City Council meeting
Monday, November 18, 2024
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on file
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:03:49 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the November 18th, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm
0:03:57 We have a quorum. We have six members present in chambers and councilman stone is excused tonight
0:04:04 So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise
0:04:10 Okay, I do have a proclamation tonight
0:04:30 And it is a titularly, but we don't have a meeting the week of Thanksgiving
0:04:36 So, we have Thanksgiving, so I'm going to go ahead and read it tonight.
0:04:40 It's the Small Business Saturday Proclamation November 30, 2024, whereas the City of Twin
0:04:48 Falls Idaho celebrates our local small businesses and the contributions they make to our local
0:04:53 economy and community, whereas according to the U.S. Small Business Administration, there
0:05:00 are 32 and a half million small businesses in the United States.
0:05:05 Small businesses represent 99.7 of firms paid with paid employees.
0:05:12 Small businesses are responsible for 62% of net new jobs created since 1995,
0:05:19 and small businesses employ 46.8% of the employees in the private sector in the United States.
0:05:26 And whereas 79% of consumers understand the importance of supporting the small businesses
0:05:32 in their community on small business Saturday, 70% report the day makes them want to encourage
0:05:40 others to shop small, independent owned retailers, and 66% report that the day makes them want
0:05:47 to shop small all year long, and whereas 58% of shoppers reported they shop online with
0:05:54 the small business and 54% reported they dined or ordered take out from a small restaurant
0:06:00 bar or cafe on small business Saturday in 2023.
0:06:05 And whereas the city of Twin Falls Idaho supports our local businesses that create jobs, boost
0:06:11 our local economy and preserve our communities.
0:06:15 And whereas advocacy groups as well as public and private organizations across the country
0:06:21 We have endorsed the Saturday after Thanksgiving, a small business Saturday.
0:06:26 Now therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim November
0:06:32 30, 2024, a small business Saturday and urge the residents of our community and communities
0:06:39 across the country to support small businesses and merchants on small business Saturday and
0:06:45 throughout the year.
0:06:47 We have Jennifer Colvin here from Duncan's and D11's
0:06:52 and representing downtown.
0:07:40 Thank you so much for having me here today.
0:07:42 And Small Business Saturday is huge to all of the small businesses.
0:07:45 Of course, we have so many amazing businesses in Twin Falls,
0:07:48 but especially in our downtown area.
0:07:51 I know on Small Business Saturday, for November 30,
0:07:53 there's two events happening.
0:07:55 Candy Cane Lane on Maine, which is from 10 to 4, on Maine Avenue.
0:07:59 and there's also downtown, downtown market,
0:08:04 and it's gonna be at redeem decor,
0:08:05 but go out shopping, shop and have lunch
0:08:09 at all the local restaurants.
0:08:10 We really do appreciate all the support of the community,
0:08:12 and we would not be able to be here without the support
0:08:15 of the person likes to do just face-to-face shopping.
0:08:18 We adore that and face, you know,
0:08:20 everything that you do for Christmas
0:08:22 and coming in and supporting us.
0:08:23 So thank you so much.
0:08:25 Thank you, Jennifer.
0:08:28 Yep, you can take it if you'd like,
0:08:31 Okay, next on the agenda is the consent calendar, Council wishes to approve.
0:08:43 Thank you to have a second.
0:08:45 Thank you motion by Chris Reed second and by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar
0:08:50 as written.
0:08:51 Amy roll call vote please.
0:08:54 Rachel.
0:08:55 Ruth Pierce.
0:08:56 Yes.
0:08:57 Chris Reed.
0:08:58 Yes.
0:08:59 Yes.
0:09:00 Jason Brown.
0:09:01 Yes.
0:09:02 Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. A next under items of
0:09:10 consideration, we have an action item, a request to confirm the mayoral appointment
0:09:16 of Sherrielson-Frank, the airport advisory board, and we have airport manager Bill
0:09:21 Carberry. Welcome Bill. Thank you Mayor. Good evening Council. Recently we had Tom
0:09:28 Frank complete his second three-year term so he sort of turned out sort of
0:09:33 speak. He was a very valuable board member. So we advertised, we had a couple
0:09:40 applicants in an interview board that consisted of Chris Reed, our council liaison,
0:09:48 Brent Renke, Jim O'Donnell and myself. Sherri Olson-Frank was the lone applicant due
0:09:55 of a late withdrawal by one of the other applicants.
0:09:58 So I'd like to just describe some of her background.
0:10:02 Sherry has a background in volunteer work
0:10:05 and a good understanding of airport operations
0:10:07 being married to Tom Frank, who's sort of an aviation geek,
0:10:11 I think, goes a long way to that.
0:10:13 Her background includes past participation on committees
0:10:17 to include planning and zoning,
0:10:19 Twin Falls Strategic Planning, Agra Falls,
0:10:22 Twin Falls County Pest Abatement, Region 4
0:10:24 development and the Twin Falls pollinator council.
0:10:29 We have some of the hives at the airport that Sherry manages.
0:10:32 She's a beekeeper, so we got off to an interesting relationship about a year ago when she put those
0:10:38 out there, and it's nice to see that most of the hives are doing well.
0:10:43 So with that, I would, on behalf of the interview committee and Mayor Ruth Pierce, I recommend
0:10:49 approval of the request to confirm the appointment of Sherry Olson Frank to the
0:10:54 Airport Advisory Board. Thank you Bill, Chris Reed. As Bill stated I had the
0:10:58 opportunity to be in that interview and get to know Sherry and it was very
0:11:02 enjoyable to see all the work that she has done. She's been a great asset not only
0:11:07 to the city but also the county and the committees that she's been on. It was
0:11:13 sad to see her husband step off but we got to keep a frank on hopefully if we
0:11:18 I would love to if that's all right.
0:11:25 Okay. I move that we approve the confirmation of the mayor appointment of Sherry Olson-Frank
0:11:31 to the airport advisory board.
0:11:33 Sherry Vomer.
0:11:34 I'll second.
0:11:35 Thank you.
0:11:36 Motion by Chris Street.
0:11:37 Second by Sherry Vomer to approve the appointment of Sherry Olson-Frank to the airport advisory
0:11:44 board.
0:11:45 Amy Roll call vote, please.
0:11:47 Yes.
0:11:51 Sherry?
0:11:52 Yes.
0:11:53 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero. Welcome, Sherry.
0:12:03 Sorry, Rachel. I will call on you here in a minute. Sorry. Old habits die hard.
0:12:08 Okay. Next item on the agenda is an action item. A request to adopt ordinance 2024-013
0:12:16 for zoning development agreement on property located at 16.07 Washington Street,
0:12:25 and we have our P and Z director Jonathan Spandland.
0:12:27 Welcome.
0:12:28 Thank you, members of the council.
0:12:29 This item went to the Planning and Zoning Commission
0:12:32 on July 9th, the council on the 12th of August.
0:12:35 We prepared the ordinance after that decision.
0:12:38 I don't know anything this way to show
0:12:39 because the ordinance is in front of you.
0:12:41 If you wish to adopt this ordinance,
0:12:42 you would need to put it on third and final by title only,
0:12:46 at plus one, which is still the same number.
0:12:48 And that language is in the staff report
0:12:50 under the conclusion.
0:12:52 I believe this conclusion could be the regulatory,
0:12:54 I forget which section I put that under.
0:12:56 It's there and I'll stand for any questions.
0:12:58 As a reminder, the section is the townhome development.
0:13:02 South Washington, about eight acres.
0:13:06 If there's any questions on it,
0:13:07 the agreement is attached as well in your packet.
0:13:12 Thank you, any questions for Jonathan?
0:13:16 Mayor, I'll make a motion.
0:13:17 I move that we dispense with the reading rules
0:13:19 and put ordinance 2024-013 on third and final reading
0:13:25 by title only.
0:13:26 Thank you to have a second.
0:13:27 Jason Brown.
0:13:28 I'll second.
0:13:29 Thank you.
0:13:30 Motion by Chris Reed, second by Jason Brown,
0:13:33 to dispense with the reading rules in place ordinance 2024-013
0:13:38 on third and final reading by title only.
0:13:42 Rachel, roll call vote please.
0:13:45 Craig Hawkins.
0:13:46 Yes.
0:13:46 Jason Brown.
0:13:47 Yes.
0:13:48 And Sir.
0:13:49 Yes.
0:13:49 Perry Volmer.
0:13:50 Yes.
0:13:51 Ruth Pierce.
0:13:52 Yes.
0:13:53 Yes.
0:13:54 think the motion passes six to zero.
0:13:57 So I'll read the ordinance 2024-013,
0:14:01 an ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls,
0:14:04 Idaho, rezoning certain real property below described,
0:14:09 providing the zoning classification, therefore,
0:14:12 and ordering the necessary area of impact
0:14:15 and zoning district map amendments.
0:14:18 Chris Reed.
0:14:19 Move to approve ordinance 2024-013.
0:14:23 Thank you to have a second.
0:14:24 A second.
0:14:25 Thank you motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Sherry Vomer
0:14:29 to adopt Ordinance 2024-013 for zoning development agreement
0:14:34 on property located on 1607 Washington Street, South.
0:14:39 Any further discussion?
0:14:41 Rachel, roll call vote please.
0:14:44 Ruth Pierce.
0:14:44 Yes.
0:14:45 Chris Reed.
0:14:46 Yes.
0:14:47 Yes.
0:14:48 Brown.
0:14:49 Yes.
0:14:50 Spencer Keller.
0:14:50 Sherry Vomer.
0:14:51 Yes.
0:14:52 Thank you, motion passes six to zero.
0:14:56 Okay, we have two public hearings tonight,
0:15:00 but before we move to those,
0:15:02 this is the time for general public input.
0:15:05 There's anybody from the public
0:15:07 that wishes to address city council
0:15:10 on an item not on today's agenda.
0:15:13 So that would be the two public hearings,
0:15:17 we'll have public input later on those.
0:15:20 If there's anybody here that wishes to address City Council,
0:15:24 please come down to the podium.
0:15:31 Hey, see, no one.
0:15:33 Vice-reboard reports.
0:15:35 I will mention I was wrong.
0:15:37 We are having the City Council meeting next week.
0:15:40 So you're not off, not off.
0:15:45 Any other advisory board reports?
0:15:48 Yeah, I've got, I'll jump in here.
0:15:49 We had our Metropolitan Planning Organization meeting last week.
0:15:54 The MPO continues to meet to develop the transportation plan for that metropolitan organization and
0:16:04 continue to work through building that organization out.
0:16:09 We have a executive director now work down the path of making sure that we're encompassing
0:16:20 everything that we need to there.
0:16:22 Perfect.
0:16:23 Anybody else?
0:16:26 Just a quick update on the rec center.
0:16:29 We do have our rec center committee that is still moving forward on the planning of that.
0:16:38 And we are still in the process of looking for some land, I think probably somewhere
0:16:47 between nine to 14 acres around there.
0:16:51 So but we're still moving forward.
0:16:54 Thank you.
0:16:56 anything from the city manager's office.
0:16:59 All right, so next we will move into the public hearings.
0:17:05 We have to, and so I will read the public hearing rules.
0:17:11 The council will follow these steps where each request listed under the public hearing
0:17:17 portion of the agenda.
0:17:19 Staff will present the request and analysis.
0:17:22 The applicant will then present their request.
0:17:26 will then ask questions of the applicant or staff. After questions have been answered,
0:17:32 the public hearing will be opened. During that time, anyone in attendance is given the
0:17:37 opportunity to comment or ask questions about the request being considered. When giving testimony,
0:17:43 please step up to the podium, state your name and address, present your comments and concerns.
0:17:50 For giving testimony, please sign the public sign in, which is up in the lobby, and you will
0:17:57 have two minutes to make your comments.
0:18:00 Once public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and
0:18:05 make a closing statement.
0:18:08 Staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed.
0:18:11 And then after the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed.
0:18:15 No further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed and
0:18:20 then the council will have discussion and take action on the request.
0:18:26 Our first item is an action item.
0:18:29 It's a request to approve a zoning district change from R6 to C1 on property located on
0:18:36 the south side of the 1900 block of 14th Avenue East,
0:18:41 here of HLLC on behalf of Perrine Investments,
0:18:46 LLC, PZ24, DAS0094.
0:18:49 We have City Planner, Kelly Eversal, welcome, Kelly.
0:18:54 Thank you, Mayor, Council members.
0:18:56 Tonight we're here to hear a rezone request
0:19:00 for the 1900 block of 4th Avenue.
0:19:02 I'm not sure if it says 14th on the agenda,
0:19:04 but it's 4th Avenue East from R6 to C1 commercial district.
0:19:10 The property is highlighted on the vicinity map above.
0:19:14 It's between Morningside Drive and Eastland Drive.
0:19:19 On October 8th, the Planning and Zoning Commission
0:19:21 recommended C1 as the appropriate zoning designation
0:19:25 for the property.
0:19:26 The property is currently vacant
0:19:28 and there are no records showing development
0:19:30 on this property at all.
0:19:32 Per City Code 10, 14, 4 through 10, 14, 7, zoning district change,
0:19:37 zoning sub districts and overlay districts shall be amended
0:19:41 if the request is in accordance with the comprehensive plan.
0:19:46 Tonight, the council may approve the zoning change as requested,
0:19:50 grant a different zone, or deny the request.
0:19:55 If approved, the zoning district change
0:19:57 will remove the current zone's development entitlements,
0:20:01 and those will be replaced with the proposed development,
0:20:04 proposed zones development entitlements.
0:20:07 In this case, it'll remove the R6 uses
0:20:09 and the C1 zoning district land uses will be allowed.
0:20:14 The applicant has proposed to rezone this property
0:20:16 to C1 to be developed for commercial uses.
0:20:20 This request is not tied to any specific project
0:20:23 and no building plans have been submitted for review.
0:20:27 The potential detrimental impacts on surrounding areas
0:20:30 will be largely due to the location of the flood plain,
0:20:33 with the canal running through the eastern portion
0:20:36 of the property.
0:20:37 The applicant will need to have the property surveyed
0:20:40 to determine how much of the property
0:20:41 is located in the flood plain,
0:20:44 and work with the Twin Falls Canal Company
0:20:46 during the construction phase
0:20:47 to determine the appropriate setbacks.
0:20:51 The comprehensive plan designates this area's town neighborhood,
0:20:54 which is primarily residential and neighborhood in character.
0:20:58 With this property's location between a light manufacturing zone and residential, the commercial
0:21:03 highway district would make a transitional zone between the two.
0:21:07 As this property has never been developed, it has been determined that commercial businesses
0:21:12 in this area is a good use of this property as it will serve the surrounding businesses
0:21:17 and residential communities.
0:21:20 Staff has determined this request is compatible with the 2016 comprehensive plan.
0:21:26 There's three zoning accomplishes a number of goals found in the comprehensive plan.
0:21:30 Land New School 3, encourage mixed use developments that provide the benefits of more compact
0:21:36 denser development with a mix of living, shopping, and working environments.
0:21:41 And Land New School 5, create great neighborhoods with a wider range of housing types, mixed uses,
0:21:47 and amenities.
0:21:48 Okay, so this is a vicinity map.
0:21:52 here shows zones surrounding this property. I have a better map showing
0:22:00 this as well. And the future land use map. You can see to the south is commercial,
0:22:07 this property is in town neighborhood and then below south of that is mixed
0:22:14 use in industrial. So this map here, let me make it a little smaller, shows this is
0:22:26 These are subject property right here, right on the edge of the R6.
0:22:30 It shows there is a diverse mix of zones in this area from C1 to the south and 1 to the
0:22:38 east residential to the north and then manufacturing below the railroad tracks, below the C1.
0:22:45 So, changing this property to C1 would be adjacent to the properties that are commercial
0:22:54 to the south.
0:22:57 This is a map showing the floodplain and it shows where the property is located in conjunction
0:23:06 with the floodplain.
0:23:07 Like I said, they would have to work that out with the canal company and if they feel
0:23:12 that the property isn't, it's actually, I think I lower here, I think I made it too high.
0:23:19 I think it's right here, I apologize.
0:23:24 If they want to re-survey the property to make sure that this floodplain map is still
0:23:36 in effect or if the floodplain may have changed, they'll have to do that before the development
0:23:41 process and work with the canal company.
0:23:45 These are, this is a land use comparison chart.
0:23:49 Right now, the zone is R6 and these are the allowed uses, so it's residential in parks.
0:23:57 These are the uses without needing a special use permit.
0:24:02 In the C1, there's a much broader opportunity for uses for that property, including residential,
0:24:12 with the retail trade, services, sports, facilities, transportation, and then this is their narrative,
0:24:23 which is explains that they want to change it to C1 to support the surrounding properties
0:24:28 of the manufacturing and the residential.
0:24:33 So tonight the council is tasked with making a decision
0:24:36 on the appropriate zone for this property.
0:24:38 And I will stand for any questions
0:24:40 and our applicant is here with his presentation as well.
0:24:45 Any questions for Kelly at this point?
0:24:48 Yeah, I've got one real quick.
0:24:50 So Kelly, I know that obviously the water body itself is controlled
0:24:56 with the canal company, but would the applicant also have to work
0:24:59 with the floodplain administrator on some of that as well,
0:25:03 not just the canal company.
0:25:05 Yes. OK. Just wanting to make sure that that was put out there as well,
0:25:09 that there's some floodplain.
0:25:10 I'm assuming that's why you have the survey as well.
0:25:14 Yes. OK.
0:25:16 Thank you.
0:25:17 Any other questions for probably that's fine.
0:25:22 OK. I guess for the applicant, any comments?
0:25:36 My name is Ben Lida.
0:25:37 I'm a representative of the applicant,
0:25:39 Prime Investments. Kelly pretty much explained everything, did a really good job. Our main
0:25:48 goal is we just want more options for developers in the future. By going to commercial this will
0:25:54 give us that opportunity. If anybody has any questions, try to answer.
0:25:59 Any questions for the applicant? That was good. Okay. Any other questions before I open up public
0:26:10 Okay, I'm going to open up the public hearing again to remind you that anyone in the audience
0:26:16 can come down and address City Council. Please come down and state your name and whether
0:26:23 you're a resident of Twin Falls and then you have two minutes. Is there anybody in the
0:26:28 audience that wishes to address City Council on this particular item? Okay, see no one. Any
0:26:41 any additional comments you'd like to make, Kelly or Appleton? Okay. Any questions from
0:26:50 this? That's it. I'm going to close the public hearing. Council, it's up to you. Anybody wish
0:27:03 to start? Chris? I don't see a problem with this. Understanding that whatever's going
0:27:11 understanding that whatever's going to be coming back for the most part is going to be going through planning and zoning making sure with the flood
0:27:17 problem. Everything's safe and sound. So just moving this in my opinion from R6 to C1 is going to be working with the the neighborhood
0:27:31 and what's currently in that area. Any other comments?
0:27:36 Marriages would say it makes a good sense to me.
0:27:38 I think it provides some more opportunity for that property.
0:27:47 Hey, I was just to say, Kelly, thank you for all the information
0:27:49 you gave us.
0:27:50 It helps a lot to be able to read through this in our packet.
0:27:53 And it does make good sense, just the other two
0:27:57 have mentioned, to have that buffer in there.
0:28:01 Perfect.
0:28:01 I'd entertain a motion if someone would like to jump in.
0:28:09 Yeah.
0:28:10 I'd move to approve the zoning district change from R6
0:28:13 to see one on the property located on the south side of the 1900 block of 4th Avenue East
0:28:22 on behalf of the Prime Investments LLC.
0:28:24 Thank you.
0:28:25 Do we have a second?
0:28:27 Second.
0:28:28 Thank you.
0:28:29 Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Chris Reed to approve a zoning district change from R6
0:28:34 to C1 on property located on the south side of the 1900 block of 4th Avenue East Cara
0:28:42 AJ LLC on behalf of Perrine Investments LLC.
0:28:47 Any further discussion?
0:28:49 Rachel Roquevo, please.
0:28:53 Yes.
0:28:54 Yes.
0:28:55 Jerry Holmer.
0:28:56 Yes.
0:28:57 Ruth Pierce.
0:28:58 Yes.
0:28:58 Chris Reed.
0:28:59 Yes.
0:29:00 Thank you, motion passes six to zero.
0:29:04 Thank you, Kelly.
0:29:06 Okay, next item is an action item.
0:29:10 A request to approve a zoning district change
0:29:13 from C1 PUD to C1 on property located
0:29:18 on the north side of the 2000 block of Poline Road East,
0:29:22 entirety of Pillar Falls Plaza subdivision.
0:29:26 Here of Greg Elmore on behalf of Dirk Reitzma,
0:29:30 PZ24-0095.
0:29:33 We have senior city planner Will,
0:29:35 Clayver, welcome Will, William.
0:29:39 You can call me Will if you would like.
0:29:40 Okay.
0:29:40 Today we have a rezone for out of a C1PUD with the Canyon Rim Overlay, the CRO.
0:29:52 What they are wanting to do is to just get out of that plan unit development and become
0:30:00 C1 with the Canyon Rim Overlay over it.
0:30:04 The property is located at the very east portion of Pole Line.
0:30:09 Just where it starts to bend into Eastland, it's on the north side of this vicinity map.
0:30:18 The subject property is zoned, like I said, T1 PUD, it's the Pillar Falls PUD.
0:30:25 That Pillar Falls PUD was originally the agreement was signed in June 2009.
0:30:34 And then in 2018, the property received a final plaque and was recorded.
0:30:43 It is a trust agreement right now because the infrastructure hasn't been completed, but
0:30:52 the lots are there and should the trust or construction approved, then there are lots
0:31:02 available on this property as well.
0:31:04 comprehensive plan. All is for a mixed use. Mixed use, really, it's exactly what it stands
0:31:14 for. Retail, office, restaurants, townhomes, condos, apartments, hotels, civic, just really
0:31:21 makes desire to have that mix. Uses where the uses can create synergy and build off of one
0:31:29 another. The C1 zone that is requested tonight is the ultimate C1 zone or mixed
0:31:36 use zone for the City of Twin Falls. It's really the only zone that would allow for
0:31:41 such a mix of uses that the comprehensive plan of the future land use
0:31:46 path would call. When this PUD was created, when here's an aerial map of it,
0:31:57 just a little bit more zoomed in so you can see a little bit of more of the
0:32:00 with land. It is this side of the red, so this little enenciula that is outside in the county,
0:32:10 and so it is surrounded by county land as well on the east, north, and west side,
0:32:17 south side of course is the city of Twin Falls. So the existing PUD calls for a couple things,
0:32:29 one of it is a master plan. The master plan went into which the developers
0:32:37 finding hard to develop and to get to get built was town homes on the north side,
0:32:46 hotel on the east side, and then you get a neighborhood, commercial, professional
0:32:53 shopping center along Poland. Furthermore, the PUD calls for a master
0:33:00 sign plan and then it calls for master landscape plan which is in conjunction
0:33:06 with this master plan or master concept plan and then there's some architectural
0:33:12 requirements however a lot of the zoning requirements points to the base zoning
0:33:17 that is for instance the R6 zoning setbacks and requirements really point to the R6
0:33:25 standards. The C1 points to the C1 standards, however there are height
0:33:31 restrictions in there where it has to be a max of 35 feet. And then so should
0:33:42 this should this rezone be approved and it goes to the C1 with the
0:33:50 Canon room overlay, it would still have all the protection of the Canon room
0:33:54 I would go revert to that height where there's 25 feet and 35 feet, 50 feet at max.
0:34:03 That's based off distances.
0:34:04 I can go into that later if you would like.
0:34:07 But then it would also revert to the wide range of uses of this commercial highway to
0:34:16 see one.
0:34:21 Now, when this was presented to plan zoning, they kind of liked the idea of the master
0:34:28 plant. So they recommended, they recommended this kind of configuration. It's a little messy,
0:34:38 so let me point it out to you. So this pink up here is the R6. This brown right here would be the C1,
0:34:46 and then this right here would be the NCO, they wanted the neighborhood commercial really
0:34:54 the NCO there. However, when we, so that's their recommendation. When we were started analyzing the
0:35:03 the recommendation as well. We saw some hiccups with it. This is outlined in your staff packet
0:35:09 pretty comprehensively however just to highlight it is NCO is a overlay to allow commercial
0:35:19 in residential districts. So if you wanted to go with the NCO you would need to have this
0:35:30 be an R6 with that NCO regulation. That makes sense. Are you tracking with me? You have questions now?
0:35:42 You can ask questions. So will the original PUD has town homes? So R6, that's what the original PUD has,
0:35:57 and that's what P&Z is recommending basically the same.
0:36:01 Essentially, however, they're just pointing to the,
0:36:04 so instead of tying it directly to the townhomes,
0:36:08 they're just saying make that R6.
0:36:10 President R6.
0:36:11 And then instead of tying this to only a hotel,
0:36:14 make that C1.
0:36:16 Got it.
0:36:16 And then instead of tying this to square footages
0:36:20 of the buildings here, it would be tied this
0:36:24 to the neighborhood commercial overlay.
0:36:29 That doesn't necessarily work with the neighborhood commercial overlay
0:36:34 as an overlay, and so there needs to be a base owning
0:36:37 and that base owning can't be C1 and how it would have to be R6.
0:36:41 R6 with an NCO overlay, correct.
0:36:46 When we originally went through this,
0:36:50 and the original application was just to go
0:36:53 for the C-1 zoning district.
0:36:56 Staff had no problem with the C-1,
0:36:59 just to be in the fly-out C-1.
0:37:01 So that's something as well for you to consider tonight.
0:37:06 Well, there's essentially what the application is,
0:37:11 is the revert just to C-1.
0:37:15 Then there's planning zoning recommendation,
0:37:17 which is to go to this mixture.
0:37:20 If you wanted to follow this neighborhood commercial overlay, you would have to have
0:37:25 R6 as a base zone, and then, or you can do a combination of it, or you can choose your
0:37:35 own mixture of the zoning.
0:37:38 So it's kind of, and Dora's Gate has kind of been brought before you today.
0:37:45 However, I just wanted to reiterate, you have two pretty solid recommendations.
0:37:51 from applicant wanting to do to just see one staff recommended that one. And then this one will work as
0:38:04 well, the planning and zoning recommendation would work. It just needs to be modified a little bit to
0:38:09 either have the hardships with that CNCO or make it commercial C1. But then for any questions,
0:38:20 has a lot. Looks like we have some questions Spencer. Yeah my question what
0:38:25 was the original zone of this subject property before the original or before
0:38:30 the PUD in 2009 was the entire property C1 at that point. I am not exactly sure
0:38:38 on the that type of history I will say that the base zoning of the PUD is the
0:38:45 C1 zone.
0:38:46 All right.
0:38:47 Thank you.
0:38:48 Hey, Jason.
0:38:50 It was so I just to clarify to make sure I understand we can look at this map.
0:38:55 So planning and zoning is recommending this R6, D1, and then what would be the NCO, but
0:39:08 you'd have to overlay that with R6, correct?
0:39:10 Correct.
0:39:11 the Indian Rim Overlay or the neighborhood commercial, sorry, does not overlap with C1.
0:39:20 So, but you could say C1 and NCO make that all commercial up front and then do a residential
0:39:29 piece in the back as well.
0:39:31 Yeah, that's correct.
0:39:32 But this is what planning and zoning staff is recommending their staff was comfortable with
0:39:39 everything being C1.
0:39:40 Is that what you said?
0:39:41 That is correct. I'm good for now.
0:39:46 Sure.
0:39:48 So without getting into every line item,
0:39:51 what are the limitations of the NCO versus the C1?
0:39:56 So the C1, the NCO would allow for the base zone,
0:40:05 it would revert primarily back to the base zone.
0:40:08 There's a few extra items I'm
0:40:12 blanking on those extra commercial items.
0:40:15 I can. Looks like Jonathan's not later. Okay. The NCO basically allows you to get commercial
0:40:23 in the residential zone, but it limits height, limits building size and some parking sizes
0:40:29 for the parking lot. It really just says here's your residential area and we'd like to do some
0:40:33 commercial. C1 zone is here's your highway commercial. There's a lot of uses. There's no building size
0:40:40 limitation. Neighborhood commercial in the name was meant to be near residential, but not over
0:40:45 burn the area with the other commercial near houses. That's why taking all of this
0:40:51 together, that canyon rim overlay has design elements within that zone that
0:40:57 restrict size of buildings, setbacks, extra landscaping. That's where we came up with
0:41:04 our we're okay with C1 because they have to follow the canyon rim design elements
0:41:07 that are not going away. So that's where we felt comfortable. We'll get a good
0:41:12 design on the rim because they self to follow that without the limitations of
0:41:17 only having residential we have we know why the Commission did not want to make
0:41:25 this all see one yeah I'd have to refer you to the minute second I'm not sure I
0:41:31 could okay I had gone through some of them here but I just want I it was a
0:41:35 split I hate to go across Commission you know go against commissions but then
0:41:39 I also like to know all the information on there for that it was a split vote
0:41:42 And I believe they said we liked this being a master plan area.
0:41:46 They felt like there was good information from that early vote on this being on the rim.
0:41:53 And we kind of got tied up into the history of it and why it was originally put into a PUD
0:41:57 and why we don't require PUDs as ZDA's in the rim anymore.
0:42:01 So we kind of got tied up into that and that's where it became a split vote.
0:42:06 Okay.
0:42:07 But commercial allows residential.
0:42:09 does allows for apartments. Okay. Five or more units were like a town home in five. Yeah, five or more in a building. Spencer, did you have any more question? Okay.
0:42:21 Just real quick. Yeah. Yeah. Go ahead.
0:42:30 So the initial PUD, was it was it just for this area or did it extend beyond this area? No, we've had conversations and again, I, you know, not trying to get out of the bounds of what we're doing here tonight, but just trying to.
0:42:45 to do some history in remembering how far around this area did the original PUD, or did
0:42:53 it just limit this area?
0:42:55 The original PUD is just this area.
0:42:57 So if we rezoned it today, that PUD would be out of question.
0:43:05 So back in 2009, did it include anything to the south, or the canyon?
0:43:13 was just just in the confines of this because it's County and this is city. Okay.
0:43:23 It's applicants turn. Welcome. Thank you, Mayor. Oh, thank you, Council.
0:43:43 Glad he got to go first and do some of this backing up a little bit as I said
0:43:50 through P and C after it was closed. The conversations kept going to see
0:43:55 mixed use. We want to keep all of these things that are in that master plan
0:44:01 available for the development. That's kind of what we want to do as well. The
0:44:05 problem we're running into right now, I'm sorry, my name is Greg Almore. Thank
0:44:09 you. Sorry, my name is Greg Almore. I live on the western most county of future
0:44:18 greater Idaho. Commonly known now is Central Oregon. I've been working with
0:44:29 the right Smiths for I'm embarrassed to say almost two years now and with staff and
0:44:35 They've done a fantastic job kind of helping us through this.
0:44:39 And when it came to our attention,
0:44:40 it came to staff's attention that PUDs were no longer
0:44:43 going to be required.
0:44:44 This was a direction that we all kind of sat down
0:44:47 at probably two face-to-face meetings
0:44:50 and several meetings over Zoom.
0:44:53 This was an easiest way for us to do this,
0:44:56 not the easiest, the cleanest way for us to do this,
0:44:59 to make it, to get what we need for this piece
0:45:03 and continue to allow you to have that mixed-use piece
0:45:06 on the rim.
0:45:07 The C1 is a mixed-use.
0:45:09 We don't have any plans right now,
0:45:11 because I can't find anybody that is going to put money
0:45:15 into a regional lift station that's
0:45:20 going to be required as part of the trust
0:45:22 that this is under right now.
0:45:24 We know that Idaho Power is going to require at least $300 to $500,000
0:45:29 worth of extension to get to this piece right now.
0:45:32 So there's a lot of money that has to be outlight,
0:45:34 and nobody right now is willing to take on a small piece
0:45:38 of that existing PUD, and build the infrastructure that's
0:45:43 required on a whim that somebody else is coming in.
0:45:48 So what we're looking at is we are actually
0:45:51 partnering with the Ritesma family, and taking down
0:45:55 a piece of it, and a larger piece of it,
0:45:57 and determining some sort of a mixed use,
0:46:00 and leaving the remainder of it for future.
0:46:03 Once we come in and develop that piece of it,
0:46:05 it opens up not only the remaining acreage of this 21 acres,
0:46:10 but the county pieces around it can get in next in a lot easier
0:46:14 because they can't do anything yet until the infrastructure is completed.
0:46:19 And you've got everything on this map here on the proposed and the current,
0:46:23 the blue sections over there, you've got developments that are all standing there
0:46:27 and waiting, but they're waiting for us with the list station
0:46:30 because it's required to be at the low point on the piece of property that the
0:46:35 family currently owns. I guess what I'm trying getting at is we understand the
0:46:42 mixed use. That's what that's kind of what we do as Cordillera the company that
0:46:47 I'm with right now done it all over the country for for many years with
0:46:53 different groups but the C1 makes the most sense to us because it allows us
0:47:00 to if we're going to pinch it down to here's the R6 and here's the C1. I don't
0:47:10 know where you set that up because I can't I still can't with it broken up like
0:47:15 that I still have a hard time getting a developer to take a big enough chunk to
0:47:20 do enough of the buildings on their own in those smaller pieces to justify the
0:47:27 infrastructure that's going to be required to get this thing out of trust
0:47:31 and build up a lot, don't want to take a whole lot more time.
0:47:38 I'm hoping that I'm clarifying a little bit.
0:47:41 Everything that we have to do with the rim overlay,
0:47:43 we're not asking for experiences, we're not asking for
0:47:45 experiences on height, we understand the landscape buffers,
0:47:48 we have to do understand the neighbors' concerns about
0:47:51 buffers that are around us.
0:47:53 We are going to present a development that celebrates
0:47:59 that rim trail.
0:48:04 When we find these places to develop this,
0:48:08 to develop what we want to develop,
0:48:12 commercial mixed use, some residential in there as well,
0:48:16 we find that synergy.
0:48:18 And we just, we fell in love with the piece,
0:48:20 and we took us a long time to find Dirk Ritzma.
0:48:23 And then once we found Dirk, the family,
0:48:26 we talked back and forth, and it's been a great partnership.
0:48:30 And again, staff has been amazing.
0:48:33 They're probably sick and tired of me.
0:48:35 place to face, but they've been very helpful.
0:48:40 So any questions you guys have to me,
0:48:42 please let me know.
0:48:44 Quick questions for the applicant.
0:48:46 Anybody have any questions?
0:48:50 Okay, looks like you're good.
0:48:52 Thank you, great.
0:48:52 Thank you very much.
0:48:59 Okay, so I think we've asked all our questions,
0:49:02 so I'm gonna open up the public hearing.
0:49:05 Again, anybody in the audience that wishes
0:49:08 to address City Council,
0:49:10 Please come down to the podium, state your name,
0:49:13 and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls,
0:49:16 and you have two minutes to speak.
0:49:20 And I think you can sign the paper
0:49:21 that we'll just put there.
0:49:24 Welcome.
0:49:25 My name is Nick Kirchner.
0:49:27 I own a property home just to the east.
0:49:32 The bedroom, the whole back of the house faces
0:49:36 this pretty good parcel.
0:49:38 I just want to mention that I received the notification for this meeting at 4.55 this
0:49:45 afternoon was postmarked Houston, Texas.
0:49:49 The thing I saw, I know that there are a number of other people who have concerns about this,
0:49:57 and but judging from when we got this notification, I'm surprised I don't see any faces.
0:50:03 So the other thing I'm a little confused about is, from what I understand from the planning
0:50:15 folks here, it was a little different from what was voted on at the public planning meeting
0:50:21 a number of weeks ago.
0:50:26 So I'm a little confused about that.
0:50:29 But our basic or my basic concern is that, as you know, this is one of the most spectacular
0:50:35 views remaining undeveloped in all of Twin Falls.
0:50:43 And while I think it's a great idea to get this developed, what I would not like to see
0:50:52 is, for example, bright, blurry lights at night of, you know, overly bright things or items
0:51:01 placed there that could be placed under the C-1, that couldn't be placed under the previous
0:51:07 designation, you know, gas station or go-kart rang or these sorts of things.
0:51:16 So I would ask the council to think about that in voting, what does this open up in terms
0:51:26 of possible, things that can be placed there versus the restrictions that were placed on
0:51:33 it before?
0:51:36 And the other thing is, I'm a little concerned about the late notification and that the public
0:51:42 was notified and I know that there's lots of friends and neighbors that live
0:51:46 there and to and falls that would have liked to have commented here tonight.
0:51:49 Okay, thank you sir. Are there anybody else from the public that wishes to
0:52:13 address City Council at this time? You've got to come up to the mic.
0:52:34 For City for planning and zoning there's a certain amount of time you have to
0:52:37 notify the surrounding property on us correct what is that?
0:52:43 I have to ask staff.
0:52:46 No, it's 15 days.
0:52:48 Okay and for this?
0:52:50 About 15 days.
0:52:52 15 days, okay.
0:52:53 I agree with him also.
0:52:54 I own-
0:52:55 Take your name please.
0:52:56 My name is Tyler Ellison.
0:52:57 I own property at $2,195 village park.
0:52:59 Please start his time Rachel.
0:53:01 Okay.
0:53:02 Thank you.
0:53:03 I agree with him.
0:53:04 Actually I'd never got a notification at all.
0:53:06 I actually had to stop by and pick one up from the thing on the side road which is actually
0:53:12 kind of hard to do. I'd have my daughter jump, I put my hazards on, because you really can't
0:53:16 get there unless you walk along the side of it. I'll just say this, there is an image not
0:53:22 shown here where they designated the planning and zoning. What other zones were around this?
0:53:27 They excluded the property directly south of this, which is actually C1PUD, except for
0:53:37 a small parcel that was caught zoned by you all to accommodate North Canyon Medical. That
0:53:44 This is now C1 and now holds a quite large tall building on it.
0:53:48 So what I'm asking is, why are we coming and changing these things that have already started
0:53:53 development around them, that I have a C1 PUD directly south of them that still abides
0:53:58 by everything that was supposed to in that PUD, my time has disappeared, just one more
0:54:05 map.
0:54:09 But why are we doing this?
0:54:11 Changing things up, C1 is allowing them to do basically anything in this.
0:54:16 It is allowing them to put a building pushing 50 feet tall in this development
0:54:20 What you're allowing for if you go to see one and you take the pud away
0:54:24 There are certain reject restrictions in that pud either were given in order for you to keep a cohesiveness right there in that area
0:54:31 Okay, I don't like how it kind of feels like this city starting to get spot zoned if you will or suit zoning
0:54:38 Which we can look up what that is okay
0:54:40 But that's my biggest concern here.
0:54:44 You're coming around and just kind of changing things as they go.
0:54:47 And I refer to this master plan.
0:54:49 I don't quite understand what we're referencing all the time when you got that.
0:54:54 Anyway, I'll sign in and be done.
0:54:57 Thank you.
0:55:01 Is there anybody else in the audience that wishes to address City Council at this time?
0:55:16 Okay.
0:55:17 Is the applicant wish to address any items or staff?
0:55:25 Thank you again. This is Greg Elmore again. Same questions came up at the P&Z as well
0:55:36 about what uses are. The C1 zone use C1 is as soon as your mixed use. There are items in
0:55:43 the C1 that likely we will be developing. The comments about gas stations and car race
0:55:53 and tracks and all that, those that are not allowed in the C1, those are all conditional
0:55:57 uses basically across all of most of yours.
0:56:00 So we are respectful.
0:56:05 I understand that the building height concerns
0:56:07 that everyone has right now, that the tallest things
0:56:09 that we're looking at are three stories.
0:56:11 We're not going to go anywhere near the 50-foot mark
0:56:14 that's going to be required on, that's allowed in a C1.
0:56:18 And it'll be further set back in front,
0:56:19 because that's going to be 150 feet plus away from the rim.
0:56:24 So if we do anything that's in that three-story range,
0:56:26 it'll be along that east, all right, west property line, away from the rim.
0:56:31 There's anything else that you guys need for me?
0:56:34 Anything from staff?
0:56:42 So I'm looking at the C1 zone.
0:56:44 The two things that were mentioned, passing service stations do require
0:56:48 special use permit, go-kart tracks, all sorts of special use permits.
0:56:51 So they're not outright permitted.
0:56:52 They need to go to another public hearing to get a building permit.
0:56:56 Turns of notification, we receive an affidavit that the applicant has mailed
0:57:01 the letters on time and that the sign is posted.
0:57:04 That's what we received.
0:57:06 That's what we require and what the code requires just to receive.
0:57:10 But leave those with the questions that we could answer
0:57:12 unless you have any more for us than need to clarify anything.
0:57:15 And sir, did you have something else?
0:57:17 Yeah, it's some kind of technical questions.
0:57:19 I don't know if it's appropriate to do this part
0:57:20 of the public hearing or wait till afterwards
0:57:22 with the discussion.
0:57:24 I'd do it if I were if it's in for new information,
0:57:26 I'll do it before you close the public hearing totally.
0:57:29 Yeah, just I guess the first question
0:57:31 would be about the canyronome overlay.
0:57:34 So assuming this was approved as C1,
0:57:38 reiterate that the highlights, as far as landscaping buffer,
0:57:42 and there is height restrictions on 85 plus percent
0:57:46 of this property, I understand.
0:57:47 Just if you could clarify that, then I have another question.
0:57:51 We can change this screen back and talk to the zone.
0:57:59 Oh, right here, I'm going to use this one.
0:58:04 This slanted line, that is the Canyon Rim Overlay.
0:58:09 So it encompasses, yep, at 80, 90, you've somewhat percent.
0:58:13 When you have a Canyon Rim Overlay,
0:58:14 a building needs to be placed, first of all,
0:58:17 placed further than 50 feet from the rim.
0:58:20 It's actually further in this area
0:58:21 because we have an easement for the trail.
0:58:24 I don't know the exact distances in every spot,
0:58:26 but a building that is close to the rim
0:58:29 is limited to 25 feet tall at the 50 foot mark.
0:58:33 It goes to 35 feet at the 100 feet, just a straight line up to that.
0:58:40 And then you can get to 50 feet if you're 150 feet from the rim.
0:58:44 You go above that mark, it's two public hearings that you would see as you're the final decision maker
0:58:49 for anything over 50 feet or anything in the city.
0:58:54 So that is the tallest you could get.
0:58:56 So there's, without getting into technical, there's some areas along this room.
0:59:00 it would be 25 up to 35 and then you'd have to get further to get to that 50-foot mark.
0:59:05 The Can Room Overlay is staying in place, they're not rezoning that, that is not going anywhere.
0:59:11 That's your next question.
0:59:13 Yes.
0:59:15 The other one was a memory about across the street at North Canyon Medical Center.
0:59:20 I seem to remember there was one issue of only that chunk out of the PUD, which I was
0:59:28 on favor of but nevertheless and there was a separate request for the height I
0:59:34 believe because they wanted to have the roof deck and with the elevator and so
0:59:39 there was the separate request for that height is that correct? Yes so this has
0:59:44 the private property owner of this lot North Canyon requested to rezone it this
0:59:51 map doesn't show that because as we're looking at it and we talked about our
0:59:54 JIS didn't update to that this be out of that PD they did rezone it just to
0:59:58 C1. That was a decision made here. North Canyon was also the group that had the
1:00:04 Canyon Rim overlay title amendment. That's the way they chose to go through it to
1:00:09 not require a PUD or a ZDA in the Canyon Rim and revert the height to that 50
1:00:16 foot at greater than 150 feet away. That was their request. So they're they
1:00:22 stand at taller than 35, but they're not above, I believe they're above 15. If it is, it's like a
1:00:28 parapet or the elevator shaft. That's the history of it. I don't know the years, but
1:00:33 your memory is correct. That was the series of events that occurred. There's been a lot of these.
1:00:40 Yes, there's roughly a tail. The third was just about the mailed notice. I will note the sign along
1:00:48 the the road front edge is pretty prominent. I noticed that the first day it went up because that's
1:00:52 otherwise a very area, but that is a concern about mailing the notices.
1:00:58 I guess this question was for the resident if the postmark seemed to indicate that it was not mailed 15 days prior.
1:01:05 I guess I was asking for clarification on that.
1:01:14 Mitch, did you have some, Dad?
1:01:16 I was, I have the fortune to sit at a computer like those guys don't,
1:01:21 and your questions, Spencer, about the history of the property.
1:01:24 The property was zoned in 2006
1:01:28 Annex sorry annex in 2006 and when it was annexed it was zoned from SUI to this c1pud
1:01:34 It took a few years before the pud agreement got signed in 2009
1:01:39 So it came from it came from in the county and essentially the county zoned into the city as a c1pud
1:01:47 So it's been it's been this pud ever since it came into the city. Okay. Thank you
1:01:52 Jason Brown
1:01:53 Yeah, Jonathan, I'm going to ask maybe restructure the question I had earlier and just trying to get to the
1:02:00 the PUD. So each PUD has its own
1:02:05 requirements, correct? So if the PUD on the south side of Pole Line, it would have its own requirements versus the PUD on the north side.
1:02:14 Yes, each PUD is essential like its own zoning district, its own rules and regulations.
1:02:20 These two are not tied together or have ever been tied together.
1:02:23 They are not tied together, nor have they, to my knowledge at all.
1:02:28 But the canyon rim overlay restricts some of the development.
1:02:36 It doesn't do anything for facade or anything like that.
1:02:43 Not necessarily in materials, but it does require certain buildings of a size to have
1:02:47 some vertical and horizontal variation variation to break up the building when
1:02:53 they are larger than a certain size and what's in my head is 3,000 or 5,000 square
1:02:58 feet if you're over that you've got to have that vertical and horizontal
1:03:01 variation. I'm good for now. Okay any other questions before I close the
1:03:13 public hearing? I don't want you to close it it's just clarifying you're not getting
1:03:19 gaining or gathering more information.
1:03:21 Right. So, have all your questions answered, then it's just discussion.
1:03:27 Did we clarify Spencer's question on the notification letter?
1:03:33 I think we probably should clarify that before.
1:03:38 I think that's an important factor at least to some level.
1:03:41 What we received was the affidavit that says the person that's responsible to mail them on the date.
1:03:47 That's a so that that affidavit is saying we
1:03:50 We mailed them on the date we're we need to because that's the mailing date not when the person receives it sure
1:03:56 There's a there's the postal service or delivery service in between there that we don't control, but there's some
1:04:03 verification that
1:04:04 The applicant mailed or this I'm assuming the app or their representative or their representative
1:04:10 Mailed it on the date because of that affidavit
1:04:13 Yeah, and I would say that if if by chance and if this is something that goes wrong, which it hasn't passed when people have done that and we find out about it
1:04:22 Whatever decision happens here. We just have to do again
1:04:24 We would just make them go through the process again to get the proper notice
1:04:27 But what we have in our possession from what we looked at was an affidavit saying they mailed it on the correct date, okay?
1:04:34 answer
1:04:35 Yeah, never mind. I think I had a question on that, but I don't I'll withdraw my question. All right
1:04:51 Do we know what was different?
1:04:56 The public input he mentioned
1:04:58 Something was different from what we're seeing now
1:05:04 Hello, I think the commission went through a process to look at
1:05:13 this document
1:05:15 And
1:05:16 To tie this into a bow what you have is what you're seeing here with a pud
1:05:21 It requires this to be a hotel and nothing else
1:05:26 And it requires these to be town homes and nothing else can be built there under the current
1:05:30 PUD.
1:05:32 These areas are more of just that, um, professional office and shopping.
1:05:37 I know the commission looked at this a lot longer for a long time to talk about this is
1:05:43 they like the look of this, but they eventually said, we don't need a hotel there.
1:05:49 We'd see one was okay.
1:05:50 We don't need town homes.
1:05:51 Our six is okay.
1:05:52 We do like this type of commercial, special office.
1:05:55 this. Again, I'm kind of like trying to take the minutes from that meeting and...
1:05:59 Yeah, I've got them pulled up here and I know we rely on P&Z to get into the nitty-gritty
1:06:05 of the planning and zoning, which is great, but I just want to make sure I understand everything
1:06:11 that's gone on with this and I'm just trying to understand. Then there's a lot of things
1:06:20 that I assume and so I want to make sure that I've got them straight in my head. Now, when
1:06:28 neighbors talk about the lights that are in a C-1.
1:06:33 There's some sort of controls over that.
1:06:36 Is that correct? Through the planning and zoning?
1:06:38 So when we review for permits, we talk about required improvements.
1:06:42 And when we're talking about that screening between residential
1:06:45 commercial, it includes the light source.
1:06:48 And had this come up recently where you put a light on a building that
1:06:52 basically leaks light infiltration to neighboring properties.
1:06:56 that's a residential. We have the commercial property shield the light source so that it's not
1:07:02 directly lighting up the residential area and that's per the code today when you get a building permit.
1:07:06 That doesn't mean there's an ambient light that at least but it's a direct light issue.
1:07:14 That's what's written in code today. If we want more restriction we would need to talk about more
1:07:17 restriction either through a tidal amendment or condition the rezone which is adding a complication
1:07:25 to what I'm doing, but that'd be the other thing.
1:07:28 Currently code, we basically say you can't have that light
1:07:30 infiltration from commercial as part of the screening requirement.
1:07:35 OK, so if we were to change this to C1,
1:07:40 I'm hearing that there's very little change that would happen.
1:07:44 And what this does is it allows R6 or hotels or somebody
1:07:50 to go in there.
1:07:53 It's not so restrictive, correct, monetarily.
1:07:56 Yeah, so what you end up having is you
1:07:57 You don't have to have a hotel built in this property on the spot.
1:08:01 If you approve it per the request, all of it becomes C1 and all of the use is available
1:08:08 and C1 could then be developed in any portion of it.
1:08:11 Still following all of the base codes that the city has for those districts and everything
1:08:15 else.
1:08:16 All that's still in place as the code is written today.
1:08:20 Okay.
1:08:21 All right.
1:08:22 Thank you.
1:08:23 Any other questions before I close the public hearing?
1:08:26 Yeah, sorry, Mayor, I just want to ask, sorry, I want to ask a couple of questions and they're based upon the comments that the public hearing at the planning and zoning.
1:08:36 So, just to restate gas stations in a C-1 would have to go through a special use permit, correct?
1:08:44 Yes, that's what it says right now, okay.
1:08:46 And then it says, there is a height restriction because of the Canyon Rim overlay, correct?
1:08:53 And that depends on the location of which you're away from the rent.
1:08:58 Up to 35 feet, 50 feet of the 150 from the rent, okay, that's good, thanks.
1:09:06 Good, be done, Terri.
1:09:08 Okay, anybody else before I close the public hearing?
1:09:15 Okay, I'll close the public hearing, you know, time for discussion, Greg Hawkins.
1:09:36 I just I think to me it makes good sense I know that if it was seat one that those items
1:09:43 when they go to develop will still come before the city planning department changes and things
1:09:50 can be made then to accommodate whatever concerns I feel comfortable with the seat one.
1:09:56 Jason Brown.
1:09:57 Yeah I'm still you know I'm still processing and wanting to hear what other fellow council
1:10:04 members have to say on some of this and want to make sure that we, you know, it seems lately
1:10:12 we've been going through some of these types of decisions and these are always difficult
1:10:17 decisions to go through trying to keep some resemblance of what's there but also understanding
1:10:27 potential future items, you know, right now, I mean, I'm trying to figure out is it, I'm
1:10:38 comfortable with the canyon and moverlay and some of the restrictions there going with
1:10:42 the underlying C1, but there's some internal dialogue happening in my mind right now trying
1:10:48 to work through that out. So, you know, that's kind of where I'm standing right now, but may
1:10:53 have something to say after everybody else weighs in.
1:10:56 Hey, Sherry Vomer? Yeah, as I'm looking through this, I'm kind of feeling the same way Jason
1:11:02 is going back and forth, but it seems to me that the C1 versus the PUD, there's not a big
1:11:12 change if I'm understanding this all correctly.
1:11:16 And it's also the PUD, which I'm sure they did not intend this to happen, but it happened
1:11:25 is pretty cost prohibitive to any development that may happen where putting it out as to all
1:11:37 C1 it seems to me that something could happen there.
1:11:43 Like you said with the overlays that are there, the building restrictions that are there and
1:11:50 as I read through some of the P&Z hearing minutes there were some suggestions that were
1:11:55 were made on different items. Anyhow, I'm leaning towards the C1 with respect that it's not going
1:12:08 to cause, I don't want to say it's not going to cause a difference in what would have been
1:12:15 there before for the residents, but very little difference. I'm hearing that correctly.
1:12:24 Anybody else have anything to say, Chris for you?
1:12:27 I'll just jump in. And Mary, you're probably in a very similar situation. We've been on
1:12:33 council long enough that we've seen a few of these come through where a PUD was put
1:12:39 in place as EDA was put in place and then all of a sudden you found somebody that wanted
1:12:42 it and there was a change that was needed and this is a situation and I really do appreciate
1:12:50 what originally was put in 2006 and then 2009 finally approved and then also planning and
1:12:56 zoning but if we start chunking this up and making puzzle pieces out of this we're going
1:13:03 to see this back again as soon as they find somebody who's interested at that
1:13:06 point in time. We have things in place to make sure that we don't end up with
1:13:13 gas stations and drive-throughs without coming back here. We want to make sure that
1:13:21 this is the most beautiful place in Twin Falls. This is beautiful property.
1:13:26 C1 I believe still protects that and makes it an area in which it will be
1:13:33 will be developed. That's the goal, not just have dirt out there or sagebrush as
1:13:40 there's currently just sitting there. So C1 still allows development to happen.
1:13:46 It allows the developer to tweak it and move it so that those puzzle pieces if
1:13:51 they need a little bit more here they can do that instead of having to come
1:13:55 back at that point in time and saying hey we need this chunk taken out or make
1:13:59 get cost prohibitive for somebody to come in. So I'm comfortable with C1. I still think
1:14:05 all the work that was done in early 2000s with all the PUDs and then afterwards, CDAs
1:14:10 we're still going to see those types of things come in because what originally was thought
1:14:14 of 15 years ago. It's weird to think that that was 15 years ago. Somebody coming in that
1:14:20 has the money that wants to develop it is going to want maybe something a little different
1:14:24 today. So we're going to continue seeing this. But I'm comfortable with C1.
1:14:28 Thank you. Anybody else have any comment?
1:14:31 I'd entertain a motion then.
1:14:37 I'll make the motion. I move that we approve the zoning district change from C1PUD to C1 on property located on the north side of the 2000 block of Pull Line Road East.
1:14:55 Care of Greg Elmore on behalf of Dirk Wright's mind.
1:15:01 Jason Brown? I'll second it.
1:15:04 Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to approve the zoning
1:15:09 district change from C1 PUD to C1 on property located on the north side of
1:15:15 the 2000 block of Poe line road any further discussion Rachel Roquevo
1:15:25 Please? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes
Download
- Transcript (text) 63 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 84 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 113 KB
- Audio (M4A) 17.9 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 18, 2024. The recording started at 16:56 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:16:02.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
116c8cd01ae1f0072dce1c7d023443d5d7e527168360105dfc29ac7e9e5eb7b8 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min, with 1 passage muted for privacy. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 3ccd0c6127bfe439bb1219c0d465f1e9ac07c9e3441b2af787891be5fa67a5d1 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-11. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
0a90fed8dd1099521eee730b7b846a4835f7a1e0c1676d2ccac1358d00b077f9
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file