OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, April 6, 2026

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:03:53 Okay, we'll go ahead and call the Twin Falls City Council for April 6th, 2026 to order

0:03:59 We have all seven members of city council in chambers

0:04:03 And so we and we have a quorum to

0:04:07 Carry out city business. The next item is the apply to allegiance

0:04:11 We'd invite anybody that would like to participate to please stand

0:04:14 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:04:26 visible with it. Thank you. We have an invocation this month. We have Pastor Paul Thompson. Thank

0:04:41 you Mr. Mayor and members of the Council. It's good to see you. I'm going to try to

0:04:46 not be longer than the meeting tonight. Sounds good.

0:04:49 Heavenly Father, we thank you. We thank you for your mercy and your grace. And I ask that

0:04:56 you grant these council members your guidance and wisdom for the duties that

0:05:02 they have before them on the agenda. We recognize the importance of our

0:05:07 community's future, particularly our young children. And we ask that you

0:05:14 watch over the children of Twin Falls. Lord protect them, guide their steps,

0:05:20 instill in them a sense of hope and curiosity and kindness. We pray that we

0:05:27 We pray for their safety, their education, and their growth, and that they would grow into

0:05:33 well-informed and responsible and happy citizens.

0:05:37 We also lift up the brave men and women of our military.

0:05:41 We ask for their families who call Twin Falls their home that you would bless them.

0:05:46 And he had grants success and safety to those who serve, who give comfort and strength to

0:05:52 their spouses and to their children.

0:05:55 And may the commitment be a source of pride and resilience even within our own city.

0:06:02 So Lord bless the residents of the city, grant them peace in their homes, strengthen their

0:06:07 daily lives, and give them a spirit of cooperation with their neighbors.

0:06:13 So humbly offer this prayer, echoing the words taught to us by the Lord Jesus Himself, our

0:06:20 Father which art in heaven, how long be thy name?

0:06:25 Like kingdom come, I will be done on earth as it is in heaven.

0:06:29 Give us this day our daily bread and forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass

0:06:35 against us.

0:06:36 And lead us not into temptation, but rather deliver us from evil, for thine is the kingdom

0:06:43 and the power and the glory forever and ever in Jesus name.

0:06:52 Thank you.

0:06:54 Our next item of businesses, we have three proclamations tonight to be read.

0:07:00 And the first one I'll read is, is week of the young child, week of the week of the young

0:07:08 child April 11th through the 17th, 2026, whereas the Idaho Association for the Education of

0:07:15 Young Children and other local organizations are celebrating the week of the young child

0:07:20 April 11th through the 17th, 2026.

0:07:24 And whereas these organizations are working to promote and inspire high quality early childhood

0:07:29 experiences for our state's youngest citizens, that can provide a strong foundation of learning

0:07:35 and lifelong success for Idaho's youngest citizens, and whereas young children thrive

0:07:41 when they have access to developmentally appropriate, affordable, and high quality early care and

0:07:49 education settings, and whereas early childhood educators and those who work with or on behalf

0:07:57 of young children, birth through age eight, who make a meaningful difference in the lives

0:08:04 of young children in Twin Falls deserve our thanks, support, and recognition.

0:08:10 And whereas public policies that support early learning for all young children are critical

0:08:17 to young children's futures and to the prosperity of Idaho families, communities, and our economy.

0:08:24 Therefore, I, Jason Brown, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim April 11th

0:08:29 through the 17th, 2026, as the week of the young child.

0:08:35 And do hereby recognize that when our communities invest in early childhood care and education,

0:08:41 we also invest in our children, families, and the future of our community.

0:08:47 was I forgot if there was somebody here that was perfect.

0:09:25 So this is a proclamation that is reviewed

0:09:29 from Idaho Association for the Education of Young Children.

0:09:33 And it is a monthly, I attend a monthly meeting

0:09:38 on behalf of the Magic Valley Early Learning Collaborative.

0:09:42 And I think it parallels well with the proclamation read tonight.

0:09:47 So Idaho's Young Children, we honor your first five years

0:09:50 of life as a crucial period of growth and development,

0:09:53 the foundation upon which all your later years will build.

0:09:57 We support your whole wellness so you can succeed

0:10:00 in school and life, regardless of where you live

0:10:03 or what your circumstances may be.

0:10:06 You are worthy of our communities, organizations,

0:10:09 and state's investment.

0:10:11 We partner with your families to create a NITO

0:10:13 in which you and your family members

0:10:15 have the opportunity to thrive.

0:10:18 So thank you.

0:10:19 I believe this is the first time

0:10:21 for our city of Twin Falls, correct?

0:10:24 I believe it is true, yeah.

0:10:26 It's a joy to be here to accept that proclamation today.

0:10:29 Thank you.

0:10:30 Thank you.

0:10:31 Thank you.

0:10:35 Okay, our next proclamation is military child month,

0:10:39 April 2026.

0:10:42 Whereas April is the month of the military child,

0:10:45 an opportunity to recognize military children

0:10:47 for their resilient spirits.

0:10:49 personal sacrifice, sacrifices, strong character and courage.

0:10:56 And whereas military children are part of the strength

0:10:59 of our nation as they support and encourage their service

0:11:03 members with a fierce patriotic spirit.

0:11:06 And whereas these children are a source of pride

0:11:10 for the great state of Idaho and to us and all,

0:11:14 and it is only fitting that we take time

0:11:17 to recognize their contributions.

0:11:19 And whereas military children continue to make significant

0:11:22 contributions to family, community, and their nation

0:11:26 as they endure prolonged and repeated absences

0:11:30 of one or both parents.

0:11:32 Whereas a month-long salute will recognize

0:11:35 the military children, service to,

0:11:38 and citizens of Idaho will be afforded the opportunity

0:11:42 to don the colors purple every Friday of April

0:11:46 in support of these children.

0:11:48 Therefore, I, Jason Brown, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls,

0:11:51 do hereby proclaim April 2026 to be military or month

0:11:56 of the military child.

0:11:59 Was there someone that's going to come down and receive that?

0:12:35 Our last proclamation for the evening

0:12:38 is Community College Month.

0:12:40 Community College Month, April 2026.

0:12:44 Whereas, April is recognizing nationally

0:12:47 as Community College Month, a time

0:12:49 to celebrate the vital role that community colleges

0:12:52 play in providing accessible, affordable, and high quality education to students and communities

0:12:59 across the United States. And whereas the College of Southern Idaho, CSI was established

0:13:05 in 1964 and has proudly served the Magic Valley region and the people of South Central

0:13:11 Idaho for more than six decades. And whereas CSI offers a comprehensive range of academic

0:13:18 programs, workforce training, professional technical education, and continuing education

0:13:24 courses that empower students to achieve their educational and career goals.

0:13:30 And whereas, CSI provides affordable pathways to associate's degrees, certificates, and

0:13:36 university transfer opportunities, enabling students of all backgrounds and walks of life

0:13:43 to access high education close to home.

0:13:47 And whereas CSI serves thousands of students annually, including recent high school graduates,

0:13:53 working adults, returning students, and dual enrollment high school students, reflecting

0:13:58 the college's broad commitment to lifelong learning.

0:14:02 And whereas CSI is a significant economic driver for the region, partnering with local businesses

0:14:08 and industries to develop a skilled workforce that strengthen our communities and support

0:14:13 economic growth.

0:14:15 And whereas CSI Campus serves as a cultural and community hub for the Magic Valley, hosting

0:14:24 events, athletic competitions, fine arts performances, and public programs that enrich the quality

0:14:30 of life for residents throughout the region.

0:14:34 And whereas faculty, staff, and administration of CSI are dedicated professionals who invest

0:14:42 in student success and in the well-being of the communities they serve.

0:14:50 And whereas community colleges like CSI represent one of America's greatest demographic institutions,

0:15:01 places where opportunities, innovation, and community come together, therefore I, Jason

0:15:06 Brown, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim the month of April 2026 as

0:15:11 Community College Month. We have an official.

0:15:15 Mayor, the use of the words, few words, is a temptation for an educator because I could

0:15:42 go on at length, but I shall not. Thank you for the proclamation and I appreciate the recognition.

0:15:50 I think this last several days was evidence of how impactful how the college can be within

0:15:56 the region. We had about 2000 FFA kids in the community, all with wonderful energy and all

0:16:04 actually giving me optimism for the future. I think it can be very easy to get pessimistic

0:16:09 about the future. I invite you to come alongside me, be around all of the young students every

0:16:14 day and you're going to have some optimism. There's a lot of great potential there. The

0:16:19 week of May 8th, if you want to let my office know, we'd be happy to sneak you into a variety

0:16:25 events. We have a week of celebrations, nursing, painting law enforcement, graduation, vet tech,

0:16:33 ceremonies and then on May 15th we have five ceremonies. We've had over 1200 students apply

0:16:41 for graduation. We'll have probably about 700 participating across five ceremonies and then one

0:16:47 of the most powerful events on that Saturday morning when we graduate students with the GED.

0:16:53 So it's a wonderful opportunity to see the power of learning and how it

0:17:00 transforms lives and I appreciate the partnership with the City.

0:17:04 You're all wonderful colleagues in that work and I thank you.

0:17:08 So I'm going to be quiet with that.

0:17:09 That's probably more than a few words.

0:17:11 I heard you say please.

0:17:13 I appreciate it.

0:17:14 Thank you.

0:17:15 Thank you.

0:17:20 I'll just take a minute.

0:17:22 I think it's important that we recognize, you know, obviously the few

0:17:25 proclamations that children and families that we have this month but also community college

0:17:31 month I have the opportunity to send my my daughter there and it's been a great experience

0:17:36 going to CSI and the importance of families and children in our community. I think we can

0:17:42 record we can all recognize their importance so thank thank you everybody.

0:17:47 Our next item on tonight's agenda is the consent calendar what are council's wishes.

0:17:53 is, Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to accept the consent

0:17:59 calendar is written.

0:18:00 I have a motion by Councilman Hawkins.

0:18:03 I have a second.

0:18:05 I have a second by Councilwoman Pierce.

0:18:09 Any further discussion on the consent calendar?

0:18:13 OK, Rachel, we'll call vote.

0:18:15 Or Amy, sorry.

0:18:16 Sorry.

0:18:18 Shame on the start.

0:18:19 Yes.

0:18:19 Chris Reed.

0:18:20 Yes.

0:18:21 Greg Hawkins.

0:18:22 Yes.

0:18:22 Jason Brown.

0:18:23 Yes.

0:18:23 Sherry Vomer.

0:18:24 Yes.

0:18:25 and that's what you get sometimes.

0:18:28 The next item on our agenda night is the items of consideration.

0:18:33 The first item is a consideration request to confirm the mayor's appointment of Mackenzie

0:18:53 read and reappoint Kristina, Spice, Polly and Todd Shea to serve on the Parks and Rec Commission.

0:19:01 We have Wendy Davis.

0:19:03 Good evening, my own council.

0:19:11 I didn't really confirm with you, Mayor.

0:19:13 So I'm going to do this on your behalf tonight and see how we want to do it moving forward.

0:19:18 So this evening, I'm pleased to be here.

0:19:21 We had three commissioners whose terms were, their three year terms were up, two of those

0:19:28 three were eligible for reappointment. Both of them have served. They've been

0:19:38 judicious and engaged and involved in the Commission and so that is Christina

0:19:45 Saip, Holly and Todd Shaw and the third one was occupied by Cory King and he has

0:19:52 served two full terms which means that it was time to find a replacement. So we

0:20:00 with the announcement out, took some applications,

0:20:05 Vice Mayor Hawkins and I and the Commission Chairperson,

0:20:10 Michael Metcalf, interviewed for applicants,

0:20:14 and we made a recommendation that Mackenzie Red

0:20:17 be appointed to serve on the commission,

0:20:20 and that is also a three-year term.

0:20:22 So all three of them are three-year terms.

0:20:24 Mackenzie is here.

0:20:26 I don't I didn't see Kristianna site Polly or Todd Shaw this evening, but

0:20:32 Went out of three is here. So

0:20:35 with that I

0:20:37 will

0:20:38 Okay, allow you to appoint make your recommendation or what are councils wishes? I'd like to make a motion to

0:20:48 appoint

0:20:50 McKinsey Reed and

0:20:52 and she's going to make a great

0:20:54 addition to the commission.

0:20:55 We're excited about that.

0:20:56 Thank you.

0:20:57 I'll second that.

0:20:58 Okay.

0:20:59 I have a motion by Councilman Hawkins

0:21:01 and a second by Councilman Reed.

0:21:03 Is there any further discussion on that

0:21:05 appointment?

0:21:06 Those appointments?

0:21:07 Okay.

0:21:08 We'll call vote.

0:21:09 Chris Reed.

0:21:10 Yes.

0:21:11 Greg Hawkins.

0:21:12 Yes.

0:21:13 Jason Brown.

0:21:14 Yes.

0:21:15 Thank you.

0:21:17 Thank you.

0:21:18 Thank you.

0:21:19 Chris Reed. Yes, Greg Hawkins. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Sherry Bomer. Yes, Nathan Murray. Yes, Grayson Stone. Yes, and Ruth Pierce. Yes

0:21:29 Okay, motion carries

0:21:31 7 to 0. I told her she had to give a speech

0:21:37 That was good. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. Our next item is a presentation on PSI

0:21:50 PSI's RFP response

0:21:52 limited versus unlimited waste and the new proposed recycling program. Turn it over to PSI.

0:22:00 Yeah, good evening. Thanks for having me. So my name is Jason Loojo. I'm the site manager for

0:22:05 PSI here in twin. Let's see. Will I pull this up or do you? Yeah, you. So why they're pulling that

0:22:28 up? If there are a few people that may be new to the process, but if your item was on the consent

0:22:34 calendar tonight it's been approved so if you're waiting for something on that

0:22:39 consent calendar and there was an item there it is been approved. Who did you

0:23:13 send it to? It's in the Teams folder. I don't know if you have access to that.

0:23:32 What's that? What's in our emails? We love you. We need one of those children

0:25:13 that we were talking about to give us a hand right? Kids that understand how to

0:25:18 I don't work all through that, that's the...

0:25:21 Oh, I understand what happened.

0:25:22 I'm just giving you...

0:25:24 It was a bit of a failure on the staff's part

0:25:27 to migrate it from the computer to the desktop.

0:25:30 It's pretty.

0:25:31 I mean, I don't need my child to have me

0:25:33 with those technology, but it's great.

0:25:35 There are lots of things I could use David and Jack

0:25:37 for when he comes to technology.

0:25:38 That's just not one of them.

0:25:43 I just had, we had to break that awkward silence, Travis.

0:25:45 That's all we're trying to do.

0:25:47 And so you made it more awkward for me?

0:25:49 Absolutely, absolutely.

0:25:52 There we go. Hey, we got it. Now we now we're good mics on presentation up. We're good

0:26:52 See I'm my name is Jason. I'm the site manager for PSI. So as you guys know, I'm suited to him falls published

0:26:58 Sanitation RFP

0:27:00 PSI has been a word of the bid, but we're kind of in talks of what options we want to go to go with so

0:27:07 So I'm here tonight to basically explain what was in our RFP packet because I don't blame

0:27:13 me if you didn't read all 70 pages of it, I completely understand.

0:27:18 So basically when the city published it, the city requested four different options.

0:27:22 The first being unlimited sanitation without recycling.

0:27:26 And then the second option was unlimited sanitation with biweekly recycling.

0:27:30 The third option would be limited sanitation with no recycling.

0:27:34 And then the fourth option was limited sanitation with bi-weekly recycling.

0:27:38 And then you guys can see the cost difference there below.

0:27:43 Not huge substantial changes between the two.

0:27:46 So I guess first breaking down kind of what is limited versus unlimited.

0:27:51 So unlimited is currently what the City of Twin Falls does.

0:27:54 And the current contract is allowing 8 extra bags to be disposed of that is placed beside

0:28:01 the PSI provided cart.

0:28:04 With this option, you do have an increased risk for employees with puncture wounds from

0:28:08 needles, glass, sharp objects, all that wonderful stuff.

0:28:14 This is also going to increase messes from stray animals, just people just randomly throwing

0:28:20 trash over the fence, all that.

0:28:24 And this is also increasing the disposal cost of the city.

0:28:26 So currently with the trash side, the city pays 100% of disposal.

0:28:32 And so the more XRS there is, the higher the trash disposal cost for that month is for

0:28:37 the city.

0:28:38 So, with the limited option, so this is going to be, all the waste would need to be in a

0:28:44 PSI provided cart, it's going to reduce your risk for employees reduced disposal cost,

0:28:49 because then it is going to, you know, have the residents choose a different option of

0:28:57 what to do with their waste, whether it's renting additional carts where the city marks

0:29:01 up to help cover for the disposal costs.

0:29:05 And then it's going to create fair rates

0:29:06 for all the customers.

0:29:07 So right now, how it works is, and the way we're seeing it,

0:29:10 is everyone pays one flat rate across the board.

0:29:15 So the elderly lady down the street who throws away one extra bag

0:29:19 is kind of subsidizing the customer down the street who

0:29:23 has eight extras a week every week, just on the disposal

0:29:27 side, because that has to be paid for somewhere.

0:29:30 So yeah, so kind of the cost difference between the two.

0:29:37 So in the unlimited option, with the numbers

0:29:40 that were published in the RFP, it'd be about $109,000

0:29:43 a month for trash.

0:29:45 The limited cost would be about $105,000.

0:29:48 So this is about an estimated $48,000 in savings

0:29:51 a year in just hauling costs.

0:29:54 If we did some backwards math to get to it

0:29:58 by the average weight of cards that we see through the industry,

0:30:02 You guys would be saving about $34,000 a year in disposal

0:30:05 by moving to a limited option versus unlimited.

0:30:11 That's our estimated cost of what the weight is

0:30:14 for the extra bags.

0:30:17 So what do residents do with additional trash

0:30:19 and limited options?

0:30:20 So we have made a transition with our sister site up in Ada.

0:30:25 Ada County had historically been a unlimited waste option

0:30:29 and they a few years back decided to go to limited waste.

0:30:32 So unfortunately, we have great experience

0:30:35 throughout the state and our whole company

0:30:39 to be able to kind of help guide the city

0:30:41 if the city were to choose to go this route.

0:30:43 But the first option would be to rent additional cards

0:30:46 they're $299 a month.

0:30:47 And then this is gonna allow the city

0:30:49 to help cover disposal costs

0:30:51 versus not charging for the extra bags.

0:30:54 If it's a bulky item, we'll still offer up to three items

0:30:56 per month.

0:30:58 We could also work out seasonal cleanups

0:31:00 to two times a week is one to two times a year is typical. It's typically in the

0:31:06 spring and it's not limited back. So we see this we call often call it a lot as

0:31:10 leaf season. This is two weeks where we go through and clean everything up and make

0:31:15 sure it's all clean. Just a second because I'm getting

0:31:19 questions and I've got one myself. Would you prefer to kind of work through it or

0:31:23 can we ask you questions? However you guys choose. I'm good either way. I'd prefer to

0:31:28 I ask as we go keep them fresh if it's okay.

0:31:30 Absolutely.

0:31:31 If anything's going.

0:31:32 Councilman Stone.

0:31:33 Mr. Speaker for a question.

0:31:34 Yeah.

0:31:35 Sorry.

0:31:36 Go ahead, Jason.

0:31:37 Sorry.

0:31:38 Mr. Mayor.

0:31:39 Sorry.

0:31:40 Go ahead.

0:31:41 It's been a long time.

0:31:42 I know what you meant.

0:31:43 Go ahead.

0:31:44 My bad.

0:31:45 How often do you see an extra bags?

0:31:46 My bad.

0:31:47 How often do you see an extra bags?

0:31:49 Yeah.

0:31:50 So extra bags are definitely seasonal.

0:31:51 But in the winter, which is our slowest time, we probably have 200 homes.

0:31:58 this a week that'll have extras out still. In the summer we're upwards of

0:32:02 probably close to 1,500 homes at least that have something extra. Leaf season

0:32:10 basically everyone. So when you say seasonal you're just

0:32:16 talking like leaves and stuff like that you're not talking like Christmas time.

0:32:20 Okay, cool. Thank you. Sherry. So do you have a recommended limit on how many

0:32:28 extra cans somebody gets. Currently, they can have as many as they want. The more cans, the cleaner

0:32:35 the alleys and the cleaner the streets are take on it because they're going to have that waste go

0:32:39 somewhere. But that would be up to the city's discretion on how many they would like to limit it.

0:32:44 I do know like over in Jerome we do no extras and there's homes over there with six, seven, eight

0:32:49 carts. So. Yes, I was just looking at it, I think the biggest. So what would be considered like a

0:32:57 bulky item just in general. In the previous picture obviously that's not

0:33:01 necessarily what we want but I am one of the you know personally I am one of

0:33:05 those guys that leaves or grass clippings in a bag on the side of the

0:33:09 street that I want to make sure we figure out something there. So what would a

0:33:13 bulky item be? Correct. So right now it is anything it's like

0:33:17 couches it's I mean we've taken treadmills just your large items, washing

0:33:23 machines, dryers, stuff that wouldn't fit into a PSI cart.

0:33:27 Okay. Any other questions at the moment?

0:33:31 Okay. Thank you. Yeah. Appreciate it. So I may stop you from time to time.

0:33:35 No, please do. Please do. We're good. So moving over to the recycling side of the world,

0:33:42 the current program where, so the way the rate is right now is it's all built in trash and

0:33:47 recycling is one. Once again, we did some backwards math to figure out, you know,

0:33:51 the estimated cost of the recycle program is $6.13 a month. Right now, we're only accepting

0:33:58 aluminum cardboard and twin, it is a bi-weekly service, we average about 90 tons a month coming

0:34:06 through those cards and then we have a cost share between PSI and the city where PSI will pay $50

0:34:14 and then the city covers anything additional above that. The proposed program, this would be a full

0:34:19 single-stream recycle program, still with bi-weekly services, PSI would then be

0:34:25 covering a hundred percent of the disposal costs, education, and rollout costs. So

0:34:29 that's the biggest change is the city would no longer be paying anything for

0:34:33 that 90 tons of material that is being thrown away or recycled or however the

0:34:39 city chooses to go that route. So when you say full single stream, so

0:34:43 indicated that you would be taking care of all of that type of stuff, so this would

0:34:48 should still show up on my monthly bill or a resident bill and you put then you

0:34:53 would just end up taking care of that is that correct so the only thing that the

0:34:56 city would be paying for and recycle would be five dollars and seventy-nine

0:34:59 cents a month we would be covering all the spools of cost so and then what it

0:35:03 means by full single stream is it means we'd be expanding it to include the

0:35:07 plastics and include the cardboard the paper then newspaper boxes basically

0:35:13 everything I got a slide here in a minute that we can I have the I do Ruth do you

0:35:16 have a question. That was my question is if it was expanded. So that's good to know.

0:35:22 Thank you. Thank you. So we didn't know some of the concerns that the residents have with

0:35:29 recycle program is the minimal materials that's accepted the amount of contaminated loads in the

0:35:35 cost of the program. Those are probably the three biggest concerns and why I would imagine the city

0:35:40 wouldn't want to continue recycling. So in the new program so we would be accepting more material

0:35:46 at our facility we would anticipate 100% of loads that have the recycle to be

0:35:51 coming to our facility. We would then be removing anything like the tree branches

0:35:56 and the stuff that we can't recycle from those loads and throwing it away that way.

0:36:03 This also is going to lower the cost for the city and the residents so with the

0:36:07 S.I. assuming the cost of the disposal of the 90 tons of material the city

0:36:11 you want to have that the city chose to remove recycling that material has to go

0:36:16 somewhere then the city will be charged the

0:36:19 transportation fees of that additional 90 tons so you guys would actually see a

0:36:22 spike in your disposal cost by removing recycling and not choosing to continue

0:36:29 that. So we had estimated about $76,000 based on the current tonnage is what the

0:36:37 city would be paying per year. And then we'd also be educating customers, so we're

0:36:41 committed to educating the public on the changes in the recycle program through

0:36:44 school talks, stickers on the cards, mailers, and however else we can get the

0:36:50 word out social media of course. And spreading like, hey you know we're

0:36:53 expanding our recycle program, we're looking to do this and every information

0:36:58 that we can possibly share. So what would be accepted? So that's basically

0:37:04 everything that would be allowed in the cards with the orange lids. So flat and

0:37:08 cardboard, paper boxes, newspapers, magazines, cartons,

0:37:12 plastics, one, two, and five,

0:37:14 which is the most common type.

0:37:16 Still wanted to accept like the plastic swimming pools

0:37:18 or styrofoam, no yard debris or glass.

0:37:21 People, key items, right?

0:37:23 Correct, yeah.

0:37:24 So you're catching on, you got it.

0:37:26 And then aluminum and tin cans also.

0:37:30 So once again, it's a lot more of that true single stream

0:37:34 recycle program that we haven't had in the city of Twin.

0:37:39 So items for consideration with stopping recycling,

0:37:42 one of the largest concerns with the Twin Falls County

0:37:44 commissioners, with a few that we've heard from,

0:37:47 is the landfill filling up.

0:37:49 There not being any more room.

0:37:51 Granted, it's 90 tons a month.

0:37:53 Going to make that big of effect, probably not.

0:37:57 But you know, if it's 50 days, if it's 100 days of expanded

0:38:01 life, it's extremely costly to open up more cells

0:38:04 and, you know, doing what we can to help reduce the cost

0:38:07 for Twin Falls County.

0:38:10 And then eliminating recycling will increase trash disposal costs,

0:38:13 so I kind of touched based on that already.

0:38:15 When we roll out a full single-string program,

0:38:19 we would anticipate that the tonnage will actually increase

0:38:23 based on people wanting to recycle more, you know,

0:38:25 having the plastics put in.

0:38:28 So in theory, the city should see a decrease in the tonnage

0:38:33 that you would have to pay for the waste material.

0:38:37 And then expanded recycling reduces waste in

0:38:41 extends the landfill life.

0:38:44 So our recommendation is for the city to go with the limited

0:38:47 trash service with biweekly recycling.

0:38:50 This would reduce disposal costs,

0:38:52 create fair pricing for residents with little and excess

0:38:54 trash, maintains clean neighborhoods,

0:38:57 improved recycle program, diverts waste from the landfill,

0:39:00 about $76,000 disposal savings.

0:39:04 And then this is the safest and cleanest option

0:39:07 that we can think of for not only our employees,

0:39:10 but also for the residents of Twin.

0:39:13 So with that, anyone has any questions I can answer

0:39:18 or try to answer?

0:39:21 Chris?

0:39:23 I'm trying to go back to when we've

0:39:26 had a discussion on this a few months ago.

0:39:28 So I apologize if I don't have a memory,

0:39:32 it doesn't serve me well.

0:39:34 When it comes to the recycling option,

0:39:37 is it an all or nothing?

0:39:40 Correct.

0:39:41 So for this rate, it would be an all or nothing.

0:39:43 There is, we did put in there that there is an option

0:39:47 for a subscription based.

0:39:50 More and more cities are moving to a full recycle program

0:39:56 across the whole West as an entirety.

0:39:59 And so if the city chooses not to continue

0:40:02 with the full recycle program,

0:40:03 I would imagine probably pretty soon

0:40:05 there's gonna be mandates down the road of,

0:40:07 Hey, you have to have some sort of something, you know, similar to the transportation side of the world. I don't think there's anything like that now.

0:40:15 But it very well could be a possibility.

0:40:18 So at this point in time, it is a city does recycling or we don't. It isn't a my house could opt in or opt out.

0:40:29 Right. This time, that's how it is.

0:40:33 Grayson Stone.

0:40:34 Well, thank you, Mr. Mayor, for a question.

0:40:37 Yep.

0:40:38 Thank you. So.

0:40:39 Are there any other municipalities around us that are currently following this recommendation?

0:40:44 So, not this full recommendation. So, City of Twin would be the only ones that would have recycling. City of Jerome, City of Filer, City of Hollister, and Hagerman all have limited draft services. City of Twin Falls is actually the only ones that I'm aware of in the entire valley that does unlimited options.

0:41:05 and then use City of Twin is also the only ones that I'm aware of that has a

0:41:11 full recycle program. Okay, thank you. Yeah, Ruth. So how many do you think

0:41:18 customers are recycling customers right now in Twin? We estimate that so we did

0:41:26 some rough estimate and we're somewhere around 60% is what we wouldn't

0:41:31 Okay. Thank you.

0:41:33 Chris.

0:41:34 I'm thinking how to ask this question so it does not sound rude.

0:41:38 No, please.

0:41:39 If it comes out like I'm a jerk, I apologize.

0:41:43 Having lived through the recycling of having it, then decreasing it,

0:41:51 dealing with all the issues we did, is there a guarantee that in this contract moving forward

0:41:58 that recycling will take place if we go with the recycling option.

0:42:03 And the reason I ask is, I don't want to say, yes, we're going to do that.

0:42:06 In two years from now, recycling costs get crazy, and all of a sudden we start pulling stuff back.

0:42:12 Yeah, no, and that's a very valid concern.

0:42:15 So with that, you know, what is put in the contract cannot be changed without Council's approval.

0:42:22 You know, if it's written in there that this is what we're doing, this is the cost of it.

0:42:27 But in order to change that, the council would have to agree to that.

0:42:31 So that's a way for you guys to know that, you know, what we're voting on, if you guys

0:42:36 vote to continue recycling with the PSI paying disposal costs with the current rates, that

0:42:43 that is a guarantee that it won't change unless the council then decides to agree to a change.

0:42:50 Okay.

0:42:53 You got to come up to the mic.

0:42:59 I am 100%.

0:43:00 I just want to relate to your question.

0:43:04 So a lot of that had to do with us not owning our recycling center and our processing center.

0:43:08 That was owned by Magic Valley Recycling.

0:43:10 So a lot of that was out of our control as well.

0:43:13 And where we do own our own recycling processing center.

0:43:16 That will have a huge effect on that as well.

0:43:18 Perfect.

0:43:19 No, thank you.

0:43:21 All our.

0:43:22 Ruth.

0:43:23 Travis has something.

0:43:24 Oh, Travis.

0:43:25 Yeah.

0:43:27 Yeah.

0:43:28 has something. Travis, do you have? Yeah, so having lived this by PSI managers ago, I think

0:43:37 it's important that if the City Council is going to continue recycling that you put in

0:43:41 an agreement that says, we're doing this and you're going to honor this commitment for the

0:43:46 balance of the term. And that I also part of the concern that I have in moving forward with

0:43:53 recycling is when I look at the pure economics of the return on the investment, I struggle

0:43:58 to see it. And what I want to make sure is that this isn't a, that there's a locked-in

0:44:05 maximum in price increase that's associated with it because it's $5.76 now and then next

0:44:13 month or next year during negotiation it because of market and commodities and no one's accepting

0:44:19 plastics in order to continue it now jumps back to 10. When you take a look at the cost

0:44:25 of solid waste sanitation inside of the City of Twin Falls, and you compare that generally

0:44:30 to other communities, ours is more expensive, and there's lots of factors to why.

0:44:36 But our price also includes a tipping fee where other cities have that on their property taxes,

0:44:46 so that there are some disparities.

0:44:47 But when you take a look at the cost of service in the City of Twin Falls, it is more than

0:44:53 and what is in other communities presently,

0:44:56 this does bring it back into alignment.

0:44:58 And I think what the Council really needs to look at is,

0:45:01 what is the return on the investment

0:45:03 for the recycling portion for the members of our community?

0:45:05 We shared with PSI when they started building

0:45:08 their recycling center that staff was not a fan of recycling.

0:45:14 Now, because we don't love the environment,

0:45:16 but because we are struggling to understand

0:45:19 whether or not that pencils,

0:45:21 And if you take a look at the full carbon footprint cost

0:45:26 associated with recycling, not just a tipping fee.

0:45:31 PSI has given you their recommendation.

0:45:34 City staff hasn't given their recommendation.

0:45:37 What we're looking for tonight is not a yes or no

0:45:43 as a definitive answer on recycling.

0:45:45 But whether or not it is something that you wanna have

0:45:47 included in a contract that when we bring forward to you,

0:45:51 It is there and on that evening you can determine whether or not you want to move forward.

0:45:56 If you've decided already that it's not something that you want to do,

0:46:00 that just let us all know because what we want to do is make sure that when we present

0:46:04 the final contract for your review, it is ready for your approval and it has all of the items in it.

0:46:12 I can also share with you that for those who recycle, it's something they're very passionate

0:46:18 about and that they would argue that my economics is short-sighted and I can accept that. So regardless

0:46:33 of that decision I believe that you should on the evening of having a conversation about

0:46:40 the contract be willing to open up for some comment regarding whether or not the city should

0:46:48 continue with recycling and be able to make that decision that night.

0:46:54 Will you go back a couple of slides? I mean Travis had indicated and I want to look at

0:47:00 the money, let's see one, oh this one right here, yeah. So the current program is every

0:47:07 month citizens are paying $6.13 is our slide? Oh first slide, that one. So I'm trying to

0:47:21 Remember, what is our sanitation rate right now?

0:47:23 What do we pay every month, Travis,

0:47:25 or $20.11?

0:47:29 Okay.

0:47:30 In that $20.11, there are a series of items that's included.

0:47:37 It's not only the cost of the contract for PSI,

0:47:42 but also we have a tipping fee

0:47:44 to Southern Idaho Solid Waste as part of that,

0:47:47 and then we have a labor component as well.

0:47:50 Okay.

0:47:53 And you said ours was unlimited right now, correct?

0:47:57 Is that kind of the service that we have?

0:47:59 Yep, so currently right now is it be option

0:48:01 to unlimited sanitation with my recycling.

0:48:08 Councilman Stone-Grayson.

0:48:09 Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

0:48:12 Like just a quick question.

0:48:13 When you propose this, when we look at the contract,

0:48:17 I would love to see it broken down

0:48:19 in an actual like Excel spreadsheet,

0:48:20 not just so many words,

0:48:21 but just like cost by cost all the way through.

0:48:24 Can you still tell it there?

0:48:26 So what's the $20?

0:48:27 Yes, I'm sure.

0:48:28 I'm sure you're not.

0:48:29 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:30 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:31 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:32 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:35 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:36 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:37 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:38 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:39 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:40 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:41 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:42 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:43 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:44 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:45 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:48 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:49 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:50 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:51 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:52 I'm sure you're not sure.

0:48:53 kind of I think ultimately to me summed it up and unlimited or limited that

0:49:00 option whether we I think the biggest thing for me is is the ability and this

0:49:06 may be a selfish request in the sense of you know Saturday I put I'm in or this

0:49:13 next week when mine comes out I mowed my lawn I had a bunch of leads and stuff I

0:49:16 want to put a couple of sec or bags out there I do that you know every couple

0:49:22 at times a year but then I also put my grass clippings in a bag and put them on the side

0:49:27 and they magically disappear. The ferry comes along and picks up the garbage and I'm happy.

0:49:34 I think that for me is a big part of it. That would still be part of the limited option

0:49:40 correct. We would still have the ability at certain times to set stuff out.

0:49:45 Correct, at certain times. But you could also rent an additional car for however long

0:49:49 for three bucks for three bucks, I mean.

0:49:53 And then the ultimate question is whether we want

0:49:57 to continue recycling services at a reduced rate,

0:50:01 albeit a reduced rate, but continuing to have that service.

0:50:06 Correct.

0:50:08 Councils, Chris Reed.

0:50:10 The Travis, where are you looking for tonight?

0:50:12 Is this just a presentation?

0:50:14 Yep, it's just a presentation to kind of get

0:50:17 a pulse of the council.

0:50:18 You would like a pulse of the council.

0:50:19 kind of want us to weigh in on what you don't want us to consider in the agreement. So when we build

0:50:25 the contract, there will be a section in there that talks about services provided. Part of that

0:50:31 service is provided will include a section about recycling. And on that evening, if you elect to

0:50:37 not move forward with recycling, you can remove that paragraph. You're going to mend that from the

0:50:42 contract that evening is the way, unless tonight you've said absolutely 100% we're doing recycling

0:50:51 no matter what. And then we will eliminate some of these options here. What we're trying

0:50:57 to do is get a pulse of the council as we create this menu and a contract to make drafting

0:51:03 a little bit easier. You may not be there this evening and then we'll have different pages

0:51:08 for you to insert based upon the options that you want to move forward with.

0:51:12 I'll share with you my opinion.

0:51:15 I think that currently we're utilizing unlimited sanitation.

0:51:18 I think that that would be a more desirable position for the city.

0:51:26 And then also I do like biweekly recycling at this cost, but there needs to be language

0:51:33 in the contract to ensure that the cost is not, you know, I know costs are going to increase,

0:51:37 But you know, we can't have it 579 this year and then a dramatic increase.

0:51:44 And so kind of maybe some options in there where if it does increase to a point where

0:51:49 it's not feasible for our citizens, we revert back and we eliminate that.

0:51:55 So you're selecting option two, is that kind of where you're leaving?

0:51:58 Two with some very strong language when it comes to the cost associated with recycling.

0:52:03 Okay.

0:52:04 Sherry. I lean a little more towards option four, but I think probably similar to what

0:52:12 Grayson had said earlier, I'd like to see like a breakdown of what also I can do

0:52:19 line-by-line and see what it is that we're seeing. Grayson? Just a question for

0:52:29 Councilman Raid. I feel yield. So you're saying just have a sunset clause more or

0:52:35 I guess ceiling correct health it hits like six bucks, and we're just cutting it off

0:52:40 Yeah, it's something something like that if it gets to the point where it is not

0:52:44 Something that we're comfortable with we can eliminate that. Yeah, so I think I'm I think I'm along the lines of councilman read on that

0:52:52 Establishing ceiling

0:52:55 Ruth and I actually am leaning more towards the limited side as well. I think you see a lot of

0:53:02 a chunk out there and it's $3 for an extra cart. I mean it would be nice not to have

0:53:11 all that extra garbage laying around. That's my personal opinion with the recycling as an option.

0:53:20 Craig I think I would lean to probably option two right now. Nate do you have an opinion yet?

0:53:29 Yeah, yeah, do it, okay.

0:53:31 Listen, I've just for whatever limits are city's

0:53:35 subsidization of waste removal, right?

0:53:38 I think so.

0:53:40 If you want to recycle, you got to pay for it.

0:53:42 I think the city can do something up to a point.

0:53:45 But what that cost is, I don't know.

0:53:46 And it's kind of the same with trash, right?

0:53:50 So you're, I guess, to sum up your leaning.

0:53:53 I guess I'm sort of,

0:53:54 or it's option five, three, four, maybe.

0:53:58 Okay.

0:54:01 I lean back, I think part of the reason I had asked for the kind of what we pay right

0:54:06 now is getting a little bit better of a breakdown of how the costs are associated with some of

0:54:12 the options.

0:54:14 I can see the benefit of unlimited and limited really from both sides.

0:54:20 I enjoy being able to take my garbage out, put it on the side and again the truck comes

0:54:27 by and picks it up.

0:54:28 I'll be honest with them a little on the fence on recycling in the sense of what does that

0:54:32 cost balance benefit to the city, you know, as the city doing some subsidization.

0:54:39 I do personally believe that there is a benefit to some recycling, but at what cost.

0:54:46 So I guess trying to sum up, I think options are two and four kind of what we've leaned

0:54:51 into generally on the council, we can throw options one and, or I guess, Nathan, you were

0:54:59 option three a little bit more in leaning that or a hybrid of something there.

0:55:03 I'm not too passionate about that yet.

0:55:07 Okay.

0:55:08 I might read your document.

0:55:09 Let me go look.

0:55:10 I think what I would like to see is really a couple of options.

0:55:14 I think for me seeing the unlimited is nice.

0:55:21 I think I am leaning more that way,

0:55:23 but then what is the option with recycling

0:55:26 and without recycling?

0:55:29 But that's just kind of the way I'm leaning.

0:55:31 So Mr. Mayor, members of the council,

0:55:35 I was in Jerome when we migrated from a limited

0:55:39 to a non-limited and the transition can be hard.

0:55:43 Because what's important to remember is

0:55:45 everything has to fit into a single blue bin

0:55:48 and the lid has to close.

0:55:50 And if the lid doesn't close.

0:55:52 And a weight restriction.

0:55:54 Well, they technically have a weight restriction here anyway.

0:55:57 But the number of bins that you may need to have

0:56:03 is something that maybe members of our community

0:56:06 have to kind of grow into.

0:56:08 Because we've had an unlimited collection system

0:56:13 for as long as I can recall in Twin Falls.

0:56:17 And we would want to have a pretty strong education program.

0:56:22 And they would also say a grace program from PSI.

0:56:27 Because on day one, if we didn't pick up garbage because we've

0:56:32 been doing it the same way, we will invite all of you to the

0:56:35 utility billing counter to answer those phone calls.

0:56:38 Because how we behave is by habit and there would need to be some pretty intensive educational

0:56:52 processes if we're going to change how we move forward.

0:56:58 Yes, the end result may be more desirable.

0:57:02 The path to get there may be arduous and that we would ask PSI to partner with us in

0:57:09 in terms of what an education period looks like,

0:57:12 what a grace period looks like,

0:57:15 how long before we just simply stop collecting

0:57:20 for people who are violating.

0:57:21 Very similar to how we implemented a backflow device program.

0:57:25 We didn't immediately go into the penalty phase.

0:57:28 We spent the better part of two irrigation seasons

0:57:34 educating the public before we got to a space.

0:57:36 So I think it's important that if we make any significant changes

0:57:42 that we have contractual language for that as well.

0:57:44 So we'll work on that too.

0:57:49 Ruth.

0:57:49 I just might add on the flip side,

0:57:51 there are those of us customers that don't put our garbage

0:57:55 out every week because we don't have enough to fill a can.

0:57:58 So some of us are subsidizing.

0:58:01 Some of you who have extra.

0:58:03 And you're welcome to bring your glass glass clippings

0:58:06 over to my house.

0:58:07 I'll take my garbage out every week, but I maybe every two weeks, but sometimes once

0:58:14 a month.

0:58:15 So I don't have the need, but I'm not alone either, right?

0:58:21 There are lots of other people like that, but you have no families left at home.

0:58:26 Yeah, I mean, I think just in general, the unlimited is nice for the stage in life that

0:58:34 I'm in.

0:58:35 Obviously, Ruth is a different stage.

0:58:38 I think what Travis's comment is limited versus unlimited,

0:58:41 absolutely has to be some type of grace period.

0:58:44 If we move that direction to fully,

0:58:48 I mean, we're always going to have a few outliers,

0:58:52 I'm assuming.

0:58:54 But yeah, I think it's a hard, this is kind of interesting

0:59:00 how much we talk about sanitation and recycling

0:59:02 and trying to figure these types of things out.

0:59:04 Chris.

0:59:05 Yep, Chris.

0:59:07 On slide three, the next one, do we have language?

0:59:12 I mean, something like this,

0:59:15 is that, do you guys pick this up?

0:59:17 We pick up everything except for just loose stuff.

0:59:20 So we pick up the majority of it,

0:59:22 and then the residents will have to pick up

0:59:25 just a little bit scattered.

0:59:27 As you put in there,

0:59:28 there's an employee risk issue.

0:59:31 I think that to me is something that maybe,

0:59:34 Yeah. As we move towards this and we take steps, those kind of baby steps in there, leaving

0:59:42 it unlimited and then saying, hey, this is unacceptable. This is not, we're not going

0:59:48 to put your folks at risk digging through this type of thing. And so we move that step.

0:59:55 If the ultimate goal is to move to limited, which I have three carts, which we fill every

1:00:00 week so yeah but but you're willing to pay for him and that yeah I'm willing to

1:00:07 pay for him but the thing that the you know as Jason's kind of talked about the

1:00:12 two weeks in the fall and I would never hit those two weeks I will be the week

1:00:18 after or two weeks after putting my law like I don't really want to be on PSI's

1:00:24 timetable of when I can put yard waste out I can never remember my

1:00:29 recycling day. That can's been sitting there with cardboard for about a month now

1:00:33 because I miss it every time. So if that's the goal to Travis's point education is

1:00:39 going to be the key and we can move towards it needs to be in a bag and then

1:00:45 we as a city start policing this because this is unacceptable. This isn't okay.

1:00:49 I'd be comfortable with that but moving to limited I think that that's

1:00:54 That's going to be a major issue.

1:00:56 Mr. Mayor, point of clarification.

1:00:58 Go ahead, Grayson.

1:00:59 So, on where it says current program allows eight extra bags unlimited.

1:01:03 That's per pickup, correct?

1:01:05 Correct.

1:01:06 That is per week.

1:01:07 So, in this situation where you're seeing this, if all of that, I call it, is trash is contained.

1:01:13 In a box or a sack, then we're good to go.

1:01:18 Please come by and pick it up.

1:01:20 Yeah.

1:01:22 Yeah, so as I think here the you know the limited option would require all of this to be in a bin, right?

1:01:29 I mean ultimately swing by pick it up and then we move on. I you know looking at I didn't realize

1:01:35 I think there's probably a time that I've had five extra bags on the on the street, but eight man

1:01:40 I'll start increasing that a little bit here

1:01:44 Some of that bulky debris or something, but I

1:01:47 I think is there is there a chance to if we if we do migrate to that limited is doing something

1:01:55 Where we have you know year one where we're?

1:01:59 Unlimited with five bags year two unlimited with one bag

1:02:04 I don't know if there's any way to work that into a contractor if that's even a logical or feasible idea to then year three go to

1:02:10 That's a great idea go into a limited type of scenario

1:02:14 I don't know here now, but I but I got staff back here like oh, you're gonna kill us council

1:02:19 We don't want to we don't want to we don't want to to get our staff all worked out of monitor that yeah

1:02:25 You have four bags. Sorry. Yeah, that's right. Yep. Well, I'm using three of yours Ruth

1:02:33 I think it'll probably help to see the itemized and then let us go through there. There's there's a lot of scenarios. There is

1:02:40 Yeah, I think we need to keep it simple

1:02:44 We've never kept anything simple.

1:02:48 I'm simple, okay.

1:02:50 But anyway, Travis pointed out there'd be a real transition in going to that limited.

1:02:58 But I think that if you staggered that transition, like you said, Jason, we'd have the city confused

1:03:06 for a long time.

1:03:09 Even though I just talked about this for a half an hour, we are confused.

1:03:12 I think also what would help is when when are the special days that you you know the seasonals

1:03:18 And I think we might the few of us might have some

1:03:23 Different opinions of what that is or assumptions of what that is

1:03:26 I don't know that that's the way that I would go on seasonal, but it would just help to see that on there

1:03:30 Yeah, and that would be a hundred percent up to I know every other city that does it they have a one city council meeting that they

1:03:37 decide when they want their

1:03:39 seasonal week or two weeks or month or

1:03:42 or year.

1:03:44 Yes, let's see if our now.

1:03:46 So Travis, do you have enough clarification or is this still unsorted trash?

1:03:52 No, I think that we can work on a collection of different items.

1:04:01 I think one of the things that we need to be mindful of,

1:04:06 and I know that everybody's kind of looking at this from maybe

1:04:10 that lends of how will this impact me. There are 60,000 residents that depend on

1:04:17 services that there's not going to be a single and unique case, but there is a

1:04:23 point of contact inside of the city, which is at the utility billing services,

1:04:29 that when we make any changes or modifications, they're going to be on

1:04:34 the front lines. And we can work towards modifying different processes. We can

1:04:46 incorporate different things. It's no different in getting rid of the

1:04:51 unlimited and the education piece as if the council would have elected to get

1:04:55 rid of the recycling piece and the level of education that would have to go into

1:04:59 that as well. So just recognize that whenever we change that service there's

1:05:03 going to need to be an education and I because there are council elections because city managers

1:05:12 come and go because folks at PSI come and go I think that we need to spell this out succinctly

1:05:19 in an agreement that as individuals occupy these chairs who may be unfamiliar with the

1:05:26 term of the agreement and what's conversations are taking place tonight subsequently that

1:05:32 it's memorialized so that it is clear so that there's an understanding of what the intent

1:05:38 was.

1:05:39 I will say that this agreement I think is we're talking about a 10-year agreement outlives

1:05:45 me.

1:05:47 Well, how long have we been under the current, I mean, we've been under a version of the current

1:05:52 agreement for quite some time, right?

1:05:54 I mean, we...

1:05:55 Correct.

1:05:56 I have pictures back in the 70s with PSI servicing Twin Falls.

1:05:59 So I mean we've been and I agree with you Travis. I think that you know, whatever whatever conclusion or resolution we come to

1:06:07 I think we need to be pretty clear and and explicit on what that is because

1:06:12 It's another another 50 years

1:06:16 We said I think that's a lot of the reason why we're in the situation of where we're at is you know

1:06:20 People have come and gone and there's been you know communication. We're gonna do this we're gonna do that and then you know

1:06:26 Nathan Murray

1:06:27 Yeah, I was just going to ask if you feel that your

1:06:33 proposal adequately

1:06:35 I guess looks at growth and routing changes new equipment additional personnel and so forth

1:06:41 I can you maintain that or attend your period you think correct? Yes, so

1:06:46 The great thing about PSI is we are owned by waste connections

1:06:50 So we do have the ability to continue to grow with Twin Falls to continue to offer the solutions

1:06:56 every city that we deal with is unique in some way or another, so I have no doubt

1:07:03 that we are able to. One of the reasons why we're able to come in and say hey

1:07:06 you know we're going to cover disposal costs for recycling is we're actually

1:07:10 with our new facility able to internalize that all the way up until it ships out.

1:07:14 So we'll be sending to it's called Pioneer Recycling in Oregon and then

1:07:20 they ship it out from there. So all under company-wise we're able to keep the

1:07:25 rates reduced for that.

1:07:27 Okay.

1:07:32 I think as long as Travis and we'll keep working at it and try to get to that resolution and

1:07:38 figure out what is best because Travis is right.

1:07:40 I mean we're seven of 63,000 people.

1:07:44 We all have our own opinions and lifestyles and everything else and trying to figure out

1:07:48 what is best and ultimately appreciate your time.

1:07:52 Yeah, thank you, Mayor and Council appreciate it.

1:07:54 Thank you.

1:07:59 Okay, next item on our agenda tonight is seeking the council's priority on the development of the

1:08:06 fiscal year 26-27 budget. And so it begins. It wasn't but what two weeks ago that maybe three

1:08:35 that we presented the audit to you that closed out the 25 fiscal year. We're in the middle of the

1:08:46 the 26th fiscal year, and on that same evening,

1:08:49 Brandon gave you a financial report,

1:08:52 and now we're moving forward and having a conversation

1:08:55 with the fiscal year 27 budget.

1:09:00 And I share that because budgeting inside of the City

1:09:05 of Twin Falls used to be done in small windows of time,

1:09:11 and now it is an annual activity.

1:09:15 When we first started the concept of long-term planning,

1:09:20 it really was seasonal.

1:09:23 And that team would begin their work in January or February.

1:09:28 They would work until about March or April,

1:09:30 depending upon how close they got.

1:09:33 We would start with community department meetings,

1:09:37 department meetings, we'd balance the budget,

1:09:38 we'd come in and have some conversations

1:09:40 with the city council.

1:09:41 The budget would be adopted,

1:09:44 and then we would have a bit of time to recess.

1:09:47 And that's now not the case.

1:09:50 We have members of our team across the organization,

1:09:53 whether they be a part of the fleet team,

1:09:56 whether they be a part of the long-term planning team,

1:10:00 even conversations at the executive management team

1:10:04 about the budget, budget strategies, and moving forward.

1:10:09 The budget that we have been working on

1:10:11 for fiscal year 27, actually started in fiscal year 25.

1:10:20 And so we are moving into a very long

1:10:25 and protracted budgeting process.

1:10:27 And I think that is just an indication

1:10:30 of how sophisticated our processes have had to become

1:10:34 for us to be successful.

1:10:37 So tonight is the first of a believe 14 public

1:10:41 conversations that we will have about the budget between now and the fourth

1:10:47 Monday in August. And tonight is really just to kind of begin to get a lay of the

1:10:56 land, to get you refreshed and to remember kind of what we did and the

1:11:04 things that we've left off the table. But if you take a look at the City of Twin

1:11:08 Falls and we share this, we're not gonna spend a lot of time. I know some are

1:11:12 interested in getting and watching Yukon win in a few minutes, in a basketball game, but

1:11:19 we really want to make sure that the value and you've got 30 minutes just so you know.

1:11:27 Okay, so I will not take that. But what's important to recognize is the City of Twin Falls is

1:11:35 a regional hub. And that we are creating a budget that services a community of about 120,000 people

1:11:43 on a daily basis, nearly double the size of the City of Twin Falls. And we have challenges

1:11:50 when it comes to housing and housing affordability. We have unemployment that is continues to be

1:11:58 strong when it comes to being fully employed. And that when you think about total retail sales

1:12:05 inside the City of Twin Falls, retail sales per capita are $7,000 more than our per capita income.

1:12:16 So it really talks about that need. We engage our citizens in the budgeting process not only through

1:12:22 every conversation, but we're using the citizen survey as part of that conversation. And Mandy

1:12:29 was here just a few weeks ago talking about the sentiment of our citizens. And I think that

1:12:35 we can all agree that there are areas that we felt are important for us to spend intentional

1:12:42 time. Community engagement being one of those faces. And so our budget, our goals, our performance

1:12:51 management systems are really talking about how do we engage the community. So Josh Palmer

1:12:57 here and this is probably one of his great frustrations is he is putting out a lot of

1:13:02 information. The process is how do we get that in a digestible consumable format across 40

1:13:11 different platforms. When I first started in city management you had television, you

1:13:19 had radio, and you had newspaper. And if you sent out five press releases, it would largely

1:13:27 be picked up and that story would be shared.

1:13:31 Today, there's satellite radio, where people may or may not be listening to normal radio

1:13:39 channels.

1:13:40 With subscription streaming services, people may not ever watch anything local.

1:13:47 And we've all seen the rise and the fall of print media.

1:13:54 And so really trying to understand how does a city like Twin Falls, how does Josh get

1:14:00 the City Manager on TikTok. The City Manager doesn't even know it. It is. But

1:14:08 really trying to find ways to engage our community because the budget is one of

1:14:14 the most important things that we do and we're going to need to spend more money

1:14:17 in leveraging and connecting with our community. And so we're going to be

1:14:23 spending more money on things that we don't know what that return in the

1:14:28 investment is because we're trying to hit a lot of people. Now, we got great people like Josh,

1:14:33 and Josh is going to be able to help us direct and share and move forward. But as the council said,

1:14:38 we want to find opportunities to get the community more engaged. We're going to try to do that,

1:14:44 but it won't be without expense. We want to continue to engage our employees,

1:14:49 and part of that is making sure that we have a workforce that is world-class.

1:14:54 You know, I share with people that the heart of what we do is public service and we're a

1:15:03 customer service entity and we don't have a lot of competition.

1:15:10 And so sometime when we're in a customer service entity and we don't have a lot of competition,

1:15:17 we tend to maybe not put forward that same effort as though if we were fighting over every

1:15:23 single competitor for market share, like many of our private sector partners have to do.

1:15:32 And so what if our citizens and our business partners had to fill out what we call a Likert

1:15:39 Survey to engage how we're doing?

1:15:42 And like Matt Hicks has said, which other chiefs have said, if there was a competitor for the

1:15:49 Twin Falls Police Department, would they be calling our department for services first?

1:15:54 So we really need to find a way to change and engage our employees on how do we become

1:16:00 that citizen service entity, and that is retaining world-class folks.

1:16:10 And we build a budget around consensus.

1:16:12 So long-term planning has been meeting.

1:16:15 We've established a whole series of public hearings, and those public hearings are going

1:16:23 to be designed to solicit public input, and we would encourage the council at the conclusion

1:16:28 of every meeting beginning tonight, if you're so interested, to ask the citizens what are their

1:16:35 budget priorities? What does it look like? We've been having a lot of conversations in our organization

1:16:41 about our fiduciary responsibility, and it really comes down to honoring the fact that

1:16:49 is not our money.

1:16:51 The individuals give us those resources

1:16:54 so that we can provide critical services day in and day out.

1:17:00 And that's what's helping us transform our government.

1:17:03 And so while I'm not perfect,

1:17:05 I think that we are really setting the tone

1:17:07 for what local governments do in the state of Idaho.

1:17:10 We are financially strong, we're viable,

1:17:14 we're creating new practices and new policies.

1:17:17 And oftentimes we're looked to as the leader in the state of Idaho.

1:17:23 And I think that's all really good things.

1:17:26 But I also believe that we have areas that we can improve.

1:17:32 And going back full circle, our citizen surveys at that.

1:17:36 I think this is a testament to doing it right.

1:17:39 Because we also share during the audit, we once again received the certificate of achievement

1:17:47 of achievement and excellence in financial reporting.

1:17:52 And as we continue to receive those awards,

1:17:54 I think it's important to acknowledge the team,

1:17:58 but also to acknowledge the why.

1:18:00 We do that to make sure that our budget isn't a series

1:18:05 of line items that no one can digest and understand,

1:18:09 that our budget is a usable document that's available

1:18:12 on our website.

1:18:13 You can go and take a look at it now,

1:18:15 and you can see what that expenditures for this year are.

1:18:20 And as we move forward,

1:18:24 these are the exact same six goals

1:18:26 that I've put out there every single year,

1:18:28 and I still think that they're relevant.

1:18:29 And if you want to change them, we can change them,

1:18:31 but create a stable, sustainable, nimble budget

1:18:35 that allows us to adapt to a rapidly changing environment.

1:18:41 The war in, or the conflict,

1:18:44 I guess we didn't, but the conflict in Iran has caused fuel prices to rise to a level that

1:18:52 we didn't contemplate when we built the current year budget.

1:18:57 So we need to be mindful of petroleum, petroleum-based products and what that's going to potentially

1:19:03 do to M&O budgets.

1:19:05 And when we built the budget, that wasn't contemplated.

1:19:08 And next year, when we are looking in 27, there will be something else that our crystal

1:19:13 did not pick up and that we're going to have to account for.

1:19:16 If not, we will find ourselves in budgetary situations

1:19:19 that our friends and Boise found themselves.

1:19:22 And I don't think that's a place that you want the City of Twin Falls to be.

1:19:27 We obviously need to be sensitive to our local environment.

1:19:31 Creating a tax policy, creating a revenue policy

1:19:36 and a service policy that fits our community is important.

1:19:39 We need to tie everything to the 2040 strategic plan.

1:19:43 plan. It's just about done and it's about ready to be unveiled and it is a great

1:19:51 document that many hands have helped work to create and it will drive our

1:19:56 community into becoming the community that we've envisioned for 2040. We will

1:20:05 not ever be able to enhance or create a higher level of service without quality

1:20:10 people working for us. We need to retain our employees. The market is getting more and more

1:20:16 competitive and resources are getting potentially more and more constrained. So we have to find

1:20:23 ways to continue to offer the highest level of benefits and compensation that we can to

1:20:28 our employees. And part of the great work that was led by Gretchen on going self-insured with

1:20:36 assistance of Brianna and the other members of the finance department. Making those moves

1:20:43 could potentially save us millions of dollars in the future and preserve something as important

1:20:49 as healthcare benefits. We need to continue to be innovative to make sure that we're caring for

1:20:55 our employees. It requires money. In the past, the city has taken the statutory allowed amounts

1:21:02 And we find ourselves in that space again this year, where it's 3%, 90% of the new construction

1:21:15 value and the allowable percentage of the city's foregone balance.

1:21:23 Money, taxes, revenue, fees are things that no one likes to pay, but those dollars are

1:21:32 transferred into a big bucket that then creates services, which allows fire trucks to respond

1:21:40 to emergencies, same with police cars, helps us maintain roadways, helps us offer parks and

1:21:46 reoccurations and open space amenities. No one likes to pay taxes. I don't like to pay taxes.

1:21:52 In fact, I talked to members of the city council and I don't think you'd like to pay property taxes

1:21:56 either. But there's a recognition of what it is transformed into and we need to do a better job

1:22:02 at the city level sharing what that is.

1:22:06 So last year we saw the city grow to $6.4 billion.

1:22:11 We included the urban renewal agency, it grew to nearly $7 and the tax rate was at $5.06,

1:22:16 which was one of the most competitive tax rates in the state of Idaho for all full service

1:22:22 municipalities.

1:22:24 This is the value and the growth of the city and like I said with the urban renewal agency

1:22:29 we crested over $7 billion, and I think that you're going to see that number continue to

1:22:36 grow as not only the city has continued to grow and continue to expand.

1:22:40 We've seen lots of more commercial permits, but also the Urban Renewal Agency, Jibani,

1:22:46 expands, and you're starting to see lots more growth inside the city.

1:22:50 Operation Maintenance is a slide that I wanted to keep in here from last year, because you

1:22:55 can see how that has kind of slowly gone up.

1:22:58 Now we don't know what that's going to go forward, how that's going to grow, but it's going to grow.

1:23:02 It's going to be a direct result of the municipal cost index.

1:23:07 The municipal cost index is what we use to measure services, and while everyone

1:23:12 wants to look at making sure that we're reducing the cost of government,

1:23:16 this is an example of where we probably underestimated the cost of government when

1:23:21 you start looking at fuels and travel and training. So we need to be more mindful of that as we move

1:23:26 forward and again connecting everything to the city's strategic plan which will

1:23:30 have these primary focus areas. Yes I know the cow is no longer there but the

1:23:42 cow was one of my favorite pieces of art that I think that we've ever presented so

1:23:46 I'm gonna remember the cow. So if you as the council elected to take those

1:23:56 those property tax revenues at 3%, the new construction,

1:24:01 assuming that we have about $70 million

1:24:03 of new construction value, and the revenue

1:24:06 equal to 1% before gone balance.

1:24:10 You can see that we would collect about $1.67 million

1:24:14 more in property taxes.

1:24:19 What I will tell you is a 3% compensation increase

1:24:26 for our employees now is almost equal

1:24:33 to the 3% property tax collection.

1:24:40 I mean, when Gretchen and I were talking about that,

1:24:44 it's about $320,000, I believe,

1:24:47 for a 1% compensation for every 1%.

1:24:55 That's the cost of retaining good employees,

1:24:58 And that doesn't include any increases

1:25:02 as you might see for health insurance moving forward.

1:25:05 That is just straight compensation.

1:25:10 Based upon where we're at right now,

1:25:11 we don't believe that we'll see any increases in water

1:25:15 or sewer, anything greater than 5%.

1:25:18 And then obviously the sanitation recycling process

1:25:20 is one that will be ongoing

1:25:22 and it will be based upon conversations like tonight.

1:25:26 But overall, based upon how the community's growing,

1:25:29 we believe that tax rates will be similar, the tax impacts will be similar, and the rate

1:25:35 increases will be justified if there are any, and they'll be in line with Municipal Cost

1:25:43 Index.

1:25:48 We have 12 positions, I believe, that have been requested inside of this year's budget,

1:25:55 and that doesn't include some of the other strategies that we have moving forward.

1:26:00 The police department is going to be coming forward and asking to once again participate

1:26:06 in the COPS grant that we would be looking at bringing in four police officers.

1:26:12 And that is outside of this process.

1:26:15 And as you're familiar with the COPS grant, we would essentially assume the cost of one

1:26:21 per year over that window of time.

1:26:24 A police officer, fully burdened salary now, is $100,480,

1:26:33 as the cost, fully burdened cost of a police officer.

1:26:36 That does include uniform duty weapon, half of a car,

1:26:43 we'll get to car costs in a minute.

1:26:46 But you can see that in order for us to continue

1:26:50 to maintain and grow, we're going to have to be able

1:26:53 to implement salary recommendations and move forward.

1:26:58 Right now, the trust is performing

1:27:04 better than I had hoped that it would.

1:27:08 And right now, I don't believe that we will be looking

1:27:12 at doing anything different with health insurance plan

1:27:17 in this next year, which means that we will not change

1:27:20 benefits and we will not increase the cost of current co-pays to both the city and the

1:27:29 employee. It will be the second year in which we will be in a space of not increasing costs

1:27:36 associated with health insurance and the average in our area is between 11 and a half and 12%.

1:27:44 So those are resources that we can divert to other places in our effort to continue to be

1:27:51 the employer of choice.

1:27:54 As I go to more retirements, we need to continue to find ways to build the talent that folks

1:28:02 as capacities to be able to learn and to grow and to become even more proficient in their

1:28:07 skills.

1:28:08 And so we're going to have to invest more with the younger workforce into training.

1:28:15 We're going to have to continue to also leverage and create strong public-private partnerships

1:28:21 with intentionality.

1:28:23 We can't do all things.

1:28:25 We can't offer all of the services that our citizens want us to offer alone.

1:28:32 There are holes and we have blind spots, but with limited resources, I'm encouraging the

1:28:37 members of our team to focus on what we're good at.

1:28:43 Obviously, the strategic plan in reporting out regularly is part of the goals, focusing on

1:28:48 technology, the use of AI, and then expanding communication, business retention.

1:28:58 We continue to grow, and the rate of growth in Idaho is what I would still describe as

1:29:04 unprecedented.

1:29:05 It is significant, and the surrounding communities are growing at faster percentages than we

1:29:11 We are as the urban hub for that geographic area.

1:29:16 We need to make sure that we have the ability to provide the level of services as they are

1:29:21 being demanded upon our community.

1:29:26 We need to same slide.

1:29:28 All right, next on capital funding.

1:29:32 This is the thing that I think is incredibly interesting that we have about $24.7 million

1:29:39 of replacements that are needed in the city's Roland stock.

1:29:43 And there's about 2.02 million that's included

1:29:46 in this year's budget for consideration.

1:29:50 And it doesn't mean that we're buying floor.

1:29:54 We're just trying to maintain,

1:29:55 because if you look at the cost of a police cruiser in 2015,

1:30:00 it was $26,457, and today they're 84,937 bucks.

1:30:10 And as we grow our force, we grow a number of police cars.

1:30:15 And so the total investment in rolling stock

1:30:18 continues to grow.

1:30:21 I've been doing this a while, and I

1:30:23 can remember in another community when I had to buy the first fire

1:30:28 truck, my career.

1:30:32 And at that point in time, it was $350,000.

1:30:37 And back in 2000, that was real money.

1:30:41 Now put it in my own checkbook, it's still real money.

1:30:45 But today, that same fire apparatus, maybe even stripped

1:30:48 down a little bit, is about 1.5 million.

1:30:54 And the cost of a water tinder is now 60% more

1:31:01 than the cost of a fire truck in the year 2000.

1:31:06 So you can see, as those costs continue,

1:31:09 having the infrastructure to be able to carry out

1:31:12 is important.

1:31:13 We also have things like parks and trails and water lines and sewer lines, all of those things that we have to maintain.

1:31:21 Open space is important. Parks are important and we have to find a way to continue to maintain the parks that we have.

1:31:31 But also continuing to make sure that all of the parks that we create have the amenities to move forward.

1:31:37 So, last year, the City Council spent $1,124,460 on making direct improvements to benefit the

1:31:47 community, and this is the list of projects that you invested in.

1:31:55 One of the larger projects that you did not include on this list was the improvements to

1:32:01 Baxter's Dog Park.

1:32:03 we recently closed on the sale of fire station number three. I believe the proceeds are looking

1:32:12 at Mitch. I believe the proceeds are in the bank. And we have already started the process

1:32:21 of, you know, understanding what does that look like with the Council's permission. This

1:32:28 This year, we're going to be looking at a couple of positions that the Council has already

1:32:35 committed funding to or said to the city to move forward with, and that is excluding an

1:32:42 outside of the seven said.

1:32:43 The first was a project manager individual, and that individual is going to be in the budget.

1:32:52 The second piece is the police officer that is 90% funded by the Elevate Academy.

1:32:59 That agreement was approved last year.

1:33:02 They're paying 90% of the total cost because that is the amount of time that they will enjoy

1:33:08 that officer in comparison to the citizens.

1:33:10 It is different than our relationship with the Twin Falls School District because we have

1:33:15 shared use facilities in which there is reciprocal agreements where we also receive compensation

1:33:22 in benefit.

1:33:25 And that's your schedule.

1:33:27 If it all goes right, we're going to be able to give to you the preliminary budget on

1:33:31 Thursday, July 2nd.

1:33:34 And then on Monday, July 6th, we will have a presentation of the budget to you.

1:33:40 We will go through all of the focus areas in a similar succession that we have had in

1:33:47 the past. We will be making presentations to you of items to be considered for

1:33:53 Council Capital and we'll be having members of the long-term planning team

1:33:58 continue and come forward. So that's what we've been doing. And in this initial

1:34:05 conversation, what we would like is for you to really begin thinking about

1:34:12 fiscal year 27, even though it feels like you just completed fiscal year 26

1:34:18 budget. To help us understand what are those projects that you're hearing about or as you

1:34:26 hear about them that you'd like to be included as we move forward.

1:34:39 You want an answer now Travis? Absolutely. Yeah, if you are ready to start firing I think

1:34:44 it's important that we're able to hit the ground running.

1:34:48 Grace and Stone. Thank you Mr. Mayor. Do you still think a local option sales tax is a

1:34:54 viable option? Well, I do. But the idea of the legislature won't allow me to ask the

1:35:00 question. I believe that in fact I have shared with many of you that a local

1:35:09 option sales tax if it's the one that I've built, if you take a look at total

1:35:15 retail sales inside the City of Twin Falls, we estimate that you'll collect

1:35:20 about $20 million on an annual basis on a penny. If you give half of that back

1:35:27 $10 million in the former property tax relief, that is reducing individuals

1:35:33 property tax burdens inside of the City of Twin Falls by a third. And then if you take

1:35:39 the other $10 million and you apply it to services that are impacted directly by being

1:35:46 a hub community, we are going to be able to do some pretty amazing things. And we're also

1:35:54 going to be able to sustain basic things. So we have 81 sworn police officers. 81 sworn

1:36:06 police officers and a community of 60,000 or 56,000, you're getting really

1:36:13 positive ratios of the number of officers that you have on the street to be able

1:36:18 to help in crime. You're able to have discretionary time for our police

1:36:25 officers, which is a big word for crime prevention, crime prevention related

1:36:29 activities. When you grow that to 120,000 individuals, those ratios of officers per

1:36:39 thousand serve drop below one. And at that point in time, if you subscribe to

1:36:46 ratios, we do not have enough police officers on the street to support the

1:36:52 community in which we serve, plain and simple. The citizens of the city of Twin

1:36:58 falls can't afford to buy all the police officers that we need because of the

1:37:03 limitations placed on property tax collections because that is the only

1:37:07 vehicle that we have. Fire station number five needs to be built. Fire station

1:37:15 number five has a two million dollar a year manning problem aside from a

1:37:20 twelve million dollar construction problem. So as we continue to grow we need

1:37:27 to be able to find innovative strategies to serve a community that's 116,000 people on

1:37:34 a tax base that is built by 60.

1:37:39 So the story that I like to share is that if you're a private business, every second customer

1:37:45 that walks into your door, you give that good or service away for free.

1:37:52 And in order for you to continue to stay viable, you elevate the cost of service to those who

1:37:58 who are the paying customers.

1:38:01 Well, it's no different in local government

1:38:03 because we do not collect all of the money

1:38:08 that we need in the form of property taxes

1:38:12 to be able to support the community.

1:38:14 And when you take a look at all the retail sales

1:38:16 that occur in the city of Twin Falls,

1:38:18 based upon $2 billion worth of transactions,

1:38:22 the city of Twin Falls sends more to Idaho

1:38:27 what we get back because it is based upon a per capita formula, not a point of sale formula.

1:38:35 And so under the current distribution formula, people are enriched because of retail transactions

1:38:41 that occur in Twin Falls. So that's my long answer. My short answer is yes.

1:38:50 Yes.

1:38:53 Thank you.

1:38:54 Yep.

1:38:55 Ruth.

1:38:56 So, you touched on it, but I wanted to reiterate, it's important for me to make sure we're competitive

1:39:05 when it comes to employees and retain our good employees, whether it's additional benefits,

1:39:11 a raises, whatever's necessary.

1:39:14 We all know it's challenging to compete with the private sector, and so whatever we can

1:39:21 do to avoid losing good people would be a priority for me.

1:39:28 Any other council members that have priorities that they want to, Chris Reed.

1:39:34 I'm excited a couple of slides you had in there for the Citizen Engagement Survey and really

1:39:40 tying into that, figuring out how to communicate with the folks of Twin Falls, whether it's

1:39:48 Normal channels, whether it's social media or purchasing platforms ourselves to be able

1:39:55 to directly communicate, I think, is extremely important.

1:39:59 We've had that Citizen Survey for years, Mandy comes and presents on it, and for several

1:40:07 years it's been very consistent in certain areas, and so trying to understand and fix

1:40:12 those things I think is really important.

1:40:14 I remember with the 770 when that originally pushed out, it was all sidewalks and that's

1:40:21 what the citizens came to us and said, hey, we want this and we were able to do that and

1:40:26 make a huge impact.

1:40:29 So finding out directly from the citizens what they want is really key, but it's how do we

1:40:35 communicate with them, because they don't come here.

1:40:40 watching a game right now. But making sure that that communication is flowing I think is

1:40:48 really key right now. I'm excited to see that in your presentation.

1:40:53 Thanks.

1:40:54 Any other council members? Travis, can we communicate through email with you if there

1:41:01 are some priorities that we haven't thought about tonight?

1:41:04 Absolutely. Obviously an open invitation for the citizens to email us or give us a phone

1:41:10 call or set up appointments directly as well. I know that you take their comments and emails

1:41:16 and texts as well. So whatever you get, please pass on and we'll continue to build that part

1:41:22 of the list. It's easier to be inclusive of those ideas on the front end than it is trying

1:41:30 to patch them on the back end.

1:41:33 Okay.

1:41:35 Any other questions for Travis?

1:41:37 Okay.

1:41:40 Thank you, Travis.

1:41:41 I appreciate it.

1:41:42 Okay.

1:41:45 That brings us to our point in the meeting tonight of the general public input for those

1:41:50 members in the audience that would like to address the council on any item that was not

1:41:55 specifically on the council agenda tonight, please stand up to the podium, please state

1:42:02 your name and if you're a resident of the city of Twin Falls and you'll have two minutes

1:42:08 tonight. Make sure the green light is bright and illuminated there.

1:42:19 There you go. Good evening everyone. I hope everyone had a wonderful, I guess,

1:42:24 week, Monday, start of the week. Hello, my name is Evelyn Martinez. I currently open

1:42:30 treasure claw here in Twin. It has been incredible to see the support of the

1:42:34 community. I am originally from Houston, so it has been a change. It's been

1:42:39 one year officially and a little bit since we made that transition me and my

1:42:43 husband. First of all, I want to thank everyone for hearing me out tonight. The

1:42:47 main reason I came tonight is because I was in the calendar. I am planning kids

1:42:54 day celebration of Pokemon theme for June 13th, 14th my apologies and I was

1:42:59 wondering if I am able to change it 13 and 14 make it a two-day event. What are

1:43:05 the proper ways to do that? Do I have to reapply the permit or can I discuss that

1:43:10 here.

1:43:11 Uh, we'll ask is Travis, do you know what the procedure would be to do that?

1:43:16 Yeah, so we have a special event permit process and some of the members are in the room today.

1:43:22 And so we would be able to engage whether it be a combination of our chief of police that's

1:43:28 back there in the back.

1:43:29 So Matt could probably have a conversation with what that looks like now.

1:43:33 Yeah, and I'd, yeah, to me, you know, go through, talk with chief and see, but I think if it's

1:43:39 an item that needs to come back, then we can take care of that pretty quick. But if not, then...

1:43:43 Perfect. And then the second thing is I would like to know if I have proper way to have, I guess,

1:43:50 pop-up events in front of my storefront for the time of summer. Again, do I have to go through a

1:43:56 permit or can I discuss that? Pop-up event. So you'd want to end up talking to our planning and

1:44:02 zoning department. Actually, Jonathan spend love right back there. And here's here tonight too.

1:44:07 help you. You came on a good night. You'd be able to navigate through that. But

1:44:11 typically, there is a process just to make sure that we're checking the things

1:44:16 that we need to. Okay, so I will go back there and talk to them. Chief of Police and Jonathan

1:44:21 Spendlove. Perfect and thank you so much. Thank you. Any anybody else? Okay, we'll

1:44:31 move. Seeing nobody else, we'll move to advisory board reports. Nathan?

1:44:38 the necessary advisory board report but um I said I mentioned I attended the funeral of

1:44:46 Doug Manning on Friday I don't know if anybody knew him former mayor of Burley long-time economic

1:44:52 developer there I just wanted to mention that I really appreciated it and I love Doug and I love

1:44:59 all the things he did for the magic valley in general and I just wanted to mention that tonight

1:45:05 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:45:10 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:45:13 Craig, did you have something?

1:45:15 I do. I see district meeting is April 23rd is a 30.

1:45:19 Really encourage all the council to come to the cans.

1:45:23 April 23rd, April 23rd.

1:45:27 It's here in twin two.

1:45:29 Perfect.

1:45:30 Any, uh, any other council members?

1:45:32 Travis city manager's office.

1:45:35 It is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 6, 2026. The recording started at 16:56 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:45:51.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    a6af9d04278d28e04802e8bdf5e83d4d48b6cfab4977dc8913ecb6bad737ddbf
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 326d34904d0135bd588e3758a178342f9d6ec257c87fee1ae830142676d599e3
    part02.m4a 7ea6bdb2235b5c47dbd02359898e33e9be4f6bcf51d7289c555472d55583dddf
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    8a80b603855feb9e38cef996ec53f354ad4187f334e78db8dfd2ca93aa38e824

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file