OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 30, 2023

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:02:03 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the October 30th, 2023 City Council meeting.

0:02:10 I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have six members present in chambers and Nikki Boyd is on the phone.

0:02:17 So first time on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you wish to join me, please rise.

0:02:22 Thank you. I have one proclamation tonight.

0:02:45 It's a proclamation for National American Indian Heritage Month.

0:02:50 Whereas the history and culture of our great nation have been significantly influenced by

0:02:57 American Indians and indigenous peoples, and whereas the contribution of American Indians

0:03:05 have enhanced the freedom, prosperity, and greatness of America today, and whereas their

0:03:11 customs and traditions are respected and celebrated as part of a rich legacy throughout

0:03:17 the United States, and whereas Native American Awareness Week began in 1976 and recognition

0:03:24 was expanded by Congress and approved by President George Bush in August 1990, designating

0:03:32 the month of November as National American Heritage, Indian Heritage Month, and in honor

0:03:38 of National American Indian Heritage Month, community celebrations as well as numerous cultural,

0:03:45 artistic, educational, and historical activities have been planned.

0:03:50 Now, therefore, I repurise by the virtue of the authority vested in me as Mayor of Twin

0:03:57 Falls, to hereby proclaim November as the National American Indian Heritage Month in

0:04:04 and urge all our citizens to observe this month with appropriate programs, ceremonies, and

0:04:11 activities.

0:04:12 And we have Helen Cutler here to accept.

0:05:38 the arrival of the rest of us.

0:05:43 But, Mason and honouring our...

0:05:49 Thank you.

0:05:50 Thank you, Helen.

0:05:53 Okay, next on the agenda is the consent calendar.

0:05:57 Council wishes.

0:06:01 I'd move to approve the consent calendar.

0:06:03 Thank you, Alex Kaval.

0:06:05 I second it.

0:06:06 Thank you.

0:06:07 Motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Alex Kaval

0:06:10 to approve the consent calendar as written.

0:06:14 Amy Rokal vote, please.

0:06:16 Ruth Pierce?

0:06:17 Yes, Chris Reed.

0:06:18 Yes.

0:06:19 Nicky Boyd.

0:06:20 Yes.

0:06:21 Greg Hawkins.

0:06:22 Yes.

0:06:23 Jason Brown.

0:06:24 Yes.

0:06:25 Alex Cabal.

0:06:26 Yes.

0:06:27 Thank you.

0:06:28 Motion passes 7-0.

0:06:29 Next, under items of consideration is an action item, and consideration of an independent

0:06:36 contractor agreement with Bruce Castleton of Castleton Law, P-L-L-C-C, for city attorney

0:06:44 services as defined in Idaho Code Section 50-208a and we have our City Manager

0:06:51 Travis Rothweiler. Welcome Travis. Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the City Council.

0:06:56 It is my pleasure to present to you in agreement for your consideration with

0:07:02 Mr. Bruce Castleton of Castleton Law to serve as a contracted attorney for the

0:07:10 City of Twin Falls as described in Idaho Code. So, as you know, the City Attorney

0:07:17 position became vacant earlier this year. And through a process, we were able to find

0:07:26 three firms that were interested in exploring that relationship. All three firms had the

0:07:32 opportunity to present their skill sets in executive session as allowed by Idaho Code

0:07:39 in that formal interview process and from that process Mr. Castleton was selected to

0:07:47 move forward with a contract for your review and your consideration.

0:07:56 In the past and prior to having in-house legal counsel the City of Twin Falls operated

0:08:01 under a contractual based city council agreement and Fritz Wonderlick and Jackie Wakefield,

0:08:09 of Wonderland Lake and Wakefield served

0:08:11 to our city attorneys for decades.

0:08:14 And so it's not a model that we're unfamiliar with.

0:08:18 What is different is in that period of time,

0:08:22 we've added significant depth to prosecutorial staff

0:08:29 that we have inside of the city of Flint Falls

0:08:31 and that team over the course of the last several months

0:08:36 has taken on some of the civil caseload and so the opportunity here is that the

0:08:43 prosecutorial staff will continue to go to court and they will continue to do

0:08:48 their work as prosecutors and then they're also going to have a relationship with

0:08:53 Mr. Castleton as they work through the civil work on behalf of the city. Bruce

0:09:02 is here this evening and he is available to answer any questions but very

0:09:06 quickly I wanted to go through Bruce and his his qualifications for your

0:09:13 review. This one pained me but he's a graduate of the University of Idaho.

0:09:19 Provandals, yes. That was a tough weekend and a pill for me to swallow as a Bobcat.

0:09:25 This weekend but it shows what happens when you control the ball for 11

0:09:29 minutes and 23 seconds in the first quarter. So that was a little painful but

0:09:35 But nevertheless, he is a vandal, graduating with a Bachelor of Arts in English literature

0:09:41 in 1987, and then in 2003, he received his Juris Doctorate from Brigham Young University,

0:09:49 the Reuben Clark Law School.

0:09:52 Over that period of time, he has served with Naylor and Hales out of Boise, and then in

0:09:58 In 2020 he ventured out and went on and formed his own firm.

0:10:07 The City of Twin Falls is familiar with Mr. Castleton as he has done extensive work with

0:10:14 us as a member of our legal team when working through different pieces of litigation as he

0:10:22 He was hired as an attorney through iCrimp to serve as counsel on a series of different

0:10:29 projects.

0:10:30 He has experience in HR, he has experience in state and local government law.

0:10:36 He has the opportunity to continue to help grow the expertise of our prosecutorial staff

0:10:45 as well as continue to represent the City of Twin Falls in the best interest.

0:10:49 So it is with my great pleasure that I submit to you the agreement with Bruce

0:10:55 Castleton to assert as the contracted city attorney.

0:11:00 The term is included in there.

0:11:02 It is for a period of one year.

0:11:04 In that one year period, it'll give the council the opportunity to really set

0:11:09 that future course of action.

0:11:10 Is it the council's desire to continue to move forward on a contractual base?

0:11:15 is the council's desire to bring legal services back in-house, both have been

0:11:22 effective and we'll kind of work through that. The primary overseer of the agreement

0:11:28 will be the city manager's office for this period of time and so members of the

0:11:34 city manager's team will assist Mr. Council but also oversee the day-to-day

0:11:39 activities in the process of tutorial staff from a coaching and mentoring

0:11:43 with that. I'm happy to stand for any questions. Perfect. Any questions for...

0:11:48 And Bruce is here too. Or Bruce. No, I didn't have a question, just a comment. I'm very happy with our choice and I do have a little bit of experience working on the other side of Mr.

0:12:05 So, he was always pleasant to work with, but firm, and so I think we've made a good choice.

0:12:16 And I, just for full disclosure, I did review that a contract for Mr. Castleton prior to

0:12:22 today and the changes that I had suggested have been incorporated in there, so I have

0:12:27 no concerns with it.

0:12:29 Perfect.

0:12:30 That's our legal legal.

0:12:33 Chris Reed.

0:12:34 That actually follows the question or the question that I have as far as reviewing that, did our legal department have an opportunity to review that contractor or yourself being the one that's overseeing this relationship?

0:12:46 In my experience of this council, I recognize that the tough questions were going to come from this couple. So I asked her to review it first.

0:12:55 And then we made the question, we made the changes as suggested by Ms. Cabal, Mr. Castleton accepted those changes, the agreement is before you in that form.

0:13:06 Perfect.

0:13:07 Perfect.

0:13:08 Well, I'm very excited. So I entertain a motion.

0:13:12 Madam Mayor, I move that we approve the agreement between the City of Twin Falls and Mr. Castleton to serve as the City Attorney.

0:13:23 Thank you. Do I have a second? Thank you. Motion by Alex Koval, seconded by Greg

0:13:30 Hawkins to approve the in-pinnock contractor agreement with Bruce

0:13:35 Castleton of Castleton Law PLCC for City Attorney Services as defined in

0:13:41 Idaho Code Section 50-208A. Amy Rolkavolt please. Chris Reed. Yes.

0:13:51 Thank you, Boyd. Yes. Great.

0:13:54 Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes.

0:13:56 Alex Cabal. Yes. Spencer Cutler. Yes.

0:13:59 And Ruth Pierce. Yes. Thank you.

0:14:02 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:14:03 Bruce, you're off the hook today.

0:14:05 It's the last day you'll be off the hook.

0:14:08 So thank you. Okay.

0:14:11 That is it under items of consideration.

0:14:14 So now is the time for public input.

0:14:18 If there's anybody in the public that wishes to address city

0:14:22 Council on anything that's not on the agenda or not personnel or personnel related issues

0:14:30 you're welcome to come down.

0:14:35 Seeing no one advisory board reports any Craig.

0:14:40 I just report that we had he has he's fall academy early last week and it was really good

0:14:48 always learn a lot there especially her each other members I know working that's hard to

0:14:54 to get off, but it's a program and I learned a lot,

0:14:58 helped me be, have some new members,

0:15:03 I certainly encourage them to, and if they can't.

0:15:05 Absolutely, anybody else?

0:15:09 Nicky, do you have anything?

0:15:12 I don't, Ruth.

0:15:14 Okay, thank you.

0:15:15 Anything from the City Managers Office.

0:15:17 Yes, Madam Mayor, just really quickly, as a reminder,

0:15:20 and as by tradition, the City Council

0:15:22 will not be meeting next week on the evening

0:15:26 prior to the election.

0:15:29 We do not host a council meeting,

0:15:32 and what we would do is to encourage all citizens

0:15:37 to get out and vote.

0:15:39 I believe that it is said that the most impactful government

0:15:45 is the one that is closest to you.

0:15:48 And so we should, in theory, have the largest voter turnout.

0:15:52 Unfortunately, we do not.

0:15:55 And so hopefully inside of the City of Flint Falls this year,

0:15:58 we can change that.

0:15:59 And we would encourage all citizens to get out and vote.

0:16:03 Perfect.

0:16:03 Thank you.

0:16:05 So we have no public hearings, no executive sessions.

0:16:08 So shortest meeting for a while, we are adjourned.

0:16:12 Thank you, everyone.

0:16:12 Thank you.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 30, 2023. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:16:22.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    565e4c4aa6d8a27c5570efe931d2144f2599bd7b9a96e28ae2d2d188a52fc474
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a d24e58deafc2b3d129b900f0b08a6152391729d951c40d14dea871d0b38a8617
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-09. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    6fd34d174ff139f756e7db8cfa82215e9f62bcbe9a123071fc37a308109be475

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file