City Council meeting
Monday, April 4, 2022
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: c,e,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:03:10 Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome to April 4th 2022 City Council meeting. I want to
0:03:18 confirm we have a quorum. We have six members present in person and Spencer Cutler is on the phone.
0:03:25 So first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. Anybody wishing to join me please rise.
0:03:32 Thank you. So today we do have one proclamation. It's a proclamation designating April is Fair
0:03:58 housing month in the City of Twin Falls.
0:04:03 Office of the Mayor City of Twin Falls, Idaho Proclamation, whereas April 2022 marks the
0:04:09 54th anniversary of the passage of Title 8 of the Civil Rights Act of 1968, commonly
0:04:16 known as the Federal Fair Housing Act, and whereas the Idaho Human Rights Commission Act
0:04:23 as prohibited discrimination in housing since 1969,
0:04:27 and whereas equal opportunity for all,
0:04:30 regardless of race, color, religion, sex, disability,
0:04:35 familiar status, or national origin,
0:04:38 is a fundamental goal of our nation, state, and city,
0:04:42 and whereas equal access to housing
0:04:44 is an important component of this goal,
0:04:47 as fundamental as the right to equal education and employment,
0:04:51 Whereas housing is a critical component
0:04:54 of family and community health instability,
0:04:57 and whereas housing choice impacts our children's access
0:05:01 to education, our ability to seek and retain
0:05:04 employment options, and the cultural benefits we enjoy,
0:05:09 the extent of our exposure to crime and drugs,
0:05:12 and the quality of healthcare we receive in emergencies.
0:05:15 And whereas the loss of this nation and our state
0:05:18 seek to ensure such equality of choice for all transactions involving housing, and whereas
0:05:25 ongoing education, outreach, and monitoring are key to raising awareness of fair housing
0:05:30 principles, practices, rights, and responsibilities, whereas only through continued cooperation,
0:05:38 commitment, and support of all IITA-Howans can barriers to fair housing be removed.
0:05:45 Now, therefore, I, Ruth Pierce, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim April
0:05:51 2022 to be Fair Housing Month in the City of Twin Falls, State of Idaho.
0:05:57 Thank you.
0:05:58 Do you want to come up and get this the interview?
0:06:00 I'm Mayor, City Council.
0:06:21 Thank you for this proclamation, this being April as for housing month in recognition of
0:06:28 the Anniversary of the Civil Rights Act.
0:06:30 This is just one of the many things that we'll be doing this year to help highlight the barriers
0:06:35 and benefits of housing as part of our community development block grant program.
0:06:39 So thank you.
0:06:40 Thank you.
0:06:44 Next item on the agenda is our consent calendar, there's several items.
0:06:50 Council wishes.
0:06:51 The motion to accept the minutes and as written.
0:06:59 Okay.
0:07:00 Okay.
0:07:01 Thank you.
0:07:02 Is there a second?
0:07:03 Oh second.
0:07:04 Thank you Jason.
0:07:05 Motion by Craig Hocken seconded by Jason Brown to approve the consent calendar is listed.
0:07:12 Mayor and roll call vote please.
0:07:14 Mayor Pierce?
0:07:17 Yes.
0:07:18 Vice Mayor Reed?
0:07:19 Yes.
0:07:20 Sean Baraker?
0:07:21 Yes.
0:07:22 Vicki Boyd?
0:07:23 Yes.
0:07:24 Ray Calkins?
0:07:25 Yes.
0:07:26 Jason Brown?
0:07:27 Yes.
0:07:29 Venture Cutler?
0:07:30 Yes.
0:07:31 Thank you.
0:07:32 Motion carries seven to zero.
0:07:34 So long list and mostly Lou, yours.
0:07:39 Approval of the facts and findings of conclusion of law for sportsman's warehouse.
0:07:44 warehouse, help build HOPE event, 2022 Magic Valley Law Enforcement Memorial Service,
0:07:51 Oxcorn HOPE Tournament event, Twin Falls Library, Dance and Block Party,
0:07:57 Idaho Hospice, Annual Memorial. They know Edward's variety show, engage in education event,
0:08:05 first federal rock, paper, scissors, tournament, and the Parade of Homes, Barbecue, Sneak Peak.
0:08:11 All were approved. So if you're here for that, your item was approved. Okay. Under
0:08:19 items of consideration, our first action item is a request from the Friends of
0:08:24 Avenues to authorized city staff to work with the Friends of Avenues to develop a local residential
0:08:31 historic district application PZ22-0039. And we have Jonathan Spindlove, our Director of Planning
0:08:40 and zoning in Chautotham.
0:08:42 Thank you Madam Mayor, members of the council.
0:08:43 I'll do a brief introduction.
0:08:45 This item comes from friends of the avenues.
0:08:47 They have their spokesperson, is Kate Lopez.
0:08:51 She worked with our Historic Preservation Commission,
0:08:53 March 7th, to do a presentation to that commission.
0:08:57 That commission ended up taking an action
0:08:59 to recommend to the council to hear this item.
0:09:03 The item is to decide or get direction on staff
0:09:06 to work on a local historic district that would include a few different things, one being
0:09:13 a survey of the area and then an enactment of some regulatory issues.
0:09:20 At this point we're going to have Kate come and do her presentation that she gave to the
0:09:24 historic preservation commission and then council can ask questions of Kate and her
0:09:29 staff at the end.
0:09:30 Thank you Jonathan.
0:09:31 Welcome Kate.
0:09:32 Welcome Kate. So I have you on the agenda for five to ten minutes. Can you keep it in there?
0:09:41 I think so.
0:09:42 Okay.
0:09:43 I have, we have display items that Lisa will help me with, but I also have some hard copies of any of those there.
0:09:50 I think so.
0:09:54 Members of council, thank you very much for allowing us to be represented here.
0:10:12 My name is Kate Lopez, I'm a homeowner and 37-year resident at 206-8th Avenue East.
0:10:19 The purpose of my presentation is to request that you, the elected city council,
0:10:24 follow the unanimous vote of your historic preservation commission to allow that
0:10:28 audience city administrative staff to assist the avenue neighbors with the
0:10:33 drafting of ordinances and other documents necessary to formalize our
0:10:37 proposed residential historic district in a future vote.
0:10:41 These documents might include, but are not limited to, ordinance language and design guideline
0:10:47 protections that require that additions, demolition, or exterior architectural modifications be
0:10:54 subject to review by the Twin Falls City Historic Preservation Commission, similar to reviews
0:10:59 currently being done in the other Twin Falls Historic Districts.
0:11:03 The City of Twin Falls contains four National Park Service designated districts, of the
0:11:08 four districts, the downtown warehouse in City Park historic districts have been adopted
0:11:13 by the city.
0:11:15 Adoption by the city allows for review of projects in those districts for compliance or the established
0:11:20 design guideline protections.
0:11:22 The protections are meant to ensure that changes to the exteriors of the buildings be
0:11:27 compatible with their surrounding neighborhood in order to preserve historic settings which
0:11:32 in turn protects property values.
0:11:35 All reviews are afforded appeal rights to both Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council.
0:11:41 The one remaining historic district, the original town site district, has yet to be adopted
0:11:47 by the city.
0:11:48 It's a section of this last district, the original town site, that the neighbors have
0:11:53 named the Avenue's Historic Residential District, and that we are currently requesting city staff
0:11:59 and Historic Preservation Commission time be allocated for prior to adoption.
0:12:04 As a brief background, the Twin Falls original town site residential historic district was entered into the National Register of Historic Places on November 30, 2001.
0:12:15 Elizabeth Giroud is an architectural historian from Salt Lake City.
0:12:19 According to her National Historic Historic Places nomination form in 2000, the town site contains 933 buildings.
0:12:29 Roughly two-thirds or 637 buildings contribute to the historic character of the district.
0:12:37 Residential properties are 93% of those buildings.
0:12:41 The adoption of the Avenue's Historic Residential District would continue the work of historic
0:12:45 preservation started by the city and the local preservation community long ago.
0:12:52 It would add protection to the residential area, a crucial and currently missing piece
0:12:57 of the Protected Historic Fabric of Twin Falls.
0:13:00 A review of the City Comprehensive Plan indicates it has always been the intent of the city to
0:13:11 develop design guidelines and provide protection to the original town site district.
0:13:17 H-4 discusses planning, framework, and implementation of goals in the city's vision.
0:13:22 H-24 states the Twin Falls original town site is the largest district encompassing 260
0:13:31 four acres and containing 919 historic buildings, making it one of the largest residential historic
0:13:39 districts in the entire United States.
0:13:43 Historic landscape site structures, buildings and features are essential components of the
0:13:48 city's identity.
0:13:49 Preservation of historic places helps to maintain a connection to the community's heritage.
0:13:54 This has been a fundamental part of the preservation movement in Twin Falls since its beginning.
0:14:00 age 25 of the comprehensive plan. Preserves existing neighborhoods and older buildings
0:14:06 helps maintain the social fabric of the city. And it goes on to say that revitalization
0:14:11 and preservation of historic downtown is essential to the economy of Twin Falls. And finally
0:14:17 on page 35, the plan states the city should develop incentives to encourage residents to
0:14:24 to reinvest in their homes, particularly in older neighborhoods.
0:14:30 Also in tab six, a quote from the Twin Falls 2018 Historic Preservation Master Plan states
0:14:37 on page one that preservation activities increase and stabilize property values.
0:14:42 They encourage civic engagement and preservation of community diversity.
0:14:47 They countercyclical economic downturns.
0:14:50 They provide for an increase in heritage tourism and revitalization efforts.
0:14:55 They reduce urban sprawl.
0:14:57 They provide for social equity through affordable housing.
0:15:02 These are also the positive results we seek through adoption of the avenues district.
0:15:08 Page 5 of the master plan also states that the HPC will reevaluate every 5 or 10 years
0:15:15 to check off completed goals.
0:15:18 new goals and ensure continued compliance.
0:15:22 Page 9, Table 1, lists the preservation laws that apply to our city.
0:15:29 The original town site, the residential district at the bottom of the page, one of the largest
0:15:34 residential districts in the United States, is the only item that has no design guideline
0:15:40 protections established because it has not been adopted by our city.
0:15:46 We have a very unique distinction with the original town site, one that we feel should
0:15:50 be respected and protected.
0:15:53 And finally on page 15, the master plan states the listed goals and objectives are the city's
0:15:59 guide for preservation and rehabilitation of heritage resources.
0:16:05 They encompass the continued engagement with the community, on the importance of historic
0:16:10 resources, and are a continued effort to identify and catalog new resources.
0:16:16 Objective 2-1, the very first objective on the list,
0:16:20 is to develop design guidelines
0:16:22 for the original town site historic district.
0:16:25 Objective 2-5 is to work with the downtown permit assistance
0:16:29 program in the URA to develop and incorporate and develop
0:16:33 an incentive program to encourage developers
0:16:35 to preserve historic structures and or incorporate them
0:16:39 into new design rather than raise them for new buildings.
0:16:44 Goal three, celebrate the historic districts with plans
0:16:46 to draw tourists, plaques, banners, et cetera.
0:16:50 These are the exact things that our group
0:16:53 of 157 residential households want.
0:16:57 We think it's time to adopt the avenue's residential district,
0:17:00 which is in keeping with everything
0:17:02 the city documents encourage.
0:17:07 There are approximately 305 structures
0:17:10 in our proposed local district,
0:17:11 230 of which are contributing properties
0:17:14 that have maintained physical integrity.
0:17:16 This is data that I gleaned from architectural historian,
0:17:21 Elizabeth's Roads document.
0:17:23 This represents just over 75% of the buildings
0:17:25 in the post district.
0:17:27 To date, our ongoing door-to-door petition drives
0:17:31 eliciting signatures, which by the way,
0:17:33 was not very easy during COVID and the winter months.
0:17:36 Of those homeowners in our proposed district
0:17:39 has resulted in 157 representative properties,
0:17:43 approving the creation of the district.
0:17:46 This is just over 52% of the properties.
0:17:50 Our neighborhoods are now over 120 years old.
0:17:53 They are the first residences of Twin Falls
0:17:56 and developers see them as an easy target to tear down.
0:18:00 However, aside from just being disrespectful
0:18:02 to the first founders of Twin Falls,
0:18:04 demolition is not an environmentally sound practice.
0:18:08 It wastes resources and actually minimizes
0:18:11 job opportunities that remodels create. They need to produce the need to produce new materials
0:18:17 is greatly reduced and space is not taken to dispose of materials and landfills when you renovate.
0:18:22 These neighborhoods were built to last and they still look wonderful but certainly there are no
0:18:27 monetary barriers to demolition. On a review of building permits in the city in 2019 the city
0:18:35 charged $22 per demolished home for the demolition of the four houses behind the
0:18:40 Christian Church on 6-7. One of those houses was the historic 1911 keel house.
0:18:46 An accessory building demolition later in the year was also charged $22. And then
0:18:53 tab four. I'd like to address the potential impact of the Avenue's district
0:18:59 designation on city staff and the historic preservation commission. I
0:19:03 I printed off every building permit issued by the city since January 1st of 2019.
0:19:11 The summary of those permits is seen in this tip.
0:19:15 The documents were retrieved from the Twin Falls Idaho Worksite.
0:19:19 In 2019, there were 848 building permits issued.
0:19:25 Ten of those were in the avenues.
0:19:28 That's an impact of 1.1%.
0:19:31 Five of those were demolitions at the $22 rate.
0:19:37 In 2020, there were 986 permits issued.
0:19:42 Twelve of those were in the avenues.
0:19:44 That's an impact of 1.2%.
0:19:47 In 2021, there were 743 permits issued.
0:19:52 Six of those were in the avenues.
0:19:54 That's an impact of 0.8%.
0:19:57 And in 2022, there have been 61 building permits issued so far.
0:20:01 far, and none of them have been in the proposed district.
0:20:07 There will be some cost to prepare design guidelines, however, there are numerous examples
0:20:15 of guidelines for which to glean information.
0:20:19 Good ones that we have at our disposal were prepared by architectural historian Elizabeth
0:20:23 Giroux.
0:20:24 She prepared guidelines at the time of the National Park submission.
0:20:28 In addition, other Idaho towns have published guidelines for their residential districts,
0:20:33 But in the past, SHIPO, the State Historic Preservation Office, has also provided funds
0:20:37 to assist with these types of costs.
0:20:40 I can't speak for SHIPO, but there's no reason to think that state funds will not be available
0:20:44 if needed.
0:20:45 They've been very supportive in the past, this is kind of what they do.
0:20:50 Private funds can also be sought.
0:20:52 But actually, the prudent and most resourceful thing to do would be to start with the geroad
0:20:57 guidelines that we already have available.
0:21:02 In summary, the residents of the 157 household properties that I represent understand that
0:21:08 their neighborhoods are facing encroachment.
0:21:12 We are experiencing unprecedented growth.
0:21:15 We want to proactively protect these first neighborhoods and structures by maintaining
0:21:21 structural styles integral to the original intent and to celebrate their styles and stories
0:21:27 by fulfilling the published goals and objectives of the city.
0:21:32 But we need your help to do that.
0:21:35 We're not asking for a handout.
0:21:37 We're just asking for a hand.
0:21:40 We want to partner with you in something admirable
0:21:43 and benefit all of us.
0:21:46 Thank you.
0:21:46 Thank you, Kate.
0:21:49 Anybody have any questions for Kate or Steph?
0:22:02 Is there still an ongoing canvassing to find out
0:22:06 the feelings of the neighborhoods?
0:22:07 Yes, yes, any other questions, Sean?
0:22:15 This is more a question.
0:22:17 Excuse me, I'm processed, so maybe it's half a question.
0:22:20 So I know that the establishment of districts
0:22:24 is outlined in the state code.
0:22:27 It speaks to the Historic Reservation Commission
0:22:32 making an investigation of the historical architectural
0:22:36 archaeological and cultural significance.
0:22:38 the fact that this last review was done.
0:22:42 When it went years ago, would we anticipate that if this moved forward, have to start over
0:22:50 with that investigation as well?
0:22:52 So I think you can use the original, the original encompassed all of it.
0:22:57 If the council wanted an updated one, it goes back and forth, someone said yes, someone said
0:23:03 no.
0:23:04 If they wanted to have just the area that this group is proposing, that's not the original
0:23:08 It's a portion of the original you with some of those buildings may or may not still be contributing
0:23:14 So it really if you wanted updated information from 20 years ago
0:23:18 They could be prudent to do so that you would just have the area there requesting to be within that
0:23:24 Survey survey or the investigation
0:23:27 Area
0:23:28 But you could certainly springboard from the original to say these buildings to exist
0:23:33 other ones may not still be contributing.
0:23:36 Maybe just a kind of folks here who at some point would be interested in speaking on this issue, though that isn't coming.
0:23:50 Evening.
0:23:51 Process also includes rings.
0:23:57 If the council makes the decision to create a district, we would follow the requirement in state statute that holds multiple public hearings to create that district.
0:24:12 And that is a public hearing standpoint of a right to speak
0:24:15 because of the area that you're encompassing.
0:24:19 Thank you.
0:24:21 Questions?
0:24:22 Did you know what I just like to say?
0:24:26 Thank you very much.
0:24:27 This was a very thorough and the hard copies.
0:24:29 You went to a lot of work on these.
0:24:31 I really appreciate having that.
0:24:32 Thank you.
0:24:33 Welcome.
0:24:34 Thank you.
0:24:35 Is there a path to Jonathan cost to us, the city,
0:24:42 create a district other than half-time?
0:24:48 What are the costs that there are any?
0:24:51 Yeah, there's some unknown costs in terms of doing a new survey or an updated survey.
0:24:55 Um, encompassed the area they're proposing, which would be a carve out or a portion of the original.
0:25:01 I don't know that cost what the survey would be.
0:25:04 I'll have those costs because I have not sought one, personally, in terms of what we've done in the past.
0:25:11 We have a map that shows which portion, if it's not the whole thing.
0:25:16 Yeah, it should be in the materials.
0:25:18 I don't know if Lisa's going to do this on our packet on the website, but tonight Jonathan
0:25:29 we're just being asked to approve that everybody worked together, story preservation, the friends
0:25:35 of the avenues and city staff to work on a project to potentially create a local district.
0:25:41 Yeah, I think what we would be looking for from a staff standpoint is, too, does the Council
0:25:46 I want to wish to direct the planning and zoning department to go after finding a budget for doing a survey for an updated survey
0:25:55 and then creating the time to work on making this district per the state statutes
0:26:03 and that would be council directive to us we would make the time to do that as a chair directive
0:26:11 okay police are directive to city manager's office who would then direct us to do it
0:26:16 This is the map of the area that the friends of the avenues folks have created.
0:26:22 I can't remember.
0:26:23 Is it that little chief that comes down to yes it is that little job as well question yes
0:26:34 was there a specific reason this particular triangle with the little offshoot was was selected
0:26:43 and not the original and I have I don't know if I saw the original or not was there a specific
0:26:49 reason.
0:26:50 particular area was selected above and beyond because as I read the state code
0:26:57 there's you know historical district has some architectural or archaeological
0:27:03 cultural significance or historical and I didn't know if this particular area had
0:27:08 that in abundance or what was the reason behind it. Well all the original
0:27:13 town site has it in abundance. But this particular area is the gateway to our downtown and we felt
0:27:23 it appropriate to start here. We would love to see you do improve the whole town site quite frankly.
0:27:29 But starting out we've decided this would be better because this is the view and the area that
0:27:35 everyone sees when they come into downtown. So it starts at Addison and Blue Lakes and it comes
0:27:43 south towards downtown and then the city park to the jog is part of that is the city park district
0:27:51 so the libraries included in that little jog down to the I guess it is yeah you good Jason yeah
0:28:04 that's very I just wanted to make make a statement I guess the thing that's important to understand
0:28:10 those that are here for or against tonight this ultimately is saying yes we want city staff to
0:28:17 work on this. This isn't a resolution that the guidelines that are discussed in the documents
0:28:23 that are here are going to be put into effect. There's just the conversation. That's what
0:28:29 we're doing. So if it is approved, I would advise everybody to be involved because looking
0:28:35 over the guidelines, somebody who feel very strongly about individual personal property
0:28:42 some of those guidelines might be something that you're not okay with on
0:28:47 either side whether it comes down to material architectural design I know
0:28:52 that was a huge issue when I was on planning and zoning you have people on
0:28:58 commissions that are architects are not individuals who have a lot of history
0:29:03 in design so I struggle with this I'm not saying I'm against it I struggle
0:29:11 because ultimately we're asking a lot to be honest the historic preservation
0:29:15 on City Council on planning and zoning when it comes to design and materials and
0:29:21 we've seen in situations where commissions have got it my opinion wrong
0:29:26 and we're telling individuals who own homes in this district potentially
0:29:33 yes or no on the design and architecture so can I address that well I just want
0:29:42 to let you I appreciate it I think that those homes are beautiful but again and
0:29:47 Someone buys their home. It's their home and now we're coming in and telling them no, you can't have this or you can't have that
0:29:55 Well, may I respond to that?
0:29:58 Go ahead.
0:30:01 This isn't really a debate tonight. I'll- I'll- Okay.
0:30:04 But go ahead, Kate.
0:30:07 I don't think you're telling them anything. This has been initiated at the property owner level.
0:30:14 to go forward as a protection to our neighborhood.
0:30:17 And yes, there are going to be people that don't agree
0:30:21 with these protections, but in all honesty,
0:30:24 we've met very few, like under five of the people
0:30:29 we've talked to.
0:30:31 And when someone owns a home in any district
0:30:34 and you make a renovation to your home,
0:30:36 you still have to get a building permit.
0:30:39 So you can compare it to that.
0:30:41 This is one other step as there would be
0:30:44 for a building permit, but it's a valid discussion point.
0:30:49 Thank you.
0:30:50 Thank you.
0:30:51 I'm here.
0:30:53 Probably a question for staff.
0:30:54 We know why this particular district wasn't adopted and why guidelines were not made at
0:31:00 the time of the other districts coming through.
0:31:02 So what we have is minutes that said the council approved the purchasing of the guidelines
0:31:09 or basically paying for someone to create the guidelines and absolutely nothing after
0:31:12 that.
0:31:13 evidence that they discussed other things. The minutes are sparse, meaning they purchased
0:31:20 them. The council was presented. They were presented to council. And council chose not
0:31:25 to enact them. I don't have a decision to not enact them. I just simply have minutes
0:31:31 that don't have a motion.
0:31:33 Thank you.
0:31:35 Another question. So when I look at this, I think it was under tab 2. You have the
0:31:42 the C-O-N-T versus NC and then I see it show up on the map. What is that actually referring
0:31:49 to?
0:31:50 Okay.
0:31:55 Okay.
0:31:56 And so there was a percentage, it's about 75% I think in the proposed district that contributed
0:32:03 to the historical integrity.
0:32:05 And then you gave another figure that was saying that you had contacted a certain portion
0:32:12 I was trying to bring that back up and want to make sure I understood all of the numbers a little bit more.
0:32:19 I contacted a certain portion of residents. We have the date obtained 157 owners, signatures supporting the creation of this district.
0:32:33 of how many, again, residents?
0:32:36 Three, there are about 309 properties
0:32:39 with residential and business.
0:32:41 And again, we just haven't,
0:32:42 it's not that they said no, we just haven't been there.
0:32:45 Okay.
0:32:46 Just haven't made it there yet.
0:32:52 The other questions.
0:32:55 I'd entertain a motion if somebody is interested.
0:32:58 A motion that city staff looks into this further
0:33:08 from the other request to have the council
0:33:17 approve the historic preservation of the avenues
0:33:19 City staff to work on project to create a local residential district.
0:33:24 Thank you.
0:33:29 Is that a good motion by Craig Hawkins second by Nicky Boyd to approve, authorize City
0:33:40 staff to work with the Friends of the Avenue and the HPC to develop a local historic district
0:33:47 and put a budget together.
0:33:49 I have a question if I can.
0:33:52 Jonathan, do you have any idea how much time this is going to take to put together?
0:33:58 I know where everybody keep talking about limited staff and numbers and trying to figure
0:34:03 out what that actually, what kind of stress and strain this would put on city staff to go
0:34:08 and do that.
0:34:09 But right now, without this project, we do one or two meetings a month for HPC.
0:34:17 That group needs to deal with certificates of appropriateness.
0:34:22 To do this, it depends on the direction I guess that we get from Council.
0:34:27 I mean, if we're looking at meeting with either this group or HPC if we're looking at once
0:34:35 a week, that's ours away from doing other things.
0:34:39 In terms of a timeline, we're looking at a budget, looking at the future budget.
0:34:43 We won't have a budget until October.
0:34:47 We would have to figure out between now and then or fairly quickly what a budget to get
0:34:51 a new survey done. The guidelines would be separate after we have the survey to know what's in there.
0:34:59 Those guidelines would then come either hopefully as he was saying if Shippo has money for a grant
0:35:05 sometimes they do. We've received those in the past or other funding sources. The last ones we did,
0:35:12 I believe, my back in memory, hey doing this in public, I believe we shared the cost with
0:35:20 with a city in Boise and our share was around 30,000
0:35:24 for the guidelines for downtown.
0:35:27 I wouldn't expect this to be similar,
0:35:29 but if we were bearing the brunt of all of it,
0:35:31 then it might be more now to create guidelines.
0:35:37 If I may deviate a little bit further to the question of further,
0:35:40 if this district is created, right now,
0:35:43 we do a certificate of appropriateness for about 113 properties.
0:35:49 This would triple or quadruple those numbers of properties
0:35:52 be seeing certificates of appropriateness for and we do, I think on average, four
0:35:57 a month, five months, so quadrupling, that would be 16. The issue is that commercial
0:36:07 properties don't change as much as residential in terms of the number of
0:36:10 owners of one property. Example, Helch Lodge does one for their whole facade.
0:36:16 They don't change that facade that often. I would anticipate property owners
0:36:21 wanting to paint their fence, paint their door, change hardware more often than the commercial businesses do, so
0:36:28 Boise has a dedicated person for their 300 and something properties.
0:36:33 Caldwell has a dedicated person for their 150-ish.
0:36:38 Those are the only two cities that have a residential district in the state.
0:36:42 Wallace has one, but I didn't get to talk to them.
0:36:49 Oh, any further discussion on the motion?
0:36:51 Aaron, roll call, vote please.
0:36:58 Vice-Barrade?
0:37:01 Sean Verger. Yes.
0:37:10 Thank you, Boyd. Yes.
0:37:13 Ray Hawkins. Yes.
0:37:15 Jason Brown. No.
0:37:17 That's your color. Yes.
0:37:20 Mayor Pierce. Yes.
0:37:23 Hey, motion.
0:37:26 I believe five to two.
0:37:28 Thank you.
0:37:31 Thank you, Kate. Thank you very much.
0:37:33 Thank you, Jonathan.
0:37:37 Okay.
0:37:40 Next, I'm on the agenda.
0:37:43 is another action item a request to approve resolution 2022-009 authorizing
0:37:51 the reimbursement
0:37:52 and maybe you might give just a couple of seconds it looks like there's a yes
0:37:56 yes it's not interested in future conversations come on for me Travis I was
0:38:06 all focused are you ready I am ready if you are okay I think I need to finish my
0:38:37 I request to approve resolution 2020 2009 authorizing the reimbursement of eligible expenses
0:38:45 associated with the construction of fire stations two and three with proceeds from the
0:38:50 cell of the certificate of participation.
0:38:53 We have Mandy Thompson, assistant to the city manager.
0:38:57 Welcome Mandy.
0:38:59 Thank you, Madam Mayor, council members, I appreciate your time tonight.
0:39:03 coming to you, essentially with a request to explore some options, keep our options open
0:39:13 as it pertains to the financing of fire stations that we are currently in design with right
0:39:20 now.
0:39:21 The purpose of the resolution is to express the intent of you, our city council, to reimburse
0:39:28 First the city from loan proceeds for any expenses of the project, the fire stations
0:39:35 two and three.
0:39:37 Advanced by the city prior to the receipt of the loan proceeds.
0:39:41 The reimbursement resolution as we are discussing tonight also known as the official intent resolution
0:39:48 is required by federal law, federal tax laws and regulations to be adopted by our city council
0:39:54 either before making any expenditures, or not later than 90 days after the city makes any project payments.
0:40:02 The exceptions to this are in design and engineering, which are obviously costs that we have been
0:40:09 incurring for well over a year now, architecture design and engineering, if the city intends to
0:40:17 reimburse itself from loan proceeds. So as I am sure you're all aware of the building environment,
0:40:25 is a little bit changed since we started this project as the process has been going along
0:40:34 and we have been in the design phase of stations two and three. We've had multiple opportunities
0:40:41 to see cost estimates through the process. In December of 2021, we received cost estimates
0:40:50 from two different sources, including Starr, who was Michael Errington, is here tonight on
0:40:55 another item, but these estimates were based in good faith in what they were seeing in the
0:41:01 economy at the time. We went to bid on this project in March of this year, or actually
0:41:08 February of this year, and saw a very different bidding environment than the one that we were
0:41:13 anticipating in December. So what we're coming with you tonight is just really the opportunity
0:41:20 to have some flexibility of how we finance the fire stations as it stands if
0:41:28 there are any costs that are incurred from today 90 days forward. This resolution
0:41:35 would allow the city to reimburse itself for any of those costs should we decide
0:41:40 to go forward with a certificate of participation to find stations two and
0:41:45 three. So we are not stating your intent to actually go forward with that
0:41:51 per certificate of participation, but this is the first step in the process. We have
0:41:55 to make sure that any costs that are incurred kind of in between would be
0:41:59 reimbursable. So with the budget impact of this would be that all expenses
0:42:07 associated with that, the construction would be eligible for
0:42:15 reimbursement and capitalized in the certificate of participation. So tonight
0:42:20 there's no budget impact with the passage of the resolution and should you as
0:42:24 council elect to not adopt the resolution we would be unable to reimburse
0:42:29 ourselves for any expenses incurred before the issue ends up that certificate of
0:42:33 participation. So again this is just basically to make sure that we can
0:42:36 pay ourselves back should we move forward with this alternate fund financing. I
0:42:41 I think at that point I'll stop and ask if you have any questions.
0:42:46 Any questions for Amanda?
0:42:50 Thank you.
0:42:51 Very clear.
0:42:54 Council wishes.
0:42:55 Tom Berriger.
0:42:59 Mayor, I would move to adopt resolution 2022-09 as presented.
0:43:07 Thank you.
0:43:08 Thank you, Chris.
0:43:09 Motion by Sean Berriger.
0:43:11 Second by Chris Reed to approve resolution 2022-09.
0:43:16 Thank you.
0:43:17 Motion carries.
0:43:19 Passes 7-0.
0:43:20 Thank you, Mandy.
0:43:24 Thank you.
0:43:25 Okay, here up again.
0:43:26 Okay, next one.
0:43:27 A request from Star Corporation to approve for pepper pose.
0:43:30 A request from Star Corporation to approve for pepper pose.
0:43:34 Yes. Vice-meried. Yes. Thank you. Motion carries. Passes 7-0. Thank you, Mandy. Thank you.
0:43:43 Okay, you're up again. Okay, excellent. A request from Star Corporation to approve
0:43:51 a proposed or guaranteed maximum price GMP for the construction of the Jimberry Regional
0:43:59 Fire Training Facility. Oh, Mandy. Okay. I will get a brief introduction. I'm sorry.
0:44:08 have Mayor Pierce. I'm going to recuse myself from this. I have a potential conflict of interest on this item.
0:44:15 Okay. Thank you, Spencer. Everybody else good? Okay. Go ahead, Matty. Thank you.
0:44:22 Okay. I will just give a brief overview of the agenda item and then we have Michael Errington with Star Corporation that can come up and talk to you about the GMP itself.
0:44:30 So, just as a reminder, the City of Twin Falls and the City and the Twin Falls Fire District
0:44:37 are working together to build this regional fire training facility in Twin Falls.
0:44:44 The facility itself is being funded by the fire district and will be owned and maintained
0:44:48 by the City as a Twin Falls City asset.
0:44:51 The regional fire training facility is located on City On Property at 430 Victory Avenue adjacent
0:44:59 to the animal shelter and also to municipal golf course.
0:45:03 As a part of the agreement, the city is managing the design and construction of the training
0:45:07 center along with the constructions of fire stations two and three.
0:45:11 So if you'll recall, I came to you in December with phase one of the GMP.
0:45:18 That was in the amount of $988,583 and that was the first of the three phases.
0:45:25 first phase was essentially just with some site clearing, bringing in some gravel and some other
0:45:31 grading of the area. So tonight Michael Harrington is going to come up and speak with you about the
0:45:36 second phase of the GMP. So what we're doing is amending the original GMP amount and he'll come up here
0:45:44 and talk to you a little bit about the project itself and answer any questions that you may have
0:45:49 about the bids that were submitted in your packet.
0:45:52 Thank you, Pandy.
0:45:54 Welcome, Michael.
0:45:59 What's going to be with you this evening?
0:46:01 So this is exciting.
0:46:03 DER is moving out on your site, and it's
0:46:05 beginning to transform from the back of house area,
0:46:10 should we say, that it was to a first class training
0:46:15 facility.
0:46:16 So this evening, the amended GMP, or the amendment to the GMP,
0:46:21 would add concrete in certain areas.
0:46:25 There's some curb gutter and sidewalk
0:46:27 at the front entryway of the area, label number one.
0:46:31 Sometimes my ones are confused as two,
0:46:34 so it's also that white area there at the bottom of the property.
0:46:40 This would also be to add the fence to go around the facility.
0:46:44 Also with the concrete is, I stopped myself short there.
0:46:48 There's also the foundation for the training facility
0:46:51 and there's the fence and there's some landscaping and a little mount at the front and then there
0:47:00 is the site utility work that goes in, that's the water lines and the storm grain, the sewer
0:47:06 things, things of that nature and that's what is taken into account in this particular
0:47:11 phase that we're asking for.
0:47:14 As Vandy already talked about, the gravel for these various areas and the paving for
0:47:21 various areas was already included, GMP, the first one, this particular GMP does refine
0:47:28 a bit those particular areas and give a little more specific information on which areas are
0:47:35 labeled here on this map, receive what treatment, whether it's being cut to subgrade, whether
0:47:40 gravel is being installed or whether it's gravel and asphalt. That's the work that's included
0:47:46 in this particular GMP amendment,
0:47:49 and he mentioned that there'll be three,
0:47:51 that there'll be a third that is in the future,
0:47:54 and that's with the training facility
0:47:56 that lies in area number four.
0:47:59 Once some of these variables are removed,
0:48:01 then design work will begin on that particular portion,
0:48:04 which is phase number three.
0:48:06 Any questions for Michael?
0:48:11 I've got one. Yes, Jason.
0:48:14 So you said there was included offense, is that correct?
0:48:17 That's correct, yeah.
0:48:18 Yes, so I know that this borders the golf course. Does that are we utilizing that or helping replace that or is there specific?
0:48:27 Are we offsetting the fence to go around the perimeter?
0:48:31 I should have brought my design documents with me. I believe that
0:48:35 that we are putting in new perimeter fence around the whole facility. The only exception that we're utilizing is
0:48:42 Is there some fence here to the East portion of the property that goes
0:48:47 long and will shelter this town. Okay, but the fence that's down the western border
0:48:53 it's it's time. Okay, any other questions? Real quick in the packet it says
0:49:03 phase two is the in the amount of five hundred eight four thousand two hundred
0:49:08 dollars. Is that what we're dealing with right now? That dollar. That is correct.
0:49:12 That's the addition to the previously proved 1988, so yes, it is the 584, 200, yes, thank you.
0:49:19 Any further discussion?
0:49:23 I want to make a motion, Chris, since you got it.
0:49:26 I move that we approve the request from Star Corporation to approve a proposed guarantee maximum price for the construction of the gym.
0:49:38 Very regional fire training facility.
0:49:43 I'll second.
0:49:44 Thank you.
0:49:45 motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Jason Brown to approve the proposed GMP for the
0:49:52 construction of the regional fire training facility. Any other discussion? Erin Roll
0:49:59 caught. Please.
0:50:02 Nicky Boyd. Craig Hawkins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Spencer Cutler.
0:50:08 Thank you, thank you, thank you.
0:50:16 Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you.
0:50:28 Okay, so next item on the agenda is general public input, it's a time for anyone from the public who wishes to speak on something not on the agenda.
0:50:40 I have a list of people that did sign. I'm not sure how many of them are still here. Would you like it?
0:50:49 Well, they were, I think, all for the seconds, but I can look at it and see.
0:50:55 There's nobody's coming up. I think it's probably all Jim, somebody,
0:51:10 ATHLEAN, MIKE, MORRY, or LIND of FLEMING.
0:51:14 Oh, okay. All right. Thank you.
0:51:20 So, no one for public input. Thank you. We're moving on to advisory board reports. Any from council from advisory boards?
0:51:33 Spencer, do you have anything?
0:51:37 No, Mayor. Thank you.
0:51:39 The manager's office. Nothing. Goodness. Okay.
0:51:45 So the next item on the agenda is a public hearing which is scheduled for six o'clock.
0:51:51 So at this point in time, I think we'll take a break for about
0:51:55 eight minutes seven minutes and we'll be ready to roll back at six o'clock. Thank
0:52:01 you back at six o'clock and we will open up. Sorry guys I can't help it. I'm a
1:02:40 little tax season roomy today. Okay so the next item on a gerant agenda is a
1:02:47 public hearing. It's a request request for zoning district change and zoning
1:02:54 map amendment for 6.4 acres from R4 to CSIPUD, and to expand the CSIPUD boundaries to include
1:03:04 property location, property located in the 1100 block of Fillmore Street, Kerr of Theoshoot
1:03:12 on behalf of the College of Southern Idaho. Sean Berger.
1:03:15 Mayor, thank you. On the advice of the City Attorney, because my wife is employed at the College of Southern Idaho, I am going to recuse myself.
1:03:24 Thank you, Sean. Spencer Keller.
1:03:27 Mayor Pierce, I am employed by the College of Southern Idaho, so I will also recuse myself.
1:03:35 Okay, thank you, gentlemen. Okay, so down to five.
1:03:43 So, the public hearing procedures are the city staff will present the request and analysis.
1:03:56 The applicant will then present their request.
1:03:59 The council will ask questions of the applicant or staff after the questions have been asked
1:04:05 the public hearing will be opened.
1:04:08 During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions
1:04:12 about the request being considered.
1:04:15 When you're giving testimony, please step up to the podium,
1:04:19 state your name and address, and then present your comments
1:04:21 or concern.
1:04:23 After giving testimony, if you haven't already signed the
1:04:26 public sheets in the lobby, please sign with your name
1:04:29 and address.
1:04:30 After public comments or concluded, the applicant will be
1:04:34 invited to answer any questions.
1:04:36 Make a closing statement.
1:04:37 Staff will then answer, clarify any comments.
1:04:40 After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed, no further testimony or comments
1:04:46 from the applicant or audience will be allowed and then the council will have open discussion
1:04:51 and take action on the request.
1:04:54 Okay, so we have Kelly.
1:04:57 I resolve from planning the zoning.
1:05:00 No, I'm sorry, we have Lisa Strickland. Hello, Lisa.
1:05:04 It's not Kelly in the audience and she left, so.
1:05:08 Good evening, Mayor, Council.
1:05:10 This is a request to rezone property located
1:05:12 at the 1100 block of Fillmore Street
1:05:15 from R4 to CSI PUD.
1:05:18 In 2018, the college requested and had approved the CSI PUD
1:05:22 to allow for additional height and a midland
1:05:25 uses to allow for residential hall and a rooming house
1:05:29 as permitted uses for a specific project
1:05:32 that was originally located on the CSI campus.
1:05:36 At this time, these 6.4 acres were excluded from the PUD amendment and this property remained
1:05:44 under the R4 zoning district regulations.
1:05:48 This is a request to amend the boundaries from the CSI PUD and to rezone the subject property
1:05:54 from R4 to CSI PUD.
1:05:58 The request is not proposing changes to the actual verbiage within the agreement and a
1:06:03 a copy of the PUD agreement was provided in the agenda packet.
1:06:07 The plan is to allow for the expansion of the campus to provide additional educational
1:06:13 facilities.
1:06:14 Upon sub-middle of building permits, a review for required improvements will occur and new
1:06:21 construction will trigger improvements along Lincoln Street, Fillmore Street frontage
1:06:26 and these improvements could include curb, gutter, sidewalk and right-of-way dedication
1:06:32 or construction. The comprehensive plan has designated this area as a CSI and
1:06:38 mixed use and the proposed plan for the property should fit within the
1:06:43 surrounding area and should be compatible with the comprehensive plan.
1:06:47 Per City Code 1014-5, a zoning map amendment, the Commission has to conduct a
1:06:54 public hearing and the Planning and Zoning Commission shall make a
1:06:58 recommendation on that request and forward to City Council. On March 1st, 2022, the Commission
1:07:04 recommended approval of the request as presented with staff recommendations with the addition
1:07:11 of a condition. The condition that was added was that they recommend approval be subject
1:07:19 to the southern property line that borders residential, contains screening upon construction
1:07:25 the building that is equal to or greater than the screening on the east side of the CSI campus.
1:07:31 The commission after conducting a public hearing and forwarding their comments to the council,
1:07:37 the council then hears the recommendation, conducts public hearing, takes public comment,
1:07:44 and deliberates and makes a decision.
1:07:46 The decision can be to approve with conditions, deny, or table for additional information.
1:07:54 So upon conclusion, should the Commission recommend approval of the request as presented, staff
1:08:00 recommends it be following the following.
1:08:02 It be subject to site plan amendments as required by building, engineering, fire, and zoning officials
1:08:07 to comply with the applicable city codes and standards and subject to the southern property
1:08:12 line that borders residential containing screening upon construction of the building that is equal
1:08:18 to or greater than screening on the east side of the CSI campus.
1:08:21 And I will stand for any questions.
1:08:23 Thank you.
1:08:24 Any questions for Kelly and Jason Brown?
1:08:27 Kelly, Lisa, sorry.
1:08:29 Lisa.
1:08:30 Sorry.
1:08:31 It's been a very long week.
1:08:33 Yeah.
1:08:34 Lisa.
1:08:35 So being on CSI's campus or property.
1:08:38 So we'll still have some input on the front edge of Lincoln,
1:08:42 putting in sidewalk, curb and gutter and sidewalk there.
1:08:46 Also, if the extension of Fillmore through, because I know that CSI does do some building permits and things through the state as well.
1:08:58 Is that correct or am I mistaken?
1:09:00 So, for building permit process, the way it works is the state approves the building portion of it, but we have to approve the site.
1:09:10 Okay.
1:09:11 Okay.
1:09:12 Thank you.
1:09:15 Any other questions for Lisa?
1:09:19 Okay, so the applicant is today. Jeff, come on down, Jeff.
1:09:24 Jeff Harmon, College of Southern Idaho, Vice President of Finance and Administration.
1:09:41 Thank you for letting me speak tonight, Mayor Pierce.
1:09:46 And again, I think that Lisa did a really nice job explaining what our proposal is.
1:09:50 What we would like to do is just encompass the existing or the proposed land of the 6.4 acres
1:09:58 and have it fall unto the same regulations and requirements as the existing CSI campus.
1:10:04 So with that, I would like to just stand for questions.
1:10:08 Anybody have any questions for Deb or Lisa before we open up for the public hearing?
1:10:16 Thank you, Deb. Pretty straightforward. Okay, so now is the time for the public hearing.
1:10:26 If you choose to speak, please come down and give your name and address and comments for tonight.
1:10:37 Anybody here that wants to come down?
1:10:46 Okay. Okay. Good. So that closes the public hearing.
1:10:51 I guess there's no additional comments from either staff or Jonathan has something I can tell.
1:10:58 one thing that I have to make clear CSI is a subclinical subdivision of the state, so the city doesn't receive a building permit, but we do review construction plans for public infrastructure.
1:11:09 So we won't see a building, but we do see like a site plan showing a building outline, and then we would see plans for Fillmore and Lincoln as part of our public infrastructure.
1:11:20 That's it. Just want to clarify that one little bit in case people are wondering.
1:11:24 Thank you, so I think I close the public hearing right okay
1:11:28 I'd like hearing his close any further comments from staff
1:11:34 Thank you, Jonathan. Okay City Council witches
1:11:39 Street
1:11:39 I'll make a motion unless somebody else has any other comments
1:11:46 Move that we approve the zoning district changes zoning map amendment for 6.4 acres from our four to see
1:11:52 CSIPUD and to expand the CSIPUD boundaries to include property located on
1:11:59 1100 the 1100 block of Fillmore Street. Thank you Chris. With the addition of
1:12:07 planning and zoning's requirement for fencing. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:12:17 Motion by Christopher Reed second by Craig Hawkins to approve the request for
1:12:21 the zoning district change and zoning map amendment for 6.4 acres from R4 to CSI
1:12:29 PUD etc. Here in row call vote please.
1:12:35 Kockins. Yes. Jason Brown. Yes. Mayor Pierce. Yes. Vice Mayor Reid. Yes.
1:12:47 Nicki Boy. Yes. Thank you. Motion carries five to zero. Thank you everyone that
1:12:57 concludes our city council for tonight.
Download
- Transcript (text) 52 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 68 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 92 KB
- Audio (M4A) 17.3 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 4, 2022. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:13:12.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
a42d7c41b0a73baf77b8630301dcdc6af4695590bafac6e89a87ae9414527ba3 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a bf56687d3da097fed4d9f5f038e2561fa246e5a9e7afef53502c783efa9305e1 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
60f036245bf96f19d74c74f1024caef0669027875476841be0e415faaf1d6db6
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file