OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Tuesday, January 16, 2024

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:01:48 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the

0:01:52 Tuesday January 16th, 2024 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum

0:01:59 We have six members present in chambers and vice mayor Brown is excused tonight

0:02:06 So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise

0:02:12 Thank you. We have no

0:02:31 So on to the consent calendar, Council wishes.

0:02:36 Thank you to have a second.

0:02:44 Craig Hawkins.

0:02:45 Thank you.

0:02:47 Motion by Chris Reed second by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar as written.

0:02:54 Amy roll call vote please.

0:02:56 Yes.

0:02:57 Yes.

0:03:00 Yes.

0:03:01 Yes.

0:03:02 Yes.

0:03:03 Yes.

0:03:04 Yes.

0:03:05 Yes.

0:03:06 Yes.

0:03:07 Yes.

0:03:09 Thank you. Motion passes six to zero.

0:03:12 So if you were here for the Canyon Ram and the Soccer Tournament,

0:03:17 the August Magic Valley Beer Festival, the Rock Paper Scissors, Downtown Farmers Market,

0:03:24 and a donation for Senway Soccer Complex, those have all been improved.

0:03:32 So next on to items of consideration, the first item is an action item.

0:03:38 Consideration of a request to authorized staff to enter into contract negotiations for software and services with BS and A software with the understanding that the springbrook cloud is identified as a contingency option in the event of substantial scope changes and we have Kathy Marcus our IT director welcome Kathy.

0:04:01 For those of you that don't know me, I'm the IT manager for the City of Twin Falls.

0:04:08 I'm here in place of Brianna Howard, who is out on leave right now. She has been preparing and working

0:04:15 hard to replace our existing software that we use for finance, for payroll, for UB, so it's all

0:04:22 of our enterprise resource planning software. We have gone through the process of first getting

0:04:28 Council approval, as you may recall, if you were on the agenda,

0:04:33 Rana brought in abacusis for you, and you got to see that outdated equipment gets you where you

0:04:39 need to be, but it's a little bit slower than the current day equipment that we have available.

0:04:44 Our package that we are currently using for software is over 20 years old, and so it's time to upgrade.

0:04:51 We went through an RFP process, and during that process, we had several vendors that submitted

0:04:57 their proposals for a solution and through the process we had many city

0:05:03 employees sit through demonstrations and then there was a subcommittee of

0:05:08 Gretchen Scott, Brianna Howard, Cynthia Torres, Matthew and Terry, Matthew Hicks

0:05:14 and Terry Thusen traded off and then me representing IT who reviewed all the

0:05:19 software and reviewed all the comments that people had made and we came and we

0:05:23 scored according to the RFP guidelines. At the end of the day, the SNA came up the best score,

0:05:32 so we would like to enter into negotiation and contract with them. We also would like to have

0:05:39 the contingency that if for some reason the contract doesn't work out the way that we are

0:05:44 hoping it will, that we have the option to use the Springbrook cloud as a backup option.

0:05:49 And so with that, I am open for any questions.

0:05:54 Any questions for Kathy tonight?

0:06:00 Christine?

0:06:01 Understanding that our old system is very old.

0:06:06 What are some of the upgrades going to be with this new system?

0:06:10 One of the things that I like the best when I saw it is that we have the ability

0:06:15 when we're entering budget numbers.

0:06:17 It actually shows the grid of the past three years budget amounts that you have,

0:06:21 what was spent and so that you could tell how much you need to budget for the current year.

0:06:26 And they do that throughout the system where they have information displayed available for you

0:06:30 to make your decisions with graphs that are actually in the data instead of what we do right now as we

0:06:35 get spreadsheets sent to us and we go through the spreadsheets and compare the data. They also,

0:06:40 Brianna's favorite feature was that you could search across the whole platform instead of having

0:06:47 to go into each module and search, so if you're looking for Springbrook, say, who are current

0:06:52 vendors, if you're looking for Springbrook, you would have to look in the AP module and

0:06:56 then you'd have to look in the HR module and then you'd have to go through all the different

0:07:00 modules. It also has fully customizable dashboards, so each person can customize their dashboard

0:07:09 to those things that they do, so a utility billing clerk doesn't have to see the same things

0:07:13 is that a finance director will see.

0:07:16 So you compare it down to just what they want to see.

0:07:19 It also has a notification system.

0:07:23 So kind of like Laserfish where it tells you

0:07:25 there's something in your box that you have to complete.

0:07:28 And so that's another added feature.

0:07:30 It's cloud-based instead of on-premise.

0:07:33 So all the updates will be performed by the company,

0:07:38 which will be another added benefit

0:07:40 what we'll keep up to date and not have to use IT resources to do that.

0:07:44 They have 30 years of experience, so they've been around for a while, and they're just a

0:07:49 lot more intuitive and simple to use, and they actually present data to us instead of us having

0:07:56 to dig it out in the background.

0:07:59 Perfect, thank you.

0:08:01 And Kathy, I understand that you did talk to some current users.

0:08:05 We did, they had wonderful things to say about the S&E software, which we didn't find

0:08:10 with the other vendors, so it was very comforting and actually one of the vendors we spoke to

0:08:17 had their data or one of the customers we spoke to had their data also converted from

0:08:22 Springbrook, and they said it was a wonderful, easy conversion process, which was very promising

0:08:28 to hear also.

0:08:29 That's great.

0:08:30 Any other questions for Kathy?

0:08:32 I'll make a motion if we're right.

0:08:35 Yes.

0:08:36 I move that we approve the request to authorize staff to enter into a contract negotiations

0:08:41 with software and services with BS and A software with the understanding that spring

0:08:46 book cloud will be identified as a contingency option.

0:08:52 Grace and Stone?

0:08:53 I will second the motion.

0:08:54 Thank you.

0:08:55 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Grace and Stone to authorize staff to enter into contract

0:09:01 negotiations for software and services with the S&A software with the

0:09:06 understanding that springbook cloud is identified as a contingency option. Any

0:09:12 further discussion? Amy Roll call vote please.

0:09:17 Chris Reed. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes.

0:09:21 Grayson Stone. Yes. Harry Bolmer. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes

0:09:28 six to zero. Thank you, Kathy. So, Amy, they're not getting the vote questions, so you might

0:09:41 work on that. Okay, next on the agenda is an action item. Consider a recommendation from

0:09:47 the Parks and Rec Commission to name the trailhead located at the corner of Poland and Eastland,

0:09:54 Canyon Trail Junction, and we have Wendy Davis, Director of Parks and Rec. Good afternoon, Wendy.

0:10:01 Good evening. Good afternoon. Evening, Mayor and Council. I'm excited to come forward with the first part of this naming process. If you recall in December, I approached Council. We got on a request from Chobani contingent on their donation about the opportunity to name the sub element of this space.

0:10:25 Subsequently, we have gone forward with the Parks and Recreation Commission to recommend a name for the overall space.

0:10:33 So this would be the entire area that Chobotty is then going to name the exercise park area adjacent to the parking lot in this space.

0:10:45 And I recognized as I was trying to get the staff report, so I had my notes that there's no staff report in your packet.

0:10:54 I'll walk you through this a little more than I normally would so that everybody's on the same page.

0:10:59 So typically, the naming policy designates the Parks and Recreation Commission as the entity

0:11:07 to review recommended names and make a recommendation to council.

0:11:14 In the event that there isn't a name that's brought forward by a citizen or by the community

0:11:20 or something, the Parks and Recreation Commission is also entitled to initiate a naming process

0:11:27 as can Council.

0:11:29 So you could say we need a name for this and then the Commission can go figure out how they

0:11:33 want to name it and then come back with a recommendation on a name.

0:11:38 In this particular instance, the Commission initiated the naming process by recognizing

0:11:49 that referring to a constantly as the Pauline Eastland Trailhead, and previously the Preserve

0:11:54 Trailhead, we needed a real name to attach to to create some space, place making, and a

0:12:00 good reference as we move forward. Plus, give Chobani something to work with as they're looking

0:12:06 at the name that they want to push forward for the internal piece. All that said, that's

0:12:12 kind of where we are now in the process. So, obviously, we need to consider it to be a

0:12:18 a permanent name. Typically, I was kind of laughing, because Mitch always teases the Parks Department

0:12:24 historically for naming things after streets or subdivisions or something adjacent. But

0:12:29 when I read the policy, it says that we will use neighborhood or geographical identification,

0:12:36 Harrison and Morningston, different places. Maybe that's why they did it. So a geographical

0:12:44 feature or something that's relevant to the space are the things that we need to take into consideration.

0:12:50 And with that the Parks and Recreation Commission deliberated on several different names, they chose

0:12:57 not to take this to a public naming process, figured that we've been talking about it long enough,

0:13:03 they had some time to reach out to their constituents, friends, whatever, to see if people had thoughts

0:13:09 on the name and came forward with, we landed on the Canyon Trail Junction and they thought

0:13:17 that did a nice job of kind of combining the fact that it's an intersection of spaces and

0:13:26 a place right there on the corner and they liked the term junction rather than trailheads

0:13:30 so it's kind of where they landed for the name.

0:13:35 At this point, I'm here asking for your approval of the recommendation of the Kenyan name, Kenyan

0:13:45 trail junction to be placed on that space over there at the corner.

0:13:51 I think you all have access to the naming policy.

0:13:54 I don't think there's anything else in my staff report that's really important to this

0:14:03 conversation right now.

0:14:04 Do you have any questions?

0:14:05 questions. Is this clear what we're doing and why?

0:14:08 It's Spencer Cutler.

0:14:11 Thank you, Mayor. Yeah, just quick clarification. So a portion of this park area is going to be named with reference to Chobani and their donation with the trailhead portion. And so we're going to have like in this one area, a couple different names.

0:14:26 names. So if you think about Carter Gibb Field at Frontier Park or First

0:14:34 Federal Park at Sunway, J.C. Field or Cowboy Field at Harmon, I mean we have

0:14:42 elements within parks that are named specifically within a bigger thing. So

0:14:47 this is the umbrella name of the entire space and then Shabani will come back

0:14:51 with a request to name the fitness area.

0:14:56 That makes sense.

0:14:57 Does that make sense?

0:14:58 Yes.

0:14:59 Thank you.

0:15:00 Any other questions for Wendy?

0:15:01 Do you have any comments?

0:15:07 I'd just like to say we're working with Wendy on that.

0:15:11 We really discussed this pretty thoroughly.

0:15:14 Trailhead always kind of implies that this is the beginning of the trail and it's really

0:15:18 not.

0:15:19 And there were a number of other names that were presented, but I think we all agreed that the junction fit probably the best.

0:15:28 I think that we're really comfortable with that.

0:15:32 So.

0:15:33 Thank you.

0:15:34 Chris Street.

0:15:35 I'll make the motion.

0:15:37 Perfect.

0:15:38 And move that we approve the recommendation from Parks and Rec.

0:15:40 The Parks and Rec Commission to name the trailhead location at the corner of Pole Line and Eastland.

0:15:49 and then we'll move on to the

0:15:53 second motion.

0:15:54 Thank you.

0:15:55 Thank you.

0:15:56 Thank you.

0:15:57 We have a motion by Christopher

0:15:58 Reed.

0:15:59 Second by Sherry Vomer to approve

0:16:00 the recommendation from the

0:16:01 Parks and Rec Commission to name

0:16:02 the trailhead located at

0:16:04 Polite in Eastland Canyon Trail

0:16:06 Junction.

0:16:07 Any further discussion?

0:16:08 Amy Rocha,

0:16:09 please.

0:16:11 Greg Hawkins?

0:16:12 Yes.

0:16:13 Spencer Cutler?

0:16:14 Yes.

0:16:15 Grayson Stone?

0:16:16 Yes.

0:16:17 Yes.

0:16:18 Ruth Pierce?

0:16:19 Yes.

0:16:20 Great.

0:16:21 Thank you.

0:16:22 Motion passes 6-0.

0:16:23 Thank you.

0:16:24 Thank you.

0:16:26 Thank you.

0:16:27 Okay.

0:16:28 Next item on the agenda is an action item requested for required improvements for building permit

0:16:35 22-0100 due to exceptional hardship.

0:16:40 Cara Brooke Redmond on behalf of Rob Green Hyundai.

0:16:44 We have Jonathan Spennelow, our, uh,

0:16:47 Hiding and Sony director. Welcome, Jonathan.

0:16:51 Thank you. May I remember the council give me a second? Will I bring up some items?

0:17:04 Actually download the agenda to my, to this computer yet. So, okay, you're good.

0:17:09 One second. So you saw this item last week.

0:17:22 It was placed on the agenda by the council to bring back an update of where we are.

0:17:32 Get to that spot. It's quite a ways back in there.

0:17:35 It's probably down aways.

0:17:37 You might want to start at the end and go backwards.

0:17:45 OK.

0:17:47 I'll go over the background very briefly.

0:17:50 As it's in the packet, 27 to get a final inspection request.

0:17:55 The department completed those on the 28th.

0:17:59 The request for the final inspection

0:18:00 was denied for the five reasons up there.

0:18:04 While you're on site, there were some other sections

0:18:09 that are required.

0:18:10 We also notified the owner of this provision, which is entitled 10, zoning title, zoning development

0:18:17 or zoning and subdivision title is technically what it's called.

0:18:21 And there is a provision for a deferral.

0:18:25 Whenever a building is constructed, place rector during large, and that building is in

0:18:28 an isolated or undeveloped area, then new idea or thought or in cases of exceptional hardship

0:18:35 improvements may be deferred by the council in cases where deferral would otherwise be unavailable.

0:18:41 The list of items in history are contained in the attachments. The owner through the attorney

0:18:53 recruitment provided this list which you would have seen which was in the packet. It has certain

0:19:01 dates for the 17 items that are on there. I wasn't going to go through those one by one

0:19:08 as it was provided to you previously. There were also some emails, correspondence with the

0:19:14 engineer of record for the project, which you would have seen as well. We wrote them asking

0:19:22 or kind of identifying these items with the plan that we have here. We did receive a plan back from

0:19:29 the engineer. I can bring that up here. I'm not going to show the whole thing, but we did receive

0:19:43 some drawings from the owner or the engineer, Dan Sharpe.

0:19:48 At this time, I will report that this plan,

0:19:52 it was provided to us on the last Friday,

0:19:56 I don't know if that was the 11th of the 12th.

0:19:59 It was on Friday.

0:20:00 We, being the engineering department,

0:20:03 exerted a lot of effort today to go through this plan

0:20:05 to see if we could approve it.

0:20:07 And at this point, we would not be able to approve this plan

0:20:10 as it was provided to us.

0:20:13 there is a discrepancy in issue with the stormwater calculation and a few other items.

0:20:20 Wasn't going to get in that level of detail.

0:20:22 I leave that up to the engineers to deal with and to handle.

0:20:26 But I can tell you that we did get it.

0:20:27 We also took a site visit today, our engineering inspectors.

0:20:34 And these are the photos that we took at approximately four o'clock today on the property.

0:20:39 I will go through these just quickly for you since this is the information we have.

0:20:44 I know it snowed quite a bit, so this is along blue lakes.

0:20:48 Approximately the location where the ADA access would be

0:20:52 is somewhere in here.

0:20:56 This would be the portion looking towards blue lakes now

0:20:59 is where the semi truck is, obviously.

0:21:01 There would be an ADA accessibility location here.

0:21:06 Again, looking towards the building,

0:21:07 it would front along these vehicles.

0:21:12 And then around this spot, take a left turn

0:21:14 and go to the front of the building.

0:21:17 We've identified this area being lower,

0:21:20 and potentially not having the grade

0:21:22 that would meet the EDA standard for slopes.

0:21:26 We've identified that with the engineer record.

0:21:29 As you've progressed down,

0:21:30 it's just taking pictures of the location.

0:21:36 I'm gonna go back one page.

0:21:39 Per the design of what we see

0:21:40 or what's actually happened here,

0:21:43 all of the water that is generated by this parking lot

0:21:47 appears the slope comes down this area,

0:21:51 what we call sheet drains across the parking lot,

0:21:53 and enters into a location back here.

0:21:56 And basically goes either the elevation of the asphalt

0:21:58 to like a gutter and then just goes towards the back

0:22:01 to that pond or the stormwater pond

0:22:03 that's gonna be in the back.

0:22:05 That's how this water gets to this point over here.

0:22:08 That's how the stormwater's supposed to work,

0:22:10 or that's how it was built.

0:22:13 As we progress through the pictures,

0:22:15 this is showing a little bit of the elevation difference

0:22:17 where that ADA ramp or the ADA accessibility spots

0:22:19 gonna go up.

0:22:22 This is towards the south of the building, now we're looking east to the back of the property

0:22:27 and these are residential homes towards the back.

0:22:31 This is their additional parking area.

0:22:34 That is where the pavement is going to be, behind.

0:22:38 We're just taking pictures of the site and how it drains from the building down towards

0:22:43 where the storm water is going to be conveyed along the southern area or southern boundary

0:22:47 of the property.

0:22:50 This is where the storm water from the front of the building is going to come.

0:22:54 There's going to be, there is a valley gutter in here that terminates around this area.

0:22:59 From that point on, it is gravel, according to what we had previously, in the gravel area

0:23:06 within progress further east to this location.

0:23:11 All the storm water from the front of the building gets to this point.

0:23:16 We are unsure that the elevation works for this storm water to get to the pond.

0:23:20 I'm also using gravel and dirt to convey it is difficult to manage and difficult to improve

0:23:26 as a stormwater plan.

0:23:30 This is the looking south, just ending that parking area that's over here.

0:23:37 This is where the stormwater progresses to this point.

0:23:43 Stormwater from the front of the property gets to this point.

0:23:45 The pond is actually behind these two piles of construction items or construction materials

0:23:52 in behind this piece of equipment.

0:23:54 This is the concrete and asphalt crusher corridor.

0:24:00 This general location would be where the garbage

0:24:05 or the trash enclosure would be.

0:24:07 The trash dumpsters are there now.

0:24:10 These are the residential homes towards the east.

0:24:14 This is the area that's to be paved

0:24:16 and some items and some things that are between

0:24:19 the stormwater location and where the stormwater pond

0:24:21 would be, which is making our way towards that pond,

0:24:25 which is behind that piece of equipment.

0:24:30 This is the pond.

0:24:33 I'm gonna outline it here.

0:24:37 The elevation is up here, and then it slopes down,

0:24:40 and this is the bottom.

0:24:42 There's a portion here that's been dug out,

0:24:44 and then it follows this along here,

0:24:47 comes down, and goes back.

0:24:51 And I'll show a picture of the plan after this,

0:24:55 so you can kind of identify this is where it's located.

0:24:58 We believe there's a pipe that has been placed underground to get the water on the north side

0:25:02 of the addition building to get here, hasn't been inspected by us yet, and then the stormwater

0:25:09 from the south side was supposed to sheet drain around and then enter somewhere in the south

0:25:15 portion of this area, and that's where the back of the pond goes down in here, and this

0:25:23 is the piece of equipment we were looking at, and the pile of construction debris or items.

0:25:36 This is where we believe there's a gutter or a valley gutter on the north side of the building

0:25:39 that conveys some of the water from the addition.

0:25:41 This is a bit further north than the Hyundai.

0:25:44 Now we're behind the Nissan which is a sister store just adjacent.

0:25:49 This water conveys down this valley gutter.

0:25:52 We believe we'll then go towards the pond.

0:25:56 We don't know how it gets to the pond at this point.

0:25:59 That's just a picture of the gutter, another area towards the back.

0:26:08 we're looking south, the pond would be over there. This is towards the north end of the pond,

0:26:18 until it goes a little bit further off to the left, and those houses towards the east

0:26:23 upon his back here. That was just the north side of the building. So the navigate through this one,

0:26:37 get to that side. On is to be here. This was the existing prior to construction,

0:26:46 and what this gutter was going to look like. I believe that was it. It's hard to see the actual

0:26:55 elevation of the pond being back in here. Our at this point the concern the

0:27:07 engineering department has is the water from the front getting to this valley

0:27:10 gutter and having no way to convey that water from this point back through what's

0:27:16 in this area there's items between there. Currently this plan shows parking

0:27:24 stopping and some either a gutter or some other way there'll be some things

0:27:29 in peeding that water from getting to the pond.

0:27:32 That we don't have a plan on how that's going to work yet.

0:27:37 This latest revision did not answer that question.

0:27:39 I'm going to go back to this point.

0:27:59 You have conveyed the information we have today where we are on the site and on the council

0:28:10 in terms of approving this and how you navigate this, it is a simple motion and majority of

0:28:15 the council.

0:28:16 I've included a sample motion. There is one thing I need to bring to your attention in conversations

0:28:23 with Bruce. It is to identify the exceptional hardship. I need a bar by which people are going

0:28:31 to look at this decision to meet. We've had some conversations with builders and developers,

0:28:38 and I say like two. They're looking at this decision. They're noting that it will be a,

0:28:44 say a bar would be something to be placed at to look at if they wanted to

0:28:51 proceed to do the same thing. We need to have that exceptional hardship defined

0:28:57 or at least identified in the situation. That's why I left that with an underline.

0:29:02 And then I gave you the whole list of everything essentially that those asked

0:29:09 for and some right in like right one through seventeen and then the certain

0:29:13 dates that would be inserted by you and I'll help you navigate whatever I can or

0:29:19 answer any questions that you have at this point. Is there anything looking at

0:29:23 others? I have a lot of things in my head that I'm trying to remember to bring up.

0:29:26 I think I covered it. Thank you Jonathan. Grayson Stone. Yeah,

0:29:33 Director Spindel, I have a couple questions. First of all regarding the

0:29:38 engineering drawings, we mentioned there were quite a few discrepancies. What is

0:29:43 preventing engineering from passing on that plan and then the second question is

0:29:46 of those 17 items I know we were going back and forth a little bit on this last

0:29:52 week of those 17 items identified as staff identified any of those as life

0:29:59 safety issues. So in terms of the drawing we did a comprehensive look today we have

0:30:04 we just finished it probably around 430 in what our look at look was the ADA

0:30:11 accessibility route is not here. It's not been installed. We know that.

0:30:16 Additionally, the elevations identified on the plan and what was constructed, we

0:30:22 believe in order to meet the slopes per the ADA Act, they're gonna have to raise

0:30:26 the elevation of this asphalt because this area is quite a few feet, like two

0:30:31 to three and a half feet below the level up here and you just don't have enough

0:30:36 room. So if you raise that area to meet that route, there's going to be an issue with water

0:30:44 from the front sheet draining down. That's what the engineering departments identified

0:30:48 for that one. We are unsure if the stormwater calculations took this into account. I don't

0:30:58 know how much to, it was a late change or a late piece of information on the stormwater

0:31:05 calculation. It was performed by a different engineer than the one that stamped this plan.

0:31:11 We're trying to work through the discrepancy between the two engineers, one that stamped

0:31:16 the stormwater calculation versus the one that designed the site. We have not gotten to

0:31:22 the bottom of that part yet. We are worried about there's no elevations here in terms of

0:31:28 how does the water get from this point to the pond back here with this drawing. There's no pipe,

0:31:34 there's no elevation to confirm that and how does it sheet drain across the dirt

0:31:38 that's there there's those are a few did I miss one for it I think those are the

0:31:43 major ones in terms of your list anything that's associated with handling

0:31:51 stormwater well potentially no one's life might be lost it certainly could be

0:31:57 damaging to property so that's why we consider it a safety issue it may not be

0:32:02 life safety but it's certainly a property safety issue with neighbors

0:32:05 that are to the east and other different property owners to the south. The building

0:32:10 that is placed there now has an elevation that's raised so this building is not, we

0:32:16 don't believe will be harmed, we don't know that for sure. The engineer of record is

0:32:20 one responsible. We don't know where the storm water is going to go because the

0:32:24 plan that they provided on Friday isn't is in approval at this point.

0:32:29 In terms of life safety, anything that deals with the storm water and how to get

0:32:33 there. That's probably your safety concerns. The landscaping, trash enclosure,

0:32:39 the accessibility I guess we could discuss whether that's a safety reason

0:32:43 for some people I think it would be. The rest of this, some of this is really

0:32:48 stormwater issue. These other things are just smaller. Like the transformer

0:32:54 protection that's not really our utility, we just don't think it's a good idea. The

0:32:58 water meter replacement was a design that they had on their plan that just hasn't

0:33:01 done yet. Some of those things or just things we require normally with the

0:33:08 building permit to be done. I don't know if that answered your question around

0:33:13 about life. Oh, I did. Thank you. Questions? Chris Reed. I know you said you

0:33:23 didn't want to go through each item. Understanding that we're going to be

0:33:29 making a ruling tonight. What code governs each one of these though

0:33:38 So understanding that I look at landscaping, that's something that the city has decided

0:33:42 to put upon the people of the city when they build, that's something that we did.

0:33:50 You have a governing body of the city, state, and then national.

0:33:55 Could you go through those?

0:33:58 Yeah.

0:33:59 And the reason I say that is there's heartburn when her legal reasons, when we go against those

0:34:06 that are above us.

0:34:09 a huge concern to me. If the state has put something on us and then nationally there's

0:34:14 something on top of that, that's where I'm concerned that we're going to get ourselves

0:34:19 into a lot of trouble if there is a problem.

0:34:22 Okay. Okay. Best way to figure out an answer. One, two are local. Three, the accessibility

0:34:30 is that's the ADA Act, United States government requirement, but the state puts on us to get

0:34:36 when we have a building permit.

0:34:38 We're supposed to review those and inspect those.

0:34:42 I don't know what our liability is.

0:34:44 I'm not an attorney on that one, but it's certainly

0:34:46 that everybody has to do that no matter what.

0:34:49 Number four is a stormwater issue,

0:34:54 but it's not creating any more.

0:34:56 It's just how the stormwater is being directed

0:34:57 in which way it's going to go.

0:35:00 Stormwater is ours, but also of being

0:35:03 part of the state floodplain group.

0:35:06 The state expects us to handle the stormwater in the right way.

0:35:09 So that would be a combination of both governing bodies.

0:35:12 So four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10 are combination state local.

0:35:22 If you create hard surface parking, it creates more stormwater.

0:35:29 So you have to deal with it.

0:35:30 Some areas are not required to be hard surface.

0:35:32 If you don't use them, 11 is just there's construction stuff out there.

0:35:37 out there, everything is more like a connective construction site, it's just a safety thing,

0:35:41 not really ours. The light pole is a requirement local, 13 I believe would be a local. 14 was

0:35:52 requested by them and that's more of a local but it's a water system so if they're going to change

0:35:56 the water stuff we have to do we have to work with them and that one's not really a it's more

0:36:02 of a clarification on the plan. Okay. 15 the same thing, 16 same thing kind of stormwater but more

0:36:09 of a clarification 17 is not ours at all really it's just a electric transformer

0:36:15 that we think can have flood potentially. It's not our requirements not our

0:36:20 electricity but it's just a form of the site that we noticed and let the

0:36:24 engineer record know. But that's summarize it quickly enough I guess.

0:36:28 Yeah it did thank you. So Jonathan back to these plans

0:36:42 when you say we don't know I'm so I'm a bean counter right I'm not an

0:36:48 engineer so I may ask some really stupid questions but when you say we don't know

0:36:53 we're not sure typically what you do is you have to approve this plan and stamp

0:36:59 it because I noticed the other one was city engineer stamped at some point in

0:37:04 time right keep going we only review the plan we do not we do not ensure that it

0:37:13 works we review it to make sure that it's complies our standard the engineer of

0:37:18 record it's the person down here on the bottom right as well it's responsible

0:37:21 for the plan but we review it to make sure it meets our standards and at this

0:37:25 point in time it doesn't meet our standards that's correct okay thank you

0:37:29 Spencer thanks mayor it's really easy to get drawn into the details of

0:37:35 construction and design which I mean that's my tendency I'm not pointing at

0:37:40 anybody but I keep reminding myself the main question is before the council is

0:37:45 this an exceptional hardship and that is the issue that we need to be debating is

0:37:49 is this exceptional hardship is this unique to challenges that other contractors

0:37:54 or owners are facing or not facing and so yeah that's that's where we're at the

0:38:00 point thank you buddy I think out loud or it goes back to are we meeting the

0:38:22 standard for an exceptional hardship. I mean, I know Bruce shared some stuff with us. Travis,

0:38:33 do you have any comments? Okay, okay. Jonathan, either.

0:38:38 I'm going to ask our attorney a question, understanding exceptional hardship. That's what we are talking

0:38:47 about here. If there's an issue with water, because we said that there's an exceptional hardship

0:38:54 to Jonathan's point earlier on his presentation, there's snow outside. I'm not an engineer,

0:39:02 laying concrete, doing a lot of this kind of stuff probably isn't going to happen right

0:39:05 now. If there's an issue with flooding, and we said, yes, not a problem, you know, there's

0:39:14 an exceptional hardship. Where legally does this council, does this city lie in saying,

0:39:23 yeah, you had an exceptional hardship and now all of a sudden all of those individuals

0:39:28 behind them. Again, I don't know. I'm not an engineer. I'm not saying that. Their basements

0:39:32 are full of water or it's in the middle of the road because it didn't run off properly.

0:39:37 Legally, where is the city putting itself? If we say yes, that's fine and it's not.

0:39:44 You're going to get to come down to the microphone.

0:39:48 So I think in evaluating all of the information you have in front of you, hardship should

0:40:05 be a plain term that you understand. Given the circumstances, the surrounding things and

0:40:11 the purposes of having all these things required and why. We're pulling up the code really quick.

0:40:20 Okay. Take a look at it. I think given the plain language, you all have it in front of you,

0:40:33 that code section without directing you any which way or that. I think as long as you articulate

0:40:42 the reason and purpose, if you do believe or you don't believe there is a hardship, I think

0:40:49 that's the question you're trying to answer. So that was the legal way of

0:40:53 answering your question. Did I answer it for you? No, no. I just want to know what

0:41:02 type of liability if something goes sideways and all of a sudden there's

0:41:07 property damage there whatever type of damage there is because of this. Number

0:41:13 three somebody's trying to get in is not able to file as a complaint as a city.

0:41:20 So I think yes, what are we doing to ourselves?

0:41:25 So there's a trickle down effect.

0:41:27 So Jonathan put forward some good words earlier

0:41:32 that these are the requirements that we have for life safety

0:41:37 meeting our requirements.

0:41:39 These are the things that we can enforce against them.

0:41:43 But also keep in mind that this is someone's private property.

0:41:46 They are coming to the city for a permit

0:41:48 to make sure they are in compliance

0:41:50 with all of those laws and statutes.

0:41:53 I'll be it while it is private property.

0:41:56 I think it would come down to a civil suit

0:41:59 or a civil issue, I should say, not a suit.

0:42:01 No one likes that word.

0:42:03 With that property owner,

0:42:04 and that's why we wanna make sure

0:42:05 that they come into compliance, I don't know.

0:42:11 I think and I'm just, it deserves an honorary law degree.

0:42:16 I think in terms of liability,

0:42:18 that's a longer term question

0:42:20 that the city should speak about,

0:42:22 but in terms of what our requirements are,

0:42:24 it is to make sure that, again,

0:42:27 we limit those liabilities for both persons

0:42:31 within the community and private businesses

0:42:34 that are trying to come into compliance.

0:42:36 So again, when you look at this definition,

0:42:39 I think it would be helpful for the council

0:42:42 to take a look at it, list out those things

0:42:45 that are maybe a burden or in the way,

0:42:47 or even if the permit or the applicant is here

0:42:52 to even give comment, should you decide to ask them questions

0:42:55 to help you evaluate the totality of that?

0:42:59 That may be helpful.

0:43:01 Perhaps articulating those things.

0:43:06 Did that better answer your question?

0:43:09 Yes, I didn't go to law school and I'm smart enough

0:43:19 to know that I shouldn't play attorney.

0:43:22 I was gonna do something fairly,

0:43:25 I think that I were in your position.

0:43:29 I would ask legal counsel,

0:43:32 but Linda should probably start walking her way back out.

0:43:35 I would ask legal counsel as to whether or not

0:43:40 granting occupancy to this building

0:43:44 increases the liability to the city of Twin Falls.

0:43:49 Because I think at the end of the day,

0:43:51 what the request is, is to work through

0:43:59 exceptional hardships with the end purpose of granting

0:44:05 occupancy, temporary occupancy, so that they can enter the facility

0:44:12 and then, if approved, work through that timeline as submitted

0:44:20 on those 17 items.

0:44:33 But because I think you're in a quasi-judicial form, I think that someone really does need

0:44:36 to ask the question that I posed to the council in the

0:44:40 back that you are truly interested in learning that answer.

0:44:43 Jason, did you want to speak?

0:44:47 Yeah, that was actually my first follow-up question was how much liability does the city

0:44:53 put on their shoulders by granting this DCO versus the private landowner?

0:44:58 That is a very good question.

0:44:59 And I think that I had with Jonathan is that really nothing would ever prevent someone

0:45:07 from attempting to sue the city.

0:45:09 It's really about whose role and responsibility is at the end of the day.

0:45:14 Ultimately, it's probably the belief that it lies on the homeowner, but something also to consider.

0:45:20 When you're granting just an occupation permit and you're going to be in a piece of property,

0:45:27 by saying yes, you can be there knowing that something's not done, someone is damaged, it's a problem.

0:45:33 So the question may still remain possibly, but I think it's also

0:45:39 circumstantially based and we can't know all the outcomes

0:45:48 But a piggyback off that and finish my thought I'm really going back and forth on this and and

0:45:57 Councilman color the reason I asked specifically about the plans was to figure out if if there were discrepancies that were creating more quote-unquote life safety issues

0:46:05 On one hand we are opening Pandora's box should we grant this?

0:46:09 And we are setting a new precedent and raising that bar that director spent that was talking about

0:46:14 On the other hand, there's also, it sounds like, 30 people waiting to go back to work that are probably going to sit there and twiddle their thumbs until all this gets done and whether it's just simply not going to be permitted to be done correctly.

0:46:28 So I'm kind of going back and forth on that.

0:46:32 Director Spinnlove, can we tie a TCO to February date, February 15th, because that seems to

0:46:44 be the only issue that's closely related to life safety, is that storm water retention

0:46:50 in the city's eyes, correct?

0:46:55 Yeah, so what this talks about is the route to swale being done by February 15th.

0:47:02 But for that to be approved, we have to verify that all the piping's been put in place from

0:47:06 The west side of the building to the east side and everything's flowing appropriately.

0:47:08 Yeah, if you were to go through this process, identify the hardship and say that we believe

0:47:13 there's hardship and then we'll grant a deferral for all things not associated with the stormwater

0:47:20 system to function correctly.

0:47:24 When the stormwater system was finished and approved for the city engineer and their team,

0:47:29 we could then issue the TCO with all the other items being deferred.

0:47:34 If that's the way you want to go, I would hook all the stormwater system together to make

0:47:39 sure that it functions properly.

0:47:40 Which is 4 through 10.

0:47:42 Yeah, most of those things have, like some of them are done, we just need to plan to

0:47:45 reflect some of these things.

0:47:47 Yeah.

0:47:48 But in my head, right, that swale is really the only thing.

0:47:52 In my opinion, everything else is just a punchless item.

0:47:55 I think people could go back to work.

0:47:57 So that's where I'm at, but I'm looking forward to hearing everybody else's thoughts.

0:48:02 So again, just to be clear, even though item 9 is the stormwater retention swale, February

0:48:11 15th, you're saying items 4 through 10 are all tied to that stormwater issue, correct?

0:48:19 Yeah, all of these things have to work together to get the water to the stormwater swale.

0:48:24 So you can't do item 9 without doing the others, basically.

0:48:31 I'm not a builder, sorry.

0:48:33 Yes, where I'm kind of just talking about stormwater system,

0:48:36 just to deal with the stormwater created on the property

0:48:38 and get it to the soil, whatever that number or items

0:48:42 look like because this list was based off of the previous plan

0:48:47 we had, and now we have a new drawing.

0:48:49 I just say the stormwater system.

0:48:51 And I hand that to the engineering team

0:48:54 to deal with it, because they're the ones that kind of review it

0:48:57 and inspect it.

0:49:00 I don't know if that helps or not.

0:49:02 But yeah, four through ten are all dealing with storm water.

0:49:12 Well, I guess I'm released, Craig Hawkins.

0:49:17 I guess I am fighting with this too a little bit, but if we issued a temporary occupancy,

0:49:28 in some ways does not reduce our liability a little bit, because we realize and acknowledge

0:49:33 that it's not totally completed.

0:49:42 I don't either.

0:49:45 Sometimes.

0:49:46 necessarily, I think a lot of it again falls on the person, private landowner, the property owner,

0:49:57 but also being significantly aware of those dangers. They, I think everyone assumes a risk

0:50:04 having people in their space. So my concern from a liability standpoint, Linda, is that if we

0:50:14 issue a temporary permit, and there's problems, no, we've issued that permit

0:50:21 knowing full well, there's problems, or there's issues that need to be addressed,

0:50:26 what's our liability? Seems to me we have a liability, not a lawyer, just from a

0:50:33 practical standpoint, knowing full well that this is what we require, but we're

0:50:38 gonna go ahead and issue a temporary permit, haven't we created a problem?

0:50:45 potentially. I think when you're looking at the reason for a hardship and why

0:50:55 there is a possibility of setting conditions to ensure that things go

0:51:00 smoothly but again you can't foresee every outcome in this kind of circumstance. What

0:51:05 we do want to make sure is that the property owners around aren't going to be

0:51:09 negatively affected by the water runoff. We want to make sure that workers can

0:51:12 return to a safe environment and any public that is entering onto that property.

0:51:16 Jerry Velmer.

0:51:20 As I'm going through all the paperwork, one thing I'm not finding that you can help me

0:51:28 with this is what is the state of hardship?

0:51:39 So I don't want to speak for the applicant, but I believe in his last presentation, it did

0:51:45 last week, it was timing issues, it was problems with equipment, supply chain issues, I mean,

0:51:56 We can have great come up here.

0:51:57 You can explain what that hardship is.

0:51:58 But in my opinion, if there's life safety issues,

0:52:01 we have to overcome, then we don't even

0:52:03 get to the question of if it's exceptional hardship

0:52:06 or not to Spencer's point is, what

0:52:08 do we want to bypass to recognize the exceptional hardship?

0:52:11 So I think the hardship is simply,

0:52:13 we're in the middle of winter.

0:52:15 They've got 30 people that aren't working

0:52:17 that we have to wait until the ground thaws.

0:52:20 And the material is good here.

0:52:22 Is that in a nutshell, correct?

0:52:26 Ms. Rolesomer.

0:52:27 But you need to come down and speak, please.

0:52:30 I would say that's in a nutshell, that it is that getting the workers back to work and

0:52:41 the work that needs to be done physically cannot be done and we're not talking about

0:52:46 4 through 9 when we're talking about that.

0:52:48 We are talking about 10.

0:52:49 You can't pay a parking lot in the middle of winter.

0:52:53 That's not something we can do, but I have spoken to both Greg and Rob Green is here

0:52:57 as well.

0:52:58 And I just, if it's, these is the council, I would like to just briefly address your liability concerns.

0:53:03 I've just spoke to Rob, so I wasn't being rude when I ran over to the other side to speak to him.

0:53:10 And he's agreed that if we can get the MCO, that if their liability issues arise that you put in,

0:53:16 he would indemnify the city from that.

0:53:19 That would be something that we could reduce to writing and written agreement that I'm sure.

0:53:23 and then I could work out together.

0:53:25 That is something that we are willing to do

0:53:28 because we want to get these people back to work.

0:53:31 So could you explain what, and I don't want to.

0:53:37 Go ahead.

0:53:38 I think it's too detailed, but I'm still just not getting

0:53:40 what the hardship is over any other typical hardship.

0:53:48 I mean, I would love to get to say yes,

0:53:49 but again, I'm looking at the precedent

0:53:51 that we're setting forth.

0:53:53 And so I think that's what we need to do

0:53:56 is really we need to focus on what is the hardship so that if we have another

0:53:59 build or developer come to us it's not just there was no outside maybe that's

0:54:05 what it is I you know but that I think we need to narrow it down a little bit

0:54:08 and let me address that because I actually came today prepared to address it since

0:54:12 we last met last Monday actually scoured case law in Idaho city codes I

0:54:18 don't statuary codes I didn't even care about anything to do with zoning I was

0:54:22 just looking for a definition of exceptional hardship.

0:54:26 I'll be blunt, I didn't find anything.

0:54:28 I found a lot of definitions of hardship,

0:54:31 all sorts of different varying gradations of hardship,

0:54:34 I didn't find anything unexceptional.

0:54:36 So instead I went to where I go,

0:54:38 when I'm arguing before court,

0:54:39 if I can't find that, I go to the common law,

0:54:41 or not the common law, but what does the dictionary say

0:54:44 exceptional is?

0:54:45 You say it's unusual, non-typical deviating from the middle.

0:54:50 In other words, it's an exception to what would normally happen.

0:54:53 And here, I want to first explain why this situation is exceptional.

0:54:58 It is extraordinarily exceptional, because we have the confluence of multiple events that

0:55:04 have led to where we're at today.

0:55:06 We have COVID causing massive, um, delivery delays, on track to our availability issues,

0:55:13 all of those things.

0:55:14 And I know you're going to say that those are something that every contractor in the valley

0:55:17 is facing.

0:55:18 What I'm going to tell you is that does not mean it's not exceptional.

0:55:20 What's going on now, the exceptional compared to where we were in 2019,

0:55:25 and everybody's having to adjust their timelines for that.

0:55:28 But that first issue, didn't we throw in the fact that I've lived in Twin Falls for 16 years?

0:55:35 This is the second time I've seen snow like this.

0:55:37 It's the first time I've seen snow like this more than once.

0:55:41 So you saw the photographs.

0:55:43 They can't pave a parking lot, and we know more snow is coming tomorrow.

0:55:48 So when you add it, when you throw in an exceptional winter with an exceptional global

0:55:54 pandemic causing an exceptional supply chain demand issues, there's your exceptional.

0:55:59 Now the hardship is 30 folks that can't go to work. The hardship is, I can't run my business.

0:56:06 Those are the hardships. I think you can say, look, it's not just this one thing,

0:56:11 it's the confluence of all of these things occurring at once. That's why we're here,

0:56:16 And we do believe that this meets the exceptional hardship.

0:56:18 And I don't think that every contractor would meet that

0:56:21 because they would have to have, I would say, more than one

0:56:24 of these exceptional circumstances out all at once.

0:56:27 And then you throw in the machinery breaking out on top of that.

0:56:32 Thank you.

0:56:33 Submit your prowess.

0:56:35 Travis?

0:56:36 So Gretchen was able to get a text message from Bruce.

0:56:45 And so I'm going to read it.

0:56:47 So as long as we are clear that this is temporary,

0:56:50 dependent on them to finish all the requirements

0:56:54 and the city has not given them final approval,

0:56:56 there should not be any additional liability.

0:57:00 Thank you.

0:57:03 Yes, sir?

0:57:06 I think I have a motion and I thought of this

0:57:08 about 14 seconds ago, so I hope it doesn't come out terrible.

0:57:13 Two days from now, the site's going to be what it is.

0:57:16 The liability is the risk, whether we approve something

0:57:19 tonight or not, nothing's changing two days from now.

0:57:23 So the risk is there.

0:57:25 It's just there.

0:57:28 The owner wants to get back to business.

0:57:31 They don't want their commercial storefront

0:57:34 to be a construction site.

0:57:36 I think I'd like to make a motion.

0:57:38 And I would, like I said, I thought of this 14 seconds ago,

0:57:43 34 seconds ago now, a motion that we

0:57:46 would grant the temporary occupancy and then direct staff to work on amending this ordinance

0:57:54 because exceptional hardship is going to be something that's going to play the council

0:57:58 and city staff that have to deal with it interpret it for years.

0:58:03 But before I formally make that motion I would like city manager's office or the city

0:58:07 attorney to advise me if there's something else I just stepped in that I didn't mean

0:58:11 to as far as definitions and that type of stuff.

0:58:17 So we can, I think the challenge, I think Ms. Redmond had shared this, I think Jonathan

0:58:25 had shared this, I think Bruce has shared this, Linda has shared this.

0:58:30 The language that's in the city code is unique and comparison to other codes, entirely defined

0:58:36 exceptional hardship.

0:58:37 And what you're here tonight is really to create that case of precedence as been shared and

0:58:45 to determine what bar needs to be established in moving forward.

0:58:52 Subsequently, we can have a ordinance ready to begin

0:58:58 through the Title 10 process to strike that section of the code.

0:59:03 I know Jonathan and team have been working on Title 10 amendments.

0:59:08 This is certainly one that we can remove, but I think that that is a separate conversation

0:59:14 than the one that is before you know.

0:59:19 And when you say that, you mean, and I get,

0:59:22 it's a separate issue, just removing that exception

0:59:26 as a potential.

0:59:27 So specifically, there is a call out

0:59:31 in the planning and zoning code.

0:59:35 Jonathan has highlighted the language,

0:59:38 and it is here in Title 10, Chapter 11,

0:59:45 where it says whenever a building is constructed, placed,

0:59:47 directed, or enlarged, and that building

0:59:50 isn't an isolated or undeveloped area,

0:59:52 or in cases of exceptional hardship,

0:59:57 improvements may be deferred by the council,

0:59:59 in cases where the deferral would otherwise be unavailable.

1:00:05 That is the section of code that has brought the question

1:00:11 before the city council.

1:00:13 And in order for us to not have individuals be able to use this part of the code, it would

1:00:22 require a code amendment, and which since it's Title 10, it requires the series of public

1:00:31 hearings starting at the planning and zoning level, again, entirely separate conversation,

1:00:38 then what Mr. Green and his team have brought for your consideration this evening.

1:00:45 Thank you.

1:00:48 And sir, or Grayson, are you still old?

1:00:53 Yeah, Councilman Keller, is your intention on that motion for staff to come back in?

1:00:58 I guess the traffic's just completely erased that.

1:01:02 So essentially what you're saying is we'll grant it this one time and then we're getting rid of it.

1:01:07 At a later date when the agenda item is not specifically this piece of property,

1:01:12 I will consider a motion at that time that would have to do with this ordinance.

1:01:19 So Madam Mayor, if I could, I think that the council should really kind of focus

1:01:26 and direct in onto this question.

1:01:28 That's correct.

1:01:29 And then we work on the other later.

1:01:31 So if you would like to state your motion related to this particular item,

1:01:37 as opposed to adding that secondary, can you do that answer or no?

1:01:49 I have it up.

1:01:50 Would you? Okay.

1:01:51 I'll just make the motion as Jonathan wrote.

1:01:56 And if there's any amendments, then we can, if that works.

1:02:00 There's something that people want to remove.

1:02:09 So we do have a motion on the floor.

1:02:11 So why don't you.

1:02:14 to restate your motion, because we do have a motion on the floor, correct?

1:02:21 Linda?

1:02:22 And it either dies for a lack of a second, though there's a motion on the floor to grant

1:02:32 temporary occupancy and at a later date, further define exceptional hardship or change the

1:02:42 code on exceptional hardship.

1:02:44 That was the motion, correct?

1:02:49 Now you thought of it an hour and three minutes.

1:02:51 I'm dragging my feet as long as I can.

1:02:54 I apologize.

1:02:55 Yeah, I'll offer a motion and people can vote how they choose.

1:02:59 Otherwise, as you say, if there's no motion, this will just die for lack of a motion or

1:03:03 lack of a second.

1:03:05 So I'll clarify the motion.

1:03:08 So I move to approve the request of finding exceptional hardship.

1:03:14 I will refer to the items presented rather than try to mumble through this, refer to

1:03:20 the item presented in the packet along with the deadlines addressed in the packet.

1:03:29 Excuse me, stated in the packet.

1:03:31 Hey, there's a motion on the floor.

1:03:35 Is there a second?

1:03:36 I'll second that.

1:03:39 Okay.

1:03:40 Amy, did you get that?

1:03:45 No, but I can't in the recording.

1:03:47 I need it to be repeated so I just want to make sure and everyone understands the motion.

1:03:53 So my understanding is that he wants to make a motion to approve based on the 17 items listed

1:04:00 in the packet with the dates included. Correct but we're not addressing the exceptional hardship

1:04:11 so I just want to make sure we're stating that because you said you didn't want to address

1:04:17 the exceptional hardship items by a list is that correct I just I'm trying to clarify

1:04:23 yeah I'm sorry I'm struggling to word this the intent of the motion is to say

1:04:32 really the first portion which is I move to approve the request finding an

1:04:37 exceptional hardship and I guess beyond that I don't know what to add

1:04:45 because you know we have a suggested wording but then it gets into the

1:04:48 details that really aren't whether or not this is exceptional hardship so the

1:04:52 The motion would be, I move to approve the request, finding an exceptional hardship period.

1:05:02 Okay, Chris, is there a second, no second.

1:05:16 So motion dies for lack of a second.

1:05:18 Chris, do you want to try?

1:05:22 I do.

1:05:23 I have to do on that one.

1:05:25 All right, I'll try this.

1:05:28 I motion to approve the request, finding an exceptional hardship or I'm just going to

1:05:35 down all 17 items. One landscaping, few a trash enclosure, three accessibility issues,

1:05:45 four slope of the roof, five rain gutters, six sheet flow, seven parking lot valley

1:05:55 gutter, eight, missing downspout, nine, storm retention, swale, swale, swale, swale, all

1:06:06 right, swale, ten, hard surface parking lot, eleven debris and unused material removed, twelve

1:06:17 light pole callouts, properly labeled on plans, 13 frost free, 14 water meter replacement,

1:06:30 15 fire hydrant correction on plans, 16 bent cap slash covers, 17 transformer protection.

1:06:42 A deferral is granted for, and then the following items, lumped together landscaping related

1:06:51 items, trash enclosure, parking space, paint stripes, ADA accessibility route, paving of

1:07:00 parking area, storm water system, drainage pipes, contours, gutters, scrubbers, and retention

1:07:08 area with a deadline to complete these deferred items by the dates as included in the attachment

1:07:18 labeled number two Rob Green timeline commitment. Okay there is a second

1:07:30 a motion by Chris Reed seconded by Craig Hawkins I'm not going to repeat it I think we all have

1:07:38 be here all night. We'll be here all night. Pardon me? No nothing that states what the hardship

1:07:43 is. Are we supposed to? So this is the motion right now and it's been seconded so there's further

1:07:50 discussion. Grayson? Yeah I was just gonna say exactly what Trey was just saying so I pretty much

1:07:56 feel like we just repeated itself and correct me if I'm wrong Travis but we have to outline

1:08:01 what we're finding the exceptional hardship to be and then the deferral is granted for the items

1:08:06 one through seventeen. So shouldn't it read, I motion to approve the request, find an exceptional

1:08:11 hardship, or delays outside of the contractor's ability, or am I misreading that? Because otherwise

1:08:24 we're just duplicating what is right below it. So the sample motion that Jonathan included in his

1:08:32 packet, and as recommended by Bruce and Jonathan, you should share the characteristics that you

1:08:44 believe are creating the exceptional hardship that creates the bar, right? And then from that place,

1:08:53 you grant the deferral on those items that you believe clear that bar.

1:09:02 Yes, you're right. Councilman Stone, it should be a whether supply chain issues,

1:09:13 something of that nature. So we can amend the motion, vote on the amendment, then

1:09:23 vote on the motion so if you I'll I'll amend it if okay like go ahead I would

1:09:33 like to amend my motion that under exceptional hardship we add weather

1:09:38 supply chain issues and mechanical failures is there a second for that

1:09:46 Jerry Vomer I'll second that okay so you have an amended motion we'll vote on

1:09:57 that first Craig Hawkins did you have a comment okay so the amendment is that

1:10:04 we're voting on is weather supply chain applied chain issues amendment

1:10:11 chemical failure so any further discussion on that councilman read I'd

1:10:18 really like to see something in your motion that addresses the fact there's

1:10:21 a significant portion of people unemployed it's tied to it because what I

1:10:25 wouldn't want to have happen now is somebody that hits weather that doesn't

1:10:30 really need the billing for the big part of it for me as employees as well. So if

1:10:36 you could put a significant amount of employees or some of that effect. Can we

1:10:43 vote on this one and then vote on the employees as a separate amendment to

1:10:50 it by adding Robert's rules of order. You have a motion on the table. Correct. We

1:11:03 have to vote on that. You have an amended motion. I don't did not hear as to whether

1:11:09 or not the amended motion was seconded. It was. Then you can, if Mr. Stone would like

1:11:19 to insert employee or employment related conditions, he can make an amendment to the amendment.

1:11:25 That's what I thought. And if that is seconded, then that becomes the germane motion moving

1:11:30 forward. Okay. So Mr. Stone. I would like to amend Councilman Reid's motion and

1:11:39 his amendment to include language to say that impacts a significant amount of

1:11:43 employees. Okay do I have a second for the amendment to the amendment? Thank you

1:11:53 Craig. So there's been an amended motion to the amended motion to add

1:12:01 significant employment number of employees impacted to add to the amended

1:12:15 motion and it's been seconded by Craig Hawkins. So we're going to vote on the

1:12:19 second amendment first. Any further discussion on the second amendment?

1:12:26 Amy Roach, I'll vote please.

1:12:30 hockens, yes. Spencer Cutler, no. Grayson Stone, yes. Cherry

1:12:38 Vollmer, yes. Ruth Pierce, yes. And Chris Reed, no. A motion passes 4 to 2. So

1:12:49 Madam Mayor, now that you have a amended motion, it's been approved. Now you call

1:12:58 the question on the motion as a stance in its entirety. It's easy for you to

1:13:05 you to say. Don't we have to vote on the second amendment? On my amendment.

1:13:10 First amendment. No, so because Mr. Stones was included in Mr. Reed you

1:13:20 approved the entire train of motion and so now you have to go to the original

1:13:26 question. If Mr. Stones if Mr. Stones motion would have failed then you would

1:13:31 have only considered Mr. Reads.

1:13:34 Got it.

1:13:35 So now we go to the original motion,

1:13:38 which is to approve the request,

1:13:42 finding the exceptional hardships as listed,

1:13:47 and granting a deferral for items one through 17

1:13:53 on the dates proposed.

1:13:57 That correct?

1:14:02 So we're approving the deferral

1:14:10 based on the hardships of I can I can read it back if you'd like

1:14:15 awesome yes okay can you scroll that up a motion to approve the request

1:14:28 finding an exceptional hardship for weather supply chain issues mechanical

1:14:33 failure

1:14:34 and a certain amount of significant employee impacts

1:14:40 significant employee impacts a deferral is granted for

1:14:45 landscaping related items trash enclosure

1:14:49 parking space, painting stripes, ADA, accessible route, paving of parking area,

1:14:56 storm water system, site drainage pipes, contours, gutters, what is that, scuppers,

1:15:06 and retention area, with a deadline to be completed, these deferral items by, as

1:15:16 stated in attachment two of this packet by Rob Green's timeline email.

1:15:25 Everybody good? Any further discussion? Amy Roach, all vote please?

1:15:39 Vince or Cutler? No. Grayson Stone? Yes.

1:15:54 Perry Volmer? Yes. Ruth Pierce? No.

1:16:01 Chris Reed? Yes. Great cockens. Yes.

1:16:10 A motion passes 4 to 2. Okay. All right. So that is it for items of consideration. Next item on the agenda is the time for general public input.

1:16:36 If there's anybody in the audience that wishes to address City Council on items not included

1:16:43 in today's agenda or not related to any personnel, you can come down now.

1:16:54 Seeing no one advisory board reports.

1:16:56 So we sent out all the assignments for new assignments for this next year.

1:17:05 So it should be in your email and also on teams and just pretty much Amy I think the

1:17:13 department heads will receive notification of their new liaisons for the new commission.

1:17:20 So just start showing up to meetings.

1:17:22 It should be good.

1:17:24 Anything from the manager's office?

1:17:28 Yeah, Madam Mayor, members of the council, I just want to take a minute and obviously for

1:17:34 the record and for those who are listening to have a conversation about snow. So I will

1:17:41 say being a native Montana and it felt a little like home in October. And I appreciate the fact

1:17:49 that snow events like that, like what we've experienced, as it's been shared, happen rarely

1:17:58 and infrequently in our community and rarely have we been impacted. And I know that some

1:18:04 Some of you have received emails and we've received voicemails, but for the record, I think

1:18:09 it's important to recognize that members of our team worked 12 hour shifts for several

1:18:14 straight days.

1:18:16 And in that period of time, they placed 128 tons of salt on the roadways.

1:18:26 And when the temperature dipped below 20 degrees, they applied sand and they applied and tons

1:18:32 of sand on the roadways.

1:18:39 We do priority one roads.

1:18:42 And priority one roads are those major arterials and collectors and for anybody wanting to

1:18:48 understand where those are, they are prominently displayed on our website.

1:18:52 The maps show where we plow first.

1:18:56 And with eight plows, it takes anywhere between five and a half hours and six hours to complete

1:19:01 the loop once.

1:19:04 So the City of Twin Palace has more than 630 miles of roadway.

1:19:09 We have eight plows.

1:19:11 We have a team of individuals that are working around the clock to remove the snow.

1:19:17 And one of the questions that we received a lot of is why do we not do residential streets?

1:19:24 And there's lots of good reasons.

1:19:28 None of which probably make our residents too happy.

1:19:31 The number one, we have found that when we do residential streets, we tend to push the

1:19:37 snow back into their driveways.

1:19:41 And that makes individuals incredibly frustrated with the City of Twin Falls and our crews.

1:19:47 Where almost no good deed goes on punished.

1:19:51 Residential streets are much narrower in scope than what they are in the arterials and collectors,

1:19:58 when individuals park on the sides of the streets,

1:20:02 we drive a plow down the road.

1:20:04 We push snow into and around their vehicles,

1:20:07 making it very difficult for them to get out.

1:20:11 And so sometimes we will snow them in.

1:20:14 And our drivers are human.

1:20:17 And the last thing we want to do is clip one of those cars

1:20:21 that's parked on the side of the road.

1:20:25 It really becomes about resources

1:20:28 and how we're really managing resources

1:20:31 to be able to hit those priority one roads.

1:20:34 And then the last thing is if you think about

1:20:36 the amount of snow that we have,

1:20:39 placing that into locations, like you can push the snow,

1:20:42 but eventually you have to be able to push the snow

1:20:45 somewhere to be able to remove it.

1:20:47 And there's really no place to put that amount of snow

1:20:51 inside of communities.

1:20:58 It's going to melt,

1:21:02 which is going to cause an entire collection

1:21:04 of other potential issues later this week.

1:21:06 And so we're asking members of our communities

1:21:09 to remember where those storm drains are.

1:21:12 And if they happen to push snow from their sidewalks

1:21:15 into the streets and they have blocked their storm drains,

1:21:20 we are going to have incredible flooding events

1:21:23 as a result of their actions.

1:21:28 We also need to make sure that our citizens do not continue to push snow from their driveways

1:21:38 inside walks into the roadways.

1:21:42 Our code enforcement team has been dealing with several complaints from neighbor calling

1:21:47 on neighbor where they have been placing snow from their driveways into their streets, making

1:21:54 their roads even more impassable because of the time that we can't spend on those residential

1:22:03 streets.

1:22:04 We're asking people to be neighborly.

1:22:05 We're asking people to understand and significantly we're asking them to go on dig storm drains

1:22:11 because if it really does hit 40 plus degrees over the course of the next few days after

1:22:17 tonight and tomorrow's storm event, which could yield another three to five inches.

1:22:25 We could have some serious complicating factors.

1:22:29 So yes, we do have plows.

1:22:32 Yes, we are out there working.

1:22:34 And when individuals got stuck, it was a combination of good Samaritan police officers, firefighters

1:22:41 more than 100 calls for service to assist motorists who found their vehicles stuck in snowbanks.

1:22:52 So credit goes to the team. I'm certain that we didn't meet the expectations of all of

1:22:57 our citizens. And I would invite them to ride around in a snowplow. The next time we have

1:23:07 such a significant storm event. I had that opportunity a few years ago and I will tell

1:23:13 you it was amazingly educational for me and that educational process might help all this

1:23:21 stand a little bit of grace to those who are working when I'm in the comfort of my own home.

1:23:28 Thank you Travis, Chris Reed. I just want to say on behalf of the Council and I'm sure

1:23:32 the rest of the Council would agree. Thank you. Please let them know. We really appreciate

1:23:36 And we know that it's not just, the street department did an amazing job, but there's

1:23:42 many other departments that went above and beyond and helped out and helped each other

1:23:49 out when one department wasn't able to do something because they were helping somebody

1:23:54 out.

1:23:55 We really, really appreciated it.

1:23:56 It is noticed, unfortunately, sometimes you do get phone calls and that one or two or

1:24:03 100 people that call and are frustrated, that's the group you listen to, but there's a lot

1:24:09 of people that really do appreciate it, so please let them know.

1:24:12 Thank you.

1:24:14 Anyone else?

1:24:15 Okay.

1:24:17 Thank you, everybody.

1:24:18 Meeting's adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Tuesday, January 16, 2024. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:24:29.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    463d098b562b57734ebc4c166868bf4271ed6caeca9f6d1eea3a4f3f4183bd08
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a a5cef002afb42852ee221402b13d6556dcd5951fb8bfc279810d099373762b80
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    b28e9206e4f58b3cd39b0dd96d12ef826322910daa6185f3dfbc16bff294f7e3

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file