City Council meeting
Monday, December 16, 2024
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileExecutive session: e
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:02:29 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the December 16th, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all
0:02:39 Seven first present in chambers tonight first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me please rise
0:02:47 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:03:03 Okay, we have no proclamations tonight, so first, next on the agenda is the consent calendar.
0:03:14 Council wishes, Craig Hawkins.
0:03:16 Here I'd like to approve the, uh, minutes from the last count, approve the consent calendar is written as a long crime say.
0:03:25 Thank you. Is there a second?
0:03:26 I'll second.
0:03:27 Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins second by Chris Reed to approve a proof that
0:03:32 consent calendar as written Rachel Rokal vote please. Yes yes. Thank you motion
0:03:48 passes seven to zero. Okay first item under items of consideration is an
0:03:54 action item are requests to award the Hankins pump station to construction
0:04:00 contract to IMCO general construction in the amount of $8,074,000 with conditions
0:04:09 and we have staff engineer Lee Gleisman. Welcome Lee.
0:04:13 Four model filled out incorrectly. I'm an assistant city engineer now. Oh sorry.
0:04:19 Yeah, on November 21st, bids were received for the construction of a new Hankets pump
0:04:25 station number two. Below bid in the amount of $8,074,000 was received from Mco-General
0:04:31 Construction at Ferndale, Washington. Staff was recommending to award the contract to Mco-General
0:04:36 Construction with conditions. I don't know if you had a chance to look at the bit tab,
0:04:40 but number two was very close on a project of this size. It was really good to see a
0:04:45 a lot of bidders and CM's closest they were together.
0:04:48 So currently there is a single water pumping station
0:04:52 on Hankins Road near Kimberly Road,
0:04:53 which we've called the Hankins pump station
0:04:55 were not real creative I guess.
0:04:57 This pump station supplies water
0:04:59 to the Hankins pressure zone,
0:05:00 which was recently split into two pressure zones,
0:05:03 the Hankins pressure zone north
0:05:04 and Hankins pressure zone south.
0:05:06 Currently the existing station supplies water
0:05:08 to both pressure zones.
0:05:10 Based on the estimated growth within these pressure zones,
0:05:12 the most recent water master plant projected
0:05:14 that the existing pump station has enough capacity
0:05:17 for at least another 10 years before a new pump station
0:05:19 would be needed for the area.
0:05:21 When built, the new pump, Hankah's pump station,
0:05:23 would be able to supply water to one of the two
0:05:25 new pressure zones and the existing Hankah's pressure zone,
0:05:28 or Hankah's pump station would be able to supply water
0:05:31 to the other.
0:05:32 In late 2022, Chobani approached the city
0:05:35 with a request for an additional one million gallons
0:05:37 of water a day to support expanded production
0:05:39 at their plant.
0:05:40 Since the existing pump station cannot support
0:05:42 the requested water demand,
0:05:44 The city had no plans to build a new station for many years.
0:05:47 Chobani and the city came to an agreement.
0:05:49 Among other conditions needed to support their proposed growth,
0:05:51 Chobani agreed to fund the construction of the new Hankas pump station
0:05:55 to provide their needed water supply,
0:05:56 and the city agreed to fund three additional pumps in the station.
0:06:00 By adding three pumps to the new station, the new station would be able
0:06:02 to provide dedicated water to one pressure zone,
0:06:05 and the existing pump station would be able to provide dedicated water
0:06:07 to the other pressure zone.
0:06:09 By using two pump stations instead of one,
0:06:11 Water can be supplied to the two pressure zones more efficiently, which will decrease energy cost to the city compared to a single station.
0:06:17 As a condition of the agreement, the city agreed to not execute the construction contract for the station until Chobani provided full payment for their portion of the work.
0:06:26 The city has already received most of the funding from Chobani as weighting a final amount.
0:06:31 I had expected something like that maybe even before this meeting hasn't come in yet, but it's on its way.
0:06:36 If council awards the contract, the award will need to be conditioned on receiving the
0:06:41 full Chobani payment first.
0:06:43 To fund the three pumps, the city agreed to pay for 1.2 million was included in the current
0:06:48 city budget.
0:06:49 However, the bid cost for the three pumps came to 1.425 million to cover the additional cost
0:06:56 plus the contingency staff is requesting $300,000 from Water Reserves.
0:07:00 Water Reserves has sufficient funds to cover this request.
0:07:03 If council awards the contract the word will need to be conditioned on allowing the use of 300,000 from water reserves and so
0:07:11 conclusion
0:07:12 Recommend that council award the hankas pump station number two construction contract in co-general construction in the amount of eight million 74,000
0:07:21 With the following conditions the ward is contingent on receiving payment friendship body to cover the construction amount and 300,000
0:07:27 Water reserves to be used for the city's portion of construction
0:07:29 Any questions for Lee for Jason Brown, I'll go ahead and make a motion.
0:07:41 Thank you.
0:07:42 I would move to award the Hankins pump station number two construction contract to M code
0:07:48 general construction in the amount of 8,074,000.
0:07:52 Is that right?
0:07:53 Yeah.
0:07:54 I just wanted to make sure with the following conditions, the award is contingent on receiving
0:08:01 payment from Jibani to cover their construction amount and 300,000 water reserves.
0:08:09 Thank you.
0:08:10 Grace and Stone.
0:08:11 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:08:12 I will second.
0:08:13 Thank you.
0:08:14 Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Grace and Stone to award the Hankins pump station number
0:08:20 two construction contract to MCO, General Construction, and the amount of $8,074,000
0:08:27 with the conditions listed.
0:08:30 Any further discussion?
0:08:33 Rachel Rocha-Rocha-Rocha, please.
0:08:36 Yes.
0:08:37 Brace and Stone.
0:08:38 Yes.
0:08:39 Barry Volmer.
0:08:40 Yes.
0:08:41 Jason Brown.
0:08:42 Yes.
0:08:43 Great Cockens.
0:08:43 Yes.
0:08:44 Chris Reed.
0:08:45 Yes.
0:08:46 Yes.
0:08:47 Thank you.
0:08:48 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:08:49 Thank you, Lee.
0:08:51 Thank you very much.
0:08:52 Okay.
0:08:53 Next item is also an action item, a request to approve the purchase of a 2024 Enviro site
0:08:59 camera van and equipment at the cost of $310,871.44 using a cooperative
0:09:07 purchasing agreement with Sourcewell and authorized the Public Works
0:09:11 Director to exit the contract and we have our wastewater superintendent Doug
0:09:16 Gonzalez welcome Doug. Good evening Mayor, Council. Come to talk about the
0:09:22 approval to purchase our Enviresight camera. A little background, Idaho code
0:09:29 with the approval of this governing board, a political subdivision may participate in cooperative
0:09:42 purchasing agreements with the state of Idaho, other Idaho political subdivisions, other government
0:09:48 entities or associations thereof.
0:09:52 Political subdivisions may also participate in cooperative purchasing programs established
0:09:57 by any association that offers its goods or services
0:10:01 as a result of competitive solicitation process.
0:10:05 Goods or services procured by participation
0:10:08 and says cooperative agreements
0:10:10 or programs shall be deemed to have been acquired
0:10:15 in accordance with the requirements of this chapter.
0:10:19 On December 19th, 2019,
0:10:22 City Council adopted resolution 2019-014
0:10:27 authorizing staff to use cooperative purchasing agreements
0:10:30 and joint cooperative purchasing programs.
0:10:33 City staff can approve purchases up
0:10:35 to the informal bid limits.
0:10:37 The city council must approve the purchase
0:10:40 if the purchase exceeds the informal bid limit,
0:10:43 which was increased to 150,000.
0:10:46 The fleet searing committee recommended this purchase.
0:10:50 It was later presented to and further recommended
0:10:54 by the LTP committee and allowed to buy the council
0:10:57 part of the FY2526 budget. This equipment is essential to the wastewater team in
0:11:06 maintaining and evaluating through video inspection the sewer collection and
0:11:11 stormwater systems. Current camera van and chassis are over 20 years old and are
0:11:17 due to be replaced. There is still value in the equipment so we are reaching out
0:11:22 to other municipalities to try and see if we can recoup some of the costs on the
0:11:27 new van. Any existing useful equipment that is compatible with the new van
0:11:35 will be transferred from the old van to the new one and reused. Approval a simple
0:11:43 majority vote will approve this request. Also something to note the quote is did
0:11:49 come in under budget so I will stand for any questions you have for me.
0:11:54 Chris Reed. Doug, thanks for the presentation. If it's approved tonight, what do you think the turnaround is on something like this?
0:12:02 So, as soon as we can get the contract signed, working with MetroQuit, this who were working through to get the Enviresite equipment in van,
0:12:12 they said the turnaround shouldn't be horrible. If we go into January-ish, it could get a little bit longer on the chassis.
0:12:23 the equipment and everything should be a pretty quick turnaround. We're hoping by early summer, we should be able to see something. I'm hoping, I don't know that for sure.
0:12:35 So that's going off basically what they were telling us from magic rip.
0:12:39 But mid next year.
0:12:41 Yeah.
0:12:42 Perfect. Thank you.
0:12:43 Grayson.
0:12:44 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:12:45 Hey, Doug's just because I'm kind of a nerd and I went through our onboarding process.
0:12:51 and we learned kind of how the video inspection works.
0:12:54 Would you mind kind of just talking for anybody listening,
0:12:56 anybody in the audience on how you utilize those tools?
0:12:59 Yes, it's actually a great tool for us to use.
0:13:03 It's probably one of the most important ones we have.
0:13:06 Being able to have the ability to look at the pipe from the inside,
0:13:10 not take anything out of service while we do that
0:13:14 helps us make recommendations, all sorts of things,
0:13:17 you know, even with backups, how to fix them.
0:13:20 We can hopefully on the front end be able to find repairs,
0:13:26 CIP projects, those types of things
0:13:29 by being able to do video inspection,
0:13:31 which really helps us with our budgeting
0:13:34 to see what the health of our system is.
0:13:37 So it's a very useful tool.
0:13:40 We can use it for storm water as well.
0:13:42 So it can help us in the future
0:13:45 with storm water needs as well.
0:13:47 So.
0:13:48 Thank you.
0:13:49 Thank you, Chris Reed.
0:13:51 ready to make a motion if we move to approve the purchase of the 2024 Enviro site camera
0:13:57 van and equipment at the cost of $310,871.44 using a cooperative purchase agreement with
0:14:06 Sourcewell and authorizing the public works director to execute the contract.
0:14:11 Thank you, Jason Brown. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to approve
0:14:18 the request to purchase the 2024 Enviro site camera van and equipment at a cost of 310,87144,
0:14:29 using cooperative purchase agreement with Sourcewell and authorized Public Works Director to execute
0:14:35 the contract. Any further discussion? Rachel Roekov, please.
0:14:40 Grace and Stone. Yes.
0:14:42 Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes
0:15:13 plus closing costs, and we have our environmental manager, Nathan Erickson, welcome, Nathan.
0:15:18 Thank you, Mayor, Council. Appreciate your time tonight. Yes, tonight I'm here because
0:15:25 the City of Twin Falls is unique in that our wastewater treatment plant is down in the canyon,
0:15:32 and we have three different sewer lines that take the wastewater from the city down to the
0:15:38 treatment plant. One of these lines is the ground view trunk line that's what we
0:15:44 call it. That's your line is it comes down Canyon Rim Road and hits the Canyon
0:15:49 Rim drops off the Canyon Rim and goes down to the plant. We are in the process of
0:15:55 making some improvements and on that system along the rim and below the rim
0:16:01 and found that we really need a redundant line in that area and in
0:16:06 process of doing that we found that currently the line that is coming off of
0:16:12 the rim is actually not completely on the city's property. It goes on into it in a
0:16:16 jointing property that's owned by a private owner and we have talked to the
0:16:24 owners of that property and they have a desire to sell the property it's 37 acres
0:16:30 It's 37 acres, it's from the canyon rim, and then it goes north to Canyon Springs Road.
0:16:39 It's a little bit of an awkward shape, but it does cover the area of where the city would
0:16:46 need to own to put in a redundant line and to actually own the property that our line
0:16:51 is on.
0:16:52 So the price for that property we've negotiated with the owners is $200,000.
0:16:58 costs are approximately 2000. We're going to split the cost with the seller, so it'll
0:17:06 be 200,000 plus closing costs. I guess if there's any questions at this point.
0:17:14 Why don't we pull up the map and that way we can... Are we looking at the same thing?
0:17:32 It's in the packet. It is in the packet. It's attachment. We all have it. I was just going
0:18:07 show it to the audience yes it is a little bit of an odd shape but the I guess the
0:18:23 southwest portion of it does follow along like I said the canyon rim and then it
0:18:28 does join the property that is currently the wastewater treatment plant what is
0:18:38 the little train who owns that property so there is a triangle that is owned by
0:18:44 the golf course. Okay, so they own up from the golf course
0:18:49 across the road, yes. Okay. Ask a question. Yes. What we're looking at that. Talk to us a little bit
0:19:00 about the work that will be done once this is purchased, knowing that we do have some lines. You
0:19:04 talked about redundancy that's needed. Yeah, so what initiated this process was, so is that line
0:19:12 comes up so it's a 30 inch HDPE pipe currently and you can imagine that the
0:19:18 sewer that comes off the canyon rim there's a lot of energy in that flow you
0:19:22 know it's a big water slide so when it gets to the bottom it hits a box
0:19:27 but the it's called an energy dissipation box at the bottom before it gets to the
0:19:34 plant and that energy dissipation box is in need of inspection and you know
0:19:39 making sure that it's in good condition and in looking at that we realized that
0:19:45 there was really no way to stop the flow and hence the recommendation from the
0:19:50 engineering firm that we put in a redundant line it would also give us
0:19:55 future capacity for that line thank you one time I don't have a power I can
0:20:18 and print it and hold it up.
0:20:20 I got a picture of it here.
0:20:23 There we go.
0:20:24 It is.
0:20:25 Fabulous.
0:20:26 Thank you.
0:20:29 Trowess.
0:20:30 So the red is the outline shape of the 37 acres, the blue is the wastewater treatment
0:20:36 plant.
0:20:37 Perfect.
0:20:38 Thank you.
0:20:41 Nathan, Chris, did you have another question?
0:20:44 I don't.
0:20:45 I'm ready to make a motion.
0:20:46 You have a question, Chris?
0:20:47 Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:20:48 Is there any value in approaching the land on earth with the golf course to square
0:20:52 that up along Canyons Springs Road. At some point I believe so but currently
0:20:58 for the wastewater project what we are getting with this 37 acres we'll cover
0:21:05 that need. Thank you. Okay go ahead Chris. I move that we approve the purchase of
0:21:13 real property located in the Snake River Canyon between the Canyon rim and
0:21:17 Canyon Springs Road south of the city's wastewater treatment plant in the amount
0:21:22 of 200,000 plus closing costs.
0:21:25 Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
0:21:26 I'll second.
0:21:27 Thank you, motion by Chris Reed, second by Sherry Vomer
0:21:30 to approve the purchase of real property
0:21:32 in the Snake River Canyon,
0:21:35 between the Canyon Rim and Canyon Springs Road,
0:21:37 south of the city's wastewater treatment plant,
0:21:40 the amount of $200,000 plus closing costs.
0:21:44 Any further discussion?
0:21:47 Rachel Rolkow, please.
0:21:49 Ruth Pierce?
0:21:50 Yes.
0:21:51 Chris Reed?
0:21:52 Yes.
0:21:53 Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Gary Filmer, and Grace and Stone.
0:21:58 Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, Nathan, but don't go away.
0:22:05 Okay. Next on the agenda is an action item. A request approval to renew the 2024 10-year agreement
0:22:14 between the City of Twin Falls and Operations Management International, or OMICH2M Jacobs,
0:22:22 the wastewater treatment plant and sewer lift stations operation with the fiscal year 2024-25 budget amount of 3,906,648.37 cents and authorized the mayor to sign.
0:22:39 Thank you.
0:22:41 All right.
0:22:42 So, yes, the city, as you all know, has a long-going cooperation with its operations
0:22:53 management international.
0:22:55 We, Jacob's engineering is who we, I guess, are more familiar with, but it's all the
0:23:01 same entity.
0:23:03 And they've operated our White Sword Treatment Planet for almost 40 years.
0:23:07 This will be 40 years and we have really appreciate their cooperation and the support in running that plant and
0:23:17 Every 10 years we
0:23:19 Have a contract that is renewed and this is the 10-year period when we renew that contract
0:23:25 In that renewal
0:23:28 We did negotiate some
0:23:30 some small changes, which did help reduce some of the contract, and so this year we did see
0:23:39 in this annual contract amount there was reduction of almost 3%, and that was due partially to
0:23:48 some savings and power usage and our chemical cost and then also some other negotiated changes.
0:23:56 I do, and I was going to start out with this, I do want to recognize that we do have our
0:23:59 plant manager Dan Black and Sean Moffatt here today from Jacobs and we really do appreciate
0:24:05 them.
0:24:07 But the annual renewal we come back every year to renew the amount of the contract and make
0:24:17 some minor changes to that.
0:24:21 We do want to recognize that with this being the 10 year renewal that Jacobs has also been
0:24:28 generous in wanting to contribute a little bit more back to the plant. And there's a project
0:24:34 for a micro aeration project that Dan, he's a smart guy and we appreciate him. He's always
0:24:41 trying to save us money and he sees that there's an opportunity for us by doing this
0:24:47 micro aeration in our digester could actually eliminate the need for us to use some of our
0:24:52 chemical. It's being done over in Boise very successfully and so he's really
0:24:58 wanting to help get that going and Jacobs is offering $35,000 to put
0:25:04 towards that project. I know if there's any questions. I read somewhere that
0:25:10 project cost is $125 that way for the aeration. The micro aeration we're not
0:25:20 I'm not sure, I think it actually is, the 35,000 will give it a good start and it may be even more like around, you know, less than 50,000.
0:25:29 Oh, correct me if I'm wrong, Dan.
0:25:38 That's what it was. I knew I saw 125 numbers.
0:25:43 And that's annually too. That's an annual savings. So this is, this is, could be big for the city.
0:25:49 That'd be huge. Anybody have any questions for Nathan on this?
0:25:54 I always like to save 3%.
0:25:58 I would entertain a motion then, Jason.
0:26:01 I'd move to approve the renewal of the 2020-24-10 year agreement between the City of Twin Falls
0:26:09 and Operation Management International, OMICH2M and Jacobs for the wastewater treatment
0:26:16 plant and sewer lift stations, operations for the fiscal years, 2024-2025, a budget
0:26:23 amount of $3,906,000 to authorize the mayor to sign.
0:26:31 Thank you, Sherry Vomer.
0:26:32 I will second.
0:26:34 Thank you, motion to approve the renewal of the 2024 10-year agreement between the City
0:26:40 of Twin Falls and OMI International CH2M Jacobs for the wastewater treatment plant and sewer
0:26:48 lift stations operation per fiscal year 24 25 budget amount of 3 million 906
0:26:55 thousand six forty eight and thirty seven six and authorize the mayor to
0:27:00 sign any further discussion you know Sean if we keep adding some some more
0:27:08 names to that it'll be even better yeah for who Rachel Rojo vote please
0:27:16 Greg Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Enter Cutler. Yes. Sherry Balmer. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. And Chris Sweet. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you, Nathan.
0:27:30 Okay, that is it under items of consideration. We have several public hearings tonight, but before we go to public hearings, it's time on the agenda for general public input.
0:27:45 input if there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council
0:27:50 today you can come down to the podium and state your name and you have two
0:27:55 minutes anybody here that wishes to address City Council and this would be
0:28:02 on items not on the public hearing tonight that helps AC no one advisory
0:28:10 board reports pretty quiet we anything from the City Manager's office yeah
0:28:18 Madam Mayor, members of the council,
0:28:21 later on the agenda, item eight,
0:28:23 you'll notice that there is an executive session
0:28:25 hosted under matters of trade and commerce,
0:28:30 Idaho Code Section 74-2061E.
0:28:34 We're going to ask that the council
0:28:37 cancel that hearing or the executive session this evening.
0:28:43 The Idaho Supreme Court recently made a ruling
0:28:47 on December 5th and staff and our legal counsel
0:28:51 haven't had a full opportunity to digest
0:28:53 the new requirements of that section of Idaho Code.
0:28:56 And so it's probably a safer approach for us
0:29:01 not to go into executive session until we understand
0:29:05 the new decision and the issue at hand
0:29:08 is not one that can't wait a couple of weeks
0:29:11 for us to digest the new opinion.
0:29:14 Thank you.
0:29:17 Okay.
0:29:19 So next we'll move into public hearings.
0:29:22 I'm gonna go ahead and read the rules related
0:29:25 to public hearings, even though not all these
0:29:27 are gonna quite fall under that.
0:29:31 The council will follow these steps for each request listed
0:29:35 under public hearing portion of the agenda.
0:29:37 City staff will present the request and analysis.
0:29:41 The applicant will then present their request.
0:29:44 Council will ask questions of the applicant or staff.
0:29:47 After questions have been asked,
0:29:49 the public hearing will then be opened.
0:29:52 During that time, anyone in attendance
0:29:54 has given the opportunity to comment.
0:29:56 Ask questions about the request being considered.
0:29:59 When giving testimony, please step up to the podium,
0:30:02 state your name and address,
0:30:04 present your comments or concerns.
0:30:07 After giving testimony, please sign the public record sheet
0:30:10 located in the lobby, which is upstairs,
0:30:13 with your name and address for the record.
0:30:15 After public comments are concluded,
0:30:17 the applicant will be invited to answer any questions
0:30:20 and make a closing statement.
0:30:22 Staff will then answer, clarify any comments.
0:30:25 After the closing statements, the public hearing
0:30:27 will be closed.
0:30:29 No further testimony or comments from the applicant
0:30:31 or audience will be allowed.
0:30:33 And then the council will have discussion and take action.
0:30:38 Okay, so our first item on a public hearing
0:30:43 under public hearings, is an action item.
0:30:46 Request to authorize a new city of Twin Falls
0:30:49 owned and operated sewer odor mitigation facility
0:30:54 on property located at 879 Fridivration Road,
0:30:58 here of the city of Twin Falls,
0:31:00 PZ24-0126.
0:31:04 We have our senior planner, Will Clayver,
0:31:07 and I want to point out that the city is mostly applicant
0:31:10 and the staff, so you're holding both hats, correct?
0:31:16 Yes, and no.
0:31:17 We're also at Nathan Erickson with our public hand.
0:31:20 Perfect.
0:31:21 To present.
0:31:23 Perfect.
0:31:24 Go ahead.
0:31:25 All right, today we have a sewer,
0:31:28 what we call a new use on city owned and operated parcels.
0:31:33 This is similar to what a special use permit is.
0:31:36 However, it's not as strict and as stringent
0:31:38 that process would be and that's why it comes to you directly as part of Twin Falls Municipal Code 10-7-9-T.
0:31:50 I believe it's 19. I might have, yes, I did a mistypo on your staff report. It's 10-7-19 rather than 10-7-9.
0:32:01 The subject property that we're looking at is on the southeast corner of Grandview Drive North and Federation Road.
0:32:09 Just to the north across Federation Road is a school.
0:32:15 And then on the south and eastern portions are residential houses.
0:32:21 The western portion is county jurisdiction and it has not been developed, I believe it's still used for agriculture.
0:32:28 zoning-wise we have this as R2 it's a pretty heavy R2 area a little further
0:32:45 south is a PUD all the center point and Connor beauty that PUD was approved however
0:32:53 no ordinance was done so it's kind of a limbo this Canyon properties is a
0:32:59 residential and commercial PUD as well. As far as the future land use goes, this
0:33:09 area is heavily denoted as town neighborhood. This means primarily residential and
0:33:15 character with desired land use of single-family duplex, triplex, and schools and civic facilities.
0:33:22 Currently, the property is being utilized as a stormwater retention for the area and the
0:33:32 ideas to have a proposed purpose park in that area.
0:33:38 Google Street View shows the area.
0:33:41 This is this road on top is Federation.
0:33:44 This is at the corner of Federation in Grandview.
0:33:47 You can see the school off on the left side of the picture,
0:33:52 and then on the right side of the proposed location.
0:33:56 On the bottom picture, you can see the surrounding area.
0:34:02 Where this proposed sewer odor mitigation
0:34:06 is right where my mouse is on the northwest corner,
0:34:10 just this general facility.
0:34:13 When reviewing this, we found that it balanced
0:34:19 the distance between the school, the Rock Creek Elementary,
0:34:22 and then the residential neighborhood on the eastern
0:34:27 south portions, it really didn't balance the smell
0:34:32 Balance the smell, the noise, if it was a placement, I was really good on this spot.
0:34:42 This would be the most ideal location for it for that balancing aspect.
0:34:47 It also has direct access that you could provide off federation.
0:34:53 Here are some drawings of the proposed site.
0:35:00 I'll just go over or just quickly go through them and then let Nathan speak
0:35:07 to the specifics of it. Here's some
0:35:13 pie symmetric renderings of it. There will be
0:35:17 a wall in these applicant narrative. They do
0:35:22 say that there will be some noise factors with the fan.
0:35:26 However, with the wall, we believe that will
0:35:30 mitigate most of the noise and should bother the
0:35:33 surrounding uses. With that, I can stand for any
0:35:48 questions or I can turn the time over to Nathan or
0:35:51 Any questions for Will while he's here?
0:35:54 Yes, Mayor, quick questions.
0:35:56 In relation to this location, where's the closest temporary
0:36:02 motor machine that you had when you were testing things out?
0:36:05 I will let Nathan answer that one. He knows the specifics on those temporary locations.
0:36:11 Okay, thank you.
0:36:12 All right. Thank you again.
0:36:22 So as you'll remember, it's been, I was just here October 28th
0:36:29 and presenting on the results of this last summer's order study.
0:36:33 And that kind of, hopefully, that reminds you of the why I'm back to request this.
0:36:38 To go to your question, Mr. B, to a map here, so looking at this aerial map, yeah,
0:36:52 so we're proposing to put it in the kind of northwest corner.
0:36:56 The nearest Mandel where we were able to test during the trial,
0:37:00 the summer was actually down here by this, just by the corner of Moose Street and Grizzly Drive.
0:37:09 It was parked right there. It was less than 100 feet from this home. And all those neighbors,
0:37:17 I did make contact with the closest homes there and let them know to contact me if there were any
0:37:22 issues and I heard nothing in the summer, neither about noise nor, I mean, obviously,
0:37:29 The odors should not be an issue because that's why it's supposed to be addressing.
0:37:37 This location, we tested here and then went over on the rim and both locations worked.
0:37:46 We saw a significant reduction in the number of odor complaints.
0:37:49 This area has a history of having odor issues.
0:37:53 This odor scrubber gives us the ability to pretty much pull the air out of the sewer,
0:38:00 run it through carbon media, and put out the clean air.
0:38:07 It, like I said, the summer helped kind of prove that that works.
0:38:13 We had reduction in complaints, and even the complaints we did receive were a lot more
0:38:22 moderate in their concerns of the orders.
0:38:26 See, the location, we've reviewed that with our Parks and Rec director, but she's aware
0:38:37 obviously this is kind of their property that we're dealing with and the location, we're trying
0:38:44 to get as close to that corner as possible, but also keep it out of the intersection causing
0:38:50 problems there and also making it so that we can access it so it's not too close to that corner.
0:38:57 We're looking at about 95 feet off of the curb of Grandview, the approximate location that would be
0:39:04 on the map that's in the packet. The permanent order scrubber, the city has already purchased
0:39:13 that. That's one that we've been using this last summer at our public works office.
0:39:17 The fan that would be used is larger than the one that's been on the trailer.
0:39:24 It's been in use, but the permanent location or the permanent fan does have several things
0:39:31 that will help mitigate the noise because we know that that's one of the biggest concerns
0:39:35 that people have had.
0:39:36 It does have a shroud around the fan itself to help, you know, contain some of the noise.
0:39:44 There's also a sound attenuator, kind of like a silencer that comes off of the fan, and then
0:39:51 the other thing that will make a big difference also that we didn't have this year around
0:39:56 the temporary one is the fence that will go around the unit will be a precast concrete
0:40:02 fence.
0:40:03 And that will obviously stop any noise from going out, it'll push it up and absorb that.
0:40:11 And I guess that is all I have right now, unless there's any questions.
0:40:16 And, sir, has the question.
0:40:20 Oh, you're good, Chris.
0:40:24 Two things.
0:40:25 Will this be the permanent home for?
0:40:27 I see that it doesn't have a roof.
0:40:28 So the elements during the winter, when it's not really being used as much,
0:40:33 or will it be used during the winter?
0:40:35 So, yeah, it would be turned off during the colder months.
0:40:40 So it would be turned off.
0:40:41 And, yeah, there's not a roof.
0:40:43 We actually have a unit, it's similar, but it's a little more complicated, it has a little
0:40:48 bit more to it.
0:40:49 It's an odor you understand by the golf course in the canyon, right by the zipline, not many
0:40:55 people realize it's there unless it's not working, but that it has also, it's an odor
0:41:00 strip that's pulling air out of the sewer.
0:41:03 You can't see what's in there, but there's no roof on that either.
0:41:06 And it's okay to have these out or would they be removed during this period of time?
0:41:10 No, this would be, once it's placed, it'll be there permanently.
0:41:15 Jason.
0:41:17 Nathan, I think you talked about it when you were here last,
0:41:21 but how often are we anticipating to have to regenerate
0:41:24 that unit with the carbon?
0:41:28 Yeah, so our temporary unit is about a fourth of the capacity
0:41:35 as far as the media that's in it.
0:41:37 And we've been able to use that for over a year.
0:41:40 we actually about mid-summer had to replace the media. This will have more media, more
0:41:45 capacity. We're expecting probably every, you know, somewhere between two to five years
0:41:50 could be longer, depending on once the media absorbs all the car or the all the hard hydrogen
0:42:01 sulfide, it starts to smell and you know, you can tell pretty much immediately and then
0:42:06 can get in there and we already have the media on site to replace it so if it you
0:42:12 know when it does reach capacity in a few years we can just replace it.
0:42:16 We'll have a question can we scroll up to the actual picture itself of the right there?
0:42:27 Is there a particular reason why the wall doesn't go to the top?
0:42:32 So they found the air circulation or no actually that's one consideration this is
0:42:38 probably the best picture here.
0:42:39 So the unit itself is seven and a half feet tall.
0:42:43 This fence right now that's shown
0:42:45 is the six foot fence.
0:42:47 We can do a seven foot fence without happily engineering
0:42:50 and it would almost cover it.
0:42:53 There will only be half a foot showing
0:42:54 and I think that would be a little bit more money,
0:42:57 but I think that would be a good option.
0:43:03 Any other questions for Nathan?
0:43:10 Okay, do you have anything to add, Will at all?
0:43:18 Nothing to add, just concluding that this will be an
0:43:22 approval of a new use, and that's the verage that I
0:43:28 recommend utilizing.
0:43:32 And then also, if you would like that fence to be 7 feet,
0:43:36 I recommend the condition to be placed upon it as well.
0:43:41 Okay, so next we'll open it up for public input.
0:43:48 Again, when you come down to the podium,
0:43:50 please state your name and your address.
0:43:53 State your comments.
0:43:54 You will be given three minutes
0:43:57 and I believe somebody will be timing.
0:44:01 You have the timer ready.
0:44:04 So anybody here wishes to address perfect?
0:44:17 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:44:19 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:44:22 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:44:26 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:44:29 I come to you with two hats on as well.
0:44:31 I also work at Rock Creek Elementary,
0:44:32 and I do have some concerns with the elementary
0:44:34 across the street as well.
0:44:36 So I live in the house right on the corner,
0:44:38 right across the street from the elementary,
0:44:40 and I do know that you guys are hoping
0:44:43 to put that in at the corner.
0:44:46 I would like to point that it is the main crosswalk where students are crossing.
0:44:50 I do fear that there would be some visibility issues for students crossing especially at
0:44:54 nighttime or during daylight savings time.
0:44:58 If you increase the fence that would make it less visible for people to see, it's going
0:45:03 to be an eyesore.
0:45:08 A lot of people in my neighborhood have reached out to me that weren't able to come but they
0:45:12 did have other concerns.
0:45:14 They asked about the flooding that happens anytime that there's massive flooding, to the
0:45:20 point where people use kayaks in the back of that area.
0:45:24 What are we going to do when it floods in that exact area about two feet?
0:45:29 How are they going to work with that?
0:45:31 Are they rebuilding the entire section over there?
0:45:35 Other concerns I had, obviously, as I'm probably the closest house would be sound, smell, issues
0:45:40 like that.
0:45:41 Again, it's a huge eyesore.
0:45:44 When it is dry, when it's not used for that, it is used for our neighborhood.
0:45:51 We do neighborhood events there, there's practices that go on in that section.
0:45:55 So if you're going to reestablish it for a new purpose, it is being used right now.
0:46:01 So I want to say that it is being used for football practice for people using it as a
0:46:06 park and playground all the time.
0:46:08 And again, my biggest concerns would be student safety on that crosswalk, that lack of visibility
0:46:14 when people are crossing there. I'd also be worried about the eyesore it would create.
0:46:20 Again, see what else they want to talk about. The flooding was the big one. Another neighbor.
0:46:28 Your time is up. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Okay. Thank you. Go ahead.
0:46:42 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:46:47 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:46:54 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:47:00 school being right there is going to be an obstructed area where people are going to have
0:47:06 trouble seeing around that corner.
0:47:08 I did notice that the place where they put the temporary facilities, we've had irrigation
0:47:14 problems there.
0:47:15 And so a lot of that smell is just coming from stagnant water.
0:47:18 So I don't know if that's the same smell we're talking about when we're saying sewer water
0:47:22 or if we're just talking stagnant water that's sitting there
0:47:25 per month on end because the drainage is not done properly there.
0:47:29 So my biggest concern is is this being done just because of poor drainage
0:47:33 or is it being done for some other reason? Something we don't know about like the sewer going
0:47:37 underneath the area. But we have noticed I've lived there
0:47:40 before I moved there in 2019 and there was a long time where we just have
0:47:44 stagnant water sitting there and that's kind of what the smell was
0:47:47 that I found, but I do live down the street and we do walk our animals around there, so if there's
0:47:53 noise like there was this summer, I think that might be a concern just because people aren't used
0:47:58 to seeing it. So when we saw it there, we just like, okay, what is this? We didn't really know how to act
0:48:03 or basically how long it was going to be there. So that's basically it. Put that whole neighborhood
0:48:09 does utilize that space serve as a part of the future. That's it. Thank you. Thank you.
0:48:14 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:48:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:48:36 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:48:43 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:48:50 is taking care of is a sewer smell and it I see it's it sounded like it was 95 feet off
0:49:00 of the corner but I don't see that that's a problem for visibility around the corner
0:49:06 and that's pretty far from houses it seems like a pretty fence that it is
0:49:13 around there so I don't see an eyesore kids across the street of the school
0:49:19 is probably 300 feet away from it and it doesn't put out smell. This is a
0:49:29 difficult situation for the people that it affects negatively and so I think
0:49:36 that thing that we have to do here is find the best scenario that it affects
0:49:43 the least amount of people in a negative fashion and it seems like this is a
0:49:48 a pretty good spot in my opinion. So I am definitely for it. We have to do
0:49:57 something. I cannot continue to have the smells come directly into my house. And
0:50:02 so I'm going to say I'm ready to fistfight anybody. No, it's a bad deal and I
0:50:12 I get that people are around there and it's not ideal, but trust me, it's definitely something
0:50:21 that's made.
0:50:22 Thank you.
0:50:23 Thank you, sir.
0:50:25 Is there anybody else out in the audience that wishes to speak?
0:50:28 I see no one.
0:50:35 Any comments from you have anything else to add, Nathan?
0:50:40 Yes.
0:50:42 And actually, I think the stormwater part, I did not, I guess, address out fully like I needed
0:50:48 to.
0:50:49 So it is a stormwater retention area.
0:50:52 So if you go out there, it is lower.
0:50:55 And the location where we're proposing to put this,
0:50:58 it is a lower spot in that stormwater retention area.
0:51:03 So we would have to build that up.
0:51:06 It's about an 800 square foot footprint
0:51:08 of where the fence would be.
0:51:10 But it'd have to be built up.
0:51:12 And in building that up, we would have
0:51:13 to add storage capacity for that stormwater retention area elsewhere on the property.
0:51:24 It would be maybe an opportunity to address some of the drainage issues.
0:51:28 However, the odors that we were addressing were from the sewer, not from any standing
0:51:33 water or anything in that area.
0:51:35 In fact, our complaints of odor issues are not, they're kind of everything north of about
0:51:41 that location.
0:51:42 It seems like that's where the issues are.
0:51:45 What this grubber does is by sucking the air out,
0:51:49 it relieves the pressure on the system.
0:51:51 And so further down, we actually have higher H2S levels
0:51:56 in the sewer along, ground view, kind of along that neighborhood,
0:52:00 but the pressure's not there.
0:52:02 So it's going down the line and coming out
0:52:05 into some of the homes down further.
0:52:06 So I think we will have to adjust some of that storage capacity in the stormwater retention area.
0:52:15 It is set back off the road in a ways, and if there's a request to have it further,
0:52:26 we could look at that if it's a concern.
0:52:29 But I do believe that it's off of the sidewalk,
0:52:35 and that sidewalk is about, it's 10 foot wide sidewalk right there, more four feet south of that,
0:52:42 where the fence starts.
0:52:45 You're actually, sorry, I have the mouse here, so they're looking at the site, so from the
0:52:56 curb you have six feet of grass and then there's a 10 foot sidewalk and then there'd be a four
0:53:07 foot before you would get to the fence.
0:53:11 But it's 90 some feet from the intersection is that yeah 95 feet okay
0:53:17 from to the intersection to the west is 95 can they zoom in on that small map up
0:53:24 in the corner kind of see it's a way the way from that crosswalk that's a concern
0:53:33 and our site triangles are 40 feet by 40 feet so that's well above it's well
0:53:43 out of the site triangle for city code.
0:53:48 That was my question.
0:53:51 And I guess one more thing, I mean, as far as an eyesore,
0:53:54 I mean, we're trying to use the precast fence,
0:53:58 and you know, going seven foot would not be a problem
0:54:02 to try and make it look nice.
0:54:03 The other thing is, is with that precast,
0:54:06 we're also going to have it coated with an anti-grifidi
0:54:10 coating so that that was one thing
0:54:12 Wendy, our Parks and Rec director, she requested just, she's worried if any any
0:54:18 at graffiti occurred. What about climbing? Those pre-castes are not like, I don't
0:54:25 think that there's really finger holes enough to climb it and being
0:54:30 seven foot, it should be more of a deterrent for kids trying to climb the fence.
0:54:34 We would hope. Or a challenge, hopefully not. Okay, anybody else that wishes to
0:54:42 to address City Council on this issue.
0:54:48 Okay, then I'll close the public hearing.
0:54:51 No further testimony or comments
0:54:53 from the applicant or audience will be allowed.
0:54:55 So Council, what are your wishes?
0:54:58 Yeah, I think, great.
0:55:01 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:55:03 I kind of had the same issues as the guy that came up
0:55:09 and talked about the side triangle
0:55:11 and also about utilizing that space for practices
0:55:15 for football and soccer, but I believe there's quite a bit of variant in that 26 feet, because
0:55:20 that's on the slope leading down to the drainage, correct? So that wouldn't necessarily be utilized
0:55:24 for practice space. So it kind of eats up some of that grade.
0:55:28 Full of water too. Yeah, I would be inclined to raise the fence to max capacity without
0:55:37 engineering. Hey, Chris Reed. I was just going to add that I'm in favor of bringing it up
0:55:45 to seven feet as well.
0:55:47 Thank you.
0:55:48 Chair Volmer.
0:55:49 I'll echo the seven foot fence.
0:55:52 I think that definitely needs to be done.
0:55:56 Looking at the map, the vicinity map,
0:55:58 and taking into consider her concerns over,
0:56:03 or that it's not just her concerns.
0:56:05 She's neighborhood concerns over the site.
0:56:08 It does appear that it's further off,
0:56:13 which would not, it doesn't appear
0:56:16 that it would impede visual of walking on the sidewalk.
0:56:23 And then looking to see to understand
0:56:25 that it's being used right now in a park sense,
0:56:33 looking at the vicinity map that looks pretty small on there.
0:56:37 Does that, and when we can't ask questions.
0:56:42 You can ask staff.
0:56:47 I was just wondering if that,
0:56:49 you've seen it on the vicinity map
0:56:51 if it seemed smaller than what the neighbors had had envisioned.
0:57:04 We know that it's an 800 square foot upward from a fence.
0:57:07 There have some rating to go down from the fence into the area.
0:57:11 And this still needs to go through to get a permit.
0:57:14 So we'll get some building permit, kind of placement permits,
0:57:17 and go through all of the development services
0:57:18 for all of the required codes for that back or those types
0:57:22 of things from the intersection, just to assure
0:57:25 that that will happen.
0:57:28 I don't just looking at what the neighbors' concerns were
0:57:31 on there and very valid concerns versus what we're trying
0:57:38 to do here, and we're not just putting up the storage building.
0:57:41 We're trying to combat the older issue as well.
0:57:46 I think this will probably be the minimal spacing
0:57:51 and I think the seven-foot fence would probably be a monster.
0:57:57 Spencer.
0:57:59 Tonight's hearing just brought to light the issue
0:58:02 or the conundrum we have with water retention in parks.
0:58:05 The EPA requires that water is retained on site, storm water cannot run off.
0:58:11 So it's less expensive up front when the water is retained there in a situation like this.
0:58:19 The downside is it floods when it rains and it's not usable space.
0:58:23 I think it's accurate to say generally this is not permitted anymore.
0:58:27 The downside is that it adds more up front costs to lots when people are buying homes
0:58:32 in the future because the developers had to take other means to try to manage stormwater.
0:58:37 So it's one of those pros and cons to doing it either way, but it's not an oversight or
0:58:45 a mistake.
0:58:46 It was actually designed that way on purpose when the developer built this to comply with
0:58:49 the regulations.
0:58:50 So I just wanted to clarify that.
0:58:52 Good point.
0:58:53 Thank you.
0:58:54 Jason Brown.
0:58:55 Yeah.
0:58:56 Well, if on Hankins, go over to Hankins and go to Street View on your map, can you just
0:59:02 of the map on your side, so I'll give you a general idea of what I think the precast concrete
0:59:11 wall would be there by Pillar Falls on Hankins. Pillar Falls Elementary School, sorry, on Hankins.
0:59:27 Hankins and stadium would be a good, yeah, that's okay. Where are you from? I'll be a little bit
0:59:34 more specific on my direct right there. So if you go to Street View there, I think it gives a good
0:59:38 indication of what what this precast wall would would generally look like.
0:59:45 I think that's what you would end up with. I drive I drive by there on a regular
0:59:50 almost daily basis and you don't even really recognize that structure.
0:59:58 Obviously this is going to be something that would be new. People would recognize
1:00:02 it for a while. But I think with the site triangle and some of the engineering
1:00:08 practices that we put in place also following other standards. I'm not sure
1:00:12 that would be a huge issue with with traffic particularly because once they
1:00:18 start going east you know you can see you should be able to see that intersection
1:00:24 pretty well the one that we're talking about but I thought that was a good
1:00:27 visual representation of what I guess I'm assuming the old castle or the
1:00:33 precast whether we go to seven foot or not I guess I'm okay if we need to
1:00:43 make a huge difference. Anybody else? Well I think the issue that Mr. Bishop
1:00:55 talked about is huge and and I know we've had complaints and complaints and you know
1:01:01 this is a to me a great long-term solution that we've been looking for to
1:01:06 help mitigate that and I would concur that the seven-foot wall is probably the
1:01:12 direction they had. So I'm entertaining a motion.
1:01:17 I move that we approve the authorization of a new City of Twin Falls owned and
1:01:24 operated sewer order mitigation facility. I'm properly located at 879
1:01:30 Federation Road, care of the City of Twin Falls with a condition of a seven-foot
1:01:35 Thank you.
1:01:36 Do I have a second?
1:01:39 Okay.
1:01:40 Thank you.
1:01:41 Motion by Chris Reed.
1:01:42 Second by Craig Hawkins to authorize the new city of Twin Falls Zone and operated a sewer
1:01:48 odor mitigation facility on property located at 879 Federation Road with a condition of
1:01:56 a seven foot fence.
1:01:59 Any further discussion?
1:02:02 Rachel Roquevo, please.
1:02:04 Councillor. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
1:02:35 and we have our URA Executive Director, Sean Baraker.
1:02:41 Welcome, Sean.
1:02:43 Thank you, one moment,
1:02:44 because I figured you're gonna ask me for a mask.
1:02:47 The delay there.
1:03:08 Thank you.
1:03:09 Thank you, Mayor and Council.
1:03:10 So this is, I believe the third time
1:03:14 you've heard some information and presentation
1:03:16 on this item that we've been working on for the last several
1:03:20 months back in June, the Urban Renewal Agency,
1:03:24 had Cushlin Associates work through an eligibility report
1:03:29 for this new proposed urban renewal area.
1:03:35 There's the map on the screen up there,
1:03:37 so it's South Washington and then Diamond Avenue
1:03:41 up to South Park Avenue, out to Grandview
1:03:44 and down to Orchard, encompassing approximately 352 acres.
1:03:50 The area provides an opportunity for future commercial
1:03:52 and industrial development, and it is supported,
1:03:57 that would be supported by eligible public improvements
1:04:00 that could be initiated by the Herbrominal Agency.
1:04:03 So the eligibility report was conducted
1:04:06 and found that it was suitable for an Herbrominal Project
1:04:09 in accordance with Idaho Code.
1:04:12 Following that, an Economic Feasibility Study
1:04:15 was conducted that spoke to anticipated private improvements
1:04:21 that would incur in that area,
1:04:22 and the associated public improvements
1:04:26 that could be supported by that.
1:04:29 That was all reported back to the Urban Renewal Agency,
1:04:33 and then recommended to the Council
1:04:36 for consideration of adoption of the eligibility report,
1:04:40 which you did back in August.
1:04:44 There are many steps, as you know,
1:04:47 to creating an urban renewal area
1:04:50 that includes drafting the plan itself,
1:04:52 receipt of agricultural consents for property owners within the area whose properties are
1:04:58 currently agricultural operations of which there are several in this reviewed by the
1:05:03 Planning and Zoning Commission for concurrence with the comprehensive plan, formal adoption
1:05:07 of the plan by the agency board, communication with the overlapping taxing districts and
1:05:13 ultimately the formal adoption of the ordinance by the city council following noticed public
1:05:18 hearing, which is what we're doing tonight. So each of those steps has been
1:05:22 completed for this urbrenal area and are outlined in the ordinance that's in
1:05:28 your packet. The purpose of the item tonight is to hold a public hearing on the
1:05:33 creation of a new revenue allocation area on the property
1:05:37 referenced. The council is also being asked this
1:05:41 evening to consider adopting the ordinance which would create the new
1:05:45 area that would need to be done with a dispensing of the rules and placing it on
1:05:51 third and final reading by title only. If the ordinance is adopted this new area
1:05:57 will assist in funding again those eligible public improvements such as
1:06:00 streets, stormwater management facilities, water and sewer systems, pedestrian and
1:06:06 bicycle facilities, irrigation system modifications, rail spur, relocation and
1:06:11 electrical and gas improvements.
1:06:16 So you must, again, if you determine following the public hearing that you wish to adopt the
1:06:21 ordinance this evening, you'll have to do the additional motion to suspend the rules and so
1:06:26 forth.
1:06:28 So current, I will say that the adoption of this ordinance doesn't have a direct impact
1:06:33 on the city's current or future budgets.
1:06:36 After the area would sunset in 20 years if it's adopted, then the city and all the other
1:06:41 other taxing entities would be able to claim the increment value that in the meantime could
1:06:46 be utilized by the Urban Renewal Agency to support public improvements. So with that I will stop
1:06:52 talking, you can do the public hearing and then I can come back up and speak to the proposed
1:06:59 motions.
1:07:00 Perfect. Okay. I will open up the public hearing for this particular item, the Urban Renewal Agency
1:07:11 plan for Southwest Urban Renewal Project.
1:07:15 Is there anybody in the audience that wishes
1:07:17 to address City Council on this public hearing?
1:07:28 Hey, see no one?
1:07:31 Have anything to add?
1:07:33 No, I would just emphasize again that tonight
1:07:35 would be held the hearing.
1:07:38 If you wish to move forward with the adoption of the ordinance,
1:07:43 can suspend the rules and place an unthird and final reading
1:07:45 by title only, and then take that action.
1:07:48 The following steps for this, we will publish a summary
1:07:53 of the ordinance, because as you noted, it's lengthy.
1:07:56 I will have a summary published, and then communication
1:07:59 to all of the overlapping taxing districts,
1:08:02 as well as recording the plan and communicating
1:08:05 with the State Tax Commission.
1:08:07 All of those entities are well aware of this process.
1:08:09 They've been engaged since we started it back this summer.
1:08:12 So.
1:08:13 Thank you.
1:08:14 So I'm gonna officially close the public hearing
1:08:17 and move on to council discussion, Grace and Stone.
1:08:20 Thank you Madam Mayor.
1:08:21 I guess my question's directed more to Director Berger.
1:08:24 If you can answer it, if I'm allowed to ask,
1:08:27 will that reset the sunset clause
1:08:30 on the existing parcel with alphigurs,
1:08:34 right there on West Washington,
1:08:35 or will it just absorb it?
1:08:37 So the South Washington Erbournole project area
1:08:42 was terminated earlier this year.
1:08:44 So it does not exist anymore.
1:08:47 It is encompassed within this property,
1:08:49 but that area is already terminated.
1:08:52 Perfect, thank you.
1:08:54 Jason Brown.
1:08:55 I'll make a motion if there are no other questions.
1:08:58 That'd be great.
1:08:59 I move we dispense with the reading of the rules
1:09:01 and put ordinance number 2024-C21 on third and final,
1:09:09 reading by title only.
1:09:11 Thank you to have the second.
1:09:13 Second.
1:09:14 Thank you motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Craig Hawkins,
1:09:19 to dispense with the reading of the rules
1:09:21 in place ordinance 2024-021 on third and final reading
1:09:26 by title only.
1:09:29 Amy, Rachel Rolkalvo, please.
1:09:33 Ruth Pierce.
1:09:34 Yes.
1:09:35 Chris Reed.
1:09:36 Yes.
1:09:36 Craig Hawkins.
1:09:37 Jason Brown.
1:09:38 Yes.
1:09:39 Spencer Cutler.
1:09:40 Yes.
1:09:41 Yes.
1:09:42 Yes.
1:09:43 Thank you.
1:09:44 Motion passes 7-0.
1:09:45 Okay.
1:09:46 I will read the ordinance 2024-021, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls,
1:09:54 Idaho approving the Urban Renewal Plan for the Southwest Urban Renewal Project, which plan
1:10:00 includes revenue allocation, financing provisions, authorizing the City Clerk to transmit a copy
1:10:08 of this ordinance and other required information to county and state officials and the effect
1:10:14 in taxing entities providing severability, codification and publication by summary, providing
1:10:23 for waiver of the reading rules and provided an effective date.
1:10:27 Chris Reed.
1:10:29 Move to approve ordinance number 2024-021.
1:10:32 Thank you.
1:10:33 Do I have a second, Jason Brown?
1:10:36 Second.
1:10:37 Thank you motion by Chris Reed second by Jason Brown to approve the adoption of Ordinance
1:10:43 2024-0 to do you have something Grayson okay Rachel Roel call vote please yes Chris Reed
1:10:55 yes yes Jason Brown yes yes yes yes yes yes thank you motion passes 70-0 thank you Sean
1:11:08 Okay, the next action item is a request for a zoning title
1:11:13 amendment to repeal and replace title 10,
1:11:16 focusing on chapter one general provisions,
1:11:22 PZ24-0129, and we have Jonathan Stenlove
1:11:27 our planning and zoning director.
1:11:29 Welcome, Jonathan.
1:11:32 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the council.
1:11:33 This will kick off the first,
1:11:38 I don't know of how many public hearings that we're going to go to to go to each chapter. We have
1:11:43 Well, we're 13. I think now we're going to cover the first three. We're going to
1:11:47 Step into the kiddie pool really lightly with a few chapters that have not a lot of changes
1:11:54 Per say from what we have but the look will be different
1:11:58 I'm going to go where I'm not going to
1:12:01 Go through everything line by line. I'm going to show you what we currently have
1:12:05 I'm going to show you what we are proposing.
1:12:08 A lot of the language is going to be the same.
1:12:10 I like a few of the changes.
1:12:11 And I will often look over at Will,
1:12:13 as we've kind of worked on this.
1:12:14 He's going to remind me of some of the things I don't say.
1:12:18 This is what our current Title 10, Chapter 1, which
1:12:21 is the general provisions looks like.
1:12:24 As you go to our website, it's actually hosted by Am Legal.
1:12:28 And it goes through the title of the authority,
1:12:31 the jurisdiction, how we are able to create these rules.
1:12:34 This is the, I'm gonna say the boring stuff of the title.
1:12:38 This is what you point to, say here's our policies,
1:12:42 land subdivisions, the purpose of why we're here
1:12:45 and some of this stuff is given actually
1:12:46 by the state of Idaho.
1:12:48 A lot of it is the health and welfare
1:12:52 for the community and some of the police power
1:12:54 of the zoning code.
1:12:58 The proposed look is a little bit different.
1:13:02 We went to a two column look.
1:13:05 We kept a lot of the same, I guess,
1:13:07 the nuts and bolts of the words,
1:13:08 but we made it look different.
1:13:10 We have an effective date, the purpose and tend,
1:13:12 the authority, and we're gonna go through,
1:13:17 I think I'll touch on a few sections of this one.
1:13:18 This is the longest of the three chapters.
1:13:21 It's just a lot of those general purpose statements.
1:13:25 In the end, we took some sections from other places.
1:13:31 Mediation is a newer one that was somewhere else,
1:13:33 I think we brought into chapter one.
1:13:36 most of these end up being just what the state statute or what a loop of
1:13:40 requires us to have our local land use planning act from the state about how
1:13:43 requires us to have and it has just some other general provisions in it. I'm just
1:13:50 going to scroll slowly and I'm going to pause for questions if anybody had any
1:13:54 specific ones on any particular section. Is there anything major? We clarify a
1:14:04 lot of things but there are no major changes from what we currently have. Most
1:14:09 of these things all have the violations penalties effective dates it just looked
1:14:13 different. When we pulled in mediation that was in a separate code section we
1:14:17 brought it in the general provisions because that mediation portion is
1:14:22 actually a state requirement and so we have to list it somewhere. That's a general
1:14:26 provision that's not a specific zoning district provision. There are no real
1:14:31 major changes we clarified because the one I stopped on this transitional
1:14:37 development. Basically if you've applied for a permit at one point in time and the
1:14:42 check code changes, you don't go with the new rule, you go with the older rule. So
1:14:48 you have some things about unexpired permits and what provision governs. It's
1:14:51 the provision when you apply for a permit. Now that wasn't explicitly stated. That's
1:14:54 just been a, quite frankly, it's a Supreme Court case type of thing. So you just kind
1:15:01 of do it. We just put it in here as a very clear what our expectation is and what
1:15:06 we're going to do. Same with the violations and penalties. Other than that we kind of clarified
1:15:11 who's the administrator, who's actually making decisions on what that person does. These were
1:15:17 found part of it in like the bylaws section, but really that's an administrative general
1:15:23 provision section. We pulled things from different chapters to create this chapter one that actually
1:15:28 deals with the general provisions of the entire title. Otherwise, no, we ended up putting all
1:15:33 that into this instead of multiple chapters now they're just into one. Thank you. I'm trying to think
1:15:40 on the on the bylaws we did one of the changes I know we made looking for where it is. Two things.
1:16:04 One has to do with when you give us information when somebody sends information in or public comment
1:16:11 is going to be accepted. That is a change you're going to make. Talk about that one and we'll talk
1:16:16 We talk about the hearing procedures.
1:16:21 We currently allow public comment, written public comment to be received up till noon
1:16:25 the day of the public hearing.
1:16:26 We've heard from multiple council members and our planning zoning commission at times
1:16:31 that is almost a disservice because we can't get through, we have a lot of them in that
1:16:35 one day from noon to five, essentially.
1:16:39 We have changed that to, I think it's 72 hours, basically the Friday before the hearing, so
1:16:46 that any written comments have to be delivered and they can be part of the packet or sent
1:16:49 to over the weekend.
1:16:50 People can still come and speak during hearing.
1:16:52 Was there a written comment or two business days, that's what it is, it's F.
1:16:57 If I will see here, help me right here.
1:17:02 Written comments shall be received two business days prior to the hearing to be accepted for
1:17:05 consideration by the hearing body.
1:17:08 There have been times where we received ten pages of comments from one person and from
1:17:13 a council or commission standpoint the day of the meeting.
1:17:16 There's not enough time to go through 10 pages or 20 pages of comments to address any of those
1:17:22 comments.
1:17:23 That doesn't mean people can't come and speak and still have those heard.
1:17:25 It was the written comments of two business days to try and get that to as part of the packet
1:17:30 over the weekends.
1:17:33 The other change was, I'm going to go back, during the public hearing, the rules that you've
1:17:37 been reading were, was the directive some years ago.
1:17:43 That yellow sheet?
1:17:44 Yeah, that yellow sheet you read.
1:17:46 we've that sheet was a directive from Council to change and then we're basically just reflecting
1:17:51 that into the code now. One of the things were we swapped who went first. That was a directive
1:17:58 some time ago that we as staff present first the bylaws have said that it was the applicant
1:18:03 first but there was always a confusion. We've gone first but that's basically reflecting
1:18:08 that currently in the code is that's how we're going to do it.
1:18:14 Yeah, ten, one, ten, um, introduces rules of language construction, so essentially defines
1:18:22 how we're gonna, how someone needs to read it. So, shall, will, and must, are all with always
1:18:27 mandatory and may as permissive. So, like three. We didn't have any of these sections here before.
1:18:33 Just clarifies what those words will mean in terms of this code. Really, as the majority of the
1:18:44 changes. We fully expect there to be spelling errors, or where has County City, as we copied
1:18:53 and we've kind of used things from other places, punctuation, those things were going to be clarifying
1:18:58 as we go along. There's just a lot of pages to go through, so we think we're going to miss
1:19:03 some. We'll hopefully fix them all before the final public hearing some months from now.
1:19:10 That is all for chapter one, unless there's any more questions. That's great. Thank you.
1:19:15 Any questions before I open up the public hearing?
1:19:23 I will, yes.
1:19:25 Do we not do all three public hearings, or do they have to be individual?
1:19:30 You can do them all if you'd like.
1:19:32 We advertise them all to have separability because some of the chapters, later chapters, might be more,
1:19:39 the controversial will have more input, so you'll want to separate those so there's not one motion.
1:19:45 but tonight we could use it go and present the next chapter until we can do a
1:19:49 public unit with that be appropriate as the next ones are pretty short chapter
1:19:58 three I'm going to show you what the current chapter three we pulled from two
1:20:09 different sections are a couple different there's a warehouse historic
1:20:11 overlay district which has a lot of provisions about historic preservation
1:20:15 and we also that's the only one that was in the zoning called the rest of the
1:20:20 rest and re-referenced by other decisions, we've truncated it down into one chapter and
1:20:29 one page. And it talks about what's applicable, the certificate of appropriateness, and how
1:20:35 they go about applying for a certificate, as well as denoting the areas right in here what
1:20:42 districts we have. We currently have downtown historic city park district and the warehouse
1:20:48 district. We have three total historic districts. We're going to reference all of them just as
1:20:53 historic districts. Removing the warehouse has an overlay because that's more of a zoning thing,
1:20:58 not a historic district thing. And these will now be referenced with their own maps that we have
1:21:04 that we'll be providing. We didn't change much else other than make this certificate of appropriateness
1:21:12 from, it was in a weird section, it was in the building code section under chapter 13. And we just said
1:21:19 said you need a certificate of appropriateness, whether you need a building criminal or not,
1:21:22 this reflects truly what the statute talks about a certificate of appropriateness for.
1:21:26 And it's just one page.
1:21:28 Great.
1:21:30 Sim, did you have something?
1:21:31 Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor.
1:21:32 So in 10, 14, 4, subsection C, if the request is not in accordance with the conference, a plan
1:21:39 that requests shall be submitted to the commission or in its absence of the council, which shall
1:21:43 recommend the council, what does it in its absence mean?
1:21:46 So, I have to pull up the code because you pulled up a section that I don't want to talk about right now, but let me look.
1:21:54 I'm sorry, I had the wrong one.
1:21:56 I don't know.
1:22:00 I was looking at the...
1:22:01 That's not even...
1:22:02 No, I was looking at the...
1:22:04 What was that?
1:22:06 How am I?
1:22:08 I was looking at the P&D minutes on this one.
1:22:14 That's a different...
1:22:17 It was part of the... I may be wrong.
1:22:19 You wanted a riff raise.
1:22:23 I was just wondering what it meant.
1:22:26 In the absence of a commission...
1:22:28 If it's referring to a planning and zoning commission,
1:22:31 not all cities have a planning and zoning commission,
1:22:33 the council retains that decision.
1:22:36 Thank you.
1:22:38 But those are the main changes about historic districts.
1:22:41 Any questions specifically on those?
1:22:43 Any questions for Jonathan on this one?
1:22:50 Chapter three.
1:22:53 Okay, moving on to Chapter 11, Area of Impact.
1:23:04 So we go from this section here, multiple portions that basically say
1:23:09 the area of impact is the jurisdiction of the county. We pretty much say that again
1:23:14 but even fewer words that it is the administration is of the County Board of
1:23:21 Commissioners and this provision here which is persons living within the area
1:23:26 of impact shall be entitled to representation that's actually a state
1:23:29 statute so we can't remove that and then the enforcement is the county and they
1:23:35 can renegotiate it at any time upon the request which is still sort of a
1:23:40 state statute and I say sort of if it's changed a bit, it's not really an
1:23:43 negotiation, but we can certainly talk with the county about it and submit any
1:23:46 recommendations to them. We still need this chapter, but it's a pretty short one.
1:23:52 As you can see, that is all. Excellent. Any questions on that one? Chapter 11.
1:23:58 Okay, so I will open up the public hearing and public hearing 4, looking at
1:24:08 Chapter 1, Chapter 3, and Chapter 11. Chapter 1 is General Provisions. Chapter 3 is
1:24:16 Historic District and Regulations in Chapter 11 is Area of Impact. Is there
1:24:21 anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on these three
1:24:26 chapters in the Code? Title 10. Seeing no one, I will close the public hearing and
1:24:38 Council discussion. Craig Hawkins. I just think it's pretty well straight
1:24:49 forward to make sense. Any problem with it?
1:24:53 Mr. Reed, I just want to thank everyone who's worked very hard on that. We talked about this
1:25:00 in...
1:25:01 Was it 18?
1:25:02 Was it 18? 17?
1:25:04 Somewhere around there, and I know a ton of work has gone into this, so thank you.
1:25:08 I agree.
1:25:09 Grayson?
1:25:10 Well, Madam Mayor, I'm willing to make a motion. There's no further discussion.
1:25:16 And can we can include all three and one motion you want three motions
1:25:24 okay
1:25:27 First one Grayson. Oh, thank you Madam Mayor
1:25:30 I will make a motion that we approve a zoning title amendment to repeal and replace title 10 folks on chapter one general provisions
1:25:37 easy to nine dash zero one two nine. Thank you. Can I have a second second?
1:25:42 Thank you motion by Grayson Stone second by Chris Reed
1:25:45 to approve the zoning title amendment to replace repeal and replace title 10
1:25:52 focusing on chapter one general provisions any discussion Rachel
1:25:59 Rokavo please yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes thank
1:26:10 Thank you. Motion passes 7-0.
1:26:12 Okay. Next item, chapter 3.
1:26:15 Jason Brown.
1:26:21 Would move to amend the zoning title, or move to approve the zoning title amendment to repeal
1:26:32 and replace title and focusing on chapter 3 historic districts and regulations.
1:26:37 Thank you, Chris Reed. Second.
1:26:39 Thank you. Motion by Jason Brown. Seconded by Chris Reed to approve the zoning title amendments
1:26:45 to repeal and replace Title 10, focusing on Chapter 3,
1:26:50 historic district and regulations.
1:26:54 Rachel Roquevo, please.
1:26:57 Yes.
1:26:58 Jason Brown.
1:26:58 Yes.
1:26:59 Spencer Cutler.
1:27:00 Yes.
1:27:00 Sherry Vomer.
1:27:01 Grace Nstone.
1:27:03 Yes.
1:27:03 Ruth Pierce.
1:27:04 Yes.
1:27:04 And Chris Rie.
1:27:05 Yes.
1:27:07 Thank you, Motion passes 7-0.
1:27:09 OK, we have one more.
1:27:11 Now, this is Chapter 11 Spencer color.
1:27:14 Well, I'll make this motion.
1:27:16 So I move to approve the proposed zoning text amendment
1:27:20 to the area of the impact chapter of Title 10 as presented.
1:27:24 Thank you, do you have a second?
1:27:27 Second.
1:27:28 Thank you, motion by Spencer Cutler, second by Sherry Volmer.
1:27:31 To approve the zoning title amendments to replace
1:27:34 and repeal Title 10, focusing on Chapter 11 area of impacts.
1:27:42 Rachel Rohe, call vote please.
1:27:44 Ruth Pierce.
1:27:45 Yes.
1:27:45 Chris Reed.
1:27:46 Yes.
1:27:46 Ray Cawkins.
1:27:47 Yes.
1:27:48 Jason Brown.
1:27:48 Yes.
1:27:49 Mr. Cutler, to share your mama.
1:27:51 Yes.
1:27:51 In Grace and Stone.
1:27:52 Yes.
1:27:53 Thank you.
1:27:54 Motion passes 7 to 0.
1:27:56 Thank you, guys.
1:27:57 That was great.
1:27:59 So next on the agenda is the canceled executive session.
1:28:03 And so we are adjourned.
1:28:04 Thank you, everyone.
Download
- Transcript (text) 77 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 102 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 139 KB
- Audio (M4A) 20.7 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 16, 2024. The recording started at 16:57 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:28:11.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
1b22bd5e4ddf02636a610ab6c8379dc73d5903ff9aa171b6ee46becfe8ac1ecb - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 3 passages muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 21ecd69b66b64596705700689b1b398b3145f92c81dbbae4ab126bffa8f1da2b - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 11 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
631845cc7e7eddeb96f19cb9eacf726cc71ba40c6141df33d0fb527b507377d1
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file