OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, August 12, 2024

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: e

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:03:06 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the August 12th 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm

0:03:14 We have a quorum. We have six members present in chambers and councilman stone is

0:03:21 Excuse tonight first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance if you wish to join me, please rise

0:03:28 Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight. So

0:03:50 So next is the consent calendar, council wishes.

0:03:56 Move to approve the consent calendar.

0:03:58 Thank you.

0:03:59 Do I have a second?

0:04:00 Second.

0:04:01 Thank you motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Greg Hawkins to approve the consent calendar

0:04:07 as written.

0:04:08 Amy Rokalvo, please.

0:04:11 Ruth Pierce?

0:04:12 Yes.

0:04:13 Chris Reed?

0:04:14 Yes.

0:04:15 Greg Hawkins?

0:04:16 Yes.

0:04:17 Jason Brown?

0:04:18 Yes.

0:04:19 Hunter Cutler?

0:04:20 Yes.

0:04:21 motion passes six to zero. Okay next under items of consideration the first

0:04:28 item is an action item. The request to award the 2024 millen inlay project to

0:04:36 Staker and Parker companies in DBA item materials and construction in the

0:04:41 amount of 467 6 10 and we have AC Palmer staff engineer welcome AC. Good

0:04:49 evening mayor and council. I'm going to do a little five to ten minute presentation.

0:04:56 Hopefully shouldn't take too long. This is a pretty standard project. We try to do one every year

0:05:02 to keep our roads in good maintenance. I am going to provide a little bit of context for this very

0:05:08 exciting project though. This Millin and Lay serves, this Millin and Lay will be on main avenue east

0:05:20 from Blue Lakes to Nevada on Eastland Drive from Kimberley Road to 4th Avenue.

0:05:25 On Grandview Drive, a 160-foot portion over by Falls. If you've been over there,

0:05:31 you know where I'm talking about. And on Monroe Street from Meadows Lane to Falls.

0:05:36 All these portions are portions of road which have been determined by our

0:05:41 street department as needing a little bit of extra help. The road is either

0:05:45 deteriorated or they're spending so much time on maintenance that it really

0:05:50 needs maintenance on it. So milling it in laying, I've kind of ridden a little bit

0:05:55 here. They will look at all the manholes and valves. They'll lower them down to the

0:06:03 road. They'll mill off the top three inches of asphalt and they'll put new

0:06:08 asphalt back over that creating a nice new smooth surface and then they will

0:06:13 bring up those manholes and valves. The very common process and we've done it

0:06:19 all over town before. This was a formerly bid project. We had one bid and it was

0:06:25 item materials and construction. It was a little bit over the engineer's estimate,

0:06:31 but we do have this money in the budget and we would like go ahead and move forward.

0:06:36 Are there any questions about this I can answer them? Okay, any questions for AC?

0:06:43 I'd entertain a motion then. Jason Brown. I'd move to approve the award for the

0:06:55 2024 Millen inlay project to Staker Parsons companies doing business as Idaho material

0:07:02 and construction the amount of 467,610 dollars.

0:07:07 Thank you, Sherry Vomer.

0:07:09 I'll second.

0:07:10 Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, second by Sherry Vomer to approve the award of the 2024

0:07:16 for Milleninley project in the amount of $467,610

0:07:23 to Staker and Parser person companies.

0:07:27 Any further discussion?

0:07:29 Amy Rokavo, please.

0:07:32 Chris Reed.

0:07:33 Yes.

0:07:34 Greg Hawkins.

0:07:35 Yes.

0:07:35 Jason Brown.

0:07:36 Yes.

0:07:37 Spencer Cutler.

0:07:38 Yes.

0:07:38 Barry Bomer.

0:07:39 Yes.

0:07:39 And Ruth Pierce.

0:07:40 Yes.

0:07:42 Perfect.

0:07:43 Thank you.

0:07:43 Motion passes 6 to 0.

0:07:46 Thank you, AC.

0:07:48 Okay, next item under action item is a request to appoint the City Manager as City Health Officer,

0:07:55 and we have our City Attorney Bruce Castleton. Welcome, Bruce. I don't think your mic's on.

0:08:03 Thank you. Good evening. So we have had a provision in City Code for quite some time that identifies the duties of a City Health Officer.

0:08:13 One of the primary duties has to do with the abatement of nuisances within the city.

0:08:18 We have recently come in some circumstances where the city believes it may need to utilize

0:08:23 that health officer in order to do some work on a specific property and possibly others,

0:08:30 but we have not designated anybody to be that health officer, even though it is provided

0:08:36 for.

0:08:37 And so the ordinance before the council is to designate the city manager as the health

0:08:41 officer, that city manager in that capacity would then take the necessary actions in dealing

0:08:47 with nuisances and attempting to abate them and so that is essentially to make

0:08:53 this official from the council designating the manager in that capacity.

0:08:58 Okay and I understand that if we're gonna pass this tonight we need to put it on

0:09:05 third and final. Yes, she'll meet. Hi, title to forgo the reading. Thank you.

0:09:11 Any questions for Bruce? Bruce, can you go over some of the other areas that the

0:09:18 city health officer for those in the audience of some of the duties of this

0:09:22 this position. Understanding it's not a complete new position but ultimately the

0:09:30 duties would be underneath the city manager. Yes, happy to do that. Primarily

0:09:35 in the city code it is actually meant for the abatement of new sentences even though

0:09:39 it's a broad title the two provisions that are falling that is under code or

0:09:43 Section 7-1-19 has to do with designating that person to take the lead.

0:09:49 That person has authority over identifying nuisances, investigating them.

0:09:54 That person then has the authority to require in writing that the owner of the property takes steps and if not,

0:10:01 ultimately the health officer has the authority to take certain actions on the cities that have to abate the nuisance itself.

0:10:10 It's really primarily what it's there for.

0:10:13 Looking through the city code, there really aren't any other responsibilities for that official.

0:10:18 Perfect. Thank you.

0:10:20 Thank you, Bruce. Any other questions for Bruce?

0:10:23 Chris Reed.

0:10:27 All right. Mayor, I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance 2024-009 on third and final reading by title only.

0:10:35 Thank you, Jason Brown. Thank you. Motion by Chris Reed.

0:10:39 seconded by Jason Brown to put ordinance number 2024-09 on third and final

0:10:46 reading by title only. Amy Rolkov please. Craig Hawkins. Yes.

0:10:54 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes six to zero.

0:11:03 I'll read the ordinance. It's an ordinance of this ordinance number 2024

0:11:08 dash 009 an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls Idaho appointing

0:11:15 the City Manager as City Health Officer Chris Reed moved to approve

0:11:20 ordinance 2024 dash 009. Thank you. Do I have a second second. Thank you motion by

0:11:26 by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve Ordinance number 2024-009

0:11:34 appointing the City Manager as City Health Officer. Any further discussion?

0:11:40 Amy Rolkel-Volt? Jason Brown? Yes. Spencer Cutler? Yes.

0:11:47 Gary Bomer? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes.

0:11:51 Craig Hawkins.

0:11:52 Yes.

0:11:53 Thank you, motion passes six to zero.

0:11:56 Congratulations, Travis.

0:11:58 I feel like that is kind of like any other duties

0:12:01 is assigned in the job description.

0:12:03 Yes.

0:12:04 You're welcome.

0:12:05 Thank you.

0:12:05 I appreciate that.

0:12:07 I look forward to continued service in a new role.

0:12:11 No, really, I think what Bruce had shared

0:12:13 is that it's for the really the abatement of nuisance

0:12:16 properties that we have within our community.

0:12:18 So it's going to help us take a look at some of those properties within our community that have been

0:12:26 that we've struggled with over the course of the last couple of years and help us come to some

0:12:32 meaningful resolution. That was excellent. Okay next item on the agenda is a presentation.

0:12:40 It's a review of the 2024 2025 fiscal year preliminary budget for the city of Twin Falls

0:12:47 in the amount of $102,649,038 followed by citizen input.

0:12:56 You're up, Travis.

0:12:58 So, members of the council, thank you for the opportunity.

0:13:04 And before I begin, this has been that conversation that seems like it was the never ending story.

0:13:12 This is, I believe, our 10th conversation that we've had about the budget this year as

0:13:22 we focused in on each of the primary drivers of the city's plan.

0:13:29 And what I want to do is just thank all of those members of our team that came forward

0:13:34 and shared not only their stories, but describe the needs, status of the department, the different

0:13:40 projects that they presented for your review. This budget would be incomplete if it were left

0:13:48 solely to me. I believe through our long-term planning process and the eyes of many we've been

0:13:53 able to put forward a a solid proposal and then over the course of the last couple of weeks we've

0:13:58 really asked the council to to review some different thoughts and projects that you had

0:14:04 and they've been incorporated in tonight, it is really the last engagement that we have before we

0:14:11 begin the public hearing aspect of the budget which will begin in the schedule for next week.

0:14:17 So tonight's presentation is not going to be as in depth for individuals of our community who are

0:14:22 curious about the budget. All of the presentations are online, they can go and they can review that,

0:14:29 And then if they have questions outside of that,

0:14:32 members of the city's team would be happy to share any thoughts

0:14:36 or answer any questions about this budget as we move forward.

0:14:39 So this budget will take effect on October 1st,

0:14:43 and it will run through September 30th of 2025.

0:14:46 That's why we refer to it as the fiscal year 25 budget.

0:14:50 Here are the general sections of the state code that are applicable.

0:14:55 The city has met all of these requirements as we're going through this process and will

0:15:00 continue to meet the requirements as we host the public hearing next week which has been

0:15:06 published not only in the Times News but also on individual tax assessments.

0:15:15 When we started this conversation very early on in April we worked with the council to

0:15:21 establish the larger overarching priorities of this budget. We wanted to have something

0:15:27 that was stable, sustainable, and nimble. We recognize that the operating environment that

0:15:34 we function in is perpetually changing, and we need to be able to respond very, very quickly.

0:15:41 We wanted to make sure that the budget is taking into account to the degree that we can personal

0:15:48 circumstances that are driving our own individual financial decisions that the

0:15:53 budget that we're creating, we needed it to be one that could be absorbed by the

0:15:58 members of the community. We wanted to make sure that it was tied directly to

0:16:02 the strategic plan where we've coined the phrase we don't want to chase the

0:16:06 shiny things and we want to make sure that we use that strategic plan as our

0:16:10 guidepost in all of our decision-making, especially the ones as we move

0:16:14 forward in this budget. We've shared with you and even last week during the focus

0:16:21 Area 8 conversation the most important piece that we have in delivering of

0:16:26 services are our employees and we want to make sure that we're viewed as an

0:16:30 employer of choice and that we're providing compensation benefits, training

0:16:35 opportunities, facilities, equipment, all of those ingredients that create a

0:16:40 quality workplace so that our employees can perform on those front lines. You

0:16:45 Municipal services are not delivered without quality services and they're not in quality

0:16:53 employees. We wanted to make sure that our budget is balanced with available revenues

0:17:00 and we wanted to make sure that we minimized all rate increases as we move forward. I believe

0:17:07 we've accomplished all of those goals and this budget is before you not only this evening

0:17:12 but moving forward.

0:17:13 And it falls in line with all the different budgeting awards

0:17:16 that we have received over the course

0:17:19 of the last several years.

0:17:20 And we don't build a budget to win awards.

0:17:24 We build it because it illustrates our commitment

0:17:26 to best practices.

0:17:28 And we're one of the few cities in Idaho that can share

0:17:31 that we've won the distinguished budget award,

0:17:33 as well as the certificate of achievement

0:17:36 for excellence in financial reporting,

0:17:38 both as presented by the government finance

0:17:40 precision substance. So what did we use? Well, we like to share that the City of

0:17:48 Twin Falls is a community that is continuing to grow at 56,000 people in

0:17:53 our community today. We believe this census that will come in 2030, our

0:17:59 population will be nearing 65,000 people. And want that just to kind of settle in

0:18:05 especially for individuals like me who've been in the area for nearly 25 years and

0:18:10 and the City of Twin Falls was right around 32,000.

0:18:15 And so in that window of time,

0:18:17 we'll nearly double in population.

0:18:20 But what's also important about that number is,

0:18:22 it's not just us that's growing.

0:18:24 It's Jerome and Kimberly and Biler and Google

0:18:29 and all of those communities that continue to grow

0:18:32 at even faster rates than we do on an annual basis.

0:18:37 They come into City of Twin Falls

0:18:39 And when they come into the City of Twin Falls,

0:18:41 our daytime service population will often

0:18:44 exceed 105,000 individuals.

0:18:47 And we know that because 40,000 people just

0:18:50 cross the prime bridge every single day.

0:18:55 And then if you think about all of the other points

0:18:57 of access into the City of Twin Falls, we are growing.

0:19:02 And we will continue to grow.

0:19:03 And when we think about our community,

0:19:05 that is who we are providing services,

0:19:09 just the residents of our community.

0:19:11 When you look at retail sales per capita,

0:19:14 another factor to look at,

0:19:15 it is double both the Idaho and US averages.

0:19:20 However, our employment,

0:19:21 our ex-union household income,

0:19:24 is not at the levels of those same areas.

0:19:29 We've watched housing continue to grow and cost,

0:19:33 and it is certainly much more expensive here,

0:19:36 especially with higher interest rates

0:19:38 than what it was just a few years ago.

0:19:42 And while the median value of home has slipped 7.6%

0:19:47 from its all-time high, it is still significantly

0:19:50 above the national average in the city of Flint Falls

0:19:53 as median home value is right in line

0:19:56 with the national average.

0:19:59 And employees, good employees, are hard to find.

0:20:03 At a three and a half percent unemployment rate,

0:20:06 we are at full employment.

0:20:10 And being at full employment means that we have to continue to do things to not only attract,

0:20:17 but most importantly retain the folks that we have.

0:20:20 This is a lot of the data that we shared with you throughout the entire process where we

0:20:25 talked about how the Windfalls County has received the national notoriety of being one

0:20:34 of the largest affordability gaps in housing

0:20:40 when it comes to what our buying power is for our citizens

0:20:44 in comparison to what the median list price is.

0:20:47 That becomes a particular concerning for me

0:20:50 when I think about trying to recruit police officers

0:20:53 and firefighters, have them come into our organizations

0:20:57 and have them have a place to live.

0:21:00 where we recognize that 47 job openings out of every 100

0:21:06 in the state of Idaho will go unfilled today.

0:21:10 And that we're seeing that number continue to grow

0:21:12 and we don't have to talk much more about housing

0:21:17 and costs are not only going up as a result of inflation

0:21:21 for Twin Falls households, but also for us.

0:21:26 So we've taken all of that information and we shared,

0:21:28 This is, these are the lenses that we've constructed this budget.

0:21:33 And it is built around the eight focus areas of the strategic plan.

0:21:37 And again, the internal organization falls in the middle of that.

0:21:44 And so here's the budget.

0:21:45 By expenditure, you can see that about $72 million

0:21:53 are in the government funds or tax-supported funds.

0:21:57 $32 million of that is going to be in the enterprise funds

0:22:01 and $4 million are going to be in those non-tax supported funds.

0:22:06 If you add all those together,

0:22:08 it's going to be slightly larger than the $102 million

0:22:11 that we talked about.

0:22:12 We focus on what's called a net budget,

0:22:14 and what we do is we remove the transfers

0:22:16 or the operating rents that the small companies

0:22:20 underneath the city's corporate umbrella pay into.

0:22:24 And then when you take a look at where those funds go

0:22:26 in terms of the major categories,

0:22:28 you can see that 38% of our entire budget goes to personnel,

0:22:32 31% to capital, 20% to operation maintenance,

0:22:37 3.2% goes to debt service, which I think talks

0:22:40 about the financial strength of the city of Twin Falls,

0:22:43 and then that transfers those rents

0:22:45 that those other parts of our organization pay.

0:22:49 So I'm gonna hit the three main categories,

0:22:53 personnel, operations, and capital.

0:22:57 And in this budget, we're going to allocate $42.298 million

0:23:02 to fund all employee related costs across the organization.

0:23:08 That's going to be 351 total employees.

0:23:14 And if you had been tracking our budget,

0:23:16 you're going to say, how did we grow by nearly 35 employees

0:23:19 in a single year?

0:23:20 It's how we're structured with the library.

0:23:23 By absorbing into the library, the library

0:23:25 has added those employees into our employee family,

0:23:29 and they are included in those numbers.

0:23:32 We've asked for a 6% performance adjustment

0:23:35 for our employees that have those merit-based adjustments,

0:23:41 a 3% table move, $1,000 HSA contribution

0:23:47 for our employees who are on the city's health insurance

0:23:50 program, continuation of our retention program,

0:23:53 which we believe has been very successful

0:23:55 in retaining the more veteran and older members of our employees, a 2.5% increase for our health

0:24:02 insurance premium. We had shared with you earlier that we're marking and taking steps to become

0:24:08 self-insured and we believe that by next year at this point in time we would have accomplished

0:24:12 that mission and we believe that we're going to be able to do more cost-bending when it comes to

0:24:17 health insurance. And then funding the Viva that was created by the organization last year as we

0:24:23 We got rid of the retirement banks and completely re-tooled our leave accrual processes.

0:24:31 So this is why the gap, right?

0:24:32 So we went from 328 employees to 351, and really in our organization we're looking at

0:24:38 adding a total of six new employees new to the organization.

0:24:44 When you net out the library, and you can see that three of them are firefighters, which

0:24:48 will only happen if we receive the Safer Award, we believe those awards, or those announced

0:24:54 We know that some organizations across our country have received their award notifications

0:25:00 and so we patiently wait and still are optimistic that we'll be able to get that award.

0:25:05 If we are unsuccessful, then we'll only be adding the three positions that are below,

0:25:10 which are the Assistant HR Director, the Open Space Supervisor, and the fleet service advisor.

0:25:15 All of these positions had gone through a series of bedings first starting with our long-term planning team

0:25:22 team and then moving up to the city's executive leadership team and then through our balance

0:25:28 budgeting efforts.

0:25:29 This is the increase in the operation and maintenance costs and you can see that we're

0:25:36 projecting our operation and maintenance costs.

0:25:38 This year will increase by about $455,000 or about 1.95% which is lower than the municipal

0:25:46 cost index.

0:25:47 And so we continue to find ways to become more efficient,

0:25:52 and we will continue to do that.

0:25:54 We believe that priority-based budgeting will help us understand the cost of programs

0:25:58 and that we're going to be able to continue to find ways to sharpen our pencil moving forward.

0:26:03 This is also a number that's increased, especially by the work of the City Council

0:26:09 over the course of the last couple of weeks.

0:26:11 And so if anybody had been following along and paying attention,

0:26:14 they've noticed that this number increased by $11 million.

0:26:17 And in that process, we were awarded a grant to make improvements on Eastland Avenue by

0:26:24 the state of Idaho.

0:26:25 We incorporated that into the budget and that's $8.2 million increase, as well as using cash

0:26:31 reserves, $3.185 to cover larger projects as we move forward.

0:26:39 Even by using $3.185 million, we still believe that we'll have over $11 million on restricted

0:26:47 reserves in the capital fund for any unforeseen emergencies or for us to take

0:26:54 advantage of unforeseen opportunities as they may present themselves. So those

0:26:59 three projects of the council agreed to support number one remodel of the city's

0:27:04 pool locker rooms at an estimate cost of $1.2 million, creating a city

0:27:10 attorney office space and making improvements to the city gym. All of those

0:27:16 facilities are in the old council chambers off of off of third. And so we're going to repurpose that structure so that our attorneys have

0:27:24 a different workspace than what they have now and then modifying the

0:27:29 current gym that we have to make sure that our employees can still

0:27:34 physically fit and well. And then we've allocated

0:27:38 $175,000 to architectural costs associated with finding a

0:27:43 a solution for police evidence and creating a new training facility for them.

0:27:48 Here are some ideas that were presented by members of the team along the way.

0:27:55 Every year since 2019, the City Council has allocated $770,000 of what we describe as Council

0:28:04 allocated or directed capital.

0:28:07 And through a series of conversations, the Council has elected to fund the design of

0:28:12 Elizabeth, both of our project from May Drive to Apache Way and the Kimberly Road

0:28:19 to 4th Avenue East located on Locust Street. Both of those are designed only.

0:28:25 We hope to have shelve-ready projects whether we apply for grants or whether

0:28:30 we are able to use additional funding at some point in time to move forward. As we

0:28:36 have shared that the great work by our fleet management committee has

0:28:42 They've looked at that different replacement schedule.

0:28:47 We had more needs than what we had available resources in the Council.

0:28:52 We took use $373,000 to help fund those needed improvements and replacement of pieces of our

0:29:02 Rolex Dock.

0:29:03 And we have a need to replace the lift inside of the Police Department and estimate cost

0:29:09 of $275,000. So we've been talking about this hypothetical person, right? This hypothetical

0:29:19 person and we took a look at what is the median water consumption and what is the cap of sewer

0:29:27 consumption, sanitation and recycling and if we were to say Zillow's right what is happening

0:29:33 to property taxes and over the course we've been presenting that the median person, if this

0:29:41 person existed would pay $8.98 more next year as a result of this budget.

0:29:49 But we wanted to provide a real example for you.

0:29:53 This is a real example that we could provide to show that that median person, the illustration

0:30:00 that we've been providing, may be reality may be different.

0:30:06 And so what I did was I was able to locate a property and from that property I took the

0:30:11 value of that home from 2023 to the current time. And you can see that reflected in the

0:30:20 different columns and then we took the different, the actual water and sewer bills associated

0:30:28 with this property. And you can see that this individual used 5,000 gallons. And a lot of

0:30:33 people say, well, I don't use 5,000. I use a lot more than 5,000 gallons. And I would

0:30:37 say that this person benefits from having fresh rise

0:30:41 irrigation, which is why you can see that additional cost

0:30:45 associated with that.

0:30:47 So this person here is actually going to pay less in

0:30:50 property taxes under this budget than they did the prior

0:30:54 year, simply because the value of the home decreased

0:31:00 greater than the increase in the tax rate.

0:31:03 And so what we'd encourage everybody to do is take a

0:31:05 look at the tax rate that's being assessed.

0:31:08 And remember, it is simply a multiplier.

0:31:11 And so this individual here, based upon this budget,

0:31:14 would actually pay $1.52 less per month

0:31:18 than what they're currently paying.

0:31:20 And we believe, based upon the research that we've done,

0:31:24 this is a more real calculation than that median

0:31:29 that we've created over a period of time.

0:31:32 If anybody has any questions on the impact

0:31:35 to their individual budgets and what this looks like.

0:31:39 We can help them walk through that process.

0:31:41 All we need is their taxable value,

0:31:47 and we'll be able to help them share what that impact would be.

0:31:53 You're nearing the homestretch.

0:31:56 Tonight is the review of the budget,

0:31:58 and that's what we've completed next week.

0:32:03 We will have a series of legal steps

0:32:07 that the council will have to take.

0:32:09 The first is a public hearing and the consideration

0:32:12 of a resolution to use 1% of the city's foregone balance.

0:32:16 After that, you'll have a public hearing

0:32:18 on the totality of the budget,

0:32:21 and then we would ask for you to consider an ordinance

0:32:25 on that evening to create this concept

0:32:30 into a functional reality.

0:32:33 I'm happy to stand for any questions.

0:32:35 Thank you, Travis.

0:32:36 Any questions for Travis?

0:32:41 Chris, Greg, somebody had a question?

0:32:44 Travis, I just wanted to say I haven't been on council

0:32:48 for a few years, that this year it seemed like

0:32:50 it made more sense to me.

0:32:52 I like the fact that not only the department

0:32:54 has gave input, but also regular employees.

0:32:58 And it was a lot more interesting,

0:33:02 and I gained a lot from it.

0:33:03 And I know there's a lot of work that goes into it,

0:33:05 so thank you.

0:33:07 And I appreciate the fact that you don't have to hear from me every week, right?

0:33:11 So it really, I think, provides a much more interesting story with those individuals,

0:33:18 with actual boots on the ground, talking about the different needs they have in service to the community.

0:33:23 So thank you for that, and we'll certainly pass it along to all those who present it.

0:33:28 I think in total we had more than 60 members of our organization come forward

0:33:33 in either directly present or assistant presentations

0:33:37 over that period of time.

0:33:38 And we also have about, you had core leadership

0:33:42 and you had the members of the long-term planning team.

0:33:45 You're getting close to probably 45 additional members.

0:33:47 So significant number of people inside of our organization

0:33:52 worked to craft the proposal that's before you.

0:33:54 That's a great job, Chris Reed.

0:33:57 I also wanted to say thank you and many of the individuals

0:34:00 that presented are here tonight.

0:34:01 And so thank you for the work that you've done.

0:34:03 In the last couple of weeks, I was very impressed with some of the projects that initially we

0:34:11 weren't going to be able to do anything about.

0:34:13 We weren't going to be able to fund the grant that came in, being able to do that, using

0:34:17 cash reserves.

0:34:20 For some of those projects, it was exciting to see that.

0:34:22 I know when we go and talk about the budget, we're over 100 million.

0:34:27 It's a little bit of a heartburn, but understanding that that's not coming completely out of the

0:34:31 pockets of the citizens. We're using cash reserves. We're using grants. We're using funds from other

0:34:38 other areas to make sure that we can meet the needs of our our community. So thank you for all

0:34:43 the hard work that you and your team have done. Thank you. So just to add on to that I believe it's

0:34:49 slightly more than 30 million dollars of the entirety of the budget comes from the form of

0:34:54 property taxes. I think that if you were to look at our finance team and all the different

0:35:01 revenue sources. I can remember one time it gave me a sneak peek just a quick glance and I believe

0:35:07 that there are more than 400 different revenue sources that they keep track of on a regular basis

0:35:13 and I believe also next week not next week either next week Brianna is going to be giving her

0:35:21 finance report prior to the adoption of the budget as well. Right what else? Okay so we have

0:35:32 Time on the agenda for some public input.

0:35:35 I just want to be clear.

0:35:36 We're going to break this out into a couple of different sessions.

0:35:40 First, we'll be taking input on the budget itself.

0:35:46 If there's anybody that has any comments they'd like to share

0:35:51 on the presentation or any of the presentations we had.

0:35:55 Once we're done with that, we'll move on to just general public input.

0:35:59 So if you have something not on today's agenda,

0:36:03 you're welcome to come up.

0:36:05 If you're planning on testifying in the two public hearings,

0:36:10 please don't testify in the general public input,

0:36:13 but save that for the public hearing.

0:36:16 And those two items are zoning development agreement

0:36:20 at 1607 Washington Street, South,

0:36:23 and a community development block grant action plan.

0:36:30 So that being said, with general public input,

0:36:35 if you do wish to speak, you can come down to the mic.

0:36:38 Please state your name and whether you're a citizen

0:36:41 of Twin Falls.

0:36:42 This is first on the budget.

0:36:44 You will have two minutes to testify

0:36:49 and we will be timed.

0:36:50 So this is budget only to start with

0:36:52 If anybody in the audience that wishes to comment on the budget was very thorough, Travis,

0:37:02 is to make sure, okay, so we'll move on to general public input.

0:37:11 I just want to make sure that you understand something that's not on today's agenda and

0:37:18 is not about personnel or personnel related issues.

0:37:23 As you come down, please state your name.

0:37:26 Amy will be timing us for two minutes.

0:37:29 And once you're done, if you haven't already signed up

0:37:33 on the sign-in sheet, I need you to do that before you leave,

0:37:38 just so we get your name and address correctly.

0:37:42 Sure. And some of you may have signed up and didn't mean

0:37:47 to sign up, thinking to speak, but just signed in,

0:37:49 so we can deal with that.

0:37:51 So the first item is Sherry Mills.

0:37:57 Sherry, if you're here, please come down.

0:38:04 Again, state your phone name and whether you're a citizen of Twin Falls, and Amy, you're ready to time.

0:38:11 Okay, go ahead, Sherry.

0:38:13 Okay.

0:38:15 and I am a lifelong Twin Falls resident.

0:38:19 I wanted to this to vent my testimony online, but that was not an option, so I'm here to read it to each one of you.

0:38:26 I'm here to address the community of Aspen scheduled in our city.

0:38:31 I was born and raised in Twin Falls. I raised all my children in Twin Falls.

0:38:36 And I currently have five grandchildren being raised in Twin Falls.

0:38:40 We have greatly benefited from the community events offered in our cities such as

0:38:45 Fund Runs, Art in the Park, Art in Soul, Music, Concerts, Movies, Praise, Car Shows,

0:38:50 Rodeos, and numerous other family events. However, I am many other citizens in our

0:38:57 community have a great concern not only for our children and grandchildren but

0:39:02 for all children being raised in Twin Falls since the city is now issuing

0:39:06 event permits to businesses that promote evil activities as entertainment, such as

0:39:13 a recent event by Paranormal Cirque that was recently set up at our local shopping mall.

0:39:19 These are not just actors and performers putting on a circus, they bring with them a

0:39:24 demonic message of murder, insanity, horror and death that is harmful to the mental, emotional

0:39:30 and spiritual health of our community.

0:39:33 I'm sure you are aware that mental health is a serious issue in our society, so why do

0:39:38 you allow outsiders to come into our once family friendly community to perform demonic

0:39:44 activity as fun and thrilling entertainment?

0:39:48 This is a travesty to our families in our community.

0:39:53 Have you not researched the online reviews?

0:39:55 Let me read to you just a few.

0:39:58 Paranormal Cirque is a dark horror field circus for those who like to be thrilled and scared.

0:40:03 It is a big top. This is the next comment. It is a big top filled with actors and performers dripping with blood

0:40:09 Donning scary mess the demonic creatures monsters murders zombies and vampires another comment. Sure your time is up on your

0:40:19 online

0:40:21 Application to speak it says that when you the first presenter is allowed 15 minutes

0:40:27 That's why is it well, then you need to update your online. I can print it out and show it to you

0:40:32 Well, I tried to submit this online and I was not given that option

0:40:38 Well, if you guys are really interested in our community and what the citizens have to say and are concerned about

0:40:47 Why are we limited to two minutes to?

0:40:50 And then go to the next person. I mean this is a serious area. That is

0:40:57 Sherry, please sit down

0:40:58 Okay

0:41:01 How next person, Kathy Thompson.

0:41:26 My name is Kathy Thompson.

0:41:27 I'm a resident of Twin Falls County.

0:41:29 On Friday and Saturday, July 26 and 27,

0:41:32 my husband and I attended a prayer vigil

0:41:34 for the R-rated Paranormal Circ at the Magic Ollie Mall.

0:41:39 Walking around the fence perimeter,

0:41:40 I saw lewd and obscene graphics of scantily clad women

0:41:44 depicted on one of the trailers and wondered

0:41:47 who allowed this display in our county.

0:41:50 The pulsating music, demonic moans and cackles,

0:41:53 and mocking laughter insulted and assaulted our senses,

0:41:56 and we were thankful for the protecting hand

0:41:58 of our mighty Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ.

0:42:01 We watched with sadness and pity as parents,

0:42:03 including pregnant mothers, brought their teens to the event,

0:42:06 imagining the mental, spiritual, and physical assault

0:42:10 they would encounter.

0:42:11 We prayed for the people attending and producing the event.

0:42:16 Paranormal Cirque combines blasphemy,

0:42:19 Public immorality, the culture of death,

0:42:22 and the public acceptance of Satanism.

0:42:25 I find this events gravely offensive acts unacceptable

0:42:28 in real life and in the public square.

0:42:31 Many families were at the mall and expressed thanks

0:42:34 for our presence of prayer.

0:42:36 They were there, some waiting for seats

0:42:38 in nearby restaurants.

0:42:39 It was very hot, they waited outside,

0:42:42 and voiced concerns about the event.

0:42:45 You know, evil dwells with activities that invite Satan.

0:42:48 Why are we inviting this darkness into our valley?

0:42:52 What will be the impact on mental health, on suicide rates?

0:42:56 What responsibility does the city council bear

0:42:58 on the impact of their support of the paranormal?

0:43:02 What stress will it put on our medical police

0:43:04 and legal systems?

0:43:06 Please consider the concerns of future decisions

0:43:10 that impact the Christian worldview

0:43:12 that comprises the majority of the local public

0:43:15 that you serve.

0:43:18 Thank you.

0:43:19 Thank you, Kathy.

0:43:27 Next is Callie Schiffler.

0:43:29 Good evening, Sir Counsel.

0:43:42 I was born and raised in Twin Falls.

0:43:43 I now live in Jerome.

0:43:45 I am a concerned citizen.

0:43:47 There are two types of supernatural.

0:43:50 The Bible clearly defines the two.

0:43:51 First, we have the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.

0:43:54 Mark 16, 15 through 17 says, go out into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature.

0:43:59 He who believes in his baptized will be saved and he who does not believe will be condemned.

0:44:04 And these signs will follow those who believe in my name, they will cast out demons.

0:44:10 The other supernatural is the enemy of God, Satan and his demons.

0:44:14 Demons are real.

0:44:16 Principalities and powers of Satan will power of the unseen realms to oppose God.

0:44:21 Ephesians 612, where we are not fighting against flesh and blood enemies, but against

0:44:26 evil rulers and authorities of the unseen world.

0:44:29 Against mighty powers in the dark world, and against evil spirits in heavenly places.

0:44:34 in John 10 10 states, God's enemy comes to steal, kill, and destroy.

0:44:41 You are the gatekeepers to this city.

0:44:43 Do not allow the hearts of the naive to be deceived.

0:44:47 St. Paul is to control the world through the minds of men who have been bewitched by his

0:44:51 way of thinking.

0:44:52 We tolerate darkness and compromise our lives and our city because we do not see demonic

0:44:58 forces for the destructive enemies that they are.

0:45:02 Either you realize it or not, there is a satanic strategy to bring humanity into agreement

0:45:08 with the demonic way of thinking.

0:45:11 We would be wise to protect our city, resist the devil and his demons, and not allow the

0:45:16 paranormal sirk or any other demonic entity into our city.

0:45:20 Though I have four questions for the city council this evening.

0:45:25 First one, the enemy is at the city gate.

0:45:28 Why would you open the gate and let him in to steal, kill, and destroy?

0:45:33 Second question, what gives you the right to allow an evil supernatural event into our

0:45:37 city and allow 13-year-old children and older to attend?

0:45:42 Third question, do you understand the seeds of destruction you are planting in our community

0:45:46 for people of all ages?

0:45:49 Fourth question, what are the risks of allowing demonic activity into our city?

0:45:56 suicide rates, increased divorce rates, increased mental health issues, increased drug and alcohol abuse, increased crime.

0:46:05 Maybe those are just a few.

0:46:08 We are here to ask you- I'm sorry, your time is up. Thank you.

0:46:12 We're here to ask you to keep our- Thank you. Thank you.

0:46:16 Hey, I have Kayla Tate.

0:46:35 Members, my name is Kayla Tate for the record.

0:46:37 Are you a citizen of Twin Falls?

0:46:40 Um, I was I'm right now. I am not a citizen. Okay. Thank you. Just a concerned community member

0:46:48 Do you live? You don't live here into it. I live in a motorhome. So I live here a part time. Okay. That's okay. Perfect. Thank you. Yeah.

0:46:57 So you can see we as the people have come to address some leadership concerns

0:47:02 And some decisions that we feel that the council has made that have created some heavy duty

0:47:09 well for lack of better terminology, health hazards and safety concerns and we feel

0:47:16 as you know as leaders of our community that safety and health should be like

0:47:22 super priority especially right now in our community and we just want to make

0:47:27 you aware and take a stand in the face of hell because as lovers of Jesus

0:47:34 What's that's what you're gonna get here today as blubbers of jesus we know by having boots on the ground

0:47:41 What happens when we go around our communities and release heaven on earth things shift and then our leadership

0:47:49 Doesn't come into agreement with what's happening with boots on the ground and so then you choose to do the opposite of that and allow

0:47:57 things of

0:47:59 ill nature

0:48:01 demonic activity demons are ill

0:48:04 Whether you think demons are real or not, they're real, just like heaven is real.

0:48:10 So as leaders in this realm, in the realm of the church, we want you to know that we want to partner with you as leaders of our community to come together and make safe, healthy decisions for our children, for our people in our places, so we can work together, so we can actually make a real difference.

0:48:33 Prayers going up, what are you guys going to do about it?

0:48:37 Thank you.

0:48:38 J.J. Love's, I believe.

0:48:46 Levens?

0:48:47 My name's Justin Levens, and I'm a citizen of Twin Falls County.

0:49:03 In a world full of chaos and fear with more awareness and less solutions,

0:49:08 deception has taken root in the hearts and minds of the innocent.

0:49:11 That which we reap, we've sown.

0:49:16 Who, what use, what used to be right is wrong, and what's wrong is not right.

0:49:22 is now right. I want to say on behalf of a generation full of a fear, anxiety, depression,

0:49:28 and suicidal thoughts, my hope and prayers that you stand for hatred of evil, that you will take

0:49:34 a stance against the promotion of iniquity and lawlessness. Our struggle here isn't against

0:49:39 flesh and blood but against demonic powers and influences. We know the devil's nature is to steal

0:49:46 kill and destroy, but Christ came to give us peace, hope, and life. I pray your eyes begin to see the

0:49:52 outcome and fruit of the disgusting event and the open doors that are allowing demons

0:49:59 to operate, an event that promotes satanic rituals and symbolism, an event that creates

0:50:05 entertainment out of evil. And I don't know about you guys, but I'm not sure when the

0:50:11 devil became a good guy all of a sudden. And as somebody who has a passive fear anxiety

0:50:18 depression and I believe my generation is one of the most depressed generations

0:50:24 on record and it's only getting worse. My question for you guys is when are you

0:50:29 gonna draw the line? Thank you. Okay, Shayla Tate. Thank you Madam Chair and for

0:50:54 the record my name is Shayla Tate and I just have a question for the committee.

0:50:58 Are you a resident of Twin Falls? That's my mom so motorhome. Okay, motorhome. Okay.

0:51:05 says Blaine County so I wasn't sure. Yeah. Is this the type of activity you want to

0:51:11 promote in our community? These demonic acts are not just imaginary. They are real

0:51:15 life health issues that exist in our society. These demonic acts and

0:51:20 performances create torment and fear to the human minds of children and

0:51:24 undercerning adults. Not just emotionally but spiritually. Demons are real like we've

0:51:30 all stated here and demons cause harm. Why does the city of Twin Falls allow

0:51:36 events in our community that are known to cause harm to mental, emotional, and

0:51:41 spiritual health of our community? How does this type of event that performs

0:51:46 demonic activities benefit the lives and health of citizens in our community?

0:51:51 This event should have never been approved by the city. Let me bring to your

0:51:57 attention according to your own stipulations the violations made in the

0:52:01 application process. Violation number one, the application forms states all

0:52:06 special events applications must be completed and submitted to the City of

0:52:10 Twin Falls no less than 45 days prior to the hosting of an event. The

0:52:14 paranormal circuit application was submitted June 18th of 2024 and their

0:52:19 event was scheduled July 26th through the 28th of 2024, 10 days past the deadline.

0:52:24 violation number two also stated on the application a non refundable application

0:52:29 fee of $25 is required at the time of application submission applications with

0:52:33 unpaid fees will not be reviewed for approval Rachel Long assisted the task

0:52:37 herself on June 14th but the record I was provided with doesn't state any

0:52:42 payment was received and if it was received June 24th that is six days

0:52:48 passed the required deadline of the day the application was submitted is this how

0:52:52 How the City of Twin Falls conducts business?

0:52:55 Thank you.

0:52:56 Thank you.

0:53:02 Hey, I have Stacey Young.

0:53:03 Hi, I'm Stacey Young and I live in Jerome, but in Jerome and Twin are linked together

0:53:25 with it.

0:53:26 Anyways, I just want to thank you this evening for hearing what we have to say.

0:53:32 I realize as a group that we come to this area and you guys have regulations through

0:53:41 the city that all that are allowed to assemble, they have to meet certain

0:53:49 regulations and I understand that. Whether you agree with them or not, however, you're

0:53:54 elected by the community, by the people, you know, to your people, the community, and

0:54:00 it's your responsibility to protect the next generation and make changes to do

0:54:05 so. There's no surprise that this evil is among us. It's a fulfillment of the

0:54:11 prophecy. Our family fathers paid laws based on faith and the word of God. Children were taught

0:54:18 the word of God and our family fathers prayed before they met, made any of their decisions.

0:54:26 My question to you is this. When did our laws change to make those elect afraid to stand up

0:54:33 for what they believe in and stop being afraid of offending evil? When did they stop relying on

0:54:39 God to lead their meetings. When do they start letting others tell them what to do?

0:54:46 You're responsible for the next generation. How do you want them to run this community?

0:54:51 They will be sitting in your seats one day. What decisions do you want them to make,

0:54:57 the right one or the one out of regulations that allow evil to pollute the minds and the

0:55:02 generations to follow? Thank you, Stacy. So that is everybody who signed up on the sheet,

0:55:15 but just because you didn't sign up doesn't mean you can't come down and speak.

0:55:21 If there's anybody else that wishes to address City Council on any issue, not on today's agenda,

0:55:30 is there anybody else? Yes, sir.

0:55:34 Riley White, Hagerman Idaho, not a citizen, but past search search in Filer Idaho and hope to be

0:55:51 a citizen of Twin Falls County when the housing market slows down and opens up a little bit.

0:55:56 But just have a question I think as I was sitting there listening to everything going on in the

0:56:00 budget, everybody's public comments for all of you guys. Myself, I work for the state of Idaho as a

0:56:06 public servant just like you guys and our job is to serve the public, is to serve our community as

0:56:12 we've heard tonight the concern from our community. But my question to you is this, because we saw

0:56:17 the city manager's new position of the health officer and we're looking out for the health of our

0:56:22 community. I drive over the prime bridge a minimum of five times a week and we

0:56:28 know that is a destination and suicide location. Correct? Agreed? And in our

0:56:34 community, our jobs are to support our community, back to our community. As a

0:56:40 pastor, that's my calling, as a state employee, that's my calling, and likewise

0:56:45 for you. So I challenge you tonight, when you go home and you lay your head on your

0:56:49 fellow, ask yourself, I do the best of my ability, the safety, the security, not only

0:56:56 of my community, my family, my kids, my grandkids that are going to grow up in this community.

0:57:02 Because as local people that love Twin Falls benefit from Twin Falls, that's our concern.

0:57:07 And so I'm going to close in my last 37 seconds and pray for you guys and your decisions.

0:57:13 Lord, we lift up every one of these people in this room.

0:57:15 As they lead our county, as they lead this place, Lord, that you would show them the direction

0:57:20 that are supposed to lead.

0:57:21 We don't know the state of each one's heart, but Lord, you do, and God, I pray that you convict

0:57:25 where conviction is needed.

0:57:27 You encourage, Lord, as it's so difficult being a servant, encourage them where encouragement

0:57:32 is needed.

0:57:33 God, I thank you for the people behind me and the people in front of me that are standing

0:57:36 up for what's right and standing up for the truth.

0:57:40 Lord, you will come back.

0:57:42 You will reign once and for all.

0:57:44 Thank you, we love you.

0:57:45 And just name everybody said, amen.

0:57:47 Hey, thank you guys.

0:57:48 Thank you.

0:57:54 Okay, anyone else?

0:57:57 All right, and I will close the public input.

0:58:05 Next, we'll move on to advisory board reports.

0:58:08 Any announcements?

0:58:10 Craig Hawkins.

0:58:12 Mayor, I just want to reiterate

0:58:13 about what we did Friday, going over to Shabani.

0:58:18 It's pretty amazing to hear their story.

0:58:21 They've produced a milk that is not for sale.

0:58:24 They had the super milk kickoff on Friday

0:58:27 and then they had a presentation

0:58:32 for a number of community leaders.

0:58:35 Sean was there, Mayor was there, I was there.

0:58:39 Really learned a lot.

0:58:40 Shobani means shepherd and they really are working hard

0:58:46 to provide service to members of the community.

0:58:51 They've got another day coming up. Do you remember the date on that?

0:58:58 August, no October 19th I believe. Let's see it week. Yeah, yeah. And this is a time when if we can,

0:59:06 we can support them in making meals for people. The super milk is not to be sold, it's just for

0:59:13 food banks and for disasters. That's pretty amazing that an employee, a business would make a product

0:59:19 not to sell and increase their bottom line.

0:59:22 So I just wanted to point that out.

0:59:25 And then the other item I wanted to mention

0:59:28 to recently moved over to the Arts Commission

0:59:32 in talking with them.

0:59:34 And I learned a great deal there.

0:59:38 But one of the main challenges that's coming forward

0:59:41 with the commission is that we just

0:59:44 don't have enough funding to meet the needs of what we want

0:59:46 to do.

0:59:47 We don't even have enough funds to meet the maintenance of what we already have,

0:59:51 let alone find new art projects for the community.

0:59:54 So that's something that the commission is going to be delving into more,

0:59:58 and I'm sure we'll be hearing more about.

0:59:59 So that's my field.

1:00:01 Thanks, Craig.

1:00:02 Anybody else?

1:00:03 That's great.

1:00:04 I have two things.

1:00:05 I do want to thank those individuals that came and spoke tonight.

1:00:08 I know it's not always easy to come here and speak.

1:00:12 Thank you for your concern, your conviction.

1:00:15 We really do appreciate it.

1:00:16 So thank you for coming tonight.

1:00:19 Number two, the airport board did meet.

1:00:22 The biggest thing that I'll bring back to the council

1:00:24 is that the work on the 2025 air show is underway.

1:00:29 So they're gonna be bringing some stuff back

1:00:31 and explaining what's happening.

1:00:33 It's gonna be an exciting time next summer

1:00:36 with the Blue Angels here.

1:00:38 Perfect.

1:00:40 Anybody else?

1:00:42 Okay, then we'll move on to the public hearings.

1:00:45 First is, I guess I should read the rules, first, give me the eyesight, okay, so as Will's

1:00:55 coming up, this is the procedure for public hearings related to planning and zoning issues.

1:01:04 We'll follow this agenda, first city staff will present the request and analysis, the

1:01:10 applicant will then present their request, the council will then ask questions of the

1:01:16 applicant or staff. After the questions have been asked and answered, the public hearing

1:01:22 will then be open. During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment,

1:01:28 ask questions about the request being considered. When you come up to the podium to give testimony,

1:01:35 please state your name and address and sign again, sign the sheet, which I probably should

1:01:42 make sure everybody's got down there, sign the sheet,

1:01:46 and after the public comments are concluded,

1:01:50 the applicant will be invited to answer any questions

1:01:52 and make an closing statement.

1:01:54 Staff will then answer, clarify any comments,

1:01:57 and then the public hearing will be closed,

1:01:59 and then the council will have open discussion

1:02:02 and take action.

1:02:04 So, as I mentioned, the first is an action item,

1:02:07 a request for a zoning development agreement,

1:02:10 zoning district change from R4 to R4 ZDA for a residential town home development on properly

1:02:18 located at 1607 Washington Street at South.

1:02:22 Here of Rex Harding on behalf of RE Financial Inc. PZ24-0043 and we have Will Plevver, our

1:02:30 senior planner.

1:02:31 Welcome Will.

1:02:32 Thank you Madam Mayor and fellow council members.

1:02:39 we have before you a request to for a zone development agreement just give you

1:02:47 a little overview of the general area this is in the far south part of town

1:02:51 South Hills Road is right here in Washington Street is right in the

1:02:55 center the highlighted and blue hopefully you can see that is the subject

1:03:01 property it's about four and a quarter acres there is has been several subdivisions

1:03:09 in the area, especially surrounding Wright adjacent, most notably.

1:03:17 In 2019, there was a townhome development right here, it's called Valencia Townhome Development.

1:03:32 They went through a very similar process with the CDA.

1:03:37 And so similar to today that they went through the zone development agreement and reduced

1:03:45 a lot of the same requirements that is being proposed today.

1:03:51 As far as the zoning goes, okay, so on the left hand council members you'll have a better

1:04:04 view of it.

1:04:05 So it's orange, those on the screen.

1:04:07 It's more of the.

1:04:12 That is the R4 zoning, that's the base zoning, they wish to keep the base zoning the same.

1:04:18 They just wish to amend what that certain items in there, and I'll go through those certain

1:04:23 items in a little bit.

1:04:25 Furthermore, the future land use map, the guide to how we think the town should be developing,

1:04:37 talks about town neighborhood on the right hand side of it, and then on the left side,

1:04:42 the western side of the property, right next to Washington.

1:04:46 They have a general guide of neighborhood commercial.

1:04:51 Again, that's just a guide.

1:04:52 You don't have to follow that per se,

1:04:56 especially when the whole parcel is being split in between.

1:05:01 So refer that to as a guide not necessarily hard and fast

1:05:05 for you.

1:05:05 Don't get too caught up on the difference

1:05:07 between the neighborhood commercial and the Tommy Road.

1:05:13 as far as items that are proposed to be changed.

1:05:18 So this application and document will create

1:05:24 the zoning development agreement,

1:05:26 which states or proposes a reduction

1:05:29 in a minimum lot area for townhouse lots to 629.

1:05:35 The lot occupancy for townhouse lots

1:05:38 can be increased to 100%.

1:05:41 This would eliminate the setback requirement for those townhouse property lines and it creates

1:05:51 a 20 foot setback for all exterior property lines.

1:05:55 So to put that in perspective, anywhere that there's an exterior, there would be a 20 foot

1:06:00 setback that they cannot build in.

1:06:05 was intended to protect more of the neighborhoods

1:06:09 and make sure that it's consistent.

1:06:15 And then the last thing that this really creates

1:06:17 is that it would require a homeowners association

1:06:21 to be created for maintenance.

1:06:25 Should this be approved,

1:06:27 there will be a preliminary plan and a final plan

1:06:32 as they would need to subdivide the lots into the town hall

1:06:35 but that I can stand for any questions.

1:06:41 Any questions for Will at this time, Chris Reed?

1:06:45 Maybe this is Will, maybe it's the applicant.

1:06:48 On the drawing, it's green on our screen as far as which one?

1:06:53 That one, yeah.

1:06:57 Only thing that is missing is where the trash receptacles

1:07:01 will be located, as I was looking at that.

1:07:03 I could not pick up where those would be at.

1:07:06 Yes, generally that's correct.

1:07:08 If they choose to use roll-away bins they can,

1:07:12 they would have to figure out how to screen those.

1:07:17 We do not require trash receptacles.

1:07:19 We just say that they have to figure out a plan for how

1:07:23 to utilize those trash.

1:07:26 And if it is a dumpster or if it's outside,

1:07:29 then I would have to show screening for that as well.

1:07:32 OK.

1:07:34 Thanks for reminding me, Council Member Reed.

1:07:36 I forgot to show you this.

1:07:38 So, this is the proposed landscape plan.

1:07:40 No, perfect.

1:07:41 This, in the Council for Planning and Zoning Commission's presentation, there was a couple

1:07:56 concerned citizens that lived to the north that was worried about access onto Third Street,

1:08:03 of Aspen Street and Cottonwood Street.

1:08:07 That was a part of the original plan,

1:08:08 was to have a connector or access to there.

1:08:14 However, staff didn't see that as necessary,

1:08:19 and we wanted to push it more to this to drive,

1:08:23 to go south to Washington or to South Hills Road.

1:08:27 We feel that would be even with a more primary access for it.

1:08:31 So we did say that this would only be required if at the time of building a preliminary plot

1:08:39 that fire would determine that it would be necessary, but we would look at talking about

1:08:46 like a Knox box or some type of access where it's not commonly accessible, it would be

1:08:53 for in-law emergency purposes only.

1:08:56 Otherwise, there was no other comments that we received either before the public hearings

1:09:05 or at the time at planning zoning commission public hearing.

1:09:16 Any other questions for Will?

1:09:20 Hey, thank you Will.

1:09:21 We'd have the applicants.

1:09:22 Thank you, Mayor and City Council members.

1:09:32 Rex Harding with TD&H Engineering here at Twin Falls, Idaho.

1:09:37 We're representing RE Financial, which is actually Jeremy Horton, and on this proposal.

1:09:43 The reason for the ZDA is to be able to do the townhome lots.

1:09:47 It almost sounds like in the presentation that we're trying to get smaller lots or smaller.

1:09:53 More density, but we're really not.

1:09:54 We're not exceeding the density for the R4 with what we have here.

1:09:59 Overall, lots, if you consider the whole area, which most of it is, a large part of it,

1:10:04 common area, the density is not any more than what the R4 allows. So he showed the

1:10:13 vicinity map over on Washington Street. From it's on Washington Street, the only

1:10:18 access going there are the two homes. The two homes that are already on the

1:10:25 property on the West edge over here, they have driveways that access out

1:10:29 the Washington Street and also we maintain that way at this time. The actual ZDA

1:10:35 would be on the eastern portion here. It would be accessed. Ponderosa Street

1:10:41 would be extended out to tie in to Vista Drive. The access would be on Ponderosa

1:10:47 Street at this time, ends right there. No turn around, no way of turning

1:10:55 around at all. It's just a dead end with a big about a four foot jump up to a

1:11:00 So that will get completed and work through.

1:11:06 This is in conjunction with the comprehensive plan.

1:11:13 It fits in with that and also the zoning.

1:11:15 Infrastructure and development on this.

1:11:18 Again, we have the connection of a Ponderosa street or a VISTA drive.

1:11:22 The city has requested this proposal would have VISTA drive completed out to South Hills Road,

1:11:31 which is the plan now, right, the properties along there,

1:11:34 there are three lots there already that are planted,

1:11:37 part of Golden Eagle subdivision number one

1:11:40 that was never developed.

1:11:43 And so that would, there would be,

1:11:46 there's been some negotiations there as far as getting

1:11:48 that put in out to South Hills Road.

1:11:54 As far as the water and sewer is available here in the area,

1:11:59 water mine would be looped through from Vista Drive

1:12:03 to Ponderosa Street, and then look to the property itself.

1:12:08 Sewer line would connect into the existing sewer main, which

1:12:13 is over here in this subdivision, to the north, which

1:12:18 is the southwood subdivision.

1:12:23 There is pressure irrigation available right here on this

1:12:27 drive.

1:12:28 It ends right there.

1:12:29 That comes from the South Hills pump station.

1:12:31 So that would be just connected into that,

1:12:33 So the irrigation water would be provided and not be

1:12:38 a burden to the potable water.

1:12:41 There is gravity irrigation that passes through here

1:12:44 and goes north, don't know exactly where to, but it goes north.

1:12:49 And so that will be piped through this property.

1:12:54 It'll be a lot better access than right now,

1:12:56 because the ditches and pipes that are there right now

1:12:57 aren't very good.

1:12:59 It leaves actually out this northeast corner and heads down

1:13:02 Long Washington Street, don't know exactly where it comes.

1:13:05 There will be fencing as required as a ZDA, along the South Edge, along here.

1:13:18 These lots over in here are unplatted, there are three lots along there, that are just

1:13:24 presumed splints, they're very large lots.

1:13:28 And then fencing along the West Edge, which is, I don't have it with me right here, but

1:13:34 It's another subdivision right here, residential subdivision.

1:13:38 I didn't along the north, at least along here.

1:13:44 Again, that was the south wood subdivision.

1:13:49 And then, most of the properties over here,

1:13:51 which are in the Golden Eagle subdivision,

1:13:53 number one, already have a privacy fence.

1:13:56 They're also gonna have a buffer of a street there now.

1:13:58 I think there's one or two properties

1:13:59 that don't have a privacy fence added to it.

1:14:04 Run off retention, it'll all be on site.

1:14:07 Yes, there aren't dumps through your location shown here, but that will be added in the actual development plans.

1:14:12 I mean, that's the plan.

1:14:14 You don't want to do roll-offs for this many residences.

1:14:19 And then, trees and shrubs will all be added in here as for city codes as far as the numbers and the types.

1:14:25 So, in conclusion, this will be located in an area that's already mixed with residential use.

1:14:30 It provides opportunity for homeownership through the townhouse.

1:14:36 And where all you're doing is buying that lot where that actual structure is at, but yet

1:14:43 you have the lawns and everything of the common area which is maintained.

1:14:48 It'll emanate that dead end which is a big concern I'm sure for on Ponderosa Street.

1:14:54 And then at this time it's planned to have Vista Drive completed down to South Hills

1:15:00 Road also.

1:15:01 It's just, it's just the drive-ins right here now,

1:15:05 in terms of considered stops.

1:15:08 Questions?

1:15:10 Any questions for Rex?

1:15:15 Okay.

1:15:16 Thank you.

1:15:17 Thank you.

1:15:18 So next, I'll open up the public hearing.

1:15:22 Again, this is time to give testimony

1:15:25 on this particular request.

1:15:29 As I mentioned before, please give your,

1:15:31 when you come down, please give your name

1:15:33 and whether you're a citizen of Twin Falls.

1:15:36 and your testimony will be two minutes.

1:15:40 Is there anybody that wishes to comment

1:15:42 on this particular issue?

1:15:50 Okay, seeing no one,

1:15:52 is there anything else you guys wanna add

1:15:54 before I close the public hearing?

1:15:56 Okay, public hearing is closed.

1:16:01 Council wishes, any questions, discussion?

1:16:05 Chris Reed.

1:16:06 I don't have any questions,

1:16:07 I just wanna say that thank you

1:16:09 to continue to investing in our community.

1:16:14 I'm excited to see Ponderosa go all the way through

1:16:16 right there, that was exciting.

1:16:18 We have several dead ends right there

1:16:19 that are very frustrating to the citizens there.

1:16:24 Especially when you're trying to find a house in that area.

1:16:26 So thank you for the investment in our community.

1:16:31 Thank you.

1:16:37 Okay, I'd entertain a motion if somebody'd like to make a motion.

1:16:43 That's it?

1:16:45 Sorry, Mary.

1:16:46 You're fine.

1:16:47 And then I just clicked out on my sheet.

1:16:53 So I would move that we amend the zoning district change

1:16:59 from R4 to R4 ZDA for residential town

1:17:02 and development on property located at 1607 Washington

1:17:06 Street, South.

1:17:08 Do I need the number?

1:17:10 Go ahead.

1:17:13 PZ24.

1:17:14 PZ24-0043.

1:17:18 Thank you, Sherry Vomer.

1:17:19 I will second.

1:17:21 Thank you, motion by Spencer Cutler,

1:17:23 seconded by Sherry Bulmer,

1:17:25 to approve the zoning development agreement

1:17:28 and zoning district change from R4 to R4 ZDA

1:17:32 for property located at 1607 Washington Street,

1:17:37 South PZ24-043.

1:17:41 Any further discussion?

1:17:44 Amy Rojo, please.

1:17:47 Spencer Cutler?

1:17:48 Yes.

1:17:49 Harry Bulmer?

1:17:50 Yes, Ruth Pierce?

1:17:51 Yes.

1:17:52 Yes.

1:17:53 Craig Hawkins.

1:17:54 Yes.

1:17:55 And Jason Brown.

1:17:56 Yes.

1:17:57 Thank you.

1:17:58 Motion passes six to zero.

1:17:59 Thank you.

1:18:00 Will and Rex.

1:18:02 Hey.

1:18:03 Next item on the agenda is also an action item.

1:18:06 It's also a public hearing.

1:18:08 A request for approval of the.

1:18:12 What's P Y?

1:18:13 Plan year.

1:18:15 Plan year.

1:18:16 Twenty twenty four community development block grants.

1:18:20 CDBG.

1:18:21 Annual action plan.

1:18:23 PZ24-0083. We have Jonathan Spinnlumber, I mean and so the Director. Welcome Jonathan.

1:18:31 Thank you Mayor, members of the Council. We're going to be pretty quick and brief on this. We do this every year.

1:18:37 The plan here does not coincide with any fiscal year and it ends up getting a little bit messed up with the federal government.

1:18:43 When we have to do it because it's in August and not October.

1:18:47 In summary, we basically go through what we're going to do in the next year with the funds

1:18:53 received from the CDBG program.

1:18:55 If you look at the annual action plan, how many people do, and it does actually kind of

1:19:02 difficult to understand what we write versus what the federal government puts in their forests.

1:19:07 It does not allow us to change the font or anything, so it's actually a little bit more

1:19:11 difficult to discern.

1:19:13 summarizing what we're going to do. We're going to just go after the City Park

1:19:17 project that we've been working towards with the bathroom and the plaza. That's

1:19:22 where all of our funds are going to. It's a public improvement in our low

1:19:25 income area which is downtown and that will be where all of our funds are

1:19:30 allocated to. We published this with the 30-day publication notice requirement

1:19:35 or comment. We did not receive any comments. Previously we had received

1:19:40 comments from the library or an internal thing and we've seen comments from various property owners

1:19:45 as we've been going through the park project and we've implemented some of those things into our

1:19:50 plans. The first stage of this project is to go with the bathroom and we are currently basically

1:19:58 in discussions with the architect to update the plan and get it bid within a few months.

1:20:02 After that, we will then move to getting plans for the plaza and going out for a bit or a project next year.

1:20:12 That is really all of this report says, there's a whole lot of other stuff in here that the federal government makes us put in here.

1:20:22 And so we filled out, some of it they fill out. If you have any questions, I'll do my best. If it's on the plan, otherwise I can talk about the project if you wish.

1:20:29 Any questions?

1:20:32 Can he show the plaza?

1:20:34 That's what I was wondering if you had a picture.

1:20:37 Keeps going.

1:20:38 I don't know if it's at the very end.

1:20:41 At the very end of this one?

1:20:43 But maybe not.

1:20:44 What you gave us, it's at the very end.

1:20:46 It is at the very end of your concept.

1:20:49 It's the next page.

1:20:50 I've shown up in what I saved on the reports and attachments

1:20:54 because I forgot to put that part in there.

1:20:56 I can find it real fast though.

1:20:58 I go to today's item.

1:21:01 I don't. They went to the wrong day. This concept was drawn by Chance Munn's, the Parks

1:21:34 super. It is a very preliminary concept. The idea is to redirect traffic from this road and make it

1:21:43 more of an open concept or plaza concept for the library to make it a reservable space similar to

1:21:50 plaza over here. The library would get priority reservations for outdoor learning,

1:21:56 They do their like bicrodi, they do out reading time, that kind of stuff.

1:22:02 This would be the idea is to have some sort of stage-ish or seating for those types of

1:22:08 items.

1:22:09 Those items outdoor amenities, there wouldn't be any vehicles through here, but we could

1:22:16 use it during park events to park vehicles into it, as well as create an all-access

1:22:23 parking or a playground in these two areas in orange. The rest of these could be

1:22:29 shelters and then this gray square block is the restroom that we're going to do

1:22:33 first because it's one of the primary drivers and we have the plan already for

1:22:37 it. We are not going to remove any trees and we are going to be including a

1:22:45 sidewalk connection on on Handsome Street essentially along that edge of the

1:22:50 park whether it comes straight south where it pulls over to go in front of the

1:22:55 library and they go back, that would be another concept. When we get that drawn

1:23:00 with the plaza. Great idea. Any other questions? Yeah. I realize so first of all

1:23:11 as far as the the plan year action plan, it's pretty high level philosophical. I

1:23:17 support it. So this is kind of just more of a citizen curiosity thing. So the

1:23:23 restroom and the sidewalks to are the priority. So that if you know we get

1:23:27 they held up somewhere, whatever shortfalls might happen,

1:23:30 the restroom is the first meeting already.

1:23:32 The restroom is currently going to be bid.

1:23:36 We have the architect's estimate

1:23:38 that we came with the original documents

1:23:39 for getting all that updated as we speak.

1:23:42 Thank you.

1:23:44 Any other questions for Jonathan?

1:23:47 Hey, so there's no applicant on this,

1:23:50 so we'll open it up for public input, public hearing portion.

1:23:55 There's anybody that wishes, oh, I'm sorry, Craig, did you?

1:23:59 Okay, if there's anyone that wishes to comment

1:24:01 on this particular project, the public hearing is open.

1:24:10 Hey, see no one.

1:24:11 I'll close the public hearing.

1:24:13 Cherry Velmer.

1:24:20 What do you want us to hear me?

1:24:22 So I'm going to, I lost my voice.

1:24:30 Move, thank you for the approval of this,

1:24:34 of the plan year 2024 community development

1:24:38 block grant action plan.

1:24:41 Thank you, Chris Reed.

1:24:42 I'll second that.

1:24:43 Thank you.

1:24:44 Motion by Sherry Volmer, seconded by Chris Reed to approve the plan year 2024 community

1:24:54 development block grants, CDBG annual action plan, he's 0083.

1:25:02 Any further discussion?

1:25:04 Amy Roll call vote, please.

1:25:07 Sherry Volmer.

1:25:08 Yes.

1:25:09 Ruth Pierce.

1:25:10 Yes.

1:25:11 Coccans, Jason Brown, and Spencer Cutler.

1:25:15 Yes.

1:25:16 Thank you, Motion passes 6-0.

1:25:18 Thank you, Jonathan.

1:25:21 Hey, the last item on the agenda before we adjourn

1:25:23 is an action item.

1:25:25 It's a request to adjourn to Executive Session pursuant

1:25:29 to Idaho Code 74-2061 to consider

1:25:34 preliminary negotiations involving matters of trade

1:25:38 commerce in which the governing body is in competition with governing bodies in other

1:25:44 states or nations.

1:25:46 Chris Reed.

1:25:47 So moved.

1:25:48 Thank you to have a second.

1:25:50 Second.

1:25:51 Thank you motion by Chris Reed seconded by Jason Brown to move into executive session under

1:25:57 Code section 742061.

1:26:01 Amy Rocco, vote please.

1:26:03 Ruth Pierce.

1:26:04 Yes.

1:26:05 Chris Reed.

1:26:06 Yes.

1:26:06 Ray Hawkins.

1:26:07 Yes.

1:26:07 Jason Brown.

1:26:08 Yes.

1:26:09 Spencer Cutler.

1:26:10 Yes.

1:26:10 And Sherry Bomer.

1:26:11 Yes.

1:26:13 Thank you.

1:26:13 Motion passes 6 to 0.

1:26:15 I want to let everybody know we will not

1:26:17 be returning to chambers.

1:26:19 And very much appreciate your input today.

1:26:22 Thank you for attending.

1:26:24 So our meeting is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 12, 2024. The recording started at 16:57 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:26:48.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    5ece9521e71a4a2a1637f0f6f63de1ac2f1f803e70db6f89575b74fc80e7b2e4
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 1992f10eae6987bb493505397eb3ad960529a22ac96f78acadbab10190f086e7
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    267ac0335fb5ea1274104cf143fa9e756ed7dbfdf4b4c15baf93d6ec660466f8

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file