EX-C01-9
Correspondence with the City, compiled in date order (with City attachments)
City of Twin Falls
View the document here · 32 pages
- Record date
- Not dated
- Source
- PRR #3946
- Record type
- Records Requests and Agency Responses
- Pages used
- all (2); all (1); all (1); all (2); all (1); all (2); all (1); all (1); all (2); all (2); all (4); all (3); all (3); all (3); all (4)
- Supports findings
- E-12 PRR #3946: 109 of 117 items withheld as vendor "proprietary"; the notice omitted the attorney-review statement
E-22 The City enforces the requester-information rule on some requests and not others - Notes
- Each email rendered to PDF from the received message; bookmarks give date/sender/subject. Requester signature images omitted.
- Redaction
- 3 area(s) redacted
Chain of custody
- Obtained. Released by the City of Twin Falls in response to public records request #3946. Request filed 2026-05-31; the City's response: Partial; late; 109/117 withheld as "proprietary" (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the file exactly as the agency released it: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 - Changes for posting.
- Combined from 15 files as released
- Redacted: 3 area(s) redacted
- Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed
- Requester names and personal contact details (email addresses, phone numbers, home or mailing addresses) redacted (pages 1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 18, 20, 21, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 32); City staff and officials' names, titles, pay, and City and other government contact details left readable
- Posted copy. SHA-256 of the file you download here, checked against our index on every build:
bde06480fda50f4be83d430c9c3d855fd8c687bea8e1275dd992c2bdcd137e5c
The original as received is kept unaltered. Anyone holding the agency's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. How to verify a file · Chain of custody for every record (CSV)
Document text (read by machine for search, and often imperfect for scans and handwriting; the file is the record)
City of Twin Falls Public Records Request Requestor Information Please list your information here. Include your request details in the space provided below. Requestor First Name * Requestor Last Name * Requestor Address 1 * Requestor Address 2 Requestor City * Requestor State * Requestor ZIP Code * Requestor Phone Number * Requestor E-mail * Type of Request * Personal Commercial Legal Request Details * If you are requesting multiple records, please attach your list below. If you do not have a case/event/citation number, please include enough information to identify the records you want. If your request is for multiple items, it may be subject to fees for preparation. We have records for the Twin Falls Police Department (city, not county) only. I am requesting all materials for the City of Twin Falls with the keyword of 'Market Analysis' possessed/received/sent by Travis Rothweiler, Gretchen Scott, Mitch Humble, Kristen Kohntopp and/or Breanna Howard. This should include files of any type, emails, messages, meeting notes, memos, meeting recordings, etc. I am requesting these materials dated on or after January 1st, 2026. Attach Files to Your Request If you have documentation that you wish to provide for this request, attach the files here. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Signature * The City of Twin Falls will respond to this request within three (3) business days. Or up to 10 business days upon notification of the requesting party. The City of Twin Falls maintains records for the City of Twin Falls, Idaho. For records including in Twin Falls County please contact Twin Falls County at www.twinfallscounty.org Requested records will be provided electronically. We do not provide your information to mailing lists. It will only be used to fulfill this request. From [email protected] To Date Sunday, May 31, 2026 04:43 PM MT Subject Copy of Form Public Records Requests Attachments City of Twin Falls Public Records Request.pdf Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 1eac451d86ea0a05064bc2424e13495a037bec6741a9728b3edad2bb990fde11 Your records request has been received. You're receiving this email because someone requested that you get a copy of this form. ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From [email protected] To Date Thursday, June 18, 2026 03:16 PM MT Subject Your City of Twin Falls Public Records Request Attachments none Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 5f2530425c086b3fd57c0dfe4de29af4f78f34c7c2670d1874ec48861453e242 Deputy City Clerk Rachael Long has been trying to reach you about your request from May 31st. That request is going to take additional time to prepare and will require payment before we start working on it. She has tried to email and call you about that payment. Please contact Rachael Long at [email protected] or at 208-735-7287 to arrange payment so that we can complete the May 31st request. Thank you. Sincerely, City of Twin Falls ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. CITY OF TWIN FALLS P.O. Box 1907 Twin Falls, Idaho 83303 Telephone: (208) 735-7374 Facsimile: (208) 735-3147 E-mail: [email protected] BRUCE CASTLETON – CITY ATTORNEY LINDA WELLS – DEPUTY CITY PROSECUTOR NICOLE SWAFFORD—DEPUTY CITY PROSECUTOR RACHAEL HUNSAKER – LEGAL ASST. June 10, 2026 Update to the Public Records Request – #3946, Good Afternoon: We have accessed the information pertaining to Market Analysis. It is determined that it will take additional time outside of the allowed 2 hours to review and redact all of the footage before it is released. Your request will require roughly 5 hours to respond to. Idaho Code §74-102(10) allows the City to charge a fee for the compilation of public records requests when: (i) The request is for more than one hundred (100) pages of paper records; or (ii) The request includes records from which nonpublic information must be deleted; or (iii) The actual labor associated with responding to requests for public records in compliance with the provisions of this chapter exceeds two (2) person hours. Further, Idaho Code 74-102(11) states, A requester may not file multiple requests for public records solely to avoid payment of fees. When a public agency or independent public body corporate and politic reasonably believes that Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. one (1) or more requesters is segregating a request into a series of requests to avoid payment of fees authorized pursuant to this section, the public agency or independent public body corporate and politic may aggregate such requests and charge the appropriate fees. The public agency or independent public body corporate and politic may consider the time period in which the requests have been made in its determination to aggregate the related requests. A public agency or independent public body corporate and politic shall not aggregate multiple requests on unrelated subjects from one (1) requester. For purposes of this response, we have estimated the following time and costs necessary to adequately review, redact, and respond to your request: Person Rate Hours Total Legal Review $ 45.07 (2 hours of review) 5.0 (2.0 ) $ 225.35 ($ 90.14) $135.21Total Before the City of Twin Falls can undertake this work and incur these costs, you will need to provide the City of Twin Falls with payment of $135.21 (See Idaho Code § 74-102(10) and (12)). Once the City of Twin Falls receives this advanced payment from you it will begin the process of printing and/or reviewing the documents and will notify you when they are available for delivery to you. If the actual amount of work and copy charges is greater than the advanced payment above, you will be asked to make any necessary additional payment at the time the documents are delivered to you. If the advanced payment is greater than the actual amount of work and copy charges, the difference will be refunded to you at the time of document delivery or shortly thereafter. An attorney for the City of Twin Falls has reviewed your request and this response. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED Sincerely, /s/ Bruce Castleton Bruce Castleton City Attorney City of Twin Falls From Rachael Long <[email protected]> To Date Monday, June 22, 2026 02:48 PM MT Subject Public Records Request Attachments Redaction For #3946.pdf Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 e0dbef1033b4702a51e531deca654e9fd26b9bfa134dd5bdb4b4869d8414f15b Hello, I am reaching out to you about the public records request you made with the City of Twin Falls. We have located the information you have requested, and it has been determined that it will take longer than the 2 hours they are allowed. Attached is the cost for them to move forward with this request. Please let me know if you would like to move forward with payment and I will have finance get the invoice created for this and sent over to you. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 “Records with Integrity” Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. CITY OF TWIN FALLS P.O. Box 1907 Twin Falls, Idaho 83303 Telephone: (208) 735-7374 Facsimile: (208) 735-3147 E-mail: [email protected] BRUCE CASTLETON – CITY ATTORNEY LINDA WELLS – DEPUTY CITY PROSECUTOR NICOLE SWAFFORD—DEPUTY CITY PROSECUTOR RACHAEL HUNSAKER – LEGAL ASST. June 10, 2026 Update to the Public Records Request – #3946, Good Afternoon: We have accessed the information pertaining to Market Analysis. It is determined that it will take additional time outside of the allowed 2 hours to review and redact all of the footage before it is released. Your request will require roughly 5 hours to respond to. Idaho Code §74-102(10) allows the City to charge a fee for the compilation of public records requests when: (i) The request is for more than one hundred (100) pages of paper records; or (ii) The request includes records from which nonpublic information must be deleted; or (iii) The actual labor associated with responding to requests for public records in compliance with the provisions of this chapter exceeds two (2) person hours. Further, Idaho Code 74-102(11) states, A requester may not file multiple requests for public records solely to avoid payment of fees. When a public agency or independent public body corporate and politic reasonably believes that Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. one (1) or more requesters is segregating a request into a series of requests to avoid payment of fees authorized pursuant to this section, the public agency or independent public body corporate and politic may aggregate such requests and charge the appropriate fees. The public agency or independent public body corporate and politic may consider the time period in which the requests have been made in its determination to aggregate the related requests. A public agency or independent public body corporate and politic shall not aggregate multiple requests on unrelated subjects from one (1) requester. For purposes of this response, we have estimated the following time and costs necessary to adequately review, redact, and respond to your request: Person Rate Hours Total Legal Review $ 45.07 (2 hours of review) 5.0 (2.0 ) $ 225.35 ($ 90.14) $135.21Total Before the City of Twin Falls can undertake this work and incur these costs, you will need to provide the City of Twin Falls with payment of $135.21 (See Idaho Code § 74-102(10) and (12)). Once the City of Twin Falls receives this advanced payment from you it will begin the process of printing and/or reviewing the documents and will notify you when they are available for delivery to you. If the actual amount of work and copy charges is greater than the advanced payment above, you will be asked to make any necessary additional payment at the time the documents are delivered to you. If the advanced payment is greater than the actual amount of work and copy charges, the difference will be refunded to you at the time of document delivery or shortly thereafter. An attorney for the City of Twin Falls has reviewed your request and this response. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED Sincerely, /s/ Bruce Castleton Bruce Castleton City Attorney City of Twin Falls From Rachael Long <[email protected]> To Date Wednesday, June 24, 2026 11:23 AM MT Subject FW: Public Records Request Attachments Redaction For #3946.pdf Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 81038fd88c457d300e983b1f3099544a7d3ee784c1fa7db6f34ad189274ab93f Following Up From: Rachael Long Sent: Monday, June 22, 2026 2:48 PM To: Subject: Public Records Request Hello, I am reaching out to you about the public records request you made with the City of Twin Falls. We have located the information you have requested, and it has been determined that it will take longer than the 2 hours they are allowed. Attached is the cost for them to move forward with this request. Please let me know if you would like to move forward with payment and I will have finance get the invoice created for this and sent over to you. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 “Records with Integrity” Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From No Reply <[email protected]> To Date Wednesday, July 01, 2026 09:01 AM MT Subject Results of your Public Records Request #3946 Attachments none Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 3558d6c52c0b4c49fd449befdbc96a966d5048954a420a04983a3e07c739da97 Fulfilled Request Per your records request, filed on 05/31/2026 Attached please find the records held by the City of Twin Falls in response to your request. This link is expires in 30 days. During that time you may use this link to review and/or download a copy of the data. https://lfws.tfid.org/PublicDelivery/Browse.aspx?dbid=0&startid=25144 This request is now concluded. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED ⚠ This message is sent from an account that is NOT MONITORED. Do not reply to this message — it will not be read. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From To Rachael Long <[email protected]> Date Friday, July 10, 2026 10:16 PM MT Subject Re: Public Records Request Attachments image001.png Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 e566f2a694bd23ebcea9a9bb2d0055054c0e06ad58876b2e42eff7955e10db48 Subject: Request for Clarification Regarding Public Records Response #3946 Ms. Long, Thank you for completing the response to my public records request. After reviewing the materials provided, I have several concerns that I need clarified. My request was for “all materials containing the keyword ‘Market Analysis’ possessed/received/sent by Travis Rothweiler, Gretchen Scott, Mitch Humble, Kristen Kohntopp, and/or Breanna Howard.” The response included fewer than ten documents, yet the documents provided clearly reference a market analysis that was completed, shared internally, and discussed in meetings. For example, the records include: A Microsoft Teams meeting titled “City of Twin Falls – Market Analysis Results” Internal Microsoft 365 sharing notifications for “Market Analysis Results” An invoice from HUB International, the vendor who performed the analysis These items indicate that additional responsive materials exist, but they were not included in the response. I acknowledge that the City sent a written notice invoking the additional 10 business days permitted under Idaho Code § 74‐103(1). However, the final response was issued on July 1, 2026, which is well beyond the maximum 13 business days allowed by statute, even with the extension. Additionally, when any portion of a record is withheld or redacted, Idaho Code § 74‐103(4) requires the agency to provide: A statement that access is denied in whole or in part, The specific statutory authority for each withheld or redacted portion, The name and title of the person responsible for the decision, and Notice of the right to appeal. Only the appeal notice was included. Without the required statutory citations or identification of the responsible official, I cannot determine what was withheld or why. Idaho Code § 74‐112 also requires agencies to segregate exempt and non‐exempt information and release all non‐exempt portions. The limited number of documents provided does not appear to reflect the full set of responsive materials. To clarify the response, please provide: 1. Whether additional responsive documents exist that were not included. 2. Whether any materials were withheld or redacted, and if so, the specific statutory exemptions applied to each. 3. The name and title of the individual who authorized any withholding. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. 4. Whether the market analysis or compensation study was categorized under a different name in the City’s financial system. Additionally, for my records, please confirm whether the City Attorney or other legal counsel reviewed or approved any decisions to withhold or redact materials responsive to this request. If legal counsel was not involved, please identify the individual who made the determination and the basis for their authority to do so. Thank you for your attention. I look forward to your clarification. Sincerely, On Mon, Jun 22, 2026 at 8:48 PM Rachael Long <[email protected]> wrote: Hello, I am reaching out to you about the public records request you made with the City of Twin Falls. We have located the information you have requested, and it has been determined that it will take longer than the 2 hours they are allowed. Attached is the cost for them to move forward with this request. Please let me know if you would like to move forward with payment and I will have finance get the invoice created for this and sent over to you. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 “Records with Integrity” Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. CITY OF TWIN FALLS P.O. Box 1907 Twin Falls, Idaho 83303 Telephone: (208) 735-7374 Facsimile: (208) 735-3147 E-mail: [email protected] BRUCE CASTLETON – CITY ATTORNEY LINDA WELLS – DEPUTY CITY PROSECUTOR NICOLE SWAFFORD—DEPUTY CITY PROSECUTOR RACHAEL HUNSAKER – LEGAL ASST. June 10, 2026 Update to the Public Records Request – #3946, Good Afternoon: We have accessed the information pertaining to Market Analysis. It is determined that it will take additional time outside of the allowed 2 hours to review and redact all of the footage before it is released. Your request will require roughly 5 hours to respond to. Idaho Code §74-102(10) allows the City to charge a fee for the compilation of public records requests when: (i) The request is for more than one hundred (100) pages of paper records; or (ii) The request includes records from which nonpublic information must be deleted; or (iii) The actual labor associated with responding to requests for public records in compliance with the provisions of this chapter exceeds two (2) person hours. Further, Idaho Code 74-102(11) states, A requester may not file multiple requests for public records solely to avoid payment of fees. When a public agency or independent public body corporate and politic reasonably believes that Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. one (1) or more requesters is segregating a request into a series of requests to avoid payment of fees authorized pursuant to this section, the public agency or independent public body corporate and politic may aggregate such requests and charge the appropriate fees. The public agency or independent public body corporate and politic may consider the time period in which the requests have been made in its determination to aggregate the related requests. A public agency or independent public body corporate and politic shall not aggregate multiple requests on unrelated subjects from one (1) requester. For purposes of this response, we have estimated the following time and costs necessary to adequately review, redact, and respond to your request: Person Rate Hours Total Legal Review $ 45.07 (2 hours of review) 5.0 (2.0 ) $ 225.35 ($ 90.14) $135.21Total Before the City of Twin Falls can undertake this work and incur these costs, you will need to provide the City of Twin Falls with payment of $135.21 (See Idaho Code § 74-102(10) and (12)). Once the City of Twin Falls receives this advanced payment from you it will begin the process of printing and/or reviewing the documents and will notify you when they are available for delivery to you. If the actual amount of work and copy charges is greater than the advanced payment above, you will be asked to make any necessary additional payment at the time the documents are delivered to you. If the advanced payment is greater than the actual amount of work and copy charges, the difference will be refunded to you at the time of document delivery or shortly thereafter. An attorney for the City of Twin Falls has reviewed your request and this response. NOTICE: PURSUANT TO IDAHO CODE § 74-115 YOU HAVE 180 DAYS TO APPEAL THIS DECISION BY FILING A PETITION IN STATE DISTRICT COURT IN THE COUNTY WHERE ALL OR PART OF THE RECORDS ARE LOCATED Sincerely, /s/ Bruce Castleton Bruce Castleton City Attorney City of Twin Falls From Rachael Long <[email protected]> To Date Monday, July 13, 2026 09:19 AM MT Subject RE: Public Records Request Attachments Redaction For #3946.pdf Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 5724ac62fa369e0df1fa9c63cb474d0214f5a8e75681ff11fd8ef51786cead9b Good Morning, In response to your email, over the course of several days I sent 6 emails total to the email address that you had on the form that their would be an additional fee to pay based off of what our City attorneys advised me, that their time would go over the 2 hour mark to review. There for the request went over the 10 days due to no response from your end that you would pay for the additional time over the 2hours. Attached is a copy of that request that was sent. With no communication response our City attorney reviewed the information again. After further review from out City attorneys they gave the request to Human Resources due to Proprietary information. (Below is one of Attorneys responses) (As I was reviewing the documents, I came across this statement from HUB: "This document and any attached materials are the sole property of HUB International and are not to be used by you other than to evaluate HUB International's service, and are not to be disseminated, distributed or otherwise conveyed throughout your organization to employees without a need for this information or to any third parties without the express written permission of HUB International." In sum, proprietary information is anything that is "privately owned, controlled, or exclusively made by a specific individual or company." I reached out to Bruce, and he agreed that proprietary information is excluded from the public records act. The problem that he and I came across is that we didn't know enough about the project to differentiate between what was proprietary information created by HUB and what was data that Twin Falls provided. There are numerous emails, reports, and Excel spreadsheets. Anything created or owned by HUB while they were being paid for the project would likely be considered proprietary) Once the information was given to Human Resources they worked with our agent from HUB and went through all the emails and information they had, what they sent to you was all that was allowed to be sent based on everything else was Proprietary information. Below is Human resources response: (The search returned 117 entries. Of those entries 109 are statutorily excluded from release by Idaho Code Section 74-107(1). The remaining entries are available for your review.) Hope this helps clear up any confusion. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. “Organized today. Prepared tomorrow. Making a Difference Everyday” From: Sent: Friday, July 10, 2026 10:17 PM To: Rachael Long <[email protected]> Subject: Re: Public Records Request ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Subject: Request for Clarification Regarding Public Records Response #3946 Ms. Long, Thank you for completing the response to my public records request. After reviewing the materials provided, I have several concerns that I need clarified. My request was for “all materials containing the keyword ‘Market Analysis’ possessed/received/sent by Travis Rothweiler, Gretchen Scott, Mitch Humble, Kristen Kohntopp, and/or Breanna Howard.” The response included fewer than ten documents, yet the documents provided clearly reference a market analysis that was completed, shared internally, and discussed in meetings. For example, the records include: A Microsoft Teams meeting titled “City of Twin Falls – Market Analysis Results” Internal Microsoft 365 sharing notifications for “Market Analysis Results” An invoice from HUB International, the vendor who performed the analysis These items indicate that additional responsive materials exist, but they were not included in the response. I acknowledge that the City sent a written notice invoking the additional 10 business days permitted under Idaho Code § 74‐103(1). However, the final response was issued on July 1, 2026, which is well beyond the maximum 13 business days allowed by statute, even with the extension. Additionally, when any portion of a record is withheld or redacted, Idaho Code § 74‐103(4) requires the agency to provide: A statement that access is denied in whole or in part, Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. The specific statutory authority for each withheld or redacted portion, The name and title of the person responsible for the decision, and Notice of the right to appeal. Only the appeal notice was included. Without the required statutory citations or identification of the responsible official, I cannot determine what was withheld or why. Idaho Code § 74‐112 also requires agencies to segregate exempt and non‐exempt information and release all non‐exempt portions. The limited number of documents provided does not appear to reflect the full set of responsive materials. To clarify the response, please provide: 1. Whether additional responsive documents exist that were not included. 2. Whether any materials were withheld or redacted, and if so, the specific statutory exemptions applied to each. 3. The name and title of the individual who authorized any withholding. 4. Whether the market analysis or compensation study was categorized under a different name in the City’s financial system. Additionally, for my records, please confirm whether the City Attorney or other legal counsel reviewed or approved any decisions to withhold or redact materials responsive to this request. If legal counsel was not involved, please identify the individual who made the determination and the basis for their authority to do so. Thank you for your attention. I look forward to your clarification. Sincerely, On Mon, Jun 22, 2026 at 8:48 PM Rachael Long <[email protected]> wrote: Hello, I am reaching out to you about the public records request you made with the City of Twin Falls. We have located the information you have requested, and it has been determined that it will take longer than the 2 hours they are allowed. Attached is the cost for them to move forward with this request. Please let me know if you would like to move forward with payment and I will have finance get the invoice created for this and sent over to you. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 “Records with Integrity” Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From To Rachael Long <[email protected]> Date Thursday, September 03, 2026 10:54 PM MT Subject Re: Public Records Request Attachments image001.png Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 c5b88693ce49367f54001f9997a79d07a358a6575c3c77cc80939a9b51f0450e Ms. Long, After reviewing the response and researching the public records request laws of Idaho, I believe that the response is missing content and context. Based on the information that was provided, it appears that there was more and that it was removed. I am entitled to know who removed/redacted material and why. A blanket denial of so much potential material is unacceptable. Please produce a listing of what was removed and why it was removed. I'm sure redactions could have been made that would have sufficed to honor what needed to be from HUB International. Also, that shouldn't necessarily apply to the communication amongst the staff about the market analysis, the decisions made and the internal workings of how public funds are determined to be spent, both on the analysis itself and the employees. Please also include the name of the person in HR responsible for the redaction/removal of all of this material. I argue that emails and discussions about the material, not disclosing the sensitive and protected data itself is not included in HUB's proprietary information. That is after all, information that HUB doesn't even know about or possess. For example, if specific dollar amounts from HUB communications were redacted, then that would be understandable, allowing more of a picture of what public funds were spent and how decisions were made and by whom. The point of the exclusions by HUB is surely to protect its business. Redactions can be made to protect that information from being provided to the public for free while still allowing the public to understand how the decisions are made and what is being done to ensure the City is being fair, equitable and competitive to its current and prospective employees, while being fiscally responsible at the same time. Please make the effort to redact when necessary and only remove entire documents when appropriate. On Friday, July 10th, 2026 at 22:16, wrote: Subject: Request for Clarification Regarding Public Records Response #3946 Ms. Long, Thank you for completing the response to my public records request. After reviewing the materials provided, I have several concerns that I need clarified. My request was for “all materials containing the keyword ‘Market Analysis’ possessed/received/sent by Travis Rothweiler, Gretchen Scott, Mitch Humble, Kristen Kohntopp, and/or Breanna Howard.” The response included fewer than ten documents, yet the documents provided clearly reference a market analysis that was completed, shared internally, and discussed in meetings. For example, the records include: A Microsoft Teams meeting titled “City of Twin Falls – Market Analysis Results” Internal Microsoft 365 sharing notifications for “Market Analysis Results” An invoice from HUB International, the vendor who performed the analysis These items indicate that additional responsive materials exist, but they were not included in the response. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. I acknowledge that the City sent a written notice invoking the additional 10 business days permitted under Idaho Code § 74‐103(1). However, the final response was issued on July 1, 2026, which is well beyond the maximum 13 business days allowed by statute, even with the extension. Additionally, when any portion of a record is withheld or redacted, Idaho Code § 74‐103(4) requires the agency to provide: A statement that access is denied in whole or in part, The specific statutory authority for each withheld or redacted portion, The name and title of the person responsible for the decision, and Notice of the right to appeal. Only the appeal notice was included. Without the required statutory citations or identification of the responsible official, I cannot determine what was withheld or why. Idaho Code § 74‐112 also requires agencies to segregate exempt and non‐exempt information and release all non‐exempt portions. The limited number of documents provided does not appear to reflect the full set of responsive materials. To clarify the response, please provide: 1. Whether additional responsive documents exist that were not included. 2. Whether any materials were withheld or redacted, and if so, the specific statutory exemptions applied to each. 3. The name and title of the individual who authorized any withholding. 4. Whether the market analysis or compensation study was categorized under a different name in the City’s financial system. Additionally, for my records, please confirm whether the City Attorney or other legal counsel reviewed or approved any decisions to withhold or redact materials responsive to this request. If legal counsel was not involved, please identify the individual who made the determination and the basis for their authority to do so. Thank you for your attention. I look forward to your clarification. Sincerely, On Mon, Jun 22, 2026 at 8:48 PM Rachael Long <[email protected]> wrote: Hello, I am reaching out to you about the public records request you made with the City of Twin Falls. We have located the information you have requested, and it has been determined that it will take longer than the 2 hours they are allowed. Attached is the cost for them to move forward with this request. Please let me know if you would like to move forward with payment and I will have finance get the invoice created for this and sent over to you. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 “Records with Integrity” From Rachael Long <[email protected]> To Date Friday, September 04, 2026 04:02 PM MT Subject RE: Public Records Request Attachments none Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 558c1df3dec6f205951696b52d133d9ffb76fbc226a0d20263ea10d80a3c9bae Good Afternoon, Your email has been sent forward to the City Attorney and I will let you know what he responds with. Have a great day Rachael From: Sent: Thursday, September 3, 2026 10:54 PM To: Rachael Long <[email protected]> Subject: Re: Public Records Request ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Ms. Long, After reviewing the response and researching the public records request laws of Idaho, I believe that the response is missing content and context. Based on the information that was provided, it appears that there was more and that it was removed. I am entitled to know who removed/redacted material and why. A blanket denial of so much potential material is unacceptable. Please produce a listing of what was removed and why it was removed. I'm sure redactions could have been made that would have sufficed to honor what needed to be from HUB International. Also, that shouldn't necessarily apply to the communication amongst the staff about the market analysis, the decisions made and the internal workings of how public funds are determined to be spent, both on the analysis itself and the employees. Please also include the name of the person in HR responsible for the redaction/removal of all of this material. I argue that emails and discussions about the material, not disclosing the sensitive and protected data itself is not included in HUB's proprietary information. That is after all, information that HUB doesn't even know about or possess. For example, if specific dollar amounts from HUB communications were redacted, then that would be understandable, allowing more of a picture of what public funds were spent and how decisions were made and by whom. The point of the exclusions by HUB is surely to protect its business. Redactions can be made to protect that information from being provided to the public for free while still allowing the public to understand how the decisions are made and what is being done to ensure the City is being fair, equitable and competitive to its current and prospective employees, while being fiscally responsible at the same time. Please make the effort to redact when necessary and only remove entire documents when appropriate. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. On Friday, July 10th, 2026 at 22:16, wrote: Subject: Request for Clarification Regarding Public Records Response #3946 Ms. Long, Thank you for completing the response to my public records request. After reviewing the materials provided, I have several concerns that I need clarified. My request was for “all materials containing the keyword ‘Market Analysis’ possessed/received/sent by Travis Rothweiler, Gretchen Scott, Mitch Humble, Kristen Kohntopp, and/or Breanna Howard.” The response included fewer than ten documents, yet the documents provided clearly reference a market analysis that was completed, shared internally, and discussed in meetings. For example, the records include: A Microsoft Teams meeting titled “City of Twin Falls – Market Analysis Results” Internal Microsoft 365 sharing notifications for “Market Analysis Results” An invoice from HUB International, the vendor who performed the analysis These items indicate that additional responsive materials exist, but they were not included in the response. I acknowledge that the City sent a written notice invoking the additional 10 business days permitted under Idaho Code § 74‐103(1). However, the final response was issued on July 1, 2026, which is well beyond the maximum 13 business days allowed by statute, even with the extension. Additionally, when any portion of a record is withheld or redacted, Idaho Code § 74‐103(4) requires the agency to provide: A statement that access is denied in whole or in part, The specific statutory authority for each withheld or redacted portion, The name and title of the person responsible for the decision, and Notice of the right to appeal. Only the appeal notice was included. Without the required statutory citations or identification of the responsible official, I cannot determine what was withheld or why. Idaho Code § 74‐112 also requires agencies to segregate exempt and non‐exempt information and release all non‐exempt portions. The limited number of documents provided does not appear to reflect the full set of responsive materials. To clarify the response, please provide: 1. Whether additional responsive documents exist that were not included. 2. Whether any materials were withheld or redacted, and if so, the specific statutory exemptions applied to each. 3. The name and title of the individual who authorized any withholding. 4. Whether the market analysis or compensation study was categorized under a different name in the City’s financial system. Additionally, for my records, please confirm whether the City Attorney or other legal counsel reviewed or approved any decisions to withhold or redact materials responsive to this request. If legal counsel was not involved, please identify the individual who made the determination and the basis for their authority to do so. Thank you for your attention. I look forward to your clarification. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Sincerely, On Mon, Jun 22, 2026 at 8:48 PM Rachael Long <[email protected]> wrote: Hello, I am reaching out to you about the public records request you made with the City of Twin Falls. We have located the information you have requested, and it has been determined that it will take longer than the 2 hours they are allowed. Attached is the cost for them to move forward with this request. Please let me know if you would like to move forward with payment and I will have finance get the invoice created for this and sent over to you. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 “Records with Integrity” Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From Rachael Long <[email protected]> To Date Wednesday, September 16, 2026 11:03 AM MT Subject RE: Public Records Request Attachments none Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 2554f1bf1bfaefd5116d5e5991dd64ba8110113d959d29a1b0c022a10e10b971 Good Morning, Sorry for the delay in response I was out sick. I have heard back from our City attorney and he wanted me to let you know that for your public records request the exemption is below on why things were exempt. Idaho Code § 74-107(1): Trade Secrets Exemption The statute exempts trade secrets from public disclosure, including those found in agency RFPs and related procurement documents. A trade secret is defined as proprietary information (such as formulas, techniques, or research) that has independent economic value from not being generally known and is subject to reasonable efforts to maintain its secrecy From: Sent: Thursday, September 3, 2026 10:54 PM To: Rachael Long <[email protected]> Subject: Re: Public Records Request ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Ms. Long, After reviewing the response and researching the public records request laws of Idaho, I believe that the response is missing content and context. Based on the information that was provided, it appears that there was more and that it was removed. I am entitled to know who removed/redacted material and why. A blanket denial of so much potential material is unacceptable. Please produce a listing of what was removed and why it was removed. I'm sure redactions could have been made that would have sufficed to honor what needed to be from HUB International. Also, that shouldn't necessarily apply to the communication amongst the staff about the market analysis, the decisions made and the internal workings of how public funds are determined to be spent, both on the analysis itself and the employees. Please also include the name of the person in HR responsible for the redaction/removal of all of this material. I argue that emails and discussions about the material, not disclosing the sensitive and protected data itself is not included in HUB's proprietary information. That is after all, information that HUB doesn't even know about or possess. For example, if specific dollar amounts from HUB communications were redacted, then that would be understandable, allowing more of a picture of what public funds were spent and how decisions were made and by Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. whom. The point of the exclusions by HUB is surely to protect its business. Redactions can be made to protect that information from being provided to the public for free while still allowing the public to understand how the decisions are made and what is being done to ensure the City is being fair, equitable and competitive to its current and prospective employees, while being fiscally responsible at the same time. Please make the effort to redact when necessary and only remove entire documents when appropriate. On Friday, July 10th, 2026 at 22:16, wrote: Subject: Request for Clarification Regarding Public Records Response #3946 Ms. Long, Thank you for completing the response to my public records request. After reviewing the materials provided, I have several concerns that I need clarified. My request was for “all materials containing the keyword ‘Market Analysis’ possessed/received/sent by Travis Rothweiler, Gretchen Scott, Mitch Humble, Kristen Kohntopp, and/or Breanna Howard.” The response included fewer than ten documents, yet the documents provided clearly reference a market analysis that was completed, shared internally, and discussed in meetings. For example, the records include: A Microsoft Teams meeting titled “City of Twin Falls – Market Analysis Results” Internal Microsoft 365 sharing notifications for “Market Analysis Results” An invoice from HUB International, the vendor who performed the analysis These items indicate that additional responsive materials exist, but they were not included in the response. I acknowledge that the City sent a written notice invoking the additional 10 business days permitted under Idaho Code § 74‐103(1). However, the final response was issued on July 1, 2026, which is well beyond the maximum 13 business days allowed by statute, even with the extension. Additionally, when any portion of a record is withheld or redacted, Idaho Code § 74‐103(4) requires the agency to provide: A statement that access is denied in whole or in part, The specific statutory authority for each withheld or redacted portion, The name and title of the person responsible for the decision, and Notice of the right to appeal. Only the appeal notice was included. Without the required statutory citations or identification of the responsible official, I cannot determine what was withheld or why. Idaho Code § 74‐112 also requires agencies to segregate exempt and non‐exempt information and release all non‐exempt portions. The limited number of documents provided does not appear to reflect the full set of responsive materials. To clarify the response, please provide: 1. Whether additional responsive documents exist that were not included. 2. Whether any materials were withheld or redacted, and if so, the specific statutory exemptions applied to each. 3. The name and title of the individual who authorized any withholding. Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. 4. Whether the market analysis or compensation study was categorized under a different name in the City’s financial system. Additionally, for my records, please confirm whether the City Attorney or other legal counsel reviewed or approved any decisions to withhold or redact materials responsive to this request. If legal counsel was not involved, please identify the individual who made the determination and the basis for their authority to do so. Thank you for your attention. I look forward to your clarification. Sincerely, On Mon, Jun 22, 2026 at 8:48 PM Rachael Long <[email protected]> wrote: Hello, I am reaching out to you about the public records request you made with the City of Twin Falls. We have located the information you have requested, and it has been determined that it will take longer than the 2 hours they are allowed. Attached is the cost for them to move forward with this request. Please let me know if you would like to move forward with payment and I will have finance get the invoice created for this and sent over to you. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 “Records with Integrity” Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. From To Rachael Long <[email protected]> Date Friday, September 18, 2026 09:31 PM MT Subject RE: Public Records Request Attachments none Filed under #3946 Source file SHA-256 38f4b7b252ad55fff195442af429aa4f1262db4acade45015b44d88c291c1b98 This is still not enough of a response. How many documents were removed? Were they all removed under the same statute? Who made the decision/performed the removal? Why was everything removed rather than redact the parts, numbers, etc. that fall within that statute? I have still not been provided with enough information to consider this matter concluded. Consider this an official appeal if that weren't already apparent enough from the previous emails. The materials left allude to several meetings and emails and completed reports. It would be quite possible to redact things like specific numbers. In this case, that would constitute the trade secrets. The city's decision-making process is not part of the trade secrets exemption and effort can and should be made to be transparent in accordance with Idaho law regarding requests for public information. On Wednesday, September 16th, 2026 at 11:03, Rachael Long <[email protected]> wrote: Good Morning, Sorry for the delay in response I was out sick. I have heard back from our City attorney and he wanted me to let you know that for your public records request the exemption is below on why things were exempt. Idaho Code § 74-107(1): Trade Secrets Exemption The statute exempts trade secrets from public disclosure, including those found in agency RFPs and related procurement documents. A trade secret is defined as proprietary information (such as formulas, techniques, or research) that has independent economic value from not being generally known and is subject to reasonable efforts to maintain its secrecy From: Sent: Thursday, September 3, 2026 10:54 PM To: Rachael Long <[email protected]> Subject: Re: Public Records Request Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. ⚠ Caution: EXTERNAL SENDER – Be cautious opening any links or attachments from unknown or unexpected senders. If the sender appears to be from tfid.org, do not trust the email. Ms. Long, After reviewing the response and researching the public records request laws of Idaho, I believe that the response is missing content and context. Based on the information that was provided, it appears that there was more and that it was removed. I am entitled to know who removed/redacted material and why. A blanket denial of so much potential material is unacceptable. Please produce a listing of what was removed and why it was removed. I'm sure redactions could have been made that would have sufficed to honor what needed to be from HUB International. Also, that shouldn't necessarily apply to the communication amongst the staff about the market analysis, the decisions made and the internal workings of how public funds are determined to be spent, both on the analysis itself and the employees. Please also include the name of the person in HR responsible for the redaction/removal of all of this material. I argue that emails and discussions about the material, not disclosing the sensitive and protected data itself is not included in HUB's proprietary information. That is after all, information that HUB doesn't even know about or possess. For example, if specific dollar amounts from HUB communications were redacted, then that would be understandable, allowing more of a picture of what public funds were spent and how decisions were made and by whom. The point of the exclusions by HUB is surely to protect its business. Redactions can be made to protect that information from being provided to the public for free while still allowing the public to understand how the decisions are made and what is being done to ensure the City is being fair, equitable and competitive to its current and prospective employees, while being fiscally responsible at the same time. Please make the effort to redact when necessary and only remove entire documents when appropriate. On Friday, July 10th, 2026 at 22:16, wrote: Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive. Subject: Request for Clarification Regarding Public Records Response #3946 Ms. Long, Thank you for completing the response to my public records request. After reviewing the materials provided, I have several concerns that I need clarified. My request was for “all materials containing the keyword ‘Market Analysis’ possessed/received/sent by Travis Rothweiler, Gretchen Scott, Mitch Humble, Kristen Kohntopp, and/or Breanna Howard.” The response included fewer than ten documents, yet the documents provided clearly reference a market analysis that was completed, shared internally, and discussed in meetings. For example, the records include: A Microsoft Teams meeting titled “City of Twin Falls – Market Analysis Results” Internal Microsoft 365 sharing notifications for “Market Analysis Results” An invoice from HUB International, the vendor who performed the analysis These items indicate that additional responsive materials exist, but they were not included in the response. I acknowledge that the City sent a written notice invoking the additional 10 business days permitted under Idaho Code § 74‐103(1). However, the final response was issued on July 1, 2026, which is well beyond the maximum 13 business days allowed by statute, even with the extension. Additionally, when any portion of a record is withheld or redacted, Idaho Code § 74‐103(4) requires the agency to provide: A statement that access is denied in whole or in part, The specific statutory authority for each withheld or redacted portion, The name and title of the person responsible for the decision, and Notice of the right to appeal. Only the appeal notice was included. Without the required statutory citations or identification of the responsible official, I cannot determine what was withheld or why. Idaho Code § 74‐112 also requires agencies to segregate exempt and non‐exempt information and release all non‐exempt portions. The limited number of documents provided does not appear to reflect the full set of responsive materials. To clarify the response, please provide: 1. Whether additional responsive documents exist that were not included. 2. Whether any materials were withheld or redacted, and if so, the specific statutory exemptions applied to each. 3. The name and title of the individual who authorized any withholding. 4. Whether the market analysis or compensation study was categorized under a different name in the City’s financial system. Additionally, for my records, please confirm whether the City Attorney or other legal counsel reviewed or approved any decisions to withhold or redact materials responsive to this request. If legal counsel was not involved, please identify the individual who made the determination and the basis for their authority to do so. Thank you for your attention. I look forward to your clarification. Sincerely, On Mon, Jun 22, 2026 at 8:48 PM Rachael Long <[email protected]> wrote: Hello, I am reaching out to you about the public records request you made with the City of Twin Falls. We have located the information you have requested, and it has been determined that it will take longer than the 2 hours they are allowed. Attached is the cost for them to move forward with this request. Please let me know if you would like to move forward with payment and I will have finance get the invoice created for this and sent over to you. Rachael Long Deputy City Clerk City of Twin Falls Twin Falls, ID 83303 “Records with Integrity” Requester names and personal contact details redacted by Oversight Archive.