City Council meeting
Monday, November 14, 2022
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:52 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the November 14th, 2022 City Council meeting. I want to confirm we have a quorum. We have all seven members present in chambers.
0:01:05 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance and we have a scout troop with us today. So the scout troop 65 is going to come down and lead us in the pledge.
0:01:33 Please follow me in the Pledge of Allegiance, the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:02:10 Okay, before you zip down, if each of you would come up to the mic and introduce yourself,
0:02:16 tell us what troop you're with and why you're here today, starting with you.
0:02:21 I'm a part of Troop 65 and I'm here for the citizenship, citizenship in the community badge.
0:02:27 Thank you.
0:02:28 That's a ship in the nation, uh, community.
0:02:36 Thank you.
0:02:37 I'm Malekai Gransberry and I'm here for the chair, the mayor badge, citizen of the community.
0:02:52 Thank you.
0:02:53 I'm Alex Varkson.
0:02:55 I'm here for the citizenship committee badge.
0:02:57 I'm with the gypsies5.
0:02:59 Thank you.
0:03:01 Two more, I think.
0:03:04 I'm Dr. Thomas.
0:03:05 I'm Hiddah, with the both, and she's centered up in the community.
0:03:09 Thank you.
0:03:10 Perfect.
0:03:25 Thank you, gentlemen.
0:03:26 Okay.
0:03:29 So next on the agenda are a couple of proclamations today.
0:03:34 The first one is a proclamation for National American Indian Heritage Month.
0:03:41 What is the history and culture of our great nation have been significantly influenced
0:03:46 by American Indians and indigenous peoples, and what else the contributions of American
0:03:54 Indians have enhanced the freedom, prosperity, and greatness of America today, and what
0:04:00 else their customs and traditions are respected and celebrated as part of a rich legacy throughout
0:04:06 the United States, and was Native American Awareness Week began in 1976, and recognition
0:04:14 was expanded by Congress and approved by President George Bush in August 1998, excuse me, 1990,
0:04:21 doesn't netting the month of November as National American Heritage, Indian Heritage Month, and
0:04:28 was an honor of National American Indian Heritage Month, community celebrations as well as numerous
0:04:35 cultural, artistic, and educational, and historical activities have been planned.
0:04:40 Now there are four bar-roofed peers by the virtue of the authority vested in me as Mayor
0:04:45 of Twin Falls, Idaho, do hereby proclaim November as the National American Indian Heritage
0:04:51 Month in and urge our citizens to observe this month with appropriate program ceremonies
0:04:58 and activities, and we have with us to accept this as Helen Cutler from Daughters of American
0:05:04 I am Helen Cutler and I am a member of the D.A.R. which is the Daughters of the American
0:05:38 Revolution. D.A.R. is an organization with a focus on education and supportive veterans.
0:05:46 I am the State Chairman for the Native American Committee. November is National American Indians
0:05:52 Heritage Month and coincidentally Thanksgiving. Native Americans are responsible for the
0:05:58 survival of the pilgrims. A challenge to
0:06:03 involve residents to research Native American customs, history, culture,
0:06:08 accomplishments, and contributions before and since the arrival of the rest of us.
0:06:14 Thank you for this proclamation, honoring our Native American families,
0:06:21 friends, and neighbors. Thank you.
0:06:24 Thank you Helen. Okay, and the next proclamation is
0:06:29 for Small Business Saturday, which is November 26th, 2022,
0:06:33 since we're not going to have a meeting next Monday
0:06:36 for the holiday week, and Small Business Saturday falls
0:06:41 the Saturday after Thanksgiving.
0:06:43 This is encouraging everyone to recognize
0:06:47 that day is Small Business Saturday.
0:06:50 Whereas the City of Twin Falls, Idaho celebrates our local
0:06:53 small businesses and contributions they make to our local
0:06:56 economy and community and whereas according to the United States Small Business Administration
0:07:02 there are 32 and a half million small businesses in the United States. Small businesses represent
0:07:08 99.7 of firms with paid employees, small businesses are responsible for 62 percent of net new jobs
0:07:16 created since 1995 and small businesses employ 46.9 percent of the employees in the private
0:07:23 sector in the United States. And whereas 79% of consumers understand the importance of supporting
0:07:30 the small businesses in their communities on small business Saturday, 70% report. The
0:07:36 day makes them want to encourage others to shop small, independently owned retailers and
0:07:42 66% report that day makes them want to shop small all year long. Whereas 58% of shoppers
0:07:51 report they shopped online with small businesses and 54% reported they dined or ordered take
0:07:57 out from a small restaurant bar cafe on small business Saturday 2021 and whereas the City
0:08:04 of Twin Falls, Idaho supports our local businesses that create jobs, boost our local economy
0:08:11 and preserve our communities and whereas advocacy groups as well as public and private organizations
0:08:18 across the country have endorsed the Saturday after Thanksgiving, a small business Saturday.
0:08:24 Therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, may have the City of Twin Falls do hereby proclaim November
0:08:29 26, 2022 as small business Saturday and urge the residents of our community and communities
0:08:37 across the country to support small businesses and merchants on small business Saturday and
0:08:42 throughout the year.
0:08:44 We don't have anybody here from representing the group that requested this, but I'm a big
0:08:50 advocate of small business and of course with our downtown.
0:08:54 As exciting as it is, it's really fun to see the small businesses downtown and throughout
0:08:59 our community.
0:09:00 So I encourage everybody to shop local and shop a lot.
0:09:05 Okay.
0:09:06 Next down the agenda is our consent calendar.
0:09:11 Council wishes.
0:09:12 Great Hopkins.
0:09:14 May I would like to make a motion to accept the consent calendar is written.
0:09:19 Thank you.
0:09:20 Do I have a second?
0:09:21 Second.
0:09:22 Thank you motion by Craig Hawkins, seconded by Alex Kaval to approve the consent calendar.
0:09:27 Amy Rolkoffo, please.
0:09:29 Jason Brown?
0:09:33 Yes.
0:09:34 Thank you, Boyd?
0:09:35 Yes.
0:09:36 Alex Kaval?
0:09:37 Yes.
0:09:38 Bruce Pierce?
0:09:39 Yes.
0:09:40 Craig Hawkins?
0:09:41 Yes.
0:09:42 Yes.
0:09:43 Thank you. Motion passes 7-0. So if you're here for the
0:09:47 outdoor license for a list go restaurant or the airport farm ground lease
0:09:53 renewal with Messner Farms, those have both been approved.
0:09:57 Okay, moving on to items of consideration. The first item is an action item
0:10:03 a request to confirm the mayoral appointment of Grace and Stone to the
0:10:07 Planning and Zoning Commission. We have Jonathan to spend a lot of our
0:10:11 of our Planning and Zoning Director.
0:10:13 Welcome, Jonathan.
0:10:15 Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.
0:10:17 We had an opening on the commission
0:10:18 when a member resigned to take a position with a state board
0:10:23 that they were nominated to.
0:10:24 And so this appointment is actually a partial term.
0:10:27 And that person served for a number of months,
0:10:30 it was six months total.
0:10:32 We put out the call for applications.
0:10:36 During the month of September, we received three total.
0:10:38 Two of them did not live in city limits.
0:10:40 And so they were notified of that.
0:10:42 And so we had one appointment, and we had the interview
0:10:45 with Mr. Stone that was myself, the mayor,
0:10:48 and the Chairman Craig Kelly.
0:10:51 And upon the conclusion of the interview,
0:10:54 we found Grace and Two,
0:10:56 we had a qualified and committed to furthering the goals
0:10:58 and objectives of the comprehensive plan that the city has.
0:11:00 And so we gave that input to the mayor,
0:11:03 and the mayor had me write up a staff report to present it to you.
0:11:08 So here we are, Grayson passed the background check, that's great and so um, Grayson's name is being proposed for the open position on the planning and zoning commission and I would take motion to that effect, Chris Reed.
0:11:25 Mayor, I move that we confirm the mayoral appointment of Grayson Stone to the planning and zoning commission.
0:11:31 Thank you, Jason Brown.
0:11:32 Second.
0:11:33 Madam Mayor, before there's a vote,
0:11:35 I would like to declare a conflict on this one.
0:11:38 Mr. Stone represents my father and their
0:11:41 with appearance of impropriety,
0:11:43 I will abstain from this vote.
0:11:45 Thank you, Alex.
0:11:47 A motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Jason Brown
0:11:51 to confirm the appointment of Grace and Stone
0:11:54 to planning and zoning commission.
0:11:56 Amy Roll call vote please.
0:11:59 Bruce Pierce.
0:12:00 Yes.
0:12:01 Yes.
0:12:02 Thank you, Boyd.
0:12:03 Yes.
0:12:04 Hi, Cawkins.
0:12:05 Yes.
0:12:06 Jason Brown.
0:12:07 Yes.
0:12:08 Hunter-Cutler.
0:12:09 Yes.
0:12:10 Alex Kaval.
0:12:11 Upstate.
0:12:12 Thank you, Motion passes 6-4 and 1 abstention.
0:12:15 Congratulations, Grayson.
0:12:17 Okay.
0:12:18 Next on the agenda is another action item, a consideration of a request to approve the
0:12:24 annual Christmas in the nighttime sky event sponsored by Kimberly Nursery on Friday, November
0:12:31 2022 and we have Lou Coronado here to bring us up to date. Welcome Lou.
0:12:39 Members of Council, Christmas and night times guys and annual band. I believe it's going on 30 years now.
0:12:52 It's a year and annual band. It takes place Friday after Thanksgiving at Kimberley Nurseries.
0:12:58 Is sure Dave Wendell is overseeing this event. Dave and Sherry Wright are no longer part of this.
0:13:06 So Dave Wendell is taking over this event.
0:13:09 It's still going to happen in the same location, Kimberley Nurseries.
0:13:13 The event starts at 5.30 and the firework display is tended to go off at 7.30 in the vacant field north of Kimberley Nurseries.
0:13:25 There will be choreographed music along with the fireworks for that event.
0:13:29 In treat to this event is a unwrapped toy.
0:13:33 It's a fundraiser to be out of the toys of all the needy children in the Magic Valley area.
0:13:38 We've done this event since I've been here 22 years and it's gone off without a hitch.
0:13:45 My main charge is the traffic control for this event.
0:13:48 We already have our app, our ready for that event.
0:13:53 The bus, nobody is able to drive down the Kimberley Nurseries.
0:13:59 Everybody will get to the Lighthouse Christian School.
0:14:01 They will then be bused over to Kimberley Nurseries.
0:14:04 And after the event, they'll get bused back to Lighthouse Christian School to pick up their vehicles.
0:14:11 We are contracting with roadwork ahead for street closures.
0:14:16 They're already on board.
0:14:18 They're ready to close the roads for us.
0:14:21 Rose will be affected as an avenue we use between Eastland and Hankins Road. Any questions?
0:14:32 So, your budget impact says approximately 2800 in overtime. Or the officers that we're going to have participated in.
0:14:40 They'll take 11 officers and then we have also space level for non-sworn civilians to work their ground as well.
0:14:49 Perfect. Anybody have any questions for Lou? I'd entertain a motion. Jason Brown.
0:15:04 I'd move to approve the request for the annual Christmas in the nighttime
0:15:09 Sky event sponsored by Kimberly Nursery on Friday November 25th, 2022.
0:15:15 Thank you, Alex. And I second that. Thank you, motion by Jason Brown, seconded by Alex
0:15:20 All to approve the annual Christmas and the nighttime event on Friday, November 25th, 2022.
0:15:28 Anyone call vote please?
0:15:30 Chris Reed.
0:15:32 Yes.
0:15:33 Thank you, Boyd.
0:15:34 Ray Cawkins.
0:15:35 Yes.
0:15:36 Jason Brown.
0:15:37 Yes.
0:15:38 Yes.
0:15:39 Spencer Cutler.
0:15:40 Yes.
0:15:41 Yes.
0:15:42 Thank you.
0:15:43 Motion passes seven to zero.
0:15:44 Thank you, Lou.
0:15:45 Thank you.
0:15:46 Okay, the next item on the agenda is also an action item.
0:15:50 It is a request requesting approval of the yearly contract amendment to the 2014 agreement
0:15:58 between the City of Twin Falls and CH2M Jacobs for the wastewater treatment plan
0:16:04 and lift station operations in the amount of 3,848,007 and 65 cents
0:16:11 and authorize the mayor to sign.
0:16:12 We have Nathan Erickson.
0:16:14 Welcome, Nathan.
0:16:15 Thank you, Mayor, Council. Appreciate your time tonight. So, yes, I'm here today. I want
0:16:23 to recognize Jack Banden here from Jacobs Engineering. He runs our waste water treatment
0:16:30 plant. We appreciate their partnership in operating that facility. This is the 9th Amendment
0:16:40 to a 10-year contract, this contract in September 30th of 24th,
0:16:46 so we have one more amendment next year.
0:16:49 This is a contract that allows us to account for any changes
0:16:54 that occur throughout the year, or I guess from amendment
0:16:58 to amendment, so it's unique in this amendment.
0:17:03 We're able to compensate for any material changes
0:17:05 or operational costs.
0:17:07 And as we all know, the last year has economically
0:17:12 has been quite costly on all of us.
0:17:16 And same for the wastewater treatment plants,
0:17:17 we've seen quite an increase.
0:17:21 It's also unique in the fact that throughout the year,
0:17:24 they do have to account for their cost.
0:17:27 And so the contract pays for what the actual costs are
0:17:32 throughout the year. To explain this, in the staff report, I want to, I guess, give a little
0:17:45 bit of a background or a story of kind of where we're at and explain why there is quite
0:17:52 a change in the amount that's budget or that we're requesting from council. So in that
0:17:58 there were two points that I brought out. I'm going to start with number two and that was
0:18:06 the increase that you're seeing is best explained initially by the amount that we put into the budget
0:18:14 was inaccurate. So on my PowerPoint, is that coming up? Can you guys see that? So
0:18:26 So to do that, I want to give you kind of a three-year kind of history.
0:18:32 If you look at fiscal year 2021, the budgeted amount of just over 3.1 million in the requested
0:18:42 amount of 3.1 million, that was consistent with really what you would like to see and
0:18:46 what we would like to see happen.
0:18:50 Then in 1.22, what happened was in that year we did see some increased costs after we had
0:18:59 projected a budget amount.
0:19:01 We found out that there was some due to some changes to the boiler and some changes in
0:19:07 our quality permit.
0:19:09 We had to start noticing ferric and there were some additional costs in labor and electricity
0:19:16 and diesel.
0:19:18 last year we had come to council and requested for almost $300,000
0:19:23 increase to that budget if you remember. And so last year council approved a
0:19:28 budget of $3.4, almost $3.5 million. You'll also remember that I'm relatively new
0:19:39 to my position and that position was vacant for some time. I would like to
0:19:44 to point out that this last year's budget, a mistake was made in that because nobody was
0:19:54 really at the will, and there were some changes in the engineering department, we mistakenly
0:19:59 grabbed the budget amount, that previously budgeted number, which wasn't the actual approved
0:20:06 number that we should have used, and so that's one reason why it looked so low as far as what
0:20:12 budgeted. So and then that 3.1 million that was budgeted in 2122 was
0:20:22 increased by 5%. So in 23 we took that number added 5% and that's what is in our
0:20:30 budget. What should have happened is we should have grabbed what council
0:20:36 approved and use that and added the 5% or in what we later found out or now know in item
0:20:46 number two is that Jacobs increased cost is actually 10.4%, actually 10.4, 2, 1, 3 if
0:20:56 you do the math and that gets us to we're actually requesting tonight. So initially the
0:21:04 number that should have been in the budget to start with should have been at $3.4, almost
0:21:10 $3.5 million, and then adding the additional costs that Jacob saw in their operation.
0:21:17 And is now we can go into the memo that was included with your packet that outlines the
0:21:24 costs.
0:21:25 And I will say that this year when Jacob's came to us with the 10.4% increase, the cost
0:21:34 the city was shocked and we're a little concerned, but we did sit down with them and they provided
0:21:43 the information in this memo explaining why. And I think all of us that go grocery shopping or go
0:21:51 buy anything, recognize that everything's costing more. And so in that memo, just for this next year
0:22:00 they're projecting electricity, they're expecting about $111,000, increased chemical, $105,000,
0:22:14 labor, just over $56,000, diesel, $32,000, natural gas, almost $14,000, labor costs,
0:22:26 Just over $14,000 and then the CDL training because there's some new requirements on that.
0:22:34 Just over $12,000 and then the miscellaneous $17,000.
0:22:37 So then that adds the $363,200 to what we pay or what was approved by council last year.
0:22:47 Oh, if there's any questions?
0:22:50 Oh, yes.
0:22:58 Real quick.
0:22:59 I think that Nathan has done a really good job explaining the process and the errors that
0:23:07 occurred.
0:23:08 We also had some complications inside of the finance office around the same point in time,
0:23:13 and so the bad news is that the budget number that was published was severely underrepresented
0:23:20 in comparison to what it should have been.
0:23:23 The good news is, as we've explored and looked at revenues, we do not believe there's any
0:23:29 need for a rate adjustment that we believe that revenues coming into the system are enough
0:23:36 to cover this increase as though moving forward.
0:23:41 So while we had an administrative error in not including that number, there should be
0:23:46 no adjustments to the rates for fiscal year 23.
0:23:51 Now we can't say that there won't be a rate adjustments for fiscal year 24 because if
0:23:57 you follow the stock market today at 2 o'clock it was flying high and at 3 o'clock it decided
0:24:03 to take a nose dive.
0:24:05 So in an hour the world can change as we've learned in the level of uncertainty out there.
0:24:11 We don't want to make predictions about fiscal year 24 when we can't predict what's going
0:24:15 to happen tomorrow in the market.
0:24:17 So while we're comfortable in covering the costs of this year, we want to continue to
0:24:24 monitor the budget moving forward to determine what future rate increases may look like based
0:24:30 upon actual expenditures in our partnership with Jacobs.
0:24:34 Travis, when was the last time we had a rate adjustment?
0:24:38 In the sewer fund?
0:24:39 I think we're going on five years.
0:24:41 Yeah.
0:24:42 Okay.
0:24:43 Chris Reed.
0:24:44 Travis answered the question that I had as far as where is this going to be coming from,
0:24:48 Ultimately, we're just going to kind of stay the course and see as funds come in.
0:24:54 Yeah, the first the first thing that we do is we monitor how revenues are coming in to be able to cover the totality of the expenses.
0:25:01 If not, we begin to make reductions and holdbacks as warranted and moving forward.
0:25:05 And then also Nathan, thank you for this presentation.
0:25:08 I know this is not a fun thing to come for Council and say made a mistake.
0:25:14 So thank you for that.
0:25:15 and also the information in there,
0:25:16 very telling as far as why we need to do this increase,
0:25:20 you know, understanding.
0:25:22 We've all felt that, personally, and then professionally.
0:25:25 And so we're also seeing that,
0:25:27 so that makes complete sense.
0:25:28 So thank you for your presentation.
0:25:30 Yes.
0:25:31 Thank you, boy.
0:25:32 My question is, I know we have CDL licensing here.
0:25:39 We have a company that,
0:25:41 but to do this, we have to go to Boise
0:25:45 get this taken care of? That's through Jacobs. That's their company arrangement is how they do their CDL.
0:25:54 I could let Jack explain that a little bit more. So they're like a contracted partner with you that
0:26:04 everybody that drives for you has been trained at this facility by the people that you know.
0:26:11 Everybody that we're hiring now does not have a CDL will have to attend the training and we we don't have a contract with these folks
0:26:21 This is a state approved
0:26:25 CDL trainer and
0:26:27 They they train our folks for four days
0:26:30 Whereas if we send them elsewhere
0:26:33 Take a multiple weeks to get the same training. So it's a all-day event
0:26:38 condensed. Yes, that is correct. Anybody else have any questions? Entertain the
0:26:53 motion. Nicky Boyd. Mayor, I move that we approve the yearly contract agreement
0:27:00 to the 2014 agreement between the City of Twin Falls and CH2M Jacobs for the
0:27:06 wastewater treatment plan and lift station operations amount of 3,848,
0:27:14 007 and 65 cents and authorized the mayor to sign.
0:27:19 Thank you, Chris Reed.
0:27:20 Second.
0:27:21 Thank you.
0:27:22 Motion by Nicky boys.
0:27:23 Second and by Chris Reed to approve the yearly contract amendment to the 24th 14
0:27:30 agreement between the city and CH2M Jacobs for the wastewater treatment plan
0:27:36 and authorize the mayor to sign any further discussion questions.
0:27:41 Amy Rob, have a vote, please.
0:27:43 Okay, Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Alex Cabal. Yes.
0:27:48 Spencer Cutler. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Reed. Yes.
0:27:52 Nikki Boyd. Yes. Thank you. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you. Thank you, gentlemen.
0:27:57 Next item on the agenda is a time for public input. This is a time for anybody in the audience who wishes to address something that's not on the agenda.
0:28:12 You can come down to the podium and speak.
0:28:16 Okay, it doesn't look like anybody in general advisory board reports.
0:28:23 Buddy, have anything?
0:28:26 Okay, great.
0:28:28 In our Parks and Recreation meeting here last week, the golf course made their kind of end
0:28:35 or report to us.
0:28:36 It was kind of interesting to me to note that the rounds of golf increased for six straight
0:28:41 years.
0:28:42 So that was good news.
0:28:44 Of course, the expenses have also risen like we know with everything else and have taken an increase of 26% over the last three years.
0:28:55 Thalaries, gasoline equipment repairs, fertilizers and so forth of all going up.
0:29:02 So they made a proposal to the board to make a slight increase in fees of less than 5%.
0:29:11 That was approved.
0:29:14 Also, the report from the pool will be open until 8 p.m.
0:29:20 Now, during the winter months, they're going to try and start some adult swim lessons.
0:29:26 And scuba diving classes will be held over the holidays, which sounds kind of fun.
0:29:30 And they're in the process of putting up Christmas decorations throughout the city.
0:29:34 Perfect.
0:29:35 Hey, Simbro.
0:29:36 Yeah, so this last week, the Greater Twin Falls Transportation
0:29:42 I met in our monthly meeting and discussed the third bridge meeting is, they're still
0:29:53 working on community input and trying to get some information, traffic information associated
0:29:59 where that third bridge location would be.
0:30:02 Some I think all of us are anticipating that information coming out.
0:30:06 Also like to thank the engineering department for attending that meeting.
0:30:10 They oftentimes have significantly more information than a council member and did well in that
0:30:19 meeting, presenting information about some of the issues and some of the projects happening
0:30:24 around Twin Falls, so appreciate them being there.
0:30:28 Perfect.
0:30:29 Anyone else?
0:30:30 Getting out of your office?
0:30:32 Madam Mayor, I was counsel, but just as you mentioned, there will be a council meeting
0:30:37 next week.
0:30:38 but there will be a meeting on the 28th at 5 o'clock.
0:30:41 Perfect.
0:30:43 Okay, so we have a public hearing at 6 o'clock,
0:30:46 which can't start any earlier.
0:30:49 We do have an action item to move to executive session,
0:30:53 and what I'm proposing is we move to executive session now,
0:30:58 and then do as much as we can.
0:31:00 We can come back at 6 and then wrap up
0:31:02 after the public hearing if that works.
0:31:05 So I guess that's our color.
0:31:07 I'll make a motion.
0:31:08 So I move that we adjourn to executive session under 742061 to consider the evaluation dismissal
0:31:17 or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer,
0:31:23 employee, staff member or individual agent or public school student.
0:31:28 Thank you.
0:31:29 Do I have a second?
0:31:30 Second.
0:31:31 Motion by seconded by Jason Brown to move into executive session under 742061.
0:31:38 Amy, roll call please.
0:31:41 Jason Brown?
0:31:42 Yes.
0:31:43 Alex Cabal?
0:31:44 Yes.
0:31:45 Benter Cutler?
0:31:46 Yes.
0:31:47 Ruth Pierce?
0:31:48 Yes.
0:31:49 Chris Reed?
0:31:50 Yes.
0:31:51 Thank you.
0:31:52 Motion passes 7-0.
0:31:53 So we move into executive session and we'll be back here right before six o'clock for the public hearing.
0:32:00 Thank you.
0:32:01 You have one minute.
0:32:03 It's the door.
0:32:04 The doors are locked.
0:32:49 The doors are locked.
0:32:50 It's been Monday all day.
0:32:54 It has.
0:32:55 It is.
0:32:57 Are we ready?
0:33:01 All our general public.
0:33:02 Okay.
0:33:03 At six o'clock I'm going to call the meeting back to order.
0:33:17 Next item on the agenda is the public hearing.
0:33:39 all our general public. Okay, at six o'clock I'm going to call the meeting back to
0:33:47 order. Next item on the agenda is the public hearing. It's an action item a public
0:33:56 hearing approving the Urban Renewal Agency Plan for the Orchard Drive East Urban
0:34:01 Renewal Project, an adoption of Ordinance 2022-024 and we have Travis
0:34:08 That's Rothweiler, our City Manager.
0:34:10 Welcome.
0:34:11 Madam Mayor, members of the Council, I'm just going to provide a brief introduction that I'm
0:34:14 going to introduce to you, Megan Conrad.
0:34:16 Megan is probably someone who you work with, the Urban New Agency.
0:34:22 In addition to that, we also have Phil Cushlon, who's with Cushlon and Associates, who has
0:34:27 helped us build the eligibility report for this proposal before you this evening.
0:34:35 So earlier you've seen a resolution, you approved that resolution for this work to go forward,
0:34:39 And tonight is a product of that work.
0:34:41 The Planning and Zoning Commission has completed their work,
0:34:44 and now an ordinance is before you.
0:34:47 Tonight, after the presentation given by Megan,
0:34:50 you will have the opportunity to suspend the rules
0:34:54 and to adopt the ordinance to form, make,
0:34:57 the urban renewal area that Megan is going to go forward
0:35:01 and describe.
0:35:01 So with that, I'm going to turn the time over to Megan.
0:35:04 We'll go through the staff piece of that,
0:35:06 then this is a public hearing, and so we'll open it up
0:35:08 public testimony and then staff and consultants will be available for any
0:35:13 questions that you have either during or after the presentation. Thank you.
0:35:17 Welcome Megan. Thank you Madam Mayor Council members. For the record my name is
0:35:28 Megan Conrad. I'm an attorney with the law firm of Ilam and Burke in Boise, Idaho
0:35:32 251 East Front Street. I represent the Urban Renewal Agency of the City of
0:35:40 Twin Falls. And as Travis indicated with me today is the agency's economic feasibility
0:35:47 consultant for this urban renewal plan that is before you. And Mr. Kirschlein will be
0:35:54 presenting a couple of the slides that are specific to the economic feasibility study.
0:35:59 Let me make sure I have, thank you. So I do understand the City of Twin Falls has a
0:36:13 robust and deep and long history with urban renewal and revenue allocation areas.
0:36:19 It has been a few years now since a plan has come before this body.
0:36:25 I will work to just really focus on the highlights of the urban renewal plan.
0:36:31 Again, both of us are here to answer questions as we go through upon completion of the presentation.
0:36:37 The area that we were talking about is approximately 80 acres.
0:36:45 It is generally located on the west side of Champlain Road and north of Orchard Drive East.
0:36:51 It is an area that is zoned industrial and it's in the future Land East Math as industrial
0:36:58 its own M2 manufacturing at this point. The area that we are talking about for consideration
0:37:05 for an urban renewal plan and project area is for a proposed industrial park type concept.
0:37:11 So it is to be used ultimately for commercial and industrial development.
0:37:16 As Mr. Rothweiler indicated, there's a number of steps that go into creating an urban renewal plan and a revenue allocation area.
0:37:29 We essentially divide up this path into two steps. One is the eligibility phase where a specific geographic area is reviewed
0:37:38 to determine whether or not certain statutory conditions are present in the area that would permit an urban renewal project to go forward.
0:37:47 So the agency board accepted that resolution for the eligibility study in February of this year.
0:37:53 It came before the city council.
0:37:56 The findings were adopted in March of this year and there was direction to the agency to commence with the planning process.
0:38:05 Following that time, the plan was developed. There's a number of attachments
0:38:12 to the plan that take some time, including a survey of the map and the
0:38:16 legal and the economic feasibility study. The agency considered the plan for
0:38:21 approval at its September meeting and there's a number of steps that it goes
0:38:26 through before it comes to you for the public hearing. So on October 14th, the
0:38:32 notice of public hearing was published in the paper. Also, all of the overlapping
0:38:37 taxing districts received a copy of the plan together with the agency resolution,
0:38:41 a copy of the notice of public hearing, and a copy of the map in the legal. On October 25th,
0:38:47 planning and zoning did consider the plan and its conformity with the city's
0:38:52 comprehensive plan and found it to be in conformity by resolution that was
0:38:56 adopted by that body. A second publication of this public hearing occurred on October
0:39:01 and then this today is the time set for the public hearing.
0:39:06 The Urban Renewal Plan is dictated by Idaho Law, specifically chapters 20 and 29 of Title 50.
0:39:23 And Idaho Code Section 50-2905 provides the specific elements that you have to cover in an urban renewal plan.
0:39:30 There are eight elements, and what we've done here is we've outlined those elements
0:39:35 and where in the plan or the attachments that you can find compliance with those
0:39:40 elements. The law has changed or provided more clarity over time that
0:39:44 these elements have to be addressed with a certain level of specificity and
0:39:49 that has been done as you look through the detail of this plan. So what I will
0:39:55 do here is I'll just quickly run through the eight elements and then I will turn
0:39:59 it over to Phil to talk about the economic feasibility study. So first is
0:40:05 The plan has to establish what we refer to as the 10% valuation limitation, and that's
0:40:11 where you have to look at the base assessed value of all of your existing revenue allocation
0:40:16 areas and then propose base assessed value for this area and whether or not those values
0:40:21 exceed 10% of the current taxable value of the city.
0:40:26 And once those numbers are run here, you can see that we're only at 1.16% of the total taxable
0:40:33 value of the city.
0:40:34 a lot of capacity left for an urban renewal districts in the future. The second is the statement
0:40:41 listing the kind number and location of all of the proposed public works or improvements to be
0:40:45 accomplished in this project area. Those are specifically identified in attachment 5 to the
0:40:51 plan. Additionally, in a narrative format, additional detail is provided in section 301.
0:40:58 So there's a bulleted list that further explains how these dollars can be used in conjunction
0:41:03 with the projects that are identified in attachment five.
0:41:07 Another element is an economic feasibility study which I'll have
0:41:10 I'll talk about but that is attachment five to the plan
0:41:15 and as well as that is included the detail list of the project costs.
0:41:20 Element five is a fiscal impact statement which essentially is
0:41:24 showing the impact to the overlapping taxing districts of
0:41:27 the adoption of this plan and project area and as you know
0:41:32 But a tax-humanity will set its budget and then we'll get the dollars through its budget
0:41:37 and levy and assessment collection process.
0:41:40 There's no change when you overlay a revenue allocation area.
0:41:44 When we talk about impacts, what we're really talking about is a deferral of the new development
0:41:49 value going on the new construction role.
0:41:52 And that's just deferred until the time of termination of a revenue allocation area.
0:41:58 ultimately that value comes back on the new construction role. First off to the statutory
0:42:03 process which right now has changed pursuant to the 389 and amendments to that bill.
0:42:08 LMN6 talks about the description of the methods of financing. There's a number of
0:42:15 ways you can finance the projects in a revenue allocation area. They can be
0:42:19 through bonds. They can be most common or pay as you go. So you earn the revenue over
0:42:25 a period of time and then you fund the projects directly. Probably the most common method
0:42:32 is this concept of a developer reimbursement where the developer or owner will advance
0:42:38 fund these specific public infrastructure improvements and then those will be reimbursed
0:42:42 over a period of time in a specific percentage over the life of the district either until
0:42:48 it's fully reimbursed or until the district terminates whichever occurs first. The plan
0:42:55 also requires that you have a termination date, Idaho Law says that you can only have a revenue
0:43:00 allocation area in place for 20 years. So the termination date is December 31st, 2042, recognizing
0:43:07 the agency will receive revenue in the calendar year following termination just as a function of how our
0:43:13 ex-levy process works in arrears. And finally, element eight is the description of the disposition
0:43:19 of assets upon termination and there is the ability for an agency to retain assets in general
0:43:26 after termination in an area such as this to the extent the agency does own any assets most likely
0:43:32 they would be transferred to the city and that's found in section 800. So with that I will turn it
0:43:39 over to Phil to talk about the economic feasibility study. Phil before you start but come on up I was
0:43:47 was remiss I did not read the public hearing procedures so I need to do that really quick.
0:43:55 Individuals was part of opening the public hearing of the session, the mayor will review
0:43:59 the public hearing procedures. Individuals were seen to testify over our city council
0:44:05 shall wait to be recognized by the mayor, approach the podium, state their name, proceed
0:44:10 with their comments, following their statements, the white names on the record sheets provided
0:44:16 by the staff.
0:44:17 City staff reports have summarized the application in history, which was Travis, the applicant
0:44:22 or spokesperson for the applicant will make a presentation on the application.
0:44:27 No changes to the request may be made by the applicant after the publication of the Notice
0:44:32 of Public Hearing.
0:44:34 Presentation shall include complete explanation and description of the request while the request
0:44:39 is being made, relocation of the property, impact on surrounding property.
0:44:44 about 8 applicants limited to 15 minutes.
0:44:49 The City Council may ask questions of staff
0:44:51 or the applicant.
0:44:53 General Public will then be given the opportunity
0:44:56 to provide their testimony regarding the request.
0:45:01 Individuals are not permitted to give their time
0:45:03 to other speakers.
0:45:05 Written comments received by noon on the day of the hearing
0:45:08 will be included.
0:45:10 On the public testimony, the applicant
0:45:11 is permitted five minutes to respond.
0:45:14 Following the public testimony and the applicant's response council shall be allowed to request
0:45:20 the applicant stop for anyone testifying, responses will be limited to answering the
0:45:25 questions asked and the mayor and chairman will then close the public hearing.
0:45:30 Council will deliver the request, deliverations and decisions will be based on the information
0:45:36 and testimony provided during the public hearing once it's closed, nor will their testimony
0:45:41 is allowed legal or procedural questions may be directed to the city attorney.
0:45:46 Thank you for allowing me to do that. Okay, Phil.
0:45:49 Thank you, Your Honor. Remember the council is indicated.
0:45:56 One of the required elements of the urban rule plan is a economic feasibility analysis.
0:46:03 And basically what that entails in high level is to have some legitimate estimation of the amount of revenue
0:46:13 that we generated over the 20-year life of the district,
0:46:17 and then compare that with the proposed
0:46:23 amount of the infrastructure that would be required.
0:46:27 And if the revenue generated exceeds the cost
0:46:30 of the infrastructure investment,
0:46:33 then it can be determined to be economically feasible.
0:46:37 What we have done in,
0:46:40 I want to detail here, but taking basically two steps.
0:46:46 One is to try to estimate the tax increment yield
0:46:51 over the life of the district.
0:46:53 And a couple of things here.
0:46:55 One is we have to basically have some assumptions
0:46:59 about what the general background growth rate will
0:47:02 be in the district itself without anything happening out
0:47:06 there.
0:47:07 And we've done that in terms of making some forecasts
0:47:09 terms of what the value of the land will increase annually, the value of the improvements over time.
0:47:17 And then add into that a proposed schedule of taxable investment. And that amount was provided
0:47:26 by the developer themselves to suggest how much and when that was going to occur. And what we
0:47:33 We did is we kind of put that in the fiscal model and their estimate was like $111 billion
0:47:40 of private investment was going to occur there.
0:47:44 We run that through the tax rates and given the bit of uncertainty that was at hand as
0:47:52 we were putting this together because we weren't quite sure what the effect of the tax limitations
0:47:57 were.
0:47:58 And so in concert with City Manager, we cinched it down pretty tight.
0:48:04 We produced the tax levy down 30% to make sure that we weren't making promises that we couldn't
0:48:11 keep here.
0:48:13 And so with that, those factors, we generated about $20 million over time.
0:48:21 And so that's a pretty good sum to work with over the period.
0:48:27 But it's only a good sum if you have a smaller number to spend a lot.
0:48:31 And so, in addition to the estimation of private taxable investment, the developer provided
0:48:40 us with a list of public improvements that were going to be supported by the project.
0:48:46 And that came out about $9.25 million.
0:48:50 And so, in addition to that, assuming that it's done through, as Megan talked about,
0:48:59 we have participation agreement where it would be reimbursed, we assume there'd be some expectation
0:49:04 of interest rate against that.
0:49:07 So we kind of calculated that in there.
0:49:09 And then also, what we normally do is we set aside a certain amount for agency operations
0:49:18 to make sure there's resources available to basically run the process.
0:49:22 And so what we've done is we basically take, set aside 10% of the annual yield from the tax
0:49:30 increment process for agency operation, but then we cap that as $75,000 a year and then
0:49:36 run that flat line down.
0:49:39 So what we assumed is that we could, and then again, these are all subject to an agreement
0:49:45 with the developer, but from our assumption, we assumed that we would commit about 75%
0:49:51 of the annual yield to the reimbursement to the developer, and then that came after the
0:49:58 10% deduction, and then we ran basically a cash flow analysis, and we came out at the
0:50:06 end with about a $414,000 net positive balance at the end.
0:50:14 So in addition to that, we provided an opportunity for advance payment if for some reason things
0:50:21 go a little better than we thought we could move that payment ahead and possibly close
0:50:26 out the district early.
0:50:27 But that certainly would be at the discretion of the agency board and the city council.
0:50:32 So my analysis reflected that indeed given the assumptions that were inherent in our analysis
0:50:39 that I just put a summary on that the project is economically feasible and
0:50:44 would be something that would be passing that economic feasibility test and
0:50:52 again that's at the discretion of the council if you want to proceed. Don't be
0:50:55 happy to answer any questions. Any questions for Phil or Megan maybe at
0:50:59 this point? Yes. Hi. Again when you were talking about valuation earlier the
0:51:12 10% rule. How does the creation of this district impact the old town revenue
0:51:22 allocator district that's being created? Because right now I think you said this
0:51:27 one is like at 1.16. Is there is there enough room in that number there to
0:51:34 adequately account for the new one that's gonna be created? Or is that or are we
0:51:39 gonna run into a problem on that new one? Or maybe Phil can answer that one.
0:51:42 Your Honor, else remember, um, happenstance is that I'm also just concluding the draft
0:51:54 and eligibility report for the new district, and I ran that calculation.
0:52:01 And while the new district's base value is significantly more than this one, I've concluded
0:52:07 that there is still a significant amount of authority under your 10% limitation with
0:52:12 the new district as I drew it up. So this is not a part of that consideration at all.
0:52:20 Just checking because when I saw 1.1% for that size and I remember the size of the other one
0:52:27 I just wasn't sure how it was going to work out. So thank you. Thank you. Any other questions?
0:52:33 Hey, Megan, go on. Thank you Madam Mayor Council. I just have a few more quick slides to hit some
0:52:39 high points and I'm happy to share these slides with you but for Phil's presentation just in terms of
0:52:47 what public infrastructure improvements are we contemplating they are all public infrastructure
0:52:52 improvements. We're talking about water and sewer, we're talking about street, some irrigation canal
0:52:57 improvements and then electric and natural gas system improvements that essentially would be
0:53:05 included in a right-of-way area. And Mr.
0:53:12 Christian's numbers are found in the
0:53:14 attachment 5 to the plan. All of these
0:53:15 charts that you see here are attached
0:53:18 there too and you can, both of us are
0:53:21 certainly happy to answer any of the
0:53:22 assumptions or charts that you see. As
0:53:27 mentioned earlier, there was a finding of
0:53:29 conformity with your existing comprehensive
0:53:31 plan so that box has been checked. Finally
0:53:36 we are talking about a post-July 1
0:53:38 2016 plan. What that means is that there are some real limitations on the ability
0:53:44 to amend a revenue allocation area once it's adopted. So that is why there is, you
0:53:51 know, a certain level of detail that goes in to the planning at this point,
0:53:55 because to the extended city council ordinance was adopted after this plan
0:54:01 was adopted, amending the plan or adding a project, it could trigger a reset of the
0:54:06 base which would eliminate your revenue stream. So there are exceptions, they're
0:54:09 very limited. Ministerial and technical changes and annexation and de-annexation
0:54:14 or for an existing commercial or industrial project, but we just want to
0:54:18 make sure that we're aware of that limitation. Another requirement is that
0:54:25 to the extent a property is deemed to be an agricultural operation, you have to have
0:54:31 consent to the property owner. That box has been checked. There's also a change in
0:54:35 in the statute under 50-2908 that addresses how the allocation of highway district levies
0:54:42 between an agency and highway district.
0:54:44 The exception there is when the city has maintenance obligations on right-of-way within
0:54:51 the city, then the allocation of the revenues do flow to the urban renewal agency.
0:55:00 There will need to be something that's ultimately signed by the city and submitted to the county
0:55:03 and state tax commission that confirms that, but for our purposes, an agreement is not going
0:55:10 to be required for those allegations.
0:55:13 Next steps today, we're here for the public hearing and potential consideration of the ordinance.
0:55:17 There's a number of post-ordinates, adoptions, steps that take place in terms of publication
0:55:24 recordation and there's a separate transmittal to taxing districts, state tax commission
0:55:29 County officials. In order to have a base year of January 1, 2022, all of these steps have to be
0:55:35 completed by December 31, 2022. So with that, happy to answer any questions. Thank you.
0:55:44 Any questions for Megan, Alex? What is the developer's timeline for that industrial park?
0:55:59 Because that's going to affect Phil's budget revenues. Like, what are they projecting in terms of
0:56:05 building that industrial. Yes, thank you. So in attachment five you will have, there is a revenue
0:56:15 projection sheet and in general it looks like the first value will be on the tax rolls as of 2024
0:56:26 and that would be so actually it would be CO of 2023 the revenues would flow to the
0:56:31 agency from that taxing district in 2024. Is this in our in your slide presentation?
0:56:39 Because we don't have it in our packet. And I turn, but under the one, two, three, four, fifth column
0:56:54 in 2024, you have the 11.3 million. So this is a combination of information provided by the
0:57:01 development team as well as what has been reviewed by Mr. Carson. I know that the
0:57:07 is currently working its way through the city process.
0:57:12 More word momentum is occurring.
0:57:15 And just to be clear, urban renewal plan is not a contract in and of itself.
0:57:19 It is a plan or a guide to how development can occur within a specific geographic area for a period of time.
0:57:25 So if ultimately adopted, there will be a separate agreement with the developer that sets this out.
0:57:30 So to the extent developments delayed, you know, that it is possible that they don't get fully reimbursed.
0:57:36 So there is that extra, yeah, you're right, there's that extra step where there's going
0:57:45 to be, they're going to have to go through that, or they're going to have to jump through
0:57:51 the request for a proposal, or is that already addressed because it came to us with the plan?
0:57:58 Thank you, Madam Mayor.
0:57:59 Councilwoman, it's what they would do is there's what would be called an owner participation
0:58:06 agreement that would have to be negotiated between the developer and the agency, that
0:58:11 would spell out specifically what public infrastructure improvements are going to be
0:58:16 deemed eligible, and it will set up a process for reimbursement of those eligible costs, and
0:58:25 they won't be reimbursed until they're fully completed and accepted by the city. And that's
0:58:31 the trigger for the reimbursement, but it's an agreement that will be entered into between
0:58:35 knows bodies. And as part of that agreement or that process, there's a financial review
0:58:40 of any plan that they're going to propose or any there's a financial review of what they're
0:58:44 going to be doing, right? That will be part of it. Just to make sure that what they're
0:58:49 also proposing at that time is economically feasible. Yes. Right. And that's and the reason
0:58:55 I was asking about that is because there's been a change in the markets since you know
0:59:00 February to now and the question will be all right. You put all those improvements in there
0:59:05 but then are you going to get any or going to be anybody in there to generate those revenues?
0:59:10 So, that extra step with that financial review is part of the development.
0:59:20 Travis wants to add something.
0:59:22 Yeah, so just a couple of things to remember. Number one, this is the developer's best guess
0:59:29 in terms of how things are going to be built out over a period of time. When we've met with
0:59:35 the developer is going to be building the AD acres in a series of phases starting with some smaller units first and then it's going to move forward as demand moves forward.
0:59:50 Megan said a couple of key points. Number one, it's a reimbursement agreement of eligible public infrastructure and what that means is either the agency nor the city is responsible for any cost overruns.
1:00:04 If the increment is not there, it is the owner's risk and that has been communicated.
1:00:09 It will also be part of the agreement that we spell out.
1:00:14 So, their public infrastructure improvements, they're eligible for reimbursement.
1:00:18 But if their project does not yield the revenues that they are believing it will, then they're
1:00:25 on the hook for those costs and they do not get reimbursed.
1:00:29 You can't reimburse out of an agency money that doesn't exist.
1:00:33 So those are the salient points.
1:00:36 The other thing is we're crucivalling 20 years, and the idea here is that we want to
1:00:45 make some reasonable steps to understand what that development could be and build out, but
1:00:52 we're also trying to project what the value is going to be in 20 years.
1:00:56 And if we were to look back 20 years from now, I don't believe anybody would have believed
1:01:02 that property in Twin Falls costs what it is to date.
1:01:07 And so there's a lot of speculation,
1:01:10 there's a lot of crystal balling,
1:01:11 and there's no risk for the agency
1:01:15 when it comes to being responsible for costs.
1:01:19 We're clarifying that.
1:01:21 Thank you.
1:01:22 Any other questions?
1:01:25 Thank you.
1:01:27 Thank you.
1:01:32 Okay, so next I will open the public hearing.
1:01:36 If there's anybody here in the public that wishes to speak,
1:01:41 There's only one person here, I think.
1:01:45 We'll open the public hearing.
1:01:48 If you choose to speak, please come down and state your name and whether you're resident
1:01:53 of Twin Falls and say what you need to say if you can say in three minutes.
1:02:00 So is there anybody here that wishes to speak on this subject?
1:02:07 See no one.
1:02:08 I'm going to close the public hearing.
1:02:10 So next will be any other questions for the applicant staff that haven't already been
1:02:18 asked.
1:02:21 Okay, so I'll close the public hearing.
1:02:24 So council wishes if we choose to pass the ordinance tonight, we put it on third and final
1:02:38 first and go from there.
1:02:41 Just read.
1:02:48 I just want to thank everybody who's participated in this.
1:02:51 I know that urban renewal has spent a lot of time on this.
1:02:54 Travis we have several that have this is not something that just started last week
1:02:59 So I appreciate all the hard work that's gone into this. I'm excited as a community
1:03:05 We continue to continue to grow and structured
1:03:11 planned ways
1:03:13 Like this is a good a good thing for our community
1:03:16 So I'll start the ball rolling with the motion if that works mayor
1:03:20 Perfect. I move that we dispense with the reading rules and put ordinance 2022-024
1:03:28 on third and final reading by title. Thank you. Do I have a second? I second.
1:03:36 Excellent. Motion by Christopher Reed seconded by Alex Kaval to put on his 2022-24 on
1:03:45 on the third and final reading by title only.
1:03:50 Amy Roll, call vote please.
1:03:52 Spencer Cutler.
1:03:54 Yes.
1:03:54 Alex Kaval.
1:03:56 Yes.
1:03:56 Jason Brown.
1:03:57 Yes.
1:03:58 Craig Hawkins.
1:03:58 Yes.
1:03:59 Thank you, Boyd.
1:04:00 Yes.
1:04:00 Chris Reed.
1:04:01 Yes.
1:04:02 And Ruth Pierce.
1:04:03 Yes.
1:04:04 Thank you.
1:04:04 Motion passes 7 to 0.
1:04:07 So I'm going to read the ordinance.
1:04:09 I don't have it in front of me,
1:04:11 so I'm going to pull it up on the screen.
1:04:13 The City of Twin Falls ordinance number 2022 dash 024 and ordinance of the City Council
1:04:21 of the City of Twin Falls itemo approving the Urban Renewal Plan for the Orchard Drive East
1:04:26 Urban Renewal Project which includes revenue allocation, financing provisions, authorizing
1:04:33 the City Clerk to transmit a copy of this ordinance, another required information to
1:04:38 the county and state officials and the effective tax
1:04:41 amenities, providing several body
1:04:45 courtification and publication by summary,
1:04:48 providing for waiver of the reading rules
1:04:50 and providing an effective date.
1:04:56 Chris Reed.
1:04:57 Move to approve ordinance 2022-024.
1:05:01 Craig Hawkins.
1:05:03 Thank you, motion by Christopher Reed,
1:05:05 seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the adoption
1:05:09 ordinance 2022 dash 024. Any further discussion? Amy will call vote please.
1:05:16 Ruth Pierce? Yes. Chris Reed? Yes. Nikki Boyd? Yes.
1:05:21 Are you cocking? Yes. Jason Brown? Yes. Alex Kaval? Yes.
1:05:24 Henspenser Koehler? Yes. Perfect. Motion passes 7 to 0. Thank you all. So we have on the agenda
1:05:35 I still to move back into executive session so I actually need a motion to that
1:05:41 effective somebody would make that motion. Mayor I move that we adjourn into
1:05:48 executive session under 742061. Thank you to have a second. Thank you.
1:05:55 Motion by Nikki Boy second of bike Jason Brown to approve moving back into
1:06:02 executive session under 74-2061. Any more
1:06:08 couple please? Chris Reed. Yes. Nikki
1:06:11 Boyd. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Alex Koval. Yes.
1:06:16 Mentor Cutler. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes.
1:06:19 Motion passes 7-0. We will not be
1:06:22 returning to council chambers. We will not be making any decisions in
1:06:26 executive session. Thank you all.
Download
- Transcript (text) 57 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 75 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 100 KB
- Audio (M4A) 15.7 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 14, 2022. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:06:34.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
35e1cef0614a5ede83331a0f74a1451979087d61bf1d7eacdc8864a64884b97a - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 819f4972e6e681cd0c1946845904175baf6a277185df4ce4e010dc0499fc3227 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
fee2497e6d0a9ce0e7a285e87c5b7f74b4ef5a6d2e17c5cb5e984c5ae0c2eefc
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file