OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, July 6, 2026

Regular meeting. 2 recordings. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording 1 started 15:43

Recording

The transcript for this recording isn't posted yet.

Download

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 6, 2026. The recording started at 15:43 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:04:36.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    7d0f4d28d4b2190d08c0ebaea206d916d9705a1be7a0310bf3c6575e85965ee2
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 986aeb0ccabe292b94e6bb51ac1015311d1622b59e37512cc7c8ed3be6a5cb86

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file

Recording 2 started 17:00

Recording

Transcript

0:00:00 the order. We have all seven council members in chambers tonight and so confirm that we

0:00:07 have a quorum. We'll move on to the Pledge of Allegiance. All of those in attendance that

0:00:12 would like to do so please stand.

0:00:14 Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:00:32 Thank you.

0:00:35 So being our first council meeting of the month, we have an invocation by Bruce Carlson.

0:00:45 He's with Cornerstone Baptist Church, correct?

0:00:48 Correct.

0:00:49 Thank you, Mayor.

0:00:50 Thank you, City Council.

0:00:51 Let's pray together.

0:00:52 God, thank you for being so good to us in our country and in our city in this time of

0:00:57 year that we get to celebrate the greatness of all that you have done here.

0:01:00 God, as we come before you tonight, we're thankful for your wonderful mercies in our city and

0:01:05 the great place that you've given us to live.

0:01:08 And Lord, thank you for these leaders

0:01:10 that have invested their time and their energy

0:01:13 and their efforts in leading and directing our city.

0:01:16 We pray for your blessing upon them, God,

0:01:18 that you would guide them and direct them,

0:01:20 help them to make wise decisions,

0:01:22 and God that you would give them insight

0:01:24 into the things that are necessary

0:01:26 for the future of our city as we prepare a legacy

0:01:29 for our children to come and make preparations

0:01:32 for them in the future as well.

0:01:34 Pray God that you bless their homes, their families,

0:01:36 care for their needs each and every day.

0:01:39 And God, we do ask that you would bless our first responders,

0:01:43 you care for their needs, God, our hospital,

0:01:46 and those that care for our medical needs as well.

0:01:49 God that you would watch over them, bless them greatly,

0:01:52 give them wisdom and the necessary things

0:01:55 to accomplish the task of caring for the community

0:01:58 of our city.

0:01:59 We pray God that you would bless this city.

0:02:01 We pray God that you would help us to become one together.

0:02:04 We'd work together.

0:02:05 We would honor you in this place.

0:02:07 And we pray God that you pour out your favor upon it.

0:02:09 Help us to look to you and trust you.

0:02:12 And depend upon you for our future.

0:02:14 We pray God for the specific needs that we do have God.

0:02:17 We bring the budget before you tonight

0:02:19 asking for your direction in it.

0:02:21 You'd help us to all to be good stewards

0:02:23 of what you've given to us.

0:02:24 We know how to invest it.

0:02:26 And Lord that we know how to plan and prepare.

0:02:29 And God that you might be glorified in this place.

0:02:32 We thank you, God, for each person here in our city.

0:02:34 And we pray, God, that you would help us know

0:02:36 how to help one another and meet the needs

0:02:38 that are here in this place.

0:02:40 We thank you, God, for the privilege of living here.

0:02:42 And we do pray, God, that you would guide and direct again,

0:02:44 all that we do, all that we accomplish,

0:02:47 help us to love one another, the way that you decide,

0:02:49 design this to do.

0:02:51 And we'll thank you, God, for your help tonight

0:02:53 and trust you in faith to do so.

0:02:55 In Jesus' name, we pray, Amen.

0:02:59 Thank you.

0:03:01 Move into our consent calendar.

0:03:04 What are council's wishes?

0:03:06 Move to approve.

0:03:08 Have a second.

0:03:09 A second.

0:03:09 Have a motion by councilman Reid and a second

0:03:13 by councilwoman Pierce to approve the consent calendar.

0:03:16 Is there any further discussion?

0:03:19 Rachel roll call vote.

0:03:21 Carried Hawkins.

0:03:22 Yes.

0:03:23 Jason Brown.

0:03:24 Sherry Holmer.

0:03:24 Yes.

0:03:25 Grayson Stone.

0:03:26 Yes.

0:03:27 Nathan Murray.

0:03:28 Yes.

0:03:29 Ruth Pierce and Chris Reid.

0:03:29 Yes.

0:03:30 motion carries 7-0. Our first item of consideration tonight is a request to use water reserve

0:03:39 funds not to exceed $150,000 to utilize professional service to investigate the canyons ring pump

0:03:48 station adjacent water supply corridor and we have Josh Baird.

0:03:52 Thanks my Brown and Council members. So this may seem like a familiar request. It's almost

0:03:59 I said anything little I came and requested back in August of last year.

0:04:04 It's to figure out what to do with this corridor and make sure to become of the good

0:04:09 presentation as we're concerned about it as part of our really important supply line from

0:04:16 our supply of water on the north side of the Snake River, the Harrison tank.

0:04:20 So that being said, we have already moved forward in higher J.A.B., but we maybe, I

0:04:28 I recognize after the fact that we need to come to council

0:04:30 because our approval ended at the end of the last fiscal year,

0:04:34 so it was only good for a couple of months.

0:04:35 So with October 1, 2025, he approved one away,

0:04:40 and so the request is to authorize spending

0:04:42 in this fiscal year to take care of that project.

0:04:45 And I can stand for any questions you may have,

0:04:47 but it's the same project we already have.

0:04:49 Any questions, Ruth Pierce.

0:04:50 I'm headed to make a motion.

0:04:52 Hey, Chris, you.

0:04:53 Okay, go ahead.

0:04:54 I move we approve the use of water reserve funds

0:04:57 not to exceed $150,000 to utilize professional services

0:05:02 to investigate the Canyon Springs pump station

0:05:04 and adjacent water supply corridor.

0:05:07 Chris, I'll second.

0:05:08 Kevin, motion and a second to use water reserves funds,

0:05:12 not to exceed $150,000 or professional service

0:05:16 to investigate the Canyon Springs pump station

0:05:18 and adjacent water supply corridor.

0:05:20 Is there any further conversation or discussion

0:05:22 from the council?

0:05:25 Okay, Rachel, roll call vote.

0:05:29 Sherry Vollmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Nathan Murray. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes.

0:05:37 Okay. Motion carries seven to zero. Appreciate it. Josh and all the work that you've done bringing us to this point.

0:05:47 Now we get to the real exciting part of tonight's meeting, right? That's why we moved through everything else really fast.

0:05:54 That's why I was making motion.

0:05:56 All the engineering stuff we got away so we could start talking budget, right?

0:06:00 Exactly.

0:06:01 So our next item is our city manager is going to kick off our budget presentations for

0:06:09 the next couple of weeks, next several weeks.

0:06:12 And so we'll turn the time over to Travis.

0:06:15 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.

0:06:20 I think that when you take a look at the cover of the budget,

0:06:24 It really is an amazing photo and it is incredibly symbolic of not only celebrating our 250th birthday as a country,

0:06:37 but also the beauty and that is Twin Falls.

0:06:43 And what a privilege it is to be able to live in a community like Twin Falls, to recreate, to raise our families.

0:06:53 And this budget and all the work that we do is really trying to make sure that our community is left in a better space than we found it.

0:07:06 You know, some time ago, Mitch brought the Athenian oath to the city and he shared that and it really has kind of been part of that legacy.

0:07:19 legacy and part of that Athenian oath is to leave it a little bit better in which you found it.

0:07:24 And hopefully through this process, not only through budgeting but also the work that we do as a city,

0:07:29 we will be able to transmit this city better. And that our work here will be looked at in years

0:07:41 to come as thoughtful, as honoring our fiduciary responsibility and creating a platform or continued

0:07:51 successes to be built upon. Tonight, I'm going to try a little bit different approach,

0:08:03 but there's some basic things that we have to kind of navigate through.

0:08:08 So, why do we budget and what is our fiscal year?

0:08:14 So we begin our process tonight in anticipation of this budget becoming effective on October

0:08:21 1st.

0:08:22 And so all of the work that we do is really a look forward and we try to use the best

0:08:30 information that we have to understand the health of our local economy, the ability for

0:08:40 our community to continue to prosper, and what role does local government have in that process.

0:08:48 And statutorily, we are required to put together an annual budget in which is balanced.

0:08:55 So unlike other institutions and governments, our revenues and expenses must equal.

0:09:05 And in that process, we are going to assign dollars to projects and to human talent in

0:09:14 an effort to accomplish the work that is expected by the citizens.

0:09:20 These are a few of the statutory guidelines that we use in following our budget, and I

0:09:28 can share with you that this budget that is created will go through the process, is really

0:09:35 the work and the labor of many hands and the talented folks that are part of our organization.

0:09:44 While I have the opportunity to present the budget, which is part of the numerated statutory

0:09:50 responsibilities that I have as you can see in 50-811. I did not build this

0:09:57 alone or if I were to have built this budget alone it would fall short of all

0:10:03 of the needs that we have and I rely upon the expertise that is present tonight

0:10:07 and all those that have contributed to this work for your review. And that's

0:10:13 important the state for your review. Over the course of the next several weeks

0:10:20 members of our team will come forward and they will share their recommendations, but

0:10:27 at the end of the day it is the seven of you that have the statutory authority to

0:10:34 adjust to modify to change any part of this budget with only one condition. At

0:10:42 the end of the day it remains balanced. And so we're happy to start this journey

0:10:47 with you. Please, as you have questions as we go through this, interrupt me. And then

0:10:56 over the course of the next several weeks, members of our team will come forward and we

0:11:01 will present this budget very systematically in accordance to the focus areas that are contained

0:11:06 within our City's strategic plan. The members of the team who helped build this budget will

0:11:13 also have an opportunity to showcase and share their thoughts and expertise.

0:11:22 So, one of the things that's important to remember, always at government, is we are public servants.

0:11:30 And in a sense, that translates to being a customer service entity.

0:11:37 And understanding the expectations and needs of our customers is critically important.

0:11:47 We utilize the Citizen Survey to determine where are we meeting expectations and what

0:11:54 can we do to continue to meet or exceed those expectations.

0:11:59 recognize when we fall short and we want to understand how we can improve in the eyes of

0:12:09 our customer. Because at the end of the day, it's our fiduciary responsibility to take the

0:12:15 resources that they provide to us and translate those dollars into tangible services. We spend

0:12:23 a lot of time analyzing the local economy and part of that build-up, every quarter, Brianna

0:12:30 presents to you a very thoughtful finance report that's not just about the City of

0:12:37 Twin Falls's budget and our overall budget health. It really is an

0:12:42 exploration in community health and what's the status of our local economy and how

0:12:48 strong is it and where are some of the things that are causing struggle and

0:12:54 concern with our citizens and then what is our role in local government to

0:13:00 help in that process. Not all problems and issues that our community faces can be

0:13:08 solved by us. In fact, there are several where our role is to simply be a convener,

0:13:14 to use our statutory authority to bring partners together to be able to assist

0:13:21 in the completion of the public's work. It really comes from engaging our employees.

0:13:28 So we have a very unique process inside of the City of Twin Falls where individuals

0:13:35 from across the organization bring their talents and expertise to the table to help

0:13:42 discuss the annual budget. The annual budget is not crafted in a silo in the

0:13:47 city manager's office but really through what we refer to as a one-city approach

0:13:52 where all the departments operate collectively in an effort to realize the

0:14:00 city's mission and vision. In that process, utilizes the city's 2030 strategic plan

0:14:07 and will transition to the 2040 strategic plan. It utilizes their needs.

0:14:14 It incorporates the work that the fleet team has performed so that our rolling

0:14:22 stock has a continual replacement schedule and we use that to kick off the annual budgeting

0:14:28 process. And so while we are sharing this for the first time with you publicly, members

0:14:36 of the city's long-term planning team have already begun work on the fiscal 28 budget.

0:14:49 We want to make sure that we're not making cuts just for the sake of making cuts.

0:14:56 And we want to make sure that in our process we analyze the cuts that we're making, the

0:15:04 reductions that it may cause in services.

0:15:07 And similarly, when we're going to expand revenues and resources, we want to understand

0:15:13 what that return on the investment is going to be.

0:15:18 And their work has really caused what we once referred to as a big budget balancing meeting

0:15:25 to last just a matter of hours in comparison to a matter of days.

0:15:30 They come together as a team.

0:15:32 The team creates a budget, and that budget is there for your consideration.

0:15:37 It's built upon a leadership philosophy and values that are two of the cornerstones of guiding

0:15:43 documents of our organization to help us truly become high-performing and our work is recognized

0:15:50 by our peers. These awards are not for the sake of earning awards and hanging more accommodations

0:15:59 on walls. We do this because this is a best practice and our citizens deserve the best that

0:16:07 that we have to offer.

0:16:11 But what is Twin Falls?

0:16:14 And in order to level set the conversation,

0:16:19 it is important that all reviewers of this budget

0:16:24 have a baseline understanding of how we

0:16:28 view the economy and the city.

0:16:31 So we're 57,000 people.

0:16:35 And we were 51,000 people at the census, which

0:16:39 a 10.17% growth rate. And as we continue through that, we will crest over 60,000 persons inside

0:16:48 of the City of Twin Falls by the year 2030. But it's not the size of the City of Twin Falls

0:16:59 that drives our budget. It's the more than 40,000 vehicles across the Prine Bridge every

0:17:06 single day, and that's only one access point inside of the city, which causes our city to

0:17:13 grow and to expand, and for the city of Twin Falls to become a supporter of those who also

0:17:23 visit our community.

0:17:25 So when you think that our area, it's important to recognize that while our estimated daytime

0:17:34 population grows to about $112,000 plus. It's more than just cars. Because when you look at our

0:17:42 per capita retail sales, it exceeds $2.1 billion and our per capita retail sales in 2022 was

0:17:50 greater than our household income in 2024. If you were to take the city of Twin Falls and you were

0:18:00 to cut our per capita spending in half. That is back in line with the state

0:18:10 average. There is no city in the state of Idaho that I've been able to find in

0:18:17 utilizing the US Census in which is spending more than their household

0:18:25 income. And I think that's an important consideration because all of those

0:18:30 individuals who come into our city have an expectation of service. And housing is a

0:18:39 concern for all of us. The median household, median house value in May in the city of

0:18:48 Twin Falls, according to Zillow, was $373,000, which is a 60% increase since 2020.

0:18:58 and the Idaho value is down slightly from its high of 506 and 2022 is still $100,000 more

0:19:10 than the median home inside of the City of Twin Falls. Housing is a concern and it is something

0:19:18 that we'll talk and spend some time in. And then unemployment. Our unemployment rate is low.

0:19:26 3.6% is a low unemployment rate and most economists, depending upon which ones you'll

0:19:33 speak to, will tell you that full employment is at four or five percent.

0:19:41 That tells us that the ability to attract and hire workers continues to remain a challenge

0:19:50 not only for our community but also for our organization.

0:19:59 So the first thing I'm going to share is this slide is intentionally wrong.

0:20:05 It's intentionally wrong for two reasons.

0:20:07 Number one, the median person that we use to create this scenario does not exist.

0:20:13 So no one uses the median value of water and sewer and sanitation and lives in a median

0:20:21 house.

0:20:22 Everything that we hear is to provide an illustration.

0:20:26 And when I get asked what is going to happen to my tax bill, I can't answer that, because

0:20:35 at local government level we set the tax rate, and our partners at the county are assigned

0:20:42 the responsibility to assess the value of the home.

0:20:47 And collectively that is going to determine a tax burden that is placed on each of our

0:20:54 individual citizens moving forward. The second reason it's wrong is because you

0:21:01 will notice that we say that sanitation and recycling is going to cost us the same

0:21:07 this year as it did last year. And with our recent request for proposals from

0:21:16 PSI, we know that the price for sanitation is going to decrease. We do not know at this

0:21:26 time the full level of services that the council is going to select. So we elected to leave

0:21:32 at the same. So at worst, it may be $2 per month less than what we're reflecting now.

0:21:40 And it best, it could be upwards of $9 per month less.

0:21:46 And so when you focus on $2 or $9, you can see that variance per month does change.

0:21:56 And that will be a conversation with the PSI contract as it will mature as the summer goes

0:22:05 on.

0:22:06 point, we felt it was safe to present what is the worst possible scenario. We want to

0:22:19 share a whole series of charts and graphs because these are the things that

0:22:25 cause us to say is this budget sustainable in the long term? Does the

0:22:34 citizens of our community have the ability to pay the bills that we are

0:22:41 going to pass on to them as we transfer them into services.

0:22:46 And so what we've done is a reflection on home values, not only in Twin Falls, but Idaho

0:22:51 and Boise.

0:22:52 And we have a running total just to kind of show how that is increased.

0:22:57 It's increased to $147,000 since 2020 or by more than 60 percent and each one of those

0:23:03 increases is reflected and you can see that May, compared to January, it continues to grow.

0:23:14 So why do we pick January?

0:23:15 January is the point in time in which the assessments of our properties are determined

0:23:20 and that is what we use for property taxes in part of our calculation.

0:23:26 And then the other thing we want to understand is what's going to potentially occur over

0:23:29 the course of the next 12 months, because as our budgets continue to evolve, we want to

0:23:34 make sure that does the city and our residents continue to have the ability to pay property

0:23:40 taxes.

0:23:41 And if you follow the news, there are some who believe the abolishment of property taxes

0:23:48 would be smart.

0:23:50 And while no one likes to pay property taxes, me included, I don't get a waiver on the property

0:23:58 tax bill that I have to pay. My failure to pay property taxes, even though I'm

0:24:04 employed by the city, would result in my house becoming default. And if it's in a

0:24:11 state of default, it can be appropriately seized by the county. So we're mindful in

0:24:17 our own organization about the property tax burdens that are passed on by a local

0:24:24 government. But I will also say that one of the things that local government,

0:24:29 including the city of Twin Falls, needs to do a better job at,

0:24:32 is sharing the return on the investment.

0:24:36 What do individuals receive for their property taxes?

0:24:40 And what are some other tools and mechanisms that we can use to lessen

0:24:45 that property tax burden?

0:24:48 I'm becoming more and more convinced that the Idaho legislature will speak to two.

0:24:54 should they be successful in November.

0:24:56 Needs to seriously look at the opportunity

0:25:01 of a local option sales tax.

0:25:04 If the City of Twin Falls based upon $2.1 billion

0:25:08 of retail sales was able to collect a penny

0:25:13 and we returned half of that collection

0:25:18 back in the form of property tax relief,

0:25:21 the City of Twin Falls would have about 10 to 10 and a half

0:25:25 million dollars more to be able to support critical infrastructure, public safety, and

0:25:35 those that impact our community on a daily basis. In addition to that, we could cut property taxes

0:25:43 by an equal and point five million dollars. Ten point five million dollars off a thirty-two

0:25:54 million dollars worth of property tax collections means we could provide immediate property tax

0:26:01 relief now. But we're not allowed to ask the question. In a Dillon Rule state, we are only allowed

0:26:14 the powers that the legislature sees fit. And while our citizens may want it, we are not allowed

0:26:23 to ask the question. I believe our citizens should have an opportunity to at

0:26:31 least answer the question. They may say no, and that's okay. But not being able to

0:26:39 ask the question in exchange for true property tax relief inside of the city

0:26:43 of Twin Falls, I believe is a disservice to local government. One of the great

0:26:53 tools that we take a look at has been developed by a news entity and it is the

0:27:01 home buyers index. That home buyers index assigns a number between 0 and 100 and

0:27:09 the higher the number the more difficult it is to acquire a home. And so

0:27:17 when you take a look at the top graph how property has changed since 2018

0:27:23 to 2026. You can see that it is grown inside. This is county-wide data. This is not available

0:27:30 at the city level. So this is a reflection just on counties. And inside of our county,

0:27:38 you can see that the first graph shows that the escalation of the median list price of

0:27:45 home has increased from 200,000 in 2018 to 425,000 dollars in 2026. Different than Zillow.

0:27:57 Why it's different than Zillow? I can't answer that. I trust the data and I will also share that at

0:28:05 the bottom it talks about the buying power and it reflects where the buying power, what our median

0:28:12 income families can afford. And you can see that gap that they can afford a home at $382,000

0:28:20 inside of the county. Again, Zillow focuses only inside of the city proper. It does not focus.

0:28:27 We don't focus on the county. And you can see what that disparity is. And what does that mean?

0:28:32 That means that Twin Falls County is the fourth worst overall county when it

0:28:42 comes to this in the 1898 counties surveyed across the country and we're

0:28:50 the most difficult in the state of Idaho. Access to homes is critical. It's not

0:28:59 only critical for the fabric that is our communities, the laborers, the teachers,

0:29:05 those in the medical profession, all of the members of our organization, it's our

0:29:10 ability to continue to raise a family and the financial stress and pressures that

0:29:17 are placed upon our families and our community as a result of home ownership.

0:29:21 We focus on cost and the municipal cost index is for this year from March to

0:29:34 March, when we measure it, was up 1.9 percent and that sounds really good.

0:29:44 It's the steep climb since this last year that has been compounding, where the cost has

0:29:52 increased of municipal services from March of 21 to March of 25, more than 20 percent.

0:30:01 And the municipal cost index is different than a consumer price index.

0:30:05 It focuses on the basket of goods that governments typically consume most, asphalt, cement.

0:30:16 All of the things that cause us to go and where our costs variations are.

0:30:22 And as many have come before you and talked about costs and increasing costs as they are

0:30:29 presenting budgets and asking for some level of support through reserves to be able to

0:30:35 complete the project. Those projects don't go away because they become more

0:30:42 expensive. Sometimes what happens is those projects become deferred and we

0:30:48 increase the list of deferred maintenance and we can hope and wish that some of our

0:30:55 infrastructure problems can have healing processes of their own but in

0:31:02 reality that's not true and when we fail to make investments in our

0:31:06 infrastructure, we are not setting a foundation for our community to be able to grow, and we're

0:31:12 not transmitting this city better in which we found it. So the report that Josh presented to you

0:31:19 tonight was really about an opportunity to explore what do we need to be doing as a community to be

0:31:28 fixing a water corridor to ensure that we have water when we turn on us. Because I'm going to bet

0:31:38 that there wasn't many people that when we all woke up this morning at whatever time that was and

0:31:43 we went to make our coffee or brush our teeth or take a shower did we have an expectation that the

0:31:49 water wouldn't turn on. If the water didn't turn on there were some pretty angry phone calls that

0:31:56 were coming into city because we were disrupting their day. My son's currently serving a short-term

0:32:02 mission in the Dominican Republic and he can't use the water to brush his teeth but yet it becomes

0:32:11 an expectation of our community and not even a second thought as to whether or not our water

0:32:17 is clean. I'm going to entirely bet that just as I was mindless when I turned on my faucet,

0:32:25 I didn't give a second thought as to where it went either. And behind all of that is a critical

0:32:31 infrastructure that is manned by talented men and women to make sure that the magic happens.

0:32:36 It is exciting. It is exciting. And sometimes it's even more exciting when we fail to deliver.

0:32:48 But part of that corridor study is to ask ourselves, is the timing right to ask the citizens

0:32:55 to invest more in our infrastructure in a form of a bond? That's what we're exploring.

0:33:03 We have a water tank that we're going to be spending more time about in subsequent weeks.

0:33:07 that's more than 50 years old, that is literally the heart of our water system, and if that

0:33:17 system were to fail on a July day, the access to clean drinking water is problematic.

0:33:28 The inability to have fire flow could be detrimental.

0:33:33 So we're going to continue to explore ways to invest in our infrastructure throughout

0:33:38 subsequent conversations. We also need to find a way to continue to invest in our employees.

0:33:46 The men and women that work for the City of Twin Falls are on the front lines of customer service.

0:33:51 They are the ones who respond during the time and eat when the water doesn't

0:33:55 be delivered in the manner that we expect. When we had to make a call because your kid or your

0:34:03 neighbor inadvertently light a firework and spark a small brush fire. It's all of those

0:34:10 those things that we call and there's an expectation that government comes.

0:34:17 And holding on to talent is one of the cornerstones of our organization and it needs to continue

0:34:23 to be so.

0:34:25 Our organization has great tenured folks that at some point in time are going to make a

0:34:31 transition from working to retirement.

0:34:35 And as they transition, we need to make sure that we continue to be that employer of choice

0:34:41 to offer packages and services to attract and retain talent,

0:34:45 because the talent is getting scarce.

0:34:48 There are fewer people that want to go

0:34:50 into local government today.

0:34:52 There are fewer people yet who want to be first responders.

0:34:57 Yet, that's part of our critical infrastructure.

0:35:00 It's a primary function of what we do.

0:35:06 We're not alone.

0:35:09 What this slide shares is that there are more job openings

0:35:14 in the state of Idaho, then there are unemployed workers.

0:35:20 That's not qualified workers.

0:35:24 That's unemployed workers.

0:35:27 The labor market remains tight, and it is important for us

0:35:33 to be competitive.

0:35:36 And I will be unapologetic in presenting this budget

0:35:40 when I'm asking for raises.

0:35:43 When I'm asking that we make sure that the men and women

0:35:47 work here have the ability to provide for their families. I'm not saying with

0:35:53 extravagance, but in a way that is appropriate for them. But as we do all of

0:36:04 these things and we talk about these expenditures, we want to be

0:36:07 mindful that is following these six goals established by the City Council.

0:36:14 Among them and being important is that it is stable and sustainable and nimble.

0:36:21 Every year, there seems to be something that causes a shock to the system, whether that's

0:36:30 COVID or conflicts in the Middle East.

0:36:34 Something is going to cause our local economy and our national economy to go through some

0:36:40 sort of bump.

0:36:42 We need to be able to be sensitive to our operating environment, to be able to respond

0:36:47 to that.

0:36:48 We want to be the employer of choice.

0:36:50 We want to make sure that our taxes are sustainable, and we also want to make sure that we're maximizing

0:36:58 our utility increases.

0:37:03 So here's the city's total taxable value.

0:37:06 This is a city of how we are in a nutshell.

0:37:10 We're going to ask for a 5% increase in water and sewer this year to be able to support

0:37:17 that critical infrastructure.

0:37:19 We've asked for a 3% property tax increase in revenue compared to the last year.

0:37:25 We've asked to use 90% of the full value of the new construction role that was submitted

0:37:32 to us and using a portion of the Foregone Balance this year.

0:37:38 And this is the last year that we will be able to use 1% of the Foregone Balance.

0:37:45 after this, that value that we have had in the bank will be evaporated.

0:37:52 And so as an entity, we've already had conversations that future budgets are going to have less predictable

0:38:01 revenues than the one that we have now.

0:38:04 And we are going to have to continue to use data in the form of performance measurement

0:38:10 and priority-based budgeting to make sure we're doing the right what for our citizens.

0:38:16 And in the spirit of one city that's hanging on all of our walls, there are seven diagnostic

0:38:20 questions that we ask, and part of them have to deal with the finances.

0:38:26 And it asks us, are we doing the right what?

0:38:29 Which goes back to our citizen survey, which helps us understand what do the citizens need,

0:38:34 what do they want, what do the level of services that they expect, and how are we going to

0:38:39 systematically be able to provide that.

0:38:41 And the tax rate this year is going to go down.

0:38:46 So here's the growth of the city, which is incredibly impressive that if you think that just since 2021

0:38:54 The total taxable value of the city is nearly double. It was three point four million dollars in 2021

0:39:02 It is nearly six point eight million dollars

0:39:06 This year and that excludes

0:39:09 717 million dollars that's inside of the urban renewal areas

0:39:13 So collectively the value that is encompassed inside of the city of Twin Falls as corporate boundaries now exceeds

0:39:21 7.5 Travis has got a question for you

0:39:26 Thank you, mr. Mary. Yeah, I have two quick questions for you one on slide 15

0:39:31 That's not helpful

0:39:36 They're all labeled so on the city of Twin Falls unemployment rate

0:39:40 We have it at 3.6 this year? Yep, that one.

0:39:44 Yep, that was from May. It fluctuates every May, and we get the numbers from the

0:39:48 jobs report furnished to us by the Idaho Department of Commerce.

0:39:52 I remember, and then one of your presentations, and you said essentially

0:39:56 anybody in R&MSA that wanted a job could have a job? Yes.

0:40:00 Is that percentage reflect that mentality still? Yes.

0:40:04 Perfect. And more importantly, as

0:40:08 point this out, I want to be mindful of a soccer match and I know that you have

0:40:13 this information to be able to take with you. Everybody in America has become a

0:40:21 football fan, right, and football F-U-T-B-O-L. Twin Falls is growing, yet, year over

0:40:31 year, we lost 99 laborers. But while the City of Twin Falls is growing, those who

0:40:41 are in the labor market is shrinking and according to the Idaho Department of Commerce 75 of those

0:40:47 individuals left last month not everyone who's coming to Twin Falls is working not everyone that's

0:40:54 coming into our community is contributing to the workforce and then just a quick follow-up question

0:41:03 I just want to reiterate you just stated based upon the data on slide 18 with the property taxes

0:41:10 that our tax rate for the city of Twin Falls is actually going down it is and we'll get into that

0:41:16 it is going down. I just want to make that abundantly clear. Our tax rate is going down.

0:41:21 Thank you. In fact, here's that slide. Our tax rate last year compared to this year is going to go down

0:41:30 slightly and it reflects all of the tax rates since 2021 and if you follow that graph and you're to do

0:41:37 a linear regression, you can see that it is downward trending. One of the questions we get asked is

0:41:49 How does my property taxes pay that I pay

0:41:53 inside the city of Twin Falls equal to other cities

0:41:58 inside of the state of Idaho?

0:41:59 And we use a couple of different sources

0:42:02 to help determine that.

0:42:04 We use Zillow because it's consistent

0:42:07 and what's what we have access to

0:42:09 in measuring all the properties inside of the state of Idaho.

0:42:12 Then we also use the Association of Idaho,

0:42:15 Associate Taxpayers of Idaho Levy Book,

0:42:17 which shares with us the tax rate that is provided

0:42:22 to the Secretary of State's office

0:42:25 at the conclusion of every budget process.

0:42:27 And so these are rear looking.

0:42:28 So if you take a look at the City of Twin Falls,

0:42:32 total city taxes paid on a median home in January 25,

0:42:37 which had a value of $363,286.

0:42:41 Again, our tax rate last year paid $1,337 in two cents.

0:42:46 Now, people will say, I pay more than that in property taxes.

0:42:50 We're going to say, yes.

0:42:52 We recognize that this is only the city's share and the only the city's portion because

0:42:56 that's all that we have control over.

0:43:00 If people scroll down and they look at their assessment, there are many other institutions

0:43:07 that the City of Twin Falls doesn't have the ability to control what they do and or should

0:43:11 we.

0:43:13 We can control ourselves.

0:43:16 And when you take a look at the city tax burden in comparison to other full service cities in

0:43:24 the state of Idaho, we are among the lowest.

0:43:27 And you'll ask yourself that there are big three cities that you're leaving off the table.

0:43:33 You left off Boise, you left off Meridian, and you left off Nampa.

0:43:39 And there's reason for that.

0:43:41 first is streets are maintained and developed by the Ada County Highway District inside of Ada County.

0:43:51 So none of those cities offer road services, which is a significant part of our budget.

0:43:58 And then recently the city of Nampa elected to have its fire department that was once in house

0:44:06 be transformed into a fire district and so the city of Nampa no longer offers fire services

0:44:12 which is a significant portion of our budget as well and so we're not able to really compare

0:44:18 apples to apples to those cities and I don't think it's a fair comparison to do multiple additions

0:44:26 to their tax rates for what that could be so we focus on something very clean and this is where

0:44:31 where the City of Twin Falls stacks up.

0:44:37 Any questions on the economics that we use?

0:44:42 Hopefully there were no surprises.

0:44:45 So we say that government budget is the lifeblood

0:44:50 because this budget right here is how we intend

0:44:54 to allocate $65 million of tax-supported funds,

0:44:59 which is defined by any part of that budget

0:45:02 that relies on a portion of property taxes to operate.

0:45:06 and then enterprise funds or non-tax supportive $32 million.

0:45:11 Those two pieces, one paid for by user fees,

0:45:15 one part funded, and then other non-tax-supported funds

0:45:21 really makes up the entirety of the city

0:45:23 of Twin Falls budget.

0:45:25 So our budget this year totals $102 million,

0:45:29 which is a million dollar increase,

0:45:31 million $122,000, 1.1% compared to last year,

0:45:36 bouncing back the municipal cost index was 1.9%.

0:45:43 Most of that is driven by the use of cash reserves

0:45:47 on the tune of $4,600,000 to complete one-time projects.

0:45:53 And enterprise funds decreased by $3.5 million,

0:45:56 because those projects that were funded by one-time cash

0:45:59 reserves have been funded and completed.

0:46:02 So when you take a look at our budget,

0:46:04 It is fairly static in comparison to years past.

0:46:11 A lot of the budget that we're going to spend time talking about moving forward

0:46:15 is what we refer to as the net budget because we remove the transfers.

0:46:20 We can get into the government detail if people want to,

0:46:24 but a transfer is a rent that we charge the enterprise funds.

0:46:29 And for the sake of making sure that we're not double counting,

0:46:35 We want to make sure that we are talking budget to budget.

0:46:40 You can see that we break our budget into five major categories.

0:46:45 The first and the largest is personnel.

0:46:48 When you think about being a customer service entity, it makes sense that our people, the

0:46:54 talent that we employ are the largest driving share of our budget, followed by operation

0:47:00 and maintenance and capital, which is similar this year.

0:47:04 For a city, the size that we are to have debt service in the tune of 3.4% is remarkable.

0:47:12 We have no general obligation debt.

0:47:14 The only debt that we have presently is inside of the sewer fund, and that is a result of

0:47:21 the 2012 wastewater treatment plant expansion, which was very thoughtful.

0:47:28 Because today at the wastewater treatment plant, we have capacity to be able to grow and expand

0:47:34 our local economy. And I believe that's where Councilman Reid got his first taste into local

0:47:40 government. So when you think about the tax supported funds, they value 61.87 million dollars

0:47:50 of the $97 million net budget. And then we kind of go through where the revenues are coming

0:47:58 in. You can see that 51% of the tax supported budget or the government fund budget is supported

0:48:06 property taxes. And so when there's a conversation that Idaho should do away

0:48:11 with property taxes, I struggle to understand how we would make up in excess

0:48:18 of $32 million or services. So what does property taxes pay for inside the City of

0:48:27 Twin Falls? I can tell you that it does not pay the entire cost of police, fire,

0:48:36 roads, and prosecution. Those four entities inside of our city cost more

0:48:46 than the entirety of the property taxes that we collect. All the other pieces are

0:48:54 from those shared revenues that you see and dedicated street reserves and transfers

0:48:59 and franchise fees and other financing sources such as earned interest, building

0:49:07 permit revenues. This is a reflection of the new construction value and

0:49:19 annexation of the city. This year it was at $95 million which will yield an

0:49:26 additional $473,000 of new property tax revenue. And you can see how it ebbs and

0:49:33 flows. Building permit revenues are one part of the equation. It is the fee that

0:49:39 is paid on that front end. The property tax piece of that is the portion that

0:49:44 that we use to sustain operations long-term.

0:49:51 I think this is a reflection

0:49:52 on the importance of economic development.

0:49:56 Continuing to grow your local economy,

0:49:59 the ability to add more payers into your system

0:50:03 helps us spread that burden and load

0:50:06 across more payers in absence of a local option sales tax.

0:50:15 And this is building permit revenue.

0:50:17 You can see that from building permit revenue,

0:50:20 This is just building permit revenue.

0:50:22 This is not electrical mechanical and plumbing.

0:50:25 This is just building permit revenue.

0:50:27 And it is flat this year for what we're projecting.

0:50:32 In all of the building permit reports that we supply

0:50:35 that is developed by Matthew Long in the building department,

0:50:39 you can see that housing starts are down,

0:50:41 commercial starts are down,

0:50:44 and that could have a direct impact

0:50:46 on new construction value in subsequent years.

0:50:50 So we're mindful.

0:50:51 We don't want to over-inflate building permit revenue.

0:50:54 We don't want to chase year after year,

0:50:56 because if we were to have said

0:50:59 that we're going to put this at $1.7 million,

0:51:03 this year we would have a $700,000 potential hole

0:51:08 in our overall budget.

0:51:10 And we'd be talking about holdbacks.

0:51:13 We would be talking about reasing expenditures,

0:51:17 similar conversations that the state had in January,

0:51:20 but our processes really are mindful and allow us to be nimble.

0:51:25 And we budget conservatively to make sure

0:51:28 that we are living within our means

0:51:30 and that we have the resources to move forward.

0:51:35 A wise old rancher, I shouldn't say old,

0:51:41 in Scott Bedke.

0:51:46 I shouldn't say old, strike that.

0:51:50 Shared with me one time that the family farm

0:51:54 doesn't go bankrupt in the bad years.

0:51:57 It's the good years in which it overspends over commits.

0:52:02 We want to make sure that when we have those good years

0:52:05 that we're using monies that are one time and one time only

0:52:10 so that our budget remains sustainable long-term.

0:52:14 And inside the enterprise funds,

0:52:15 we go through a detailed calculation of what those look like.

0:52:18 The enterprise funds, you can see that nearly 47% of that

0:52:22 is to fund our water in our water system.

0:52:25 37% is to fund our wastewater system.

0:52:28 13% is to service the PSI contract

0:52:33 that we have for solid waste and recycling services.

0:52:36 And the other non-major 2.1%,

0:52:39 but should show them falls in Derkeys Lake

0:52:43 and other things that rely on user fees

0:52:46 to be able to support their operations.

0:52:51 So focusing on our people,

0:52:54 We're looking at a 3% performance adjustment this year,

0:52:58 and a 3% table move to our general employees.

0:53:03 That doesn't mean that 3 plus 3 equals 6

0:53:06 are pay tables much more complicated than that.

0:53:08 It means that we'll shift our pay table at the start

0:53:12 and at the ending points,

0:53:13 and that people will navigate in between that.

0:53:18 We're asking for continued funding

0:53:20 of the $900 employee Viva account,

0:53:23 $1,000 per employee for our HSA contribution, which is tied to our health insurance plan,

0:53:30 to maintain health insurance funding.

0:53:34 Gretchen shared with me some data a little earlier today.

0:53:41 And I want to just speak to the ingenuity of our team.

0:53:46 So had we not changed our health insurance plan when we did, moving and adding a high deductible

0:53:53 plan and maintained a traditional plan since 2018 and then through the

0:53:59 other iterations now going through a self-insured model. The City of Twin Falls

0:54:05 would spend $2,193,000 more health insurance than what we do today. $2,000,000.

0:54:19 Over the course of the last two years we've been able to maintain health

0:54:26 insurance benefits for our employees and not increase costs because of the

0:54:30 movement to being self-insured. In those two years alone, we've saved nearly

0:54:39 $900,000 in actual premiums. And this year, CrossFingers, when my

0:54:48 bet with Brianna, there'll be even more. We are asking for two new

0:55:04 employees. One that is fully funded, which is a project manager, which was suggested by the

0:55:11 council last year, and affirmed during our first budget conversation earlier this year.

0:55:17 And that project manager will be in the engineering department, entirely dedicated to parks,

0:55:24 or as long as we have those parks loads. But to ensure that we have that talent

0:55:31 appropriately positioned in our organization, we wanted to make sure that should we not invest

0:55:36 in the parks and the trails and the systems that we are at the current rates, that that talent can be

0:55:42 moved to fund other project pieces. And you could see the total burden of that cost of that employee

0:55:49 is $120,776. And then we also included a school resource officer for the new charter school at their

0:55:59 request that is going to come into our community and we'll start operations later this fall.

0:56:07 However, 90% of the $92,000 is reimbursed by the charter school because they will use

0:56:17 this person 90% of their working year and percent of that time will be the burden of the city.

0:56:27 So we will be adding a police officer to the City of Twin Falls for the net cost of $9,256.

0:56:37 Those are the only two new positions.

0:56:40 But please don't believe that those are the only positions that we wanted.

0:56:47 We spent time inside of the budget talking about all of the additional positions that

0:56:53 were asked by employees because there's a true need.

0:56:57 The work of servicing a community of 116,000 people is on the backs of 356, and when you

0:57:06 take a look at that ratio per thousand served, it is right around three and is one of the

0:57:13 smallest staffs of full service cities in the state of Idaho.

0:57:20 Operation and maintenance you can see is increased, about 2.19% to $500,000, which is about in

0:57:28 line with the Municipal Cost Index for this year. And we still continue to play catch-up

0:57:35 from those years that impacted us in the past since 2020. And then you can see that our expenditure

0:57:45 on capital this year is $23 million. The ebbs and flows of capital really talks about one-time

0:57:54 money. The monies that came in, a part of the SLFRF, have been expended, that is one of the

0:58:01 sources of the largest drop. But if you take a look at the investment that we've made inside

0:58:07 of the City of Twin Falls since 2016, is more than $213.6 million. Again, this council has

0:58:16 been thoughtful in creating a foundation for us to continue to build our community, and

0:58:21 our work is not done.

0:58:25 Any questions on the overview of the budget?

0:58:31 So like I said, we build our budget

0:58:33 around a strategic plan.

0:58:34 We're in the last year of this strategic plan.

0:58:37 And next year, our budget will be focused

0:58:40 and funded used to fund the 2040 strategic plan.

0:58:44 This year was a bit of a blended approach

0:58:46 because of timing.

0:58:48 A lot of the main initiatives are the same.

0:58:51 The focus areas remain the same.

0:58:53 So internally, we'll do some rectifying of what that budget looks like as it's connection

0:59:01 to our strategic plan, but it is driven by these focus areas, and like I shared over the

0:59:05 course of the next several weeks, we will break this budget from a high-level overview

0:59:10 into each one of these focus areas.

0:59:12 So I'm just going to hit this really, really quick, because you're going to hear this over

0:59:17 the course of the next several weeks.

0:59:19 I may not have a lot of comment on these budgets.

0:59:22 They're inside of your slides.

0:59:24 But at the very beginning, we talk about what the vision is,

0:59:27 that vision was created in concert with the council,

0:59:31 our community members, commissions and advisory groups,

0:59:38 staff members, really what is the vision of the city

0:59:41 that we expect to 2030, and how do we hang that out there,

0:59:44 and then what are the individual ladder steps

0:59:46 that we need to achieve on an annual basis.

0:59:49 to realize that vision.

0:59:51 So that's what we fund.

0:59:52 So you can see that we break that down by department,

0:59:56 by fund on how each of those individual funding types

1:00:00 are going to help us in realizing a healthy community.

1:00:05 The next vision is going to be really,

1:00:11 how do we create a learning community,

1:00:12 which is going to be talking about the library.

1:00:18 A secure community is going to talk about all

1:00:20 of those elements inside the public safety.

1:00:23 These are some of the highlights that are being asked for in this process.

1:00:30 I can slow down, but I also know that you're going to hear this a lot, or the course of the

1:00:37 next several weeks.

1:00:38 I should say that all of this is going to be available online.

1:00:42 Our budget will be online.

1:00:45 Our individual presentations of the individuals want to review them are going to be online.

1:00:49 We're accessible by email.

1:00:51 We can set up appointments for our community to have conversations moving through this.

1:00:56 We're not moving, I'm not moving through this rapidly to kind of hide something.

1:01:02 I just know that over the course of the next eight weeks, you're going to be having conversations

1:01:07 about each one of these projects in greater detail, and I will tell you the 13 conversations

1:01:12 that you have about the budget on an annual basis is probably more by a factor of several

1:01:20 than what other communities are doing in their budgetary conversations annually.

1:01:24 We're trying to fund and create a prosperous community.

1:01:34 Part of our being a responsible community is being part of that involvement and in this

1:01:39 budget we've dedicated $820,000 towards council capital projects.

1:01:46 One time projects that each of the members of the team are going to say these didn't

1:01:51 make the long term planning list.

1:01:57 we would like for your consideration for these projects, and you may have some of your own.

1:02:03 The citizens may come forward and they may say we think that this is important and it

1:02:07 really is an opportunity for the community to engage and to advise the council on how

1:02:12 to allocate an additional $820,000 towards one time projects.

1:02:18 We want to make sure they stay one time because again we want it to be sustainable and anything

1:02:23 that we put into ongoing is something that we are going to have to account for in subsequent

1:02:28 years, which may or may not be possible, depending upon the state of our local economy.

1:02:34 As a refresher, these are the projects last year that you committed.

1:02:39 We had a little bit more money than the typical $770,000 because we had a larger new construction

1:02:48 final value than what we were anticipated when we set the budget.

1:02:52 So these are the projects and members of our team have shared and talked about what some

1:02:58 of those projects look like and will continue to advise the Council on how to fund projects.

1:03:06 We spend some time talking about the employees.

1:03:09 An additional piece, there's about 373,000, there's a typo, it's not 375, 373,000 in targeted

1:03:18 compensation adjustments.

1:03:21 It is important for us to go through and analyze our pay structure and we continue to do that

1:03:29 in our target at the executive team level is to have a proposal that is ripe and ready

1:03:38 to implement later this year.

1:03:40 We're still working through the data set to make sure that the information that we have

1:03:46 It's our organization, but again, that is part of being an employer of choice is thoughtfully

1:03:52 evaluating your compensation plans and structures and making sure that they are sustainable long-term.

1:03:59 We anticipate that 375 or 373, excuse me, will be incorporated into the budget in the form

1:04:06 of strategic compensation adjustments where we're failing on a market perspective long-term.

1:04:15 to help solve that problem.

1:04:18 And here's your schedule.

1:04:21 This is your road map, so you'll see next year

1:04:23 we're going to be talking about focus areas one, seven,

1:04:26 and eight, which is going to be a healthy community,

1:04:31 responsible community, and our employees.

1:04:40 And with that, happy to stand for any questions

1:04:44 that you may have.

1:04:45 Questions for Travis on the presentation.

1:04:49 Thank you, Travis, very thorough, as usual.

1:04:54 I guess we'll look forward to the coming weeks.

1:04:57 Ruth, you got a question?

1:04:58 No.

1:04:59 Okay.

1:05:00 So I guess we'll look forward to the coming weeks

1:05:02 and digging in a little bit deeper.

1:05:05 Thank you for the presentation and I, Travis.

1:05:11 I didn't have one question.

1:05:17 No, I was so close.

1:05:18 The new guy.

1:05:19 I said one.

1:05:20 The new guy.

1:05:21 Let me do it.

1:05:23 So I went through, there's reading the budget

1:05:25 and the word maintain came out.

1:05:27 It's like a real word search.

1:05:29 I think maintenance and maintaining it like 290 times.

1:05:33 So you tell me I need to expand my vocabulary?

1:05:35 No, no, no, no, no.

1:05:36 I guess my thought was,

1:05:39 do you think that we as a city are cataloging

1:05:43 and have an accurate, I guess our hands around

1:05:46 all of the maintenance that we actually have?

1:05:48 I know because there's some statutorily

1:05:50 that we have to do, some that we're adding to it

1:05:53 when we do new projects.

1:05:55 We have a good grasp on that as my question.

1:05:57 I believe that we have, we probably know more than what we don't know, but there are surprises.

1:06:15 We have old systems and members of our team, especially in water and water delivery and

1:06:24 wastewater can't see the pipes that are underground and we get surprised and we've

1:06:34 had some surprises this year with irrigation lines that have failed and have

1:06:42 caused the roads to go away and the condition of those pipes weren't

1:06:50 immediately know it. We have facility plans that say this is how much money we

1:06:57 should be investing in our systems on an annual basis. I believe you could look at

1:07:04 the dudes behind me see if I get this right. I believe our water facility plan

1:07:09 says that we should be spending in excess of three million dollars a year

1:07:14 replacing existing lines. I believe this is the first year that will hit that

1:07:20 benchmark. But Rob Bowling will tell you that at three million dollars a year it's

1:07:26 going to take us decades to be able to fix all of the water lines that are

1:07:32 undersized inside of our community and that doesn't talk growth. We have water

1:07:38 facility plans that describe the projects that we need to move forward

1:07:42 with. Part of the work that Josh is doing in public works with the JUV

1:07:47 contract is to understand what additional monies that we need, maybe in the form of a

1:07:53 revenue bond, to be able to ensure that we can build a $20 million, $10 million gallon

1:08:01 water tank to ensure that we can assure water delivery.

1:08:08 We do not have the ability to fund all of the needs.

1:08:18 through a budgeting process, try to pick those items that are potentially the

1:08:27 more significant items that should there be a catastrophe we have responded

1:08:34 appropriately. When you take a look at impact fees and the amount of projects

1:08:43 that are an impact fee list, we don't ask in the impact fee to fund all 20 traffic signals.

1:08:53 We describe 20 traffic signals that need to be replaced probably all in excess of $600,000

1:09:01 and we fund four or five.

1:09:05 Because we need to make sure that the budget that we present is also sustainable.

1:09:10 Not only sustainable for the city as an operating entity, but sustainable for the pocketbooks

1:09:15 that we're asking our citizens to pay for, and as we continue to grow our economy, we need

1:09:21 to remain competitive.

1:09:22 And so it's a balance.

1:09:24 So when I say, hopefully most, I believe we have a talented people that are very thoughtful.

1:09:33 There is certainly more that we could do, and this certainly does not fund all of the potential

1:09:40 issues that are out there, and that is why we carry the cash reserves that we do.

1:09:46 So in the time of emergency, we have the ability to dip into our bank account and to make those

1:09:53 one-time expenditures without burdening our citizens for those costs.

1:10:00 Okay.

1:10:06 Anyone else?

1:10:09 Thanks, Travis.

1:10:10 We'll work to reduce the word maintain.

1:10:13 What was that target?

1:10:14 270, you said?

1:10:15 290 is what I had.

1:10:17 Team will know that.

1:10:19 We're going to get 260.

1:10:22 Okay, so this brings us to our time in the meeting for general public input.

1:10:31 This is the time that the general public has to address the council on any issues that pertain

1:10:35 to the City of Twin Falls.

1:10:38 And we ask that you state your name and whether you're a resident of the City of Twin Falls.

1:10:44 And you have two minutes.

1:10:46 How do you go?

1:10:57 I am not on.

1:10:58 You want to start over?

1:10:59 Start the clock over?

1:11:01 Now.

1:11:02 By 5th, I was asked how was my 4th of July the best one yet?

1:11:06 Why do you ask?

1:11:07 It was the revelation that we're all fireworks for the universe or fire crackers.

1:11:11 CSI started with my friend's son, Dominique, being a part of the color guard with a civil

1:11:15 air patrol.

1:11:16 Metaphorically, he and other civil air patrollers were fire workers for the city.

1:11:20 The city band played patriotic symphonies and someone dressed as Uncle Sam.

1:11:24 Metaphorically speaking, the city band represented the grand finale of fireworks.

1:11:28 Even Uncle Sam displaying his colors for his country, red, white and blue.

1:11:32 Display of fireworks were spectacular.

1:11:34 I happen to have the best seats I have ever had.

1:11:37 What made this fourth different was what happened

1:11:40 after the last display of fireworks went off.

1:11:42 A loud voice echoed through the crowd.

1:11:44 She said yes.

1:11:46 Oh, so a second set of fireworks were going on.

1:11:48 A marriage proposal.

1:11:50 A silent whisper to the universe.

1:11:52 I sure would like to hear their story.

1:11:53 I rush off to the crowd as I'm crossing the street.

1:11:56 I hear a hello, Maria.

1:11:57 Do the array of smoke and darkness so the night

1:11:59 it could not make out who was talking.

1:12:00 To my surprise, the mayor, Jason Brown, saying hello.

1:12:04 Son, I have a humble mayor with great leadership

1:12:06 supporting our CSI fireworks in our community.

1:12:08 Go, Jason.

1:12:10 Well, my whisper to the universe was answered.

1:12:12 I met Keith and Abby, the marriage proposal couple I was

1:12:14 was waiting for the crowd to dissipate.

1:12:16 Keith allowed me to videotape his proposal.

1:12:18 He says, I played our song by Chief Buckley.

1:12:21 Lover, you should have come over.

1:12:22 I asked her to stand up and I told her I loved her.

1:12:25 My legs went wobbly.

1:12:26 Will you marry me?

1:12:27 Abby replied on the recording, I didn't have a clue,

1:12:31 and I am so happy today.

1:12:34 This year, I see you city council members

1:12:36 as a grand finale of fireworks

1:12:38 for the city responsible for decisions,

1:12:42 the budget, Travis, you were the bomb.

1:12:45 I ask if you were a firecracker,

1:12:47 what color sounds and vibrations would you be,

1:12:51 would you illuminate?

1:12:52 Be someone's firecracker, platonic, or otherwise.

1:12:55 That takes us to our two minutes, thank you.

1:12:57 I appreciate it.

1:12:58 Thanks Maria.

1:12:59 Almost got it.

1:13:00 Almost got it.

1:13:01 I didn't forget to identify herself, but I believe we know who she is.

1:13:05 Yeah.

1:13:06 No, you're good.

1:13:07 You're good.

1:13:08 Thanks Maria.

1:13:09 You're fine.

1:13:10 Okay.

1:13:13 Is there anyone else in the general audience who would like to address the council tonight?

1:13:18 Okay.

1:13:20 Seeing no one scurrying up to the podium will move on to advisory board reports or announcements.

1:13:26 last week I attended the Veterans Appreciation Day County West and it was

1:13:33 really well attended they also presented quilts of valor to I think six individuals

1:13:41 it was really a neat thing to see there was only standing room there so I was

1:13:46 grateful to be there so Councilan Hoggins what's a quilt of valor the quilts of valor

1:13:52 Yeah.

1:13:53 Person can get an application and nominate a person for a quilt for their service as a

1:14:00 veteran.

1:14:01 And there's a group that makes, they produce over 70 quilts a year, they present to people

1:14:07 in Magic Valley.

1:14:08 Wow.

1:14:10 Yeah.

1:14:11 Anyone else?

1:14:12 I just want to say thank you for the fireworks display, I've heard a lot of good reviews and

1:14:17 comments back from the people that have reached out to me, so I really appreciate the efforts

1:14:22 of all those that did that.

1:14:24 Thanks for the fire department, police department

1:14:25 for keeping us safe.

1:14:27 I know it was a busy night.

1:14:28 And Sean, thank you for your narrative.

1:14:30 Yes.

1:14:31 I don't know how many people listened to it,

1:14:33 but I did listen to the whole thing.

1:14:35 You did a fabulous job.

1:14:37 Good radio voice, right?

1:14:38 Yeah.

1:14:40 So that takes us to our next item, which

1:14:43 is the executive session request to adjourn

1:14:46 into executive session pursuant to Idaho Code 742061B

1:14:51 to consider the evaluation dismissal or discipline of or to hear complaints or charges brought

1:14:57 against a public officer, employees, staff, member or individual, agent or public school

1:15:02 student.

1:15:03 What are councils wishes?

1:15:04 So moved.

1:15:05 Second.

1:15:06 Can I have a first and a second to adjourn into executive session?

1:15:10 Any further discussion?

1:15:12 Rachel, we'll call vote.

1:15:15 Ruth Pierce?

1:15:16 Yes.

1:15:17 Chris Reed?

1:15:18 Yes.

1:15:19 Craig Hawkins?

1:15:20 Yes.

1:15:21 Jason Brown?

1:15:22 in stone and Nathan Murray. Yes. Motion carries seven to zero. That brings us to

1:15:27 the conclusion of our meeting tonight. We will not return to council chambers

1:15:30 after the executive session. Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, July 6, 2026. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:15:38.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    2089dcdb47a18b64f7850795e1cfc0a17434bc5f753497a97ef76d2690fe4c55
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a dd12d4ff731113aaba92ebaee952933edb0dff581685bd56906e030d1411037b
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    e60b0dd177ff7022c2a2856f7f686efe5a32b48a5a9b509cbded3079323126f9

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file