OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, March 16, 2026

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: c

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:00:26 Okay, we'll call the City Council meeting for the City of Twin Falls for March 16th,

0:00:56 2026 to order. I will confirm that we have six Council members in chamber and Councilman

0:01:02 Grayson Stone is on the phone tonight. We'll move into the Pledge of Allegiance, so all

0:01:07 those that would like to participate, please stand.

0:01:10 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:01:20 When nation and the five, either this will possess us or all.

0:01:27 Thank you.

0:01:30 Our next item on the agenda is the consent calendar.

0:01:34 What are council's wishes?

0:01:37 Move to accept the consent calendar.

0:01:39 A motion to accept.

0:01:41 And a second.

0:01:42 Is there any discussion on the consent calendar?

0:01:46 Any Rachel roll call vote?

0:01:48 Chris Reed.

0:01:49 Yes.

0:01:50 Jason Brown.

0:01:51 Yes, Craig Hawkins, yes, Sherry Volmer, yes, Ruth Pierce, yes, Nathan Murray, yes, and Grayson Stone.

0:01:58 We'll go with motion carries six to zero.

0:02:12 We'll move on to our items of consideration for tonight.

0:02:16 And the first item is a request to appoint Alexis Gatsby and Reapoint Robin Weatherford to the Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:02:24 And we have Jonathan Spinmoop.

0:02:26 Thank you, Mayor Brown. So this last year,

0:02:31 space going to December, we put out a call for volunteers for the Plains only

0:02:34 commissioned me on one opening. We had four applicants and the committee met, went

0:02:39 through the applications. I wasn't actually part of it, but then they narrow

0:02:44 down to Alexis Gadsby and Robin Weatherford is fulfilling her first full term, so she

0:02:48 would like to be reappointed for her next term. Turn over the mayor for the rest of

0:02:53 And I was part of the interview, and so I would make a request to appoint Alexis Gadsby and

0:03:00 reappoint Robin Weatherford to the Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:03:03 I'll second that motion.

0:03:11 Wait, wait, wait, how many needs to make the motion?

0:03:14 Okay, you can't make the motion.

0:03:16 I'll make the motion.

0:03:17 Perfect.

0:03:18 I move we appoint Alexis Gadsby and reappoint Robin Weatherford to the Planning and Zoning

0:03:23 Commission.

0:03:23 I'll second it.

0:03:25 Okay, we have a first and a second to appoint Alexis Gadsby and reappoint Robin

0:03:29 and Weatherford to the Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:03:32 There any discussion?

0:03:35 Okay, Rachel Roll call vote.

0:03:40 Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed, Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown,

0:03:45 Jerry Volmer, and Nathan Murray.

0:03:48 Yes, Alexis Robond, either one of you want to say anything?

0:03:53 Okay, sounds good, we're good, thank you very much.

0:03:56 Appreciate it.

0:03:57 Thank you.

0:04:01 Okay, our next item is a presentation of the city

0:04:06 It's a good to be with you tonight and present the audit like we do every year.

0:04:55 We have new council members and so it's important that we explain what we're doing and what our role is as the audit firm of the city and

0:05:03 Kind of explain that huge document you received

0:05:07 In your packets it's there's a lot to it and so we'll kind of go through that and explain that we've met

0:05:15 Last week with Travis Brianna and Parker

0:05:19 As our audit team and them and went through things answered any questions that they may have and

0:05:25 But this is the formal presentation to you, the City Council.

0:05:30 The audit documentation talks about the City Council being those charged with governance is what your role would be.

0:05:38 And so we're required to present to you any findings that we have and kind of explain things.

0:05:45 We won't really get into the numbers.

0:05:47 I believe we'll be getting into the numbers in detail here,

0:05:51 and these numbers are from several months ago,

0:05:54 but really more talk about the audit

0:05:57 and who we are and what our role is with the city.

0:06:00 I ask one of our staff, younger, several decades younger

0:06:04 than me to freshen up my presentation,

0:06:07 so it looks a little better.

0:06:10 I appreciate that.

0:06:12 We didn't use magnifying glass at all during the audit,

0:06:16 It kind of explains what we're doing here.

0:06:18 First of all, who are we?

0:06:20 Mulkey Hensaker and Company.

0:06:21 We're a firm here in town, a CPA firm,

0:06:25 that we do quite a few government audits in the area.

0:06:30 And we appreciate the opportunity to work with the city.

0:06:33 We've been here for a number of years,

0:06:35 and appreciate this relationship we have.

0:06:38 We do quite a few profit, for-profit, nonprofits,

0:06:41 and governments as well as single audits,

0:06:43 and we'll talk about that a little bit.

0:06:44 but it would do a lot in the area down into Nevada as well.

0:06:50 Doing government audits is a little bit of a niche

0:06:53 that not many firms are still doing

0:06:56 because there's significant requirements

0:06:59 to do these types of audits.

0:07:00 So a lot of continual education that are required as well

0:07:04 as you have to be peer reviewed by other firms to come in

0:07:07 and make sure that our documentation meets those standards.

0:07:11 So that's who we are.

0:07:13 The question is why do you need an audit?

0:07:18 And I think there's many reasons.

0:07:20 Here's just a few.

0:07:22 First, the Idaho Code requires it.

0:07:25 It says it shall be the duty of the Council in every city

0:07:28 to cause a full and complete audit of the financial statements.

0:07:31 So you're required by law to do this.

0:07:34 But there's also other kind of ancillary benefits

0:07:38 to doing an audit.

0:07:40 First, it maintains transparency in public trust,

0:07:44 that you have an independent group coming

0:07:46 and looking at your finances

0:07:47 and making sure that they look accurate.

0:07:50 It also helps you qualify for grants and loans.

0:07:54 Most of the time required for those items

0:07:56 and then detect any misstatements

0:07:59 or mismanagement as well.

0:08:03 So a government audit is kind of a unique method

0:08:08 method and unique experience, really.

0:08:12 You have the financial statements that are there

0:08:14 that you have as part of your packet.

0:08:17 And we go through those and make sure they're presented

0:08:19 fairly and make sure there are no material misstatements.

0:08:22 And then we issue an opinion on those financial statements

0:08:26 and we'll show the opinion in just a second.

0:08:28 We also look at the internal controls of the entity

0:08:31 and make sure that they're functioning.

0:08:33 And then in your case, we also perform a single audit,

0:08:37 which is related to federal monies.

0:08:40 So this is the most important page of that whole document

0:08:44 that you have that says,

0:08:49 that's what it looks like,

0:08:49 but the main paragraph there is,

0:08:51 in our opinion, the financial statements referred to

0:08:53 above present fairly in all material respects,

0:08:56 the respective financial position of the city of Twin Falls

0:08:59 Idaho in accordance with general accepted accounting

0:09:01 principles of the United States.

0:09:03 But that's the punch line right there.

0:09:05 That's the most important thing,

0:09:07 is that we're issuing a, they call it an unqualified opinion,

0:09:11 but that's what you want, that's a clean opinion,

0:09:13 there's nothing that would make us qualify our opinion.

0:09:16 So that's the most important part for you to hear.

0:09:21 So how do we arrive at this unqualified opinion?

0:09:24 How do we do this with the massive amounts

0:09:26 of transactions that you have and balances of the city,

0:09:30 which are significant?

0:09:31 How would we do this?

0:09:33 We do some planning and assess the risks

0:09:35 of the balances and transactions.

0:09:37 We look at the transactions that may be a little bit higher risk and assess the risk associated

0:09:43 with those.

0:09:44 And according to that assessment of risk, we test those balances and those areas that have

0:09:50 higher risk.

0:09:51 We are higher complexity or maybe you're a little bit more susceptible to fraud.

0:09:56 We would do additional procedures on those to test them.

0:10:00 So your balance sheet, we go through and make sure that those balances tie out to external

0:10:05 of internal sources and bank conformation and bank balances or loan balances and those types of things.

0:10:13 So internal controls, we've talked about a couple of times like this definition of internal controls.

0:10:19 Internal controls are mechanisms, rules and procedures implemented by an entity to ensure the integrity of financial and accounting information,

0:10:28 promote accountability and prevent fraud.

0:10:31 The city has these procedures in place to prevent fraud or have approvals and those types of

0:10:37 things.

0:10:39 And we test those controls that are in place.

0:10:42 So we'll trace a transaction, go through the whole system, make sure the approvals are

0:10:46 in place.

0:10:47 Some of those approvals are done by software.

0:10:51 And so we'll test to make sure that those approvals happen.

0:10:55 After we test those, we issue an opinion on the internal control as well.

0:10:59 That's part of a government audit.

0:11:01 We have to assess the internal controls of the entity.

0:11:05 And that's at the very back of your document,

0:11:08 our opinion on the internal controls.

0:11:11 Single audit, we've mentioned this a few times.

0:11:13 It's a strange term, but it's related to federal monies.

0:11:19 So it's a separate audit that we do,

0:11:22 related specifically to federal funds that you receive.

0:11:26 So anybody, any entity, nonprofit,

0:11:29 or any entity that receives and expands in the fiscal year,

0:11:33 a million dollars or more in that fiscal year is subject

0:11:37 to a single audit, and has to submit that single audit.

0:11:40 And it depends on the grant or the reward that you get.

0:11:45 And so we test it according to that grant

0:11:48 and make sure that you're complying with those requirements.

0:11:51 And then the results are part of your reporting package.

0:11:54 We issue an opinion there too.

0:11:57 And then we also submit the audit report as well as the whole financial statements

0:12:03 to the clearinghouse for the city.

0:12:05 So it becomes a public document.

0:12:09 Just real quick, you're that whole, they call it a CFR, that whole packet that you've received.

0:12:18 They're broken down into different sections.

0:12:20 The audit report we've discussed, I'd like to draw your attention to that MDNA,

0:12:24 the management's discussion analysis.

0:12:27 This is written by the city staff

0:12:30 Kind of written in in plain English

0:12:33 To the public as to how the city's done what what's been happening through the city

0:12:38 There's graphs about the revenues and expenditures for the city

0:12:42 That's kind of condenses that whole 130 page document down into just a few pages

0:12:48 So that's that would be where I would start if I was sitting in your seats, but there's all these other sections

0:12:54 in that

0:12:56 Caffer that that you have in front of you. I just always like to draw attention to this again

0:13:04 The city received the certificate of achievement for their financial reporting from the GFOA, which is the governing group of financial

0:13:14 government accounting

0:13:15 This is this is a bigger deal. I think people realize this is significant. The city works hard to receive this award

0:13:22 There's also a budget award that they receive as well

0:13:24 well. I looked again today to see how many in the state of Idaho. There's six cities still.

0:13:33 I think that's been the case for the last several years and the twin falls is one of those that

0:13:38 receives that award. And it's really just to encourage proper financial reporting that the

0:13:43 definition is there as to what the awards for, but it's the highest standard you can get

0:13:49 of reporting and it's amazing how detailed that review is, the comments

0:13:57 that we'll get back and what about this? Have you looked at this and it's very

0:14:01 detailed and so the city staff does a great job in getting that award. There's

0:14:08 a few highlights, financial, as we met with Travis the other day and we're

0:14:15 talking about, and he said, I remember the exact term he used,

0:14:20 but he said the city was in a good financial position.

0:14:24 And I think it's in an incredible position.

0:14:26 You're very strong, financially.

0:14:30 Plenty of reserves to do what you need to do.

0:14:34 Good trends, pain down dead, and those types of things.

0:14:38 Nothing that rose to the point where

0:14:41 we need to draw your attention to it.

0:14:43 It was what was budgeted in those types of things,

0:14:46 so good trends and very stable financial position.

0:14:53 We're required to discuss with you any findings that we have

0:14:57 and there's really nothing that we need to disclose to you.

0:15:01 There are no unusual transactions or difficulties

0:15:04 in completing audit, no disagreements

0:15:06 or those types of things.

0:15:08 But that's easy to do, just say there aren't anything,

0:15:11 everything went very smoothly.

0:15:14 The staff was great to work with, as always.

0:15:18 Parker and Brianna have been very good to work with

0:15:20 and get us the information and answer the questions

0:15:23 that we have.

0:15:24 So just overall, audit went well, just like I said,

0:15:28 it very qualified, or accounting staff,

0:15:31 which is great.

0:15:34 Most of the entities we'd work with

0:15:36 don't have as deep of staff as this entity.

0:15:40 And so that's great.

0:15:42 The internal controls have been established

0:15:44 or being followed financially.

0:15:46 The city is in good position with good reserves.

0:15:49 And I just always like to emphasize your role

0:15:52 as a city council.

0:15:53 These internal controls, your role as a city council

0:15:57 is part of that internal control.

0:15:59 It's reviewing the documents, asking questions.

0:16:03 How did this get handled?

0:16:04 What is this?

0:16:05 Those types of questions are important as a city council.

0:16:08 And it's good for us to see that and read the minutes as to your role of internal controls

0:16:15 as well.

0:16:16 So that's what we have.

0:16:19 If there's any questions, we'd be glad to answer or call the waiters if we need to.

0:16:25 Any questions for Scott?

0:16:26 I just want to say again, thank you, Scott, for all the work you and your team have done.

0:16:33 Please take that back to them.

0:16:36 one question because again this document's 141 pages. The general public sometimes, you know,

0:16:44 in his Idahoans, there's somewhat of a mistrust of government just in general. I think that when

0:16:49 you're in Idaho and you look at government and you think, okay, we're the skeletons. For those,

0:16:56 maybe that don't have the time to read 141 pages, where would you direct them? I mean, at the end,

0:17:02 you have kind of that report, but as somebody who does this for a living who's looking at

0:17:11 these types of reports, where would you direct them?

0:17:15 Well, like I said earlier, I think the first place I would suggest is to read the MDNA,

0:17:21 which is, you know, 10 or 12 pages long, and it condenses those things down into readable,

0:17:29 understandable language. Government accounting is unique, and even if you have a somewhat

0:17:36 significant financial statement background, governments handle things very differently,

0:17:42 and you have two sets of financial statements here that are different types of accounting,

0:17:46 and that can be very confusing. But the MDNA is really meant exactly for this type of person

0:17:55 person that wants to know how things are going, where we're at financially, what's happened

0:18:01 this last year, that would be the best place.

0:18:05 And then, if that doesn't answer the questions, maybe the city staff or some others could help,

0:18:14 but that usually answers the majority of the questions, it's starting there first.

0:18:19 That's a great question.

0:18:20 Chris.

0:18:21 Can I ask one more question, and you might have brought this up a little bit.

0:18:25 your responsibility to as an independent auditor. You're not employed by the city, but who who's

0:18:33 who do you report to? Yeah, who do you report to? You to the city council. We report directly to

0:18:41 you. So if there were a finding that caused some some problems or fraud or something like that

0:18:49 that we discovered during an audit, we would come to the City Council. You know, we would,

0:18:56 it depends where that was happening. We would probably work with some staff with Travis or

0:19:01 whatever if that's where it was happening, but it would get reported. There's no materiality with

0:19:06 fraud, so that doesn't mean that the fraud has to be over X dollars for it to get reported to the

0:19:13 City Council, it's supposed to be reported. So we report directly to you, you would be like an

0:19:19 and audit committee if this was an SEC entity

0:19:22 that's this group that reviews those things.

0:19:26 Oh yeah, no, we work for you.

0:19:28 Perfect, thank you.

0:19:29 You bet.

0:19:30 Nathan Murray.

0:19:31 Yeah, so glad to hear we're in a strong financial position.

0:19:36 I just wanted to ask,

0:19:37 as someone who's worked with other cities and communities

0:19:40 around this state and others,

0:19:43 do you see any long-term trends

0:19:45 that we might want to watch out for?

0:19:47 We're just kind of monitoring over the next five to 10 years,

0:19:50 so we don't get any further risk

0:19:52 or kind of maintain our position.

0:19:54 Maybe that's kind of a grand question.

0:19:57 Yeah, there's a big question that I haven't really considered.

0:20:01 I don't see anything that because of the city,

0:20:06 and I don't want to be a cheerleader up here

0:20:08 because I don't want, I want to be independent here,

0:20:10 but the city of Twin Falls has really managed very, very well.

0:20:14 And I think there's a prospective look down the road.

0:20:20 And that's why you have significant reserves.

0:20:22 There's always an awareness of growth.

0:20:26 And so, I think both the finance and other departments

0:20:31 do a very good job of anticipating those types of things.

0:20:35 But I don't see anything that's like a blinking light,

0:20:38 like this is coming and it's gonna get ya

0:20:41 because I think the planning and the homework's been done.

0:20:45 So I don't have anything that's like,

0:20:48 we've got to watch out for this.

0:20:50 I don't see any, but I should think about that

0:20:52 a little bit more than I have, but that's a good question.

0:20:57 Hey, any other questions?

0:20:59 Thank you, Scott, appreciate it.

0:21:01 Okay, thank you.

0:21:02 Thanks, Scott.

0:21:06 Okay, our next item on items of consideration

0:21:09 is a presentation of the 20-year-old.

0:21:12 We're going to ask that we take a quick recess.

0:21:15 Okay.

0:21:16 During the meeting, our team's calls dropped.

0:21:20 Okay.

0:21:21 And so some of your presentations and City Councilman Stone are trying to get on.

0:21:26 And so the best way that we can do that is to reset the technology.

0:21:31 And so we're going to take, if we could take a quick break to reset the technology,

0:21:35 that would be great.

0:21:37 We'll reconvene in about five minutes.

0:21:39 You think that'll be?

0:21:42 management team of the city extends greater than a single individual and

0:21:48 it is lots of conscientious hands working and creating a better community that is the result of

0:21:57 these types of quality decisions moving forward. So if you give us a quick minute to break and recess

0:22:02 we'll get it going and hopefully it will all work. We'll come back here in just a minute do you want

0:22:06 want us to log off of our kind of the 2025 annual report of the urban renewal agency of the City

0:22:13 of Twin Falls of Sean Berger. Good evening, mayor and council. Thank you for the opportunity

0:22:18 to visit with you briefly. So Idaho Code requires that the urban renewal agency presents an annual

0:22:26 report regarding the activities of the agency. That can be something as simple as us handing

0:22:30 that report to the city clerk as a courtesy, since you are our good partners with the agency.

0:22:36 We wanted to take an opportunity to just go through the highlights of that report and

0:22:40 certainly answer any questions that you may have.

0:22:43 So for the report, we spoke generally about the agency activities.

0:22:48 So again, we run a public agency, so conducted our regular meetings,

0:22:54 and shared that information with the Board of Commissioners.

0:22:58 One item of note, just kind of with our routine business, was this year we did have a change to state code

0:23:03 that allowed the Twin Falls Ambulance District to make a request to withdraw from the revenue allocation areas that the agency manages.

0:23:11 Following that state code, the agency board of commissioners considered those requests and actually denied withdrawal from three of our urban renewal areas, 4-3, which is Chobani, 4-4, which is Cliff Bar, and Orchard Drive East, which is the Gemini Business Park,

0:23:30 because the agency has financial obligations in those areas

0:23:34 that are funded in part by those revenue allocation proceeds.

0:23:38 The two other areas, the Old Town 2, which is the downtown area,

0:23:43 and the Southwest area do not have any current financial obligations,

0:23:46 and so the agency board did allow the ambulance district

0:23:50 to opt out of those areas.

0:23:53 Specific to the other revenue allocation areas,

0:23:55 the Chobani area, you'll all recall, about a year ago,

0:23:59 We celebrated the announcement of a significant expansion at Chobani, and looking forward

0:24:05 to that project continuing, following that, and with the passage of the new legislation

0:24:11 at the state, the agency also processed a DNxation of 28 acres from the Chobani revenue

0:24:19 allocation area that Chobani did not own.

0:24:23 That was in anticipation, potentially moving forward with a request to extend the life

0:24:28 of that area. In the cliff bar area, really routine business dealing with the outstanding

0:24:35 debt obligations that we have there. The old town 2 revenue allocation area, the agency

0:24:41 board has had some significant discussion about properties that the agency owns and advancing

0:24:48 request for redevelopment, redevelopment proposals in those areas. That is ongoing at this time,

0:24:53 But we began that process in 2025 and then noted the properties that the agency does continue

0:25:00 to own in the old town to revenue allocation area.

0:25:05 We did have a couple of projects that we supported as well downtown.

0:25:09 One was a request from developers in the Hanson Street East area.

0:25:15 We provided some initial funding for a review of engineering, pre-engineering, of what some

0:25:23 streetscape enhancements may look like.

0:25:26 We also launched the Development Assistance Participation Program, which is a program designed

0:25:31 for assisting private investment with public improvements that they may be required to do

0:25:37 as part of their investment.

0:25:38 So for example, we had the CrossFit Gym that went in just down the street here on Hanson.

0:25:44 They made some significant private improvements,

0:25:47 but also it triggered some ADA compliance issues

0:25:51 with the sidewalk.

0:25:52 We were able to assist them with some of that.

0:25:56 And then finally, the agency has been working

0:26:00 with a couple of our board members on discussions

0:26:02 with downtown business owners and operators

0:26:05 to find more opportunities for them

0:26:07 to better connect and collaborate

0:26:09 on joint projects moving forward.

0:26:11 And then finally, the or not finally,

0:26:13 The Orchard Drive East Revenue Allocation Area really was an area where we saw a lot of activity

0:26:18 this last year.

0:26:19 Gemini Business Park has had some significant construction going on there at 100% occupancy

0:26:25 of their square footage that they have constructed and they currently have another building under

0:26:30 construction that will be opened this summer.

0:26:35 In that area we have what is called an owner participation agreement so that private developer

0:26:39 has advanced the cost of public improvements in the area and as new revenue comes into the

0:26:45 agency we're able to reimburse for a portion of those. And then finally the southwest revenue

0:26:51 allocation area was just established at the tail end of 2024. So really last year was just

0:26:58 kind of getting our feet under us there with development opportunities in that area. Finally

0:27:05 as part of the annual report is financial information and as I mentioned you get two audits with

0:27:10 this report because the annual report required of the agency is a calendar year, the fiscal

0:27:18 years overlap that.

0:27:20 So you have both the 24 and 25 audits that are included with this.

0:27:25 I will not go through them in great detail, but we'll let you know that Parker today at

0:27:31 the Urban Renewal Agency Board meeting noted that our audit too was in good shape.

0:27:37 And we appreciate the work that he has done to keep us there.

0:27:42 With that I would stand for any questions you may have.

0:27:45 Any questions for Sean?

0:27:46 Okay.

0:27:51 Seeing none, we'll move on to our next item.

0:27:55 Thank you, Sean.

0:27:56 Welcome.

0:27:57 It looks like you're also on the presentation of the Multius event center feasibility study.

0:28:03 I am.

0:28:04 Hold on just a moment here and let me get the report opened up.

0:28:17 So back in 2022, the City of Twin Falls

0:28:21 solicited proposals for use of some of the state

0:28:24 and local fiscal recovery funds for qualifying projects.

0:28:29 And the Economic Development Department

0:28:31 submitted a proposal to request funding

0:28:33 to support a comprehensive feasibility

0:28:35 and economic impact study for a convention conference meeting

0:28:40 type center.

0:28:41 The SLF or F Committee and the Council

0:28:43 approved that request, allocating $125,000 toward the project.

0:28:48 Since that time, the Council also established an event center

0:28:52 study committee to advance this project.

0:28:55 That committee developed a charter for its work,

0:28:57 released a request for qualifications for a firm

0:28:59 to assist with the study, and eventually selected

0:29:02 Johnson Consulting after reviewing proposals.

0:29:05 They've worked with Johnson Consulting over the past

0:29:07 several months to provide input on the study.

0:29:10 So Johnson is on the phone, in theory,

0:29:13 are still connected.

0:29:14 We have, yeah, excellent.

0:29:17 So we have representatives from Johnson Consulting

0:29:19 who are going to go through the final report

0:29:23 and recommendations.

0:29:24 So I believe you have the full report in your packet.

0:29:27 This is a slide deck that will summarize those findings.

0:29:30 And tonight we're looking for some,

0:29:33 any questions or comments you may have or feedback.

0:29:36 And then I will have a short presentation to make

0:29:40 after john makes his

0:29:42 presentation and sit here and push buttons for

0:29:46 john welcome

0:29:49 thank you shot really appreciate it and and thank you to everybody on the

0:29:53 council

0:29:54 i'd like to confirm that you guys can hear me all right

0:29:56 yes we can

0:29:59 okay and then uh... shawn are you going to be sharing the screen so i can

0:30:04 see what's later on otherwise we can just try to coordinate here and i can run

0:30:07 it on my end to just give me the chimes whenever i'm supposed to turn the page

0:30:13 Okay, so we are on the title page multi-use events and our feasibility study presentation

0:30:19 of findings.

0:30:22 Yes, we are.

0:30:23 Yes.

0:30:25 Okay.

0:30:26 Well, again, thank you all for having me tonight virtually and getting the teams calls

0:30:32 stood up.

0:30:33 My name is John Fleming.

0:30:34 I'm a project manager with Johnson Consulting.

0:30:37 As Sean said, we've been working with the City of Twin Falls and the Multi-use Events

0:30:42 Center Committee studying the feasibility and market opportunity for a multi-use event

0:30:47 space within the City of Twin Falls.

0:30:50 So I'll kind of walk you through some of our research findings, how we synthesize those

0:30:57 into recommendations and then based on the recommendations around facility and kind of

0:31:04 facility plan, you know, how we kind of converted that into a business plan, demand projections,

0:31:10 financial projections and economic and fiscal impact analysis as well.

0:31:14 Sean, if you could take me to the next slide, you're there.

0:31:21 All right.

0:31:23 Thank you.

0:31:24 So just in terms of an agenda, I'll start with a brief introduction of the team, go through

0:31:28 some of our key research findings, our recommendations, some of the financial and demand projections,

0:31:34 and then open it up for discussion or any questions from the council.

0:31:37 Next slide, please.

0:31:38 And then you can advance one more to the RT and slide.

0:31:46 All right, so again, I'm with Johnson Consulting, and we were the lead consultant on this engagement.

0:31:57 We're a strategic planning advisory services consulting firm for the public assembly facilities industry.

0:32:04 So we've been around for 30 years now. We just passed our 30th anniversary.

0:32:09 And we work on convention and conference centers, sports facilities, arenas, stadiums, youth sports facilities as well.

0:32:17 We do a lot of work on fairgrounds as well as on performing arts centers and then other hospitality projects.

0:32:23 Ryan Johnson is the principal who has involved on this project. He wasn't able to make it tonight.

0:32:28 But he is our practice leader for the convention and conference practice area.

0:32:34 And then we worked with Cushing Terrell, which is an architecture firm.

0:32:38 And they have offices really all over the region headquartered in Boise,

0:32:42 but offices in Idaho, Montana, Utah, et cetera.

0:32:45 They've been really great to work with as well.

0:32:48 Next slide, please.

0:32:51 And then next slide, please.

0:32:52 We can get into some of these key research findings.

0:32:55 And hopefully, you all are seeing the slide that

0:32:58 says, placement and drive times.

0:33:01 Yes.

0:33:04 Excellent.

0:33:04 OK, thank you.

0:33:05 So as we think about a facility opportunity

0:33:09 like this, the first thing to consider

0:33:11 is really the larger market context

0:33:13 from a geographic standpoint.

0:33:14 So I think the first and most critical thing is the proximity to the interstate I-84 that

0:33:21 Twin Falls enjoys, and the way that that connects that to some other major markets in the region.

0:33:26 So thinking about I-84 and its connectivity that it provides to Boise, the connectivity

0:33:32 along the highway, the Salt Lake City as well, and then some of the Eastern Idaho markets,

0:33:37 Pocatello, I-the-Hoe Falls as well.

0:33:39 And so really what that drives that is within a three-hour drive time catchment, we're looking

0:33:44 about two and a half million people and so that's, you know, a pretty strong market opportunity

0:33:49 for drive-to-conventions in terms of a population that could be served and then if you look

0:33:54 more locally at Twin Falls and Twin Falls County itself, you know, as you know, we're

0:33:58 seeing really rapid population growth and this is true across Idaho, I've been working

0:34:05 in Boise with the Greater Boise Auditorium District and they're seeing some more boom and it's

0:34:10 It's really pointed to a need for new public facilities to help support some of that population

0:34:15 boom.

0:34:16 If you could jump us to the next slide here.

0:34:20 And then in terms of some population trends, we're seeing really a lot of young families

0:34:25 within Twin Falls in terms of its growth.

0:34:28 So a higher proportion of young population, a lower median age.

0:34:32 And I think that's another strong indicator of the market's continued growth is we're

0:34:37 folks moving to the market who want to have families and then hopefully perpetuate that growth

0:34:43 by keeping folks in the market. Next slide please. One of the other things that we tend to look at

0:34:50 is largest employers and economic clusters, and I'll get into some of that. But some of the reasons

0:34:55 that why we look at those largest employers is they often, in the case of the defense center,

0:35:00 can create some opportunities for relationships, sponsorships, advertising.

0:35:05 And I think about sort of the clusters that Twin Falls has in food and production, health

0:35:11 care, transportation, and the conferencing and corporate event opportunities that those

0:35:16 economic clusters provide.

0:35:18 And so I think, you know, thinking about, you know, those economic clusters and how you

0:35:23 could link them to the local economic base with that event center, it's a real opportunity.

0:35:29 It's something that, you know, we've seen perform in a lot of markets across the country.

0:35:33 if you can advance the next slide here.

0:35:38 You know, kind of continuing off of that economic side of the analysis and looking at some of

0:35:42 the largest industries.

0:35:43 Again, we've seen unemployment rate into involved that has historically tracked a little

0:35:49 bit above that of the state, but below that of the nation and overall pretty strong local

0:35:56 economy.

0:35:57 Again, some of the investments that we've seen from some of these food production businesses,

0:36:02 businesses. Sean just mentioned Chibani's continued investments in the

0:36:06 community have helped drive some of that strong employment and population growth.

0:36:11 And again, you know, really ties back to some opportunities for trade shows and

0:36:17 things of that nature. If a facility were provided that could help accommodate

0:36:23 some of those things. Next slide please. One of the other things that we really

0:36:29 look at is a key element of any project like this, especially, you know, thinking about

0:36:35 out of town conferences and events and that nature is a hotel inventory.

0:36:40 And so within Twin Falls there's really one primary hotel cluster and that's kind of located

0:36:47 between CSI's campus and the Snake River Canyon.

0:36:51 So it's more of the city center in the long pole line road, right?

0:36:56 And so as we think about how to really maximize an event center,

0:37:00 you either need to be located near existing inventory

0:37:04 or ideally co-located with a hotel.

0:37:08 And that's really just because as we look at out-of-count events

0:37:12 and one meeting planar's prioritized in terms of those events,

0:37:16 that hotel proximity is key. They want their attendees to be able to park their car,

0:37:21 go to their hotel, go to their event, not have to get back into their car

0:37:25 unless maybe they want to go offsite for some sort of

0:37:27 excursion.

0:37:28 So that convenience factor is really important.

0:37:31 Next slide, please.

0:37:34 And then as we look at sort of the hotel market performance

0:37:37 and how hotels in the community are doing,

0:37:40 what we've seen is a surge in average daily rate

0:37:43 and revenue per available room in the Twin Falls Market

0:37:46 since the pandemic.

0:37:47 However, that surge has leveled off somewhat in recent years.

0:37:51 So we saw a big growth in 2021 and 2022,

0:37:55 but more incremental growth since then.

0:37:58 And then a couple of hotels currently in the pipeline,

0:38:01 in the market, one that's under renovation,

0:38:04 that's really more of a motel,

0:38:05 but then a home to suite that's in the planning stages

0:38:08 as of now.

0:38:09 So there is market support for additional hotel inventory,

0:38:13 obviously given the additional hotel inventory

0:38:16 that's in the pipeline.

0:38:18 But it hasn't been sort of growing at the same rate

0:38:21 that we saw coming out of the pandemic.

0:38:23 And then next slide, please.

0:38:26 We also look a lot for a study like this

0:38:29 at an existing local event facility.

0:38:32 So really, what is the competitive landscape,

0:38:34 and what facilities might complement or compete

0:38:37 with a potential new multi-use event center?

0:38:40 On the local market basis, they're a handful, right?

0:38:43 The number one in terms of psi is C and S I,

0:38:47 and specifically the Elbens Expo Center.

0:38:49 That's about 60,000 square feet

0:38:51 of total sort of floor space and the CSI itself can be used for conventions and conferences

0:38:59 using its kind of classrooms and in academic spaces, as various breakout rooms. However,

0:39:05 it's really challenged in that respect. And thinking about the Expo Center specifically,

0:39:09 it has a dirt floor. It's really more of an agricultural type facility for livestock,

0:39:15 rodeo, things of that nature, but not necessarily the type of facility where on a regular basis,

0:39:20 you would want to be hosting more formal events.

0:39:23 Then you have the Pasture Events Center at the Fairgrounds, just west of town.

0:39:30 And that's a nice facility, but it's a little bit on the smaller side of the 11,400 square feet.

0:39:36 And then they're pretty limited in terms of their ability to do catered events.

0:39:40 There's not a kitchen on site, so that's a limiting factor.

0:39:44 And then a handful of sort of wedding venue event centers in town as well can you crest

0:39:51 360 main.

0:39:52 And again, those are all really valuable amenities, but really what we've heard from

0:39:59 various event planners and observed is that those venues have been kind of outgrown by

0:40:07 the market for some of these larger banquets and events.

0:40:10 And each of those on its own is not large enough to host, you know, necessarily sort

0:40:16 of state association type conferences where you might have 400 or 500 for a seated banquet

0:40:22 function plus need for breakout rooms for smaller sessions, et cetera.

0:40:27 Next slide, please.

0:40:28 And then looking at the regional market for event facilities, so thinking about a 90-minute

0:40:34 drive from Twin Falls, you know, there really isn't a whole lot in that sort of 90-minute

0:40:41 drive time catchment, right? Twin Falls really kind of dominates this region in terms of an

0:40:47 economic force, a population center. You know, there's only one other facility and it's in

0:40:53 Mountain Home at the Gala Event Center that we're adding. So, you know, really what we

0:40:59 see as an area of opportunity is a facility with, you know, a larger space, maybe somewhere

0:41:04 between the 20,000 and 20,000 square foot range based on that. And then if you go to the

0:41:09 Next slide, we also looked at statewide effect facilities, and statewide is really pertinent

0:41:15 because as we think about state and regional associations, they often serve as a requirement

0:41:23 of their association will rotate among various facilities in the state.

0:41:27 So for instance, the Idaho Association of Orthodontists, right, they want to be able

0:41:32 to serve all of their association members in different regions in the state.

0:41:37 So eastern Idaho, central or southern Idaho, western Idaho, northern Idaho, right?

0:41:44 And what we see is that northern Idaho, you have the Casino Resort Hotel in Coeur de Lane,

0:41:50 western Idaho in Boise.

0:41:53 There's a number of facilities in the Treasure Valley Metro.

0:41:58 And then eastern Idaho, you've got the Mountain View Event Center in Pocatello as well as some

0:42:04 event spaces and Idaho Falls as well, but really the only option in Southern Idaho of any sort

0:42:09 of substantial scale, and I'm using that 20,000 square foot larger space as kind of a cut off,

0:42:15 is the Elden Evans Expo Center at CSI, which again is a dirt floor facility. So it's pretty limited

0:42:25 in terms of the ability to host more formal dining type events, et cetera. And so if we go to the

0:42:31 next slide, just kind of summarizing the opportunity from our perspective in terms of conference

0:42:37 and convention space.

0:42:40 Despite the growing population that we've seen statewide and particularly in markets like

0:42:44 the Treasure Valley and Magic Valley, Idaho has a really limited inventory of event spaces

0:42:49 and particularly larger event spaces.

0:42:51 So I'm talking a thousand plus people for a banquet function and this is something that

0:42:56 we really observed as well in our work with the Greater Boise Auditorium District and looking

0:43:01 can get opportunities for expansion at Boise Center.

0:43:06 There's a lot of demand for event space within this state,

0:43:09 but there's a rule under supply.

0:43:11 Most of those existing event spaces

0:43:13 are really clustered in the Treasure Valley,

0:43:15 and we're seeing the Magic Valley as a pretty significantly

0:43:19 underserved market.

0:43:20 And so what we see is an opportunity

0:43:22 for a new facility that could perhaps

0:43:25 take advantage of some of those rotating state

0:43:27 and regional association events, as well as corporate

0:43:30 or compressing activity associated with the corporate clusters that we see in Twin Falls,

0:43:36 thinking about agribusiness, Chibani, Cliffbar, as well as healthcare and the healthcare clusters

0:43:42 that are there isn't here.

0:43:43 And then also serve some larger local banquet and event needs.

0:43:47 And the goal of any type of facility like this would never be to compete with existing

0:43:52 offerings within the community.

0:43:54 So looking at how can a new facility fill a market need that isn't necessarily being

0:44:00 by some of the existing event centers within the twin-false market.

0:44:04 And then if we go to the next slide, one of the other demand letters that we potentially

0:44:09 would have got, and this is really where the multi-use component of this comes in,

0:44:13 was youth sports. And when I say youth sports, I'm thinking really specifically

0:44:18 sports tourism or tournament sports, and why sports tourism or tournament sports?

0:44:23 It's really because that type of use is really where you see kind of the majority

0:44:29 of tourism and economic development is an outcome here.

0:44:33 And what we observe from our analysis here, as well as our analysis from our work with the auditorium district

0:44:39 in Boise, is that, again, these are real undersupply of facilities that are large enough to host these tournament type events,

0:44:47 within the broader region. So, through those facilities, and I say large enough,

0:44:53 It's barely large enough, are in the treasure valley area.

0:44:58 We've got the treasure valley athletic center.

0:45:00 You've got cabin, wilderness, sports, complex,

0:45:02 but that's really associated with Boise State University.

0:45:07 So it's really not programmed very often for youth sports

0:45:09 tourism.

0:45:10 You've got the Meridian home court as well.

0:45:13 But all of those are smaller, four or six basketball courts.

0:45:18 Typically we like to see eight basketball courts

0:45:21 as a starting point, you know, six of the minimum

0:45:24 for these tournament-type facilities.

0:45:27 And when Salt Lake City has really kind of dominated the market,

0:45:30 they have a couple of facilities that are just outside

0:45:33 of this catchment area that you see in the map

0:45:37 on the right hand of the screen, but it's done really well

0:45:40 in terms of capturing that youth sports.

0:45:42 And so, you know, what we see is there is a really strong opportunity

0:45:46 to serve these Idaho markets with a larger youth sports type

0:45:51 facility.

0:45:52 And then if we go to the next slide here, you know, what we see is significantly below-average

0:45:59 spend on sports, participants' sports, admission to sports events within the Twin Falls area.

0:46:06 But participation rates are pretty strong.

0:46:09 I mean, relatively speaking, they're just about in line with the national average.

0:46:13 And so that high participation or relatively high participation paired with the lower spending

0:46:18 does kind of indicate from another direction kind of the lack of sports facilities in the

0:46:22 Twin Falls area as well as particularly sports tourism capable facilities.

0:46:28 However, if we go to the next slide here, I think this kind of summarizes our thoughts.

0:46:35 That market analysis that I just presented really does identify indoor sports tourism

0:46:39 as a significant facility gap within the regional market.

0:46:43 But at the same time, as you all probably know, the J-Foundation is currently looking at developing

0:46:54 a facility called the Sports Ranch at the former Fluidly Ranch site just south of Twin Falls.

0:47:00 And we did meet with the J-Foundation and Jason and kind of got to see a little bit about sort

0:47:09 of his plans and intention and our assessment of that is that the market need for sports

0:47:17 tourism is likely to be met by that facility.

0:47:20 There is intention on the part of the Jay Foundation that hosts some of those weekend long

0:47:24 basketball or volleyball tournaments and as a result, and I come back to, we don't want

0:47:30 to recommend a public investment that's going to be competing with private enterprise.

0:47:34 We would recommend an investment and do a project that would be competitive with the

0:47:38 the sports ranch, we would prefer that that be sort of their market and then point this

0:47:46 project in a different direction.

0:47:47 So that really brings us, if you take us to the next slide here, to our recommendations,

0:47:53 and you can take it to one more slide where we're looking at some of these demand layers,

0:47:58 excuse me, just having a sip of water.

0:48:01 So we like to think about a demand strategy in terms of layers, and primary layers being

0:48:08 kind of the bigger building blocks that make up the demand profile of the facility with

0:48:13 some of the secondary layers being infill events, right?

0:48:17 And so starting up that primary building block, I think conferences and conventions, really

0:48:22 looking at how can we tap into state and regional associations, how can we tap into the corporate

0:48:28 market and bring some of these more formal conferences and conventions into the facility.

0:48:33 And then, you know, the next layer up might be banquets and social events.

0:48:38 We've heard pretty consistently throughout our research process that a lot of the sort

0:48:43 of banquets and social events in town were having trouble finding adequate space, having

0:48:49 trouble finding the right dates, especially around the holidays, right?

0:48:53 Elmore's banquets, Gala's, things of that nature, it could be a real strong demand there.

0:48:58 And something to consider is that those types of events tend to drive pretty strong revenue.

0:49:02 just due to the food and beverage considerations associated with them.

0:49:06 And then, you know, kind of a tertiary there, if you will, might be around civic and community use.

0:49:11 So, you know, having a facility like this within the community, you know, even if these events

0:49:18 are not necessarily generating as much tourism, it can be really useful to have a larger,

0:49:23 multi-use type of event space for community events for consumer shows, things like that

0:49:30 where you're bringing in community members

0:49:34 to utilize this space in addition to it primarily being utilized

0:49:38 by out-of-town type folks. And so with those demand layers in mind

0:49:42 and, Sean, if you go to the next slide here, we essentially recommended this high-level

0:49:46 program of function and support spaces. So on the function spaces, we'd recommend that it

0:49:52 really be built off of a 30,000-square-foot convention hall.

0:49:56 hall. And when I say convention hall, it's sort of a hybrid of an expo hall and a ballroom,

0:50:02 right? So it's a little bit higher finish than maybe the expo hall that you would see in a typical

0:50:09 big box convention center or event center, but a little bit more finished than a ballroom. And

0:50:14 that enables us to host some of those banquet type events, but still have the ceiling height

0:50:20 required to bring in large equipment and host some more expo type shows. And then

0:50:26 You know, we'd recommend that be subdivisible in the smaller spaces

0:50:31 so that you can run multiple events concurrently, so maybe you could do it

0:50:37 in the three spaces of 10,000 square feet of piece and maybe even subdivide one

0:50:41 of those into two 5,000 square foot halls and really add some flexibility

0:50:45 and convertibility to the facility.

0:50:47 And then supporting that would be breakout rooms.

0:50:49 We've recommended eight individual rooms, totally 10,000 square feet.

0:50:55 So 1,250 square feet of peace, and again some flexibility and

0:51:00 combined ability in that.

0:51:01 And then, Sean, if you could go to the next slide here, we

0:51:05 worked with our partners at Cush and Terrell to put together a

0:51:08 very conceptual site and facility plan, just so that you

0:51:12 can kind of get some eyes on what it would be that

0:51:15 program needs, like let's translate that table into a

0:51:19 very hypothetical floor plan.

0:51:21 So this is not site specific at all, but it kind of gives you an idea of what this might look like.

0:51:27 You know, again, building it around that primary conference and convention hall,

0:51:32 and then surrounding it with breakout rooms, and then supporting it with lobby space,

0:51:37 restroom, catering kitchen is extremely important here to be able to serve those banquet events,

0:51:43 loading dock and back-of-house space, offices, et cetera.

0:51:47 And then what we're showing here is a typical layout

0:51:51 for a potential phase two expansion, right?

0:51:53 So with a facility like this,

0:51:57 if the community continues to grow,

0:51:59 you wanna keep in mind that you may want to expand it

0:52:02 in say 20 to 25 years to accommodate a larger community,

0:52:06 a larger demand profile.

0:52:08 And so keeping that expandability in mind and planning

0:52:12 for that in the future is really critical.

0:52:14 And I go back to our current ongoing work

0:52:16 with Boise Center in Boise at the Grove Plaza.

0:52:21 That's a great facility and they do a ton of business.

0:52:25 However, as any of you have been there will know,

0:52:29 it's very integrated within the buildings around it.

0:52:32 And as a result, it's very challenging to expand.

0:52:35 And so that's something that we're

0:52:36 puzzling through with the auditorium district right now,

0:52:38 is how can we execute on that?

0:52:41 And the answer is complex.

0:52:45 It's expensive, right?

0:52:46 And so keeping that expandability in mind

0:52:49 when you're initially planning for a facility like this

0:52:51 is really critical.

0:52:53 And then, next slide, please.

0:52:56 We did do some site analysis work

0:52:59 and kind of looked at different location options.

0:53:02 And I just wanted to kind of give you some broad strokes

0:53:05 thoughts on location considerations.

0:53:07 And I think back to the map that I showed

0:53:10 of your hotel clusters, it would really

0:53:12 be more on that North Side Pull Line Road.

0:53:14 And so, you know, when we think about, you know,

0:53:16 kind of the two primary areas of the community,

0:53:20 commercial quarters of the community,

0:53:22 downtowns, pros or that, it's very walkable.

0:53:25 It has really strong access to shopping,

0:53:27 dining, and a strong sense of place.

0:53:30 You know, the city's done a great job

0:53:32 of putting in these place-making features,

0:53:36 you know, narrowing some roads,

0:53:37 bringing in local businesses, et cetera,

0:53:40 and making it feel like Twin Falls.

0:53:42 You know, that's where we would typically recommend

0:53:44 that a conference or event facility be located.

0:53:47 However, you know, the cons are that, you know,

0:53:49 there are really no existing hotel,

0:53:52 at least not of the price point level,

0:53:56 typically associated with the conference or event center.

0:53:59 And then, you know, land availability is a real challenge.

0:54:03 And so with the density of downtown,

0:54:06 there aren't a whole lot of larger sites

0:54:08 that could help support this type of facility.

0:54:12 And then on the Converse side, looking at sort of the

0:54:15 Pole Line Road corridor of the North side of town,

0:54:18 you know, there are numerous hotels.

0:54:19 That's where most of your hotel inventory is.

0:54:23 There's still strong access to shopping

0:54:25 and dining options, right?

0:54:27 I think a real pro is potential access

0:54:30 to the Snake River Canyon and the trail development

0:54:33 that the city's done along that.

0:54:34 You know, that's a real spectacular asset

0:54:36 something that's a draw for the, a potential draw for the facility relative to competitive

0:54:43 facilities and with name availability, you know, there are a number of empty parcels still

0:54:47 in this region of the market and that, you know, could make a significant difference

0:54:52 in terms of actually executing that project.

0:54:55 Again, the cons, you know, the walkability is really a challenge.

0:54:59 There's very little of it and it's, you know, if you kind of go to our report, we did look

0:55:05 look at some case studies of more suburban, car-centric type conference centers, they can

0:55:11 have a lot of success. The Three Rivers Convention Center in Kenaway, Washington is a great example

0:55:18 of one that's done really well, but they've actually paired with a hotel on site and are

0:55:24 actually standing and adding another hotel on site as well as restaurant amenities. So

0:55:28 They've tried to think about, you know, how can we keep as much amenity space

0:55:34 on site as possible to ameliorate the walkability left?

0:55:38 And then, you know, the other piece is sort of the sense of place thing, right?

0:55:42 You know, Pullwind Road has a lot of really strong infrastructure,

0:55:45 but outside of the Snake River Canyon, you know, it doesn't necessarily screen more

0:55:51 in Twin Falls and doesn't necessarily sort of showcase a lot

0:55:55 of the communities more unique assets.

0:55:58 And then next slide, please, Sean.

0:56:03 So, and excuse me, I just grabbed a sip of water.

0:56:07 Just wanted to take you through some of our projections

0:56:10 and business planning.

0:56:11 If you go to the next slide, Sean, this takes us

0:56:14 to our demand projections for that recommended facility.

0:56:18 So again, 30,000 square foot convention hall

0:56:21 with about 10,000 square feet of breakout spaces,

0:56:23 as well as kitchen lobby, et cetera, right?

0:56:27 So we'd like to look at year five,

0:56:29 is really the stabilized year when you're established within the market, you're not ramping

0:56:34 up your demand as much.

0:56:36 And what we would see in that year five is just under 200 total events, about 67,000 total

0:56:43 attendees and really strong attendance from that consumer show and public event category.

0:56:49 So trying to bring in a lot of those types of events and make sure that it's both a tourism

0:56:58 driver as well as the local amenity.

0:57:00 And then moving on to the next slide, in terms of the financial projections associated with

0:57:06 this, we would project about an operating deficit around 225,000 at stabilization.

0:57:14 And, you know, that may seem like a lot, but it's actually just about in line with facilities

0:57:20 like this.

0:57:21 And it's partially a function of managing revenue earned versus economic impact.

0:57:27 And what I mean when I say that is, you know, you can operate a facility to maximize its revenue,

0:57:33 right, and bring in only the events that are going to pay the most in terms of rent

0:57:37 and food and beverage costs, right.

0:57:41 But those events may not bring in as many out-of-count attendees, drive as many rude nights

0:57:46 and drive as much tax revenue and economic impact.

0:57:49 And so, you know, what we're looking at here is somewhat of a balanced model, perhaps tilted

0:57:53 slightly towards the economic impact goal that could help sort of drive some of those

0:57:59 room nights and externalities to the community while keeping that operating deficit at a

0:58:04 manageable level.

0:58:05 And then if we go on to the next slide here, really the last piece of our financial projection

0:58:11 and business planning exercise is an economic impact analysis and essentially what we're

0:58:16 trying to understand there is for a subject facility and its kind of visitation profile

0:58:22 in terms of overnight attendees and day trip attendees,

0:58:26 what are we looking at in terms of new activity

0:58:30 brought to the economy? So that's direct spending associated with the

0:58:34 facility and the attendees from the facility, as well as the trickle down of that

0:58:38 dollar. So I go to a restaurant and I buy a meal, that's direct spending.

0:58:43 The restaurant is having to buy more food because

0:58:47 because so many more people are buying meals.

0:58:50 And then that's indirect spending,

0:58:52 and then they do spending is, you know,

0:58:54 I tip my surfer, and then the surfer's

0:58:56 are spending at a portion of their money

0:58:58 in that local economy, and so that all adds up

0:59:00 to economic impact.

0:59:02 And then on the both side of that,

0:59:04 we look at fiscal impact as well,

0:59:06 which is really tax revenues generated

0:59:08 to state and local public bodies.

0:59:12 So if you go to the next slide here,

0:59:14 this table really summarizes

0:59:16 of those economic and fiscal impact projections.

0:59:18 So again, looking at that year five stabilized level,

0:59:22 we've projected about 22,000 room nights on an annual basis.

0:59:26 An economic impact of about 23 and a half million dollars,

0:59:30 again, on an annual basis.

0:59:32 And so that's looking at that sum of direct,

0:59:34 indirect, and induced spending.

0:59:36 And then in terms of fiscal impact,

0:59:39 just over $1 million of annual tax revenues,

0:59:44 The vast majority of that would be sales tax generated at the state level and we can talk

0:59:52 about some of the funding options associated with that as well.

0:59:55 So that kind of brings me to the end of the slide that I prepared for you all the day.

1:00:01 And I'd love to just, I think Sean, next up here is questions but correct me if I'm

1:00:05 wrong.

1:00:06 Yes, John, that would be next on the agenda here would be an opportunity for any questions.

1:00:14 And I want to visit a little bit about some of the recommendations of next steps.

1:00:21 Any questions for Council?

1:00:24 Nathan Murray, there we go.

1:00:29 Sure.

1:00:30 Okay.

1:00:31 Of these benchmarking facilities you've mentioned, I'm assuming most of those receive some sort

1:00:38 of subsidy.

1:00:39 Do you think that's, you know, what kind of percentage that is?

1:00:45 Yeah, so it is typical for these facilities to receive an operating subsidy.

1:00:51 The percentage is going to vary on a case-by-case basis, and I can pull up our report real quick

1:00:58 just to see if I can get you a quick answer on that.

1:01:01 But I can also follow up with you offline counselor to get you more information there.

1:01:09 And maybe John, while you're looking at that.

1:01:12 Yeah, so a good example might be the Dixie Convention Center in St. George, Utah.

1:01:22 That operated at a loss of about $300,000 in 2023.

1:01:29 So, you know, as a percentage of their revenue, that's just under 20% of their revenue was

1:01:38 of that, that operating loss.

1:01:46 So when the committee met and visited with the consultants, I think the short answer is if

1:01:57 the industry standard is these operate at a quarter of a million dollar a year loss at

1:02:02 stabilization, some subsidy is required.

1:02:07 And the discussion was those can come from a variety of places.

1:02:10 They can either be a public subsidy of, say, property tax

1:02:15 dollars, which wouldn't be a good strategy for Twin Falls.

1:02:19 It could be an auditorium district, which

1:02:20 is a bed tax that would be charged on hotel rooms

1:02:24 and could offset an auditorium district, which could operate it.

1:02:29 Or potentially, that public-private partnership,

1:02:33 where you have a private hotel, for example,

1:02:37 who may be willing to eat the loss on the event center

1:02:41 if they're able to offset that with hotel revenues

1:02:45 or a full development.

1:02:46 So that was kind of the general discussion

1:02:48 is that the likelihood of a facility like this

1:02:53 operating with a positive bottom line

1:02:58 is not really typical.

1:03:00 And so looking for those different options.

1:03:02 Yeah, I guess I was just more interested.

1:03:03 Yeah, I guess I was just more interested in the percentage

1:03:05 of it.

1:03:05 Oh, I'm sorry, go ahead.

1:03:07 Yeah, I just want to, I mean, I would love this asset Twin Falls.

1:03:13 I mean, ideally you would have some sort of public-private partnership

1:03:17 where there's an entity that operates, like a hotel that can offset.

1:03:21 I noticed that Canada would go on, has a little hockey venue next to it.

1:03:24 I don't know if it falls.

1:03:25 They have that basketball arena hockey place, right?

1:03:28 Some of those types of facilities, I don't know that that's an option right now in Twin Falls.

1:03:32 But I was just wondering what percentage of their loss was subsidized.

1:03:37 That's kind of what I was at.

1:03:40 Yeah, and in the case of the Kennewick facility,

1:03:43 the three-year resconvention center,

1:03:45 they actually opposed to the net operating profit in 2024,

1:03:50 but it was a minor one.

1:03:52 It was about $68,000.

1:03:54 So around 5% of their revenue in terms of a profit margin.

1:04:00 And a couple of reasons why we wouldn't project for that.

1:04:05 One is, that's one of the more successful examples

1:04:09 of these facilities from an operations standpoint.

1:04:12 And so, we like to be more conservative

1:04:16 with our projections.

1:04:17 We see operating losses being more typical,

1:04:19 so that's where we would land it.

1:04:21 However, I'll note, there are some revenue categories

1:04:25 that aren't accounted for in this pro forma.

1:04:27 One is parking and parking revenue

1:04:30 can often represent a pretty significant source

1:04:33 of revenue for a facility is charging 10 bucks a car,

1:04:37 or 15 bucks a car for your event.

1:04:39 That does add up pretty quickly and can help offset

1:04:42 some of those losses.

1:04:44 Naming rights sponsorships can also

1:04:47 be a significant source of revenue.

1:04:50 But again, those things are strategic decisions.

1:04:55 And we want to be kind of conservative

1:04:58 with our model as of now.

1:05:00 I do think that one really key point is even for facilities that do post positive net operating

1:05:06 income and don't require annual subsidy in that regard, they very rarely cover their own

1:05:12 debt service.

1:05:13 So, you know, when you're thinking about sort of the funding picture, full funding picture

1:05:18 around something like this, you know, debt service is the other piece of this and what

1:05:22 is the source of funding to make sure that that's offset in some way or another?

1:05:29 Ruth Pierce?

1:05:34 Well, what I'm seeing in your projections kind of in answer to Nathan's question is the first year it was about a 10%

1:05:41 operating loss and a 10% of revenue and in year five when it was stable

1:05:47 It's more like 5% and again that doesn't include deck coverage which

1:05:55 is where you think about an auditorium tax or naming rights or something to help that

1:06:01 Yes. Absolutely. And that actually, I know we'll probably get into this a little bit in terms

1:06:13 of next steps, but we do see auditorium districts as one of the strongest tools within Idaho

1:06:22 to finance and maintain funding for these types of projects. So, you know, if the community

1:06:31 work to pursue this type of project I think that would have to be a really strong consideration.

1:06:36 Any other council member?

1:06:44 So just to hit at a very high level sort of next step so again you have the full report

1:06:49 you'll see in those recommendations this is going to take partnership with first and foremost

1:06:57 the community and then I think a lot of community organizations.

1:07:01 So we've had some good engagement from a number of those through the events center committee,

1:07:07 including the college, the chamber, and others.

1:07:12 So what I would like to recommend as some next steps and get your head nod today is to convene

1:07:18 some of those partners, broadly share this report to help people really understand the

1:07:25 data behind what the demand may be out there as opposed to everybody's guess from the one

1:07:31 event they didn't get to go to last year and therefore we need XYZ.

1:07:35 Bring those people together.

1:07:37 Start to do a little bit of discussion as well about what it would take to create an

1:07:41 auditorium district because it is a relatively heavy lift, finding the best way to create

1:07:48 those partnerships so that this particular item doesn't continue to sit on the city's plate,

1:07:55 that we can be a convener and help advance it.

1:07:57 So that's sort of the direction I'd like to go

1:08:02 with your blessing and then certainly bring back

1:08:05 further information to you.

1:08:07 And if you have any other specific questions,

1:08:08 by all means, reach out.

1:08:11 Everybody comfortable with that?

1:08:13 It seems logical, thank you, Sean.

1:08:16 And thank you, John, for being on the call.

1:08:20 Yeah, absolutely.

1:08:21 I want to thank everybody in the council

1:08:23 their time and thoughtfulness today. If any of you have any questions that pop into your

1:08:31 head following this, I think you can get my email address from Sean and feel free to pass

1:08:36 those along to me and I'll be happy to answer for over email or we can set up a call to talk

1:08:42 more about it.

1:08:43 Thank you very much. Appreciate your time and efforts on this and everybody else's.

1:08:49 So really appreciate it

1:08:51 Okay, that brings us to our next item in that's a presentation on the finances of the City of Twin Falls in the first quarter of the fiscal year

1:09:03 Bring on an hour

1:09:04 Hey, good evening mayor and council

1:09:43 so tonight I'm going to talk about the

1:09:46 The fiscal state of where the City of Twin Falls is I'll start out with a national context and see how that relates to the City of Twin Falls

1:09:53 as many of you are aware and you watch the news reports, it's extremely volatile.

1:09:58 In fact, I had this presentation prepared about two weeks ago, and in a two-week time frame,

1:10:03 we have declared war. On Iran, we have had the Supreme Court downplay tariffs,

1:10:09 we've had economic issues across the nation. And so I had to go in and update my report

1:10:14 and numbers because there's a lot of volatility. One thing I do want to leave ultimately with the council

1:10:20 is that we don't see that here. We have strong reserves, we have great fiscal policy, we have

1:10:26 conservative budgeting, and so just like our auditor presented earlier, we don't seem to

1:10:31 see the fluctuations at the national level does. So when starting off, we're talking about the

1:10:39 national economy. It's still expanding, but momentum is fading, and this matters because

1:10:44 Idaho's revenue performance typically lags the slowdowns between six and 12 months. Over

1:10:49 history we have seen that we don't follow suit quickly.

1:10:53 Peril growth in 2025 averaged just 49,000 per month.

1:10:57 This is the weakest pace outside of COVID since 2009.

1:11:02 Leading indicators have been declining since 2022, and manufacturing has contracted in

1:11:06 36 of the last 38 months.

1:11:10 Housing is losing momentum and asset markets are stretched.

1:11:14 Over the past few weeks, the geopolitical tensions in the Middle East and has higher

1:11:18 oil prices and have increased short-term uncertainty.

1:11:22 These add volatility but do not materially change the overall trend we're seeing, a slowing

1:11:27 economy rather than a contracting one.

1:11:29 In Piper Sandler, that's a report I follow consistently, they do a lot of governments

1:11:34 across the nation, the Financial Strength Index fell over the third consecutive quarter in 2025,

1:11:40 weakening economic conditions across many states.

1:11:43 Yet, Idaho ranked third nationally and financial strength indicators, reflecting strong personal

1:11:50 income growth and coincident economic activity.

1:11:55 Consumer spending remains resilient.

1:11:57 I'm sure we all watch these reports.

1:11:59 We are all still spending.

1:12:01 People are still spending.

1:12:02 Largely because of elevated home and stock prices.

1:12:06 Research shows if wealth growth flattens, spending could slow towards 3%, which would bring real

1:12:11 growth close to zero.

1:12:13 This is a fragile strength, not structural momentum.

1:12:17 One area we are watching closely is the energy prices with oil.

1:12:21 If oil prices remain elevated for a long period of time, that acts as a direct tax on households

1:12:27 and they will spend less.

1:12:29 For Twin Falls, continued consumer spending supports state revenue sharing and local retail

1:12:34 activity but is increasingly dependent on asset prices.

1:12:40 Consumer confidence.

1:12:41 Consumer confidence expectations are in territory historically associated with recessions.

1:12:46 Recent volatility in the energy prices have contributed to declining consumer expectations

1:12:51 consistently over and over again the Michigan of consumer is continued to decline.

1:12:58 People, but there's a still it is connect.

1:13:00 People are still spending.

1:13:01 But they feel worse about the economy.

1:13:03 If asset valuations flatten or employment weakens further, sentiment can quickly translate into

1:13:08 to reduce discretionary purposes,

1:13:10 especially large ticket items like the ones that we track

1:13:12 with housing permits, homes, vehicles, and renovations.

1:13:16 For city implications, permits, impact fees,

1:13:19 and discretionary spending are the first to soften.

1:13:24 Labor market, I'm not saying anything

1:13:26 that anybody hasn't seen.

1:13:27 I mean, these are all just,

1:13:28 they're all normal statistics that we're seeing,

1:13:30 but trying to tie it into how we see it here

1:13:33 and the things, the levers that we're looking at.

1:13:35 The labor market, December payroll growth

1:13:37 was just 50,000.

1:13:39 Three month averages are flirting with the contraction.

1:13:42 Wage growth has cooled over the last five years

1:13:44 that I've been here.

1:13:45 We've had significant pay increases

1:13:46 to try to keep up with the national economy.

1:13:50 But wage growth is flattening.

1:13:52 It's cooling to 3.6% to 3.8% year over year news cycle.

1:13:57 Large employers are emphasizing efficiency and automation

1:14:00 over workforce expansion.

1:14:02 Layoffs are concentrated in tech,

1:14:04 financial knowledge sectors.

1:14:08 wind falls, this is lower turnover risk, easier recruitment, but it signals the slowing economic

1:14:16 momentum nationally.

1:14:18 Corporate layoffs, there's been a lot in the news lately.

1:14:21 Productivity rose 4.9% in Quarter 3 and 2025, while hours worked, only rose 0.5%, so we can

1:14:30 derive where that's coming from.

1:14:32 The growth is being achieved with fewer workers, that signals, companies are protecting margins

1:14:37 and a high rate environment. Automation and AI tools allow companies to grow output without

1:14:43 expanding their head count. For the city, this reduces wage escalation pressure long term,

1:14:49 but signals cautious business expansion from taxpayers nationwide. BPI, trending towards

1:14:57 3 percent. MCI, which is what we look at more closely because this strips out things like

1:15:02 food and shelter costs, is 2.25 percent. This is what the city spends money on. Shelter,

1:15:09 which makes up 40% of CPI,

1:15:11 is on a lagged cooling trajectory.

1:15:14 Wage pressures are easing.

1:15:17 Markets are not pricing a resurgence of inflation.

1:15:20 Inflation swaps remain anchored around 2.5%.

1:15:24 Energy prices remain the largest near-term risk

1:15:27 to inflation due to geopolitical developments.

1:15:31 For the city impact, construction inflation should moderate,

1:15:34 contract escalators may ease,

1:15:38 and feel when utilities remain volatile and are accelerating.

1:15:43 Tariffs, policy and certainty.

1:15:46 We don't know where tariffs are going.

1:15:47 We know that the Supreme Court struck down the tariffs,

1:15:50 but we also know that there's a potential 15% flat tariff.

1:15:53 Research shows that historical tariff shocks

1:15:56 tend to reduce growth and lower inflation, not accelerate it.

1:16:00 Tariffs historically reduce demand

1:16:02 rather than drive inflation,

1:16:03 which means that they compress the purchasing power

1:16:06 that people can buy rather than broadly inflating the basket.

1:16:09 people choose to get something different over something that they previously purchased if

1:16:13 the price increases. Trade policy uncertainty continues to rise. For city, our implications

1:16:20 are capital goods pricing may see volatility, but we are not seeing systemic inflation

1:16:25 research. Housing. New home prices are beginning to roll over. Builders can adjust faster than

1:16:33 existing sellers through incentives, price cuts, and inventory management. Housing affordability

1:16:38 nationally as tight and Idaho remains one of the least affordable states relative to income

1:16:43 time after time. If labor softens further, housing adjustment accelerates. I thought this chart was

1:16:53 it didn't go. Chief, I just charted in there. I apologize. I had a chart of what people are moving

1:17:00 in twin falls and it's not showing up in here. So it didn't make the cut. City implications,

1:17:05 Lower permit for revenue growth, potential moderation, and construction cost inflation,

1:17:11 and less upward pressure on land values.

1:17:16 Asset markets' wealth effect is at risk.

1:17:18 The cyclically adjusted PE ratio is nearly levels only exceeded since the 1900s.

1:17:25 Expansion and consumer spending has been supported heavily by asset appreciation.

1:17:28 I thought this was interesting.

1:17:29 There's a lot of articles about how people feel like they're more wealthy because their

1:17:33 stocks are more wealthy, their homes are more expensive, and so that they're spending

1:17:37 more because they feel that. Once you start to see that shift and change, people

1:17:41 start spending less. Margin debt has surpassed 1.1 trillion. If equity growth

1:17:47 flattens, consumer spending likely slows as well. This is the single largest macro

1:17:52 risk entering fiscal year 26. Corporate bankruptcies are rising. S&P Global

1:18:00 reports 785 large US corporate bankruptcies in 2025, which is the highest since

1:18:05 2010. Rising bankruptcies are largely occurring in highly leveraged industries that are struggling

1:18:10 to refinance debt in a higher interest rate environment. This reinforces that the economy

1:18:16 is not breaking but stresses accumulating. Highlights the value of our strong financial

1:18:22 position in the audit. We have strong reserves. We are fiscally conservative. We don't have

1:18:27 a lot of debt and we continue to budget without a deficit.

1:18:30 Well, in the National Outlook, what this means, we're not entering fiscal year 26 in a crisis.

1:18:38 entering in late cycle deceleration. It's also worth noting that Idaho's economy remains

1:18:43 among the strongest nationally. Recent state economic reports ranked Idaho among the top

1:18:48 performing states due to strong personal income growth and economic activity.

1:18:53 When falls remain comparatively insulated because we have a balanced revenue mix, we

1:18:57 have strong reserves, we have low turnover, and we have conservative capital planning.

1:19:02 I can't emphasize that enough. We are very conservative in how we spend we outlay our

1:19:06 capital. But we should assume that growth is going to slow, volatility is going to rise,

1:19:12 and forecasting requires more discipline. So that's the national environment. That's where we're

1:19:24 sitting today, which is volatile, which is risky, which is scary, but it's not what we are saying

1:19:29 today. Right now I'm going to dive into our total budget. So we have tax-supported funds,

1:19:36 we have a total budget that includes tax-supported and enterprise funds. As you can see in this

1:19:40 charged about 40% of our budget of $10.3 million in revenue is non-tax-supported fun, which

1:19:46 is our enterprise funds like our water or wastewater in our sanitation, and 60% 60.5 million is from

1:19:53 tax-supported funds. Diving into the tax-supported funds to show what makes up our numbers, property

1:20:00 taxes make up over half of what we receive annually. So we are estimating budgeting about

1:20:05 $33 million. The next couple of bars you can see other big items that included are in our

1:20:10 property to earn our tax-supported funds. State shared revenues, this is like liquor licenses

1:20:15 and sales tax. We don't get near the sales tax that we send out. No matter what we do,

1:20:26 we don't get sales tax that come back in at a large percentage. Dedicated street fund

1:20:32 is $4.9 million. We have transfers from other funds. That's like our enterprise funds paying

1:20:37 for your work, for council, for finance, for city manager, anything HR, those things that

1:20:44 come in, that's 4.3 million, or franchise fees on a smaller basis is 2.4 million, we have some

1:20:50 grants of 1.1 million.

1:20:53 All other things that are smaller in nature in that other category, which includes building

1:20:57 permits of 1.4 million, airport 1.4 million, investment income of 1.2 million, we're starting

1:21:03 to see that decrease with rates go down as well.

1:21:06 and the 640,000 of fire district funds.

1:21:11 This gets spread out over the tax-supported funds

1:21:14 as shown in this chart.

1:21:15 About 67% goes to tax-supported funds,

1:21:18 which is, or to the general fund,

1:21:19 which is mainly your larger things like police, fire,

1:21:22 as parks and recs, and anything else that's smaller.

1:21:28 Property tax history, for the last four years,

1:21:31 we've gone from 27 million to 33 million that we see today.

1:21:35 This is mainly from a 3% allotted growth

1:21:38 that you as council can choose to take,

1:21:40 as well as any new construction that we have.

1:21:43 In the last five years, this has increased more,

1:21:46 even six years, because of the new construction

1:21:48 that we have seen.

1:21:49 We're starting to see things level off,

1:21:51 and we're getting a little over a million dollars more each year

1:21:54 to accommodate all of the extra that we provide to the city.

1:21:59 Other parts of our funds are our highway money,

1:22:01 700,000 is what we received of the 4.9 million.

1:22:05 It's not pro-retta, we don't get that quarterly,

1:22:07 we get it as people drive.

1:22:09 Revenue sharing, we've received 1.8 million

1:22:11 of the six million we're anticipating.

1:22:13 In the franchise fees, we've received 600,000 of 2.4.

1:22:19 What's made up of franchise fees

1:22:20 are mainly gas, electric, and cable.

1:22:22 We haven't received anything for gas to this point,

1:22:26 but we have received it for electric and cable.

1:22:28 Mainly consistently, we get 3% of gross fees.

1:22:32 What's interesting when you pull the last five years

1:22:35 since COVID, revenue from our Idaho Power franchise fees

1:22:39 has increased 29% in the last five years,

1:22:42 and Intermountain Gas has increased 32%

1:22:44 in the last five years,

1:22:47 but we're paying more as well.

1:22:49 So when they are getting more gross revenues,

1:22:51 we're actually increasing their fees.

1:22:55 Building permit revenue, permits are an indicator

1:22:59 of economic activity and we continue to track them closely.

1:23:02 We are seeing, we are not seeing the number of permits

1:23:04 increase, but we are seeing the value of homes increase.

1:23:07 Single family homes received 18% less,

1:23:10 Yet the value of homes increased 3%.

1:23:14 This is the historical chart that shows

1:23:16 for the last 20 years ish,

1:23:19 and you can see the major drop in the real estate

1:23:21 housing market crash and then the COVID cliff later on.

1:23:30 On the expenditure side, more than half of what we pay

1:23:33 in expenses is for personnel.

1:23:35 It takes people to do what we do.

1:23:37 We've spent almost 25%, so 24.8% of our budget

1:23:41 to 37.9 million in salaries and insurance expenses.

1:23:46 M&O is about a quarter as well,

1:23:48 we're at 2.6 of the 10.7.

1:23:52 Capital improvements of 10.4 million include a handful of things.

1:23:56 We've got four patrol vehicles of 340,000.

1:23:59 We have the 400,000 designed for the evidence storage

1:24:03 and training center, a million dollars

1:24:05 for fire station two lease payment

1:24:07 and fire apparatus lease payments,

1:24:09 600,000 for a water tender, 736,000 for the Harman's skate park infrastructure, which includes the West

1:24:17 Kannas and Piccawaw Courts, and then we have 2.6 million seal coating mill in inlay.

1:24:25 600,000 in road reconstruction, 380,000 in a sweet sweeper, straight sweeper, and 250,000 in the late

1:24:33 library ADA compliance. Transfers are a little more than a quarter. We don't quite get at these

1:24:41 on a pro-rata basis because it depends on some funds like

1:24:43 Durkies and she's shown falls as people are traveling

1:24:46 how much we get.

1:24:49 So jumping into the enterprise funds.

1:24:52 Enterprise funds are like a business without a profit motive.

1:24:55 Water, wastewater and sanitation are our biggest enterprise funds.

1:24:59 We receive user fees in both funds,

1:25:01 and both of these have between $10 and $11.5 million

1:25:04 of revenue, of which we've received currently

1:25:07 2.5 of 11.4 and 2.9 of 11.1.

1:25:13 on the expenditure side for the enterprise funds.

1:25:15 Personnel is the highest cost in water,

1:25:19 but not wastewater.

1:25:20 In water fund, we have a lot of personnel

1:25:22 in the wastewater fund we contract out most of our services.

1:25:26 MNO is significantly less because we spend a lot more

1:25:29 in the summer months as we have power to pump water.

1:25:32 Water capital budgeted, we have so of that 5.7 million,

1:25:37 a couple of large things are 300,000 in sign pump station,

1:25:41 $4.1 million is the main line meter replacement and a $338,000 jet truck.

1:25:49 Wastewater on the capital expenditures, the $5.9 million that we have budgeted, $4 million

1:25:54 is the Canyon Rim Drop line and $700,000 is dewatering an aeration system.

1:25:59 We have no debt in the water fund.

1:26:01 We do have debt in the wastewater fund, but we only make principal payments annually in

1:26:05 September.

1:26:06 We just pay interest until then.

1:26:09 The sanitation is even more consistent at $4 million each year, and we contract out most

1:26:14 of those expenses with PSI.

1:26:18 Our current contract ends with PSI in December of 2026, and then up until that point, we will

1:26:23 have some more negotiations and conversations with you guys and to how we want that to look

1:26:28 going forward.

1:26:31 So, Idaho's, so the risks that we are seeing, economic growth nationally is slowing as expansion

1:26:39 measures, housing affordability and higher interest rates are reducing housing momentum.

1:26:45 Energy prices volatility and geopolitical events could pressure consumer spending.

1:26:49 Healthcare remains a concern for us.

1:26:51 We are constantly watching our healthcare and how we manage it.

1:26:55 But we have stability in the city of Twin Falls.

1:26:58 Inflation continues trending downward towards normal levels.

1:27:01 Labor market conditions remain stable despite the slower hiring.

1:27:06 spending remains positive, supporting tax revenues and Idaho's economy continues to

1:27:10 remain ranked among the strongest in the nation. In summary, when Falls enters

1:27:15 fiscal year 26 from a position of financial strength, even as the national

1:27:19 economy slows and as indicated by our audit, we have strong reserves, conservative

1:27:24 fiscal management, and stable utility funds. That's all I have if you have any

1:27:29 questions. Any questions? I'd just like to mention thank you Rihanna for your

1:27:36 insight and information that's pretty interesting and kind of a wake-up call to so thank you.

1:27:43 The other council members. Okay. Seeing none. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. That brings

1:27:55 us to our point of the meeting of general public input. Again, this is an opportunity

1:28:00 for the general public to come down and address the city council on city related items. We

1:28:06 that you provide your name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls and you have two

1:28:11 minutes. Okay. Seeing none, nobody's moving. We'll move on to our advisory board

1:28:19 reports and announcements.

1:28:22 Jerry? Just an announcement that today is Vice Mayor Craig Hawkins's birthday.

1:28:34 Oh, so a happy birthday, Craig. Happy birthday. You are welcome.

1:28:38 No, no singing. No, we won't see. We won't we'll spare the general general public on that matter. Any other council members on advisory board?

1:28:51 City City Manager's office. The only announcement we have is that there won't be a meeting next week, but we will be resuming our regular meeting schedule on March 30th meeting at 5 o'clock p.m.

1:29:05 Thank you very much.

1:29:08 Our next item is an executive session.

1:29:11 Joining to executive session pursuant to

1:29:15 Idaho code 74261C to acquire an interest in real property not

1:29:20 owned by a public agency.

1:29:23 So moved.

1:29:24 Second.

1:29:25 First and second.

1:29:27 Any discussion?

1:29:30 Rachel.

1:29:31 We'll call vote.

1:29:33 Ruth.

1:29:34 Yes.

1:29:35 Yes.

1:29:36 Chris Reed.

1:29:37 Yes.

1:29:38 Ray Cawkins.

1:29:39 Yes.

1:29:40 Jason Brown.

1:29:41 Yes.

1:29:42 Sherri Bomer.

1:29:43 Yes.

1:29:44 And Nathan Murray.

1:29:45 Yes.

1:29:46 Okay.

1:29:47 Motion carries six to zero.

1:29:48 That means our meeting is adjourned.

1:29:49 We will not be coming back into this meeting after our executive session.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 16, 2026. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:29:54.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    017963f3ce5eacaf8dc890f495664c4f1cc4e316a5274138893464066dad5ac5
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a b21d1f13639a199145ea86074d79e171f5029170647b553f3b8aca791682c160
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    581a8595fb08a722c4f940a842eca601e8e575e7f9b47e7ce86897613fef386e

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file