City Council meeting
Tuesday, January 3, 2017
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:06:54 To order the meeting at the Twin Falls City Council for Tuesday, January 3rd, 2017.
0:07:00 Happy New Year everyone.
0:07:02 For those of you wishing to join us, please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:07:09 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:07:22 Stand like can you hear?
0:07:27 Yes, I can hear.
0:07:30 Welcome everyone.
0:07:31 I would confirm we do have a quorum of the council.
0:07:33 Our four members are here in person, Vice Mayor Suzanne Hawkins is on the phone.
0:07:40 Mr. Rothwell, do we have any amendments to our agenda?
0:07:43 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, there are no amendments this evening.
0:07:47 Thank you.
0:07:48 We have no proclamations.
0:07:49 So the first item is a general public input.
0:07:51 This is an opportunity for anyone here to address the council on an issue that is not on
0:07:55 this evening's agenda.
0:07:57 There's anyone wishing to do so.
0:07:59 You can come forward now.
0:08:03 Seeing no one, we will move on with the agenda.
0:08:06 First item for consideration is the consent calendar.
0:08:09 Council wishes.
0:08:10 Chris Dockington.
0:08:12 Move approval, the consent calendar is approved,
0:08:14 but I do have one question on the budget.
0:08:15 I'd like to pose the city manager
0:08:17 after we're through with this motion.
0:08:19 Okay. Second.
0:08:22 A motion by Chris Dockington,
0:08:23 seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar.
0:08:27 Did you need your question before we vote on it?
0:08:29 Well, Mr. Manager, I'm terribly upset
0:08:31 that on pay the sex of the main payables,
0:08:34 we had a $519.23 bill for damage caused
0:08:40 by a deer breaking through a window of the airport.
0:08:42 And I'd like to have an explanation of that.
0:08:44 Because the city manager is avoiding me.
0:08:47 I mean, the airport manager is avoiding me.
0:08:51 So the city manager was on vacation
0:08:53 at the time in which the accounts approved,
0:08:55 but the acting city manager would be more
0:08:58 than happy to answer your question.
0:09:00 Have we no order on this society?
0:09:05 So is there an answer from Brian?
0:09:13 Brian, do you want to leave us the answer?
0:09:15 Brian shared that we'll be addressing animal cruelty later on in the agenda.
0:09:20 So did you just jump through the window or something?
0:09:28 Alright, the other discussion on the consent calendar?
0:09:34 None of it.
0:09:35 Seeing none, Sharon and roll call vote please.
0:09:38 Suzanne Hopkins.
0:09:40 Yep.
0:09:42 Sean Baraker.
0:09:43 Yes.
0:09:44 Chris Hockington.
0:09:44 Yes.
0:09:45 Greg Lanting.
0:09:46 Yes.
0:09:46 Ruth Pierce.
0:09:47 Yes.
0:09:48 Motion passes five to zero.
0:09:51 Under items for consideration, the first item on the agenda
0:09:53 is a presentation of a public safety award.
0:09:56 And for that, we have Deputy City Manager Brian Pike.
0:10:05 Thank you, Mayor and members of the council.
0:10:08 About five years ago, the Twin Falls Police Department
0:10:10 started a tradition of providing our officers with their oath of office on their first-year
0:10:15 anniversary date.
0:10:16 This tradition really focused on reaffirming that oath that oath that all of our officers
0:10:22 take.
0:10:23 And it was designed really to remind them, following a challenging year of training
0:10:28 and experience and exposure to readiness, why they decided to choose a career in law
0:10:33 enforcement.
0:10:34 Tonight, I would like to honor Chief Craig Kingsbury with his oath of office, and I'd
0:10:38 I'd like to ask the chief to come forward.
0:10:44 Just feel comfortable to come right up, right up, right up.
0:10:47 No, just right up here.
0:10:51 I mean, let yourself right at home.
0:10:53 No surprises here.
0:10:56 Yes, Chief, it has been one year.
0:11:01 And everywhere I've been with the chief,
0:11:02 he's been sharing that with everyone.
0:11:04 I've been here for one year.
0:11:06 He actually was sworn in prior to his official date.
0:11:10 but its official date was January 1st, 2016.
0:11:14 And really looking back over the past year,
0:11:16 I would say that it's been quite a challenging
0:11:18 and rewarding year.
0:11:21 You know, when I was thinking about the oath of office,
0:11:25 and all that it means to our law enforcement officers,
0:11:29 I was really thinking about the things
0:11:31 that we all kind of experienced and witnessed
0:11:34 taking place right here.
0:11:36 And I like to call this the year of the oath
0:11:38 in action for you, Chief,
0:11:40 Because in this particular situation,
0:11:42 I think it was a guide to moral and ethical leadership
0:11:45 for the department.
0:11:46 It was a statement to perform to the best of one's ability
0:11:51 every time that you came up here and in doing so
0:11:53 with a sense of honor.
0:11:56 Chief, you've demonstrated in this very council chambers
0:11:59 a commitment to these ideals and a dedication to our community.
0:12:03 And it's my honor to present you your official oath of office
0:12:08 and to thank you for your dedication and commitment to our community.
0:12:45 Chief, a few words?
0:12:49 You don't mean mayor, I'm always short on words.
0:12:53 Mayor and council and the city managers and the fine men and women
0:12:56 of Twin Falls Police Department and our other fellow Twin Falls City
0:13:01 family members in our community.
0:13:02 It's been an honor.
0:13:03 It is hard to believe it's been a year, but it has been.
0:13:07 As we know this year has been a year of some major incidents
0:13:14 with the police department and the community.
0:13:16 And I think we've come out on this end
0:13:19 better for what we went through.
0:13:21 And I'm just proud to serve with these fine minimum.
0:13:24 And I thank you for your faith in me
0:13:25 and we'll continue and hope for many more years to come.
0:13:30 Thank you very much, Chief, congratulations.
0:13:37 Next on the agenda is a presentation reviewing
0:13:39 the penalties for animal cruelty.
0:13:42 City Manager, Brian Pike, just a second to make technology work for me. Hopefully not
0:13:49 against me. And may I have any questions or need to do the group Eric Price who was one
0:14:08 of the spokespeople from the O'Leary School is available. Thank you. Sure he's enthusiastic
0:14:18 about you volunteering him to speak. It's actually a great segue because just a little
0:14:29 while ago the city council listened to presentation from the student group
0:14:32 referenced an animal cruelty and during the presentation and it was it was a
0:14:36 fine presentation one of the students and I wasn't for sure which one suggested
0:14:40 that the city of Twin Falls should have a progressive or a tiered penalty system
0:14:45 for animal cruelty violations and why they were presenting we we decided that we
0:14:51 would look into this take a look at the code and then come back to council with
0:14:55 and I really want to start tonight with just looking at Idaho Statute Title 25, which really focuses on animals.
0:15:03 And from that title, drilling down into Title 25 and looking at Chapter 35, which is animal care.
0:15:10 And there's two issues here that the state statute has, 253504, which is committing cruelty to animals.
0:15:18 And there's a whole definition section for that. I did not include that tonight.
0:15:22 And then 253520a is the penalty for those violations.
0:15:27 And as I was going through this, looking at what other cities and what the state is doing,
0:15:33 what I found under that penalty.
0:15:38 So under the penalty of this section, there is a provision and a tiered system that has been provided through state statute.
0:15:47 So the first violation, very, very similar, actually identical to what
0:15:51 Ketchum and what was presented to you from the City of Ketchum.
0:15:54 The first violation is a Jelsons of not more than six months, or by a fine, not
0:15:59 less than $100 or more than $5,000 or both.
0:16:02 And then the state allows for a tiered system, a second violation within 10 years
0:16:08 of the same offense, a Jelsons of not more than nine months, or if a fine, not less
0:16:13 than 200 or more than 7,000 or both, and then we step into the third violation, which I believe,
0:16:20 and maybe, for instance, you could help me. I believe the third violation is considered
0:16:24 in this moment. Within 15 years of the same penalty, a jail sense of not more than 12 months
0:16:32 or a fine of not less than 500 or more than 9,000 or both. So some of the exact language
0:16:38 that the students shared with us reference a tiered system related to
0:16:42 animal cruelty is actually provided under the state statute and as you can see
0:16:48 really our first violation is somewhat comparable so when in working with Fritz
0:16:53 and our city's attorney's office one of the things that we discussed is that we
0:16:57 have a lot of flexibility we can use the city code on the first offense we could
0:17:02 we could use the state code under first offense.
0:17:06 But subsequent violations of that specific penalty
0:17:09 with individuals within a certain time frame,
0:17:12 the state statute would apply to.
0:17:14 So we already have a tiered system that's in place
0:17:17 and established for us.
0:17:20 And our recommendation would be for the city
0:17:23 to utilize the statutes provided through the state
0:17:26 and not to try to rewrite this as an ordinance for the city.
0:17:32 With that, I'd be happy to try to stand for questions
0:17:35 or to yield.
0:17:39 Chris talking.
0:17:40 Well, I'm supposing that second, third animal
0:17:44 cruelly charges are relatively rare.
0:17:48 I've not heard of many, but nonetheless,
0:17:50 what we're saying, no accident is required.
0:17:52 We could simply use the existing city code
0:17:57 and then step into the state code.
0:17:59 If there should be a second or third
0:18:01 or multiple offenses.
0:18:03 We can't with no action required with no action required as a matter of fact
0:18:07 I suppose it could be it could be argued that we can't preempt what the state is established
0:18:13 But I think the code is clear and really accomplishes what I think the student group asked
0:18:20 And it's and it's always been available to us
0:18:23 Ruth Pierce
0:18:26 Do you know what the county law reads?
0:18:32 Did you happen to check that out?
0:18:34 You know, I do not know if the county has a specific ordinance
0:18:38 or if they use the state code.
0:18:39 You know, one of the things that we've tried to do
0:18:42 is to really mirror what the state has
0:18:45 so there's not confusion.
0:18:47 And certainly if you wanted to be a little more specific,
0:18:52 to be a little more specific, we could do that,
0:18:56 but very similar to what we've seen with bicycles, right?
0:19:00 Consistency across both city and county is important,
0:19:03 and the state code really allows for that to take place.
0:19:07 I think it's a great idea.
0:19:08 I would just be curious as to what the county code said.
0:19:12 I can certainly look into that.
0:19:13 Yeah, thank you.
0:19:16 Greg Lantham.
0:19:17 All right, I would have, or Fritz, possibly.
0:19:20 Would it make it stronger if we went ahead
0:19:22 and put the state tiered into our own city code.
0:19:27 Does that help us or not?
0:19:29 Just clear it up or?
0:19:32 And as Brian mentioned, I think an argument could be made
0:19:35 that the state has already occupied the field
0:19:38 and were preempted from having a separate one
0:19:41 that looks just like what the state has already done.
0:19:43 Okay, so, but ours, our staff and yourself,
0:19:49 we understand that the state is there
0:19:50 so we can enforce that if necessary.
0:19:52 And we and we do that on various violations sometimes we use the city code sometimes we use the state code
0:19:59 Thank you
0:20:00 Suzanne did you have anything to add? I do. Thank you Sean. You're welcome Ryan. I'm just curious you have any numbers on how many
0:20:11 I'm sorry animal cruelty
0:20:14 Violations we had in the city last year, you know what I don't so I can get that for you
0:20:19 I'm I I know we've had a few not
0:20:23 It's not a high number, and when you look at second and third violations, I don't think
0:20:28 you'll see any second or third violations of animal cruelty.
0:20:33 Thank you.
0:20:34 So you'll actually need to come up so we can get you on the microphone please.
0:20:42 There were 15 violations last year.
0:20:45 15 last year that you researched.
0:20:48 Thank you.
0:20:49 Don't go too far.
0:20:50 I need you.
0:20:51 Chris Tockington.
0:20:52 But I think it needs to be clarified that we think that that's a higher number because we've begun our own enforcement and here before it's been a county jurisdictional issue.
0:21:03 That is our recall of some of the background on where we're looking at it a couple months ago.
0:21:10 You know, one of the things that we are doing too is trying to develop a tie between our code enforcement teams.
0:21:17 And these are really, they tie right into code enforcement as a whole and quality of
0:21:22 life issues.
0:21:23 And one thing that Sean Stanley is doing a really good job of blending both animal control
0:21:28 and our code enforcement officers, and really taking advantage of the fact that they're both
0:21:33 in the fields and they're capitalized on their time and it's a really efficient approach
0:21:38 to handling these issues.
0:21:40 So.
0:21:42 Thank you.
0:21:43 Chris Stockington.
0:21:44 I'm pleasantly surprised that we have an ordinance that might work, and I like Ruth's
0:21:48 idea to get additional information, but I really think we need to complement the group from
0:21:53 Maleri for gathering the four to five pages of petitions of people that are concerned
0:21:59 enough about protecting animals in Twin Falls and Twin Falls having a record as a community
0:22:07 that cares not only for his people, but animals that Eric and his cohort should be really plotted
0:22:13 for this. And I think we can have this be a little bit more information come to you, as
0:22:19 Ruth suggested, and for us to direct the city, even though we don't need to, to utilize the
0:22:26 state code for any second or tertiary abuse complaints.
0:22:31 The Fritz did jump on the county website. He's not finding anything on the site related to
0:22:38 this. So we're just assuming that they're using the state code also.
0:22:42 Well Eric thanks to you and your your students and for bringing this information forward again
0:22:49 I think the resolution here is that
0:22:51 We do have that tool available to us that you all requested to be able to make sure we're
0:22:56 Having that tiered system and trying to reduce the number of repeat offenders certainly with animal cruelty and I think it's been a chance to help
0:23:05 Enlighten us and hopefully the public as well. They'll learn a little bit more about it
0:23:09 Thank you. Next on the agenda is a request to adopt an ordinance for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment from R4 to C1, 4.16 plus or minus acres of undeveloped property located west of 515 Washington Street North, Renee Caraway Johnson.
0:23:35 Welcome, Renee.
0:23:36 Thank you.
0:23:37 I need to name my hearing and council.
0:23:39 It's a pleasure to start my year in front of you.
0:23:42 I'm sure.
0:23:43 This is a request this evening to ask for your adoption of an ordinance for a rezone of
0:23:52 property.
0:23:53 In the spring of 2016, EHM engineers did approach the city on behalf of Dan Willy, the OASIS
0:23:59 stop and go to expand a parking area that was located west of the OASIS at 515 Washington
0:24:05 Street North.
0:24:07 It was determined at that time that that property that dates on this map subject property was
0:24:12 zone residential and would need to go through a rezone process to zone it to
0:24:17 commercial in order to develop as a parking lot. On November 8th of 2016 the
0:24:24 Commission did hold the public hearing and was asked to make a recommendation to
0:24:27 the City Council on a request to rezone this property. The adjacent property
0:24:33 owner to the west of this did have some concerns. There's a different level of
0:24:39 of property grade level.
0:24:41 And he was concerned that that would be taken care of
0:24:43 through the development process.
0:24:45 And he was assured by EHM at that public hearing
0:24:48 that they would work with him and make sure it met code.
0:24:53 Upon conclusion of the public hearing
0:24:55 and the discussion of the commission members,
0:24:58 Commissioner Tatum did make a motion
0:25:00 to recommend approval to you as presented.
0:25:04 The Commissioner Gray seconded the motion
0:25:06 and all members voted in favor of that motion.
0:25:10 On December 12th, this request had come to you.
0:25:13 There was no public comment
0:25:14 through the public hearing at this meeting.
0:25:20 At the close of the public hearing and deliberation,
0:25:23 Council Member Lansing did make a motion
0:25:26 to approve the reason of this property to C1
0:25:30 and it was seconded by Council Member Boyd.
0:25:34 The motion was approved six to zero.
0:25:35 So I am here this evening to ask, as you directed staff
0:25:40 to prepare an ordinance for your consideration,
0:25:43 it's in your packet and then asking you to adopt it
0:25:45 so that it can be published
0:25:47 and the property can be developed in the spring.
0:25:50 Thank you, Renee.
0:25:51 You're welcome.
0:25:52 Sharon, do you have an ordinance number please?
0:25:53 Ordinance number 2017-1.
0:25:58 Greg Lansing.
0:25:59 Mayor, I move that we place what was the number again?
0:26:02 2017-1.
0:26:04 2017-1, that should be easier, remember?
0:26:07 to suspend the rules of place 2017-1 on third and final by title only second
0:26:14 motion by Greg Lansing seconded by Chris Tockington to place ordinance 2017-1
0:26:20 on third and final reading by title only under suspension of the rules is
0:26:24 there any discussion seeing and hearing none Sharon Volkow please Sean
0:26:32 Baraker yes Chris Tockington yes Greg Lansing yes Ruth Pierce yes Suzanne
0:26:39 Hawkins. Yes. Motion passes five to zero. Sharon, would you read the title please.
0:26:46 Ordinance number 2017-1, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho
0:26:59 rezoning real property below describe, providing the zoning classification therefore and ordering
0:27:06 the necessary amendments to the area of impact and zoning district map and the revised area
0:27:13 of impact. Motion by Chris Stockington seconded by Greg
0:27:24 Lanting to approve Ordinance 2017 dash one is there any
0:27:28 discussion? Seeing and hearing none Sharon roll call vote
0:27:32 please. Sean Beriker yes Chris Stockington Greg Lanting yes
0:27:38 Ruth Pierce yes Suzanne Hawkins yes passes five to zero. Thank
0:27:44 Next, we have a request to accept the recommendation of the Canyon Springs Grade Ad-Hoc Committee
0:27:54 and direct staff to finish engineering and develop a funding strategy.
0:27:58 We have our Assistant City Engineer, Troy Vitek, and Entourage.
0:28:12 Thank you, Mayor and City Council, Troy, Vitek, Assistant Engineer, and I'll begin the discussion
0:28:18 of our brain here, sets up the presentation.
0:28:22 So in September of 2015, we came before the City Council per your direction to set up an
0:28:28 ad hoc committee to kind of go over what are the recommendations for Canyon Springs grade.
0:28:34 That committee met a total of nine times with nine different options.
0:28:38 It's a night Brian's going to briefly discuss those, maybe skip a few, but really he's going
0:28:43 to focus on what the committee came up with.
0:28:45 There are members of the committee that are in the audience tonight and they may want to
0:28:51 voice, some of what they felt the committee was about, but really tonight it's really just
0:28:55 a discussion with Council, what they found out, and what we plan to go forward with, so with
0:29:05 the presentation on that, Brian and Phil kind of set this up, but Phil will kind of begin
0:29:12 the discussion and then Brian will actually go through the presentation and I'll stand for
0:29:16 additional questions.
0:29:17 Great.
0:29:18 Thank you, Trey.
0:29:19 Thank you, Troy. Good evening, your honor. Welcome, Council. Again, my name is Phil Cushlan,
0:29:28 post office box 8463, Boise. I think I'll talk just a couple minutes about the process that
0:29:34 we went through and then lead the technical information after those who have understand
0:29:39 that far better than I. In addition to the committee members who participated, the Council
0:29:46 certainly had a significant role in this in establishing
0:29:49 originally the charter that kind of sets the sideboards
0:29:52 around the conversation that was to be held.
0:29:56 And I think that was really useful in terms of kind of
0:29:58 keeping us on track.
0:30:01 The mayor certainly was stalwart in attending
0:30:04 virtually all of the meetings that we had.
0:30:07 And let's put on the spot a few times as mayors
0:30:11 want to be, so that was we appreciate your willingness
0:30:14 to do that.
0:30:15 Again, Mr. Roy indicated, you have people in the audience who are members of the committee
0:30:23 and just run quickly through the membership.
0:30:26 Katie Breckenridge served on the committee, Todd Schwartz, John Matamis, Tony Mannin, Dave
0:30:32 McCallen, Rick Novicek, Jim Olson, Linda Roberts, and J.V.T., were the people who participated.
0:30:41 And this was a group that really worked.
0:30:44 they were there when they couldn't be there, they called in, they asked questions, made
0:30:51 us go back and reanalyse things that we thought we'd kind of put in the can, but they wanted
0:30:56 some more information on that.
0:30:58 So I think it's really safe to say that I had the process that you set up, I think,
0:31:04 is working for you.
0:31:06 And of course, we're certainly interested in reporting back and finding out if we hit the
0:31:11 mark.
0:31:12 The other thing that I'll talk just a moment about is through the process, we were committed
0:31:18 to kind of getting other opinions in this conversation as well.
0:31:23 We met in this room, so all our meetings were televised.
0:31:28 Each agenda had an opportunity for citizen commentary, and we actually had people show
0:31:32 up and talk about their interest in these issues.
0:31:37 And then, at one point, I was even called to be on a radio talk show here locally, so
0:31:44 about the subject.
0:31:45 So I think the issue is out there.
0:31:48 I think people are aware of it.
0:31:50 I think we've kind of put some sideboards around the conversation that I think in looking
0:31:55 at what we believe to be the preferred alternative to dig deeper and focus our energies to give
0:32:02 you some more information on what to do and possibly how to fund it.
0:32:06 So again, I think while the committee has gone in advance, I don't think they've gone away
0:32:16 but expressed an interest if issues come up that they need to be called back, they're
0:32:21 willing to come back and have additional conversations with the council.
0:32:27 So they're still out there but we're not going to use their time anymore.
0:32:31 They're absolutely necessary and I do appreciate their braving the weather to come out this
0:32:35 this evening to kind of back me up.
0:32:36 So I'm sure that when the time's appropriate for the area,
0:32:41 they'll be happy to provide any commentary
0:32:43 that they might have in addition to what you're gonna hear.
0:32:45 So is that on the?
0:32:46 Thank you.
0:32:47 I hope for the, bye.
0:32:53 Thanks Bill, thanks Troy.
0:32:54 Mr. Mayor and members of the Council,
0:32:55 Brian Smith, J.U.B. engineers.
0:32:57 So thank you again for the opportunity to be here
0:33:00 and I appreciate seeing members of the Ad Hoc Committee
0:33:03 in the audience.
0:33:04 It was a great process I felt
0:33:06 I thought it was very informative and very educational for me as well.
0:33:10 So I think we covered a lot of ground and I don't want to backtrack too much.
0:33:13 Phil and Troy did a great job in the introductions.
0:33:16 A number of my first couple slides here we can probably go through pretty quick as they
0:33:21 covered data stars there being a total nine ad hoc committee meetings that started about
0:33:25 a year ago this time and we wrapped them up in November.
0:33:29 So it was a pretty consistent, a lot of good input, a lot of good questions, good recommendations
0:33:35 and suggestions from the committee.
0:33:39 So the charter, which was established back in September of 2015, a lot of the objectives
0:33:44 or the primary objectives are listed right there.
0:33:48 Reconstruction of the roadway was certainly a primary objective along with improving some
0:33:52 of the drainage as well as looking at improvements for the pedestrians and the cyclists that use
0:33:57 it, looking at some of the slope stability and some of the access also from some of the
0:34:03 larger trucks that are using it particularly during construction associated with the wastewater
0:34:07 treatment plant.
0:34:08 So just a little bit of background, the ADT, the average data traffic, that's probably
0:34:14 a couple of years old, it's around 1,340 vehicles per day, it might be a little better
0:34:18 than that now.
0:34:20 The city staff did some pedestrian counts this past summer and the average count was around
0:34:26 150.
0:34:27 There was one day I think where the football team was doing some training and that count
0:34:31 went way up but I believe that was backed out.
0:34:34 So, roughly 150 on an average day, pedestrians use that.
0:34:39 The width of the road itself is, it varies, down to 22, there's probably a couple of areas
0:34:43 that are actually a little bit less than that, and the average grade on that road from
0:34:48 top to bottom is right at 10%, so it's pretty steep and obviously anybody that's walked,
0:34:52 it can attest to that for sure.
0:34:56 So there's been some work, and this is just a recap of strata geotechnical engineers, and
0:35:02 They were a sub-consultant to us actually on this particular phase of the project.
0:35:06 They started looking at the grade back in 2009 and did a two-phase approach where they
0:35:12 sent a technical engineer, a licensed geologist out there who has experience in rock fall
0:35:18 and in looking at these types of facilities.
0:35:22 And they looked at about 2,200 feet of the canyon rim that's above the upper hairpin
0:35:29 of the roadway, and tried to put together or did put together a risk matrix analyzing
0:35:35 a space, mostly on visual observation with their expertise and trying to assess risk of
0:35:42 different areas that may have some rock fall concerns.
0:35:47 So that was completed in 2009, 2010, and that report I think was presented to Council back
0:35:53 at that time.
0:35:55 Since that time in March 2014 then, we teamed again with Strata on a conceptual design evaluation
0:36:02 that was presented in 2014 and looked at those recommendations from 2009, 2010, and then
0:36:09 also identified a couple of potential alternatives to address the recommendations in those previous
0:36:15 reports.
0:36:16 Those alternatives from that 2014 report actually show up in this presentation as alternatives
0:36:21 two and three.
0:36:22 So just real quickly, the Strata reports, that risk matrix, they use some different factors,
0:36:30 zero to one being pretty low risk, two to three maybe a little bit more risk, and four
0:36:35 to five a higher risk, and I want to say higher risk in their view, that is a larger
0:36:42 type of boulder or a cobble that has enough energy and has a higher likelihood to come
0:36:47 down off of the rock phase and potentially do damage to significant damage to a vehicle
0:36:53 or obviously someone walking or riding their bike on the grade.
0:36:57 So they identified a total of 44 different locations
0:37:00 along the canyon wall.
0:37:02 Four of them were listed as the higher risk factor areas.
0:37:07 And then the other 40 at various degrees of lower risk.
0:37:11 It's not to say that something couldn't happen
0:37:13 in those lower areas, but just from a risk evaluation,
0:37:18 that's where they landed anyway.
0:37:24 So the ad hoc committee, like I said did, in my opinion,
0:37:28 great job in looking at a number of different alternatives.
0:37:30 Those first two that we discussed from the 2014 report,
0:37:34 but then also asked us to look at a number of others.
0:37:38 That's the design team in the city staff, total of nine alternatives,
0:37:42 and those alternatives range from simple signing on the grade,
0:37:47 which is roughly $15,000 to more than $66 million.
0:37:50 And we'll go into each of those alternatives now
0:37:52 I just kind of briefly talk about them.
0:37:55 And I ask if there's any questions that I'm going through,
0:37:57 please feel free to interrupt
0:37:58 because there's a lot of information.
0:38:00 And Suzanne, if you have any questions,
0:38:02 just yell real loud.
0:38:04 Thank you.
0:38:05 I will let you know.
0:38:09 Well, alternative one, this is the first description.
0:38:12 I'll show a couple exhibits to kind of demonstrate this.
0:38:15 So this, in essence, was less of a mitigation.
0:38:20 There's still mitigation on the rock ball,
0:38:22 more of really widening the roadway to the uphill side, if you will, of the canyon rim
0:38:27 and providing a 20-plus foot rock catch ditch.
0:38:31 The idea there is, and that was based on some recommendations from Federal Highways
0:38:35 and ITD for similar type of facilities.
0:38:39 So the idea is that if there was a rock full event in the future that it would roll into
0:38:43 the ditch and have a higher likelihood of being caught on that.
0:38:48 In order to accomplish that, we were looking at approximately 180,000 cubic yards of rock
0:38:53 blasting and removing, which is pretty significant effort.
0:38:56 There would be pedestrian as part of this alternative.
0:39:00 We installed pedestrian improvements along the north side of the road, which would move
0:39:04 the pedestrians further away from the rock phase.
0:39:07 The estimated construction cost for this alternative, we put an estimate between $29 and $39 million.
0:39:13 And a lot of that had to be with, obviously, the significant rock excavation that occurred.
0:39:22 Even with my glasses on, that's kind of tough to see, but you can get an idea of the dark
0:39:27 line along the north side of the road, north is pointing down.
0:39:33 What that pathway side would be, it's really tough to see.
0:39:44 That's about what the limit of the rock excavation would be.
0:39:47 That's pretty close, you probably got steady hands in me.
0:39:56 So it's obviously really close to those homes and not very practical from that point of view
0:40:00 without taking some of that property.
0:40:06 That's a cross-section view of that upper roadway up above the first hairpin.
0:40:11 You can see the laying back of the slope and then that rock catch ditch.
0:40:15 Really the width of that ditch varies from 10 to 20 feet depending on how high above the
0:40:20 ditch you have the rock.
0:40:23 On the lower side of the road with this alternative is lower side being on the downhill
0:40:27 side of that first hairpin, you're more in a fill section, and so the way to widen that
0:40:31 because we really did not want to get into that talus slope, particularly where the boulder
0:40:35 field is from the previous excavation and construction, we would widen it to the downhill
0:40:40 side and use a mechanical stabilized earth wall.
0:40:43 We'll use that term quite a bit here to accomplish the fill on that side, pushing the roadway
0:40:50 out further to the west on that north and west.
0:40:58 So the advantage on that is pretty high reliability for the rock fall protection along the full
0:41:04 length of the canyon wall.
0:41:06 It would add some dedicated pedestrian facilities and the improvements as far as the roadway
0:41:11 and drainage would be accomplished.
0:41:12 Obviously the disadvantages are the cost and a lot of blasting risks and one of the things
0:41:16 that we didn't talk about or haven't talked about yet but we certainly talked about what
0:41:19 the committee was.
0:41:21 There is the city's main sewer trunk line that goes down this road and it's not very deep.
0:41:27 We don't want to obviously risk damaging that or try to minimize the risk to damaging that
0:41:32 because that could be a significant problem.
0:41:34 The other thing is when you're talking about this much rock exploration or rock excavation,
0:41:41 we really haven't done as a part of the conceptual analysis at this point any significant or really
0:41:46 any field evaluation that includes putting holes on the ground.
0:41:50 so we don't know what we'd get into necessarily when we started executing that hillside from
0:41:55 that rock face.
0:41:59 So this is alternative 1A.
0:42:03 The bottom alternative will be alternative 8, I said there's 9, so we have a 1A in here.
0:42:06 So this is similar to alternative 1.
0:42:09 It's a lot more significant excavation.
0:42:12 In essence, the advantage of this one was it would provide a connectivity of the path from
0:42:18 up above on either side of the Breckenridge property, both the west and east side to the
0:42:22 property, and basically take the path from that point down to the canyon grade.
0:42:28 And you can imagine at that location we want to vertically run out of horizontal rooms.
0:42:34 So you're going to have to switch back to keep a grade somewhere near 10%, which is about
0:42:42 what the existing grade is going to be right now.
0:42:48 That is a view, I'll put my glass on again, that alternative where you can see the switch
0:42:55 back of the upper pathway that we come down and meet the grade at that point there. It
0:43:03 also shows connectivity up above on the top of the canyon rim so you can kind of get an
0:43:06 idea on how much rock excavation would be required or the limits horizontally anyway to accommodate
0:43:12 that path con activity across the northern side of the property. A lot of excavation that
0:43:20 The entire face would obviously have to be removed to the tune of about 320,000 cubic
0:43:26 yards that leaves what we came up with.
0:43:29 That is a section cut of alternative 1A, so that gives you some pretty good perspective
0:43:33 of what that would look like.
0:43:35 The pathway moving downhill would be protected with rock catch ditches as well.
0:43:42 Estimant cost for alternative 1A, and that's a pretty wide range.
0:43:45 They're 50 to 66 million, so very expensive alternative.
0:43:50 similar advantages and disadvantages to alternative one.
0:43:55 This, the rock excavation would occur further to the west from alternative one.
0:44:02 So it gives a little bit more distance away from the houses there on the canyon rim,
0:44:07 which would help, but there's still some other disadvantages to that,
0:44:11 as far as risk of controlling that nature.
0:44:15 I'll turn it two and three.
0:44:16 So these are the ones I talked about that were presented in that 2014 report.
0:44:20 This in essence consists of a top-down construction along the north side of the road on the upper
0:44:27 hairpin anyway that would excavate the rock down adjacent to the existing roadway and create
0:44:34 a bench, a 12-foot wide bench that would be for pedestrians.
0:44:38 Now, in order to do that and to accomplish that top-down construction without impacting
0:44:43 the boulder field or trying to fill on top of that steep slope on the downhill side, we
0:44:49 It would start again, like I said, with that top end construction.
0:44:53 I'll show you a little picture there to show.
0:44:57 So adjacent to the roadway, and this would also include a reconstruction of the road and
0:45:01 some improvements to the drainage.
0:45:03 The cost included in this alternative included some of the rock foam mitigation that was mentioned
0:45:08 in the original Strata report for those four high-risk areas.
0:45:12 And then you can see on the right-hand side there where the path would be separated vertically
0:45:16 from the traffic.
0:45:18 And again, that is just on that uphill side.
0:45:21 So the idea there would be we don't feel anything.
0:45:23 We drill and blast down carefully and create a vertical separation at that point.
0:45:31 That vertical separation would be in this alternative somewhere around.
0:45:35 It would range from 5 to 15 feet plus or minus.
0:45:41 That's a engineer artist concept of what that might look like.
0:45:51 So the banish is this, obviously it's a significant less cost than the first two alternatives.
0:45:56 It does move the pedestrians, keeps them away from traffic, and it moves them quite a bit
0:45:59 away from the rock fall.
0:46:01 Some of the disadvantages in this came up during the discussions with the Committee,
0:46:04 for sure, is that with that path being on the north side of the road and particularly
0:46:08 lower, there's going to be some freezing issues, some maintenance issues, safety.
0:46:13 You're really out of sight there from a sight distance, and then lighting could become an
0:46:18 issue as well.
0:46:19 Alternative 3 and we go through that real quick is very similar to alternative 2.
0:46:24 This was more designed to reduce some of the excavation costs with, instead of going with
0:46:30 a paved path, more of a natural path, a steeper path with grades up to 20% in some locations.
0:46:36 It would be more in line with what FHWA has for some of their mountainside design paths,
0:46:42 things like that.
0:46:44 Rock wall protection is still using the same rock bolting and the rock scaling and netting
0:46:49 on the higher risk areas.
0:46:52 So the estimated construction cost on this one,
0:46:54 this all turns about four and a half to $5 million.
0:46:59 Some of the same advantages and disadvantages
0:47:02 that we just talked about.
0:47:03 Now that actually the disadvantage of that is there would be
0:47:05 some very steep sections of the pathway.
0:47:10 One of the things the committee asked us to look at was just,
0:47:12 what if we just fix the road?
0:47:14 And don't really talk about the pedestrians,
0:47:18 but widen the road to the 28 feet where we'd have two feet
0:47:23 of shoulder on either side and then a full 24 foot wide pavement for the travel lanes.
0:47:28 So it would be generally an improvement over what's there now.
0:47:31 It would be a full reconstruction of the road, but really no additional improvements at that
0:47:37 point.
0:47:38 I think the idea, which is more of a baseline of what that might look like.
0:47:41 So probably looking at about 1.4 to 1.7 million dollars, and that's what that would look like.
0:47:55 Some of the advantages and disadvantages are really from a cost point of view significantly
0:47:58 lower and it does address some of the goals of the charter, but really as far as the separation
0:48:05 of pedestrians from the traffic does not accommodate that objective.
0:48:13 This was kind of a fun one looking at alternative five was to say, all right, let's think out
0:48:18 of the box a little bit and move the pathway west or move it to a different location to
0:48:23 see if we can connect to an existing city pedestrian facility and still get folks down to the canyon
0:48:30 floor and accomplish maybe some of the same ideas.
0:48:34 So this connection that we're talking about,
0:48:38 and I'll show you a picture over here in just a minute
0:48:39 as far as where it is.
0:48:41 The estimated cost on this was around 9 1.5 to $11.4 million.
0:48:47 Big part of that is it's where we're looking at
0:48:50 for this location, there's a lot of vertical difference
0:48:53 between the existing canyon room up there, obviously,
0:48:55 and trying to meet where the canyon floor is next
0:49:00 to the westward treatment plant.
0:49:04 So I'm playing to you, that's the location,
0:49:05 just west of the gun club and you can see the treatment plant
0:49:08 just above that arrow there.
0:49:11 And that's a pretty good view if you're standing
0:49:13 at the bottom of how much work you'd have ahead
0:49:14 and you're going up that hill.
0:49:18 You have fun planning that, when you're saying.
0:49:20 I was trying to, our designer tried to make that fit
0:49:24 and you can see kind of on the bottom of the picture,
0:49:27 trying to make that fit within,
0:49:29 you've got that rock face still.
0:49:31 And then once you get on that tala slope,
0:49:33 which is on about a 45 degree angle,
0:49:35 trying to make that fit, get the grays that you want.
0:49:39 That's probably not an optimal layout,
0:49:41 but it works, at least for the concept ideas anyway,
0:49:45 of trying to put some figures to paper.
0:49:52 That's a quick section cut of what it would look like,
0:49:55 where the rock face would be, again,
0:49:57 go with the rock catch ditch to try
0:49:58 and catch anything that might fall.
0:50:02 And then on the fills section, on the downhill side
0:50:04 that talis slope use, the idea here would be to use gavian baskets or another mechanically
0:50:10 stabilized earth type of structure. The advantage of gavian baskets is you're going to generate
0:50:16 a lot of excavated material from that rock phase so you can just build the baskets up
0:50:19 with them. It's a little less expensive, but you'd still have to reinforce behind them,
0:50:24 as you can see. The other nice thing about that is if you use the rock that's excavated
0:50:30 there, it would look more natural, I think. So this, you know, like I said, we were talking
0:50:36 around a $10 million construction cost for that, less than those first alternatives.
0:50:40 Does provide some closer pedestrian connectivity, dog or falls, and largely the way it's what
0:50:45 a treatment plan, if there's interest in that.
0:50:47 It is still a significant cost.
0:50:50 And I think some of the committee felt like people are still going to use the grade, the
0:50:54 Cambridge Grades.
0:50:55 So it really does not address any of those issues associated with the grade.
0:51:00 But there was discussion that maybe this is something to look at in the future, or hybrid
0:51:04 this alternative to provide more access over on the one side closer to the other falls.
0:51:11 Alternative 6, which I'll give away the end game here, is the recommended alternative.
0:51:18 And it's similar to those presented in alternatives 2 and 3 as far as a top-down construction,
0:51:26 particularly on the area above the first hairpin.
0:51:30 But then what we would do is instead of excavating that down and then just leaving it below grade,
0:51:35 is using mechanically stabilized earth walls adjacent to the face there of where the cut
0:51:41 is and back fill up so that there's the plan to do it again.
0:51:47 But it looks something like that on that upper section.
0:51:50 So pedestrians would be at grade.
0:51:52 There's still be some separation with a concrete jersey barrier or some of the form of protection
0:51:57 from traffic, although you know that that speed, Kerbin Gutter would work as well, not
0:52:03 the same level of protection, I guess, but it addressed to a lot of the safety concerns that
0:52:08 were brought up from the committee as far as that graded separated path that was shown
0:52:14 in alternatives to human-3, that same view on the downhill side of that first hairpin.
0:52:24 So this one probably meant the object is better than the other alternative that came up.
0:52:30 It does provide the strong conductivity and the separation of pedestrians from the traffic.
0:52:37 The construction cost is a little bit higher than some of the other alternatives on the
0:52:42 range of $4.8 to $5.8 million for that one.
0:52:47 The last two alternatives, this is the lease costly alternative and this is basically signing
0:52:52 the roadway prohibiting pedestrian use.
0:52:54 So the estimated cost just assigned and some of the installation and things along those
0:52:59 lines is somewhere between $15,000 and $20,000.
0:53:02 This would require a bit of enforcement from the sheriff's department, really doesn't address
0:53:10 the project goals and objectives.
0:53:11 I guess safety would be accomplished just by keeping pedestrians off of the grade.
0:53:16 Although I think the thought process was, it's folks still would like to use the grade because
0:53:20 that's something that has seen a lot of use.
0:53:23 It's obviously an attraction.
0:53:29 Final alternative, this would be to install a traffic signal at the top and the bottom
0:53:34 the grade, basically create a one-way roadway similar to what you see over on the north side
0:53:39 of the river by the country club over there.
0:53:42 This may cost for this one, it's around $400,000.
0:53:48 Again this really, I think it was good to explore it is to see what type of impact that would
0:53:53 have.
0:53:54 We did not really get into any traffic queuing but you can kind of imagine that with the time
0:53:58 would take to go one-way traffic up and down that steep grade, you'd get some pretty significant
0:54:05 cues that would probably certainly impact the property driveways along the canyon there,
0:54:10 but also back up likely into the film or intersection. So really looking at some lengthy traffic
0:54:15 delays. That is a summary of the different alternatives, the different, the nine different
0:54:25 alternatives with the range of the cost forum. It's kind of a brief recap of that.
0:54:33 Any questions?
0:54:34 I went through that really fast and then I'll jump in and I'll turn it in and I'll get
0:54:38 it away.
0:54:39 Suzanne, I'm going to start with you.
0:54:41 Do you have any questions at this point?
0:54:43 No, I'm good right now.
0:54:46 Thank you.
0:54:47 Chris talking to me.
0:54:48 Not sure who to address the question to, but none of these improvements would meet
0:54:55 ADA compliance for grade as I understand.
0:54:59 They're all for an excessive 5%.
0:55:02 Is that going to be a problem for us on the utilization
0:55:07 of public funding for a non-ADA compliant project
0:55:11 of this size?
0:55:13 I don't know, Fritz, if you have an idea on that,
0:55:15 or Travis or Brian?
0:55:19 One of the things that we did with some of the research
0:55:21 and included that.
0:55:22 It looks like we're making ourselves out of compliance
0:55:25 by doing this.
0:55:26 That's what I'm trying to say.
0:55:28 Right.
0:55:28 There is some provisions with, and it's in the report.
0:55:34 I can probably read from that,
0:55:35 but at the back of the report, there's some caveats in there
0:55:38 that we listed.
0:55:40 And the Americans with Disability Act,
0:55:43 there are some provisions with some of the,
0:55:47 I guess you could call them the regulatory authorities,
0:55:48 where if you've got an existing facility
0:55:50 that has a grade in excess of the 5%,
0:55:53 and it's not practical, it's not,
0:55:56 you know, you just really can't practically meet that 5% grade.
0:56:00 There is some allowances in there that I think would keep you out of trouble
0:56:03 in that regard. I think that's something that
0:56:07 certainly want to confirm, but our interpretation of reading through that
0:56:11 and some provisions there is that it should be fine.
0:56:14 You would not meet the 5%. There's no way.
0:56:18 There's no way. I mean the very nature of that existing grade and
0:56:21 what you have to work with, and I don't know about your goat trail coming down the
0:56:24 wall, but it doesn't look like 5% is anywhere in the books.
0:56:28 No, no, and that's like I said, I can get some more information and I think we quoted
0:56:35 a chapter in the subsection of, I'm trying to remember the title of the manual, but basically
0:56:42 it addresses some of the ADA concerns.
0:56:44 Well, Dr. I do think we should at least have some verification of them.
0:56:51 So that came out of the Access Board guidelines and standards for pedestrian accessibility
0:56:58 routes within the public right-of-way.
0:57:00 So in those sections there, there are some, again, in our interpretation, but I think it's
0:57:07 good to look into that maybe a little bit further, maybe get further legal advice to
0:57:12 make sure that my interpretation is not eroding some of that, but there are some areas of
0:57:18 of allowance and obviously, you know,
0:57:20 Twin Falls is not alone where you have streets
0:57:22 that exceed that grade and there's just no practical way
0:57:26 to construct a year route that would meet that 5%.
0:57:30 Do you have anything?
0:57:38 Well, one we can look at for reference would be the trail
0:57:42 up out of Shusham Falls, which was built with Centennial funds,
0:57:47 but we certainly maintain it to a certain degree
0:57:50 and it certainly has percentages well above 20,
0:57:53 Well, about 5%.
0:57:54 I think they probably had something closer to 20% coming up
0:57:58 out of Shoshim Falls.
0:57:59 And so that doesn't seem to have been an ADA name.
0:58:04 That's a fairly new trail.
0:58:05 The whole trail is new.
0:58:06 I mean, what, 10 years ago?
0:58:08 Well, maybe 15 now.
0:58:09 But so well after the ADA requirements were put into place.
0:58:14 So Jackie's got to talk.
0:58:16 So to Brian's point, there are roadways that have managed
0:58:21 to be so steep that compliance with ADA was not even close
0:58:26 to being a reasonable opportunity
0:58:28 or perhaps even achievable.
0:58:31 We don't have a sample spot to show you on a picture,
0:58:36 but I've seen them and I know they exist.
0:58:38 And before we actually pursued funding construction,
0:58:41 of course we ended up going through a process
0:58:43 where we had to validate that as part of the design
0:58:47 of the people path.
0:58:49 And that would apply to most of those options,
0:58:52 except for the sign either comments or questions for Ryan or Phil or Troy or
0:59:12 Kristoff. I'll just make a comment that it certainly looks like six is the
0:59:17 desirable one by keeping the pedestrians which my use of the of that trail in
0:59:24 times past that hundred and fifty day I'll I'll vouch for but keeping them at
0:59:28 great I think is an integral part of overall safety.
0:59:33 And also to put the pedestrian walkway to the outside in minimizing rockfall.
0:59:41 I've had at least one experience where I was on the outside of a trail coming up.
0:59:45 The lady was on the inside.
0:59:47 The canyon side of a rock fell between us, between here and that wall.
0:59:51 And it was a known size rock and I have no idea how far it fell,
0:59:56 but it could have killed somebody.
0:59:58 So minimizing the rock following, keeping pedestrians
1:00:01 that great are important for me.
1:00:09 Well, I will add as the committee was going
1:00:14 through the alternatives, and I commend them
1:00:17 for pushing the envelope a little bit to come up
1:00:18 with a couple of other alternatives too.
1:00:23 The safety concerns of the original recommendations
1:00:26 of two and three were a long discussion, the fact
1:00:31 that you were down below grade.
1:00:33 You couldn't see the discussion of would you need lighting
1:00:36 down there, certainly on a day like this or a day like the past couple
1:00:41 of weeks, the fact that that's just going to be a solid sheet of ice
1:00:43 for six weeks or two months.
1:00:46 I think alternative six gives the same concept, separates pedestrians,
1:00:52 keeps that access, hopefully mitigates the rock fall issues.
1:00:57 And also in the discussion was pretty good discussion of the matrix, the risk matrix,
1:01:06 and talking about the fact that if we were to move forward with this, once you get out
1:01:10 there and start doing some of that work, being able to have some flexibility to address
1:01:13 areas that maybe were a two or a three on the original matrix, but once you're up there
1:01:20 being able to address some of those, you know, you can't eliminate it all, but to mitigate
1:01:26 those areas that were at risk so again I commend the committee I thought they did
1:01:30 an outstanding job of really delving in maybe even to a certain extent to a greater
1:01:37 detail level than I expected them to at the beginning so it was enlightening and I
1:01:42 said many times I don't speak for the council when I was in those meetings so
1:01:47 I don't think I was speaking great. Any other comments from the council?
1:01:57 So try and we'll move.
1:01:59 So going forward.
1:02:01 I guess tonight we're before you really to see what the council wishes are.
1:02:06 I mean the committee has made a recommendation but really it is up to the council to make a decision.
1:02:10 And we are recommending the council adopt the committee's recommendation of option six.
1:02:16 And there was already design funds available, engineering design funds to go forward with the project so that is already budgeted and taken care of.
1:02:24 So at this time we would recommend the council allow the
1:02:27 engineering to continue on option six and we can go forward and just kind of
1:02:31 start solidifying things. We have to talk to a bunch of property owners, really a
1:02:35 more detailed analysis of the design, what it looks like, and bring that back
1:02:40 before the council as well as a funding solution. I know that's gonna be a very
1:02:44 long discussion. The Travis and the City Council on that and four point eight to
1:02:51 5.8 is a large sum of money and it really needs to be delved into but we
1:02:55 would like to solidify the numbers to make sure those are absolutely accurate
1:02:59 before we present to you and then we'll come back with a full project at that
1:03:04 point and I guess tonight we're just asking to go forward the project and I
1:03:09 just want to say thank you to the committee members all of them there's
1:03:12 quite a few of them here tonight and they were really fantastic and they did
1:03:19 think outside the box and they brought both concerns of being a user of it and
1:03:26 also looking at the financial aspect they know there's a lot of people in the city
1:03:32 that would be impacted by a large dollar cost so they really I think we're a fantastic group to work with.
1:03:41 So Chris talking to you.
1:03:43 Well I would say there will be a
1:03:45 have the recommendation number six and
1:03:47 instruct the city staff and associate at
1:03:50 consultants to proceed with further
1:03:53 engineering and cost refinement of the
1:03:55 project report back to us in 90 days okay
1:03:59 I'll second that is that feasible
1:04:04 at this time I think we need probably a
1:04:07 little bit more time with that just for
1:04:08 91 days
1:04:11 Oh, and then that to 48 inches of snow tonight.
1:04:15 So, four months?
1:04:17 Yeah, we can work and we'll try to have something in the spring time.
1:04:22 Travis?
1:04:24 So, it would be our intent to be able to try to include this recommendation for funding for the FY18 budget.
1:04:35 And so I think that from a timeline perspective, so long as we could vet this during that budgeting
1:04:42 process would probably give the staff the appropriate time to be able to find those true costs,
1:04:49 the revenue sources are actually, I mean just to kind of talk a little bit about that tonight,
1:04:55 may not be as challenging as you might think trying to find $4.8 to $5.8 million.
1:05:04 So remember that you took a million dollars from the bond proceeds of the wastewater treatment
1:05:10 facility and you reserved those back for this project because of the damage done to the roadway.
1:05:17 We also advanced constructed part of the Washington Street project several years ago in which we
1:05:24 utilize cash reserves and we have received our portion of that back from the state.
1:05:30 So that is now in cash reserves.
1:05:33 The Street Fund Cash Reserves account is also very healthy.
1:05:37 And we have used the Cash Reserve account
1:05:40 in the Street Fund for one-time capital projects.
1:05:45 In addition to that, this has been a priority project
1:05:48 that has been discussed by the Council,
1:05:49 and we could also augment that
1:05:51 within coming Street Fund reserves.
1:05:53 And so really, if it stays within this $4.8 to $5.8 million
1:05:58 project, I believe it really is financially achievable for the city to move forward with
1:06:04 construction. Should it climb significantly above that as they get into their engineering
1:06:09 work? That's when I think that we need to come back and begin to explore other alternatives
1:06:14 with the Council on this option and its fundability.
1:06:18 So I'll get right to you, sir. Great to do you have another comment.
1:06:23 I just had a question for a vote. What's the estimated breakdown between the rock and
1:06:29 fall mitigation in the new trail or the whitening for the trail. Do we have just
1:06:36 an estimated breakdown between those? I'm more interested. I'll be honest with you
1:06:40 whenever I walked out of the canyon I did it for several years. I went down to
1:06:43 Shoshan Falls where I didn't have to worry about any traffic and walked out
1:06:47 there because it's a nice 10 feet wide trail with those cars on it and I just
1:06:52 felt safer there. So I'm not as worried about the trail as I am the the rock
1:06:57 I mean, to me, the rock fall mitigation is under me.
1:07:01 We need to address just to keep our treatment plan open
1:07:05 if not in else.
1:07:07 So the rock fall mitigation, if you look at that,
1:07:12 that reconstruction.
1:07:15 So the rock fall mitigation, as far as just the higher risk areas,
1:07:20 those four higher risk areas, we're looking for around $1.5 million
1:07:24 of $5.5 million plus or minus for those areas.
1:07:29 If you got into some of the more risk matrix three type levels,
1:07:34 you know, add some costs to that.
1:07:36 But just to give you an idea of what we're sitting at right now,
1:07:38 to really focus in on those four high risk areas,
1:07:40 probably about a half million dollars of rock,
1:07:42 bolting, netting, scaling, things like that.
1:07:46 OK, so 10% of the pen?
1:07:51 I think that's.
1:07:52 So we're, you know, I'm just thinking a lot here.
1:07:56 We're basically paying $4.5 million to $5.5 million
1:08:00 to for 150 people to walk up and down a roadway.
1:08:06 Well, the other thing that that cost does not include
1:08:09 is any improvements to the roadway itself
1:08:10 as far as the reconstruction, so.
1:08:12 I forgot that part.
1:08:13 Thank you.
1:08:14 That's a good question, very good question.
1:08:19 So do you have a gentleman in the audience here
1:08:20 who has a comment that I'd like to make.
1:08:23 So you're welcome to come forward, sir,
1:08:24 and please state your name for the record.
1:08:30 I walk on the grade in excess, well, several hundred miles annually.
1:08:37 I probably spend as much mileage there as anybody in the county.
1:08:42 I feel I probably stand to gain as much as anybody in the county through the advantages of safety for alternative six, which I do not support in any way.
1:08:54 I'd like to compare alternative four and alternative six.
1:09:00 Both of them provide rock stabilization, identical rock stabilization.
1:09:07 Both of them provide widening of the road, which will in fact make it safer for pedestrians.
1:09:14 Both of them provide for a two-foot shoulder on either side of the road,
1:09:20 which will make more room and more safety for the pedestrians.
1:09:23 Both of them, at that point, cost $1.7 million maximum.
1:09:31 That's where we separate from the two proposals.
1:09:34 Proposal six adds a two-thirds of a mile sidewalk down to the second switchback.
1:09:42 The purpose of that sidewalk is to add pedestrian safety by getting them out of the road, as you've already heard.
1:09:50 I'd like to address the safety aspect.
1:09:52 I've talked to all of the regular walkers that I've ever had a chance to meet.
1:10:00 None of them have any awareness of any pedestrian ever having been hit by a car on that section
1:10:05 of the road.
1:10:06 I've got an 88-year-old friend and twin who's very active in the community and extremely
1:10:11 sharp lived here for 88 years.
1:10:14 He's never ever heard of an accident on that stretch of the road.
1:10:17 I submit to you that the accident rate, pedestrian versus automobile, on that stretch of road
1:10:22 is zero and has been for the entire duration of the road.
1:10:28 So in fact what you get for alternative six over alternative four is four million dollar
1:10:35 sidewalk to nowhere.
1:10:38 And the sole purpose for that is to improve on a zero percent accident rate, not with
1:10:44 my money.
1:10:45 Thank you.
1:10:46 Thank you, sir.
1:10:55 So we do have a motion before us by Chris Stock and then seconded by Ruth Pierce to
1:11:01 Accept the recommendation of the Canyon Springs grade ad hoc committee and direct staff to move forward at the engineering and develop a funding strategy to return
1:11:12 To the council is there any discussion on that motion?
1:11:18 Seeing and hearing then Sharon roll call vote, please
1:11:23 Chris Hockington. Yes, Greg Lanthine. No
1:11:28 Ruth Pierce
1:11:30 Suzanne Hawkins
1:11:32 Yes
1:11:34 Sean Baraker
1:11:36 Yes, motion passes four to one.
1:11:44 Once again, thank you to the committee members for your service on the committee.
1:11:48 If we need more work from you, we'll definitely come find you because you did a fine job. Thank you.
1:11:54 Yes, thank you. I agree.
1:11:56 And next on the agenda is a request to authorize modification of city code sections related to driving site obstructions.
1:12:04 And we have our city engineer, Jackie Fields. Welcome, Jackie.
1:12:10 Good evening. The request this evening is to seek some kind of willingness in your part
1:12:21 to consider code changes that deal with sight distances. We have some sections of code that
1:12:28 may not work as well as they could work. We have businesses that have complied perfectly
1:12:34 with the laws that stated and it's still difficult or maybe scary to pull out of their driveway
1:12:42 approaches onto the roadway. We've also had some ongoing conversations about
1:12:52 intersections like Fillmore and Canyon Springs Great. You know, is that actually
1:12:58 safe enough for sight distance and people are feeling somewhat uncomfortable and so
1:13:04 we wanted to spend the time and effort to consider revising the city code to
1:13:11 perhaps update some of our codes to be more in line with ASHTO and or which is
1:13:22 I can't remember the name of the acronym but it's our transportation
1:13:26 federal transportation guidelines and perhaps improve some pedestrian
1:13:37 visibility which doesn't always appear to be the case so we've had citizens
1:13:43 call in and they say, gee, you know, my neighbor has a fence right at the edge of the alley,
1:13:48 and I just about hit that kid who was walking on the street. And they're really concerned,
1:13:53 but their neighbor has complied with the law. So maybe we need to investigate that a little
1:13:58 bit more and see if we can make it a little bit easier or more comfortable for people.
1:14:05 Because when they call, they are horrified that they've been in a spot where they could have
1:14:10 heard someone legitimately. I think it's worth looking into. So I'm asking that you
1:14:17 authorize us to propose modifications to the city code related to visual
1:14:22 obstructions for the drivers. Any comments or questions from the Council? Suzanne
1:14:34 do you have anything? I do. So your request might suggest you market because of the
1:14:41 So you were a little muffled on that, Suzanne, can you try it once more, please?
1:14:48 Sorry, so the request is to further investigate what these codes should say or to accept the changes that we're in our packet.
1:14:58 Oh, in theory, there's no changes in your packet, so you're just authorizing staff or basically accepting the idea that staff may come to you with proposed code changes in the future.
1:15:10 changes in the future.
1:15:13 Got it.
1:15:14 Thank you.
1:15:15 I would think if there are potentially identified problems, it would be silly of us not to authorize
1:15:22 you to go look at making changes to address those.
1:15:25 I would certainly be supportive of that.
1:15:27 Sorry, it was very intense.
1:15:29 That's okay.
1:15:30 Chris talking.
1:15:31 I'm just wondering why this wouldn't come through the traffic safety commission with the engineer.
1:15:36 Is that not part of the traffic safety commission's jurisdiction?
1:15:40 Certainly it could.
1:15:42 I'd send them out to Bird Dog and get all the hazards for you and help you with that a little bit.
1:15:49 Bird, do you have them all red tagged already?
1:15:52 No, I don't have them all red tagged and it certainly would be worth it to have a conversation with that group.
1:15:57 I wouldn't want to engage them in a conversation if it was not the time and the place to do that.
1:16:05 Without you come here and ask.
1:16:07 I think it sounds like a great idea, and thank you for bringing it to our attention, and we look forward to seeing the future potential code changes.
1:16:17 Thank you.
1:16:19 Next on the agenda, another opportunity for public input. If there is anyone here left from the public who would like to address the council on any issues, now is your time.
1:16:33 Dave Moore, 230 Coronado Twin Falls, and this is basically basically a request I was fascinated
1:16:40 with the multiple options shown for the Kenyon Springs grade.
1:16:45 Will those be posted, can those be posted on the city's website for review by citizens
1:16:51 who are not here, who may have questions once they see it in the paper?
1:16:56 So I actually believe those are probably already on the website as a part of the minutes from
1:17:00 the ad hoc committee, their November meeting when that final report was included, but we
1:17:07 certainly can do a better job of trying to direct a second there.
1:17:10 Very good.
1:17:11 Thank you.
1:17:12 Yeah, there's a written report that has all, actually a much more detailed review of each
1:17:16 of those recommendations.
1:17:17 Travis.
1:17:18 It was also included in tonight's packet, so if you look at tonight's agenda, it is the
1:17:26 The entire report that Brian went through that was submitted by GUB was included for review.
1:17:34 Thank you, Mr. Moore.
1:17:36 Any items from the City Manager?
1:17:39 Anything from the City Council?
1:17:44 Meeting is adjourned.
1:17:47 There's just some indication of how all meetings in 2017 really are.
Download
- Transcript (text) 69 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 91 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 123 KB
- Audio (M4A) 18.4 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Tuesday, January 3, 2017. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:17:53.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
1262a737e97ed16eeac7b4b8de4928b31c7cd4688deed231184d234f949e9c8d - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 723195eaf501e0ba37bcaa0c251b298edebcd11226fbbfdd665beb2e845d0818 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
82075202ef10716a7ed229dce3e7b84e09d024cf6e7ddb51e2f1bc299692d066
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file