OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, April 1, 2024

Special meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:01:24 It was I did mention your name.

0:01:26 Listen, you didn't mention me.

0:01:33 What about her?

0:01:34 She's just talking.

0:01:35 Oh, yeah, she laughs.

0:01:42 And then there's Craig.

0:01:48 Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen.

0:01:50 Welcome to the April Fool's Day City Council meeting.

0:01:54 I want to confirm we have a quorum.

0:01:56 We have all members present in chambers.

0:02:00 I'm going to change up the agenda a little bit.

0:02:02 I'm going to save the Pledge of Allegiance

0:02:04 until after we get back from executive sessions.

0:02:07 So we actually have two executive session items

0:02:11 under section 74-206-1B to consider the evaluation

0:02:17 dismissal or disciplining over to hear complaints

0:02:21 or charges brought against the public officer employees

0:02:23 staff member individual agent or public school student

0:02:28 and 74-206-1F to communicate with legal counsel

0:02:33 for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications

0:02:36 of and legal options for pending litigation or controversies

0:02:41 not yet being litigated but imminently likely to be litigated.

0:02:46 The mere presence of legal counsel

0:02:48 and executive session does not satisfy this requirement.

0:02:52 So moved.

0:02:53 Thank you, Chris, to have a second.

0:02:55 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Craig Hawkins

0:02:58 to move into executive session under 74-2061B and 74-2061F.

0:03:08 Amy Roll, call vote please.

0:03:12 Ruth Pierce?

0:03:13 Yes.

0:03:13 Chris Reed?

0:03:14 Yes.

0:03:15 Great Hawkins?

0:03:15 Yes.

0:03:16 Jason Brown?

0:03:17 Yes.

0:03:17 Spencer Cutler?

0:03:18 Yes.

0:03:19 Grace and Stone?

0:03:20 Yes.

0:03:20 And Sherri Bohmer?

0:03:21 Yes.

0:03:22 Thank you.

0:03:22 Motion passes 7-0.

0:03:24 So we'll move into executive session.

0:03:26 And we should be back down here about 5 o'clock.

0:03:29 Thank you.

0:03:36 You ready?

0:03:42 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen,

0:03:44 and welcome to the April 1st, 2024 City Council meeting.

0:03:48 I want to confirm we have a quorum.

0:03:50 We have all seven members in chambers today.

0:03:54 We met at four o'clock and moved into executive session

0:03:59 and we're finished now,

0:04:00 and so we're gonna go on to our regular meeting.

0:04:02 So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:04:06 If you wish to join me, please rise.

0:04:25 Thank you.

0:04:26 have two proclamations today. The first one is military child month, whereas April is the

0:04:34 month of military child, an opportunity to recognize military children for their resilient

0:04:40 spirits, personal sacrifices, strong character and courage, and whereas military children are

0:04:47 part of the strength of our nation as they support and encourage their service members

0:04:52 with the fierce patriotic spirit and whereas these children are a source of pride for the

0:04:57 great state of Idaho and to us all and it is only fitting that we take time to recognize

0:05:03 their contributions and whereas military children continue to make significant contributions

0:05:09 to family, community and their nation as they endure prolonged and repeated absences of

0:05:15 one are both parents and whereas a month-long salute will recognize that military children

0:05:22 serve two and the citizens of Idaho will be afforded the opportunity to don the Keller

0:05:27 Purple every Friday in support of these children. Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City

0:05:33 of Twin Falls, do hereby by proclaim April 2024 to be month of the military child. We

0:05:41 We have anybody here that's here to accept.

0:05:45 Okay.

0:05:46 The second one is Child Abuse Prevention Month, whereas child abuse is a serious and growing

0:05:52 problem affecting more than 3.2 million of our nation's children annually and thousands

0:05:59 of children locally and whereas this societal malignancy called child abuse respects no racial,

0:06:06 colleges, class, geographic boundaries, and in fact has been declared a national emergency,

0:06:14 and whereas St. Luke's cares through its community outreach and education and community service

0:06:20 activities within the Magic Valley Prevention Coalition is making significant progress in

0:06:29 stopping this crime against children's and families.

0:06:32 Therefore, I Ruth Paris Mayor of the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim the month of April 2024 to be Child Abuse Prevention Month to anybody from St. Luke's here today, okay?

0:06:46 So moving on to the consent calendar.

0:06:50 Council wishes.

0:06:52 Mayor, I'd like to make a motion that we approve the consent calendar is written.

0:06:55 Thank you, Craig. Do you have a second?

0:06:57 I had a mural second.

0:06:58 Thank you. Motion by Craig Hawkins, seconded by Grace and Stone

0:07:02 to approve the consent calendar as written.

0:07:06 Amy Rokalvo, please.

0:07:09 Chris Reed. Yes.

0:07:11 Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes.

0:07:13 Spencer Cutler. Yes.

0:07:15 Grace and Stone. Yes.

0:07:16 Jerry Volmer. Yes.

0:07:17 And Ruth Pierce. Yes.

0:07:19 Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero.

0:07:22 Hey, next under items of consideration, our first item

0:07:27 is a request to confirm the mayoral appointment of Alicia Perry and Ben Ramirez to the Impact

0:07:34 Fee and Improvement Reimbursement Commission and we have William Clayver, our senior planner. Welcome,

0:07:40 William. Thank you Madam Mayor and members of the council. Today we've here to appoint or to

0:07:51 We request to appoint some members to the impact fee commission back in December of 2023 in January

0:08:02 2024 so these past December and January we advertised for some openings and on that impact fee commission

0:08:12 Vice Mayor Jason Brown and then myself and Impact Fee Commission Chair Tom Fering, reviewed

0:08:25 and conducted interviews of several candidates.

0:08:36 We have found multiple, multiple people eager to and willing to serve to us to go out for

0:08:44 for us and they went through local background checks

0:08:48 past that, and we're happy to have Alicia Perry

0:08:54 and Ben Ramirez up for your consideration today.

0:08:58 And with that, I'll turn the time back over to you, Madam Mayor.

0:09:03 Thank you.

0:09:04 Does anybody have any questions or, Jason,

0:09:07 did you have any comments or questions?

0:09:09 I'll wait, but I'll make a motion.

0:09:10 That'd be great.

0:09:12 move to approve the confirmation of Alicia Perry and Ben Ramirez to the impact the

0:09:18 Improvement Reimbursement Commission. Thank you to have a second. Thank you.

0:09:24 Motion by Jason Brown seconded by Craig Hawkins to confirm the appointment of

0:09:28 Alicia Perry and Ben Ramirez to the impact fee and Improvement Reimbursement

0:09:33 Commission. Amy Roll call vote please. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes.

0:09:40 Spencer Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes. Jerry Volmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. And Chris Reed. Yes.

0:09:47 Thank you. Motion passes 7 to 0. Now I see Bann here. Oh, Alicia's in the back. Okay. Great.

0:09:56 Welcome. Both of you. Thank you. Okay. Next item on the agenda. My agenda is to confirm the mayoral

0:10:06 appointment of Sharon Dowdle and Gary Sype to the historic preservation commission and

0:10:12 we have City Planner, Lisa Strickland. Welcome, Lisa.

0:10:16 Good evening, Mayor, Council. This is a request to appoint Sharon Dowle and Gary Sype to the

0:10:21 historic preservation commission. As of February 2024, the historic preservation officially

0:10:28 now consists of five members and we had two vacancies to fill. We published a request in

0:10:35 December of 2023 for anyone who wanted to volunteer

0:10:38 to be on the commission.

0:10:40 We interviewed three people

0:10:41 and the interview panel consisted of

0:10:45 Council liaison, Cutler, senior planner, Will Clayver,

0:10:50 city planner, Strickland

0:10:52 and historic preservation commission,

0:10:54 chairman of DevBauchmann.

0:10:57 And they interviewed applicants.

0:10:59 We found three or two applicants

0:11:01 to be very enthusiastic

0:11:03 and committed to serving the committee

0:11:04 and furthering the goals of the objective

0:11:07 of the Historic Preservation Commission.

0:11:09 So we decided to present Sharon and Gary

0:11:12 for confirmation of this appointment.

0:11:15 And if appointed, Sharon will finish a partial term

0:11:19 that will expire June of 2025.

0:11:22 And Gary will be finishing a partial term

0:11:24 that will expire in June of 2026.

0:11:28 A simple majority vote of the council

0:11:30 is needed to approve the request

0:11:32 and staff recommends council confirm

0:11:34 appointment to the Historic Preservation Commission.

0:11:37 Thank you, Lisa.

0:11:39 Any questions for Lisa?

0:11:41 Sherry Volmer.

0:11:43 If there's no questions, I'll move.

0:11:47 I move the mayor appointment of Sharon Dattle and Gary

0:11:50 Seidt to the Historic Preservation Commission.

0:11:53 Thank you, Spencer.

0:11:56 I second, and thank you for the applicants.

0:11:59 Very enthusiastic, and I'm excited.

0:12:02 Thank you.

0:12:02 Thank you very much.

0:12:04 Motion by Sherry Volmer, seconded by Spencer Cutler,

0:12:07 to confirm the appointment of Sharon Dowdle

0:12:09 and Gary Seidt to the historic preservation commission.

0:12:13 Any further discussion?

0:12:15 Amy Rokelvo, please.

0:12:17 Jason Brown.

0:12:18 Yes.

0:12:19 Mentor Cutler.

0:12:20 Yes.

0:12:20 Grayson Stone.

0:12:21 Yes.

0:12:22 Jerry Bulmer.

0:12:23 Yes.

0:12:23 Ruth Pierce.

0:12:24 Yes.

0:12:24 Chris Reed.

0:12:25 Yes.

0:12:26 And Craig Hawkins.

0:12:26 Yes.

0:12:27 Thank you.

0:12:28 Motion passes 7 to 0.

0:12:30 I see Sharon.

0:12:32 Where's Gary?

0:12:33 OK, right there.

0:12:34 Thank you.

0:12:34 Welcome, YouTube.

0:12:37 Okay, next on the agenda is a presentation,

0:12:41 a recognition for Craig Kelly, Mary Lou Perez,

0:12:44 and David Detweiler for their use of service

0:12:47 on the Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:12:49 And we have our Planning and Zoning Director,

0:12:51 Jonathan Spinnlove, welcome, Jonathan.

0:12:53 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the council.

0:12:56 I'm gonna take a few minutes,

0:12:57 celebrate three of these individuals

0:12:59 that have served a long time.

0:13:00 Mary Lou Perez joined the commission.

0:13:02 In March of 2019, she serves as the Vice Chair

0:13:05 of the commission of his past year with the doctorate in chemistry and from Iowa State,

0:13:09 the native Magic Valley residents she brought thorough analysis and values-based decision-making

0:13:13 skills to the commission.

0:13:14 He's been a dedicated commissioner, she's probably one of the most capable remote meeting attendee.

0:13:19 She did it a lot because her work required her to with travel.

0:13:23 Her unique perspective we missed in the planning and zoning staff would like to extend our thanks

0:13:27 for her diligence and hours of volunteer time.

0:13:29 Dave Detweiler joined the planning commission in March of 2018, served as the area of impact

0:13:35 commissioner.

0:13:36 He has a background of multi-generational family of farmers in the Magic Valley.

0:13:40 He had the ability to discuss the development we were experiencing from a different view.

0:13:45 He would convey his thoughts on complex issues very plainly and on occasion very bluntly

0:13:50 to people when it was needed.

0:13:52 The planning is on the Sanfoelectric Center of Gratitude for the many farming topics that

0:13:55 Dave has educated us on during his six-year tenure on the commission.

0:13:59 Craig Kelly I believe the only one in attendance in person up there. He joined

0:14:05 the Commission in March of 2018 served as the chair of the Commission for the

0:14:08 last few years. Craig has been a steady member of the Commission with a solid

0:14:12 reputation for managing difficult meetings particularly during some COVID

0:14:17 years as we all know those were difficult. While being firm in his views on

0:14:20 development decisions Craig always sought for consensus and a lot of

0:14:23 opportunity for opposing views to be heard during the process. Oning zoning staff

0:14:27 I'd like to thank Craig for his patience with us as a staff and could

0:14:29 to congratulate him on a job very well done.

0:14:32 With that Mayor, we have a few items released for Craig

0:14:35 if you'd like to come present a few things for Craig.

0:14:38 I just want to make a comment.

0:14:39 I had the privilege several times of serving

0:14:42 on interview committees with Craig

0:14:45 and it's been really fun to get to know him

0:14:47 and we're sorry to see him go, but he's turned out.

0:14:53 It doesn't mean he can't come back in the future, right?

0:14:56 No, he can't.

0:14:57 On this one or a different committee,

0:15:03 With all of our departing chair people,

0:15:04 we have a gavel with his terms as a chairperson.

0:15:46 Hey again, thank you, Craig, very much.

0:15:48 And to Mary Lou and David as well.

0:15:52 Okay, next on the agenda is a request

0:15:54 for a non-conforming building expansion waiver

0:15:57 for a residential property located at 1442 Haber

0:16:01 and Avenue East, Carab, Mark,

0:16:03 and Carab, Mark and Pauline Beams PC27-0027.

0:16:08 and we have Lisa Strickland, our City Plan, or welcome back.

0:16:14 Good evening, Mayor, Council.

0:16:25 This is a request for a non-conforming building expansion waiver for residential property for

0:16:31 a proposed addition to the south side of the home located at 1442 Haverton Avenue East.

0:16:38 Per City Code 1034-D permits to expand non-conforming buildings or conforming buildings with a non-conforming

0:16:46 use allows the City Planning and Zoning Commission the authority to issue a non-conforming building

0:16:52 expansion permit to expand upon that building.

0:16:56 This process requires a public hearing before the Planning and Zoning Commission.

0:17:01 However, the last sentence of this section of the code states that these requirements

0:17:05 may be waived for residents and residential uses by motion and minute entry of the City

0:17:11 Council.

0:17:12 If the council wishes, it may waive the public hearing

0:17:15 before the Planning and Zoning Commission

0:17:17 as per City Code 1034, which would allow the applicant

0:17:21 to proceed with the building permit process.

0:17:24 Per City Code 10-2, the definition of a nonconforming building

0:17:28 is a building or a structure not conforming

0:17:30 to the provisions of the current title,

0:17:33 but which was lawfully existing or under construction

0:17:35 at the time of the adoption of this title.

0:17:38 County records indicate the house was constructed in 1964.

0:17:42 Staff has determined the current residence was made nonconforming by the adoption of the

0:17:47 front yard setback ordinance 2620 in 1999 for arterial and collector streets.

0:17:55 The ordinance establishes 62 foot center line setback along Locust Street North so the east

0:18:00 side of the residence sits within the center line setback.

0:18:04 Her city code 1034C, no building or structure, alteration, improvement or reconstruction shall

0:18:11 be made which expands a non-conforming building beyond any part of the existing wall or roof

0:18:17 line.

0:18:18 The applicant would like to expand the non-conforming building by adding on to the south side of

0:18:24 the home and the addition would align with the existing east wall located within the

0:18:29 center line setback.

0:18:31 It will not encroach further into that setback.

0:18:34 Staff has reviewed the request and does not anticipate any negative impacts if the request

0:18:38 is approved as presented.

0:18:41 staff is tasked with acting on the waiver requested.

0:18:45 So if you look here, it's at the corner of Hayburn and Locustreet North.

0:18:52 And this is approximately where the center line is.

0:18:56 And if you go 62 feet, this is approximately what sits in the setback.

0:19:05 The applicant would like to do an addition on the backside of the home, but they do not

0:19:10 That one encroach further into this setback, they would like to just align it with the same

0:19:15 east wall and that is the request and the council is allowed to make that waiver so that

0:19:22 they don't have to do a public hearing in front of the planning and zoning commission.

0:19:25 I'll stand for any questions and the applicant is here this evening if you have any questions

0:19:30 for them.

0:19:37 Any questions for Chris?

0:19:38 Chris, I don't have a question.

0:19:40 I don't see a problem with this.

0:19:44 matching up with what currently is is there they're not encouraging any more

0:19:48 so I don't have a problem let's anybody else has a question I'll make the motion

0:19:52 anybody else have a question or comment I would just say this curse on your

0:19:57 motion do you want to go sorry Councilman read on your motion do you

0:20:00 want to go ahead and request to approve it and then also waive the

0:20:03 public hearing simultaneously we need to do that so this process allows for the

0:20:09 waiver to if not have to have the public here.

0:20:13 Right.

0:20:14 If we do the waiver.

0:20:15 Yeah.

0:20:16 I didn't want to have to amend the motion.

0:20:17 Yeah.

0:20:18 That works.

0:20:19 Okay.

0:20:20 I move that we approve the nonconforming building expansion waiver for a residential property located

0:20:26 at 1442 Haper and Avenue, Carab, Mark, and Pauline Beams.

0:20:31 Thank you.

0:20:32 Do I have a second?

0:20:33 I second.

0:20:34 Thank you.

0:20:35 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Spencer Cutler to approve the request.

0:20:39 for a non-conforming building expansion waiver for residential property located

0:20:45 at 1442 Avern Avenue East. Any further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.

0:20:52 Spencer Cutler. Yes. Grayson Stone. Yes.

0:20:58 Jerry Volmer. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes.

0:21:02 Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you. Okay next item

0:21:13 on the agenda is an action item, consideration of the future MPRC is she here, there you are.

0:21:25 Thank you.

0:21:26 After the future of MPRC program we have Mandy Thompson, assistant to the City Manager, welcome.

0:21:31 Good evening, Madam Mayor, members of council.

0:21:34 At the request of the mayor, I place this on the agenda for our discussion tonight.

0:21:38 A little history, especially for our two new council members.

0:21:45 Some time back in the early 2000s, I could find records going back to 2002.

0:21:53 A process was established to formalize how nonprofits could approach the city of Twin Falls for support of their programs and services that they offered in the city of Twin Falls.

0:22:08 prior to the establishment of MPAG which is municipal power outsource grants.

0:22:14 I believe there would be entities that would come in sort of very erratically asking for support.

0:22:19 So, MPAG was established in order to create a process.

0:22:23 So, one of the many items that I included in your packet

0:22:28 was the history of MPAG through 2018.

0:22:33 And could I, could you, give me, thank you, okay, so looking at this you can see kind of

0:22:46 going back as it grew, and along the left side the organizations, these are all the organizations

0:22:53 that had received funding through MPOG.

0:22:58 And I'm going to scroll here a little bit, sorry.

0:23:01 So starting with this one, you'll see for most of the initial years, there was a much

0:23:09 larger request versus the amount that we were giving out for most of the history of

0:23:19 MPAG, we had allocated $100,000 to the program.

0:23:22 So as you can see here, the actual amount given versus the amount requested, you can

0:23:29 it was fairly consistently that we were asking for,

0:23:33 or the requests were in excess of the amount of money

0:23:37 that we had to grant out to these organizations.

0:23:41 So, fast forward to 2018,

0:23:44 and I came before the council

0:23:48 and presented a list of criteria and guidelines for M-POG

0:23:53 to streamline the process.

0:23:56 That included capping the amount

0:23:59 that any single organization could request to $10,000.

0:24:03 It also eliminated the opportunity for partial funding.

0:24:07 So if Council wanted to fund an application or a program they had

0:24:11 to fund it in its entirety or not at all.

0:24:14 And then the third really big change was duplication

0:24:17 and services.

0:24:18 And so if an entity came to us and asked for funding for a program

0:24:23 that we are already offering with city dollars

0:24:26 for city tax payer dollars, then that would not be considered.

0:24:30 Part of the reason that we started having these conversations is because several of the past

0:24:38 recipients of funds for, gosh, almost as long as I've been a part of the program,

0:24:44 are going to be interlinked volunteer caregivers, IVC and link,

0:24:51 And both of those entities receive funding from the city to provide essentially transportation,

0:24:57 transit, public transit services to our residents.

0:25:01 And so those are really definitely duplication of a new program that we have at the city now

0:25:05 with RITFT.

0:25:08 So we've had conversations about whether or not those programs would be eligible under

0:25:16 the guidelines.

0:25:17 I believe they would not base upon how they utilize their funds.

0:25:21 And then if you look at some of the more recent years

0:25:24 of allocations, you're going to see that we're not even

0:25:28 allocating the full amount of funds that we've had available.

0:25:32 We have $85,000 in the budget.

0:25:37 And the last several years, we haven't fully allocated

0:25:40 those amounts.

0:25:41 So I'm not sure if there's any other information

0:25:47 that I can provide.

0:25:54 One thing I did think about offering up to

0:25:57 is several times along the way we have taken programs

0:26:02 out of the MPOT process and created them

0:26:04 as a permanent line in the city budget.

0:26:06 An example of that would have been two examples

0:26:09 that I can think of were back in the,

0:26:12 I think it was in 2010 or 2011,

0:26:15 we removed the city ban from the MPOT process

0:26:18 and they have a permanent line item

0:26:20 in the parks and recreation budget.

0:26:22 And then the same thing with transfer.

0:26:25 They used to come to us every year

0:26:27 and request funding.

0:26:29 A lot of times they would request what they needed,

0:26:33 but it would be a lion's share of the MPOG allocation.

0:26:37 And so again, we took them out of the MPOG process

0:26:41 and they had a permanent line for about four years

0:26:44 in the city manager's budget

0:26:45 that we gave them $45,000 a year as match

0:26:48 for their transit services that they were providing.

0:26:53 So those are just kind of anecdotally some thoughts.

0:26:56 If there are some programs that we think might need

0:26:59 to potentially stay, they can be removed and set out

0:27:04 and they can become a line item

0:27:06 in a particular department's budget.

0:27:11 So, Mandy, how much do we have to allocate this year?

0:27:14 85,000.

0:27:15 85,000, okay.

0:27:17 So the concern was brought up as to whether,

0:27:21 because we've got these duplication of services,

0:27:25 is to weather a chunk of that money,

0:27:28 we ought to be applying to transfer,

0:27:32 and, excuse me, TFT and future,

0:27:36 you know, at some point in time,

0:27:38 we're gonna have to pay money on that program, right?

0:27:41 We're not, the grants are gonna go away,

0:27:43 and so whether there's, this year is a transition year

0:27:47 that we've moved some of those out of there

0:27:49 because they are duplication of services.

0:27:52 So that was my thought, but I'm really open

0:27:55 for discussion this read.

0:27:57 So that was my question, knowing that Mary, you asked,

0:28:01 you wanted this on, what was the ultimate goal,

0:28:06 knowing that in the packet talked a little bit

0:28:08 about those areas, those nonprofits

0:28:12 that help out in transportation,

0:28:14 potentially can be a conflict

0:28:15 where we're currently offering that.

0:28:20 There are other good nonprofits

0:28:22 that we have helped out in the past,

0:28:23 looking at the going through the list,

0:28:27 seeing the band, seeing transfer,

0:28:28 where they became a line item.

0:28:30 I don't know if that's a direction

0:28:32 that I would want to go personally.

0:28:34 I don't think that that's just putting them down

0:28:38 and saying, hey, this is, you're gonna get 20, 10,

0:28:40 whatever it is.

0:28:42 I know M-POG is challenging every time we do it, and I feel like it's gotten better in

0:28:52 the last several years.

0:28:57 I would agree with Mandy, those other transportation non-profits probably would not be eligible

0:29:03 at this point in time where we're trying to bolster up that.

0:29:07 And then moving forward for budget reasons, and I know we're going to have a conversation,

0:29:12 be some of this budget needs to go towards that and building up right TFT and making that

0:29:21 dollar amount a little bit smaller, but we do have some that come every year that we know

0:29:28 that they're going to come and request and they're great organizations and they do great

0:29:33 things for our community. That's kind of my thought.

0:29:39 I don't think this really is an action item but I think it's more a discussion, Jason.

0:29:43 John, I would probably echo what Chris or Councilman read.

0:29:47 He said, I, you know, I'm looking at this.

0:29:49 I think there are some organizations here

0:29:54 that I think are put the money to good use for our citizens.

0:30:00 Look at some of the other ones might, you know,

0:30:03 just been thinking about it,

0:30:04 trying to think I think there would be a reduction in budget.

0:30:08 I was, you know, looking at who provided a ride

0:30:10 who has historically gotten money for that, I would say if you reduced the budget by $30,000,

0:30:18 that would encompass the right portion of it.

0:30:22 But I definitely wouldn't want the program to go away.

0:30:26 You know, it's always a hard process to go through trying to figure out who deserves the money,

0:30:33 who doesn't deserve the money.

0:30:34 So the question I had for you, Mandy, have we gotten a response from these applicants back

0:30:39 of have they been following the rules that have been set up by in part?

0:30:45 Yes.

0:30:46 They have.

0:30:47 I haven't sent you.

0:30:48 So one of the requirements that they have to do is they have to turn our new report every

0:30:52 year because this was a discussion item or action item.

0:30:55 I didn't know what it was going to be.

0:30:56 I haven't sent those on to you.

0:30:57 But yes, part of the requirements, if you want to apply the following year, is you have to

0:31:02 submit a report to Council that I'll provide to you.

0:31:05 I'll put it in your team's folder and you can read and see, you know, keeping them

0:31:09 accountable, you know, reminding that they ask that they remind you what they

0:31:12 apply for and then in accounting of how they spend their dollars. But yeah, it's, as

0:31:18 you can see, I mean, if you looked at if you recall some of those earlier years, I

0:31:23 mean, there were people that were coming in and all by themselves asking for 50 or

0:31:26 60,000 dollars. So what would happen is we didn't have enough money and we would

0:31:31 start peace-mealing or counsel would start peace-mealing it together. So by

0:31:35 by limiting it one to $10,000 and then all or nothing.

0:31:40 It's really helped.

0:31:42 I think weed out the stronger applications

0:31:45 and then they have to be a little bit more thoughtful

0:31:46 and what they're requesting and what they're asking for.

0:31:49 So I would say yes, most of the time everyone,

0:31:52 I mean they're following the rules,

0:31:53 especially if they come back for repeat requests.

0:31:58 Last year, if you see Twin Falls Senior Center,

0:32:00 we took them out of the budget

0:32:01 because they continually asked for improvements

0:32:05 their building and their building is our building. So we took them out and paid

0:32:10 that through a different line and so that's not to say they can't come back and

0:32:15 ask for dollars that are not capital improvements to the facility but that's

0:32:21 by and large in fact that's what they've asked for every single year. Yes since

0:32:25 I've been on you know the last couple of times we've done this one was for

0:32:28 flooring and the other one was for cabinets and yes and another they're a

0:32:32 previous director they did yeah they did tons of different things so they've

0:32:37 always utilized those funds to make improvements to the building itself. Yeah

0:32:42 I think we need to perpetuate the program but I would be in favor of a

0:32:49 reduction in an overall allocation.

0:32:54 The Twin Falls Senior Center is the only outlier and that was before you

0:33:01 went into that that was kind of the one in the last several years it's always

0:33:04 about the building and so I don't know if that's one that would be the only one

0:33:08 that I would say let's take out I don't want to make a line item for them but

0:33:12 maybe view that one differently because they do come in they talk about it we

0:33:16 talk about it and then we say let's go back and look at this a little different

0:33:20 right and if you recall I think the year before last when they had that request

0:33:23 for flooring they were going to piece miller flooring together yes and so

0:33:27 instead we got involved and they were able to get all of the flooring done at

0:33:31 So that would be the only one that, again, just having the discussion, maybe that's something we view differently, where historically they're coming in, not for programs, or for something that they do, but for the building maintenance, since it is our building.

0:33:46 Maybe we look at that different, maybe in the budgeting process, we ask them what's happening, just something a little different.

0:33:54 Okay, that's just kind of the discussion I wanted to have and see if there was pre-limbed

0:34:02 to Travis talking about budgets, just this particular item.

0:34:06 So I appreciate everybody's input.

0:34:09 Anybody else have anything?

0:34:10 Wanna add?

0:34:11 Doesn't look like it.

0:34:13 Thank you, Mandy.

0:34:14 Can I ask a point of clarification just so I understand.

0:34:17 So we'll keep the budget as is this year.

0:34:20 But we will not fund those duplicative transportation services.

0:34:26 then we can potentially do you do I have some direction on how much we should reduce it in

0:34:32 the 2025 budget or should we just put a number in and we can have that conversation during the

0:34:37 budget process. When is our process? It's May. Today was a it's ready to go out Morgan is

0:34:44 she's ready to email it out. We always do it the month of April and then we'll do the awards in

0:34:50 kind of mid May so we're ready to go it was just based upon council wishes tonight. Okay all right

0:34:55 All right.

0:34:56 Thank you.

0:34:57 All right.

0:34:58 Thank you.

0:34:59 Thank you, everyone.

0:35:00 Okay.

0:35:01 Next item on the agenda is an action item.

0:35:03 Seating City Council priorities on the development of the fiscal year 2425 budget.

0:35:09 We have city manager Travis Rothweiler.

0:35:12 Welcome, Travis.

0:35:15 Thank you, Mary and Council.

0:35:20 So believe it was two weeks ago, we had a conversation and a report back on the city's

0:35:31 financial audit and on that audit really to look at that as the final report card

0:35:39 for fiscal year 23 and we're in the middle of fiscal year 24 and we will begin the

0:35:47 process of talking about fiscal year 25 and so what we like to do for those that

0:35:57 are either new to our process or viewing our process for the first time is we like to begin

0:36:03 this process very early.

0:36:06 In fact, members of the city's long-term planning team have started having conversations about

0:36:11 the budget shortly after the first of the year, and then they will have a proposal that will

0:36:18 be coming through the staff, will ultimately have budget hearings with the members of the

0:36:24 the different departments internally, the first week of May, and then the third week of May,

0:36:31 we go through this budget balancing process, and in this process we want to make sure that

0:36:37 we are engaging with the council and making sure that the council's priorities, those things

0:36:43 that will help set the tone for the budget will be incorporated.

0:36:51 like all things, we're going to start at a really, really high level, maybe 35,000 feet.

0:36:59 And that's kind of the conversations that we start.

0:37:03 And then we'll go incredibly granular into the entire budget process after the budget

0:37:09 has been presented and drafted, prepared for you, and that will occur after July 4th holiday.

0:37:21 And then our summer of fun begins with a different focus area every Monday throughout

0:37:28 the course of the summer with final adoption to occur in August.

0:37:31 So it's kind of like a lay of the land and the way our budget process works.

0:37:37 Many organizations do their budget.

0:37:40 They have a simple public hearing.

0:37:42 They ask the citizens to come forward and the citizens may come and they may be engaged

0:37:48 or they may not.

0:37:50 We invite the citizens to be a part of this process.

0:37:54 It's incredibly transparent and we want the citizens to feel like they understand where

0:37:59 our dollars are being spent.

0:38:04 So whenever you look at a problem and you look at a situation or you look to find a solution,

0:38:10 I think it's important that we all look at the problem through the same lenses and what

0:38:16 we like to do is share with you the community as the staff looks at it.

0:38:20 This is the lens in which I look at the City of Twin Falls and so when I'm looking at how

0:38:26 do we create a budget that is going to supply the goods and services to our community, we

0:38:32 should probably first define our community.

0:38:35 And for some, people know that the City of Twin Falls is the eighth largest city, that

0:38:40 it's 56,000 people, sometimes we forget that the City of Twin Falls today on a random Monday

0:38:51 through to nearly 100,000 persons if not larger.

0:38:55 And people come into the City of Twin Falls every single day.

0:39:00 And by last estimates from I.T.D.,

0:39:02 there were 40,000 individuals that cross the prime bridge

0:39:06 every single day.

0:39:08 And that is not the only access point

0:39:11 into the City of Twin Falls.

0:39:13 And you can watch the streams of traffic,

0:39:17 whether they're becoming from the east, the west,

0:39:20 the south, all of those individuals come into our community and they impact service delivery.

0:39:28 We know that houses have appreciated significantly over the course of the last several years.

0:39:35 And while it is not at its all time high, it still remains much higher than what it has

0:39:41 been.

0:39:42 And then if you take a look at the overall median house in Idaho, it continues to outpace

0:39:47 the national average.

0:39:48 that our unemployment rate has held a steady 3.3%. So that's the community that

0:39:54 we look at. It's growing. The services that we provide are far greater than the

0:39:59 community. Daytime population exceeds residential population. Housing prices

0:40:04 are continuing to grow and the labor market is incredibly tight. These are

0:40:10 the overarching budgets that we set. These are the priorities and the overall

0:40:15 strategies that we had set. And one of the things that we'll ask you to do is to

0:40:19 to determine if these still remain the priorities

0:40:21 for this upcoming budget year.

0:40:24 Creating a budget proposal that is sustainable,

0:40:28 that is stable, and that is nimble.

0:40:31 And we have talked about those being important virtues

0:40:35 of a budget because the environment that we're operating in,

0:40:39 it feels like it changes regularly.

0:40:43 In fact, that is probably the greatest thing

0:40:46 that it remains uncertain is the level

0:40:49 the degree of change that we're going to experience over the course of this upcoming year.

0:40:55 We also need to make sure that it is sensitive to the operating environment.

0:41:01 We understand that citizens are beginning to consume less, that is having an impact on

0:41:06 maybe several of our frontline retailers, but is also having an impact on the amount of money

0:41:12 that the City of Twin Falls is collecting in the form of sales tax receipts through shared

0:41:18 revenue. We need to be cognizant of that, that the budgets that we are preparing have and

0:41:25 reflect the current economic circumstances, the insight of the citizens of Twin Falls. We want

0:41:31 to make sure that they too can afford the proposal that we're laying forward. We want to make

0:41:36 sure that everything is tied to the 2030 strategic plan and I'll talk about the strategic plan

0:41:41 on the next page. We have long said that we are a service organization and that our employees

0:41:49 should be that first thing that we fund, because that is where services are delivered.

0:41:57 All of the individuals on the front lines are the employees every single day that make

0:42:02 Twin Falls the community that it is.

0:42:05 And then we also want to minimize all rate increases, whether that be associated with

0:42:09 water, sewer, sanitation, tax rate increases.

0:42:16 in a manner to make sure that they are what is necessary, not collecting what we can just

0:42:24 because we can, because state code allows it.

0:42:28 And so we're not asking you to make the decision tonight, we'll continue to come back, but we

0:42:33 wanted to make sure that you were aware of the overarching priorities that have been set,

0:42:37 and we're asking you to validate those for this upcoming year.

0:42:43 The second piece is the strategic plan, and in the center is that internal organization,

0:42:48 and we have long talked about the important role that our employees play in realizing the

0:42:52 vision.

0:42:53 But what is also important is the recognition that as we shared with the Council in our workshop

0:42:59 is that we're going to work towards updating the city's strategic plan.

0:43:04 That 2030, when we started this in 2012, was 18 years away, and as we've chipped away

0:43:10 and we've made progress. The year 2030 is just now six years away and we believe that

0:43:20 our work will not be finished and while we've made great improvements and we've realized

0:43:26 many of the strategic planning goals and objectives, we're in partnership with a council advocating

0:43:33 towards moving that goal post to the year 2040 because the community is going to continue

0:43:41 to exist, the environment is going to continue to evolve. The problems that we're working

0:43:47 and addressing today are not the same problems and issues that we began to work on in 2012

0:43:52 when we've created this first plan. So being nimble, being able to change, and also most

0:43:58 importantly, not chasing shiny things. We want to make sure that we are rooted in what

0:44:06 we value and we place our money and our resources in those things that are going to further the

0:44:12 community in the long run. Not necessarily those things that look nice now. So, beginning

0:44:21 this fall, after the budget, we'll begin the lift of the strategic planning process and really

0:44:27 credit to Gretchen and Mandy for the dashboard that they're working on that's really going

0:44:35 to be able to reflect the city's strategic planning goals, the accomplishments, its connection

0:44:42 to our priority based budgeting effort as well as the citizen survey results. All of that

0:44:50 is going to be placed into a singular place that is going to be amazing and the department

0:44:55 leaders are beginning that process of completing and filling in that data. Now we'll be excited

0:44:59 to share that with you.

0:45:04 So this is what the budgets look like.

0:45:06 You can see that net expenses for fiscal year 24 were significantly larger than fiscal year

0:45:13 23.

0:45:15 And that makes sense, especially when you listen to our auditors when they say there was a

0:45:22 huge influx of all of these different COVID dollars coming into our system, SLFRF, equated

0:45:29 to about $8.5 million that the City Council had incorporated into its budget and then it

0:45:35 moved out. Bill was also, who's here tonight, was also very successful in capturing grants

0:45:41 and resources and over the course of the last several council meetings you've seen, more

0:45:46 than a million dollars of grants come into our system. Those are lots of the outside dollars

0:45:51 that are coming in and driving some of our costs. And at the same time, you can see that

0:45:56 the tax rate went from $4.78 to what we believe to be an all-time low of $4.71 per $1,000 of

0:46:05 taxable value.

0:46:06 Now, it's important to note that just because the tax rate decreases does not necessarily

0:46:13 mean that individuals' tax burden is going to decrease.

0:46:16 That's not what we're saying, because individuals might say, but you're saying that the tax rate

0:46:20 went down so I should have paid less in taxes and it's important to recognize that because

0:46:27 there is not a true indexed homeowners exemption in the state of Idaho and the rapid appreciation

0:46:34 of homes is causing homes to be paying more in property taxes proportionally each and

0:46:41 every year than what they have had to in the past.

0:46:46 So how fast has Twin Falls grown?

0:46:48 shared this last year and we'd like to continue to share this because we I find

0:46:52 this incredibly fascinating. If you take a look at the total value of the city of

0:46:58 Twin Falls in 2030, the total estimated taxable value of the city of Twin Falls

0:47:05 was $2.152 billion in between fiscal year 22 and 24. We grew by nearly that

0:47:16 same amount. Just think about that for a minute that it took 109 years for the City of Twin Falls

0:47:26 to achieve a $2.1 billion value in the City of Twin Falls in a two-year period grew that

0:47:33 same amount and collectively when you include the urban renewal agency areas the city's taxable

0:47:39 value grew to more than $6.68 billion. That's a sign of the strength of our local economy

0:47:50 as properties continue to grow. That means that there is a demand for those properties,

0:47:55 but it also is putting some incredible pressures on our citizens. It's putting incredible

0:48:02 pressures on our employers. So what do we look at? Want to know how fast we're growing.

0:48:12 And again, this map reflects very similar to last year's map.

0:48:18 This is a map that's provided by the Bureau of Economic Analysis, and the Census Bureau

0:48:24 estimates that the population of Idaho is just shy of 2 million people.

0:48:31 And it statewide grew at a rate of 1.8%, which is faster than the national average.

0:48:39 if you take a look at the state of Idaho, nearly all of our counties increased in population

0:48:48 and some of our counties increased by more than 3%. And in Twin Falls, we were somewhere

0:48:54 between one and one and a half percent of increased population over the course of this

0:49:00 last year, which is important to recognize because as the city of Twin Falls continues

0:49:06 to grow from 51 to an estimated 56,000 in population from census to current day, every

0:49:15 surrounding community has also grown.

0:49:18 In fact, their percentage of growth is probably more significant than ours.

0:49:23 And as a result of that, that 100,000 population served every single day is only going to continue

0:49:32 to get larger as all of our surrounding communities continue to grow.

0:49:40 And 100% of the services that are provided are paid for by those who reside here.

0:49:49 The roads, the police, the fire.

0:49:52 Those services are paid for by the ratepayers and the property taxpayers.

0:49:57 And if there is an issue, if there is a need, our team responds regardless if you live here or not.

0:50:07 That causes us to have to really look at levels of service and how we're able to offer those levels of service moving forward.

0:50:14 Any questions?

0:50:21 All right.

0:50:23 So the next is taking a look at income growth.

0:50:26 And not only is our community growing, but you can also see that the per capita income of counties from 21 to 22 also grew.

0:50:37 And the average residents saw an increase of about 4.6%.

0:50:42 nationally is a 3.5% total income. So you start thinking about how the communities

0:50:50 continue to grow and then you start looking at those rates of income inside

0:50:55 of Idaho are growing by a much faster percent. One day I'll remember how to use

0:51:03 them out so it's been a while. By the end of agency. I will have it. But you start

0:51:08 looking at these things called unemployment numbers and inside of the

0:51:12 City of Twin Falls, there are 871 persons that are unemployed as a result of the most

0:51:17 recent report from the Idaho Department of Labor.

0:51:20 And inside of the City of Twin Falls, we have vacancies.

0:51:24 And the largest source of our revenues that we carry over and we pass into the capital

0:51:31 fund, a result of salary savings positions that we are unable to fill.

0:51:36 So not only are we serving a larger population, but we're not able to functionally add the number

0:51:43 of positions that we need in our community to serve our community at the rate is growing.

0:51:48 We can't fill the positions that we have allocated in the budget.

0:51:53 In fact, there are many positions that are inside of our police department that always

0:51:59 and routinely go unfilled.

0:52:02 We have vacancies within the police department.

0:52:04 We have vacancies within the dispatch center,

0:52:09 and we have vacancies across other parts of our organization.

0:52:14 So when you take a look at the unemployment,

0:52:16 it's important to remember that nearly 5%

0:52:22 is what people would consider to be fully employed.

0:52:26 Your local economy remains fully employed

0:52:29 when you're at 5% or at 3.3.

0:52:32 we exceed what is classically defined as full employment.

0:52:38 It is an indicator that the labor market's tight,

0:52:43 but another piece of that is what's called

0:52:45 the labor participation rate.

0:52:48 And while the unemployment rate looks at those

0:52:52 who are actively seeking,

0:52:55 it lacks in the discouraged, right?

0:52:58 The discouraged worker, those who have not

0:53:02 with stopped looking.

0:53:03 And in 1990, the labor participation rate was

0:53:07 at an all-time high also in the United States at 71.4%.

0:53:12 And now it has dropped to 62%.

0:53:14 And so what that means is not only is our labor market tight,

0:53:19 but you have fewer and fewer people participating

0:53:22 in the labor market.

0:53:23 And we shared this slide, and that

0:53:27 is nearly the entirety of the state of Idaho population

0:53:33 elected to early retire during the pandemic for a variety of reasons and those who are

0:53:41 between 16 and 24 have not entered the labor market to replace them. So we're short, we

0:53:50 have fewer participation and we have more people who have retired and we're trying to

0:53:58 fill positions that are hard to fill. Some of the toughest jobs that we have are in the

0:54:06 front lines. An individual who works in a dispatch center is an amazingly tough position. Our police

0:54:14 department, our firefighters, you think about those who are getting called out to plow the snow,

0:54:19 those who are working on the front lines of our organization have a multi-toughest jobs,

0:54:25 and they're also the most difficult to fill. This becomes incredibly important when you start

0:54:33 thinking about compensation. What is our compensation policy going to be for the

0:54:39 City of Flint Falls this year? We look at full compensation, we incorporate the

0:54:43 benefits into that model, but we also need to make sure that it's sustainable,

0:54:48 that we can't offer huge percentages every year because you'll create a

0:54:57 scenario where you're unable to fund your liabilities in future years. And the

0:55:03 The worst thing that I could do is to encourage you to adopt an unstructurally sound budget.

0:55:13 So compensation is going to be one of those important things that we talk about moving

0:55:18 forward.

0:55:21 We talked about the median price of a home.

0:55:24 And yes, it is down from its all-time high, but not much.

0:55:31 And yes, it's stabilized.

0:55:33 But if you take a look, the average home in Twin Falls is $144,000 more today than what

0:55:42 it was in 2019.

0:55:45 And many of us remember in 2012 you could buy a home for $144,000.

0:55:56 Think about that.

0:55:57 As we're recruiting individuals to come into our organization, they're walking into a housing

0:56:04 market where the median home value of Twin Falls exceeds the national average.

0:56:11 At one point in time, Twin Falls and Idaho were considered to be affordable places to live.

0:56:23 Affordable places to raise your family.

0:56:26 And now when you compare the cost of living indexes of Twin Falls to many places in the

0:56:31 country, we rival that.

0:56:35 But one of the things that has not kept pace is the income.

0:56:42 And so while our income on those prior charts show significant increases,

0:56:47 we still need to push where we can in the areas of compensation

0:56:51 and making sure that we're providing high-quality benefits to our employees.

0:56:57 Because while we're building a lot more houses,

0:57:00 we're not building the same number of houses that we were the past.

0:57:05 And this looks great, right? We have built 107 homes in this first six months of the fiscal year.

0:57:20 And look at that, 28 homes, building permits were pulled last year this time.

0:57:26 And while percentages can lie, we're up 282% for the year.

0:57:34 We fall considerably short of the number of single family homes that we permits that we issued

0:57:40 in the city of Twin Falls in 2019 and 2020.

0:57:48 And the number of individuals that can continue

0:57:50 to come into our community continues to grow

0:57:53 and outside dollars are affecting home prices.

0:57:59 And we're trying to get individuals to come into our

0:58:02 community to take public service positions

0:58:06 to join the public sector and they can't find homes.

0:58:13 So that's why we need to make sure

0:58:14 that our salvage marine competitive,

0:58:18 but we also need to make sure that we're doing

0:58:21 what we can be a desirable community

0:58:24 that we're actively encouraging the right construction

0:58:29 and the right activities so we can continue to grow,

0:58:32 we can continue to expand.

0:58:35 Building permit revenues is an important piece

0:58:37 of revenue coming in and you can see that

0:58:38 for this fiscal year, we've collected 718,000

0:58:42 the $800,000 that we have budgeted.

0:58:45 But it's a bright spot.

0:58:48 It's still short of the $2.2 million that we collected just a couple of years ago.

0:58:54 So when we're creating revenue estimates, it's important that we being consistent and that

0:58:59 we don't over-late revenues, because what will happen is we'll create structural holes

0:59:06 and those revenue sources if we're not able to move forward.

0:59:09 And something that we have absolutely no control over is the interest rate.

0:59:20 You can see that while it is much lower than what it was historically, for the new generation

0:59:28 of home buyers, it is significantly higher than the reality in which they believed it was always

0:59:34 going to last.

0:59:35 And I think about me and my personal situation where I was able to get one of those really,

0:59:44 really good interest rates somewhere near the bottom of that trough, right?

0:59:52 And for me to sell my home and to move into a new place, I'm going to be paying more for

0:59:59 my home than what I did, and I'm going to be paying more for the cost of money to be able

1:00:06 to have that home with a higher interest rate.

1:00:09 And that is one of the impacts that we're seeing in our community, is it's not only the significant

1:00:15 rise in the cost, but also the cost of an annual mortgage that's driving up that cost.

1:00:22 And we know that the interest rate on a like-size home and a like price, a median home price

1:00:34 at $350,000, the change in the interest rate alone, from where it was in early 2022 today,

1:00:44 it's $1,250 a month for that same piece of property.

1:00:50 $101,250 more just for the cost of money.

1:00:56 is impacting individuals coming into our community and then we also look at

1:01:01 cost index and it's it is flattening that's the good news right we're seeing

1:01:07 that the CPI was only up 3.2 percent the MCI which is what we use was up 2.03

1:01:13 percent but they're up nearly 30 percent in a decade and we're continuing to see

1:01:20 those costs moving forward so it's the lenses when we're taking a look at the

1:01:26 economic analysis, those are the lenses that we use and I would ask the council

1:01:32 are we using the ones that you would? Oh, I think we're being consistent. We use

1:01:49 those indicators over the past several years and they really seem to drive our

1:01:55 budget in the right direction. So personally, I'm happy with them. Are we

1:02:03 viewing the community the same way that you are? That's like there's a head nod.

1:02:11 on. Jason, did you know I was just going to weigh in or yeah just for a conversation purposes

1:02:19 I mean Travis I've been a part of this for the last couple years and going through it

1:02:24 and trying to understand and you know from a personal note I've learned a tremendous amount

1:02:29 about budgeting and how that aspect of the city works. My question is is really one of

1:02:36 more of a hypothetical is, what would we do differently if we didn't do it this way?

1:02:41 Because to me, this seems logical.

1:02:43 It seems reasonable other than what you stated earlier, other than not be open in communicating

1:02:52 the process, as maybe other communities do.

1:02:55 To me, I believe that it seems a logical way to do budgeting.

1:03:01 Yeah, I think the process is sound, but I'm hoping is that, so when you look at the economy,

1:03:08 it's kind of like looking at a kaleidoscope, right, and you, we've got a beautiful kaleidoscope

1:03:13 outside and you kind of turn that kaleidoscope around and it creates an incredibly different

1:03:18 collection of images depending upon how fast it's been the kaleidoscope.

1:03:22 And when asking, are we looking at the economy the same way that you are looking at it in

1:03:28 when falls are you seeing housing prices continue to be higher than what they were in

1:03:33 the past, the labor market in your respective areas tighter than what we've seen, a huge

1:03:39 outside influence and demand of dollars and resources coming in, driving up home prices

1:03:47 in comparison to what they were.

1:03:54 we can get pretty biopic in our viewpoints and it may not be looking at the same community

1:04:02 and it could change around us. What we don't want to do is create a budget that does not

1:04:09 work in our current operating environment. Sometimes we can become so entrenched in our policies

1:04:15 and our practices that we put our blinders on and we might be missing the simplest of

1:04:20 that's why it's really good for us to check in with the council to say are we

1:04:24 seeing the community the same way you do I think that word nimble is absolutely

1:04:32 necessary we saw that in 2020 we had not have been nimble who knows where we

1:04:39 have been so Spencer I think we see the community the same and I think the high

1:04:46 level of philosophy you're taking is the right one to pursue just an anecdote

1:04:51 I get a lot of people comment to me that they think property taxes are too high.

1:04:56 In the same conversation, they'll tell me the things they want the city to do or improve

1:04:59 or expand.

1:05:00 And I'm just curious anecdotally if any other council members or city staff have had people

1:05:05 tell them, you know, I don't want the service or you guys do too much.

1:05:11 I'm sure it's happened before, but I think it's rare and I just, I find that interesting.

1:05:18 So it comes down to then, okay, are we taking the dollars we do have and being as efficient

1:05:23 as possible?

1:05:25 And I think when you compare to cities similar to us that we're doing a great job.

1:05:32 I know we got members of the team here.

1:05:35 I've never heard us being accused of doing too much.

1:05:41 Maybe in code enforcement, if you're the one that's at the beginning, right, you're the

1:05:47 the neighbor that didn't mow their weeds, right?

1:05:49 Maybe I think that we're doing too much.

1:05:57 We were strongly encouraged this year

1:06:01 during a snow event.

1:06:05 I have to keep that in perspective, right?

1:06:06 So being born and raised in Montana,

1:06:08 I have this thought and philosophy of snow events

1:06:11 and I've only seen one since I moved Idaho 23 years ago.

1:06:16 And it wasn't this year.

1:06:18 And we actually had individuals ask

1:06:19 when we were gonna come shovel their sidewalks.

1:06:24 That's a true story. We really did have individuals wonder when we were going to come to shovel their sidewalks

1:06:29 and we had to play with share with individuals that that's how the service is performed by the city and

1:06:34 We encourage them to go to their local hardware store and and you know

1:06:38 By the shovel because that's how we'll be much sooner and yes

1:06:42 There are citizens that get frustrated that we don't plow residential streets, but it's it's really

1:06:50 because if you think about the width of the plow blade and how narrow the

1:06:56 streets are, we can't win. We may accidentally clip a car. We may, after that

1:07:04 individual did, shovel their sidewalk. We might be the one that came and pushed

1:07:08 back the snow in their driveway. So, I mean, there's lots of reasons. So, are we

1:07:11 hearing of things that we don't do in all seriousness? Yes, but there's

1:07:15 There's sound justification for that.

1:07:18 And no, we did not sell a shishnow plows to Jerome 35 years ago.

1:07:25 And had we done that having worked in Jerome previously, it would have brought him with me.

1:07:30 But when it comes to taxes, when it comes to fees, historically we've taken the statutory allowed 3%.

1:07:37 We'll take the new value of the annexation rules, which is equal to 90%.

1:07:41 And then we've incorporated revenues equal to the 1% of the foregone balance of that's

1:07:45 what the council looks at.

1:07:47 We still believe all of those will drive down the tax rate.

1:07:52 We're going to be looking at sewer and water rate increases to make sure that the rates

1:07:57 that we move forward with are rates that can be absorbed and that focus on the long-term

1:08:05 future.

1:08:06 So one of the things that our team is brilliant at is they really focus on the capital needs

1:08:12 that are going to be needed at some point in the future.

1:08:15 And what we don't want to do is we would much rather

1:08:18 raise rates gradually than have shock rate increases

1:08:23 because all of a sudden we need to have a funding stream

1:08:27 for a particular project.

1:08:29 And what's important to remember is that, as you can recall,

1:08:33 we have not raised rates significantly over the course

1:08:38 of the last decade.

1:08:39 and our rate increases have been far less than both the MCI and the CPI.

1:08:47 Last year we raised rates and I think that's something that we need to keep open.

1:08:51 This is not a commitment or a statement that we will raise rates,

1:08:54 but it is something that I think that we need to be open to

1:08:57 and I think modest rate adjustments are what may be needed

1:09:01 to maintain the vital infrastructure of sewer and water.

1:09:04 There's not one person in Twin Falls today that took a drink of water

1:09:08 in question whether or not it was safe to drink and there's not one person that when that water went

1:09:15 down the drain they really wondered where it was going to go. These are things that are part of our

1:09:21 daily routines that people don't think about and yet there's an army of individuals behind us that

1:09:27 are making that magic happen and lack of access to clean water is still one of the leading killers

1:09:34 of people in the world, and yet into it falls,

1:09:37 it's not something that we worried about.

1:09:42 In terms of new positions, and we have not added any new

1:09:46 positions, but just to give you an idea

1:09:48 where we're at in our process, we're going to continue

1:09:51 to look at adding new positions strategically.

1:09:54 The executive leadership team of the city

1:09:56 will continue to evaluate those.

1:09:58 There have been 12 new position requests

1:10:01 that have been aided through the process so far.

1:10:03 I am not saying that we'll have any new positions

1:10:06 in the budget, and I'm not saying that we'll have 12.

1:10:09 It may be somewhere between zero and 12.

1:10:12 But what again, going back to sustainability,

1:10:15 making sure that it is something that we can fund long term

1:10:18 is important.

1:10:19 We also want to make sure that we're using our priority based

1:10:22 budgeting and strategic planning accomplishments

1:10:24 to help drive our budget.

1:10:26 And it's important to recognize that every 1% of salary

1:10:29 increases now cost the organization wide $314,000.

1:10:36 We also want to make sure that we are providing updated kinds and levels charts for the positions

1:10:41 that are needed.

1:10:43 We want to make sure that we're providing a solid benefit structure that everyone percent

1:10:47 of health insurance costs our organization $48,000.

1:10:54 We want to continue to make sure that our employees are learning new technologies through

1:10:59 training and we also want to continue to build partnerships with private entities to help

1:11:05 in service delivery where that's appropriate.

1:11:12 Operation and maintenance is something

1:11:14 that continues to move forward.

1:11:15 We want to make sure that we're using technology

1:11:18 that we're able to celebrate and share our branding

1:11:22 for talent attraction.

1:11:24 We want to make sure that we're recruiting.

1:11:27 As aggressively for hard to fill positions

1:11:30 as any other employer would,

1:11:32 we also want to make sure that we are funding those departments

1:11:36 that are realizing unprecedented growth.

1:11:40 And remember that their needs may be more than a simple multiplier of a consumer price index

1:11:51 because of how their service population is growing and expanding.

1:11:57 And if you think about the number of parks that we continue to look at exploring and adding

1:12:03 those well are amazing amenities, they are significant because significant burdens on

1:12:13 additional revenue streams coming in. Our capital strategy is becoming more and

1:12:21 more refined and you know credit to all of those who part of the city's fleet

1:12:27 management team. They've really taken a look at the entirety of the city's

1:12:31 rolling stock and they estimate that rolling stock to be about $24.7

1:12:37 million. I'll talk about that in a minute because that was the purchase price and

1:12:43 And they're looking at replacing about $2.6 million of that this year, at least that's

1:12:49 what's on the list.

1:12:50 And we're going to go through a process of balancing our rolling stock with our technology

1:12:55 needs with other one-time capital needs.

1:13:00 And of that $24 million, one of the things that Gretchen shared with me is just a reflection

1:13:08 of cost increases.

1:13:10 So in 2015, a patrol car was $26,000, and out of cost, and get one up, it is $85,000.

1:13:19 I won't look over my left shoulder, but this is why I get so frustrated when we have little

1:13:25 accidents, right?

1:13:30 They're in more than three times the cost of what they were nine years ago, and a new

1:13:44 fire truck that is three years out is now $1.2 million and I can still recall

1:13:58 when I put a new fire truck in the budget for the very first time and choked at a

1:14:06 $350,000 price bank. It's now nearly four times that amount, the outfit, brand new fire truck,

1:14:16 And how we deploy fire services is now profoundly different because now we're running EMS calls.

1:14:23 And EMS calls constitute a huge increase in the total number of calls that we're running.

1:14:30 And the fire trucks that we have are not built to go on those types of calls because they're too heavy.

1:14:38 And the engines are underpowered.

1:14:40 All of the things that when you start thinking about the costs, delivering services, the cost to replace a frontline fire truck is now significantly more than what it was.

1:14:54 And the work of the fleet management team is now helping us understand the cost of rotating out that rolling stock and what it's going to cost us to add new.

1:15:07 here's a list of just some of the things that they're looking at and it's it's

1:15:15 significant one of the things that we always want the council to be reflecting

1:15:22 on is that $770,000 of council discretion capital that we always have

1:15:28 into the budget and so portion of that whether you take the $85,000 of

1:15:33 MPOC and you roll that into council capital projects and you create a

1:15:39 a continuous project or you keep it as standalone.

1:15:42 It may make sense to roll that into the budget,

1:15:44 and that's why we had Mandy maker presentation today

1:15:47 to be thinking about do you take

1:15:49 Impog dollars and do you incorporate it

1:15:51 into these still larger projects?

1:15:54 And you can see the projects that were set up

1:15:57 or created by the city council this last year.

1:16:00 And this list was very, very different than years

1:16:03 in the past because I asked you not to include

1:16:07 any projects that were significantly engineering intensive because you had

1:16:12 already invested eight point five million dollars in SLF RF funds and we

1:16:18 intend to put that same 770 in the budget and during the entirety of the

1:16:23 council presentations we would ask for you to share projects of where you should

1:16:30 allocate those dollars and those resources. Then here's our schedule. We'll

1:16:40 come back one more time. So again today's a high-level conversation it is to get you

1:16:46 thinking about budget. It's kind of like a baseball right so my red socks are

1:16:56 already out of it right we're four games in. We've determined that we're

1:17:01 going to be a 500 baseball team that's not going to get it done but it's kind of

1:17:08 like for us our analogy be pictures and catchers are now reporting and we're

1:17:14 We're going to have a conversation about the budget moving forward and pre-season will

1:17:19 be incoming with what do you want us to fund and then regular season begins for us on Monday,

1:17:28 July 8th.

1:17:32 Any questions?

1:17:35 Chris, I don't have any questions, more of a comment and this goes back to the original

1:17:42 discussion that you had about the economy.

1:17:45 What does our community look like?

1:17:46 What are our folks?

1:17:49 two things that kind of stuck out to me. I completely agree with the analysis. One

1:17:56 other area that I find very interesting right now is the change of demographics as

1:18:02 far as age of our population. When I moved here many years ago, the demographics of

1:18:12 my family coming into the demographics of the folks coming in currently completely

1:18:17 changed and the level of service that that demographic is requiring, wanting,

1:18:23 needing, whatever it might be is different than what it was several years

1:18:28 ago and then the other thing that I would say as you talked about the increase

1:18:35 the cost of living and then the increase of wages and they don't match up and then

1:18:42 the last portion of your budget as we went through it is a decrease of

1:18:45 purchasing power. What we were able to purchase, and I think that on a city level, on a personal

1:18:51 level, on a business level where you're at, what you were able to purchase 10 years ago,

1:18:57 you are not able to purchase at the same level. And that's where the pain and suffering I think

1:19:03 coming from most individuals and as a community, when you look at a police car or a police vehicle,

1:19:11 three times what it cost who were not able to get as many and that purchasing

1:19:16 power is what's causing a lot of frustration that to me is that's what I'm

1:19:22 feeling that's what I'm seeing you just explained it it's that lack of purchasing

1:19:27 power the decrease of purchasing power. Thank you Chris anybody else perfect way

1:19:36 to end that. Thank you. Hey thank you Travis. So we next on our agenda is a public

1:19:46 hearing do you guys want to take a break or do you want to keep going?

1:19:51 Okay, so there we go. Okay, so public hearing is an action item. It's a request

1:20:18 for additional height up to 50 feet on property located at 2082 Bridgeview

1:20:23 Boulevard, Carabridge View Holding Zellel CPZ24-002. And we have our City

1:20:32 the senior city planner William Clayver to speak with us.

1:20:36 But before we do that, William,

1:20:38 I'm going to read the public hearing rules.

1:20:44 The council will follow these steps for each request

1:20:47 under public hearing portion of the agenda.

1:20:49 City staff will present the request and analysis.

1:20:53 The applicant will then present their request.

1:20:56 The council will then ask questions of the applicant

1:20:59 or staff after the questions have been asked.

1:21:02 the public hearing will be open.

1:21:04 During that time, anyone in attendance

1:21:06 is given the opportunity to comment

1:21:09 or ask questions about the request being considered.

1:21:12 When giving testimonies, please step up to the podium,

1:21:15 state your name and address,

1:21:17 and then present your comments or concerns.

1:21:21 After giving testimony tonight,

1:21:23 if you do, please sign the public sign and sheet

1:21:28 in the lobby with your name and address for the record.

1:21:31 After public comments are concluded,

1:21:33 the applicant will be invited to answer any questions

1:21:36 and make a closing statement.

1:21:38 Staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed.

1:21:42 After the closing statements,

1:21:44 the public hearing will be closed.

1:21:46 No further testimony or comments from the applicant

1:21:49 or audience will be allowed.

1:21:51 And then the council will have open discussion

1:21:54 and take action on the request.

1:21:56 So, you're up, thank you.

1:22:02 evening, Madam Mayor and members of the Council.

1:22:05 Today we have before us a additional,

1:22:10 a request for additional height on the Canyon Rim.

1:22:15 I tried to load the maps a little bit,

1:22:17 so they would load a little faster.

1:22:20 Hopefully we don't have too much time

1:22:23 flipping the maps and exhibits.

1:22:27 The first map we have is just general zoning

1:22:31 and future land use map.

1:22:34 I get a little bit familiar with the area.

1:22:36 The Best Buy is just around here,

1:22:42 and then iHop is here,

1:22:44 and the canyon rim is to the north.

1:22:50 You have blue lakes running around the west side,

1:22:55 and then the prime bridge is just to the north as well.

1:23:00 The current zoning is C1, PUD, however, with a in the Canyon Rim Overlay.

1:23:11 The PUD is the Canyon Park East, planned unit development, and it essentially states for

1:23:21 height that the height shall follow the canyon room overlay setbacks or setback

1:23:30 requirements and high requirements. The let you be aware of what that is. No one can

1:23:38 build to be able to build that 50 feet from the canyon room. You have to get a

1:23:45 geotechnical report. To be able to and the maximum height is 25 feet at that at that at 50 feet.

1:23:55 And then evenly at 50 feet and then when you get 100 feet back from the canyon room you can increase

1:24:05 it to 35 feet and at 150 feet from the canyon room you can go up to a maximum of 50 feet.

1:24:11 the request today is to allow for a little adjustment of those. So where you

1:24:21 can normally build to 25 feet you can build 50 or the request is to build that

1:24:27 35 feet and then where they would like normally where you can build that 35

1:24:35 feet the request is to build up to 50 feet. So the maximum height is 50 feet

1:24:41 overall that they're requesting. However, they're just pushing it up a little bit.

1:24:45 Let me pull up these conceptual drugs. This is just the area of the site, a little bit of the

1:25:01 view from the bridge site plan generally, the red that you see. That's where they're

1:25:13 hoping to get to the 50 feet height and then the purple that you see is the 35

1:25:20 feet height. This is a smaller building, the one right here on the west side closest

1:25:31 to Blue Lakes and the bridge. When we were doing the analysis here, most of

1:25:41 this would actually meet code as it's written. It's awesome and so this one

1:25:53 could benefit from it but really the big benefit fishery would oh here's some

1:25:59 isometric views of the building some 3D renderings we also have today before

1:26:08 Kobe Ricks with Lothlin and Ricks he's the one that designed this building I will

1:26:13 leave all the decisions of why he chose to design the building as he did he does

1:26:19 a beautiful job of explaining why but this is the bigger building and this is

1:26:28 is where you would prove those additional heights up to the 50.

1:26:36 One of the reasons, let me scroll up,

1:26:38 so excuse my little C sickness, I guess.

1:26:45 If you notice this a lot, it's very narrow.

1:26:49 It doesn't look like that much square footage

1:26:51 could be built there.

1:26:54 But with the building within setbacks,

1:26:58 and then with this additional height,

1:27:01 they're hoping to have a little over a hundred thousand square feet in residential.

1:27:07 So that's going to be on three floors. I just saw everybody's aware this best

1:27:15 by building this outline right here with the Michaels and TJ Maxx. That is roughly a

1:27:21 hundred thousand square feet itself. So it's going to be this square footed but

1:27:26 on three floors. At the planning zone meeting there was concerns about or no

1:27:39 public comment was addressed and negative for this or against the proposal. There was

1:27:47 one public comment that was in support of it. They liked the architecture and they thought

1:27:54 this would be a great aspect to the building or to the canyon rim and the entryway to the

1:27:59 city. At the public hearing amongst the commissioners, they had conversations about signage being

1:28:11 on the rim, really protecting the canyon rim, making sure it didn't look like Vegas, I guess,

1:28:17 or just bright, flashy signage. So they recommended a condition that should commercial signage

1:28:25 be placed on the canyon rim that would need to go before the planning and planning commission.

1:28:33 Another aspect on the conditions that I thought I corrected, but I must have missed it.

1:28:42 Condition number three, it's supposed to say subject to 50 feet rather than the 60 feet.

1:28:49 I had a couple for doing my research, I found, just across Blue Lakes, there was an additional

1:29:00 height in the form of a PUD amendment that allowed up to 60 feet, so I messed up those

1:29:08 two.

1:29:09 So it's really the request today is for a 50 feet maximum.

1:29:14 that I can answer any questions.

1:29:17 Who are you saying in your staff report you said 60 or where

1:29:21 did you say 60?

1:29:22 Yeah, it is in the conclusion section.

1:29:26 OK.

1:29:27 It's item three.

1:29:29 OK.

1:29:29 It's 50 feet, not 60.

1:29:32 OK.

1:29:32 Thank you.

1:29:41 You can ask questions or we can wait till the applicant's

1:29:44 Spencer.

1:29:45 Go ahead.

1:29:48 Thank you, Mary.

1:29:50 We'll be the buildings beautiful.

1:29:53 So I just wanted to give you my compliments on that.

1:29:56 I was curious about if we were to not allow the variance for this,

1:30:03 and then the owner developed a size not to pursue this,

1:30:06 if someone else came in, they could meet the high three

1:30:09 requirements, but they would have a lot more leeway

1:30:12 than to do color signage, things like that,

1:30:15 that we don't like, is that correct?

1:30:18 So we have a little more leverage here.

1:30:20 Right, because of the special use nature of this request,

1:30:24 we can condition the architecture, we can condition

1:30:28 the signage of it.

1:30:30 Otherwise, if they meet code, they can do as they wish.

1:30:35 Thank you.

1:30:37 Prince V. Do you know, remember which way you were scrolling?

1:30:44 If you could scroll, I would like to look

1:30:46 at the elevation change, the elevation here.

1:30:51 It is a pretty steep grade, and I

1:30:53 know that we are measuring from the front of the canyon room but what is it

1:30:58 on the backside of it yeah

1:31:02 Kobe knows off the top of his head all right so I will revert to him I can I

1:31:07 remember a number I don't know if it's that's fine no we can wait for Kobe thank

1:31:12 you thank you hey we're ready for the applicant Kobe do you want to come on

1:31:19 Good evening Madam Mayor and Council members. So I'm excited to be able to present this project

1:31:31 for to you. I think this will be a very neat project for the City of Twin Falls, for the

1:31:36 County, I think for the State of Idaho. This is a very, very unique site. And I think that

1:31:44 as where this site is located, that it should be a very unique building. I know the owner

1:31:53 When in 2020 when he was driving around, he decided to come into Twin Falls, and he saw

1:32:03 the Visitor Center, and he got the Visitor Center as a very attractive building.

1:32:10 And then this property was for sale at that time, and it's when he got interested in purchasing

1:32:17 this property and trying to develop it.

1:32:21 a little bit about the property. So this property is approximately 660 feet long and it ranges from

1:32:28 about 26 feet to 152 feet deep. So it is very long and narrow. The existing city sewer lift

1:32:45 station is right here and last year I know that some of the pumps were replaced on this city

1:32:54 sewer lift station and it so it's kind of in need of some some rehalls and being updated.

1:33:03 So as part of this project this this sewer lift station will be relocated here and which

1:33:12 allows a little larger building but it also it gets the sewer lift station so it's not one

1:33:19 of the first things you see as you drive across the bridge. This property with

1:33:26 Sportsman's warehouse and those other developments, most of this property was

1:33:32 built on feel. It was imported and even on our property, this portion of the site

1:33:44 has feel that we'll end up needing to be removed because we knew what the

1:33:53 owner wanted to build here, a geotech investigation was conducted in November of last year.

1:34:00 This is the most in-depth geotech that I have requested as an architect for a project that

1:34:07 I've worked on. There were five borings that were drilled on this site, and they ranged

1:34:12 from 20 to 70 feet deep. It did a very thorough investigation to verify that this site would

1:34:23 a three-story building, and that we would be able to get within 50 feet of the canyon rim.

1:34:29 And that geotech, if we move forward, it will be submitted to the building department for review,

1:34:37 but that geotech did indicate that we could build within 50 feet of the canyon rim.

1:34:43 Now we know that this site we are right by the canyon rim trail, and we don't want to put a 50 foot

1:34:53 tall building right by the Canyon Rim Trail. One of the things that we have looked at is we will

1:35:02 have walkways and patios, this is on the main floor, to push the actual building further away

1:35:12 from the Canyon Rim Trail. We will also work with planning and zoning and engineering and provide

1:35:20 access these months along the Canyon Rim Trail to verify that if work needs to be

1:35:26 done on the Canyon Rim Trail that the city has access and can go and work on

1:35:32 the Canyon Rim Trail. One of the difficulties on this where Phil has not

1:35:42 been imported onto this site, it's it's rock and we don't want to impact that

1:35:49 basalt. So we're trying to minimize that. So one of the things that we are doing that we will move

1:35:56 forward with when we design the building is that the lower level will need to be raised two to three

1:36:04 feet so that we're not having to drill or blast or chip a lot of the basalt for the sewer lines.

1:36:13 So, by the time we do that, it would be incredibly difficult at the 25 foot height to get a two-story

1:36:21 building.

1:36:22 It would limit this to a one-story building unless we wanted to impact the rock, which

1:36:28 we do not want to do.

1:36:32 Another thing that we are doing, the owner wanted this building to look like the canyon

1:36:45 rim to mimic the canyon rim yet provide amazing views of the trail of the bridge and of the canyon.

1:36:55 So that is what we are trying to do with this design. There will be a lot of structural steel,

1:37:02 there will be concrete. We could possibly use precast concrete, but we want the building to look

1:37:10 similar to the canyon rim. In a way it feels like it's a cave and then we're

1:37:17 putting class in between in the cave. And one thing that I've always liked as I

1:37:25 hike and rock climb, sometimes when I'm out in nature it just amazes me how you

1:37:32 can climb up a rock and there's one bush or one tree in solid rock. And around

1:37:40 both of these buildings that we are proposing. We have elevated columns and

1:37:48 we will be putting landscape in though so we will have landscaping at different

1:37:53 heights throughout this project. We are also planning on doing green roofs,

1:38:01 having some vegetated roofs and patio space so that you can go out

1:38:11 using native landscaping and to be able to, I don't know, feel like you're more in

1:38:19 nature even though this is the built environment. We are also working on a

1:38:33 lot of height variation. Instead of just building a big massive building, we are

1:38:38 trying to do a lot of height variation. So this is a person that is on the

1:38:44 Canyon Rim Trail. This is the smaller building and this is an outdoor patio.

1:38:51 There's a patio here. That is what is up the two to three feet and then this is an

1:38:58 outdoor patio. That patio is at 19 feet. So like Will was talking about this

1:39:04 building here other than this roof element it meets the requirements of the

1:39:13 current zoning requirements. On the larger building, it ranges from 18 feet to close to

1:39:29 the 35 feet on that main level. We are the larger building has, we will have a patio

1:39:39 here again that pushes the main building a little further ways back from the Canyon

1:39:44 room trail but we have a patio space here and here and then we have patio space on the other end.

1:39:54 This larger building we have five different exterior patios and they're at different heights

1:40:01 so we're trying to vary the heights north and south and east and west to try to minimize the size

1:40:09 of the building. From on the larger building, from the parking lot, the highest point of

1:40:18 that building will be 40 feet tall. And to put that into perspective, the historic all room,

1:40:29 the tallest point on that building is 36 feet. So it wouldn't feel a lot different

1:40:36 a walking along this building than it does the historic bar. The proposed use it is a mixed-use

1:40:48 building. As far as I know, there are no tenants that are under contract to be in this building,

1:40:54 but some of the possible uses, there could be office space, there will be retail space,

1:41:00 some restaurants, a possibly a boutique hotel that would have 15 to 25 rooms, and a possibly

1:41:13 a museum. So doing very much mixed use and trying to get a diversity of businesses down

1:41:20 into this area. And that's my presentation.

1:41:29 Thank you.

1:41:32 Do we have questions?

1:41:35 Yes.

1:41:36 Cody, are you thinking about parking?

1:41:40 That would be where bus buys would be included in there, or do we have room for parking?

1:41:48 So, when we look at the parking calculation that was done when bus buy and sports wins,

1:41:55 all of those developments were done, there's over 200.

1:42:00 were 200 additional parking spaces built into the existing parking lot. So these buildings

1:42:08 we will bill adjust if we need to to meet the parking requirement of what is currently

1:42:16 there. We are not planning on doing any additional parking lots. Where we are moving the lift

1:42:29 station we will add some parking there but where we're planning on moving the

1:42:34 lift station they'll lose a couple of parking spaces but there should be enough

1:42:41 enough parking to meet the requirements of planning and zoning. So this building

1:42:49 building A is proposed at about 13,000 square feet and then on the two levels

1:42:56 of the patio space is about 5,000 square feet of exterior patio space. The larger

1:43:03 building we are planning on about 64,000 square feet and currently there's 21,000

1:43:12 square feet of exterior patio. So when we're talking about a hundred thousand

1:43:17 square feet a lot of that square footage is actually patio space.

1:43:21 I don't know what design shows you've been watching, but this is awesome, so all that time is spent, it's incredible. I'm supportive of the idea, and then reading through the P&Z minutes, I address the anti-glare treatment on the north side of the building.

1:43:52 Actually, my biggest complaint, not complaint, but my biggest reservation on the building, so I would be in support of this project, and great job, Colby.

1:44:03 Thank you.

1:44:04 Sherry Volmer.

1:44:05 Yeah, the building actually does, it looks gorgeous the way that it's done.

1:44:12 I think that, you know, looking through the height, I would defer to this, to the staff

1:44:22 to let us know if there are any other issues that may be with the foundation part of it

1:44:31 or any other issues like that, I'm a little skeptical on the windows with the way that

1:44:37 it's facing. I don't know how much glare that that would be. I think my visual complaint

1:44:45 on this would be no signage on the canyon rim side, what that would provide for anybody,

1:44:53 and I think it would probably take away from the natural aspect and the visual aspect of

1:45:00 there but yeah when when we presented this to planning and zoning we've actually

1:45:07 presented not allowing building or signage on the north side of the building

1:45:13 on the canyon rim and the planning and zoning commission said I think if there's

1:45:20 people down on the canyon rim trail and they want to get up to a specific

1:45:26 tenant in this building that they would like signage and then that's why they

1:45:32 put in a stipulation that any signage on the north side of the building has to be

1:45:38 reviewed and approved by planning and zoning. That's a couple. I'd just like to

1:45:45 share it's exciting that someone's interested in investing in putting this

1:45:49 type of a building in our community. I'd like to recreate in around the canyon and

1:45:53 And it's disappointing when you see truck docks, dumpster enclosures, brightly colored signs.

1:46:00 And so I just appreciate this concept.

1:46:02 Hey, any other questions for the applicant or staff at this time?

1:46:14 Hey, thank you, Coby.

1:46:17 So with that, I will open the public hearing just to remind you that when you give testimony,

1:46:24 step up to the podium state your name and address and present your comments or concerns

1:46:30 will allow two minutes for each person to come up and address City Council so public

1:46:37 hearing is opened. So anybody here that wishes to step up to the podium and address City

1:46:44 Council? Okay then, see no one. No one did any additional comments? Okay, just to

1:47:01 have anything, William, are you good? Okay, then I will close the public hearing. No

1:47:08 further testimony or comments from the applicant or the audience will be allowed.

1:47:12 So now Council, it's up to you. Grayson, are you up from last time? Are you up again?

1:47:19 I might help if I turn on my mic.

1:47:22 Madam Mayor, I'm just prepared to make a motion.

1:47:24 If there's no further discussion.

1:47:26 Oh, I think we have some discussions.

1:47:28 So, yep.

1:47:29 When this came forward, I thought this was going to be very interesting because go back a year, seven years ago.

1:47:40 Height was, I mean, that's what we talked about.

1:47:43 And even recently, we've had conversations about the canyon and overlay and buildings going up certain heights.

1:47:49 And I'm not going to say that not having any public input is a reflection on that, but it

1:47:58 does speak very loudly.

1:48:00 That was tonight, as I saw this coming forward, I thought, okay, there was going to be some

1:48:05 concern with this.

1:48:07 I think it's a beautiful building.

1:48:09 I think it meets the requirement of Colby's description of it.

1:48:16 I feel works really well.

1:48:20 I had concerns about the height.

1:48:22 I really did. It's something that this council in years previous have talked about.

1:48:28 We've discussed it many times and nothing tonight was brought up about it.

1:48:35 So I have to believe that at this point in time, that's not a concern and so I think it's beautiful.

1:48:44 I don't have a problem with it. Look forward to something beautiful being placed there.

1:48:48 I just find this very interesting tonight.

1:48:53 Thank you, Chris.

1:48:55 Sherry Vomer.

1:48:57 Hey, this is a beautiful building and I wasn't sure what to come into with the height aspect

1:49:03 of it, but I think the way it's designed is very good and it's very thoughtful of the

1:49:09 community and I appreciate that.

1:49:12 I still a little bit of pains with any signage, so I'll leave that up to staff to as you work

1:49:22 you work through all of this to make sure that that stays, this stays to beautify that

1:49:27 side of the canyon.

1:49:28 I think it's Sherry, Jason Brown.

1:49:31 So is we approve this or go through the process of approval tonight?

1:49:36 So what happens if this doesn't go through, if we give the approval for this, does that

1:49:44 height restriction in this property?

1:49:47 It's just this one.

1:49:49 It's also, you know, it appears as Colby had mentioned was concrete still.

1:49:56 I mean, that's what we're approving that type of facade or the structure and things like

1:50:02 that.

1:50:03 Correct.

1:50:04 Yeah.

1:50:05 So we would be approving with this special use of the nature as well.

1:50:08 So this type of material, this type of this type of variation, quick clarifying question

1:50:16 for Sherry or common for Sherry. We will be instead of them going before asking us and us reviewing it, it would be a decision that the Planning and Zoning Commission will go forward.

1:50:31 And if there's any appeal, then it would be appeal to you.

1:50:34 So, are you, is your question good Jason?

1:50:41 I'm good.

1:50:42 Okay. So we are basically approving this project.

1:50:45 Okay. Okay. Are you ready, Grayson?

1:50:54 Yes, ma'am. I'd like to make a motion to request for additional height up to 50 feet on property located at 2020 or sorry,

1:51:01 2082, Bridgeview Boulevard, care of Bridgeview Holdings, LLC, PZ24-002.

1:51:10 Thank you, Craig Hawkins.

1:51:11 Thank you. Motion by Grace and Stone, seconded by Greg Hawkins to approve the

1:51:18 request for additional height up to 50 feet on property located on 2082 Bridge

1:51:24 View Boulevard, Carab Bridge View, Holdings LLC. Any further council

1:51:29 discussion? Amy Rolkauvo please. Grace and Stone? Yes.

1:51:36 Jerry Bulmer, yes, Ruth Pierce, Chris Reed, Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, and Spencer Cutler.

1:51:44 Yes, thank you. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you, gentlemen. Okay, I was remiss and skipped a couple on our time for general public input at a regular meeting.

1:51:59 So, general public input is the time for anyone out in the public who wishes to address City

1:52:06 Council on something that is not on today's agenda.

1:52:11 Is there anybody there here in the audience that wishes to address City Council tonight?

1:52:17 Okay, thank you.

1:52:20 Seeing no and advisory board reports.

1:52:23 Chris Reed.

1:52:25 We have two committees tomorrow.

1:52:29 the airport advisory committee will be meeting tomorrow at 11 at the airport and then the

1:52:34 public arts council will be meeting here at 12.

1:52:37 Thank you. Chris or Craig.

1:52:40 I just want to encourage members of the council if they can to attend the AIC with spring workshop

1:52:48 over in Burley on the 11th. That's Thursday the 11th, be at 9am and I found these to

1:52:54 be really interesting and fun and enjoyable, get to meet other people from other cities

1:52:59 and interact with them and also as a new member of the council it's really informed that you

1:53:08 learn quite a bit so if you're interested, please make sure you see Amy get that going so.

1:53:15 Thank you Craig. Anybody else have anything? Did he manage our office nothing tonight?

1:53:21 Okay.

1:53:22 Thank you.

1:53:23 And our meeting is adjourned.

1:53:24 Thank you, everyone.

1:53:25 Thank you very much.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 1, 2024. The recording started at 15:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:53:35.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    066ff1c98aea528851700c33e7ec583242d7c7f8b43536fff82d6fb2f4ec5b08
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 9a9b1d1834f3458b2a3645c2202e4838def945b13b095bce5c3e3779ae045100
    part02.m4a aacf5ae6ac4e9d76f670d7a7343c56623a765c75f99c10c89dcb7dd8ba6a7652
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    2b955a9ccfee3da0a7916b4a6d72e02693b956012966630aee7919ef6761476c

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file