City Council meeting
Monday, August 17, 2026
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Moments cited in findings and the timeline
Transcript
0:01:37 Okay, we'll go ahead and call the Twin Falls City Council meeting for August 17th, 2026 to order. I will confirm we have a quorum. We have six members of the City Council in chambers and possibility of having Councilman Stone online.
0:01:55 Still haven't worked through some of that. So we do have a quorum and we'll move on to the Pledge of Allegiance. Any of those that would like to participate, please stand.
0:02:04 the state of America or which is thank you again so tonight we'll move into our consent calendar
0:02:30 what are council's wishes move to approve second have a motion and a second to approve
0:02:36 the consent calendar as written any discussion by the council. Okay Amy roll call vote please.
0:02:42 Ruth Pierce yes Chris Reed yes Greg Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes Sherry Wilmer yes Nathan
0:02:49 Murray, and Grace and Stone.
0:02:54 Okay, we're gonna say that's six to zero,
0:02:56 and we'll move on.
0:02:59 We'll note as we've had done in the last couple of weeks,
0:03:02 if you tonight, if you want to have a desire
0:03:04 to address the council, we're gonna ask that you sign up
0:03:07 in the lobby, fill out the documentation,
0:03:10 and as we get to that point in the City Council meeting,
0:03:12 we'll call you up to address the council.
0:03:15 So I'll start the meeting off tonight with that,
0:03:19 and then remind everybody a couple of times
0:03:23 before we get to that point.
0:03:24 So we'll move into our first item of consideration
0:03:27 and that is a request for Council to approve a contract
0:03:31 with Jacobs Engineering in the amount of 140,000
0:03:34 for the program management in support
0:03:36 of the Rock Creek Watershed Restoration Collaborative
0:03:38 and we have Mandy Thompson.
0:03:41 Good evening, Mayor and Council.
0:03:44 I just have a brief request for you this evening.
0:03:46 So as you recall, a few months ago, March to be exact,
0:03:51 City Council adopted the Rock Creek Watershed
0:03:54 Master Restoration Master Plan
0:03:57 that had been prepared by Jacobs Engineering,
0:03:59 really creating a framework and a path forward
0:04:02 for water restoration projects in Rock Creek.
0:04:06 So tonight I'm bringing you an agreement
0:04:08 with Jacobs in the amount of $140,000.
0:04:11 And really what this is going to do
0:04:13 is provide some program management services
0:04:16 for the collaborative steering committee.
0:04:19 So we have a plan, next step is to put that plan to action.
0:04:23 And because there's so much of the plan
0:04:26 that is outside of the city's jurisdiction,
0:04:29 we're really wanting this to look
0:04:30 as much like a collaborative as possible.
0:04:33 And so it really needs to be that group effort
0:04:36 of the agriculture industry,
0:04:38 those organizations that are interested
0:04:42 in the improvement of the riparian waterway itself
0:04:45 and then also the storm water.
0:04:47 And so Jacobs has presented us with this plan
0:04:50 to move that collaborative steering committee forward
0:04:53 in the amount of $140,000.
0:04:55 This is for a one-year management of that group.
0:04:58 The hope being that in that year,
0:04:59 we can create some structure for this group moving forward
0:05:02 and look for some additional funding
0:05:04 to potentially hire somebody
0:05:06 to kind of steer the ship on a more permanent basis.
0:05:10 So if you have any other questions,
0:05:12 I'd be happy to answer them.
0:05:13 Any questions for Mandy?
0:05:15 I do, these funds are actually going to be reimbursed.
0:05:20 Yes, so, and thank you for pointing that out.
0:05:24 So these funds will be paid for through the funding
0:05:27 that we received with that direct appropriation
0:05:30 with the help of Congressman Mike Simpson.
0:05:32 So the original appropriation was $4 million,
0:05:36 we added a million onto it.
0:05:37 So we had $5 million and we just spent right at $1 million
0:05:41 for the creation of the master plan.
0:05:43 So this 140 will come out of the remaining balance of that as will future projects that
0:05:48 we move forward.
0:05:49 Perfect.
0:05:50 And it's a reimbursement process and it's 100% reimbursement.
0:05:54 Thank you.
0:05:55 Any other questions?
0:05:56 Kay Ruth.
0:05:57 I'm ready to make a motion if we're good.
0:06:00 I move we approve the contract with Jacob Sandin nearing and the amount of $140,000 for
0:06:07 the program management and support of the Rock Creek Watershed Restoration Collaborative.
0:06:12 I have a motion and a second to approve the contract with Jacobs Engineering in the amount
0:06:19 of 140,000 for the program management and support of the Rock Creek Watershed Restoration
0:06:24 Collaborative.
0:06:25 Any comments by the council?
0:06:28 Sherry, I noticed you were up, did you have any, okay, any roll call vote?
0:06:34 Chris Reed.
0:06:35 Yes.
0:06:36 Raycocans.
0:06:37 Yes.
0:06:38 Jason Brown.
0:06:39 Yes.
0:06:40 Sherry Bomer.
0:06:41 Yes.
0:06:42 Thank you.
0:06:44 Thank you.
0:06:45 Thank you, Mary.
0:06:46 Yes.
0:06:47 And Ruth Pierce.
0:06:48 Yes.
0:06:49 Okay.
0:06:50 Motion carries six to zero.
0:06:51 Grayson just did email me and said he was online, but it appears that he's not coming through
0:06:55 on his side.
0:06:58 Thank you, Mandy.
0:06:59 Okay.
0:07:04 We'll move on to the next item on the agenda, which is a request to enter a negotiation was
0:07:13 suburban construction management to provide CMGC services associated with the
0:07:19 part property located at the corner of Elizabeth Boulevard and Hankin's Road
0:07:24 and we have Wendy Davis. I don't know why she turned the light off. Thank you, Mayor
0:07:32 and Council. It's exciting to be here this evening to get a couple more projects
0:07:37 rolling and the fact that we've got several that are about to finish up
0:07:41 which is really exciting. So tonight I have two requests and we'll start with the
0:07:46 suburban construction. This one's for that property that we purchased with
0:07:51 park impact fees at the corner of Hankins and Elizabeth with park impact fees using
0:07:58 the master plan and identifying kind of a deficit over in that area. We created a
0:08:06 service roster for CMGC services. And so we used that approach this time, created a
0:08:14 scope, scored the providers and selected on suburban as the top qualified service provider
0:08:25 for the work on this particular park. And then we did rank them. So as you can see, I've
0:08:30 got, I don't rank down to five. I think we went all the way down to like seven or nine,
0:08:35 but I thought I'd just list the top five.
0:08:37 So with your blessing, we'll move forward
0:08:41 with a negotiations with Suburban
0:08:46 and if we can't reach an agreement with them,
0:08:49 then we would move on to Guho
0:08:53 and keep going until we find something that works.
0:08:56 Sounds good.
0:08:57 Any questions for Wendy?
0:09:01 Okay, what are Council's wishes?
0:09:03 Craig Hawkins, I'd like to make the motion
0:09:06 ready. Perfect. I move to enter in negotiations with suburban construction
0:09:11 management to provide CM slash GC services associated with the park
0:09:17 property located at the corner of Elizabeth Boulevard and Hankins Road.
0:09:21 Sherry Volmer. I'll second. Candy for first and a second on the approval to
0:09:29 enter into negotiations with suburban construction management to provide CM
0:09:33 and GC services associated with the park,
0:09:35 property located at the corner of Elizabeth Boulevard
0:09:38 and Hankins Road.
0:09:39 Is there any further discussion?
0:09:42 Okay, Amy, roll call vote.
0:09:44 Great Hawkins. Cited in E-25
0:09:45 Yes.
0:09:46 Jason Brown.
0:09:47 Yes.
0:09:47 Nathan Murray.
0:09:48 Yes.
0:09:49 Kerry Bomer.
0:09:50 Yes.
0:09:51 Ruth Pierce.
0:09:52 Yes.
0:09:52 And Chris Reed.
0:09:53 Yes.
0:09:54 Okay, motion carries six to zero.
0:09:56 Thank you, Wendy.
0:09:57 Move into that next one.
0:10:00 And I have to apologize as I was taking a look at this.
0:10:03 made a mistake. I obviously cut and pasted and I left the last paragraph on this
0:10:12 staff report but this truly is Guho. So this one is for Baxter's. This is we have
0:10:19 the construction documents on that. Again we ranked those through the service
0:10:24 roster and came up with Guho as the top candidate to enter into negotiations.
0:10:30 And so even though it says Guho and then later it says core, strike that and I apologize for that here on my part.
0:10:38 Do you have any questions about this one or is it pretty simple just like the other one?
0:10:42 Questions for Wendy on that?
0:10:44 Good question. Go ahead Chris.
0:10:46 This is for the improvements that have been discussed for the last several years.
0:10:49 Yes, so we, you funded a plan.
0:10:56 We did the plan. We got that plan done. It's been sitting out there. We've been looking for funding for it and this one's the one that I think we're using fire station.
0:11:09 The cell fire station. Yes. Yes. Yes. To make these. So this is just an improvement to the dog park. It changes kind of the outline of it. It's, it'll be a good improvement to that space for sure.
0:11:23 And yes, it's that project.
0:11:25 Any other questions.
0:11:26 Okay, Ruth Pierce.
0:11:29 Hi, yes, Mayor.
0:11:30 I move we approve entering into negotiations with Guho Corp for CMGC services associated
0:11:38 with the Baxter's Arc renovation project.
0:11:41 Do you want to have a second?
0:11:43 Second.
0:11:44 I have a motion and a second to approve the request to enter into negotiations with Guho
0:11:49 for CMGC services associated with Baxter Dog Park renovation project. Is there any further
0:11:57 discussion? Okay, Amy, roll call vote please. Jason Brown? Yes. Nathan Murray? Yes. Sherry
0:12:05 Womar? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Chris Reed? No. And Craig Hawkins? Yes. Okay, motion carries
0:12:12 five to one. Thank you, Wendy. Appreciate it. Okay, we'll move into our next item of consideration.
0:12:25 And that is a request to authorize the use of 899672 dollars and 79 cents of street fund reserves, 884,456, 88 of capital fund reserves,
0:12:42 $1,120,300 of park impact fees, $1,885,563,307 of water fund reserves, $980,924,68 of wastewater
0:12:57 fund reserves, and $115,000 of library fund reserves for a total amount of $5,085,91742,
0:13:06 to finish 12 different projects in fiscal year 26.
0:13:10 And we have Mitch Humble, and Mitch
0:13:12 was trying to to tax my ability to read numbers again.
0:13:16 That was a, that was a, that was a.
0:13:18 Mayor, can I ask who, who wrote that?
0:13:20 Yeah.
0:13:20 That was, was that Mitch?
0:13:22 Yeah.
0:13:22 You need to take Mitch's ability
0:13:24 or a way to write requests like that.
0:13:25 That is.
0:13:27 I thought about just, just finishing with the 5 million
0:13:30 number.
0:13:31 Yeah.
0:13:32 Yeah.
0:13:32 We'll have to figure out what that motion looks like.
0:13:34 That's the motion.
0:13:35 That could be the motion, but it's important that all these different chairs, because these
0:13:38 12 projects span, it makes sense, different areas of funding, and so we need to make sure
0:13:44 that people knew what we were talking about so they could come and comment if they wanted
0:13:47 to or listen.
0:13:48 I mean, we needed some reason to give you a hard time, Mitch.
0:13:51 Yeah, yeah.
0:13:52 It's more than I like to normally write in these kinds of.
0:13:55 But this is a complicated topic, and I'm going to try to go through it, and I want you to
0:14:01 to stop and ask me questions as they come up.
0:14:06 But as we have large capital projects that span fiscal years,
0:14:11 these things will sometimes happen.
0:14:13 And this year, we happened to have a few more than maybe
0:14:16 normally because we had a lot of large capital projects
0:14:18 spanning fiscal years.
0:14:20 And so as we were preparing, I say we, like I had anything
0:14:24 to do with, as the finance department was preparing
0:14:27 the budget amendment that's coming up next month,
0:14:29 We identified several projects where we needed to reauthorize them spending.
0:14:33 So rather than having 12 different people come up here at 12 different times, I thought
0:14:36 I'd just take them all myself and we'll do this once.
0:14:39 One motion should be able to cover it and then Matt will get the green light to include
0:14:45 all of this stuff in a budget that needs to be included.
0:14:49 With that, there's a variety of reasons why these things happened on this report and so
0:14:55 So I'll try to talk about those, because they end happen now and then.
0:15:00 And then I'll try to talk about each of the 12 independently to sort of share those details.
0:15:06 So anyway, so the idea tonight would be to reauthorize the spending that had happened in
0:15:11 the prior fiscal year with all the exception of one.
0:15:14 One was not a fiscal year thing.
0:15:16 The rest of them we'll talk about as spanning a fiscal year.
0:15:20 So the first project on the list is Eastland Drive.
0:15:24 Eastland Drive, this was the widening
0:15:27 and the reconstruction of the street.
0:15:28 So this is a street fund project.
0:15:31 This was completed or funded in fiscal year 25.
0:15:35 It was completed in the fiscal year 26.
0:15:37 Some of those funds span the fiscal year.
0:15:40 And then we need to reauthorize that amount
0:15:42 that span the fiscal year.
0:15:42 And in this case, it was $530,000, $530,125.27.
0:15:49 Washington and Filer was a very similar situation,
0:15:52 funded in a prior fiscal year,
0:15:54 and some of the work got down into this fiscal year,
0:15:56 and that one, 74,586 thousand dollars
0:16:01 needs to be reauthorized for fiscal year 26.
0:16:06 Addison Avenue East, this is a slightly different,
0:16:08 but it's a street fund project as well.
0:16:11 We funded the design of Addison Avenue East,
0:16:14 not the construction.
0:16:15 And so that design had taken some time.
0:16:18 It again spanned a fiscal year.
0:16:20 And this one, this was originally funded
0:16:23 in the 24 budget, and then in the 25 budget,
0:16:28 this is a complicated one to design.
0:16:29 It's in a busy part of town.
0:16:31 Lots of different properties involved.
0:16:33 And it went through the 25 budget, and now we're in the 26.
0:16:37 So that one did get encumbered in 25,
0:16:39 but you can't encumber into a third year.
0:16:41 This is gonna be something we'll see a couple of times.
0:16:43 And so the third year of that project
0:16:47 is needing to be reauthorized for this fiscal year.
0:16:51 That amount is $62,281.52.
0:16:57 Next one of this is Candy Trail Junction Park.
0:17:00 This is the trailhead park that's
0:17:03 going on at the corner of Eastland and Pole Line right now.
0:17:06 That, again, was funded in the prior fiscal year.
0:17:09 And then the construction spanned into this fiscal year.
0:17:12 That one was being funded with a combination of donations
0:17:15 from primarily Chobani.
0:17:17 And then the balance of that was a park impact fee funding.
0:17:22 And so this one is $1,120,300 in park impact fees.
0:17:33 The donations from Chobani just kind of go
0:17:36 into that general capital fund, and then we'll pay them all
0:17:39 out of there.
0:17:41 Vista Benina Park, this is another little bit different
0:17:44 And then some of the rest of them, if you'll remember,
0:17:46 Vista Benita was funded with the SLF or F money
0:17:49 that we went through that process a few years back.
0:17:52 It was eventually budgeted, and then the construction
0:17:57 is now spanning into this fiscal year as well.
0:17:59 When Wendy stood up here and said I have a few big projects
0:18:03 that are coming to a conclusion, these two are on that list
0:18:07 that we should be done in the next, you know,
0:18:09 matter of weeks, really close.
0:18:11 of a Anita Park. We did a contract, a CMGC contract with core construction and the council
0:18:19 approved that and authorized that. We also had some work out there that was done outside
0:18:24 of that contract like construction management with our designer and then we paid auto power
0:18:32 to move a transformer and those were not in the CMGC contract so they needed to be authorized
0:18:36 separately. And so that amount for Visiting of the Park is $143,000 and $12. And this is
0:18:43 again for the other stuff that is not the core construction contract. Last fiscal year, the next
0:18:52 one that listed the trail out by the Gun Club on Federation Road. This was funded in the last fiscal
0:18:59 year and it was actually completed in the last fiscal year. It was completed in September of 25,
0:19:04 But that contractor failed to send the final invoice until a few months into 26 and it was
0:19:11 too late to apply it to the prior fiscal year and so it got credit to this fiscal year.
0:19:15 We just need to include that in the budget amendments so this authorization is needed.
0:19:21 Next one is the airport well.
0:19:22 If you'll all remember, IDEQ gave us a $2.5 million grant to kind of find a solution to
0:19:28 the water quality at the airport.
0:19:31 We signed a contract with Hiddleston Sons, actually drilled the well, but the work that
0:19:39 was done by our consulting engineer is the work that we need to authorize.
0:19:43 So JUB engineering has done $100,000 worth of work in FISQ 26.
0:19:49 This will be money that's reimbursed from IDIQ with that $2.5 million grant.
0:19:55 I probably should tell you that once we get this well-drilled,
0:19:59 and we can then start testing the water quality there,
0:20:03 this will lead to more future expenses.
0:20:06 Those future expenses will be budgeted
0:20:08 and go through the appropriate process of time.
0:20:11 This is just to take care of the fiscal year 26 work.
0:20:16 Can really road water line.
0:20:18 This was kind of a big project, if you'll remember.
0:20:21 A few years ago, we had, this seems like this happened
0:20:24 two or three times where we budgeted money from the water fund to build Southwell number five,
0:20:29 and then something would have come up. In this case, state's going to pave the road. We need
0:20:33 to make sure we replace the aging water line on the road before they repave it. So we reallocated
0:20:38 the money from Southwell five that the Kimberly Road water line, and we signed a contract for
0:20:45 that work, and this one has a couple different things going on. So I'm going to spend a little
0:20:48 time on this one. When the council awarded the contract, we also awarded a contingency
0:20:53 that contract. The contingency amount was $600,000 and that contingency amount was
0:21:00 just kind of held in reserve. It wasn't part of the construction contract. That's
0:21:06 important because at the end of a fiscal year we can encumber the amount that
0:21:10 was included in the contract. Since the contingency wasn't included in the contract
0:21:14 it was not able to be encumbered. Comes into play later in the project when we
0:21:21 we start using the contingency.
0:21:22 And this is another one where 24 was the start of the project.
0:21:27 We go and encumbered into 25, and now we're in the 26,
0:21:30 and this is a long, re-ear construction project.
0:21:34 We're all into the third year of a construction.
0:21:36 And so we got here for a couple of reasons.
0:21:38 And then the final thing on this one,
0:21:41 this is the only one on the list
0:21:42 where we need to get a little bit additional money
0:21:45 than what was originally allocated for it.
0:21:47 When we got into the tail end of the construction,
0:21:50 And there were some unforeseen circumstances, primarily with the crossing of the railroad
0:21:56 line that cost quite a bit more money and we allocated some of that contingency dollars
0:22:01 and it ended up spending a little bit more than it was ever originally approved.
0:22:06 And so in fiscal year 26, we need to authorize the Water Fund reserves to pay $122,678.39.
0:22:17 is that is including the little bit that that went over budget about eighty
0:22:25 five thousand dollars over budget. Okay the next one is the public works
0:22:33 campus their site improvements. If you'll recall this one was funded in a prior
0:22:38 fiscal year. This was split between the water fund and the sewer fund each paying
0:22:43 half. This is the curb better sidewalk landscaping parking lot area that's now
0:22:48 new and finished. It's also finished in fiscal year 25. It finished in September.
0:22:53 This is another one where the contractor didn't send that bill over until, you
0:22:58 know, like December or so of 25. And so we need to authorize 162,884 dollars and 68
0:23:07 since from the water fund and the same amount from the sewer fund pay that last
0:23:14 bill from the contractor. The next one on the list is the water creek water shed.
0:23:20 Man, he just came up here and talked to you about the next project in the rock creek water shed.
0:23:24 This is the last one. This was the creation of the master plan and that was funded with the grant
0:23:31 and reimbursed, but we didn't have the budget allocation needs to also happen.
0:23:36 And so for that project, it's $229,000 and $229,104 to be reimbursed by that NRCS grant.
0:23:48 And then the last one on the list, this one is slightly different than the rest.
0:23:54 As you're all aware, the library used to operate independently from the city.
0:23:59 And a budget time, they would come in and say, we need whatever the number was.
0:24:04 We need a million dollar shop rate this year and we would just approve the total.
0:24:09 We didn't ever look at the line items and how those million dollars were broken out.
0:24:13 As we started that transition, the 26th budget, this current budget that we're in now, was
0:24:20 the first time that the library had to go through the budgeting process, the same as
0:24:25 all the rest of the departments.
0:24:26 They had to break down their request by a line item and we have a practice where the finance
0:24:33 team and the HR teams kind of work together and they come up with the salaries and so we
0:24:37 don't ask departments to submit what their salaries are going to be with the exception
0:24:41 of part-time salaries. Well that exception was a little bit of a miscommunication between
0:24:46 the library director and the other teams and so she didn't ask for any part-time salaries.
0:24:52 You didn't double check are you sure you don't need any part-time salaries and so they have
0:24:56 a bunch of money in part-time salaries that we've been spending all year about having that authorization
0:25:00 do so. What we need to do, there's also some savings in the library fund that we've projected
0:25:06 for this fiscal year and the money that we need to make up the difference is $115,000 from
0:25:12 the library reserve fund. And so those are the 12 different things. Happy to talk about it.
0:25:19 Any one of those in more detail if you want. I've also got a room full of people behind
0:25:23 me that might know more about the details than I do. And so if you have any questions, I are
0:25:28 And if not, then we would recommend the approval of the $5,085,917.42 across the funds as described.
0:25:41 Ruth Pierce.
0:25:42 So Mitch, you included a schedule that was pretty informative.
0:25:46 I don't know if we could pull that up on the screen, so everybody could hear that.
0:25:54 Read the fine print, right?
0:25:55 I got the other one.
0:25:56 I don't know.
0:25:57 I don't know.
0:25:58 I didn't plan to do a presentation, but yes, it is.
0:26:03 And it's in the packet, but it was very helpful to see which reserve.
0:26:07 So I'm actually comfortable making a motion unless anything.
0:26:12 She brought it up. I did have one quick clarification that Matt wanted me to make in my table.
0:26:17 I talked about a few of these funds and those aren't truly for the grant projects. Those aren't exactly right.
0:26:24 the grants will be reimbursed, not necessarily coming from the fund reserves.
0:26:29 Right. And so like the airport well isn't necessarily coming from the water fund
0:26:34 reserves, it'll just be a reimbursement from my EQ. But the label there is
0:26:38 describing the generally the type of project that it was, and there's a few of
0:26:42 those. The rock water shed is another one where, but in general, it helped me
0:26:47 kind of visualize where the money was coming going. Well, and we still have to
0:26:51 to approve the right, yes, expenditures.
0:26:55 Yep.
0:26:56 Travis, Mr. Mayor, members of council.
0:26:58 So I will talk about, like, as an example,
0:27:01 how these are kind of nuanced,
0:27:03 and the one would be like the Rock Creek grant
0:27:08 that we received, or direct appropriation
0:27:10 that we received from Congress from Simpson's office.
0:27:12 The council went through the process
0:27:14 and they approved and accepted the grant.
0:27:18 The step that wasn't taken was that we didn't incorporate that into the budget and the allocation
0:27:26 process.
0:27:27 And so you took that step, that second step wasn't taken, and so we're making sure that
0:27:33 we're dotting our eyes and our cross-parties.
0:27:36 Councilwoman Volmer sent me an email earlier today, one of our questions in this coming
0:27:42 out of cash reserves.
0:27:45 What is the state of the city's cash reserves?
0:27:48 that is something that we track on a quarterly basis.
0:27:52 When we do cash reserves,
0:27:56 we take a very conservative approach as an example.
0:28:00 The City Council has, by agreement, committed to partner
0:28:05 in the expansion of the sewer line
0:28:09 going down Pole Line Road.
0:28:11 And we've committed $6 million
0:28:15 by agreement to that project.
0:28:19 That project is under design, but a significant piece of that has not been expended.
0:28:26 We take 100% of the estimated project costs, and we remove them from unrestricted reserve accounts.
0:28:35 And so if you think about all of the different projects that we're balancing, whether it be through long-term planning or in the budget,
0:28:41 The total value of unrestricted funds across the funds that Mitch talked about is about
0:28:48 42.6 million dollars.
0:28:51 When you add back all of those other projects that have not necessarily received a direct
0:28:57 order of appropriation from the council, it exceeds 70 million dollars.
0:29:04 What's important is, again, this might be nuanced, what happens with those resources
0:29:10 is if it did not receive an allocation or appropriation,
0:29:14 they fell into reserves.
0:29:16 And so we're taking those resources
0:29:18 and pulling them out of reserves
0:29:20 and incorporating them into the budget
0:29:22 so that we can penalize the budget amendment process.
0:29:25 These are non new monies.
0:29:26 These are monies that you've already committed
0:29:28 to other projects.
0:29:30 From a staff perspective, we've had conversations
0:29:33 about doing a better job in executing these processes
0:29:36 and we're building processes to ensure
0:29:39 that we don't have to do this again.
0:29:43 Appreciate it Travis.
0:29:44 I would add one thing.
0:29:46 I'm grateful that Travis just mentioned that Poline Project,
0:29:49 because I just skipped right over it in my presentation.
0:29:51 It was the one that I missed.
0:29:53 So the Poline Project that he's talking about, yes,
0:29:56 for details, $818,040 is coming from the waste water fund
0:30:02 reserves, 232,680 from the street fund reserves,
0:30:06 because that's both sewer line project and a road widening
0:30:09 project.
0:30:11 Thanks, Mitch. Any other questions? Go ahead, Ruth.
0:30:14 Okay. I move we authorize the use of $5,085,917.42 as outlined to finish 12 different projects
0:30:27 in fiscal year 2026.
0:30:29 Do I have a second? I'll second. I have a motion and a second to approve the use of
0:30:35 reserve funds for a total amount of $5,085,917.42 to finish the 12 different projects as outlined
0:30:45 in Mitch's presentation in fiscal year 26. Any further conversation by the council? Okay.
0:30:52 Amy Rollcoveau, please.
0:30:54 Nathan Murray.
0:30:55 Yes.
0:30:57 Gary Vomer.
0:30:58 Yes.
0:30:59 Ruth Pierce.
0:31:00 Yes.
0:31:01 Chris Reed.
0:31:02 Yes.
0:31:03 Greg Hawkins.
0:31:04 Yes.
0:31:05 Yes.
0:31:06 So this is an opportunity again as just as a reminder that if you do want to address
0:31:11 Council tonight, please make sure that you sign in I notice a couple of people walk in after
0:31:17 the previous announcement, so please sign in and
0:31:21 After Travis's presentation we will we will go through that process. So now we have
0:31:27 the opportunity to kind of recap and and finalize our
0:31:31 our budget process before public hearing next week.
0:31:34 Yeah, Mr. Mayor, members of the council,
0:31:37 I'm here again.
0:31:40 So as we like to share,
0:31:42 this is the 12th of 13 public budget presentations
0:31:47 that we will have in the development of this budget.
0:31:50 And while there is no action tonight,
0:31:53 the idea is that we want to make sure
0:31:55 that we have a budget that has been thoroughly vetted
0:32:00 as next week as the mayor had shared, we will go through the process of holding a series
0:32:05 of public hearings as required by Idaho Code to adopt the budget.
0:32:10 We want to make sure that if you do have questions, staff has the opportunity to research and
0:32:16 be prepared to answer those.
0:32:22 So as I've shared, and as we have new members of our community that jump into our book at
0:32:31 some point in time, kind of want to paint how we see the City of Twin Falls and the lenses
0:32:38 that we use. And as I look at you, I know that each one of you can give this piece of it,
0:32:43 but I want to share some different information. This is the same slide that you have seen. And
0:32:51 this slide is important because this is the information that we used in the construction of
0:32:58 of the budget for the budget hearings with individual departments as well as the information
0:33:05 that we used when we went through the balancing process.
0:33:08 But just to give you an idea how our area has changed and you take a look in May, the median
0:33:15 home value was $373,232.
0:33:21 Now it is 374,978, that's a 3.2% increase, and that 3.2% increase is expected to continue
0:33:32 over the course of the next rolling 12 months.
0:33:35 Unemployment is something that we also keep an eye on.
0:33:38 We shared the unemployment number as it relates to striving to be an employer of choice and
0:33:45 how we are competing against every other employer for the right people to join our organization.
0:33:53 Unemployment inside of the City of Twin Falls since May has gone up a bit.
0:33:57 It is now at 3.7, while the state remained the same and the national unemployment rate
0:34:06 drop to 4.2%. So you can see that we are still in a very tight labor market. And there are
0:34:16 1,023 individuals inside of the city corporate boundaries that fall under the definition of
0:34:22 being unemployed. That number continues to fluctuate. And again, these are the non-farm
0:34:31 numbers that are presented by the Idaho Department of Labor.
0:34:37 So this is the information that we use, and one thing that is always important to recognize
0:34:44 is the City of Twin Falls while it may be slightly over 50,000 persons.
0:34:51 We service a community that's about 112,000 individuals a day, and more than 40,000 vehicles
0:34:57 across the Pride Bridge alone. That is as we share one singular access point into our community.
0:35:05 And so the community that we serve is much bigger than the tax base that is used to support it.
0:35:13 When we create the budget we establish and we confirm six overarching goals.
0:35:20 The budget that you have perceived and presented not only by the City Manager's Office but by all
0:35:26 of the different departments, follow these and I can confirm that each one of these goals
0:35:35 is met inside of this city's budget.
0:35:41 One of the questions that we routinely get is what is that impact to me, what is that
0:35:46 impact to the bottom line and that is hard for us to accurately share and so we've developed
0:35:53 this median person, this fictional person that probably doesn't exist, but we take a
0:35:58 look at all the medians in terms of water, sewer, and median home value, and then we apply
0:36:06 water rates, sewer rates, sanitation rates, and a tax rate.
0:36:11 And you can see that inside of the City of Twin Falls, the monthly bill, combination
0:36:18 of property taxes and utility bills will decrease by $0.28 per month.
0:36:25 Now it's not a commitment that everyone's bills are going to decrease by $0.28 per month.
0:36:31 It is all highly variable upon the amount of water that you choose to use.
0:36:36 It is highly variable on your property and how it was reassessed for the upcoming tax
0:36:46 year.
0:36:47 gives an idea of the budget as it doesn't boil down to the individual level, it really
0:36:54 looks at more of the macro level and that median person.
0:36:59 The budget process is highly defined by Idaho Code.
0:37:05 These are some of the relevant sections of the code that are part of that process.
0:37:12 And so it describes those and I can confirm that this budget is in complete compliance with Idaho
0:37:19 Code.
0:37:22 When we start looking at the total taxable value of the city, you can see that we've increased
0:37:27 spending is slightly out and the tax is going down.
0:37:33 There are two causes for the variations.
0:37:36 One, you'll see about a $4.5 million expenditure increase and that is the
0:37:43 the infusion of cash reserves to complete projects
0:37:46 that are completely described within the budget.
0:37:49 And then when you take a look at the non-tax supported bonds,
0:37:51 which is water, wastewater, those that we capture a fee
0:37:56 to be able to operate, those projects have decreased
0:38:00 largely because of the completion of several
0:38:02 of those projects.
0:38:04 And Mitch kind of went through a long laundry list
0:38:08 of public works related projects
0:38:11 that you can see why some of those total budgets would fall.
0:38:18 I think it's important to recognize
0:38:19 that the city's total valuation is about 6.78 million dollars.
0:38:25 That is the net value of the city,
0:38:27 that is after homeowners exemptions have been removed.
0:38:31 It also excludes all properties
0:38:33 that are bound into urban renewal areas.
0:38:37 Urban renewal values inside of the city of Twin Falls
0:38:39 have a collective value of $717 million, bringing the total value of the City of Twin Falls,
0:38:52 that amount that resides within the city's corporate boundary of just over $7.5 billion.
0:39:00 This is an illustration of our tax rate. You can see that since 2023, it has been relatively
0:39:06 flat, and if you were to expand this graph out, you can see that it is continually downward
0:39:13 trending. We've shared and we've been asked how does our city compare to other full-service
0:39:23 cities inside of the City of Twin Falls, and I would argue that we're extremely competitive.
0:39:31 Or the person who is going to examine this and the first thing they will probably notice
0:39:37 is that we've excluded three of the largest cities in the state of Idaho from this calculation.
0:39:44 The first reason is the city of Meridian and the city of Boise have all of their transportation
0:39:52 needs furnished by the Ada County Highway District.
0:39:55 It is a separate taxing entity.
0:39:57 They do not perform road construction and so will road maintenance and so we have removed
0:40:03 those two cities from inclusion.
0:40:05 And then the city of Napa a few years ago has elected to create its own fire district,
0:40:10 so the city of Napa no longer offers fire services.
0:40:15 When we do a apples-to-apples comparison, this is the information and you can see that the
0:40:22 city of Twin Falls ranks second behind Coeur d'Alene, and we fare better than Caldwell,
0:40:29 Toronto, Lewiston, and the Falls.
0:40:36 We have shared, and as we've demonstrated, the City of Twin Falls Strategic Plan is the guide
0:40:42 post that we use and the creation of the budget.
0:40:46 As you witnessed, all departments came up when we broke this budget presentation into
0:40:53 a series of focus areas.
0:40:54 They came up, they presented, they shared their thoughts and their ideas.
0:40:59 We use this strategic plan for every financial and policy decision that we make.
0:41:03 I like to say that we have a plan so we don't chase shiny things.
0:41:09 Shiny things will tend to get you in trouble.
0:41:12 It's not to say that we are not always looking at better ways to improve service, but it's
0:41:17 after careful thought, exploration, and the use of qualitative and quantitative data to
0:41:23 assist in that decision-making process.
0:41:25 This is the last budget that we will use the city's 2030 strategic plan.
0:41:32 And later this fall, the city staff will be presenting to you the work that has been
0:41:37 done not only by the council, the community, and the staff ask you to review and then ultimately
0:41:42 approve the 2040 strategic plan and it will be used for the first time in the fiscal year
0:41:50 28 budget.
0:41:54 Breaking down into the numbers, you can see that the total budget, while 102 million, is
0:41:59 broke into really two distinct pieces, those that are tax-supported and those that are
0:42:05 enterprise funds. The tax-supported funds equal about $65 million, and the enterprise
0:42:13 funds who add those two together, and you're about 32. We have shared, and I hope that we
0:42:22 have demonstrated that the backbone of our organization is the quality folks that we
0:42:28 have working here. Public services are delivered by the
0:42:33 brains in the hands of 355 employees and that is why
0:42:38 it represents the single largest cost. At 44.5% of the budget spread across
0:42:44 all funds. Capital and operation maintenance
0:42:47 both equal 23.5. As we've shared the city has
0:42:52 very little debt. The only debt that we have is a result of the 2014
0:42:58 bond that was passed for wastewater. When we take a look at property taxes you can see that it
0:43:07 is the conversation and it is the tax that no one likes to pay including me. Working for the city I
0:43:15 don't get a voucher or a waiver to excuse me from paying property taxes. It is a collective tax that
0:43:22 that we pay. While it represents 55.1% of the tax-supported funds, it is closer to slightly
0:43:31 less than a third of the total collections for the entirety of the budget. And if you
0:43:36 look at property taxes alone, they do not cover the costs of police, fire, street, and
0:43:44 prosecutorial services. All of the other functions of government that fall under the
0:43:51 supported funds come from a whole series of other sources. And then in the enterprise funds,
0:44:01 again, those funds that assess a fee for that service, 46.6% is water, 37.4% is sewer. Those
0:44:11 funds are separated, they're isolated, and they can only be used for the purpose for which
0:44:16 they were collected in accordance with Idaho Coon. Two weeks ago, the city council went through the
0:44:24 process and they allocated $721,000 and they also gave some assignments to staff to consider
0:44:34 and to bring back to be included at a later date.
0:44:38 These funds are allocated in the capital fund.
0:44:42 They are reserved for future projects and you can see that seed money for the Arts Commission
0:44:49 shade umbrellas for the downtown commons, in particular the engineering aspect of it,
0:44:54 as well as is there an opportunity to assist the senior citizen center
0:45:01 after the instruction that we received from legal counsel. That was an abbreviated presentation
0:45:11 out of respect for the fact that you probably could all give this. For those that are interested,
0:45:18 every single one of our meetings are archived. The entirety of the budget is online.
0:45:23 they can view to their heart's content. I do recommend intermissions in going
0:45:33 through because I think in total you spent about two to two and a half hours in
0:45:39 evening going through conversations about this and other related components in the
0:45:45 budget since the first week in. So next week, you will have two public hearings. Those public
0:45:56 hearings are slated and ready to go, and the public has been duly notified to participate
0:46:03 should they choose. We will have the ordinance available for you to adopt next Monday even.
0:46:13 to stand for any questions that you have. Any questions for Travis? Okay. I'm not
0:46:22 seeing any at this point Travis. Continue to move on. Thank you very much.
0:46:29 Appreciate it. So again I saw a few people come into the meeting after the
0:46:36 previous announcement so this is an opportunity to have public input on the
0:46:43 the budget and other items not on the budget tonight.
0:46:47 So if you'd like to address the council, Amy,
0:46:49 do you have the signup sheet or is it, okay.
0:46:52 Mr. Mayor, if there are individuals here
0:46:55 for the public hearings, there are two public hearings
0:46:58 that will appear later this evening.
0:47:00 The public input session is not the proper time to speak.
0:47:04 There will actually be a different process
0:47:06 for them to speak within those windows.
0:47:08 Perfect, thank you, Travis.
0:47:09 I appreciate that reminder.
0:47:11 But yeah, so there will be other opportunities, as Travis noted, but that we are at our general
0:47:21 public input at this time, so I think we've got a few people on the list tonight.
0:47:27 This is the general, and then if it are public hearings later on for land use types of items
0:47:35 that will be here in just a few minutes.
0:47:37 So, Amy, oh, I'd go through, like we've done the last couple of weeks,
0:47:43 we'll provide two minutes for each individual that would like to address the council tonight.
0:47:48 And we'll work through that process.
0:47:52 We will go no longer than 60 minutes on that because we do have other items on the agenda tonight.
0:47:58 So we will start out, we ask that you approach the dais,
0:48:03 make sure that the green light is on and state your name is you come up
0:48:08 and you will again will have two minutes.
0:48:10 Amy, there's the first one tonight.
0:48:12 The first one is Maria.
0:48:40 Hi, my name is Maria Hernandez
0:48:42 and I was born and raised here in June of Al-Zydahoe.
0:48:44 Jason, Mayor Jason and the council.
0:48:59 I am brave, who I be?
0:49:04 This is me, cause here I come.
0:49:08 I'm gonna be, I'm gonna be seen.
0:49:24 Today on August 17th, I'd in and out restaurant
0:49:28 the first time. I ordered an Ashley Burger to honor Ashley Garibay, one of the victims
0:49:35 in this shooting. I ordered the right one. The burger was delicious. It fit right in with my diet.
0:49:41 It's a no bun and I encourage people to try it. And today I'm here to honor in and out for their
0:49:51 kindness of holding a prayer vigil for the three victims in our community. Let alone one of their
0:49:57 victims was one of their own. My condolences, also my condolences to the Stockton in and out.
0:50:04 After hearing about Ashley's character, I realized I had a better understanding of
0:50:09 this is what Ashley would have wanted for her employees to do to get back up,
0:50:13 yes grief, but keep going. I read several times that Ashley brought right into the darkness. She
0:50:19 had a positive attitude of the in and out employees and to keep going undoubtedly was Ashley's spirit
0:50:26 of resilience and leadership qualities, she wanted to own her own in-and-out burger,
0:50:33 and her philosophy was to get back up and to keep going. I was so proud of the in-and-out employees
0:50:43 when I went in this morning. I wanted to hug each one of them, but of course you can't do that.
0:50:49 But the resilience and the kindness of that business is great.
0:50:54 Thank you, Maria. I appreciate it the next excuse me the next one is William. I'm not sure what the last name is
0:51:05 Lucy
0:51:07 No, we won't start until you start start speaking. So you you've got you've got time to get up there
0:51:19 Mr. Mayor, Mr. Vice Mayor council members. Thank you
0:51:22 My name is William Lucy. I'm a resident of temple
0:51:27 Our concerns are the street repair the chip repair going on right now
0:51:31 If I may say very shoddy work, it's a complete mess.
0:51:37 Both of our vehicles have been damaged
0:51:39 because of flying rock and debris from other vehicles
0:51:42 passing.
0:51:43 We were told by the workers that it was a force at process.
0:51:47 There was a ceiling coat, rock, gravel,
0:51:50 crush it, then they clean it.
0:51:51 And then they were gonna put asphalt on top,
0:51:54 which I find out later is not the case
0:51:55 from Bud in the street office here.
0:52:01 Thank you. It's a growing concern. Our neighbors the same way. So we moved here seven years ago,
0:52:08 not an issue. Now I feel like I live on a country road and my wife's car the other day got pummeled
0:52:14 by oncoming vehicles throwing rocks. I invite you to drive Madrona, Castle Ridge,
0:52:22 Ar Street Pillar, Clearwater. They said they're finished with those and the other concern is the
0:52:29 gravel besides being in our front yard in our driveway still in the gully of the
0:52:35 waterway so when the rains come all of this is going to go down into the storm
0:52:39 drains you're gonna have a big problem but I do invite you to come and see if
0:52:43 there's something in the budget that we can put asphalt on top I feel sorry for
0:52:47 liability for children playing fuel riding bikes where the case is road rash
0:52:52 it's gonna hurt. Madrona they said is finished not so much I I
0:52:58 I really hope that council gets the attention on this because it needs to be done right.
0:53:03 That's all we're saying.
0:53:05 So, liability factors are bad.
0:53:08 If I may.
0:53:10 So, anyway, appreciate it.
0:53:11 Thank you very much.
0:53:12 Thank you so much.
0:53:13 Thank you.
0:53:14 Just kind of a general, you can sit up.
0:53:18 So, we do, it probably, if you moved here just recently, we do have a zone maintenance.
0:53:23 So, it comes around every seven, seven years, I believe, is our zone.
0:53:27 Yeah, so we do a zone maintenance, but I appreciate the comments and if you've talked to Bud and the street department will
0:53:35 Will continue to to work through them. I'm sure the the city manager's office is is taking note and and I've gotten mine
0:53:43 So thank you very much. Appreciate it
0:53:47 Amy do we have anybody else for the for the general public input or no not on the list, okay?
0:53:53 And that brings us to our conclusion of the general public input and we'll move through
0:54:01 the next items which is advisory board reports and announcements are there any from the council,
0:54:09 right?
0:54:10 Just joining forces tomorrow morning at seven o'clock county west that's a veteran support
0:54:15 group so everybody's welcome.
0:54:17 Anyone else?
0:54:20 Okay.
0:54:22 City manager's office.
0:54:24 office. Mr. Mayor, we have nothing for this. Okay, thanks Travis. We'll move into our public
0:54:32 hearings. The first one, I probably should read my notes, right Jonathan? Read the rules.
0:54:42 Make sure I get that part of it. We'll go to our first one and we'll follow the public
0:54:47 hearing procedures as follows. We'll follow the nine steps for each request listed on the
0:54:54 public hearing portion of tonight's agenda. The first one, staff will present the request
0:54:59 and analysis. Number two, the applicant will then present their request. Number three,
0:55:04 the council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff. Four, after questions have
0:55:11 been asked, the public hearing will then be opened. During that time, anyone in attendance
0:55:17 is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request being considered.
0:55:22 five, one, giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address,
0:55:28 and then present your comments or concerns. After giving testimony, please sign the public
0:55:33 sign-in sheet located in the lobby at this point. It's at Amy's desk here and fill that out with
0:55:42 your name and address for our records. After public comments, number six, after public
0:55:47 comments are concluded the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and make
0:55:52 a closing statement. Seven staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed. Eight
0:55:58 after the closing statements the public hearing will be closed. No further testimony or comments
0:56:04 from the applicant or audience will be allowed. And nine the council will have an open discussion
0:56:09 and then take action on that item. Okay, Lisa, our first one is a zoning district change
0:56:16 for central city to town neighborhood,
0:56:19 T-3 on property located at 451 Russet Street.
0:56:26 Okay.
0:56:28 Okay. Thank you, Mayor, Council members.
0:56:30 So tonight, the applicant is asking to rezone the property
0:56:35 from central city to town neighborhood 3, known as TN3.
0:56:40 This property is located off Washington Street,
0:56:44 close to Rock Creek Canyon. The property is currently vacant and there used to be a home on it, but
0:56:50 it was demolished earlier this year prior to the applicant's purchase of the property. So this area
0:57:03 of town has a diverse mix of uses from residential to industrial. Around this property, there's a truck
0:57:09 depot to the south, residents to the north, Rock Creek Canyon to the west in a pipe company,
0:57:15 Hersilon and Loco Park located east of the property along Washington Street.
0:57:19 So the zoning map shows the properties to the west and northwest of the property
0:57:25 or zone T and 3. Might be a little small, which is this color right here, this
0:57:33 brownish color. While the block closest to Washington Street is central city, which
0:57:42 is in the red. While central city zoning district is established to be a mixed
0:57:47 use environment, new residential uses are limited to the in this zone. Detached
0:57:53 single family duplex, triplex, and foreplex units are not allowed uses in the central city zone,
0:58:00 but based on lot size they could be permitted in the TN3 zone. This lot size for this property
0:58:07 is 6,000 square feet and in the TN3 that would equal either a single family dwelling or duplex
0:58:15 being allowed to be built on that property. So our future land use map, sorry, shows us as downtown
0:58:26 high-density residential. This designation is defined as being central business districts serving
0:58:31 the local and regional area with a diverse mix of land uses, encouraging redevelopment and infill.
0:58:38 So this is the older part of town, closer to our downtown. And then staff has reviewed this
0:58:46 request and has found that the request meets the criteria for a rezone. Here's a better area.
0:58:53 kind of shows the area. There's Buffalo Cafe, Milner's Gate, so here's Shoshone,
0:59:01 Washington Street, and then the property is right here off of Rock Creek Canyon. On July 14th,
0:59:10 the Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval unanimously of this request, and City
0:59:17 Staff finds that the proposed zoning district to be compliant with a comprehensive plan by
0:59:21 supporting diverse desired land use patterns and housing guidelines.
0:59:25 Here's a street view that helps north, south, east, and west.
0:59:30 The west is, there's Rock Creek Canyon where the trees are.
0:59:36 And that was the narrative for the request.
0:59:44 And I will stand for any questions, but we had the applicant and the
0:59:48 representative are also here to present to you tonight.
0:59:51 Okay. I just realized Kelly, I called you Lisa. I apologize.
1:00:02 I've been called worse. It's hard. I apologize. So that's what I was going back and making sure. So I apologize.
1:00:09 I know you know who I am. It's okay.
1:00:12 I guess I'm willing to accept my my mistakes. Any questions at this time.
1:00:18 Okay. Go ahead, Sherry. Better not call you by somebody else's name.
1:00:23 I might accept it.
1:00:27 So I have the question on this.
1:00:29 I'm, first of all, I'm very open to always putting housing where we need, especially in
1:00:36 this environment.
1:00:40 And then I'm also careful on, you know, we've created zoning and so what happens when we rezone.
1:00:45 And so we're talking about rezoning one lot, correct?
1:00:48 Yes.
1:00:50 Is there, and this might be a dumb question, but is there a reason why we would not do maybe
1:00:58 a special use or something other than a permanent rezone?
1:01:04 What I'm wondering is, is if they do this as a house, and then let's just say two, three,
1:01:11 four years down the road, then they want to do commercial, then they have to rezone it.
1:01:16 have to rezone it. So the reason for the rezone is because the residential uses are very limited
1:01:22 in the central city. Only multifamily, five plus or more units are allowed and townhouse
1:01:30 development is allowed with a zoning use permit which is administrative approval. So because of
1:01:38 the size of this law being so small, it couldn't accommodate any of those uses. And it already had
1:01:44 residents on their probably back from the 1930s. So they just want to replace kind of
1:01:50 sure what was there so and it's not I know it's just the one lot but because
1:01:56 there's T and 3 to the west and the northwest it does connect and so it
1:02:01 isn't like a spot zoning but that was the reason for it but you're right if on this
1:02:06 small lot they wanted they sold the property and somebody wanted to come in
1:02:10 they would have to rezone it. They would have to rezone it. Okay I was just trying
1:02:12 to think if there was any other option other than a complete rezone.
1:02:18 In the central city, not even with the special use permit,
1:02:20 could residential be allowed.
1:02:23 Thank you.
1:02:25 Any other questions?
1:02:28 OK.
1:02:28 OK.
1:02:29 You're from the applicant.
1:02:30 OK.
1:02:50 OK.
1:02:50 My name is Juan Torres.
1:02:52 I'm the owner for a lot of his playing the project.
1:03:00 Hello, good afternoon.
1:03:01 My name is Javier Beltran, helping him out.
1:03:05 So the reason is what we want to do,
1:03:08 instead of being just a single home,
1:03:10 you want to do a duplex with a detached garage
1:03:15 with an alley axis if possible.
1:03:18 So he wants to do curb and gutter and everything,
1:03:20 trying to bring up that area,
1:03:22 make something nice instead of just being an empty lot.
1:03:27 Okay, any questions for the applicant?
1:03:33 Jerry?
1:03:34 I'm just like I'm looking at a Google map here. So is there there is not
1:03:38 No, it goes down to all street, doesn't it? The curb and gutter
1:03:41 Then it stops right at this property. Okay
1:03:45 Yeah, so he's willing to do like improvements and stuff around if you need to yeah, yeah, definitely
1:03:52 I'm sure that'll be part of the the process as we as we go on to that. So no, thank you
1:03:58 Thank you guys
1:04:02 Kelly, anything else you want to add there?
1:04:08 The only thing I would say is that with the building permit,
1:04:11 when if this gets approved and they come in
1:04:13 for the building permit, all of those improvements,
1:04:15 like the curb gutter sidewalk,
1:04:17 they would all be addressed at that point.
1:04:19 Perfect.
1:04:21 Okay, at this time, we'll open up our public hearing
1:04:26 for this property located at 451 Russet Street.
1:04:34 Okay, not seeing anybody to come down for this one,
1:04:37 We'll close the public hearing.
1:04:40 And any further questions, comments?
1:04:45 Kelly, applicant, okay.
1:04:48 What are Council's wishes on this item?
1:04:52 I would make a motion.
1:04:53 Okay, Sherry, go ahead.
1:04:55 Let me get to that screen.
1:04:59 Okay, I move to approve the zoning district change
1:05:03 from Central City to Town neighborhood three
1:05:07 on the property located at 451 Russet Street
1:05:11 in Carabuan Torres.
1:05:13 Is that correct?
1:05:15 Okay.
1:05:16 Okay, Chris.
1:05:17 Chris Reed, second.
1:05:18 We have a motion and a second
1:05:20 to approve the zoning district change
1:05:22 from central city to town, neighborhood 3-T-N-3
1:05:27 on property located at 451 Russet Street
1:05:31 in Carabuan Torres.
1:05:32 Any further discussion by the council on this item?
1:05:35 Okay, Amy, roll call, vote, please.
1:05:39 Thank you.
1:05:42 Now it's Lisa's turn.
1:05:44 Call you Kelly just to make it make it even as we go along.
1:05:47 So this is a request for annexation of 2.42 acres.
1:05:55 With a proposed zoning district of community market.
1:05:58 should I call you Kelly just to make it make it even as we go along? So this is a
1:06:05 request for annexation of 2.42 acres with a proposed zoning district of community
1:06:12 market for property located at 857 Hankins Road North and we have Lisa.
1:06:21 Good evening Council. The applicant is requesting annexation of approximately
1:06:27 42.42 acres at 857 Hankins Road North at the southwest corner of Falls Avenue East and
1:06:35 Hankins. The applicant's requested zoning designation is community market. There is already an existing
1:06:43 office building on the property that has historically been used for the Boy Scouts of America. The
1:06:49 property sits at the intersection of two major arterials, Falls Avenue and Hankins Road with
1:06:55 with residential development surrounding it.
1:06:57 Comprehensive plan, future land use map
1:07:01 designates this location as neighborhood commercial,
1:07:09 which is intended for neighborhood serving, retail, offices,
1:07:13 civic facilities, services, and similar uses.
1:07:17 The Planning Zoning Commission considered this request
1:07:21 on July 14th and after discussion,
1:07:23 the commission recommended the zone
1:07:26 If the property were to be annexed, be TN1 with a professional office overlay rather than
1:07:33 the community market.
1:07:35 Their primary concern was that community market contains some uses that are either outright
1:07:40 permitted or available through a special use permit that could have a greater impact on
1:07:44 the surrounding residential neighborhood than the commission preferred.
1:07:48 Staff finds that community market is consistent with the neighborhood commercial future land
1:07:52 use designation and it would allow neighborhood serving retail office service and civic uses
1:07:58 while providing development standards intended to offer a transition to the arterials to the
1:08:06 surrounding residential area. The existing office use is also relatively a good transition
1:08:13 between residential neighbor and the arterial ways and staff notes however that the community
1:08:17 market does allow some uses that could be more intense than the existing office
1:08:22 use. Those use would still be subject to applicable staff and commission review
1:08:28 process. The comparison of the options for the zoning of this property have been
1:08:33 provided in the packet. Under the neighborhood commercial
1:08:37 future land use designation the options for that with our new zoning code were the
1:08:44 to the residential with a professional office overlay,
1:08:47 community market, and then there's also mixed use.
1:08:50 And I provided both all three of those different types
1:08:54 of zones with the list of land uses and whether they require,
1:08:57 if they're already permitted, require special use permit
1:09:00 or require staff approval.
1:09:03 The primary question is not whether commercial type activities
1:09:06 appropriate at this intersection
1:09:08 because the comprehensive plan is already identified
1:09:10 as neighborhood commercial.
1:09:12 But do we want this corner to remain primarily residential
1:09:16 with a professional office in character?
1:09:19 Or do we want to allow the broader neighborhood commercial
1:09:21 opportunities envisioned by the Conference of Plan?
1:09:25 The property is already developed with an office building
1:09:28 and parking.
1:09:29 Staff finds the site physically capable
1:09:31 of accommodating uses prevented within the proposed zone.
1:09:36 Water and sewer are already available.
1:09:38 Falls Avenue and Hankins Road provide arterial access for traffic, police, and fire services.
1:09:45 In addition, there are future development requirements such as right-of-way dedication and reconstruction
1:09:51 of right-of-way to the arterial city standards for both falls and Hankins Road.
1:09:56 Upon conclusion, the council is not limited to the Planning and Zoning recommendation.
1:10:01 They can approve it as the TN1 with the professional office overlay as recommended.
1:10:07 You can approve it with community market zoning, or you can approve it with another zoning designation
1:10:14 you think more appropriate, or you can table the application to collect additional information,
1:10:19 or you can deny the application.
1:10:22 However should you move forward with the approval of the annexation, staff does recommend that
1:10:28 the right-of-way for Hankins Road and Falls Avenue must be deeded to the city before signing
1:10:33 annexation ordinance, and upon development or reconstruction of the site falls Avenue East
1:10:39 and Hankins Road North must be reconstructed to city arterial standards to the road's center
1:10:44 lines. That concludes my presentation. The applicant's representative is here to present
1:10:50 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:10:59 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:11:31 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:11:36 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:11:42 office on this application. As you know, this site has occupied an office for scouting the
1:11:57 existing Council, acquired the property in 1978 and constructed this building in 1980.
1:12:03 As part of my role with the Council and just professional skill with scouting America and
1:12:10 the local councils coming out of the bankruptcy,
1:12:13 out of COVID, out of the departure of the LDS church,
1:12:17 and the Baptist church organizations.
1:12:20 We've seen a realignment of scouting throughout
1:12:23 the United States.
1:12:24 And the Mountain West Council was created
1:12:27 by a merger of the Orida Council
1:12:29 and the Snake River Council about five years ago.
1:12:32 And with that, we had a portfolio of properties.
1:12:36 We have been working through the disposition
1:12:39 those properties because some of them are obviously surplus to our needs. The
1:12:44 traditional scout camp for the Orida Council of the Mountain, when going back
1:12:48 to the Mountain View Scout reservation in McCall, Camp Morrison was sold several
1:12:54 years ago. We have also identified certain other properties that no longer
1:13:02 meet the mission of what needs to be done for us to be able to meet the needs
1:13:06 of youth here in southern Idaho. So as we have this this property one of the
1:13:12 issues that has just percolated out there is the fact that I think to the
1:13:17 surprise of everyone this property has always been in the county. It's never been
1:13:21 in the city and I do remember going back as a kid to it was on the outer
1:13:27 reaches but it is in the city it's on the adjacent to the city and as your
1:13:34 Your staff and you and your planning and zoning commission went through the rather comprehensive
1:13:41 zoning code rewrite and comprehensive plan efforts last year.
1:13:45 We felt it was an appropriate time to come forward with a request to annex this property
1:13:50 because it is a historic, non-conforming existing use and would have the discussions previously
1:13:57 and in consultation with your staff we decided it was time to bring it in because it gives
1:14:01 us flexibility for what we do with this property.
1:14:05 Scouting American, the Mountain West Council,
1:14:07 are not abandoning the Magic Valley.
1:14:09 In fact, we are in the midst of a multimillion dollar capital
1:14:13 investment in the Snake River Council's traditional historic
1:14:17 camp, Camp Bradley, and the Sawtooth Mountains,
1:14:20 because that is a property that cannot be replaced.
1:14:24 But as we go through this, as we look and evaluate
1:14:26 the future of this site, annexation seemed appropriate.
1:14:31 As indicated, and as depicted on the map, the actual area that's usable is considerably less
1:14:39 than two acres, and that's because prior easements were granted for the roadways, and we are prepared
1:14:45 to make that dedication as requested by staff.
1:14:50 The site currently does have curb-gutter and sidewalk along all of its frontage, and it currently
1:14:56 does have the office building that was constructed in 1980.
1:15:01 It has been utilized as office and retail space supporting scouting for nearly 50 years.
1:15:08 And it is a site that we've had a variety of potential users express interest in.
1:15:13 But the problem with it being an existing non-conforming use is whether we went to the
1:15:19 county to obtain a conditionally used permit or we came to you.
1:15:23 There's always that issue of if the property is own residential and it's got a existing non-conforming
1:15:30 use on it, that poses issues and concerns for municipality in terms of the entitlement,
1:15:36 it poses issues for lenders, it poses issues for buyers.
1:15:39 It poses issues from an operational perspective, from building codes and what we can and cannot
1:15:44 do.
1:15:45 So, we are appreciative of the effort that your staff has made and more, I mean again,
1:15:52 I do this professionally in jurisdictions all over state, your comprehensive plan and
1:15:57 zoning rewrite or to be commended because that is a heavy, heavy lift. I know when municipalities
1:16:05 go through it. It is hard. But the designation of the property on the future land use map in
1:16:11 your comprehensive plan, we believe is appropriate. A staff indicated it is an existing neighborhood
1:16:17 commercial type use. It is at the intersection of two arterials. It's at the intersection of two
1:16:23 arterials that have matured and that the areas around it have matured. And so to
1:16:31 facilitate the reused redevelopment potential disposition of the property, we
1:16:37 think it appropriate to resolve the nonconforming use. And so that's why as
1:16:41 staff indicated with your new comprehensive plan and the designation of
1:16:46 this sector, this intersection as neighborhood commercial, we believe that it is appropriate
1:16:55 to annex it in with a request for community market due to the fact that community market
1:17:03 very much describes and identifies what the property's historic use has been. We recognize
1:17:10 and acknowledge that the Planning and Zoning Commission expressed some concerns about what
1:17:15 the community market district would do.
1:17:18 But I don't think people comprehended,
1:17:20 and I think both staff and myself did a poor job
1:17:23 of articulating to the Planning and Zoning Commission
1:17:26 and to some of the neighbors that were,
1:17:28 and appeared that night, as to the limited nature
1:17:32 of the commercial development capacity
1:17:34 within the community market.
1:17:36 Community market is very much intended
1:17:38 to be neighborhood serving.
1:17:41 It intended to be professional office,
1:17:43 the types of Dennis office and orthodontist office that we've seen spring up all over this
1:17:48 date in the vicinity of elementary and middle schools to be the accountant office that's
1:17:55 close to somebody's home.
1:17:58 That's what we think is appropriate.
1:18:00 So the one thing we struggled with, and I visited with your staff about it, is that it wasn't
1:18:07 exactly clear which uses were objectionable to the commission and how we could address
1:18:14 that because the fact of the matter is there is significant oversight for most
1:18:19 uses within the CMT zone. In fact of the over 450 uses designated in the CMT zone
1:18:28 only 15 are permitted of right and of those 15 only 12 really relate to the
1:18:38 type of commercial use as three of them are our public uses that this property
1:18:43 doesn't qualify for.
1:18:44 So what are we talking about that's permitted?
1:18:46 Well, we're talking about administrative, small,
1:18:49 administrative or professional offices.
1:18:51 We're talking about barber shops or cosmetology,
1:18:55 seamstress, tailor, print shop, photography studio.
1:18:59 You could have assisted living or daycare there of right.
1:19:04 I don't know what a minor fund center is.
1:19:06 It's obviously less than a major fund center,
1:19:08 but you could do that.
1:19:09 And the staff did an excellent job,
1:19:11 I think of describing the fact that, yes, under your code,
1:19:14 the Z designations require administrative review
1:19:17 and S requires conditional use permits.
1:19:21 The uses that were intensive,
1:19:23 that I heard at least one commissioner express concern
1:19:25 about about, oh, the possibility of a drive-through restaurant
1:19:28 or AC store, those are all uses that require
1:19:33 a special use permit that somebody would have to come back
1:19:36 to you for.
1:19:38 So, we're not here to make any commitments as to what this is.
1:19:43 This is just, it's time for us to bring this property
1:19:46 into the city as we evaluate how best to manage the portfolio
1:19:50 that we have.
1:19:52 We do think that CMT is the appropriate zoning designation
1:19:55 because as we look at what those permitted uses are,
1:19:59 that is what the use is.
1:20:01 That is what the use has been.
1:20:03 That is what the use has been since 1980,
1:20:08 that mix of office and community meeting and small retail.
1:20:13 We don't know what the use necessarily
1:20:15 is going to be in the future, but we do know
1:20:18 that if it is a, in the community market zone,
1:20:24 it is not a general commercial zone.
1:20:26 It is a neighborhood serving use.
1:20:29 So the CMT's permitted uses are consistent
1:20:32 with historic use, objectionable uses
1:20:34 require further permitting, and the majority of the CMT
1:20:39 uses require additional administrative or planning
1:20:43 and zoning approval.
1:20:45 As such, we request annexation with the CMT zone.
1:20:51 As it's reflective of 50 years worth of ongoing use,
1:20:55 it resolves the nonconforming nature
1:20:58 of this property providing flexibility with it.
1:21:01 We also believe it promotes Twin Falls' newly adopted land use map
1:21:05 and your newly adopted comprehensive plan.
1:21:08 And most importantly, it's an example you can point to is what is intended with CMT
1:21:14 in implementing your new zoning ordinance.
1:21:17 And with that, I'd stand for any questions.
1:21:19 I also have, sorry, I also have tonight with me the scouting executive
1:21:25 for the Mountain West Council, Lynn Gunter who can answer any additional questions
1:21:30 about operations of the facility because some of those came up with planning and zoning.
1:21:34 Thank you.
1:21:35 Okay.
1:21:36 Any questions for the applicant?
1:21:37 I don't see any right now, but as I'm sure we'll have some as things get moving along.
1:21:44 Thank you.
1:21:45 Thank you.
1:21:50 Okay.
1:21:51 That brings us to the opening of our public hearing for property located at the 857 Hankins
1:22:00 Road North.
1:22:02 So any one in the audience that would like to address the council pertaining to that property
1:22:09 specifically, please come up, state your name, and we'll go from there.
1:22:26 Again, I will note that that provide two minutes for any comment on that.
1:22:31 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:22:32 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:22:38 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:22:39 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:22:45 of use that this new designation, whatever it is, the reason he wanted the TNT or whatever
1:22:56 the TNT, whatever that other designation was, is because it was a little more restrictive
1:23:03 than the community market and a major concern for me is there's a school right there, there's
1:23:10 a church right there, there's a lot of foot traffic walking through that intersection and
1:23:17 things like that and people go down to evil, can you able to jump and I mean there's hundreds
1:23:21 of people to walk down that road and I think if we depending on what you put in there I
1:23:27 mean I don't want to have to come every time somebody wants to put something in there that's
1:23:32 going to generate a lot of traffic, car traffic, and that kind of stuff in that area. And I
1:23:40 think that the more restrictive designation fits that property better for the location,
1:23:47 because it's surrounded by residential. I mean, they can say it's 50 years of the same
1:23:53 thing, but they haven't tried to change it for 50 years. They tried to put a gas station
1:23:58 on the other corner of the other day and that was of course shot down but I just
1:24:04 think it needs to be a little more restrictive and I think the designation
1:24:09 that you had two city council members there that night that recommended that
1:24:13 other designation for that exact reason so I think you should I concur with that
1:24:19 previous designation that's a little more restrictive. Thank you David appreciate
1:24:26 Anybody else that would like to?
1:24:40 Good evening.
1:24:41 I'm Jay Dodds.
1:24:42 I have property at 3818 Laurelwood Drive, just north of the proposed annexation of the Boy Scout office there.
1:24:52 I also know something about the Mogginsons who provided the property to the Boy Scouts years ago,
1:25:02 So they could have that property and use it for the further development of young people at that time.
1:25:10 And even though it has been, as Dave mentioned, used for somewhat activity that would fall under the other designation that is being proposed,
1:25:24 I don't think Mrs. Mogensen ever planned on that property being a commercial type property.
1:25:30 She wanted it used for the young men in the area and wanted that to be well taken care
1:25:39 of for the Boy Scouts.
1:25:41 So I don't think the designation that provides for what was proposed here tonight should overshadow
1:25:50 what the idea was in the first place.
1:25:53 And also that the Planning and Zoning Commission, in my estimation, as Dave mentioned, proposed
1:26:00 the correct designation, I would support the Planning and Zoning Commission's position that
1:26:07 they took at the meeting they had.
1:26:09 And I just want to say that I recommend what the Zoning Commission came up with, thank you.
1:26:20 the other comments on the property located at 857 Hinkins Road North.
1:26:36 Robin Shank, 3046 Laurelwood Drive and I'm just going to say I concur with the previous two
1:26:41 speakers with everything they said.
1:26:43 Thank you.
1:26:44 Thank you.
1:26:45 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:27:07 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:27:12 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:27:16 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:27:21 let them do some high use thing on that corner.
1:27:26 Other people have said very intelligent things.
1:27:28 I'm more the emotional person tonight because I'm there often.
1:27:33 And with the school and the people, it's amazing how many people are out there.
1:27:38 You would go spend some time there.
1:27:40 But anyway, yeah, please try to uphold that country feeling.
1:27:47 I remember it was, I don't know, maybe 15 years ago when Dan,
1:27:52 Willie, wanted to put a sea store and gas station on the corner
1:27:56 of Falls and Locust, a couple hundred yards from my house,
1:27:59 and we fought tooth and nail so that we could have office buildings
1:28:03 so it wouldn't destroy and make that more busy.
1:28:06 Although I can't even imagine how much more busy it would have been
1:28:08 because it's pretty busy now, but anyway, hold the line for us.
1:28:13 It's important.
1:28:14 Thank you.
1:28:15 Thank you.
1:28:18 Anyone else that would like to address the council
1:28:21 side of.
1:28:22 Okay.
1:28:27 Seeing none, we'll go ahead and close the public comment period.
1:28:34 You have the opportunity.
1:28:38 The applicant has the opportunity to address the concerns
1:28:43 that were brought here tonight.
1:28:50 Remember members of council.
1:28:52 If I can switch back to this, please.
1:28:56 Mr. Mayor, members of council to address the concerns that we've heard
1:29:06 Again, Jeff Wortle, 251 East Front.
1:29:09 I would point out that to the extent you heard testimony
1:29:14 that they don't want to have to come back
1:29:16 for future hearings on the use, the residential designation
1:29:22 with the professional office overlay only permits
1:29:28 special use permits.
1:29:30 It necessitates every possible use coming back
1:29:34 with that type of an application.
1:29:37 and it's not consistent with what your vision is for the city.
1:29:43 Second, you've heard multiple people talk
1:29:48 about convenience stores and we're not talking
1:29:50 about a convenience store.
1:29:51 I can, we're not proposing a convenience store,
1:29:55 a convenience store, if one were to ever be proposed
1:29:58 would require a special use permit,
1:30:00 but the bigger issue that you have is that this parcel
1:30:02 is actually quite small.
1:30:05 And it is quite small.
1:30:06 And once we get done dedicating the right-of-way,
1:30:09 the staff has requested we dedicate,
1:30:12 it becomes even smaller.
1:30:14 So this notion that you should deny our request,
1:30:20 or you should impose a residential zone
1:30:23 on a piece of property that has not been utilized
1:30:26 residentially does not make a lot of sense.
1:30:30 All we're doing is furthering the non-conforming nature
1:30:34 this use. And I would pause it as we look at the list of the limited permitted uses within
1:30:41 the CMT zone. There is not a single one of those private uses there that are intensive.
1:30:49 There's not a single one of those uses listed there that generate excess traffic on a regional
1:30:55 or beyond neighborhood basis. Every single one of those serve the individuals in the
1:31:01 immediate neighborhood. And as to the concern about pedestrian safety, this is
1:31:08 one intersection at this corner where the improvements have been made. The
1:31:13 improvements do exist. You do have curb, gutter, and sidewalk serving those needs
1:31:17 and providing accessibility through the area. That's what's ultimately going to
1:31:23 be there and when the intersection gets redeveloped in the future, those will be
1:31:27 enhanced and preserved. It provides the type of walkable service that we find, again, as
1:31:35 I noted, adjacent to education institutions throughout the state of Idaho. There's a reason
1:31:41 that every middle school, high school, grade school that we pass in this state seems to have
1:31:47 within 600 feet. You know, those small local serving uses, the dentists, the broker, the
1:31:56 the dance studio, those types of uses that are permitted. Finally, I just want to be
1:32:05 clear that we certainly take our responsibility seriously for ensuring
1:32:13 that the needs of the youth of Idaho are taken care of. And one of the struggles
1:32:19 that councils throughout the United States with the decline in membership
1:32:24 have had to come to grips with is what alternative uses can we make for our real property assets
1:32:32 and what disposition. We don't necessarily know what the plan would be here. We have considered,
1:32:38 you know, do we go ahead and put it on the market to lease it? Do we sell it? What do we do? But
1:32:43 we can't do anything. We can't do anything unless we have some finality and consistency
1:32:50 with respect to the zoning.
1:32:52 So I understand the concerns that were articulated.
1:32:56 I, however, don't think that's what your code actually
1:32:59 permits.
1:33:00 Your code only permits these 15 uses
1:33:03 to be utilized on the site, and anything else
1:33:06 will require a hearing.
1:33:08 Contrary to the public's belief, if you do annex it
1:33:13 with a designation of residential with professional office,
1:33:17 you are going to have to come in for a special use
1:33:20 permit, and we'll be back in under those circumstances if we accept that zoning,
1:33:27 we'll have to come back with that. And any future modifications to that will
1:33:33 necessitate it. So it doesn't create any procedural ease or benefit to the neighbors.
1:33:38 They can have confidence that those are the uses that are permitted and anything
1:33:42 else will require their engagement, involvement, and notice. So with that, again,
1:33:48 And it is our request that you annex the property, zone it CMT, and we bring this property finally
1:33:56 into the city of Twin Falls.
1:33:58 Thank you, Lisa, Jonathan, anything from the staff side that clarification or open it up
1:34:12 for council discussion.
1:34:15 As a date to not add more to confuse, there are uses that are now zoning use permits, so
1:34:25 So it's not a public hearing, but it isn't outright permitted.
1:34:27 It means there are some uses that somebody has to follow a prescriptive method of building
1:34:31 something a certain way in a certain location with either screening or a distance from residential
1:34:41 in order to be put in there.
1:34:42 That's a little bit more comprehensive list than what's shown.
1:34:45 The list that you're shown there is permitted by a right, get a building permit to do it,
1:34:49 follow the law in terms of safety of the building, that kind of thing, and you could do that.
1:34:54 other uses their zoning use permits that we have a prescriptive thing to follow and
1:35:00 you're aware of that process it's a staff level process that we make sure
1:35:05 people build it correctly so any other questions that you might have for us to
1:35:10 and that's designated by Z in this table correct that you've provided in the Senate
1:35:15 report yeah an example I'm gonna pick one the religious facility is one that's a
1:35:20 a zoning use permit in the community market and now there's going to be a specific either number of
1:35:27 mostly these are tied to occupant load which is therefore tied to how many people are going to
1:35:32 show up or are allowed to be in that building at one time. So religious facilities we have occupant
1:35:37 load limits for the size of that facility in certain spots or how they access the property.
1:35:44 That one's the one I just know because I saw today and it's like you have to access an
1:35:47 an arterial or collector, you can't go through like a local road.
1:35:50 You don't have a large facility that has like 1,000 people,
1:35:54 occupant load driving through a neighborhood.
1:35:56 They have to be on larger roads that can handle the traffic.
1:35:59 That's the kind of things that we would require
1:36:01 with the zone you use permit.
1:36:03 That's the only clarification I would have for you.
1:36:05 Okay.
1:36:07 Council, do you have any questions for Jonathan
1:36:09 before he sits down?
1:36:11 Hey, I'm gonna excuse myself from voting.
1:36:15 I'm on the board with the Scouts of East Scouting in America.
1:36:18 I need to excuse that.
1:36:20 I've had a lot of fond memories in that building,
1:36:21 and I want you to know.
1:36:23 Sounds good, Craig, thank you.
1:36:27 Do you have a question?
1:36:28 It's really a delay in uses, and I'm just looking at,
1:36:33 so the P&Z Commission recommended one
1:36:37 of the town neighborhoods, is that correct?
1:36:39 Yeah, they did town neighborhood one,
1:36:41 which is what's predominantly in the area.
1:36:42 Okay.
1:36:43 And with that professional.
1:36:44 And then with professional office,
1:36:46 everybody, okay, correct.
1:36:47 And then, yeah, I'm pulling it.
1:36:53 I just have it looking at uses like financial institutions
1:37:01 and group homes, which are around the neighborhood,
1:37:05 but special use are not allowed in community market.
1:37:10 Okay, we'll go ahead and have,
1:37:12 there's no questions, any more questions
1:37:14 for Jonathan at this point.
1:37:18 Okay, we'll go ahead and have a council discussion.
1:37:22 What are, what are council wishes on this one?
1:37:25 Mayor, if you don't mind, just officially closing the
1:37:27 public hearing.
1:37:28 Thank you.
1:37:29 And then it's just clarification, no additional
1:37:31 information, essentially.
1:37:32 Thank you, Jonathan.
1:37:34 Yeah, we'll go ahead and close the public hearing on the
1:37:37 item that we're talking about.
1:37:40 And now we'll have Council's discussion.
1:37:48 I can jump in first, my thoughts.
1:37:52 I appreciate the discussion that happened.
1:37:53 I appreciate the Boy Scouts and what they're trying to do.
1:37:59 And at this point in time, I do have some concerns with community market while everything would
1:38:06 need to come back that the list of items that were permitted, absolutely, but there are also
1:38:13 several that are special use that would not fit at all in this area.
1:38:20 And so understanding that this is a moment in time where we have the opportunity to say
1:38:24 this is what it could be, future councils, if we do move it into the community market, could
1:38:29 decide with the special use especially if you were to scroll down under the
1:38:34 commercial sales and services there's several that absolutely in my opinion
1:38:39 would not fit there and so I have some concerns with that so I am in favor of
1:38:45 the town neighborhood one with the professional overlay and annexation. Okay
1:38:50 I go the other way I'm a little more permissive live that neighborhood not too
1:38:58 far from there, I don't see a problem with an office or my other potential services.
1:39:04 They add that much more traffic than say a very large church or school which is right
1:39:09 near there.
1:39:11 Thank you Nathan.
1:39:12 Thanks Chris.
1:39:13 Ruth, Sherry?
1:39:14 Well I'm going to agree with Nate.
1:39:17 I have the same feeling and I have a lot of confidence in future councils and future commissions
1:39:23 that they will be smart when it comes to special permits.
1:39:28 So I'm actually in favor of the community market.
1:39:34 Okay.
1:39:35 Sherry, what are your thoughts of?
1:39:39 No.
1:39:43 Um, community market is pretty narrow, but it does allow for, um, I think my only pain
1:39:54 with community market is the possibility of a gas station being there and backing right
1:40:02 up to the single family is bothersome to me because there is not a barrier typically you
1:40:11 would normally see a I don't know maybe apartment complexes or pro overlay between that and the
1:40:20 single family so as much as I can appreciate the market use and in the hopes
1:40:32 that future city council people would be diligent and understand the single
1:40:40 family that's behind there I'm leaning towards the the town neighborhood with
1:40:47 pro overlay. It's kind of what I'm out right now. Okay. Thank you. Just kind of looking
1:40:59 through through the the list here again and trying to yeah to work through some of
1:41:04 this and I mean these are these are I can see both sides of the the conversation
1:41:09 working through some of these obviously with these types of of opportunities
1:41:19 situations, want to provide the ability as Nathan said is the greatest use, but also
1:41:28 then Chris and back to Sherry's point of seeing, you know, making sure that we're protecting
1:41:35 that area.
1:41:40 I hate to limit their ability for what they want to do, but I'm thinking, I'm envisioning
1:41:48 in the office complex that is on the corner of falls and locust, I think if I was in a single
1:41:57 family home I'd want to back up to that more than I would something a little more intense.
1:42:05 Okay, so I guess this is our opportunity for someone to make a motion or push this item
1:42:19 down the street for just a little bit.
1:42:21 I can start it.
1:42:22 Go ahead.
1:42:23 All right.
1:42:25 We approved the request to annex 2.42 acres with a proposed zoning district of town and
1:42:38 neighborhood one with a professional overlay for the property located at 857 Hankins road
1:42:44 north as presented this evening.
1:42:49 Okay.
1:42:51 Do I have a second on that item?
1:42:53 I'll go ahead and second that.
1:42:56 have a motion and a second to pull it up here real quick to approve the
1:43:02 annexation of 2.42 acres with the proposed zoning district of town
1:43:10 neighborhood one with a professional overlay or property located at 857
1:43:16 Hinkins Road North that summit up Chris. Sure. Okay. Any further discussion by
1:43:24 Council. Yeah, do we have to include a condition of the right-of-way dedication and the reconstruction of roadway?
1:43:31 I believe so. I believe we do. I would add that as well. So the amendment, the second
1:43:39 that amendment, yes, so the amendment would be the inclusion of the right-of-way
1:43:45 request. The two conditions as outlined. Okay, set a better way the two conditions as outlined.
1:43:52 Yes. Any any further discussion on that on that item? Okay. Maybe roll a call vote.
1:44:01 Ruth Pierce. No. Chris Reed. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Dean. Jason Brown. No. Nathan
1:44:14 Murray. No. Jerry Bulmer. Yes. Okay. Motion fails three to two. Okay. What are
1:44:27 Council's wishes. That's it. We want to make a new motion or? Oh, that's right. Yeah, I will do that. Yeah. So I move we approve the request for annexation of 2.42 acres with a proposed zoning district of community market for property located at 857 Hankins Road North with the two conditions as proposed by staff.
1:44:58 Okay, I have a motion to approve the
1:45:05 annexation of 2.42 acres with a proposed
1:45:10 zoning district of community market
1:45:12 correct Ruth yes for the property
1:45:15 located at 857 Hankins Road North with
1:45:18 the two conditions any further discussion
1:45:24 on that item. Okay, maybe a real
1:45:28 Please.
1:45:29 Chris Reid.
1:45:32 No.
1:45:33 Craig Hopkins.
1:45:34 Jason Brown.
1:45:36 Yes.
1:45:37 Nathan Murray.
1:45:38 Yes.
1:45:39 Harry Volmer.
1:45:40 No.
1:45:41 And Ruth Pierce.
1:45:42 Yes.
1:45:43 Okay.
1:45:44 Motion carries 3-0.
1:45:45 Thank you.
1:45:46 Thank you.
1:45:47 Oh, 3-2.
1:45:48 Sorry.
1:45:49 Yep.
1:45:50 Thanks, Jonathan.
1:45:51 Perfect.
1:45:52 My items come back for ordinances at a later time when we have those written up.
1:45:55 Yes.
1:45:56 Thank you.
1:45:57 So, again, to clarify that, the motion did carry 3-2.
1:45:59 Okay, that takes us to our executive session
1:46:07 For the for this evening a request to adjourn into executive session according to Idaho code 74 206 F
1:46:15 to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal
1:46:24 options for pending litigation or
1:46:27 Controversies not yet being litigated but
1:46:29 but imminently likely to be litigated,
1:46:33 the mere presence of legal counsel at executive session
1:46:36 does not satisfy this requirement.
1:46:37 What are council's wishes?
1:46:39 So moved.
1:46:40 But motion to have a second.
1:46:42 Second.
1:46:43 We have a motion by Chris Reed and second by Craig Hawkins
1:46:47 to adjourn into executive session under Idaho Code 74206F
1:46:52 to communicate with legal counsel for a public agency
1:46:56 to discuss legal ramifications and lead,
1:46:58 And legal options for pending litigation of controversies
1:47:03 not yet being litigated, but imminently likely to be litigated.
1:47:07 The mere presence of legal counsel
1:47:09 at this executive session does not satisfy the requirement.
1:47:12 Any discussion?
1:47:14 Any roll call vote, please?
1:47:18 Greg Hawkins?
1:47:19 Yes.
1:47:20 Jason Brown?
1:47:21 Yes.
1:47:21 Nathan Murray?
1:47:22 Yes.
1:47:23 Mary Bomer?
1:47:24 Yes.
1:47:25 Ruth Pierce?
1:47:26 Yes.
1:47:27 And Chris Reed?
1:47:28 Yes.
1:47:29 inclusion of our council meeting this evening.
1:47:32 We will not be returning to the council chambers and we will adjourn until next week.
Download
- Transcript (text) 95 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 126 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 171 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.1 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 4.3 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 17, 2026. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:48:00.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
749b376d13e200ffdd178acb1dba84d423e5a5bcfe8e9e43f9e7e6a2defcd43a - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 3 passages muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 4b3d859b700d5888e23d31c8fc3ce6297c188943c1ec1f01cfaa84fbfce80ca6
part02.m4a 4d99fb1a1e9d70822764c78f70adad1e02d942c6d89050e86ebd5eb91a86605c - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 12 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
e2a98747f6d9693fca44e433089945e9f646bf32aa23c410389e50a76cbe544c
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file