OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, November 8, 2021

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:00:00 22 to truck Bartley to bring this request to us.

0:00:10 Good evening.

0:00:11 Good evening.

0:00:14 Mayor Hawkins, library liaison, councilman Reed, rest of the council.

0:00:19 Thank you.

0:00:20 It is a pleasure to be here tonight to be able to introduce Lindsay Burles, the Twin Falls

0:00:26 Library Board recommendation for a new trustee.

0:00:30 Before I give it over to Lindsay, I just want to give a little bit about the process and

0:00:35 why she is standing where she is today.

0:00:37 So, the Library Board is a five-member board.

0:00:42 Each member serves a five-year term.

0:00:46 Monica DeAngelo is our current board chair, and she is ending her final year.

0:00:52 In December, she will be done.

0:00:54 So, in August, we opened up, put a call out to citizens here in the community of Twin Falls.

0:01:04 they actually have to reside here in Twin Falls and Lindsey took that call and

0:01:08 she wrote us a letter of interest and then we had the opportunity to sit down

0:01:12 and talk with her and find out why she wanted to be a library trustee and so again

0:01:19 like I said I'm happy to say that the board put forth the recommendation to

0:01:24 you tonight to have Lindsey and girls as our library trustee in your packet you

0:01:30 should have the letter that she submitted but one of the things that I'm

0:01:33 most excited about is that Lindsay is a library user and I can say that when I

0:01:39 even shared with my staff that Lindsay was an applicant that the board was

0:01:45 putting forward they were very happy as well because they don't hurt she's at the

0:01:50 library and she already is familiar with what it is that we do so with that if

0:01:57 you don't have any questions for me I will hand it over to Lindsay thank you so

0:02:04 much I'm really excited about this opportunity and I don't have you have

0:02:09 my letter in front of you I think so that's a lot about me about my family

0:02:13 my is here we use the library we're there twice a week so I'm excited to

0:02:20 serve the library and I don't if you have any questions I'd be happy to answer them.

0:02:23 Great are there any questions for Lindsay? Before we take a motion I just want to

0:02:29 say thank you it takes citizens to fill positions all over the city to make the

0:02:33 City continue to be such a great and wonderful place to live.

0:02:37 And so thank you for taking the time.

0:02:39 I know it's nerve-wracking sometimes

0:02:41 to put your name out there and be considered.

0:02:43 But we do.

0:02:44 We really appreciate it.

0:02:45 So thank you.

0:02:46 I'm happy I'm excited to serve.

0:02:47 Thank you.

0:02:49 So with that, I will stand for a motion.

0:02:52 Mr. Fareed.

0:02:56 Before making the motion, I just wanted

0:02:58 to say how grateful I am for Lindsey

0:03:00 had an opportunity to sit on that meeting,

0:03:03 sit in on that meeting.

0:03:04 I had some really good candidates and I was excited to have Lindsey there learn a little bit more about her, I think she's not really of that wasn't me, right?

0:03:18 So with that I move that we approve Lindsey Earl to serve as a library trustee for a full term of office from January 2022, June, 2000, 27.

0:03:29 We have a motion from Christopher Reed, seconded by Sean Berriger to approve the recommendation to have Lindsey Earl serve as a library trustee.

0:03:42 Amy, roll call vote please.

0:03:44 Ruth Pierce?

0:03:48 Yes.

0:03:49 Mr. Fareed?

0:03:50 Yes.

0:03:51 Great Hawkins?

0:03:52 Yes.

0:03:53 John Bericher?

0:03:54 Yes.

0:03:55 And Suzanne Hawkins?

0:03:56 Yes.

0:03:57 Motion passes 5-0 and welcome to the family of the City of Flint Falls.

0:04:00 Thank you, Tara.

0:04:02 Next on our agenda is a quest to accept a public right of way and we have Josh Bair, our city engineer.

0:04:16 Good evening, Josh.

0:04:21 It's pretty rare to come forward with the request of this nice, pretty excited

0:04:27 present to you. I was excited to read this one. I wish Greg was here because

0:04:33 he's the one who really wanted to see this one. So there this is I'm showing you

0:04:40 an exhibit. This exhibit is near the intersection of Washington Street

0:04:48 North and Federation Road and so the request is to accept right-of-way from

0:04:55 this property owner here, Steve McMullen, and the intent is to accept right away to give

0:05:02 us some contiguous detached sidewalk from this location here all the way across his property

0:05:09 to the development that's occurring in that southwest corner of that intersection.

0:05:14 The developer of developers engineers worked with him and he's willing to do it.

0:05:18 The developer of this property will also be constructing all of those improvements to

0:05:24 sidewalk curb gutter as well as a patch back landscaping so all we have to

0:05:28 accept the right away and it's gonna be a beautiful night I'm not only best for

0:05:33 the citizens that will occur if that happens so I can I can stand for any

0:05:38 questions you might have on this request.

0:05:43 Are there any questions for Josh on this issue this evening?

0:05:49 and this is with this there's a discussion about a crosswalk I know this is not

0:05:56 specifically, have those plans come forward.

0:05:59 So there's a preliminary plan that's

0:06:01 going to prove for this project.

0:06:03 The crosswalk was shown at the intersection,

0:06:05 with a note on it that said, crosswalk

0:06:07 to be turned to the final location.

0:06:09 We're still waiting for construction plans,

0:06:10 and the final plan to be approved, so not yet.

0:06:12 But yes, we are with this specifically, but also,

0:06:16 this is that same development, same area.

0:06:18 Correct, and accept the.

0:06:34 Second, we have a motion from Sean Beriger,

0:06:37 seconded by Ruth Pierce to accept the public right of way as it was presented

0:06:43 this evening. Amy Roll, call vote. Yes. Craig Hawkins. Yes.

0:06:50 He's Ann Hawkins. Yes. Yes. motion passes by Deziro.

0:06:55 Thank you very much. If you're in communication with the property owner

0:07:00 would you please pass along our thanks for being willing to help us with this

0:07:04 Well done, thank you.

0:07:06 Thank you.

0:07:07 And I would say as well with the developer.

0:07:09 The developer.

0:07:10 Yes.

0:07:11 The neighbor.

0:07:14 Absolutely.

0:07:15 All right.

0:07:16 Next this evening we have a request to approve ordinance repealing for the Twin Falls City Code Section 6-2-1B, which regulates concealed weapons.

0:07:31 And we have our city attorney.

0:07:33 Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of the council.

0:07:36 This is just kind of a, it is.

0:07:40 I just need to thank the microphone up, thank you.

0:07:43 This is to clean up our current city ordinance back in 2016.

0:07:48 The state legislature passed a concealed carry.

0:07:52 All citizens at that time, those 21, they've since loaded to 18.

0:07:56 But in essence, this law just needs to be cleaned off

0:07:59 of our books because the state law has changed

0:08:01 and that pre-amps city law, any questions?

0:08:10 I don't see any questions in, I'm not sure what brought this back to the forefront, but thank you for catching it.

0:08:16 I have to give some credit to our police chief who reminded me that we needed to clean it up.

0:08:20 Well, okay. We know it's a team sport around here, so that's great.

0:08:27 So I would stand for a motion if there's no questions.

0:08:30 Do we need an ordinance number to redo it?

0:08:35 We do, and I believe we're at 018.

0:08:37 Oh, yes it is. It's on this paper.

0:08:43 It's Ordinance 2021-018.

0:08:47 So I'm assuming we need to put this in third and final

0:08:49 by title only then, that's correct, okay?

0:08:56 Suspend the rules in place, ordinance number 2021-018.

0:09:02 I'm third and final reading.

0:09:04 Second.

0:09:05 We have a motion from Sean Barrigar,

0:09:07 seconded by Craig Hawkins,

0:09:09 to suspend the rules and place ordinance 2021-018

0:09:14 on third and final by title only.

0:09:17 We'll call vote please.

0:09:19 Craig Hawkins.

0:09:22 Yes.

0:09:23 Don Maricar.

0:09:24 Yes.

0:09:25 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:09:26 Yes.

0:09:27 Ruth Pierce.

0:09:28 Yes.

0:09:29 Christopher Reed.

0:09:30 Yes.

0:09:31 Oceans passes five to zero.

0:09:32 I will read the title.

0:09:33 Ordinance 2021-018.

0:09:35 An ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho.

0:09:40 Repealing city Twin Falls city code.

0:09:43 Six dash two dash one B.

0:09:46 Be it ordained by the Mary Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho.

0:09:51 Ruth Pierce.

0:09:53 Yes, Mayor.

0:09:54 I move we approve the ordinance repealing Twin Falls City Code Section 6-2-1-B, which

0:10:03 regulates concealed weapons.

0:10:05 We have a motion from Ruth Pierce, seconded by Sean Berriger, to adopt Ordinance 2021-01-8.

0:10:15 Amy Roll, call the please.

0:10:18 on America. Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Mr. Fareed. Yes, and Craig Hawkins. Yes, Ocean Pass says

0:10:27 five to zero. The next item is also being presented by our city attorney and it is a

0:10:36 request to authorize the mayor to sign the opioid litigation settlement agreement. Thank

0:10:45 you again, Madam Mayor, members of the council. In 2019, the city passed resolution 2019-008,

0:10:53 which authorized the mayor to sign an agreement with the law firm, Special Counsel, to work

0:11:01 for our interests as it relates to the opioid crisis. They have been in negotiation since

0:11:06 that point. This particular agreement has come as the result of the state of Idaho. I'm

0:11:13 working with municipalities. I will note that what's interesting about this particular

0:11:19 proposal, should we choose to agree, that doesn't mean that everything is done.

0:11:24 In essence, the three major defendants in the case have agreed that if I believe

0:11:31 about 60%, maybe a little less depending on the numbers of population, if they

0:11:35 agree to this settlement, then it will move forward. And so, though we may be

0:11:43 one of the first to sign on and say we're comfortable with this agreement, it may

0:11:47 still has some work to be done with other municipalities.

0:11:50 The benefit to the city as we spoke with our council is that the terms are very favorable

0:11:59 for the cities as compared to what would be a default settlement that was approved.

0:12:04 In this particular case, I know the state of Idaho has agreed that 40% of the money recovered

0:12:09 would go directly to the municipality, which is different than I believe 15%, which is

0:12:16 the default that would otherwise be the amount that would come.

0:12:21 I believe this is a great opportunity.

0:12:23 I know different chiefs of police have been reaching out already

0:12:26 to our chief of police saying, you know, what are we going to do?

0:12:29 How are we going to address the issue?

0:12:31 And I reminded them then, we just need to take this first step.

0:12:34 I believe this is a very good step forward.

0:12:37 Our legal counsel has also advised that this is very favorable

0:12:42 in terms of allowing us to control where those dollars are spent

0:12:46 and a higher percentage of those dollars that are going to come back into our community.

0:12:50 Are there any questions?

0:12:56 Great questions.

0:12:57 She had a question for you.

0:13:01 I think this is a good idea and I'm in favor of it.

0:13:04 My question is, is this this come to fruition?

0:13:07 Who's can administer all of this?

0:13:09 It seems like it is so broad and there are so many working, moving parts to it.

0:13:15 It seems like it could be difficult to absolutely answer a great question.

0:13:23 question that that's still being worked out in terms of who's going to regulate

0:13:30 how the dollars are spent and that's the real question. The reason this

0:13:34 agreement is favorable and why I have an advice that we agreed to is again that

0:13:38 those dollars we can look back and see how much did we spend on our can or

0:13:43 drugs the drugs our officers use to help an individual who has overdosed or other

0:13:48 expenses. The agreement does have certain criteria of what things the dollars

0:13:56 can be spent to work? I did ask that question when we were speaking with the

0:14:00 Leopats, who in essence is going to oversee that or do we have to confirm

0:14:05 that with them? They also didn't have the answer at that point. I will note that

0:14:10 the default settlement agreement talked about establishing a board

0:14:16 kind of govern the spending and that would ultimately be controlled by the

0:14:21 state of Idaho. Again, the reason why I think us agreeing to this specific

0:14:26 settlement would allow us as a city to work with council and work with our staff and our

0:14:32 public safety, you know, to really target where we really have felt the pinch of...

0:14:38 Ruth Pierce. Jane, remind me this settlement is, that the, that would be received is after

0:14:51 the lawyer's cut, correct? Of course. And what percentage was that? Refresh my memory.

0:15:01 Do you remember I don't recall those 33 or 40% I can go back and get that but it will be greater than a third

0:15:11 Right towards attorney fees and costs

0:15:16 Okay, thank you

0:15:20 And also looking at the fact sheet that you sent this is paid out over 18 years I will say yes

0:15:27 But I know in communications that again

0:15:31 There's some movement that could happen with how this actually go forward

0:15:36 They're just trying to get greater than the majority of municipalities to sign on so that they can feel comfortable.

0:15:43 Obviously the defendants want to say we're not going to be sued by anyone else to really start getting nuts and bolts of how it's going to move forward.

0:15:51 Okay, just looking at it, looking at the calculations that they put out $48 million more municipalities, we are at 1.8%, $875,000 or 18 years.

0:16:06 It's helpful bringing somebody on and trying to do all that kind of stuff in a

0:16:13 board to do a lot of work that I'm in favor of this. I don't think we need more

0:16:23 much for what can occur with that those that I've been speaking with the county

0:16:34 level as well as the city of that.

0:16:41 So I do think that I appreciate the great partnerships that we have with the

0:16:50 state on many many projects. I do think that the advantage of being able to

0:16:55 received these funds directly to save bureaucracy and how did this happen to

0:17:10 already dealt with able to sign on early and hopefully can be first started

0:17:28 looking at this it was pretty overwhelming and to realize how much work and how far

0:17:32 you've come on it is very impressive and such a short amount of time. Thank you.

0:17:37 I said that the City of Toronto has authorized the mayor to sign the opioid litigation settlement agreement as presented.

0:17:51 Second.

0:17:53 Have a motion from Sean Berger.

0:17:55 Seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the request

0:17:59 to authorize the mayor to sign the opioid litigation

0:18:03 settlement agreement.

0:18:06 Amy Roll call vote please.

0:18:09 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:18:10 Yes.

0:18:11 Ruth Pierce.

0:18:12 Yes.

0:18:12 Mr. Fareed.

0:18:13 Yes.

0:18:13 Ray Hawkins.

0:18:14 Yes.

0:18:14 And Sean Berger.

0:18:15 Yes.

0:18:16 Motion passes 5 to 0.

0:18:18 Thank you, Shane.

0:18:19 Thank you.

0:18:22 Next on our agenda is a presentation

0:18:25 of the finances of the City of Twin Falls.

0:18:27 And on our agenda, it did have a misprint of third quarter.

0:18:30 We will be hearing our fourth quarter

0:18:33 of the fiscal year 2021 this evening.

0:18:37 And we have Brian Howard, our CFO this evening.

0:18:40 Good evening.

0:18:42 Good evening, and council, I send my appreciation

0:18:57 to my two biggest fans so far, Ruth Pearson,

0:19:00 Gretchen, who has already told me

0:19:02 that they're excited for this presentation.

0:19:04 I appreciate the support.

0:19:09 Hey, so tonight we're gonna review

0:19:10 the City's fourth-order finances,

0:19:12 and I'm gonna start with the broad picture,

0:19:14 dive into the tax-supported funds,

0:19:15 some of the major, major funds inside of there,

0:19:18 the revenue sources,

0:19:20 and then we're gonna talk about enterprise

0:19:21 and some of our national comparisons.

0:19:26 One thing, well, a couple things I wanna note

0:19:28 is this one's a fun one,

0:19:29 because we get to see where, well, this one's fun,

0:19:34 because we get to see where we ended up.

0:19:35 How did we do throughout the year?

0:19:37 where do we measure up? Plus, I wanted to bring out to your attention that for the last three

0:19:43 quarters I have been presenting on the adopted budget of 77 million. We are now, this for the most

0:19:50 part, I'll have a couple of slides that are going to show the differences between the two,

0:19:54 but for the most part, most of this presentation is going to be on our amended budget. Our amended

0:19:59 budget, if you remember, takes into account these few items here, the $6.4 million water bond paid

0:20:05 off $4.5 million in federal grants that we have received. We had $1.2 million ladder truck payoff,

0:20:13 a $1 million land purchase for fire station, $1 million COVID money, and an additional $600,000

0:20:20 in central square. Those are the biggest pieces that take into account going from $77 to $94 million.

0:20:29 This first slide, if you'll remember, shows our total budget. This is the amended budget,

0:20:34 If you look to the next slide, this one to compare, that was what we would have at the

0:20:41 adopted budget versus the amended budget that we're showing here.

0:20:45 So our total budget at 94 million, 45% is non-tax-supported funds, that's their enterprise funds like water, wastewater, and sanitation.

0:20:55 55% is our tax-supported funds, which is majorly made up of property taxes.

0:21:01 You can see the major fund composition on the side of all accounts.

0:21:05 The biggest one is general at 33%, and then we've got water at 20%.

0:21:10 Look to the next slide, you can see the difference here.

0:21:14 Water obviously goes from a 17% piece to 20% because of our debt payoff.

0:21:23 These next two slides are going to be the only other ones that I compare to prior so I don't

0:21:27 confuse you too much.

0:21:29 So the largest contributing revenue sources is $51,477 in combination.

0:21:35 If you look at the top six, it makes up 87% of our revenue sources.

0:21:45 Property taxes are $23,000,000.

0:21:48 Reserves $7,000,000.

0:21:49 So the biggest difference between this slide and what I present in the past is reserves.

0:21:53 We used a lot of money to pay off our debt, pay off the ladder check, etc., that we just

0:21:57 talked about.

0:21:58 That's the second highest.

0:21:59 Our state shared revenue is $4.8 million, and we have transfers of $3.9 million, dedicated

0:22:05 straight to $3 million, in franchise fees of $1.7, those all total $51,477.

0:22:13 The fund composition on the left is how we allocate those tax-supported funds.

0:22:18 Most of the general fund is PD and fire at 60%.

0:22:21 We've got three as the second largest at 17%.

0:22:25 Yes, the other at 13% large, can you address that for me?

0:22:32 The other is me, Julie, permits and airport revenues.

0:22:35 We've received a lot in airport revenue from the federal grants that we've received, and

0:22:40 that's the bigger difference from the other on the second slide.

0:22:44 And the bigger difference between this one and the next one is the reserves jump from

0:22:52 the 3.5 million to the 7 million, but numbers remain relatively stable.

0:22:58 1664 is not a huge difference.

0:23:06 Next slide talks about our property tax history.

0:23:09 You can see from 2018, the difference is the increases that we've received over the years

0:23:15 with the biggest difference in 2021.

0:23:20 Is it from the CARES funding?

0:23:21 If you remember Governor Little's plan for divving out COVID CARES grant money, only three

0:23:28 cities popped it into it.

0:23:30 Kimberly, you'll want to win falls. And so that means $5.2 million of our property tax revenue

0:23:36 wasn't really property taxes. It was actually come from the government. But in total, if we had not

0:23:42 opted in, our total revenue from property taxes would have been $24 million. And that's just a

0:23:48 function of how much we receive each year. Do we take the 3% increase? Do we take any reserves

0:23:53 in what our annexation growth is? So our total this year is $24 million. I talked with Becky

0:23:59 Peterson at Twin Falls County Treasurer and she said our collections are at 98.6%

0:24:04 as opposed to last year's 98.5%. This is interesting to know and significant in

0:24:11 the reason why I know has been doing so well in the nation because we have

0:24:15 relatively stable funding that comes in. It's not really subject to a buying market

0:24:20 etc. Most of this is coming from property tax dollars which as we've seen as

0:24:24 significant increase in the last few years. Next slide talks about some of our other

0:24:34 major revenue sources, major is in their bigger, but not as big or even close to as

0:24:38 big as the property taxes. Our franchise fees to make up three percent of our total

0:24:44 revenue tax-supported funds. The next slide shows a little bit more detail on our

0:24:48 tax-supported funds. The state-shared revenue includes state-sharing from

0:24:55 sales tax and liquor apportionment. So last year, if you'll remember the

0:24:59 state legislature changed their formula for calculating the distribution that

0:25:03 that comes to us and they've kept the distributions

0:25:05 that have 1% increase year over year.

0:25:08 So this is the last year that we're gonna see

0:25:10 somewhat of a fluctuation in state shared revenues.

0:25:13 For the most part, we'll probably anticipate budgeting

0:25:16 revenue, state shared revenue at 100%,

0:25:19 possibly with that 1% increase,

0:25:21 depending on how much more.

0:25:23 I mean, we don't know how much more people are to spend

0:25:25 this last year has been crazy,

0:25:27 but anticipating the future that'll be relatively stable.

0:25:30 One thing to note is we actually have liquor

0:25:32 We had $200,000 in more revenue from our liquor apportionment this last year, so I think a lot of other things we budgeted less, and nobody saw some of this highway money, some of the liquor money is extra money coming in.

0:25:53 Highway revenue is one that will potentially could fluctuate.

0:25:57 It is ahead of our three-year average,

0:25:59 which is one of the resume sources that can be impacted

0:26:02 by the current environment.

0:26:03 We received a one-pime payment from the stage for 563,000,

0:26:08 but additionally, this money comes

0:26:09 from vehicle registration fees, state fuels taxes,

0:26:12 and other transportation related fees,

0:26:14 such as fines and forfeitures.

0:26:16 If people are traveling, they're considering more fuel.

0:26:23 The next slide is our franchise fees.

0:26:25 This is over the three-year comparison.

0:26:28 These franchise fees are the ramps

0:26:29 that we received from a utility company for the city to pay for its right of waste.

0:26:34 Gas has been relatively consistent except for the high in 2018 because we had record cold temperatures daily.

0:26:42 This year is the opposite. We've had record high heat temperatures so electric is higher because of our hot summer.

0:26:50 I've heard that this coming winter is going to be the same, not a lot of snow, but does anybody really know?

0:26:56 So our budget to actual expenditures, this is a couple of interesting comments on this

0:27:04 one.

0:27:05 So the 27 million that we had budgeted for personnel, we've come in at 98.6%, that seems

0:27:13 relatively close but one thing that's hidden behind these numbers is we budget for so

0:27:17 many five weeks in a year, you get that extra paycheck, we actually had one extra one.

0:27:25 So take into account the one extra actual expenditure that we paid for an extra fifth

0:27:30 week and then put it up against what we had budgeted for.

0:27:33 We're significantly lower in our personnel expenses and I've got a couple of slides later

0:27:38 on that shows some of the struggle that we have with our personnel.

0:27:42 But even though it says 98.6%, we are having some struggles with hiring and keeping people

0:27:48 and maintaining.

0:27:50 M&O is actually pretty consistent and pretty good.

0:27:54 90% of it you can't really ask for much better than that.

0:27:57 We do have some lag times in supply that water, for instance,

0:28:01 is significantly experiencing.

0:28:02 In fact, capital improvements, we have had some struggles there.

0:28:07 We have had some significant starts that haven't happened.

0:28:10 The biggest portion of the capital improvement fund here

0:28:13 is Hankins Road and Seal Coding, that is around $6.7 million,

0:28:17 that hasn't been started.

0:28:19 I'm sure you've talked to Travis and a couple of conversations.

0:28:21 I know we have management wise that you just can't get stuff.

0:28:25 You can't get supplies.

0:28:26 You can't get things to start.

0:28:28 Some things are booked out a couple of years,

0:28:30 so we're sensing and feeling some of the struggles.

0:28:34 One thing I did want to know too, I forgot to mention a couple of slides ago.

0:28:37 Even though these are the actual numbers that we have,

0:28:41 we still have there still going to be a little bit of a difference

0:28:43 between these numbers and what's audited,

0:28:46 Because most different from this order than prior quarters is that we still have accounts payable and voices that come in, that we have to match with whichever quarter.

0:28:56 So prior quarters doesn't matter as much because there's no close off, whereas we will have a little bit of a difference.

0:29:02 So far we haven't seen a huge difference, but there's one of which of capital improvement fund, I think we've seen 200,000 in airport that's not included, these numbers, and that will continue to change.

0:29:12 So far I don't see this being material.

0:29:17 permits this was the fun one we did great 190 percent almost 200 percent it was actually a

0:29:25 level off though we had anticipated having the first if you remember the first two quarters talking

0:29:30 about this is crazy it's going off the charts and it still is we're still having a significantly

0:29:35 higher amount of permits coming through and our revenues is a lot more it's just a little bit

0:29:40 less than what we had possibly thought the first couple quarters of the year so if you

0:29:46 you remember I'll keep reiterating this because this budget is old as before

0:29:51 covid we all revenue we estimated down because to be able to have a conservative

0:29:55 conservative budget you don't want to estimate high because your expenses

0:30:00 match your revenue and if you expend more than your revenue comes in then you

0:30:04 don't have fun so we did estimate conservatively before covid but even

0:30:11 still is a pretty good year at 2.1 million. This is updated, if you remember I

0:30:17 presented this last time updated for the close of this fiscal year at 1.8 million.

0:30:22 I wanted to show some of the leveling off that I was talking about. So last

0:30:29 year, so we like to look at the single family permits because that's

0:30:34 indicative of our residential increases, you know what people are building. Last

0:30:39 Last year we had 573 single-family permits and this year we had 486 so you can see we didn't

0:30:46 match what we had last year as far as permits goes.

0:30:49 The reason why it's more money is because those are based off of value and we all know that

0:30:54 the value of our housing is crazy here.

0:30:59 Just to put it in comparison in 2007 we had 641 permits.

0:31:03 You can kind of see that the difference is we still had a record here but as far as permits

0:31:09 This go is not quite as high as what we possibly thought.

0:31:12 I'm going to jump into some fun national comparisons and then back to the enterprise funds.

0:31:20 Is there any questions so far on tax supported funds?

0:31:27 Okay.

0:31:28 This is one of my favorite parts.

0:31:30 I love seeing how we compare.

0:31:32 How does it match up?

0:31:33 What are we seeing?

0:31:34 I like to read.

0:31:35 I like to figure out, you know, how do things look compared to what we're at today?

0:31:40 So in my mind, after what I've read and what I've been watching, what I've seen, the city

0:31:44 of Twin Falls.

0:31:45 big basic things that I have at the top of all news housing crisis labor shortage

0:31:51 supply shortage inflation US economy see a lot of you shaking your heads because

0:31:55 those are things that we are hearing about constantly so I summarized a couple of

0:31:59 different data points from a lot of these different topics to show that what we're

0:32:04 seeing in the city of Twin Falls and even have a graph or a couple PowerPoint slides

0:32:08 on what we're seeing here in our labor market but to show that what we're seeing

0:32:13 nationwide is what we're seeing here. The first few slides are on the housing crisis.

0:32:20 This chart shows, I like to, it shows there's black as home builders confidence and then the red is home buyers confidence.

0:32:31 So, and this is a report to an economic stand snapshot from Piper Sandler. It's intriguing that home builders have such a high expectation of the future.

0:32:42 And what's going on at home builders are so much lower. I compiled a couple of different stats from this report.

0:32:48 And this report was through September and it had said through mid-August, we lumber prices

0:32:53 were actually 67% higher to that it jumped to $760 per 1,000 feet.

0:33:00 I don't know what it is right now.

0:33:01 I'm sure Jonathan could probably come in at some point.

0:33:05 But I know it's still high, but I think it's lower than what it is now.

0:33:09 What was interesting though is it was at an all-time high of $1,711 and that was just

0:33:15 in May.

0:33:16 but was intrigued at the difference between what we are now.

0:33:20 So it's going down, but the question is,

0:33:22 is how much interesting to note in this article,

0:33:25 home buyer optimism that they have quantified

0:33:28 is a lowest that has been in 40 years.

0:33:34 So another one from Piper Sandler,

0:33:36 there was a quote saying pending home sales declined

0:33:39 for the second straight month in July

0:33:41 as surging prices may be weighing on home buyer's enthusiasm.

0:33:45 Market may be starting to cool slightly,

0:33:47 that at the moment, there's not enough supply

0:33:49 to match the demand.

0:33:51 I thought it was interesting to see from June 19,

0:33:54 where pending home sales went.

0:33:56 You can see November, December of 2020,

0:33:59 and then how it's dropped off, since then.

0:34:05 Here's a fortune article.

0:34:07 I would almost venture to guess some of you have read this.

0:34:10 It was talked about quite extensively, interestingly enough.

0:34:14 One of the things I wanted to bring out

0:34:16 is this chart on the right.

0:34:19 The 10 most, I'll say quote, overvalued markets because, I mean, they have their own data,

0:34:24 I'm sure they get the other sources, they have their calculations, but what's interesting

0:34:28 to know is Boise, Idaho is valued at 80% above what they say market value is.

0:34:35 I know that's Boise, it's not twin, but we really go in line with some of the Boise prices,

0:34:40 just not quite as much as Boise, and just look in relation to where we're at, who we're

0:34:45 Austin, Ogden, Provo, Detroit, Spokane, Salt Lake, Phoenix, Las Vegas, and Stockton.

0:34:51 I mean, we're up there highest in the nation for our home market.

0:34:56 This article said they say everything's bigger in Texas, but when it comes to overvalued homes,

0:35:00 the Lomestar state doesn't hold a candle to Idaho.

0:35:04 There's also in this same article, it says in Virginia Beach, homes are selling for a 2.46% discount,

0:35:11 and you can get home in Honolulu at a rate nearly 5% where it should be valued.

0:35:15 So if you like to purchase real estate and you want to know where to buy on the lulu might be here retirement home

0:35:21 I also have a quote here from Robert Kiyazaki. He's one of my I love reading his books rich dad or dad etc

0:35:28 And it's kind of fun to follow and see what he says, but there's he isn't there's article where he's quoted saying biggest crash and tweeted

0:35:35 Actually, so it's not quite total sentences biggest crash in world history coming protect yourself now and encouraging people to buy gold and silver

0:35:43 He was quoting, tweeting, China's Evergrande group cannot pay evaluation of properties fake will real estate crash spread to us. He says, yes, I'm not saying well my gold and silver. In fact, I don't own gold and silver. But I think it's interesting. Some of it builds their platform on real estate is saying run something's going to happen.

0:36:01 So it'll be interesting to see who has cash and what happens in which state's home. Hopefully ours does. The housing market's way too high.

0:36:09 So this is an Idaho Capitalist Sun's article regarding the population change from the two

0:36:16 sentences, 2010 to 2020.

0:36:20 Idaho added 271,000 people.

0:36:23 This shows the counties, this graph is kind of neat, it actually shows in pink the lowest

0:36:29 increase change if negative, and then in green the darker green is the highest population

0:36:35 change.

0:36:36 median.

0:36:37 The median is the median.

0:36:38 The median is the median.

0:36:39 The median is the median.

0:36:40 The median is the median.

0:36:41 The median is the median.

0:36:42 The median is the median.

0:36:43 The median is the median.

0:36:44 The median is the median.

0:36:45 The median is the median.

0:36:46 The median is the median.

0:36:47 The median is the median.

0:36:48 The median is the median.

0:36:49 The median is the median.

0:36:50 The median is the median.

0:36:51 The median is the median.

0:36:52 The median is the median.

0:36:53 The median is the median.

0:36:55 The median is the median.

0:36:56 The median is the median.

0:36:57 The median is the median.

0:36:58 The median is the median.

0:36:59 The median is the median.

0:37:00 The median is the median.

0:37:01 The median is the median.

0:37:02 The median is the median.

0:37:03 The median is the median.

0:37:04 The median is the median.

0:37:05 economist with the Idaho Department of Labor. Labor shortage. And it goes hand in hand. This is from the Washington Post in October, geography of the Great Resignation.

0:37:20 You'll see green is the lowest changes in population and the dark blue is the highest. I know it's actually referenced in this Washington Post article as the third highest in the nation, Kentucky and Georgia are 4.5% and I know that 4.2%

0:37:36 lowest or Washington, New York, Connecticut, and Pennsylvania at around 2%.

0:37:41 They said in this article it was notable that more rural states have the highest

0:37:46 quick rates. That may be a sign there's more competition in those parts of the

0:37:49 country than other parts. There's another article by a CFO magazine that says owners

0:37:54 are clearly trying to hire but are not being very successful despite paying higher

0:37:58 wages. As a result of the earnings erosion, 53% of small businesses reported a

0:38:03 higher average selling prices than three months ago and at 46% planned price hikes in the next

0:38:09 three months. This is an article from the Bureau of Labor Statistics talks about the job openings

0:38:19 and labor turnover. It's another four million workers quit is what the article is titled.

0:38:24 It's a record breaking for the fifth month in a row for people quitting. Highest levels since

0:38:30 data tracking in 2000 so it could be longer but for the last 20 years this is the highest

0:38:36 job openings and labor turnover that we've pretty much ever seen. So if you can extrapolate

0:38:42 this and says this means nearly 3% of the US workforce quit in August. A separate Twin Falls

0:38:49 article in August reported a search on the job website and D showed 139 job openings for

0:38:55 just restaurant positions in Twin Falls. I don't know how many restaurants we have in Twin Falls,

0:39:01 But I'm pretty sure it's not 139 which possibly based on the signs that I showed last time could mean every

0:39:08 Restaurant in Twin Falls is hiring

0:39:12 Do you know what they say with if that's quit or retired or is it a company?

0:39:17 It's a district whatever jobs quit so it could be a combination. I did actually read an article talking about

0:39:24 I don't know if you follow Adam Grant. I like his podcast. He's some good information

0:39:28 He talks about this isn't a new thing

0:39:29 what happened is you had ten years of people that should have, would have, could have quit,

0:39:34 could have retired, etc.

0:39:36 They didn't because the job market was great, the labor market was awesome, you know, things

0:39:40 were going phenomenal.

0:39:41 And then this crash happened and people just decided to pull out whether it is retirement

0:39:45 or quitting or staying at home or living with parents.

0:39:48 It's a, it's accumulation.

0:39:49 I know my studies show that a lot of the baby boomers decided that this one does not, this

0:40:00 one does not separate, it just shows based off the data.

0:40:03 So you twin falls. So these are calendar year not fiscal year. It's through October. So we have two months left

0:40:14 Applications are probably relatively similar similar about

0:40:18 1,091 year date 1430 in 2020 remember it is all of 2020 all of 21 so we still aren't going to have more job

0:40:25 Oblocations what's interesting is our job postings? So here to date we have 74 job posting as opposed to last year's 62 and 77

0:40:34 So we are posting a whole lot more, I've got a couple of quotes from our wonderful HR department, especially since we're sitting right here.

0:40:43 Kristin, chef, actually told me, candidate responses are down as well as several are not responding to requests to complete testing or to schedule interviews.

0:40:51 There are more repeated postings this year compared to the last two.

0:40:54 So I've heard Gretchen mention multiple times in meetings, we effectively turn over 10% of our workforce.

0:41:00 This year we're probably on track to turn over 20% that would be retirement plus job postings, etc

0:41:07 So there's a couple articles one and twin false quoting jakers general manager Jasmine Smith said jakers bar and girl is offering up to

0:41:14 $16 an hour and you hire them and they never come back or they are here for a day and are like nope

0:41:19 Don't want to do this scooters manager Jamie Carlton was quoted saying we get people that are coming in or say that they are coming in

0:41:27 for an interview and they don't show up. I don't know if that has to do with the unemployment

0:41:30 and they have to show up to so many interviews, but I would say if I have 10 interviews in

0:41:34 a week, I will have maybe one show up for that interview.

0:41:40 On the flip side, this was kind of fun because I was all excited sharing some of this information

0:41:44 with me. So out of state applications is off the charts and I know we've received in state

0:41:50 at 817. If we received 174 out of state applications, that's effectively 18% or outside

0:41:57 If I'd hope that would be kind of fun to compile where we're seeing him from, Washington, California, Utah, Oregon, there's a myriad of other states. She gave me a huge list of them. But out of country, we actually received one from Canada and two from India, people like I know.

0:42:13 She also said that we are seeing more applications in the public works and police department from out of state.

0:42:23 The Apply Shortage.

0:42:28 This is an article from Piper Sandler, Disruptions from COVID-19, primarily in Southeast Asia, continue to have an impact on many industry sectors.

0:42:36 Congestion at ports in China and the U.S. continues to be a headwind as transportation networks remain stressed.

0:42:42 Average wait times for container ships in the Port of LA have increased to eight and a half days while the normal wait time is between zero and one.

0:42:49 There's a separate report from the Commerce Department in August that showed the U.S. trade deficits surged to a record high in June as efforts by businesses to rebuild inventories to meet robust consumer spending drew in more imports.

0:43:02 inflation on numbers. So there's a financial planning article says consumer

0:43:14 prices spiked 5.4% in the 12 months through last September. The highest rate in 13

0:43:19 years according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The federal reserves annual

0:43:24 target is 2%. We're well above what we are targeting. Another interesting

0:43:30 written article is Social Security recipient. They have she received a

0:43:33 of 5.9% ads unheard of, the highest cost of living adjustment in 39 years. MCI, we like

0:43:40 to talk about MCI because that's what we focus on, that's what we purchase, 10.8%. I started

0:43:47 going back to a report I'd compiled to see what the highest has been and I couldn't find

0:43:53 at least in the last 10 years. The highest I had seen was 5.2% in 2011. MCI is not touched

0:44:00 the 10.8 percent.

0:44:03 CPI is at 5.35 percent.

0:44:05 The PPI, producer price or index

0:44:09 is charged by domestic producers to suppliers and

0:44:13 retailers. An article by the Hill said roughly 75

0:44:17 percent of July's monthly PPI increase came from rising prices

0:44:21 for services. The Labor Department said, but much of that rise was driven by the automobile

0:44:25 sector and auto retailers, which have been slammed by crucial part

0:44:29 or to just, we're seeing that in the City of Twin Falls.

0:44:31 We can't buy big equipment.

0:44:33 We can't buy vehicles.

0:44:34 We're actually at a meeting just a couple of weeks ago

0:44:37 talking about if you want something,

0:44:39 you have to put in a request for it.

0:44:43 They won't guarantee the price

0:44:44 because they're gonna say you can get it

0:44:46 in the end of 2022, possibly 23,

0:44:49 which means you have a whole new model

0:44:51 that you're purchasing.

0:44:52 And so you just don't know that it is crazy.

0:44:56 And when you look at these numbers

0:44:58 compared to what our workforce is seeing, what we're paying for, what we have is astronomical,

0:45:03 it's filtering down nationwide to the city of Twin Falls. This is a fun one, nothing to do with,

0:45:12 I guess the city of Twin Falls, but I'm just curious. So this is a article with Business Insider,

0:45:20 it says, I got a quote here, says, experts have largely agreed that the pandemic era market was

0:45:25 crucially different. The late 2000s frenzy was powered by dubious lending practices and rampant

0:45:30 speculation, factors exacerbated the crash in 2008. The drivers then are different, but

0:45:36 when you look at the data it's ominously similar to 2006. The market might not be in

0:45:41 a bubble for the reasons that 2006 through 2008 was, but a handful of measures suggest

0:45:46 it's coming close for different reasons. And they indicated these three that I put on this

0:45:51 slide. Prices are above bubble levels. Homes are selling with bubble-like intensity. Only

0:45:56 16 median days on the market before we're sending August, nearly 36 days in 2020, 38 in 2019,

0:46:04 rents are also spiking higher right now. Nationwide are priced to rent rate, these ratios just

0:46:09 above the 1.5% during the 2006 peak. Nobody has a crystal ball, but it's intriguing to

0:46:17 read a history has shown us. This sums up the national ones, and I'll jump over to enterprise

0:46:25 If there's funds unless there's any questions on that piece of fund-sharing groups, it finds some value in it.

0:46:39 Okay, so water waste water and sanitation. This starts our analysis of our enterprise funds.

0:46:44 Our enterprise means they're like a business, so we charge fees without a profit motive.

0:46:50 Our water revenues, this is compiles our user fees, our water fund user fees received for each of the fiscal years of the current.

0:47:03 current. So again, we budgeted conservatively in 2020 for this budget and we had anticipated

0:47:10 that if people need funds, if they need money, they're not going to pay for having green lawns.

0:47:14 But in this case, we actually found that we have surpassed what our budget is. So we budgeted

0:47:20 at 6.9 million, almost 7 and we're about 8.5 million. We actually, in behind these numbers,

0:47:26 we have about 400 more accounts than what we had last year.

0:47:30 I do in my office. I know we have 17,097. We went to 18,384 residential. I can find out the breakout of

0:47:50 industrial. I'm curious if there was a is that? Oh, it's 400 houses or yes. That was the residential. It's not industry.

0:47:59 Industry didn't work. It makes it both to get to that larger number. Yeah. It's even though I understand we mentioned it

0:48:07 It's a lot more than $1,000 so for what we did last year.

0:48:12 Sure.

0:48:13 I'm curious if that was even mixed between residential and industrial art.

0:48:22 I'll send you back the information on the expense site.

0:48:31 Personnel has been over 19% of our total budget expenses,

0:48:37 but is 13% after accounting for the debt payoff.

0:48:40 So this fund has a significant difference because of our debt.

0:48:44 Water has not been fully staffed and continues to be under budget.

0:48:48 This again is with that extra fifth week in there so you can see that we are struggling in the water department to fill our staffing needs.

0:48:56 It's typical for water to spend most of their M&O expenses during the summer months using power to pump water.

0:49:01 The water was well under budget 81%.

0:49:04 Additionally, we are still experiencing huge lead times on meters and other parts,

0:49:09 probably over 12 weeks at times.

0:49:12 Our capital is 18% of total budget expenditures.

0:49:17 This is another spot that we have not started doing most of what we had planned because we can't get the parts and we can't get the supply.

0:49:25 Larger projects that we budgeted here, Southwell number 5 at 2.1 million, and only 18% of what we've budgeted has been expended.

0:49:35 Our debt, we paid off, so our amended budget shows that we have 9 million that we budgeted and we did the 9.1.2 bonds left only in the water fund.

0:49:47 fund the 2012 bond with $335,000 and the 2017 bond for $2.3 million left in

0:49:54 principle. Overall we spent 81% of our budget in the water fund. Waste water is

0:50:08 relatively consistent. You can see from 2018 to 2020 we've gone from 9 million

0:50:14 to 10.1 million. So in the last four years it's not significantly different. It's

0:50:19 pretty similar from year to year. We've received 105% so pretty close to what

0:50:25 budgeted 10.1 million over 9.5 million. Personnel again, name story, 89% of

0:50:38 personnel. We have a hard time filing, fulfilling our positions. We do contract

0:50:45 most of our services out, so personnel is not the largest percent of our

0:50:49 expenditures budgeted. We have budgeted personnel to be about 9% of the total,

0:50:54 and are under budget because of the staffing. It's a pretty close

0:50:58 on M&L. We didn't have a lot budgeted for capital expenditures. Our debt is

0:51:03 It's just the two debt payments that we pay throughout the year.

0:51:09 We've expended 9.9 million as opposed to what we budgeted, 9.7 million.

0:51:16 Annotation is even smaller and even more consistent.

0:51:19 The sanitation, we've received 3.6 million, almost 3.7 million, and in 2019 was 3.3, so

0:51:28 a gradual increase over the last three years.

0:51:33 We have no personnel, a sanitation, a stamina and transfers, which are pretty close to

0:51:39 What we budgeted wraps up the enterprise section,

0:51:45 just one of the questions or anything else you would like

0:51:49 to see more of.

0:51:53 A good presentation is always,

0:51:55 I always learned something I impressed, so thank you.

0:51:59 Questions, go ahead, Greg.

0:52:05 On page 74 in the path, there was an item,

0:52:09 miscellaneous, 1,608% mean,

0:52:17 I just was putting what was listed miscellaneous?

0:52:29 Page 74, so I just kind of threw it in the kind of jump.

0:52:38 What was the percent increase?

0:52:40 2,600.

0:52:42 Point 8's in the wastewater fund.

0:52:44 Did it with 3,000 actual revenue?

0:52:50 78,025 dollars.

0:52:52 Research that one if that's all right?

0:52:57 Because I'm pretty sure it's not in the back of the detail.

0:52:59 I'm just curious.

0:53:01 Yeah. I can look into that and then email it.

0:53:03 You guys?

0:53:05 I don't want to present it. Just the actual number.

0:53:08 That is a revenue and not an expense, correct?

0:53:12 At least.

0:53:13 Right.

0:53:14 Just making sure.

0:53:16 Yeah, let me look like it's safe to top them.

0:53:22 Well, while we're in that, there are sewer capacity fees in your actual revenues.

0:53:28 Yeah.

0:53:29 In that waste water fund that we're not budgeted, do you want to explain what that is for somebody?

0:53:49 One sewer capacity fees, anytime that an individual connects into the system.

0:53:56 So, at the sale of a building permit, a digital home, in addition to that, our industrial customers will also pay a capacity fee or flow with TSS.

0:54:13 And all of those capacity fees that we collect are not used as operating revenue, but they are placed into reserves.

0:54:21 And then the city has the ability to use those to assist in the expansion of the infrastructure system.

0:54:29 So if there's a pipe that needs to be expanded,

0:54:35 monies, out-apacity fees that we've got increased,

0:54:45 and you can also use that to,

0:54:49 additional of the MIMU's as the primary treatment

0:54:53 in the IFAS system at the waste bar treatment plant.

0:54:55 So, it's a fee that's assessed,

0:54:58 individuals to buy into a system.

0:55:01 It is the, as it works.

0:55:09 So it's not budgeted,

0:55:11 because it basically goes directly into reserves.

0:55:15 And so it'll be part of our reserve card access that we'll go on to reserves for this.

0:55:23 Yes, there's a sewer capacity fees that you see we collected $1,927,000.

0:55:29 We do not know how much we're going to collect and it's not an operational revenue.

0:55:35 And what we will do is we'll collect that and then by capacity related improvement we will come to the city council

0:55:43 and we will ask to use that form of cash reserves

0:55:46 and incorporate that into our spending line.

0:55:49 Thank you.

0:55:52 Any other questions?

0:55:57 I had to guess on the miscellaneous,

0:56:02 I'm going to believe a portion of that

0:56:06 could be relief comes as a result of our waste water treatment

0:56:14 plan to receive non-expanded directly related

0:56:29 to the expense.

0:56:31 He has rebated back to the city, and we've been Jacobs,

0:56:35 and we anticipate a rebate check this year,

0:56:38 and we're presenting that.

0:56:53 just looking at the wastewater document that was in the packet it's always the

0:56:59 budget has always been released for the last three years 3,000 and I do remember

0:57:03 2018 was over a million dollars that rebate was significant which was

0:57:18 unique about that agreement as I believe in the entire Jacob's portfolio we are

0:57:23 the only one that has that type of an agreement with them and we truly

0:58:56 Health City Youth Councilmen this evening and they are excited to participate in the Christmas

0:59:03 parade on Main Street coming up December 3rd. So if you don't have that night on your calendars,

0:59:08 mark it out. It will be a fun one. We are working with our police department on some upcoming projects.

0:59:16 So if you have youth looking for a place to plug in, we'd sure like to have more teenagers

0:59:21 join us in making this community thrive for everyone, also like to remind everyone that

0:59:30 this Thursday is Veterans Day and from the mayor's office and the council would like to

0:59:35 say thank you to all of those who have served our country.

0:59:40 It takes the sacrifice of a lot of people and know that we are thankful for your service.

0:59:47 Anything from the city manager's office.

0:59:50 Just to add to that we have two individuals that deployed

1:00:00 That are serving in our organization that will be deployed in shade as a special

1:00:18 I just received an email from the school board about the mountain lions that people have been seeing South Hills

1:00:25 Southeast area just thought maybe if others aren't receiving that email don't approach the animal don't try to capture the animal contact

1:00:32 I don't know if it's a game. I believe if you can't find that number, maybe call 3-1-1.

1:00:39 And I know we shouldn't. The other thing that the email did say not to over alarm, but in the early morning hours,

1:00:45 if there are some rural bus stops, you might want to be mindful of those before day break,

1:00:51 as well as taking garbage out. So I just wanted to give that PSA.

1:00:55 Thank you.

1:00:56 And to add to that they said do not run, make a lot of noise and yeah, interesting things

1:01:10 happening and if we can help spread the word we're happy to do so, it's 604 so we can move

1:01:24 forward to our public hearing.

1:01:27 This evening we have a request for an amendment to the latitude 42 PUD to allow for tandem

1:01:35 parking to be included in the required off-street parking calculations and we have with us good evening

1:01:47 I was looking around to see who was going to come talk to us.

1:01:49 Rules first are do you want to need for a planning and zoning public hearing?

1:02:06 We will first of all have the city staff present the request and analysis and then the applicant

1:02:12 will present their request. The council will then have the opportunity to ask questions of the

1:02:19 applicant or staff. After questions have been asked, the public hearing will be opened.

1:02:25 During that time, anyone in attendance will have the opportunity to comment or ask questions about

1:02:30 the request we are considering. When giving testimony, please step up to the podium.

1:02:36 State's your name and address and present your comments and concerns.

1:02:40 After giving testimony, please sign in on the public signage sheet that's located in the lobby behind you for our public record.

1:02:49 After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and make a closing statement.

1:02:56 Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.

1:03:00 After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed and no further testimony or comments from the applicant or the audience will be allowed.

1:03:08 At that time, the council will then have an open discussion and take action on the request, even if the action is to bring it back at a later date.

1:03:17 Thank you Madam Mayor and evening Councillors. So again, this is a request for a PUD amendment to the latitude 42 C1 PUD agreement.

1:03:33 Lattitude 42 is a PUD on the northwest side of the city located at the corner of Poline

1:03:39 and Creek Sideway, just west of the Twin Falls Reform Church in St. Luke's Hospital.

1:03:45 Lattitude 42 PUD consists of two subdivisions, Lattitude subdivision number one and number

1:03:51 two which is a total of 15 watts.

1:03:56 The PUD amendment would apply to both subdivisions, so the area in the red hashing identified as

1:04:02 as the subject area is the entire latitude 242 PUD.

1:04:06 The proposed amendment is to allow tandem parking

1:04:09 as part of the off-street parking requirement.

1:04:13 So what is tandem parking?

1:04:16 Tandem parking is described as two parking stalls

1:04:18 with one of the spaces placed behind the other,

1:04:21 causing one space to block the other.

1:04:24 The example on the screen is an example of residential parking.

1:04:28 There are some instances in commercial developments

1:04:31 that commercial developments will utilize TANDA parking.

1:04:34 So our Title 10 does not have standards relating

1:04:38 to TANDA parking, and therefore it is not permitted

1:04:40 within the city.

1:04:42 Our code allows for individual vehicles to be able

1:04:45 to maneuver independently, meaning they can get in

1:04:48 and out of a space on their own.

1:04:50 TANDA parking does not allow independent maneuvering

1:04:53 in or out of one space, meaning one space is always

1:04:56 governed by the other.

1:04:59 So again, the applicant is requesting that the PUD be amended to allow for part tandem parking.

1:05:05 And for post-language that they're suggesting is, this tandem parking is allowed.

1:05:11 Garages and driveways are to be included towards the minimum parking requirements.

1:05:17 So in the next few slides, I'm going to show you the applicant's multifamily development

1:05:25 and how the tandem parking looks and works for their site.

1:05:29 Again, this PUD amendment is, if approved, is for the entire latitude-to-42, and I'm going

1:05:35 to show you specifically for their site.

1:05:40 So the property outlined in yellow on the screen is the applicants' property for their multi-family

1:05:44 development, and then the red outline is for the entire latitude-to-42 PUD.

1:05:50 The main driver of this request is the applicants' development.

1:05:54 They want tandem parking to be allowed so that they can meet the minimum off-street parking

1:05:58 requirements with the site design I'm going to show you in the next slide. Without the

1:06:03 tandem parking, the site design would change. They would still meet the minimum parking

1:06:08 requirement, but it would be a different site design, which the applicant is going to show

1:06:12 you in third presentation. So above is the proposed site design with tandem parking. Outline

1:06:21 and blue are garages, and outlined in red are the parking spaces in front of the garages.

1:06:26 These are the tandem parking spaces outlined in green are additional required parking spaces.

1:06:33 In between the green and red are the internal drive aisles for the parking.

1:06:38 So not all units have access to a garage and those units that don't will access the parking

1:06:44 stalls on site that are outlined in green.

1:06:49 So one question that came up during the planning commission meeting was how were these garages

1:06:53 to be accessed.

1:06:54 So the applicant, this is part of their building permit, so the applicant is showing that the

1:07:00 garages are accessed in different ways.

1:07:03 A unit may have direct access to a garage, which the green outline shows.

1:07:08 A unit may have access to a stairwell from the garage that leads up to a unit, which is

1:07:13 the yellow outline.

1:07:15 Or a unit may not have direct access to a unit, but access to the garage is via the

1:07:21 the Preseway, which is the red outline.

1:07:24 And then in front of these garages

1:07:26 would be the other parking space outlined in blue,

1:07:29 which would be the tandem parking.

1:07:32 So this next slide just shows you how the yellow access

1:07:35 is the unit above.

1:07:44 In October 12, 2021, the planning commission

1:07:47 had a public hearing and forwarded a positive recommendation

1:07:50 with a three to two vote.

1:07:52 Council may approve, approve with conditions, deny

1:07:55 or table for more information.

1:07:58 Should the Council City Council approve this request,

1:08:00 prior to the document being signed by the city

1:08:03 and recorded, it will need to be signed

1:08:06 by all property owners within the latitude 42 development.

1:08:11 So that is my presentation.

1:08:13 Are there any questions for staff

1:08:14 before I hand it over to the applicant?

1:08:50 Addresses 267 West Everest Lane and Meridian,

1:08:55 made 3646.

1:08:58 Thank you staff, that was a fantastic presentation.

1:09:02 We have the best in Twin Falls.

1:09:05 Well done.

1:09:06 Real.

1:09:07 Um, we say everything that she said, but the slide kind of shows the proximity location

1:09:16 of the site.

1:09:17 While we have this one up, I just want to point out that, um, the nearest residential subdivision

1:09:23 is about .67 mile or so.

1:09:28 If there's concerns that there's going to be spillover in the communities, it's not

1:09:33 can happen in this particular case. So what we are requesting tonight is an amendment to the PUD.

1:09:41 What we are not requesting is approval for the 130-in-appartment complex that we already have.

1:09:46 Basically approval for through the zoning. What's up?

1:09:50 Discussion tonight is how that site plan is going to look. So regardless of what happens tonight,

1:09:57 these are the general looking field of the apartments themselves. There's 20-in-a buildings

1:10:02 and 10 unit building. Obviously, see the garages with the ways adjacent to them along with some internal photos as well, so this isn't above average.

1:10:13 This is a third amendment, but these things happen because the market changes in different desires of the owners.

1:10:23 The sites at the end of a 900 foot cul-a-sac and of a lot's front latitude circle, the other five are on chaining.

1:10:31 those lots on chain here are less effective. As I stated, you know, their

1:10:40 subdivisions pretty far away, so there's no concern about spillover. These are the

1:10:46 two side plans. The one on the left has 130 units, 102 surface stalls, 78

1:10:53 sinkerages, totaling 200 arching stalls, as you can see has the exact same numbers.

1:11:01 The question is which side plan? So the difference between the two side plans is

1:11:13 that we just removed the driveways and clustered them together into a large parking area open

1:11:22 space instead. And so you can see on the site plan on the left that you just have the garage

1:11:32 and get back. So if it's denied, this is what we'll go with. It'll have a clubhouse. It'll

1:11:46 have an outside management and around the south and maybe one buildings are obviously closer

1:12:01 together. And so there's an increased fire hazard. The parking is way more important for

1:12:07 residents having to walk further. It's approved. This is what the site plan would look like with the

1:12:18 Piccolo corridor and two dock parks. Residents will be able to park closer to their units. It's safer

1:12:32 with fire because of the distancing of the buildings and it provides for 28% open space for

1:12:39 10% required so significantly more open spaces as required and personally I just think this is a

1:12:44 better look. Just to maybe address some of your concerns that were the same might be the same

1:12:53 concerns of a race at P&Z and one of them was to quote negative this would

1:12:58 negatively affect the surrounding communities because of spillover parking

1:13:02 I think I pointed that out that's not really an issue here because we're not

1:13:06 talking about whether this is going to be a 130-unit apartment complex or not

1:13:09 and that was that this would be not fair the adjacent church I presumably meant

1:13:19 that we put parking the church parking lot in order for that to happen they

1:13:24 They would have to drive down all the way,

1:13:26 latte circle, find no parking.

1:13:28 As any on-street parking there might be,

1:13:32 100 feet on both sides of latte circle,

1:13:35 head north, at East on Pole Line,

1:13:37 at south, into the parking lot,

1:13:40 west again in the parking lot.

1:13:42 That's 0.75 miles.

1:13:44 No one's gonna do that,

1:13:45 so the comment of this isn't fair,

1:13:47 the church, I think, doesn't apply here.

1:13:50 Even if they were to do that,

1:13:51 they would then have to hop a six foot final fence

1:13:54 and trucks through the landscape, trees.

1:13:56 The last concern was that the businesses around here would have zero access getting in and out.

1:14:03 I personally think that's a stretch people typically don't park in front of drive.

1:14:11 I've wasted points to businesses. I personally never seen that.

1:14:18 The businesses here that are actually affected are affected in favor of this neighbor.

1:14:30 That's their now as a tool rental business and them directly to the west as a stargent.

1:14:38 better, the departments and storage units together.

1:14:43 So they're clearly in favor, and that concern is that, hey, if people have these garages,

1:14:50 they're just going to store all their stuff in it, and that's how you're going to have the issue of parking.

1:14:54 And so the group that's going to manage these apartments for us, they manage over 6,000 apartments,

1:15:03 many, many, many of them have garages. The system's in place to make that clear in the

1:15:09 contract that the tenant agrees to, and there's fines imposed, and then they're

1:15:13 Yes, to that point. There's some self-interest there. We don't want parking issues either.

1:15:20 We don't want people parking way down the street either. And so we have ourself interested in mind.

1:15:27 And make sure that these garages are also used as garages. And if there's a car behind it, that happens almost all the time across America.

1:15:35 Within a household you'll have a garage and you just negotiate that between the people that are living.

1:15:43 Here, it's kind of stating that there's no negative impact from a general point of view,

1:15:54 and if you narrow into the general area with businesses there in schools and housing,

1:15:59 they won't be negatively impacted.

1:16:01 And then, specifically, there's no one that's negatively impacted on that. It takes circles south.

1:16:06 In fact, it's the opposite. They will be positively impacted.

1:16:16 It's the last slide. That's kind of what's up for tonight.

1:16:22 The no vote would be the one on the right.

1:16:26 It's the same way to request for a PDF.

1:16:32 This time, is anyone on the council have questions for the applicant or staff?

1:16:41 In the U.S.

1:16:51 We received units, like these have been built in patients in Bell River, to Lehigh, and Boise, and of those.

1:17:02 So we have done the ones in Boise.

1:17:05 A builder is a part owner and several of those described to me.

1:17:13 Those are up in the rest of this presentation.

1:17:19 That's the intent.

1:17:22 I can't speak for all of them as of right now.

1:17:25 But the systems in place to make sure that those garages are in fact used as garages.

1:17:33 And then speaking to that point about sort of policing and regulating the use of the garages for actual vehicle storage, as opposed to general storage.

1:17:43 How is that? How many other process works? How is that enforced in 100?

1:17:47 What we have onsite managers, they're keenly aware of what's going on, cars, the license, and actually look at their tools.

1:18:19 Are they open for purchase?

1:18:21 These are all rentals.

1:18:23 And is anything in this development, and I know this isn't on subject, but for these considered...

1:18:34 These would just be...

1:18:36 Market rate?

1:18:37 Market rate?

1:18:38 Thank you.

1:18:39 Chris Farid.

1:18:40 What is it like to do those driveways just understanding with Live in Idaho and not everybody drives an economy car.

1:18:45 of the car. It seems like the biggest, longest pickup truck is whatever he wants to drive.

1:18:50 You have that fit in that driveway. That will fit. They're over 20 feet on, in effect.

1:18:55 With that in mind, we then all throughout the... Thank you. We might have measured our driveway

1:19:12 exactly before we built, so... To get into the housing part, is that through the garage only?

1:19:27 I know the upstairs stairs going up, but basically is a primarily going that way.

1:19:35 If I understand your question correctly, you can kind of see that the garages are broken up in blocks of three.

1:19:40 And so one of those accesses is the first level directly, and then the other one you have to go upstairs internally, into your second level apartment, and that's a private stairwell.

1:19:56 And then the third one you go outside into the stairwell that's in between the doors and have a sine at garage

1:20:04 Are the little white wears on the back towards the boundary? Are those entrances or doors or those are representing paddies?

1:20:14 There is a separate like front door entry to these units besides a garage entry I think is the question.

1:20:25 Because I'm not all units have garages.

1:20:31 My son lives in a unit, Boise, and it's similar to what this is.

1:20:37 But the way in, I guess the front door is facing another role of apartments,

1:20:45 and you can't drive where the front doors are.

1:20:48 Does that make sense? There's a walkway.

1:20:50 So the only way a visitor could come is to park outside of access to...

1:21:03 So on this picture on the top right, you can kind of see the

1:21:10 hornico and the building's kind of separate.

1:21:13 Down that is internal stairwells and those are the doors into the apartments.

1:21:18 So visitors, if for example, we were living there and I had a car in the garage in the driveway,

1:21:23 and had a visitor, they wouldn't need to park the question.

1:21:31 I've been thought of, but as far as the plot goes, just access from the circle.

1:21:38 There's only way really in and out.

1:21:39 And we have two access points on a lot of two circles for fire.

1:21:51 Any other questions? So at this time then we will go ahead and open the public hearing if there's anyone in the audience that has a comment or a question now is your opportunity to come forward.

1:22:18 Dean knows before we close it any other, so probably not, I'm assuming, did you have any other closing statements closing from F so we will go ahead and close the public hearing and turn it over to the council for discussion and or motion.

1:22:40 It makes sense, I like this layout much better than the C of Asphalt, I mean access to the clubhouse, I'll get access to the human community.

1:23:04 I do agree, I think that's much more inviting and folks that are renting apartments there will understand what they're renting and that's their choice to make, whether or not they choose to rent their...

1:23:15 there. Anybody like to take a stab at a motion from Craig Hawkins seconded by Christopher

1:23:59 Reid to approve the request for the amendment to the latitude 42 pud as presented this evening.

1:24:07 Amy Roll call vote please. Sean Berriger yes. Dan Hawkins yes yes. Christopher Reid yes.

1:24:17 And Craig Hawkins yes. Motion passes five to zero. Thank you for investing in our community.

1:24:24 So we do have an executive session listed on this evening's agenda, but that request has

1:24:29 been cancelled.

1:24:31 So with that, we are adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, November 8, 2021. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:24:39.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    7e35c674a2c56f5d2c4b5deb86f7235f6f34b3cb10009c055daef3e0197c0b7e
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 847fe48343f4bacc47e30cced037132e6dc24e290e0be1bf3463fa3d2523a476
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    06f7c855ecfd824fe5b211e95cb3d2e76d1a6ffa273742d384b6b4bedcf3f1a6

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file