OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, July 27, 2026

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:58 Okay, we'll go ahead and call the City Council meeting for July 27th, 2026 to order.

0:01:05 I will confirm that we have all seven council members in chambers tonight.

0:01:10 I will note that we have a council overflow in room 116.

0:01:16 It's the room just behind here that if you want to have a seat, you can hear and see

0:01:22 the City Council meeting tonight from that room.

0:01:27 And then when the time comes for public comment, we'll need you to come into this room.

0:01:32 So we'll go ahead and start with Pledge of Allegiance.

0:01:36 All of those that would like to participate, please stand.

0:01:59 Thank you.

0:02:01 So I will know what I obviously, Council meeting tonight.

0:02:06 We'll know that if you want to speak or address the Council, there's a sign up sheet and the

0:02:11 before you're up there, we need to make sure that your name and address get on that. If

0:02:17 you are not on the list, you will not be able to address City Council tonight. We will take

0:02:23 a quick recess right before public comment. So if you don't sign in now, there will be

0:02:29 another opportunity to do so before the comment period begins. And I'll go over the formalities

0:02:37 and some of that before we we go to that point. So it brings us to our consent calendar night.

0:02:43 What are Council's wishes? Mr. Mayor, for me. Yep. I would say we approve the consent calendar

0:02:50 as presented. I have a motion to approve the consent calendar as written. Do I have a second?

0:02:56 Second. I have a second motion by Grace or Councilman Stone, a second by Councilman Hawkins

0:03:02 to approve the consent calendar as written any further discussion.

0:03:06 Rachel Roll call vote please.

0:03:08 Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed.

0:03:10 Yes.

0:03:11 Ray Coccans, Jason Brown.

0:03:13 Yes.

0:03:13 Sherry Bulmer, Grayson Stone, and Nathan Murray.

0:03:17 Yes.

0:03:17 Okay, motion carries seven to zero.

0:03:20 That brings us to our items of consideration.

0:03:23 A request to authorize the use of up to 750,000 reserves

0:03:28 for the expansion of the Twin Falls animal shelter,

0:03:30 and we have Mandy Tonksen.

0:03:33 Good evening, Mr. Marin Council

0:03:36 Tonight I am coming to you with a request to authorize the use of up to $750,000 of reserves

0:03:43 for the

0:03:45 people for pets or to supplement the funds that people for pets have

0:03:49 Fund raised over the last nearly decade for the expansion of the animal shelter. So just a little background

0:03:57 in 2024 the city agreed to partner with people for pets and be the

0:04:02 provide the design oversight and management of the project in order to

0:04:07 assist in getting this project to fruition. Colby Ricks of Laffron Ricks

0:04:12 architecture was retained to design the project as the project

0:04:16 architect and Star Corporation was selected as the CMGC.

0:04:21 As project design progressed, the initial cost estimates

0:04:25 substantially exceeded the funding that people for pets had raised.

0:04:29 And so to align the project with available resources,

0:04:32 we went ahead and did as we created two scopes.

0:04:35 One scope was for the addition to the existing building

0:04:39 and the services that were to provide additional services

0:04:42 to be provided for cats.

0:04:45 And then we also had a scope that included

0:04:48 an addition, a new building that will provide

0:04:51 additional services for ducks.

0:04:54 And then we went through the design process.

0:04:56 We had some initial estimates and we found that it was going to save between about 170

0:05:04 and $185,000 if we did not do it in two different projects and instead we did it all at once.

0:05:15 So what we are here tonight to do is to ask the City Council to authorize up to $750,000

0:05:22 reserves to supplement the funds that people for pets have raised to date. We have representatives

0:05:30 from people for pets here tonight. We have Jackie Fry who is president of the board. And

0:05:36 Debbie Blackwood. I'm a little bit shy with all these people in the room tonight. Debbie

0:05:44 Blackwood with people for pets here if you have any questions. But I just want to take a minute

0:05:48 to kind of help you understand how much money Debbie has raised.

0:05:54 She has raised over nearly, I think it's been nearly a decade,

0:05:57 she's raised nearly $1.3 million for this project.

0:06:01 And that is a variety of different ways

0:06:05 in which she has worked with the community.

0:06:08 But I am shocked at the number of people that walk into Debbie's facility,

0:06:13 learn about the work that she does with animals in our community,

0:06:16 and leaving, pledging very large sums of money.

0:06:20 She is very passionate about what she does,

0:06:23 and I just wanted to take the opportunity,

0:06:24 especially in front of all the individuals

0:06:26 that we have here in Chambers tonight,

0:06:28 to recognize the work that people for pets have done

0:06:31 on behalf of stray pets in Twin Falls.

0:06:34 So with that, you have any questions of myself,

0:06:39 or Debbie or Jackie, we would certainly be happy

0:06:41 to stand for that.

0:06:42 Otherwise, my request for authorization of reserves

0:06:46 pays for $750,000.

0:06:48 Thank you, Mandy, Grayson Stone.

0:06:50 Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

0:06:51 I just have a quick question.

0:06:53 And if you wouldn't mind, Ms. Fry,

0:06:56 raising a big sum of money like that over a decade

0:06:58 takes a lot of hard work.

0:07:01 How did you, what practices did you put in?

0:07:04 Like, what service groups did you utilize?

0:07:06 Like, come tell your success story.

0:07:08 We don't hear these stories very often.

0:07:11 If you wouldn't mind, I'd love to hear from you.

0:07:16 Come on.

0:07:16 Down here, Jackie, come up.

0:07:19 Sorry.

0:07:24 In the time that I have been on the People for Pets board,

0:07:29 I can say that I have another position in the county

0:07:32 and addressing that with the FEMA requirements

0:07:35 of having a shelter for animals during any kind of an event.

0:07:38 It was really a critical part when

0:07:40 I was asked to be on the board to really fully understand

0:07:45 of what was needed to make the shelter successful.

0:07:48 But I am a businesswoman, I will be honest with you.

0:07:50 And so I'm the piece that came in and said,

0:07:53 we need to have a plan to make sure we have maintenance

0:07:57 and operations in place if we do a expansion

0:08:00 and make sure that the funding we get

0:08:02 is very transparent for our citizens

0:08:05 who have been so generous and kind,

0:08:07 as well as for the city who has gifted us the shelter.

0:08:11 The time that I've been on the board,

0:08:12 It has been incredible to see the people Debbie has shown friendship to and comfort and has

0:08:19 actually worked with through her family and has brought them to show such support to the

0:08:26 in all actuality, to the shelter.

0:08:30 I have never seen this because I usually do grants or I do finding that comes in a whole

0:08:36 other manner and I really do want Debbie to address this because she has the ability to

0:08:41 go out and fundraise or to ask people in the community who already offer those funds that

0:08:48 she can apply for, but I've got to be honest. She needs to tell this story a little bit because

0:08:55 it is incredible. So Grace and I, I don't know if I answered your question. I really think

0:09:00 we should have coffee because I don't know you, but it really would be nice to have you

0:09:06 ask some questions both about my position with the county and the things that I'm involved

0:09:10 in and I'm involved in many other things.

0:09:12 So you might really be intrigued with that.

0:09:15 So Debbie, please.

0:09:18 Well, thank you.

0:09:19 Thanks for having us here and thanks Mandy

0:09:20 and the organization from the city

0:09:24 to help this project come to be.

0:09:27 We just decide, well, first of all,

0:09:30 People for Pets has been operating the animal shelter

0:09:33 by the city's request since 1989.

0:09:37 We came in as a volunteer organization

0:09:39 to help kind of bring up the level of care

0:09:43 and expose the animals that need a second chance.

0:09:46 And pretty soon we were asked to operate the shelter.

0:09:49 Like I said, so we started the operations back,

0:09:54 like I said in 89.

0:09:56 It was in the late 90s that we realized

0:10:00 we had only 18 kennels, but we're terribly out of room.

0:10:04 So we started a capital campaign back then

0:10:07 to build a shelter that we exist in right now.

0:10:10 And that, we moved into that shelter,

0:10:13 and we raised a third of the funds

0:10:15 to build the building that we're in back then.

0:10:19 And we moved in in 2004.

0:10:22 Then in 2017, I thought,

0:10:27 there's some things missing

0:10:29 and with the close to 20 years

0:10:32 or moving toward our 20th year

0:10:35 that are kind of missing from the best practices,

0:10:40 keeping vicious dogs and sick animals away from other animals

0:10:46 was become necessary in our best practices

0:10:49 and our cat population is exposed to way too much noise

0:10:53 from the canines, blah, blah, blah, blah.

0:10:55 So we started thinking we need something,

0:10:58 we hired an architect firm,

0:11:01 or at least a preliminary look at what's necessary,

0:11:04 They're out of Colorado.

0:11:06 Their name was Animal Arts Architecture,

0:11:08 and she did a needs assessment with the community back in 2019,

0:11:14 2020 around there, and came up with a design based

0:11:20 on their years of expertise and stuff.

0:11:23 We always knew we wanted to just go with a local architect firm

0:11:29 to move forward, but we had those preliminary studies

0:11:32 surveys done. So then we just actively, you know, we just communicate that here's what we need,

0:11:40 and then literally like Jackie said, we, you know, used to have tea and and break bread with

0:11:50 just interested people in the community that really liked the fact that a humane society was

0:11:55 coming in and up leveling. And lucky enough, they gave us two different families, gave us

0:12:05 a large sum of money. So personal contact raising would answer your question. People we met along

0:12:12 the way that really like the fact that a humane society was operating the shelter and they liked

0:12:19 what we were doing. Janice Seagrays for one is another person who really loved

0:12:27 how we were caring for animals and they actually helped us quite a lot with the

0:12:31 building we already exist in. But moving forward like that we've written some

0:12:36 grants but people have literally come in they want to know they want to see our

0:12:42 financials and so we just visit and they're just really excited about the level of care that

0:12:50 we are currently giving and the proposal for the improvements from the addition. So not to take too much time but that's that's where we've come from.

0:13:00 Thank you. I appreciate that. Thank you. Good job. Chris Reed, I'm ready to make a motion. Thank you for that explanation by the way.

0:13:09 I was, can I just say one thing really quick.

0:13:12 I've been to several furballs and I will tell you

0:13:14 that Debbie and her sister will not let you out the door

0:13:18 unless you spend money.

0:13:19 So, do you want to explain what furballs are?

0:13:22 It is, yeah, it's not dealing with cats.

0:13:27 Right to junior high.

0:13:28 Yeah, I did, I did, all right, okay.

0:13:31 Mayor, I'm really authorized the use of up to 750,000

0:13:35 in reserves for the expansion of the Twin Falls animal shelter

0:13:39 presented this evening. Ruth Pierce. I'll second. Have a motion and a second to

0:13:43 authorize the use of up to $750,000 in reserves for the expansion of the Twin

0:13:49 Falls Animal Shelter. Any further discussion? Hey Rachel, roll call vote please.

0:13:54 Craig Hawkins. Jason Brown. Yes. Sherry Bulmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Nathan Murray.

0:14:00 Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. And Chris Reed. Yes. Okay motion carries seven to zero.

0:14:05 Thank you, Mandy. Appreciate it. Thank you, and I will be returning next week with a GMP for the we've been construction. Sounds good. Thank you.

0:14:14 So that brings us to our budget presentation tonight. It looks like Gretchen's gonna get us started

0:14:20 Tonight in our focus areas two and three. Thank you, mayor and council. It's our pleasure to be here tonight

0:14:28 This is the fourth budget meeting that we have now had the first night of course Travis opened and gave you the overall

0:14:35 picture of the objectives, the funding strategies, and some of the national

0:14:40 trends that are affecting our local economy. The second night was our healthy

0:14:45 community, responsible community, and our internal organization. On those nights for

0:14:53 healthy community, the parks department spent quite a bit of time focusing on

0:14:56 trails, parks, improvement of services, and then responsible community talked about

0:15:02 about things that we're doing for our community engagement

0:15:05 in terms of Polco, where we do for polling, outreach,

0:15:10 our citizen community groups that meet with us,

0:15:14 and then in an internal organization

0:15:16 what we are doing in terms of supporting our employees.

0:15:20 Last week, of course, was accessible, environmental

0:15:23 and prosperous community, the areas of economic development,

0:15:27 what we are doing in terms of our major infrastructure

0:15:29 water, wastewater, a lot of the transportation pieces that we have, sidewalks, roadways, those

0:15:35 sorts of things. And so tonight, last time, they started this. Okay, so tonight we're going

0:15:55 to go ahead and on to the last two of the focus areas that we will be talking about. And that

0:16:01 includes the learning community focus area and the secure community focus areas. We will go

0:16:08 through the recommended budget, what the financial pieces of it look like, and the impact to

0:16:12 our citizens. And then we will also talk about how we connect this to our strategic plan and

0:16:16 the objectives that we are hoping to achieve. So, by state law, we are required to present

0:16:25 to you a balanced budget. And this budget is indeed balanced. It seeks to both incorporate

0:16:33 the revenues that are given to us by the taxpayers to achieve the objectives and the outcomes that

0:16:39 that we are hoping to reach.

0:16:44 This translates community priorities into services

0:16:47 that are delivered through our employees.

0:16:50 It invests responsibly in both infrastructure

0:16:52 and the people that are part of our organization

0:16:55 and it hopefully plans for our needs into the future.

0:16:58 On the slide ahead of you is just some statistics

0:17:01 about our community, both the impacts of our influx population,

0:17:06 the number of folks that come in and out of Twin Falls

0:17:08 in order to do business, seek services,

0:17:11 and are passing through,

0:17:13 as well as some of the statistical assumptions we make.

0:17:17 We set a median value,

0:17:19 which isn't the highest or the lowest value

0:17:21 of a piece of property that is affected by the tax

0:17:24 that are levied, but how we kind of go through this.

0:17:29 Okay.

0:17:32 So, this is generally the picture

0:17:37 of how the taxes are impacting each individual residence home.

0:17:41 And you can see that this year, the proposed budget

0:17:44 is a decrease of the property tax rate.

0:17:47 That's just slightly, it'll go from $5.06 per $1,000

0:17:54 of value to $5.05 per $1,000 of value.

0:17:59 In addition, we have proposed a 5% water and sewer increase

0:18:05 in order to maintain the vast infrastructure improvements

0:18:09 that we need to continue to make as the years go forward.

0:18:13 That was presented last week for those people

0:18:15 that would like to get online and view that presentation as well

0:18:17 so they can get an idea of the scope of the infrastructure

0:18:20 that is currently being built and rebuilt.

0:18:24 In general, sanitation is looking like a static on the slide

0:18:28 but we're expecting a decrease.

0:18:30 That presentation is coming up in September.

0:18:34 This is a balanced $102 million budget.

0:18:42 Okay, some of our strategies when we're building the budget on an annual basis is to make sure

0:18:47 that it is both reflective of the community outcomes that we're trying to achieve advances the strategic

0:18:53 plan. It is sensitive to the economic environment of the community and the demands of the citizens

0:19:00 as they are serving in it. And we are looking to make sure that leadership is making thoughtful

0:19:06 choices among a lot of competing priorities.

0:19:11 This includes the 3% statutory allowed increase, includes the new construction value as is

0:19:17 allowed under state law, and 1% of the city's work on balance.

0:19:26 The total taxable value of our community had an increase this year.

0:19:31 It's at $6.7 billion.

0:19:35 That drives them the net expenses that we have shown there of $102 million, and those

0:19:41 are broken out in between both tax-supported funds and non-tax-supported funds. We'll go

0:19:46 through what that looks like in just a minute for a little bit more detail for those folks

0:19:50 that are here and watching tonight. Before we go forward just a little bit more information

0:20:00 about the taxable value of our community. This is not controlled by the city, it is controlled

0:20:07 by the county assessor and they give us this figure and you can see that the city's value

0:20:13 increased by about 3.3% this last year for about $359 million, not included in this figure

0:20:20 that is levied tax that comes into the city's property taxes that supports operations is

0:20:26 the value of the urban renewal properties. Those things that are used for economic development,

0:20:32 business retention and expansion and the goal to bring a more profitable area to our community.

0:20:38 This is a historical look at our tax rate.

0:20:45 You can see in 2021, it was at $6,

0:20:49 sorry, $6 and $83, 84 cents per $1,000 of value.

0:20:55 And since then, it has significantly declined.

0:20:59 We try to maintain a low tax rate in order to provide valuable services

0:21:04 without unduly burden the citizens of our community.

0:21:07 We also like to show everybody how we compare to other major cities in Idaho where the 8th largest city in Idaho and

0:21:20 Our population is growing

0:21:23 We only compare with like cities. So as an example

0:21:30 Boise does not provide a street department

0:21:33 They have a data County Highway District that takes care of that

0:21:37 So we don't compare our tax rate with them because they don't have the same amount of services a

0:21:42 recently now but just moved their fire to a fire district so they no longer have a

0:21:46 fire department as part of their city budget as well and you can see that in

0:21:50 comparison we're very competitively situated for tax rates across Idaho. So

0:22:00 just another couple of quick bullets or slides in order to make sure that

0:22:04 everybody understands how the budget is used and what it funds and

0:22:08 services. So the largest slice of the pie in front of you this is the expenditures

0:22:19 by fun type. So the largest piece is the governmental funds which are tax-supported.

0:22:24 People can refer to that in large part by property tax. Property tax supports

0:22:31 services like police, fire, streets, and parks. The purple piece, or blue, depending on

0:22:40 your color site, is our enterprise funds. Those are non-tax-supported funds. Those

0:22:45 are ones that are charged where they run like a business. It charges a fee for the

0:22:49 services that are delivered, and then that fee supports all of the operation pieces underneath it.

0:22:56 That includes things like water, sewer, and sanitation. Sanitation is garbage collection.

0:23:07 Yeah, we have a big crowd. This is kind of cool. As Lori would say, where's the popcorn? Okay.

0:23:13 And then the last one, the other non-major funds include smaller self-supported funds like

0:23:18 Shishone Falls where the fees for the vehicle entrance support the park improvements and the roadway maintenance

0:23:29 Okay, so now that you have an idea about the kinds of funds

0:23:33 How are they all made up and this is kind of an overview of how those funds are then broken out as?

0:23:40 A service organization it takes people to do the stuff

0:23:44 Sometimes you do it in cars and sometimes with other vehicles or equipment, but mostly it's all done by people

0:23:50 It's not automated or by machinery.

0:23:53 So it's no surprise that personnel is 44.5% of our overall budget for all across all funds.

0:24:00 The next is maintenance and operations, and then followed by capital.

0:24:03 We have a strong history of investing in the infrastructure and the ongoing improvement

0:24:09 of the assets that the public gives to us, and that is a substantial piece of what we

0:24:13 do.

0:24:18 As Travis mentioned during his previous presentation, we don't have any general obligation debt

0:24:25 and our existing debt is limited to our wastewater treatment plant expansion.

0:24:35 So the next step of the presentation tonight will be a review of the different focus areas,

0:24:42 learning and secure community as part of our strategic plan.

0:24:48 We tie all expenditures to the strategic plan in a effort to make sure that we are achieving

0:24:55 the outcomes.

0:24:56 Strategic plan is built from community input.

0:24:59 The 2030 plan was adopted in 2012, updated in 2018, and the new 2040 plan will be coming

0:25:07 up in this fiscal year.

0:25:09 We've been working through community groups, stakeholder invitation conversations as well

0:25:14 as a variety of public outreach to get people to comment on the plan and drive its direction.

0:25:21 As I mentioned, none of the things that we do do without the people.

0:25:26 And that's why the internal organization is at the center.

0:25:29 And then all focus towards the vision of what we are hoping to achieve.

0:25:36 So the last slide that I have is to introduce a learning community.

0:25:39 And from the library, we have Erica tonight.

0:25:43 Good evening, Mayor Brown, City Council.

0:25:53 My name is Erica Littlefield, I am the Youth Services Supervisor at the Twin Falls Public

0:25:57 Library.

0:25:58 I am also here with our library director, Tara Bartley.

0:26:01 Thank you so much for the opportunity to come and speak with you about the library tonight

0:26:05 and present our budget information.

0:26:07 We are so proud to serve the citizens of Twin Falls and the surrounding community.

0:26:11 I'd like to share some statistics with you about the usage of the library.

0:26:16 So we welcome about 586 visitors daily on average.

0:26:21 When people walk through our doors, we are wanting to create an environment that fosters

0:26:25 learning, growth, connection.

0:26:29 Last year, over 404,000 physical items were checked out from the library, as well as over

0:26:35 125,000 e-materials.

0:26:40 Our bookmobile visited over, did over 3,628 stops, and they also made over 1,000 deliveries

0:26:49 to patrons here in Twin Falls.

0:26:51 So that includes many deliveries to assisted living facilities, to other homebound patrons

0:26:56 that otherwise would not have access to library services.

0:27:02 Public access, we offer computers and Wi-Fi, and we also offer other educational databases.

0:27:09 We did have two facility improvement projects over the last year.

0:27:13 So we did recarpeting, or face two of our recarpeting project, which was the carpeting

0:27:19 on the main floor.

0:27:20 So as you can imagine, moving all of those books and furniture was quite a feat, but our

0:27:25 staff really pulled together as a team and created a plan to make sure that we did it as

0:27:29 efficiently as possible and had the least amount of disruption to our services.

0:27:34 We also added two new ADA bathrooms, or family bathrooms, one on the main floor and one on

0:27:42 the lower floor in the Youth Services Department.

0:27:45 That has definitely been a significant improvement

0:27:47 in the patron experience at the library,

0:27:49 especially for the families and caregivers

0:27:52 that use our Youth Services Department.

0:27:55 So for our 2627 budget, we are budget remains consistent

0:28:01 with the last few years.

0:28:02 We are not asking for any major changes or major projects,

0:28:05 but I did want to highlight a few pieces of our budget

0:28:08 and how it impacts our community.

0:28:12 So, of course, as you can imagine,

0:28:14 we are asking for items to purchase materials,

0:28:17 so we are asking for $221,000 for books and other materials.

0:28:21 So this includes books, electronic materials,

0:28:24 audiobooks, all of it.

0:28:26 So these funds allow us to create a collection

0:28:28 that is engaging, diverse, and that supports the needs

0:28:31 and interests of our community.

0:28:34 But what does that actually mean

0:28:35 for the citizens of Twin Falls?

0:28:37 What do they actually get out of the library?

0:28:40 So if you check your books out from our wonderful circulation

0:28:43 staff and you look at the bottom of your receipt,

0:28:46 it will show you how much you have saved

0:28:48 by using the library and checking out items instead

0:28:51 of purchasing them.

0:28:52 So I thought I could show you my related receipt,

0:28:54 but I thought it might be more impactful to show you receipts

0:28:57 from some of our actual patrons.

0:28:59 So I have permission from these families to share these.

0:29:02 And I hope it will illustrate the impact that the library has.

0:29:07 So, this is family number one.

0:29:08 So, this is a family of five with three young boys.

0:29:11 The dad comes in with his family.

0:29:13 This is received from checking out books last week.

0:29:15 Checked out 29 items, saved $444 or $45 that visit.

0:29:20 He saved almost $2,000 this year and over $4,000

0:29:24 since he got his card in 2003.

0:29:26 And his wife and kids also have cards.

0:29:28 So, if we added up what they have saved on theirs,

0:29:31 the whole savings for the whole family would be even larger

0:29:34 than that.

0:29:35 So, family number two is a mom who comes in with her two young kids.

0:29:38 I don't have a picture of her receipt from that day, but this is her total savings.

0:29:43 This year, she has saved over $3,600 lifetime since she got her card in 2021,

0:29:49 over $17,000 she has saved by using the library.

0:29:53 And again, just like the other family, if her husband and kids also have cards,

0:29:59 if we would have added up the total, it would have been even larger.

0:30:03 So family number three, this is a family of six

0:30:07 with four young kids.

0:30:09 So mom comes in, she checked out 13 items,

0:30:13 saved $163 and over $16,000 since she started using the library.

0:30:19 So we realized that people are still struggling

0:30:22 in this economy.

0:30:23 Every dollar matters, people are working hard

0:30:26 to provide for themselves and their families.

0:30:28 We also realized how important it is

0:30:30 to be good stewards of public funds.

0:30:33 So I hope that these examples show how the money that is

0:30:38 invested in the library, our building, our materials, our

0:30:40 staff goes right back into the community and really impacts

0:30:45 the citizens of Twin Falls.

0:30:47 So the next thing that I want to talk about is my favorite

0:30:50 thing at the library, our programs and activities that

0:30:52 we offer.

0:30:53 So last year, we did 641 programs and over 20,000 people

0:30:58 attended those programs.

0:31:00 So this year we are asking for $7,000 for our programs

0:31:04 and activities.

0:31:06 At the library, we truly do have programs for every age.

0:31:09 We offer everything from multiple age-specific story times

0:31:13 to our kindergarten readiness program,

0:31:15 to team cooking classes, history presentations,

0:31:19 genealogy classes, everything.

0:31:21 We have regular programs that we offer every week

0:31:24 or every month, but then we also have special one-off

0:31:26 programs that we bring in.

0:31:28 A lot of times we bring in the experts from the community and beyond to present our programs.

0:31:34 All of our programs are research based and we're constantly reevaluating our programs

0:31:39 based on the needs and interests of our patrons.

0:31:42 So each year we increase the number of programs that we do and all of our programs are free

0:31:47 and open to the public.

0:31:48 So the money that we spend on our programs allow us to provide these opportunities for

0:31:53 education, enrichment, and entertainment all at no cost to the citizens of Twin Falls who

0:31:59 come to the programs. So along with our regular budget, there are two special projects that we're

0:32:05 asking funding for. So first we are asking for $49,000 for Phase 3 of our carpeting project.

0:32:12 As I mentioned, we average about 586 visitors a day and we're open six days a week. So you can

0:32:17 imagine that with that much use, there is wear and tear on the carpet. So Phase 3 of the carpet is

0:32:23 the lower floor of the library including our very busy and yes sometimes messy youth services

0:32:31 department. So I was working at the library the last time that we did recarpeting and we did the

0:32:36 entire library at the same time. Doing our recarpeting in phases over several years like we are right now

0:32:43 is I think has made it much more manageable not only for staff but I feel like it has also caused

0:32:49 less overall disruption for the patrons and then we are also asking for $10,000 for a boiler

0:32:57 htf or heat transfer fluid pump so the pump is critical to the function of our boiler so the boiler

0:33:04 has two pumps to help reduce the overall strain on the system and then also act as a backup if one fails

0:33:10 so replacing the htf pump will ensure that the boiler continues to function and also provide a

0:33:16 comfortable environment for patrons and for staff. Thank you again for the

0:33:21 opportunity to come and speak with you tonight and thank you for the support of

0:33:25 the library and the critical work that we do. If you have any questions about our

0:33:29 budget or about the library in general please don't hesitate to reach out. We

0:33:35 look forward to continuing to serve our community. We're deeply committed to

0:33:40 providing the citizens of Twin Falls with opportunities to learn and grow

0:33:44 and connect over the next year and for many years to come.

0:33:50 So with that, I would stand for any questions.

0:33:54 Otherwise, thank you so much for having us.

0:33:56 Any questions?

0:33:57 No.

0:33:59 Thank you very much.

0:34:00 Thank you.

0:34:01 Appreciate it.

0:34:03 Thank you.

0:34:04 Chief Brooks is next.

0:34:07 To me now, because you're walking down this direction.

0:34:13 Well, good evening, mayor, council,

0:34:15 and everybody that's in attendance.

0:34:18 Big shout out to Erica.

0:34:19 she has a lot of energy and she's going to be hard to follow, to be honest with you.

0:34:24 So I basically want to talk to you a little bit about what the fire department has going

0:34:32 on here in the next coming fiscal year as well as what we just accomplished and are finishing

0:34:39 up.

0:34:40 So obviously we're working off of the 2030 vision and you can see at the bottom of this

0:34:47 screen the objectives that are directed towards the fire

0:34:50 apartment.

0:34:51 They're mainly looking at our training,

0:34:54 our partnerships, our MOUs, Councilman Grayson.

0:34:58 You and I spoke a little bit about MOUs a couple weeks back.

0:35:03 And it's also to ensure that we have proper response

0:35:07 for what the community really needs.

0:35:09 So I'm excited to move on from 2030

0:35:13 and look into the 2040 strategic plan.

0:35:16 think there's a lot of good things that are going to be inserted into that. So just a recap

0:35:22 last year, I'm not going to give you an annual report, but I did want to just show a little

0:35:26 bit of stats of what our year look like. Essentially, I mean, I'm not going to read this to you.

0:35:33 You can see the amount of calls that we go to, the significant structure fires that we have,

0:35:40 amount of EMS calls, which is about 71% of our workload. And at the bottom, I'm proud of

0:35:47 the number. I wish this was a zero fire loss, but that's in reality impossible. So basically

0:35:54 what that says is we save about 82% of a building when we respond to a structure fire. So I think

0:36:02 that's a pretty good return on investment and that's something that we are working on to improve

0:36:07 on. So some things that we did accomplish in our the current budget year is the type

0:36:16 six brush truck which I recently came to council and got authorization to pay for

0:36:20 that and we have a three thousand gallon of water tender that our couple staff

0:36:26 members are going to pick it up this week. They're going to inspect it and so

0:36:31 hopefully we'll have that soon. We have a twenty thousand dollar equipment line

0:36:37 that's inside of our budget. We're very thankful to have it this year. We had some

0:36:41 thermal imager that went bad that we had to purchase. We were able to use those

0:36:46 funds to replace them. And then just the miscellaneous equipment that you see

0:36:51 listed at the bottom. Here's some pictures of the Type 6 brush truck that has arrived

0:37:00 and is getting upfitted as we speak. Very beautiful light truck. It's a Fi50

0:37:08 very agile. This will certainly help us in our operations. Here's a picture that

0:37:16 just hot off the press that we got recently of the tender that we purchased.

0:37:21 I made a comment today that this is the most sophisticated technology driven

0:37:27 water truck that I have ever seen in my career, but I think everything on it

0:37:31 serves a purpose that will help us in our operations. We do have a lease payment

0:37:40 that we will be having to pay for next fiscal year.

0:37:46 These monies come out of the impact fees,

0:37:48 the fire impact fees.

0:37:53 We do have two lease payments for type one fire engines

0:37:57 in our coming budget.

0:37:59 Thankfully, I believe engine one,

0:38:02 that'll be our final payment

0:38:03 on that particular piece of apparatus.

0:38:07 And they are twins, those aren't the same apparatus.

0:38:10 We order them and it's intentional that they look the same

0:38:13 and they're actually set up the same with all the equipment on them.

0:38:19 That moves me into a remodel project that we're taking on.

0:38:23 Here is a picture of station one when it was first built.

0:38:26 Kind of hard to see on these screens.

0:38:29 Hopefully the screens behind me show this better.

0:38:32 Pretty cool picture.

0:38:34 This was taken in 1975.

0:38:38 The president at the time to take a little stab

0:38:42 and use Chance Munn's analogy of a little history.

0:38:46 Gerald Ford was the president.

0:38:51 Bobby Bope was the fire chief.

0:38:56 And Jean-Malar was the city manager.

0:38:59 So I don't know Travis, did you happen to meet?

0:39:03 That was a long time ago.

0:39:05 And I was born right here too.

0:39:09 So, Councilman Hawkins, do you remember those people?

0:39:12 I'm just, good question.

0:39:14 I wasn't going there. I wasn't going there. I was going to age myself. You know, looking

0:39:19 at the age of the council, you know, you might be going into history.

0:39:22 Let's move on here. Anyway, this is a 70s version of our fire station. This happens to

0:39:28 be our bathroom that we share, whether it's male, female. We've had to do some accommodations.

0:39:34 This wall, this white wall that you're seeing, had to be put in just so that we can make sure

0:39:39 that both genders had opportunity.

0:39:43 This is looking down the hall of station one.

0:39:47 Here's the kitchen.

0:39:49 You can see it's just, it's time.

0:39:53 You guys have really supported us, city administration support us

0:39:57 and modernizing our fire station and rightfully so.

0:40:01 So it's really time to give this station some attention.

0:40:07 We're looking at 1.63 million to do the project and we're really focused on the core inner parts of the building so we're looking at bathrooms, kitchen, bedrooms.

0:40:20 But the problem is we've gotten through the design and the costs are much higher than we anticipated.

0:40:28 And so we have competing projects with police fire, they want to build an evidence building.

0:40:35 I'd like to see a remodel here.

0:40:38 We've worked really well together and kind of ironed out some things and to chief Hicks'

0:40:43 credit and his staff.

0:40:45 They have elected to let us take the priority and we're hoping to see this funded.

0:40:51 If prices are too high, we'll defer back to them.

0:40:58 I'd like to introduce, I'll pause if you have any questions on what I talked about before I introduce

0:41:07 any questions for chief. So this is Deputy Fire Chief Smith.

0:41:16 Good evening Mr. Mayor Council. This first slide, I'll go through a couple of slides here that

0:41:22 represent the regional training facility. It represents a significant and important portion of our

0:41:28 ongoing maintenance and operation budget. The facility supports readiness of not

0:41:33 only our own personnel but also serving as a regional resource that

0:41:38 strengthens interoperability, improves, how agencies work together prior to complex

0:41:45 incidents. This slide over the past year the facility supported two regional

0:41:52 recruit firefighter academies and a regional driver operator academy

0:41:57 covering mobile water supply, driver operator pumper, driver operator aerial

0:42:02 operations. These programs included 12 windfalls firefighters and 13 members from

0:42:09 surrounding departments. The facility also supports training for our our our all

0:42:14 hazard rescue team and our regional hazardous materials team. Beyond the

0:42:22 Fire Service, the training center is also used by law enforcement, regional

0:42:26 SWAT teams, the Idaho National Guard, College of Southern Idaho programs,

0:42:31 Wildman Fire Agencies, Rescue teams outside of Twin Falls Fire, Leadership

0:42:36 Groups, Fire Investigators, and other community and regional partners. This

0:42:40 investment gives agencies a place to train together before an emergency occurs,

0:42:44 improving coordination, communication, and the overall effectiveness of our all

0:42:49 hazards response. Moving into some of the capital requests operationally, the first is portable

0:42:59 mobile radio replacement. Reliable radio communications is critical for firefighter safety, command

0:43:06 and control, dispatch coordination and regional interoperability. This request replaces aging

0:43:13 portable and mobile radios and helps standardize equipment across our department. The request

0:43:19 was reduced to focus only on outfitting our frontline apparatus and response vehicles,

0:43:28 tablets to support our internal processes. These tablets provide firefighters with a mobile platform

0:43:35 for emergency medical charting and reporting at the point of care. They reduce reliance on hand

0:43:42 written notes, which the photo on the right is how we do business today, eliminates duplicate data

0:43:48 entry and improves the accuracy and timeliness of patient documentation.

0:43:53 They will also get first responders quick access to prefire plans, occupancy information, and

0:43:59 other critical response data while in the field.

0:44:02 Over time, they may actually support electronic records sharing as patients move from field

0:44:07 care to transport agencies and ultimately to definitive health care facilities.

0:44:16 Outfitting new fire engine, as you know, we got a new fire engine this year.

0:44:21 This request provides the updated tools, hose, appliances, and response equipment needed to

0:44:26 outfit the new fire engine with modern and fully operational equipment complement.

0:44:31 It also allows for the older equipment that's currently on it, but still serviceable equipment

0:44:36 to be reassigned from frontline apparatus to our reserve apparatus.

0:44:42 This supports our goal of maintaining reserve apparatus in a ready status, reducing time-consuming

0:44:48 equipment transfers and improves readiness when off-duty personnel are called back to

0:44:53 staff reserve units.

0:44:57 He Brooks mentioned this a little earlier, but this fire department equipment request

0:45:02 is the flexibility to replace the essential equipment that becomes damaged, unreliable,

0:45:08 or unexpectedly reaches its end of service life.

0:45:11 These needs are not always predictable during the normal budget process and can be directly

0:45:15 or can directly affect emergency response.

0:45:21 Last year, as he mentioned, this funding was used to replace thermal imaging cameras that

0:45:24 had become an operable mid-year.

0:45:31 The Wildland Urban Interface Firefighting Gear provides lightweight durable hose packs, protective

0:45:38 equipment and specialized tools for vegetation in Wildland and Urban Interface fires.

0:45:45 The equipment improves firefighter mobility, water delivery, and endurance in areas where

0:45:49 structural firefighting equipment may not be appropriate.

0:45:53 The request represents a second half of last fiscal year's planned investment and will complete

0:45:59 our goal of updating the department's wildland firefighting equipment complement as it was

0:46:03 intended.

0:46:07 Next, we have ventilation modernization.

0:46:11 This standardizes aging ventilation fans with modern battery powered electric equipment.

0:46:19 These fans improve smoke and heat removal during structure fires while reducing the use of gasoline

0:46:24 powered equipment that can introduce additional carbon monoxide into the incident environment.

0:46:31 They will operate on the same battery platform used by other tools in our equipment complement,

0:46:36 improving standardization, reliability, and ease of use.

0:46:39 These fans are also valuable on lower acuity incidents, such as minor stovetop or oven fires,

0:46:46 where smoke removal may allow occupants to safely return to the structure sooner.

0:46:51 Because the fans do not produce exhaust, crews can ventilate these spaces without adding carbon

0:46:56 monoxide from gasoline-powered equipment.

0:46:59 Overall this modernization improves our operational flexibility.

0:47:07 Okay, so these individual situational awareness thermal imager cameras are different than

0:47:12 in what was replaced last year.

0:47:15 The request provides individual handheld thermal imaging

0:47:18 cameras intended primarily for firefighter orientation

0:47:21 and situational awareness.

0:47:25 Situational awareness and smoke-filled

0:47:27 and limited visibility environments.

0:47:29 These smaller cameras help firefighters identify walls,

0:47:32 doors, furniture, changing heat conditions,

0:47:35 impossible travel paths, reducing the risk

0:47:38 of disorientation during interior operations.

0:47:42 These units are different from the larger,

0:47:43 High resolution thermal imaging cameras carried on frontline apparatus and used by officers for tactical decision-making, victim searches, fire location, size up and hazard assessment.

0:47:55 The individual cameras supplement, not replace, those tactical cameras by giving firefighters immediate access to basic thermal imaging capability while operating inside a structure.

0:48:10 That is all I have if you have any questions.

0:48:14 Any questions?

0:48:15 Thank you.

0:48:17 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it. Apologize. I forgot to introduce our

0:48:24 foreign marshals. Thank you Deputy Fire Chief Smith, Mr. Mayor Council and our

0:48:34 lovely citizens of Twin Falls. I'm just gonna wrap it up with this final slide

0:48:40 in our presentation for the evening and in the prevention division we've

0:48:45 really kind of turned a corner this year and bringing in CRRs, community

0:48:50 risk reduction. It's been around the country as a best practice for a decade or

0:48:57 more now. Our own governor has the last two years has signed this into proclamation in

0:49:03 January as Community Risk Reduction Week. So it's getting attraction here in Idaho

0:49:08 and Chief Smith and I attended a conference for this year to understand

0:49:12 what it really means and we see this as a solution moving forward to install this

0:49:19 into our framework as the fire department. Community risk reduction takes the same

0:49:25 thing we've always kind of been doing but it really categorizes it and it puts it

0:49:29 into a streamlined order. Bottom line is our goal is the fire department is to

0:49:35 reduce our community's risk and using a proactive approach, right? We have the 911

0:49:41 calls that's our reactive service. We've been doing that forever. We will continue to

0:49:45 do that forever. A lot of that training that Chief Smith talked about is

0:49:47 preparing for the reactiveness of our fire department, but in the name of my

0:49:53 division, the prevention division, it goes without saying that we're supposed to be

0:49:57 and need to be more proactive in our community. So we're looking at ways to be

0:50:02 proactive in the pre-emergency setting. How can we prevent emergencies before they

0:50:07 even begin in the first place? Post-emergency, when we have an emergency of

0:50:11 any scale in that community, what can we do? How do we look at that? We've always

0:50:16 We can understand that with fire investigations,

0:50:18 if we can figure out how the fire started,

0:50:20 we can educate the public how to reduce that risk,

0:50:23 but it also goes into things like even slips,

0:50:25 trips and falls, which is one of our biggest factors

0:50:28 in our medical response.

0:50:29 How can we team up with members like MVP

0:50:33 and the KEMS program and different partners

0:50:35 to lower that risk to educate our community,

0:50:38 to help even there in the home with our elderly

0:50:41 who might be falling down on a regular basis?

0:50:45 how can we help them with that?

0:50:47 CRR is all based on data.

0:50:49 So we're looking in the future in our budget request

0:50:53 to improve that data, and there's two pronged approach

0:50:57 will be coming in the months and years ahead.

0:50:59 It's called CRA and SOC.

0:51:01 CRA is Community Risk Assessment,

0:51:04 and that is doing studies, not just using our database,

0:51:08 but getting outside into the demographic data space

0:51:12 that's there, and it's also getting into the community,

0:51:15 getting into the community members and hearing from them.

0:51:18 What is our community needing?

0:51:20 What are our risks in our own community?

0:51:23 And then the SOC, the standards of cover,

0:51:26 is the program in which will help us to utilize

0:51:30 our equipment and our personnel in the best choice,

0:51:34 the best choice for that action.

0:51:36 And it helps us to respond to that CRA,

0:51:39 effectively doing more with less

0:51:43 and doing it more efficiently and effectively for the community.

0:51:46 So we recognize we're here for the public, for the community,

0:51:50 and this tool, CRR, is going to help us to dig into that even better.

0:51:56 We have one project we're working on.

0:51:58 I'm working on it with parks very closely in the county with WUI,

0:52:02 which is a wildland urban interface, which this time of year is very evident for us.

0:52:07 We have several areas in our own city that have a wildland threat.

0:52:11 So we're working very hard to gather data

0:52:14 and to build those partnerships,

0:52:16 to reduce that risk, and eliminate,

0:52:20 and build a mitigation process in our own area

0:52:24 so we can help build a safer community.

0:52:27 And that is what we're working on in the future.

0:52:30 Any questions from me or any of the fire presentation?

0:52:32 Any questions?

0:52:35 Thank you.

0:52:36 Outstanding, thank you.

0:52:37 I appreciate it.

0:52:41 And now I introduce the police chief

0:52:44 the Twin Falls Police Department, Matthew Hicks.

0:52:46 Thank you.

0:52:50 Well, good evening, Mayor and Council.

0:52:54 We're excited to talk to you tonight.

0:52:56 I just wanted to reflect that I've

0:52:57 had a chance to present to numerous councils

0:53:00 during my 32 career in three different buildings.

0:53:04 And I can remember years that we've had one, two,

0:53:06 sometimes years we've had nobody come to hear our budget

0:53:10 proposal.

0:53:10 So this is actually remarkable and kind of exciting for us.

0:53:15 As you know, the T.F.P.E. strives to maintain, build upon the one successful thing that all police departments have, and that's community trust.

0:53:26 So at the core of what we do, that's the core of the culture of our organization, we try to solve problems as one city, and we're guided by our values and those that we serve.

0:53:35 This department has a 119-year tradition of providing professionalism, respect, integrity,

0:53:41 dignity, and excellence to our community, and we're committed to maintaining and building

0:53:46 that trust.

0:53:47 So we're going to do this in two parts tonight.

0:53:49 We want to briefly review our fiscal year 26 capital, and because we just gave you our annual

0:53:56 report in May, we're going to just highlight a few of the things we touched upon that night.

0:54:00 And I'm going to turn the time over to Sergeant Dave White, who was our representative on the

0:54:05 the long-term planning committee.

0:54:06 We're gonna talk about some of our capital requests

0:54:08 for this year, and then I will come back to the podium

0:54:10 to talk about the topic that I'm assuming most people

0:54:12 here tonight talk about ADOPR

0:54:14 and are arranging with the Flaw Corporation.

0:54:16 So before we get going, I wanna talk real quickly

0:54:18 about your police department.

0:54:21 As you've heard several times before,

0:54:23 we are policing a population much larger

0:54:26 than the number of residents that we have.

0:54:27 By most estimates, this is at 110,000 people

0:54:30 or more on a daily basis.

0:54:32 With a police department that's staffed,

0:54:33 police exactly half of that population.

0:54:37 Just for the record, we have 123 employees

0:54:39 that work for the Police Department,

0:54:40 or we are budgeted for, 82 of those are police officers.

0:54:45 As of today, we have three vacancies,

0:54:48 we have six officers that are in different forms

0:54:50 of initial training, one who's on maternity leave,

0:54:54 and one who's injured.

0:54:55 That leaves us with 71 police officers,

0:54:57 myself included, to perform all the breath of policing services

0:55:00 that are cities demand.

0:55:02 24-hour patrol, our detectives, our special operations, and special investigation groups,

0:55:07 or school resource officers, our canine, our training, and all the administrative functions.

0:55:11 I just want to also give you an update.

0:55:14 Brent Wright and Manny Thompson worked tirelessly over the last two years, and they were able

0:55:17 to get our COPSAP population turned in three days ahead of schedule, which we think is

0:55:21 a record.

0:55:22 We'll be asking for four additional positions in that grant, hopefully we'll be successful.

0:55:29 The reasons why people come to Twin Falls vary, as you all know.

0:55:32 They shop here, they get medical attention here.

0:55:35 They come here to work for education, tourism, and entertainment.

0:55:39 As much as everybody wants sometimes, we simply cannot put a cop on every corner.

0:55:44 I checked the number of officers working at this very moment right before it shifts change

0:55:48 is nine officers working in patrol, policing a population of over 100,000 people at this

0:55:53 moment in time.

0:55:54 But we try to use the technology and the tools that we're best can to police the people

0:56:00 that we're tasked with keeping the safety of.

0:56:02 policing means modern tools. We're determined to find a solution in using those tools that

0:56:07 everybody can live with while giving our officers the best possible tools to do their job. By all

0:56:12 accounts, we are an exceptionally busy police department and we hear that mostly from officers

0:56:16 that we recruit from other organizations that have worked in large metropolitan organizations.

0:56:22 As indicated on those slides, almost 8,000 of our calls are priority ones and twos,

0:56:27 those are calls of where we are immediately needed on scene or there's urgency to get there.

0:56:31 We took over 6,000 case reports last year.

0:56:35 We arrested nearly 2,000 people in the completion of our tests.

0:56:38 In order to try and maintain traffic safety, we conducted nearly over 10,000 traffic stops.

0:56:44 Our notable calls for service are indicated there.

0:56:46 I'm not going to read them or read them.

0:56:48 Last year, Lieutenant Diamond reported you a couple months ago.

0:56:51 We had a notable increase in crashes, a very disturbing trend last year,

0:56:54 which we hope is an anomaly.

0:56:56 We had nine fatal crashes within the city limits of Twin Falls.

0:56:59 A number of those were injury and as we have been seeing, there is a trend with eBikes and

0:57:05 eMores cycles that we are dealing with on an educational level and there is a possibility

0:57:10 that we may be presenting an alternative to you for city ordinance.

0:57:14 Please know this.

0:57:15 I am always very hesitant to have the police department present legislation to you.

0:57:19 We are looking for partners on this topic to work together and try to find a solution and

0:57:24 educate our public rather than having a heavy hand of enforcement to deal with this issue.

0:57:29 As we present our capital projects to you for consideration, we completely understand that

0:57:34 there's great interest in our systems as it should be.

0:57:37 We want to offer policing, servants, and a manner that our community expects and understands.

0:57:43 We want to use these developing technologies in a way that we can all live with and produce

0:57:46 the results that they demand.

0:57:48 We appreciate the interest in ALPR technology because it raises serious concerns that deserve

0:57:53 a serious response.

0:57:55 Privacy and constitutional rights and public trust, these are not side issues for their

0:57:59 of the Police Department,

0:58:00 they're at the core of how we operate.

0:58:03 We will be reviewing capital purchases

0:58:05 for the current fiscal year

0:58:06 and the recapping our request for 27,

0:58:09 and I'll be coming back up at the end

0:58:10 to talk about AOPR and our FLOC program.

0:58:13 I'd like to turn the microphone out

0:58:15 over to Sergeant Dave White.

0:58:17 Thanks Chief.

0:58:24 David Mayer and members of council

0:58:26 and those in attendance.

0:58:29 So I'm here to speak with you

0:58:31 because I am the rep for long-term planning

0:58:34 from the Police Department in the last couple of cycles.

0:58:37 So to start, I'm gonna give you just a little bit of a recap

0:58:40 on some of the major things that we accomplished

0:58:42 with last year's approved budget for our capital items.

0:58:46 One there on the left is a upgraded packaging island

0:58:49 in our evidence packaging area as a stainless steel top

0:58:52 so that we can effectively sanitize

0:58:56 and avoid cross-contamination issues with evidence.

0:58:59 You can see on this angle of the photo,

0:59:01 there are digital lockers.

0:59:04 That is so we can return evidence that the evidence room did not accept from an officer,

0:59:10 but it can still remain secure for chain of custody purposes.

0:59:14 And the other side of that island is compartments for packaging materials and what.

0:59:19 Then on the photo on the right request last year that came by way of the police department

0:59:24 through code enforcement was a request for epoxy and the kennel floors at the animal

0:59:30 shelter to prevent disease spread and those sort of concerns with animals with porous concrete

0:59:37 that couldn't effectively be sanitized. So that project was completed.

0:59:44 So, recap, continuing from FY26. I believe this would be probably phase three of our long-term

0:59:53 evidence storage and training center design. That amount was allocated by council last year.

1:00:00 for the rest of the expenditure for the architect design through completion.

1:00:07 We were also able to purchase and replace four aged patrol vehicles that were 10 years old

1:00:14 and probably had 150,000 miles on them at that point.

1:00:19 We were able to purchase 15 slot headsets that are compatible with their existing helmets

1:00:26 and reliable communication and tactical situations

1:00:29 and emergency situations.

1:00:32 The HDU SCBA system is a breathing apparatus,

1:00:35 like you see the fire personnel wear,

1:00:37 for our bomb squad members.

1:00:40 If you remember the last presentation,

1:00:43 that was so that they could not choose between

1:00:47 wearing their ballistic helmet or wearing a breathing

1:00:50 apparatus that this machine will allow them

1:00:53 to wear both and be fully protected.

1:00:54 And then the Elevate Academy SRO, this is a charter school that wanted to have SRO services.

1:01:03 And the city's obligation is 10% of that expense is elevating 90% of that obligation.

1:01:12 And this is the overall list.

1:01:13 I won't go into great detail of any of these because we're going to do so on certain ones

1:01:18 as we move through additional slides.

1:01:21 The big item there that has been earmarked in reserves

1:01:25 is construction costs of the evidence,

1:01:28 storage and training center,

1:01:30 and subsequent design of what we call phase two and phase three.

1:01:34 The initial phase is the long-term evidence portion.

1:01:38 Phase two would be adding a space

1:01:42 for having training area, classrooms,

1:01:45 mat rooms, heating rooms for off-site training.

1:01:49 And then the third phase would be the eventual probable move

1:01:53 of all of our day-to-day evidence out of our existing building

1:01:56 to this location to free up necessary space

1:01:58 in the main police facility.

1:02:00 So we want to try to design all three phases at once

1:02:03 so that we're not reinventing the wheel

1:02:05 and wishing we had made different choices at a different phase.

1:02:09 So we're making sure that those designs are happening

1:02:12 concurrent with the regional design for the evidence area.

1:02:17 this year's ask we again have four additional patrol vehicles to replace

1:02:20 aged patrol vehicles the next item is the flock safety real-time information

1:02:27 program what they refer to as safe cities.

1:02:29 Grayson has a question real quick for you okay thank you Mr. Mayor are we going to

1:02:36 be removing the flock safety real-time information program from my budget my

1:02:42 understanding is that is correct at this point I'm just

1:02:46 I guess there's a lot of people in the audience that are probably steering at your back right

1:02:53 now that are wanting to know about that.

1:02:56 The chief was going to address that when he comes back up.

1:03:00 The next item is to patrol motorcycles.

1:03:05 We have two aged Honda motorcycles that are not made anymore and so they, you know, to

1:03:12 to repair them and keep them operational

1:03:14 and have replacement parts become non-existent.

1:03:16 So that would pay for two police motorcycles

1:03:19 and all the upfitting necessary to put them into service.

1:03:22 The next item is a vehicle for our victim service position.

1:03:27 We have two of those positions.

1:03:29 One is filled and one is still going through

1:03:32 a hiring process, but using opioid funds,

1:03:36 we would purchase a vehicle for their use

1:03:38 to work with victims.

1:03:40 The next item is a $20,000 patrol equipment line, which is similar to the fire department's

1:03:45 equipment line for those unforeseen needs to replace or repair things that have gone out

1:03:51 of service.

1:03:53 The next item is ICAC storage, which is our internet crimes against children, storage,

1:03:59 physical hardware to store those internet crime evidence.

1:04:04 The next item is Everbridge software.

1:04:06 is a software that's used for mass emergency notifications,

1:04:11 geographical notifications,

1:04:12 and the event of emergencies.

1:04:14 Right now, that program is owned

1:04:17 and operated through CERCOM,

1:04:19 and there was some discussion about them

1:04:22 possibly looking to go away from that,

1:04:24 and we're charging cities that are using

1:04:27 the Everbridge software under their ownership.

1:04:30 So preemptively, we're trying to acquire our own

1:04:34 for the ever-bitch software that way we're not reliant on the other entity if they

1:04:38 should choose to go away from it. A next item is scheduling software to a better

1:04:44 schedule instead of on paper and excel spreadsheets and wall calendars. All of

1:04:49 the members of the Patrol Division include special assignments and special

1:04:53 events that come up throughout the year. This and then the next item is the

1:04:57 SWAT team replacement plates for their vests. There's a lifespan of five years on

1:05:05 ballistic panels and things for that protective equipment, but for 15 members

1:05:11 of the team it's a large bill to try to replace all. Excuse me all at once. So

1:05:16 this would be phase two of three buying those in segments overlapping years

1:05:20 with exploration years of those that equipment. The next four items are

1:05:26 things that we're asking how to approve from asset forfeiture funds, one being a

1:05:32 patrol canine vehicle, a crime lab fingerprint fuming chamber for the crime

1:05:37 lab to be able to fingerprint articles and items in-house rather than the

1:05:41 delays sending them to the crime lab. The one machine we have now is from early

1:05:45 2000s and it's reliably worked well for a while. And then purchase for a

1:05:53 special desigations unit of a band and portable radios for inter-agency operations that they

1:06:01 might do with partner agencies that would not have our frequency on their radios, we

1:06:06 would be able to provide them radios. This is a rendering of the outside of the proposed,

1:06:14 where we're at so far in the design phase for the evidence, the long-term evidence.

1:06:19 There are garage bays there to pull vehicles through for processing or vehicle storage for

1:06:26 evidence purposes.

1:06:29 Then also on this property would be a large fence in yard for outside vehicle storage.

1:06:34 I already spoke ahead of time on Everbridge, but it does have its own slide if there's any

1:06:44 questions that I didn't answer about what Everbridge is and why we're asking for it.

1:06:51 I don't see any.

1:06:53 Okay.

1:06:54 questions about anything that I have preliminary presented before we go through the rest of

1:06:58 the presentation and I know a number of those things will still be addressed further by those

1:07:02 that follow. Any other questions? Thank you very much. I turn the time over to Lieutenant

1:07:08 Luke Gallo. Good evening, Mayor and members of Council. I'll continue with what David already

1:07:20 presented. I'm going to present the slides on some specific items moving forward. If you

1:07:25 have any questions about those, these are the items that we thought maybe some questions

1:07:28 would arise. So I'll present on those with the slides, if you have any questions, please

1:07:32 let me know. First will be the police motorcycles that we're requesting. One of the things with

1:07:37 this, I don't know if Sergeant White mentioned, was the Honda motorcycles, we can no longer

1:07:43 service so we're, they don't make the parts form. So that's what we're moving forward and

1:07:46 requesting these purchase for different motorcycles. Next is the ICAC storage. What this is just

1:07:54 for an explanation is we have digital and forensic evidence that we collect from cell phones and

1:07:58 computers that we cannot store in the cloud. They cannot be cloud-based. They have to be on a secure

1:08:02 server. This will give us approximately 50 terabytes of storage to continue with the year. This is kind

1:08:09 of an ongoing thing. I think you've seen, we ask for this quite often just because we use so much

1:08:14 store so much data there. Next is the 191 funds. These are the asset Forfister funds. These do

1:08:20 not come out of the direct budget. These are from things that we see. This would be the K9 vehicle

1:08:26 in the crime lab fuming chamber, that's for us to do.

1:08:30 One thing we've not been able to do for several years

1:08:32 is process our own fingerprinting on items

1:08:35 that have different materials on them

1:08:38 and what this fuming chamber allows our crime lab personnel

1:08:40 to do is put them in and use a chemical to pull fingerprints

1:08:43 off that we can then send to the state lab,

1:08:45 rather than have the state lab take the item from us,

1:08:48 pull the fingerprints themselves.

1:08:49 This helps us save time and process our own evidence that way.

1:08:54 These are the council directed capital items that we're requesting that for your consideration for this upcoming fiscal year, one is a CID vehicle for approximately 50,000.

1:09:05 This is to replace a old Ford focus that we've been using to transport evidence to the state lab, as well as we use it for training and other departments and within the city have also requested to use that vehicle for us.

1:09:18 We are also requesting for your consideration for ballistic shields.

1:09:23 These are pistol rated ballistic shields for our police officers to have in their patrol

1:09:28 cars.

1:09:29 This is to outfit four cars that we have on our current fleet that are not equipped with

1:09:35 these ballistic shields.

1:09:36 So this is to make sure every car in our fleet has these pistol rated ballistic shields.

1:09:43 Also for consideration, we're asking for a 40 millimeter tactical four shot launcher.

1:09:48 This is a less-than-lethal launcher that shoots impactor, like a bean bag, a big bean bag,

1:09:56 and some impact munitions.

1:09:59 This is similar to the shotguns that we carry that shoot bean bags, but this one shoots a

1:10:03 larger projectile.

1:10:04 It's a little bit actually more safe because of the size of it.

1:10:07 The smaller one-ounce bean bag can have a tendency to weld or maybe even cause more injury

1:10:15 because of the size of it.

1:10:17 And then we're also asking for some crowd control equipment.

1:10:21 This would outfit 20 officers, it wouldn't outfit all of our officers, but we would know

1:10:25 that this would allow for officers if we had an incident that we needed for crowd control.

1:10:31 We could get 20 officers out there who would have helmets with face shields, clear shield

1:10:35 and a large baton for those things.

1:10:38 I know I went through this fairly quickly.

1:10:40 Is there any questions on any of the slides that I presented?

1:10:44 Any additional questions?

1:10:45 Thank you.

1:10:46 Thank you.

1:10:47 All right.

1:10:48 I would like to invite Chief Hicks back up.

1:10:49 Thank you.

1:10:50 Thanks.

1:11:01 So during my first council meeting with you last year as your police chief, I stated that

1:11:04 public trust is the basis in the foundation of effective policing.

1:11:09 As we progress as a team, we want to focus on strengthening that trust with those that

1:11:13 we serve.

1:11:14 We firmly believe that police legitimacy is predicated on public trust and requires collaboration

1:11:20 between a law enforcement and the community.

1:11:22 We engage in programs like Copy with a COP and Citizens Academy and the National AI Program

1:11:29 will be hosting next week on August 4th to do exactly that, to generate conversations with

1:11:34 those that we serve to find out how we are doing.

1:11:36 Our primary goal as an organization is always to maintain and build upon your trust.

1:11:42 And during this discussion tonight, we want to highlight some technologies that we've been

1:11:46 using, answer some questions in advance, perhaps what the system does and what it doesn't do,

1:11:52 And then to listen, during my early days of TFPD in the early 1990s, it could be said

1:11:58 that we were an organization that did not enjoy the same level of trust that we do today.

1:12:02 While we had good people working for us back then, we were not policing in a way that the

1:12:07 community demanded.

1:12:08 I've been told that a community serving taken in the mid-90s indicated that only 39% of our

1:12:13 citizens at that time thought we were doing a good or excellent job.

1:12:17 I've always reflected on that.

1:12:18 I thought nearly 7 out of 10 people at that moment in time did not have our trust and we

1:12:24 did not have theirs.

1:12:26 While we always are striving to make that better, we've been telling officers and employees

1:12:30 for years that we must never take the current trust that we enjoy for granted.

1:12:35 We implemented community policing standards nearly the entire course of my career over

1:12:39 30 years ago and hopefully our efforts tonight will reflect that.

1:12:44 As we present this project to you, we understand that there is great public interest in this

1:12:49 system.

1:12:50 We look forward to presenting the why behind our request tonight and listen for feedback.

1:12:55 Objects and things in technology, hopefully we can all agree, can never replace good police

1:13:00 officers.

1:13:01 And the TFPD has the best officers around me, but these things should always make them better.

1:13:06 I'm in a unique position tonight to relay some information to you and our use of it.

1:13:12 One falls is a very safe community and we should all be very proud of that.

1:13:16 But we do have crime here.

1:13:18 Our goal is to have programs and systems that we can all live with while giving the men and

1:13:22 women in uniform the best tools that they have to solve crime.

1:13:27 I also want to tell you that we have been closely monitoring the public discourse on this topic

1:13:32 and we are listening.

1:13:33 Future and local statewide conversations are absolutely going to take place and we expect

1:13:38 this will be an issue taken up in the upcoming legislative session and we look forward to

1:13:41 part of that conversation. I want to tell you about three compromises that we've made or will

1:13:46 be proposing tonight in order to show that we are listening and we are more than willing to find a

1:13:50 solution that works for everybody. So I just want to reflect and maybe this might be news for people.

1:13:56 This marks the fifth year in a row and one of numerous presentations we've made in this room

1:14:02 to the city council regarding our use of automatic license plate readers.

1:14:07 For the last three years we have made numerous social media reports. We grant

1:14:11 and immediate interviews and outlined our program and our annual report like we did to you back May.

1:14:16 But in hindsight, I will be the first to admit that we could have done a better job of educating

1:14:20 our community about this. And we accept that. To be honest, Idaho has had some form of AL parallel

1:14:27 technology for almost 20 years. And we were not the first Department of Idaho to work with Flock.

1:14:33 For the last two years, I think we've all been under the assumption that this system

1:14:37 have been posed in a public forum and that we had widespread support for the system that

1:14:42 we were using. The Police Department's use of this technology is not a system to monitor

1:14:48 our residents' daily lives. Their political activity, their religious activity, medical

1:14:53 appointments or their lawful travel. The purpose of these cameras is much narrower. It's to

1:14:58 help identify vehicles that are connected to crimes or missing people. They help us with

1:15:05 the stolen vehicles, finding danger people,

1:15:07 wanted individuals to help us all hit and run,

1:15:10 investigations, solve burglary steps,

1:15:12 and other criminal investigations.

1:15:14 In reviewing our current program,

1:15:16 I wanna tell you about three changes that we'll be making.

1:15:18 But first, I wanna review our program for you.

1:15:21 So as I can indicate it up here,

1:15:23 our AOPR cameras were fully installed at the end of 2023.

1:15:27 We got 12 of them the first year

1:15:29 after presenting the council and receiving input.

1:15:33 This year, in 2026, we asked and we received $48,000

1:15:38 for 12 edition cameras, totally 40.

1:15:41 Currently, we are spending $128,500

1:15:45 on three different contracts with Vlog.

1:15:48 I wanna tell a little bit about some of our why,

1:15:51 behind why we first initially researched

1:15:53 and then proposed this technology,

1:15:55 because that story often gets lost in the comments.

1:16:00 There were several examples that happened

1:16:02 up to up to 10 years ago, examples.

1:16:04 we could have used this technology to solve cases quicker, if at all.

1:16:09 And these cases most notably include the vase in Whitman homicide,

1:16:13 15 year old young man that was shot during daylight here in Twin Falls.

1:16:17 We did not have this technology available and we spent weeks trying to find

1:16:20 the vehicle that was seen leaving the scene.

1:16:23 We helped with the Bule homicide a couple of years ago before we had the flock technology

1:16:27 in which an elderly lady was murdered in her home and then placed in the South Hills.

1:16:32 this technology would have been invaluable for that.

1:16:35 And finally, the Capri-Drive homicide,

1:16:37 which happened in the November of 2023,

1:16:40 right before the implementation of this.

1:16:43 So often in the comments I've read,

1:16:45 well, you've had this technology for only three years,

1:16:47 you were obviously solving crimes before,

1:16:49 why can't we just get rid of it and go back?

1:16:51 I just wanna highlight our why behind

1:16:53 the Capri-Drive homicide.

1:16:55 That tragic situation occurred on a cul-de-sac,

1:16:57 Capri-Drive, and the technology and our methods

1:17:00 not exactly rocket scientists. We found a door video camera on that cul-de-sac

1:17:07 depicting a white pickup truck with a toolbox leaving the scene about the

1:17:12 time of the shooting. We know that when you came when the person drove to Falls

1:17:16 Avenue they could either take a right or take a left. So we sent teams to the

1:17:20 right and to the left to try to find additional camera footage. We found

1:17:24 vehicle indicating it had taken a right. We kept following that path and it took

1:17:28 us the better part of a day to figure out the description and finally the license plate

1:17:32 for that vehicle.

1:17:33 Had we had the flock technology at that time, we would have been able to identify vehicles

1:17:37 moving at that time and night based on the description and we would have had a plate shortly

1:17:41 after it left when it falls.

1:17:43 That made an impression on us to try to find that vehicle before they could hurt anybody

1:17:47 else.

1:17:51 In February 2022, we were called to assist the old police department with a homicide investigation

1:17:56 involving an elderly female.

1:17:58 as I stated, detectives obtained surveillance footage

1:18:01 from the location of the victim's residence

1:18:03 and along the suspected route where her body was taken.

1:18:07 After narrowing the timeline,

1:18:09 surveillance was manually reviewed

1:18:10 and each vehicle was documented from each of these cameras

1:18:13 going to the suspected direction of travel.

1:18:15 In total, almost 1,400 vehicles were manually logged,

1:18:19 producing almost 10,000 individual data points

1:18:22 listed by their different characteristics

1:18:24 into a spreadsheet.

1:18:26 The volume of this information

1:18:27 in the limitations of manual comparison,

1:18:30 required investigators will not able to identify a match

1:18:33 during that process alone.

1:18:34 Later that May, detectives develop a suspect

1:18:37 through other investigative means,

1:18:39 and the spreadsheet was used to confirm

1:18:41 that suspects path to travel.

1:18:42 Had we had that this technology at the time,

1:18:44 we would have known that within hours, not months.

1:18:48 Now I'm gonna ask everybody to listen to these stories

1:18:50 and do something for me.

1:18:52 I want you to take a breath,

1:18:55 and I want you to place yourself in the role

1:18:56 of a family member of the people involved in these cases,

1:18:59 want you to ask yourself, you want your police department capable of using these tools. The

1:19:06 first case, the Scott Mead Prison Escape and Homicide. In March of 2024, inmates scoured

1:19:14 their need to escape the Department of Corrections custody during a violent incident at a Boise

1:19:19 hospital. Later that day, two homicides occurred in Northern Idaho. Mead and his accomplished

1:19:24 Nicholas Empower were suspected in the killings. The following day, the investigators revealed

1:19:29 information that the pair may be traveling in an unknown blue or silver minivan with wildlife

1:19:34 bluebird plates. The search for the minivan was conducted and a possible vehicle identified.

1:19:40 Officers ran this plate and it was associated with a case after receiving what we referred to as

1:19:46 an NCIC kit indicating that the vehicle belonged to the homicide victim. Later we learned that

1:19:51 the NCA data was placed minutes after it had entered Twin Falls. Had it been entered prior to

1:19:58 hitting the AOPR camera, our officers would have been immediately alerted it had entered our community.

1:20:04 Vescators know that the van left the city of Twin Falls west on pole line towards Filer,

1:20:09 where mean was known to have closed connections. The pair were located in Filer Bay that day,

1:20:13 and along with help from the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office, we were to apprehend both of

1:20:17 those individuals after a brief pursuit. The second case I want you to tell you about,

1:20:22 the one that really impacts me was done in the first several days after we implemented the flock

1:20:27 cameras. In February 2024, we received a flock alert and an NCIC hit on a wanted vehicle out of California.

1:20:35 The vehicle was seen leaving Twin Falls on Poland Road and the Twin Falls County Sheriff's

1:20:40 Office was alerted and they began searching for the vehicle as it had left Twin Falls.

1:20:44 26 minutes later, county deputies pulled the vehicle over near Rogerson. The driver had a

1:20:50 $1 million warrant for charge of sexual abuse for a minor child in its care. Yes, he was in the vehicle

1:20:56 with him. The nonverbal child, who was the victim in the case, was in the vehicle with

1:21:02 the suspect. The man was arrested and the child was rescued and taken to help the welfare.

1:21:07 Case three, we find missing or vulnerable people all the time. In April 2025, officers

1:21:14 were dispatched to a critical missing person. Jerome County advised us they had received

1:21:19 a flock alert on Highway 93, southbound towards Twin Falls with an endangered elderly male.

1:21:26 locate the vehicle and initiated the stop. Officers found the mail suffering from a medical emergency

1:21:32 that was transported for a hospital for treatment. Officers notified the family that he was located

1:21:36 and they thanked us for being able to rescue their loved one before something bad had happened.

1:21:43 In April 2025, officers were noted by Gooding County detectives that a male with a warrant may

1:21:48 be traveling to Twin Falls. The warrant had a million dollar bond and was for accessory to commit first

1:21:53 degree murder, mutilation of a corpse, and destruction of evidence. Shortly thereafter,

1:21:59 the license plate hit one of our flock cameras. Suspect was located at a local business and taken

1:22:03 into custody without incident. And finally, in July of 2024, TFP responded to a homicide in a local

1:22:10 apartment complex. We quickly developed a vehicle description and with a general vehicle description

1:22:16 with no license plate. We were able to narrow it down to a make and model within a seven-year window

1:22:21 of the manufacturing date.

1:22:23 List of all Idaho registered vehicles

1:22:25 and those parameters was obtained.

1:22:27 That list contained almost 1,500 vehicles,

1:22:30 including 56 that were registered in Twin Falls.

1:22:34 Using ALPR, an employee was able to eliminate 27

1:22:37 of those vehicles in less than an hour.

1:22:40 Over the next day, patrol squads eliminated 10 additional

1:22:44 vehicles.

1:22:44 This technology in our minds has been a force multiplier

1:22:48 with being able to extrapolate information much quicker

1:22:51 than we could in a period of days or even weeks.

1:22:54 Once the suspects were identified and located,

1:23:00 we really confirmed their timeline

1:23:01 after the murder using this technology.

1:23:04 And most recently, many of you may have read,

1:23:06 we had a drive-by shooting here in Twin Falls

1:23:08 about two weeks ago.

1:23:11 On July 16th, the Twin Falls Police Department

1:23:13 was dispatched to report of a drive-by shooting.

1:23:15 Responding officers learned that a resident was outside.

1:23:19 when a vehicle drove by and fired three rounds at him.

1:23:22 Thankfully, there were no injuries.

1:23:24 Investigators received a suspect description

1:23:27 in using a nearby surveillance video.

1:23:30 Using the flocked system, detectives were able to see

1:23:33 exactly what type of vehicle was used in this crime.

1:23:36 Later that night, within two hours,

1:23:38 we were able to identify and locate the suspect

1:23:40 that he was taken in the custody.

1:23:43 Now, since December of 2023, AOPR has produced strong results

1:23:47 for us, resulting in over 500 cases closed. 230 arrests. We've located numerous missing

1:23:54 people, several stolen vehicles and used in a part in the investigation of six different

1:24:00 regional homicide cases. ALPR technology has been involved in solving cases that I mentioned

1:24:06 here before and in other jurisdictions. So let's talk about something that we all want

1:24:12 hear about and that's accountability. Excuse me. So back in May we told you that we had set

1:24:20 up a transparency page on the City of Twin Falls website as we were trying to answer some

1:24:25 common questions about what this technology is and what it's not. And I want to be clear

1:24:30 what it is and what it's not. This is a license plate and vehicle identification tool. It does

1:24:35 not use facial recognition. It is not intended to identify occupants. It does not replace the

1:24:41 legal requirements that an officer must meet before taking enforcement action.

1:24:45 An ALP alert is just an investigative lead. It is not proof of a crime.

1:24:51 So one of the questions I've been asked over the last couple weeks is this mass

1:24:54 surveillance, and I completely understand why people are using that phrase.

1:24:58 From our standpoint, ARBR should not be used for mass surveillance and it's not.

1:25:03 It should be narrowly focused and it's an investigative tool.

1:25:07 It means that legitimate law enforcement uses only with limited

1:25:10 and short periods of retention and frequently auditing its use.

1:25:15 Our personnel must have clearly defined reasons for using it,

1:25:19 but basically they condensed down to two reasons

1:25:21 for investigating a crime or trying to locate a missing person,

1:25:24 and that is it.

1:25:26 We conduct monthly audits of our activities

1:25:28 and inquiries from outside agencies.

1:25:31 So one of the major concerns we've heard is that regional

1:25:34 or national stories of someone abusing access to their system.

1:25:38 And while we're disheartened to hear fellow officers violating the public's trust, we are

1:25:43 happy to hear that people are being held accountable for their misdeeds.

1:25:47 The first people to applaud officers being held accountable for doing the wrong thing are

1:25:52 good police officers.

1:25:55 Let's talk about one of these instances that happened here locally with the Jerome County

1:25:58 Sheriff.

1:26:00 Back in February, the Twin Falls Police Department was incredibly disappointed to learn of its

1:26:04 misuse by an employee of another agency.

1:26:09 month our department was informed by then Chief Deputy Gary Taylor that

1:26:14 information had been uncovered reporting misuse of our system in 2025. It rose

1:26:20 during Attorney General's office investigation of the former Jerome

1:26:24 County Sheriff himself. Our department was advised that the former sheriff had

1:26:28 most likely used the system on hundreds of occasions for reasons unrelated to a

1:26:33 legitimate law enforcement purposes and really known only to him. Upon receiving

1:26:37 In this information, our department and I ordered their access to our system be immediately suspended

1:26:43 even before they left the room.

1:26:46 The next day I outlined a letter to the sheriff at that time indicating three stipulations

1:26:51 that had to be met before I would restore access.

1:26:54 One, he himself had to be removed from access to the system in any way, shape or form.

1:26:59 Two, their department had to adopt a policy as is dictated by Idaho Code.

1:27:03 In three, they had to turn over audits of their system to us on request, which they have done.

1:27:09 This incident reflects badly in our profession.

1:27:11 It should not reflect on the great men and women of the Jerome County Sheriff's Office.

1:27:16 But it does also highlight for it that law enforcement leaders like now, current sheriff,

1:27:22 Barry Taylor and myself, we will take the appropriate action we find of any officer misusing these

1:27:27 tools and violating the public's trust.

1:27:30 talk a little bit about the Fourth Amendment and public perception about that. So, thus

1:27:36 far, the appellate courts have consistently ruled that the standard use of automatic

1:27:41 license plate readers does not violate the Fourth Amendment, relying on the plain view

1:27:44 doctrine in a principle that there is no reasonable expectation of privacy on a

1:27:49 license plate displayed in public. Now, on our transparency page with the help of our

1:27:53 legal department, we have put the most relevant court cases that dictate this.

1:27:58 This issue has been challenged in court and in the appellate course.

1:28:03 We will continue to monitor that and once that situation would change if ever,

1:28:07 we will take our legal team's advice and evaluate our use of the system.

1:28:11 The FLOC hardware captures video and images in public spaces where there is no

1:28:15 reasonable expectation of privacy.

1:28:17 The FLOC footage does not contain personal information that connects an individual

1:28:21 to any identifiable image.

1:28:24 As a result, flock cannot identify individuals who effects appear in the footage and are unable

1:28:29 to process data requests subject to such images.

1:28:34 I want to talk about the first of the three concessions that we are willing to talk about

1:28:38 tonight because we are listening.

1:28:40 The flock contract, we have been paying attention to public comment not just here in Twin Falls

1:28:44 but across the state.

1:28:46 We will be recommending with the advice of our legal team to recommend a change to the three

1:28:51 current contracts will be up with the flock organization regarding its use of our data

1:28:55 for training purposes. I want to read in part the Idaho code that I think that this deals

1:29:00 directly with. Idaho code 491432 in part reads, automatic lace and plate reader data,

1:29:07 shall not be used for any law enforcement purpose. Some in the public conversation have

1:29:12 said that our current contracts allow for flock uses small portion of the images captured

1:29:17 for training data and I want to try to explain exactly what that means.

1:29:21 So the company has told us they will use a small fraction less than 1% of the images

1:29:25 captured when they are stripped of all their metadata and identifying information for the

1:29:30 purposes of improving their products and software and they call this training data.

1:29:36 Training data is used internally to help them better recognize vehicles, objects and descriptions.

1:29:41 This is the example that was given to me.

1:29:44 For example, if a new red Ferrari is released, they may use de-identified images for that vehicle

1:29:50 to teach our system how to accurately distinguish it from other vehicles, such as a red Lamborghini.

1:29:56 These images are never sold or shared with third parties.

1:29:58 To protect the privacy, training data is maintained separately and is never combined in a way that

1:30:04 would render a personal identifiable.

1:30:07 The use of training data, as we've been told, is essential in ensuring the accuracy and effectiveness

1:30:11 of the services.

1:30:13 But since our first contract, the laws, especially in Idaho, have changed.

1:30:18 Idaho law 49-1432, while some can make the agreement, and we were under the perception

1:30:24 that the use of the training data is a legitimate law enforcement purposes, we here want to be

1:30:29 reasonable.

1:30:30 So, Bruce Castleton, our city attorney, has advised us that in an abundance of caution,

1:30:35 let's go ahead and change that portion of our contract, which I will be bringing to you

1:30:39 very soon to change that language in all three contracts.

1:30:43 numerous other concerns have been raised with the data secured, the corporate transparency

1:30:47 in the use of AI.

1:30:48 So, let me just relay a little bit of information regarding the data that is being collected.

1:30:54 All of the data that we're collecting through this system must be in our world, referred to

1:30:58 as CJIS compliant.

1:30:59 That stands for Criminal Justice Information Services, and that applies to the FBI's CJIS

1:31:05 security policy, which really governs almost all of the data that our profession gathers.

1:31:11 It establishes mandatory cybersecurity and personal standards regarding strict personal information.

1:31:18 It requires 13 core tenants and all regarding the police department has to be tested regularly

1:31:23 and trained on CJ's compliance.

1:31:26 That means that no one who hasn't been trained and can access this information.

1:31:30 From our contract, Block complies with the data C privacy framework that is set forth by the

1:31:37 Department of Commerce.

1:31:39 is also subject to investigatory and enforcement powers by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission.

1:31:44 We know of no instances or any of the rules that they govern have been violated.

1:31:50 Walks use of the data.

1:31:52 So the footage collected on the flocks devices are transmitted through the Amazon Web Service

1:32:00 using encryption.

1:32:01 AWS is one of the most secure government web servers that there is, and multiple government

1:32:08 organizations use this. The data is gathered for 30 days and then permanently

1:32:13 deleted. Customer data is encrypted throughout the entire lifecycle and is

1:32:17 transmitted only through encryption. While it is stored in the cloud, all data and

1:32:23 footage is fully encrypted. Our contact states that the customer data is owned

1:32:28 by the customer, which is us, and is only shared directly by the customer. Any

1:32:34 Any license plate data that may be searched by authorized personnel and law enforcement

1:32:39 have to justify the legitimate law enforcement reason behind the search and they create an

1:32:44 audit trail.

1:32:46 Customer data is securely stored and transmitted and deleted and law enforcement use, as I've

1:32:50 told you, is contingent upon authorized use.

1:32:53 This is largely recognized.

1:32:55 This server is one of the most secure for government agencies to use.

1:33:00 The truth is that many professions use third-party and cloud stores to operate their respective

1:33:04 systems, banking, medicine, education, and government organizations all use third-party

1:33:10 cloud-based storage.

1:33:13 Organizations use this primarily for cost savings, for scalability, and accessibility.

1:33:18 Instead of buying and fixed hardware and maintaining it, companies rent remote space to let workers

1:33:23 share files and keep data automatically available.

1:33:28 don't need cannot pay or build infrastructure if they cannot afford it, and this helps maintain

1:33:33 their highest load levels.

1:33:36 In reviewing this system and its company, we have fed that they've met the highest standards

1:33:40 of security.

1:33:42 We routinely receive requests from federal agencies to access our data, and unless it is

1:33:46 tied to an active arrest warrant or a crime is occurring in our jurisdiction, we routinely

1:33:52 deny them access to our system.

1:33:55 For Idaho law and our contracts are flocked, it is strictly prohibited for anybody to sell

1:34:00 or data-mind this information without our knowledge, and we have no such knowledge of that being

1:34:05 done.

1:34:06 Block has repeatedly stated to us that their system has not been hacked, and they do not

1:34:10 use data other than for its intended purpose.

1:34:14 So next I want to show you an example of what is actually captured by a flocked photograph.

1:34:19 This is obviously one of our patrol vehicles.

1:34:22 Information contained in this is the photo location and as I said, we have 40 cameras here in the city of Twin Falls

1:34:28 The photo is dated

1:34:30 The stamp with the time of the date and of course the license plate is in high enough resolution that we can read and then a

1:34:36 Basic old vehicle description this instance. I told this it was a Ford SUV and was black now

1:34:43 We know as I've stated with the example here

1:34:46 Unfortunately with the former drone County sheriff any modern system can be misused

1:34:50 credit cards, fishing scams, I've just recently had to change my debit card

1:34:54 number. What a huge hassle that is. But we have the systems in place, we've done our

1:34:59 deal deal and just to make sure that we can use this technology in the best

1:35:02 conscientious way. I want to describe here the second concession that we've made

1:35:07 tonight and listening to the public conversation and that is what we

1:35:10 understand how your officers use the system, what about the other officers in

1:35:14 the country that may have access to this. Now there is a tool and I really

1:35:18 I wish I could show you this, but I would be violating

1:35:20 the SEGIS rules by doing this.

1:35:22 But there is a tool within the FLOC system,

1:35:24 and over 6,000 organizations use this,

1:35:27 that is called the Nationwide Lookup Tool,

1:35:29 and allows officers in other parts of the country

1:35:32 to search for a particular vehicle of vehicle description

1:35:35 based on a recognized law enforcement purpose.

1:35:38 Now, to be honest with you, because crime doesn't know

1:35:40 Baton Rouge, and because we border a number of states

1:35:43 right here in the Magic Valley, that we've had criminals

1:35:46 drive from and drive to after committing crimes here.

1:35:49 We see some value in having local partners

1:35:51 and regional partners have access to that information

1:35:54 as I've given you before.

1:35:55 We've had examples of crimes that we've been able to solve

1:35:58 and victim we've been able to rescue because of it.

1:36:00 But we don't see much value in the National Lookup Tool.

1:36:03 There's not much need for a officer in North Carolina

1:36:07 during a search looking for a vehicle and a crime

1:36:09 that happened there to scan and make an inquiry of our system.

1:36:12 So last week, we shut that National Lookup Tool off.

1:36:16 I do reserve the right based on if we have an incident here in Twin Falls, if we have

1:36:20 an incident that is spilling over geographic bounds, we have a reason to search another

1:36:24 organization's cameras, we will turn it back on for a limited amount of time and when our

1:36:28 work is done we will turn that back off.

1:36:36 Now I want to get to the next part of our presentation because until about two weeks ago

1:36:40 we were prepared to ask you in our upcoming budget for an additional product, but that

1:36:46 is getting back to the third session that we want to make tonight.

1:36:50 Baby before I do I want to tell you to just a recap. We are challenged with policing over a hundred and ten thousand people every day

1:36:57 We police numerous special events major investigations. We have large parks and trail systems

1:37:03 We have public rallies and protests and we have serious complex investigations that we have special events that require barricades

1:37:13 drones large trucks and

1:37:15 And we try to learn lessons that other communities have learned a hard way, and we're trying to learn those lessons to make a safer twin falls.

1:37:23 But the public expectation that we have been operating on is that we maintain the peace successfully, that we find offenders, and that we're ready for emergencies before they happen.

1:37:32 We at the city are very focused on explaining our why, so that people don't understand how these assets are managed.

1:37:39 and our current method is a little clunky and problematic with gathering

1:37:43 footage from numerous sources. We have all of our officers headboard body

1:37:48 worn cameras. We collect cameras routinely when investigating crime from

1:37:52 private entities to try to piece together what happened. This can be very

1:37:55 problematic when we're using multiple platforms on different computer screens

1:37:59 to try to piece together what happened. But because public trust is more

1:38:03 important was to that, we are going to remove one of the

1:38:08 capital items that we were going to request for this year.

1:38:14 Up until recently, and the tone of the public

1:38:17 conversation has changed, we were getting ready as a

1:38:20 sergeant-wide indicated to ask for a different platform in order

1:38:23 to bring real-time video onto one platform.

1:38:27 When we see in the future the benefit that other communities

1:38:30 that have real-time information centers have when trying to

1:38:33 figure out what is going on in their community and solve crimes as quickly and efficiently

1:38:37 as possible. This would have allowed us to place five additional cameras throughout our

1:38:41 community and it would have allowed us to engage in partnership agreements with organizations

1:38:46 that will only opt in and let us see those cameras in an emergency. But in light of the

1:38:50 public conversation, we think that this is ill timed and we want to be sensitive to that.

1:38:55 We know that the conversation is really just starting tonight and we're really looking forward

1:38:58 to hearing what the people behind me have to say. And I think in the best interest of

1:39:02 of our community, this is not the right time for this right now.

1:39:05 So we are removing this from consideration for the night.

1:39:09 Now this price tag that we were getting right asked for

1:39:12 is $88,400.

1:39:14 At this time, if I understand Travis's advice correctly,

1:39:16 we recommend that that be placed in the contingency fund

1:39:19 to be used at a time later to be determined by the council.

1:39:26 So we're open to hearing all alternatives to this.

1:39:29 And I'm really looking forward to hearing the public dialogue

1:39:32 on what we presented tonight and their standpoints.

1:39:35 and we respect all of it.

1:39:37 We want to provide policing services

1:39:39 in a way that they feel comfortable with,

1:39:40 and we're always welcome for constructive feedback.

1:39:43 At this moment in time, it's really important

1:39:45 we listen to public concerns,

1:39:46 and we adapt to where we need to.

1:39:49 We are always welcome to share reasonable ideas

1:39:53 to make Twin Falls safe.

1:39:55 I will ask for this though.

1:39:56 If someone can share about reasonable ideas and side rails

1:40:00 we can put on the technology, we are here to listen.

1:40:03 If somebody wants to propose an alternative solution

1:40:05 to the program we have in place, we are all ears.

1:40:08 At that point, ladies and gentlemen,

1:40:10 I would stand for any questions you might have.

1:40:12 Questions for Chief?

1:40:16 Hey, Travis, I think that brings us to you.

1:40:27 So Mr. Mayor, members of the council,

1:40:28 just really quickly, what is the process

1:40:32 with the contingency funds?

1:40:33 And while the city council may know,

1:40:36 we have many who may not understand the nuances

1:40:40 of our budgeting process.

1:40:42 So as you know, the contingency funds are built

1:40:45 into our capital planning because while we try

1:40:49 to anticipate every single need, sometimes we fall short

1:40:54 and that contingency provides a little bit of a buffer.

1:40:57 Those funds are not appropriated to a particular project.

1:41:03 And by our process, any funds that are in contingency

1:41:06 must again come before the city council

1:41:09 in a public meeting in which that conversation takes place.

1:41:14 And the Council debates the merits of that project

1:41:17 in comparison to other processes.

1:41:20 So we wanted to assist and to understand

1:41:23 what that contingency process means in life

1:41:27 that they may not understand the nuances

1:41:29 of our budgeting processes.

1:41:33 So that wraps up all of the focus areas.

1:41:36 And I am beyond impressed with all of the presenters

1:41:40 that have come before you.

1:41:43 Where many of the members of our organization

1:41:45 have participated in a long-term planning process.

1:41:49 But most importantly, they helped me build a budget

1:41:52 that's more complete for your consideration.

1:41:56 And as part of the Idaho Code responsibilities

1:41:59 that outlined the responsibilities

1:42:01 of a city manager 5811,

1:42:04 it says that I will always keep the city

1:42:06 the prize of its financial status and that we will consider a budget that has been recommended

1:42:15 by my office. The budget that was presented to you over the course of the last four weeks

1:42:24 follows a process that we have carefully followed really since about 2014. And the idea is to

1:42:32 have members of our organization come forward and share their expertise. Or they are the ones

1:42:39 they're utilizing these tools every single day.

1:42:43 And there are very few tools that they ask that I understand how to operate, and you really

1:42:48 don't want me ever driving a fire truck.

1:42:52 We engage our citizens, and we engage our partners, and we do that by opening the door and asking

1:42:58 them routinely to comment on our budgeting process.

1:43:03 We use the National Citizen Survey to give us an illustration and a report card on the

1:43:08 services that we've done well in their eyes and those areas that we need to improve.

1:43:15 We construct our budgets to enhance our performance and to make sure that we're realizing our

1:43:20 city's expectations.

1:43:23 In budgeting for our organization doesn't start in July when we make a presentation as

1:43:28 you are aware, we begin our public dialogue of a budgeting process each April.

1:43:34 But prior to that, members of our team have been working on the budget since December 2025.

1:43:41 And we will begin in December of this upcoming year in preparation of the fiscal year 28 budget.

1:43:52 Tonight, as you know, is an opportunity to listen.

1:43:55 And there are no legal decisions that you'll be making.

1:44:00 Next week, I am going to be asking you to take all of the information that you've heard

1:44:05 over the last four weeks, and to adopt the preliminary budget, and that preliminary budget

1:44:10 sets the maximum expenditure level for this upcoming year's budget. After that point,

1:44:19 it cannot grow. We will also then use that evening to set the official public hearing

1:44:25 on August 24th, at which time we will be asking you to approve the budget for the upcoming

1:44:33 fiscal year 2027 that begins on October 1st of 26.

1:44:40 With that, I'm happy to stand for any questions that you might have about the budget that has

1:44:46 been presented to you over the course of the last few weeks.

1:44:51 And one of the decisions that you have to make is how to go forward and expand Council

1:44:58 capital.

1:44:59 So, just as a quick recap, these are the projects that you elected to fund in fiscal year 26.

1:45:06 And throughout this entire process, we have been able to share the status of those projects

1:45:11 as they move forward.

1:45:15 And then, we've been building through each of the conversations how to grow and expand

1:45:24 our capital acquisitions through the use of capital, a council capital again.

1:45:31 This year's amount is $820,000, and over the course of the last several weeks, a total

1:45:36 of $807,000 of projects have been considered.

1:45:41 But this list is not exhaustive.

1:45:44 You may have particular projects that you've heard from the community about, projects that

1:45:48 you believe that we should fund based upon your conversations with members of our SIS

1:45:53 and advisory groups, or things that you've just simply noticed.

1:45:58 So, what we would like to do is to hear those requests.

1:46:02 And then we want to continue to expand this list

1:46:04 because on August 10th, we're going to ask for you

1:46:08 to finalize that list.

1:46:10 And so on the 17th, when we present the budget,

1:46:14 it is a complete, we can provide a complete understanding

1:46:17 for our citizens of every dollar

1:46:19 that is being expanded in this budget.

1:46:23 All right, Travis, I jumped in a little early

1:46:25 before you were ready.

1:46:25 It looks like Ruth has a question.

1:46:27 Well, actually, that was my question,

1:46:29 is what our date was for the council,

1:46:33 directed funds and whether we were able

1:46:35 to add anything on our own.

1:46:37 So I appreciate that.

1:46:39 I just want to say what a great job your team has done.

1:46:43 I've been very, very impressed every year, it gets better.

1:46:47 So I do appreciate everybody.

1:46:51 Chris Reed.

1:46:52 Also, thank you to everybody that presented tonight.

1:46:55 Really appreciated it.

1:46:57 I would like to add one thing to the Council directed funds.

1:47:01 I don't know the cost of this,

1:47:02 so I'd ask the team to go and look at this,

1:47:06 but ultimately speed limit signs for the trails

1:47:09 with a radar to display how fast people are going.

1:47:13 I had quite a bit of feedback

1:47:15 that there's some vehicles moving pretty quick on that.

1:47:19 That'd be really nice.

1:47:21 Show the speed limit and show how fast they're going.

1:47:25 We can certainly have that available for you next week,

1:47:29 and we'll present that to you.

1:47:30 Perfect, thank you.

1:47:31 Thanks, Chris.

1:47:32 Anyone else?

1:47:35 Okay, thank you, Travis.

1:47:37 Appreciate it.

1:47:42 Okay, that brings us to our opportunity for public input,

1:47:47 but before we do that, I think it's appropriate

1:47:51 to take a 13-minute break.

1:47:56 That brings us back right at seven o'clock.

1:47:59 we can take care of what we need to during that time.

1:48:04 So one quick thing is,

1:48:07 is if you want to address the council tonight,

1:48:09 we're asking that you please sign in.

1:48:12 Please provide your real name over the last couple of weeks.

1:48:16 We've had some issue with that.

1:48:19 So please provide your name and fill out that form

1:48:23 appropriately.

1:48:24 And when we return at seven o'clock,

1:48:27 we'll go through the rest of the format.

1:48:28 Thank you.

1:48:35 Is that a fine word?

1:48:36 Ooh.

1:48:53 Well, there's a...

1:49:17 I'll stay there.

1:49:18 I'll stay there.

1:49:19 I'll stay there.

1:49:20 I'll stay there.

1:49:21 I'll stay there.

1:49:25 I'll stay there.

1:49:26 I'll stay there.

1:49:27 I'll stay there.

1:49:28 I'll stay there.

1:49:29 I'll stay there.

1:49:30 I'll stay there.

1:49:31 I'll stay there.

1:49:34 I'll stay there.

1:49:46 I'll stay there.

1:49:47 I'll stay there.

1:49:48 I'll stay there.

1:49:49 I'll stay there.

1:49:50 I'll stay there.

1:49:51 I'll stay there.

1:49:52 I'll stay there.

1:49:57 I'll stay there.

1:49:58 I'll stay there.

1:49:59 I'll stay there.

1:50:00 I'll stay there.

1:50:01 I'll stay there.

1:50:02 Okay, buddy.

1:50:09 Hey.

1:50:12 Hey.

1:50:18 Hey.

1:50:24 Hey.

1:50:39 I have a talk to you for a while.

1:53:07 Let's go.

1:53:09 Let's go.

1:53:10 Let's go.

1:53:11 Let's go.

1:53:12 Let's go.

1:53:13 Let's go.

1:53:14 Let's go.

1:53:15 Let's go.

1:53:16 Let's go.

1:53:17 Let's go.

1:53:18 Let's go.

1:53:19 Let's go.

1:53:20 Let's go.

1:53:21 Let's go.

1:53:22 Let's go.

1:53:23 Let's go.

1:53:24 Let's go.

1:53:25 Let's go.

1:53:26 Let's go.

1:53:27 Let's go.

1:53:28 Let's go.

1:53:29 Let's go.

1:53:30 Let's go.

1:53:31 Let's go.

1:53:32 Let's go.

1:53:33 Let's go.

1:53:34 Let's go.

1:53:35 Let's go.

1:53:36 Now I know you, so I'll make sure I take care of it.

1:53:43 Oh, yeah.

1:53:50 I'll give everybody a few minutes or a few seconds, I should say.

1:54:08 Okay, it looks like everybody's kind of found their way back to it.

1:54:27 We'll go ahead and open up the comment period for this topic just again to kind of go over

1:54:35 a few things to make sure we need to make sure that you've signed up. Rachel and Amy

1:54:42 have the sign up sheets at this point and your name will be read aloud. If that sheet

1:54:47 is not filled out appropriately, your name will not be written or read. You'll have two

1:54:53 minutes to address the City Council and with any concern that you may have, we will conclude

1:55:03 this portion of the public comment period in 90 minutes.

1:55:07 So we'll have 90 minutes to conclude it,

1:55:09 each individual that would like to address the council

1:55:12 will have two minutes to address us, please.

1:55:17 Again, I think the biggest thing is please be respectful.

1:55:20 We're here to listen.

1:55:22 If at any moment that we feel like recess needs to occur,

1:55:27 we'll go into another recess and we'll reset what we need to.

1:55:32 that we will not add additional time on the back end of that time.

1:55:38 We're not in a soccer game,

1:55:40 so we won't add any additional time on the back of that.

1:55:44 But we're all professionals, we're all adults,

1:55:47 and we ask that we address each other in an appropriate manner.

1:55:51 So again, two minutes, and Amy,

1:55:56 I think we'll go ahead and get started.

1:56:01 So first I'm going to call Michael Wendler.

1:56:07 And your time will start when you first start speaking.

1:56:11 Yes, my name is Michael Windler.

1:56:13 I'm a Twin Falls City resident.

1:56:15 And I just wanted to applaud the chief here

1:56:19 in talking about the trust conversation.

1:56:22 That's, I think, the best way for us to go forward

1:56:25 and have something constructive happen

1:56:27 as opposed to just in us versus that mentality

1:56:30 that seems to be so pervasive in these days.

1:56:34 And the successes that he outlined in terms of felonies

1:56:37 and misdemeanors, and such are wonderful,

1:56:41 and I'm glad to hear that that's what it's being used for here

1:56:44 locally.

1:56:45 I think some of the concern that comes from these systems

1:56:48 is from the broader perspective of it,

1:56:53 and that's even from public information requests

1:56:55 from local agencies around here that's

1:56:57 being used for things like suspicious vehicles.

1:57:01 So if you see a vehicle in a parking lot, an officer

1:57:04 might go ahead and run that plate and see where it's been.

1:57:07 and such, and in terms of the Idaho statutes,

1:57:10 I don't believe that's a appropriate use,

1:57:14 because as he highlighted,

1:57:15 it's supposed to be for misdemeanors, felonies,

1:57:17 and missing persons.

1:57:19 So the fact that we're using it that way

1:57:21 is a big and good step towards the conversation

1:57:26 that we're having, and he answered a lot of my questions.

1:57:29 And in that regard, I think in that web page

1:57:33 that they have, it may be as simple to get some

1:57:37 of that public trust instead of putting out just a sheet

1:57:40 that kind of explains things maybe having the chief

1:57:44 or someone from the city explaining exactly what he just

1:57:48 explained so people can watch that and have a broader

1:57:51 understanding of the specific safeguards we have here

1:57:55 in our area.

1:57:56 And the only idea is that I could really think of after

1:57:59 that conversation where maybe we should head off these issues

1:58:03 before they start and have memorandums of understanding

1:58:05 with these agencies instead of letters afterwards,

1:58:08 and then also show what agencies were sharing

1:58:12 this information with.

1:58:13 Thank you.

1:58:14 Appreciate it.

1:58:19 Ritu, who is our?

1:58:21 Maria Hernandez.

1:58:37 My name is Maria, well, that's loud.

1:58:39 My name is Maria Hernandez, and I was born and raised here

1:58:42 in Twin Falls, Idaho, and the song conveys a lot of emotion

1:58:45 at this moment, so I wanted to play this.

1:59:11 This song was created in 1984, 42 years ago,

1:59:14 still invoking the same emotions as today.

1:59:16 What am I saying?

1:59:17 Well, big brother always be watching us.

1:59:19 The answer is yes to what degree now.

1:59:22 Our winning society fearful of change

1:59:24 or our rights being infringed upon.

1:59:27 Common sense is law enforcement needs

1:59:28 to be able to do their jobs.

1:59:31 A couple weeks ago, I witnessed a teenager not stop

1:59:34 at a stop site.

1:59:35 Cameras would be able to catch this mistake

1:59:37 the teenager made.

1:59:38 I've also been a victim of stalking and gangstocking.

1:59:42 Cameras would and can catch criminals more efficiently

1:59:45 with cameras.

1:59:46 So what am I saying?

1:59:48 If you track me all the way to my house and other places,

1:59:52 we are talking about the movie Independence Day.

1:59:56 Independence Day, all over again.

2:00:00 Cameras to stop crime, all for it, but to track me,

2:00:06 that's a little uncomfortable.

2:00:08 And I don't believe that's going to be done here in Twin Falls, Idaho, as you heard

2:00:12 Chief Hicks speak.

2:00:13 I can't help but share Daniel 12 verse 4, a knowledge book I read all the time.

2:00:20 AICIA, FBI, all knowledge is increasing.

2:00:25 The Daniel 12, 4 is knowledge shall increase in the last days.

2:00:31 And we're seeing that with AI and other agencies.

2:00:36 just need to really put trust. Thank you. There. Thank you. Okay. So sorry if I put

2:00:51 your name, the next one is Bob Browski. Bob, you may want to say that again if you don't

2:01:00 mind. Just so. Good evening. My name is Bob Browski. I'm a Twin Falls resident, a retired

2:01:06 law enforcement officer and I currently run and own the Idaho 2A News. I'm here to voice

2:01:12 my opinion on flocked safety cameras and fixed ALPR systems. I could stand here and walk you

2:01:18 through the abuses, the case law, and the statutes. But you already know that. So instead, I'm going

2:01:26 to walk you through something much simpler to understand. The will of the people versus the

2:01:31 will of the government. You see, in this country, the elected govern only by the consent of the

2:01:37 people. And when the government decides it knows better than the people, the people will

2:01:43 eventually remove their consent. Look around this room, left, right, conservative, liberals

2:01:50 and independents, every color, every background, all of us, united, saying the same thing, and

2:01:56 the warless surveillance of Twin Falls. The government loves it when the people are divided.

2:02:04 or not divided on this one. Not even close. You all have the power. You also have the

2:02:10 responsibility. You have the ability right now to end this city's contract with

2:02:16 flock and remove every one of these cameras. Tomorrow if you chose to or

2:02:22 you could choose to do nothing. If you do choose to do nothing, the people, the

2:02:28 Conservatives, Liberals, Independents, all of us, will may choose to sign a recall petition

2:02:37 and I've taken the liberty of drafting one for each one of you.

2:02:43 I'm holding onto them for now.

2:02:45 I'm hoping you will heed the will of the people, not the clock corporation.

2:02:50 Do the right thing, or we'll find a Council who will.

2:02:53 Thank you.

2:03:04 Rachel, who's our next one?

2:03:05 Greg Kingsbury.

2:03:06 Mayor Brown, Council, my name is Craig Kingsbury and I am a Twin Falls City resident,

2:03:24 I have been for the last decade.

2:03:26 At 35 years as a police officer in the state, I think you're aware of the last 9 years of my career as a chief of police here in this fight city.

2:03:34 I as a city resident am in favor of the FLAC program.

2:03:39 I'm in favor of the way it's being utilized and with the outline that Chief Hicks gave tonight.

2:03:44 I think it makes our community safer, and I feel confident under the leadership of you at the dias of our city administration and of Chief Hixen, his team, that will continue to be used in the right way.

2:03:56 We don't want to go backwards in safety. We have to make sure we're doing this the right way, and we are protecting the rights of our citizens, those of us that live, work, and travel through our city.

2:04:06 I thank you for your time.

2:04:07 Thank you.

2:04:08 Rachel.

2:04:13 Web.

2:04:15 Webb, Glauner.

2:04:26 He said, Webb, that's correct, okay.

2:04:34 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

2:04:35 My name is Webb Glauner.

2:04:37 I'm a resident of Higerman, Idaho, and it's better.

2:04:41 And a representative of the Southern Idaho Democratic

2:04:43 Social America, based in Twin Falls.

2:04:45 The Flock Safety Falcon LPR camera is a device used

2:04:49 to watch, listen to, and report on citizens

2:04:51 as they go about their normal everyday lives,

2:04:53 record every innocuous interaction,

2:04:55 and send that data, not only to our local police department,

2:04:58 But to the record halls of a multi-billion dollar corporation,

2:05:01 completely out of reach of the people,

2:05:03 so they can do who knows what with it.

2:05:05 Our police department claims it's only used to track vehicles

2:05:08 using criminal activity,

2:05:09 and that it is not used for facial recognition

2:05:11 or other mass surveillance activity.

2:05:13 We hope our police department has been wiped

2:05:15 too by this company, but we do know that this is a lie.

2:05:18 It has already been used in our own community

2:05:20 by Sheriff George Oppendig, an individual who swore

2:05:24 to protect us and to serve us to illegally track his life

2:05:28 and then a simple woman who did not commit a crime.

2:05:31 It has also been found that flock employees and executives

2:05:33 have been remotely accessing flock cameras

2:05:35 to view children while in their elementary schools.

2:05:38 It was to say these things are not still happening.

2:05:40 It was to say it is happening to me

2:05:41 or other people in this room,

2:05:43 it may even be happening to you.

2:05:46 Reposed women to flock's contracts

2:05:47 in order to regulate the corporation's access

2:05:49 to our city's data are nothing but procedural.

2:05:52 Which corporations do you trust

2:05:54 to follow these laws and regulations?

2:05:57 In addition to all this, we, the taxpayers, get the privilege of paying for our own cage.

2:06:02 We may spend $88,000 on an exorbitant amount of money, money that could pay for our children's

2:06:07 good schools, put food on our neighbors' plates, or put asphalt on our roads, on the chains these

2:06:13 corporate beaches used to bind us.

2:06:15 Idaho ranks the last and poor people funding for public schools.

2:06:19 Shouldn't we be striving to deliver more for our students, rather than giving them scraps,

2:06:24 so that the city can afford to watch through every move?

2:06:27 Even if you last seen this room so full, the people have shown that they are strongly against

2:06:30 these devices in their community and it is your duty to listen to them or it will be our

2:06:34 duty to replace you when elections come later this year.

2:06:37 Your time is up.

2:06:38 Thank you.

2:06:39 Thank you.

2:06:48 Thank you.

2:06:55 Erby?

2:06:56 Was that pronounced correctly?

2:07:00 Good evening, Mayor and City Council.

2:07:03 My name is Scout Erby and I live here in Twin Falls and I'm a student at Twin Falls High

2:07:06 School as well as a member of the Southern Idaho Chapter of the Democratic Socialists

2:07:10 of America.

2:07:11 Lately, I've been seeing these flock cameras more frequently in my town. These flock cameras

2:07:15 can and have been used to violate Idaho Law. Senate Bill 1180 states that automated license

2:07:21 plate reader data shall not be used for any non-law enforcement purpose. As reported

2:07:25 by CAM BT on April 1st of 2026 and mentioned by Chief Hicks, Jerome County Sheriff George

2:07:31 Abadai used walk cameras to search for his wife's vehicle hundreds of times between July

2:07:37 in September 2025. This system was not used by TFPD units but an outside officer. Preventative

2:07:43 action goes further than accountability measures taken after abuse is committed. This abuse

2:07:48 in Jerome is not isolated as the Institute for Justice has as of July 25th. Recorded

2:07:54 28 such cases of abuse across the country, many of which weren't uncovered until the

2:07:59 victim reported the officer's behavior. That said, I don't believe the city of Tounfala

2:08:04 should continue contracts with flock safety. There are far too many privacy concerns which

2:08:08 abuse becomes safety concerns, threatening the very safety flock advocates claim it protects.

2:08:13 In addition to this, the money for crowd control equipment concerns me. As someone who is frequently

2:08:18 protesting in Twin Falls, I can attest to the fact that our organizations have teams that

2:08:22 are there primarily to assist with safety in first aid as well as de-escalation. These protests

2:08:27 are non-violent and have not threatened the safety of Twin Falls residents in any significant

2:08:31 way. Thank you.

2:08:41 Thank you for the opportunity to address the council. I appreciate your time. My name is Joshua Van Dyke. I'm a business owner here in Twin Falls. I do support law enforcement efforts and I want to save city as much as anyone, probably more so because I own a firearm shop.

2:09:10 However, law enforcement needs to operate within the bounds of constitutional law specifically the Fourth Amendment. I understand that while in public, a person has a lower expectation of privacy.

2:09:22 That is not the same, it's very different from the mass surveillance and interrogation

2:09:28 that the flock cameras effect.

2:09:31 Regardless of being in public or not, the courts have routinely acknowledged the extension

2:09:36 of privacy to include people's vehicles in a site, United States versus Jones, quote,

2:09:42 five justices had agreed that such tracking, i.e. the flock cameras, counts as a Fourth Amendment

2:09:48 search because the individuals have a reasonable expectation of privacy while

2:09:52 in their physical movements. Every license plate read by the flock

2:10:01 cameras submits the owner to a search against law enforcement databases not

2:10:06 against this adversarial but within. This is without probable cause, it's

2:10:11 without suspicion, the chief mentioned 14,000 to round up one car, I'm uncomfortable

2:10:17 with that. And without a warrant, the driver is essentially treated as a

2:10:21 criminal and that's not right. This is more this is more than a casual observation or a photograph

2:10:27 being taken while you're out in public. This is a search of your property without consent,

2:10:32 without the requisite court orders or probable cause and time does fly by. All right, the database

2:10:38 is shared amongst law enforcement agencies potentially all the way up to federal levels.

2:10:42 The innocent are being tracked and searched and interrogated without a valid cause. This

2:10:47 intrusion of the privacy of rights of the vast majority of law

2:10:51 biases and just kind of you guys does not justify this violation of my constitutional rights.

2:10:57 Thank you. Dan Miller. I am Dan Miller. I want to thank every one of you for being here today.

2:11:17 I thank you for what you do. It is appreciated. I wanted to thank the chief for calling out

2:11:26 several problems with Flock.

2:11:28 One of the main ones is that mass surveillance

2:11:31 ex-aspect of it.

2:11:35 Perhaps we've never thought of, but there

2:11:38 are people within our community that should not be surveilled.

2:11:43 I have personal knowledge of airborne rangers, green berets,

2:11:47 several different units that the Navy has,

2:11:49 personal knowledge of those.

2:11:52 The problem with Flock and the chief alluded to it,

2:11:56 There are several times where that information has gotten out of control.

2:12:00 They block themselves, mention third party vendors.

2:12:04 They've lost control of all that data.

2:12:07 The data is illegal to collect on everybody all the time without a search mark.

2:12:13 Then when they lose control of that data, who knows where it goes?

2:12:18 It's very easy to imagine that that would be going to America's enemies

2:12:23 that should not know of the movements

2:12:26 of those different types of people

2:12:28 within our community that should not be surveilled.

2:12:31 So because of that, I'm asking for you guys

2:12:35 to get the flock out of Twin Falls.

2:12:38 It needs to be shut off.

2:12:39 There needs to be some way of setting up boundaries

2:12:44 to where these violations do not happen.

2:12:47 I am pro-law enforcement.

2:12:50 I wish the successes that the chief had talked about

2:12:53 could be exponentially more.

2:12:55 And I mean much exponentially more.

2:12:58 But until we get control of it and stop it

2:13:01 from being misused, it's got to be stopped.

2:13:04 So I'm going to take this torque claim that I'm filing

2:13:09 and pass it on over here.

2:13:10 Thank you.

2:13:25 Steve Ogan.

2:13:43 Hi, I'm Steve Ogan.

2:13:46 This is a historic moment.

2:13:48 It could have a right wing dude agreeing with DSA and the ACLU,

2:13:53 which I don't think I've ever done before.

2:13:56 I hear a lot about all the data safe.

2:13:58 I was an IS guy with the master's degree.

2:14:02 And data's not safe.

2:14:03 The only way you're going to prevent data from being deleted

2:14:06 or totally deleted is to take a hammer

2:14:10 and break up a hard drive into a bunch of little tiny pieces.

2:14:13 So anything it has to do with communications, et cetera,

2:14:17 it can be changed.

2:14:18 AI can change all these camera images, do whatever they want.

2:14:23 In 2018, I believe it was carpenter versus United States, which had to do with cell phones.

2:14:29 Same issue was that no, you're not in private, you're out there in the public with your phone

2:14:37 and you're on these different social media things.

2:14:41 But one unit like that is not doing anything with your privacy as far as taking away your

2:14:49 rights.

2:14:50 a multiple unit network does. And the cases have not gone to the Supreme Court. Obviously,

2:15:00 but the appellate courts do have comments of descending opinions on, okay, in 23, we had

2:15:08 40 cameras. This 26, this thing has got to, or no, 12 cameras. Now it's 40. It's gone

2:15:15 up 300% in three years. There's nothing to say that this is going to happen, but this

2:15:22 council can be replaced as a political cycle. The chief police, chief of police can be replaced

2:15:29 or fired whatever. These things are not permanent. All it takes is one corrupt council, one corrupt

2:15:36 police chief, one corrupt policeman. Is that going to happen? Probably not, but it can.

2:15:42 So this is spying on people a little too much.

2:15:46 Thank you.

2:15:53 Eilir Kane.

2:16:02 How's it going, Council?

2:16:03 My name is Tyler Kane.

2:16:04 I'm with D-Flock Idaho.

2:16:05 I'm a Wilder resident.

2:16:07 Thank you for everyone who showed up today.

2:16:10 People have covered a lot of the constitutional things,

2:16:12 but I'm going to cover a few things

2:16:13 that the chief kind of lied about.

2:16:17 So a couple of months ago, we said,

2:16:19 hey, you guys are misusing the data

2:16:21 by sharing it with Flock to improve their product.

2:16:24 And then just, and then their response was,

2:16:26 we're doing nothing wrong.

2:16:28 So just now we're addressing that.

2:16:30 About three weeks ago to a month,

2:16:32 we requested, hey, are you guys sharing federally?

2:16:34 So which we got the answer was yes.

2:16:36 And so by Twin Falls, sharing federally,

2:16:38 let's see here, in March, we had 55,861 searches

2:16:44 for traffic infractions.

2:16:46 We had 958 searches categorized as suspicious,

2:16:50 And 196 immigration searches, April, 53,865 searches

2:16:57 for traffic infraction, 941 searches categorized

2:17:00 as suspicion, and 282 immigration searches, May, 52,711 searches

2:17:07 for traffic infractions, it's like it's a pattern, right?

2:17:10 1,151 searches categorized as suspicion,

2:17:14 and 158 immigration searches.

2:17:17 And as the chief said, they're only supposed to use this

2:17:20 for law enforcement purposes, investigation of misdemeanor or felony.

2:17:24 Let's see, what else?

2:17:26 So he brought up the proverbial emotional argument.

2:17:30 I'd like to dispel that.

2:17:31 We already have tools that work.

2:17:33 In 1997, 40% of true stranger abductions of children were not solved.

2:17:41 In 1997, that's when the federal, what's it called,

2:17:46 Amber Alert system started. By 2017 when Flock started there was 195 true

2:17:52 stranger abductions, 193 of them were solved. That leaves 1% unsolved by a system

2:17:59 that works. It's called the Amber Alert system. So they already have the resources

2:18:02 to solve crime. Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you very much. Here's

2:18:07 my tort claim against the city. I'm gonna deliver a tort claim.

2:18:11 Good afternoon. I'm Candice Miano. I stand before you today not only as a

2:18:37 Twin Falls resident but as an American deeply concerned about the direction our

2:18:40 nation is heading. How much of our privacy and liberty are we willing to

2:18:44 surrender for promises of greater security? History gives us that answer.

2:18:48 Freedom is rarely lost overnight. It is surrendered piece by piece, policy by

2:18:53 policy, until what was once unthinkable is now the new normal. Benjamin Franklin

2:18:59 once warned, those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety

2:19:04 deserve neither safety nor liberty. And those words remain just as relevant today. Every

2:19:11 new surveillance system creates another opportunity to monitor, track, and collect information about

2:19:17 law abiding citizens. Once an infrastructure exists, it rarely disappears. It expands history

2:19:23 as shown that when governments are given power, abuse is not a question of if it is when. Our

2:19:28 Our founders understood this, they wrote the Constitution to restrain government because

2:19:32 they knew liberty could not survive with limits with no limits on power.

2:19:36 The Fourth Amendment was written for moments like this, when fear makes it tempting to trade

2:19:40 our rights for the illusion of safety.

2:19:44 Of course, safety matters, but safety should never require us to surrender the freedoms

2:19:48 it exists to protect.

2:19:51 Privacy is not a privilege, it is the cornerstone of our society.

2:19:55 We are not defined by fear, we are neighbors who look out for one another, parents who are

2:19:59 raising the next generation and citizens entrusted with self-government. Our strength

2:20:03 has never come from constant surveillance and has always come from free people who

2:20:08 have fought for those freedoms. Freedom's not lost in one dramatic moment, it has

2:20:12 lost one compromise at a time. Let us be the generation that draws that line.

2:20:17 Choose liberty over fear, choose privacy over unnecessary surveillance, and choose

2:20:23 freedom. Thank you.

2:20:25 Good evening. My name is Ben Miano and I live here in Twin Falls. I'm here today to oppose

2:20:44 the clock camera system that has been installed in our town, and urge you to reject any future

2:20:48 expansion of mass surveillance technologies. These cameras do far more than re-license plates.

2:20:53 They record the make and model color and distinguishing features. Over time, that information can

2:20:58 be used to build detailed profiles where law abiding citizens travel and the routines that

2:21:03 they follow. As AI powered surveillance technology advances, there is a legitimate concern that

2:21:09 systems like these could be integrated with technology such as facial recognition. The issue

2:21:14 is not whether this technology can help solve crimes. The issue is whether a free society

2:21:17 should accept widespread government surveillance in the hope of catching a few. Our constitution

2:21:23 was written to limit government power and protect individual liberty, not to treat every

2:21:27 citizen as a suspect. Our surveillance system is built, or once the surveillance system

2:21:32 is built, it's far easier to expand its use than to scale it back. As free people, we must

2:21:37 oppose permanent surveillance infrastructure. There are practical concerns as well. Expanding

2:21:42 AI surveillance requires more computing infrastructure and data centers that consume significant amounts

2:21:47 of electricity and water, increasing demand on limited resources. At a time when our community

2:21:53 should be focused on responsible resource management, we must ask whether expanding

2:21:56 surveillance is the best use of those resources. History reminds us that government powers are

2:22:00 are rarely surrendered once they are,

2:22:02 that government powers are rarely surrendered

2:22:04 once they have been granted.

2:22:06 We also have seen reported, repeated examples of technology,

2:22:10 companies failing to protect data.

2:22:12 They collect or using it in ways

2:22:14 the public never expected or authorized.

2:22:17 You are elected to represent the people of this community

2:22:19 and to protect both our safety and our constitutional freedoms.

2:22:23 I ask you to remove existing floor cameras

2:22:25 and reject any expansion of floor cameras

2:22:27 or similar surveillance systems.

2:22:29 public safety and individual liberty are not opposing values.

2:22:33 We can protect both, but only if we are willing to defend our individual liberties.

2:22:37 Thank you.

2:22:38 Thank you.

2:22:45 Doug Bureau.

2:22:46 My name is Doug Bureau.

2:22:57 I'm a resident of Twin Falls, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council.

2:23:03 I'd like to thank Chief Fickz for providing us with information on how TFPD intends to

2:23:07 use block technology.

2:23:10 There's a definite trend in this country towards a growing surveillance society.

2:23:14 1984 was not supposed to be an instruction manual.

2:23:18 George Orwell wrote his novel 1984 as a warning

2:23:21 to scare people away from tyranny.

2:23:24 I was a guidebook for government,

2:23:25 federal, state, or local, to use to control citizens.

2:23:30 Yet here we are in a growing police state

2:23:32 with full-blown blanket surveillance.

2:23:34 I'd like to remind the council, and it's already done,

2:23:38 but I think it's worth noting again,

2:23:40 Benjamin Franklin's famous quote.

2:23:42 Those who would give up essential liberty

2:23:44 to purchase a little temporary safety,

2:23:47 deserve neither liberty nor safety.

2:23:50 I'm not clear on the total amount for the contracts

2:23:54 on flock safety.

2:23:56 But I do believe the city must have needs.

2:23:59 Those financial resources could go to.

2:24:01 It actually improves citizens' lives

2:24:03 instead of tracking or archiving or every move.

2:24:06 I'd like to quote Pierre or Joseph Prudon

2:24:09 because there's a little difference

2:24:11 between the nature of government from his time to ours.

2:24:14 To be governed is to be watched, inspected,

2:24:17 spied upon, directed, law-driven, numbered, regulated,

2:24:21 enrolled, indoctrinated, pre-stat, controlled, checked,

2:24:25 estimated, valued, since they're commanded.

2:24:28 To be governed is to be at every operation,

2:24:31 at every transaction noted, registered, counted,

2:24:34 taxed, stamped, measured, numbered, assessed,

2:24:38 licensed, authorized, admonished, prevented, forbidden,

2:24:42 reformed, corrected.

2:24:44 Truly, Henry David throws 1849 essay civil disobedience

2:24:48 says it all succinctly.

2:24:50 That government is best, discovers, leaves.

2:24:53 Twin Falls can make a start of this today

2:24:54 by not renewing the flocks he had to contract.

2:24:57 Thank you.

2:24:58 Thank you.

2:25:06 Tori Wakewood.

2:25:12 Tori's still here.

2:25:14 Tori, sorry, sorry, sorry.

2:25:19 Okay, Tori, correct?

2:25:36 Okay.

2:25:43 My name's Tori Wakewood.

2:25:44 I want to thank Council for being so open

2:25:49 to listening to us.

2:25:52 I think transparency is something that is admirable.

2:25:57 The very fact that you're willing to listen to us

2:26:01 says a lot, same with the police department.

2:26:05 One thing that I would like to say is that

2:26:09 I don't know where these cameras are,

2:26:14 and I don't know if there's currently a map

2:26:17 of where they are, so that I can avoid them.

2:26:25 I don't have a whole lot more to say,

2:26:28 other than what is already being said,

2:26:31 and I do appreciate your time,

2:26:34 and I do want those block cameras removed.

2:26:37 Thank you.

2:26:43 George, done.

2:26:56 Before I begin, I'd like to take a poll,

2:26:58 because Officer Hicks made reference to a National Night Out.

2:27:04 How many people have been to Twin Falls Park

2:27:06 for National Night Out?

2:27:08 Raise your hand high.

2:27:09 OK, not many.

2:27:10 All right.

2:27:11 I'd like to make an advertisement for National Night Out.

2:27:16 I'm a science teacher.

2:27:18 I am a substitute teacher in Twin Falls School District.

2:27:21 But that night is one of the best nights in this community.

2:27:26 When you go to National Night Out, this

2:27:28 is a national all across the country program.

2:27:31 This is not just Twin Falls.

2:27:34 Any county, any city, any state that supports and funds

2:27:38 police are going to support National Night Out.

2:27:41 National Night Out will have Twin Falls Police Department

2:27:44 there with a crime scene investigation

2:27:46 and a table to answer any question you have about being

2:27:49 a police officer.

2:27:51 You have the fire department.

2:27:53 The fire department is there with their fire trucks,

2:27:55 and they will show you all the equipment they use.

2:27:57 Scuba diving equipment, search and recovery,

2:27:59 anything that they use is out in the open.

2:28:02 I highly recommend people to go to this

2:28:05 and see what questions you might have,

2:28:08 and actually might be able to use equipment.

2:28:10 They let middle schoolers use, well,

2:28:13 not just middle schools, all students,

2:28:14 anybody there use the search and recovery

2:28:17 and the bomb squad, the little robots.

2:28:21 They can use that equipment and see what it's like.

2:28:23 This promotes funding the police.

2:28:26 That's my point.

2:28:27 Big thing for me is that the police are not going away.

2:28:31 They're being funded and they are being visible.

2:28:33 In so many things, the offense he talks about,

2:28:35 they're out there every day setting things up.

2:28:38 So there's a lot of transparency here

2:28:40 that just isn't happening here.

2:28:42 It's visible all over, okay?

2:28:45 Funding the police, that's a very, very big deal.

2:28:48 Also, we got CSI and we have academies over there at CSI that actually have officer training

2:28:57 and they're going to the sheriff department.

2:28:59 So there's a lot of-

2:29:00 George, I got a stone bridge.

2:29:01 Thank you for your comments.

2:29:02 Thank you.

2:29:03 Cheyenne Lovato.

2:29:04 Hello.

2:29:05 Thank you, Mayor, Vice Mayor and members of the council.

2:29:31 My name is Cheyenne Lovato.

2:29:32 I am a lifetime lifelong Idahoan and resident

2:29:36 of Twin Falls of over 10 years.

2:29:38 And I'm asking you not to renew the city's contract

2:29:40 with block safety, remove all existing cameras,

2:29:43 and to save us from the surveillance state.

2:29:48 These cameras do not investigate only people

2:29:50 accused or suspected of crimes.

2:29:52 They photograph and catalog every vehicle that passes them,

2:29:55 recording license plates, vehicle characteristics,

2:29:57 locations, and times.

2:29:58 That information is transmitted to an infrastructure

2:30:01 operated by a private company, as many have already pointed out.

2:30:05 We are being asked to trust flock security, deletion practices,

2:30:08 employees, subcontractors, and every outside agency granted access.

2:30:12 But security researchers have already identified

2:30:14 vulnerabilities and flock devices, as one commentary

2:30:19 pointed out, anything that has been encrypted can be decrypted.

2:30:24 Encryption is not a safeguard to our data privacy.

2:30:31 And then a flockhammer feed in Colorado was recently found publicly accessible online.

2:30:36 Once someone's location information is exposed, copied, and misused, it cannot simply be taken back.

2:30:42 This surveillance also does not affect everyone equally.

2:30:45 We have a lot of immigrants here in our community who are experiencing some distress at the time.

2:30:52 They might be afraid of detention, deportation, or family separation,

2:30:56 and the possibility that their vehicle may be tracked as fear to ordinary life.

2:31:00 life, driving to work, taking child to school, attending church, visiting a doctor or seeking

2:31:04 community support should not feel like creating a record that could later be searched and shared.

2:31:09 Public safety should make people feel safer, not watched.

2:31:13 Please do not renew this contract when necessary to be targeted and transparent public safety

2:31:19 measures based on individualized suspicion, not the non-consensual routine tracking of

2:31:24 an entire community.

2:31:25 Thank you.

2:31:26 Thank you.

2:31:33 Julian, Kessel.

2:31:44 Hello, good evening, Chamber.

2:31:46 It's good to see you all.

2:31:47 I'm Julian, Kessel, I have three big ideas

2:31:48 that I want to address as we talk about this flock system.

2:31:53 And the first being that we live in an age where we are

2:31:56 actively giving up our privacy.

2:31:58 We give up our locations, our data, our photos,

2:32:02 to these corporations, but the key word

2:32:04 is that we are giving them up with our consent.

2:32:07 Now, with the flock safety system,

2:32:09 now we are not giving it up with our consent.

2:32:11 we're giving it beyond our control,

2:32:14 and it is not only going to a corporation,

2:32:15 but it is going to the government.

2:32:17 And as many people in here believe

2:32:19 that any level of government should not have access

2:32:21 to this level of technology,

2:32:23 no matter whether they be federal, state, or local.

2:32:25 My second big issue with this is the use of the funds.

2:32:29 As we see with seeing that it's an unpopular budgetary item,

2:32:35 the 88,000 could go towards something

2:32:38 about four years of fire department equipment maintenance

2:32:41 or similar line items that would be more useful

2:32:45 to our community, that people would appreciate better.

2:32:48 And finally, the last issue I want to address is that

2:32:51 we live in a changing democracy right now.

2:32:54 And this is where the buck needs to stop here.

2:32:56 In this age of privacy loss and artificial intelligence,

2:33:01 it is up to us to take a stand at any moment

2:33:04 to explain what we believe is right and wrong

2:33:07 our constituents and for us as people in our community. I want to

2:33:12 windfalls to blaze the trail for the future, but just not on the side of

2:33:15 tyranny. Thank you.

2:33:24 Brandon me.

2:33:27 Said Brandon or Brandon.

2:33:30 Brandon.

2:33:37 Good evening. I just want to touch on a few things that were said by the

2:33:40 police chief. He said that now is not the time to block contract.

2:33:47 What that reads to me is that once public interest dies down, that will be a

2:33:51 more favorable time. This is not a concession is claimed, but a statement that a shift in

2:33:57 policing will happen only when people aren't as heated. This is not an anti-flock concern.

2:34:03 It's an anti-surveillance concern. Be it flock, axon, a crowd by any other name. Excuse me.

2:34:12 I ask, does this amend a contract not to renew the flock cameras simply mean that no new

2:34:18 additional cameras will be installed or that the current ones will also be removed?

2:34:24 On that topic, the murder on Capri Drive, I knew Fred Rodriguez, he was my neighbor.

2:34:34 Our dogs played together, his daughters came over, and it was a tough topic for me to go

2:34:40 through that.

2:34:42 And what I want to say is don't use my friends, family or peers as a pretext to take away my

2:34:49 personal liberties.

2:34:50 Thank you.

2:34:51 Lea, bye-bye, Ian.

2:35:36 Good evening.

2:35:38 Good evening, community.

2:35:41 I come before you tonight as a citizen,

2:35:43 as a parent of a minor who just started driving,

2:35:47 and a local small business owner,

2:35:49 and someone who has built a career in serving this community,

2:35:52 listening, supporting, advocating for individual dignity,

2:35:57 civic access, and liberty.

2:35:59 I also come with a lived experience

2:36:03 that shaped how I view government surveillance.

2:36:06 My family's history connects me to life

2:36:09 under the former Soviet Union,

2:36:11 in which the government intruded deeply

2:36:14 into our private lives.

2:36:16 They would have loved the idea of flock and ALPR systems.

2:36:23 Those experience shaped my beliefs

2:36:26 that individual liberty must always be protected

2:36:29 and that the government must always have

2:36:32 clear boundaries. The concern is not about opposing the cameras. Private

2:36:39 businesses, including my own, use cameras for security and safety. The

2:36:43 difference is choice, purpose, consent, and accountability. Government

2:36:50 surveillance systems like FLOC and ALPR create something much broader. The

2:36:58 The ability to collect information about not only individuals but entire marginalized and

2:37:04 even vulnerable communities who are not suspected of any wrongdoing.

2:37:11 This is even more concerning when it comes to collecting data on miners or drivers.

2:37:16 These systems capture license plates, vehicle location, time-lapse, timestamps, and movement

2:37:23 patterns.

2:37:24 individual movements can become a detailed map of a person's private life,

2:37:29 like where they worship, when they visit a friend, a family member, seek medical

2:37:35 care, meet with their legal counsel, attend-

2:37:38 We have time's up. Thank you. Thank you.

2:37:40 Last one on the list is Jeffrey Nielsen.

2:37:51 Hi there, I'm Jeffrey Nielsen. I've been a resident of Twin Falls for five years.

2:38:02 I'm a little worried about this thing. It seems like it's all the wonderful people

2:38:07 earlier they've stated their objection to this that police department will win out.

2:38:16 Our liberty has to come first.

2:38:18 I know the chief here, I appreciate him, I know he does a good job, but you know what,

2:38:24 there's good police work without this type of surveillance.

2:38:29 Coming over here today, I was cambered at least four times.

2:38:34 I only live a mile and a half away.

2:38:38 What the hell is that all about?

2:38:40 Just wrong.

2:38:42 I've never been to a city council meeting before and I've never spoken up in public before but this is just wrong

2:38:49 Get rid of this flock camera

2:38:51 Go back to doing original police work. I know you can do it and let's move forward

2:38:59 Rachel you said that was all we had at this point everybody it filled out okay. I appreciate everybody's comments

2:39:15 It was presented tonight. Sorry stumble over my words

2:39:19 appreciate the input and as we as Travis had mentioned we are not going to make

2:39:26 any decisions tonight. We still have public input as the budget proceeds and

2:39:31 and we'll continue to follow our processes and procedures as we move forward but

2:39:36 appreciate your willingness to come and stand. I did I did forget to note before I

2:39:41 said we do have public comments that have come in through our online module and

2:39:48 And they will also be a part of the public record as well.

2:39:52 So there were several more individuals

2:39:54 that provided public comment on this topic.

2:39:57 And I apologize for not saying that

2:39:58 at the beginning of the public comment period.

2:40:01 So we will move on to our next item of a business tonight,

2:40:06 which is advisory board report.

2:40:16 Thank you.

2:40:17 I just said thank you.

2:40:18 I just said thank you.

2:40:20 I appreciate it.

2:40:21 Thank you.

2:40:24 So we'll move on to advisory board reports.

2:40:28 Can I just say something quick?

2:40:30 I know some people are leaving and totally fine.

2:40:33 We do follow the agenda.

2:40:35 I just want you to know that this conversation,

2:40:38 as I'm sure many of you are, this conversation is not done.

2:40:40 Our police department does not want to just wait

2:40:43 till things cool off.

2:40:44 That's not who they are, okay?

2:40:47 Please continue to communicate.

2:40:49 We've had a lot of public comment input.

2:40:52 We've received it all.

2:40:53 Our email information is out there.

2:40:55 Please communicate with us,

2:40:56 communicate with our law enforcement,

2:40:59 we want to have a good relationship.

2:41:01 So please know that just because the agenda,

2:41:05 the next step on the agenda has come to,

2:41:07 we've come to that point,

2:41:08 does not mean this conversation's done, okay?

2:41:11 Thank you.

2:41:11 Thanks, Chris.

2:41:14 Seeing none, that brings over City Manager's office.

2:41:17 Nothing this evening, Mayor.

2:41:18 That brings us to our Executive Session,

2:41:20 a request to adjourn to Executive Session,

2:41:23 pursuant to Idaho Code 742061F

2:41:26 to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency

2:41:31 to discuss the legal ramifications of

2:41:33 and legal opinions for pending litigation

2:41:36 or controversies not yet being litigated,

2:41:39 but imminently likely to be litigated.

2:41:42 The mere presence of legal counsel

2:41:44 at an executive session does not satisfy

2:41:47 this requirement, order counts.

2:41:49 So moved.

2:41:50 Second.

2:41:50 Can I have a first and a second to adjourn

2:41:52 to executive session, any further discussion?

2:41:55 Okay, Rachel, we'll call vote, please.

2:41:57 Craig Hawkins.

2:41:58 Yes.

2:41:59 Jason Brown.

2:42:00 Yes.

2:42:01 Sherry Volmer.

2:42:01 Yes.

2:42:02 Grayson Stone.

2:42:03 Yes.

2:42:04 Nathan Murray.

2:42:05 Yes.

2:42:06 Ruth Pierce.

2:42:07 Yes.

2:42:08 And Chris Reed.

2:42:09 Yes.

2:42:10 Hey, motion carries seven to zero.

2:42:11 That does conclude our city council meeting for tonight.

2:42:13 We will see, be back here next week.

2:42:16 We will not be making any decisions in executive session.

2:42:18 Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 27, 2026. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:42:21.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    4f7f918f1950d19a7ffdea73d02b15d4963a1b6daa9ebea4772507a9df5d67d5
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 35a4aba0301a2e5a5b30cf6eb47df8195bfd8f9beccf986b08877efdde7ce34e
    part02.m4a b482f6a8c9670fa52bbea291fcd4f35dc504f84065ee045bb6494db6ef61636e
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    42ad52e05736e8812baa8def163c7377f3bf6dcb5afa03eefb9c0dda60ee7b25

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file