City Council meeting
Monday, August 22, 2022
Special meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:46 Thank you for your patience actually we're not to that.
0:00:52 Calling to order the City Council meeting for August 22nd, 2022, I'll call the meeting
0:01:00 to order and confirm we have a quorum.
0:01:02 We have six City Council members in chambers today.
0:01:08 First item on the agenda is Executive Session under Section 742061B to consider the evaluation
0:01:16 to dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought
0:01:21 against the public officer staff member and or individual agent or public school
0:01:27 student. How's it wishes?
0:01:30 Into executive committee session please.
0:01:35 Thank you Chris. Motion by Christopher Reed second by Craig Hawkins to move into
0:01:42 Executive Session under 74206.
0:01:47 Aaron Rolkoffo, please.
0:01:50 Mayor Pears?
0:01:51 Yes.
0:01:52 Nice, Mayor Reed?
0:01:53 Yes.
0:01:54 Nicky Boyd?
0:01:55 Yes.
0:01:56 Craig Hawkins?
0:01:57 Yes.
0:01:58 Jason Brown?
0:01:59 Yes.
0:02:00 Spencer Cutler?
0:02:01 Yes.
0:02:02 Thank you.
0:02:03 Motion passes 6 to 0.
0:02:04 So we will be now moving into Executive Session.
0:02:07 We're scheduled to come back at 6 o'clock for regular council meeting and then we'll see
0:02:13 And then we'll have our public hearing hearings today on the budget.
0:02:17 So expect us back in about 30 minutes.
0:02:21 Thank you.
0:02:58 We're reconvening to the council.
0:02:59 We met at 5.30 and moved into executive session.
0:03:02 We're now complete.
0:03:04 So again, I want to confirm that we have a quorum.
0:03:07 We have six council members present.
0:03:12 First item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:03:15 Anybody wishing to join me?
0:03:16 Please rise.
0:03:37 though we have no proclamations tonight.
0:03:40 So the first item, so the next item is the consent calendar.
0:03:46 Council wishes the consent calendar has presented.
0:03:56 Thank you.
0:03:57 Great.
0:04:01 Somebody use their button here.
0:04:03 Okay.
0:04:04 So it's a motion by Spencer Cutler,
0:04:06 second by Craig Hawkins to approve the consent calendar.
0:04:12 Aaron Rolkavo, please.
0:04:14 Mayor Pearson.
0:04:15 Yes.
0:04:16 Thank you, motion passes six to zero.
0:04:26 If you are here for the right-of-way dedication for the Kacil sidewalk project, to enfals
0:04:32 school district, a building permit, and a Spanish heritage festival and the final
0:04:41 that for Kenyan meadows subdivision those have all been approved so next item is
0:04:48 items of consideration and we actually don't have anything on the agenda so
0:04:53 we're going to now move to the public hearing and we have public hearings and
0:05:00 we have two items yes would it be appropriate to do general public input
0:05:06 for items not on the budget prior to the public hearings thank you very much I
0:05:11 I was moving right along.
0:05:13 So before we move into public hearings,
0:05:16 it is now time for general public input, which
0:05:19 is input from anybody in the audience who wishes to comment
0:05:24 on something tonight other than the budget.
0:05:27 Is there anybody out there that wishes to speak?
0:05:32 It looks like two people.
0:05:36 So please state your full name and whether you're
0:05:38 a resident of Twin Falls.
0:05:39 And I'll give you two minutes to push the green button.
0:05:45 Thank you.
0:05:53 My name is Patty Cameron, and I'm a resident of Twin Falls.
0:05:57 And I want to address something that a hearing of last week.
0:06:02 Am I able to do that?
0:06:05 On the hearing of last week with the historic and part of it?
0:06:09 You can make a comment, yeah, in your time frame.
0:06:12 OK.
0:06:12 So I was wondering, I know that there
0:06:16 are some that wanted their homes to be historic,
0:06:18 and then there's those that who do not.
0:06:21 was wondering why we could not let those move forward who wanted to and those that did not
0:06:29 have a specific guideline that when they sold their home the person that purchased that would
0:06:34 have to be understanding that they'd have to follow the guidelines for their home to be a
0:06:38 historical home. Does anybody have the answer to that, Travis? So either Shane or I can take that
0:06:46 So I believe that there are two processes, and I think that John and Elmine, both one,
0:06:51 is that you had created geographic area in which all of the properties that are defined
0:06:56 in that geographic area would be included.
0:06:59 That was the request that was moved forward.
0:07:02 The secondary request would be on that individual selection process, like that you had described.
0:07:07 And so that is an option, but that is not necessarily the option that the citizens who came forward were requesting.
0:07:15 And you vote on that to so that everybody's happy,
0:07:21 so that the people that want to can move forward
0:07:23 and those that didn't want to.
0:07:24 When they sold their home, it has to fall
0:07:27 under those guidelines.
0:07:28 The quick answer is, no, we can't do that hybrid approach
0:07:40 is what it sounded like you wanted to create.
0:07:41 It has to be where one individual applies for and receives
0:07:47 kind of historical building designations
0:07:49 for their specific house.
0:07:51 But if it's for a geographic area,
0:07:54 We can't really maneuvering car valves, certain houses, and not others in that area, even if, even with the idea that future homeowners kind of goes to this idea of heavily spot zone, things and districts, it has to be an old geographic location.
0:08:12 Thank you.
0:08:15 Yes, ma'am, you need to come down to the microphone, please, and state your phone name and whether you're a resident of Twin Falls.
0:08:23 Justine Hernandez, I'm here to, uh, for the vacancy.
0:08:29 Is it time for to do that one?
0:08:30 Not today, we'll, I'll be discussing that later, but we will be doing that next week.
0:08:35 Oh, it was announced that it was good to do it this week, but no. Thank you. Thank you.
0:08:40 Anybody else out there? Okay, so any advisory board reports before I move into the public hearing?
0:08:51 No advisory board reports? Okay, now we're moving into the public hearing.
0:08:58 So, I might just mention that anybody wanting to testify today will be asked to come down
0:09:09 to the podium and speak.
0:09:11 We will be allowing two minutes for your comment or question and we'll do that after we've
0:09:19 had our staff presentation.
0:09:21 So, the first one is Travis, a public hearing to consider approval of the use of 267 or 20
0:09:30 out of work on revenue in the fiscal year 2022-23 budget and adoption of an associated
0:09:37 resolution authorizing the same.
0:09:40 Welcome, Travis.
0:09:43 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the Council.
0:09:45 At the conclusion of the public hearings, I would just ask that if you go back to the
0:09:49 staff report, I know typically the city manager doesn't have an opportunity to provide a report, but we've committed to provide an update on the city council election
0:10:00 city appointment process and so on, the conclusion of the public hearings, if we could just kind of revert back to that degree.
0:10:08 So, you all know I love sports analogies and this is the national championship game, the playoffs, the world series, this is it.
0:10:19 it. And really thank you to the council for your patience as we've gone through this process.
0:10:25 For members of the community who are joining us for the first time this evening, this is the
0:10:31 13th conversation and 9th consecutive that we've had on the budget this year. There are two public
0:10:39 hearings that you have tonight and we're going to make one presentation but we would ask that you
0:10:45 host one presentation as a result of the SAS portion of the public hearings. You would
0:10:51 open it up for public hearings and you will consider the two items independently of one
0:10:57 another. The first item that you will be asked to consider as part of the public hearing
0:11:03 is the use of the 1% of the foregone amount and there is a resolution as required by state
0:11:09 statute that is included in your packet for your consideration. Then there will be the
0:11:14 the appropriation ordinance that you will do after.
0:11:19 And those are all things that we've talked about
0:11:21 through the entire process of how we're going to be able
0:11:24 to move those, create those revenues to be able
0:11:27 to supply the services moving forward.
0:11:31 So as we have shared, this budget has been crafted
0:11:33 by many hands and it's also been done in review
0:11:37 of Idaho Code and the best practices
0:11:39 of several different organizations,
0:11:42 whether it be the Government Finance Office Association
0:11:44 of the International State Management Association.
0:11:47 It is all constructed around a strategic plan.
0:11:50 A strategic plan that has eight core focus areas,
0:11:53 each one of those focus areas, members of our team presented
0:11:56 to you in detail.
0:11:57 We shared staffing constraints and concerns.
0:12:01 We shared successes.
0:12:02 We shared challenges.
0:12:04 We shared opportunities.
0:12:05 We shared projects.
0:12:08 And we spent the summer going through a fairly detailed
0:12:12 explanation of how our strategic plan drives the budgetary processes. And I'd
0:12:19 like to congratulate all the members of the city team and all levels who really
0:12:23 helped create much better budget than if it were just created by my hand. So the
0:12:29 city's budget is larger than last year. One of the questions I was asked is is
0:12:36 this the largest budget ever issued by the city of Twin Falls? And the answer is
0:12:41 Now, our budgets tend to have been flow, and the largest determining factor is the size
0:12:49 of the capital projects that will be included in early 2010-12-13.
0:12:57 We had an arsenic project as well as a wastewater project, and when we go through the budget
0:13:03 amendment process, that budget for the city to involve us, we include those capital dollars
0:13:08 Crusted over a hundred million place where we've also shared with the council
0:13:15 There's a potential upwards of 18 million dollars of fire station money
0:13:20 Combination of certificates of participation and cash reserves that will incorporate into this budget
0:13:24 And so this is not the largest budget that has ever been recorded the other question
0:13:31 It was asked is what happens if there's a three three tie without a seventh member we make you sit here until you vote. Yes
0:13:40 Yes, so tonight really is an opportunity to ask those final questions and to be in a space
0:13:50 to be confident that the budget that you're setting forward for the next fiscal year will
0:13:55 drive all of the city services moving forward.
0:13:59 As we've shared repeatedly, it is among the lowest of tax rates that we have ever issued
0:14:03 at $4.78 per thousand and it's really a result of the city's total taxable value of a community
0:14:11 growing by nearly $1.6 billion this year. That's in addition to the nearly $200 million
0:14:18 rule inside of the urban rule there is, so if you think about that. The city of twin falls
0:14:24 grew collectively by nearly one point you look at the total value of the city of twin falls
0:14:34 almost as much as the total value of the city in 2013. So this budget is broken to two major
0:14:47 pieces we refer to them as the tax supported and the enterprise funds we spent lots of time
0:14:53 going through those two those two differences and then the budget can also be broke down into five
0:14:58 components you'll see the personnel is the largest and that makes sense when you think that we are
0:15:04 a human organization we deliver public services through talented and gifted human hands this is
0:15:14 is a graphical illustration of the tax rate.
0:15:19 And then one of the things that we'd like to do
0:15:21 is we'd like to answer the question,
0:15:24 how does the city of Twin Falls property tax burden
0:15:28 compare to other municipalities in the state of Idaho
0:15:33 that we would consider to be our peers?
0:15:36 And what we do is we look backwards
0:15:38 because every single one of those cities
0:15:39 is probably going through their final budget process
0:15:42 sometime later this week or next week.
0:15:46 And so we look backwards one year.
0:15:50 You can see the City of Twin Falls median house income
0:15:54 on January 1st as well as the tax rate that was applied
0:15:58 for the current fiscal year.
0:15:59 And you can see what the median home pay is in property taxes.
0:16:05 And you can see the City of Twin Falls is among the lowest.
0:16:07 We've shared why we don't include Boise and Meridian
0:16:11 and that's largely because of the impact that Haida County
0:16:14 Highway District has on their overall tax rate.
0:16:18 We spend time sharing the need of employees and we recognize that there are more employees
0:16:24 that are needed or position upgrades that are needed that are included in this budget.
0:16:28 But one of the things that we've always committed to this council is that our budgets will be
0:16:33 thoughtful and will be sustainable.
0:16:34 I want to make sure that when we hire somebody into our organization, it is not a decision
0:16:41 that hasn't just, members of our team have gone through review of their processes.
0:16:49 they've reviewed workloads and they develop a good solid justification for these positions
0:16:56 and that's why we're confident in placing these budgets, these positions in the budget
0:17:00 we're also confident in our ability to fund them going forward.
0:17:05 Operation impedance is one of the things that we spent time talking about.
0:17:09 We're all aware of inflation. It seems to be one of the largest topics of conversation that we have
0:17:15 whether it be in the media or with our own organization.
0:17:19 You can see that the cost of us doing business, our operation maintenance, applies us up 7.46%
0:17:26 and the municipal cost index is up nearly 12.5%
0:17:30 so you can see that the queen at the city members of our department teams have found ways to cut costs
0:17:38 to offer high levels of services and find ways to be more efficient and more effective in our approaches
0:17:45 And then again, 18 million dollars that we're spending on capital programming this year, that excludes the potential 18 million dollars that we will be expending on fire stations.
0:17:57 And so that's why that budget process really had the budget amendment does have that ebb and flow.
0:18:02 When you add an additional 18 million dollars, it gives close to maybe being one of the largest budgets, but it is still not the largest budget to hold on.
0:18:10 The council heard all of those projects and then they came together and they built their
0:18:17 council capital list of projects and really again just the creativeness of our team, how
0:18:24 they had shared in that process that we would be able to take $271,000 of CDBG funding and
0:18:30 apply to additional sidewalk projects for the city council.
0:18:38 So in the end, we believe this budget is as conservative as we can make it, and yet we're
0:18:46 not guaranteeing property tax reduction with the declining tax rate.
0:18:50 In fact, we have been very transparent in saying that residents in our community may
0:18:54 pay more property taxes, and that is a result of how fast homes are appreciating in our
0:19:02 area.
0:19:03 A tax rate in Idaho is a simple multiplier.
0:19:05 It is a multiplier that is taken between the total government spend, which is 3% statutorily,
0:19:13 the value of new construction and the 1% foregone balance, divided by the total taxable value gives you the multiplier of the tax rate.
0:19:21 And while our tax rate has declined nearly 24%, as we've shared throughout this entire process,
0:19:28 homes in some cases have grown by more than 40%.
0:19:33 While the home values continue to rapidly increase, citizens of our community may see
0:19:41 slightly larger property tax bills.
0:19:45 It will also say that we're one of the few cities that I'm aware of that is not increasing
0:19:50 water rates, sewer rates, or sanitation rates.
0:19:53 In fact, I think we're one of the few public utilities that isn't doing that.
0:19:58 If you reflect upon the other public utilities that you may be consuming into it falls or
0:20:03 Look at their rate increases, and I think that this is an effective use of our dollars, but it's also an indication of our team's
0:20:11 recognition of the status of our economy while strong.
0:20:15 Still in the state of flux with a level of inflation, and they really found ways to ensure that we're moving forward with zero increases
0:20:23 on those areas that we had the most control of.
0:20:25 This is it. Here we are, and we're happy to stand for any questions. Again, there's two public hearings.
0:20:35 The first public hearing that you need to move forward with is the inclusion of the 1%
0:20:41 for gun balance.
0:20:42 We've talked about that, and then the second piece of that is public hearing to the general
0:20:49 budget.
0:20:50 Staff is available to answer any questions that you might have along the way.
0:20:56 So any questions for Travis on either of those items?
0:20:59 Well just to be clear, we'll have both public hearings and then we'll discuss both items
0:21:05 at the end and vote for both items at the end, that would you suggest it?
0:21:11 So I would take them one at a time.
0:21:13 Yep, so we made a presentation because of the budget.
0:21:16 Okay, close.
0:21:22 So with that, we on the first item, the first public hearing, we will open up the public hearing
0:21:37 to consider the approval of the use of 2067-420, a foregone revenue in the fiscal year 2022-2023
0:21:46 budget and adoption of associated resolution authorizing the same. So is there anybody out
0:21:54 in the public that would wish to come down and comment on that particular item? Seeing
0:22:06 No one next action item is the public hearing to consider approval of the fiscal year 2022-2023 budget and adoption of the associated appropriation ordinance for the city of Twin Falls.
0:22:21 Is there anybody out there that would like to come down and comment on the budget?
0:22:34 See no one Travis.
0:22:41 So Madam Mayor, your first did you close the public hearing?
0:22:44 I didn't. The public hearing is closed.
0:22:49 Madam Mayor, the first action of business would be a consideration of a resolution authorizing
0:22:56 the use of $267,420 of foregone revenue in the fiscal year 2022-2023, but counsel wishes
0:23:10 Chris Reed.
0:23:13 Here I move that we approve the use of $267,420 of foregone revenue in the fiscal year 2022-2023
0:23:25 budget and adoption of an associated resolution authorizing the same resolution
0:23:30 number 2022-12 use of foregone. Thank you, Nicky Boy. Thank you, motion by
0:23:39 Christopher Reed, seconded by Nicky Boy to approve the resolution 2022-12 or use of
0:23:51 the 267,420 of fork on revenue in the fiscal year 2022 23 budget any discussion
0:24:00 Aaron Roekoff please. Hi, it's my read. Yes, Nikki Boyd. Yes, right,
0:24:09 Hawkins. Yes, Jason Brown. Yes, venture Cutler. Yes, Mayor Pierce. Yes. Thank you,
0:24:16 motion passes six to zero. Next item is approval of the fiscal year 2022-23
0:24:25 budget and adoption of the associated appropriation ordinance for the city of
0:24:31 Twin Falls or the city of Twin Falls. Council wishes. Nicky Boyden, associated
0:24:57 appropriation ordinance for the city of Twin Falls. And that's...
0:25:05 Staff aired in the fact that we would ask for you to suspend the rules this evening.
0:25:09 On both of those?
0:25:12 Not both of those?
0:25:13 Just that one?
0:25:14 Just on the order of students.
0:25:16 You're going to present 22-015.
0:25:18 Go ahead, Nikki, start over.
0:25:20 At least suspend the rules.
0:25:35 But you must suspend the rules in place of ordinance.
0:25:37 That's 015.
0:25:40 On third and final reading.
0:25:45 It's suspend the rules.
0:25:46 Okay.
0:25:48 Third second.
0:25:49 Craig Hawkins.
0:25:52 Okay, so motion by Nikki Boyd, seconded by Craig Hawkins to suspend the rules and put
0:26:01 Ordinance 2022-015 on third and final reading by Title Homie.
0:26:09 Any further discussion?
0:26:11 Erin Rokal, please.
0:26:14 Thank you, Boyd.
0:26:15 Yes.
0:26:16 Craig Hawkins.
0:26:17 Yes.
0:26:18 Jason Brown.
0:26:19 Yes.
0:26:20 Spencer Cutler.
0:26:21 Yes.
0:26:22 Mayor Pierce.
0:26:23 Yes.
0:26:24 Vice Mayor Reed.
0:26:25 Yes.
0:26:26 6-0.
0:26:27 Chris Reed.
0:26:28 I move that we approve ordinance 2022-015.
0:26:32 Thank you.
0:26:33 Do I have a second?
0:26:34 Jason Brown?
0:26:35 Second.
0:26:36 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to adopt ordinance 2022-15.
0:26:48 Any further discussion?
0:26:52 Aaron Roll, pal, vote please.
0:26:56 Craig Hawkins?
0:26:57 Yes.
0:26:58 Jason Brown? Yes.
0:27:00 Spencer Cutler? Yes. Mayor Pierce? Yes. Vice-Mayor Reid? Yes. Nikki Boyd? Yes. I think I'm supposed to read the title.
0:27:09 So we're gonna have to do that again. Sorry gang. Somebody stop me. Okay. Ordinance number 2022-015
0:27:21 and ordinance of the City of Twin Falls IDO, appropriating $78,630,390 for the 2023 fiscal year to defray all necessary expenses and liabilities of the City of Twin Falls, providing for the objects and purposes for which such appropriations are made, and the amount appropriated for each object or purpose,
0:27:47 Leveying at Valoram taxes in the amount of $27 million, $9,389 for the 2023 fiscal year providing
0:28:00 that a copy of this ordinance shall be filed with the county commissioners of Twin Falls
0:28:05 County Idaho providing for this ordinance to take effect upon its passage approval and
0:28:10 publication according to law the rules requiring that an ordinance be read on
0:28:17 three separate occasions having been suspended. Okay, Aaron let's do that vote
0:28:23 to give please.
0:28:24 And we have a motion and a second just to make sure that I'll move to approve Ordinance
0:28:30 2022-015.
0:28:31 Thank you.
0:28:32 Thank you.
0:28:33 And I'll second that.
0:28:34 Motion by Chris Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to adopt Ordinance 2022-015.
0:28:43 Now Aaron Rokow, please.
0:28:45 Craig Hawkins?
0:28:46 Yes.
0:28:47 Jason Brown?
0:28:48 Yes.
0:28:49 Hunter Cutler?
0:28:50 Yes.
0:28:51 Mayor Pierce?
0:28:52 Yes.
0:28:53 Yes.
0:28:54 Thank you, Motion passes 6-0.
0:28:57 For such a simple meeting that really was messed up.
0:29:01 Sorry, gang.
0:29:03 Aren't you glad you stayed?
0:29:06 Travis, did you have some comments on our meeting next week?
0:29:11 Yes, Madam Mayor.
0:29:12 Members of the Council, so we would receive a total of 26 applications, individuals who are
0:29:19 interested in serving the vacancy on the Twin Falls City Council.
0:29:26 By process, we take those names and we submit them to the elections of the Supreme Twin Falls
0:29:33 County to certify that they are eligible to be a considered a qualified
0:29:39 elector in the eyes of the state code and that is a requirement for them to be able
0:29:44 to sit as an elected member of any board of the city account state legislature.
0:29:53 Three individuals were not lecturers by the definition, so you will have 23 individuals
0:30:03 that will have the opportunity to come and share their thoughts on why they should be considered
0:30:09 to fill vacancy.
0:30:14 We are in the process of reaching out to each one of those members to confirm that all
0:30:20 23 would like to still consider moving forward in those conversations one
0:30:28 individual has made the initial determination that she will be removing
0:30:34 herself from consideration and so you may now be down to 20 as we continue to work
0:30:39 throughout those names we will supply you with a final list and a community list
0:30:43 but as part of our due diligence and our check to making sure that they're first
0:30:47 eligible and then to making sure that they're still interested. Tomorrow, excuse me, on Monday,
0:30:55 next Monday at 5 o'clock individuals will be invited to share as part of that process.
0:31:02 Keep this very, just a thought understanding 20, potentially 23, maybe 22. Do we want to do
0:31:14 maybe a two-tier approach to that so that we don't have, because this is going, this is going
0:31:20 to go later into the evening, individuals for that first flight will say, tears sounds like,
0:31:28 there's some that are better than others first flight, and then similar to our public hearing,
0:31:34 the rest will not speak or have an opportunity before a certain time so that those that are
0:31:42 going to be coming to go watch them. If you're number 20, 21, 22, you might be sitting there
0:31:49 for three and a half four hours their family members that would want to come
0:31:54 and watch them welcome to City Council. Amen, excellent.
0:31:59 Travis do you have any thoughts on that? Staff is happy to share or to come in any
0:32:11 process that you come up with to help you make a decision. Aaron has been in the
0:32:15 process of notifying all the individuals requesting that they show up at 445 as
0:32:21 part of their our effort to confirm that they're still is that we would
0:32:33 of those that were eligible and still interested and placed into a randomizer without say,
0:32:41 so once the deviate from any of those processes,
0:32:53 and I know that we had a request from one individual who is looking at coming his way back to town,
0:33:03 like a presentation in person.
0:33:18 Do you hear them?
0:33:22 Process at the end will be considered for a convomium motion.
0:33:32 Hair has the opportunity to solicit input, but unlike other processes,
0:33:41 with the responsibility of the mayor to actually, in a sense, make a motion.
0:33:46 And if I understand correctly, it's not mandatory a decision is made that night.
0:33:56 You do not have to make a lot of people to process in one evening.
0:34:02 And so I'd like to give myself the opportunity to potentially think about it, depending on how this goes.
0:34:10 But, you know, my feeling is 22 people need to come, and they need to sit through the process
0:34:21 just like the rest of us have, and we will make it as smooth as possible.
0:34:27 I will suggest with 22 people, we may take a short break at some point in time, but if
0:34:34 you're a candidate and you come and you see on the random generator that your number 11,
0:34:39 family has time to come and see or they can also watch it on television. I really
0:34:45 would. I don't want to make this too complicated. I'd like to keep a simple as
0:34:51 possible and you show up at 4.45 and we do a fancy random generator, number
0:34:57 generator, and by five o'clock we know what that's my preference, yes.
0:35:05 Wherever they fall in the random number of draw, I agree, I agree.
0:35:23 Thank you. Questions or comments? Great. Do you have any thoughts?
0:35:34 Okay. So I think we have a plan. We'll just have a plan on everybody showing up at 4.45.
0:35:39 We'll do our random number of draw at that time. And we'll work through it the best we can.
0:35:47 Thank you very much everyone.
0:35:50 Eating a turn.
Download
- Transcript (text) 28 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 37 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 50 KB
- Audio (M4A) 8.5 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 22, 2022. The recording started at 17:30 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:35:58.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
455f7377d0c204ebadc844a895aa9d4c72e8f6bd19036ca89e4aa44ed5c15f1b - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 75a8dc3393bdf749a9930ec483ad0b387c9049557e9c7bcddddb40c998e6fa6e - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
b91a8e7789facb9806a6683f284563bd9bcf9be6797753dc2e0afe5636f9c4f9
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file