City Council meeting
Monday, September 9, 2024
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:02:37 Ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the September 9th, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers tonight.
0:02:50 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me please rise. That's September 20th through 20th 2024.
0:03:32 Whereas more than 43 million Americans can't read or write at the most basic level, while 62.7 million lack basic math skills, as well as the credentials and skills necessary to succeed in post-secondary education.
0:03:49 And whereas every year, one in three young adults
0:03:53 dropped out of high school, and whereas 101,076 working adults,
0:03:59 18 through 64 in the state of Idaho
0:04:02 are without a high school credential.
0:04:05 Whereas adult education programs
0:04:07 contribute to solving these challenges
0:04:10 by helping Americans move along along the continuum
0:04:15 in their educational journey to achieve basic skills
0:04:18 and get prepared for career and college, and whereas adult education programs in community
0:04:24 colleges and Idaho Department of Corrections offered low-cost, high-value programs that upgrade
0:04:32 the skill set of our citizens, and whereas our state celebrates adult education and family
0:04:38 literacy week as a proud participant in the National Educate and Elevate campaign, which
0:04:45 our citizens learn about all their adult education options to attain their
0:04:52 professional and personal goals. Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin
0:04:57 Falls, do hereby proclaim the week of September 16 through 21st as adult
0:05:04 literacy week in the City of Twin Falls.
0:05:07 Leave Ginger, are you here? Ginger, Naram from the college will accept this.
0:05:14 It's a wishes.
0:06:29 Chris Reed, Craig Hawkins, motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent.
0:06:37 Call and roll call.
0:06:41 Please.
0:06:58 Consideration is a presentation, a presentation to recognize Twin Falls Fire Department, it's
0:07:05 newly promoted Captain Gerald Dilman and driver, Cal Larson, along with taking their oath
0:07:10 of office and pinning their new rank and we have our fire chief, Les Kinworthy.
0:07:16 Welcome Les.
0:07:17 Thank you, Madam Mayor, council members.
0:07:20 This like Chief Kingsbury talks about
0:07:24 Fire Chief one of the pieces of work is doing these sort of these sort of things this
0:07:43 This painting tonight's a little later than other things these two and so I'd like to call a Larson is
0:08:35 On C-shift. He's under the direction of the town. He was hired January 5th
0:08:42 2009 as a firefighter until he was
0:08:45 Captain, now this is a little different typically as you probably recall a lot of
0:08:51 our firefighters that reach the captain rank usually promote to driver before they
0:08:56 move to camp. We do have Jerry was promoted on June 29th. He was a relief
0:09:19 captain, he was also a relief driver doing the same thing so it's not like he doesn't
0:09:26 know the driver position. He's a member of our rescue team. Jerry not only is a
0:09:34 a member of our team but he's fairly distinguished instructor throughout many
0:09:42 states. As you recall the the rescue have, Wheeler was dangling off the side. I think
0:09:53 Jerry was the first rescuer on the road to reach those people inside of me. The less
0:10:05 is quite a feat. I'm gonna let you as his family be promoted to the position of
0:10:19 run a shift direction of Italian chief Aaron Hudson. He was hired January 22nd of
0:10:27 He was accepted to helicopter school, I think he'll be flying a black hawk, introduce your
0:11:07 families, responsible if you decide to stick to your husband, rest of the city council and
0:16:22 also city management and ELT members and also all fire staff that is here as well.
0:16:27 I got to tell you, so I did a ride along.
0:18:12 Individuals, I just want to, if Chief Brooks, if you could just stand up for a second, he's
0:18:17 I hate this, but that's all right.
0:18:20 You can just stay right there if you want.
0:18:23 One of Mitch Brooks, Mitchell Brooks, our deputy chief,
0:18:27 recently, we didn't really do a lot as far as recognition
0:18:31 for this feat, but he's been working over the last couple
0:18:36 of years to get his batch complete that recently,
0:18:45 not only for Mitch, but we've also had a significant increase
0:18:49 in education in our department.
0:18:50 We have several others.
0:18:52 Some have completed their associate's degrees
0:18:55 and bachelor degrees, those as well, but specifically and probably recently we should
0:19:13 make him come in with this cap and gown. Next on the agenda is I mean the city of Twin Falls
0:19:37 and the Twin Falls Rural Fire District from October 1, 2024 through September 30, 2027
0:19:43 to stay.
0:20:02 Well the opinion is just to as you know or Twin Falls Rural Fire District contracts for
0:20:35 service to the Twin Falls Fire Department for services and that's basically all
0:20:41 fire services including EMS. To date we've completed three year contracts and
0:20:50 this year is no exception so this year the contract is almost identical with
0:20:56 one exception and I pointed that out in your agenda packet and basically it is
0:21:03 is on section, both section 1.3, which talks about equipment
0:21:09 that the fire district owned, including apparatus,
0:21:13 for those who don't know apparatus fire trucks.
0:21:18 Really, that no longer occurs anymore.
0:21:20 There was a time where the fire district owned to date
0:21:26 and in the future, they basically sign over those titles
0:21:30 and or if it's property, and it's for fire station
0:21:35 to property. Those have all been transferred into the city's name prior to this section
0:21:43 out. This was reviewed by our city attorney, dates, you saw on the specifics on that, especially
0:21:57 for council members who weren't here for the last one. Specifics that we didn't cover,
0:22:03 I can certainly try to answer any questions for Chris Reed. No questions, but I do want
0:22:31 to thank you Jason Brown. Keep motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to approve
0:22:37 the contract between the City of Twin Falls and the Twin Falls Rural Fire District from
0:22:42 October 1, 2024 to September 30, 7-0. Next item on the agenda is a presentation,
0:23:10 presentation on PSI's work to maintain the city's recycling collection program in
0:23:18 lieu of Magic Valley Recycling's closure in August and we have Justin Ash, Water Manager.
0:23:26 Welcome, Justin.
0:23:27 PSI in their recycling program with them, though, Aaron and Jason are here since 2000,
0:26:20 it's stabilized.
0:26:33 It's got a pretty high level, except, it has been pushed back.
0:31:29 Thanks, Jason.
0:31:36 As Jason said, I had a business setting up for Mr. Facility.
0:34:28 It's a Salt Lake City.
0:34:31 Like I said, in 2021, they invested $17 million.
0:35:11 Facility actually is money in this.
0:35:15 It has a achieves a 95% recovery, which is actually really substantial.
0:35:22 Materials start their journey on the pre-sport line, where sorters watch for contaminating.
0:35:26 They figure out the large items there.
0:35:50 Okay, so then next the cardboarders here, you can see these big rolling tumblers there, larger pieces float over the top.
0:35:57 Well, fiber screens are smaller items, such as paper, plastic, cans fall through the machinery and continue.
0:36:04 Upsized fiber screens are one innovation being used in Salt Lake City.
0:36:07 A series of optical sorters and separators.
0:40:06 See the process soon feeds PSI share videos, someone asks, you know, how long does the process of Twin Falls actually extend the landfill?
0:40:54 It was like 50, they probably still true with this.
0:41:02 So, what I would say about that is, I can't wait for stories here, if you see NPR questioning
0:41:45 the value of recycling, it kind of makes you take a step back and collect your pearls, I
0:41:49 guess, and see, okay, what's going on here.
0:41:52 So, I just wanted to highlight some of the stories, the very top left, 196, it was the
0:41:58 first story out there that really recycling is not worth another story here, the myth
0:42:05 of plastic recycling, plastic recycling doesn't work, and it will be as good as good as you
0:42:13 I see these headlines out there, especially with the whole China thing, and it's a recycling
0:42:19 that does, is it worth it? And I think that's a valid question, and I think that we should
0:42:24 always be questioning those things to see what reality is in person at two of the public,
0:42:28 and that most of them are the plastics industry during the 80, increasing
0:42:56 with all this new material, and so chasing arrows started going on to items.
0:43:08 The truth is, that's not really reality. I think it's recyclable, or at least not everything
0:43:22 is recyclable. You can see there ones and twos definitely have a more of a very
0:43:28 stabilized market of these are bottles of nupshogs. The rest of them are difficult. This is only seven numbers, and so what started happening is people started doing it deeper.
0:44:08 So this started coming up, physical assessment. So it's a study of, if you take a product, cost environmentally, materials out of the ground, distribution, usage, and then the M.
0:44:27 And so it's really revealed is that most of the energy and most of the waste happens to the recycling process, and the recycling process is good and vital, but somewhat of a bandy, larger issue of
0:44:46 So that studies have really sort of provided that for recycling.
0:45:13 It takes, it's a glasses, 25 papers, 68% although paper at some point does break down.
0:45:35 Plastic is up to 88. If you look at this bottom, there's different versions of,
0:45:42 if you just look at the purple, you can see that that is the virgin manufacturing
0:45:48 of just, you can see that the virgin creation of the material is recycling process.
0:46:04 And if you actually dig into the weeds and all these articles, that's what they're saying.
0:46:08 They're basically saying that Bob Axe, recycling room,
0:46:13 the remaining swissers and surfers, and they're basically
0:46:22 they're speaking about the plastic and the zoomers
0:46:27 and the culture and sort of the spin that's been happening
0:46:30 in the six, and even at the bottom of the center,
0:46:42 but the energy is still very valued.
0:47:10 So this is what's happening in the legislation.
0:47:17 So there's seven states, and there's seven states
0:47:22 right now that have been that.
0:47:25 Basically what they're doing is here,
0:47:34 also subsidized the cost of that processing legislation
0:47:48 is probably, what's happening is at some point,
0:48:19 And so it would be very clear.
0:48:20 At some point there would be some benefit for the future.
0:48:25 The other future is the whole recycling company.
0:48:31 So this whole recycling arrows thing.
0:48:45 OK, so it's specifically each one kind of stuff.
0:48:53 And I did my best on this fall.
0:49:06 So I had that question.
0:49:08 Is it worth it?
0:49:13 And so you can see here they rise this off.
0:49:16 And they transport in their second materials,
0:49:23 of collecting materials, of the curve,
0:49:24 of getting it to the merc.
0:49:31 So the recycling materials versus the perdose materials,
0:49:38 not the perdose.
0:49:40 And so I ran the numbers.
0:49:49 You can see here the very latest numbers based on what
0:49:56 This is sort of a breakout, actually, this is an important slide that I'll get back.
0:50:04 What happens is now that we can send our bales directly to that waste management facility,
0:50:07 they're going to tell us exactly what is in our material and what is in our first set
0:50:17 of our curbside commingal.
0:50:23 And so they're going to go through and do the metrics and multiply it by cost that they,
0:50:35 so it's a very transparent process for us down there.
0:50:41 But for the issue of the warm model, I, you know, it shows Idaho.
0:50:45 You guys use the landfill, the mineral review of the landfill actually has landfill gas recovery
0:50:50 burning from energy, so that's actually a really great
0:50:53 future of that landfill, so that provides benefit there.
0:50:56 And then I put the mileage down there of the distance we
0:50:58 have to travel to the landfill, or the distance we have to
0:51:01 travel for recycling.
0:51:04 And this is what it spits out.
0:51:06 So it's a CO2 equivalent.
0:51:15 It's if we just took the difference there, it's the
0:51:20 savings of 179 metric towers savings.
0:52:49 Now, I'm just watching through, that's exactly what you
0:53:40 guys have achieved, Jason was talking about.
0:55:21 Recycling is sort of a personal thing.
0:55:24 your house, you decide whether you're experiencing
0:56:20 the other thoughts, get this.
0:57:18 So see if we can sort of apply this a little bit,
0:57:21 and make sure to sort of take it from there in life.
0:58:09 So to me recycling is just sort of a baseline food rescue.
0:58:21 Our mental standpoint goes in the landfill.
0:58:34 And also food rescue is very important socially,
0:58:51 as well as clothing.
0:58:52 If you had textile industry,
0:58:56 a few percent of the total environmental codes
0:59:07 and helping other people help us as locally.
0:59:10 So in my mind, if you can have this,
0:59:28 let's say we source separated
0:59:38 and essentially get rid of a freeze recycling.
0:59:49 So in other cities in 2019, the same thing as you guys did.
0:59:52 And in some cities have since put them back in the stabilization of the class.
1:00:01 And so this is sort of a program that I did in one of the cities where people come back
1:00:04 or shows.
1:00:07 And so typically messaging that I would material stream and also a content.
1:01:29 You can stop your junk mail.
1:01:30 There's processes to it.
1:01:31 So that's just another piece.
1:01:39 It's like wrapping our truck with your own key that it was at 100.
1:02:30 So we have an intro.
1:02:50 Question, is it possible to get your presentation emailed to us?
1:03:24 Yes.
1:03:27 on this computer.
1:03:30 Questions for Aaron versus taking a existing plastic bottle,
1:03:56 politicizing it, and then the plastic's changes.
1:04:05 There's like, there's any questions I think of processing.
1:04:27 Yeah.
1:04:28 Type VI brush truck, gate fire equipment is a 200,000
1:05:15 allocation for the purchase.
1:06:54 Unfortunately, the questions for man.
1:07:50 Chris Reed, Jason Brown.
1:08:05 Key motion by Chris Reed, second by Jason Brown.
1:08:08 To award the bid for a Type VI brush truck to cascade fire equipment
1:08:12 of 184,253 discussion vote please yes thank you motion passes seven to zero
1:08:35 next item on the agenda it's a request to approve and adopt resolution 20 24-0 0 9
1:08:48 declaring trans-map as a sole source supplier for pavement asset management
1:08:54 and maintenance that is specific to the needs of the Twin Falls Street
1:08:58 Department and we have Aaron Steele assistance public works welcome Aaron
1:09:02 Thank you Madam Mayor and Council tonight I'm here one of the largest assets in the city of
1:09:11 Toronto. In other ways we do this make sure that so transmap into the city and the pictures
1:09:39 produce data points and based on that data we can feed it into a system that
1:09:45 helps us determine surface treatments and surface treatments consist of things
1:09:58 like chip seal, we just finished it with a large slurry seals, fog seals, friction seals,
1:10:05 those kinds of different surface treatments and this system allows us to have a system
1:10:19 that comes in that helps us process the data.
1:10:23 And you're actually, I'm, Thompson is on the case, so he asked me, kind of just texted
1:10:53 me a picture of me sitting in, sitting there and he said, how look where I am.
1:11:10 So by way of fact, the City of Twin Falls has about 250 center line miles or nearly 700
1:11:22 It is always one of those things that we have to teach our attention to.
1:11:26 And so that's why we're asking for trans maps to become a source source.
1:11:30 Drives all our decisions, right?
1:11:41 And so that's why we're asking them to become a source source.
1:11:44 This last fiscal year we budgeted $100,000.
1:11:48 And so that's when we decided we wanted to.
1:12:04 So Idaho Code 6728082 permits soul sources
1:12:17 in the way we do that,
1:12:18 allowing the soul source because we also have rans as well as in the cold.
1:12:40 Hold.
1:12:48 Face and Stone.
1:13:07 Once the resolution is passed.
1:13:08 Jason Brown, seconded by Sherry Vollmer, two, approve and adopt resolution 2024-009, firing
1:13:42 trans-map as the sole-source supplier for pavement asset management and maintenance of the
1:13:50 Twin Falls Street Department.
1:13:54 Thank you, Aaron.
1:14:14 Thank you.
1:14:15 This item on the agenda is an action item.
1:14:20 It's a request for approval of Ordinance 2024-012, a zoning title amendment to Title 10, Chapter
1:14:30 11, required improvements in Chapter 13, motion by Spencer Cutler, seconded by Grace and Stone,
1:16:04 to put Ordinance 24-002, third and final reading by title only.
1:16:13 and passes 7-0. So I will read the
1:16:33 number 2024-012, an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, and Twin Falls City Code section 10-11 required improvements
1:16:49 removing exceptional hardship exemption and clarifying when and how temporary
1:16:54 certificates of occupancy may be received and dash 13
1:17:03 Finance Certificate of Occupancy is required and the process to receive a full
1:17:11 and temporary Certificate of Occupancy authorizing publication of the ordinance
1:17:16 by summary and providing an effective date. Chris Reed, thank you Jason Brown, motion
1:17:29 by Chris Reed, second by Jason Brown to approve ordinance number 2024-012
1:17:36 the zoning title amendment to the title 10 chapter 11 required improvements in
1:17:42 chapters 13 building permits any further discussion Amy roll call vote
1:17:49 please yes you motion passes 7 to 0 thank you Jonathan okay so that is it for
1:18:08 items of consideration next on the agenda is the time for general public
1:18:13 input this is a time if there's anybody in the public that wishes to address
1:18:19 City Council on an issue, not on today's agenda and not about to come up to the podium.
1:18:27 Okay, seeing no one advisory board report.
1:18:34 Senator So the bill in Abajigua, so it's 1-3 September 11th will be an event at the visitor center.
1:19:56 It starts at six o'clock. Parking is limited so they're suggesting that you park elsewhere.
1:20:04 and I believe there are some buses taking people but I know if not so that
1:20:14 event starts at six o'clock and there's a pretty full schedule just did I think
1:20:20 you can go on to the Magic Bury Valley Memorial page Facebook page or their
1:20:25 website and get the information so that's a great event it's been 23 goes fast
Download
- Transcript (text) 20 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 25 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 34 KB
- Audio (M4A) 19.1 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, September 9, 2024. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:21:16.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
2aec8fb6d9899f267ab03b0673a8c6e797f4f3b706a9e152aebe72180369f1b0 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a c9eac96adb65d98c5c26a81bb27bc5ce31adab19e4af07dac7b2a8fc421ca00b - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
96cf42b2a8db64d2a3d8b3476db315654faf80a0181b50d805e128d5c67e7616
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file