OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, March 9, 2026

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:17 Okay, we'll go ahead and call the City Council meeting for March 9th, 2026th order.

0:00:26 I will confirm we have five members in chambers.

0:00:30 Councilwoman Volmer is excused and Council, Councilman Grace and Stone is on the phone.

0:00:37 Tonight will be through our Pledge of Allegiance, but we'll have our Girl Scouts do that for

0:00:42 us.

0:00:43 Lead us all in the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:00:44 So if you want to follow along, please stand.

0:01:08 This is one of the exciting weeks we get to look forward to every year.

0:01:11 We get to read a proclamation for Girl Scout week and I'll go ahead and read that.

0:01:17 It says, whereas March 12th marks the 114th anniversary of Girl Scouts of the USA founded

0:01:26 by Juliet Gordon Lowe in 1912 in Savannah, Georgia, and whereas throughout its long and

0:01:33 distinguished history, Girl Scouting has inspired millions of girls and women with the highest

0:01:39 ideals of character, conduct, and patriotism, including the 5,800 current members of Girl

0:01:46 Scouts of Silver Sage. And whereas Girl Scouts of Silver Sage provide a space for Girl Scouts

0:01:53 to dream big, be themselves, and find adventure. They have made a difference in our community

0:02:00 and many for many years, and whereas every girl deserves the opportunity to thrive, and

0:02:07 through its programming, Girl Scouts of Silver Sage works to ensure girls in our communities

0:02:12 know they can do anything they put their minds to doing, and encourage them to feel empowered

0:02:20 and embrace their unique strengths.

0:02:22 And whereas more than 2.6 million current Girl Scout members nationwide will be celebrating

0:02:30 the 114th year of this American tradition and nearly 50 million women are former Girl Scouts

0:02:38 and living proof of the impact of this amazing movement.

0:02:42 Therefore, I, Jason Brown, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby applaud the commitment

0:02:48 Girl Scouting has made to America's girls proudly proclaim the week of Sunday, March 8th as Girl

0:02:56 Scout week.

0:02:59 this. Mayor Brown and council members we just like to thank you for again

0:04:09 recognizing these girls and over 80 adult leaders that we have in the Magic

0:04:16 Valley in Girl Scouting so it is cookie season so we have brought you all some

0:04:22 cookies and the girls now will say their name and what level you are that

0:04:27 you're a brownie and what troop okay you want to start Haley. My name is Haley the

0:04:36 The troop number is nine nine nine nine eight eight seven nine eight eight eight eight.

0:04:48 I'm in troop four eighteen and I'm a junior. My name is Lennox and my troop is nine eight.

0:04:58 My name is oh my name is Katherine. I turn it on. You may have to hit that button that

0:05:04 says push right yep. My name is Katherine. I'm fighting. I'm fighting and my my level

0:05:15 My name is Claudia and I, my troop is 988 and I'm a brownie.

0:05:27 My name is Paisley, my troop is 988 and I'm also a brownie.

0:05:32 My name is Paisley and I'm from troop 418 and I am a cadet.

0:05:38 My name is Katalaya and I'm in troop 478 and I'm a cadet.

0:05:43 My name is Emmeline, I am troop 470 and I'm a cadet.

0:05:48 My name is Piper, I'm troop 418 and I'm a senior.

0:05:53 My name is Riley and I'm troop 1086 and I'm a junior

0:06:00 My name is Breck and I'm to trip 1086 and I'm a brownie

0:06:05 My name is I'm full one eight

0:06:10 Perfect. Thank you very much

0:06:12 So mayor Brown, I guess I'm the only one up here that can say I was a Girl Scout, too

0:06:24 Not 114 years ago, but definitely a Girl Scout 113 right?

0:06:31 Well, thank you for leading us in our Pledge of Allegiance tonight, and thank you for the

0:06:35 treat.

0:06:36 We have cookies coming from behind us.

0:06:39 Thank you very much.

0:06:40 Appreciate it.

0:06:44 Okay.

0:06:45 Thank you.

0:06:46 I have another blue one.

0:06:55 We'll give just a minute before we read our next proclamation.

0:07:24 Thank you again.

0:07:26 Appreciate it.

0:07:27 Okay, our next proclamation is the 54th anniversary of the National Senior Nutrition

0:07:39 program, so I'll go ahead and read that proclamation. It says, whereas since 1972, the National Senior

0:07:46 Nutrition Program has funded local agencies and organizations to serve home delivered and

0:07:55 meals to help ensure older adults have opportunities to stay healthy and stay independent and stay

0:08:01 connected. And whereas more than 13 million older Americans face hunger or malnutrition, malnutrition

0:08:10 each year and whereas local senior nutrition programs help older adults access nutritious

0:08:16 meals, national screening, nutrition screening, sorry, education and counseling, social opportunities

0:08:24 and various activities amid the company of their peers and neighbors.

0:08:29 Whereas the Idaho senior nutrition program is an integral part of the city of Twin Falls

0:08:35 community providing sustenance and so much more to our older community members, especially

0:08:41 those most vulnerable to food insecurity, social isolation and chronic health conditions.

0:08:47 And whereas Fiscal Year 2025, the Idaho Senior Nutrition Program had a positive impact on

0:08:54 the senior community of the City of Twin Falls by serving 5,621 congregate meals to participants

0:09:04 and delivering 26,960 home delivered meals to two participants.

0:09:11 Therefore, I, Jason Brown, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim March 2026

0:09:18 to be the 54th anniversary of the National Senior Nutrition Program.

0:09:23 Who's going to receive?

0:09:25 Perfect.

0:09:26 Pull up the mic.

0:10:01 We at the office on aging would like to thank the Twin Falls City Council

0:10:06 for doing this proclamation.

0:10:09 It's very important to our senior community

0:10:12 that we provide nutritious meals at the senior centers.

0:10:17 Both congregate at the senior center

0:10:20 and home delivered meals.

0:10:22 One in six seniors suffers from malnutrition,

0:10:27 so this is a very important thing to us

0:10:29 and we appreciate you doing this.

0:10:32 Thank you.

0:10:32 Thank you, appreciate it.

0:10:38 Thank you for providing the service to the community.

0:10:40 Thank you very much.

0:10:43 So our next item on our agenda tonight

0:10:45 is our consent calendar.

0:10:46 What are the council's wishes?

0:10:49 Move to approve the consent calendar is published.

0:10:51 Okay, go ahead.

0:10:52 I'll second that.

0:10:53 Okay, I have a motion to approve the consent calendar

0:10:56 as published in a second.

0:10:58 Any further conversation?

0:11:01 Okay, Rachel roll call vote.

0:11:02 Ruth, Paris?

0:11:04 Yes.

0:11:05 Chris Reed.

0:11:05 Yes.

0:11:06 Ray Hawkins, Jason Brown.

0:11:07 Yes.

0:11:08 Nathan Murray.

0:11:09 and Grayson Stone.

0:11:11 Yes.

0:11:12 Hey, motion passes six to zero.

0:11:15 So items on there would be the CSI chair leader,

0:11:20 national send-off.

0:11:21 So thanks for coming tonight.

0:11:22 So that's as quick as it was.

0:11:24 So thank you for showing up.

0:11:26 And then anybody else that was on the consent calendar tonight,

0:11:30 everything has been approved.

0:11:32 Thank you.

0:11:37 The next item, the next item on our agenda

0:11:40 items of consideration and the first one is the request for the City Council to

0:11:46 adopt the Rock Creek Watershed Master Plan and we have Mandy Thompson. Good

0:11:56 evening Mayor and Council. I'm gonna get this pulled up here. Okay so kind of

0:12:06 exciting to be here tonight. This is a culmination of what feels like many many

0:12:10 years of hard work. So a little history for those in the audience that aren't

0:12:15 familiar. Back in 2023, the City of Twin Falls was awarded a $4 million congressional direct

0:12:21 appropriation through Congressman Mike Simpson's office. And then a year later, we were awarded

0:12:26 an additional $1 million. These funds were specifically designated for the improvement of water quality

0:12:33 within the Rock Creek watershed. With the ultimate goal being that we could enhance the

0:12:40 quality of the water in the Snake River that are the segments of the Snake River that are

0:12:45 affected by the city's wastewater treatment permit.

0:12:48 So once we went through the motions and kind of figured how to access those funds, we knew

0:12:56 that we had to start with a little planning.

0:12:59 So the first effort was the development of a comprehensive master plan.

0:13:04 We did that by hiring Jacobs Engineering and spent the last two, almost two full years,

0:13:10 going through the process of focusing on the three key areas of the watershed, which would

0:13:15 be agriculture, the agricultural practices that impact the water, riparian restoration,

0:13:21 and urban stormwater management.

0:13:23 So as I said, we retained Jacobs and went through this two-year process that included an incredibly

0:13:29 in-depth assessment of the watershed.

0:13:33 We compiled the history historical data from multiple sources throughout the state and the

0:13:38 Magic Valley, along with two years of our own new field data as far as water quality, and

0:13:45 then went through a fairly robust public engagement process as well as reaching out and meeting

0:13:52 on a very regular basis with the stakeholders that would be impacted by the project.

0:13:57 So the plan that we are considering tonight is hundreds of pages, so I did not include

0:14:04 it in your packet, but it will be made available tomorrow morning on the website, and you will

0:14:10 all have a link in your e-mails for your reading pleasure.

0:14:17 And so we have with us tonight Erin Cox, she is an engineer with Jacobs Engineering, and

0:14:23 going to go through a process of explaining to you a little bit about the methodology

0:14:29 surrounding how we identified potential projects to be included in the master plan, how we prioritized

0:14:36 and ultimately chose the projects that are in the master plan, and then steps moving forward

0:14:41 to implement those projects, kind of how we will pick and choose where we start, and some

0:14:48 ideas on how we'll pay for it.

0:14:50 So Erin, if you would like to come up.

0:14:52 Thank you, Mandy. Well, I feel like I've gotten to have some regular check-ins with you all to keep you apprised of our progress

0:15:00 It has been a phenomenal project

0:15:03 And I think that we've come up with a plan that is very actionable and has some really fantastic projects

0:15:11 So a quick overview of my talk this evening

0:15:15 You guys have heard like I said a lot about our process

0:15:18 But I'm just gonna give you a quick overview again of how we developed this master plan the project types

0:15:23 the recommended projects and how we prioritize them,

0:15:26 because that's a really important part of this.

0:15:28 And then what you've all been waiting for is the recommendations,

0:15:31 the initiatives, policies, and programs.

0:15:33 And then what all we're going to be delivering.

0:15:37 So if you recall, we had this process where, like Mandy mentioned,

0:15:41 we looked at all the projects that we could accomplish

0:15:44 to improve water quality in Wat Creek.

0:15:46 And we identified that there are some areas of the city

0:15:50 that can contribute to urban stormwater pollution.

0:15:53 So, we've got the urban stormwater types of projects, which, incidentally, will help you

0:15:58 with your MS4 permit compliance in the next few years as that comes into play.

0:16:03 You've got riparian projects, so that's the river corridor, and then agricultural projects.

0:16:08 And so, this is the process that we took.

0:16:10 But today, I'm going to tell you, we've talked about those other parts of the process.

0:16:14 I'm going to dive in a little bit more about how we prioritize those projects and then the

0:16:19 resulting projects.

0:16:20 So, the storm water projects can be things like bioswales, bioretension, and then there

0:16:27 are some proprietary types of systems that you can put under parking lots.

0:16:31 The whole point of it is if you think about like a large wall mart parking lot with a lot

0:16:35 of oil and sediment and all the things we put on surfaces, salt, road salt, and then when

0:16:40 there's a runoff event, a storm event or a snow melt, it all washes into the drain.

0:16:45 And generally speaking, that will go right into a river.

0:16:49 What these types of projects do is they take the most urbanized areas and they create a

0:16:54 bio system that can really improve water quality.

0:16:58 So some of the sediment filters out, some of those pollutants subtle to the bottom, and

0:17:02 what you then put into the river is much cleaner.

0:17:05 We've got riparian stabilization.

0:17:07 The picture on the left there is on the Boise River where they had a severely eroded river

0:17:12 bank that we were able to stabilize.

0:17:14 So when there is erosion, that is sediment with a lot of times phosphorus attached to it that

0:17:19 goes into the waterway.

0:17:20 We're trying to prevent that.

0:17:22 So really the idea is then to make a more robust river corridor.

0:17:27 And then finally, we looked at places where we could put projects in the agricultural parts.

0:17:31 Because if you recall from our water quality sampling, we identified the parts of the watershed

0:17:36 that were contributing disproportionately to some of the impairment.

0:17:41 So total suspended solids, total phosphorus, flow alteration, those types of things.

0:17:48 And what I'm showing you there on the right is actually a constructed wetland that we're

0:17:52 designing for the city of NAPPA right now that has tremendous ability to improve water

0:17:57 quality.

0:17:58 So you could take the most polluted spring runoff or ag return flows, put them through

0:18:03 this really robust natural treatment system.

0:18:06 It is different than the average wetland because it has these really impactful polishing cells.

0:18:11 proven treatment media to remove some of that phosphorus before the water goes

0:18:15 back into the waterways. So we developed a project list. We looked after all this

0:18:20 water quality sampling that Mandy mentioned, years of data, sampling, and

0:18:24 evaluation. We looked at all the USGS data, IDEQ data. We had a really good idea of

0:18:30 where projects would be really impactful. So we developed this massive project list

0:18:34 and you have that list now. But you can't do them all, right? So we had to

0:18:39 evaluate them using criteria. We started with some basic criteria then we

0:18:43 worked shopped with the city to really hone in on the criteria that meant the

0:18:47 most to Twin Falls. Number one criteria obviously water quality

0:18:53 improvement. We also wanted the projects to be able to help with future permit

0:18:57 compliance for the wastewater facility because that can be really helpful in the

0:19:01 future with cost. We wanted to make sure these projects would be really

0:19:05 successful. They would all be successful but some of them might have more

0:19:08 challenges with easements or acquisition or you know just there are challenges that

0:19:12 can come into play. And then the thing that we really wanted is for these projects

0:19:16 to have multiple benefits. And then those that could possibly achieve additional

0:19:21 sources of funding. This is just to show you all the criteria that we used. When

0:19:28 you're excited when you have that opportunity to sit down and dig through

0:19:31 that sizable master plan you can read this in more detail. But these are all the

0:19:35 criteria that we used for those agricultural river quarter and urban storm water projects.

0:19:42 These are the non-monetary criteria.

0:19:44 Financial implications are obviously very important and we overlaid that onto everything.

0:19:49 But before that, we wanted to look at things like flood damage mitigation, habitat value,

0:19:55 recreational value.

0:19:56 They weren't the main goals.

0:19:58 Water quality improvement was the primary goal.

0:20:00 These were other things that projects could accomplish.

0:20:03 And that would be fantastic if you could have multiple benefits.

0:20:05 So those projects would then rank higher.

0:20:08 And then we waited the criteria based on, again, what is most important to the outcome of this

0:20:14 project.

0:20:15 We took all those projects, we put them in through this multi-objective decision analysis

0:20:20 tool and calculated the list of projects that we were then able to develop the master plan

0:20:28 with.

0:20:30 So a lot of sausage making, you know, lots wanted to this, as you can imagine.

0:20:35 But what we did here is we wanted to look at the projects two different ways.

0:20:40 First we prioritized projects just based on all those criteria with water quality being

0:20:45 weighted most heavily.

0:20:47 So this first, it's the second to the farthest right is the rank of projects based on just

0:20:54 there those criteria.

0:20:55 And then the very farthest to the right we added in the cost.

0:20:59 And you can see that the project order didn't change that much, but the project that was

0:21:05 listed as five, move down a bit, it's AG5 if you can see because it's a more expensive

0:21:11 project coming in at $11 million. The first-ranked project is $1.4 million. You know, they kind

0:21:18 of range in cost, but that's a really impactful project because not only will it improve water

0:21:23 quality coming from the urban environment, it will help with future MS4. So the MS4 is

0:21:29 the stormwater permit and then there's also the permit at the wastewater facility. So again,

0:21:33 anything that we were accomplishing, we really took those things into consideration.

0:21:38 In the master plan for each of the projects, one thing I also want to point out here, you

0:21:42 can see that US is the urban stormwater, AG are the agricultural projects, and then there's

0:21:50 the riparian projects, the riparian quarter projects.

0:21:53 So we had them all ranked in separate lists.

0:21:55 So if there's a group like Trout Unlimited who are like, we're really interested just

0:21:59 in your riparian quarter projects, we can direct them straight to that list.

0:22:03 for the master plan purposes, we put them all together.

0:22:06 So now the city can look at these prioritized projects

0:22:09 and figure out how to fund them, how to get them accomplished.

0:22:13 So this is what you're going to see.

0:22:15 It is a cut sheet from the top projects.

0:22:18 And you can see where the project is located,

0:22:20 what it consists of.

0:22:21 This is what we like to call a conceptual design.

0:22:24 You can also see that how it ranked and scored

0:22:27 in all these different areas, you know, water quality improvement,

0:22:30 AIDS and future wastewater compliance, successful implementation, all those additional benefits,

0:22:36 cost estimates.

0:22:37 So in one page here you can get a lot of information and we have this for all of the top projects.

0:22:42 So I thought I would share a few highlights.

0:22:47 You might remember we identified projects throughout the watershed because to improve

0:22:52 water quality in Rock Creek, you have to look at the entire watershed, every part of the landscape

0:22:57 that drains into the river.

0:22:59 So they are focused on the urban environment, but there are a few, the agricultural projects.

0:23:05 You can see those orange triangles that are up higher in the watershed.

0:23:09 Those are intended to really capture some of that spring runoff where we know when the

0:23:16 soil is exposed and all that snow melt runoff, it can carry a lot of sediment and phosphorus.

0:23:21 So those projects are really targeted for that.

0:23:23 So those orange triangles are agricultural.

0:23:26 those pink stars, those are the riparian corridor, and then the urban stormwater.

0:23:30 So, focusing in on those, it will all feature a few more projects.

0:23:35 One of the top-rank projects is right along Rock Creek.

0:23:37 You can see that this is a long shishone, and it is basically a bio-filtration system

0:23:44 that would take that stormwater, that captures all of the impervious, like parking lots and

0:23:50 roads and things like that, and it would put it first through a pretreatment pipe, and

0:23:54 then through this bioretension area. These bioretension areas can be absolutely beautiful.

0:24:00 They are an asset. And they also improve water quality. So what is now going, and you can

0:24:05 see in the bottom right hand corner, it's kind of showing that that yellow circle, it actually

0:24:11 is draining the runoff from a much larger area. So you're capturing that, putting it through

0:24:17 this treatment system, and you'll have much better water quality going into Rock Creek.

0:24:22 There's an agricultural project near the railroad in South Park Avenue West, and what we are

0:24:28 looking at here is some ag return flow.

0:24:31 The first few cells that's going to go through, the first cell is a sediment pond, and basically

0:24:36 you want the water to be in that pond for a bit so that the heavy sediment can settle

0:24:40 to the bottom.

0:24:41 A lot of the phosphorus gets removed that way, but there's some dissolved phosphorus then

0:24:46 that can go through the wetland system and will be removed by that wetland polishing cell.

0:24:52 The polishing cell, like I said, that's really innovative.

0:24:55 It's proven media that we know can remove everything from phosphorous to things like PFAS.

0:25:01 So it's really going to be impactful.

0:25:03 Again, this is just a conceptual design, but it is, we've verified that this is the adequate

0:25:11 size and enough to know that this is an effective project.

0:25:16 And then here's another project in the River Corridor near Victory Avenue.

0:25:20 So this would be some floodplain reconnection.

0:25:24 Floodplain reconnection is really important because what it does is it allows

0:25:29 some of that natural aquifer recharge in the shallow aquifer. It mitigates

0:25:34 flooding downstream and that is also really important. Those urban storm

0:25:39 water projects are also very effective at mitigating some runoff and potential

0:25:45 flooding events. So you've got floodplain restoration and then you've also got

0:25:49 bank stabilization so places where erosion is occurring. That one picture I

0:25:54 pointed out of the Boise River where you stabilize that riparian area so that it

0:25:58 can't erode anymore. It also protects other infrastructure. One of my clients in

0:26:04 the Boise area right now is really struggling because Stream called Indian

0:26:08 Creek has basically eroded away and it's about to impact a bike trail. So the

0:26:14 better you stabilize those you know kind of impaired river banks, it's really

0:26:19 important because it does protect your infrastructure in the future. So along

0:26:24 Along with this prioritized list of projects that is really robust, a lot of science went

0:26:28 into selecting those.

0:26:30 We developed some very strategic recommendations as far as initiatives go, policies, and programs.

0:26:39 And again, you don't have to put all of these into play, but to really restore Rock Creek,

0:26:44 we think this would be a really good path forward.

0:26:48 One of the best things you can do is to get these projects in the ground.

0:26:51 The city doesn't need to own all of these projects, but the city can be a participant

0:26:55 And just having supported this storm water map,

0:26:58 or this master plan process really gives whatever happens

0:27:03 in the future this amazing road map

0:27:05 on what to get put in the ground.

0:27:07 So developing a watershed restoration collaborative

0:27:11 would be a really great opportunity to pull together partners

0:27:15 and pursue other sources of funding.

0:27:18 We have really great examples of how we've done that

0:27:20 in other places that I'd be happy to share.

0:27:22 Another thing is a city storm water program and potentially even a storm water utility so

0:27:27 that you could start pulling together the funding needed to implement some of these storm

0:27:32 water projects that could really help with water quality and with future permit compliance.

0:27:38 And then when you do that, you're looking at all these future permit compliance needs

0:27:42 and maybe developing an integrated permitting plan would be effective because then you work

0:27:47 with the permitting agencies to remove constituents in other places, but get credit for it, for

0:27:53 example, at the wastewater facility.

0:27:57 We do need to take, if you want to get NRCS funding, you need to take this master plan and

0:28:03 use it as a starting point for what they call a watershed plan.

0:28:07 It's basically like an environmental assessment, so they match up to some degree, but then you

0:28:12 are applicable for NRCS programs like what's called the RCPP program, their

0:28:18 watershed restoration programs, and they can contribute funding. Education and

0:28:23 outreach is going to be a big part of anything to help you know get the word

0:28:27 out, get the community continuing to be engaged. Then we've got some financial

0:28:32 incentive programs that could be developed through the restoration

0:28:35 collaborative. So not from the city but from this collaborative organization. And

0:28:40 And then the city might want to consider some water quality and flow monitoring into the future.

0:28:45 The only site that had long-term flow and water quality monitoring was at the USGS site.

0:28:51 So we collected this amazing set of information, but it would be great if at some regularity you could keep collecting the data and then watch how the river improves over time.

0:29:03 That is a very exciting thing to watch.

0:29:06 So we are pulling together, well, the master plan is complete.

0:29:12 It is a detailed technical document.

0:29:15 My goal was that you could deliver this massive document to

0:29:19 Congressman Simpson's office and say thank you very much, put a big bow around it.

0:29:23 But really what we did with this document is we detailed and

0:29:27 documented our science, all the calculations, all the water quality data

0:29:32 that went into this.

0:29:34 Anybody in the future can go back and look at the methodology and basically be very reassured

0:29:40 that this is a very sound document that they can get behind.

0:29:45 It really details all the things that I've been telling you about today.

0:29:49 One of the best things is we have developed a strategic funding approach.

0:29:53 We have a strategic funding expert who went in, looked at all the different types of projects,

0:29:58 came up with a list of all the potential funding opportunities when those applications are due.

0:30:04 If that watershed collaborative is pulled together, they've got a basically a road map,

0:30:08 not just for projects, but also for funding.

0:30:13 And then we've got the interactive story map.

0:30:15 If you're some images of that, you'll all get a hot link to that.

0:30:18 Basically what we did is we took this highly technical document and made it into a very

0:30:22 approachable, engaging story map that anybody in the community can look through, understand,

0:30:29 enjoy, get excited.

0:30:32 If you guys remember when we had the community engagement events last summer, the community

0:30:35 community overwhelmingly said we support this over 85% so that they really are supportive

0:30:42 of this restoration effort.

0:30:44 So this is a continuation of that and I think that this could be a living document that in

0:30:50 the future as you implement projects, you can update the community on how things are going

0:30:55 and keep them engaged and excited.

0:31:00 Are there any questions?

0:31:01 Any questions for Aaron?

0:31:03 I don't see any Aaron.

0:31:12 I have one, sorry, I was, my screen like went blank,

0:31:15 so I can't, gotta type my password again.

0:31:18 Chris, why you type it like Chris, how about that?

0:31:25 Not so much for Air, maybe for Mandy,

0:31:27 and so who's had the opportunity to review

0:31:30 the document, the plan?

0:31:36 So I know that I have, I know that several members

0:31:38 of the city staff have, we've reviewed the plan,

0:31:43 We did not see any corrections that were material, and we would recommend approval, but it has

0:31:49 been read.

0:31:50 I will tell you, it's very thorough.

0:31:52 I will add that many people have been a part of this throughout the entirety of the process.

0:32:00 Some aspects of it are, I would describe it as not technical and pretty, like this storybook

0:32:07 piece, which is really good for the non-technical people like me.

0:32:11 If you could go back to that scroll area, if you could, to that it was towards the beginning.

0:32:18 It really kind of talked about the different projects, the Excel document, not that that

0:32:23 right there.

0:32:24 Oh, this one.

0:32:25 Yeah.

0:32:26 What I like also is then this becomes a fairly technical document where some preliminary

0:32:31 engineering has been completed.

0:32:34 We have the ability to take these projects or heal these projects out of the book and then

0:32:41 fund and create to make improvements in Rock Creek as we move forward.

0:32:47 So I think that it works for a multitude of different audiences.

0:32:53 I don't know how to read this.

0:32:55 That's not my expertise.

0:32:56 There are people in the organization that really like these types of things and this can

0:33:02 be built into actual engineering and construction documents.

0:33:08 Thank you.

0:33:09 One thing I would add is that this is what the funding entities would consider kind of shovel ready almost.

0:33:16 We're enough to where you have the information to put into permit or to grant applications.

0:33:22 Really that's a goal because they ask for, they don't need a full design, but they need enough where you can fill out some very specific questions.

0:33:30 And that is exactly what this provides you.

0:33:32 Thank you.

0:33:33 Thank you.

0:33:35 Good work.

0:33:36 It's very thorough.

0:33:38 thorough, just wondering what your projected lifespan was for the document, like what,

0:33:42 we think in 20 years out, 30 years out, or is this something worth it?

0:33:46 That's a very good question. It really depends on the ability to receive funding.

0:33:52 This could be something that with some serious effort, you could accomplish the

0:33:57 top 10 projects in five to ten years. I'm working on a few other

0:34:02 watershed restoration efforts and it's fascinating because we thought it was

0:34:07 going to take 10 years plus, but then this large entity foundation that's really interested

0:34:13 in watershed restoration came to the table and they said they wanted to pay for it.

0:34:18 And so I think that if you could get the interest of local business community, possibly

0:34:25 some corporate partners, they are looking for projects to be a good community partner.

0:34:32 The city of Nampa just got a very large, over $3 million donation from a large industry

0:34:37 in the Boise area to complete their wetland project.

0:34:40 So I am very optimistic and the way you get that is to not have this be a document that

0:34:47 just goes and gets put on the shelf.

0:34:49 It's something that you keep the energy behind.

0:34:52 They're communities obviously really interested in this.

0:34:56 Keep that momentum moving forward.

0:34:58 Keep presenting it.

0:35:01 Nathan and I spoke about this at the Idaho Water Quality Conference.

0:35:05 a lot of interest was gathered there.

0:35:07 I mean, the more you present about it,

0:35:09 people will just start coming to you and say,

0:35:12 wow, we're interested in this, how can we help?

0:35:15 And the city could just be more of like the,

0:35:18 we've got this, if you've got funds

0:35:20 or you've got interest, like, let's do this.

0:35:23 That's how these things happen.

0:35:24 And I just think I grew up on a lake in South Dakota.

0:35:27 That was really utrophic or full of algae,

0:35:30 high nutrients when I was a kid.

0:35:32 They had a major watershed restoration effort that started in the 90s.

0:35:36 And when I go to my parents' house that live on the lake now, it is crystal clear.

0:35:40 But it took, I won't say how old I am, but it took a while, but those projects, you put them into place.

0:35:44 And then it's remarkable how when you prevent that phosphorus and the sediment from getting

0:35:50 into the river, it can repair itself very rapidly.

0:35:57 We have questions.

0:35:59 What are the council's wishes?

0:36:02 Chris Reed, I'll make the motion if we're ready.

0:36:04 I move that the City Council adopt the Rock Creek Watershed Master Plan as presented.

0:36:10 Hey Ruth Pierce.

0:36:11 I'll second that.

0:36:12 Okay.

0:36:13 We have a first and a second to adopt the Rock Creek Watershed Master Plan.

0:36:17 Any further conversation?

0:36:20 Rachel Rolkovo.

0:36:21 Nathan Murray.

0:36:22 Yes.

0:36:23 Jason Brown.

0:36:24 Yes.

0:36:25 Greg Hawkins.

0:36:26 Yes.

0:36:27 Chris Reed.

0:36:28 Yes.

0:36:29 Ruth Pierce.

0:36:30 Yes.

0:36:31 And Grayson Stone.

0:36:32 Yeah.

0:36:33 Okay.

0:36:34 Motion carries six to zero.

0:36:35 of work at this point, Handy and Aaron and the rest of the group really appreciate us getting

0:36:41 to this point.

0:36:42 Great presentation.

0:36:43 Thank you.

0:36:44 So Mr. Mayor, just really quick, what I will share is it's sometimes amazes me how things

0:36:51 kind of line up and one of the projects as you recall, they have the urban projects, the

0:36:56 egg projects and the riparian projects.

0:37:00 The city was recently notified that we have to begin the process of MS4, which is making

0:37:06 sure that our storm water that does enter into water bodies of the U.S. has some, we

0:37:14 have a process to ensure that we're not contaminating water bodies through our runoff.

0:37:22 This has identified significant projects that we're going to be able to use in relationship

0:37:28 to building that plan and then creating our storm water utility and moving forward.

0:37:33 So this plan is already going to start showing real value to the city in this next fiscal year

0:37:40 as we begin to move forward.

0:37:42 Thank you, Travis.

0:37:45 We'll move on to our next item and that's a request to approve a contract with JUB engineers

0:37:51 in the amount of 158,760 to provide project formulation

0:37:57 through project closeout service with the FFA pavement rehabilitation project

0:38:02 and authorize the mayor to sign the agreement we have.

0:38:06 Matt Barnes, our airport manager.

0:38:09 Good evening, mayor and council.

0:38:12 This marks kind of a special occasion where you'll get to see me interact

0:38:16 with you a little bit more often.

0:38:18 We've got a lot of exciting projects coming.

0:38:20 for the airport to kind of start working on it more diligently and taking advantage of that

0:38:27 AIP, that FAA money. So tonight we're starting with a request to approve project formulation,

0:38:37 design, bidding, construction and project close-out services with JUB engineers. This first project

0:38:44 is for pavement rehabilitation and this project will apply seal coat, crack filler and refresh

0:38:52 pavement markings on the airport pavement processes that won't be affected by an upcoming runway

0:39:00 project that you may have heard some about and you'll hear a lot more about in the months

0:39:05 to come.

0:39:08 We anticipate bidding to occur this spring in 2026, and then we hope to actually perform

0:39:15 this project by summer of 2026.

0:39:20 This project is, or this contract is AIP eligible, along with the rest of the project, 95% will

0:39:26 be paid by FAA grant money with a 5% match from airport funding using the passenger facility

0:39:35 charges.

0:39:38 The contract is subject to the standard FAA grant assurances and it is currently under review

0:39:46 by the City Attorney's Office.

0:39:49 So staff recommends the Council approve JV's contract in the amount of $1,158,765.60 cents

0:39:59 to provide project formulation through project close-out services for the FAA pavement rehabilitation

0:40:05 project and authorize the mayor to sign the agreement contingent on legal review and FAA funding.

0:40:10 I'll stand for questions.

0:40:12 Any questions?

0:40:13 Hey, what are Council's wishes?

0:40:18 Craig Hawkins.

0:40:20 Like to make a motion to approve the contract with JU and B, engineers in the amount of

0:40:28 158,765 dollars and 60 cents, provide project formulation through project, close out services

0:40:37 for the FFA pavement rehabilitation project and authorized the mayor to sign the agreement.

0:40:44 I have a second.

0:40:49 Tension upon legal review and contingent upon legal review.

0:40:55 I'll second that.

0:40:56 Okay.

0:40:57 Have a motion to approve the contract with JUB engineers in the amount of $158,760 to provide

0:41:05 project formulation for the FFA pavement rehabilitation project, authorized the mayor

0:41:12 to sign a contingent upon legal and other reviews.

0:41:17 Just to be clear, it's FAA.

0:41:19 What did I say?

0:41:20 Both of you said FFA.

0:41:22 Okay.

0:41:23 Yeah.

0:41:24 FAA.

0:41:25 I mean, they might like it too.

0:41:26 They might make many times from this guy.

0:41:27 Yes.

0:41:28 Yeah.

0:41:29 Yeah.

0:41:30 Your farmers right now.

0:41:31 That's the way it goes.

0:41:32 You never know.

0:41:33 Somebody might come calling.

0:41:34 That's true as written in the in the agenda tonight.

0:41:39 So any further discussion on this item?

0:41:43 Okay, Rachel, roll call vote.

0:41:46 Jason Brown.

0:41:46 Yes, Nathan Murray.

0:41:48 Yes, Ruth Pierce.

0:41:49 Yes, Chris Reed.

0:41:51 Yes, Greg Hawkins.

0:41:52 Yes, and Grayson Stone.

0:41:54 Yeah, okay.

0:41:55 Motion carries six to zero.

0:41:58 That's going to stay up here and provide us a presentation

0:42:03 And on for a contract with JUB engineers in the amount of $250,752.80 to provide project

0:42:15 close out services for the FAA equipment acquisition project and authorize the mayor to sign the

0:42:21 agreement.

0:42:22 All right, thank you.

0:42:25 This is a very similar project, again it's hiring JUB engineers and contracting with them

0:42:31 to formulate three separate bid documents that will help the airport acquire FAA eligible

0:42:38 equipment for snow removal and for an object debris removal.

0:42:46 Mayor Brown got a little bit of a lesson while we were welcoming Breeze in regard to our concerns

0:42:52 with FOD as we call it out at the airport.

0:42:56 So this project gets us three different pieces of equipment, it again goes through all those

0:43:03 different phases for project formulation, bidding, and construction.

0:43:10 And it will give us a whole new capability with a high speed rotary blower that provides

0:43:19 the airport team the capability to remove those windrows of snow that we create when

0:43:25 and we're plowing that main runway

0:43:27 and the other priority one surfaces.

0:43:30 Now we'll be able to blow them and spread that snow out

0:43:33 and make it much safer and quicker experience for our users

0:43:38 along with purchasing a new loader and ramp plow

0:43:43 that helps us with the larger aircraft parking areas.

0:43:47 And then finally, the FOD removal truck.

0:43:49 It's very similar to the street sweepers

0:43:52 that you'll see the street department team use.

0:43:55 And it just removes any kind of debris that could cause hazards for aircraft users.

0:44:02 Again, this is AIP eligible.

0:44:06 It is a – the grant will cover 95 percent and 5 percent will come from passenger facility

0:44:13 charges in the airport fund.

0:44:17 Also like the previous contract, this contract will be subject to standard FAA grant assurances

0:44:25 and it is under legal review currently with the City Attorney's Office.

0:44:32 Finally, staff recommends the Council approve J.B.'s contract in the amount of $250,752.80

0:44:40 to provide project formulation through project close-out services for the FA Equipment Acquisition

0:44:46 Project and an authorized mayor to sign the agreement contingent on legal review and FAA

0:44:52 funding.

0:44:53 questions for Matt on this particular one, if not all Ruth Pierce. I don't have a

0:44:59 question but do you Nathan go ahead. So is this mostly just I guess replacement

0:45:07 of sort of aging pieces of equipment? Can we move on or are we moving just like

0:45:11 upgrading kind of stuff? The rotary plow is it's a new piece of equipment that

0:45:18 aligns us with what's currently best practice within the industry as far as

0:45:23 having that high speed capability, the FOD removal truck is replacing existing

0:45:28 piece of equipment and the loader and ramp plow would be in addition to a current

0:45:34 loader and ramp plow that we have.

0:45:38 I make a motion if we're ready. I move we approve JUB's contract in the amount of

0:45:45 $250,752.80 to provide project formulation through project cost closeout services for

0:45:54 FAA equipment acquisition project and authorized the mayor to sign the agreement, contingent

0:46:00 on legal review and FAA funding.

0:46:03 Chris Reed, I'll second.

0:46:04 We have a motion and a second to approve contract with JUB engineers in the amount of $250,752.80

0:46:13 to provide project formulation throughout through project close out services for the FAA equipment

0:46:20 acquisition project and authorize the mayor to sign upon legal review and FAA

0:46:27 documentation funding funding there we go there we go any any further discussion

0:46:34 Rachel Rolkelvo Nathan Murray yes Ruth Pierce yes

0:46:40 Chris Reed yes Greg Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes and Grayson Stone yeah okay

0:46:46 motion carries six to zero. I will say real quick the the breeze airway event

0:46:52 was well put together appreciate the community support on that our airport

0:46:57 is doing good things so thanks Matt. Okay our next item is a presentation of the

0:47:08 2025 National Citizen Survey and we have Mandy Thompson. Good evening thank you

0:47:15 and Council. I am bringing to you tonight the results of the 2025 survey that was

0:47:21 conducted last fall and into the winter months. A little background. As most of

0:47:27 you know we have been conducting this survey from the National Citizen or

0:47:33 Community Survey since 2009. We this has marked the 10th survey that we've done.

0:47:39 In 2022 we elected to go from a bi-annual survey to an every year survey.

0:47:45 Just to, I think, more adequately and more consistently measure the

0:47:49 sentiment of our citizens in relation to the services that we are providing the community.

0:47:57 So, the survey itself captures residents' opinions about the three pillars of our community,

0:48:03 and that's really the community characteristics, our governance, and then participation.

0:48:08 And it does that across eight facets of the community.

0:48:12 So it looks at safety, mobility, natural environment, the built environment, the economy, recreation

0:48:18 and wellness, education and enrichment, and community engagement.

0:48:22 And so what the report does is it provides the feedback that the community or the citizens

0:48:28 that elected to participate in the survey, with those sentiments in this year's survey, but

0:48:38 also they look at trends over time.

0:48:40 They look at different comparisons to benchmarking against communities.

0:48:47 This year we were able to have some customized benchmarks because I recommended to the City

0:48:55 of Idaho Falls to participate in a survey and so we got a little extra this year.

0:48:59 We have some custom benchmarks that are based upon communities in the Mountain West that have

0:49:05 a similar median household income.

0:49:07 So that's kind of nice to know that we're not being compared to or a little bit more like

0:49:12 in some of those comparisons.

0:49:15 The survey gets mailed in waves and really for the last probably, I think for the last

0:49:21 three surveys, you have the option of doing a paper survey or you have a code that you

0:49:25 get if you're selected that you can go online and you can take the survey online.

0:49:29 So we actually do kind of two different types of surveys.

0:49:32 So we have the survey that is statistically accurate, and that goes out to randomly selected

0:49:40 residents in the community.

0:49:42 We send out about 3,000 surveys every year.

0:49:47 We are averaging the same 14 to 16% participation that we have been really probably for as long

0:49:55 as I've been involved.

0:49:57 So this year, we received 395 surveys that were completed, which is at a response rate

0:50:02 of 14%.

0:50:04 And then the last two weeks of the survey data collection, we opened it up to the entire

0:50:09 communities in open survey.

0:50:11 We don't combine the results, but it gives residents an opportunity to take the same survey.

0:50:16 They don't have to be randomly selected, and so then we can report on both the open survey

0:50:21 results and the formal survey.

0:50:25 So what I'm showing you tonight is the formal survey.

0:50:28 So, just a quick reminder.

0:50:31 When I talk about percentages, I'm talking typically about the percentage of respondents

0:50:37 that rated the questions, answered the questions sort of in the positive category.

0:50:44 So either excellent or good.

0:50:46 So if you see a percentage, this is 95%.

0:50:49 That means 95% of respondents see that particular question or that category.

0:50:56 They rated that either good or excellent.

0:50:58 So, obviously, the higher the percentage the better we're doing, the lower percentage means

0:51:02 that that's, you know, the smaller number of members of the community that think that we

0:51:07 are succeeding in that area.

0:51:10 So, just a little compliment and a little some data on the survey this year.

0:51:18 So kind of the overall snapshot, the big picture,

0:51:21 is that residents still feel very positively about the city

0:51:24 of Twin Falls overall.

0:51:26 Certainly some areas where we're struggling, certain some areas

0:51:28 where there's some real giant red flags.

0:51:31 But interestingly enough, the biggest red flags are really

0:51:34 those areas where we don't have any direct influence.

0:51:37 But I think it's so important to include it

0:51:38 in sort of that overall report because it really

0:51:40 gives an understanding and a little bit of a snapshot

0:51:44 into what residents are thinking as they fill out

0:51:48 surveys. The responses are similar to the national benchmarks in most areas. 79% of respondents

0:51:57 favorably agree that Twin Falls is a place that is desirable to live. 74% want to raise

0:52:06 their children here. 72% believe that the overall quality of life in Twin Falls is either

0:52:11 good or excellent. And 85% are likely to remain here for the next five years. So really the

0:52:17 take away from that is that the core community sentiment remains strong and stable about

0:52:23 the, I mean, for those that responded is the direction that the city is taking.

0:52:28 So here's a couple of strengths, safety, public safety, so 91% feel safe in the neighborhood

0:52:33 during the day. They feel safe downtown, they feel safe from violent crime, and a 70%

0:52:41 feeling of overall safety. And I'm going to show you after I go through this formal presentation

0:52:46 how you can kind of dig down into the questions if you'd like, because there's a lot of options

0:52:51 online where you can kind of get a better idea of what some of those more detailed questions were.

0:52:56 And then this one always, this actually just made me quite excited because there are years when

0:52:59 our Parks and Recreation Department has gotten some not overly favorable responses in the citizen

0:53:06 survey. So they were a bright spot this year. So seven with the exception of the non-existent

0:53:13 recreation facility, which we opted to change the verbiage on that this year because I think

0:53:19 there are some people that were answering that thinking that they were missing out on a recreation

0:53:24 facility somewhere in Twin Falls that they didn't know about. So I think that might have

0:53:27 helped a little bit to make those questions around recreational centers a little clearer.

0:53:33 But 72% of respondents, overall believe that we have quality parks and recreation facilities

0:53:39 and services and programming.

0:53:42 72% look very favorably upon our city parks,

0:53:47 our walking paths and trails did well,

0:53:49 and even fitness opportunities within the community.

0:53:51 So really the takeaway is that these are some

0:53:54 real pillars of satisfaction in the community

0:53:56 as far as sentiment of the respondents.

0:54:02 So again, if you remember, I talked about

0:54:03 there's kind of three different buckets that we look at,

0:54:05 and one of those are kind of the community characteristics

0:54:07 and quality of life.

0:54:09 So over all over the past four years the City of Twin Falls has remained a favorable place

0:54:15 to live.

0:54:17 Quality of life has remained steady.

0:54:19 People want to stay here.

0:54:22 The reputation and image of Twin Falls has rebounded since the 2023 survey.

0:54:27 So I mean people believe that this is a good place to live.

0:54:31 They are, I think, you know, that represents that people are proud to live here and they

0:54:35 are proud to be a part of this community.

0:54:38 And there's really kind of the takeaway from this is there doesn't appear to be any real

0:54:42 erosion in the public perception of the City of Twin Falls.

0:54:47 As far as how we're doing our job, kind of the governance section of the report.

0:54:52 The overall confidence in Twin Falls government is 59% as CS is doing an excellent to good job.

0:55:00 Our performance ratings remain more in the 40 to 50% ratio, so we're about average, about

0:55:04 half of the respondents are, look up on what we're doing favorably, 45% for values of services

0:55:13 for the tax is paid, that we're acting in the best interest of the community and citizens,

0:55:18 that we're open and transparent, and that we treat residents with respect.

0:55:23 So again, those are just a few data points that kind of just give you an understanding

0:55:30 of what that overall confidence in Twin Falls City Government is.

0:55:34 And customer service by employees, 71%.

0:55:37 So I think the takeaway here is that our staff is doing a good job.

0:55:40 We are interacting well with the community.

0:55:42 And we've got some, maybe some, our trust within the community,

0:55:47 as I would say moderate, but I think as long as we can remain

0:55:50 on that 50% and above that we are continually working to improve.

0:55:56 So the economy, this is one of the areas that not necessarily,

0:55:59 can we have a direct impact on the economy?

0:56:02 But I think it's also important to understand

0:56:03 how individuals are seeing the economy.

0:56:12 They see, or Twin Falls is a positive place to visit,

0:56:15 which is an increase from last year.

0:56:17 Overall, the quality of the businesses that are here,

0:56:20 and that it is a good place to work.

0:56:22 So again, we're doing well in those areas.

0:56:25 Concerns, which I don't think this is a,

0:56:26 would be a surprise to any of you, the cost of living,

0:56:30 the over-economic health of the community, and economic development seem to be some areas

0:56:36 where people have some level of concerns.

0:56:39 Affordability is a pressure point, and I think we all know that.

0:56:42 Interestingly enough, only 19% of those respondents expect the economy to positively impact their

0:56:47 family income.

0:56:49 So our residents are concerned about their own, their own, their own family's ability to support

0:56:59 themselves, and then they're obviously in concerned with the cost of living as well.

0:57:04 And again, that's that red flag.

0:57:06 So affordability, whether it is quality health care, mental health care, child care, affordable

0:57:12 housing, this is a real concern to the individuals that took the survey.

0:57:18 And affordable housing was the lowest rated item in the entire survey.

0:57:22 So, and I think we've seen that over the years, I mean, as we've gone through the budget preparation

0:57:28 for the budget, and we were looking at the medium household incomes, we're looking at

0:57:31 the cost of a home in Twin Falls, it's skyrocketed, and so that really this, I mean the individuals

0:57:37 that took the survey are just agreeing with us in a minute.

0:57:42 Another area that we had some challenges is immobility.

0:57:45 So the overall transportation system, the overall opinion of our transportation system.

0:57:50 So remember those are the roads, the sidewalks, this could be public transportation, just the

0:57:57 condition of the roads, street sweeping, those are all lumped into mobility. And that is only

0:58:02 at 29% positive. And we saw some declines in from the 2020 survey. An area such as street

0:58:09 cleaning, parking, street lighting, and sidewalk maintenance. So again, these are, you know,

0:58:18 it's hard to know what individuals' experiences were when they took this. I think we talked about

0:58:24 that every year when I come and talk to you.

0:58:27 If you look at the amount of money that we are investing

0:58:29 in sidewalks and roads over the last 10 years,

0:58:33 that's increased significantly.

0:58:37 And yet we still have individuals that are not satisfied.

0:58:39 So one of the things that Josh Palmer and I are working

0:58:42 on doing, and it's a part of the company that does

0:58:45 the Citizen Survey, is that we're able to do sort

0:58:49 of many surveys with any registered user.

0:58:52 We have about 670 registers users and we're going to push to get some additional ones.

0:58:57 All you have to provide, there are minimum as an email and a zip code and you can become

0:59:01 a registered user.

0:59:02 And then we're going to start asking some of these pinpointed questions about specifically

0:59:06 mobility because that was an area where we definitely had some losses.

0:59:11 And then, you know, ease of travel, obviously by car and walking seemed okay, bicycle, 30%.

0:59:16 I'm having a hard time getting off of that 12 to 14% for public transportation.

0:59:22 I was really thinking after three years of a bright TFT that we'd see a little bit better

0:59:26 in numbers there, but interesting when you go again, dive into the numbers and you look

0:59:31 under that, the number of people that have actually utilized the existing public transportation

0:59:39 in the city is less than 15%.

0:59:42 So it's like 12% of 15%.

0:59:44 So it's hard because the individuals are taking this or not initially the individuals

0:59:49 that are utilizing RITFT.

0:59:51 So part of it is just really maybe doing some education that RITFT is our public transportation

0:59:55 provider in the community and not just another rideshare service.

1:00:03 Natural environment and our utilities, I guess we'd call it quiet strengths, they are pretty

1:00:08 steady.

1:00:09 The overall quality of the natural environment in Twin Falls has continues to be positively

1:00:13 rated, water resources are air quality and are utility infrastructure all doing well.

1:00:18 Nobody's, not nobody, but the majority of people are not, you know, concerned about the drinking

1:00:23 water or their toilet flushing.

1:00:25 So those are all things that I think are really, they reflect the investments that we've

1:00:31 made in that infrastructure over the years.

1:00:33 DSI got an 85% approval rating, so I thought that was great.

1:00:38 And then I thought it was interesting too that recycling's down to 24%.

1:00:41 So, again, is it 24% because they think we should have a more robust recycling program?

1:00:47 I don't know.

1:00:48 Those are questions that we could drill down into in a more specific tailored poll if we'd

1:00:53 like to do that.

1:00:54 And then lastly, resident engagement.

1:00:57 So over the past 12 months, of those that took the survey, 46% had contacted the city

1:01:02 for help.

1:01:03 24 had presented a 10-at-a-public meeting or watched a public meeting, and 16% had contacted

1:01:09 an elected official.

1:01:11 So engagement is happening.

1:01:13 But as I think we all know, especially when we went through some of those public engagement

1:01:16 opportunities in December and surrounding the strategic plan update, participation in the

1:01:22 horrible process still remains low.

1:01:24 I think one of the things that we are really working at here as staff is to figure out the

1:01:29 best way to engage the public.

1:01:33 So a couple more slides.

1:01:35 This one I think is one that's most interesting.

1:01:37 So the green dots are the quality that they were rated at, and the blue are important.

1:01:46 So if you look up at the top, 95% of respondents felt that the economy was important, and 51%

1:01:55 of those, 51% said that the economy of Twin Falls was, that was like the equality, so good

1:02:03 to excellent or good.

1:02:06 So the smaller the gap, I guess, is a better grade.

1:02:12 So you see that in safety, 70%, see as we're doing a quality job, 91% think it's important.

1:02:18 The larger the gap means that's where you have some work to do.

1:02:20 So again, if you remember I talked about mobility, that's a large gap.

1:02:24 Community design is a fairly large gap as well, and also the economy.

1:02:29 So again, something may be able to directly impact, but that is sort of the sentiment of

1:02:34 of the individuals that took the survey.

1:02:37 And again, you can see with parks and recreation

1:02:39 and the natural environment.

1:02:40 Those were there's a really small gap

1:02:42 between quality and importance

1:02:44 is where we're kind of hitting the mark.

1:02:47 So again, national comparisons nationwide,

1:02:51 we didn't receive any higher ratings in any of these areas.

1:02:54 103 categories received civil ratings,

1:02:58 and 18 received lower ratings.

1:03:00 But when you look at our custom benchmarks,

1:03:03 we did better than some communities.

1:03:05 And those benchmarks for 25 community,

1:03:07 and those were, we were benchmarked against 25 mountain

1:03:10 communities with similar median household incomes.

1:03:13 111 categories received a similar rating

1:03:16 and only seven received a lower rating.

1:03:19 And then in comparison to last year,

1:03:21 we did 19 received a higher rating,

1:03:25 about 117, so a similar amount in the similar ratings

1:03:29 and then 13 decreased to some degree.

1:03:34 So what I wanted to then show you, hopefully this works.

1:03:41 Okay, so I will, I'm working with Josh

1:03:46 to get the kind of the public portion of this out online.

1:03:51 But this is, these are the, here's the results

1:03:54 of the survey and you can go into these sort of key findings

1:03:57 which is really what I just talked to you

1:03:58 about kind of those big high points.

1:04:00 But then you can go in and you can kind of dig in

1:04:03 and get a little bit better idea of, again,

1:04:06 what some of those questions were, are the benchmarks,

1:04:11 were we were in 2002, 2023, 2024.

1:04:16 So you can really kind of dig into and get an idea

1:04:19 of what some of the responses were

1:04:24 and why some of those larger or overarching things

1:04:28 like the sentiments around public safety,

1:04:31 you can get in there and you can really get an understanding

1:04:33 of what people feel about specific areas of public safety,

1:04:37 about crime, about just emergency services

1:04:40 in the community, and so on.

1:04:42 So I'm going to be getting these,

1:04:44 this will be, I'm working with Josh to get this place online

1:04:48 in addition just to the PDF report that you all saw,

1:04:51 and then I'll get a link to all of you

1:04:53 so that you can go in and kind of play around with it

1:04:54 a little bit and see a little bit more

1:04:56 about what we saw.

1:05:00 And then last, this one's actually one of the things

1:05:02 I thought it was really interesting.

1:05:04 So we did this data dashboard here,

1:05:07 and we see sort of our index score of how we did.

1:05:10 Under, for this, it's the economy.

1:05:13 But then what they've done,

1:05:15 I said this is what your resident sentiment is,

1:05:18 is 42% of your residents believe that you have a,

1:05:22 you know, a good or excellent economy.

1:05:24 But then you can go down, come in,

1:05:26 and what they've done is they've really pulled together

1:05:28 a whole bunch of statistics from all sorts of different resources.

1:05:34 So this is the Bureau of Labor Statistics on unemployment rate, on job growth,

1:05:39 on the per-working age resident, the number of jobs that individual has,

1:05:45 the number of employed residents who work from home.

1:05:48 So this is fascinating because it really gives you a ton of data surrounding

1:05:53 the economy of Twin Falls.

1:05:55 And they get as much, I mean, obviously a lot of these are US Census, but if there's ever

1:05:59 an opportunity for them to pull local data, they will.

1:06:03 So there is one of the things that I hope that we can do, especially as we kind of finish

1:06:08 our strategic planning efforts and we look to performance measurements, is really kind of

1:06:13 digging into some of these areas to understand, you know, what is successful, like in safety,

1:06:21 talking again about, you know, resident sentiment is that the overall filling of safety is 65%

1:06:26 so that we're safe. But then you look at what does that mean? And, you know, what comes

1:06:31 into the violent crime rate, clearance rate, homicide rate, property crime rate. So it just

1:06:37 is a ton of information that, again, we're going to put online and encourage our residents

1:06:42 to go out and dig around and get an idea of some of the statistics that support those resident

1:06:49 sentiments that were that were revealed in the survey. So, with that I will stand for

1:06:55 any questions you might have. Questions, Chris Reed. Mandy, in the packet you, under

1:07:00 the demographic characteristics, are we able to break it out by those numbers as

1:07:08 well? Looking at it, you know, 55 plus, 64 percent, and we can only, can't force

1:07:15 people to take the survey so you know it is what it is but base it off of and and

1:07:20 kind of look at the numbers from the 18 to 34 year olds and and those yeah that

1:07:28 would be kind of fascinating to see which demographics because there's three 18 to

1:07:33 34 35 to 54 and then 55 plus on how they're feeling in these areas and then

1:07:41 And also area, there's four areas of which area one and area four have the bulk and kind

1:07:48 of seeing where those areas are.

1:07:50 Yep.

1:07:51 Yeah, that is all available on here.

1:07:54 And then you can see you can select age, you can select sex, housing type.

1:08:00 And then area is going to be then those different, those four different areas of the city.

1:08:06 And I can give you a, I would have to go back and look at some of the, just, you know, just

1:08:10 to see what one, two, three, and four are, but really,

1:08:12 we just use Addison and Blue Lakes,

1:08:15 and that creates those four quadrants.

1:08:16 Oh, perfect, okay.

1:08:18 Those four quadrants, but yeah.

1:08:19 We find that a lot of women, 55 years and older,

1:08:22 like to take a survey.

1:08:24 One of the reasons, yes.

1:08:26 And we have waited and unweighted.

1:08:31 This is the, these are the unweighted results,

1:08:33 because what would happen is based upon the demographics

1:08:37 of our community per the census, those 55 and older women's voices would get muted because

1:08:46 they were responding at a higher rate than which they're represented in the community.

1:08:52 But at the same time, the 18 to 25-year-old man, his voice was getting elevated.

1:08:58 So we really wanted to see, like, how does that look, and is it really reflective of the

1:09:04 entire community or do we need to you know or do we need to pay a little bit

1:09:08 closer attention to the people that are actually answering the question. Absolutely.

1:09:11 To your point the 55 plus woman is 33% of this survey where the 18 to 34 year old

1:09:19 man is 6. Yep. Yeah. Very few. But if you then take how many 18 to 34 year old men we

1:09:25 have in the community and you multiply that you know you use that that that way

1:09:29 to version then that those opinions then get elevated. So that's why we chose to

1:09:33 offer both of those options this year. Thank you. Any other questions for Mandy?

1:09:39 Okay. Mr. Mayor, just really quick. So I think that you know Mandy and Josh deserve a

1:09:49 lot of credit for getting this to where it's at right now. And this is just the

1:09:54 beginning. So there's a couple of things that so you get a survey and it tells

1:09:58 you how people feel at a particular minute in time. It doesn't share the why.

1:10:03 So part of our job is to explore as to why.

1:10:07 And so one of the things that we look at is there was about a 14% response rate.

1:10:15 And everyone says that's really low.

1:10:18 And then I remind everybody we had a 14% voter turnout rate,

1:10:24 which is identical to the same number of people that tend to be engaged.

1:10:28 And so when we think about engagement across the community,

1:10:32 It's not just here, but it's in all aspects of the community.

1:10:44 If you take a look at areas in which the City of Twin Falls can directly improve.

1:10:51 So one of them is 45% feel good to excellence on the value of services paid with taxes.

1:11:02 and the challenge that we have is saying,

1:11:05 do you know what services your taxes pay for?

1:11:11 And most may not be able to answer that question.

1:11:16 And when you think about taxes, it's far greater

1:11:19 than just the city of Twin Falls.

1:11:22 It doesn't say city taxes.

1:11:25 It says taxes.

1:11:27 And so we get lumped with the federal government

1:11:32 and counties, and schools, and special purpose districts.

1:11:38 So one of the things that we're trying to do

1:11:41 as it relates to also improving on transparency,

1:11:43 because I think that's something that we can know

1:11:45 how open are we, how transparently do we operate,

1:11:49 is we want to find a way to better communicate

1:11:53 what services the city of Twin Falls provides,

1:11:57 and how can we best engage our citizens

1:12:02 to provide the services at levels that they expect.

1:12:06 And so part of the process is using this data in the construction of the strategic plan improvements

1:12:14 that are also underway.

1:12:16 And then to be able to come back to you on an annual basis and say,

1:12:20 these are the improvements that we have made as part of our citizen survey.

1:12:25 These are the areas that we have intentionally spent more time, talent and resources,

1:12:31 building and improving, and then these are the areas that we need to continue to remain

1:12:37 vigilant and focus on.

1:12:41 I, Mandy, said it perfectly that there are lots of areas that we can't directly influence,

1:12:49 but there are some areas that I think that we do directly influence, and those are the

1:12:53 areas that focus that I think this helps create that roadmap and moving forward.

1:12:58 Thanks to Mandy and thanks to Josh and everyone who goes through this process annually.

1:13:04 We take this seriously.

1:13:07 You know, I look at it as a 64% approval rate.

1:13:11 I could look at it as a D minus or I could look at that any organization in the country

1:13:18 that serves as community at a government level would gladly take a 64% approval rating right

1:13:23 now.

1:13:24 But for us, I don't think it's good enough.

1:13:27 Thanks Travis.

1:13:28 Thank you, Mandy.

1:13:30 Appreciate it.

1:13:31 I'm just going to stay up here.

1:13:33 Sounds good.

1:13:34 Okay, our next item, our next item is discussing the M-POG grant program.

1:13:45 So last year during the budget process, we had a conversation about M-POG and the future

1:13:51 of M-POG.

1:13:53 And, um, Council elected to table the discussion, um, the funds are included in the budget.

1:13:59 And I'm here tonight because we're getting close to the opening date of the Impog application if you choose to continue with the program.

1:14:07 So just a little background as far as the program itself was established in 2003 as a way to formalize the process to evaluate funding requests

1:14:19 from local nonprofit agencies and organizations that were seeking some level of support from the City of Twin Falls.

1:14:24 In 2018, I think some of you will remember that I went through a process of revising the

1:14:30 program so that we establish some limits on funding requests, some rules about having to

1:14:38 be directly tied to the strategic plan.

1:14:42 And obviously, as always, anyone that's asking for these funds has to be carrying out a municipal

1:14:48 power.

1:14:49 So something that by Title 50 of the state code says is a municipal power that has to

1:14:55 be somewhere encompassed within the request of the organization that's making that request.

1:15:01 Since it's inception, the level of funding has varied annually from a high of $105,161,

1:15:07 which is a very interesting amount.

1:15:12 And we had that for two years, so there was something there in 2008 and 2009 to the current

1:15:16 level that we have now, which is 50,000.

1:15:20 There have been several consecutive years

1:15:21 where we have not awarded the full allocation,

1:15:25 even at a reduced amount, which is kind of where we got

1:15:27 to the 50,000.

1:15:30 And that's where we're here to have this conversation about tonight,

1:15:34 is do you want to continue to offer the MPOG process to area

1:15:41 nonprofits and organizations?

1:15:43 Do you want to absorb that into Council-directed capital?

1:15:48 Do you want to support a specific entity,

1:15:52 or once a year you support a specific entity based

1:15:55 upon an application process?

1:15:57 I mean, there are lots of options on the table.

1:16:00 But in interest of answering the question

1:16:03 of organizations that have been acquired

1:16:05 when the application is coming out,

1:16:07 I have let them know that Council is considering

1:16:09 the future of the program.

1:16:13 I mean, I guess I should have what I should have done this

1:16:15 because I could have provided you with the history of the types

1:16:16 of organizations that have been requested in the past.

1:16:20 There are some that have been recipients for 20 years.

1:16:23 There are some that don't even change their application anymore.

1:16:26 They just change the dates.

1:16:28 And then there are some that come every year with something

1:16:30 different based upon the needs of their organization.

1:16:32 So I think for some organizations, they're using it

1:16:36 as a budgeting tool, and I think for others,

1:16:39 they're really trying to find ways

1:16:41 to make an impact in the community and we have some pretty unrestricted dollars.

1:16:47 So those are kind of, I think, the realities of the types of organizations that are requesting

1:16:53 money right now.

1:16:56 Okay, this is the time that we get to express our opinion on the MPOG program.

1:17:04 So Mandy, refresh my memory.

1:17:06 We currently have 50 in the budget.

1:17:09 Yes, 50 in the budget.

1:17:11 And the money that we gave transfer flipped over for, um,

1:17:16 Well, we took, well, yeah, because we took transfer out of the process years ago and just

1:17:24 started giving them a straight for $5,000 that we just budgeted for.

1:17:27 That's one of the reasons our number went down over the last several years.

1:17:31 No, no, we just took that one out and just said we're just going to give

1:17:34 transform money because we have to start planning for transportation anyway.

1:17:38 We took some, I'd have to go back and try to remind, we went from 100,000 to like 87,000.

1:17:43 Right.

1:17:44 And then we secondated the 1000 for a while, and then we hit like three years in a row,

1:17:49 where we were, I mean, one year we really gave away 27,000.

1:17:53 And so this year we elected to go to 50,000, actually it was the year before as well, because

1:18:00 we hadn't been getting, the requests were less than 50,000 at that point.

1:18:07 You know, now we're kind of sitting in a space where, I mean, it's continuing getting less.

1:18:13 Last year, we did get enough requests that we did give out the full 50,000 last year.

1:18:18 And when you go through the applications, you determine that they do qualify under municipal

1:18:25 powers or it even comes to us.

1:18:29 Yes, Bruce, and goes through and he ensures that it there is a capital.

1:18:32 I feel like there's some that might have been on the edge, but maybe not.

1:18:35 We have had someone that you could, you know, yeah, but they've all, they always go through

1:18:43 that legal review process.

1:18:45 Chris, I'm trying to go back to the discussion that we had months ago and then go back to the

1:18:57 fun evenings that we've had for the last, how many years with MPOG?

1:19:01 12.

1:19:02 12.

1:19:03 Yeah.

1:19:04 And I'm aware.

1:19:05 Yeah, it's been good times.

1:19:07 I think that the issue, and again, going back a few months, is one night where the seven

1:19:16 of us look at organizations that are coming and saying, yes, you get money not knowing

1:19:22 the impact that they actually have to the departments and organizations within the city.

1:19:30 We've had some applicants where they've come in and they work with our police department,

1:19:37 which is a huge impact to the community, to the city directly, and at one point in time

1:19:43 we made some changes, which I think we're good, that it was, you know, you couldn't go

1:19:49 over 10,000, and some of them were much bigger, yeah.

1:19:54 And then there's some that come that, again, we don't know, because we're not in the day

1:20:00 to day, where we give money, and maybe it's good for the community, but the impact to the

1:20:06 we don't know. And so, as we were looking at this last year and having the discussion about this year,

1:20:16 I don't know how the mechanism would work, but ultimately taking these funds because we do have nonprofits

1:20:23 that do amazing things for our community and have direct impact to the city.

1:20:28 They work with the police department, with the fire department. They work with parks and rec directly,

1:20:34 where those funds would be directly impacted because the amount of work that they do with

1:20:40 us directly and it's not a side where there's really no impact to the community or I shouldn't

1:20:48 say community.

1:20:49 There's no direct connection to the city.

1:20:51 They operate independently and they do great things and that's fine.

1:20:58 But we want to make sure because it's something we don't currently do.

1:21:02 I think of Valley House, I think that's an easy one, where it's a direct link between

1:21:08 us and our law enforcement and our first responders and helping these families out.

1:21:16 That's a direct impact.

1:21:18 And I would love that the police department, the fire department, those types of organizations,

1:21:26 as they're working with them, can say, you want to know something, you guys need, here's

1:21:30 There's the pool, however it's deviated, and if that needs to come to us on an evening

1:21:35 and say, hey, we work with them directly, even in the questionnaire, we say, how many

1:21:42 twin false citizens does this impact?

1:21:46 And there's some that it's small, some that's large.

1:21:49 So to me, it would be more, instead of one night, they come to us and say, hey, we do this

1:21:54 and it's great, which they do, all the non-profits do.

1:21:58 I'd rather work with our internal partners,

1:22:02 and they say, you want to know something?

1:22:05 We have a direct impact.

1:22:06 We work with them.

1:22:07 It's direct to the city.

1:22:10 Over time, they know really truly it is,

1:22:13 as opposed to one night, once a month.

1:22:18 We divvy up this money and we really don't know,

1:22:21 because we're not part of the day-to-day operations.

1:22:26 I will say that we are maybe one of the only cities

1:22:30 in Idaho, that has a process by which we grant tax dollars

1:22:35 to other entities, if they've looked,

1:22:38 and there have been some that have done it in the past

1:22:41 and then gotten into some situations

1:22:43 where they just said it gets too complicated

1:22:46 and so they have ceased doing that.

1:22:49 And I guess I would say I won't say we're the only ones

1:22:51 but I believe we're one of them.

1:22:53 Yeah, and I would say if there isn't a mechanism

1:22:56 to be able to do that,

1:22:58 where we work with our internal partners

1:23:01 within the city to do that,

1:23:02 I would say we stop doing it all together.

1:23:07 That would be my vote, can't trust.

1:23:13 So I think everyone, most everyone,

1:23:16 not every, but most every group that comes forward

1:23:21 as a relationship with a department within our organization.

1:23:30 That relationship doesn't necessarily indicate

1:23:33 that there's a return on the investment.

1:23:36 And in some cases, that return on the investment

1:23:38 is going to be entirely subjective.

1:23:44 I don't think putting the department

1:23:49 in the space of picking winners and losers with people

1:23:52 that they work with is the right place for them.

1:23:59 I believe that the council earlier this year

1:24:05 elected to retain the right or at least to have the conversation as to if this is something

1:24:11 that you want to do.

1:24:14 And if it's something that you want to continue to do.

1:24:22 We have, as an organization, tweaked this process every year probably that it has been

1:24:32 in existence.

1:24:35 have been really good at following the rules that they have created for themselves some

1:24:39 years and in other years not so good where it gets difficult for members of the city managers

1:24:56 office including Mandy to describe what that process really is going to look like each year.

1:25:06 I think MPOG, if you go back to its roots, served a purpose because we had several individuals

1:25:16 that were on the City Council that had direct funding ties to organizations and they created

1:25:23 MPOG as an opportunity to still contribute and vote on the budget.

1:25:32 Because they couldn't vote on the budget if they were going to potentially benefit from

1:25:39 those allocations.

1:25:43 We had members of the council who worked for the Boys and Girls Club.

1:25:46 We had members of the council who worked for the Chamber of Commerce.

1:25:50 We had members of the council who have worked for various organizations that the city had

1:25:56 partnered with.

1:25:58 And this was developed.

1:26:01 I want to say 2005, 2003, and so we're going on nearly 23 years of having MPOG and probably

1:26:14 that many iterations of what the process looks like.

1:26:20 Ideally, we would have people that would directly connect to what we do.

1:26:25 We would have a matrix, we'd be able to show a return on an investment, and we would be

1:26:30 able to say this is the value and the return that the citizens are receiving in exchange

1:26:36 for the allocation of property tax dollars to the project or the process.

1:26:44 And then human nature takes over and there's an amazing story that walks down and they share

1:26:53 that story and it pulls at our heartstrings and we've got to find that we want to find

1:27:00 a way to fund it. And so we go back over several iterations to try to find a way to

1:27:06 fund that project, whether it neatly fits in the rules that have been constructed or not.

1:27:16 I honestly thought that the council was going to pull the plug on M-PUG during the budget

1:27:20 process and you went to the precipice and you looked and you went, we'll have that conversation

1:27:25 later. So we're here tonight to determine whether or not this is something that you want

1:27:30 to continue with because we did allocate $50,000 in this process and as Mandy has shared, it

1:27:37 is getting close to that time in the spring in which we release our application and then

1:27:42 we'll bring individuals before you.

1:27:45 Hey Travis, this is Grayson.

1:27:48 Go ahead.

1:27:49 Sorry, Mr. Mayor.

1:27:52 I apologize.

1:27:53 Can we put a sunset pause on this to essentially say, hey, we'll run it this year, but next year

1:28:00 we will not be budging that.

1:28:04 Yes, you the council has the ability to amend any budget that comes forward

1:28:11 It just requires four members of the city council to say we're not going to fund m-pog and then it's not funded

1:28:22 and I'll be I'll jump in here and I I mean I

1:28:26 and I say this with some

1:28:30 reservation in the sense of I

1:28:32 Kind of got to the point is I buy as I've sat on council and with I kind of feel the same same way as

1:28:39 Councilman Reed, but Travis, I think you kind of said what I, you know, probably better than I'll say it, but I'm kind of

1:28:46 I'm to the point where I think we we sunset clause that now and and allow that money to go into city

1:28:57 City Council directive or get pulled back into the the reserve fund and we

1:29:02 We distributed that.

1:29:04 I think the hard part about these conversation is we all try to remember what we said three

1:29:10 months ago, three weeks ago, and it becomes very difficult.

1:29:14 What I do, my recollection is that we were kind of to that point where I think the program

1:29:19 has over two decades has run its course.

1:29:23 Now I say that knowing that that emotional side of good stories that come into our community

1:29:30 We're able to provide a small chunk to help them keep going.

1:29:35 But my personal feeling is I think we have come to the sunset of the M-POG program,

1:29:41 at least for now, who knows it in five years.

1:29:43 It may start back up in some form or fashion, but those are my feelings of-

1:29:48 Mr. Mayor, can I ask for a point of clarification?

1:29:53 Yep.

1:29:55 Okay, so essentially what we're saying is we will, I don't use the term kill M-POG,

1:30:00 We will shut down empog and then reallocate the $50,000 and it goes back to the general funds

1:30:07 But yeah, so the the the empog money is in the general fund

1:30:12 Currently if it's not spent under its line item

1:30:15 We have to do a budget amendment to spend it or it goes into reserve funds at at the end of the fiscal year

1:30:24 Okay

1:30:25 So it would just be an unspent line item that would then get pulled back into the reserve

1:30:31 unless we find a specific project to amend the budget.

1:30:36 Hey, I'm ready to make a motion if it's okay.

1:30:41 Go ahead. Just a heads up.

1:30:44 So you guys kind of discontinuing impog,

1:30:48 and then reallocating the $50,000.

1:30:52 Do you want it general or is it council directed funds?

1:30:58 What would be easiest?

1:31:01 I'm going to, I just want to make sure that we are all in the same page.

1:31:07 So I don't have a second amendment.

1:31:10 Mr. Mayor, you do not need to have a place for the funds now.

1:31:19 What you're sharing with staff is we will not be creating an M-POG process in this fiscal year.

1:31:32 And those funds would remain in that allocation.

1:31:40 We have the ability to reassign those when those needs come and as the mayor had shared,

1:31:49 if those funds are not expended at the conclusion of the fiscal year, they will fall into cash

1:31:55 reserves.

1:31:56 All right, Mr. Mayor, I move that we discontinue MPOG.

1:32:01 I'll second that.

1:32:03 Okay.

1:32:04 first and second to discontinue the City of Twin Falls

1:32:09 and POG program, any further discussion?

1:32:12 Rachel Roll call vote.

1:32:14 Ruth Pierce.

1:32:15 Yes.

1:32:15 Chris Reed.

1:32:16 Yes.

1:32:17 Craig Hawkins.

1:32:17 Yes.

1:32:18 Jason Brown.

1:32:19 Yes.

1:32:19 Nathan Murray.

1:32:21 Yes.

1:32:22 And Grayson Stone.

1:32:23 Yeah.

1:32:25 OK, motion carries 6 to 0.

1:32:27 Mandy, thanks for your input tonight

1:32:29 and putting that on the agenda.

1:32:31 You're welcome.

1:32:32 Thank you.

1:32:33 You're done with me now.

1:32:36 Okay, our last item of discussion or consideration tonight is a request to use 215,000 of cash

1:32:43 reserve for the purchase of furnishing and equipment and to complete the legal office,

1:32:49 City Gym and Police Department lift remodel project that is currently underway and we

1:32:54 have Mitch Hubble.

1:32:56 Okay, and the fiscal year 25 budget, we had two different projects that we funded in

1:33:04 and there are ones for the lift replacement of the police department, one is for the remodel

1:33:08 of the old council chambers and turn it into a legal office in the city of Chile.

1:33:14 We bid those out as one project in the total amount that we had in the last year's budget

1:33:20 was the $2,085,000 contract that was signed for the guarantee maximum price for that work

1:33:33 back in September was $1,401,246.

1:33:38 There's a savings of $683,000.

1:33:40 If you'll remember back in September,

1:33:42 when we talked about the GMP project,

1:33:44 I said there's a big savings.

1:33:46 We're gonna come back

1:33:47 because we know we're gonna need more

1:33:48 for the furniture, the finishings, the equipment.

1:33:53 Things like conference tables and conference rooms,

1:33:54 offices, desks, security cameras, all that good stuff.

1:33:59 And in the gym, all the bunch of gym equipment.

1:34:01 So, we're at that point now where we're starting to need to order those things and we've gone

1:34:08 through, there's been a committee that's worked with Gretchen to put together a list of equipment

1:34:15 for the gym.

1:34:16 There's another committee that's been basically the legal team who didn't sit down and say I'm

1:34:20 not taking a need for their office space and we've got those estimates, IT is provided their

1:34:25 estimate.

1:34:26 We think if we had $215,000 of that $683,000 of savings,

1:34:33 we could fully outfit this building,

1:34:36 as well as a couple of little minor things in the police

1:34:39 department.

1:34:40 Really, the carpet doesn't match.

1:34:44 So we took out a bunch of carpet in the base of stairs,

1:34:46 and we're putting new carpet, and all the adjacent carpet

1:34:50 is different.

1:34:51 So we're going to run that out to the hallway.

1:34:53 We do all those things.

1:34:54 $215,000 will get it done for us.

1:34:57 Now again, this was in the 25 budget,

1:35:00 and so that rolled into reserves.

1:35:03 We need to make it out of the reserves

1:35:05 if we're gonna use the money for this.

1:35:07 So the recommendation tonight would be to use $215,000

1:35:11 of cash reserves for these projects.

1:35:16 And I can try to answer your questions if you have any.

1:35:19 Any questions for Mitch?

1:35:22 Ruth Peters.

1:35:23 So Mitch, with the 682,000 that we put into reserves, this is just bringing 215 back, so

1:35:31 we still have 400 over 470, 60, something that still is in reserves that we're not going

1:35:40 to spend on this project.

1:35:42 Yay.

1:35:43 I like it going that way.

1:35:45 I'm ready to make a motion.

1:35:46 Any other comments?

1:35:47 Okay, go ahead.

1:35:49 I move we approve the request to use 215,000 of cash reserves for the purchase of furnishings

1:35:55 and equipment and to complete the legal office city gym and police department lift remodel

1:36:00 project that's currently underway.

1:36:03 Craig Hawkins.

1:36:04 Second.

1:36:05 So I have a first and a second to use $215,000 of cash reserve for the purchase of furnishing

1:36:12 and equipment and to complete the legal office city gym and police department lift remodel

1:36:19 project. Any other discussion? Rachel will call vote.

1:36:25 Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Nathan Murray. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.

1:36:31 And Grayson Stone. Yes. Motion carries six to zero. That concludes our item of

1:36:38 consideration. This now goes to our general public input. This is an opportunity for the general

1:36:44 public to provide input on any city specific related business and nothing that was on the

1:36:54 agenda tonight will be discussed further and you have two minutes.

1:36:58 Hi, my name is Maria Hernandez and I'm from Twin Falls, Idaho. I'm a proud follower of

1:37:03 the Chief Standing Bear, the Puck Engine Tribe. Proud follower of Democrat John Lewis, Martin

1:37:09 Luther King. I'm also a proud to be an alumni of the Girl Scouts and Brownie Association,

1:37:16 an alumni of the CSI women's basketball team. On Saturday afternoon, which I saw you, Jason

1:37:22 Brown, and also I believe I saw Mitch back there at the CSI game. But on Saturday afternoon,

1:37:29 I decided last minute to go to the CSI men's championship game. I'm so happy to be a citizen

1:37:35 that one falls, why?" you ask. A random citizen did a random act of kindness and paid for my

1:37:41 ticket. I was not prepared for this blessing as I did not know this stranger. I was just

1:37:46 standing in line, talking about how I decided, last minute, to watch the game. This stranger

1:37:52 said the same thing. He replied that his wife and son did not want to come to the game.

1:37:56 Then out of nowhere, he said, let me pay for your ticket. I can't believe these random

1:38:00 acts of kindness still exist. So today I would like to thank this stranger publicly as I did

1:38:06 not have time to really thank him because he ran off so quickly. So thanks random stranger.

1:38:13 And yes, Twin Falls is a great place to live. And I just really enjoy seeing other faces

1:38:25 there at the game because there's so much unity and you know there's so many

1:38:31 CSI men's basketball game and the women's team are just excellent and to be a

1:38:36 part of that way back in the day when I didn't have gray hair was like it's just

1:38:42 an honor and to see how the sports has accelerated but also the kindness of

1:38:47 our community of people who are still kind enough to just step out and do some

1:38:51 random act the kindness. I don't even ask. Maybe I looked poor that day. I don't know.

1:38:56 I have no clue. But I was thankful and grateful. I took the blessing. But yeah, I'm just proud

1:39:04 to be a citizen here. And I'm really honored to be under your counsel here and that you

1:39:08 guys conduct yourself in some professionalism. So thank you.

1:39:13 Thank you.

1:39:14 Thanks Maria.

1:39:16 Appreciate it.

1:39:17 Any other citizen general public input?

1:39:20 Seeing none, we'll move on to advisory board reports and announcements.

1:39:27 Again, not to harp on it, but I really thought the Friday event was great.

1:39:32 Again, shout out to Breeze Airways.

1:39:36 Those services are important and I think that was indicative of how many people were on the

1:39:41 plane.

1:39:42 It was sold out.

1:39:43 And I think the community from what I've heard are excited for that service direct flight to Las Vegas and then on into Orange County and back. So appreciate the airport.

1:39:55 City manager's office.

1:39:58 There will next week we're going to meet.

1:40:02 So relatively full agenda again, including a finance report by Brienne Howard.

1:40:07 Okay.

1:40:08 There are a few that are probably pretty excited about that.

1:40:10 Yeah.

1:40:11 and then the following week because you can have a finance report. We're gonna not

1:40:17 have a meeting on the evening of the 23rd. Now it's good. So next week we meet the

1:40:23 evening of March 23rd we will not have a meeting. Okay. Any last comments? Okay

1:40:30 meeting adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 9, 2026. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:40:34.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    a76734d0bd84ee8877e1d437ccbdb2292ae3015990380fb282af9f8cde001914
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 5ea540c0b2d25f5a78126730d9616511cad43ac7acd2fed44dccaf55ec78dc6b
    part02.m4a ac19ee2ac431c811f25d9d9f02805abf6febae054604a714346ca08bb9193b87
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    f47159e7184f2150de21b7137124497cdeb36269345db5f5af31055c5751fc32

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file