OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, April 21, 2025

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:02:22 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the April 21st.

0:02:26 April 21st, 2025 City Council meeting.

0:02:32 25 City Council meeting.

0:02:42 I want to confirm we have a quorum.

0:02:44 I want to confirm we have a quorum.

0:03:05 Okay, good evening, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to the April 21st, 2025 City Council meeting.

0:03:11 I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers.

0:03:17 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:03:20 If you wish to join me, please rise.

0:03:43 Thank you.

0:03:44 So we do have a proclamation today.

0:03:47 It's an Arbor Day proclamation.

0:03:51 Whereas in 1872, Jay Sterling Morton proposed

0:03:55 to the Nebraska Board of Agriculture

0:03:57 that a special day be set aside for the planting of trees.

0:04:01 And whereas this holiday called Arbor Day

0:04:04 was first observed with the planting

0:04:06 of more than a million trees in Nebraska.

0:04:09 and whereas Arbor Day is now observed throughout the nation and the world,

0:04:13 and whereas trees can reduce the erosion of our precious topsoil

0:04:18 by wind and water cutting, heating and cooling costs,

0:04:23 moderate the temperature, clean the air, produce oxygen,

0:04:27 and provide habitat for wildlife,

0:04:30 and whereas trees are a renewable resource giving us paper,

0:04:34 wood for our homes, fuel for our fires,

0:04:37 and countless other wood products, and whereas trees in our city increase property values,

0:04:43 enhance the economic vitality of business areas, and beautify our community, and whereas

0:04:49 trees wherever they are planted are a source of joy and renewal.

0:04:53 Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim Saturday,

0:04:59 April 26, 2025 as Arbor Day in the City of Twin Falls.

0:05:05 I urge all citizens to celebrate Arbor Day and to support efforts to protect our trees

0:05:10 and woodlands and further I urge all citizens to plant trees to gladden the heart and promote

0:05:16 the well-being of this and future generations.

0:05:19 Thank you Mayor and Council members. I just have a letter. I'd like to just read it.

0:05:58 Julia Stirling-Morton wrote, Other Holidays Reposed Upon the Past.

0:06:03 Arbor Day proposes for the future. As an American journalist and Nebraska Territory Secretary in 1872,

0:06:11 Mr. Morton proposed a tree planting holiday that resulted in over a million trees planted in the state.

0:06:17 By 1920, more than 45 states were participating and now all 50 observed the annual tree planting holiday known as Arbor Day.

0:06:26 This is the 27th year that the City of Twin Falls has become named a tree city by the National Arbor Day Foundation, meeting all four standards for recognition.

0:06:39 Those four standards include maintaining a tree board, implementing a tree care ordinance,

0:06:45 demonstrating a per capita spending for urban forestry, and celebrating Arbor Day.

0:06:52 This year, the Parks and Recreation Department requested the City of Twin Falls celebrate

0:06:58 Arbor Day on April 26.

0:07:01 On this date, four trees will be planted at Thompson Park by community members along

0:07:07 with Parks and Recreation staff.

0:07:09 We invite City Council members and Parks and Recreation Commission members to join from

0:07:15 10 a.m. to 12 at Thompson Park for this tree planting celebration.

0:07:21 Come see the new improvements also happening at Thompson Park, including a new playground

0:07:26 and storyboard trail in collaboration with the library.

0:07:30 We're excited to plant new trees that complement these enhancements as we know trees appreciate

0:07:38 over time and add value to public space.

0:07:42 Thank you for your consideration and once again recognizing and celebrating, Robert

0:07:48 A.

0:07:49 Thank you, Jen.

0:07:50 Okay.

0:07:52 Next on the agenda is the consent calendar.

0:07:55 Council wishes.

0:07:56 Move to approve.

0:08:01 Thank you, Craig Hawkins.

0:08:02 Second.

0:08:03 Thank you, motion by Jason Brown.

0:08:05 Second by Craig Hawkins to approve.

0:08:07 The consent calendar has written.

0:08:09 Amy Roquevo, please.

0:08:12 Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes.

0:08:23 Grayson Stone. Yes. Jerry Wilmer. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes.

0:08:28 Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Okay. Next under items of consideration, our

0:08:34 first item is an action item or consideration of a request to amend CD

0:08:40 code 9-6-8 by omitting subsection A3, a trailer of more than one half ton capacity and replacing

0:08:51 it with A3, any trailer. Staff would also like to add the definition of a recreational vehicle

0:08:58 to the city code, recreational vehicle, a vehicle that has living quarters and is designed for

0:09:04 recreational use such as camping travelers seasonal use and we have Sean Stanley our

0:09:10 code enforcement coordinator welcome Sean thank you madam maren council the

0:09:18 code enforcement department receives a significant number of complaints regarding

0:09:23 trailers in general being stored on the street trailers of half-ton or lower right

0:09:32 now are legal to park and store on the street and these types of complaints that we receive

0:09:40 are some of them from our street department. They're unable to sweep the gutters which

0:09:47 they're unable to clean up the debris and which may cause flooding as it pluses up storm

0:09:54 drains. There's safety issues regarding motor vehicles having to yield on an oncoming traffic.

0:10:01 of these trailers, especially when they parked straight across from one another, will turn

0:10:06 the two-lane road into a one-lane road pretty quickly. Bicycle and pedestrian safety issues

0:10:14 and also side obstruction issues when being scored next to dragways and intersections.

0:10:22 Also as many different trailers that are out there right now, it's pretty difficult to

0:10:27 tell what a half-ton trailer is anymore. It used to be just a single axle trailer was

0:10:31 half-ton and now it's pretty difficult to tell. So the idea is to just keep the

0:10:40 trailers off of our streets and keep them for traffic and pedestrian access and I

0:10:48 do want to mention in paragraph B of the same code there are some exceptions so

0:10:53 in the manufacturing district you are allowed to park these in that zone only

0:11:00 for 24 hours but you are allowed to go in there. If the person is actually engaged and

0:11:06 loading or unloading a property then that is no problem. It's you know somebody moving

0:11:12 out of their house or doing yard work or something like that. It's just when they're being stored

0:11:17 on the street it creates a lot of issues and we just kind of want to clear that up.

0:11:28 Recreational vehicles still in 2018 the council decided to allow those on the street for 24

0:11:35 hours while loading or unloading. So that's still in the same section as

0:11:39 paragraph C. Should the council desire to adopt the ordinance a special motion to

0:11:47 waive the rule and place the ordinance on third and final reading by title only

0:11:52 will need to be approved. Happily answer any questions. You have any questions for

0:12:02 Sean on this issue. Jason?

0:12:07 Yes, Sean. So this ordinance would change. So it would really be any trailer at any time or do they have like a 24-hour period?

0:12:16 You'd mentioned that a recreational trailer or something like that. Is there a time limit for a smaller trailer?

0:12:23 I see some of the pictures that were provided or you just can't leave it there at all at that point.

0:12:28 Yeah, you just can't park it or store it on the street. There are those exceptions that I state about the

0:12:35 manufacturing district or if you're engaged in. And I do have a few photos that Rachel may be able to put up there.

0:12:47 These are the trailers that we're talking about. You can go to the next one if you wish.

0:12:56 They park in the next driveways and intersections causing safety issues.

0:13:03 And there you can see the gutters, the sweepers can add yet to the gutters, so.

0:13:14 Yes, I know when we originally talked about this a few years ago,

0:13:21 the subsection B, number three, the person engaged in ongoing lawful construction projects.

0:13:28 That was a concern as well because we do have those larger trailers where somebody is

0:13:33 working on the home and so that trailer would be there most of the day and then they even then

0:13:38 to come back or potentially be there overnight.

0:13:41 Correct.

0:13:41 They dropped it off.

0:13:42 So those are exceptions still, and that would still be appropriate.

0:13:45 Yes.

0:13:46 As long as they have an active building permitted, and they're parked within 100 feet of that

0:13:50 location.

0:13:51 Perfect.

0:13:54 Thank you.

0:13:56 Any other questions?

0:13:57 We need to put this on third and final if you all are ready to do that or?

0:14:06 Is the ordinance number that 20?

0:14:08 2025-008.

0:14:09 Okay.

0:14:10 I'll go ahead.

0:14:11 Thank you.

0:14:12 Thank you.

0:14:13 I move to that we dispense with the reading of the rules and put Ordinance number 2025-008

0:14:19 on third and final reading by title only.

0:14:23 Thank you.

0:14:24 Do I have a second?

0:14:25 Grayson Stone.

0:14:26 I think you made a mirror on second.

0:14:27 Thank you.

0:14:28 Motion by Jason Brown seconded by Grayson Stone to put Ordinance number 2025-008 by dispensing

0:14:37 with the reading of the rules and putting that ordinance on third and final reading by

0:14:42 title only. Amy Roll call vote please. Great Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer

0:14:51 Cutler. No. Grayson Stone. Yes. Jerry Volmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. And Chris Reed. Yes.

0:14:59 Thank you. Motion passes six to one. So I will read ordinance number 2025 dash zero

0:15:06 and ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho providing for the amendment

0:15:13 of Twin Falls City Code Section 9-6-8 to parking trucks, trailers and unused and in operative vehicles.

0:15:22 Need a motion to approve? Craig Hawkins?

0:15:36 I move that we approve a request to amend city code 9-6-8 by omitting subsection A3,

0:15:48 a trailer of more than one half ton capacity in replacing it with any trailer staff should

0:15:55 also like to add the definition of a recreational vehicle to city code.

0:16:01 Recreational vehicle is a vehicle that has living quarters and is designed for recreational

0:16:06 use such as camping travel or seasonally use.

0:16:09 So it would probably be easier if we just passed Ordinance 2025

0:16:14 Dash.

0:16:15 OK.

0:16:15 If you could make that motion.

0:16:17 I move that we pass Ordinance 2025 Dash 008.

0:16:21 Thank you.

0:16:21 Sherry Volmer.

0:16:22 I'll second.

0:16:23 Thank you.

0:16:24 Motion by Craig Hawkins.

0:16:25 Second by Sherry Volmer to approve Ordinance number 2025 Dash 008.

0:16:33 Any further discussion?

0:16:35 Amy Ro, call vote please.

0:16:39 Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Grayson Stone, Jerry Volmer, Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed, and Craig

0:16:48 Hawkins.

0:16:49 Thank you.

0:16:50 Motion passes 7-0.

0:16:51 Thank you, Sean.

0:16:52 Thank you.

0:16:53 Next item on the agenda is an action item, a consideration of a request to adopt a new

0:17:00 city code for unlawful assemblies and public spaces.

0:17:05 would also like to include a section or failure to disperse in this code we have

0:17:11 Terry through this and welcome Terry. Good evening Madam Mayor Council

0:17:18 appreciate giving us a little bit of time. Last August I came before the

0:17:23 council with an informal presentation to inform the council of a number of calls

0:17:29 for service significant increase in calls for service that we were receiving

0:17:35 from the downtown area primarily main avenue between Shoshone Street and Idaho Street.

0:17:43 After we presented the problem and shared our efforts as an organization to address those calls

0:17:53 for service, it was our intention to meet with downtown merchants and residents to find a solution

0:18:01 to the problem that had occurred or that was occurring at that time. Over the last

0:18:08 eight months we've had an opportunity to do just that. We've had several meetings

0:18:12 with downtown merchants, really appreciated the opportunity to work

0:18:17 closely with Sean Berriger in coordinating and organizing those meetings

0:18:22 with our merchants to address the issues and concerns. Our first meeting was not

0:18:30 necessarily for us to provide any recommendations but to simply listen to

0:18:35 the concerns of our merchants and downtown business owners. To get a fill

0:18:41 for what they would like to or how they would like to see the problem addressed.

0:18:46 And after that first meeting it was fairly apparent that they were

0:18:51 desiring more of an enforcement ability for our officers to protect the flow

0:18:59 of commerce in the downtown area as well as to address quality of life issues that

0:19:06 were stemming from large groups gathering in that area. After that meeting we

0:19:15 agreed to draft a proposal for a city ordinance that would allow our officers

0:19:21 to address those concerns those quality of life issues in a more efficient and

0:19:27 effective manner than what we were able to last summer.

0:19:31 Following the initial draft, we sent the draft

0:19:35 to our legal team to get their input.

0:19:39 Following that input, we sent the draft

0:19:41 to our city management team to further solicit input.

0:19:46 Following the adoption or including the input from legal

0:19:50 and our city management team, we again

0:19:53 with the downtown merchants to present the draft that we were recommending to

0:19:59 ensure that it did meet the language that they desired to address the problems

0:20:05 they were experiencing. Following that input we again made a couple of minor

0:20:11 adjustments to the draft following a number of emails back and forth addressing

0:20:16 any concerns that might have surfaced, we were able to finalize a proposal for a new

0:20:24 ordinance that governs unauthorized or unlawful assemblies in public spaces to include a section

0:20:33 for failure to disperse after legal order by law enforcement.

0:20:39 With that, I would stand for questions.

0:20:42 Thank you, Terry.

0:20:43 Questions for Terry?

0:20:44 Yeah, quick question.

0:20:45 I appreciate your work on this.

0:20:47 I remember last summer, that was a lot of upset people.

0:20:51 I totally support the concept of this.

0:20:53 I was curious, how are public spaces defined?

0:20:56 Is there other city code that refers to what that is,

0:20:58 or is there some definition like a parking lot,

0:21:03 like in a private business or something?

0:21:05 So how do you differentiate it?

0:21:07 There are definitions that outline public spaces,

0:21:10 primarily it's any space that is not owned privately,

0:21:14 that may be owned by a city or a government entity

0:21:17 or public use.

0:21:19 Okay.

0:21:20 Just wanted to clarify that.

0:21:21 Thank you.

0:21:23 Any other questions for Terry?

0:21:28 So this ordinance would need to be put on third and final reading,

0:21:32 like the other one, correct?

0:21:34 Yes, and I would add to that that all,

0:21:36 should the council approve to adopt this ordinance,

0:21:40 it will be published, we hope, by Saturday.

0:21:44 We then have 30 days to enact,

0:21:47 and so we would publish this with a fund date to enact.

0:21:50 Perfect.

0:21:51 Thank you.

0:21:52 Chris Reed.

0:21:53 I'll make the motion.

0:21:54 I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put Ordinance 25-007 on third and final

0:22:01 reading by title only.

0:22:03 Thank you.

0:22:04 Do I have a second?

0:22:05 Jerry Vomer?

0:22:06 I'll second.

0:22:08 Thank you.

0:22:09 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Sherry Vomer to dispense with the reading of the rules

0:22:13 and put Ordinance 20-20, excuse me, 25-007 on third and final.

0:22:20 Reading by title only any further discussion Amy roll call vote, please

0:22:28 Spencer cutler no grace and stone. Yes, Jerry Bulmer. Yes. Yes

0:22:36 Yes, and Jason Brown. Yes. Thank you motion passes six to one

0:22:41 So I will read the ordinance ordinance number

0:22:45 25 dash zero zero seven an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho

0:22:51 providing for the creation of a new city code provision relating to unlawful

0:22:56 assembly. Chris Reed moved to approve ordinance 25-007. Thank you Craig

0:23:03 Hawkins. Thank you motion by Chris Reed second by Craig Hawkins to approve

0:23:08 ordinance number 25-007. Any additional discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.

0:23:20 Brace and Stone?

0:23:23 Yes.

0:23:24 Sherry Vollmer?

0:23:25 Yes.

0:23:26 Bruce Pierce?

0:23:27 Yes.

0:23:28 Chris Reed?

0:23:29 Yes.

0:23:30 Brace Hawkins?

0:23:31 Yes.

0:23:32 Besser Cutler?

0:23:33 Yes.

0:23:34 Thank you.

0:23:35 Motion passes 7-0.

0:23:36 Thank you, Terry.

0:23:38 Okay.

0:23:39 Next on the agenda is an action item.

0:23:41 Consider a request to approve the memorandum of understanding between the

0:23:46 Department of Agriculture in the City of Twin Falls, and authorized the mayor to sign.

0:23:51 We have Wendy Davis Parks and Rach, welcome Wendy.

0:23:55 Thank you, Mayor and Council.

0:23:57 Just for the record, Colm Morrison with the Idaho State Department of Ag is on the call,

0:24:04 so he's available if anybody has any questions that I can't answer.

0:24:08 So I wanted to start with just kind of a little history, as you may recall, October

0:24:14 of 23.

0:24:22 We had the cargo muscle situation and last summer, the boat ramp at Shoshan Falls was

0:24:31 closed for the entire year because they didn't have enough staff and were ready to go down

0:24:38 and put a wash station down there.

0:24:40 Now, as we're finishing construction,

0:24:43 ISDA is prepared to set up a wash station

0:24:47 and inspection station at Social and Falls boat ramp,

0:24:50 as well.

0:24:51 This memorandum of understanding is basically the formality

0:24:56 that we would need to go to that describes their authorization

0:25:02 as it relates to dealing with pests like the quagamecil

0:25:06 and would describe the relationship between the city

0:25:10 and the state in order to operate that wash station there.

0:25:14 So they have the authority to do this.

0:25:17 They're asking for permission to set up a wash station

0:25:19 in the park.

0:25:21 And then there's a financial piece to it too

0:25:23 that describes the fact that any costs,

0:25:27 if there was any utilities that they'll pay for that

0:25:29 and then we need to make any improvements,

0:25:33 the city would initiate the improvement

0:25:34 and then they'll reimburse us for it.

0:25:37 The right now, the main improvement

0:25:40 that we would probably try to do first and quickly

0:25:43 is install a gate.

0:25:44 And the gate would go up at the top of that hill

0:25:46 going down into the boat ramp, which would make it easy

0:25:49 to close it when they're not able to be there.

0:25:54 And historically, we could have benefited from a gate

0:25:58 when the water flows get high, and we

0:26:00 need to shut the boat ramp off because it's not safe.

0:26:02 For one reason or another for construction,

0:26:05 we would be able to close that area at the top,

0:26:09 instead of trying to set up barricades or cones or chains

0:26:12 or whatever.

0:26:14 The other piece is we may make some more permanent improvements

0:26:18 to that parking lot area to make the wash station work better.

0:26:24 And then we would benefit in the long run

0:26:26 with additional asphalt for a parking lot.

0:26:28 But we kind of wanted to get started and see just

0:26:31 how it works and what we need.

0:26:33 So that's basically what it is.

0:26:35 It's a fairly long agreement, but it's pretty simple.

0:26:39 I guess I'll stop there to see if anybody has any questions

0:26:42 for me or Cole.

0:26:44 Thank you, Chris, for the staffing would be city staffing.

0:26:48 No, they'll staff it.

0:26:50 They will staff it.

0:26:54 Any other questions for Andy?

0:27:00 Terry?

0:27:04 I will move to approve the memorandum of understanding

0:27:08 between the Idaho State Department of Agriculture

0:27:11 and City of Twin Falls and authorized the mayor to sign up.

0:27:14 Thank you, Jason Brown.

0:27:16 Second.

0:27:17 Thank you, motion by Sherry Vomer, second by Jason Brown

0:27:20 to approve the request to approve the memorandum

0:27:24 of understanding between the Idaho State Department

0:27:26 of Agriculture and the City of Twin Falls

0:27:29 and authorize the mayor to sign.

0:27:32 Any further discussion?

0:27:35 Amy Rokavo, please.

0:27:37 Ruth Pierce.

0:27:38 Yes.

0:27:39 Yes.

0:27:40 Great Hawkins.

0:27:41 Yes.

0:27:42 Jason Brown.

0:27:43 Yes.

0:27:44 Spencer Cutler.

0:27:45 Yes.

0:27:46 Grayson Stone.

0:27:47 Yes.

0:27:48 Yes.

0:27:49 Yes.

0:27:50 And Sherry Volmer.

0:27:53 Yes.

0:27:54 Thank you.

0:27:55 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:27:56 Thank you.

0:27:57 Wendy.

0:27:58 Okay.

0:27:59 Next item is an action item.

0:28:00 A request to approve the purchase of a 2025.

0:28:03 Great liner truck fitted with a mechanical broom sweeper at the cost of 365,000.

0:28:09 cooperative purchasing agreement with Sourcewell and authorize the Public Works

0:28:13 Director to execute the contract and we have Mark Thompson Street Department.

0:28:18 Welcome Mark. Thank you very much Mayor and Council. I appreciate you giving me

0:28:23 the time to come before you tonight and make this request. On July in July of

0:28:28 2019 I'd owe code 67-208 when into effect and that code essentially gave

0:28:34 political in it is the ability to participate in cooperative purchasing

0:28:38 programs with the approval of its governing body.

0:28:42 As long as those goods and services procured were the result of competitive solicitation

0:28:47 process.

0:28:48 Shortly after that, in December 2019, City Council adopted Resolution 209-015-014, which

0:28:58 authorized city staff to participate in the cooperative purchasing programs.

0:29:03 Staff can approve purchases up to the informal bid limit.

0:29:06 If purchases exceed the informal bid limit of 150,000,

0:29:11 the council must approve that purchase.

0:29:14 Over the last few years, the City Fleet Committee

0:29:17 has developed a fleet replacement schedule,

0:29:20 and it's our goal in the street department

0:29:21 to follow this program and replace equipment

0:29:23 based on its useful life.

0:29:26 The sweeper we're recommending to be replaced

0:29:29 was purchased in 2016 and has passed its useful life.

0:29:34 This current sweeper will be cleaned up and sold at auction in June

0:29:38 This purchase was approved by the fleet committee. It was later presented to and approved by the LTP committee and

0:29:46 adopted by the council as part of the

0:29:49 Fiscal Year 24 25 budget

0:29:51 We've also sent it in to be reviewed and approved by our city attorney

0:29:56 As you may be aware the vehicle and equipment prices have increased over the last few years

0:30:02 prices are still fluctuating and it looks like they're going to continue to fluctuate

0:30:07 for some time depending on how the tariffs all play out.

0:30:14 We have $360,000 budgeted for this purchase.

0:30:18 As such, we are $5,503.21 over budget.

0:30:25 Due to the mild winter we had, we didn't spend all of our salt and street cleaning budget.

0:30:31 budget, so we would like to reallocate a portion of the remaining funds to cover the

0:30:37 overreach.

0:30:39 With the Council's approval, we should see the delivery of the new sweeper in 90-120 days,

0:30:45 so it's a pretty short turnaround if we can get it ordered.

0:30:51 In the conclusion portion of the staff report, I've included the entire request for your

0:30:58 approval, which is to approve the purchase of the 2025 Freightliner truck fitted with

0:31:03 the mechanical broom sweeper at a cost of $365,503.21.

0:31:10 Approve reallocating $5,503.21 from our operating budget to cover the overage and then authorize the Public Works Director to execute the contract.

0:31:22 Answer any questions you may have.

0:31:26 Thank you, Spencer.

0:31:28 Just a quick comment actually about these purchasing agreements and I get a lot of questions about them

0:31:34 I don't know if it's if anybody else gets those or maybe it's just because of my day job.

0:31:38 I get this question a lot, but they are a good deal.

0:31:43 I purchase equipment and vehicles all the time for my other job and oftentimes especially

0:31:48 equipment like this you find there's one or two people that will or can bid on it and

0:31:56 I've actually gotten better prices when they're already locked into something like this, especially

0:32:00 in times of rapid price escalations so I'm happy that we can take advantage of things like this.

0:32:06 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Spencer. Any other Jason Brown? Sure.

0:32:12 I had moved to approve the purchase of a 20-25 Freightline truck fitted with a mechanical broom

0:32:19 sweeper at the cost of $365,503.21 using a cooperative purchasing agreement with source

0:32:27 and reallocate $5,503.21 from the operation budget

0:32:35 to cover the overage and authorize the public works

0:32:38 director to execute the contract.

0:32:41 Thank you.

0:32:42 Craig Hawkins.

0:32:42 Second.

0:32:43 Thank you.

0:32:44 Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins

0:32:47 to approve the purchase of a 2025 Freightliner track,

0:32:51 fitted with a mechanical broom sweeper at the cost of $365,503.21.

0:32:57 using a cooperative purchasing agreement with Sourcewell

0:33:00 and reallocate $5,503.21 from their operating budget

0:33:07 to cover the overage and authorize public works director

0:33:11 to execute the contract.

0:33:14 Any further discussion?

0:33:16 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:33:19 Sherry Bulmer.

0:33:20 Yes.

0:33:20 Grayson Stone.

0:33:21 Yes.

0:33:22 Spencer Cutler.

0:33:23 Yes.

0:33:24 Jason Brown.

0:33:25 Yes.

0:33:26 Ray Hawkins.

0:33:26 Yes.

0:33:27 Yes.

0:33:28 Thank you.

0:33:29 Motion passes.

0:33:30 Seven to zero.

0:33:31 Thank you, Mark.

0:33:35 Okay.

0:33:36 Next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:33:39 A request to authorize up to 60,000 from wastewater reserve funds for the preliminary design of

0:33:46 the canning room drop line and approve a contract with Hazen and Sawyer to perform that work.

0:33:52 We have environmental manager, Nathan Erickson.

0:33:55 Welcome, Nathan.

0:33:56 Thank you. Good evening mayor council. Appreciate your time tonight

0:34:00 And yes, I'm here to talk about our Canyon Rim drop line project

0:34:06 We I will remind you that that is the project that

0:34:10 Takes the grand viewer sewer line which is approximately half of the city's sewer flow

0:34:16 From the Canyon rim. So at the end of Canyon Rim Road

0:34:20 down to the sewer plant

0:34:22 It is a little bit of a complex project because it does need an updated control system up on top, so a box up on top.

0:34:30 And we're putting in a redundant line, and then we need another box in the bottom for the energy dissipation control down there to connect it back to the plant.

0:34:42 And I was here a month ago and we discussed that we had selected an engineer for the project,

0:34:49 Eason and Sawyer, and we have reviewed their scope of work on the project.

0:34:57 And it includes up to 30% design for this project, and it came out a little bit more than what we have budgeted.

0:35:06 budgeted. So we're here today to request an additional $60,000 to supplement what we already

0:35:15 have. So the scope of work is just under $350,000. And again, this is to get us to the 30% design.

0:35:27 Moving forward, we will be back. And there is a chance that in the future this may be

0:35:32 broken into smaller projects because the box on top, the box on bottom, there's

0:35:37 because it's so complex we could be back multiple times so you might see me quite

0:35:41 often on this project but if there's any questions for Nathan you could just

0:35:53 share with us where that where these funds knowing that it was over budget

0:35:56 where were these funds becoming from so it's the wastewater reserve funds and

0:36:00 there's sufficient in the reserves to cover the $60,000. Thank you Jason

0:36:07 I'll make a motion if we're ready.

0:36:11 I'd move to authorize the use of up to $60,000 from wastewater reserve funds for preliminary

0:36:20 engineering design of the Canyon Rim drop line project and approve a contract with Hazen and Sawyer to perform the work.

0:36:27 Thank you, Grace and Stone.

0:36:29 Thank you, Madam Mayor.

0:36:30 I'll second.

0:36:32 motion by Jason Brown, second by Greatson Stone, to authorize up to 60,000 from

0:36:38 wastewater reserve funds for the preliminary design of the Candy Room

0:36:43 drop-line project and approve a contract with Hazen and Sawyer to perform that work.

0:36:48 Any further discussion? Amy Rokow, please.

0:36:53 Mr. Cutler?

0:36:56 Yes.

0:36:57 Jason Brown?

0:36:58 Yes.

0:36:59 Greg Hawkins?

0:37:00 Yes.

0:37:01 Chris Reed?

0:37:02 Yes.

0:37:03 Ruth Pierce?

0:37:04 Yes.

0:37:05 Harry Vollmer?

0:37:06 Yes.

0:37:07 And Grayson Stone?

0:37:08 Yes.

0:37:09 Thank you.

0:37:11 Motion passes 7-0.

0:37:12 Thank you, Nathan.

0:37:13 Okay.

0:37:14 Next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:37:17 A fee waiver refund request for mechanical permit for the Tharen W.

0:37:21 Ward judicial building.

0:37:23 27th, just on the street, North Permit, 25, does 1,265, and we have Matt Long, our building

0:37:29 official. Welcome, Matt.

0:37:30 Hello, Madam Mayor and Council. Good to be here tonight. So, this fever, fee waiver request

0:37:39 I've got is from the community development director from the county. We currently have

0:37:47 a memo of understanding what the county that we waive all permits for plumbing and electrical.

0:37:55 They are currently, they don't have the staff right now to do that there in search of it, so they've asked us to come in and help out.

0:38:03 But we want to waive the mechanical permit fees for this and provide that service for them.

0:38:10 The difference in this one and the next one I'm going to give you is we're not doing a 10% hold back on this one because we wanted to be consistent with the memo of understanding that we've already got in place.

0:38:21 Hey, thank you.

0:38:25 Questions for Matt on this?

0:38:32 Would you guys like to talk about the amount or do you see it in here?

0:38:37 Sure with everybody the amount. We've seen it.

0:38:40 How do you get for everybody else to hear it?

0:38:42 Okay, the fee waiver, the total permit fees for this will be $11,668.79.

0:38:50 Thank you.

0:38:52 Grace and Stone.

0:38:54 Thank you Madam Mayor. I'm prepared to make a motion.

0:38:56 There's no more discussion.

0:38:58 Any discussion on this fee waiver? Go ahead, Grayson.

0:39:02 I'll make a motion that we approve the fee waiver slash refund request for mechanical permit, Theron W. Ward, judicial building 427, Shoshone Street North, permit number 25-1265.

0:39:15 Thank you, Sherry Volmer. I'll second.

0:39:17 Thank you, motion by Grayson Stone, second by Sherry Volmer to approve the fee waiver refund request for mechanical permit at the Theron W. Ward judicial building 427.

0:39:27 27 just shown street north permit number 25-1-2-6-5. Any further

0:39:35 discussion? Amy Rokal vote please. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes. Ruth

0:39:43 Pierce. Yes. Perry Volmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes. And Jason

0:39:49 Brown. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Hey next on the agenda is also an

0:39:55 action item. The Twin Falls School District is requesting a fee waiver for Lincoln Elementary

0:40:01 HVAC upgrade, 238 Beale Street North, permit 25-0874, and Matthew Law.

0:40:11 Hello Madam Mayor and members of the Council. Okay, so I got a fee waiver request from the

0:40:22 Twin Falls School District and it's for the Lincoln Elementary School. We've got some

0:40:28 substantial HVAC systems that they're upgrading there. So that they've

0:40:34 requested this fee waiver and the total amount of the permit is $23,603.25

0:40:42 because as I spoke of earlier, this one I want to do at 10%, I'm

0:40:48 recommended that the building department hold back 10%. So that would be $2,360.33

0:40:57 So the total amount for this fee waiver would be $21,242.92.

0:41:04 Thank you. Comments? Spencer.

0:41:12 I'll make a motion if you're ready. Sure. Thank you.

0:41:15 So I move to waive the fee for Lincoln Elementary HVAC upgrade.

0:41:19 Permit number 25-0874.

0:41:23 There is a holdback, but the total fee waiver would be 21,242,92.

0:41:31 Thank you.

0:41:32 Thank you.

0:41:33 Thank you.

0:41:34 Thank you.

0:41:35 Thank you.

0:41:36 Motion by Spencer Cutler.

0:41:37 Seconded by Grayson Stone to approve the Twin Falls School District fee waiver request for

0:41:43 Lincoln Elementary HVAC upgrade permit number 25 dash 0 874 in the amount of $21,242.92

0:41:54 Any further discussion?

0:41:59 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:42:01 Ruth Pierce?

0:42:02 Yes.

0:42:03 Chris Reed?

0:42:04 Yes.

0:42:05 Ray Cawkins?

0:42:06 Yes.

0:42:07 Jason Brown?

0:42:08 Yes.

0:42:09 Spencer Cutler?

0:42:10 Yes.

0:42:11 Tracy Stone?

0:42:12 Yes.

0:42:13 And Sherry Wilmer?

0:42:14 Yes.

0:42:16 Thank you.

0:42:17 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:42:18 Thank you, Matt.

0:42:19 Okay.

0:42:20 Next on the agenda is the time for public input.

0:42:22 This is a time where anybody in the audience who wishes to

0:42:25 on items that were not on this agenda or not about personnel.

0:42:30 So please come down, state your name,

0:42:33 and whether you're a resident or property owner

0:42:35 of the City of Twin Falls, and begin your input

0:42:39 just to remind you you are limited to two minutes,

0:42:42 and please remain respectful.

0:42:45 So is anybody in the audience that wishes to run down?

0:42:50 That mic on the green light there.

0:42:55 There you go.

0:42:57 John Jacobson, President of Twin Falls.

0:43:00 A couple of weeks ago, I was hearing your fire chief

0:43:03 took out the office and swore to uphold

0:43:05 the constitution of the state of Idaho.

0:43:08 I'm sure you've all done something similar

0:43:09 when you became councilman.

0:43:11 The constitution of the state of Idaho,

0:43:13 Article 9, Section 6, prohibits no religious tasks

0:43:18 or qualifications shall ever be required

0:43:20 any person as a condition of admission

0:43:23 into public education, educational institutes

0:43:26 of the state, either as a teacher or a student.

0:43:29 And no teacher or student of any such institution

0:43:32 shall ever be required to attend or participate

0:43:35 in any religious service, whatever.

0:43:37 No sectarian or religious tennis or doctrines

0:43:40 shall ever be taught in the public schools

0:43:42 or shall any distinction or classification of people

0:43:45 be made on account of race or color.

0:43:48 No books, papers, tracks or documents

0:43:51 of a political sectarian or denominational character

0:43:54 shall be used or introduced in any schools.

0:43:58 I think it's the original inference

0:43:59 from the strong language used in the Constitution

0:44:02 that they also felt strongly about

0:44:03 religion being introduced into the city government.

0:44:08 Using city staff, city attorney,

0:44:11 to create the policy of having prayer

0:44:14 at the beginning of the city council meetings

0:44:17 is using city resources.

0:44:19 That's city funds, that's taxpayer money

0:44:22 that has been collected and that they're being paid with.

0:44:26 This is a divisive issue.

0:44:29 It's obvious from the state if you're aware of what's going on.

0:44:32 It was obvious from the discussion that the city council

0:44:34 was pretty intensive.

0:44:36 It was a four to three vote.

0:44:37 Mr. Brown was a deciding vote and seen somewhat

0:44:41 on the fence about it.

0:44:42 So it's even divisive here.

0:44:45 A comment was made by one of your council members

0:44:47 why open this can of words when you don't have to.

0:44:50 It's not council business.

0:44:52 It's not required to run the government.

0:44:54 Please reconsider that resolution on city on prayer

0:44:57 in council meetings.

0:45:00 Thank you for your time.

0:45:01 Thank you.

0:45:04 Is there anybody else in the audience?

0:45:06 Hello.

0:45:11 My name is Eric Wenninger.

0:45:12 I am a resident and property owner of Twin Falls.

0:45:16 So I'm also here to voice my opposition to the proposed plan

0:45:20 to introduce prayer in Twin Falls City council meetings.

0:45:24 So I understand the intent behind the proposal

0:45:27 might be rooted in tradition or desire

0:45:30 to offer a moment of reflection, but I think it's really important to consider the implications

0:45:35 of such an action.

0:45:36 So going back to our own founding fathers who were deeply committed to ensuring a fair and

0:45:41 just government and deliberately constructed the US Constitution to protect individual

0:45:46 freedoms, including the fundamental right to religious freedom.

0:45:50 James Madison, who's been called the father of the Constitution, wrote that religion of

0:45:55 every man must be left to the conviction and conscience of every man.

0:45:58 And it is the right of every citizen to exercise it according to his own judgment.

0:46:03 So this wasn't just an abstract idea, but it was really a foundational belief that the

0:46:07 government should never impose religious practices on its citizens.

0:46:11 Thomas Jefferson was also clear that government should not be involved in religious affairs.

0:46:16 He stated, religion is a matter which lies solely between man and his God.

0:46:20 He thought that including religion and government and fringes upon the personal rights of the individuals.

0:46:25 A much more contemporary and local government official, Representative Jack Nelson of District

0:46:30 26, Idaho, in a town hall held at CSI on March 1st stated, this country has been really

0:46:37 great for centuries with an absolute separation of church and state.

0:46:41 This line received the biggest applause of the day, including a standing ovation, and this

0:46:45 underscores how important this issue is to politically engage citizens in the Medge Valley,

0:46:50 and I encourage you to look up the video on Kevin Bradshaw's YouTube channel.

0:46:54 I just want to wrap up by saying, again,

0:46:57 that introducing prayer before public meetings

0:46:59 risks infringing upon the principle of government neutrality

0:47:02 in religion that is enshrined in the US Constitution.

0:47:05 And I ask you to respect the rights of all citizens

0:47:10 by keeping government proceeding separate

0:47:12 from religious practices as our founders intended.

0:47:15 Thank you.

0:47:18 Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes

0:47:20 to address the city council today?

0:47:27 Hey, come on down.

0:47:28 You can work your way down if you'd like.

0:47:32 You're fine.

0:47:39 Do I need to push a button or is it already?

0:47:40 No, you're on.

0:47:42 OK, my name is Maria Hernandez.

0:47:43 I'm a native of Twin Falls, Idaho.

0:47:48 I am a proud follower of Chief Standing Bear,

0:47:49 Ponca, and to tribe.

0:47:51 Martin Luther King, Democrat John Lewis,

0:47:53 line of the tribe of Judah.

0:47:55 Imagine Dragons, Chief Kingsbury, Twin Falls Police

0:47:57 Department, and the mayor of Ruth Pierce.

0:48:00 I just wanted to say that there's a fact here in AI

0:48:03 looked up that 25,700 people identify as Hispanics, which is 22% of Twin Falls

0:48:12 population, three more percent and it's a quarter, but on today I just wanted to

0:48:17 give honor where honors do, as I look around you guys are all leaders up here,

0:48:22 you're not followers, and so today I just wanted to, because of the big

0:48:29 population here in Twin Falls. I just wanted to give honor where Honors do were the death

0:48:35 of the Pope today in just a moment of like silence and honoring what a great man he was.

0:48:44 It said he had a humble style concern for the poor, embrace the refugees, the downtrodden,

0:48:51 and he brought a breath of fresh air into a 2000 year old institute. One of his famous

0:48:56 This quote was, who am I to judge, and he says, we've all realized that we are on this

0:49:02 same boat, all of us fragile and disoriented, and so I just wanted to acknowledge him as

0:49:08 a leader.

0:49:09 Forget the labels, forget the religion, he was a leader.

0:49:16 And so because I'm rooted and grounded in Catholicism, although I'm a born-again Christian

0:49:22 now. I acknowledge and honor and give honor where honors do and I wanted to do that in part

0:49:29 of my people and any other people of any race or ethnicity to this leader of the Pope today

0:49:38 and I was heartbroken when he passed away. Thank you Maria.

0:49:44 Good afternoon. My name is Zoya Myers and I am a citizen here in Twin Falls and also

0:49:56 So, this is more so like an overview of like something that's me and some of my classmates,

0:50:07 and peers have been planning and proposing, and like a request for approval, maybe.

0:50:16 We have, one of my peers has contacted, I believe Spencer Cutler, about having an Earth Day

0:50:26 event in City Park on April 26th, this Saturday, and the idea is that we plant some flowers

0:50:36 in the City Park and support the Twin Falls High School Environmental Science Program,

0:50:44 support some sustainability and maybe some small businesses helping to get some small

0:50:49 businesses in our area involved and basically just like involving a lot of the community,

0:50:58 getting a lot of kids from school involved and just educating on the environment for

0:51:03 Earth Day.

0:51:05 And I just wanted to bring this here because of just like maybe get the more pus for approval.

0:51:15 It is incredibly important to myself and a lot of my peers that we take care of our

0:51:21 earth.

0:51:24 It's especially important around like this time of year when the weather is warming up

0:51:30 and it's just, and we're going outside more, and the air quality is so important to have

0:51:38 a healthy life and planting flowers and trees is a really great way to, you know, do that

0:51:45 kind of a thing. And I just really want to be able to like have some form of like a community

0:51:52 like event that gets a lot of people involved and supports our day. Thank you.

0:51:59 So I what I would recommend is we do have an Arbor Day event in Thompson Park this is coming

0:52:08 Saturday and any activity in the city park it requires to go through a permitting process.

0:52:15 So you may want to reach out to Parks and Rec when he's back there, Wendy and Chance,

0:52:21 and maybe talk to them.

0:52:23 Okay.

0:52:24 Thank you.

0:52:26 Is there anybody else here that wishes to address City Council?

0:52:32 Seeing no one advisory board reports.

0:52:39 How about City Manager's office?

0:52:41 I'm Madam Mayor.

0:52:42 We have just a couple of items.

0:52:45 Number one, again, I'll say it for the third time, but I wrote it because it was at the beginning

0:52:48 of the meeting.

0:52:49 We have Arbor Day celebration this week.

0:52:53 I think it's an important opportunity, but I also, what I would share is it's a celebration

0:53:01 also of the hard work of the members of the city's parks team as they care for the city's

0:53:09 trees and help celebrate that.

0:53:12 If you could help us in letting us know your summer calendars so as you want to take those

0:53:18 vacations, please let us know what days you will be gone so that we can make sure that

0:53:23 that we're coordinating the summer calendar appropriately.

0:53:28 And last but certainly not least, tonight is Chief Kingsbury's

0:53:32 last official city council meeting as our chief of police.

0:53:38 And we have an opportunity to celebrate his career,

0:53:43 not only with us, but the span of his entirety of his career

0:53:48 in law enforcement this Thursday in this room,

0:53:52 starting it between 130, 145 ish. So, Craig King's very last council meeting. Well,

0:54:01 Mr. Chief. Hey, anybody else have anything? If not, our meeting's adjourned. Thank you,

0:54:08 everyone.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 21, 2025. The recording started at 16:57 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:54:33.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    da6339cd5e1752b7fbf681364d18e38a24dd7e7996aa2ea2ec79a15889a27840
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 47ee0a403e118681c5fba00c7a457d5eb03954bcfe3bd395dff8937b822e19cc
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    0587e5515bb69697487987ad9fd9caed66d8a2021dfd7fb8462b25927b4864c1

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file