City Council meeting
Monday, October 18, 2021
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
Recording
Moments cited in findings and the timeline
Transcript
0:00:49 to the October 18th meeting of the Twin Falls City Council at this time we're going to call
0:01:08 the meeting to order and I'm going to confirm we do have a quorum. We have six members present
0:01:15 in person and Councilmember Berger is joining us by the telephone this evening. At this time
0:01:21 we are going to move forward to the Pledge of Allegiance and if you'd like to join us please
0:01:25 We will move forward to the consent calendar and I will turn it over to the council.
0:01:55 May I roll it to make a motion that we accept the consent calendar as written?
0:02:04 Second.
0:02:05 We have a motion from Craig Hock seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar as it is printed.
0:02:13 See any questions or comments?
0:02:17 questions or comments so Amy roll call vote please.
0:02:19 Sorry was that the ancient non-barrier?
0:02:31 Yes.
0:02:32 Uh, Craig Hawkins?
0:02:36 Yes.
0:02:37 Mr. Fareed?
0:02:39 Oopstate.
0:02:40 Ruth Piers?
0:02:43 Yes.
0:02:44 Craig Lanting?
0:02:45 Yes.
0:02:46 Is that Hawkins?
0:02:47 Yes.
0:02:48 Mickey Boyd?
0:02:49 Yes.
0:02:50 And Sean Barrier.
0:02:53 I'm sorry, yes.
0:02:54 Okay.
0:02:55 So that motion passes six to zero with one abstention.
0:03:01 First item this evening under our items of consideration is a request to award a bid
0:03:08 and contract to Terry's heating and air conditioning for replacing the airport terminal heat pump
0:03:14 units and we have our airport manager Bill Carberry this evening. Good evening.
0:03:19 Welcome. Thank you Mayor. Good evening Council. The airport terminal building was constructed
0:03:32 back in 1996 and the heat pump units that we have currently there are beyond their useful
0:03:38 life. It's been quite a while and they're in need of replacement upgrades. So in addition
0:03:45 to the service ability, the ability to get the new freon types and parts and things
0:03:49 like that, the new heat pumps that we've specced out with the bit package will have increased
0:03:56 filtration, the higher a MERS unit number, and don't ask me how it works, but it has new
0:04:03 disinfection capabilities through germ killing, ionization technology, now there's a mouthful.
0:04:10 But the idea of improved air quality, particularly in the times where living is really desirable,
0:04:16 so it happened to come about at the same time when we were respecting the project to really
0:04:20 try to improve that air quality in the building as well.
0:04:23 So I think we've got a nice package that was put together.
0:04:27 The bid was opened September 16th with one bid received from Terry's heating and air conditioning,
0:04:33 a local firm, and if you could put up my monitor, I've got just a quick breakdown of some of
0:04:41 the numbers for you.
0:04:44 So the base bid from Terry's here in town was $232,841.
0:04:51 There was a contingency allowance of $30,000 for old bidders, so the total bid was $262,841.
0:05:00 Now that contingency would have to obviously be something that's approved, needed, and reviewed
0:05:05 by the architect, their engineering firm, their engineering personnel to justify any
0:05:11 type of contingency.
0:05:14 The engineering on the project, the bidding administration and the construction observation
0:05:19 with CSHQA architects, we've worked with them before in the modernization upgrade of the terminal building.
0:05:27 I also want to incorporate some commissioning, which is really sort of that eagle-eye home inspection at the end.
0:05:33 You make sure everything's working well. We'll get an inspection report.
0:05:37 The firm is CI to help and we'll work with Mike Jones in the past as well.
0:05:42 I think the $13,750 is well worth it.
0:05:46 total cost is $301,076, the airport budgeted $274,897, so we have a deficit to meet that cost of $26,179, so with that, I would ask the council to approve the request to award
0:06:09 for determining building, bid and contract,
0:06:12 it carries heating and air conditioning,
0:06:15 the total bid of $262,841,
0:06:20 and increase the project budget by the $30,000
0:06:23 from airport finder reserves for any contingencies.
0:06:27 I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.
0:06:31 I will jump in first.
0:06:33 Remind me, I believe that this was part
0:06:35 of the federal care package.
0:06:39 Is that correct?
0:06:39 the cares dollars that would receive certainly these types of projects with
0:06:43 things they encourage with those cares funding so so receiving some of that
0:06:48 funding and it being in our fund you could say it's sort of being used
0:06:51 essentially for the project absolutely and is this a any kind of a split match
0:06:57 between the city county or is this just all funded out of the pool of airport
0:07:01 funds or 50 percent city and 50 percent county so would be equally divided amongst
0:07:07 I was going to say, you don't know how it works, but the ionization, whatever, I know
0:07:16 years ago they had a filtration system that was really wonderful that actually decreased
0:07:23 flu spreading within your home that actually had results.
0:07:28 So I know that there seems like that out there in an airport.
0:07:32 I move that the council approve the request to award the terminal building heat pump bed
0:07:46 and contract to Terry's heating and air conditioning for the base bed of $2.3281 plus a potential
0:07:54 contingency of $30,000 and increase the project budget by $30,000 from airport fund reserves
0:08:03 to fund any contingency costs. Do you want the total of 260 to 741 or a total of 273?
0:08:13 Well, I apologize because my report I think I said the same thing differently than I put up on this
0:08:18 on the board here. So my apology for that. I have a couple numbers. So are we at 301-07-6?
0:08:32 I'll second that. All right. So we have a motion from Nicky Boyd seconded by Christopher Reed
0:08:38 to outward the bid and contract to Terry's heating and air conditioning and to adjust the budget and add the 30,000 from the reserves for a total of 3.01.076.
0:08:52 Could I correct that? That's just a little excuse. My apologies.
0:08:57 So, I'd like the motion to be as it reads here on your screen for a total bit of 262-841,
0:09:05 that includes the contingency, and then you increase that by 30,000.
0:09:11 So, what is the architect and the seed money come into it?
0:09:17 You're right, it's an approval of the total cost of 301-076, which includes the 30,000.
0:09:24 Okay, so my paraphrase was accurate that
0:09:33 say it again.
0:09:34 What's for me?
0:09:35 Okay.
0:09:36 So the ocean was to award the contract to Terry's heating and air conditioning for the
0:09:44 262 841 adding in the architects of the seed 301076 and to change the project budget increasing
0:09:54 by 30,000 from the reserved funds.
0:09:57 Well said.
0:09:58 Correct, yeah.
0:09:59 And then the 26,179 is coming from reserved funds.
0:10:03 Is the 30?
0:10:06 Yeah, that's my deficiency where I'm asking for the 30.
0:10:08 So it's just made you over.
0:10:10 It's just made you over.
0:10:11 But that's where it's coming from reserved reserves, yeah.
0:10:14 My apologies.
0:10:15 To you all.
0:10:16 This is new math.
0:10:17 This is new math.
0:10:18 Yes.
0:10:19 Because I didn't even sound like the motion I made that it kind of was.
0:10:22 It kind of was.
0:10:23 Yeah.
0:10:24 You're being very kind, thank you.
0:10:28 It's not trigonometry, it's about.
0:10:30 I don't know how to do trig.
0:10:31 Amy, so is that clear enough to write that out?
0:10:34 Okay, Gergen, thank you.
0:10:36 Okay, so the motion maker is okay, the second's okay.
0:10:41 Yeah, I think we figured it out.
0:10:42 And Amy's got us all under controls.
0:10:47 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:10:50 Would anybody else like to add to this party?
0:10:53 Amy, roll call vote please.
0:10:57 Christopher Reed. Yes. Right Hawkins. Yes. Not America. Yep. Nicky Boyd. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Right. Lanting. Yes. And Ruth Pierce. Yes. Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you. Thank you very much. The next item on our agenda is also dealing with our airport and this is a request by Sequoia Schmidt to lease space in the airport terminal to operate a retail bookstore.
0:11:30 And I will let you go ahead and give the history because I'm sure you will handle it much better than I will.
0:11:35 Would it be okay if Sequoia presented her proposal and then I have to live with a staff report after?
0:11:42 So I'd like to introduce Sequoia Schmidt.
0:11:44 Good evening. Thank you for having me and thank you, Bill.
0:11:54 If you don't mind pulling up what's on the screen here.
0:11:57 So if you don't remember me, my name is Sequoia Schmidt.
0:12:12 My husband and I are both base jumpers and we've been coming to Twin Falls for about five to six years to jump in your beautiful bridge.
0:12:19 And then in January of 2020, we moved here full-time.
0:12:25 Since that time, myself and my company have purchased three properties here in Twin, including a building on Main.
0:12:34 I'm not sure if you guys have seen the beautiful construction we've done to the building,
0:12:38 but one of the reasons that I wanted to move my company here along with seven of my employees who have been here full-time.
0:12:44 was because I love the town and I think it's an incredible little town and it has amazing potential to grow more and more.
0:12:52 One of the things that we had planned for the company over the next coming years was to open retail locations
0:13:01 and traveling frequently in and out of the Twin Falls Magic Valley Regional Airport.
0:13:08 I did notice that it is lacking a little bit of culture in the airport and airports say a lot about the city
0:13:14 in which you're coming in. We did a study last week and found that nine out of ten airports
0:13:20 have bookstores in the United States. Magic Valley Regional Airport does not have a book.
0:13:26 I took this originally to Bill, who respectfully denied it immediately, and his, what would
0:13:36 it be called, advisory board, and did a presentation to which I was told by Bill to the board.
0:13:45 already said no. So that's what brings me here today. The concerns that Bill raised
0:13:50 were that there was not enough space within the airport. For those of you who
0:13:56 have been in the airport, which I'm sure is all of you, there's a front little
0:13:59 location with multiple windows around it and a door. That location currently sits
0:14:04 empty and is used if I understand correctly, periodically for meetings.
0:14:09 That would be my proposal is that location for a rental for three months to see how the
0:14:17 bookstore does.
0:14:18 It could be that we put the bookstore in and we're not making enough revenue to cover expenses
0:14:22 and so we decide to pull it out.
0:14:25 All I'm asking is for an opportunity to actually have a bookstore there present.
0:14:29 So, a little bit about my company, I started it when I was 17 years old.
0:14:34 We published about 25 books a year in multiple different genres.
0:14:39 It's called D'Angelo Publications, but the name of the bookstore will actually be Dap Booknook.
0:14:44 It'll be featured as a little nook area within the airport.
0:14:49 So as I mentioned, one of the areas that we proposed was that front space, that way we
0:14:55 could capture people both leaving and coming to the airport.
0:15:00 Since we've moved here, we've hosted a couple of events here, one at the Gemstone Climbing
0:15:05 Jim with renowned author John Long. He's a best-selling New York Times author.
0:15:10 It was wonderful to work with the local climbing gym on that. We did a layout plan
0:15:16 for if we were to do the booknook within the terminal. The terminal currently
0:15:21 has a little nook space on the corner and it is only being utilized by vending
0:15:28 machines at the moment. I've been in and out of the airport six times in the last
0:15:32 two months and during those times I only saw a total of four people go into the
0:15:38 vending machine area. Those vending machines could be moved to outside that
0:15:42 little book area. We would set up, as you can see here, an inviting modern design
0:15:49 allowing for some culture we would feature. Some of the books would include
0:15:55 our wildlife book which is an activity book for kids which would make for a
0:16:00 a really great activity book to keep kids busy while they're flying on the airplane.
0:16:05 Icarus Syndrome, which is adventure book by John Long, which makes for a great airplane read.
0:16:12 The Way of the Warrior Kids series by Jocko Willink, which we published.
0:16:16 That would be a really good kids book for the plane.
0:16:20 And then also we have some Idaho authors as well.
0:16:23 So writing in the backseat with my brother by Judy Blaze, who's an Idaho author.
0:16:28 we could feature activity books and local Idaho authors as well. This is another example
0:16:35 of what the inside of the bookstore could look like. We could do some beam bags,
0:16:39 make it a really fun cultural inviting display for those who are coming into Magic Valley Regional
0:16:45 Airport. My proposal is not for you to give me the space for free. So I would lease the space
0:16:52 obviously with a fair market value of what the space would be worth, we would stuff it with our
0:16:59 own editors who are here in Twin. So people who are coming in and out will have the rare opportunity
0:17:05 to meet and talk with the editors of the books that they're picking up. And these are some of our
0:17:12 imprints that we feature. The Affiction, Non-Fiction, Children's Books, Activity Books.
0:17:17 And we would select the books that would best represent the airport, the area, and also interactive activity books for kids and things for travel.
0:17:28 Have any questions?
0:17:30 Push the button.
0:17:40 I'm struggling, apparently.
0:17:42 When you talk about inside the terminal, are we talking before TSA after TSA?
0:17:47 So there are two options on where we can put the location.
0:17:50 Obviously, this would depend on Bill's opinion.
0:17:55 So, this particular one that we had set up was based off of inside TSA, okay, as you guys know, airports all around the country have stuff going inside TSA, that was a concern of bills.
0:18:07 We would have the staff schedule on who would man the bookstore based upon when flights are coming and going.
0:18:14 The other option was outside of TSA, which was that little nook that I was telling you about that had all the windows around it.
0:18:22 We would open the door there and we would put the books on display and have the inside
0:18:27 area set up as a little bookstore.
0:18:29 And would you just be selling books?
0:18:33 Or are you going to be selling the bookstores that I've been in where there's bookstores
0:18:41 and it's more of a convenience store where there's more than just the books.
0:18:45 There's drinks and snacks and all those things that you forget when you've rushed out of your
0:18:50 house to catch an airplane.
0:18:51 Are those things as well?
0:18:54 We had thought about potentially adding some elements like that, like some of our books are activity books, so we could sell like little pen sets or crayonsets to go along with the activity book, maybe some M&M's, things like that, just to kind of enhance the book store itself, the majority of the book stores that are in the US airports, like Tattered Cover, the Zendember, et cetera, concentrate primarily on the books, and then they just have little things to check out, so that's probably how we would do it.
0:19:23 Perfect, thank you. Other questions?
0:19:25 I fly in another allotment.
0:19:29 My dad, absolutely no where you're talking about the veterinary inside, past security.
0:19:35 Yes.
0:19:36 On the outside of the security, could you describe me in the airport? Where are that?
0:19:39 That room is at? I think I have it.
0:19:41 I don't want to be sure.
0:19:42 Yeah, of course. So if you're walking into the airport, you know, where the mural is, on the far left door, when you look up and there's a mural there, if you go along there, there's the check-in on the left side.
0:19:52 and then on the right side there's a little area that sticks out and you don't
0:19:58 really notice it that well until you're actually looking. It's a little area
0:20:01 that sticks out, it's a little nook area, it's got windows all around it and
0:20:06 that's kind of an ideal location because it's right when people hop off the
0:20:10 plane, they're coming straight through the door and they're staring straight at
0:20:13 that little area and then when you're exiting a lot of people because it's
0:20:18 such a small airport. They don't want to go straight into TSA because there's
0:20:23 really nothing to do in TSA. So a lot of people will check in and then they'll
0:20:27 look around for something to do. So that's kind of an ideal placement because
0:20:30 it's directly across from the check-in. So if they look around for something to
0:20:34 do, they would see our display with the books and the door open for them to come in.
0:20:38 Add it onto that airport, made that beautiful new terminal. The idea was to
0:20:51 have so we have really nice restrooms in there and we have the vending machines
0:20:56 And we have a pretty aesthetically pleasing place to sit and wait for your flight.
0:21:02 So if you're looking around for something to do, all the best stuff is in that area.
0:21:08 I mean there's restrooms in the city, all the older stuff, and then baggage claim.
0:21:13 But pretty much that is all the nice amenities.
0:21:18 And I think people have really enjoyed those.
0:21:21 Sorry, you're talking about outside of TSM or inside of TSM.
0:21:28 Okay.
0:21:29 And we don't have a lot of people waiting a very long time either.
0:21:36 And I am aware that we have kind of a no-retail policy that this has come up before and that's
0:21:46 a policy that we have out there.
0:21:49 And so maybe Bill can speak a little bit more to that.
0:21:52 I love really about how that works, but I am really proud of our airport and I think it's nice and I think it's very user friendly.
0:22:03 Most everybody I see either has snacks or a book or a candle with them already, so I like what your idea is, but I just don't necessarily see it at our airport.
0:22:18 I understand completely and for a small airport it is beautiful.
0:22:21 I just, my thing was like the cultural element being added to it.
0:22:25 So my understanding and Bill can speak to this more is that front,
0:22:29 if we go outside of TSA now, that front area was leased previously.
0:22:33 He told me 15 years ago, so it's been 15 years since it was leased.
0:22:38 In that front room, I understand the concerns of going inside the terminal
0:22:43 in regards to potentially having retail space within there.
0:22:48 But if we shift the focus then to outside of that TSA terminal,
0:22:52 to that front little area that has the windows
0:22:55 that I'm talking about,
0:22:56 I think that could add a really great element.
0:23:01 Rickers.
0:23:02 So have you had any conversations with the restaurant at all
0:23:07 about doing some sort of joint thing
0:23:09 or consignment within their facility?
0:23:12 That's where you tend to get the most traffic.
0:23:16 If somebody's not gonna wait in the waiting area,
0:23:19 have you had a conversation?
0:23:20 So, part of the reason why we wanted to own
0:23:23 our own retail location is because of the percentage given away.
0:23:27 Our books are featured in Barnes & Noble's
0:23:28 and bookstores all over the country.
0:23:30 Part of the reason why we wanted to own our own
0:23:32 was to not do it on consignment
0:23:34 and not give away a percentage of our royalty basis.
0:23:36 We print here, we create here,
0:23:38 we're the creators of this book,
0:23:41 and we don't want to give it away
0:23:42 to a retail location.
0:23:43 That's part of the reason why we bought
0:23:45 warehouse here in Idaho is to maintain the ability to have 100% of the revenue from the
0:23:50 book coming to us and therefore allowing the authors to have an increased percentage on
0:23:54 their royalty. As soon as we go to a consignment basis, automatically you're looking at 35% to
0:24:00 50% of your royalty gone to that location. Not to mention that particular area that you're
0:24:05 talking about, although it's wonderful, it's in the very back of the airport. And so I
0:24:10 was looking for something that's right there in people's faces that they can really enjoy
0:24:14 way. And just to speak for two seconds to your point, Nikki, you know, although
0:24:21 people do come in and out quite frequently and there's not a lot of
0:24:24 waiting, they're also quite a bit of delays in the small airport. So in that
0:24:29 delay period it allows something for people to kind of engage in. So your
0:24:35 answer to my question is you haven't spoken to the Hanger people because of
0:24:41 your commission, exactly the shoe, and the location of where it is.
0:24:46 I find this interesting for the fact that not only do I fly through there, I have relatives
0:25:02 who fly in there a lot and they come off your city and place like that, so I end up picking
0:25:07 them up, taking them to their homes, I end up waiting, where I'm waiting in the waiting
0:25:12 room most of the time, is waiting for a flight to arrive, then I'm going to pick somebody up
0:25:17 So I am in that outside area quite a bit during that time and I've also seen or noticed
0:25:24 But a few other people with me and a few years of your milling around looking for something to do and there's anything to do really
0:25:30 I don't want to get most of your video games anymore. There's a couple of arcade video games over there one side
0:25:37 I also Nikki just not to disagree with how I do it differently
0:25:41 I don't go through TSA until I absolutely have to even our for my way in that outside area
0:25:47 I don't know if I feel trapped in there, I'm not sure what, I forgot some of my car, so if I get it, I wait outside of that part as well.
0:25:57 And I agree, I would be nice if it would work for the rest of the restaurant.
0:26:03 I agree with her, I never go on the restaurant unless I'm going to eat, so I never eat.
0:26:08 I don't.
0:26:09 Is there retail now? They do have retail there, so I don't know that we've totally banned retail, because they have retail in the restaurant.
0:26:16 They have a certain amount of, they have like crocheting items.
0:26:20 Yeah, available there, so I'm interested to hear from the airport side of it and make a motion to see where it goes.
0:26:30 Well, I'm going to add my two cents worth real quick, so I was at the airport last night and I called before I went because we had family flying out and we were planning on having dinner and the recording's wrong, so the restaurant was closed.
0:26:45 We had nothing to eat, nothing to do, and they had 45 minutes to change planes in Salt Lake
0:26:51 so they didn't have time to get there and eat.
0:26:53 So we actually made a mad dash back to McDonald's to get them a hamburger so they could eat
0:26:58 before they flew out.
0:27:00 And then they couldn't take their drinks through TSA so they were out waiting and had
0:27:06 nothing to do.
0:27:07 And so I agree having options and not being tied to somebody else's business hours.
0:27:15 So if the restaurant's not open or,
0:27:19 and you want to be selling your things there,
0:27:21 I can see how that could be a conflict.
0:27:24 I don't understand all this may seem needs at the airport.
0:27:27 So I'll be interested to hear what Bill has to say,
0:27:30 but I think anything we can add as a feature
0:27:33 is we're trying to get more flights
0:27:36 as we've increased to have other locations.
0:27:40 I just, I think that having amenities at the airport
0:27:44 what we've been after with all the money we've spent on upgrades and having
0:27:48 somebody willing to give it a shot and try it doesn't treat me and to your
0:27:54 point where it would be way easier for me to give it to another location because
0:27:57 I don't have to stop it or worry about my editors being there but this is a new
0:28:02 venture that I'd really like to try and I'd like to try it here in
0:28:04 You come up and hear the difficult side of this.
0:28:12 Thank you for your time.
0:28:14 Thank you.
0:28:19 Well, I don't think Bill's the difficult side.
0:28:21 He knows the operation.
0:28:22 We all go out there an hour here and hour there and we don't have to work.
0:28:28 After that first, I did.
0:28:30 He knows the new math.
0:28:32 So let's see how this rolls.
0:28:34 Bill, could you tell us how this ends up?
0:28:37 I hope you know how much we appreciate you and all your work.
0:28:44 I thank you very much, likewise.
0:28:47 So thank you, Sequoia, for your presentation.
0:28:49 So I just wanted to methodically go through the history here.
0:28:54 There's been conversations.
0:28:55 There's been advisory board meetings.
0:28:57 There's things that are maybe need some clarity.
0:29:00 So I'll just try to take my time through this.
0:29:03 It was an excellent presentation, I appreciate it.
0:29:06 So the background on this, I was initially contacted
0:29:09 by Sequoia Schmidt this past August about her request
0:29:13 lease space on a trial basis for three to six months for a retail looks or operation
0:29:19 and manned operations on the new point of sale collect things that sell books. She mentioned
0:29:28 she has an office here at Twin Falls, DeAngelo publications. So I think to her back in August
0:29:34 we told that we didn't have retail space available. It really wasn't in our plan, that
0:29:40 type of thing. We did, I think Donna had given her a tour of my absence of some time prior
0:29:45 to her contact me. I mentioned that 15 years ago we had a little coffee shop and what was
0:29:50 the old smoking room and unfortunately it didn't do well and there were also a lot of conflicts
0:29:55 with the restaurant operator, those kinds of things. So since that time, there's been
0:30:00 some lessons learned and things like that as well but just to get back to the space a
0:30:04 a little bit or the history here. So subsequently after I told her we wouldn't be able to accommodate
0:30:12 it, she went to the airport board meeting September 7th, and during the public input period,
0:30:18 she made her proposal. It wasn't an agenda item, an action item, but certainly we want
0:30:23 to be hospitable. The board listened to her, listened to her proposal to operate a bookstore.
0:30:29 Following that, Tom of Frank's here tonight, the chairman allowed me to explain some of
0:30:35 the reasoning that I gave Sequoia with a denial for her request.
0:30:40 I'd like to just summarize and essentially read from past emails what I had told the
0:30:46 board and what I had told Sequoia as far as some of the background on the difficulty
0:30:53 accommodating it.
0:30:54 I mentioned the only retail operation or terminal is designed for as the restaurant gift shop.
0:31:00 There really are no other areas designated for retail operations.
0:31:06 The area that she requested inside the secured gate area for the retail book operation of
0:31:11 Booknook was designed for vending machines during the remodel back in 2017 and it's
0:31:18 utilized as such.
0:31:21 The old smoking room out front which she mentioned around the corner from the mural
0:31:25 in the common awaiting area has been repurposed as a small
0:31:30 conference training and testing room.
0:31:32 There's testing that goes on with TSA,
0:31:35 training that the airline uses that we use
0:31:37 as an overflow conference room as well.
0:31:39 So although intermittent, it does play a role
0:31:42 in our tenants and their space meeting,
0:31:46 testing and training needs.
0:31:49 We've had numerous requests over time from folks
0:31:51 that we've had to deny,
0:31:54 who have had interest in retail space for arts and crafts,
0:31:58 barber shops, this large therapy to name a few,
0:32:01 and we've had to decline those interests
0:32:04 because we don't have space to support and to sponsor that.
0:32:08 We did ask her to speak to the restaurant operator
0:32:11 about possibly partnering to sell books in their gift area,
0:32:16 and there were advertising opportunities
0:32:18 with our advertising company that's run by Ron Yates,
0:32:23 many of you may know, terrific marketing.
0:32:27 So after listening to the proposal,
0:32:31 the board gave me no guidance and had no interest
0:32:34 to put this item on the formal agenda as an action item
0:32:39 to hear out and make a recommendation
0:32:41 to the city council.
0:32:48 September 13th, the following week,
0:32:51 Sequoia Schmidt approached the city council
0:32:53 and during the public input segment requested
0:32:57 City Council consider a proposal that she offered to operate the book star and a mayor advised her that
0:33:04 the request if it were to be heard by this body would have to be put on the agenda.
0:33:09 It's my understanding the City Council was unaware that the item was discussed at the airport
0:33:14 board meeting one week earlier. This was a budget impact for accommodating any kind of retail.
0:33:22 We don't receive grant monies for any kind of reconfiguration or repurposing of the terminal
0:33:28 space for revenue, producing operations from the FAA. We don't receive any grants for that
0:33:33 type of thing to accommodate and build out for retail. From a regulatory perspective, the
0:33:40 FAA does allow the local airport operator to the discretion of managed terminal non-airnautical
0:33:46 uses as it sees fit to do so. So you could have one, two, three, no retail operations that
0:33:53 would be completely within your own strategic plan. So in conclusion, over the years that
0:34:00 The airport has allowed the restaurant operator to have a lease agreement and part of their
0:34:05 lease agreement.
0:34:06 They're allowed to offer gifts, souvenirs, books and other small sundries to meet traveler
0:34:11 demand and that's where we've been for quite a while.
0:34:16 During our recent master plan inventory with our subcommittees that analyze what we have
0:34:21 in our terminal space, looking at our forecasting, they did not identify any needs incorporating
0:34:28 additional retail operation space in the terminal, and it was thought the existing restaurant
0:34:34 with its souvenir gift shop was adequate for the future. So in conclusion I would recommend
0:34:40 the City Council deny Mrs. Schmitt's request to lease space in the terminal building for
0:34:45 her retail book operation. I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.
0:34:50 Thank you Bill. Before we go to that, Tom, did you have anything you would like to add to
0:34:55 that presentation. So sometimes things, you know, the council gets involved in that. I
0:35:04 don't want to step on the commission's toes if you guys have already moved this over.
0:35:09 Well, I agree.
0:35:10 They're so good. You had the presentation, did a great job of slicing it tonight. We discussed
0:35:16 it, but there was, it was kind of laying on the floor. No one wanted to bring it up. So
0:35:22 because it didn't make, it wasn't, it wasn't clearly past this makes sense to this.
0:35:27 Okay.
0:35:28 Uh, no one wanted to pick it up and run with it, so there was no motion to say this, but
0:35:32 it was on the agenda as an action item.
0:35:34 Because no one felt that they wanted to pursue it.
0:35:36 Again, we have knowledge that the applicant, that she didn't have, you know, people think
0:35:42 they'll have lots of space, um, because they're out there and they see a lot of chairs out
0:35:47 and keep parts sitting out.
0:35:48 I've also been out there where it's hard for us to run a meeting, because we have no
0:35:52 Because of the training thing and it was I think you know skywells and the United thing
0:35:59 There's things going on in there kicks these space up and we don't have a lot of extra space if you look
0:36:05 I thought we kind of did it one time, but then I we start talking about we don't have a lot of extra space
0:36:10 I think it's it's a neat proposal to meet idea, but it's the wrong time
0:36:17 The wrong time for the airport expanded to that. I appreciate the you know
0:36:25 The airport's going through a lot of changes right now with flights and stuff like that.
0:36:29 They mentioned the restaurant being close, they're probably the caries in the mine a little bit like that.
0:36:36 You know, how can they staff if the planes are...
0:36:39 So they're going through changes and evolutions right now.
0:36:43 I don't think we're feeling good right now to just pile on and open up another business.
0:36:48 We don't have a place to clear that anyways, but I think she has a nice proposal, an interesting proposal, but it's not the right time.
0:36:56 I'm kind of vision all the space at the airport and obviously like somebody else mentioned
0:37:10 we're there now or I guess somewhere we're there now or two at a time and they're all
0:37:14 time is there is the airport board doesn't mean in the space we're talking about where
0:37:20 the old spoken room do not does the airport board meet in the room right across from your
0:37:25 office they do there's a conference room there that we meet okay and now I'm going
0:37:30 Often is that competition used for board meetings
0:37:34 typically once a month.
0:37:37 And it's also used to conduct business
0:37:38 and have other meetings that I conduct.
0:37:41 And the restaurant uses educationally
0:37:43 to have some clients that might use it,
0:37:45 but it gets used on a fairly regular basis
0:37:49 by administration.
0:37:52 But I've said I'm just wondering
0:37:53 because I kind of got the impression for a second
0:37:55 through the board and in that.
0:37:58 Well, I think Tommy had been thinking about with COVID.
0:38:01 We were trying to get places with phones.
0:38:03 We're trying to figure out video.
0:38:06 We're trying to do different things.
0:38:07 And so I think that baby, one of those things
0:38:12 he was thinking about, OK.
0:38:15 So Bill doesn't TSA have a break room and area behind the counter,
0:38:20 also where the airline counters are.
0:38:23 Isn't there room over there for them?
0:38:25 They have an office complex over there.
0:38:29 And there's also really what was an old bus depot area
0:38:33 and our busing company uses that during the busing season
0:38:37 over the winter as well.
0:38:38 It's just sort of an open air little front.
0:38:43 If they had to do training, there's a possibility.
0:38:46 Maybe that they could do that behind their counter area
0:38:50 on that side of the building.
0:38:52 I think some of it's very sensitive.
0:38:53 As your analysis, there's other things that go on.
0:38:56 People set up laptops.
0:38:58 People come in, contractors, things like that.
0:39:01 So, I think it would be a little bit more sensitive than the area you're making.
0:39:04 Everybody's looking like they don't want to speak.
0:39:12 Sean, would you like to weigh in?
0:39:19 I will. Thank you.
0:39:20 I'm going to be airport managers, official presentations, and recommendations, also listed in the airport board.
0:39:33 Free market economics is something we should try to be promoting.
0:39:40 In terms of this, I can't exit this.
0:39:43 We're not going to get fit with our current airport operations.
0:39:46 Also, I mean, trying to help me use the airport personal level of policy to our meeting.
0:40:11 The recommendation that this particular operator could sit at the day operate.
0:40:21 That makes the most I would be hesitant to see figurines.
0:40:27 Thank you.
0:40:39 Hold on just a minute, please.
0:40:44 Bill, is there a way to accommodate, like maybe towards where the luggage comes in.
0:40:52 a kiosk, instead of a retail space, have we looked at that option?
0:40:56 I would recommend if developing retail operations and a terminal building,
0:41:03 this desire we slow down, look at that, what that would look like,
0:41:08 the costs associated, you have an RFP, you know, have request solicitations
0:41:15 versus reacting to unsolicited requests.
0:41:18 So, yeah, but at this point, and the folks I get guidance from just doesn't seem like it's the right fit for us for a three months, four months trial to rearrange repurpose space.
0:41:35 That's why I was wondering if it was just like a kiosk in the middle of the floor area somewhere to see what the...
0:41:43 It may not be desirable by the applicant.
0:41:46 You know, there's circulation.
0:41:48 When you walk into the building and there's not flights going on,
0:41:51 you can play a handball and go dancing.
0:41:54 But it's that sudden rush of folks.
0:41:57 So the terminal building is really made for the efficient circulation of bags and passives.
0:42:02 If you were to point to one thing, you have that that's what's in between the parking lot
0:42:08 and the plane is you process passengers and baggage.
0:42:12 So the other items are ancillary, they're nice services, the restaurants are a gift shop.
0:42:19 I know they have other authors in there, I don't know what kind of terms, I think they'd be fairly friendly to anyone.
0:42:26 I would not have the need to point out sale, I think that would be very costly.
0:42:33 But not to comment on a business proposal, but just really from a space perspective and an efficiency
0:42:40 And the design of our operation, it doesn't seem to really work for us at this point.
0:42:45 So I would need to try to steer the applicant into some corner of the building that really just might not.
0:42:56 Alright, I'll give you 60 seconds rebuttal and then we're going to turn it to the Council for a decision.
0:43:01 Thank you very much.
0:43:03 I just wanted to say that I'm not requesting any kind of build out or any kind of change in that capacity.
0:43:08 I'll come in, my staff and I will do all the work.
0:43:11 If it doesn't work after three months, we'll return it to the exact way it was, and we'll move out.
0:43:16 And if it is working, fantastic. Then we keep going. Thank you.
0:43:21 I will turn it over to the council.
0:43:23 I see a couple of things going on. Number one, we're talking about police space.
0:43:30 And from the airport, they're saying we don't have space.
0:43:33 And so if that's something as a council, we would like the airport to start looking at.
0:43:38 I think that's something that we need to advise the airport on, that we need to start looking at least space.
0:43:45 And we have a desire as a council, whether that turns into people actually being able to succeed in those spaces,
0:43:54 that I've been there multiple times.
0:43:57 I am different than Greg.
0:43:59 I like to get through TSA as fast as possible, and that's where I sit.
0:44:03 So there's a lot of debate going on there, where something like this goes.
0:44:07 I, at the same time, when we have somebody who really wants to go and add to our airport,
0:44:13 have a hard time saying, yeah, no, because I do believe it would add to our airport, where
0:44:20 I have purchased one shirt dinner at the restaurant.
0:44:25 I've also gone to the vending machines and got something.
0:44:29 I also just went through O'Hare last Monday, and there's stuff galore where we are not O'Hare.
0:44:35 and I understand that, but also when you get to an airport you kind of expect
0:44:42 some of those things, some of those amenities, and so I do like the kiosk, but
0:44:47 at the same time if we're looking at leasing space, currently at
0:44:53 airport, we don't have a plan in place for leasing any space. We have rooms that
0:44:58 sometimes it vacant, sometimes have meetings in them, we don't have a plan
0:45:04 in place to lease anything except for where the restaurant is but we have
0:45:11 proposed areas and so I I'd love to work on it and that would be something one
0:45:19 council member to the airport I'd love for you guys to find some places that
0:45:24 work and I'd love to have a bookstore in our airport I'd love to see it succeed
0:45:30 as well I don't want it there for three months and then they can see but I think
0:45:37 it right now we're asking for something that we can't answer a question that's
0:45:44 my personal opinion if a kiosk works and that's you know we could find a little
0:45:49 spot I'd be all in favor of that but as far as saying hey can you take over
0:45:54 that room we're being told by the airport board that's not available I'm
0:46:03 torn right now I want it but the folks that are out there saying there's there's
0:46:10 Great lead team.
0:46:14 Doing well stated Chris.
0:46:15 I'm kind of in the same category.
0:46:21 I certainly very intrigued about a bookstore at the airport.
0:46:24 I would like to see it.
0:46:27 The kiosk, I think of, as I think about there a lot, I'm waiting in my leggings.
0:46:37 There seemed to be a lot of space to just north of the leggings area that we even ourselves
0:46:44 have admitted that we're not using it very well because that's where we had all the placards
0:46:48 the possible runways and axes and everything else holding off an area that would actually
0:46:55 possibly retail but it would have to be constructed to hold over buggy. As far as beyond the
0:47:04 TSA that's where we're used to it now. I fly just like you do quite a bit and once you
0:47:10 get through security you've got a mirror of things you can look at. I think some of
0:47:15 Okay, remember which airport is now, but there's a serpentine thing through a button.
0:47:20 Twenty different retail places that they don't even have walls, they're just all there, and I don't have the security at night, but they must have something, because they're not manned all the time.
0:47:29 I too would like to see something out there. I think I'm along with Chris.
0:47:34 I may not be, we miss, may not be the time. Plus where we're dropping down to one flight.
0:47:39 on this guy or the Delta part might be better for next spring, anyway for the three month
0:47:45 travel. I would challenge the airport to look at all the options and the board to look at all the
0:47:50 options and see what might be available to provide a more entertaining experience for our flyers.
0:47:59 Right now we're for just here and so maybe we could come up with something there that would
0:48:05 not necessarily force it away as an idea, but something to make it a better situation and
0:48:14 also provide a small one for income for the airport, so that's where I'm at, there's a
0:48:23 motion, I'm not sure I'm going to have to see one of the people I'm just saying.
0:48:28 Great Hawkins.
0:48:29 I just want to say that I agree with what's being said, I think this would be a great
0:48:35 addition to the airport, I think it's exciting that we're going to possibly expand, but I also feel that advisory board would respect their opinions.
0:48:55 I would be all in favor of it that space.
0:49:05 I tend to agree. I love the entrepreneurship and the idea that Sequoia came to us, but I do respect the airport board and the manager.
0:49:24 I think we need to think out of the box and if it is, go back and I'm up with potential ideas because that's, we just don't have maybe one realtor that might be, I've been talking real estate all day.
0:49:41 One business owner that might retailer that might be interested but there may be others and I don't remember turning down anybody else but there may have been some great idea.
0:49:55 other ideas out there and so as opposed to jumping in and making a snap decision
0:50:02 I think we need to step back and maybe look at the big picture. The airport has
0:50:11 been going through a master plan. That airport is a really key piece to our
0:50:18 economy here. The passenger planes are not the biggest piece of what goes on
0:50:26 out there and so when I heard you know there should be things to do while you
0:50:32 wait there should and I think and I think a bookstore for kids or whatever would
0:50:39 be great but it takes me back to where we've been really focusing on building
0:50:46 the airport having big business out there that helps our economy that keeps us
0:50:53 running that brings money into the city and and other businesses and
0:51:00 where we have limited flights I don't know that this timing is is really
0:51:06 great but also I go back to an old scene from the old days in airlines when you
0:51:12 go to a restaurant you never asked for an airplane ride but on a plane you can
0:51:17 complain about the food. So it's, you know, most people come prepared with a Kindle or
0:51:24 a book or toys for the kids or whatever, would a bookstore be great? It would. But I don't
0:51:30 know if we have the numbers out there to even speak to that. And if we can maybe talk about
0:51:35 future retail as, I don't know if it could be part of the master plan now, but I mean,
0:51:40 at least have a dialogue going. Maybe that would be something that we can do in the future,
0:51:45 but I don't think the numbers, there's not enough traffic out there to make that concept fly as near as I can tell.
0:51:52 Christopher, you just put in the sense push, I should probably push it when I speak.
0:52:00 Um, just add one more comment to it.
0:52:03 Sequoia's coming in with her own money.
0:52:12 She's not asking.
0:52:14 She's asking for space.
0:52:16 That's it.
0:52:19 And so, I'm not going to pretend to run a bookstore, know what type of traffic flow is needed, but we have someone who is wanting to do this, and the fixator fail will learn something from it.
0:52:36 Now understanding at least space is a big question, and that needs to be done properly.
0:52:43 But again, we have a business owner who is saying, hey, I'm going to put time, energy, and money into this.
0:52:49 Can you give me space which we need to work on that?
0:52:54 That's, I guess, the problem I'm having is somebody's wanting to do something.
0:53:00 We can say, hey, we want retail space, and in ten years we can be having that same conversation.
0:53:05 We want retail space. I don't really want to look at a business owner and say because
0:53:13 we would like to have, you know, put it out to bed for who knows. I don't know. Do we
0:53:19 bid the restaurant? I'm saying that I want to bid the restaurant, but do we do we do
0:53:23 that? Because if we're going to go into a bidding process on everything that changes
0:53:27 things. We have someone who's approaching us and wants to do this and put their own time,
0:53:33 energy into it and we'll learn something from it. We would have to work on space
0:53:39 just because we think there's space there doesn't mean that there is but that's
0:53:44 why as I've been listening and thinking about it I am in favor of it because I
0:53:47 think that that's something we could find and work on it. Again the space is
0:53:54 the issue and I'm going to fall on the airport to say hey there is this space
0:53:59 it's this big or you know we're gonna have to work on on something but we
0:54:04 We have someone who wants to do this, something we don't have, and there's a lot of ifs, and
0:54:12 it's not going to cost us.
0:54:15 John Barrieger.
0:54:16 I look at a conversation we had a few meetings ago where we talked about franchise operations
0:54:32 or, you know, concessionaire operations on our part properly establishing a process.
0:54:42 to a certain extent that it's the same conversation we're having today.
0:54:56 The private operation is like the operating of public space,
0:55:00 and frankly a public space that has well-established processes
0:55:05 with our blind services that operate as a private vendor in our public space.
0:55:16 Our rentals, the restaurants, have been present private.
0:55:25 So what I would say is called the implement the same policies and procedures
0:55:33 that we have for these other outfits for the current
0:55:43 for board and airport manager who actually facilitate that
0:55:48 on a regular basis.
0:55:50 We as a council approve those leases.
0:55:52 We are not negotiating them.
0:55:55 We should take their recommendations with this.
0:55:58 Not the appropriate operation to be moving forward
0:56:01 at this time, though it sounds that the bill has provided some
0:56:05 are alternative, but they should be taken out of it.
0:56:11 I just think this is a council getting in the weeds
0:56:15 on things that doesn't need to be, you know,
0:56:26 through a property as well, that's involved in this,
0:56:32 that we aid on to the near-purport.
0:56:36 A massive way to do that is as much better waiting
0:56:39 with the business as opposed to whoever being went off
0:56:42 who wants to cancel and make a recommendation
0:56:45 that we decide how operations should be working.
0:56:47 To see that, I think we should call
0:56:51 we should call the recommendation that I'm going to share this time and see how it goes in the future.
0:57:01 Thank you. Thank you Sean. I was just waiting for everybody else. So I was very excited about
0:57:15 this request because I would like to see our airport have more amenities and more things.
0:57:19 But I do understand that I'm not there daily in the operations and in the space
0:57:24 and the little time I go out to fly in and out or to pick people up or take people out
0:57:29 is probably not a really good representation on the day-to-day work that goes on at the airport.
0:57:36 I would like to highly encourage our airport board and staff to start looking down the road
0:57:43 at these opportunities and just not have a no policy, but see where we can fit things in,
0:57:50 and maybe how we can utilize this makes better because I think it will make
0:57:54 it better for the airport and the community both. I don't want to micromanage the airport
0:58:02 and tell you how to do your job. That's what we hire you to do. And so I have to defer to
0:58:08 you and trust that you're making the best judgments, but I would like to explore and
0:58:14 see maybe if there isn't opportunity down the road for having some more amenities. So
0:58:21 So with that, I will let Chris make the motion.
0:58:23 I move that we approve the request by situation,
0:58:26 it to lease space in the airport terminal to operate a retail bookstore.
0:58:33 Second.
0:58:34 We have a motion from Christopher Reed, seconded by Greg Lanting to approve the request as presented.
0:58:41 Amy, roll call vote please.
0:58:47 Hickey Boyd.
0:58:48 John Berriger.
0:58:56 Chris Reed.
0:58:57 Yes.
0:58:58 Greg Hawkins.
0:58:59 No.
0:59:00 Ruth Pierce? No. Great glanting? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? No. Motion fails on the
0:59:13 2-5 vote. Sequoia, thank you very much for your time and I see your heart and your
0:59:19 desires but we do have to lean back towards the professionals that run our
0:59:24 operation and I hope you guys can all stay in touch and if the opportunity works
0:59:29 It works, bring it back before the Council at a future date.
0:59:50 Thank you very much for being here this evening.
0:59:53 At now is an opportunity for general public input.
0:59:56 If there's anyone in the audience that would like to address the Council on an issue that
1:00:01 was not on this evening's agenda, now is your chance.
1:00:05 You know what?
1:00:09 We will turn it over for advisory board reports and announcements.
1:00:20 I haven't reported on the, uh, our Shrek board for a while, we did spend a lot, we spent
1:00:26 the entire last meeting on determining whether some trees should be taken down and it was
1:00:34 a lively discussion on such a planned and I think it was a discussion and they may be
1:00:42 coming to us with a possible tweak of our ordinances because they're not sure they actually have
1:00:48 the authority to force somebody to take down a tree if it's been topped or something on
1:00:52 So that's maybe coming to us with probably through, maybe through Sean Stanley actually
1:00:59 who would be tasked with that, requires somebody to do so.
1:01:06 City Manager's office this evening.
1:01:16 I'm going to take a personal moment and just congratulate my nephew and his wife on having a handsome baby boy this afternoon at 2.30
1:01:23 and welcome my new great nephew Winston Brave into this world.
1:01:28 So, pretty exciting day for us.
1:01:33 We have Sean, go ahead.
1:01:37 All right, let's go quickly.
1:01:39 I think it's important to note that early voting begins today
1:01:43 or begins today, if the council consider a production
1:01:48 when folks can clearly vote for the next two weeks
1:01:50 in the election that's upcoming on November 2nd.
1:01:53 Now we'd encourage residents of Twin Falls
1:01:57 to get to know and understand the candidates
1:02:01 who are running and be engaged in the process.
1:02:04 Thank you.
1:02:05 Now, as I believe I heard from the other end of the dias
1:02:09 that Ruth was the very first person to vote.
1:02:14 Not only that, but she got to verify that the ballot box was
1:02:17 empty.
1:02:18 She is the witness to this being a fair and honest election.
1:02:22 So pretty awesome.
1:02:25 So we do have a request this evening to adjourn into executive session under Idaho Code 74-2061B
1:02:34 to consider the evaluation, dismissal, or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought
1:02:40 against a public officer, employee, staff member, or individual agent or school, public school student.
1:02:48 I move we move into executive session session.
1:02:57 We have a motion from Ruth Pierce seconded by Nicky Boyd to move into executive session
1:03:03 under the title code red Amy Roll Call vote.
1:03:09 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:03:10 Yes.
1:03:11 Great, Lanti.
1:03:12 Yes.
1:03:13 Ruth Pierce.
1:03:14 Yes.
1:03:15 Hi, Hawkins.
1:03:16 Yes.
1:03:17 Mr. Fareed.
1:03:18 Yes.
1:03:20 and Dickie Point. Yes, Ocean Pass is 7-0. We will not be reconvening this meeting this evening Cited in E-05
1:03:26 and we will not be making any formal decisions in the meeting as well. And with that, we're adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 56 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 71 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 95 KB
- Audio (M4A) 15.0 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 18, 2021. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:03:37.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
1b00d82bed9a088884623f89b0d7a2f5cdf687baef9dfaf354ef3807744caefe - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a e9095435db545abcc6160b4389698d8f88888ef1bf7718f444d6589f11d03219 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
2bdc937f742c18108ddb4f89f09ee7c49ab79b3bb06eb610bc8fdde29782a8c3
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file