OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, April 11, 2022

Special meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: a

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:00:00 Good evening everyone. I'm going to call the meeting to April 11th, 2022 meeting to order.

0:00:46 I will note that we have a quorum. We have five council members present and Nikki Boyd is joining us by the phone.

0:00:55 First item on the agenda is to move into executive session under Code Section 74-206 to consider hiring a public officer

0:01:05 officer employee staff member individual agent here with wherein the respective

0:01:10 qualities of the individual so to be evaluated in order to fill a particular

0:01:15 vacancy or need. This paragraph does not apply to filing a filling a vacancy

0:01:21 and elective office deliberations about staffing needs in general.

0:01:26 Also wishes to executive session under Idaho code 742061 a as presented. Thank you

0:01:41 Second motion by Sean Barrick or seconded by Craig Hawkins will move into executive session under code section listed

0:01:49 we will be in executive session for an hour and

0:01:54 Reconvening out 5 p.m. For a normal meeting. Thank you Aaron row call vote, please

0:02:04 Mayor Pierce, Sean Baraker, Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Ben Cucutler, Nicki Blight,

0:02:17 Thank you. Motion carries six to zero. We'll move into executive session now.

0:02:27 Thanks. Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the continuation of the

0:02:55 April 11, 2022 meeting. Previously we gathered together and then moved into

0:03:02 executive session and we've completed that and we're now going to start our

0:03:06 regular meeting. Again confirm we have a quorum five of the seven members are

0:03:13 present in person. Nicky Boyd is on the phone and Vice Mayor Reid is excused

0:03:20 tonight. So first item on the agenda is if you join me with the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:03:26 Thank you. Next on the agenda we actually have two proclamations tonight. I'll be

0:03:53 reading both of those. The first one is Office of the Mayor City of Twin Falls

0:04:00 Idaho Proclamation on Healthcare Decision Day whereas Healthcare Decision

0:04:05 Day is designed to raise public awareness of the need to plan ahead for

0:04:09 healthcare decisions related to end-of-life care and medical decision-making whenever

0:04:15 patients are able to speak for themselves and to encourage the specific use of advanced

0:04:22 directives to communicate these important healthcare decisions.

0:04:27 Whereas it is estimated that only 27% of Americans have completed an advanced directive and whereas

0:04:36 It is likely that a significant reason for this low percentage is that there is both a lack of knowledge

0:04:44 and considerable confusion in the public about advanced directives, whereas one of the principal goals

0:04:50 of healthcare decisions day is to encourage hospitals, nursing homes, assisted living facilities,

0:04:56 continuing care retirement communities and hospices to participate in a citywide effort

0:05:02 to provide clear and consistent information to the public about advanced directives as well

0:05:08 as to encourage medical professionals and lawyers to volunteer their time and efforts

0:05:13 to provide public knowledge and increase the number of citizens in Twin Falls with advanced directives.

0:05:19 Whereas healthcare associations and other organizations throughout Idaho have endorsed this event

0:05:26 and are committed to educating the public about the importance of discussing healthcare

0:05:31 choices and executing advanced directives, whereas as a result of April 16 being recognized

0:05:39 as Healthcare Decisions Day in Twin Falls that we hope that most more citizens will have

0:05:45 conversations about their healthcare decisions, more citizens will complete an advanced directive

0:05:51 to make their wishes known, and fewer families and healthcare providers will have to struggle

0:05:56 with making difficult healthcare decisions in absence of guidance from the patient.

0:06:01 Now therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim April

0:06:07 16, 2022, as National Health Care Decisions Day, and encourage all citizens to join me

0:06:14 in this worthy observance.

0:06:16 And I believe, Heidi, are you here?

0:06:18 Yes, Heidi?

0:06:43 No, talking about death won't kill any of us.

0:06:51 And the baby boomers coming of age and just the health care system just being inundated,

0:06:57 It's more important now than ever to do your advanced directives, so we would like to challenge our City Council and ask you

0:07:05 How many of you guys have completed your advanced directives raise your hand?

0:07:30 Next one is

0:07:33 Proclamation for telecommunicators week April 10 through 16 2022

0:07:39 Whereas emergencies that require police or fire services can occur at any time and

0:07:46 whereas an emergency occurs the prompt response of police officers and firefighters

0:07:51 is critical to the protection of life and preservation and property and whereas

0:07:56 the safety of our police officers and firefighters is dependent upon the

0:08:00 quality and accuracy of information obtained from citizens who contact the

0:08:05 City Communications Center and whereas Public Safety Emergency Communications

0:08:11 officers are the first and most critical contact our citizens have with emergency

0:08:16 services and whereas Public Safety Emergency Communication officers are

0:08:21 single vital link for our public safety responders by providing them information

0:08:26 actively engaging in and monitoring their activities and ensuring their safety

0:08:33 and whereas public safety emergency communications officers of the City of

0:08:37 Twin Falls have contributed substantially to the apprehension of criminals, the

0:08:43 oppression of fires and treatment of the injured, and whereas each emergency

0:08:48 communications officer has exhibited compassion, understanding, and

0:08:52 professionalism in the performance of their job in the past year. Now, therefore I

0:08:58 I Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim April 10 through

0:09:03 16 2022 as Teller Communicators Week in Twin Falls, Idaho and encourage all

0:09:10 citizens to join me in this worthy cause. And I think that there's a lot to say

0:09:41 today. Thank you very much for doing this for us. I will say that your public safety

0:09:45 team has knocked it out of the park today. It has been lovely weather and they have

0:09:50 all been incredibly busy so and that is definitely true with EMS with us today

0:09:55 so thank you very much. Thank you. Okay moving on to the next item is our

0:10:09 consent calendar. I've been asked to separate out item 5E into a separate

0:10:22 vote as we need to separate that out though on all the other items I counsel

0:10:28 wishes to approve the consent calendar with the extraction of item 5e. Thank you.

0:10:39 Do I have a second? I second that motion. Motion by Sean Barrigar seconded by

0:10:44 and Sir Cutler to approve consent

0:10:48 Keller items A through D, F, and G. Any further discussion?

0:10:55 Aaron Roll call vote please.

0:11:00 Sean Baraker. Yes.

0:11:04 Nikki Boyd.

0:11:06 Matt. Craig Hawkins. Yes.

0:11:09 Jason Brown. Yes.

0:11:11 Spencer Cutler. Yes.

0:11:13 Mayor Pierce. Yes. Motion passes 6-0.

0:11:18 Thank you.

0:11:19 Okay, next item is action item on E, approval of the fact, findings of fact and conclusions

0:11:28 of law, CSI zoning, district change and zoning map amendments.

0:11:38 You guys are recusing abstain, okay?

0:11:44 I will abstain for voting.

0:11:46 Okay, so I need a motion please.

0:11:49 I move to approve consent calendar item item 5E approval of the finding of fact and conclusions

0:11:58 of law CSI zoning district change in zoning map.

0:12:02 Okay.

0:12:03 Second.

0:12:04 Second.

0:12:05 Thank you.

0:12:06 Motion by Jason Brown.

0:12:07 Second.

0:12:08 And by Craig Hawkins to approve action item E on the consent calendar.

0:12:14 Aaron Roekall vote please.

0:12:16 Craig Hawkins.

0:12:17 Yes.

0:12:18 Jason Brown.

0:12:19 Mayor Pierce, Nicky Boyd, what?

0:12:23 For the record, you need to call Sean and Spencer,

0:12:30 and they need for the record to have a recuse.

0:12:32 Sean, Baraker.

0:12:34 I'm staying.

0:12:35 Spencer, Cutler.

0:12:36 Recused.

0:12:39 Thank you.

0:12:42 We good?

0:12:44 Motion passes.

0:12:46 4, 4, and 2 abstentions.

0:12:49 Hey, moving on, action item, items of consideration,

0:12:54 Action Item A, Consideration of a Request Approved FAAAIP-42 Grand Amendment Request Letter to the

0:13:04 FAA or $3,840 to authorize the Mayor to sign and we have Bill Corbary, our Airport Manager.

0:13:13 Thank you, Mayor.

0:13:14 Good evening, Council Members.

0:13:15 So, I was looking at the date we issued AIP-42 Grand

0:13:21 of 2019. The last grant, I think the one we're working on is AIP-53, so we had a lot of things

0:13:27 happening over the last couple of years out there with grants. This is more or less a housekeeping

0:13:33 issue. It's a grant amendment request letter that both the county and the city are requesting

0:13:38 that they sign to bump up the amount of the grant by $3,840. Do you reconcile the expenditures

0:13:47 in the funding on this grant.

0:13:49 At the time, they had some limited funding in what they issued,

0:13:54 and they have the ability to amend grants,

0:13:56 so I'm asking for that today.

0:13:58 This was for construction of the very first taxi lane out

0:14:02 in the northeast area, so that would change the total

0:14:05 for the grant from $748,525 to $7,752,365.

0:14:15 Once again, a difference of $3,840, so I would ask for the counsel to approve the request to sign the letter by the mayor, and I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.

0:14:28 Any questions for Bill? I'd entertain a motion.

0:14:35 for the consideration of request to approve an FAA AIP-42 grant amendment request letter

0:14:50 to the FAA for $3,840 and authorize them here for sign letter.

0:14:58 Thank you.

0:14:59 Do I have a second?

0:15:01 I'll second.

0:15:02 Thank you.

0:15:03 Motion by Craig Hawkins.

0:15:04 Seconded by Jason Brown to approve the grant request amendments.

0:15:11 Any further discussion?

0:15:14 Mayor and roll call vote please.

0:15:18 Jason Brown.

0:15:19 Yes.

0:15:20 Spencer Cutler.

0:15:22 Yes.

0:15:23 Ruth Mayor Pierce.

0:15:24 Yes.

0:15:25 Sean Baraker.

0:15:26 Yes.

0:15:26 Nikki Boyd.

0:15:28 Yeah.

0:15:30 Thank you. Motion passes six to zero.

0:15:32 And vote here.

0:15:33 Oh, you didn't?

0:15:35 Great hotkins.

0:15:36 Oh.

0:15:37 Hey, cockkins.

0:15:38 Yes.

0:15:39 Now, motion passes six to zero.

0:15:43 Thank you, Bill.

0:15:44 Thank you.

0:15:44 Moving on to your next item.

0:15:46 The next item, two items deal with snow removal equipment, and never did I think when I put

0:15:52 the date April 11th on this item, sweeping myself in on the lizard conditions we have

0:15:59 out there at the airport, I'm sure you probably had that here and down.

0:16:04 This next item is for a JUB contract in the amount of $45,930, and this is the engineering

0:16:12 contract for the acquisition of the next item that I've got on here, we call it a M-V5

0:16:19 as the model and it's an M-V company.

0:16:23 We just recently used the joint purchase acquisition process to purchase the snow removal equipment.

0:16:29 We call it multitasking where it had a plow up front and a broom in the midsection and

0:16:35 we had another position on our capital improvement list for another piece of snow equipment.

0:16:41 reviews from the staff who were out there the better part of December it seemed this year

0:16:46 utilizing it and it's performed beautifully. It's very efficient. We're able to use one

0:16:52 operator to both plow and room which is the condition that DFA requires us to keep the

0:16:58 runways and taxiways and no worse than what we also do to de-icing applications, those

0:17:03 types of things. So with that, back to the contract, when we have an engineering program

0:17:11 consult contract that exceeds $100,000. I typically use what they call an independent

0:17:17 fee estimate where I'll take an hour list, a scope of work, utilize an independent group

0:17:24 of consultant to go through that, give me their fee estimate, and I utilize that for

0:17:29 negotiations with our consultant that we're seeking a contract with. This was for $45,000.

0:17:34 It was below that threshold which triggered that independent fee estimate approach, and

0:17:40 I used the reasonableness of cost approach.

0:17:43 I was able to provide a letter and break down to the FAA,

0:17:46 how we've acquired other pieces of equipment

0:17:48 and the reasonable fees that were approved in the past

0:17:52 and this very much fell in line with those same fees.

0:17:55 So with that, I would recommend the council

0:17:57 approve an agreement with JUB engineers

0:18:00 in the amount of $45,930 for services

0:18:04 to acquire a new FAA-funded, multi-tasking

0:18:07 and author of a prize in the various science agreements.

0:18:11 So with that I'd be happy to answer any questions.

0:18:16 Any questions for Bill?

0:18:18 Yeah, maybe I'll say.

0:18:21 Thanks, Bill.

0:18:23 You probably won't be surprised by my question.

0:18:25 I thought, what's so hard about picking out

0:18:27 a piece of equipment out of the catalog?

0:18:29 And then I saw the estimate for the services,

0:18:32 and there's 20 project tasks associated

0:18:36 with putting this requisition together.

0:18:40 I think it's just good for the public

0:18:41 to hear a little bit about why it's so hard

0:18:44 to buy something like this.

0:18:46 And it's illuminating, I believe.

0:18:49 Yeah, no, thank you for the question.

0:18:52 So I think the best way to put this,

0:18:55 and I've been asked this before,

0:18:56 and it's a lot of money,

0:18:58 and it sounds like a lot of money,

0:18:59 and it is a lot of money.

0:19:00 But the FAA process is fairly lengthy.

0:19:03 There are many, many things involved with that process.

0:19:07 So really what you have is when you get into FAA projects,

0:19:10 you have fixed costs right away with scoping,

0:19:14 with typically with design and bidding.

0:19:16 This is not, doesn't have a design bid component

0:19:19 because it's a piggybacking component.

0:19:21 But there are all kinds of paperwork things

0:19:24 that are involved with the FAA along the process.

0:19:26 So there's a lot of man hours involved with this

0:19:29 more than you would realize.

0:19:31 So the costs are really justified with this.

0:19:33 There's really fixed costs, whether it's a $100,000 project,

0:19:38 $3 million project, there's really fixed costs associated

0:19:42 with just engaging with the FAA process.

0:19:44 And I often refer to our consultants.

0:19:47 A commotion approval, and under $45,930 for services

0:20:05 to acquire a new FAA-funded, multitasking piece

0:20:10 of snow removal equipment, and authorize the mayor

0:20:12 to sign the agreement.

0:20:14 I apologize, can we pause for just a moment, I think?

0:20:18 Just went down, I wanted to confirm a few things before we moved forward.

0:20:21 Sure.

0:20:21 With the motion that's on the table.

0:20:22 Sure.

0:20:23 Good now?

0:21:10 Yes, so you're where I did see on the screen the delay of me walking up here so the motion should be good.

0:21:24 Waiting for a second.

0:21:25 Okay.

0:21:27 So there's a motion on the floor to approve the request for the agreement.

0:21:32 Sean Berger.

0:21:33 Second.

0:21:34 Thank you.

0:21:35 Motion by Craig Hawkins.

0:21:36 seconded by Sean Barrier to approve the agreement with JUB Aaron Rokalvo please.

0:21:44 Mayor Pierce yes Sean Barrier yes Nikki Boyd

0:21:50 Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes Spencer Cutler yes thank you motion carries

0:22:06 six to zero. Hey Bill you're up again. I am this third item is consideration of a

0:22:16 request to award a contract to envy companies as I mentioned for an FAA

0:22:20 funded airport multi-task snow plow in room and the amount of $787,077

0:22:27 dollars to authorize the mayor to sign the contract contingent upon FAA funding

0:22:32 and legal review. So with this this is and I should have had another picture up

0:22:37 here to remind you what this looks like I apologize but it's a fairly

0:22:41 sophisticated piece of equipment we do own one we're familiar with it and if

0:22:46 fits into our plan very well. This was bid by Idaho, no, excuse me, Pocatello Airport last summer,

0:22:52 and Idaho Code does allow one city or county, one municipality to piggyback on a bid from another city.

0:23:01 So the FAA certainly yields to the state code with us and took a little conversation years ago,

0:23:08 but they've come around and I'm happy we're able to exercise that. So I'm here today to

0:23:13 to ask for your approval of this award of the MB contract for the piece of equipment.

0:23:20 I'd be happy to answer any questions with that.

0:23:24 Any questions for Bill?

0:23:28 I'm Ericard.

0:23:29 I'm ready for a motion if you are.

0:23:31 Yes sir.

0:23:32 I'm Eric.

0:23:33 I would move to award a contract to MB companies for an FAA-funded airport multitask, snow plow,

0:23:39 and Broom, the amount of $787,077 and authorized the mayor to sign the contract contingent upon

0:23:47 FAA funding and legal review.

0:23:49 Thank you.

0:23:50 Do I have a second?

0:23:51 Thank you.

0:23:53 Motion by Sean Barricker, seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the awarding of the contract

0:23:59 to MB companies for the snow plow and Broom in the amount of $787,077.

0:24:06 Aaron Rokavo, please.

0:24:09 Sean Barricker?

0:24:10 Yes.

0:24:11 Boyd, Matt, Craig Hawkins, Jason Brown, Spencer Cutler, Mayor Pierce, motion passes 6 to 0.

0:24:26 Thank you Bill.

0:24:30 Thank you Mayor.

0:24:31 Thank you Council.

0:24:34 A next item on the agenda again is an action item, consideration of a request by Star Corporation

0:24:42 to approve a proposed guaranteed maximum price,

0:24:45 DMP for Fire Station to Spencer Color.

0:24:49 Mayor, I have a family member employed

0:24:51 by the potential contractors,

0:24:52 so I will recuse myself out of a conflict of interest.

0:24:57 Thank you.

0:24:58 No one else?

0:25:01 Mandy Thompson, thank you.

0:25:03 Thank you, Mayor Pierce, Council.

0:25:06 This evening, very excited to be coming with to you

0:25:08 with a request to approve the GMP

0:25:11 for Fire Station number two.

0:25:14 So a little background per the agreement, the CMGC contract agreement that we signed with

0:25:21 Star Corporation in 2021, the Save Twin Falls along with Star Corporation are presenting the

0:25:27 guaranteed maximum price for the construction of Fire Station 2.

0:25:32 That is in the amount of $7,123,166.

0:25:39 This includes all the bid packages for the project with the exception of five bid packages that

0:25:43 We did not receive responses to when we opened the bids to her up to the contractors.

0:25:52 That is for structural steel, rough carpentry, case work, specialties, and window coverings.

0:25:58 So when you look at the attachment as far as where we established the JMP, working with

0:26:06 Star Corporation Michael Arrington, he put together estimates based on current building

0:26:12 environment into those five-bit packages and we will go back out to bid at some point in

0:26:17 the future to establish those as part of the GMP, keeping into consideration that we have

0:26:23 to stay under the amount that we set this evening.

0:26:28 The GMP includes a 3% contingency, a payment and performance bond, and then the CM fees that

0:26:36 were negotiated and established also in 2021 at 4.4%. So with that, I'm going to invite Michael

0:26:44 Harrington with Star Corporation to come up and speak with you and go through a little bit of the

0:26:51 ins and outs of the GMP as presented and open it up to questions. Thank you. Welcome, Michael.

0:26:59 Council is going to be with you this evening. Not much to add to what Mandy's already told you.

0:27:08 But we did go out to bid, just like she said, and got coverage from any of the packages,

0:27:15 but not all.

0:27:17 So as we've done in the past, when we have that kind of an issue, we'll just slide down into

0:27:22 and allow its category and then go back out to bid at a future time.

0:27:28 This does allow us to move forward with the project.

0:27:33 So any of those things that are, that we did not receive bids on right now are not items

0:27:40 that would need to be taken or work would not need to be done.

0:27:44 In the first months of the project, we do have coverage for site, concurring for masonry

0:27:50 and those would be the activities that are right out of the gate.

0:27:53 That would be likely one question I would ask if I was in your position of doing, are

0:27:57 we really able to move forward without some of these?

0:27:59 And we are in a position to do that.

0:28:01 to try to time it right in the market where we can jump back in and

0:28:05 hear bids for those other items.

0:28:08 With the way the market is right now that doesn't seem to be an anomaly,

0:28:13 we're facing similar challenges of other projects where

0:28:16 it limited coverage or perhaps no coverage on those items.

0:28:20 Our team is working to fill those gaps and we're confident that we can do that.

0:28:27 We're excited to look forward with you guys and put together a wonderful new station

0:28:34 and that portion of town for firefighters to be based out of and serve the communities.

0:28:41 Happy to answer questions they may have had.

0:28:48 Did you review that or if I've said something that didn't make sense?

0:28:52 Anybody have any questions?

0:28:55 No one in construction would actually start.

0:28:59 We're working on getting that scheduled right now.

0:29:02 There is some equipment on site and we're working

0:29:05 and knowing that we're optimistic

0:29:08 and moving forward with some initial paperwork,

0:29:11 but it would likely be sometime in the month of May,

0:29:13 but that's not scheduled just yet.

0:29:18 But it is not, but once the day like today.

0:29:22 Yeah, it makes you wanna get your winter coat back out

0:29:26 of the day like today, but we expect it next month.

0:29:29 Thank you.

0:29:32 Michael, when do you anticipate rebidding those five areas?

0:29:36 Do you have a timeline on that?

0:29:38 So the one that would be most urgent

0:29:40 would be the rough carpentry package.

0:29:43 And we've been talking to contractors

0:29:47 that would be interested as well as the lumber buyers

0:29:51 trying to time out at the right time.

0:29:56 We have a drop dead date of need to be out to bid

0:30:00 by mid-July is what we've set.

0:30:03 Backly when in there, I have not said yet,

0:30:06 but that's our backing into the schedule.

0:30:08 That's our drop-ded, and when we meet back out.

0:30:14 Any other questions for Michael?

0:30:17 John Berger.

0:30:18 Good comment if I make, you know, we certainly

0:30:20 appreciate the partnership with Star on this project,

0:30:23 and certainly all of those who have

0:30:25 bid for those other pieces.

0:30:27 And I would encourage those who have those skilled trades

0:30:31 in those areas where we don't have bids now to look forward

0:30:35 to that opportunity really to be part

0:30:37 of a pretty significant legacy project

0:30:40 for the community.

0:30:41 I know that emotions don't roll

0:30:44 into business decisions very well.

0:30:47 However, I do think that there is a greater good coming

0:30:51 from this and would really encourage folks

0:30:53 to take a look at that and see if they can help you

0:30:57 part of that to move it forward.

0:30:58 And again, appreciate your patience and expertise

0:31:01 as we have to get through some of the hiccups in this.

0:31:05 Thank you very much.

0:31:06 Yeah, I suppose if I were a contractor that had those

0:31:09 and I was calling you my house on fire,

0:31:11 perhaps I'd look at this different.

0:31:14 Yes, thank you very much.

0:31:17 Anything else for Michael?

0:31:21 Council, anything else, Mandy?

0:31:26 Council wishes.

0:31:31 Okay, Jason?

0:31:33 A move to approve a request by Star Corporation

0:31:36 for a proposed guaranteed maximum price contract for fire station number two in the amount of,

0:31:49 sorry, 7,123,166, is that correct?

0:31:55 Second.

0:31:57 Thank you.

0:31:58 Motion by Jason Brown.

0:31:59 Seconded by Sean Berger.

0:32:01 To approve the request by Star Corporation to approve the proposed guaranteed maximum price

0:32:08 the prize for fire station to Aaron

0:32:12 roll call vote please Mayor Pierce yes

0:32:15 Sean Baraker yes Nicky Boyd

0:32:19 Craig Hawkins yes Jason Brown yes Spencer

0:32:25 Cutler Epstein thank you motion passes

0:32:37 fought five with one abstention and no

0:32:41 opposed thank you Michael thank you very

0:32:45 much okay next item on the agenda is a

0:32:51 a discussion about a proposal that would reduce losses on rental property utility accounts.

0:32:58 And we have Brent Hyatt are you standing in a system finance director utility manager

0:33:05 slash CFO I think are you right now.

0:33:10 Yeah, thank you.

0:33:12 I appreciate Council taking this time.

0:33:17 and members of the council to have just a brief discussion.

0:33:21 As I look at some of the other agenda items today,

0:33:24 I recognize that 140,000 on an annual basis

0:33:29 might not be significant, but I think it's worth a discussion.

0:33:33 I think it's worth a discussion just from an equity standpoint.

0:33:37 We've found that historically we turn over

0:33:42 to our collection agency about 140,000 a year,

0:33:47 and we recover about 24% of that back,

0:33:51 which is right on spot with the national average.

0:33:57 What's troubling is that 93% of that comes from

0:34:03 properties that are rented have about 16%

0:34:11 of the city's accounts are tenant occupied,

0:34:14 and I should point out single residences.

0:34:17 We have other tenants that are in municipal or multiple accounts, duplexes, triplexes, apartment buildings.

0:34:25 We are not structured so that they pay their utility bill.

0:34:30 Those are already shifted over to the owners of the property and they'll have one meter that's built.

0:34:37 So what we're discussing is properties that have only one meter and it's tenant occupied.

0:34:44 I believe years ago the Council was approached and a discussion was presented about shifting

0:34:55 responsibility for tenant accounts over to the property owners.

0:35:00 And I didn't really go anywhere, so we're kind of back again with a little different approach.

0:35:07 I've found it interesting as we were looking at this at the State of Washington five years

0:35:12 established a state statute because of municipalities were having this issue shifting the responsibility

0:35:21 and not allowing tenants to take a utility account in their name by forcing the owners

0:35:30 of the properties to be responsible for those because it's, again, historically people

0:35:38 who are transitioning frequently might not have the same level of commitment as a property

0:35:44 owner who's going to be there and be in a structure for many years.

0:35:53 We think we have an idea that's a more balanced approach.

0:35:58 I don't know that we're concerned too much with somebody who has a long-term relationship

0:36:04 with their landlord. They pay their utility bill. They aren't the problem. We think that

0:36:11 we can identify risky properties by monitoring our penalties that we have built into our

0:36:18 utility structure. Tracking those, I referenced kind of like the IDO Department of Transportation

0:36:26 does, where they have a point system. We would run ours for two years at the end of two years.

0:36:33 those points would fall off, but they would accumulate over time.

0:36:37 And if a property ran afoul of that point system, then the next time the account needed

0:36:46 to be changed, we would require that the owner take responsibility.

0:36:50 I know that's shifting responsibility to the owner, but they're really the ones who

0:36:57 have control over background checks requiring enough of a deposit, you know, some of the

0:37:05 things that we don't to ensure that those utility accounts are taken care of. It would

0:37:13 be a one-way street once a property was defined as e-trouble something. We would just have

0:37:19 the owner of that property responsible, property was sold, we would just continue to have that

0:37:27 property owner as being responsible. And we think that over time nothing would happen

0:37:34 right now, but over time those accounts would shift to the people who have control. And

0:37:46 the city would be alleviated of a burden. And there would be a little bit of equity to

0:37:52 our citizens right now who are subsidizing that cost, all of the right payers are participating

0:38:01 in that without really being a part of it. So it's a novel idea. I don't know if anybody

0:38:09 else is trying to do this. We believe that we can software in place and we can just access

0:38:15 our data tables and record when people are late with their payment or they have a bounce

0:38:21 or their utilities are turned off for non-payment or they've gone to collections and we think

0:38:28 those properties would be the ones that we want to shift.

0:38:33 Having said that, this is not an action item, it's just a discussion because we don't really

0:38:40 want to go do far down this path if the council's indicating that something that they're interested

0:38:49 in.

0:38:50 So I'm happy to take questions that you might have as you've thought about this.

0:38:57 Any questions for Brad?

0:39:00 Is any other cities working the process like this?

0:39:05 No, they're not.

0:39:08 We're aware of other cities who have shifted their responsibility by resolution to property owners.

0:39:16 But it's just been a blanket approach.

0:39:18 As a targeted approach, it's been a contentious, as far as I'm aware, it's been a contentious thing, because the

0:39:29 property owners don't want that responsibility, but we're not trying to do it to all properties, we're just trying to do it to those who

0:39:37 demonstrate a history of issues.

0:39:44 We'd be the only ones that I'm aware of that would take us to.

0:39:48 I just wanted to perform somewhere in some other city or something.

0:39:53 But it sounds like a good idea to me.

0:39:57 Thank you.

0:39:57 Some, Eric.

0:39:59 Thank you, Meredith.

0:40:00 I appreciate the innovation out of the box

0:40:04 thinking to try to find something that maybe helps

0:40:06 to address the immediate challenges my concern would be

0:40:13 the time systemization of this internally,

0:40:19 that outweigh the actual cost to implementing that.

0:40:24 So I mean, if I'm running rough numbers,

0:40:27 It's $30,000 a year-ish that we're actually collecting on those accounts that actually run through collections.

0:40:35 So the incremental increase in collection does that offset the cost of your staff and time having to navigate point systems and communication back to owners and all of that.

0:40:52 That went at the end of the day when it just makes sense to say, you know, what goes with the property, and what went it out?

0:40:59 That's a good question.

0:41:02 And that's... I don't know that that would be too burdensome on us because as I visited with utility buildings, after their attitude is, listen, we can almost tell you who's going to be up here next month shutting off their water.

0:41:20 And we know which landlords don't really do a good job.

0:41:26 So I think we would ferret out some of those and it would actually release.

0:41:33 We think we can design the software so that it's not difficult to just do the drop-down box

0:41:39 and mark the properties and let it track.

0:41:42 Let it pop up.

0:41:44 It would be a little bit of a trouble when we're in for it.

0:41:51 you indicated maybe the best thing is just to bite the bullet and shift I'm

0:42:02 not opposed to that I'm just not sure if I was on the dice if I want to take that

0:42:06 on yeah no and I appreciate that and again I'm just thinking a little bit

0:42:12 so I mean I've never been in this situation where I'm the one delinquent

0:42:16 of my water bill or whatever thank you I do know I should well only once that was

0:42:23 your fault. So, but I do know having dealt with some other properties of family members,

0:42:32 like with Idaho Power, for example, I know on rental properties, it's the tenants' responsibility

0:42:38 up until the point they're not responsible anymore, so if they're not making that payment,

0:42:42 there's a backup that the property owner is sort of on the hook for that. So maybe there's

0:42:48 middle ground of there's a backup that at x x days pass due or x amount or

0:42:58 something again I'm not an expert in that and I appreciate the innovation trying

0:43:04 to find flexibility but in the grand scheme of things I do question if time

0:43:09 and energy of implementing and managing a program really offsets what you're

0:43:16 going to actually collect at the end of the day and if it's just worth the use among some

0:43:24 of the right ones who might be suddenly on the hook there. Hey, that's the kind of feedback

0:43:29 we're looking for. Jason Brown. I was going to ask, I think you already indicated that you

0:43:36 have but do you have a list of already have you tried to do this and implement maybe looking

0:43:43 back of how many properties would actually be into that point system. We run a little experiment

0:43:50 or they're just, let's say, 10 properties,

0:43:54 you're like, these guys just need to go on the list right now.

0:43:58 We have two thoughts.

0:44:00 One is we would do it going forward.

0:44:03 And two, as Sean mentioned, it's troublesome.

0:44:07 If we don't have a system in place,

0:44:09 we go back and do it historically.

0:44:12 If we have it created and we're just tracking going forward,

0:44:17 we think that would be kind of easy.

0:44:19 But I don't know that we try and go back and say, okay,

0:44:22 if this had been in place for the last two years,

0:44:26 how many properties would have shifted?

0:44:28 I don't know that we want to do that.

0:44:30 Any other questions?

0:44:33 Mayor Pierce?

0:44:34 Yes, Nikki.

0:44:39 Did a very real situation,

0:44:46 you have starting with builders.

0:44:50 There's two out there building, they take all the bills,

0:44:59 somebody buys the property or rents the property,

0:45:02 and it's supposed to go into their name.

0:45:05 First, it doesn't do that.

0:45:11 We have a backup there.

0:45:15 The next backup is, in the situation you're talking about,

0:45:23 the only way a property owner would have

0:45:29 to pay electric bills or whatever it is for their tenants

0:45:34 is to increase the amount of rent to protect them from the hundreds and hundreds of dollars

0:45:44 that they are going to get while people who rent things understand how to skip out.

0:45:51 I'm not against renters at all, but it is a dynamic of the rental market industry world.

0:46:05 So it's really, I really haven't heard time with this proposed idea that if the people

0:46:18 who use the power, the water, whatever it is they're using, they need to be the ones paying.

0:46:24 And there's a lot of grace on the front end when you're building something.

0:46:29 And the people quite haven't gotten around to putting it in their name.

0:46:33 And so you sort of pay it on their behalf.

0:46:37 Rentals are another interesting thing.

0:46:40 You think, oh, they're so busy moving in.

0:46:42 They don't have to ever see their name.

0:46:45 But this is a problem that I'm not that comfortable with.

0:46:50 with, I think, I don't know, I have a problem with this, because this is an ongoing thing

0:47:01 that's always been ongoing, always always always, and everybody has to be in cooperation.

0:47:08 So I'm not really sure what the answer is, but I think more work needs to be done.

0:47:16 So Nikki, if I could just get some clarification, I think I understood what you're saying.

0:47:24 As you look at this proposal and as you weigh it against the option of just blank it, shifting it over to the landlords, which would you be most in favor of?

0:47:40 Thank you, Brent, so much. You reworded that very simply. If you shift it over to one or which we've done, I totally get this.

0:47:56 The problem is there's no way to go back and recoup any losses.

0:48:02 The only way that you can make this come out for a landlord is to raise prices on rent

0:48:10 in case they're not going to pay their bills on the way out the door and it automatically

0:48:16 refers to you.

0:48:17 I understand that this works good for the city and good for paying those people who need

0:48:27 to be paid for what's been used, but I don't think it's good for property owners.

0:48:33 Okay, I understood a little bit better.

0:48:39 You're right.

0:48:40 It's really a discussion about who do you want to have the risk of the property owners

0:48:46 or the city, and we're trying to strike a little better balance, but...

0:48:51 And I understand that.

0:48:54 I do understand that.

0:48:57 And I also do understand that in today's world, more and more and more risk is put on property

0:49:05 owners than ever before.

0:49:09 I have to respect that in kind of the American way.

0:49:17 And so I think property owners can shore up a lot of things, but what I'm watching over

0:49:27 the last six years is that property owners are now become responsible or about to come

0:49:35 responsible for absolutely everything that happens in the community and that's not right.

0:49:45 So you're asking for our guidance, this is not a vote.

0:49:51 It seems to me it's kind of a compromise and at the end it says staff recommends this targeted

0:50:00 approach, so that's your recommendation?

0:50:03 I think it is.

0:50:04 I think I take a little bit of work on the beginning of it, but I think going forward

0:50:09 once it's implemented, it wouldn't be troublesome to track, and on the other hand, I mean, if

0:50:19 the direction from the council is the status quo B, I can easily accept that, sure.

0:50:28 Travis.

0:50:29 So the idea of tonight was not to then launch into a process.

0:50:34 The idea tonight was before staff invested any time in a process that we wanted to make

0:50:39 sure that there was concurrence from the council that this problem was worth exploring further.

0:50:45 Next steps would involve property owners, share this idea, share this concept and see

0:50:51 it with there were any tweaks that they might have to this program as well.

0:50:55 We think it's really important as a city staff to involve the property owners.

0:51:00 We think it's important to recognize that it's not appropriate.

0:51:05 The situation that we have right now is not a system that we want to continue moving forward

0:51:11 with and we believe that the program is in need of reform.

0:51:16 That said, we want to partner with the property owners to find that solution that is about

0:51:24 sharing risk because the City of Twin Falls doesn't have a profit motive and we

0:51:31 need to make sure that we are sharing the risk to the degree that we can in

0:51:35 protection of our ratepayers. This is potentially one solution to do that.

0:51:41 John.

0:51:43 I agree it's worth some some exploration. I mean again I would just read or

0:51:47 comment. I think we do need to be cognizant of is the is the effort and cost to

0:51:52 implement the system actually going to pay off if we're able to do this. The second

0:51:57 The question I would have and maybe something to contemplate is the point system, is that

0:52:04 track with the person who has been delinquent or only with the property.

0:52:10 So if I'm a renter who hasn't been paying my, whatever, I've helped accumulate the six

0:52:17 points, and now I'm the delinquent one who's not there anymore, the next time I show up

0:52:21 to sign up for water services on a different property, do those points track with me or

0:52:27 is it now just that original landlord that's stuck with? They have to do that. They would

0:52:31 track with the property. So I do think that that's something to be mindful of as well because

0:52:37 it may not be property per se that is the bad aim. Right? And so is there a way to track

0:52:47 for that as well that if it's a rent hopper that's jumping from property property and

0:52:53 Ever paint their water bill? Are you suddenly punishing a bunch of maybe good hearted landlords who are trying to do their best to help people?

0:53:01 But they are now on the hook for that with bad renters.

0:53:05 So I think the way the system, the point system is set up, it would be if there's oopses and if there's hiccups, those are going to fall off after two years.

0:53:17 points wouldn't accumulate on a property, because they were accumulating with one tenet or four or five over the two years.

0:53:27 That's the controls that Landhoard has.

0:53:33 So, it would probably proceed with tracking by the property.

0:53:40 When the tenants leave, when they go to collections, it's all over by then.

0:53:45 So, we're just trying to identify them ahead of time.

0:53:53 That sounds like next step.

0:53:57 How does everybody feel?

0:54:04 It's worth pursuing.

0:54:09 Looks like they had not.

0:54:10 Thank you.

0:54:11 Thank you.

0:54:18 Next item on the agenda is a time for public input.

0:54:22 Anybody in the audience who wishes to speak.

0:54:25 Please come down to the microphone.

0:54:28 See no one.

0:54:32 We'll move on to advisory board reports and announcements.

0:54:36 Anything from council?

0:54:37 Not very good.

0:54:40 I would just note the public parts commission

0:54:43 that they're meeting this week after many months

0:54:46 of muddling through bureaucracy,

0:54:49 of setting up good things we wanna do in the community.

0:54:52 I think they have finally settled in on an update

0:54:56 to the public art resolution that the council passed

0:55:00 several years ago,

0:55:02 was a little more me on the bones

0:55:04 of what they're gonna be doing.

0:55:05 So I know the plan is to bring that forward

0:55:07 to the council on the next a few weeks.

0:55:10 I have some discussion on that, but that commission really has, I think everyone came in with a ton of energy excited to do projects and unfortunately with all of these things we've spent a lot of time on creating the framework around that and they're very excited to have accomplished that.

0:55:29 I look forward to having that on the agenda.

0:55:31 Thank you.

0:55:32 Hey, Key, do you have anything?

0:55:35 I don't do this time.

0:55:38 Thank you.

0:55:39 Anything from the city manager's office.

0:55:41 So the only item that I would share is that on the 25th, we wouldn't ask the council to

0:55:48 anticipate a we've been experiencing potentially. We've invited ITD to come in and have a conversation

0:56:01 about the potential additional bridge crossings as well as interception work. And so they

0:56:08 will be coming in on the 25th of this month and they'll be sharing their thoughts and

0:56:12 plans that they've kind of I guess been tentatively sharing but they've been

0:56:19 changing a little bit so they're going to come and share their ideas with you and

0:56:23 I think it's important for the community to be aware of the presentation that's

0:56:26 going to occur and so that they may be here to listen what I TD may have in

0:56:32 store for a third bridge crossing and the whole line of Lake intersection.

0:56:36 Thank you. What else? No. We have no public hearings tonight so our meeting is adjourned.

0:56:47 that.

0:56:48 Alright.

0:56:49 Alright.

0:56:50 Alright.

0:56:51 Alright.

0:56:52 Alright.

0:56:53 Alright.

0:56:54 Alright.

0:56:55 Alright.

0:56:56 Alright.

0:56:57 Alright.

0:56:58 Alright.

0:56:59 Alright.

0:57:00 Alright.

0:57:01 Alright.

0:57:02 Alright.

0:57:03 Alright.

0:57:04 Alright.

0:57:05 Alright.

0:57:06 Alright.

0:57:07 Alright.

0:57:08 Alright.

0:57:09 Alright.

0:57:10 Alright.

0:57:11 Alright.

0:57:12 Alright.

0:57:13 Alright.

0:57:14 Alright.

0:57:15 Alright.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 11, 2022. The recording started at 16:03 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:56:55.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    86719ee1a98e05f4a210420c0b63e8bc42d491a9e5c50f427b4de4b441e42314
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a fd4481978ed0e7f3c554b987f6b1c5e42082afd8b0ca6afb7d995c8ad27ab151
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    79fc4d2beb36acde0262f9bfb79524d845b595521910c6c14db50db6688033d7

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file