City Council meeting
Monday, August 30, 2021
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:01:11 August 31 fall city council. At this time we're going to call the meeting to order and confirm that we do have a quorum.
0:01:19 We have four of our seven members in person this evening and we might be having one more join us by phone before the evening's over.
0:01:28 Next on our agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. If you would like to join us please rise.
0:01:34 We have no proclamations this evening so we will move forward to the consent calendar and I will turn it over to the council for council wishes.
0:02:04 I move we approve the consent calendar as written.
0:02:14 We have a motion from Ruth Pierce, seconded by Greg Hawkins, to approve the consent calendar
0:02:19 as it was published this evening.
0:02:22 Amy Roll, call vote please.
0:02:28 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:02:29 Yes, Greg Lanting?
0:02:31 Yes.
0:02:32 Ruth Pierce?
0:02:33 Yes.
0:02:34 Christopher Reed?
0:02:35 She passes 4-0.
0:02:43 Amy, do we need to give you a minute to try to get Chris on the phone?
0:02:49 Okay, we're just we're not going to recess or anything. We're just going to hang out for a minute
0:02:53 So if you were here for the
0:03:09 Paxson fight the finding of facts and conclusions of law for Canyon Village number three or for the
0:03:16 Improvement agreement for developing Sun West subdivision number two those were both approved
0:03:22 Can you stay for the rest of the meeting? Can you hear us Chris? Can you hear us? Thanks Chris for your patience and welcome to our meeting
0:06:05 Right moving forward first item of consideration
0:06:12 This evening is a request to approve a resolution declaring sole source for Avtech LLC Radio Hardware.
0:06:21 And we have Mitch Humble.
0:06:26 We're just going to let Mitch run us through the whole show tonight, so.
0:06:29 Funny thing is none of these items originated from me.
0:06:35 But I've got some help tonight on these first two in Tammy because I think she can help.
0:06:41 But these are a Cathy item and Cathy's on vacation, so we decided to let her take a break.
0:06:47 So this first item, though I can tell you about, is a soul source resolution.
0:06:52 You did one of these last week, and it's a very similar reason that we're replacing parts of an overall system.
0:06:59 The overall system is just to have tech radio system, and we need the rest of the systems to still work,
0:07:05 work and so really this one provider is the one that we need to use to do this in order
0:07:10 to do a public acquisition like this where you just have the one provider that we have
0:07:16 the sole source resolution that you guys are being asked to approve tonight and so again
0:07:21 that's basically that's involved in doing is we're going to replace the radio consoles
0:07:30 and some software in the dispatch center but all the other radios are still part of the
0:07:35 same system and we need them all to talk nicely together and so we're asking that the council
0:07:39 I'll adopt this resolution, and Amy can give us a number.
0:07:43 We need to get one dash zero one four.
0:07:46 And that's it. We can have questions and answer questions if you want.
0:07:50 Like I said, Tammy's here and she might be up too if I can't answer them.
0:07:53 After this one.
0:07:57 I move we approve Abtech's Scout hardware and software upgrade.
0:08:12 Whoops.
0:08:13 Right.
0:08:14 All source.
0:08:15 All source.
0:08:16 Now for some reason I'm our agenda jumped ahead.
0:08:20 Oh, yep, that's great, huh? Okay, let's go back to this one. Sorry. We just need resolution 2021-014.
0:08:30 I move we approve 2021-014 resolution for making have-text-sull-source purchase.
0:08:42 We have a motion from Ruth Pierce, seconded by Greg Lambtine, to approve resolution 2021-014.
0:08:51 Amy will call vote please. Greg Lanting. Yes. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Mr. Perrie. Yeah.
0:09:02 Right. Hawkins. Yes. Yes. Motion passes five to zero. And now the
0:09:10 piece to that is a request to approve the F-TEX Scout hardware and software
0:09:16 upgrade and installation for a cost of $78,840.
0:09:23 Exactly.
0:09:24 Any questions?
0:09:25 No, I'm just kidding.
0:09:27 So we've been using these consoles in the dis-spec center
0:09:31 for five years, and in the technology world, five years
0:09:33 is really, really old.
0:09:35 And so basically, we're buying replacement radios
0:09:39 of the same dev tech system.
0:09:41 We've got one already that we just recently acquired,
0:09:43 and we're going to buy five more.
0:09:45 and then the installation and the software for the six total.
0:09:49 And so that cost is coming to a total amount of 7840.
0:09:54 And we've got a contract that's in your agenda tonight
0:09:59 for approval.
0:10:01 Really, this just updates the very end of the software
0:10:06 in the dispatch center to allow our dispatchers
0:10:08 to communicate effectively with our public safety folks
0:10:11 in the field.
0:10:12 Leave those funds are coming from caristoles.
0:10:16 And so the care's from these,
0:10:17 But we're paying for it these and that was authorized, I think, by the council, months ago.
0:10:23 Permission.
0:10:31 Thanks, Scott, hardware and software. I'm great in installation for 12,000, 78,000, 4,000.
0:10:44 78,840 dollars.
0:10:49 We have a motion from Greg Lantine, seconded by Craig Hawkins, to approve the request for the Abtex, Gout, Hardware, as presented.
0:10:58 Amy, roll call, vote please.
0:11:00 Craig Hawkins?
0:11:01 Yes.
0:11:02 Christopher Reed. Yeah. Ruth Pierce. Yes. Greg Lanti. Yes. And Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. Motion passes 5 to 0. Next we have a request to approve the purchase of real property located in the Snake River Canyon approximately 3300 feet northwest of the city's wastewater treatment plant.
0:11:26 You know, this one, I really wanted Lee to come talk to you guys about this because Lee has done so much work on this project over the last nearly 20 years.
0:11:36 I mean, he's been with the city for 19 years now, and I think almost all of that, he's been working on this Argy Falls project and he really deserves a ton of credit for this.
0:11:45 But he also couldn't be an attorney, this is not...
0:11:50 So the math that you see on your screen there, that blue line is basically the property that
0:11:58 we own, currently own for the Agar Falls property.
0:12:04 That line is several hundred acres, right?
0:12:07 There's a little green box down at the far right side of that picture, that's the wastewater
0:12:13 treatment plant.
0:12:14 And then that red box that's kind of closer to the treatment plant is the property that
0:12:19 we want to talk about tonight.
0:12:21 And back in like 2001 or 2002, we started this acquisition process where the city started
0:12:29 buying the properties and getting properties from the federal and the state governments
0:12:34 to put together this agar falls property and it's been just a real great success for us.
0:12:41 Lee was the primary working on this project for the city and in his efforts, the folks
0:12:50 that owned that little red box of property that's about 20 acres.
0:12:54 The property has since changed hands recently, and the current owners have reached out to
0:13:05 Lee, and they are willing to sell, and in fact, they said we'd sell that to you for $50,000
0:13:12 for which is less than we thought we might have to pay for it, and so basically the request
0:13:19 tonight is, can we approve this sale, or I guess if we have purchased this purchase on
0:13:23 property from the current owners of that for $50,000.
0:13:29 Again, please put a ton of work into this and he's got a great relationship with these
0:13:34 guys and we're ready to go.
0:13:36 It just needs your approval.
0:13:38 Now, the one thing we need to look at is that we didn't plan for this when we adopted
0:13:44 the budget for the fiscal year 21 last August.
0:13:48 This was not known.
0:13:49 This was going to be an option for us otherwise we did budget for it.
0:13:54 So we don't have anything the budget to cover this $50,000 right now, but we do collect park
0:13:58 impact fees and our park impact fees are collected for the purpose of acquiring or developing regional
0:14:05 community park land, of which Niagara Falls certainly qualifies.
0:14:10 And so this is the impact fee eligible.
0:14:13 We have enough park impact fees in the bank right now that can only be spent on that purpose.
0:14:19 So we're recommending that we haven't approved the property and purchase and use parking fees
0:14:25 for that any questions if you have any.
0:14:34 But this really is that last little piece that gets us pretty much everything between
0:14:40 the treatment plant and even a little bit past rock, so this is a great.
0:14:52 So which have we already annexed all of this in or is that something that's coming?
0:14:55 No, this is annexed and what's interesting about that, I'm glad you asked that question
0:14:59 because I wasn't going to talk about annexation.
0:15:03 It's not really the bulk of agar falls.
0:15:06 Park is not an acceptable meaning that we're not adjacent to current city limits.
0:15:12 There's a little, there's a hope that we can be at the very
0:15:16 tip closest to the treatment plant and we might need to get one or two little properties in there
0:15:21 to be adjacent. But once that happens and we purchase this parcel then we can grab the whole thing.
0:15:29 and so that's actually this makes annexation this property much higher like
0:15:35 the near future which means we'll have control of it from a and it's about a thousand like 800 feet
0:15:51 a riverfront that's kind of like to make a real property located in the Snake River Canyon
0:16:13 approximately 3,300 feet northwest the city's wastewater treatment plan and using
0:16:18 parking back fees to pay for the $50,000 a second that right we have a motion
0:16:25 from Craig Hawkins seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the requesting as it was
0:16:30 presented this evening Amy roll call vote please Christopher Reed yes Ruth
0:16:39 Pierce yes right landing yes yes and Craig Hawkins yes motion has this fight to
0:16:46 zero this time we would like to offer anyone from the public a chance to
0:16:51 address the council on any issues that were not on the sea means agenda and we
0:16:56 will be allowing up to two minutes the sea
0:16:59 need it please state your name for the record there's a button right on that
0:17:07 base there you go as mayor members of the council my name is mag themester since
0:17:14 your budget negotiations discussions are over I can comment on those tonight
0:17:19 I wanted to give some unsolicited, deliberative advice and opinion.
0:17:26 There's a concept in organizational or management science called bike shedding,
0:17:33 and that is that in very large systems, because they're so hard to grasp,
0:17:38 humans normally gravitate towards a small, picky, inconsequential part of it,
0:17:43 but ignore the bigger parts.
0:17:45 And it's based on a hypothetical scenario where,
0:17:48 building a nuclear power plant.
0:17:50 The people planning and doing it won't spend too much time
0:17:53 thinking about the bowels of the plant,
0:17:55 but they'll spend a ton of time talking about what they should,
0:17:58 how they should build the bike shed,
0:17:59 just store little bicycles to ride around the plant.
0:18:02 So it's called bike shedding.
0:18:03 And I noticed some of that in your deliberations
0:18:06 where you spent almost 20 minutes talking
0:18:08 about the council race that you were going to do,
0:18:11 which comes out to like a hundred or so dollars a month
0:18:14 per council member per month.
0:18:16 That was maybe 20 minutes of discussion, but you know 250 grand for a new digester at the sewage plant or in a grand for a truck that can dig up pipes on and on got pretty much just a head nod and so I would just say in the future as a member of the public prefer to see less
0:18:35 by shedding and more focus on the big things.
0:18:38 That's all.
0:18:39 Thank you.
0:18:40 Thank you very much for bringing that to our attention.
0:18:43 There anyone else who would like to address the council
0:18:45 come forward?
0:18:53 No, this is the right time.
0:18:54 But there was a past issue that when I listened to me,
0:18:59 but brought to my attention.
0:19:01 Please state your name for that.
0:19:03 My name is Michael Allred.
0:19:04 All right, thank you, Michael.
0:19:05 So, and I certainly appreciate you guys' time.
0:19:08 So I wanted to talk really quickly
0:19:10 about the incorporating the new, you know,
0:19:13 the avenues of making a new historic district
0:19:15 here in downtown Twin.
0:19:17 So one, I want to say I absolutely love old homes.
0:19:20 I love going to the process.
0:19:22 Actually, I'm a neighbor to Ruth Pierce's business.
0:19:26 I apologize for the clutter,
0:19:27 but I am in the restoration process of that home.
0:19:31 So for me, I absolutely love these homes.
0:19:33 They're very, very beautiful.
0:19:34 And I do not think of this as something
0:19:37 that we should mandate on a whole, you know,
0:19:41 on a neighborhood.
0:19:41 I do not believe it's a city's job to act as an HOA.
0:19:45 I certainly appreciate the history
0:19:48 and the historic values of these homes.
0:19:51 And I do like the historic downtown.
0:19:53 There were significant, you know,
0:19:55 city investment into that area.
0:19:57 And I do think there should be, you know,
0:19:59 requirement from businesses who want to operate downtown
0:20:02 because they are benefiting from the direct contributions.
0:20:06 I don't see that, you know, that's not the same thing for our neighborhoods.
0:20:11 There is no, you know, contributions to help us offset that cost.
0:20:15 It's really a labor sum, and it's very, very burdensome, and I don't think we should be pushing that on citizens who did not sign up for that.
0:20:24 You know, if you want an HOA neighborhood, it's okay.
0:20:27 You know, they're beautiful, but you should be able to choose to move into one.
0:20:31 but to have that mandated on to you, I think it's a violation of property rights.
0:20:35 So just real quick, that issue has not come before the council yet, it is in the Historic
0:20:41 Preservation Commission.
0:20:42 Yes.
0:20:43 And I would highly recommend that you get your opinions heard on that level first, because
0:20:48 then they will be the ones making the official recommendation to this board, and so by time
0:20:53 it gets here, sometimes it's a little late, but if you can talk to them and kind of work
0:20:58 through some of the things that the Council Member Hawkins is the liaison to that board
0:21:03 and he would be a great resource for you as well.
0:21:06 Perfect.
0:21:07 And so just so you kind of understand the process that it goes through.
0:21:10 Yes, and I understand that.
0:21:12 But the other problem that I did have is that I happened to pass by and hear about it on the news.
0:21:16 I did not get any sort of notification or anything that was in consideration.
0:21:21 I'm going to defer to my.
0:21:24 Okay.
0:21:25 Okay.
Download
- Transcript (text) 16 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 20 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 27 KB
- Audio (M4A) 6.6 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 30, 2021. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:27:56.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
d7b61385c814a498d104b795d828f2dca100723d5983002b5b39ae0f88dae069 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 0614f72a8c03fc5741595268b4082daac02cf2e6d0b3a0d70d95e233c442cd41 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
166ad3d7a76d1bf9bfb6ee84d89909688de7a54393fb18af10c9fa826f1048d0
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file