EX-C03-3
Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)
City of Twin Falls
View the document here · 9 pages
- Record date
- Not dated
- Source
- PRR #4729
- Record type
- Records Requests and Agency Responses
- Pages used
- all (4); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1); all (1)
- Supports findings
- E-22 The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others
- Notes
- Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.
- Redaction
- 3 area(s) redacted
Chain of custody
- Obtained. Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #4729. Request filed 2026-08 (approx.); the City's response: Produced HR documents (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the file exactly as the agency released it:
316d60bbeab4280b053f68308848ca585feb8c10bc71d84e4945c8e2cdd12d14
3e69b9ad0c9fef88bbd3aeb71b0e68077df96f7da2a5f12a4abc8f4ae3ec9cbf
8736464202ab57d952dcf1a42ef0d72d74e11f99567bfa571dbd01472323fc07
f911b3ff39d8743245230a5d7c90b6f9ca77d153c5edd53dd52d6e57810ef02b
d3de6742efb71b5b451bafcb1a516dc2ec9077bc2c2990569a5b21ff1237ca81
daeab25a870148cafa400ada588df2701d4d0fbba7a6e9aae40f512b4d9c687e - Changes for posting.
- Combined from 6 files as released
- Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted
- Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed
- Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable
- Posted copy. SHA-256 of the file you download here, checked against our index on every build:
1a797a0ff30ed53aa0d406ef0ab666ab23e5ac14878184fb565a335ee4696b14
The original as received is kept unaltered. Anyone holding the agency's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. How to verify a file · Chain of custody for every record (CSV)
Document text (read by machine for search, and often imperfect for scans and handwriting; the file is the record)
City of Twin Falls Public Records Request Requestor Information Please list your information here. Include your request details in the space provided below. Requestor First Name * Requestor Last Name * Requestor Address 1 * Requestor Address 2 Requestor City * Requestor State * Requestor ZIP Code * Requestor Phone Number * Requestor E-mail * Type of Request * Personal Commercial Legal Request Details * If you are requesting multiple records, please attach your list below. If you do not have a case/event/citation number, please include enough information to identify the records you want. If your request is for multiple items, it may be subject to fees for preparation. We have records for the Twin Falls Police Department (city, not county) only. RE: Public Records Request Pursuant to Idaho Code § 74-101 et seq. – Senior Executive Leadership Compensation Records (FY 2020–21 through FY 2025–26) I. Statutory Authority and Basis for Request Pursuant to the Idaho Public Records Act, Idaho Code § 74-101 et seq., the undersigned, a member of the public and a resident of Twin Falls, Idaho, hereby submits this formal written request to inspect and obtain copies of public records in the custody or control of the City of Twin Falls. This request is made in an individual capacity as a taxpayer and concerned citizen and is not made for any commercial purpose. The City is respectfully requested to treat this correspondence as a formal public records request requiring a timely response in accordance with applicable law. II. Records Requested I hereby request all public records — including but not limited to documents, data, agreements, resolutions, correspondence, and electronically stored information — for the period of October 1, 2020 through September 30, 2026 (Fiscal Years 2020–21 through 2025–26, inclusive), pertaining to the compensation, benefits, and employment terms of each of the following named City of Twin Falls employees (hereinafter, "the Named Employees"): Travis Rothweiler, City Manager Gretchen Scott, Deputy City Manager Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Mitch Humble, Deputy City Manager Breanna Howard, Chief Financial Officer Kristen Kohntopp, Human Resources Director Shawn Barigar, Economic Development Director For each of the Named Employees individually, the requestor seeks all records related to the following categories: a. (a) Base Salary and Salary History: All records reflecting base salary and any changes thereto during the request period, including but not limited to step increases, merit increases, cost-of-living adjustments (COLA), and compression adjustments, together with the effective dates and any documentation supporting or authorizing each change. b. (b) Supplemental Compensation: All records reflecting any and all forms of supplemental compensation provided in addition to base salary, including but not limited to bonuses, performance pay, incentive pay, longevity pay, and any one- time or recurring stipends of any nature. c. (c) Employment Contracts and Agreements: All employment contracts, offer letters, employment agreements, and any amendments, addenda, memoranda of understanding, or side letters thereto, reflecting the terms and conditions of each Named Employee's employment with the City. d. (d) Above-Range or Exception Compensation: Any records reflecting salary or compensation set above the standard pay grade or classification range applicable to the Named Employee's position, including any written justification, administrative authorization, or City Council authorization for such exceptions or deviations from standard pay classification schedules. e. (e) Non-Standard Leave and PTO Benefits: All records reflecting any extra, enhanced, or supplemental paid time off (PTO), vacation accrual rates above standard policy, vacation bank balances awarded outside standard policy, administrative leave with pay, or any other non-standard leave benefits negotiated, awarded, or granted to any of the Named Employees. f. (f) Fringe Benefits and Perquisites: All records reflecting vehicle allowances, housing allowances, cell phone allowances, technology stipends, deferred compensation contributions (including but not limited to PERSI supplemental plans and 457(b) contributions made by the City on behalf of the employee), and any other fringe benefits or perquisites provided beyond the standard City employee benefits package. g. (g) City Council Authorizations: Any City Council resolutions, ordinances, meeting minutes excerpts, or executive session summaries (to the extent not otherwise exempt from disclosure under Idaho Code § 74-206) that authorized, approved, or memorialized any compensation, bonus, benefit, or benefit adjustment for any of the Named Employees. III. Format of Production The requestor seeks all responsive records in electronic format — preferably PDF or native electronic format — delivered electronically via email or secure download link. IV. Statutory Response Deadline I respectfully remind the City that Idaho Code § 74-103 requires the public records custodian to respond to this request within three (3) business days of receipt. That response must, at minimum: (1) produce the requested records; (2) deny the request in whole or in part with a specific statutory basis for the denial; or (3) provide a reasonable, good-faith estimate of the time required for production if the volume or nature of the records necessitates additional time to compile. I expect the City's strict and timely compliance with this statutory obligation and respectfully request that the City acknowledge receipt of this request in writing at its earliest opportunity. V. Request for Fee Waiver The requestor is aware that, pursuant to Idaho Code § 74-102(9), the City may assess a charge for personnel time spent locating, compiling, and reviewing responsive records beyond the initial two (2) hours, which must be provided at no charge. The requestor respectfully requests that, before incurring any billable personnel time beyond that two-hour threshold, the City provide advance written notice that it anticipates the threshold will be exceeded. The requestor further requests a reasonable opportunity to narrow or prioritize the scope of this request before any such charges are incurred, so as to minimize burden on both parties. Additionally, the requestor asks that the custodian exercise the discretion afforded under Idaho Code § 74-102(9) and waive any applicable personnel-time charges in connection with this request. This request concerns the compensation and employment terms of senior public officials compensated entirely with taxpayer funds. Disclosure of the requested records is unambiguously in the public interest — it bears directly on the stewardship of public resources and public understanding of government operations — and is made solely in the capacity of a private citizen and taxpayer, with no commercial purpose. Waiver of fees is fully warranted on these grounds. VI. Notice Regarding Claimed Exemptions In the event that the City determines that any portion of the records requested herein is subject to a statutory exemption and will be withheld in whole or in part, I request that the City provide the following in connection with each withheld or partially withheld record: a. A specific citation to the applicable statutory exemption under the Idaho Public Records Act or other governing law upon which the City relies in withholding the record; b. A brief description of the nature and subject matter of the withheld record sufficient to allow me to assess whether the claimed exemption is properly applicable; and c. All non-exempt portions of any partially exempt record, produced in redacted form with the exempt portions clearly indicated. I reserve all rights to challenge any exemption claims that I believe to be improper or overbroad. VII. Closing Thank you for your attention to this request. The requestor has endeavored to make the scope as clear and specific as possible to facilitate efficient and complete production. The requestor is available to clarify any aspect of this request or to discuss the most practical means of production in order to facilitate an efficient response. I look forward to the City's timely response in accordance with the Idaho Public Records Act. Attach Files to Your Request If you have documentation that you wish to provide for this request, attach the files here. Signature * The City of Twin Falls will respond to this request within three (3) business days. Or up to 10 business days upon notification of the requesting party. The City of Twin Falls maintains records for the City of Twin Falls, Idaho. For records including in Twin Falls County please contact Twin Falls County at www.twinfallscounty.org Requested records will be provided electronically. We do not provide your information to mailing lists. It will only be used to fulfill this request. From [email protected] To Date Friday, September 04, 2026 02:49 PM MT Subject Copy of Form Public Records Requests Attachments City of Twin Falls Public Records Request.pdf Filed under #4729 Source file SHA-256 15625f441c9f38b41eac1458ca6b89ee7509645f69adc4d92dbe4e245b81f8bf Your records request has been received. You're receiving this email because someone requested that you get a copy of this form. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From No Reply <[email protected]> To Date Friday, September 04, 2026 02:56 PM MT Subject City of Twin Falls Records Request Extension Notice for Request #4729 Attachments none Filed under #4729 Source file SHA-256 76d9376c908e4f2a99d2a285ea10c9aefbd1592ee38b5aebe4441da0167e6a0d Your request to examine public records was received on 9/4/2026 2:43:30 PM. The City will be unable to process the request within statutory three (3) working days and a longer period of time will be necessary to locate, retrieve, and review the records. This letter is to provide notice for an extension of ten (10) working days from the date of your original request under Idaho Code 74-103(2). Your patience in this matter is appreciated and we will contact you when these records are available for release. Thank you, and we look forward to processing your request. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From [email protected] To Date Friday, September 04, 2026 02:56 PM MT Subject Your Public Records Request #4729 is being processed. Attachments none Filed under #4729 Source file SHA-256 281941f72dc4e435f54e6c575444590f80298dd438012289e2f96f8acb0d393d Your Public Records Request #4729 is being processed and materials are being gathered. You will be updated as the status changes. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From No Reply <[email protected]> To Date Friday, September 11, 2026 05:10 PM MT Subject Public Records Request #4729 is under final review. Attachments none Filed under #4729 Source file SHA-256 296b096251bdc6e248a0d11757e595d0382006476f2cb35de5b7cb62bb94f133 Public Records Request #4729 is undergoing final review before the information is released. You will be notified upon its completion. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From No Reply <[email protected]> To Date Monday, September 14, 2026 09:33 AM MT Subject Results of your Public Records Request #4729 Attachments none Filed under #4729 Source file SHA-256 3b5e3bf0e806080daf9463400d2cf001df56f8d5545e3e65ad6ffe135e0cf496 Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 09/04/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse.aspx?dbid=0&startid=29043 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive.