OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

EX-B09

2022-12-05 minutes - evaluation session, no motion on City Manager pay

City of Twin Falls

View the document here · 4 pages

Record date
2022-12-05
Source
Council minutes
Record type
Governing Body Records
Pages used
all (4)
Supports findings
E-01 Mayor's letter lifted the vacation sell-back cap for the City Manager; no Council vote located
E-05 Pay directions follow "evaluation" executive sessions (2018-2025)

Chain of custody

  1. Obtained. A City Council meeting record, published by the City of Twin Falls on its meeting portal and website.
  2. As received. SHA-256 of the file exactly as the agency released it:
    774b4e9ecfa34840c3f7d4247cc6aca1b28769dba4493a0e819fc40430302777
  3. Changes for posting.
    • Document properties (author, software and similar fields) removed
  4. Posted copy. SHA-256 of the file you download here, checked against our index on every build:
    3a005bb03def9acf880c25832a9d5a8013d09b64832b16403a8b6dcd0eb404dc

The original as received is kept unaltered. Anyone holding the agency's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. How to verify a file · Chain of custody for every record (CSV)

Document text (read by machine for search, and often imperfect for scans and handwriting; the file is the record)
Twin Falls City Council Minutes
Monday, December 5, 2022, 4:30 PM Council Chambers
203 Main Avenue East, Twin Falls, Idaho
**SPECIAL MEETING starting at 4:30pm** TO ADJOURN 
TO EXECUTIVE SESSION:
§ 74-206(1)(b) To consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of, or to hear 
complaints or charges brought against, a public officer, employee, staff member or 
individual agent, or public-school student.
Regular Meeting starting at 5:00PM
1) CALL MEETING TO ORDER/CONFIRMATION OF QUORUM
Present: Mayor Ruth Pierce, Vice Mayor Christopher Reid, Council Members Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown 
(Joined part way through by phone), Spencer Cutler, Nikki Boyd & Alexandra Caval.
Absent:
Staff Present: City Manager Travis Rothweiler, Deputy City Managers Mitch Humble & Gretchen Scott, City 
Attorney Shayne Nope, Police Chief Craig Kingsbury, Airport Manager Bill Carberry, Airport 
Operations Supervisor Matt Barnes, City Planner Lisa Strickland, P&Z Director Jonathan Spendlove, 
Economic Development Director Shawn Barigar, Human Resource Director Ida Clark, Help Desk 
Technician Sonia Salas, Finance Administrative Assistant Amy Luna.
Mayor Pierce called the meeting to order at 5:00 PM. A quorum was present.
MOTION: Council Member Caval moved to adjourn to Executive Session 74206(1)(b) to consider the evaluation, 
dismissal, or disciplining of, or to hear complaints or charges brought against, a public officer, employee, staff 
member or individual agent, or public-school student. Council Member Boyd seconded the motion. The roll call 
vote showed all members present voted in favor of the motion, 5 to 0.
The council reconvened at 5:03 for the regular meeting.
2) PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Mayor Pierce invited all present, who wished, to recite the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
3) PROCLAMATIONS
Mayor Pierce asked everyone to participate in a moment of silence for Dr. Thad Scholes who passed away 
today.
4) CONSENT CALENDAR
MOTION: Council Member Caval moved to approve the Consent Calendar as presented. Council Member Hawkins 
seconded the motion. The roll call vote showed all members present voted in favor of the motion, 6 to 0.
a) Request to approve City Council 2022 November 28, Minutes.
b) Request to approve Accounts Payable for November 16-30, 2022.
c) Request to approve Alcohol License Application for Antojos Eatery & Cafe'
5) ITEMS OF CONSIDERATION
a) Air service presentation and possible action to consider approving a renewal of the minimum revenue guarantee 
contract with SkyWest Airlines for Delta Airline service to Salt Lake City. 
Mayor Pierce invited County Commissioners Don Hall, Brent Reinke, and Jack Johnson, Chairman to join the City 
Council on the dias and the commissioners called their meeting back to order.
Airport Manager Carberry, Volaire Aviation Consultant Mooney & Economic Development Director 
Barigar made an Air Service Presentation asking for possible action to consider approving a renewal of the 
minimum revenue guarantee contract with SkyWest Airlines for Delta Airline service to Salt Lake City.
Discussion ensued on the following:
Vice Mayor Reid: Asked for clarification on the total local cost numbers.

County Chairman Jack Johnson: Asked for clarification on the intention of a 30-seat carrier model by later in 
2024. Has there been discussion at the federal level about helping to keep services in these areas?
Commissioner Don Hall: Asked for clarification on "Pay to Preserve". Asked about using the retired pilots to 
fly the 30-seaters and is this a safety issue?
Council Member Caval: Asked for clarification on the subsidies. Asked what steps have been used to get other 
carriers at Twin Falls? Is there interest?
Economic Development Director Barigar gave a brief comment regarding this request. 
Recommended preservation mode.
Commissioner Don Hall: Asked for clarification on the timeline and when a decision needs to be made.
County Commissioner Reinke: Asked if there was a possibility of going from a 50 to a 76-seater instead of 
from a 50 to a 30-seater.
Airport Manager Carberry: Summarized the presentation and thanked all that spoke.
Public Input Opened: 5.55 pm
Citizen Greg Pike spoke in favor of keeping the Airport running. 
Citizen Dan Olmstead spoke in favor of keeping the Airport going. 
Citizen Andy Hohwieler spoke in favor of this request.
Citizen Ron Yates spoke in favor of this request. Suggested getting ahold of our State Representatives to 
have hearings with the FAA.
Citizen Mark Beams spoke in favor of this request.
Citizen Patricia Migliuri: spoke in favor of acting on this request.
Citizen Zach Gregersen: Spoke about the economic impact of not having a flight leaving Twin Falls.
Citizen Will Costello: Spoke in favor of having the flights in and out of Twin Falls and the number of flights that 
they have used.
Citizen Greyson Stone: Spoke as the Vice Chair of the Twin Falls Chamber of Commerce.
Public Input Closed: 6:10 pm
Further discussion ensued on the following:
Council Member Boyd: Thanked all for speaking and spoke in favor of this request.
Council Member Cutler: Asked for clarification on the motion to move forward.
Vice Mayor Reid: Spoke in favor of this request.
Council Member Caval: Spoke in favor of this request.
Council Member Hawkins: Spoke in favor of this request.
Mayor Pierce: Spoke in favor of this request and the economic standpoint and jobs at the Airport.
Council Member Brown: Spoke in favor of this request.
County Commissioner Hall & Johnson thanked the citizens for their input and moved to table their vote 
on this item.
MOTION: Vice Mayor Reid moved to approve the renewal of the minimum revenue guarantee contract with 
SkyWest Airlines for Delta Airline service to Salt Lake City contingent on approval by the Twin Falls County 
Commissioners. Council Member Caval seconded the motion. The roll call vote showed all members present 
voted in favor of the motion, 7 to 0.
City Manager Rothweiler asked the commissioner when they would have this item on their agenda and if we 
could be notified of the meeting date so that some staff could attend.
6) GENERAL PUBLIC INPUT
7) ADVISORY BOARD REPORT/ANNOUNCEMENTS
Reminder of the Christmas Lighting Parade at 6 pm on Friday, December 9, 2022.
8) PUBLIC HEARINGS
a) Request to amend the Magic Valley Mall ZDA to allow for three multi-tenant signs to be a maximum of 300 sq. 
ft and to include 200 sq. ft. of message center signage as a portion of that on property located at 1485 Pole 
Line Rd E. c/o Brent White on behalf of Woodbury Corporation. (PZ22-0140)
City Planner Strickland requested to amend the Magic Valley Mall ZDA to allow for three multi-tenant signs to 
be a maximum of 300 sq. ft. and to include 200 sq. ft. of message center signage as a portion of that, on property 
located at 1485 Pole Line Rd E. c/o Brent White on behalf of Woodbury Corporation. (PZ22-0140)
The applicant made his presentation.
Public Hearing Opened: 6:51 pm Public Hearing 
Closed: 6:52 pm
Discussion ensued on the following:
Council Member Hawkins: Would this replace the existing sign? Would this block any views that would cause 
a safety issue or obstruct the existing business signage?
Council Member Caval: Asked for clarification on the request.
Council Member Hawkins: Spoke in favor of this request.
Vice Mayor Reid: Spoke in favor of this request.
MOTION: Council Member Boyd moved to approve the request to amend the Magic Valley Mall ZDA to allow for 
three multi-tenant signs to be a maximum of 300 sq. ft. and to include 200 sq. ft. of message center signage as a 
portion of that, on property located at 1485 Pole Line Rd E. c/o Brent White on behalf of Woodbury Corporation. 
(PZ22-0140) Vice Mayor Reid seconded the motion. The roll call vote showed all members present voted in favor 
of the motion, 7 to 0.
b) Request for a rezone of property from C-1 CRO PUD to C-1 CRO on property located at 1671 Canyon Plaza Drive 
c/o Tom Scofield on behalf of North Canyon Medical Center. (PZ22-0155) 
City Planner Strickland requested a rezone of property from C-1 CRO PUD to C-1 CRO on property located at 
1671 Canyon Plaza Drive c/o Tom Scofield on behalf of North Canyon Medical Center. (PZ22-0155)
The applicant made their presentation.
Public Hearing Opened: 7:06 pm
Citizen Tyler Ellison: Spoke against the zoning change and the request.
Public Hearing Closed: 7:09 pm
Discussion ensued on the following:
Council Member Boyd: Is this request something different?
Council Member Cutler: Is the building that is being proposed to cover both lots 9 and 10?
Council Member Cutler: Expressed his concerns about this rezone.
Vice Mayor Reid: Spoke about the initial zoning of this property and the challenge of this request.
Council Member Cutler: Asked for clarification of the subdivision phases. What are the heights currently?
Council Member Brown: Asked about the height component of the request.
Vice Mayor Reid: Asked about the possibility of the property changing hands and going back to the current zone 
should that happen
Council Member Caval: Is this consistent with the comprehensive plan? Would the additional traffic
MOTION: Vice Mayor Reid moved to approve the request for a rezone of property from C-1 CRO PUD to C-1 
CRO on property located at 1671 Canyon Plaza Drive c/o Tom Scofield on behalf of North Canyon Medical 
Center. (PZ22-0155) Council Member Caval seconded the motion. The roll call vote showed all members 
present voted in favor of the motion, 7 to 0.
c) Request to approve the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluations Report (CAPER). 
P&Z Director Spendlove requested to approve the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluations Report 
(CAPER).
Public Hearing Opened: 7:22 pm 
Public Hearing Closed: 7:23 pm
Discussion ensued on the following:
Council Member Boyd: Asked for clarification on the progress.
MOTION: Council Member Cutler moved to approve the request to approve the Consolidated Annual 
Performance and Evaluations Report (CAPER) for 2021. Council Member Caval seconded the motion. The roll 
call vote showed all members present voted in favor of the motion, 7 to 0.
d) Presentation of the CDBG City Park Project.
P&Z Director Spendlove made a presentation about the CDBG City Park Project.
Discussion ensued on the following:
Council Member Boyd: Spoke in favor of this idea. 
Mayor Pierce: Spoke in favor of redoing the bathrooms. 
Vice Mayor Reid: Spoke in favor of this idea.
Deputy City Manager Humble: Added to the information.
9) ADJOURNMENT
a) REQUEST TO ADJOURN TO EXECUTIVE SESSION:
§ 74-206(1)(b) To consider the evaluation, dismissal or disciplining of, or to hear complaints or charges 
brought against, a public officer, employee, staff member or individual agent, or public-school student.
MOTION: Council Member Caval moved to adjourn to Executive Session 74206(1)(b) to consider the 
evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining of, or to hear complaints or charges brought against, a public officer, 
employee, staff member or individual agent, or public- school student. Council Member Hawkins seconded 
the motion. The roll call vote showed all members present voted in favor of the motion, 7 to 0.
Adjourned into Executive Session at 07:36 PM
The regular meeting adjourned at 08:30 PM.
Amy Luna, Administrative Assistant
**If you wish to have a full accounting of this meeting, please listen to the recording that is 
located on our website. ** Tfid.org