
0:37:50 And I have emails out to a couple of other communities that are operating micro-transil
0:37:55 right now to just kind of get some of those lessons learned.
0:37:59 I mostly want to speak to who they're utilizing as their vendors or contractors.
0:38:03 Perfect.
0:38:04 The other question I have and I'm going to throw this out there just to, and I don't
0:38:09 know maybe if some other people have thought about it is, would there be some of that money
0:38:13 to help read that gap with trans4 for the three months from October, November, December,
0:38:20 to keep those that service going until we can get something.
0:38:25 I don't know what that cost would be.
0:38:27 I don't know.
0:38:30 And I don't know if it's part of their, I mean, they chose that date
0:38:35 because that's when they're funding.
0:38:37 True.
0:38:37 So I don't know.
0:38:38 And I believe CSIs also on October 1st.
0:38:41 So yeah, I don't know.
0:38:42 I mean, I certainly could ask the question.
0:38:44 I'm happy to approach that with the college.
0:38:46 But actually, CSIs on June 30th.
0:38:49 Oh, they are.
0:38:50 Yeah.
0:38:50 So, okay.
0:38:51 So that was a really.
0:38:52 Yeah.
0:38:53 Okay, so there could be some.
0:38:55 And the city, some of you would recall that we used to fund a portion of transverse match
0:39:01 through the city.
0:39:02 We used to give them an m-pog-gram, and at some point in time we decided to quit making
0:39:05 them come ask for it every single time, and we just took a portion out.
0:39:10 And so we did provide them with some match, so if there's some addition, and they always
0:39:14 provide an accounting of that, and I don't believe that they will utilize all of their funding
0:39:18 by the time September 30th has come around and that's from Jim himself saying he's not sure.
0:39:24 So there is a possibility if there is a match left we could ask them if they'd be willing
0:39:27 to continue operations for a few months while we get this set up.
0:39:30 Absolutely.
0:39:31 Yes, it's an idea.
0:39:32 I know it's an idea.
0:39:33 It's an idea.
0:39:34 If we do have leftover for not spending all of that, maybe there's another mechanism to
0:39:42 take a look at, at least help fill that gap.
0:39:45 Do you know what we put in our budget this time?
0:39:51 So for the coming budget, we did not put, let me take it out.
0:39:57 I need to know today, but just out of curiosity.
0:40:06 But funding that we did provide out of the 22 budget,
0:40:10 we provided a transfer, they started spending that after.
0:40:15 I don't know, I think they received that in June,
0:40:18 I believe, for the last four months.
0:40:22 All questions that I can easily get clarification on.
0:40:28 Good, thank you, Mandy.
0:40:33 Okay, next item on the agenda is a says action item,
0:40:37 but it's a presentation of the city managers recommended
0:40:41 by CHIP for fiscal year 22, 23,
0:40:44 and we have a believe Mitch Humble,
0:40:47 deputy city manager will be leading this discussion.
0:40:56 Welcome, Mitch.
0:41:02 You can probably tell by the people in the room tonight
0:41:04 what we're gonna be talking about.
0:41:06 We have quite a lot of our public folks,
0:41:09 public-versus folks here today,
0:41:11 that will be helping me present this is tonight's presentation is actually quite a lot to it
0:41:16 so I'm going to probably rush through these intro slides a little bit quicker than I did last week
0:41:20 to leave more time for the the meat of the presentation to come later and then I'll introduce
0:41:25 kind of these guys as they come up and take part of this presentation so first slide I'm just going to tell you that we have
0:41:35 presented to you budget that you've got in your hands to look at that needs all the requirements that it needs to me
0:41:41 That's basically a lot of words to say that, right?
0:41:46 This is good.
0:41:47 It's all of our requirements, OK?
0:41:51 Also, Government Finance Officers Association best practices
0:41:55 is in their duty to be fully anticipated to apply for
0:41:57 and get that award again this year.
0:42:00 These are the goals that we were trying to aim to for
0:42:05 with the preparation of this budget you've seen these goals
0:42:07 before several times.
0:42:09 The one I want to hit again, I told you last week
0:42:13 when I had this presentation that there's themes emerge every year, right?
0:42:16 To me, the theme this year is probably that last one.
0:42:20 And because of the struggles that we're having with recruiting and maintaining our employee
0:42:28 core, this is causing us a lot of issues.
0:42:31 And we really need to focus on that issue of being an employer of choice.
0:42:35 We're about 29 positions down today at the city.
0:42:40 And that's a lot of resignation to you, so in flux here.
0:42:51 It's a problem that we need to stay on top of.
0:42:56 So we'll talk a little bit tonight about new positions
0:43:00 that we're going to be requesting,
0:43:01 and some of our efforts to recruit.
0:43:05 To me, that seems like one of those big important things
0:43:08 in this year's budget.
0:43:11 So I want to show you, again, Travis would say that we're
0:43:14 going to show you the punchline at the beginning, right?
0:43:16 That's kind of what this slide does for you.
0:43:19 This will show you the impact to that average homeowner.
0:43:24 And the average homeowner is hard to fight,
0:43:27 but basically this is the median value home that uses the average amount of water and sewer.
0:43:32 I don't know how many of these guys are out there, but for those guys,
0:43:37 the tax rate you can put in there is going to drop with this budget.
0:43:42 It's going to drop by $1.47 per $1,000 of value increased by use of property that we're seeing.
0:43:53 This is about $288 a year for that average home or $24 and not proposing any increases at all to our utility rates of water sewer or sanitation.
0:44:04 And so this really, this $24 a month impact is just in the tax rate.
0:44:10 That's kind of the budget right there. That's how we're going to get most of our revenues from taxes and general fund anyway.
0:44:26 So this is here to show, share with you what is happening with our property values.
0:44:31 You can see that number on the top right at 5.6 billion dollar tax assessment, right?
0:44:41 The valuation for our community.
0:44:43 That's a big number.
0:44:45 That's the reason why the tax rate is actually dropping as much as it is.
0:44:49 It's a 23% decline in the tax rate because the values went up so much.
0:44:53 That just shows it kind of graphically.
0:45:00 What this interesting piece of information on this slide here is that we increased $1.5
0:45:06 billion from year to year, last year to this year.
0:45:10 It's a 38% increase in valuation of the community.
0:45:13 That's the same value, dollar value that we saw the prior four fiscal years.
0:45:18 So this is incredible.
0:45:19 This probably is one of those other things that's emerging.
0:45:22 It's the rapid increases in valuation.
0:45:26 So, this kind of shows that increase in really good graphic form there with the green barbie
0:45:33 and the big one for next year.
0:45:35 And this shows the same thing the graphic representation of what's happening with the
0:45:41 tax rate because of those increases in values.
0:45:47 So, new construction, this is an interesting issue.
0:45:51 I think this is interesting.
0:45:55 I get involved in the new construction stuff a little bit more.
0:45:57 So I look at this and I go, that's really weird how this is happening.
0:46:00 But we are increasing this year's value in new constructions $115 million.
0:46:11 That's more than last year's new construction value at $100.
0:46:16 Yeah, we're collecting less money than we collected last year.
0:46:19 So it's just kind of weird how that played out this year because of that tax rate dropping so much, right?
0:46:25 But that's, like I said, I look at that and it works out.
0:46:32 It's just something we don't, but it's interesting
0:46:38 So we have to show it out there for, because of that,
0:46:44 not necessarily because of that, but this is new construction here.
0:46:46 You'll see that in the Fiskier 22 budget this year's budget,
0:46:50 we budgeted on our million dollars in building perimeter revenue.
0:46:54 We're still on track to meet that.
0:46:56 When they say meet that, we're not going to exceed that,
0:46:58 like the prior years, right?
0:47:00 We're all on this table here, you see a bunch of actuals, right?
0:47:03 Those are what we actually collected.
0:47:05 As for your 22, it shows the budgeted amount.
0:47:08 We're probably going to end up very close to that budget amount and not much, not exceed it very much this year.
0:47:13 Over on target to still meet it. Building permit activity is declining.
0:47:19 And so we're not issuing the same number of permits that we issued nears.
0:47:27 Those permits again, this is not.
0:47:30 And so I actually wrote down the note here that our permit count just from June this year compared to June last year.
0:47:40 A permit count is down 41% numbers of permits, but the value of those permits is up 23%.
0:47:53 So we're going to project a flat building permit revenue.
0:47:57 That is because the numbers are coming down with the values are going up.
0:48:01 So we're keeping this one flat for next year.
0:48:04 How many questions about that?
0:48:06 I want to talk to you a little bit about the homeowners exemption.
0:48:13 You've seen this slide before too.
0:48:18 The homeless exemption increased last year to 125.
0:48:21 It's going to stay at 125 this year.
0:48:23 If the exemption were still indexed at the homeless exemption,
0:48:29 this year would be 176,000.
0:48:32 So significantly more than 125 that it's going to be.
0:48:35 If we're indexed, our average older
0:48:39 than the guy we talked about earlier in the presentation
0:48:41 would be paying $203 less in taxes than he is now.
0:48:49 Again, another kind of result of increased property value.
0:48:58 This is last year's data, right?
0:49:00 So we don't have this year's data, obviously,
0:49:02 because we're all still talking about it.
0:49:03 All the cities are still having this conversation,
0:49:05 but what we want to illustrate with this slide
0:49:07 is to show you that living in Twin Falls
0:49:10 and paying property taxes in Twin Falls
0:49:13 is still a pretty good deal
0:49:14 when we compare ourselves to all of our sister cities
0:49:18 across the state.
0:49:19 So you have a bunch of cities up here.
0:49:21 They're the larger cities,
0:49:23 drums not quite a larger city,
0:49:24 but drums next to us, right?
0:49:25 So they're one of our neighbor cities.
0:49:27 And so when we compare ourselves to our peers,
0:49:30 we're still a pretty affordable place to live
0:49:32 in terms of property taxes that are paid to the cities.
0:49:38 And so that's kind of what this is to show you
0:49:43 is the breakdown.
0:49:44 We talked about this a little bit last year,
0:49:45 the breakdown of the fund types,
0:49:47 most of the money that we collect,
0:49:50 and then we're gonna spend 60% of it,
0:49:51 almost 59.5% of it goes to the general fund departments.
0:49:56 The general fund is like HR and Finance and IT and all those kind of government city managers
0:50:06 officer and we're in through two.
0:50:09 37% of that is our in-price funds, that's water sewer sanitation.
0:50:13 And then those last little bit, 2.7%, is the other guys, that's the impact fee fund,
0:50:18 it's the airport construction fund to come with those smaller ones.
0:50:22 And then by expenditure type, category personnel is again the biggest one, that's typical
0:50:29 for cities. Our service organization takes people to perform services, so 43, 44% of those
0:50:35 dollars are going to personnel costs. New employees, we talk about new employees each
0:50:45 year. You see I put the little good here off to the side here. I may be biased, but I am
0:50:50 up the belief that city employees are heroes. And we're looking for more heroes, right,
0:50:54 to add to our superhero team. These top four are the new positions that we're including
0:50:59 this budget and we'll talk about two of those tonight so I decided to have this
0:51:03 little thing here when you see this guy pack up on a few future sites
0:51:06 those are new positions that we're going to talk about.
0:51:08 Ebony prosecuting attorneys want to them traffic tech engineering department water
0:51:13 operator position will be fired chief art positions we're going to have this year
0:51:16 we'll talk about two of those tonight the others up there the planning zoning tech
0:51:20 and the police officers with the college grant you've already had those
0:51:23 conversations we've already made those decisions we're including them in this
0:51:26 budget because they weren't included in the last one. So this looks like an increase of eight positions we're adding for.
0:51:36 Okay, so this will show you that we have a slight increase in our, no budgets, our maintenance operation budgets.
0:51:44 The increase is 7.5%. We saw last weekend number come out from the CPI that was, this is fuel, this is electricity, this is travel and training.
0:52:00 training, this is those kinds of expenses, where those costs are going up, right? We need to reflect those increases
0:52:07 are going up even more since we gave you the budget last month, right? So that's what that one is. This shows you the increase to capital.
0:52:15 Now tonight you're going to talk, you're going to hear, you can also talk if you want to talk, and hear most of the capital, right?
0:52:23 That we have in this year's budget is going to come from these guys here to talk tonight. That's a big number 18 million dollars for the capital projects.
0:52:29 projects, a lot of that is in water, a little bit more in sewer and streets, so we'll talk
0:52:34 a lot about those tonight, the capital expenses, those are a big deal for our budget moving
0:52:39 forward. So that's kind of the brief run through the intro stuff. Again, I'll go back to the
0:52:46 slide here, you've seen this for the last several years now, we've got all these focus areas and
0:52:51 they're all important for us as we grow our community, all of them rely on the internal
0:52:55 organization, all of the rely on the people to do the work and so they're all kind of pointing to that and then we're going to move forward
0:53:03 Folks here tonight, and so first here we're going to talk about tonight is there a folks here for that's our accessible community
0:53:10 This is primarily like streets and sidewalks and things like that. So the first
0:53:16 Person I'm gonna have come up here to join me tonight is gonna be Tom's and you all these are streets superintendent
0:53:22 He's got another one of his guys here. It's gonna help him out tonight. I'll let him introduce Dan
0:53:27 I'm going to come up and talk to you a little bit and come back.
0:53:35 Good evening, Mayor and Council.
0:53:37 Tonight, the Street Department gets the pleasure of kicking off the discussion of Focus Area 4, which is our accessible community.
0:53:45 This first slide shows basically our routine and also the replacement schedule.
0:53:57 Within the Street Department, as with other departments, we really have two separate divisions that we made those responsibilities in.
0:54:09 What is that as the asphalt of the site?
0:54:11 It's everything that does
0:54:14 makes care of the roadways.
0:54:16 Then we also have
0:54:17 signing and striping division, which takes care of everything on top of the roads.
0:54:21 And their responsibilities are
0:54:23 they maintain all the signage, all the pavement working, all our signalized intersections.
0:54:30 And AC 2.1.3 of our strategic plans
0:54:34 is that we'll maintain our traffic signals,
0:54:37 illumination, signing and striping to meet established.
0:54:40 One of our capital request this year is the replacement of our pay machine.
0:54:46 Beanstrap from our signing and striping division to help kind of explain why it's important.
0:54:55 Pivot markings are an accepted method to communicate both the intended travel path and roadway alignment for drivers during day and night time conditions.
0:55:23 To ensure consistent application of pavement markings are characteristics and warranty criteria are described in the manual of uniform traffic control device also known as the MUTSIT.
0:55:34 Section 3A.03 of the MUTSIT requires agencies to use a method designed to maintain longitudinal pavement markings to a minimum level of retro-reflectivity.
0:55:44 Within the MUTSIT section there are three subtle but important distinctions that categorize pavement markings to three general types.
0:55:54 not required to be retro-affective. These are payment markings where an
0:55:58 empty of elimination, which are adequate visibility or payment markings that are
0:56:03 needed only in the daytime, like access to a park. These payment markings do not need
0:56:11 to be maintained to a minimum level of retro-reflectivity. Number two,
0:56:15 required to be retro-affective but not subject to minimum levels. All markings other than those
0:56:22 discussed in the first bullet must be retro-effective, but some of these markings are not subject to new, minimum, retro-reflective levels.
0:56:29 Examples of exceptions provided by the new mustard language include truss-fuck markings, otherwise transverse markings, words, samples, arrows, etc.
0:56:41 etc. Some longitudinal lines are exempt from the new minimum retroreflective levels under certain conditions, such as presence of continuous spread weight lighting or
0:56:52 of retroreflective payment markings.
0:56:56 Subject to minimum retroreflective levels,
0:56:59 this includes the white and yellow longitudinal payment
0:57:01 markings that are required or recommended in the message,
0:57:05 such as the center lines, edge lines,
0:57:07 lane lines, and channelizing lines that the message says shell
0:57:10 or should be used above certain volumes
0:57:13 or for certain roadway conditions.
0:57:15 We currently paint them, roughly 510 miles of white and yellow
0:57:18 longitudinal payment markings a year
0:57:21 to maintain the retro-reflectivity levels.
0:57:24 We usually do this in June, all the way through August.
0:57:30 In fiscal year 2023, we are asking for $385,000
0:57:34 to replace our current paint machine
0:57:36 with the new updated version.
0:57:39 For the past 11 years, this had been a great machine,
0:57:41 but we are starting to have cost-free repairs to Duke's age.
0:57:45 We typically would have replaced this machine
0:57:47 at the 10-year mark, but due to the cost and amount
0:57:49 of other equipment in our replacement schedule,
0:57:51 we had to push it back a couple of years.
0:57:54 If we do not get this piece of equipment replaced, it can be settled in several years before we get back into our schedule.
0:58:00 Some error.
0:58:08 Promise it won't be difficult. The $385,000 is that just for the machinery that's on that truck or is it the truck as well?
0:58:17 Is it all one thing?
0:58:18 It's all one thing, yeah.
0:58:19 And so what do we do with a machine like that when we're not using it anymore?
0:58:24 Is it a backup for us? Do we have other uses?
0:58:27 Actually, like that machine we'd probably
0:58:31 Try to trade that one in ourselves to another like highway district or smallest city
0:58:35 The other questions is great. I understand the economy
0:58:48 So I've been talking to the guy MB and I was like six or eight months ago. He was talking like
0:58:57 Get like a truck itself would be maybe here
0:59:02 But then he emailed me a couple months ago and said that it's actually move up quite a bit and he will be in town Thursday
0:59:07 for the first day, around 2.30, so we'll know more.
0:59:10 Last crisis, yeah, well, prices and then availability.
0:59:15 Yeah, you can get the added issue with needing to move the fire truck because we didn't
0:59:23 do, so something that specialized, I was kind of wondering, is that something that we
0:59:29 would be able to get, sounds like we would be able to be able to.
0:59:31 Yeah, and we'll talk to more authors, and so if you guys have any more questions, you
0:59:34 can ask more of them, or I can let you guys know on that.
0:59:37 It sounds like we should be able to.
0:59:40 Hey, some ground.
0:59:42 This might be for Mark, but the reconstruction of Orchard in the Hankins.
0:59:51 So I know we've got some work on Hankins. Is this just a continuation of what we've done in the last couple of years?
0:59:56 Two separate projects in Orchard would be from Blue Lakes to Eastland.
1:00:02 Okay. We have a bunch of shared jurisdiction right in there.
1:00:05 Okay. Between the Highway District and us.
1:00:08 That would be actually from a drone into the West.
1:00:11 I just passed, it's about, just passed the field, entire road place, so that would be that portion of that project right there.
1:00:21 And then the Hankins project would be a filer, new fire stations going in.
1:00:26 I'd believe the fire station is only paying in or a portion of that roadway.
1:00:31 And then the other, we would set money aside to repair that.
1:00:35 So I took that as the intersection, at the intersection, up or six down eight to six.
1:00:40 Not two separate projects, okay.
1:00:43 That clarifies it a little better.
1:00:44 Okay, thank you.
1:00:45 Thank you.
1:00:46 Any other questions? Okay, thank you very much, gentlemen.
1:00:52 I mean, guys, like Dan in here for these presentations, even though it makes them really nervous,
1:00:59 but it's kind of fun to introduce you to more of your city employees, super heroes, right?
1:01:05 So, I'm just going to bring Troy up now as we're still in section, or if I'm sorry,
1:01:09 Troy is going to talk to you a little bit more from the Engineering Excite service.
1:01:23 Okay, before you a traffic technician, this person is essentially,
1:01:32 If I want to upset my mom, I have her sit through two red lights.
1:01:38 I'm sure you've all felt that frustration too.
1:01:44 This person is commonly involved with coordination, timing,
1:01:48 execution, optimization of those throughout the city.
1:01:51 We have 49 of them.
1:01:54 We also have the need to move some lights.
1:01:58 Those flashing ones at school position or even session or out of session.
1:02:03 Those aren't quite as smart.
1:02:05 We have to actually go to some effort to program those and tighten those with the school district stuff like that.
1:02:11 We also look at subdivisions coming in.
1:02:14 We renew subdivisions and they have a lighting plan.
1:02:18 Some of them have traffic control.
1:02:20 Now it's currently utilizing orchard and service announcements
1:02:29 to try to make sure that we're forming our as much as possible impacts are happening.
1:02:37 We are also trying to work with schools and we're gone safe for us to schools.
1:02:43 We do headcounts seeing where we really need to focus on.
1:02:46 Just trying to follow up.
1:02:57 Why did this happen?
1:02:58 Should it happen?
1:02:59 So Troy, this is a second traffic technician.
1:03:27 Is that what you're saying?
1:03:28 That's great.
1:03:28 OK, thank you.
1:03:29 Any questions for Troy?
1:03:31 Off easy.
1:03:36 Thank you.
1:03:37 We don't like sitting in red lights either.
1:03:41 I've got a couple of lights that come with red lights.
1:03:46 Let's wait till the new person's hired.
1:03:48 I can tell you that we go through this process every year.
1:03:52 So I forgot who we're going to put in for new, for new positions.
1:03:54 And this one has been on the request list for, I don't know,
1:03:58 how many years Jackie requested this position several times
1:04:02 before it finally made it to today's presentation.
1:04:05 So this is one that we've needed for a while,
1:04:08 and it's written to the top of that.
1:04:10 That's good, so yeah, this is kind of
1:04:13 just those choice questions.
1:04:15 Okay, moving on from focus area four,
1:04:17 and I shall have questions or comments
1:04:19 about accessible communities, right?
1:04:22 Okay, so focus area five is the environmental community.
1:04:25 This is where we're talking about water and sewer.
1:04:28 So at first I think I'm going to bring you up with Rob.
1:04:33 Rob will talk to you about water stuff.
1:04:35 Welcome Rob.
1:04:41 Council, appreciate your time this evening.
1:04:45 I'm happy to come and propose our CIP projects.
1:04:50 Then, with respect of everybody's time, I've got 11.
1:04:53 I'm still talking probably about the top five.
1:04:56 There's any questions on the elements.
1:04:57 I'll be glad to answer those.
1:04:59 The first one on our list is the water operator.
1:05:03 As you can see in the last five years, the work I love for our locating operator has almost
1:05:15 one tripled in the last five years.
1:05:19 This position is required to go out and work all over our water, fire hydrants, anything
1:05:26 that has to do with water in our system for our infrastructure so that when other companies
1:05:32 go out
1:05:33 to
1:05:40 I'm somewhere
1:05:41 requesting this position
1:05:44 will also help us with TDS coming to town
1:05:47 and the fiber locates
1:05:49 just won't be able to keep up
1:05:52 they haven't got going for yet
1:05:54 but when they do
1:05:55 guys
1:05:57 also
1:06:01 EDS
1:06:14 says they're going to be around
1:06:15 so we thought
1:06:17 well this would be a good time for things to happen
1:06:24 there's a lot to learn out
1:06:25 then it doesn't
1:06:28 it doesn't happen in a six month period
1:06:30 so
1:06:31 the crest and
1:06:34 nothing moving forward
1:06:47 The existing pressure zone boundary and the proposed new pressure zone boundary, it's kind of hard to see on these maps because they're so small.
1:06:54 The Hankins pressure zone is the zone that we'll be talking about requesting.
1:06:59 We're asked with this project, the opportunity, Twin Falls is basically the pressure zone systems that work with the water system in the late 70s and 80s.
1:07:32 Twin Falls is prone exponentially, I know.
1:07:37 water up hill on moving water down hill either causes either loss of pressure or more pressure
1:07:43 and we have keep those pressures within the peoples stuff off their utilities and their homes
1:07:53 or supply enough pressure for them to be able to use it.
1:07:58 This project will help us use our system more efficiently and improve our boundaries
1:08:04 and help us fix some of those deficiencies in our pressure zone and it will also provide
1:08:09 In those areas where we didn't have the pressure, the fire flow, for some industrial growth also in that area.
1:08:17 But as the blue lakes on the roadside stream project, I'm a project request that we are bringing in Council.
1:08:35 When we moved to the office streams, where we used to pour water out of the lakeside, we took our pumps and moved them.
1:08:50 with the city and blue lakes was that we wouldn't even see the scale on those rocks.
1:09:08 So what this project is, we will be piping off of our 30-inch line,
1:09:13 of those 12-inch bridge, 12-inch line down to the blue-electropside stream,
1:09:23 and then the city will, on March 15 through October, have to provide up to 6CFS,
1:09:45 a stream that will depend on natural stream flow.
1:09:49 As well be controlled with skater engages in the creek
1:09:52 It will change how much water we send down with the bell
1:09:56 to counsel I think in replacement
1:10:25 waste water, ITD and other entities in town
1:10:36 zone maintenance and thoughtfully about where we're replacing stuff
1:10:49 and the lead someone going a bunch of lead
1:11:15 that starts leaking into them a diligent on where pumps this
1:11:28 on track some of that out and then we also have our guys in the house
1:11:38 do some of those smart projects
1:11:40 Unless I'm at least over on the blue lakeside.
1:11:45 Also, where are we?
1:11:47 The spouse we're putting in their kids or park kids for these valves.
1:12:06 Any more of this requests us to replace us for about a day in summer.
1:12:12 We pull about two thirds of our water, blue lakeside.
1:12:16 And we send out to the students.
1:12:20 Any questions for Rob? Looks like you're off the hook.
1:12:32 Thank you.
1:12:36 I'd like water to drink.
1:12:42 I just want to add one quick thing if you remember.
1:12:44 In the fiscal year 22, this is Korean fiscal year.
1:12:46 we changed our water rate structure to create the capital improvement fund for water.
1:12:54 And we saw that the pressure zone project was about three million dollar project.
1:13:00 And some others like it are kind of in that sweet spot where they're a little more
1:13:05 than we can usually afford in a given year, but not enough to really go do a bond for.
1:13:10 And so this capital fund is now getting put to work,
1:13:14 and I've spent a point that out,
1:13:16 the decisions that we made are now marching forward,
1:13:19 and we're able to do those kinds of a little bit big,
1:13:23 but not really big projects with that capital fund.
1:13:25 So that's a good thing moving forward.
1:13:29 Okay, so next we're gonna talk about wastewater.
1:13:31 I'm gonna have Doug come up and talk to you a little bit
1:13:32 about the wastewater expenses.
1:13:39 Welcome, Doug.
1:13:46 I'm kind of excited to talk about
1:13:48 some of the wastewater improvements we have coming up.
1:13:51 I'm going to kind of talk a little bit about this current year and then into forward years.
1:13:58 Looking to improve our wastewater system in new and less interested ways.
1:14:04 We are in the process of putting the other project in this current budget year to utilize the money for mainline improvements.
1:14:11 a certain place pipe or CIPP pipe is the process we are focused on for pipe improvements this
1:14:19 year and moving forward into future years. The first slide represents the first area in town
1:14:25 we are wanting to improve. So I know that's really hard to see but if you hit the top of
1:14:31 the slide there's that's north, that met meadison going straight across. So it's your right
1:14:37 That's five points. It has most of the oldest pipe.
1:14:48 Our crews have done a great job this past year and a half going in and making improvements.
1:14:57 The CIP being done inspection improvements. We have inspected this whole area.
1:15:11 Projects we know where the areas that we need. Excuse me to make repairs.
1:15:18 The tractors come in jobs instead of them coming in and making those improvements.
1:15:26 We're doing that before. Excuse me. We're doing that before they come.
1:15:30 We, approximately this year with the money out, we can do 15 to 20 line segments.
1:15:41 So a line segment would be between manhole to manhole.
1:15:45 That's one segment of sewer line.
1:15:47 We can do 15 to 20 segments in this current year's budget.
1:15:53 And then hopefully be able to do more as this next slide shows basically what the CIPP improvement does.
1:16:07 It's basically a pipe within a pipe, pulling the sleeve from one manhole to the next, using
1:16:13 either steam or air to inflate the pipe out to the sides of the host pipe.
1:16:19 After that, you can use steam, hot water, or you can cure the pipe, and processes done,
1:16:30 they'll take a camera unit in, better on it, and then they reinstate the services.
1:16:40 So it's all done with no digging, no disruption to service, and it's just great when you don't
1:16:48 have to, people are happy, you don't have to, as I showed you on the first slide, that whole
1:17:00 section of town done, trying to put truck contracts together, chip seal, and just the
1:17:12 same as chip seal does, they go in and they crack seal and they patching, we do the same
1:17:19 thing with the pipe.
1:17:26 So one more thing I'd like to mention, and we've done in this current budget year, this
1:17:31 This is a piece of equipment we purchased this year, looking still at trying to make pipe
1:17:38 improvements without having to do any disruption to service or excavation.
1:17:44 This is actually called a quick lock sleeve.
1:17:48 We can do point repairs with this equipment.
1:17:51 The first, the slide furthest to the left is actually showing a repair in a pipe that
1:17:58 broken spot in a pipe that'd be able to see IPP through unless it was fixed. So the second slide is
1:18:06 actually what this equipment is is it fits on your camera equipment and it's got a from which that's
1:18:15 what you see in the pipe. So you take you put a stainless steel sleeve on the packer, the sleeve
1:18:23 out to the repair point with the camera you can see and he can line up with the sleeve and then
1:18:36 flates to sleep out. So it inflates out, and you can kind of see right up on the top the
1:18:46 ridge is it's got a locking system. So as that sleep goes out, and that packer pushes
1:18:52 it out, it pushes out tight against the pipe, and then once those lock, they just, they
1:18:59 deflate the pack. So the third, the slide over for this to the right is a finished product.
1:19:07 what it looks like. These are actual pictures of what we have done in our system. So I thought
1:19:14 it would be nice to see what these guys are doing. We probably put in 15 or 20 of these,
1:19:21 and again, it's you, there is no digging. So two guys can go an inspection unit and another
1:19:29 guy to retrofit the equipment and send it out. It takes about depending on how far he
1:19:37 to go about an hour to do so and you can also see IPP through these so this not
1:19:45 only helps a lot say it's a lot safer for our guys to do repairs we use this
1:19:52 mainly and where there'd be a roadway or an asphalt alley traffic can do this
1:20:04 without any so the last slide I'm showing you is a liner system that we
1:20:17 We can align existing manholes that have deteriorated because of corrosive environments.
1:20:23 A manhole has exposed to these environments over long periods of deteriorate,
1:20:28 and they'll lose strength and structure.
1:20:33 We have 150,000 in this next year to make the improvements in areas where they are in these.
1:20:44 We have an illustration. We did two of these slides here or not in the ones in our system.
1:21:04 Sorry about that, I didn't have time to put the slides together, but this would give you an idea of what these do.
1:21:09 So, there's a polyurea, they go in and they, inside the mantle, they'll spray a polyurea first,
1:21:29 and a polyurethane foam of the orange is what you see is the outside part of the liner.
1:21:41 This also adds structure to these manholes that desperately need it, if they have a 10-year warranty
1:21:48 and if we were to go in and we've tried several different corrosive types of
1:21:54 manholes that hold up to these environments well. The best ones we've had
1:22:00 that I've seen besides this is it's a full manhole so it requires excavating
1:22:09 bypass pumping it's it's pretty this they don't have to do any digging and
1:22:19 and there's a 10-year warranty on it, so these have performed very well too, and this next year to be able to.
1:22:33 So, um, how does our wastewater flows through town? It ends up down in the canyon. That's the last part of the wastewater.
1:22:46 I think Jason has a question.
1:22:48 Sorry. Before we get there, so how much money were you looking at for the liner?
1:22:54 the slide previous or to the CIPP, what was in the budget for that?
1:23:02 This current year, we have 250,000.
1:23:05 And then if you go to that next slide with that, this device on the front end of that,
1:23:14 can you come then go back behind that and CIPP that to give us additional strength?
1:23:20 You don't have to do it.
1:23:21 These here, you can pull the CIPP sleeve through.
1:23:29 You will just wouldn't have, of course you won't see it.
1:23:36 This is to be able to go in and make those improvements when some of the repairs are
1:23:41 fair acts that they cannot just see PIPP.
1:23:47 These couplers, that's an 8-inch coupler they're about to just ask of me.
1:24:02 It's a lot more. So this is a great way to make these improvements
1:24:06 and also with the CIPP, it works well with that.
1:24:09 Any other questions for you, Ms. Son?
1:24:19 Thank you, Doug.
1:24:29 City Council appreciate your time tonight for wastewater treatment. Just have one
1:24:36 major project in the budget this year that we want to bring for you. That's the
1:24:42 energy dissipation structure. This would be considered a critical part of the wastewater
1:24:48 system and just so you have perspective these pictures are taken from down the
1:24:55 canyon just outside the gate of the wastewater treatment plant. So just
1:24:59 looking up the canyon wall. Energy dissipation structure is bringing the sewer flow off of the
1:25:09 canyon rim down to the wastewater tree on plant. That's why I say it's critical. Before this
1:25:12 to fail, we would have some serious issues. And left picture, as you look at that, the green arrow
1:25:22 at the top of the canyon rim putting down is where currently there is a box that collects the
1:25:28 the Grand View sewer trunk line water into that box and then it comes down through a pipe.
1:25:35 Now to the left of that green arrow you do see a box and two pipes coming out of it.
1:25:41 That is the old system that is not in use so that's not what we're looking at.
1:25:45 It's being used currently.
1:25:47 Actually if you come down from that green arrow you see the yellow arrow in the middle of the picture.
1:25:52 If that location, you can kind of see it, there's a HDPE pipe, 24-inch pipe, that is actually where the sewer water is coming through.
1:26:03 It's a 390-feet drop from up on the rim down to the middle picture, which is where the energy dissipation structure of the box is.
1:26:15 The sewer, the sewage flow, flows into there and it's constructed in a way that the energy of the sewage that comes into that box is dissipated
1:26:24 and it's slowed down so that it's able to go into the waste water treatment plant without
1:26:30 all that behind it.
1:26:33 This system was put in and what was originally brought to the city in 1985, so it's been a
1:26:42 while.
1:26:43 In the far right picture you see a sewer cap there on top of the dissipation box.
1:26:52 It has not been taken off for many years and previous employees have told me that they
1:26:58 did not dare.
1:26:59 So the idea is we have a million dollars in this budget, and it is to replace the box
1:27:06 at the top of the rim and here at the bottom of this patient structure.
1:27:12 Using the same line that 24-inch HDPE pipe is in good condition, it can be utilized to
1:27:18 just build a box next to you, think this you want, provide the city a structure that we
1:27:28 can depend on and know that it's going to last.
1:27:35 Any questions?
1:27:36 Yes, those two lines that we're seeing coming down that are exposed, they're not in use.
1:27:46 They're not in use.
1:27:47 They're not in use.
1:27:48 They're not a backup.
1:27:49 I can imagine that in 1985 that, you know, at this point they were left there as a backup.
1:27:58 The idea now would be this whole box with the new box.
1:28:05 So we would have backup boxes or the energy dissipation box would be backups.
1:28:12 So the ones you see are abandoned, they're not connected at the top at all.
1:28:22 And they could not be used.
1:28:23 It's been severed.
1:28:25 For the reason of what you're looking at and the concern.
1:28:30 But what is the cost associated with this particular project?
1:28:34 A million dollars.
1:28:36 A million dollars.
1:28:37 Yes.
1:28:38 So the DIPP, for what was the cost for the CIPP?
1:29:21 So in the budget, we have 250 in this year and 300 next year.
1:29:27 Okay, so that's...
1:29:29 It's in the whole book, right?
1:29:33 I remember, I tried to find it on the pages.
1:29:35 I can.
1:29:36 So each page had a little bar that named in your forecaster,
1:29:42 named the name of the project, and the dollar amount,
1:29:45 and that part you did.
1:29:47 It didn't have dollar amounts, and so that's why I'm just wondering.
1:29:51 Yes, 300 for next year, 300,000, and then 250 in this year.
1:29:59 in this year.
1:30:00 I mean, it's served with this new year as 300.
1:30:04 The new budget here.
1:30:05 Yes.
1:30:06 It's 300, okay.
1:30:07 So the quick walk, I would end.
1:30:08 That's where I got loaned to.
1:30:17 We purchased that equipment this year.
1:30:18 I just wanted to show you what we were doing for improvements.
1:30:19 And how?
1:30:20 Okay.
1:30:21 Beautiful.
1:30:22 Is that same with the OVC eyeliner?
1:30:23 We have 50,000 M for liners this in 23.
1:30:26 I'm just going to add that this is going to show up as the main line made in its dollar
1:30:42 maintenance dollars in the wastewater budget.
1:30:48 Can you just show me some examples of what they're doing
1:30:50 for maintenance.
1:30:51 Yeah, that says 500, so.
1:30:56 So on this page right here.
1:30:58 Just as it.
1:30:59 We're on page 14.
1:31:01 Thank you.
1:31:02 Like 27 main line maintenance under wastewater's 300,000.
1:31:06 Right here.
1:31:07 This was kind of at the start of our presentation,
1:31:09 all the chemical projects.
1:31:11 So these are main line maintenance dollars
1:31:13 that we're talking about.
1:31:14 Thank you.
1:31:15 I'll just add in our big book since one one sixty four page one sixty four
1:31:20 budget book looks like we're clear thank you so excited to learn about wastewater
1:31:32 collections there's not much more exciting than that well and now you're
1:31:36 glad you've sent there right because that's some pretty cool stuff that they're
1:31:39 doing not having to dig up all those pipes and being able to do all that
1:31:44 is much more efficient much more cost effective and safe way for our
1:31:48 So that's it for environmental community, I'm just going to move on quickly to the Prospers
1:32:02 community and that's going to have any more conversation about the fact that we're in
1:32:09 our process community as our focus area number six.
1:32:12 So this is the economic development sort of section and as I told you earlier in the
1:32:17 meeting tonight as we were talking about the economic development director position.
1:32:21 This is economic development, this is a certain renewal, this is also the airport, so we're
1:32:26 going to talk to you a few little bit here as we close.
1:32:29 We had this conversation earlier tonight with the adoption of the ordinance, we're going
1:32:33 to be underway on the recruitment for the economic development position right away,
1:32:38 and that's what the changes are going to be there.
1:32:42 executive leadership team, work with the airport much more closely in this position,
1:32:48 what kind of focus on that strategic planning effort of Prostras community, right?
1:32:53 And so that's underway.
1:32:54 We hope to have that position filled with another one of our, of our Supero team members
1:32:59 really quickly.
1:33:00 I just wanted to show you a few things that economic development in association with Urban
1:33:05 Renewal has done recently and these are, some of these are ongoing projects.
1:33:09 see this picture on the top left is a picture of the 160 main Avenue Lofts project. That's
1:33:14 the one that's kitty corner of this building. Obviously that one's a few months ago. They're
1:33:18 making great progress on it, but this was a good picture across the plaza with the city
1:33:22 on the side. Anyway, that's a project that's been worked on with Urban & New Lake and see
1:33:28 that the city has been supporting. The top right picture is an artist rendition of a children's
1:33:35 museum of the Magic Valley. This is a group that's been coming and working with Urban & New
1:33:39 and with that kind of development to move forward with the Children's Museum,
1:33:43 generally in the area of, I don't know, this way from where we're at, and so that project is
1:33:51 is moving along, making some progress. We have done some place-making. You'll see the art from
1:33:57 the back wall of City Hall. The second phase of that is now generally complete, so on your way out today,
1:34:02 if you go out the alley, you can see the whole thing pretty much done. That's another project
1:34:07 that we worked on.
1:34:08 And then the bottom right is another one of these downtown
1:34:13 mixed-use complex, but the parking structure,
1:34:15 that's on second, out of block, the other way
1:34:18 behind the 160 project.
1:34:20 And these are things that are coming,
1:34:21 they're incoming.
1:34:23 Urban Hill has been a great project,
1:34:25 a great partner on these projects with the city
1:34:29 and working with some also good partners
1:34:31 in the private sector.
1:34:33 So these are underway and continuing to go.
1:34:36 Another thing that we've been working out with Urban Renewal
1:34:39 that you'll see very soon will be the creation
1:34:41 of two new revenue allocation areas.
1:34:44 As you're all aware, there's a current revenue allocation area
1:34:47 downtown, and that one expires within a year, right?
1:34:51 So it's gonna go away, but it's been such a fantastic tool
1:34:55 for us to use to do some of these redevelopment projects
1:34:58 for the downtown area, this downtown renovation projects
1:35:01 that the agency is talking a lot about,
1:35:03 Once that expires, implementing a new revenue allocation area
1:35:06 out there, map on the left kind of shows an early version
1:35:10 of their draft of what that might look like.
1:35:13 Likewise, Orchard Drive East.
1:35:16 That's another revenue allocation area
1:35:18 that they've been putting together.
1:35:20 That is at the corner of Orchard and Champlain.
1:35:22 This is just a little bit south of the Cliff Bar,
1:35:25 another industrial park that they're working to put out there.
1:35:27 And so these are again, some economic development projects
1:35:31 that are being worked on, they'll continue
1:35:33 we worked on next year, they're just going to be kind of included in our operations budget.
1:35:38 I needed money for these apart from hiring the person that's going to do the work.
1:35:42 And then the agency is going to do some funding of these with the Red River Renewal TIFF money.
1:35:49 So with that, I'm going to turn some time over, unless you have any questions.
1:35:53 I'm going to turn some time over to the airport. Bill come talk to you.
1:35:58 Bill's got Ryan with them and they'll kind of tag team their presentation here
1:36:01 towards the end and that's actually about what's going on down the airport and also some budget stuff.
1:36:06 Any questions for Mitch on the economic? You alright? Okay, welcome Bill.
1:36:13 Thank you Mitch and good evening Councilman and Mayor. I just wanted to pre-do a little bit of what you'll be hearing.
1:36:22 The airport really has a sort of a potpourri of goals and areas that we work in accessible community,
1:36:30 Prosperous, responsible, those kinds of things, so we're going to sort of mash it all together
1:36:37 and deliver it to you tonight, so we're going to look, Ryan's going to help us with the first look at
1:36:44 some of our accessible, give you an update on our 2022 projects for our secure community stuff,
1:36:52 related to capital improvements at the airport, what's happening this current year on Access Control and Surveillance.
1:36:59 He'll also take a look at our capital requests and our operations fund for mowers and things
1:37:05 like that.
1:37:06 I'll give you a little preview of where the airport construction fund is.
1:37:10 That's the fund we use for FAA projects.
1:37:13 So those lap over different fiscal years and they're very fluid as you guys are familiar.
1:37:18 We'll talk a little bit about air show planning and where that is and round off a little
1:37:24 been talking about the airport as infrastructure and certainly an engine for
1:37:29 economic prosperity in the community. So with that I'd like to introduce Ryan
1:37:35 Johnson to talk to you about a couple of slides.
1:37:37 The first thing I'm going to talk to you guys about is just kind of an update on
1:37:54 last year's access control upgrades project that we had going on. We started
1:38:01 that are going to implement the access control system from the airport and
1:38:08 standardize it with the city and as well as the airport surveillance system and
1:38:14 get it on the exact same platform that the rest of the city uses and the IT department uses.
1:38:23 So as far as the access control aspect of the project, much like Vice Mayor mentioned,
1:38:33 it is extremely difficult to acquire parts, especially electronic parts.
1:38:41 So we are in the process with IT gathering parts because with the access control system,
1:38:50 You can't really piece it together.
1:38:52 It's got to be down for an animal amount of time.
1:38:55 So we want to have all the parts in place
1:38:58 and do it as quickly as possible.
1:39:00 So we are still working on the access control portion of that.
1:39:05 The airport's surveillance system,
1:39:07 all of the cameras, camera software.
1:39:10 All of that is up and running.
1:39:12 And we have implemented all the new cameras
1:39:15 and replaced all of the original cameras,
1:39:17 working extremely closely with IT, I haven't figured out all of the capabilities of these
1:39:25 cameras yet, but when I do, I'm sure I'll be giving you guys a presentation of what we
1:39:34 went from to what we have now, but that is currently almost complete except for working
1:39:43 working with our IT department to kind of iron out some, you know, first wrinkles that we find.
1:39:51 But I didn't want to throw a shout out to our TSA partners.
1:39:57 They got federal funding to install, as the picture shows, a million dollar baggage screening device behind the Sky West ticket counter.
1:40:09 So, um, that allows them to efficiently screen, um, every bag they don't have to just run to the machine similar to what you would at a checkpoint and the machine actually will determine whatever's in the bag they, they, uh, it's all automated now, so, that, uh, just kicked off, I think they started using that machine over the weekend, so, uh, first impressions with them are extremely high at the mark.
1:40:39 Hi, at the moment, but any questions on XS control?
1:40:44 Survey on XS, any of that?
1:40:46 Um, the next letter I'm going to be talking about is separate topic, so...
1:40:50 Any questions on this site?
1:40:53 Just to ask...
1:40:54 Correct. Yeah, the machine determines whether it's got to be checked and all of that, so...
1:41:13 Um, what this machine you don't have to do, any of that, it, uh...
1:41:17 That's down. The efficiency is a lot higher compared to what it was before.
1:41:22 Good. I think that's it. So here's some of our 2023 improvements. The phase two of our terminal
1:41:38 landscape upgrade. This is rehab of the parking lots landscape in front of the terminal or green
1:41:47 belt leading up to the terminal. This is phase two of a five-year approach. So the total is $45,000
1:41:56 for Phase 2, which would be this year.
1:42:01 The second item is a terminal building painting.
1:42:06 So other than the expansion in 2017,
1:42:09 the rest of the building hadn't been painted since 2009,
1:42:15 which is quite a long time.
1:42:18 That would be $34,500.
1:42:22 And then a new mower would like to upgrade our current mower, our mower, the end current
1:42:32 one that we're using is on that picture on the right there is from 2007.
1:42:36 So we felt like it would be a nice upgrade.
1:42:40 I didn't pull the oil pan out underneath, but you know, it's quite an old piece of sheeting.
1:42:46 But that is it for me.
1:42:51 Any questions?
1:42:52 Any questions?
1:42:53 Looks like you're good.
1:42:55 Thank you.
1:42:56 Thank you.
1:43:07 So I'd just like to talk a little bit about the airport construction fund.
1:43:11 It's a separate fund where we are accounting with our federal projects.
1:43:14 And often I come in and review the capital improvement plan with you all.
1:43:19 And we'll continue to do that.
1:43:21 We usually do that once or twice a year in length.
1:43:24 So, but really just to look at some of the highlights.
1:43:27 And there aren't numbers here.
1:43:28 These federal projects tend to go over one fiscal year.
1:43:32 It's all federal funding.
1:43:33 There is a slight component of match.
1:43:36 So, rather than get caught up with the numbers, we usually just put a placeholder in there and we reconcile at the end of the fiscal year.
1:43:43 So, Matt Farnsworth's very closely with me on that.
1:43:47 So, we've been taking just this funding generally as we look historically, we've been taking more and more discretionary type funding.
1:43:54 There's been more stimulus funding available.
1:43:57 You've noticed that the capital projects at the airport have been getting pretty expensive.
1:44:04 So, the first highlight I have here is environmental assessment design, and we've talked about
1:44:10 the main runway rehabilitation. It's been since 1998, 1999, since the runway was rehabilitated.
1:44:17 So, we're getting at the point where we're going to need some rehabilitation, some millen overlay,
1:44:23 and actually some reconstruction where the new crosswind is going to come across this.
1:44:28 So, we'll have some full depth reconstruction and grades meant for that.
1:44:32 So, you'll see this year we're starting out, I'll come in with a contract for an environmental
1:44:39 assessment beginning and 30% design next year, we'll be looking at full-blown design and be
1:44:45 fairly extensive engineering work next year.
1:44:48 So, you'll be seeing these types of things rolling through in the coming months.
1:44:54 Next year we have on our list a lower and a snow blower to sweep or truck, we may be
1:45:00 ambitious with that but we're aiming high we'll see how if we can negotiate
1:45:05 some funding there I think we can at least probably get two of those pieces
1:45:10 next year and we're going to be applying for a discretionary grant through the
1:45:16 bipartisan infrastructure legislation that came through we've been struggling
1:45:21 with funding that we have aging infrastructure with the term on roadway
1:45:25 the sidewalks. I've talked to the council some may remember about the
1:45:30 front of the terminal building and starting to crumble. The ADA access is
1:45:36 inferior and not compliant so I think we've got a good chance. We didn't get
1:45:42 the funding this year but we'll just apply again and fall and I think we
1:45:46 check a lot of the boxes for some of these terminal funding. Any questions
1:45:53 about the construction funding in general.
1:45:58 Looks good Bill.
1:45:59 We're going to talk a little bit about, you know,
1:46:03 in the city's mission statement we talk
1:46:05 about preserving honoring our heritage.
1:46:08 And next year will be the 75th anniversary of Jawsland Field.
1:46:13 And you can see the May 2nd headline on Sunday, 1948,
1:46:18 from our local newspaper.
1:46:19 There's Mr. and Mrs. Jawsland there.
1:46:22 And Mayor Lauterbach, I think is the mayor's name at that time.
1:46:26 They came out 4,000 strong on Saturday the May 1st through snow squalls, believe it or not.
1:46:32 They had bands from high schools, it was quite a civic event to cut the ribbon on a new airport.
1:46:39 And these folks had many of the same goals that we do today about prosperity and being accessible and healthy.
1:46:47 They just wore different fashions and things like that.
1:46:50 Our forefathers did a great job with taking a decision.
1:46:55 In fact, the FAA even put out mention recently
1:46:58 within the trades that we received the very first grant
1:47:03 after World War II for airport improvement.
1:47:05 So we had some very progressive people back then,
1:47:08 lobbying the federal government,
1:47:10 starting to build an airport for us.
1:47:12 So more about the air show, the city and counties
1:47:15 both budgeted 25,000 in next year's budget
1:47:18 to help fund that event, particularly with its unique characteristic of being an anniversary.
1:47:25 Any questions about that?
1:47:26 I'm sure you'll be hearing a lot more about the air shows, we turn into the fall in a
1:47:31 new year, prosperous community.
1:47:38 So with tonight's news about the airport joining forces, with the economic development
1:47:44 directory yet to be hired, I just wanted to talk a little bit about that.
1:47:49 First of all, I want to say I welcome that pairing with the airport and an economic development
1:47:54 director.
1:47:55 I think a lot of good work will come from that in the future years, I think long term,
1:47:59 that's a nice pairing.
1:48:01 I wanted to put this up.
1:48:03 It's almost really what I was thinking in here is what can I say that's very foundational,
1:48:08 what's almost a definition, what is the core responsibility of an airport and it's much
1:48:13 like our road systems and many other activities that we do as a public sector organization.
1:48:18 I just wrote it up there that the airport and it's a belief I have it provides the service
1:48:23 and infrastructure platform for aeronautical businesses to conduct safe, efficient movement
1:48:29 of people, goods and services.
1:48:31 I tried to illustrate some of those things with pictures, but that's what I feel is
1:48:37 our core responsibility out there.
1:48:39 You know, when people, you pick up the phone and ask it, when are you going to provide
1:48:43 more air service, it's something that's really not included in that core definition.
1:48:48 that we certainly, as public sector organization,
1:48:51 we try to get together with the private sector out there
1:48:54 and take advantage of opportunity
1:48:56 and create prosperity and economic development.
1:48:59 So I was a highlight here tonight
1:49:02 and some news about this and I wanted to acknowledge it
1:49:05 and let you know that I welcome that pairing
1:49:07 and that restructure that we will see.
1:49:13 So I wanted to just preview,
1:49:14 we're gonna talk about three things
1:49:16 as we just look for improvements in economic development
1:49:19 I thought I'd just run down, give you a little bit of background and status on where we are with some of these things right here.
1:49:26 So first off, he's here, so we all know the industry's in pretty rough shape right now.
1:49:33 Coming off this whole downturn with COVID, now they're suffering with high-fueled prices.
1:49:38 They've got labor shortages, our local condition, we were really riding a high, we were going to Denver and Salt Lake.
1:49:46 We had three flights to Salt Lake, one to Denver, and suddenly it seemed like the bottom fell
1:49:52 out and we reduced to one flight.
1:49:54 We were asked to provide a minimum of revenue guarantee.
1:49:57 These are all difficult conversations, so the good news on the revenue guarantee, and
1:50:02 I've been sending out reports that you've probably seen, it's for fiscal year, just for
1:50:07 for everyone in the room, it's for fiscal year.
1:50:10 for calendar year 2022, the revenue guarantee is for $400,000, it's for the 12-month period.
1:50:18 We had a small payment in the first quarter of $25,000, and the second quarter we're in
1:50:24 the black.
1:50:25 There was no subsidy required as a guarantee, so good news.
1:50:30 I continue to have conversations with the planners at SkyWest.
1:50:34 We've been also trying to dialogue with Delta when we can.
1:50:38 Our first goal is to maintain network connectivity with the air transportation system.
1:50:44 The closest option we have for that is the relationship and the retention of the delta
1:50:48 service to Salt Lake.
1:50:49 So that's absolutely our priority to retain and expand that service.
1:50:54 I think it bodes well that the second quarter of the flights have been very full.
1:50:59 I think we're averaging about 42% load factors.
1:51:02 So this isn't lost on the planners at Sky West.
1:51:05 see this, I've asked them to maybe take a look at that fall schedule, they're very fluid, their fleet is changing.
1:51:13 There's a lot going on with their organization, but I'm putting as many little placeholders with them as I can at a return.
1:51:21 So I think as we move into the fall and the last quarter, we'll have to really see what the con to 2023 looks like as this term of this
1:51:32 of this matter on revenue guarantee starts to expire, so we'll stay tuned on all those
1:51:38 things that we'll keep you impressed. So economic development, prosperity, I am
1:51:42 simply we all have a role in that. You know the business community, our citizens, the
1:51:48 people that fly the business community out at the airport, so I think I'm
1:51:53 testing out a new slogan for a fly local campaign here tonight, fly local fly twin,
1:51:58 so we'll have to fit that in somewhere, but I certainly think we all have a role
1:52:02 in prosperity, general aviation.
1:52:10 This is activity other than air service.
1:52:14 For those that aren't familiar with the term, and this is just the sampling
1:52:18 of the things that happen out at the airport. The photo at the right
1:52:22 is some overflow from the Allen Convention, I think that was last week.
1:52:26 So unfortunately we don't look like that every day, but
1:52:30 I thought I'd just give you a quick shot of what it does look like at times.
1:52:34 you know, during holidays, sometimes it does look like that.
1:52:37 But we do have corporate aviation, and I've had people say
1:52:41 to me, here's Passo, they're all going to Sun Valley,
1:52:44 and they're all doing this and that, and that's not true.
1:52:47 There's many businesses in the Magic Valley that use corporate
1:52:51 aviation to come to town and do business.
1:52:53 So I'd like to say that they come because we have a nice airport,
1:52:56 but that's really not why they come.
1:52:58 They come to do business in the Magic Valley.
1:53:01 So corporate aviation is a very strong component out there, very important.
1:53:05 As you know, beyond firefighting, there's strong partners with us.
1:53:10 We've developed sophisticated firefighting base. I think they'll be with us in a long long haul.
1:53:15 I'm renegotiating at least renew it with them currently.
1:53:19 Ag Spring is really hard to quantify. We know Ag is a huge economic driver.
1:53:24 And aerial applicators that use the airport to use fertilizers and herbicides.
1:53:31 Those types of things play an important role in the agricultural production and prosperity.
1:53:37 Like training, I'm really proud of the new school we have out there, we're training more
1:53:41 pilots, those are the future hand-your-owners, and just people that enjoy flying, maybe they
1:53:46 take off an east flight flying for other components of business.
1:53:52 Medical transport, well hours of the day, I can't say enough about that military cargo
1:53:58 with the FedEx facility is quite an investment
1:54:00 and certainly the pleasure of flying.
1:54:02 So that's a sampling of those other things
1:54:05 that happen out at the airport
1:54:06 that I think are very important for our community.
1:54:13 So it was in 2021, I came to the council,
1:54:16 there was some council directed a capital spending
1:54:18 that I had requested for utilities to complement
1:54:22 the Northeast development area and the taxi lanes out there.
1:54:26 We currently have one hand or pictured up there
1:54:28 on the right next to FedEx that's being constructed,
1:54:33 and that should be nearing completion here
1:54:35 in the next month or two.
1:54:36 Large hanger, 120 by 100 feet.
1:54:39 We've got more conversations going on
1:54:42 about near-term development.
1:54:43 So, with those utilities, it would have been impossible
1:54:47 to really get to this point.
1:54:48 So, appreciate the investment once again,
1:54:51 and I think long-term land development is steady dollars
1:54:55 and steady revenue.
1:54:59 So, if you're happy to answer any questions
1:55:01 Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you for your participation, as a liaison, and bringing
1:55:54 those messages forth in the community as an ambassador.
1:55:58 Thank you.
1:56:01 Anybody else?
1:56:02 Thank you Bill.
1:56:05 Thank you Mayor.
1:56:06 Thank you Council.
1:56:11 All right so that's it for our focus areas tonight.
1:56:13 So I just have one or two quick more slides for you.
1:56:17 You've seen this one before.
1:56:18 This is that list that we've been kind of populating as we've gone through the last several meetings of some of those ideas you might have for your Council directed capital, the 7, and 7,000.
1:56:28 And notice I added one this week.
1:56:30 The bottom one on that list is the downtown residential historic district investigation.
1:56:35 If you all were paying attention this last week we had an open house where we invited all those folks from the downtown area to come and hear it.
1:56:43 We have a public hearing scheduled on the 15th. There's nothing in the budget.
1:56:47 Or this investigation happened. So if after the 15th the council would like for us to move forward with that creation process we had Jonathan present to you all a couple of months ago.
1:56:59 Okay, we have a project estimate what that would cost to do the investigation all that kind of stuff and this is kind of a
1:57:04 Middle of the road we got range from a little high to a little lower than this number
1:57:09 So there's nothing budgeted in the 23 budget to move forward that project if we
1:57:15 It liked to move forward with that project after that hearing on the 15th
1:57:19 We need to find some money for it here's potentially one source of money for it
1:57:22 It could also maybe go into contingency or we can grab some reserves or whatever, but I thought I'd throw it up there for you to
1:57:28 So you're saying August 15th, that's it?
1:57:30 It's 15th.
1:57:31 But we have to make our allocation decision for that.
1:57:37 We will set the maximum spending a couple of weeks before that.
1:57:42 And so we need to start thinking about, I guess, like I said, there's a couple of sources we can.
1:57:51 This is one.
1:57:52 Contingency would be another.
1:57:54 We need to pull some money out of reserves to put in for that.
1:57:57 We could do that as well.
1:57:59 The budget right now doesn't include any of those things for this particular project.
1:58:07 So, again, we'll need to, we'll need you would ask that we hear from the both sides.
1:58:14 Certainly at the open house that we had, there was both sides present, more so than the first presentation.
1:58:20 It's not quite so unanimous as maybe it appeared to be, so we'll hear from them on the 15th.
1:58:25 It's just you thinking about that.
1:58:27 And so anyway, not necessarily making a plug for it.
1:58:31 Just kind of get it up there so we can start thinking about it.
1:58:34 The other thing that I've done in tonight's presentation,
1:58:37 if you would like us to go there, this last bullet point
1:58:40 is the master plan, sidewalk priorities.
1:58:43 And so I've got several slides here if you would like to.
1:58:46 We can talk about what some of those other sidewalk projects are,
1:58:50 if you want to talk about that, or we can save that for next time.
1:58:53 And I think you're in here too.
1:58:57 What do you want?
1:58:58 I think I can talk about those.
1:58:59 I've been a minute on the sidewalk.
1:59:00 Okay.
1:59:01 With my swell.
1:59:02 While we're in here.
1:59:03 On a roll.
1:59:09 Five or six slides here.
1:59:10 This one will show you.
1:59:11 Well, I'm here to get some room.
1:59:19 Okay, Councilman.
1:59:20 Which was about to steal my thunder.
1:59:22 Yeah.
1:59:23 So, this first slide, actually, I think speaks volumes to what we've been able to accomplish
1:59:28 the last couple of years.
1:59:30 The Sidewalk Master Plan was kind of the brainchild back in 2019 and we got it.
1:59:35 It came to you in 2020, like 2020, and kind of showed you some options of different areas
1:59:43 for sidewalk that would help with connectivity.
1:59:46 This map actually shows all of the pieces that we have done since that time.
1:59:50 You can see that there's quite a few pieces completed, is thanks to the Council Director
2:00:00 funded piece that you were all a part of.
2:00:03 So, personally, I want to say thank you.
2:00:05 I did not realize how much of a success this plan was going to be and now that I'm here and looking at it, we've done quite a bit of work.
2:00:14 So, this has been completed from the original plans. You see, these are what's left and so I went through and kind of chose a few pieces that I thought would be important for you to see.
2:00:25 We are in the process of adding some more locations to the plan. We've got about six other locations that we're trying to get at it, but of course with the shortage of staff
2:00:34 staff or superheroes as much call them. We're running just a little bit behind the schedule.
2:00:39 So the first location that I want to talk about tonight is on Stadium Boulevard.
2:00:45 This is east of East one Drive. There's a little section of the concrete sidewalk that's missing.
2:00:52 We estimate about $80,000 to complete this little piece here.
2:00:56 The question is about that location. I'm going too fast, but I do know your time is valuable.
2:01:05 That would be part of the original design when we look at it, but I believe we already have the right away in this location.
2:01:19 So the successor, I'm going to back up one slide.
2:01:22 So the success story here is both location D and location N.
2:01:26 Oh, this year we're just doing the design, looking right away only.
2:01:31 If you're not right, Cammy here, go and we talked about that.
2:01:34 This year we're almost through the design with both of those two locations.
2:01:38 There's no right away that's going to be needed.
2:01:40 So that kind of saves us some time, and then the other nice piece is when the design's done,
2:01:46 we'll have a very good cost estimate to come back and say, this is what those two locations will cost us.
2:01:51 Go ahead.
2:01:52 Aaron, on this map, B does not have a location. A blue box, what is it?
2:01:58 So B was right there by the nursing school, across the street from North College,
2:02:05 from CSI, and that was completed.
2:02:07 So first location, second location is actually right there,
2:02:15 and the street just crossed the street from the library.
2:02:18 There's no sidewalk along the city park portion,
2:02:21 and so this location actually is the piece
2:02:26 of missing sidewalks, so we believe it'll cost us
2:02:29 about $271,000 to do.
2:02:33 We're pretty confident with that cost
2:02:35 that that's about what it'll cost us.
2:02:37 So that's another piece that I think is critical
2:02:39 that adds connectivity to the library
2:02:43 down to the city buildings. It's just a critical piece that's missing on that side.
2:02:47 So the next location is down at Southwood, close to South Hills Middle School.
2:02:55 Now there is a subdivision that's been added so this estimate is going to be high,
2:02:59 but there's a subdivision that was added that did a piece of that sidewalk already
2:03:03 so we can, we'll be able to take that portion out. I just don't know what it is yet.
2:03:09 And the other piece that we've been dealing with a lot with is the rise in inflation and construction
2:03:13 So a lot of these estimates change, but I think this one, the price, would be the last
2:03:22 thing that we're showing here because of the peaks that was constructed with the construction
2:03:26 of the subdivision.
2:03:27 So Aaron, on this piece, when they get to Washington, they're away from the pedestrians.
2:03:33 They get bad assumptions and most of the kids get across Washington.
2:03:40 Don't, so as part of this design, we take a look at that.
2:03:48 because the last thing I want is people crossing at 45 miles an hour right there
2:03:52 so we definitely take a look at something to see what that is.
2:03:55 That would be part of that $350,000 or so.
2:03:59 Last but not, let's see, no, this is the last month.
2:04:06 So this is the current, in this current fiscal year we budgeted for the design of this one.
2:04:11 I've had multiple individuals reach out to us as we were out walking the site with the designer
2:04:18 and the surveyor, they were approached and the residents very much want the sidewalk to be completed.
2:04:24 I don't count some member Brown and Rita both heard from citizens and they reached out to me personally say,
2:04:30 hey we need to get this one done. So this is one that the design is in process and then once we get that design,
2:04:36 it'll probably be another couple of months. I'll have a good estimate, but we can fund this for design for next year.
2:04:43 the principal behind this one. The last one is on Elizabeth Boulevard right there
2:04:50 between Harman Park and it'll create a connection from Harman Park all the way
2:04:55 to Eastland. There's a short section already towards the east on your map.
2:04:59 There's already sidewalk and so really we'll just make a solid connection all
2:05:04 the way through. We've got a few little pieces of art. There's a few little pieces
2:05:08 in here that they're like an, for example, the box culvert that takes the
2:05:12 I have to take a look at that, make sure that everything's okay with that, but that's all being taken care of right now with it, with the design.
2:05:19 So again, a couple of months when I get the final design done, we'll be able to come back with that as done to tell you exactly any questions about anything that I've talked about.
2:05:33 So, Erica, can you back up to the first one too?
2:05:42 So, short section, Emanislyn has a sidewalk deferral?
2:05:52 Yes.
2:05:53 So, there are no sidewalks that at that corner?
2:05:55 I believe the sidewalk's already in place on that corner, so the deferral, I'm not sure which she says that's a...
2:06:01 The sidewalk?
2:06:02 Yeah, I'm not sure why that line doesn't continue, my guess is, because it was a deferral we didn't include it, but we would...
2:06:09 to council ask to go after them if they get the sidewalk to come in.
2:06:15 As we run into some of these projects around, is that a...
2:06:22 Absolutely.
2:06:23 Yep, it's, you know, that's one of the tools in our toolbox that we carry around with us, right?
2:06:29 of those is the deferral mechanism. Others are grants, you know, those kinds of things,
2:06:33 but that one definitely is a...
2:06:40 Any other questions? Perfect. Thanks. Good information.
2:06:44 I think that's it for you for a presentation. If you don't have any more questions, I'll just tell
2:06:59 you that next week we're going to talk about Focus Area 2 and 3. We're going to have the Library here
2:07:07 to talk to you a little bit about what's going on with the Library and the Lab on the public safety
2:07:10 folks, so police and fire and dispatching the city attorney's office is going to train.
2:07:15 So, that completes the business, next item on the agenda is the time for public input.
2:07:39 Anybody in the audience wishes to address council on items not, well I guess if there's any comments
2:07:46 on the budget that would be allowed but also any other items not on the agenda that you wish
2:07:55 to comment on. There's anybody in the audience? One scene, no one. Advisory board reports.
2:08:05 Did he have anything to manage his office?
2:08:16 I think you all have been being aware of this but we are back together as a city for our
2:08:20 city breakfast squirrely. That's this Thursday, Thursday, just as a reminder for you.
2:08:26 Okay, so that we will move on to public hearings.
2:08:38 Do you guys want to take a five minute break?
2:08:40 You want to go?
2:08:42 We have two public hearings.
2:08:46 So we have two public hearings tonight.
2:09:00 I'm going to go ahead and read the rules to set work.
2:09:03 Okay, so we're going to follow this agenda.
2:09:07 City staff will present the request and analysis.
2:09:10 The applicant will then present their request.
2:09:14 The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff.
2:09:18 And after questions have been asked, the public hearing will be open.
2:09:22 Anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions
2:09:26 about the request being considered.
2:09:29 When you give testimony in the public hearing, please step up to the podium,
2:09:33 State your name and address and present your comments and concerns.
2:09:38 After giving testimony, please sign the public sign and sheet located in the lobby with your
2:09:44 name and address and we will allow two minutes for those of that testimony.
2:09:51 After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and
2:09:56 make a closing statement.
2:09:58 Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.
2:10:02 And then we will, after the closing of the public, after the closing statements, public
2:10:08 hearing will be closed, no further testimony from the applicant or audience, and then council
2:10:15 will have our discussion.
2:10:18 So first on the agenda is an action item requesting a zoning district change and zoning
2:10:24 map amendment from R4 to R4 ZDA for approximately 34 acres on property located at the 1200 to
2:10:34 of the east side of Harrison Street, South Carolina, on behalf of Idaho Land Holding LLC,
2:10:45 and we have Lisa Strickland, City Planning, welcome Lisa.
2:10:55 Good evening Mayor and Council.
2:10:57 This is a request for the property located along the 1,200 and 1,300 block of Harrison
2:11:02 Street, to rezone the property from R4 to R4 ZDA for approximately 34 acres. ZDA allows
2:11:12 development to request variations to the zoning and development standards and provide flexibility
2:11:18 using a creative approach to land development. The property does not have any significant
2:11:23 zoning history and is undeveloped. It is surrounded by both residential and undeveloped properties.
2:11:29 The proposed development is for attached single household dwellings or town homes with four
2:11:36 units per building.
2:11:38 The property will be subdivided to allow for individual ownership and will consist of a
2:11:42 layout that has 75 buildings with 300 residential units.
2:11:47 The remainder of the area surrounding the lots will be owned and maintained collectively
2:11:51 by the owners in the subdivision and will provide open space for the residents.
2:11:56 The Arford Zone allows for attached single household dwellings, also known as townhouses,
2:12:02 on lots fronting arterials and collectors.
2:12:05 The development will be constructed along an extension of Pheasant Road, which is a collector.
2:12:13 The applicant has provided several depictions of varying types of structures with basic architecture,
2:12:18 such as single story and two story buildings with pitched roofs.
2:12:22 There will be multiple streets constructed to support this development as well as provide
2:12:26 future connections as more development occurs. The applicant has provided a phase plan consisting
2:12:32 of three phases with plans to complete the project by 2027. Currently, the density provided
2:12:38 for in the R4 zoning district will allow for 11,000 square foot loss with the four plaques
2:12:44 on each one, which is the equivalent of approximately 400 dwelling units. The applicant
2:12:51 has applied for a zoning development agreement in order to provide a master development plan
2:12:56 and to request some exceptions to the code that would allow for this 300 dwelling unit.
2:13:04 Exceptions include a change in the following requirements.
2:13:08 The minimum lot area would be changed from 4,000 to 720 square feet.
2:13:13 The maximum lot occupancy would go from 60% to 100%.
2:13:19 They would have no property line setbacks which would allow each dwelling to be built on the property line.
2:13:25 There is no current screening requirement in our city code.
2:13:30 However, the development is planned to have a six-foot fence installed around the perimeter of the property to minimize the impacts of the surrounding properties.
2:13:40 Staff has reviewed this request. This is not for C. The exceptions, nor the land uses of townhounds being detrimental.
2:13:49 that are mentally different from current permitted land uses within the zoning district.
2:13:54 Each townhouse can be individually owned and is more in line with a typical residential development rather than apartment complexes.
2:14:01 The design provides a reasonable out of open space and should help lower the visual impacts of the cluster development.
2:14:08 Staff has determined the overall development will have a similar impact on the surrounding area as a typical subdivision.
2:14:17 And we find this plan to be in conformance with the overall goals and objectives listed
2:14:22 within the comprehensive plan.
2:14:23 Upon conclusion, the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval of the request
2:14:27 as presented on June 14th, 2022 to the Council.
2:14:31 Should the Council approve the request as presented, staff recommends the following conditions.
2:14:37 Subject to site plan amendments as required by building, engineering, fire, and zoning
2:14:41 officials to comply with applicable city code and standards.
2:14:47 So one of the things I wanted to show you on the site plan that they provided originally
2:14:53 a pheasant road was going to go straight east and dead end and there were residential homes
2:15:03 there.
2:15:04 And we know that in the future there may be plans to have a school on the school property
2:15:15 that is just southeast of this location, so the developer, we brought them in and they
2:15:22 worked really closely with us to try and make a better connection for pheasant, so that if
2:15:31 a school were to develop southeast of this property, they would be able to make a connection
2:15:35 as well, to pheasant, so that once the area is constructed, we actually will have an east-west
2:15:43 connection from Blue Lakes to Pheasant, which we think was very important when you're looking
2:15:50 at the overall picture of how the area is planned to develop.
2:16:11 So if you see Pheasant Road, it is going to now come from the west, it's going to curve
2:16:17 down just a little bit, and it's going to connect to Gregory, which is the one that runs north
2:16:23 and south, and then there will be a way for a connection to occur on the east boundary
2:16:29 of this property that can be connected to blue lakes. Staff reviewed this site master plan
2:16:52 and feels like it's pretty compatible with the comprehensive plan. And as stated before,
2:16:59 the development with an R4 would naturally allow for 400 units. There's 300 in this one
2:17:05 And there is a much more open space and a walkability.
2:17:12 This concludes my presentation,
2:17:14 and the applicant is here to answer any questions
2:17:16 and do their presentation as well.
2:17:18 And I'll stand for any.
2:17:20 Any questions for Lisa?
2:17:26 Does that look like?
2:17:32 Evening, Madam Mayor, members of the City Council.
2:17:34 My name is David Tebow,
2:17:35 with the EHA Engineer's at 621 North College Road.
2:17:38 Here in Twin Falls,
2:17:39 I'm representing the applicant this evening
2:17:41 for the request for ZDA.
2:17:44 The applicant has constructed these types of units already, south of Twin, just south
2:17:49 and west of the middle school that's built on Harrison Street, just kind of south of
2:17:55 this project.
2:17:56 And that project was successful, so they've come back and are requesting the ZDA to accomplish
2:18:01 the same thing.
2:18:02 Just on Mauryacridge this time, we have 34 acres in this project.
2:18:05 We're proposing about 75% of the maximum density that's available to us with the base R4 zone.
2:18:13 So the R4 ZDA zone, there's a couple points I'd like to make, maybe to help clarify just a few points.
2:18:20 So we're requesting a deviation or change from your city code as it's written today with the minimum lot area.
2:18:27 So each of these structures, the one that I'm kind of pointing to, has a dashed line around it right there.
2:18:32 And that is actually a lot. That line sits about two feet out of the proposed building footprint.
2:18:37 And that is the reason that we're asking for a minimum 722 square foot lot is so that each
2:18:44 of these residential townhome type units can be located on their own lot.
2:18:49 And then there will be lots that are the common area around the perimeter.
2:18:53 There's some advantages financially and managerial relief for that condition.
2:18:57 And so that's why we're requesting it.
2:18:58 That request was granted in their other project as well, so it's consistent from project to project.
2:19:04 at least alluded to the fact that we would provide perimeter fencing, I just want to make
2:19:08 sure everybody understood perimeter fencing be along the north boundary, potential along
2:19:12 the east boundary, the south boundary, and it may be somewhat intermittent along here
2:19:17 since we're here, we would not fence off a pheasant or feather or graggery inside the
2:19:22 project.
2:19:23 There will be onsite management on this project, I'm going to have some office space, at least
2:19:30 available to manage. Similarly with the law size, the minimum law size we are asking for
2:19:40 zero-lot lines so again the structure can be constructed just right in immediate proximity.
2:19:44 We still maintain building separation that's consistent with fire code
2:19:48 recommendations and guidelines that would afford us the most cost-effective
2:19:53 building structure. I believe they're spaced out at about 20 feet between the
2:19:57 structures sufficient parking zone sign. We're not deviating from the city's parking
2:20:01 code, but we're just asking for the ZDA as it's written and presented here this
2:20:06 evening to be approved. It's very similar to what they've already completed and
2:20:11 constructed as far as the deviations from city code. This project does have a
2:20:17 lot of open space and we did work extensively with state staff to make
2:20:20 sure that Fesin could transition towards the south and have a connection for a
2:20:25 potential future school. Immediately north is probably notable to point north of
2:20:32 This project is the Calist-Doga Springs subdivision,
2:20:35 which is commenced with their first phase of construction
2:20:37 up on Orchard.
2:20:38 They'll phase from north to south
2:20:40 and be towards a construct down to this location.
2:20:45 It does tie in.
2:20:49 I stand for any questions that Council might have.
2:20:51 Not very good.
2:20:53 You, this is one question.
2:20:55 So each of the, would be its own mod.
2:21:02 Yes.
2:21:03 And the open space would be probably multiple lots.
2:21:07 Yeah, because of the roadways, same ownership,
2:21:10 more than likely with the manager management.
2:21:12 And then the parking lot, so what there?
2:21:15 So if I went up on a townhouse, is it just the house?
2:21:18 Yep, that's correct.
2:21:24 I believe that would be held in common interest
2:21:25 in management.
2:21:26 Any questions for staff before?
2:21:40 Okay, so we will now open up this project
2:21:45 for a public hearing.
2:21:47 Again, you come down to the podium, please state your name
2:21:52 address and present your comments or concerns. Is there anybody that wishes to speak on this
2:21:57 project? Seeing none, we will close the public hearing. Any questions for staff? Jason?
2:22:10 I've got a question. So I look at the, I guess the site location, that lateral running through
2:22:23 that location. The yellow line is associated with that, but on the site map, it looks like
2:22:31 there's a little bit more something in squaring off. Are we encompassing all of that property
2:22:36 in this? Yes. The top of the specimen. So since the time that we've submitted this application,
2:22:49 the landowner to the north and the applicant have actually completed a land on line adjustment.
2:22:56 That's what I need to say, a lot of line adjustment to square that off.
2:23:00 And so the plan that you see before you, it has a straight sort of east-west line is the accurate boundary as it exists today.
2:23:07 Prior to completing that line adjustment, it did follow the center of that line.
2:23:13 Okay, correct. Thank you. Any other questions? Time for discussion.
2:23:28 I also wish I did close the public. John Marigar.
2:24:59 to seek change and map amendment for the property 1200 to 1300 blocks of the east side of Harrison
2:25:06 Street South. Any further discussion? Aaron roll call vote please. Jason Brown. Yes.
2:25:16 Andrew Cutler. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Vice-married. Yes. Sean Baraker. Yes.
2:25:23 Thank you, Boyd. Yes.
2:25:25 Thank you. Motion passes 6-0.
2:25:28 Thank you.
2:25:30 Okay. Next public hearing is a request for a zoning title amendment to Title 10, Chapter 4, Section 19,
2:25:40 Canyon Rim Overlay, Removing Permitted and Special Uses,
2:25:45 Modifying a Loud Maximum Heights, and Removing the CDA Requirement,
2:25:50 of Ria Ramon on behalf of North County Medical Center.
2:25:56 Again, we have Lisa Strickland, welcome Lisa again.
2:26:02 Good evening, Mayor and Council.
2:26:04 This is a request to amend the Canyon Rim Overlay
2:26:08 Zoning District Title by removing certain sections
2:26:11 regulating land use types, ZDA requirements
2:26:14 and amending location restrictions
2:26:17 on applying for extra building height.
2:26:19 Title 10 419 was adopted in 1996, and the intent was to establish an overlay district
2:26:26 for the Canyon Rim.
2:26:27 The overlay along the Snake River Canyon Rim includes all of the area within 700 feet of
2:26:32 the rim and all of the area within 200 feet of the rim along the Rock Creek Canyon.
2:26:38 In 2006 and 2014, limits to this title dealing with the building high restrictions were approved,
2:26:45 that additional building heights beyond 100 feet from the canyon rim may be allowed,
2:26:50 but only in certain locations.
2:26:54 Within 1,000 feet of state administered highway, or between Washington and Blue Lakes,
2:27:00 and only for certain land use types, such as hotel, convention center, or private public mixed-use developments.
2:27:09 The code also requires a zoning development agreement for all development proposed in the overlay area
2:27:15 within the 700 and the 200 feet from the rent, respectively.
2:27:19 The applicant has coordinated with staff on the proposal to amend Title 10-419,
2:27:25 Canyon Ramp Overlay, and upon request, staff provided a draft
2:27:29 of the proposed changes we've been working on internally.
2:27:33 These changes would include removing land use regulations,
2:27:36 updating the building height development standards,
2:27:39 and removing the requirement for a zoning development agreement
2:27:42 for proposed developments within the overlay.
2:27:44 removal of the use regulations would cause the land uses to be determined by the base
2:27:49 zone district upon which the overlay is placed. Placing the building height development standards
2:27:55 with a while for the maximum height allowed for the base zone within 100 feet of the canyon
2:28:01 rim, additional height beyond 50 feet would be required to follow city code 1073, a process
2:28:09 it requires a public hearing and final approval from the City Council. Currently, a zoning
2:28:14 development agreement is required if the property is within the Canyon Room overlay and the purpose
2:28:20 of a zoning district development agreement is to allow for development creativity and
2:28:26 allow an applicant to request variations from the underlying zoning and development requirements.
2:28:32 Historically, the ZDA requests have been used for the state of purpose in the code have not
2:28:38 been used for the state of purpose in the code, rather it's been used to ask for additional
2:28:43 height and to modify permitted and special use land uses. The Snake River Canyon is a
2:28:49 space with natural beauty. It's been developed with requirements for public amenities such
2:28:54 as walking trails for all to enjoy. The Snake River Canyon has been an attractive area for
2:28:59 development over the years with the majority of undeveloped areas currently master planned
2:29:06 within an existing planning and development, or a zoning
2:29:09 development agreement.
2:29:11 The amendment to the title eliminating the zoning development
2:29:14 agreement requirement within the governed by the base zoning
2:29:17 district upon which the overlay is placed.
2:29:20 For City Code 1014-5, the commission
2:29:24 was to hold a public hearing and make recommendations
2:29:27 on proposing a zoning amendment.
2:29:31 The commission prior to recommending the zoning title
2:29:34 amendment held that hearing on June 14th, 2022, and made a positive recommendation to
2:29:43 approve this request as presented.
2:29:46 Council is charged with deciding to approve the request, deny the request, table the request
2:29:51 for additional information, or approve with conditions.
2:29:55 In the event that Council shall approve the amendment, it will be made part of this title
2:29:59 upon preparation and passage of importance.
2:30:01 This concludes my presentation. I'll stand for any questions and the applicant is present
2:30:06 for theirs. Any questions for Lisa at this point? Let's move on to that.
2:30:15 Council members, Scott Daly, other services from North Canyon Mental Center, are protected
2:30:29 following the Illinois Law Project granted. This isn't a project specific request, but
2:30:37 this is what we serve services in the clinic, in adjacent to the property that we use approximately
2:30:57 that that space is not sufficient to expand the services.
2:31:03 So we've been working with LCA on a design of a new 20,000 square foot building to expand
2:31:10 the services that we can offer in the Twin Falls community.
2:31:14 The design incorporated the look in the field of North Canyon but also took into account
2:31:18 the location so that it would enhance the location.
2:31:22 Due to recent events as well as the location of the property we felt had in the outdoor.
2:31:26 We tasked LCA with creating that space and it was actually on the rooftop so instead
2:31:36 to have your top access for maintenance.
2:31:38 We'd have a patio where we can meet and gather outside
2:31:41 in the process, review process.
2:31:46 We found out that it's impossible to do the one-leaser in her team.
2:31:57 So it was determined to request this code change.
2:32:12 Any questions for the applicant?
2:32:19 It doesn't look like, okay, so...
2:32:28 I have a question for Lisa.
2:32:30 Okay.
2:32:32 So in your presentation and the notes,
2:32:36 to this process has been used for construction within the reference that...
2:32:47 Yes, we had quite a few that are about height and that they want to do the mixed-use developments,
2:33:00 and so that they adjust their development plans based on special use permits
2:33:06 and permitted uses moving special use permits, land uses to permitted uses
2:33:12 and there's only development agreements, so we found that quite a few along the north on the Snake River,
2:33:18 the Snake River Canyon Rim were related to height and adding that in their agreement.
2:33:26 So, that's in the packet that basically redlines the east coast and reverts it back to,
2:33:41 does it have the unscathed purple step backs?
2:34:01 So, the landscaping currently is that their 20% of the total area included any commercial ratios,
2:34:21 She has filaments, a canner in the related district,
2:34:23 shall be devoted to lens open space.
2:34:26 That's not changing.
2:34:28 That's what's in the code currently.
2:34:30 And the street covers and all of that.
2:34:34 That's not going away.
2:34:35 That's all in the current.
2:34:37 That's in the current, yes.
2:34:42 The other thing I want to show is we have kind of a visual aid.
2:34:56 So currently, if they're at least 100 feet from the rim,
2:35:01 They can, the height of the building can gradually go up to 35 feet and this code of
2:35:09 in with allow for when they get to 150 feet, it could gradually increase from 35 to 50
2:35:16 foot height.
2:35:17 The height increase is, it doesn't change how it's allowed currently, it's just allowing
2:35:33 for them to have a 50 foot building, but they still have to be 150 feet from the rim.
2:35:41 want to go taller than 50 feet then they have to go through this public hearing
2:35:46 process which requires two public hearings one for zoning they make a
2:35:50 recognition council council has public hearing and they make a final decision
2:35:54 on the additional height.
2:36:14 But it does not necessarily leave that as how I've been reading it.
2:36:39 So one could...
2:36:41 ...stroll steak or with a trail?
2:36:51 Or with...
2:36:52 ...as we typically usually actually require what they've done.
2:36:55 The trail would be required, but it wouldn't necessarily need to be landscaped as the other buffers are required.
2:37:07 Thank you, Sean. Jason.
2:37:08 So, just if I heard you correctly, this would be a global change for the Canyon Rim overlay.
2:37:15 looking at the meeting minutes from the planning and zoning, this would be a change, the whole
2:37:25 canneagram overlay, once we're from 100 to 150 feet, we could go up to 50 feet, is that?
2:37:34 It's based on the base zone, so if it's residential, the maximum height is 35.
2:37:40 So whatever that base zone is still beyond that point, but this is across the board, can
2:37:45 Yes, it's commercial, and it's for the whole snake river and rock creek canyon.
2:37:56 And that's basically the only change.
2:38:01 Other than taking away the list of land uses that were in there, basically those would go away,
2:38:08 and whatever the property has for a underlying zone will determine what the land uses would be.
2:38:18 So intrusive is this on owners.
2:38:36 They would have to get a special use permit to be on this list that's crossed out.
2:38:46 Whatever their zone is, that's what they can do.
2:38:49 And if they wanted to do one of these things in it, they could get a special use permit to do that.
2:38:55 Actually, what's occurring is this list is what has actually restricted previous owners' abilities to ask for things.
2:39:04 But we're now taking the restriction away, allowing just the base zone, so in a commercial zone, typically you're permitted to do some of these things like have a bakery, which uses C1 zone as a permanent, right?
2:39:21 This really actually restricted in saying you need to dismiss use permit.
2:39:27 Now we're going to remove that and just go with what the permanent uses are of C1, or the special uses of the C1.
2:39:34 But it's actually removing the regulation on the property.
2:39:40 So property owner is actually gaining more property rights back.
2:39:46 I'm going to say 99% of the cases that I can think of, there might be one that I'm missing, but the majority of it, the regulations being removed and they have them.
2:39:53 For example, if somebody wanted to like the one proposal we had about three years ago,
2:40:01 other than the height variance, the other uses they were requesting would have just automatically been approved.
2:40:13 I believe if you're talking about some, yes, and a very specific one that I've stopped on
2:40:18 because it's come up a few times is the alcohol beverages are consumed on premises.
2:40:23 The C1 zone says you can do that outright, but if you have or within 300 feet, get a specialist
2:40:29 permit.
2:40:30 The canner and overlay said you sell them anywhere in the canner and overlay, get a specialist
2:40:35 permit, right?
2:40:36 A matter of it's just around the other commercial businesses, so we've had, I can specifically
2:40:42 lose place pizza, which actually was split in half with the building where they were selling
2:40:46 it was in the canner overlay, where they stored it was out of it, and it was very particular,
2:40:52 So they needed to get a Smoshy's permit.
2:40:54 This would just take that away, go for what the base zone is.
2:40:58 We require a lot less work.
2:41:01 So yes, for some things.
2:41:05 Any other questions?
2:41:09 Hey, so we've had a presentation from the applicant and staff.
2:41:16 And so next I would open up the public hearing.
2:41:20 Again, anybody in attendance?
2:41:23 You wish to give testimonies, please step up
2:41:26 to the podium, state your name and address,
2:41:28 and don't forget to sign the book when you leave.
2:41:34 So, thank you, go ahead.
2:41:36 I'm Raskin Zilopkin, I'm David Tebow.
2:41:38 This time I'm representing a handful of developers
2:41:41 that are in the vicinity who've reviewed this language
2:41:44 as part of North Canyon Medical's request this evening.
2:41:47 I work from Mr. Taylor, the Ryso family,
2:41:50 and Mr. Lithommies, and Mr. Shillington,
2:41:52 who all own properties in some type of ZD or PUD
2:41:56 on the canyram there in support of this request.
2:41:59 It appears that the area between Blue Lakes
2:42:02 and Washington was seriously contemplated
2:42:04 for additional height, allowing up to 50 feet,
2:42:07 consistent with the C-1 zone.
2:42:09 However, there are some other areas outside of that
2:42:11 that are now being developed.
2:42:13 And they were forgotten in our underlying city code.
2:42:16 Similar to what Lisa has presented,
2:42:20 the canyram overlays extends some 750 feet south
2:42:23 of the canyon rim.
2:42:24 In fact, the property that North Canyon Medical Homes
2:42:27 happens to be on the south side of Pole Line Road,
2:42:30 and yet is impacted and affected by this height restriction.
2:42:34 They're not the only ones.
2:42:35 So we did work with city staff.
2:42:38 I was involved with this process as well,
2:42:40 and some of the language review proposed changes
2:42:45 that are under revision for Title 10
2:42:47 that have not yet been completed,
2:42:48 because we've just been a little bit busy developing
2:42:50 other things in the Valley,
2:42:52 would have addressed some of these issues,
2:42:54 and ideas that are being presented,
2:42:57 and we would hope that we would have the support
2:42:58 of the council in this request this evening.
2:43:00 Thank you.
2:43:01 Thank you, Dan.
2:43:04 Any other public people from the audience
2:43:06 that wish to address this issue?
2:43:11 Seeing none, do you have any response to,
2:43:16 or are I close to public hearing?
2:43:17 A public hearing is closed.
2:43:22 So council, what would you like to have some discussion?
2:43:28 Any wish to?
2:43:31 Yes, thank you, Mayor.
2:43:34 So, were you with some comments on addressing the issues between Washington and Blue Lakes?
2:43:46 That's where activity was great.
2:43:48 I was even on the council at that time.
2:43:51 Maybe raise that question at the time of what we do when everything starts moving the other
2:43:56 direction, but I'm consistent.
2:43:59 See there?
2:44:00 I guess my only general comment I would make because I know that the Canyon Rim is one of
2:44:08 those discussed past the honest with you, I'm frankly a little surprised we haven't heard
2:44:25 where you put about this, except for the fact I'm certainly supportive of this revision, as
2:44:39 long as the who is involved in ownership or property out there and development of property
2:44:47 understands that the community's voice has spoken in the past and the purpose remains the
2:44:52 of what the Kingdom of that stated very commissively happier and think responsible as so.
2:45:27 So the C1 on, say, X, Y, Z, and I think it is a little bit of a slippery slope.
2:45:56 Yes, I'd make that more as a plea to...
2:46:02 I know it's late, I guess I have to add my piece.
2:46:33 When I saw this on the agenda, I thought, oh, I don't feel good about this at all, because I thought about it.
2:46:38 I got more and more comfortable.
2:46:40 It's logical, it makes sense.
2:46:42 It's cleaner.
2:46:43 So, yeah, I'm just apprehensive on anything with this topic,
2:46:48 but really I think that's maybe a need trick reaction.
2:46:51 I do like this when considered in a hole.
2:46:55 So, thank you.
2:46:56 What else? Just to comment.
2:46:59 Any wish to make motion?
2:47:11 Where options are, prove the amendment, and hide it, or...
2:47:21 Table of four information, or a conditioner.
2:47:24 If there's a material change, we would need to talk with Shane about how large that is, isn't it?
2:47:32 Potential to go back to the not money zoning commission. Thank you
2:47:36 I mean again, I know Spencer sort of said as as I look at what the change actually is
2:47:44 It's it's really
2:47:49 Loosening the kinds of things that can be built out there a little bit
2:47:53 In some zones, but not much
2:47:56 There were a ton of absolutely can't do this
2:48:01 C1 PUD or C1 CDA
2:48:03 And really sort of standardized the height thing without having to go through a process.
2:48:13 The rest of the, I mean that's why I was asking a lot of questions about the landscape and things,
2:48:18 because that's important too, and that's all still there.
2:48:22 Past, obviously being here, I think the height of the restriction is really what a lot of the conversation in the community
2:48:34 and their feeling was around some of these, and maybe that's why I asked the question
2:48:40 of where some of those heights or stretches of things stay in this area.
2:48:44 We lose that height, the collection is not.
2:48:50 Yes and no, you know.
2:49:13 Do I want to, you know, 20 stories skyscraper there?
2:49:16 Maybe not, but times it's pretty.
2:49:21 This happens to be North Canyon brought this one up tonight,
2:49:25 where we're pushing it. I mean the location that that specific facility is intended to go for.
2:49:32 There's no issues, but I think it goes back to just that feeling of what the community is.
2:49:44 It is the subject matter that's so hard.
2:50:30 Isn't that potentially a bit redundant?
2:50:35 When you're minutes within a certain zone, what you can and can't do,
2:50:39 and then you list all this other stuff, what's almost like you're repeating, partially?
2:50:44 I think it's time to clean it up a little bit.
2:50:53 But, history.
2:50:55 I'll make a motion.
2:50:56 I feel that the changes are ultimately in the spirit of what was originally desired.
2:51:07 Everybody's comment is a little concerning conversations, and people here, I was surprised
2:51:19 that there's only a few of us here with this.
2:51:24 So, Mayor, I move that we approve the Zoning Title Amendment to Title 10, Chapter 4, Section 19,
2:51:31 Overlay removing permitted and special uses, modifying out loud maximum
2:51:36 heights and removing the CDA requirement. As presented. Thank you. Do I have a second?
2:51:44 I'll second. Thank you. Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Jason Brown,
2:51:54 to approve the we cause for zoning title amendment to title 10 chapter 4 section
2:51:59 2019 Canyon Rim Overlay. Any further discussion? Aaron Rokavo, please. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes.
2:52:14 Vice Mayor Reed. Yes. Sean Barreger. Yes. Nicki Boyd. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 6-0.
2:52:24 Thank you, everyone. That is the end of the meeting.
2:52:28 Enjoy your evening.
Download
- Transcript (text) 143 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 186 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 248 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 19.6 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 18, 2022. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:52:45.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
53682b22e7617c7911136d654c951b8c826db7ff725c4cab53fafdf1051bc726 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a f11832eafb0b16f97695f08fc6755634b8146b6bcc060a6d1f5065efb2f10160
part02.m4a 89a3606f207dfb6544675c169fddb0994b21a170442e3776b380c8bc0897ec89 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
ea2046b8709dbb622366531c2c9f8c6f6474fb04e0f80e1bc68d46ac0d66f052
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file