City Council meeting
Monday, August 11, 2025
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Part 3 (from 3:00:00)
Transcript
0:00:05 Good evening ladies and gentlemen
0:00:23 Thank you, we have no proclamations tonight, so we'll move on to the consent calendar council wishes Craig Hawkins
0:00:32 We have AC welcome AC
0:00:35 Good evening mayor and council. I apologize for the lengthy requests. I was a little unique
0:00:42 I'm asking for the total budget so we can maybe expand this project a little bit,
0:00:48 use the big quantity and get the most out of our budget. And of course being an engineer,
0:00:55 I can't seem to keep myself from the three syllable words. So a little background on CIPP.
0:01:04 The CIPP is a project where we use a liner and go into the sewer pipe that is degraded
0:01:17 and rehabilitate it with an epoxy coating.
0:01:22 This is a pretty non-invasive project, they'll go into the manholes and sewer will not be
0:01:31 able to be used for about four hours and they'll use a little robot to go back in and cut out
0:01:36 the sewer services. So we really like this project. It helps reduce the maintenance and
0:01:43 all these really old sewer lines in Twin Falls. We get a good extension of life out of this sewer
0:01:49 or out of the sewer pipes after this is done. So very non-invasive. There's a good chance
0:01:55 that people that are having this project done may not even know it's being done. They might
0:01:59 be able to just call them with their day without anything happening. We're doing almost
0:02:04 four miles, 19,000 feet of eight-inch sewer pipes. This is happening in the downtown
0:02:10 township area where we've got our oldest pipes, a lot of clay pipe down here that
0:02:14 we're rehabilitating along with a little bit of a larger pipe. We did this project
0:02:24 most recently in the beginning of 2024 so this is kind of a continuation of
0:02:28 maintenance. This will help the sewer department by reducing the point repairs
0:02:33 is all the digging and alleyways to repair sewer lines.
0:02:37 So we're excited to get this done.
0:02:40 The engineer's estimate was 1.16 million.
0:02:43 The low bid came in at 912,000, which is significantly lower.
0:02:47 So as you saw with the request, I am
0:02:50 asking that we get to use our total 1.1 million budgeted
0:02:53 to extend this project just a little bit and have contingency
0:02:58 funds.
0:03:02 As far as finances go, I came to you in November this year.
0:03:06 to use reserve money from 23, 24 year.
0:03:11 And so we'll use the 23, 24 funds and the 24, 25 funds
0:03:15 to fund this project.
0:03:18 Are there any questions?
0:03:19 I will go ahead and answer those.
0:03:20 CIPP, sewer rehabilitation project
0:03:23 of Vortex Service LLC of Helena, Montana.
0:03:26 In the amount of $912,500 in authorized use
0:03:32 of the total budget for potential change orders.
0:03:36 Thank you for Shari Volmer.
0:03:38 I'll second.
0:03:39 Thank you, motion by Jason Brown.
0:03:40 Second by Shari Volmer to approve the award of the 2025 CIPP
0:03:46 sewer rehab project to work tech services
0:03:49 in the amount of 912,500 and authorize
0:03:56 the use of the total budget of $1.1 million.
0:04:00 Any further discussion?
0:04:03 Rachel Roquevo, please.
0:04:05 Craig Hawkins.
0:04:06 Yes.
0:04:06 Jason Brown. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Sherry Volmer. Yes.
0:04:10 Grayson Stone. Yes. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.
0:04:15 And Chris Reed. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero.
0:04:19 Thank you, AC. Okay. Next item on the agenda is an action item.
0:04:25 A consideration of a contract with Star Corporation for the CMGC services on the police evidence
0:04:32 storage and training facilities. And we have Mandy Thompson, our assistant to our city manager.
0:04:37 Welcome, Nati.
0:04:39 Good evening, Mayor and Council.
0:04:41 I have bringing for you tonight a contract,
0:04:44 a consideration of a contract with Star Corporation
0:04:46 for the CMGC services for the police evidence,
0:04:51 long-term storage and training facility
0:04:53 that we are currently designing adjacent
0:04:56 to the fire training facility off of Victory Avenue.
0:05:00 So several months ago, the city entered into an agreement
0:05:04 coal architects to design this new off-site long-term evidence storage facility.
0:05:10 As we've gone through conversations, we have made a decision internally to kind of expand
0:05:17 the scope of the design for future consideration.
0:05:23 We just want to make sure that whatever we design will have some long-term ability to
0:05:28 to expand some different functionalities out there,
0:05:32 including training.
0:05:34 So because the site is directly adjacent
0:05:37 to the Fire Training Center,
0:05:41 that is currently owned by the city,
0:05:44 we were able to, her Idaho statute,
0:05:48 rehire the CNGC services,
0:05:51 and just do an amendment to the contract out there.
0:05:56 We had this reviewed by Bruce Castleton, our City Attorney,
0:06:00 because it had to be a like type of construction and it had
0:06:06 to make sense why we would extend the contract out there.
0:06:09 So, we have approval from the City Attorney that it could be
0:06:13 considered as an additional phase of the training facility given the nature
0:06:17 of the building project and the proximity to the existing structures out there.
0:06:21 And it just makes a lot of sense.
0:06:23 We encountered, I don't know if you recall, but we encountered
0:06:26 with some challenges out at the building site out there.
0:06:28 There's a lot of groundwater that's under the surface out there.
0:06:33 So to have the experience of STAR out there and understand kind
0:06:36 of the challenges that we run into in the early phases
0:06:39 of the Fire Training Center, and they can take a little bit
0:06:43 of care as we go into the, especially to the site work
0:06:46 for this new facility.
0:06:49 So once I got the approval from the City Attorney,
0:06:52 I reached out to STAR.
0:06:54 And we negotiated a contract for the project.
0:06:59 So what you had in your packet and when I have here
0:07:01 for the Mayor's signature is a 7.5% CMGC for the services
0:07:09 on the project and Star has agreed to no additional cost
0:07:12 for pre-construction services, which is appreciated
0:07:16 because there will be some, there'll be a bit of work ahead
0:07:19 of the construction that we hope to include in the year fiscal year 2027.
0:07:27 So that's very comparable to what we're seeing right now.
0:07:30 I think it's actually the same CMGC percentage that we recently saw for the full expansion.
0:07:40 Oh, please, the city gym, thank you, and the legal facilities.
0:07:49 Michael, Arrington is here if you guys have any questions for him otherwise I'll stand for questions as well.
0:07:56 Grayson.
0:07:58 Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'm fine just sitting kind of on the peripheral.
0:08:03 I'm comfortable making a motion pending any further discussion.
0:08:07 Did you have some questions?
0:08:09 Just comment.
0:08:10 So I'm going to abstain from voting on this.
0:08:12 I have family members employed by Star Corporation.
0:08:15 So I have voted in favor of CMGC contracts
0:08:18 in the past for other contractors.
0:08:20 I think it's a good method and makes sense in this case,
0:08:22 but I won't vote on this one.
0:08:24 Thank you.
0:08:26 Any other questions for Mandy or Michael?
0:08:32 Hey, go ahead, Grayson.
0:08:35 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:08:36 So I make a motion that we approve the contract
0:08:38 with Star Corporation for the CMGC services
0:08:40 on the police evidence storage and training facility.
0:08:43 Thank you, Chris Reed.
0:08:44 I'll second that.
0:08:45 Thank you, motion by Grayson Stone.
0:08:47 second by Chris Reed to approve the contract with Star Corporation for the
0:08:51 CMCG services on the police evidence storage and training facility. Any
0:08:57 additional discussion? Rachel Roquevo, please. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Yes. Yes.
0:09:05 Ray Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Barry Bummer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes.
0:09:09 Spencer Cutler. Epstein. Thank you. Motion passes six yes and one
0:09:16 abstention. Thank you. Thank you, Mandy. Okay, here we go. Next item on the agenda is a presentation,
0:09:25 a council review of the 2026 budget recap with focus on council capital, and we have
0:09:32 our city manager, Travis Rothweiler. Welcome. Thank you, members of the council. I'm planning
0:09:40 on going relatively quickly through the slideshow and the presentation. I know each one of
0:09:48 view has been through this presentation, enough times that you could probably be able to give
0:09:54 it yourself. In fact, in some of the interviews that you've done, I think that you have. This
0:09:59 is really more for an opportunity for the audience to kind of catch up on where we're at, so kind
0:10:05 of look at it in previous episodes of the city's budget process. This is what we've discussed.
0:10:12 Again, just to confirm the budget that's presented to you is in complete alignment with
0:10:22 these sections of the Idaho Code.
0:10:24 These sections are the most relevant when it comes to municipal budgeting and it is following
0:10:33 those statutory requirements.
0:10:38 The City of Twin Falls is dynamic and changing, and just maybe a bit of old hometown lore
0:10:48 for me being born and raised in Great Falls, Montana.
0:10:51 Sometimes when you are in a community for a long period of time, you still see things
0:10:58 that are no longer there because that was a big part of your history, and if you ask folks
0:11:03 in Great Falls, Montana, where the smokestack is,
0:11:06 they'll point to a hill.
0:11:08 But the stack has been gone since about 1982.
0:11:12 But the ghost of the stacks still exists.
0:11:14 And unless we're looking through the same lens
0:11:18 of the community at the same time,
0:11:20 we're going to see different things.
0:11:21 And so that's why we present the figures of Twin Falls.
0:11:25 These are the statistics that we see
0:11:29 when we're trying to offer services to a community,
0:11:33 a community of 56,000 people that could be 65,000 at the next census, our daytime population
0:11:39 that exceeds 116,000 people as more than 90,000 vehicles cross into the community 40,000 alone
0:11:47 over the prime bridge. We talk about per capita income, we talk about the economic strength
0:11:53 of the City of Twin Falls exceeding $2.1 billion annually. We talk about the cost of housing
0:12:02 and how home prices have continued to grow.
0:12:07 We wanna share the end of the story
0:12:09 so that people can then start understanding
0:12:12 what makes up the entirety of the budget.
0:12:15 The budget that is before you,
0:12:17 if you take a look at a median home,
0:12:20 and someone who uses the median amount of water, sewer
0:12:25 and participates in the city's solid waste
0:12:28 and sanitation is going to see,
0:12:30 about a $9.05 per month increase in this budget
0:12:35 in comparison to the last.
0:12:36 And that is only if they're the median.
0:12:38 So when I run my numbers through this,
0:12:40 and I take a look at my taxable value of my home
0:12:43 by comparison, my difference is about $1.03 per month.
0:12:48 And so what we would encourage is everybody
0:12:50 to look at the tax statements that were sent to them
0:12:55 by the assessor's office, use the tax rate
0:12:58 that is included in here, and they can see how this budget truly will impact them as opposed
0:13:06 to the fictitious example that we provide here.
0:13:09 We have thrown a lot of statistical information at you, a lot of economic data.
0:13:16 We've talked about rising costs.
0:13:17 We've talked about the impact of housing, and we've talked about labor and how tight the
0:13:26 labor market continues to be while improving. We've emphasized the goals that we've set
0:13:33 through this entire process to be nimble, sustainable, to be stable. Those are all goals
0:13:40 that we created during 2018's budget, 2020 budget, during coronavirus when we had a tremendous
0:13:48 level of uncertainty. And while there's more certainty today in some things, there's also
0:13:55 probably a greater deal of uncertainty in other areas
0:13:59 and other facets as well.
0:14:00 And it's important for us to be able to be nimble,
0:14:02 to find opportunities to take advantage
0:14:04 of those situations as they present themselves.
0:14:07 And most importantly, we want to be the employer of choice.
0:14:11 Retention is the greatest strategy that we have
0:14:13 in offering public services.
0:14:15 And the ability to retain high quality men and women
0:14:18 that are part of our organization
0:14:19 is one of the cornerstones of this budget.
0:14:23 So you can see what the total value of the city is.
0:14:27 You can see that the total budget is down to about $7.2 million.
0:14:32 The tax-supported funds are down slightly more than 11.
0:14:37 And the non-tax-supported funds are up by about 3 million.
0:14:40 So the net is about a $7 million decrease in this budget compared to last year.
0:14:47 But one of the things that's pointed out, well, why is the tax rate going up?
0:14:50 The tax rate in this example is going out for many, many factors,
0:14:54 but probably the greatest factor that's causing the reduction in spending is the completion
0:14:59 of lots of CARES dollars, or projects that we're assigned to CARES dollars.
0:15:04 The completion of large projects like Eastland, where we had received the grant
0:15:09 to be able to complete that project.
0:15:11 And so there's lots of parts and moving pieces, and it is not as easy to tie one number
0:15:18 to another number when there are multiple variables in our equation.
0:15:24 The total taxable value of the city continues to grow, and when you include the urban renewal
0:15:29 agency into our total value, we exceed $7 billion for the first time in the city's history.
0:15:37 And then even though the tax rate is reflecting a slight upward trend this year compared to
0:15:42 the last, you can see that it is definitely within the ranges that it has been in the last
0:15:47 four years and significantly lower than those tax rates that were issued in 22, 21, and 20.
0:15:59 We like to share how we compare.
0:16:01 I think it's fairly noted that I can be competitive and I know the rest of you are competitive
0:16:08 as well.
0:16:09 And one of the things that we like to do is show the value of the dollar of taxes paid
0:16:15 inside the City of Twin Falls in comparison to other communities.
0:16:19 This is information that is easily accessible by taking a look at Zillow.
0:16:24 We use Zillow, not because we view it as the best source, but it is the most consistent
0:16:28 source that we can use for any property value.
0:16:31 And then we also use the Associated Tax Affairs of Idaho's Tax Levy book to get the tax levy
0:16:37 information.
0:16:38 We only focus on the city portions of the taxes because that is the only thing that we
0:16:43 have control of.
0:16:44 We don't have control of what Twin Falls County is going to assess or the College of Southern
0:16:48 Idaho or the different abatement districts, highway districts, ambulance districts, we
0:16:53 only focus on the City of Twin Falls and on the City of Twin Falls we are incredibly competitive
0:17:00 with our peers.
0:17:01 So when you take a look at the total budget, you can see that about $60 million is coming
0:17:07 from some form of property tax support.
0:17:11 Another $35.7 million is coming from user fees and then we have some outside dollars of non-tax
0:17:19 supported funds are about 4.8 million making up the total budget. Where it's spent is these five
0:17:25 categories. It makes sense that personnel is the largest cost. We are at our heart a service organization.
0:17:33 The services that we have are provided by talented human hands and minds and they contribute to
0:17:40 our community and its overall success. The second largest piece of that is capital.
0:17:45 the investment in not only our rolling stock but also into parks and to trails and the neighborhoods
0:17:51 and apparatus. It is monies to go to roads and water lines and sewer line projects as we've talked
0:17:58 about over the course of the last several weeks and then maintenance and operation. You can see
0:18:03 also that the city's level of debt is very very small in comparison to other communities our size.
0:18:09 So, again, about $60 million or about 64% of the total budget is going to be coming in
0:18:18 some form of tax-supported funds, enterprise funds is going to be those, again, that we
0:18:30 charge a user fee and you can see that water makes up the lion's share followed by wastewater
0:18:36 and second of that is going to be the sanitation fund.
0:18:42 The reason we focus on those three is because the rest of them equal to 0.1%.
0:18:50 Everything that we've driven home in this budget has been wrapped around focus areas and starting
0:18:55 from 14th of July.
0:18:58 All members of our team came forward.
0:19:00 They shared how different operations have been impacted by our environment, capital opportunities
0:19:07 to help for their goals and initiatives and strategies they have in the areas of priority
0:19:12 based budgeting and program enhancement are all tied around driving home this strategic
0:19:17 plan and this budget is what it is today because of their efforts and I think that they all did
0:19:22 a really good job this year which leads us to this, your list.
0:19:31 And we do have, you did ask for one quick item, this is the item that you had asked for to look
0:19:41 at. And so I took this specifically from the PowerPoint presentation that you were provided
0:19:51 by members of the team on July 14th. So I believe you might have some questions for Wendy,
0:20:00 but in total you can see that the total Harmon Park improvement is the totality of all of those
0:20:06 cost and I think it's somewhere around north of three million dollars and Wendy
0:20:17 is available to answer any questions. After you work through that we have
0:20:23 prepared so anyway we provided a spreadsheet that we'll be able to kind of
0:20:49 work through. You have some questions that we've been priming for you to answer. The
0:20:58 The first is you have a totality of projects that is about $1.72 million.
0:21:07 The amount of money that you have available ranges based upon the decisions that you want
0:21:12 to make, we know that we have $770,000 of council capital that we have traditionally had.
0:21:19 We also have an additional $365,000 of additional funds that came in after the budget was published
0:21:24 that we placed into contingency that can be allocated
0:21:28 out tonight or it can remain into contingency.
0:21:31 And then also the $50,000 question of what do you choose
0:21:34 to do with MPOG?
0:21:35 Do you make that decision this evening?
0:21:37 Or is that something that you delay until later on in the year?
0:21:41 So with that, Wendy has a few slides that she would like to share
0:21:44 with you and then I'll come back up and work through some
0:21:46 threadsheets.
0:21:47 Thank you, Travis.
0:21:50 Yes, go ahead, Wendy.
0:21:51 I'm wondering if we need to do this.
0:22:18 So I just kind of recap the list and the priorities
0:22:21 for your, just to recall what, here we go,
0:22:31 to kind of give you that list and the priorities
0:22:33 just for reference again.
0:22:34 And then as Travis had shown,
0:22:37 I just kind of simplified this one a little bit,
0:22:39 and let's talk about this one for just a minute.
0:22:42 So the intention with this design
0:22:45 was to cover the entire redesign and rebuild
0:22:50 rebuild of the whole skate park area.
0:22:53 And so the 385,000 that we have on the list right now is the one that Canada does the infrastructure.
0:22:59 We put the conduit in, put the lighting in, and put the base pieces of this project so that
0:23:10 then we can move on to the next pieces.
0:23:12 The 804,000 is the parking lot and the water retention area.
0:23:19 other pieces that we would probably more of the hard stuff that we'd have to do and then
0:23:24 as you see instead of phasing it we just named each section. So there is a pump track. There's
0:23:31 a bike skills park. There's an addition to the skate park and there's a strider track. So each of
0:23:37 those can be done in any order once we kind of get this infrastructure in. And obviously the parking
0:23:44 law is going to be another hard sell as far as a grant or donation, but I'm hoping that
0:23:52 those other pieces will be easier to get people excited about.
0:23:55 So that's kind of the intention is let's get it rolling with getting that infrastructure
0:23:59 in so that we can start encouraging fundraising and other efforts.
0:24:07 The Harmon Park tennis court rebuild, you asked if that could be phased.
0:24:14 So the design that you're seeing right there is the overall area improvement that we have
0:24:21 planned.
0:24:22 And it includes improvements to that parking lot, which you can see right there.
0:24:27 It adds a space for food truck pad, as well as the tennis court and pickleball expansion
0:24:38 piece.
0:24:39 So there were three courts there.
0:24:42 This design still is basically three courts, except that the third court has turned into
0:24:49 pickleball courts.
0:24:51 So we could do four pickleball courts and two tennis courts for this 351.
0:24:57 The lighting part of it is not included in this request.
0:25:01 The total courts plus lights would be 388,375.
0:25:06 the demo we're planning to do in-house, and the site improvements would be that later phase.
0:25:13 So I don't know if that really gets to your question.
0:25:16 The only other thing we could do would be to just start eliminating cords.
0:25:19 If we've already pulled the lights out, we could pull out the pickleball cords.
0:25:28 And then, do you want me to keep going or do you have any questions on that one?
0:25:33 Anybody have any questions on what she said so far?
0:25:37 Did you have a question?
0:25:40 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:25:41 So I had a question for Travis, but now I have a question on this.
0:25:45 So, all right.
0:25:47 So on our Council Director Capital, so when we pull up our projects,
0:25:51 it shows 351-500.
0:25:54 Yeah.
0:25:55 So that's, okay.
0:25:56 So the.
0:25:57 3,500.
0:26:00 Based upon this projection, it says we're covering everything.
0:26:03 What you're presenting now is saying that it's not covering everything.
0:26:06 I went and asked again cuz I was worried about that number and what I was told is
0:26:11 351 does the courts and the fencing okay?
0:26:15 So
0:26:16 388 would be the whole thing plus the lights so we've already phased the lights out
0:26:26 Or we can do the whole thing
0:26:36 Wendy how many pickleball courts do we have not counting these right now 12 12?
0:26:42 Well, I thought she was going to ask the question, Chris.
0:26:46 Why don't we just turn it all into pickleball courts?
0:26:51 It's joking.
0:26:53 And then I just, I threw this one back on there for review if you wanted to look at that space again.
0:26:59 So, and then the other two were the polling medians and the true, but I don't think you have any questions about that.
0:27:07 So, I can flip back to anything or.
0:27:12 Anybody have any, I think that's.
0:27:14 Does that cover it?
0:27:15 Sherry wants to talk.
0:27:17 Thank you, I love to talk.
0:27:20 Sorry, Sherry, you can talk.
0:27:24 Okay, the infrastructure.
0:27:27 You talked about lights going up.
0:27:29 Lights would go up at this stage.
0:27:33 Is that correct? I believe so.
0:27:36 And when I'm looking at, I'm feeling a little,
0:27:40 like I'm sure I understood, but when I see the lighting phase,
0:27:46 Oh, no. Okay. So the infrastructure is that part that's kind of dropping off the edge.
0:27:51 So this is the lighting in the conduit and that part of it.
0:27:54 And then the parking lot in the sidewalk would be that second, that other phase, the 804.
0:27:59 So this is lighting and whatever RTS is.
0:28:05 Okay. What is the light?
0:28:08 I mean, not in a detailed manner, but what does the lighting look like around there?
0:28:12 It's lighting that would go around the courts, and I think on this design
0:28:17 It's hard to see but the lights are placed on there in
0:28:22 And I have a different picture
0:28:24 With the location of the light poles, but they would they light the court they light the parking lot
0:28:30 they they light that whole area has no lighting right now, so it lights up that area in a way that
0:28:37 that it likes to fill a little dark hole over there.
0:28:44 And it's part of the 385.
0:28:47 Yes.
0:28:50 Mayor, can I jump in on that?
0:28:52 So this last summer, I was out at Harmon Park
0:28:55 and that parking lot is pretty dark.
0:28:59 That skate park area is pretty dark.
0:29:01 So I think that that's one of those,
0:29:03 this would be really good to add in that area.
0:29:07 So the ball field lights, I've got my cursor on them.
0:29:09 So that is probably the closest lights to that area.
0:29:14 Okay. That's what I was wondering because when we,
0:29:18 when I listened in the commission meeting,
0:29:20 it sounded like there would be lights around there and that to me is important.
0:29:25 Yes. No, this infrastructure project.
0:29:26 So this is the lighting piece of it. Yes.
0:29:29 So we would get some lights and yeah, it's pretty dark.
0:29:35 So this would be a huge improvement and 385 covers everything.
0:29:39 Do you don't do you know what the light portion of it is?
0:29:42 No.
0:29:43 No.
0:29:44 Maybe while we're talking about some other things, I can pull up the construction document,
0:29:50 the whole phase.
0:29:51 That's something that could be done by itself without doing the other infrastructure.
0:29:55 I'll look and see if there is, if that 385 can get broken down more.
0:30:02 I guess I didn't understand that you were trying to break that one down more.
0:30:05 So I can go look.
0:30:07 I have my computer.
0:30:08 and then the total of this whole project appears
0:30:12 with one point close to three million, a little bit more.
0:30:18 Okay.
0:30:22 It's sexy.
0:30:36 Wendy, I think that's good.
0:30:38 I don't see any more questions.
0:30:40 Okay, let me-
0:30:41 I wanna look at that light.
0:30:42 Yeah, I'll go look at that real quick
0:30:44 and I'm gonna escape Travis so that you can get
0:30:46 to your red sheet.
0:31:06 So here you go.
0:31:07 Here we go.
0:31:08 Again, the British self-explanatory, the projects that have been submitted to you through the
0:31:19 process are included on the web.
0:31:25 Here is the value, then the projects that you will support will go here.
0:31:31 Depending upon which fund you choose to take, if you choose to take up and through the
0:31:38 impog, you have a total of $1,185,000.
0:31:43 If you choose to use less, you have $1,135,000.
0:31:48 If you choose only to keep the counts of capital, you're at $770.
0:31:52 And so we'll have three running totals.
0:31:54 If I got it, I did it right, you'll be able to see exactly where you're at.
0:32:01 offered to drive the cursor tonight I'm gonna try to manage that but if not I'm
0:32:07 gonna call another relief driver okay all right all right okay so Grayson
0:32:14 you're on there is yeah you have a question yeah thank you Madam Mayor so
0:32:18 I have a couple questions one a trap so on slide number 10 I got questioned
0:32:26 on we're talking about total city taxes paid for lane that's based upon density
0:32:33 and just volume isn't it because they have higher property taxes all the way
0:32:39 across like their homes in of themselves yeah so like right if you look at the
0:32:44 graph it's 587 versus 356 yeah so what what is important is we've always said
0:32:54 you cannot look at a tax rate to determine what the tax load is because all values and
0:33:01 properties are not the same. So the example is if you take my home and you were to put
0:33:08 my home on a roller skate and you would move it someplace, right? You move it to Sun Valley.
0:33:15 The value of my home, the structure just significantly increased. But if I move my home to another
0:33:24 place, it may lower in value. And so when you look at the median value of a home, it is
0:33:32 more of an indication of the local housing market. And that's why when we take a median
0:33:39 home, it is in New Zillow, they have defined what a median home is and they say that median
0:33:45 home has X features and has Y dollar value. And that's why we like to use that feature.
0:33:54 And so then a tax rate is in Idaho, if as we have other people coming from other states,
0:34:02 they're used to a term called a mill levy, where a number of mills are assigned to a total
0:34:07 taxable value.
0:34:09 We don't do mills in Idaho.
0:34:11 We have a tax rate.
0:34:12 In our tax, it is about as simple of a mathematical formula as you can create.
0:34:18 On the top, you have the total taxable value of a community.
0:34:23 So for us, it's about $6.4 million this year.
0:34:26 And it's going to be divided by the total amount
0:34:28 that governments spend.
0:34:31 And that's going to come up with our tax rate of 00509.
0:34:37 It's just math.
0:34:39 And I think sometimes we try to make it overly complicated.
0:34:41 Pretty simple, yep.
0:34:43 And then thanks, Trev.
0:34:44 And then my second question is actually you, Madam Mayor.
0:34:47 So on the MPOG stuff, on these council directed capital
0:34:51 projects, so if we were to get rid
0:34:54 of M-POG, hypothetically speaking, could we then, what we would have historically given
0:35:00 to like, art councils, can we direct that to the Twin Falls Art Commission, and then could
0:35:06 we also, what we've given to voices against violence, could we just put that in a line
0:35:12 item for the police department? Or how does that work? Because those are two things I think
0:35:18 we need to keep up doing. I'm probably, if there's a motion to get rid of M-POG, I'll
0:35:24 probably be in favor of it but those are two line items I think we need to
0:35:27 continue doing and I think we kind of have unfunded mandates with the arts
0:35:31 commission we're not funding that and we could use this as a way to fund that and
0:35:34 then with the police department I'm all for throwing them some coin so I think
0:35:40 that's a good item for discussion if we're gonna start out right now so but yes
0:35:45 in theory yes we can do that okay and historically the the council has so if
0:35:51 If we go all the way back, the funding that once went to the municipal band was part of
0:36:00 the MPOG process.
0:36:03 The council made the decision that as it was always allocating the money towards the municipal
0:36:09 band and they didn't see a time in which they wouldn't allocate the money to the municipal
0:36:13 band, they said we'll make it a line item budget.
0:36:15 We made it a flat line item budget and then you'll recall earlier this year they came to
0:36:20 and said, hey, we'd like to have a little bit more money.
0:36:21 We haven't had an increase in the city's contribution
0:36:24 since, I think, it was 2007, 2008.
0:36:28 And so they asked for that money that money was provided.
0:36:31 And then we put in the $25,000 request
0:36:34 for this year moving forward.
0:36:36 Yep.
0:36:37 OK.
0:36:38 Ben, sir.
0:36:40 Hi, thanks, Mayor.
0:36:41 As you can see, we should probably decide as a council
0:36:43 if we want to continue an impug before we start working
0:36:46 on these other projects.
0:36:48 To me, the MPOG process seems like it's unnecessary.
0:36:52 It's created at a different time,
0:36:54 different circumstances,
0:36:56 and it'd probably be in favor of getting rid of it.
0:36:59 I was wondering about some of these in line items,
0:37:01 such as the band.
0:37:03 Do we have, within the One City organization
0:37:06 in the different departments?
0:37:08 Maybe I shouldn't have said One City,
0:37:09 but within the different departments,
0:37:10 do we have departments that are advocating for some of those?
0:37:13 Or are they kind of out there,
0:37:15 floating on their own,
0:37:16 And it's up to Council to be aware of those and make sure we know those are happening each
0:37:21 year.
0:37:22 I don't think there's any real advocation for any of the hemp PUG projects from a staff
0:37:29 perspective.
0:37:31 Our process has been fairly mechanical.
0:37:34 We will work with legal Council to determine if it falls under the municipal powers outlined
0:37:39 in Chapter 3.
0:37:42 If there is a preference towards where funding could go, it's often probably kept close to
0:37:50 the best recognizing that we're not voters and we don't want to have any undue influence
0:37:55 on the presentations that you receive from those who participate in the process.
0:38:00 Great.
0:38:02 Thank you.
0:38:03 Yeah.
0:38:04 It seems logical to have those as a line item that the council would consider each year.
0:38:08 Thank you.
0:38:09 Chris.
0:38:11 Chris, in regards to the impact that I would like to see it go away as we've currently been doing it.
0:38:20 I do think that the partnerships with many of those nonprofits are important for our team, but also for our community.
0:38:28 I would be more in favor of potentially setting that those funds to the side.
0:38:34 Ultimately, those nonprofits, because they're not part of the community, so I'm not 100% comfortable making it a line item,
0:38:41 because they are a separate organization, but ultimately in partnership with whatever organization
0:38:48 they partner with within the city, Voices Against Violence, the police, the Arts Council,
0:38:55 with our Arts Commission, those types of organizations where that communication would happen there,
0:39:01 and it would, our department or committee would come and approach the council at that point
0:39:06 time for those funds, and they would be the stewards over that.
0:39:10 We've done MPOG for many years.
0:39:14 There's a few times that there's a kind of a return in report, not always the case, and
0:39:19 so I would rather have those groups look over it.
0:39:22 So if we were going to set that money aside, they are a separate organization, not comfortable
0:39:28 making them a line item.
0:39:29 They are important to our community, so continuing to help, but through those organizations that
0:39:34 work with them day in and day out.
0:39:36 That's where I would put MPOG, personally.
0:39:42 Is that a possibility, Travis?
0:39:44 Yeah, so what I'm hearing is, so the beauty is, is you've allocated the revenue side.
0:39:53 And the direct placement for the expenditure can be delayed for a period of time.
0:40:01 We have the $50,000 year market, I believe, for MPOG in the budget.
0:40:07 So, no action means that it stays where it's at.
0:40:12 And then we can come and have the conversation
0:40:14 about what is the mechanics of M-POG look
0:40:16 after you go through the budget process.
0:40:21 As opposed to just saying we're eliminating M-POG
0:40:24 and we're putting it in here.
0:40:27 Right, so you would have two options.
0:40:29 Those are your two options.
0:40:36 Go ahead.
0:40:36 Then I would say eliminate it and then we'll talk about
0:40:39 how to do it later.
0:40:40 And we can set the money aside in this,
0:40:42 but eliminating it as it currently stands.
0:40:47 So, and to be perfectly clear,
0:40:51 we do not have to allocate the full 1.185.
0:40:55 We could, whatever number a million we come up with
0:41:00 and the balance can be used for special contingency fund needs,
0:41:08 but correct?
0:41:09 My suggestion would be that if you do not want
0:41:14 to use mPOG dollars on the capital list,
0:41:21 keep them where they are now,
0:41:25 and that we can come back and have a conversation
0:41:28 on how to best address mPOG moving forward.
0:41:33 That's fine.
0:41:34 As long as we do that sooner than later,
0:41:37 like not me.
0:41:39 We will have that done, we can do it in October.
0:41:44 That'd be great. Yep. We'll make sure Mandy's ready. It's her favorite topic
0:41:52 Okay, Grace and you're still up to you another question. Yeah, thank you, Adam Eric. Can I dress?
0:41:57 directly
0:42:00 So if we got rid of MPOG and we allowed the historical allowance to
0:42:08 Voices against violence and the arts Commission that work
0:42:11 So like we just take that like subsection and then we just get rid of the rest and then take the balance and then roll it into
0:42:19 Council directed capital projects. Would you be okay with that?
0:42:23 Or do you want to just station everything?
0:42:26 I kind of want to just hold it there and see what I agree what we're approached from those organizations
0:42:32 Okay, and what works best for the city of Twin Falls?
0:42:36 I guess it kind of I guess we're kind of saying the same thing like we're just kind of
0:42:39 else you want to do it now and he wants to wait a little bit. I'm okay. We're good on that.
0:42:45 So do we want to just have a motion to observe by by not doing anything we just leave it over
0:42:51 there and we're fine right? Travis okay. Can I just make a motion to kill and pog and put it in our
0:43:01 cap of reserves? So we just decided that it would be best to leave it there and then we come back
0:43:08 later in October and decide how to where to put it. Right? That what we just said.
0:43:16 That's what I'm thinking is we we we don't make a decision on it. We don't face
0:43:20 up the conversation. We don't want what it has been. What it has been in the past.
0:43:24 We we don't want to. But we need to have that look on the rules. We need to make
0:43:28 rules. We're still going to take the 50. We're going to hold it and then we're
0:43:31 going to make rules based off of what we would like to do it moving forward. But
0:43:35 for the budget purpose, it's just being held.
0:43:38 And then we will make rules based off
0:43:40 of what do we want to do with those funds
0:43:43 to still support our community,
0:43:44 support our team with those non-profits.
0:43:48 Who, Councilman Reed, my question then is,
0:43:50 if we do that, then how do we fund these
0:43:52 with the Council of Director?
0:43:54 And we go down.
0:43:55 So then we only have 1.135, less the 50, okay?
0:44:05 You good?
0:44:06 All right, I'm with you.
0:44:07 Okay, Jason.
0:44:10 I think everybody summed up what I yeah, I'd like to table
0:44:13 and POG. I think we need to revise the the process. So if
0:44:19 there's a motion that needs to be made, I we can move forward
0:44:23 just leave it in the budget and then we'll talk about it later
0:44:25 on.
0:44:26 Doesn't sound like we need to motion on that right now.
0:44:31 Okay, so with that being said, we're looking at allocating up
0:44:38 to 1.135, but also keeping in mind we do not have to allocate the whole thing.
0:44:45 So if we choose to leave some money for contingency, other things we can, Wendy, were you able
0:44:58 to find out yet?
0:45:00 I mean, not rushing you, but you've got it great.
0:45:05 I'm still trying to find the drawing of the location of the lights, but when I have my
0:45:44 cost analysis, the sports lighting phase, which is what we're talking about, is the transformer
0:45:51 in primary power to the panels, power panels, distribution conduit and wire, and musco
0:45:58 sports lighting system.
0:46:00 And that's awesome.
0:46:02 No way phone isn't close.
0:46:06 So now it doesn't want to sign me in.
0:46:15 the transformer and primary power is 60,000, the power to the panels is 40, and the sports
0:46:26 lighting is 250,000.
0:46:28 It's 350 of the, that doesn't make sense.
0:46:34 350.
0:46:35 350 for the lighting.
0:46:39 So it's 60 plus 40 is 100, and then 250 for the actual lights, and then they put a 10%
0:46:45 contingency in there to get you to 385.
0:46:48 So that is just lighting, just lighting, period, then 365 number is only lighting no other
0:46:57 infrastructure.
0:46:58 385, but yes.
0:46:59 There may be 385.
0:47:00 And then I think it does the conduit to all the lighting areas, right?
0:47:08 Thank you.
0:47:09 All right, Spencer.
0:47:10 Hi, Max, just start putting numbers down.
0:47:12 I wanted to go ahead right now and propose that we put the senior citizen sighting and
0:47:17 the resource officer on the list,
0:47:22 be grabbing Microsoft issues.
0:47:23 Okay, works.
0:47:25 I've got a spreadsheet here that I'm working on.
0:47:28 We all have a spreadsheet store.
0:47:30 Yeah.
0:47:32 The public can't see those.
0:47:33 I know, but the siding is 55.
0:47:37 And the, what did you say the other one?
0:47:40 Police station?
0:47:41 Resource officer.
0:47:42 So, the 3,500, isn't it?
0:47:45 Yeah.
0:47:46 Can I offer a suggestion?
0:47:49 I'm assuming that the mass majority of us
0:47:53 are struggling on the big dollar item ones that really come
0:47:56 down to some of those bigger items.
0:47:59 So I look at the commercial air service.
0:48:02 I think that's an extremely important part
0:48:04 of the promotion of the airport, the tree grant.
0:48:10 The median, I'm still up in the air,
0:48:12 but station one, fire tender trucks, school resource officer,
0:48:15 and Carter kid, if we, I mean, those are the items,
0:48:19 I think we could, we could fund,
0:48:20 but I think the big majority will come around the skate park
0:48:25 and the Harmon park improvements and or Baxter park improvements.
0:48:30 I mean, I think that's where the big discussion comes around.
0:48:33 I could go for that.
0:48:35 I think we had all in and then discuss the last three.
0:48:38 Yep, I agree.
0:48:42 And that right there, just so everybody knows,
0:48:45 I'm going to change of course, because it's a read-only.
0:48:53 So that is $387,960, I believe, without the three big projects.
0:49:09 So we're at $387,960, right now, without the three big projects.
0:49:16 that would include the city emergency operation plan.
0:49:20 Correct.
0:49:21 The senior citizen improvements for city center.
0:49:25 Yeah, our commercial air service tree grant,
0:49:28 whole line median station one,
0:49:30 fire tender trucks, school resource officer
0:49:33 and the Carter kit.
0:49:34 Correct.
0:49:35 Okay.
0:49:40 Everybody trying to see what we're doing there?
0:49:42 Yeah, so assuming we fund all that was our balance.
0:49:46 So, right now that's 3.87, 960, and...
0:49:52 He's running on my excel sheet right now.
0:49:54 Oh, me too.
0:49:55 Yep, so it's this one right here.
0:49:58 But the 3.87, 960.
0:50:01 That's our balance.
0:50:02 Yeah, that's...
0:50:03 So our balance left is 747.
0:50:05 Right, to fund those three other different projects.
0:50:09 Which we also have one that...
0:50:11 So Travis, did you catch that?
0:50:15 No, I was experiencing that.
0:50:16 Experiencing the joys of multi-factor authentication. Okay. Oh, I thought you were keeping him out of that. Okay
0:50:25 Travis were if you just put under supported projects, so it's equal this right or plus either way and
0:50:36 This one mm-hmm. I was gonna give Travis a hard time Mitch. You ready to drive. I was just gonna say I want to go down there
0:50:43 This one yes, and you could do a copy and paste if you want
0:50:48 I'm not going to make you do that.
0:50:51 I could just do that.
0:50:53 It's hard to watch.
0:50:54 There you go.
0:50:55 Thank you.
0:50:56 And those are the three that you're not doing this column right here.
0:50:59 Correct.
0:51:00 Good.
0:51:01 We won't even hide it.
0:51:02 Are we about that?
0:51:03 Or that.
0:51:04 Okay.
0:51:05 So depending upon which option you want to go with, you have 382,000 remaining or $747,000
0:51:16 remaining.
0:51:17 Okay.
0:51:21 everybody good with that so far. Okay, I should probably get off my spreadsheet. So, Chris
0:51:28 Reed. Oh, sorry. No, I- Okay, Jason. Yeah, I have a- I'll just kind of let my- I know
0:51:37 we've been kicking Baxter's dog park around for quite a while and I think that's a good
0:51:43 plan. I'm struggling with the fact that I also believe that, you know, providing some
0:51:51 safety features at Harmon Park, particularly with some lighting, is an important project.
0:51:58 I guess if I were to really choose one, I like the Harmon tennis park pickleball one myself,
0:52:11 but I and I personally struggle with the dog park.
0:52:19 It's a big price tag, we could get two other projects moving forward, but again we can
0:52:28 kick the dog park down the road quite a ways.
0:52:34 Right, Sherry.
0:52:39 I have some of the same sentiments.
0:52:42 In my mind, the Harmon Park lighting
0:52:46 is extremely important.
0:52:47 It's pricey, but it has to do with safety
0:52:51 and being able to use the park in a safe manner.
0:52:56 A lot of people use that.
0:52:59 I'd love to fund the dog park upgrade and the tennis and pickleball courts, but I just think
0:53:08 that the skate park infrastructure, I mean we call it skate park infrastructure and I
0:53:14 kind of look at it as the park lighting that's not there and it is very dark and it's also
0:53:22 in front of residences that are there that would probably benefit from the lighting and
0:53:31 the safety factor.
0:53:36 So if we couldn't do, if we had to pick from the three of them, my first choice would be
0:53:42 the park infrastructure.
0:53:45 And if the dog park doesn't get funded, I'm just curious, and maybe this is not a question
0:53:57 that can be answered right now, but is there any funding anywhere else that we
0:54:02 could get from for that if there are any grants that we're unaware of or
0:54:06 anything like that? Madam Mayor. Yes. So I want to challenge the Council a
0:54:13 little bit. Yep. It's always important for the City Manager to challenge the
0:54:16 Council during his review time, right? I mean that's that's always called job
0:54:20 security. Yes. So one of the things I would ask for you to do is when you make
0:54:28 make your funding decision, make it based upon your intention to complete a project.
0:54:38 Because we have a lot of half completed projects where we have individuals that will
0:54:44 approach us and they will say, this is really important and as an organization say, we agree
0:54:49 with you and we're going to fund a piece of it.
0:54:53 And then we fund I think more than $100,000 or close to $100,000 on some level of engineering
0:55:00 at some level of effort and community interest and we get some portion of the community's hopes
0:55:05 up and then we say yeah we're going to find something different and whether that be the
0:55:12 dog park or whether that be Harmon park I don't believe that you can hit and say well we're just
0:55:21 going to do this this year without creating an expectation that you're going to follow through.
0:55:27 So with the infrastructure that's not just for the skate park, that is for
0:55:35 Harmon Park and if the rest of the infrastructure does not get completed
0:55:39 for 10 years we still have the lighting that is at the park. No doubt and we
0:55:46 always have the Baxter plans that we can dust off and move forward. What I'm
0:55:51 sharing is you create an expectation of stakeholders that will say this is an
0:55:58 an important project because. And I just want you to be mindful that as you continue to have
0:56:04 these conversations, I mean, be aware of the slopes that you may be choosing to navigate.
0:56:13 Well, the other issue I have is by committing to a phase of Harmon, that's a $3 million project.
0:56:23 So somehow, at some point in time, it has to be completed.
0:56:29 In a sense, they're both not different.
0:56:32 I mean, you, you not, you was at council,
0:56:37 and there could be interchanging faces
0:56:38 throughout the entire process,
0:56:40 authorized planning documents for both of those projects,
0:56:46 both Harmon and the dog park.
0:56:48 Both of those were funded through a process
0:56:51 that involved the council and through the council
0:56:53 support to be able to say move forward. Then when we get to a place, we see the cost of the projects
0:56:59 and we go, do we want to spend $600,000 on a dog park? Do we want to spend $3.2 million on
0:57:09 Harmon Park? Is that the highest and best use of our funds and what does that look like?
0:57:17 When Wendy first came as the Parks and Rec director, one of the things that I challenged her with was
0:57:24 to complete a park. G hopefully is nodding because one of the philosophies we had was
0:57:32 well maybe we'll build a restroom in this park and we'll build a basketball in
0:57:37 this park and we'll maybe fix a swing set over in this park and yet we were never
0:57:43 completing a park. We were doing a little bit to appease some but really what we
0:57:49 were doing is we were making most angry because we can never follow through and
0:57:53 get things done. So I asked Wendy, I said, can we just start completing the projects? I know
0:57:58 what I've asked that same challenge of the council is, we have met long-term planning
0:58:02 members that will use this conversation tonight and they will use to help determine what are
0:58:09 we going to fund next year. And if the council directive is fund X, we as a staff may come
0:58:20 back and say it's not a council priority to fund Y. And when long-term planning doesn't
0:58:28 support it, it comes back and we find ourselves on the merry-go-round that we are at this evening.
0:58:35 And I'll jump in a little bit different train of thought but I think it's going to lead a
0:58:40 lot of people's minds to maybe where your comments may lead to people's minds. I don't like the idea
0:58:46 of Peace Mealing Harmon Park. It's not efficient for city staff's time and then when it comes to the design
0:58:51 and construction there may be economy of scale if it's one package and I think there's some public
0:58:55 I think there's some public perception too about we're jumping around, kind of chasing
0:59:00 shiny things but not finishing anything.
0:59:03 And so that leads me away from doing anything at Harman Park right now, not saying that it's
0:59:09 not maybe a very high priority next year or something, but I think this year we need to
0:59:14 decide to either wrap up some loose ends elsewhere like Baxter's Park or never do anything at all
0:59:20 in the future.
0:59:21 I'd be, yeah, that's my thoughts on that, so thank you for bringing that up, Travis.
0:59:28 Okay, so Sherry, are you done?
0:59:33 Or do you have anything else?
0:59:35 No, but yes.
0:59:36 Yes, you're done.
0:59:37 I just think the safety of the lights.
0:59:40 I understand the completion.
0:59:42 I'm done.
0:59:44 Okay.
0:59:45 Grayson.
0:59:46 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:59:48 I have three things.
0:59:49 I'm going to go right to
0:59:51 Commission or sorry Councilman
0:59:54 Keller good for a question. Thank you. So on
0:59:59 Escape Park like I think I'm with you on that
1:00:03 Like because that's gonna be a three million dollar project and then maybe Travis could wear it way on this but the tennis and pickleball courts
1:00:10 that's
1:00:12 400 and to resurface everything and lights and then we have that done right so that's a phase
1:00:20 So, I'm kind of inclined to go with that, if that's correct, and Wendy, will you jump down here?
1:00:33 So, for the tennis and pickleball courts, we're at 388-375 for new lighting, new servicing,
1:00:40 we're good to go. And then you restored an amenity with why it's added to it. Parking lot's not done,
1:00:50 but that's not a problem. You'd have a full completion.
1:00:56 Hey Madam Mayor, I'm going to throw a huge grenade into the meeting and I'm going to make
1:01:03 a motion that we approve the street light grant startup, the pull line mediums redesign,
1:01:09 the city of emergency operations planning, city hall emergency plan, building plan, commercial
1:01:13 air service marketing, station one architectural design services, fire tenor truck, additional
1:01:20 costs from the original bid, school resource officer from the Alveda cabinet, including
1:01:25 partial funding 10% wage and pre-benefits for three months,
1:01:30 Carter kids, and resetting the senior system center.
1:01:33 Hey, there's the motion to have a second.
1:01:39 So what we have right here on the screen,
1:01:43 you've approved these leaving out those three that we'll still discuss.
1:01:46 Yeah, so what I'm saying is I'm not including
1:01:50 the skate park and Baxter's.
1:01:53 So look at his spreadsheet.
1:01:56 So, you've...
1:02:00 He's not including the tennis courts.
1:02:03 I'm including the tennis courts.
1:02:06 Okay.
1:02:07 So, there's a motion on the floor.
1:02:10 Is there a second?
1:02:11 I'll second that.
1:02:15 Just a quick discussion, if that's all right.
1:02:17 Yeah, I'd like to discuss it.
1:02:18 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:02:19 So, understanding if we put the tennis and pickleball,
1:02:23 it kicks out backsters.
1:02:27 That almost sounded really bad.
1:02:29 Yeah. I apologize.
1:02:31 It was very close.
1:02:32 a rough day today. All right. No pun intended. Yeah. It ultimately removes that one. So the
1:02:40 only other one that would be able to be in there is the skate park based off of what we
1:02:44 currently have in. Yeah. So my motion on kicking out the skate park infrastructure and I'm
1:02:49 kicking out Baxter's. But the infrastructure was the only other thing that we could fund
1:02:56 based off of what our budget is. Correct. We couldn't. And I will tell you the reason
1:03:01 that I'm leaving that out just because it's going to cost us three million to
1:03:04 finish it up to Spencer or sorry councilman colors point about starting
1:03:10 projects that we're not fulfilling and I totally my thing would be is if we're
1:03:15 gonna put Harmon Park in there that the tennis and pickleball courts we should
1:03:20 start also if we're gonna move down that road which I'm in agreement with with
1:03:25 Harmon because three million dollars on the budget that the city has will take
1:03:30 multiple years it is not something and maybe next year we're going to have that in the
1:03:34 budget I don't know that's next year something we need to discuss but it's a multiple phased
1:03:41 approach to it Madam Mayor I'll entertain amendment from Councilman Reed okay let's not
1:03:48 get too complicated because I don't even think we were quite done with discussion sorry so
1:03:52 Chris that was discussion on this amendment correct Spencer because I have a couple things
1:03:59 to say. I needed a clarification about lights, so there's two Harmon Park projects on this list.
1:04:05 Lights have been talked about for both projects, so can you confirm is there a lighting, improved
1:04:11 lighting with both projects, and which of those, if that's the case, which is more important for
1:04:16 safety right now? So the tennis courts both sets currently have lights on them. So the Harmon Park
1:04:26 tennis court and pickleball would add lights on those courts if you added that
1:04:33 35,000 which I think is what Altsman Stone was talking about and that would
1:04:39 light those courts. The Harmon Park, Skate Park, and I think maybe to get rid of
1:04:46 the word infrastructure and talk about lights is adding sports lighting to that
1:04:51 area around the current skate park. So one lights the tennis courts and the
1:05:01 other would light the skate park and some of the parking lot. Is there a
1:05:05 suggestion by staff that one is more important than the other for safety for
1:05:09 lighting or is it just it's two separate conditions and they're both important?
1:05:15 It's it's hard for me to prioritize in my feel like getting that Harman Park
1:05:22 skate park things started. This is one that was an easy bite because it kind of
1:05:28 generates some interest in it and maybe helps us get funding for other parts of
1:05:32 it. The skate park is or not park the tennis courts are frustrating to me because
1:05:38 that's an amenity that we've identified needed some work, we budgeted for it, we've
1:05:43 had a hard time getting it to happen and right now they're just sitting there
1:05:46 With weeds growing on them, they're not playable.
1:05:49 And so one is restoring in amenity.
1:05:54 The other is having some lighting.
1:05:57 So I'm not answering your question because I don't know the answer either.
1:06:01 No, that is helpful.
1:06:02 I can see that picture now.
1:06:04 And yeah, I'd be less inclined to start infrastructure for something else that we are
1:06:09 pretty seriously committed about following up with the more inclined for the tennis courts.
1:06:14 But I think I still go back to my vote alone.
1:06:18 I probably vote for Baxter's Park and do nothing at Harmon Park at this point and prepare a
1:06:24 package deal in future budgets.
1:06:27 And I'm going to agree with you, Spencer.
1:06:30 One of the things I remember is that Baxter Park was a citizen-driven request, and we sat
1:06:38 here.
1:06:39 Most of us were here when the citizens came to us and said, and it's horrible.
1:06:44 I've been out there, so I know what the park looks like.
1:06:48 And so my question is, we started it,
1:06:51 when are we gonna finish it?
1:06:56 That's, I'm struggling with that.
1:07:01 A lot of people have dogs and I constantly get calls
1:07:04 about it and the people that brought it to us
1:07:08 are curious where it's going.
1:07:10 So, hey, any other discussion on this motion?
1:07:19 Can I just say something about, well, never mind.
1:07:23 I'm good.
1:07:24 Okay, so the motion.
1:07:26 I'm gonna talk bad about dogs, so I did that
1:07:29 a few years ago, didn't end well.
1:07:32 So the motion is to support the projects listed
1:07:37 under the supported project column,
1:07:41 or a total of 776-335,
1:07:46 And that includes the tree grant pull line,
1:07:52 Harmon Park tennis courts with lights and pickle bar courts,
1:07:57 or emergency operations plan, commercial air, station one,
1:08:01 fire truck, school resources, carter kits,
1:08:04 and the siting project for the senior center.
1:08:09 And the motion was made by Grace and Stone, second by Chris Reed.
1:08:13 So one more time for any discussion,
1:08:16 or we can have a roll call vote.
1:08:20 You have anything to add to us?
1:08:27 If you do not allocate the money in the right column,
1:08:36 the extra $358,000, it will sit in contingency.
1:08:42 Correct.
1:08:44 And can be used later.
1:08:47 Yes, something comes up.
1:08:48 You can be used throughout the entire fiscal year.
1:08:50 Okay.
1:08:58 The motion that's on right now
1:08:59 is the limiting three projects right now, correct?
1:09:02 No.
1:09:03 No.
1:09:04 Okay.
1:09:05 I thought his motion was supported.
1:09:07 Project included the 388 or the tennis and picklebar course.
1:09:12 Okay.
1:09:14 So do I need to read?
1:09:16 Can I add some just real quick?
1:09:18 So I agree with everything.
1:09:19 I'm still struggling with the 388.
1:09:22 I'm probably going to mote both the motion down on my side because I think those three projects
1:09:27 I don't think we need to have a conversation on that's where I'm sitting on that.
1:09:32 I'd like to approve everything else with the exception but I understand what the motion
1:09:36 is.
1:09:39 Great.
1:09:40 This is a big, beautiful budget.
1:09:43 He's been dying to say that all night.
1:09:47 It's really a tough one.
1:09:53 I wish we could fund all of them but I would probably be in favor of where we're at right
1:10:00 now. Hey, Chris, you're still up. Do you have one more thing?
1:10:08 Ultimately, I would like to use the rest of it. So if we want to
1:10:11 vote on it right now, or I would like to do a mended and add the
1:10:17 the Harmon part infrastructure. However, you guys would like to
1:10:21 move forward. But I don't think Travis, it would be cleanest
1:10:26 with an amended motion.
1:10:30 Madam Mayor, I sponsored the motion. I will accept the
1:10:32 amendment.
1:10:33 So, what is the amendment?
1:10:35 If the amendment that I heard or understood Councilman Reid to share is that he would like
1:10:42 to also add the 385, that is correct, I would like to amend it.
1:10:51 So that puts us over.
1:10:54 And you could use, it means you're tapping more into the contingency fund that has, who
1:11:01 would have a balance of about $250,000, which is larger than the contingency that we usually
1:11:06 carry.
1:11:07 That's another like almost 30 grand, 27,000.
1:11:13 I see.
1:11:14 Sorry.
1:11:15 I'm going off of these numbers that we had the lights for the, okay, the lights for the
1:11:21 tennis court and pickle bar were added in on this one.
1:11:24 Yes.
1:11:25 Okay.
1:11:26 I'm not going to vote in support of the men's lives, but my original emotional support,
1:11:29 but I don't know your amendment.
1:11:31 Okay.
1:11:32 So, are we amending the motion or are you withdrawing your amendment?
1:11:36 I'm withdrawing for right now. I don't want to go into the motion.
1:11:45 Okay. So, the motion is column D for a total of 776-335. Any further discussion?
1:11:57 Okay, Rachel Rocha-Volt.
1:12:01 Ruth Pierce.
1:12:02 No.
1:12:03 Chris Reed.
1:12:04 Yes.
1:12:05 Ray Cawkins.
1:12:06 Yes.
1:12:07 Jason Brown.
1:12:08 No.
1:12:09 No.
1:12:10 In Grayson Stone.
1:12:11 Yes.
1:12:12 Okay.
1:12:13 So three yes, four no.
1:12:17 Motion fails.
1:12:18 Okay.
1:12:20 So, somebody wanted to attempt another motion.
1:12:27 Spencer.
1:12:28 Yeah.
1:12:29 I'll make another motion, but I'm going to throw a councilman read a lifeline first.
1:12:32 I'm going to get you out of hot water.
1:12:35 I didn't hear the comments you made about dogs.
1:12:37 I didn't.
1:12:38 That's the problem.
1:12:39 I voted against it.
1:12:41 original design and people think I hate dogs. Well, I'll jump in hot water anyways. I like dogs.
1:12:48 Everybody knows I like dogs. Dr. Amazing. Chris is going to the dog. Go ahead Spencer. I'm just going to say I don't understand the appeal of pickleball so I'm just guaranteed I'll never get re-elected.
1:13:00 Wow. How about safety is very important right? That's right.
1:13:07 So I'll make a motion so if we got our spreadsheet pilot over there so that we add Baxter's Park
1:13:23 upgrade to this remove the Harmon Park tennis and pickleball courts and then the other items
1:13:33 would stand the same.
1:13:36 Thank you.
1:13:38 Do I have a second to that?
1:13:43 I'll second.
1:13:44 Thank you.
1:13:45 think I hate dogs. Motion by Spencer Cutler, seconded by Jason Brown to approve
1:13:53 supported projects for a total of 982, 960 as listed in column D. Any further
1:14:00 discussion? Chris? I'll just make a comment real quick. I understand what Travis was
1:14:07 saying completing a project. Totally get it. It's interesting because all of the
1:14:11 conversations I've had around dog parks are we need a dog park on this side
1:14:16 of town. We need a dog park on this side of town. We need a dog park over here. And so I understand
1:14:21 that Baxter Park might not be the greatest park in the world. But we're looking at close to $600,000
1:14:29 on a dog park when our skate park doesn't have lights. When some of the current infrastructure
1:14:38 that we have at other parks is failing. So I get it and I totally understand but this is kind of a
1:14:47 a monster that we will continue to feed where that is quite a bit of money for a dog park
1:14:54 when some of our kids are playing potentially on not the safest as well. So that's what I'll say.
1:15:02 Did you have a comment Travis? Madam Mayor I just learned and like I said you learned something new
1:15:07 every day. I just learned that the new design for Vista Benita Park includes a small dog park.
1:15:13 You will make some people very happy.
1:15:15 Hopefully it's not $600,000 for it, though, okay.
1:15:20 Okay, any other discussion?
1:15:24 Rachel Roquevo, please.
1:15:29 Ruth Pierce?
1:15:31 Yes.
1:15:32 Grace Reed?
1:15:32 No.
1:15:33 Craig Hawkins?
1:15:35 Yes.
1:15:36 Jason Brad?
1:15:37 No.
1:15:37 Spencer Cutler?
1:15:39 Yes.
1:15:39 Barry Fulmer?
1:15:40 No.
1:15:41 Grace and Stone?
1:15:42 No.
1:15:44 Motion fails, three to four.
1:15:48 Okay, let's see who's up next Jason
1:15:55 But I'd like to just get the ones that we all agree on off of the off the table if we can let's do it
1:16:02 So I'd like to make a motion. Can you just add the third one in and
1:16:09 Go around the horn
1:16:11 Then we'll go back to the original one
1:16:13 move on so I would like to approve the column that says supported projects in
1:16:22 the amount of three hundred eighty seven thousand nine hundred and sixty dollars
1:16:25 do I have a second on our spreadsheet column D do I have a second I second thank
1:16:32 you motion by Jason Brown second advised Spencer Cutler to approve
1:16:36 $397,960 of supported projects as listed in column D. Any further discussion?
1:16:49 Rachel Roquevo, please.
1:16:56 Yes. Craig Hawkins.
1:16:58 Jason Brown.
1:16:59 Yes.
1:17:00 Spencer Cutler.
1:17:01 Yes.
1:17:02 Sherry Volmer.
1:17:03 Yes.
1:17:04 And Ruth Pierce.
1:17:05 Yes.
1:17:06 Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero.
1:17:08 So half of us like dogs.
1:17:10 Half of us like cats apparently.
1:17:12 My God.
1:17:13 Okay, so Jason, are you still up?
1:17:21 Oh, no, I'll take it off. I'm still trying to get my mind around this whole thing.
1:17:26 Hey, Madam Mayor, if I may, can we table the other three or do we have to have those done by August 25th?
1:17:38 Like, theoretically, we could table this until we are...
1:17:44 I'm like figuring out what?
1:17:46 Yeah, well, we have those three things, right? And obviously we're like throwing out versions of this.
1:17:51 I think we're in an impasse, so we could theoretically write Travis, just say on the 25th, we could come back and
1:17:59 we vote for it, or no. That's not a promising look.
1:18:05 You could. Matt Barnes would prefer that you got it done this evening.
1:18:11 This evening then.
1:18:13 But if you are unable, so when Matt came to my office today and he said, the Council's going to allocate that right, and he said,
1:18:19 we're certainly going to try. But there's no guarantees.
1:18:22 And I think that we're certainly going to try.
1:18:24 You've tried.
1:18:27 You have, if you only use the 770,
1:18:30 you have about $382,000 left if you also
1:18:34 include the additional amount that
1:18:36 was included in the Intangency Fund.
1:18:42 And it would leave a contingency fund balance of $250,000.
1:18:48 You have about 747.
1:18:51 There is nothing that says that you
1:18:52 have to maintain a contingency balance of $250,000.
1:18:57 Typically, we've held that at about $150.
1:19:03 I would rather have that buffer.
1:19:05 So I would make a mirror.
1:19:07 Yes, go ahead, Chris, please.
1:19:08 OK.
1:19:09 I move that we fund the Harman Park, Harman Skate Park
1:19:13 infrastructure.
1:19:16 And I also the Harman Park West Tennis and Pickleball
1:19:22 Courts minus the lighting for it, bringing it down
1:19:26 for 351,500.
1:19:40 That puts us at 10 under, correct.
1:19:49 Councilman Reed, it needs to be seconded.
1:19:52 We need a second.
1:19:53 I'll second it.
1:19:55 Okay.
1:19:56 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grayson Stone that we approve the projects.
1:20:03 The two additional projects of Harmon's Gate Park infrastructure for 385 and Harmon Park.
1:20:11 and Harmon Park, Tennyson Pickleball
1:20:14 course for 351.5.
1:20:18 OK, discussion?
1:20:21 Councilman Reed, question.
1:20:23 So if we knock off the infrastructure,
1:20:27 and then we just, like, to your point,
1:20:29 about not half-assing anything, which I don't even
1:20:31 know if I can say that.
1:20:33 I said it.
1:20:34 Perfect.
1:20:34 Kind of like backstage.
1:20:35 We just do the Harmon Park, Tennyson Pickleball
1:20:37 course, do it right with the lighting and everything else.
1:20:40 My preference would be we do that,
1:20:42 than just the infrastructure on the skate park.
1:20:46 With the lighting, we just do it correctly.
1:20:50 I don't disagree, but with the funds that we currently have,
1:20:54 we can make this work.
1:20:55 And currently, we've had tennis courts there for years
1:21:00 without lights.
1:21:02 Do we currently have lights?
1:21:04 OK, Mitch is telling me we currently have lights.
1:21:06 We will lose the lights.
1:21:08 Or we wanted to upgrade the lights.
1:21:10 We're upgrading the lights.
1:21:11 We were going to upgrade the lights,
1:21:12 so that's what that was.
1:21:13 That was great.
1:21:14 But we currently could leave the lights in place. No, we have already pissed off everybody that had a dog
1:21:18 And now you're gonna
1:21:22 Why do we have to ask Wendy Wendy exactly why do we have to take the lights if the lights are
1:21:30 Not on the pickleball and tennis court number
1:21:34 There will there continue to be some sort of lighting just not upgraded lighting is that what that means?
1:21:40 No, I don't think so, and I would need,
1:21:42 I can go talk to John Leisure about that,
1:21:44 but the lights are old.
1:21:47 Those are the ones that have the wires
1:21:48 that string in between them.
1:21:50 Right.
1:21:51 And he's said that we can't,
1:21:53 because we thought we were just gonna be able to save them.
1:21:55 I think that's why originally our number didn't include that
1:21:57 until John said no.
1:21:59 So the old lights are there, they work,
1:22:05 but maybe they're not hazardous.
1:22:07 So the preference is just to upgrade the lighting
1:22:09 while we're doing that project.
1:22:13 because they do not think the city electrician
1:22:15 is going to allow us to salvage the old lights.
1:22:19 So when we do the work, if they come down,
1:22:23 or we're not going to be able to continue to use them,
1:22:25 but I can double check that.
1:22:27 Yeah, I could question that.
1:22:28 And then I'm gonna just push right back at you.
1:22:30 Okay, so we have like 10% down on a project
1:22:35 that's gonna cost us almost three and a half million today.
1:22:39 We're only gonna drop 400,000 in it.
1:22:42 So let's just and then over the next several years,
1:22:44 we can continue to work on Harmon Park
1:22:46 as we've done on other parks.
1:22:49 Yeah, that's true.
1:22:52 But we don't bite off three million one year.
1:22:55 No, I got you.
1:22:56 So there's a motion on the floor right now
1:22:59 for adding infrastructure at 385,000
1:23:03 and pickleball and tennis courts at 351.5.
1:23:08 Is there any further discussion on that motion?
1:23:11 With the exception of the lighting, correct?
1:23:13 without the lighting, yes.
1:23:18 No more discussion.
1:23:23 Wendy, did you have something?
1:23:30 I was just checking to see if there was a thought
1:23:32 that John might answer his phone if I called him,
1:23:34 but I could try him, just to try to get an answer
1:23:39 on those old lights to see if there's any way.
1:23:43 But not lighted courts wouldn't be the absolute end
1:23:47 of the world.
1:23:49 Thank you.
1:23:50 Okay, so there's a motion on the floor.
1:23:53 Is there any further discussion before we vote, Craig?
1:23:57 I just like to say that for the most part, I think the busiest time for tennis courts and
1:24:03 pickleball courts is in the evening because it's cooler.
1:24:08 And that's something I think we need to take in consideration.
1:24:11 So anyway, I just want to bring that up.
1:24:15 Can I add just one comment that does stay at Light Tilt 9, 9, 30?
1:24:21 I mean, the park does close at 10, 10, 30, 11,
1:24:30 way off on that one, but it does stay light
1:24:35 much later when they're being utilized.
1:24:41 Okay, so there's a motion on the floor.
1:24:43 Any further discussion?
1:24:47 Rachel Roach, call vote.
1:24:50 Ruth Pears.
1:24:53 Yes.
1:24:54 Chris Reed.
1:24:55 Yes.
1:24:56 Harry Cawkins.
1:24:57 Yes.
1:24:58 Jason Brown.
1:24:59 No.
1:25:00 Spencer Cutler.
1:25:01 Yes.
1:25:02 Yes, in Grayson's Stone.
1:25:03 No.
1:25:05 Okay, motion passes five to two.
1:25:09 Okay.
1:25:10 We good?
1:25:13 Okay.
1:25:14 Thank you, everyone.
1:25:18 So that is end of our items of consideration.
1:25:21 Next is the time for general public input.
1:25:25 If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on the budget first,
1:25:32 we'll do that first.
1:25:35 And then we'll have general.
1:25:36 Is there anybody here that wishes to address City Council on the budget?
1:25:40 Okay.
1:25:46 Seeing no one.
1:25:47 Is there anybody here that would just like to address the Council on any general item,
1:25:53 not on today's agenda?
1:25:58 Okay.
1:25:59 Seeing no one.
1:26:01 Advisory Board reports.
1:26:02 Yes, Chris.
1:26:03 We have an air show this weekend.
1:26:05 So very excited.
1:26:06 Saturday and Sunday.
1:26:09 The air show will be happening.
1:26:11 These tickets, it's all online, but it should be an amazing event. We have the Blue Angels. I think they might even be in town right now, aren't they are?
1:26:19 They are. Hey, Travis, did you have something else to add? Okay. Yes.
1:26:28 I just wanted to mention the Police Department had the National Night out this past week, and it was a lot of fun. I thought it was pretty well attended, and people seemed to really enjoy themselves, so it's a good job.
1:26:40 Good night. Yes. Okay. Anybody else? Anything from the City Manager's office? Right.
1:26:57 So a couple of things for the Council. We look forward to first. As you continue to work through,
1:27:03 we do have two more conversations potentially on the budget on the 25th. You'll adopt the budget.
1:27:09 We will host our public hearing. We will not be meeting on September 2nd,
1:27:13 which is the Tuesday following Labor Day. And we will be having the state of the city address
1:27:19 at 7 a.m. on September 3rd at the Second Street Market, the location we've had
1:27:24 the last couple of years, and we will also be closed on Labor Day, September 2nd.
1:27:30 Okay, thank you. Okay, so we have two public hearings. Do we need to take a
1:27:38 break real quick? Madam Mayor, on the public hearings, we would ask that you
1:27:44 to flip the order, published agenda, so that item B, which is the annexation of the zoning
1:27:54 goes first.
1:27:55 Okay.
1:27:56 Don't know, Brad.
1:27:57 We're good.
1:27:58 Okay.
1:27:59 So this action item is a request to City Council on the appropriate zoning district for
1:28:07 a proposed annexation on property generally located on the east side of the intersection
1:28:13 of Kimberly Road or Highway 30 and Champlain Way 3300 East, care of Champ LLC and we have
1:28:21 Will Claver, our senior planner before we will, let me read the public hearing procedures.
1:28:29 Council will follow these steps listed under the public hearing portion of the agenda.
1:28:34 City staff will present the request and analysis.
1:28:37 The applicant will then present their request.
1:28:41 will then ask questions of the applicant or staff. After questions have been asked, the
1:28:46 public hearing will be opened. During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity
1:28:51 to comment or ask questions about the request being considered. When giving public testimony,
1:28:58 please step up to the podium, state your name and address and present your comments or concerns.
1:29:04 After giving testimony, please sign the public sign-in sheet located in the lobby upstairs
1:29:10 with your name and address for the record.
1:29:12 After public comments are concluded,
1:29:14 the applicant will be invited to answer any questions
1:29:16 and make a closing statement staff will then answer,
1:29:20 clarify any comments as needed.
1:29:23 After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed.
1:29:26 No further testimony or comments from the applicant
1:29:29 or audience will be allowed.
1:29:31 And then the council will have open discussion
1:29:33 and take action on the request.
1:29:36 Okay, Will.
1:29:37 Thank you.
1:29:41 Could we get the things Rachel?
1:29:47 Okay.
1:29:48 So today we have an annexation of approximately,
1:29:52 or annexation request of approximately 230 acres.
1:29:57 The property is located on Kimberly Road.
1:30:01 There's several parcels here,
1:30:03 three or four, get into that in a little bit.
1:30:07 But general location is east of Chobani.
1:30:10 It's a very far east portion of our city limits.
1:30:14 In May 2025, so earlier this year,
1:30:18 we just went through an annexation request
1:30:21 to, or sorry, a comprehensive plan amendment
1:30:24 to add this into the planning boundary.
1:30:29 That included putting, amending the water service boundary
1:30:32 along this portion of the area of impact
1:30:37 or the area east of the city limits.
1:30:41 And we, the council ultimately chose to adopt the planning boundary of industrial, a south
1:30:54 of Kimberly Road and then mixed use to the north of Kimberly Road.
1:30:59 That process was to continue the designations that were re to the west.
1:31:07 The current zoning, current jurisdiction is the county.
1:31:12 That's why we're going before you for the annexation.
1:31:16 The, let me get to the aerial.
1:31:20 So the east is a little industrial commercial park
1:31:26 that is in the county jurisdiction.
1:31:32 The south is railroad tracks,
1:31:36 and then to the north is a residential subdivision
1:31:39 coming into the boundary.
1:31:41 When discussing this with the Planning and Zoning Commission,
1:31:45 the Planning and Zoning Commission only looked
1:31:47 at what was the appropriate zoning designations,
1:31:51 not necessarily if the council or if we should annex it
1:31:55 and they looked at the zoning designations.
1:31:57 They found that this was appropriate,
1:31:59 the C1 along the Kimberly corridor
1:32:05 and then roughly 600 feet,
1:32:08 more or less, they would have it be the M2 zoning designation.
1:32:16 There is a, that's the exhibit did not come in.
1:32:21 Let me go up here.
1:32:23 So there is a plant exhibit that I apologize
1:32:29 to not make it into this portion of the presentation.
1:32:34 However, I do believe it is in the packet that he received.
1:32:39 The, there's a exhibit of where we're looking for roads,
1:32:43 cause this is a large area area.
1:32:46 And to have collectors roughly quarter mile to half mile.
1:32:51 To do that, we were hoping to line up with Wayne Road,
1:32:56 which is right here.
1:32:57 And then it would go somewhere like here,
1:33:01 then would ultimately connect to a potential crossing
1:33:09 along Champlain Road to this general section, but when in condition number three I believe
1:33:18 I'm going to put that up, yes in condition number three when I'm talking about the exhibit, this
1:33:31 is what I'm talking about, so a road would go somewhere around here and then another road
1:33:37 at 3750 North would continue and then would go up and then would end somewhere around here,
1:33:45 where the developer and the city don't know exactly how this would develop.
1:33:54 It's a little cleaner for us to get the right-of-way and construction when they
1:34:00 develop the property not necessarily at this time as if they need to move the road
1:34:06 or if we need to move the right-of-way then we have to go through a vacation process
1:34:09 process, which is a long timely and somewhat complicated process that we wanted to avoid.
1:34:16 So the condition would read that they need to construct and dedicate right away in the
1:34:23 collector's road sections at the time when they are developing that portion of the property.
1:34:32 Number one is that prior to the, prior to annexation,
1:34:43 signing of the ordinance,
1:34:45 we're recommending getting the right-of-way
1:34:47 for Champlain Road that we would need.
1:34:52 Condition number two is at the time of development,
1:34:54 they would build Champlain Road to that arterial
1:34:56 or to the section that the city engineer
1:35:00 has decided at that time when they develop.
1:35:04 With that, as far as the zoning goes,
1:35:10 that has no problem with the M2 and C1 designations
1:35:13 as proposed, but with that,
1:35:16 I'll stand for any questions that you may have.
1:35:19 Thank you, Will.
1:35:20 Any questions for Will on this particular item?
1:35:26 Okay.
1:35:27 Okay, Gerald Martin's the applicant is here.
1:35:29 Okay, welcome, Gerald.
1:35:40 Thank you.
1:35:41 For the record, my name is Gerald Martins.
1:35:43 I'm here this evening to represent applicants of this property.
1:35:49 We have reviewed the staff report.
1:35:52 We know that this is about a third of the way
1:35:55 through the process.
1:35:57 We have had several contacts from users
1:36:05 that were triggered, I believe, by the signs that have been out
1:36:08 here and the fact that this property is now
1:36:12 available because of the ability of the
1:36:16 city to provide the necessary services.
1:36:20 At this point in time we do not know exactly who those users are
1:36:24 or what the configuration will be. The rail spur
1:36:28 and the rail spur is a big issue.
1:36:32 Rail use I think is difficult to come by
1:36:36 to come by, and we've got at least two users. One is recent as today, and a couple of them
1:36:44 before that, that are really focused on the rail spur and how the rail spur will work.
1:36:55 There is continued expansion, as you know, taking place by Shabani, and the people that
1:37:02 Why Shabani and they are players in this game.
1:37:07 So where we go from now that we know we can be annexed into the city.
1:37:13 We will be determined where the roads will be and determine how we can
1:37:18 dedicate those right-aways.
1:37:20 But we do concur with the concept, the staff report that we know
1:37:28 which ampled roads not going to move, so that is going to be fixed.
1:37:34 We can deal with it right away, commitment on that.
1:37:39 That obviously any development cost will be paid for by the development when a developer
1:37:44 is nailed down, who the users will be, the interior roadways are dependent upon the size
1:37:51 of the users.
1:37:52 really dictate the size and the configuration of the rail spur. We have a demand for rail
1:37:59 spur that exceeds the amount of rail frontage we have currently. So that may be an internal
1:38:05 loop or something we're working through. But I think the language in the staff report
1:38:12 is flexible enough that we can work through that. The other big issue that is really
1:38:21 unknown is the Champlain Road, Kimberly Road intersection. That's already with Shabani and
1:38:30 Shabani's expansion plans a problem. And the turn lanes and the power structure out there
1:38:38 are issues that we're working our way through. But that intersection is going to have to be
1:38:46 a controlled intersection and we have to find the use and the traffic counts and the issues
1:38:54 to determine exactly the configuration of that but I think the language and the staff
1:39:00 report and the conditions allows the flexibility to work with engineering, to get a signal and
1:39:08 turn lanes and utility relook, it says necessary.
1:39:15 A big expansion, as you know, is occurring at Shabani.
1:39:18 That's going to bring in a lot more traffic into this area.
1:39:23 And to access a Shabani plant, potentially and probably
1:39:28 using Champlain Road for that access.
1:39:32 There's a lot of moving parts.
1:39:34 But the number one is being able to commit to the users
1:39:39 that the city is, we're in the city of Twin Falls.
1:39:42 We have city services available,
1:39:45 and we can work with city engineering,
1:39:47 the city economic development group
1:39:50 on developing this property.
1:39:52 So with that, we request your support
1:39:57 and approval of this application
1:39:59 as summarized in the staff report.
1:40:02 Thank you.
1:40:03 Thank you, hang on. Any questions for Gerald? Okay, thank you.
1:40:09 I can't disclose many secrets anyway.
1:40:21 Okay, so no questions. So I'm going to open up the public hearing.
1:40:25 If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address
1:40:29 City Council on this particular annexation,
1:40:33 please come down to the podium, state your name, and
1:40:37 express your thoughts and you have two minutes.
1:40:40 Anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on this issue
1:40:47 Okay, see no one I
1:40:54 will
1:40:55 Close the cup public hearing Gerald any additional comments
1:41:00 Will a so City Council ready for your discussion?
1:41:15 Okay, I may want to make a motion
1:41:18 motion.
1:41:22 Thank you Madam Mayor.
1:41:23 I guess you didn't address me.
1:41:25 I'm going to jump in here.
1:41:26 So the way it's presented now, it says on the appropriate zoning district for a proposed
1:41:31 annexation on the property, I'm assuming that's M2, correct?
1:41:35 It was the combination.
1:41:36 B1 and M2.
1:41:37 Okay.
1:41:38 So if I make the motion to say I'll make a motion to have the appropriate zoning district
1:41:45 for a proposed annexation be C1 and M2 on the property, generally located, is that the
1:41:50 best way to do that or you can just say as outlined in the proposal and remember
1:41:56 there's some three conditions as well okay Madam Mayor I'll make a motion that
1:42:01 we approve the zoning district for proposed annexation on property generally
1:42:05 located on east side of intersection community road highway 30 in Champlain
1:42:09 3300 east care of Champ LLC PZ 25-0015 with staff recommendations
1:42:19 Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
1:42:21 I'll second.
1:42:22 Thank you, motion by Grace and Stone, second by Sherry Vomer to approve the appropriate zoning
1:42:28 district change for proposed annexation on property generally located on the east side
1:42:33 of intersection of Kimberly Road and Champlain Way with the three conditions outlined by staff.
1:42:42 Any further discussion?
1:42:45 Rachel Rolcovo, please.
1:42:47 Chris Reed.
1:42:48 Yes.
1:42:49 Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, Spencer Cutler. Yes, Jerry Bulmer. Yes, Jason Stone. Yes, and Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Will.
1:43:01 Hey, next item on the agenda is an action item request for a recommendation for a zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10 items to include our regulations pertaining to landees conditions.
1:43:20 Here are City of Twin Falls, PZ24-0121, and we have our tag team, Jonathan and Will.
1:43:31 Welcome.
1:43:34 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the Council.
1:43:36 We're going to get prepared here.
1:43:38 We have a few exhibits to show and talk about.
1:43:43 So I'm just going to say buckle up.
1:44:12 We've got some time here.
1:44:13 We're going to spend together, and I'm going to start with this version chart that will
1:44:20 fill the space with here, all right.
1:44:26 So this is a lengthy chapter.
1:44:29 This is chapter four, which talks about every land use
1:44:32 and the entitlement of the uses
1:44:35 across all of the zoning districts
1:44:37 that we are proposing within the city.
1:44:39 On the left-hand side, you're gonna see
1:44:41 our existing zoning districts.
1:44:43 Every zone that we have, including all of the overlays.
1:44:47 So you'll see some familiar numbers, letters, et cetera,
1:44:51 with their official names.
1:44:53 The middle shows the proposed changes, a couple of things to eliminate, and the changes are
1:45:00 in blue, which is on the right-hand side.
1:45:03 And then the last column concludes with what we will have at the end of the day.
1:45:09 And as you'll note, there's essentially four things missing from the right-hand column that
1:45:14 are on the left.
1:45:15 Two of them are eliminated, so the other two we have to, you know, what did we do?
1:45:19 We combine them into one district and we'll go through that.
1:45:26 Many of them are just being renamed to things that are found within our comprehensive plan.
1:45:31 Town neighborhood being what we call things in the comprehensive plan and then we have
1:45:36 some things that are going to be just changed to make a little bit more sense or that are
1:45:41 mimicking the comprehensive plan language.
1:45:44 When you have your comprehensive plan amendments or changes, you end up wanting to have your
1:45:47 regulations be very closely aligned with that so that you could determine whether
1:45:51 things comply with it or not. So one thing is currently we have on our
1:45:57 comprehensive plan a commercial and we have highway district commercial over
1:46:02 here and we sometimes it matches and sometimes it doesn't we have mixed use
1:46:07 some places like we saw today along Kimberly Road do we have a mixed use
1:46:12 zone not really we're going to in the future but what else could actually go
1:46:17 go into that so commercial ends up being the one that has a mix of uses that pretty closely
1:46:21 aligns. So what we have is some things that got combined into one district. Old town is
1:46:27 one of those that's just in the old town warehouse type area. Frankly, it didn't allow
1:46:33 warehousing. It was a really weird thing that they wrote. That's where it was located but
1:46:36 it didn't allow warehousing outright. So we put all of that into the central city district
1:46:41 which is a central part of our city. And then we have mixed use where the commercial
1:46:46 residential mixed uses got combined into a mixed use district. Therefore you have
1:46:50 what we have left over here on the right-hand side. Town neighborhoods one through
1:46:54 three. I'm skipping HAG and rural residential those are actually usually
1:46:57 outside city limits so we don't deal with those are just part of an area of impact
1:47:00 agreement. Central City commercial two industrial districts open space airport
1:47:05 mixed use. College of Southern Idaho has its own district. I can't hear them over
1:47:09 the district which you're familiar with. A new type of thing which is a community
1:47:12 market, that's a combination of the residential business or a change from residential business
1:47:17 to community market. And then we have our parking overlays that we're taking into two instead of three,
1:47:24 and then we're keeping the professional office overlay district. So as we're referencing things,
1:47:30 those are the things you'll be seeing within the matrix that I will now move to. So if you,
1:47:36 I can keep this up if we have any questions, but we're going to move to the matrix here.
1:47:42 So, you have the overlays along the top that deal with your land uses.
1:47:51 What you won't find up here is like a zoning development agreement because those are separate
1:47:55 agreements.
1:47:56 It's not actually a district per se.
1:47:59 It's like an overlay type of thing, but it's really just an agreement that we have on
1:48:02 property.
1:48:03 You're going to see a new type of thing here.
1:48:08 We have permitted uses.
1:48:09 We have special uses in what we're calling zoning administrative review or zoning use permits,
1:48:15 we can have SUPs and ZUPs, the Z would be administrative review that we do in-house.
1:48:23 So that's a new thing that we do not have right now. Currently, we just say it's permitted
1:48:28 or you get a special use permit for it or it's not permitted at all. So we added that
1:48:33 Z and that was a directive that we received from Council to streamline some of the items
1:48:38 that could be reviewed in-house by meeting certain code sections. So I'm going to go through
1:48:45 this generally and then Will's going to make sure I hit about eight or nine of
1:48:51 the highlighted ones that we know we were going to touch and change but I'm
1:48:56 going to show you how this will work. This will be in chapter four and it
1:49:02 will show anybody the use that you have the category that it's in and then which
1:49:08 zoning districts you're allowed to have that land use and it's either permitted
1:49:13 by right or you get the special use permit or you get the administrative permit, if it's
1:49:18 not, if there's nothing in the box, it means it's not permitted there.
1:49:23 As we go along, either today or in the future, changing out a P or an S into a blank space
1:49:30 is easy.
1:49:31 So we just added in, if we find that it's what that we want to where people can request that.
1:49:37 If you add a Z, it's a little bit more complicated because we need to create the conditions that
1:49:41 you want to see.
1:49:42 So we've gone through this and had conditions set up for a lot of different scenarios, but
1:49:49 not everything.
1:49:51 And I'm going to get to the first one on the list, and we'll just going to remind me
1:49:56 because I can't remember standing in pre-blank as a first one.
1:49:59 Okay.
1:50:00 One of the bigger ones that we had to deal with, which was indoor recreation, something
1:50:06 that we've had has been separated into multiple uses.
1:50:11 So currently, if you were a yoga studio or you were a nightclub or bar ahead music, you
1:50:18 were into recreation.
1:50:19 That's what our current code says.
1:50:21 We separate that into event centers.
1:50:23 We've actually separated into three different ones based on the occupancy or the occupant
1:50:30 load of the building.
1:50:32 That ties directly to the number of people attending, the parking that gets associated
1:50:37 with it and the size of the building and basically the disruption that we feel like is going to happen.
1:50:42 So that got separated into three different types. It's under 100 people. It could be a zoning permit
1:50:49 in multiple locations. And that isn't always like a nightclub, it's just an event center that you could
1:50:55 host parties or weddings or corporate events, that type of stuff. And then we'd have some
1:51:03 corresponding conditions. If it's a convention center, we felt like that was a public hearing
1:51:08 in all of the areas that it could possibly be. Then you have something in the middle that we split,
1:51:15 which was conditional in our more heavily used districts, commercial industrial, but special
1:51:22 when you got into a mixed use or downtown. Because that 100 to 500 people is a fairly large building
1:51:29 still and it still requires a fair number of parking spaces and so you have a public
1:51:33 hearing for certain areas. Everybody following how that is going to work in our intention with
1:51:39 indoor recreation for that part. We separated out like the yoga studio and the fitness club,
1:51:45 we made that something different and I can go through each one of those if you'd like.
1:51:48 This is just to get the concept of this.
1:51:50 Okay.
1:51:53 In one comment, if you read the table left to right so open space to CSI, the thought process
1:52:01 This is open space is the most protected, while the right side to industrial two, airport
1:52:08 and CSI special districts, but from open space to industrial two, it goes from like most protected
1:52:15 to you can do more uses, more intensive uses as there, it goes.
1:52:22 So it's kind of a gradient.
1:52:24 The one exception is the mixed use and the CMT, the community market, that should be flipped,
1:52:30 But that's generally how this table works.
1:52:32 If it's not OK for T and 3, it's typically not OK for T
1:52:36 and 2.
1:52:38 That's the general thought process.
1:52:41 OK.
1:52:43 Thanks, Will, for the chapter 4.
1:52:46 This is where you actually get the regulations.
1:52:48 And I'll zoom out here in a second.
1:52:51 Is set up to the first section, anything that
1:52:55 gets a zoning used permit.
1:52:56 So these are the administrators by staff reviews.
1:52:59 So all of these things have to be exact and very
1:53:01 specific so that all we are doing is making sure someone is following the rule.
1:53:05 There's no discretionary decision-making unless there's an administrative
1:53:09 determination if the language isn't clear. We'll get to that on a different day.
1:53:13 But every zoning use permit is going to follow A, B, and C right here, which is we
1:53:21 have a landscape buffer and then you have non-residential income or community
1:53:26 market industrially kind of carve those out. We've made sure that exhaust fans and
1:53:31 and then if you have a use permit, you've got to submit just an application to us.
1:53:36 And with that, we believe there's a 4-2 is also there.
1:53:43 Everybody has to have the required improvements.
1:53:50 When I'm saying required improvements, this is a specific we're talking about curb gutter sidewalk, storm water, trash enclosure,
1:53:59 walk, stormwater, trash enclosure, all of those things we've talked about when you
1:54:05 have a new building, you put those things in. Now that's gonna be important to
1:54:09 remember 1042 because later we exempt that requirement out of some of these
1:54:13 things. We have to put we put it in there to blanket everybody does it and then
1:54:16 we're gonna exempt some things out and I'll show you in a minute. But that's what
1:54:20 1042 does is everybody has to put in those required improvements whenever
1:54:23 there's a zoning use permit. I'm gonna skip down to what you see was the event
1:54:30 center just as a talking point. So this was the major and minor event centers and
1:54:35 these are the criteria that we had created and this generally out follows as we go
1:54:42 through all of these types of uses. We're gonna be similarly worded or we hope they
1:54:47 are simply worded as we look through it a bunch of times. Particularly with with
1:54:51 major ones. Any area with outdoor event operations, I'll be screened within 300
1:54:57 feet of residential user's own. So if you're in the community market and you have
1:55:04 an event center and you're within a certain distance of people's houses, you're
1:55:08 gonna screen those outdoor operations. Beyond that distance, you don't have to
1:55:13 screen it. If you're gonna have outdoor sound, get a special use permit. It's
1:55:18 actually what the current code says today and outdoor sound can be intrusive to
1:55:22 people. And then if you have any alcohol served, it needs to be facilitated by a
1:55:26 a valid alcohol license.
1:55:31 Gotta do that anyway, but we're just gonna put it in there.
1:55:36 The miner is similar.
1:55:37 We added some other things on the time for minor ones
1:55:45 and the reason for that, forgive me for swapping
1:55:48 between screens and only a few.
1:55:50 Minor, because they are in certain areas
1:55:56 with the zoning use permit, they're in that community market
1:55:59 and the rural residential, they're closer
1:56:02 people's houses. Therefore, we wanted to put a time limit on them specifically if
1:56:06 they're going to go through that permit process with us. Otherwise, most of those
1:56:12 places are going to be governed by like selling about, call their out to you know
1:56:15 they're done at a certain time. So this just says one half hour before sunrise,
1:56:19 one half hour after. Every time of day that I mean time of year it is just you're
1:56:25 done on the outside stuff. I'm gonna look for like we got the gist of how
1:56:32 those gonna work. We're not gonna have to go through every single one of them. We're
1:56:34 going to hit the highlights. That is how this zoning use permit criteria will work as you
1:56:40 see those. Everything else is just like our code in terms of special and permitted uses,
1:56:45 except we've now added a definition for every land use that we have. We did not have that before.
1:56:51 Every one of these has a definition to it. Some of them, like the major and minor, we've included
1:56:58 occupant loads and that's designed occupant load to be part of that so we can see the
1:57:03 intensity of how they're being, how they function.
1:57:11 The next one.
1:57:14 Oh, right.
1:57:24 Yeah, the indoor rec ones split up.
1:57:25 We have event centers we did,
1:57:29 trying to get down.
1:57:30 We did bar and bar night clubs,
1:57:31 smoking lounge, which are very similar.
1:57:33 So that'll be a separate use,
1:57:35 health and fitness facility.
1:57:37 Health and fitness is here for major and minor,
1:57:40 and the definitions are dealing with how big they are,
1:57:42 like a small yoga studio is going to be minor,
1:57:44 and that's going to be permitted in more places
1:57:47 than like a bigger one.
1:57:49 the other one. And then fun centers, my favorite definition, all about just fun. Yeah, we call
1:57:56 it fun center. And I think it's down the wreck. Yeah, down here. We have fun center, major
1:58:02 minor and then a fun park is when you have multiple things. So we felt like the definition,
1:58:08 we had a big argument for a few years as to some recreation, you're really just there
1:58:13 to have fun. So we just called the fun center me the definition. So indoor recreation is
1:58:18 now all of those different types of things that are more specific and permitted in more
1:58:22 areas whereas right now the yoga studio gets a special use permit because they happen to
1:58:27 have music being played and our definition into recreation says if you have music inside that's
1:58:32 kind of that works as part of the operation so it'll be a lot easier for a lot of these
1:58:38 things to be to be done. Right, what's after that? Oh, okay, religious facilities currently
1:58:50 are especially used in every single zone.
1:58:54 I'm just like Travis, sometimes challenges,
1:58:58 and I'm going to say some hard things,
1:58:59 like religious facilities as a special use
1:59:01 are fraught with problems, because it's
1:59:04 a discretionary decision, but there's
1:59:06 some federal regulation called our LIPA, Religious Land
1:59:10 Use Institutional Persons Act.
1:59:13 You don't want to mess with it, and there's a city,
1:59:16 and I'd hope actually with the court case currently when
1:59:18 they denied one for a religious facility.
1:59:21 And my advice, and the advice most often is mitigate the impacts,
1:59:28 and religious facilities should just be an administrative type of use or permitted.
1:59:33 We've made them a zoning use permit in basically neighborhoods.
1:59:38 When you're in a mixed use or commercial zones are permitted,
1:59:42 and what we get out with that is really distance, outdoor, any kind of outdoor music type of stuff,
1:59:48 and then the size and the parking.
1:59:52 When they're really large, we want them to be on collectors, not within a neighborhood.
1:59:56 So if they're in residential, they just say, hey, access the collector so that you're not accessing somebody's neighborhood street.
2:00:04 So that's really what that zoning use permit is going to get at.
2:00:09 It's right here.
2:00:11 Access off collectors, materials, if they're greater than 300 or greater, it's 25 feet from residential use, side obscuring non street frontage property lines.
2:00:25 And then you can have outside music,
2:00:27 unless you're especially permitted.
2:00:29 And something interesting about the religious facility
2:00:31 is the first time that we get into conditions specifically
2:00:34 for two districts and then conditions specifically
2:00:37 to residential.
2:00:39 So we get a little bit more of my newton, more detailed,
2:00:41 into really defining what that context is,
2:00:45 what a residential context is.
2:00:47 This is the way to mitigate those impacts.
2:00:49 For our community market and airport districts,
2:00:51 these are how to mitigate those impacts.
2:00:54 So it's really tailored to those contacts.
2:00:58 The only difference actually between them
2:00:59 is you can't have amplified sound outside in the residential
2:01:03 district where you can if you're in the community market
2:01:05 or airport.
2:01:08 OK, what was the next one, the list, fuel charging.
2:01:21 We kept drive-throughs as special uses.
2:01:24 The commission basically said that they wanted
2:01:26 to keep it as special.
2:01:27 That's a recommendation to you.
2:01:30 If you wish to make it a zoning use permit,
2:01:32 we can certainly do that.
2:01:34 But if you'd like to keep them special,
2:01:35 we're going to keep them special, even though, yeah,
2:01:38 I'm not even going to get into it.
2:01:40 I'll just skip that one, okay.
2:01:42 Fuel charging station is something we haven't had
2:01:45 necessarily otherwise.
2:01:46 I mean, we've just been calling them gas stations,
2:01:48 but they're not just gas stations anymore.
2:01:51 And so fuel slash charging stations,
2:01:53 the impact of having charging in a large parking lot
2:01:58 is similar to like a fuel station.
2:02:00 And so we've made them special in the community market,
2:02:04 those places that are closer to people's homes,
2:02:06 but when it's commercial, we're just, we create,
2:02:10 we made it a zoning permit,
2:02:12 and we can kind of deal with the impacts of them,
2:02:13 and I know you guys have all of these with you,
2:02:16 so I'm gonna go through each of the conditions,
2:02:18 but we have conditions for them that can be updated
2:02:22 or changed to be find issues with them.
2:02:25 I know one of the issues that we've talked about
2:02:28 with our fire department is like spill prevention plans
2:02:32 that we haven't always gotten those,
2:02:34 But when you have charging stations,
2:02:36 they believe there might be other types of things they need
2:02:42 when they have multiple vehicles with battery fires.
2:02:44 That could be a problem.
2:02:45 So that's something that we've talked them about.
2:02:47 We just didn't have all that criteria
2:02:49 if we had multiples.
2:02:50 So it's something we have talked about.
2:03:00 Pack grooming, which is basically your dogwash type of stuff.
2:03:07 And I'm going to have Will remind me why we were going
2:03:09 to talk about that one other than the pure volume
2:03:13 that we get as special use permits for pet grooming
2:03:16 is really high.
2:03:19 And so we figured to streamline our processes,
2:03:23 to streamline applications, there is certain conditions
2:03:25 that every time that we got a petting grooming facility,
2:03:30 the commission would always put on it.
2:03:32 But we figured if they're the same,
2:03:34 why don't we just have those P standard conditions
2:03:37 and in the appropriate areas,
2:03:40 we can have them be permitted by right
2:03:42 are permitted with the condit zoning use permit.
2:03:46 What is the one special use, the only S in there?
2:03:50 What's the community market?
2:03:51 So that's like near neighborhood.
2:03:54 Essentially, the community market is the intersections
2:03:57 of arterials and collectors near neighborhoods.
2:03:59 That's where those are kind of about.
2:04:01 Base camp on the Base Camp gas station.
2:04:04 Got it.
2:04:05 And we did put a caveat.
2:04:08 You can't do peg grooming for livestock.
2:04:12 or generals we were gonna have that and then so
2:04:15 i know that's a thing but
2:04:17 uh...
2:04:17 i think
2:04:18 we desert
2:04:20 do that where you keep the horses not
2:04:22 don't bring them to town then wash them
2:04:24 anyway
2:04:25 i know we have to think of these things you did i don't
2:04:29 don't like horses
2:04:30 i love horses just don't like the waste from horses
2:04:34 doesn't like dogs
2:04:37 here we go
2:04:38 okay probably not lost control
2:04:41 I know there's anything before we move on from this.
2:04:44 So the whole section four is called commercial sales and services.
2:04:50 In our current code, it's actually two categories.
2:04:57 Retail sales and then services.
2:05:01 That's important because now they are in one category rather than two.
2:05:06 and in our current code with required improvements,
2:05:11 if you go from a retail to a service,
2:05:15 then the required improvements kick in.
2:05:18 We kind of eliminated that.
2:05:21 Part of the reason for that is a lot of the uses
2:05:23 are very similar.
2:05:25 They kind of get interjected.
2:05:28 You can say it's X or you can say it's Y,
2:05:31 and you could find them in the retail or the service.
2:05:34 It just depends on how you looked at it that day.
2:05:38 We wanted to combine them all into one
2:05:41 and just make them one clean list.
2:05:44 This is a big offering, I guess,
2:05:48 to the community in terms of that.
2:05:50 There will be fewer times where we have to get
2:05:53 curb gutter side duct.
2:05:54 The other way to think of it is we won't get it as often,
2:05:56 but it is a sticking point for a lot of businesses
2:05:58 that are just trying to start up going
2:06:01 from what was an office to what was like a hair salon
2:06:04 or what was a restaurant.
2:06:06 They're in different categories or areas.
2:06:09 And so this just is you're all in one.
2:06:11 You don't have to provide those service,
2:06:13 those things anymore.
2:06:17 So there's some downside to it,
2:06:18 but it's also one of those things.
2:06:20 We've had a lot of questions on why we do it that way.
2:06:23 And so we've read to just one commercial sales and services.
2:06:29 The next item we talked about was retail,
2:06:31 and that was one that we've separated
2:06:34 into three different things.
2:06:36 and these are based on, again, this is occupant load,
2:06:39 which ends up being small shops to Walmart.
2:06:44 So the retail shop is that traditional,
2:06:46 it's less than 5,000 square feet or so,
2:06:49 and it has 50 people or fewer.
2:06:50 Those things are less impactful in these zones,
2:06:55 particularly the mixed use commercial downtown,
2:06:59 commercial along the major arterials,
2:07:02 And we made it a zoning permit for those very small stores
2:07:06 in the community market where we want them to be
2:07:08 close to people's houses, small entrepreneurial type things.
2:07:12 And there's some conditions that were pretty strict
2:07:15 and stringent on some of those,
2:07:17 because they are closer to people's houses.
2:07:19 When you get into the minor store,
2:07:22 which ends up being larger,
2:07:24 it's when you get to your 100 to 150 people
2:07:26 or over 50 to 150.
2:07:28 So we need a bigger parking lot.
2:07:30 It's when you're gonna have external things.
2:07:33 We kept that special in that closer area
2:07:36 to people's houses, but permitted on the commercial highway
2:07:38 like they were.
2:07:41 And they've got some smaller things
2:07:44 if you're within a 300 feet of residence
2:07:46 then get a specialist permit for it
2:07:48 because those impacts of somebody picking up the trash
2:07:51 or somebody trying to deliver goods at four or five
2:07:55 in the morning, those things can impact people.
2:07:57 So we're trying to mitigate that,
2:07:59 but also allow them to happen a little bit easier.
2:08:02 And if you're a major store, you can't have a giant Walmart
2:08:06 in a neighborhood market or a community market,
2:08:08 we're not messing with that's for.
2:08:10 And they're special in the mixed use.
2:08:12 And in, I think it's down below central city.
2:08:15 So if you have a giant store downtown,
2:08:16 we're gonna have you get a specialist permit.
2:08:18 They're still permitted where they were before.
2:08:21 Generally, most of these things are just gonna be
2:08:23 a little bit easier in those spots closer to people's homes,
2:08:26 where you can have really that community market feel.
2:08:29 That's a big change first particularly downtown and in those neighborhood areas the next is daycare facilities. Oh boy. Yeah, okay
2:08:41 There are three
2:08:44 daycare
2:08:45 Currently, we just have like daycare as like one thing in the city
2:08:50 We put our definitions more in line with the state and the state has I
2:08:56 Know they just changed them again a little bit
2:08:58 But the definition was still the same as to the number of kids that they had
2:09:01 So, the daycare home is anything six kids or fewer.
2:09:07 And those currently are special use permits.
2:09:12 And I can't believe it's any other way.
2:09:14 We see a lot of controversy with those in terms of I don't want to discount anybody's
2:09:21 feelings when there's one next door and they usually end up being very just emotional for
2:09:28 all people involved with the current direction that we've heard slash seen from the state
2:09:36 in the legislature in trying to get more daycare available
2:09:39 because of another shortage,
2:09:41 we took the bold step to make those just permitted.
2:09:45 Six or fewer kids, we do get those applications
2:09:50 so they have to bring form to us to sign
2:09:56 or whether it's permitted or not by local code.
2:09:59 So we see those ones, we know the number
2:10:02 because they declare how many.
2:10:04 So if you have a daycare home,
2:10:06 We feel that they should be permitted six or fewer kids
2:10:10 in these areas.
2:10:13 Once you get to a daycare facility that goes up to 12 kids,
2:10:17 that's what the state says, over six and under 12 kids.
2:10:20 And we've created a zoning use permit for that
2:10:24 so that we can have some look at,
2:10:32 oh, sorry, I would probably did.
2:10:34 Go on, go back, right there it is.
2:10:43 And we just wanted to see them.
2:10:45 So they have to provide us everything
2:10:48 in the first section of the zoning use permit.
2:10:52 So at the very top of those applicable to everything,
2:10:55 they have to provide us some type of screening
2:10:57 and landscape offer.
2:10:59 They can't have exhaust hands,
2:11:00 and they need to provide us an application.
2:11:03 The next portion is we didn't feel
2:11:06 that they needed to provide us all the required improvements.
2:11:09 That's a huge barrier for someone taking care of six.
2:11:13 12 kids. We need daycare in our community so we felt that was too much to ask. That's never been
2:11:19 required in the past for these type of facilities. So we decided this would be appropriate one
2:11:27 to exempt. You send in essence they give us their plan and if they don't operate within their plan
2:11:34 people could ask us to reevaluate it and check it and we can revoke these zoning use permits.
2:11:40 there by revoking the ability to go from 6 to 12. They just have six or fewer. And
2:11:49 then the center is anything larger than 12. I'm going to pause on this one so
2:11:58 we can have any questions. Raising your name is up. Is that left from before? Did
2:12:07 you have a question? No thank you Madam Mayor. So I have two things. One on the
2:12:10 recreational facilities. Why aren't we allowing that all the way through
2:12:14 commercial all the way through industrial one and two? Which recreational facility?
2:12:19 You guys are calling to invest but event space but like gyms and like sports training like there's there's nothing outlined in here
2:12:27 Sports training and so some people will call to school
2:12:31 It looks like it's been defined in here as health and fitness if though and we're permanent and permanent and what's the
2:12:41 One correct don't think this one is but let me check
2:12:45 Nope, that's commercial. Yeah
2:12:47 My question is why isn't allowed in all three and then the other thing is I would love to see drive-throughs
2:12:53 Not allowed in the CRO or north of Poland is that
2:13:03 Change like it's a little drastic
2:13:07 Kind of a big deal, but I will answer the first one another second
2:13:13 The major the major definition of health fitness really is a big one, okay, so those are
2:13:20 large ones that
2:13:22 I have a larger demand on parking in area.
2:13:25 It's not smaller facilities,
2:13:26 and I'd have to go and get into the definitions
2:13:28 to go into that, but it was to have that escalation,
2:13:32 and that could easily be changed and permitted.
2:13:34 I mean, just say, you know what, we're okay
2:13:35 with those big ones being non-special
2:13:38 or just permitted in the commercial zone.
2:13:40 Currently, all of them are special uses.
2:13:43 So we went with just a gradient.
2:13:46 I'm happy to change it from a P, her an S to a P,
2:13:49 and that's fine.
2:13:50 If we wanted to create any type of zoning permit,
2:13:54 we could try and do that as well if we needed to.
2:13:56 I would leave that discussion, but then I would go to.
2:13:59 But if you want to talk about the drive-through
2:14:00 and the CRO zone, the only thing I would say is
2:14:04 the Kenner overlay, we tried to take the uses out of that
2:14:08 as it was more of a setback and a aesthetic thing
2:14:13 in terms of, we took the uses away
2:14:19 because the uses were not being utilized that way.
2:14:23 They were getting PUDs and everything else along the rim.
2:14:26 So everything has been permitted through a PUD type of thing.
2:14:30 But we could certainly, that's why the CRO is not
2:14:33 on the land use table anymore, because every single stitch
2:14:36 of those properties are zoned to something,
2:14:38 and then the CRO was limiting them further.
2:14:42 When they were 700 feet from the rim, there was no,
2:14:45 we felt there was no, by evidence,
2:14:48 to not allow some of those uses there.
2:14:51 And I think that not having that CRO on that table
2:14:53 is a big issue for me.
2:14:57 I don't know if anybody else caught that, but it's
2:14:58 going to be a topic.
2:15:00 Because we took the uses out of it earlier in a previous
2:15:04 and then from the CRO.
2:15:05 Oh, yes.
2:15:13 OK.
2:15:15 Leave that up for your discussion.
2:15:16 What was the next one?
2:15:27 Industrial building for financial.
2:15:30 Now we are at the accessory dwelling units,
2:15:33 an accessory building conversation.
2:15:40 accessory building is first. Currently, the code reads the best of my memory, accessory
2:15:48 buildings that are under 1000 square feet in the R2, R1, R2, and our four districts,
2:16:00 they're permitted following the setbacks, which is three feet from property lines on
2:16:05 the sides and three feet on the back property line when you're not on a road. If you're
2:16:11 in a bigger area you can have up to 1500 square feet and that's the footprint of
2:16:16 the building not two-story type of thing. We've received a fair number of complaints
2:16:22 about two-story accessory structures 35 feet tall, three feet from property lines.
2:16:28 That does happen, that's happened, it's not a fair number, a number of times.
2:16:33 Trying to mitigate that is difficult to put into words and we've put what you're
2:16:41 reading here, Will and I understand, probably doesn't make sense to a lot of people because
2:16:47 it's not super easy to follow. The idea is, if you are a certain height of a building,
2:16:55 we want you to just use the main building setback. So if you can build a house in the location,
2:16:59 then you can build over 15 feet tall in that location as an accessory building. That's
2:17:05 really the intent. As we've received from Planning and Zoning Commission, this wording is not clear
2:17:10 on what that means. It just reads side yard is three feet for buildings 15 feet tall or
2:17:17 less or same as primary or building if accessory height is over 15 feet. So it's a little bit
2:17:23 worthy. The real intention is if you're over 15 feet, put it where you can build your house
2:17:29 and the setbacks for the district are going to be generally it's either 5 feet or 7 feet
2:17:33 on the sides and either 15 or 20 feet in the back. And then you can go up to 35 feet tall
2:17:39 and that's the height of the house that could be built there.
2:17:42 That's what we're after.
2:17:44 Don't believe the words in there actually adequately
2:17:46 describe it, so most garden sheds are under 15 feet tall.
2:17:51 Most things are.
2:17:52 It's when you get into your accessory shops
2:17:54 that end up having that 18 foot tall door
2:17:56 to have an RV in it, or they have two stories.
2:17:59 That's when they get over 15 feet.
2:18:01 We were deliberate in the 15 foot tall
2:18:02 because that's usually where you can get a wall.
2:18:06 I'm looking at like from the building perspective
2:18:08 can get a good pitch on the roof for a garden shed. That was the intent. You don't have to
2:18:15 get a building permit for anything under 200 square feet as long as it's one story. That's
2:18:19 for the building code. And so we're kind of stuck with if it's single story. We exempted
2:18:26 these zoning permit for all of these things, which is under 200 square feet single story,
2:18:31 it's only for storage. Nobody's living in it. And then you just follow the setbacks. And then
2:18:37 if it's in easement, you just have to move it if you're in violation.
2:18:43 So this is a complicated one that's written to allow people to not have to get special use permits all the time.
2:18:51 For a shop that just happens to be 1,000 square feet or bigger, some people have larger properties, some people have smaller ones.
2:18:57 And we wanted people to be allowed to build a building to the height of the district.
2:19:02 But minimizing that impact to their neighbors by having them put it where the primary building could be already.
2:19:09 And that is the intent of the accessory building, which is just your sheds and shops.
2:19:18 Those types of things are also exempted from the required improvements.
2:19:22 So curb gutter sidewalk, they used to have to do it when you had a special use permit,
2:19:27 and now we're going to say you don't have to do that on your property per the code.
2:19:36 That's what's, if they meet all these things, right, it's on F.
2:19:44 I'm going to pause for any questions on accessory buildings or shops slash shits.
2:20:00 I'm going to bring back to you as different language in the final version that explains
2:20:04 what I have, but it might look different from this because as we've got different people
2:20:09 not us read it, we're like, yeah, that doesn't make sense.
2:20:13 So we're going to do better.
2:20:15 All right, accessory dwelling units.
2:20:20 This is brand new.
2:20:21 We've never seen this before.
2:20:23 These would require zoning permit.
2:20:26 I can tell you before I get through all of it, here there is an item that was forwarded
2:20:33 by the Planning and Zoning Commission,
2:20:34 their recommendation is to strike the owner occupancy
2:20:39 requirement and the number of occupants.
2:20:43 That's why we highlighted in yellow.
2:20:44 So their recommendation is to not have those two items
2:20:47 and so a parking would become item six.
2:20:50 And so that was their recommendation.
2:20:54 Accessory dwelling units can come in many forms.
2:20:57 These are, this is a really good graphic kind of showing
2:21:00 kind of where they could be located on a property
2:21:02 within a property.
2:21:04 And we have a purpose, we added a purpose to this one
2:21:07 because we wanted to be clear on what we were after.
2:21:09 And that was to allow accessory dwelling units
2:21:12 about trying to maintain the integrity of the neighborhood
2:21:15 and make sure that they're done,
2:21:19 yes, tastefully, but that's different with the facility,
2:21:21 you know, just in a good manner that is a good and orderly.
2:21:24 So the criteria that's applicable to all districts
2:21:26 is you can have one, only one per legal lot or parcel.
2:21:32 And only if it's a single household dwelling.
2:21:34 So you can have a 4plex and then add access for dwelling units to it because those aren't single lot households
2:21:39 the size
2:21:42 We threw in a number at 45%
2:21:45 I'll tell you as staff we're not that set on that number. It's just it's less than 50
2:21:51 So if you have a thousand square feet 450 square feet
2:21:56 I've seen some in Idaho go up to 60% but I I've hardly seen anything above
2:22:02 That I think maybe there's 75% but as low as 25%
2:22:05 What do you see mostly in twin?
2:22:09 I don't see any aid to use legally established in twin.
2:22:13 What do you mean, Mayor?
2:22:16 What are people trying to do?
2:22:17 Yeah, that's what I meant.
2:22:19 We think most of them can meet because if you've got, this is going to be permitted
2:22:22 in most, in all of the zones.
2:22:24 There's not going to be a zone excluded if you have a single family home.
2:22:31 Our average or our median, we're talking about that median home.
2:22:34 I tell you about the starter homes are coming around 14 to 15 to 1500 square feet, but a lot of homes are
2:22:41 2000 or greater you can get a pretty sizable I say sizable the numbers work out as 45
2:22:47 But again that number could change however your direction, but I think 45 would meet most people's needs
2:22:53 You can build a dwelling unit in as little as I
2:22:57 Think I've done it with the building department like it's small had like 180 or 200 square feet, but that's like a
2:23:03 a very tiny bathroom, a very studio-ish, like it's super small, I mean generally you can
2:23:11 three or four hundred square feet is a decent ADU. In terms of just like a studio type or
2:23:17 one bedroom type of thing. The other way that you could do it instead of if you don't
2:23:23 want a percentage of the primary, you could have it just be a flat, I want it to be 750
2:23:29 max or thousand max or I don't think you want to do that but right okay just
2:23:34 wondering what what you're seeing that's my best guess okay this allows for if
2:23:39 you ever really big property with a real large house you could have a nice
2:23:42 footage in the back if they're attached so it's basically an addition to the
2:23:48 house just meet the principal residence requirement the height limit if it's
2:23:53 detached. We were pointing to the detached the accessory building, meaning if
2:23:59 you're going well taller than 15 feet, then you're gonna be set back from the
2:24:02 property the same distance as the house. That's what that intention was for the
2:24:08 height. Setbacks was gonna follow the principal building setbacks. That's really
2:24:14 where you just end up following the principal building setbacks because
2:24:16 most of them are gonna be taller anyway. I know we've had some questions on that.
2:24:22 We had some emails on that and some people discussion.
2:24:25 Not every property will be able to have an ADU.
2:24:28 Some of them are just going to be too small
2:24:30 for a detached one specifically.
2:24:33 If there's a home on the property,
2:24:35 if the home's legal non-conforming, we work through that process.
2:24:39 If the home is legal and they want to add on that would make it non-conforming or illegal,
2:24:43 we'd kind of work with them on what they could or couldn't do.
2:24:47 You've always have legal non-conforming permits, which is a public hearing,
2:24:51 and you have variants is if it's doesn't meet that one either. There's a process
2:24:58 set up for people to be able to do it but I fully admit not every single property
2:25:03 would be able to do one just like not every property can have 3,000 square foot
2:25:06 home on it so you end up having to have a smaller house. That's just kind of the
2:25:11 until we start working with it we won't see the issues any other we try to keep
2:25:21 the additional design criteria to a minimum. We want it to be consistent where it's consistent
2:25:29 as we can and some of that is going to be a little bit of a yeah it looks pretty close
2:25:33 to the house although beauty is in the eye of the holder so there's going to be some
2:25:38 things we might find to be the neighbor doesn't think is consistent but we find it to be and
2:25:44 there's a process to challenge those if we need to or if they are needed. We added one
2:25:52 parking stall for the addition for the ADU and the utilities need to be on the same primary
2:25:59 service lines as the house otherwise it's not accessory and then you basically have a split of the
2:26:07 building of the buildings from each other. I'm gonna sit here for a minute. So the number of
2:26:15 occupants allowed for a household unit to find in this title what is that number? Currently have that
2:26:21 But as four unrelated individuals, everybody, if they're related, just no matter the number.
2:26:29 My caution is that's our current code.
2:26:32 A lot of times those numbers and those things are not recognized when they're challenged,
2:26:37 meaning there's court cases that talk about you can't define a household by only those
2:26:44 that are related.
2:26:46 And so that was one of the reasons why the commission said, you know, if we're just going
2:26:53 to strike that.
2:26:54 Okay.
2:26:55 It's a difficult one to enforce, because we don't really enforce it with homes now, right?
2:27:01 It's difficult.
2:27:03 And there's been a number of times where the course system just says you can't define
2:27:07 a household or a family that way.
2:27:10 And so those types of charges end up being not part of it, and that's not usually part
2:27:14 of the issue, that's usually just one of the things. Really it ends up being there's a lot
2:27:20 of cars parked at this spot and they're parking in front of somebody else's driveway. That
2:27:24 is the act which is illegal or frowned upon, shouldn't park in front of other people's driveways,
2:27:29 or they're doing some other things, you know, they're loud, noisy places and you end up having
2:27:35 to deal with it otherwise.
2:27:39 owner occupancy there was a comment that somebody said not everybody owns it that
2:27:46 files a homeowners exemption whether or not we should change that to say sign
2:27:53 certified copy of homeowners exact exemption or other proof of owner
2:27:59 occupancy which I don't know what that would be but yeah cities that have this
2:28:04 in there currently are struggling with enforcement and they're coming up against
2:28:09 the challenge of when it changes hands and the owner is no longer occupying do
2:28:15 you enforce it by requiring the removal of the ADU and they're finding the most of
2:28:22 their legislative bodies or governing bodies are not willing to force or order
2:28:28 the removal of the ADU because you're removing real property from the home
2:28:35 which is I mean the opportunity that you rip out the kitchen or the bathroom or
2:28:40 and what do you do to make it no longer a dwelling unit?
2:28:43 And that's where I agree with the commission.
2:28:48 We have it in there because that was originally
2:28:50 our kind of direction and it is difficult to enforce
2:28:53 and some places are taking those out.
2:28:55 Well, and I think that's a lengthy discussion we had
2:28:58 is how do we enforce that?
2:29:00 And once the property changes hands,
2:29:03 how do we really enforce that?
2:29:05 Yeah, and if we know we're not willing to force them
2:29:07 into remove it out of the property,
2:29:08 then I would, my advice would be not to have it in there
2:29:11 in the first place and just have the other conditions
2:29:14 or create something else.
2:29:16 Because if somebody's, I was just thinking like somebody
2:29:23 rants to a traveling nurse a room, that's not owner occupied.
2:29:29 And we're not even looking at those.
2:29:32 Yeah, we don't regulate those necessarily
2:29:34 we're have a licensure for it.
2:29:35 Right.
2:29:36 So, okay.
2:29:39 There's nothing to say that that couldn't be just used
2:29:41 like for rental, the main homes of rental,
2:29:45 and then they wanted a second one, a second rental income.
2:29:49 But the utilities have to be.
2:29:51 Part of the original, yep.
2:29:52 Part of the original.
2:29:53 Yeah, we won't let them put in a separate water sewer service.
2:29:56 They have to be able to be talked to each other,
2:29:58 essentially from the water and sewer standpoint.
2:30:03 I don't have a problem with taking either one of those up,
2:30:06 personally.
2:30:07 Specifically the number of occupants.
2:30:09 I don't think you should.
2:30:10 The only occupancy I can, how much do we want to control it?
2:30:14 I think in a residential area, I guess right now in a residential area, I've always asked
2:30:25 the old, we don't have anywhere right now that prohibits duplexes though, right?
2:30:34 We don't have an R1.
2:30:35 R1 does allow town homes, not duplexes specifically, and so by taking R1 and putting it with R2,
2:30:43 they're going to be one district and all the similar types of things.
2:30:46 So is that going to be our town neighborhood one?
2:30:49 Yep.
2:30:50 be in R1 and R2, essentially an R2.
2:30:54 Okay, so we won't, there won't be any zoning
2:30:56 that we're gonna have to worry about then
2:30:58 if they do end up being two rentals.
2:31:00 Yeah, so you do have a minimum, no.
2:31:04 And they could still be an ADU,
2:31:05 as long as they meet this size requirement.
2:31:07 It's gonna be hard to regulate,
2:31:08 and I can see where we're going with this,
2:31:10 but I think your owner occupancy is up to,
2:31:16 definitely take out the number of occupants.
2:31:19 It would be nice to, everybody just kept it,
2:31:22 be nice, but it's the big.
2:31:26 Okay.
2:31:28 I'm trying to go through our list of, I since not hitting every single one, I'm trying to
2:31:34 find.
2:31:40 That's fine.
2:31:41 All right.
2:31:42 The next ones are actually in line.
2:31:43 So, attached single town homes or single dwelling units.
2:31:46 This was currently permitted in code, but is very weirdly applied.
2:31:50 I don't know, I don't know, it was added after, but there are, it's in the list in every zone
2:31:56 our one through our six.
2:31:58 what we've tried to create and they were permitted and they were permitted
2:32:02 through a essentially through a subdivision type of process. We've tried to
2:32:09 create a zoning permit that talks about those here and it's basically saying you
2:32:15 still go through that subdivision process which you've already created and it's
2:32:17 already set and it talks about the rear inside. I didn't do that. That says we're
2:32:27 done. Sorry, Jonathan. Okay, there it is. I didn't do anything, but okay. So it's
2:32:38 all admin. It is administrative is what we put it currently is anyway, so we
2:32:44 couldn't we don't want to make it harder backwards, but what we did was added so
2:32:48 that in certain areas you can't have large blocks of them. And what Will and I have
2:32:53 noticed in other places is you could have like 30 of these things in a row and
2:32:58 they have this look along a roadway that we kind of have one similar that's off a
2:33:04 ground view that's there they're actually only 12 long they just end up
2:33:10 being the same and it's a repeat of the same thing so we just in some districts
2:33:14 we want to just four per block and then you'd have a space you can have four more
2:33:18 in the town room they read one, two in CMT we put six.
2:33:23 We just kind of gradually put them into more intense areas.
2:33:28 Otherwise they're just gonna follow the subdivision
2:33:31 and the subdivision has a certain lot size
2:33:33 and then you can have a common wall.
2:33:35 We can just do this that we haven't had this kind of thing
2:33:37 before, but it is allowed currently in all of those zones.
2:33:41 We just made it into a permit that we could look at
2:33:44 and have this, basically this criteria.
2:33:47 And really, they located on an access to collector,
2:33:50 collector and arterial.
2:33:53 That's something we put in.
2:33:55 It's, right now it's written to be on those roads,
2:33:58 and we just said the access has to be there.
2:33:59 So you'd end up probably having like a rear driveway
2:34:03 with garages on the back.
2:34:09 Home occupations currently require a special use permit
2:34:15 for all of them.
2:34:17 Unless you don't have the money coming to your house.
2:34:21 As soon as you have anybody coming to your house,
2:34:22 you need to specially use permit per current code.
2:34:26 We kept home occupations and residential
2:34:28 because that's primarily what they are.
2:34:30 And we've created a list of items to follow.
2:34:37 And we exempted some things out of it,
2:34:39 just to make sure we were clear.
2:34:43 Can't have auto repair,
2:34:44 you can't have adult entertainment,
2:34:45 you can't have manufacturing type uses,
2:34:48 or anything that creates a hazardous or biomedical waste,
2:34:51 those similar classifications that we determined.
2:34:55 It's not exhaustive, but it's anything that really bothers
2:34:58 in the people next door, and we've had people ask
2:35:00 for some of these things as home occupations before,
2:35:03 that are more difficult in a neighborhood.
2:35:06 Otherwise, if people follow this list,
2:35:11 then we're gonna just review them internally.
2:35:14 They don't have to do the required improvements,
2:35:16 that's what this exemption is for again,
2:35:19 and we'll let you have your home occupation.
2:35:24 One conversation that we wanted to bring up was F.
2:35:28 It was a service to patients,
2:35:29 shall be arranged by a primary and scheduled
2:35:31 so that no more than one patron vehicle
2:35:33 is on the premise of it one time.
2:35:36 When we were reading this again, we're like,
2:35:38 well, what about dance lessons?
2:35:41 It would generally be okay with a home occupation
2:35:43 and we have been okay with home occupations
2:35:45 as dance lessons versus one lessons,
2:35:48 but that would prohibit it.
2:35:50 So maybe we have six in home daycares as was a thought process for us.
2:35:58 If we could get some input on that, that would be helpful for us.
2:36:03 Even if you have a point by appointment only, you're going to have crossover.
2:36:08 So you're going to more than likely have at least two.
2:36:11 So I don't think you can limit it to one.
2:36:16 maybe that's a per-case administrative.
2:36:23 By that mind, I just put six vehicles.
2:36:27 Okay.
2:36:29 Because then I know that the daycare is refined and you have most of the smaller scale swim lessons,
2:36:34 voice lessons, slash dance lessons in a house.
2:36:38 Okay.
2:36:40 We got to put something?
2:36:41 Yeah.
2:36:42 Okay.
2:36:43 And I know there are going to be some people out there that have never gotten,
2:36:45 especially these permits that we know are operating,
2:36:47 know because I know there's 50,000 people in the city and 13,000 properties, somebody's
2:36:52 doing it. In this case, we'll have a process to say here's the just follow this and you
2:36:57 won't have a problem. Okay. That will and I had this discussion of ones probably too few.
2:37:02 Yeah. More than six is going to be problematic. Yeah. I don't really have a good direction.
2:37:12 Six sounds good just because it follows in line with the daycare. I can see a lot of
2:37:19 home occupations that probably will never have the max of six.
2:37:23 Yeah, I think the majority of them is going to be one or two.
2:37:26 Yeah, yeah.
2:37:27 And that's really where we should regulate to not do it.
2:37:30 That alleviate the administration.
2:37:32 Okay, I made a note. We will change that.
2:37:35 The other item we were going to specific ones.
2:37:38 The hours.
2:37:41 We can talk about those.
2:37:44 We've created a wireless communication,
2:37:47 currently every wireless communication tower comes for special use permit whether
2:37:52 it's hours or anybody else's. We've created a list of items that we would like
2:37:59 them to do if they are going to be stealth or alternative design. We've seen
2:38:06 these in other places and sometimes they work and sometimes they don't and you
2:38:11 can Google stealth cellular towers if you want. These are some of the common ones.
2:38:15 And if somebody wanted to go that route, they could put them up in more locations through a zoning permit.
2:38:22 I will tell you a lot of the tower people will choose to tell towers because they don't like special use permits.
2:38:28 Public hearing element of it is unknown and it takes a lot longer.
2:38:33 So if we create a list of things that we're okay with being put up, a lot of times they'll choose it.
2:38:39 It might be more expensive, but they like, I think they'll choose it more often than they are now,
2:38:45 Which is we don't require them so they don't choose them at all
2:38:48 Yes, there's a bit of a joke in there that I don't think trees will work here at all
2:38:53 That's what I was and so I said if they have them that they have to put lights on them during the holiday season so
2:39:00 So do we have examples of stealth design right now? I do
2:39:06 You want to share it? Yep, and I can
2:39:09 We've seen designs of cactus, so honestly, they can put them in cactuses, they can put
2:39:22 them in silos, they can put them in um, religious facility like towers, um, the trees are common.
2:39:33 The ones that I think we don't have any in twin, though, we do actually do, um, not water towers.
2:39:44 Okay.
2:39:45 But the, um, the silos have them on top, the, um, the church that is outside city limits.
2:39:53 Reformed church?
2:39:54 Reformed.
2:39:55 The white one.
2:39:56 North east of town on the way to Shoshone.
2:39:59 There is set of towers in their tower in their area.
2:40:03 There's towers on top of, that are actually just a recreation or a painted the same as
2:40:09 more like a co-location on Lincoln, which one's Lincoln and Bikle.
2:40:14 I always get them confused.
2:40:15 One of the northwest part, they're on that stack,
2:40:20 their old coal stack, it's on the outside.
2:40:26 CSI has them inside or have them inside of their flag poles
2:40:32 on the baseball fields,
2:40:34 because they were really thick flagpole type things,
2:40:37 they were inside of that.
2:40:38 That would be a stealth tower,
2:40:40 I don't know if they kept them there,
2:40:41 but they used to be there.
2:40:43 So that would be a stealth tower.
2:40:47 So you're basically some of them are special use
2:40:49 and some are happening?
2:40:51 Yeah, so depending on the area, next to you's down and down,
2:40:55 and commercial and industrial, you
2:40:57 want to go in the neighborhood market, and we're like, yeah,
2:41:00 we're going to have to do a stealth tower in the Ag Zone.
2:41:02 They're not allowed in neighborhoods,
2:41:05 unless they're on, I don't want to get too far into it.
2:41:09 FCC actually preempts us on some of those.
2:41:11 So it won't that you will never see on the neighborhood.
2:41:13 They usually do like a co-location on top of a school
2:41:16 lights.
2:41:17 That's why all the high schools have them,
2:41:19 because you can do that through a co-location type of exemption.
2:41:23 But we didn't want to get into that in your existence
2:41:26 of being complicated with the FCC rules.
2:41:28 Really it was after are we OK with generally a stealth tower
2:41:31 designs like water towers, steeples, crosses, bell towers,
2:41:34 clock towers?
2:41:36 I can remove the trees and say we don't like the trees.
2:41:39 That was more of a joke that we had in there thinking
2:41:41 that it would be funny.
2:41:42 I think we have a tree on Kimberley Road somewhere, don't we?
2:41:47 I don't know if it's in our city limits, if it is.
2:41:50 Yeah, I'm trying to remember which road,
2:41:52 but I think it was Kimberley Road.
2:41:54 There's one you'll see.
2:41:54 That might be.
2:41:57 Trees usually don't work around here,
2:41:58 because they're not really,
2:42:00 but other things are possible.
2:42:02 Yeah, this one, once you see it, it really sticks out.
2:42:05 Yeah, I want them to put lights on it,
2:42:07 because that would be fine.
2:42:09 I had a question on this section.
2:42:10 I was curious about the logic.
2:42:12 So parking structures in the CSI zone
2:42:15 special use. I was curious why it's not just outright permitted. Is it an aesthetic
2:42:20 consideration? Is it the emergency response implications and not thinking
2:42:25 about? I think it just matched what the PUD said. I think we tried to match what
2:42:33 the PUD had or the permitted but we can take a look at it again and
2:42:37 I didn't notice this one until tonight. I thought we went through everything to
2:42:43 match the PUD more that was permitted. I'm not beholden to being the special or
2:42:50 permitted you by the way myself. If CSI has any thoughts on that I'll have
2:42:57 their administrators reach out to CD staff. Yeah an amendment to this is kind
2:43:02 of what we're doing right now too is just one at a time so it's pretty easy to put
2:43:05 the S to appear as something else. That was all the items we wanted to go through
2:43:11 specifically and everything else is you've had this for a little bit and if you
2:43:16 have any specific questions on the zoning uses or just like that item what's
2:43:20 logic some of them it'll be exactly that answer I just what we thought it was
2:43:25 did you have something in the beginning you wanted feedback on I'm trying to
2:43:33 remember if we did them as the time progressed right at the very top was do
2:43:40 we address every question that you had clarification I believe you did in my
2:43:48 mind. Okay. Oh, sorry. This is a note that I forgot to bring up my apologies. But on
2:43:57 mortuary and conditions, one of our commissioners wanted to add a condition that talked about
2:44:06 distance from schools and residential. What is it now? Right. It's H right there. And
2:44:27 The only thing that we're saying in addition to the above so the landscape buffers would
2:44:33 be that the activity relating to the dead shall be handled discreetly and rescreened from public
2:44:39 view.
2:44:41 So maybe don't park the hearse at the front and then have a hundred foot walking.
2:44:48 What was the concern?
2:44:50 The concern was the fumes of cremation.
2:44:56 Yes.
2:44:57 Are there fumes from cremation?
2:45:03 There's a cremation oven in my old building on Main Street, and I don't know that there's
2:45:09 ever been any fumes.
2:45:11 My answer to the commission was we don't regulate the air quality from those, the state does through
2:45:17 the DEQ, and I leave it up to them because I'm not an air expert on that kind of thing.
2:45:23 So we say if they following state DEQ regulations for discharge of whatever the air.
2:45:32 Have we had anything?
2:45:33 We have one cremation oven in Twin Falls, actually, one for human and one for animal.
2:45:42 We haven't had issues with those.
2:45:43 I have not heard of them from my standpoint, other than this.
2:45:57 Is this currently what it says related to mortuary's government changed it?
2:46:04 Currently they are, I'd have to look at them with the other comment that we have as a funeral
2:46:13 center. Four is mortuary is a different land use as well. So if we go to the election.
2:46:24 Right after a field center so not sure the meaning of that. The mortuary what was added
2:46:33 right there. I struggle with it just a little bit because it's very big. What does it mean
2:46:40 to handle discreetly that could be very different for different people. So yeah be screened
2:46:48 from public, we now require fencing up to a certain height, there's just a lot of
2:46:55 vagueness to it.
2:46:58 We were going to use to the extent possible in our best judgment of how you do that.
2:47:03 I don't know.
2:47:05 And what's, I mean, is it the hearse, is it, and removing the body, I mean, there's so
2:47:11 many things when it comes to it, so.
2:47:13 And these, in terms of this, and the matrix I found in there, we're talking Central City
2:47:19 in commercial districts. Okay. It's downtown and it's on the commercial area and we would
2:47:28 basically be the one mortuary that's down or someone tried to do a new one. Yeah. It's
2:47:35 already built for sale. And to that it could be just permitted as well. I don't see a way
2:47:54 to have in the categories for mortuary. If you can find the page that under commercial,
2:48:01 Right. This is the criteria. Right here. And then this is where they're permitted. Yeah.
2:48:06 And mortuary's definition, if I'm remembering is different from like a funeral center where you just have people gather.
2:48:12 It's where you're handling the affairs of the dead. And that is embalming all the way to cremation.
2:48:19 Like that's what the mortuary includes both of those things. That's why those are restricted further than a funeral center where I have people gather to celebrate and or to whatever you do.
2:48:30 to honor the dead, celebrate, honor.
2:48:32 I'm gonna celebrate, some others might not, but.
2:48:40 I guess that's an area that we could always revisit
2:48:43 if necessary, correct?
2:48:45 Yeah, right.
2:48:47 It's the only thing we could see that would be needed
2:48:49 was long as you know you're not windows out to the open
2:48:52 when you're trying to take care of the affairs.
2:48:55 Yeah, just have a question real quick.
2:49:00 I have some things that I'd like to propose.
2:49:02 Do we want to do public hearing first
2:49:04 or do you want to propose them now?
2:49:07 I have no questions.
2:49:08 Public hearing first.
2:49:09 That's okay.
2:49:10 I would, then you can hear and then we can address it after.
2:49:13 Okay.
2:49:15 So I will open up the public hearing
2:49:17 if there's anybody in the audience
2:49:19 that wishes to address City Council
2:49:22 on any of the issues brought up under this item.
2:49:27 Please come to the mic, state your name
2:49:29 and whether you're resident of Twin Falls
2:49:31 and you have two minutes to comment.
2:49:36 Thank you Mayor and City Council.
2:49:38 I just want to talk about the AD units.
2:49:41 I'm in favor of France as a resident of Twin Falls.
2:49:46 Thank you.
2:49:47 I am in favor of the AD units.
2:49:52 I do not believe that an owner can put one in,
2:49:56 but I don't feel that he should have to rip it out
2:49:58 when he leaves.
2:49:59 Number one, he's going to have to get a permit for one.
2:50:03 You're going to tax him on that increase of that building
2:50:06 that he's added on.
2:50:08 When he moves, it now, his home owners
2:50:11 are centered would go away.
2:50:13 So the city would collect more money
2:50:15 for an improved property in the area.
2:50:19 The other thing is, as I recently went to DC,
2:50:22 with the Idaho delegation of realtors,
2:50:24 and we were told that the nationwide
2:50:28 were 4 1,500,000 homes short,
2:50:30 but Idaho is 30,000 homes short.
2:50:33 And there's a big need for affordability.
2:50:36 We've approved through planning and zoning a lot of properties
2:50:40 where they're building all these nice lovely apartment
2:50:44 buildings, but there's a big need for people
2:50:46 for one unit or maybe a small two bedroom unit
2:50:50 because not everybody can afford the $14,000 to $2,000
2:50:54 a month rent that these units are gonna be charging.
2:50:57 So I really get so many veterans, people on social security
2:51:02 security that could definitely benefit by living in an AD unit that would be
2:51:07 a affordable price for them. That's all. Thank you Francis. Is there anybody else in
2:51:15 the audience that wishes to address City Council on this title 10? Welcome.
2:51:25 Thank you. Good evening. Thank you for the opportunity to speak. My name is Rosanna
2:51:31 Campbell. I am a resident in Wind Falls. Also the chair for the Region 4
2:51:36 homeless coalition, which is comprised of a lot of community organizations that are trying
2:51:43 to help combat unsheltered homelessness in our area.
2:51:49 We do know that there are a lot of unsheltered homeless people, and I am in support of the
2:51:55 ADUs, the idea that it will potentially house some of our unsheltered homeless.
2:52:04 In completing a community needs assessment, the data has shown that there are quite a few
2:52:11 families that are living out of their cars and with doubling up with other families and
2:52:21 I think having the opportunity for an ADU would help reduce our number of unsheltered homeless
2:52:31 families.
2:52:32 Also, in looking at the data, there are a lot of seniors that are on very limited incomes
2:52:41 and the cost of living and the increases in property taxes and everything else that's
2:52:47 going up groceries and fuel and car repairs.
2:52:50 They are at the point of either not being able to keep their homes on their own for either
2:52:56 medical or financial reasons.
2:52:58 So again, I am in favor of ADUs for our area.
2:53:07 Thank you for your time.
2:53:08 Thank you.
2:53:10 Okay.
2:53:11 Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council on these particular
2:53:17 items?
2:53:18 Okay.
2:53:22 Seeing no one, I'll close the public hearing.
2:53:26 Also, Chris Reed.
2:53:30 Just bring up a couple of things.
2:53:31 I know it was discussed with ADUs.
2:53:34 I'm in agreement of removing the number of occupants, and then also the homeowner occupancy
2:53:40 requirements.
2:53:41 I think we should remove those also, and I'm going back several months.
2:53:46 So I apologize if I'm wrong when it comes to this, when it comes to drive-throughs, but
2:53:50 I remember the meeting we had up in the overflow.
2:53:53 I would like to remove or change in drive-throughs.
2:53:59 All of them except for the CMT from special use to a zone permit.
2:54:08 We had a discussion about how many times drive-thru came through and that type of discussion
2:54:14 and ultimately we felt like city staff could deal with that better now in the CMT, by
2:54:21 getting that correct.
2:54:22 Okay.
2:54:23 That's a little different situation because it is close to residential property.
2:54:26 I think that that would be good for a special use and have that come to the Council to the Commission first
2:54:35 And then Council yes, yep. Yep. Hey
2:54:41 Anything else that anybody has?
2:54:44 Yes, Grayson. Oh, thank you, Madam Mayor
2:54:46 So I would just say I would take it a step further and I would be inclined to say anything north of Poland
2:54:51 I would not want to even have a drive-through period
2:54:55 So
2:55:19 Anybody having, yes, Spencer?
2:55:21 No?
2:55:22 I'm there, and sorry.
2:55:27 Yep, go ahead.
2:55:28 Okay, just so in situations like this, are you looking for feedback and then we'll bring this back?
2:55:32 Do you want?
2:55:33 On.
2:55:34 So what I'm saying is an action item.
2:55:35 We're writing this down.
2:55:37 Number one, the item number one was you've got a recommendation from the commission.
2:55:42 So that one could just be approved as recommended by you.
2:55:45 So that would take care of those two items.
2:55:47 On the second item which is the drive-thru's, your request or your proposal would be as shown.
2:55:56 If we can swap these back to as shown, you would make it a zoning use permit and we create conditions for everything here shown as special except for the CMT.
2:56:08 That would then still say special. Everybody else would be the Z.
2:56:12 We have, I'll share, I have some conditions already written
2:56:16 because I had it before, but I wasn't quite ready.
2:56:17 And anyway, as a, I was thinking ahead,
2:56:22 but we'd have to bring that back to you at a future time,
2:56:24 but before the gracens, we're sorry, Councilman Stone's deal,
2:56:28 our item would be to add, and I basically add another item
2:56:34 which would put drive-through located,
2:56:38 and then I'd have to write the geographic area
2:56:41 as a new using in that area.
2:56:43 It's just not permitted.
2:56:46 On that item, there will be a number of legal nonconforming
2:56:53 locations that would be created.
2:56:55 So anything at the mall is all preexisting.
2:56:59 And anything like the mall, a significant value mall,
2:57:02 and then any word, West of Pauline.
2:57:04 And then we have a number on the West side of town
2:57:06 that are north as well.
2:57:08 So Culver's is North of Pauline, Starbucks up there,
2:57:11 the car washes up there are also to be legal non-conforming just numbered
2:57:17 Tom I had north of 10 south of 20 I don't know if we want to go link it I'm
2:57:26 not personally in favor of that but I'm not either could be done I'm my
2:57:30 standpoint I could write that now if I were to do that I would just have them
2:57:33 as a motion separately and say add a condition to address these issues and
2:57:39 And then we'd certainly have those written.
2:57:41 Otherwise, you are gonna see this in another public hearing.
2:57:44 It has everything in one giant document
2:57:51 with all these changes that we've been talking about.
2:57:56 Jason.
2:57:57 I was just gonna echo Jonathan.
2:57:59 That was my thought is just looking
2:58:01 at the North of Poland and probably have further discussion
2:58:06 on that, but I was just looking at some of the businesses
2:58:08 that are already there.
2:58:11 Some of the challenges of making a statement
2:58:14 of saying nothing north of Poline, I think there were certain areas, but I think there's
2:58:23 drive-ins that function appropriately at that point, so yeah, I think we would need further
2:58:29 conversation on what that actually means.
2:58:32 So you'd like a motion on removing the two owner occupied and number of occupants on that
2:58:42 one section?
2:58:43 That would be pretty clean to do, yeah.
2:58:44 right now and then any other motion at this point in time the you'll have to come back on the drive-thru
2:58:54 recommendation by Chris yeah if you if I think what we'd want to do at a future time is to have those
2:59:00 Conditions if you guys want to see him because that's kind of a we have some written but
2:59:05 Some maybe one way if we have certain conditions
2:59:07 Yeah, I'm able to different way
2:59:09 so we can have that as an option in the future or at a future time and
2:59:13 And open it up for probably yeah, yeah, I don't have those conditions in front of you
2:59:19 Yeah, I think that's good idea. So Chris do you want to go ahead and yeah?
2:59:23 I'll make a motion okay ready. I move that we approve the recommendations for a zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10
2:59:32 items to include our regulations pertaining to the land use conditions including
2:59:40 removal of the
2:59:43 requirements for ADUs with a number of occupants and owner occupancy as presented tonight.
2:59:53 Thank you. Jason? I'll second it though. Okay. Okay, so let's make sure.
3:00:06 That's trying to decide how to say that. So does everybody understand the motion?
3:00:11 and how about that?
3:00:12 We're good, it's eight o'clock.
3:00:14 Okay, it is eight o'clock.
3:00:15 Okay, it's been moved by,
3:00:17 and seconded, moved by Chris,
3:00:19 seconded by Jason to replace,
3:00:26 remove those two particular items
3:00:27 as it relates to 80 use.
3:00:31 Any further discussion?
3:00:34 Hope you got that, Rachel.
3:00:36 Rachel, roll call, vote please.
3:00:38 Ruth, Pierce.
3:00:39 Yes.
3:00:40 Chris Reed.
3:00:41 Yes.
3:00:42 Craig Hawkins. Yes.
3:00:43 Jason Brown. Yes.
3:00:43 Spencer Cutler.
3:00:44 Yes.
3:00:45 Sherry Filmer.
3:00:45 Yes.
3:00:46 And Gray Head Stone.
3:00:47 Yes.
3:00:48 Thank you.
3:00:48 Motion passes 7 to 0.
3:00:50 Anything else you need us to do before?
3:00:54 Yes.
3:00:54 Is there any desire for this drive-through
3:00:57 other than I can bring back the conditions
3:00:59 and talk about it, or are there any other item?
3:01:01 I just want to make sure that's clear.
3:01:03 I don't think so.
3:01:04 Yes, I'll jump on that.
3:01:05 So that's my preference.
3:01:07 I think I want to get voted down on it,
3:01:09 just based upon discussion.
3:01:13 I would obviously entertain anything
3:01:14 like grandpa that everybody that was in existence now,
3:01:18 but I wouldn't spin your wheels on.
3:01:20 It's, and they'll get voted down, it sounds like.
3:01:23 Yeah, I personally think if we put an extreme like that,
3:01:29 we're gonna be sorry, personally.
3:01:32 There's too much commercial along that road
3:01:34 that would require a drive-through.
3:01:38 Can I share an opinion?
3:01:41 Sorry, if we do that,
3:01:43 we would be taking away a development, right,
3:01:45 from a lot of people that have invested money in North of Poland as it is, and we have been
3:01:48 opening ourselves up to a good point of legislating taking costs.
3:01:54 That's a good point.
3:01:56 So yes, some sort of revision on the drive-through as...
3:02:00 We'll bring the conditions and...
3:02:01 Chris's requests.
3:02:02 We'll have a separate item at a future time or with the final item, and then you will
3:02:07 be able to see those separately.
3:02:09 Perfect.
3:02:10 Okay.
3:02:11 Anything else you need from us?
3:02:12 Hey, that means it's 807 and the meeting is adjourned. Thank you everyone
Download
- Transcript (text) 165 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 224 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 308 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 3 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 3 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 3 of 3 (M4A) 584 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 11, 2025. The recording started at 17:01 by the recorder's clock and runs 03:02:25.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
700691cdd2830a0766064ecfc823f7480a34f3b7ca83b4c318af200841ebcc09 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 3ad75442c59b4191231cdb208c1d391bbb3a62193946909f05e6da48cdddd385
part02.m4a 4a00588e1883e36e3aa0de19816c4c6c20a63aaf06064aea6bfb451af1388c47
part03.m4a b05e029eea6d8d7e7dc1b6caf8e9eda3eea43af3f31b8d11644db4cb029c3afb - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
e2d0c567ddc585e25e0534ddaa5d13d00d074dea6fa36ef96e9b50d805ad6223
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file