OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, January 29, 2024

Work session meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:01:54 Good afternoon ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the January 29th 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm

0:02:02 We have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance

0:02:09 If you wish to join me, please rise

0:02:12 Thank you. We have no proclamations tonight. So next on the agenda is the consent calendar

0:02:35 Council wishes

0:02:37 Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to approve the consent calendar is written. Thank you. Do I have a second?

0:02:42 I'll second. Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins seconded by Sherry Vomer to approve the consent calendar as written

0:02:51 Amy Rokavo, please

0:02:53 Ruth Pierce. Yes, Chris Reed. Yes, Craig Hawkins. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, enter cutler. Yes, race and stone

0:03:00 Yes, and Sherry Vomer. Yes. Thank you motion passes seven to zero

0:03:05 Okay, then now we're going to be moving upstairs to a work session and we're going to be working

0:03:13 on the strategic plan and the citizen survey and so we will not be coming back to chambers

0:03:19 so we will move up there and meeting will return upstairs.

0:03:24 So we'll do it this way, that we're going to ask the council to sit through at some point

0:05:25 in the future, we emphasize that the work of leadership is often done when you're having

0:05:34 the opportunity to just be still and not complete the task work.

0:05:39 And so organizationally we refer to it as Q2 time.

0:05:42 If you're familiar with the work of Stephen Covey, it is the same work that he often says

0:05:48 that that's when you're able to provide some level of thought and you're not worried about

0:05:52 the task.

0:05:53 And if you think about council meetings, we are layering a whole series of agenda items

0:05:57 or tasks in front of you routinely, and we're never given you the opportunity to come together

0:06:02 as a body to engage in a conversation about where's our organization going, what are the

0:06:08 issues impacting our organization as we see them, and getting your thoughts and your insights

0:06:14 as we move forward.

0:06:15 And so this is our first workshop with the City Council, and we hope it is successful.

0:06:22 enjoy it and it's not the last and we'll kind of see what this looks like and we'll

0:06:26 find times that accommodate people's schedules recognizing that you are a

0:06:31 citizen council which means that you have day jobs and so we won't be

0:06:36 respectful of that. Today we're gonna have a conversation about the City's

0:06:39 Strategic Plan. We want to set the framework by doing a couple of different

0:06:44 things. Number one I'm going to provide a brief introduction of past work.

0:06:50 Mandy Thompson is going to provide an update to you on the results of the citizen survey

0:06:56 that we recently completed last fall to give you an idea of the citizen sentiment and using

0:07:03 that as a gauge that goes into our strategic planning process.

0:07:07 Also going to provide a quick update on the priority based budgeting process and what that

0:07:11 looks like and how we're going to take the priority based budgeting piece that we've been

0:07:14 working on across the organization and include that into our long term planning efforts and

0:07:20 and ultimately the creation of the fiscal year 25th budget process this year.

0:07:25 The long term planning process kicks off today at 1.30 and so we're going to have some

0:07:30 members that if we're still here, we'll have to get up and go to start that process.

0:07:38 After Mandy, Gretchen is going to go through and really kind of talk about what I would

0:07:42 say is an environmental scan of where is the organization today, which is a process that

0:07:50 we started in 2012, we reflected as an organization and as a community, the issues, the challenges,

0:07:59 the opportunities that were before the organization, and we created, and we documented that, right?

0:08:08 We created documentation to say, this is where we're at today. As we were planning on going

0:08:12 to 2030, saying, this is where we want to go. We completed that exercise also, we reviewed

0:08:18 where we were in that scan in 2017, 2018,

0:08:21 and Gretchen through her work with members of all

0:08:25 of the departments in the various eight focus areas,

0:08:27 also spent time saying, this is where we stand today.

0:08:30 So we'll be able to give you an update on the things

0:08:32 that we've been able to complete as part

0:08:34 of the strategic planning process.

0:08:35 And then Phil Kuchlan is online,

0:08:40 and we'll ask Phil to join us as he talks

0:08:43 about what that strategic planning update process

0:08:46 is going to look like moving forward.

0:08:48 And we'll certainly have some other members of the team

0:08:52 jumping in.

0:08:54 So that's kind of your agenda that we're

0:08:57 going to be going forward with for the balance of the day.

0:09:02 Workshops, just because maybe this is new for all of us,

0:09:08 workshops are designed to be free-flowing.

0:09:12 There's no motion.

0:09:14 There's no vote that will be taken.

0:09:16 And in a workshop setting, we're really

0:09:18 hoping that it is a dialogue. So as you have questions, wrap it fire and we'll

0:09:25 hopefully be able to respond and if we're not we'll certainly seek those answers

0:09:28 for what that looks like. So the City of Twin Falls, any questions? All right, so

0:09:36 the City of Twin Falls started this version of a strategic planning process

0:09:42 in 2012 and in that process we were able to take the strategic plans that

0:09:49 the organization had done previously and created a longer vision for the community moving forward.

0:09:56 Past strategic planning efforts were really action plans that were boiled down to one and

0:10:01 two year increments and it had very specific tasks on what the organization needed to accomplish.

0:10:07 But it didn't go so far as saying these are the outcomes that we hope to realize and

0:10:12 this is the the longer vision that we have to the community so really sequencing all of

0:10:18 that work.

0:10:19 So in 2012, we engaged the community.

0:10:21 We engaged the council.

0:10:22 We engaged members of our organization,

0:10:25 and we had a conversation.

0:10:27 We completely retooled the organization, and we said,

0:10:31 by the year 2030, we want Twin Falls to look like this.

0:10:36 And Bill put us through an exercise,

0:10:39 almost going into a time machine,

0:10:41 having you describe what you wanted Twin Falls

0:10:43 to look like by the year 2030.

0:10:48 And then we compartmentalized some of the similar components

0:10:52 and we created what we refer to organizationally

0:10:55 as focus areas.

0:10:57 And each of the eight focus areas in 2012

0:11:01 were really looked at equally and very similar.

0:11:07 And then in 2017, we made a change,

0:11:20 an intentional change to the illustration.

0:11:23 And that was that we put the internal organization

0:11:26 into the center, recognizing that all of the other seven focused areas cannot be realized

0:11:35 if it's not for the capable hands and minds of those working in our organization.

0:11:42 We deliver services.

0:11:44 And in delivering of those services, it takes highly competent, knowledgeable, dedicated

0:11:52 individuals to deliver those.

0:11:55 We don't have a lot of machines, we don't make a lot of widgets, a lot of the things

0:12:00 that we do our hands on.

0:12:03 So we put that intentionally in the middle, and even during our budgeting processes, when

0:12:08 we go through and we have a conversation, we connect those focus areas that are similar

0:12:15 in nature, where we'll connect focus areas four and five, and we bring our public works

0:12:20 team in that conversation.

0:12:23 Because Area 8 is one that we always have stand alone in that conversation in that process.

0:12:34 And really we go through this strategic planning process to help create a financial roadmap for

0:12:40 us not only this year but in years to come.

0:12:44 And so this year the long term planning process like I said is going to kick off later this

0:12:47 afternoon and they're going to have a five year financial vision for the organization.

0:12:54 that financial vision is designed to further the organization in realizing the community

0:13:03 that we want to become by the year 2030. And one of the conversations that Phil is going

0:13:08 to talk to you about later is when we started in 2012, 2030 was 18 years away, nearly two

0:13:17 decades. And now we're looking that in 2024, it's six years away.

0:13:25 It is 2030, really, the right place to start, or do we need to push that goal post out.

0:13:35 Also we want to make sure that we continue to remain nimble.

0:13:38 And so we're going through the process and we're answering questions.

0:13:41 Part of that priority-based budgeting process is what are we doing?

0:13:44 What do we have to do?

0:13:46 How do we take resources and allocate it to areas that are new and emerging opportunities

0:13:51 and challenges and threats?

0:13:53 And how do we stop doing those things that are no longer returning the value that they

0:14:00 once did because our community is profoundly different?

0:14:05 In thinking about the City of Twin Falls of not as a community of 56,000, but recognizing

0:14:12 that 40,000 people crossed the bridge today.

0:14:15 And there are seven other points that people came into the community.

0:14:20 It's applying goods and services really to a community that exceeds 100,000 people every

0:14:26 single day.

0:14:27 And what are the financial challenges associated with that as we move forward?

0:14:31 And so we look at cost and value and what is the analysis and what is the return on our

0:14:36 investment and that's part of that priority based budgeting process that we're honestly

0:14:41 struggling to implement because as we had a consultant come in and share with us, organizationally

0:14:49 were a little resistant to change.

0:14:54 And while we continue to do great works,

0:14:57 and we've been able to respond to an environment

0:15:00 that is ever changing, we still like to tend to hold on

0:15:05 to the way that we've done things,

0:15:06 especially if those sacred cows were born under our tenure.

0:15:13 And Eric Keck, who's been helping us through the process,

0:15:16 I had a great phrase and that phrase is the most sacred of cows make the tastiest of burgers.

0:15:24 So we have to find a way as an organization to stop doing the things have no value.

0:15:29 We're asking the council to do the same thing.

0:15:33 Where you're coming here with a mindset that there is a way that the council has always

0:15:39 operated or things that the city has always done.

0:15:42 And you're going through that strategic planning process, we want you to be aware that the environment that we're operating in today is profoundly different than the time that we created the strategic plan, and it will continue to change.

0:15:55 And I want you to just think about COVID.

0:15:59 Think about COVID from the fact that on December of 2019, you might have heard some rumblings of what was going on in parts of the world.

0:16:13 But by March, we had shut down our local economy.

0:16:19 An unemployment rate went from 2% to 11% in a blink of an eye.

0:16:26 And the strategic planning process never contemplated such a disruptive event.

0:16:33 At this organization, we were able to roll, we were able to respond, we were able to adapt

0:16:38 to a new operating environment and that operating environment is still not as it was in 2019.

0:16:45 You can just ask those on our fleet management team who are building a fleet plan on how

0:16:53 hard it is to get rolling stock replaced in a timely manner.

0:17:00 So those are the changes that are impacting our organization and just one example of how

0:17:04 the world we're operating is not the same.

0:17:08 Thinking about the number of individuals that are coming into our community.

0:17:12 What is their expectation of services?

0:17:15 How do we meet their expectations with the resources that we have?

0:17:22 And are we willing to say no?

0:17:25 Because sometimes that is the toughest word to say when you're getting approached with

0:17:31 a request.

0:17:34 And what is the cost of saying yes?

0:17:39 We're hoping that this kicks off that process today.

0:17:42 We're hoping that you find it worth your time.

0:17:47 We're going to use this to build the strategic plan in which we will take a look at these

0:17:51 focus areas and we'll determine whether or not they're still right.

0:17:57 We'll build the matrix to help us be able to report out and a series of performance measurements

0:18:03 that we'll report back to you.

0:18:06 And then annual basis moving forward as it relates to our initial budget presentations.

0:18:15 But I want to just take a minute to remind you that the work that this team does is good.

0:18:24 accolades and the opportunities to grow are always around us. This team that's

0:18:36 in here is ready to be your partner in creating the outcomes that you and the

0:18:44 community would like to see. So with that I'd be happy to answer any initial

0:18:49 questions but if not I'm going to turn the time over to Mandy to begin a

0:18:54 process. Phil, I see you on there. Do you have anything to add to what I had shared?

0:19:00 Phil, you can go ahead and speak if you want to. I'm watching you on your live feed so I don't have any visual of the meeting here on my screen.

0:19:38 Well, yeah, but I understand that, but, well, so am I on?

0:19:50 I guess what you've asked us to do, and I, again,

0:19:56 maybe reiterating some of your comments earlier, going back to 2012.

0:20:05 The charge that we received from the city was to create a working document that could be used for a variety of purposes going forward.

0:20:21 A lot of institutions do strategic planning and basically put them on the shelf and then wait for a period of time and do it again.

0:20:33 And your admonition to us was that's not what you wanted to see.

0:20:38 You wanted to see something that was going to be functional in terms of

0:20:43 supporting the decision-making process of all levels of city government.

0:20:48 Plus that you basically said it had to be done in 20 pages.

0:20:53 So given that as a charge,

0:20:59 We knew that it was critically important that it was going to need to be owned by the Council.

0:21:09 And so the process that we used was involved the Council extensively as well as members of the community.

0:21:19 And so I think generally what you've came up with at the time, and I think have used throughout the last several years, is basically a process that kind of lets you focus on those things that the elected leadership and the community as a whole,

0:21:47 found to be particularly critical to the future and so recognizing that things

0:21:55 change we did that update in 17 and now we're doing it again and as you indicated

0:22:05 we had a two initial conversations that asked the question is 2030 the right

0:22:12 planning horizon or should we push that out a bit. So based upon the conversation

0:22:19 we had with the management team, I think it was concluded that maybe without at least

0:22:24 exploring the possibility of reaching out beyond the 2030 horizon. And that

0:22:31 basically gave rise to the 11-page memorandum that you have before you

0:22:38 today and I apologize for the length of it, but I thought it probably gonna help set the

0:22:46 stage for the end-depth conversation that it was going to be needed to reach out that extra

0:22:53 ten years.

0:22:55 And so while we've looked at a variety of sources, some of which are global and some of

0:23:03 which are local, we think that kind of defines the

0:23:08 what some of the issues are that you or any other community in the United States West is

0:23:16 going to be struggling with over the next several years.

0:23:22 So we've looked at some of the implications of growth.

0:23:29 One of the things that was kind of a threshold question, should we look just at the city

0:23:36 of Twin Falls or do we understand that you function in a broader community that impacts

0:23:44 what you do?

0:23:45 And so we looked at primarily the metropolitan area that has been defined basically as your

0:23:56 MPO and looked at that in terms of the population statistics that will be driving the functioning

0:24:06 of city government as you know it over the next several years and I think that was a realistic

0:24:17 approach to looking at the numbers so as to make sure we've got the right goal post out

0:24:27 there that we're going to try to figure out how to resolve.

0:24:33 You've looked at your various planning documents, you see that they have various planning horizons,

0:24:40 and those are all the doctor plans that are listed there on page two that talked about things that you have actually adopted.

0:24:49 So you've got a variety of horizons there as well, and we're trying to pull together and make sense out of that.

0:24:58 And again, looking at just raw population numbers in terms of forecasting what that's

0:25:08 likely to occur is probably not sufficient going forward.

0:25:16 We look at 2040 as not just doing possibly more of the same being driven by more people.

0:25:25 What we've concluded in looking at a variety of sources is that population number is going

0:25:32 to change in terms of characteristics in terms of population getting older and what implications

0:25:39 does that have for service delivery by the city government in Twin Falls.

0:25:48 I think that's going to take some time to kind of struggle through that question in terms

0:25:54 of what does that really mean in terms of who we are and what we do in the services we provide?

0:26:02 We used an national data source called Woodson Pool Economics out of Washington, D.C. that

0:26:10 has a very robust series of prognostications, I guess, for every county in the United States.

0:26:20 So it's a fairly aggressive database that we've kind of tapped into, but I think tells

0:26:30 an interesting story, both in terms of just raw population data, but also how it changes

0:26:35 over the coming years.

0:26:38 The other thing that we looked at in terms of what does always mean is pulled out a forecast

0:26:50 by the National Organization, that every four years looks at global trends.

0:26:57 And what do they mean in terms of not only the world out there,

0:27:04 but also how does that translate into issues at the local level?

0:27:08 And while many of the things that we've described in the real quick summary of the data that we put in the memorandum

0:27:17 You can kind of see a bunch of that stuff, but I think the other thing that kind of got

0:27:25 my attention was the rapid evolution of technology, not only in the hands of the city, but in

0:27:32 the hands of the people you serve.

0:27:35 What does that mean in terms of the ability of the organization to keep up with it?

0:27:41 I think government by its very nature is basically stable and being stable, it's slow to change.

0:27:51 And so I question whether or not the way that we've always done business is going to

0:27:56 be the way we can do business in the future.

0:27:59 And I think some conversation both internally and externally to the city staff is going to

0:28:05 be necessary to kind of understand those trends and figure out how we relate to that.

0:28:15 I think also the thing that was discussed there is in terms of the information silos that we

0:28:21 observe around the national political dialogue can in fact occur local level too and how and

0:28:32 And that kind of ethic, I think, tends to erode what has been described as the public interest.

0:28:42 And is there a public interest anymore?

0:28:46 And finally, I think the question is, is there a role in the city of trying to bridge those

0:28:53 silos to basically connect to that community of interest that does in fact exist?

0:29:02 help us to connect with the broader population in a meaningful manner.

0:29:09 I think that's a question that's out there.

0:29:12 Travis asked me to focus on the major questions at the end of the document in terms of how

0:29:23 do you want to approach this process, rather than to answer all the detailed questions

0:29:29 today and so we had those six questions on page 11 that basically ask and I'll

0:29:36 run through them very quickly and then we go back and address them individually but

0:29:39 knows now time to just feel we're gonna actually have before we get into those

0:29:47 questions I want to set the stage just a little bit more with Mandy and with

0:29:51 Gretchen talking about where we stand in the citizen survey piece of that and

0:29:57 And then also what Gretchen has been able to do

0:30:00 in the environmental scans of sharing where we're at

0:30:05 to kind of couch that information

0:30:09 or to receive that information so that we're better able

0:30:12 to answer the questions coming up.

0:30:15 Okay, that's fine.

0:30:16 Any questions for Phil in moving forward?

0:30:25 There are none, so Mandi, I'm gonna turn the time over to you.

0:31:16 Good afternoon, everyone.

0:31:18 I apologize if I'm living in this world where I need glasses to read, but if I were, then

0:31:23 I can't see you all, so I'm going to be taking them on and off.

0:31:26 I learned about a thing called Progressives this weekend, so I'm going to get this in with

0:31:30 those.

0:31:31 But I have a couple things to talk to you about, the first being the Citizen Survey, and then

0:31:37 I'm going to talk a little bit about party-based budgeting and how it fits in with some of the

0:31:44 information that I'm sharing with you today, and then also with the strategic plan and the

0:31:51 concept of performance measurement. So these are the results of the 2023 Citizen Survey.

0:31:58 So a little background for those of you that are new or forgot from the last time I gave

0:32:02 this presentation, the Citizen Survey is conducted by the National Research Center, which is located

0:32:09 in the Denver, Colorado area.

0:32:11 It is provided to communities across the country as a way to essentially assess and interpret

0:32:18 the opinions of their citizens in a scientific manner.

0:32:22 So that the decisions that are being made to some degree can be made based upon the thoughts

0:32:27 and sentiments of the citizens that the government is serving.

0:32:32 We have been conducting the Citizen Survey since 2012 and set from 2012 through 2022

0:32:40 we did it every other year.

0:32:43 We started having a conversation in 2022 about whether or not it was time to start looking

0:32:51 at the sentiments of the citizens on an annual basis.

0:32:55 So this year is the first year that we have back-to-back data and moving forward we will

0:33:00 be doing it every year.

0:33:02 So we used to have a smaller survey pool, so initially when we did the citizen survey,

0:33:12 we only sent surveys to 1,500 citizens.

0:33:16 As we moved through the processes, the community grew and at the recommendation of the research

0:33:23 center, we have increased that size of the pool that we're hoping to receive responses

0:33:30 from from 1500 to first it was 2,500 and then this year we did 3,000. So

0:33:37 essentially the city is divided into four areas and think about it as the

0:33:42 intersection of Blue Lakes and Addison and so you have those four quadrants

0:33:46 based upon Southeast, Southwest, Northeast and Northwest and that's just a

0:33:52 way by which we can understand the geographic location of the responses

0:33:59 without having to know the actual address name or any personal identifying information

0:34:03 of the people that respond to the survey.

0:34:07 The recipients are selected at random, the means by which if you had an opportunity to read

0:34:14 through the report that I sent you, it does outline to a degree how the households are selected.

0:34:23 And we do tend to oversample multifamily units just because they're hard to reach.

0:34:29 We get a lot.

0:34:30 I would say we get about two to three hundred return, not, you know, not on at this address,

0:34:36 undeliverable.

0:34:37 And a lot of those do come from those multi-family units.

0:34:40 But part of the reason we also oversample is because they tend to be the places where individuals

0:34:46 of the lower income and even younger citizens are living.

0:34:52 And so that's why we make that decision to seek out,

0:34:57 or to over sample our multi-film family units.

0:34:59 And then they're contacted three times.

0:35:01 The initial contact, they get a postcard letting them know

0:35:03 they've been selected.

0:35:04 The second time they get a postcard, well, it's kind

0:35:08 of like a postcard in the mail, but it's also a paper copy

0:35:11 of the survey, but now for the last several years,

0:35:14 they have the opportunity to do it online.

0:35:16 So if you, as a citizen are selected, you can put in a code

0:35:20 and you can do your survey online.

0:35:22 And that's becoming more and more popular.

0:35:24 And then they get a third contact two weeks

0:35:27 before the survey closes, just reminding them

0:35:31 that they've been selected if they have already done it.

0:35:34 They say, we apologize through this postcard away.

0:35:36 And it's just, again, another way to remind them

0:35:38 to complete their survey.

0:35:43 So given a 4% error rate, I suppose,

0:35:48 is what you would call it, of the 3000

0:35:51 that were sent out, we know that 2,887 reached a destination,

0:35:57 or at least were not returned to us, of that number, 586 were completed.

0:36:03 That is a 20% response rate, which is a little bit below the national average,

0:36:11 but as in increase from the last time that we did this with a higher number

0:36:16 of surveys being mailed out last year,

0:36:21 we had a response rate of about 18%.

0:36:23 So find it encouraging that more people are completing the survey.

0:36:26 I also found it really interesting that I knew like five

0:36:29 or six people personally that received the survey this year.

0:36:33 So I tried to give them some encouragement to fill that out.

0:36:36 And then also just the results were rated based upon the demographic demographics

0:36:41 of our community.

0:36:42 So, they take those demographics from the census data in 2020,

0:36:47 and then also from the 2022 American Community Survey.

0:36:49 And the purpose of that is just make sure that the response is a reflective of our population.

0:36:54 So, if a smaller number of Hispanics returned individuals

0:36:58 that are Hispanic returned their survey, but they're weighted in order to reflect the amount

0:37:06 of the number of Hispanics living in our community.

0:37:08 because the survey does ask for some demographic questions.

0:37:12 And then this is just a visual of, again,

0:37:14 how the community is broken up,

0:37:18 and then the dots just represent the addresses where they went.

0:37:25 And then this right here is just a, hang on a second.

0:37:29 I'll answer this was also in the report that I gave you,

0:37:35 but really this is just a quality importance matrix.

0:37:39 Because essentially the citizens that are answering these,

0:37:41 they're asking for what, you know, if it's quality,

0:37:44 basically quality and importance.

0:37:46 And so when you see something above either

0:37:50 of those medians to the right above to the left or below,

0:37:54 then you see where citizens were saying

0:37:58 that there were offering quality services

0:38:00 and they're also important, or were offering quality

0:38:03 and services, but it's not as important to them.

0:38:05 So again, this is just sort of a scatter graph

0:38:08 to show you an idea of sort of where the general results

0:38:11 of the survey landed as far as the intersection of quality

0:38:15 and importance to our citizens.

0:38:18 So there were some four key findings again if you read the report.

0:38:21 This was sort of at the beginning, but essentially key findings,

0:38:24 and I'll go into detail, but the residents appreciate our leadership

0:38:27 and governance.

0:38:29 They see a value for the services of taxes paid.

0:38:32 And again, you have to remember that these are just based

0:38:34 on those individuals that did respond.

0:38:36 But when I say they see a value in it, that means that they gave

0:38:40 they were a good or I'll go into the actually how they scored them, but essentially they're

0:38:49 giving them a vote of confidence that they see value in the services that we're providing.

0:38:59 Additionally, as was pointed out in the report, the support that was initially called out

0:39:10 in the report for the local option sales tax question that we asked.

0:39:15 I'm not sure how many of you had the chance to read through it,

0:39:17 but we actually went through the process of authoring a couple of questions

0:39:23 surrounding the local option sales tax.

0:39:25 And the citizens interested in not only seeing it be on the ballot

0:39:31 for them to have the opportunity to vote on, but also whether or not they would support it.

0:39:34 And the results of that suggest that citizens are interested in at least being asked the question.

0:39:40 Over 70% of the respondents responded favorably that they would like to have the opportunity

0:39:48 to vote on that.

0:39:49 Around 50% said they would support it.

0:39:51 So obviously, great to know they want it on the ballot.

0:39:54 We have some work to do on whether or not we could get it passed if we ever had the opportunity.

0:39:58 But I think it goes to show that there's some level of trust that they would like to see

0:40:04 something that would, one, potentially have an impact on their property taxes, too, but

0:40:08 also an impact on the types of projects and the size of the projects that we could start

0:40:14 to complete in the community if we had an additional funding course.

0:40:19 What did I do?

0:40:20 Secondly, residents experience a very strong sense of safety within our community.

0:40:26 They have low personal experience with crime, those individuals that responded and also

0:40:30 they feel they're safe in their neighborhoods and then their commercial areas of the city.

0:40:37 responses to our community design overall, but there is some room for improvement based

0:40:44 upon the responses.

0:40:46 And then also that our mobility services reflect some success, but as we all know, there's still

0:40:53 a lot of challenges surrounding mobility in our community.

0:40:59 So in general, one of the overarching questions that is measured in the survey is quality

0:41:07 of life. So those are questions like what type of a community is Twin Falls, what type

0:41:13 of a place is it to be? The overall quality of life image and reputation, would you want

0:41:19 to raise your kids here and do you want to retire here? So the graph on the side says

0:41:24 so essentially when we talk about 79% and you see that percentage, that means 79% have

0:41:30 said that it's either good or excellent. So those individuals that took the service said

0:41:35 that Twin Falls is a place to be is either excellent or good.

0:41:40 So when I talk about percentages,

0:41:41 that's what I'm referring to,

0:41:43 are those good or excellent categories.

0:41:45 But then you can also see where there are individuals

0:41:47 that are responding to the kind of overall quality

0:41:50 of life questions within this survey

0:41:53 as either being poor or fair.

0:41:56 The up arrow indicates that this is an improvement

0:42:00 over the last time we took the survey in 2022.

0:42:02 Kind of sideways arrows indicate it's fairly stagnant and then there will be places where

0:42:08 you'll see a decrease or a downward arrow which indicates that the satisfaction of our

0:42:13 citizens has declined in that area.

0:42:15 So I don't think anything in this is overly surprising to any of us.

0:42:23 We have the quality of life and the desire to live here continues to be fairly strong.

0:42:30 as far as governance and how will the government,

0:42:34 the government of Twin Falls meets the needs

0:42:35 and expectations of its residents.

0:42:37 So again, the overall quality of services is that 63% say

0:42:42 that is either good or excellent.

0:42:45 And again, the overall, like the graphic on the side

0:42:47 is sort of a average of all of the questions

0:42:52 that fall under governance.

0:42:53 So they don't necessarily match up

0:42:55 with what some of these percentages are.

0:42:57 depending on the area that it's categorized under,

0:43:00 there could be 10 questions or there could be 20.

0:43:04 But the overall direction of the city

0:43:05 remains around 48% believe that we're doing fair or good.

0:43:09 Confidence in the government is increasing.

0:43:12 And again, also is the value of the services for taxes paid.

0:43:17 So I think these are indications that we are,

0:43:21 to some degree, satisfying the needs of the community,

0:43:25 but also that there is some room for improvement.

0:43:30 So back to that, one of those overall arching themes

0:43:34 of the survey, and that went back to our citizens' feeling safe.

0:43:38 To the residents, I'm feel safe and secure

0:43:39 in their neighborhoods and in the greater community.

0:43:42 And overall, the feeling of safety in Twin Falls is 72%.

0:43:46 And that's an increase over the last year,

0:43:47 and it's been steadily increasing.

0:43:51 And that is, you know, that's a variety of different, I think.

0:43:55 But the hard thing about this is in survey is you don't know how individuals are interpreting

0:43:59 these questions, but just kind of in an overall sense, 72% believe they feel safe in our community.

0:44:05 They feel safe in their neighborhoods.

0:44:08 They see the quality of police services at 75%.

0:44:10 I think that's an excellent indication of the progress that we're making with our police

0:44:14 department because that percentage has been as low as 52% in the years that we've been

0:44:19 doing this.

0:44:20 So that's an excellent attribute area that shows that the efforts that our police department

0:44:26 has put towards not only just the quality of the services that they're providing, but

0:44:29 their efforts to communicate with and really engage in our community.

0:44:34 And quality of fire services, 90%.

0:44:36 The jokes always been that everybody loves a fire fire.

0:44:40 But in my infinite wisdom, I decided, and I thought we should go forward with the Citizen

0:44:45 Survey in 2020.

0:44:48 Maybe Travis didn't think that was the best idea.

0:44:49 I push forward and so in 2020 we didn't feel fair super well and even the firefighters took

0:44:55 a dip in 2020 so they are not immune from criticism but overall I think they're doing

0:45:02 I think this shows that safety in the community is not only a priority of the city but also

0:45:08 it's being recognized and then again I know that I provided you guys with the report and

0:45:16 you'll see there are a lot of facets, even in safety,

0:45:19 that I'm not including.

0:45:20 Mostly because not a lot of those,

0:45:22 some of those don't even fall under the purview of the city,

0:45:24 but also again just because this, for time purposes,

0:45:29 needed to not include every question.

0:45:33 Yes, oh, Grayson.

0:45:34 Yeah, I have a quick question for you.

0:45:36 So when we're looking at this data,

0:45:38 and you're seeing a barrel versus the staggerio,

0:45:43 is that a couple?

0:45:48 For me, it was more than three percent,

0:45:50 and then when you look in, now, but this is the look confusing and I apologize for this.

0:45:57 When you're going through and looking at your report and you look at some of those numbers

0:46:01 and that kind of that graph line, and it says similar to, you need to remember that similar

0:46:07 to, is it similar to the year before?

0:46:09 It's similar to the communities that were benchmarked against, and I apologize that I didn't mention

0:46:13 that earlier on.

0:46:14 We're also benchmarked against communities within the United States that participate in

0:46:19 participate in the Citizen Survey as well.

0:46:22 They have similar size populations, similar demographics,

0:46:25 similar economies, and so we are benchmarked against those.

0:46:28 And so when you see those in your report

0:46:30 and it says similar kind of a decrease,

0:46:32 it's just we're benchmarking well for the most part

0:46:35 against other communities of our size and demographics.

0:46:40 But for the purposes of the presentation,

0:46:42 that for me, I left it, I only increased or decreased

0:46:46 if it was more than a couple of percentage points.

0:46:48 So mobility, overall quality of the transportation system

0:46:54 as a whole, this was a challenging area of the report.

0:47:01 We used to do the survey in the winter time.

0:47:05 And so you can imagine that the repair

0:47:08 in the state of the roads in February

0:47:10 with potholes emerging and causing issues

0:47:13 didn't do us a lot of favors as far as the street department.

0:47:17 It's just taken in the fall, so take that into consideration.

0:47:21 But I do think sometimes people's memories are longer

0:47:23 than we give them credit for.

0:47:26 So again, just looking at things like traffic close,

0:47:29 signal timing, traffic signal timing.

0:47:31 There's some level of frustration there as far as,

0:47:35 again, with the respondents as far as how they see

0:47:38 that we're doing paths and walking trails,

0:47:42 69% think we're doing a great job,

0:47:43 but then if you go down to the next one,

0:47:46 They only give us just a general 50% rating for ease of walking,

0:47:51 and then the sidewalk repairing maintenance is at 37%.

0:47:54 So only 37% of the respondents believe

0:47:56 that we're doing either a good or excellent job

0:47:59 of maintaining and repairing sidewalks.

0:48:04 Public transportation, this is an interesting one,

0:48:08 one because we've never had public transportation up until 2023.

0:48:13 And again, this was taken in August.

0:48:15 Well, excuse me, started in September, concluded in October.

0:48:18 So I'm guessing that there are so a lot of individuals

0:48:21 that are not familiar with right TFT, have not used right TFT,

0:48:25 or just maybe unsure of the system in general.

0:48:28 However, I will say that, you know,

0:48:32 travel by public transportation, 8%, yes.

0:48:34 Use of public transportation is at least 18%.

0:48:36 But when you look at these numbers compared

0:48:38 to where they've been in the past,

0:48:40 we have a lot of room for improvement.

0:48:41 So I think this is a hard one, because we didn't really

0:48:46 up until this year even have the services

0:48:48 to even have a baseline comparison.

0:48:52 And in general, the street department,

0:48:54 all of these numbers signify at least a 2% to 3% decrease.

0:49:01 So street repair, cleaning, lighting,

0:49:03 such as street lighting and snow removal.

0:49:06 So unfortunately, the street department did not fair

0:49:08 this year in the Citizen Survey. We struggle to understand why. We have a couple tools,

0:49:15 so the company used to be offered by, or it still is offered by the National

0:49:20 Research Center, but the Research Center was purchased by a company called Polco.

0:49:25 And Polco is, I mean, it's not only do they do these larger citizen surveys, but

0:49:31 they have the ability, which we have access to because we contract with them

0:49:35 every year to kind of dive into our community

0:49:40 and do some specific sort of, okay,

0:49:42 so what's wrong with our streets department?

0:49:44 We never are gonna be able to find the same people

0:49:46 who answered these questions

0:49:47 to know what they were thinking when they answered them,

0:49:50 but we're working with Josh Palmer

0:49:52 to create essentially a group of users

0:49:55 because they have to sign up for POCO,

0:49:57 but to then start asking specific questions,

0:50:00 and it can be anything that we're doing in the city,

0:50:02 but they really try to make the tie

0:50:04 between. If you're finding questions within your citizen survey results that you don't

0:50:08 really understand or you want more information, it's a way to further dial down into the community

0:50:12 and see if you can figure out if there are similar sentiments from other people and what

0:50:17 exactly is it that they're disappointed with or would like to see improvements in.

0:50:22 As far as the natural environment, these are just really our natural spaces and the role

0:50:28 they play in the well-being of our residents. This scored well, it always scores well. We

0:50:34 We live in a beautiful community.

0:50:36 We put a lot of emphasis on our water resources, cleanliness, I think overall, just I mean

0:50:43 and again, not really sure how everyone interprets sewer cleanliness, but I think in general our

0:50:48 community is seen as very clean and inviting and welcoming.

0:50:52 And then the importance that we place on open spaces in natural areas is at 54%.

0:50:57 So in general, yes.

0:50:59 You didn't have any up or down arrows on that, how did we compare to the criteria?

0:51:08 Oh, I apologize for that.

0:51:10 These all were fairly similar.

0:51:13 I might have to go back and look, but in general, they've all been in that kind of high 60s high 70s.

0:51:19 So nothing of any, I guess, maybe an importance that I saw, but I did skip that one, didn't I?

0:51:25 But just in general, if you look at that overall quality of the natural environment in Twin Falls,

0:51:29 73% believe that we're doing either a good or excellent job.

0:51:35 As far as community design, and essentially the overall kind of layout of our community,

0:51:42 overall design and layout of residential and commercial is declined, and is at 45%.

0:51:50 However, people like the variety of housing options that we're bringing in.

0:51:58 They believe that their neighborhood is a place to live is great, really good, either

0:52:02 good or excellent, but definitely some room for improvement as far as how we're growing.

0:52:15 Well-planned growth was 39%, I do know that is a decline.

0:52:18 I left the arrow for that, I apologize, but actually that was somewhat of a significant

0:52:23 decline.

0:52:24 So I think as we grow, this shouldn't be a surprise that as we're growing, especially

0:52:29 citizens that took this survey have been here for a while, they maybe are starting to see

0:52:36 the impact of growth not only personally but on the community at large.

0:52:42 And then the availability of affordable housing options, again, shouldn't surprise anybody,

0:52:47 given the current market that we're in right now, the real estate market and the cost of

0:52:53 housing, but that one below it, the variety of housing options, I think citizens are starting

0:52:58 to recognize the number of multifamily projects

0:53:01 that we are improving at the city level

0:53:04 and that are taking place in the community

0:53:06 and the desire to address the affordable housing challenges

0:53:11 that we have.

0:53:16 Utilities, this race, all utilities,

0:53:19 I included the utilities that we obviously govern over

0:53:23 are there under our control.

0:53:27 Overall quality of the utility infrastructure

0:53:28 down slightly at 57%. Garbage collection, 82%. They seem fairly happy with PSI. However,

0:53:35 recycling and yard waste both took a hit. So I'm going to log on to priority based budgeting.

0:53:43 I'm in a minute to kind of show you the tool and I want you to remember that recycling number.

0:53:47 So only 20% percent of the respondents believe that we are doing a good or excellent job

0:53:52 in recycling. So remember that because I'm going to talk to you a little bit and kind of show you

0:53:56 how we can take some of this information and some of this data and look at it through a

0:54:03 different lens. 65% of respondents drinking water were doing a good job with our water.

0:54:07 Sewers doing great. Storm drainage, that doesn't necessarily surprise me considering some of

0:54:12 the large storm events and rain events that we've had over the last couple of years and

0:54:16 some of the challenges that we've seen in storm water. So again, an area that we can

0:54:21 pay attention to and take into consideration, especially as we move into Phase 2 storm water.

0:54:35 Community engagement, this is really about how residents feel they're able to engage

0:54:41 within the community and their willingness.

0:54:44 So I think those are kind of two different questions.

0:54:46 I think a lot of people might be willing to, but they don't know how.

0:54:50 And I've been here for 10 years.

0:54:51 I've been working with the public for most of those 10 years and it has been a constant battle

0:54:56 to try to figure out the best way to engage our citizens to really get the positive impact

0:55:01 and put or not even positive but getting input and engagement on the front end instead of them

0:55:07 coming to you and a council meeting to complain about something that we're not doing well enough.

0:55:11 So this I think is interesting, some of these numbers are interesting as far as just their

0:55:17 connection engagement to their community seems to be going down slightly, but they see that

0:55:25 we value and respect the residents of diverse backgrounds. So I think that's interesting

0:55:28 because I don't know that I would necessarily personally think that. So from again the perspective

0:55:34 of those individuals that are taking as they see that there's an increase in individuals

0:55:39 in our community of diverse backgrounds. And then opportunities participate in volunteer

0:55:45 and local matters.

0:55:46 I think they see the opportunities to do it, but whether or not they're actually participating

0:55:51 I think is an entirely another story.

0:55:54 And then as I mentioned to Kristen when we were talking about whether or not anyone could

0:55:59 hear us over the streaming, I mean you can see this number here, just general civic involvement,

0:56:06 people aren't attending public meetings.

0:56:08 They're not watching public meetings.

0:56:10 So again, not sure how you move the meter on that.

0:56:14 again, there's some budgetary challenges and decisions that we make based upon our belief

0:56:19 that people are watching or need a particular service. So again, taking some of these numbers

0:56:24 into consideration as we make budgetary recommendations is part of kind of this overall plan about

0:56:30 why we're accessing all different of these different points of data. This one's another

0:56:35 kind of gloom and doom. I think this is a representative of the economy, not gloom and doom, but definitely

0:56:41 a lot of decreases and you know their overall opinion of the economic health of our community.

0:56:47 Employment opportunities, cost of living went down a lot.

0:56:51 So again not our fault but I think in general people are you know the sentiment is the cost

0:56:56 of living is going up so we're not doing a good job.

0:57:00 Now again that's nothing that we can control but it's the reality of the citizens that

0:57:05 are taking the survey and I think it's the reality that we always have to take into consideration

0:57:08 of the citizens that we're serving, that they're facing a lot of financial challenges right

0:57:13 now with housing costs, inflation, cost of living, and again, even potential issues with

0:57:19 employment. Although we do have a very low employment, we know a lot of people that are

0:57:24 underemployed or are working multiple jobs to make ends meet.

0:57:29 By Brent downtown, commercial area, that was only a couple of percentage points, but I just

0:57:33 I thought it was interesting because we have put so much time and effort in planning into our downtown course.

0:57:40 So again, I think that may be reflective of the economy at this point in time, but you know, the overall quality of businesses and services that are in Twin Falls was remained fairly stagnant and a very favorable rating, and also economic development, you know, at least half of those that took the survey believe that we're doing a good or excellent job at, you know, developing the economy, bringing in new,

0:58:03 businesses and new opportunities within our economy and the community.

0:58:11 Parks and Recreation kind of put two together, which was kind of the health and wellness because

0:58:16 we don't really have a lot of real influence over that, but yet at the same time it kind

0:58:20 of dovetails into our healthy community focus area, which primarily is Parks and Recreation.

0:58:25 So overall the health and wellness of the community, the respondents thought was declining.

0:58:31 health care continues to decline here after year and also I thought was

0:58:37 interesting as access to healthy foods that also was about a 10 point change

0:58:41 from the first time we took the survey in 2000 that they were that it was

0:58:45 reporting which was in 2018. Our recreational opportunities were down

0:58:50 slightly as were our recreational programs and then this one is always an

0:58:55 interesting one our recreation facilities because in centers because we

0:58:58 obviously don't have a rec center but we do have a lot of recreation facilities we

0:59:01 of the pool, we have the golf course, we have our trail systems, we have you know ball fields,

0:59:07 so we have a lot of facilities, but it was, it's been declining year after year, and this

0:59:14 is one that is significantly lower than our benchmark communities. And then you know the

0:59:21 city parks at 65% was actually up from the last time that we took the survey but down significantly

0:59:26 from 2018. And again, the availability of PASF and trills is 69%. So they're used, they're

0:59:34 appreciated. But again, why only 65%? You believe that we're doing a good or great job.

0:59:43 I mean, those are the questions that we have to fair it out. Well, you know, does that have

0:59:46 anything to do with some of the issues that we've been having in some of our parks specifically,

0:59:50 maybe first federal? I don't know. And again, you can't ask the people that answered the

0:59:54 that are answering the questions, but those are the types of the interpretations that we

0:59:59 have to make without all of the information.

1:00:03 So that is the end of the formal presentation, but I would appreciate it if we had some sort

1:00:11 of conversation about your thoughts on what you read and what you saw here.

1:00:16 And if you have any questions about how we plan to utilize the data.

1:00:20 Anybody have any questions for Mandy?

1:00:31 Mandy, one of the things I noticed, and you mentioned it already, is communication always

1:00:40 seems to be the crux of any feedback that you get is we never can have too much communication.

1:00:49 So I think that's something, um, cleaning sidewalks was a perfect example last week,

1:00:56 is you can't have too much communication and I think that's key in working with our citizens.

1:01:02 So that's the one thing I noticed.

1:01:04 Last question real quick.

1:01:09 So, Mandy, there were, you know, there's a lot of questions

1:01:13 on what were the people thinking in the survey themselves.

1:01:16 Was there opportunity to quantify what they were thinking

1:01:19 about that or does that just make the survey too extensive

1:01:22 that Ned would maybe lose more interest

1:01:24 in answering those types of questions?

1:01:28 Quantify as far as I give like anecdotal answers or?

1:01:31 Yeah, so the last couple of slides talked about Parks

1:01:34 and rec, what were some of those, do we ask a question of,

1:01:39 is there a park specifically that you're concerned about?

1:01:41 We can make a conclusion that it may be first fed

1:01:45 or something happened there that people reached out.

1:01:48 But I didn't know if the survey asked,

1:01:50 since you responded this way, would you give us

1:01:52 a little bit more detail or ask leading questions that way?

1:01:56 So then maybe we're not guessing what the citizens

1:01:59 are trying to say.

1:02:01 But again, I think if you go too complex,

1:02:03 that may turn people off.

1:02:07 Yeah, unfortunately there is not.

1:02:09 And it's based upon the way in which this is statistically

1:02:16 found survey.

1:02:18 And so introducing quantitative answers

1:02:26 into a survey that's really based upon quantitative numbers.

1:02:30 So that's, I mean, they give you the opportunity

1:02:31 say like good, you know, what is it, you know, poor, fair, good or excellent? I mean, I think

1:02:37 that's maybe part of it. But then I think that's where we can, we need to start utilizing

1:02:44 the other survey tool that Polco offers. When you see a question that you're not like, well,

1:02:50 what does that mean? I think it's a great opportunity to start working to engage with

1:02:54 our citizens. Josh and I have had several conversations and I think this is, some of the questions

1:03:01 in here really make me want to make sure we start really focusing on that tool and getting

1:03:06 people signed up and willing.

1:03:07 I mean all it requires is like an email address, you don't even have to give your name and they

1:03:12 want to know what like quadrant of the city you live in and that's about it.

1:03:16 And then you can go okay so you can give the sort of the lead in that you know based on

1:03:22 a recent survey of our citizens you know come to our attention that perhaps there's some challenges

1:03:29 within our park system.

1:03:30 And then we can write our own questions and we can provide any means by which we can collect

1:03:35 that information so we can provide yes-no questions, we can give, you know, they can give

1:03:39 like a one through ten.

1:03:40 There's a lot of flexibility in that and it's a pretty cool tool.

1:03:46 Yeah, because I'd like to see, you know, if going back to the streets department aspect

1:03:51 of it, if there's something specifically that we need to address from the streets department,

1:03:56 of us have probably filled out a survey. It may have been we had a bad day at the

1:04:00 street light. We got stuck there a few seconds longer than what we wanted to.

1:04:04 And so I just it would be really nice to know because I believe over the course

1:04:09 of time the city has worked hard on sidewalks, worked hard on that. We've

1:04:13 added some lights, we've added some things like that. It would be would

1:04:16 just be really nice to know what what citizens are thinking specifically.

1:04:20 So thanks.

1:04:21 You know, and that's a challenge of doing a survey like this. You really never

1:04:24 willing know will know what was motivating them to answer the questions.

1:04:28 Maybe they're new to the community, so they've never known Twin Falls when it

1:04:31 was 35,000 people and you could drive down, you know, blue lakes and make

1:04:35 every light and never worry about it. Now I avoid blue lakes at all costs. So I think

1:04:41 it just depends like how long they lived here, how old they are, you know, again

1:04:44 maybe their their income level and I don't even know if that, you know, some of

1:04:47 the questions definitely could be motivated by that. But you know, if I'm a

1:04:50 a young parent who relies on parks to keep my kids entertained, I probably might be a little bit more, you know, maybe not critical, but I probably look at parks a lot different than I do now.

1:05:03 I mean the last time I was in a park, park park has been years, but I used to go to them probably three or four times a week when my kids were little, so it's hard, right?

1:05:12 And you have to recognize that you're looking at that demographic information about who answered. It's kind of actually pretty interesting.

1:05:17 And then, you know, we have a lot of older individuals that took the survey, so, okay,

1:05:24 are they even going to parks?

1:05:26 Maybe not, I don't know.

1:05:27 So, what are the things that we've done in the past is we will then take this information

1:05:32 because it's, remember, this is just a point in time, and it could be that bad day, right?

1:05:38 They got home, they were late for something, the traffic signals just weren't working

1:05:44 the way they expected them to, whatever that looks like.

1:05:47 so they took that out on the survey.

1:05:50 But there's a couple of things that you can look at,

1:05:52 number one, trends over time.

1:05:54 So we've been able to do the survey over a period of time,

1:05:57 and we can see what, how are we doing today in comparison

1:06:03 to how we've done in the past.

1:06:05 Internally, we can say, did we make programmatic changes

1:06:09 that may be influencing some of those outcomes?

1:06:13 We've also gone on and had conversations

1:06:15 with different service groups, made presentations,

1:06:18 and so in years past, members of the Public Works team

1:06:22 and the Parks team would go out and they do a whole series

1:06:26 of conversations about this is the services that we offer.

1:06:30 It also gives us a really good opportunity to use this

1:06:34 information to build a strategic plan to help us allocate

1:06:40 resources to realizing the community that they may want.

1:06:45 And that's when you start having conversations about funding,

1:06:49 and how do we fund, and is the value of an enhanced park

1:06:53 system worth blank dollars, and recognizing

1:06:58 that it's funded through property taxes.

1:07:01 Citizens might say, absolutely, I would expect more of a property

1:07:05 tax increase for higher quality parks,

1:07:06 or they may come back and say, no, I'm good with what I got.

1:07:10 I don't want to pay anymore.

1:07:12 But sometimes it's just making the connection between the level of service over a period

1:07:18 of time and that's where having this baseline knowledge, it doesn't help us answer the why,

1:07:24 but it will help us build, process, and have a good understanding of where we are now.

1:07:32 So Mandy has a few more slides and we're going to turn it over to Gretchen.

1:07:36 I just was going to say that one of the things that stood out for me was we've got a great

1:07:42 story to tell but it's not getting out there and I guess how do we address that?

1:07:48 Wow, it's almost like you teamed me up for party based budgeting right there.

1:07:51 We'll talk about party based budgeting but one of the things I think all local

1:07:57 governments are really bad at sharing their successes because members of our

1:08:05 team probably feel like some of the work that we do is fairly mundane and in the

1:08:10 one city training that we've been having we've been having conversations

1:08:14 about clean water and I'm going to bet that no one listening and no one on the

1:08:20 council today had a concern when you took a drink of water whether or not you

1:08:26 were going to survive and you go we have an expectation of clean water and that

1:08:33 is probably a fair expectation but lack of access to clean water is the number

1:08:38 and killer people across the world.

1:08:40 Yeah, we take it as a, it is always going to be delivered always.

1:08:45 And because our teams are so good at always delivering clean water,

1:08:48 we don't talk about the success or the story of that.

1:08:51 And there are so many other examples of where members of not only our team,

1:08:56 but other teams provide high level of services, and that has just become routine and expected.

1:09:05 Kind of like Alabama football, right?

1:09:06 You always expect them to win.

1:09:11 Yep, here we go.

1:09:13 And so for us, it is really sharing what

1:09:20 is the level of effort and the care that members of our water

1:09:26 supply and distribution teams are taking

1:09:28 to ensure access to clean water in our own community.

1:09:35 Because there are communities, even in the US,

1:09:38 like Flint, Michigan, that had that expectation

1:09:41 and their organization failed them.

1:09:44 And so how do we continue to build that communication?

1:09:48 Priority-based budgeting is a piece of it,

1:09:51 but the other piece is that we have to be maybe

1:09:54 a little less humble in sharing the good works

1:09:58 that we're doing because we're really good

1:10:00 at completing the task and going to the next,

1:10:03 rather than taking a moment and celebrating

1:10:05 all the good works that we are doing.

1:10:07 like our street team, and the last snow removal.

1:10:13 We know we didn't meet everyone's expectations,

1:10:17 and that is something to strive for,

1:10:20 but it is not without effort,

1:10:23 and the great works that all the street team did

1:10:26 in that process, and so I think it's a reconciliation

1:10:29 of resources that we have, the effort that we put forward,

1:10:32 and then understanding what are the citizens' expectations,

1:10:35 and understanding if they're realistic or not.

1:10:38 Andy, before you move on, is there a question on that survey that states how long somebody's

1:10:43 been in a resident at Twin Falls?

1:10:44 And the reason I ask that is because I think the longer you're here, the more you appreciate

1:10:54 the growth versus migrating from a bigger area with a bigger municipality and bigger

1:11:00 services.

1:11:01 And so I don't know if that skews that data or not, but I would be interested in seeing

1:11:06 what that looks like from folks who have been here longer versus, I don't want to say short

1:11:10 that folks that are just coming into the area and comparing their MSA to RMSA versus folks

1:11:18 that have grown up here and so on and so forth.

1:11:24 I'm looking at the demographic page, but of course I can't find it now.

1:11:27 Or there it is, okay.

1:11:30 It does not appear that it asks for length of time that they've been a resident.

1:11:39 It does?

1:11:42 We have, okay.

1:11:43 So right now, it's not on the report.

1:11:47 on the report, I'd have to go back in and look at the full tool, I guess it's the survey

1:11:53 tool to see whether or not it asked that. I think you'd get back to you on that question.

1:11:56 Because actually, considering the rate of growth we've had, it would be really interesting to

1:12:00 know if you've lived here less than five years, more than five years, your whole life.

1:12:04 So yeah.

1:12:05 So I really don't want to jade those, some of those statistics where you said, yeah, we've

1:12:10 got this big downturn. There's been so much growth and so much progress. Folks moving from communities

1:12:18 that are benchmarked communities?

1:12:25 I will look at that and see if I can get an answer for you

1:12:26 before we're done with the workshop.

1:12:28 So the other thing I wanted to talk to you a little bit

1:12:30 about is party-based budgeting.

1:12:32 So Travis did tee it up a little bit.

1:12:35 It's a means by which we can look at our organization

1:12:39 through a couple of different lenses.

1:12:42 We have been forever, really, when

1:12:45 we've gone through budgeting processes,

1:12:46 it's a line on a budget, right?

1:12:48 So we go into our, our each department has, I mean,

1:12:52 we have a line item for training,

1:12:54 we have a line item for supplies,

1:12:55 we have a line item for travel, contract services, right?

1:12:58 You have all these line items,

1:12:59 and we fund all those line items,

1:13:01 and then we go about doing the work of government.

1:13:04 But if you were to look at a line on a budget,

1:13:06 say for the police department,

1:13:07 I mean the police department,

1:13:08 they have a variety of different,

1:13:10 a lot more line items than most departments,

1:13:13 one because of the difference in how they operate,

1:13:15 but also just because of this year's size.

1:13:17 You're not going to go on a line on a budget and find out how much costs to operate patrol.

1:13:23 No idea.

1:13:25 So one of the ideas behind party-based budgeting is to start looking at the services that we

1:13:30 offer through programs.

1:13:33 And patrol is an example of a program.

1:13:36 And it's not just like how much money we allocate in the budget for maintenance and operations,

1:13:42 but how much do we think?

1:13:44 This is not an exact scientist.

1:13:45 This is not an exact tool.

1:13:47 But how much do we estimate that each individual

1:13:51 in the police department spends in patrol?

1:13:53 Not everybody is going to have any allocation to patrol.

1:13:57 But the idea being when you start talking

1:13:59 about patrol is going to be training

1:14:01 and it's going to be uniforms and it's going to be

1:14:05 when butchering it now.

1:14:07 But a variety of different line items, cars, right?

1:14:11 A variety of different line items go into the functionality

1:14:14 of the performance of, you know, offering control services in the City of Twin Falls.

1:14:18 And we've never been really able to say, okay, well, what is that?

1:14:22 What does that cost? So now we get to go in and

1:14:28 see that, again, not a science, but

1:14:32 this is non-personnel and personnel. We're looking at probably

1:14:36 around directed control response in operations is about 3.7 million dollars.

1:14:40 So that includes, again, all of our maintenance operation

1:14:44 capital and the big one, personnel.

1:14:50 And I think it's fascinating because it gives us an understanding of, okay, we know that's

1:14:56 probably one of the biggest programs in the city.

1:14:58 We know based upon the sheer size of the police department, the sheer size of the, you know,

1:15:02 the sheer number of officers that are assigned to patrol, that it's got to be a big number.

1:15:05 But we've never been able to quantify it.

1:15:08 And we do a variety of things in this city that, I mean, we're not going to have a lot

1:15:12 of $3.7 million programs, but when someone comes to you as a counsel person and says,

1:15:20 well, how much does it take cost to operate patrol because they're terrible and they're

1:15:23 not doing a good job and crime is on the rise and people speed all over Twin Falls, you have

1:15:28 some data here now that we can provide you to give you an idea of like, this is how much

1:15:33 we believe is going into that particular service that we're offering, but on the other

1:15:41 other side of that where we went through a process of scoring these as well to make sure

1:15:46 that they're aligning the programs that we say we're doing, that we believe we're doing

1:15:50 in the functionality and the operations of the City of Twin Falls, that they align with not

1:15:56 only our strategic plan, the strategic value set out by the plan, but also in an area like

1:16:01 what we call five basic program attributes. Is it mandated? Is there any sort of cost recovery

1:16:08 for the program, is anyone else doing it in the community that perhaps we could partner

1:16:13 with or perhaps we could do on someone else's behalf and create another form of revenue,

1:16:18 another stream of revenue?

1:16:21 Is the demand for the service increasing or decreasing?

1:16:25 And lastly, the percentage of the population that a particular program is serving.

1:16:32 So it's a really interesting way to look at what we're doing and through a different lens.

1:16:40 And then, should we be doing it, if it's not mandated and we don't get any money for it,

1:16:46 and not very many people are using it, and the demand seems to be going down, that creates

1:16:51 a really interesting conversation for us during budgeting of, well, why are we doing it?

1:16:56 Is this a sacred cow that we might need to have a conversation about?

1:17:00 Again, as a tool, we're not budgeting through priority-based budgeting, but it's providing

1:17:05 us with data that we've created on our own in order to have conversations about what we're

1:17:10 doing.

1:17:11 Because we all know we're not getting any more revenue.

1:17:14 I mean, we get our 3%, I mean, there's not going to be some windfall of money that's

1:17:18 coming to pay for all of the services that continue to be demanded of us.

1:17:22 So it can also become a conversation about how do we reallocate the revenues and the resources

1:17:27 that we have if we're performing a function or a program that perhaps we don't need to

1:17:32 do any longer.

1:17:34 And then I just remember that recycling, if you remember recycling was, what was it, does

1:17:46 anyone remember?

1:17:47 Okay.

1:17:48 And it costs us, then this is an easy one because we know this is just contract services, right?

1:17:55 But it's $77,000 in additional costs to do our recycling program and we have a fairly

1:18:01 low vote of confidence from our citizens.

1:18:04 So these are tied to this data points that we can bring to council to have conversations,

1:18:10 tough conversations sometimes about maybe whether or not this is a program we should continue

1:18:14 to do.

1:18:15 I'm not making any suggestions.

1:18:16 It was just one that I knew it had a low rating on the citizen survey and I could easily

1:18:20 pull up the amount of money that I know that we're allocating to that program.

1:18:23 But that's what we're trying to do, we're really trying to make more strategic decisions

1:18:26 about the resources we have and the programs that we're funding.

1:18:29 So we'll continue to utilize this in long-term planning and asking the participants to, if

1:18:35 they have a request, they need to associate it with what program are we, is this associated

1:18:42 with, and how does it score, and how much money is in that program, and kind of make the case

1:18:47 for and utilize this tool as we move forward.

1:18:51 questions on priority based budgeting. So that's kind of a preview of some of the

1:18:58 things that we're looking at as we're kind of moving forward with priority

1:19:01 based budgeting. I think it's going to be a really insightful tool. If you got

1:19:08 about 30 minutes left and I'm gonna have Gretchen come up and talk about kind of

1:19:14 like the environmental scan as we kind of move forward with, you see, so we're

1:19:22 We're starting to plan with a, this is how the citizens believe that we're doing in these

1:19:28 different areas that we can can tie to a focus area.

1:19:31 Gretchen's going to spend some time going through the environmental scans of what we've been able

1:19:37 to accomplish as an organization and what we see those opportunities are in the coming

1:19:44 years and then probably part of that homework assignment is you're going to have six questions,

1:19:49 right?

1:19:50 they'll kind of read those six questions but really those are going to be not only

1:19:53 for just the council but also for members of the executive leadership team to really

1:19:59 dive in and think about those six questions as we move forward not yet but

1:20:04 we're gonna have Gretchen kind of share the progress that we've made since 2012 as a

1:20:07 result of following a strategic plan so Gretchen. So I'm going to give you just a

1:20:30 very brief overview of the process that we went through starting last June of

1:20:35 2023 and some of the things that we did in order to provide a condition update in 2023.

1:20:44 Those are draft statements right now. There are some pieces that we essentially have only focused

1:20:50 on from an internal perspective. We haven't connected with our external partners to have that

1:20:56 same conversation with them in terms of an external scan. So what we did, when you review

1:21:03 the Strategic Plan document, you'll see that you have the initial vision statement, then

1:21:07 you have the 2012 condition, 2017 condition, and then you have what we have drafted.

1:21:14 And what we did was we met as department managers and leaders for each one of the focus areas,

1:21:21 and then we had a pretty long conversation where we brainstormed challenges that we were

1:21:26 looking at of things that were becoming aware of, things that were changing within our operational

1:21:32 environment that affected what we were able to do, new demands that were happening.

1:21:37 We put all of those together in sort of just a large conversation on a big tear off sticky

1:21:43 note.

1:21:44 And then we went through and we wrote the statement, trying to gather as much external

1:21:48 data that was available through things like the community health assessment from the hospital,

1:21:55 the school district report card that they have to report annually on in order to supplement

1:22:00 that information by what we saw is happening within our major community partners.

1:22:04 Now there are other things that we need to do to continue to round out those condition

1:22:09 statements with external partners.

1:22:12 I know that Phil Kuchaland was also going to talk about some of those things as well.

1:22:17 We have some outreach that we need to do and the citizen survey informs some of those conditions

1:22:23 as well and those pieces weren't readily available when we completed the condition statements

1:22:28 either.

1:22:29 that we need to thread in that as well.

1:22:33 So the work sessions began.

1:22:35 We started putting together all of the information,

1:22:38 then kind of writing that in a narrative form

1:22:40 in order to inform current condition,

1:22:42 still looking towards the 2030 vision.

1:22:45 We also don't have the council's thoughts

1:22:48 and what you see as part of those.

1:22:50 So we've done at least the initial step,

1:22:53 but we do think that there are portions

1:22:55 that we can continue to add into that

1:22:56 to make it more complete.

1:22:59 Do you have any questions?

1:23:05 All right, Bill, I think you're up,

1:23:08 and I'm not sure what needs to happen over here.

1:23:14 Okay, you're on.

1:23:17 Okay, thanks Gretchen.

1:23:20 Again, being sensitive to your time constraints

1:23:25 and assuming there's gonna wanna be some conversation

1:23:29 regarding the questions.

1:23:31 They're kind of baseline direction

1:23:35 And we're going to be seeking from the Council to kind of direct our work as we move forward

1:23:40 with this process.

1:23:43 So Travis indicated there are six questions.

1:23:47 They were basically those that were highlighted in the blue boxes on page 11 of the document

1:23:56 that was circulated with your agenda.

1:23:59 And so I'll run quickly through them and then see if there's any clarification need on the

1:24:05 part of council members and then I understand it will set another time to go into more formal

1:24:13 discussion of the various impacts of the questions here.

1:24:17 So the first one that we pointed out, basically kind of basic, is now the best time to update

1:24:26 the strategic plan.

1:24:27 we've been doing a kind of on a five-year rotation that is something that you're

1:24:33 interested in dedicating time to at this particular time. And then second one is if

1:24:40 we want to proceed with the planning process should that planning horizon be

1:24:47 extended beyond the original 20-30 date provides some interesting challenges and

1:24:54 opportunities to do so, but I think that's a question we want to have some

1:24:58 response from the council to proceed that. If we you want to go beyond that is

1:25:04 2040 the appropriate planning horizon. There are different dates we could

1:25:11 pursue and 2040 seems to be one that might be reasonable but would want to

1:25:18 here from council members on that score. Question number four, should we use the

1:25:25 economics data that was presented to you from Woods and Pool to kind of frame

1:25:33 our information on the dynamics of your population growth. And number five, I

1:25:41 think this is pretty critical, is extensive public outreach required or

1:25:47 can the recent citizen survey and community health survey be used as a guide for the plan

1:25:55 as opposed to going out and generating a whole bunch more new data among the community.

1:26:02 So that's an important question I think you're going to want to weigh in on.

1:26:08 And then finally, should the plan consider regional growth impacts beyond the corporate

1:26:15 limits and what that means for the city. So those are the questions that we had in terms

1:26:23 of kind of the starting gun questions. And so we'd be interested in any clarifications

1:26:31 that you might seek at this point for those questions or are there others there that you'd

1:26:38 want to address it at the next opportunity to kick this around. So that's important for

1:26:46 us to hear your thoughts at this point on those questions. Back to Travis.

1:26:58 I was just going to say, does anybody have any feedback for Phil or are we pretty comfortable

1:27:05 with those questions as they are? Looks like we don't have any further questions Phil.

1:27:14 Okay, thank you, then. That's kind of helps focus our work in terms of moving forward and

1:27:21 what's most important is get the information that will be most useful for

1:27:26 the elected leaders as we move forward the process of your comfortable with that approach then we'll move forward.

1:27:34 So I'm thinking that the first question is a yes

1:27:39 that we think that it's appropriate now to go through a strategic planning effort and that

1:27:45 possibly that initial timeframe needs to be extended beyond 2030 to 2040.

1:27:50 Yeah, not that I don't believe it is the best time.

1:27:54 So my question is, is the question that I thought of was, so what happens if we just say, hey,

1:28:00 let's go to 2030 and then in 2030, what do we do after that step?

1:28:04 What do we do with our strategic plan after that?

1:28:07 Do we create a whole new one or do we, what do we do if we said no?

1:28:14 Yeah, I think that's a great question, so in 2017, we just did a simple, I guess, update.

1:28:24 We maintained the focus areas, we maintained the goals, the objectives, the tasks, and if

1:28:29 we said 2030 is the appropriate timeline, we'd probably follow a similar path.

1:28:34 If we shoot for 2040, it's going to require us a deeper dive, and we're going to ask

1:28:39 the questions.

1:28:41 Do the focus areas largely still make sense, or is there an opportunity to maybe combine

1:28:45 some of those. Because the community of Twin Falls is very, very different today than what

1:28:52 it was when we created the strategic plan. Do those focus areas still make sense? Are there

1:28:58 modifications? What are the goals? And so it really is a very different pathway and the

1:29:08 2040 plan would probably give you, in my opinion, I'd recommend going to a 2040 timeframe or

1:29:15 even longer if that's where you wanted to go.

1:29:20 The seven years isn't a very long planning horizon.

1:29:25 I mean, it seems like a long time from now.

1:29:29 But in all reality, we're constructing a five-year plan

1:29:36 for future budgeting beginning today.

1:29:38 And so our budgeting range right now

1:29:41 will be from fiscal year 25 through fiscal year 30.

1:29:45 And maybe that was my question a little bit,

1:29:47 is if we push it out to 2040, are we kind of going to stay

1:29:52 with some of the categories or not?

1:29:53 Or can we modify those a little bit because of some

1:29:56 of the changes that have happened over the last, say, five years?

1:30:00 Yeah, we believe that there's probably a review

1:30:02 of the focus areas.

1:30:03 We believe that there'll probably be some combination

1:30:06 of those focus areas.

1:30:08 We also believe that some of them will remain largely intact,

1:30:11 right?

1:30:12 the internal organization is always going to be important.

1:30:15 And so some of those things might

1:30:18 like a responsible community and a learning community.

1:30:21 Is there an opportunity to combine those

1:30:23 into a singular focus?

1:30:31 Other thoughts or other questions?

1:30:37 So there's a lot of information that we shared with you today.

1:30:41 And we wanted to stay at about 30,000 feet

1:30:47 with a couple of dips.

1:30:48 We also want to make sure that you are reviewing the data

1:30:53 after today's meeting, understanding the citizen survey.

1:30:57 Understanding, that's essentially how well are we doing?

1:31:01 How are we maximizing the resources that we have

1:31:04 to be able to complete the citizens' goals

1:31:06 and objectives and their tasks?

1:31:09 To create the community that they want.

1:31:11 That's directly connected to the City Strategic Plan,

1:31:15 which is going to be a large piece

1:31:17 of how you're going to fund services and programs

1:31:22 and projects to help further the strategic plan

1:31:28 and help improve the overall sentiment

1:31:34 or the report card of our citizens that we're serving.

1:31:43 There's Phil's email, or excuse me, not Phil's email,

1:31:47 Phil's document that was emailed out

1:31:50 has a lot of information in terms of demographics

1:31:53 and what do we believe the city of Twin Falls is going to be?

1:31:56 And when you think about the size of the city of Twin Falls,

1:32:01 remember the multiplier effect that occurs.

1:32:05 And it is probably going to be at some point greater than two.

1:32:11 Right now, we can safely say that the city of Twin Falls

1:32:14 roughly doubles on a daily basis.

1:32:17 But if all the surrounding communities

1:32:19 continue to grow at the rate in which they are,

1:32:23 that daily multiplier may grow as well.

1:32:27 And so as the City of Twin Falls continues

1:32:29 to provide services, think of a community

1:32:32 if we are 65,000 people by the year 2030,

1:32:38 we might be supplying services to a community

1:32:42 in excess of 130 to 150,000 residents.

1:32:48 And what do we need to be doing in the areas

1:32:52 of accessible community initiatives

1:32:56 to prepare for what that future looks like,

1:32:59 because at 2040, we could be sitting at 80,000 people.

1:33:06 So the idea here is for you to now begin

1:33:12 to think as the elected leadership of the city,

1:33:18 on the priorities the organization needs to take

1:33:22 to realize that community in 2030 or in 2040.

1:33:29 Any questions?

1:33:31 So, Phil, in the remaining, say, five to seven minutes,

1:33:37 do you wanna maybe outline the process

1:33:39 as you see it moving forward as it relates

1:33:43 to workshops, community engagement and process?

1:33:50 Okay, and again, I think you suggested we get together

1:33:55 with the council again as they've had an opportunity

1:33:58 to digest some of the stuff that they've received today

1:34:02 and recognizing this is kind of a serious data dump

1:34:06 that's hard to deal with, but I think,

1:34:10 given some time, I think, to focus on the long range futures

1:34:14 is going to be important.

1:34:17 Then I think working with the leadership team

1:34:24 within the municipal organization

1:34:26 is going to be a critical piece of the puzzle

1:34:28 because they're, the ones are gonna have to put the flesh

1:34:31 on the skeleton as we move forward.

1:34:35 And then looking at whatever in-depth communication

1:34:45 we're going to have with the general public in terms

1:34:49 of trying to understand their response to their expectations

1:34:55 for either 2030 or 2040, depending on the planning horizon

1:34:59 we choose.

1:35:01 And then what we've done before is kind of sweep on that up and bring it back to the council for kind of gut check in terms of, you know, is this what you're seeing out there in the community as well.

1:35:15 And again, what further information are you going to want to have in order to define a, he said a goalpost that you're going to measure yourself against going forward.

1:35:27 So, I think it's going to be an iterative process in terms of involving elected officials, your

1:35:35 executive management team, and then to whatever extent you feel it's critical important to

1:35:43 have a broad-based conversation with the public, either in terms of community workshops or a

1:35:50 a series of interviews with the T-stakeholders and your partners in terms of achieving these

1:35:58 goals.

1:35:59 So it's going to be a fairly significant work product, but again, one that will have the

1:36:06 council directly involved with as we go forward.

1:36:10 Everyone's good to go.

1:36:25 Okay.

1:36:26 All right.

1:36:27 He has requested just a couple of minutes and then at that adjourned because I'll be the conclusion

1:36:35 of the workshop and the materials that have been posted.

1:36:44 I hope you guys are like not asleep or overwhelmed with all that information.

1:36:52 So back in October Gretchen sent me an email asking me what I planned to do for new council

1:36:57 members and I, if she could have seen me, I was a deer in headlights.

1:37:02 I had no idea what she was talking about.

1:37:05 So we had several meetings on the information

1:37:09 that we needed to present to the new council members.

1:37:11 And we didn't want to leave anybody out

1:37:13 because I don't think we did this

1:37:15 for the prior new council members.

1:37:18 So, and Cena graciously put together some binders

1:37:23 that has lots and lots of information in it.

1:37:28 It has the department heads, pictures of them, phone numbers, contact information, our strategic plan.

1:37:37 It's just a great resource and I want to give it to the two new members, got it during orientation

1:37:43 and I want to have one out to each of the other council members.

1:38:09 Also on page 73 of your report are the demographics.

1:38:13 Okay. So, interestingly, about 32% of the respondents have lived here less than five years.

1:38:17 So, I guess I officially need to adjourn the meeting, meetings adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, January 29, 2024. The recording started at 11:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:38:50.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    a2ff82276520b6fc33d2e789b88b162e95e5d64cf4648e4b24f721846cbe8d78
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 829e422b762b2e13cf4f475e5cd973ec292d70af82cee5a2dbd0507119904dd0
    part02.m4a 2ca82ceda9158e76b16364b517710d57ec365abd76547cc71f6992c1b77b373f
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    fec4f10f7d5f1fc7903ec15a6213f3ec141d8982a3db61ecab829d19049f8cfa

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file