OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, August 9, 2021

Regular meeting. 2 recordings. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording 1 started 09:26

Recording

The transcript for this recording isn't posted yet.

Download

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 9, 2021. The recording started at 09:26 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:06:44.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    2eb8766f3008972aa26e895ce4e37be20a98182e53a7b6b4b579c68b872f6753
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a adc6f3c62319ed3a3436ad259804e7f094b5cf41ff7698a7e872e717aafff431

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file

Recording 2 started 16:59

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:01:53 We have six of the seven council members present this evening.

0:01:57 At this time we are going to say the Pledge of Allegiance,

0:01:59 and if you would like to join us, please rise.

0:02:26 Since this evening, so we will continue on.

0:02:41 I'll second that.

0:02:43 I'm a motion from Nikki Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce,

0:02:46 to approve the consent calendar as printed.

0:02:50 Amy Rollkalmope, please.

0:02:54 Hawkins?

0:02:55 Yes.

0:02:56 Ruth Pierce?

0:02:57 Yes.

0:02:58 Mr. Fareed?

0:02:58 Yes.

0:02:59 By Hawkins?

0:03:00 Yes.

0:03:01 And Nikki Boyd?

0:03:03 Yes.

0:03:04 If you were here this evening for the field of boot fundraiser, the bands at the bridge event, the Magic Valley 911 Memorial, the City of Twin Falls 911 Memorial, the summer showdown car show, or the alcohol license for Magic Valley Brewing, those were all just approved.

0:03:26 welcome to stay but you do not have under items of consideration. The first item this evening is a

0:03:34 request of a consideration of an FAA American Rescue Plan grant offer in support of our Magic

0:03:41 Valley Regional Airport and we have Bill Carberry, our airport manager. Good evening. Thank you

0:03:46 mayor. Good evening council members. So due to the coronavirus pandemic and interest of the

0:03:53 continuing support for for airports the Congress passed in the president's

0:03:58 signed the American Rescue Plan Act where it also known as ARPA back in March of

0:04:04 2021 a few months back. With any lingering effects of the virus difficult to

0:04:11 forecast the ARPA grant is a welcome source of funding to help insulate the

0:04:15 airport's operating fund for a period of time. This is the third and

0:04:21 And for simply the last of a three grand series offered to the airport as relief grants.

0:04:28 With this latest grant offer for $1,253,363, some of all three of the relief grants to

0:04:36 the airport and to the cares packages I called it is $3,464,557.

0:04:46 The grant funding is for the costs related to operations, personnel, cleaning, and improving

0:04:52 terminal building air quality.

0:04:56 The funds in large part will be reimbursed to the airport for all operational expenses

0:05:01 incurred and submitted to them for reimbursement over the next few years and held in airport

0:05:07 reserve funding.

0:05:08 The reserve funds will be utilized to make up any pandemic-related revenue losses and

0:05:15 strategic investments such as the pending terminal HVAC upgrades to improve air quality,

0:05:23 utility improvement project, and other future facility and capital investments.

0:05:29 On conclusions that recommend the City Council approve acceptance of the airport rescue plan grant offering the amount of $1,253,363 and authorize the mayor to sign the grant agreement.

0:05:46 I'm happy to stand for any questions you may have.

0:05:49 Dense, are Rescue Plan 363,

0:06:10 a motion from Niki Boit,

0:06:16 seconded by Sean Berger,

0:06:18 to approve the request to accept the grant offer as presented.

0:06:24 Dervis, Mr. Perrine,

0:06:32 Mr. Rank-Hoggins?

0:06:33 Yes.

0:06:34 Niki Boas is 6-0.

0:06:40 Thank you, Mayor.

0:06:41 Discussion?

0:06:50 This area is 1-6 from the Twin Paul City Strategic Plan

0:06:54 plan and how they relate to our fiscal year 21-22 budget so guys have seen this

0:07:14 like six times now points too much I'll just over and talk about prosperous

0:07:26 community and I still hear from our parks department I'm stuck at the end so I guess

0:07:37 I'll start by saying I was supposed to come last week and I apologize I was

0:07:43 looking forward to it and hearing what the group last week had to say but I had

0:07:48 something better to hear some. With our budget this year we were trying to hit

0:07:58 several goals and these goals are listed up here we were wanting to have a

0:08:01 sustainable budget but also one that was nimble that we could kind of react to

0:08:05 some changing environment as they come along. We wanted to have a budget that was

0:08:11 sensitive to our operating environment to our local in the last several years.

0:08:20 Now it's our incurvices and expanded services and what you're trying to do

0:08:30 is to get rid of that arsenic and then also we want to continue our efforts to be an employer.

0:08:41 I do you've seen this and I don't know how many.

0:08:48 This is our representation of our strategic plan.

0:08:51 It's got all these focus areas that we're trying to hit

0:08:54 and they all focus or they all go through

0:08:56 the employees of the organization.

0:08:58 And that's again, why we want to.

0:09:05 So this is kind of a snapshot of what falls.

0:09:09 We've got 5,000-ish residents in each day.

0:09:14 Almost the state, the median household value

0:09:44 is up to $403,000.

0:09:47 The rate is still kind of over 3%.

0:09:51 Our sales end as we prepare.

0:09:59 This shows a couple of cost indicators

0:10:01 that we follow a little bit, the municipal cost index is kind of that index that compares

0:10:07 all those kinds of things that cities spend their money on, which is a little different

0:10:10 than a consumer, but it's one that we pay attention to.

0:10:14 We also show the consumer price index, and both of those are up significantly.

0:10:18 The municipal cost index is up when the super price index is up the five months.

0:10:42 This slide is going to show you, again, you've seen these, this is going to show you the

0:10:46 trend over time. A little bit on the far right side of that slide is increases,

0:11:01 very dollars in the last year. I've had to see many questions along the way. So anyway,

0:11:28 this is kind of the overview of our budget. All the changes that we've proposed with the tax

0:11:35 collections, with the utility rate resolutions and all that stuff that's happening.

0:11:39 Basically, it's going to come to see an impact a little bit cheaper because of what the

0:12:13 city is doing in our $43 a month. So that's kind of what we're a few things going on.

0:12:27 Post budgeting and assessed value of 4.0 which is the highest we've seen for this and that's a big part of it.

0:12:51 So that makes the tax payment, drops the tax payment from $6.24 per $1,000 of assessed value.

0:12:58 The lower tax rates as we've seen.

0:13:01 That shows you kind of what I just talked about, this is a little bit better representation of what's happening to the valuation values and twin falls.

0:13:17 You can see that 4.02 billion valuation is for it last year.

0:13:25 Now it's grown in the last, but in the city tax,

0:13:51 going with happening to the tax rate,

0:13:52 with those increasing values,

0:13:54 you can see the tax rates are coming now.

0:13:56 I'm 0.0062 proposed tax rate for the fiscal year 2022.

0:14:07 I've seen this slide the last several weeks too.

0:14:10 What this shows you is that we're incorporating

0:14:12 our 3% statutory tax increase and annexation.

0:14:26 All those things make up that tax rate,

0:14:29 previous couple slides that we have a dress

0:14:38 and so you have a dress and so you should relax

0:14:39 and see it in deduction.

0:14:42 As of what we're doing with the arsenic feed,

0:14:44 That also allows zero rate is not proposed to change at all.

0:14:55 What I do want to talk a little bit about tonight, more so than the rest of the slide is the last one

0:15:00 out of the sanitation recycling.

0:15:03 If you remember last week, that was a proposed increase of 0.68 percent of increase that amount.

0:15:13 As I reached out to us recently in the last couple of weeks,

0:15:16 and costs are going up for labor operations for proposing a 5 percent increase for PSI,

0:15:23 which equals a 3 percent increase to the customer.

0:15:27 And so that's what this 3% that recommend is to any questions that we've seen this slide.

0:15:43 This goes back to the conversation we were just having about the water rate.

0:15:46 You make the changes to the ideas that we have these big capital projects out there.

0:15:57 And we also have this kind of need to maintain our water lines.

0:16:01 And we can start knocking some of those capital projects out and adding money to our...

0:16:18 Sorry, I'm sorry.

0:16:19 I'm sorry.

0:16:22 My person equates to about...

0:16:23 And we have this telling you I know so about a sixty cent per month that'll change that get that changed on next week's slides

0:16:42 We were just kind of picking this up as we go so the slide early right talked about the dollar forty three cheaper

0:16:57 So first we're gonna jump into focus area

0:17:37 talking about Healthy Communities, my favorite part of the strategic plan and I

0:17:42 thought before we would really dive into our requests we wanted to talk a little

0:17:47 bit about Healthy Community and how we support Healthy Community objectives with

0:17:54 our programs and facilities and open spaces. So instead of putting a bunch of

0:18:01 numbers up there for you I thought it just brings some pictures of different

0:18:04 spaces of people using them, which we saw a great deal of increases last year and

0:18:12 obviously continuing this year. We offer over 1,500 acres of public space in

0:18:18 over 80 different spaces, including parks, playgrounds, ball fields, splash pads,

0:18:24 buildings, landscaped areas around the community. We have over 10 miles of

0:18:28 asphalt trail and 30 miles of dirt trail, probably a little bit more because people

0:18:33 make them every, and about 430 acres of manicured grass.

0:18:40 It's really difficult to gauge use when we talk about numbers

0:18:44 of people using our spaces.

0:18:46 Obviously, at Shosham Falls, we collect a vehicle fee,

0:18:49 and so we can get an idea of how many vehicles are driving

0:18:53 in the Shosham Falls, and I can tell you

0:18:54 that when we pulled the numbers about a week ago,

0:18:58 we were at 7893, and that was a little bit lower

0:19:02 than last year.

0:19:04 Yeah, I think a little bit lower than last year,

0:19:07 and we had the ticket booth close for a couple of months,

0:19:11 last year, so we're down a little,

0:19:13 and I'm assuming part of that's the water.

0:19:17 And then the other thing that we kind of thought

0:19:20 about doing a couple years ago is using our reservations.

0:19:24 And so I pulled, one person pulled in for me two years ago,

0:19:30 and another person pulled in for me at this time,

0:19:32 and I don't know how to compare them,

0:19:34 so I'm not going to, but I know what we did this year,

0:19:36 so we can do it moving forward.

0:19:38 But we had 1,937 park use requests.

0:19:45 So that's things that go outside of this kind of stuff.

0:19:51 This is, these are people that are doing

0:19:55 picnics, birthday parties, things that they want

0:19:57 to reserve space for, ask for use of space

0:20:01 in order to get permission.

0:20:04 So that shows you, I mean, that's the best way I can do it,

0:20:08 sort of standing out at the parks and counting people

0:20:10 when they walk in and walk out and counting people

0:20:12 on the trail.

0:20:14 So before we really dive into the,

0:20:18 as our next step, when we talk about the

0:20:20 healthy community and the strategic plan,

0:20:23 we are first objectivists to seek opportunities

0:20:25 to expand the trail.

0:20:27 And so instead of talking about new things right now,

0:20:30 I wanna talk a little bit about what we have done.

0:20:33 And so the Breckenridge connection was a huge connection for us.

0:20:38 That gave us 7.4 miles of continuous Canyon Rep Trail

0:20:44 at this point, which realizes a dream that was hatched years ago

0:20:49 and enormous accomplishment, I think.

0:20:53 We also were able to add a little bit of trail

0:20:55 to the Old Town Parkway down in Rock Creek

0:21:00 when they're cooperation with the Urban Renewal Agency.

0:21:04 We got that one in, and I suppose I need to mention

0:21:06 that we didn't pay very much for that

0:21:08 recognition connection.

0:21:09 That was a map tag on private donors as well.

0:21:13 But, and then the last one, I just throw it up there.

0:21:16 As we look for opportunities, we have an opportunity

0:21:20 to expand some trail on the west side of town.

0:21:22 And we'll probably be talking about that

0:21:24 a little bit more later on, but it gives us

0:21:26 some pretty neat views right above that bend

0:21:29 in the river near honor falls.

0:21:31 So we're continuing to work toward those things.

0:21:35 As we, before I start talking about our requests,

0:21:40 we thought it would be fun to talk a little bit

0:21:43 about some of our accomplishments

0:21:44 and the things that we've accomplished

0:21:46 over the last few years in our budgeting process.

0:21:49 So you know we use our individual plans to kind of,

0:21:53 we've been working on park plans

0:21:55 and then we come up with capital projects

0:21:58 that meet those plans, and we've been doing that for a few years,

0:22:02 and so instead of starting to just flat out with requests,

0:22:06 I thought we'd show you some of our accomplishments

0:22:10 over the last few years as we've used these dollars,

0:22:12 and I've invited Todd Anderson, the Park Supervisor,

0:22:16 to come and talk about some of these accomplishments

0:22:20 over the last few years.

0:22:31 Okay, first slide we have, others ago, it's failing,

0:22:45 But we'd go into parking lot maintenance.

0:23:49 We did the landscaping, that's from the city's street spotter.

0:24:39 We also did another project that had to do with asphalt.

0:24:42 It was a some way parking lot.

0:24:43 We did a reseal on that one, which we strived.

0:24:50 We were here, it was here.

0:25:19 The thoughts, the storage, it was messy.

0:25:25 It was a lot of stuff to go through.

0:25:28 But through it all, it's got to be with parks.

0:25:32 He really dove in there and really made it happen.

0:25:35 We planned sidewalks with those in the spring, accessible dock system,

0:26:33 gained a store, we got tables in there, access to that restroom,

0:26:41 the concession stand, and all shelters are all connected,

0:26:45 that same sidewalk.

0:26:58 Cascade, a hard-walk system, we did an ADM,

0:27:13 a sidewalk store, the restroom, the vault court,

0:27:16 it tested a sand on where they could load sand.

0:27:51 We used the old buildings, we also did inflatables,

0:28:20 which we also had, also did slowly kind of going through.

0:29:31 for the next one, and I don't know how this is going to work, but it seems like when I click, it starts, so I'm going to preface it, and then click.

0:30:07 So John Pauli wanted to talk to you about his request of $175,000 for the pool membrane, and so he made, wait a minute, I got my slides on order.

0:30:22 So this is a little harder to capture in pictures, but this just kind of overviews our uses and as you can see

0:30:31 We're balancing back

0:30:33 We're less than

0:30:35 2019, but we're getting we're coming back and I don't know how much of that is just kind of the trend

0:30:42 Nationally of people doing more things on their own and doing less organized sports kinds of things, but

0:30:48 This just kind of gives you an idea of how we're reaching the people through our programming so

0:30:54 As you know, we tend to, we've been working more from lump sums and less itemized projects,

0:31:05 giving you every little detail of the project and asking for money for each piece of it,

0:31:10 which gives us a little more flexibility, both in a project like Cascade,

0:31:15 where maybe the sidewalks came out higher and the building came out lower,

0:31:18 and we're not back here constantly asking for shifting money from one side to the other.

0:31:24 and that's partly why we wanted to go back and kind of highlight that so you can see how that's working and what that's looking like.

0:31:31 It also gives us the flexibility as we move into things to respond to priorities and things that come up.

0:31:39 The budget or the strategic plan is going to broken down into two halves.

0:31:44 The maintenance side and then enhancements and planning.

0:31:53 So on the maintenance side, we're looking for another $250,000 for parking lots that is

0:32:02 usually driven by public works and engineering and we work off of their zone maintenance plan.

0:32:07 I don't know which parking lots are on the list, but the whole piece that we can stop rebuilding

0:32:12 them and start maintaining them better so that we don't have these huge rebuilds.

0:32:18 and park had gotten way too far down the line,

0:32:21 and so hopefully we can stay on top of that.

0:32:24 Trail maintenance, park facility maintenance,

0:32:28 as Todd was talking about that recreation facility maintenance

0:32:31 is where we are doing the dugout repairs

0:32:35 and working on the ball fields

0:32:36 and doing some of those kinds of things.

0:32:39 We're also looking to do a golf course parking lot upgrade.

0:32:42 That parking lot slopes pretty significantly,

0:32:45 And we do not have ADA access, so that's the last piece of the ADA part of the golf course

0:32:51 is to fix that parking lot and fix the ramp going into the clubhouse.

0:32:58 They also want to upgrade a couple of pieces of equipment.

0:33:01 And I just have to note that Todd ran out and took a picture of those tractors for me

0:33:05 on Friday morning.

0:33:06 And if anybody was outside on Friday morning, you will know that that picture does not have

0:33:11 any kind of filter on it.

0:33:13 with the air like right touching. And then the city pool resurfacing piece. So now I'm

0:33:19 gonna hit my button and hopefully John's little video will play. I don't know if there's

0:33:24 sound. Oh, there's Dr. Phoebe sound. He narrates this whole thing. Okay. Well, he did a beautiful

0:33:34 job. I'm just gonna tell you, he narrated it greatly. I wanted him to have some fun with

0:33:38 it, but this is really kind of like those old school elementary educational videos. But

0:33:44 along in this short is as the pool is aging, once the surface starts to break down, the

0:33:54 water can deteriorate the plaster.

0:33:56 And he brought me a box of plaster and I forgot to show it to you because I thought his video

0:34:00 was so good.

0:34:01 But he's showing you where it's bubbling up on the bottom, kind of like a volcano, and

0:34:07 then that breaks free and causes more holes.

0:34:11 And as the under part gets exposed, it continues to deteriorate.

0:34:15 And so the plan is to, I think it's, see, he describes it so well, but I think it's to

0:34:22 patch it and then you put a membrane over the top of it.

0:34:25 It's a different way of doing it.

0:34:29 And the hope is that the membrane is more of a plastic membrane, which won't be as susceptible

0:34:37 to the leaching of the chemicals in the pool.

0:34:41 So, I'm sorry, John, and then in addition, our capital improvement, or developing and improving

0:34:55 our facilities, we're asking for $25,000, and that's the recreation department, does that

0:35:02 with their program equipment, things are doing, rolling replacements on equipment, and they

0:35:07 purchase new things like soccer goals or things to do new programming.

0:35:12 We'd like to work on the social and falls ticket bids, see if we can't come up with a

0:35:17 The design that allows the ticket booth staff to sit in the booth and not have to stand on the side of the road, hit their feet run over and drop cash on the road.

0:35:27 And then facility enhancement, $300,000 and then another $300,000 down at Shosho Falls and Jerky's like, we have a couple of ideas of things we'd like to do down there.

0:35:42 So, do you have any questions?

0:35:47 in a little de-dancements, are those things we've already talked about?

0:35:53 No, so we haven't, that's what we've used this money for before, so I was showing you

0:35:58 kind of what it looks like. This year, again, we want to be able to be sort of flexible depending

0:36:04 on what comes up first, but there's able-can-evil jumps, I would like to do some work out there.

0:36:12 We are looking at the frontier park.

0:36:16 The pickleball of course phase one is complete.

0:36:19 We're working on phase two.

0:36:20 We got some money this year in capital B. I think it was actually a council funded project.

0:36:26 But the money we got doesn't give us the entire project.

0:36:29 It gets the courts in, but it doesn't get the sidewalk around the outside or the lights.

0:36:34 We're also hoping at some point that Rotary is going to be able to come through with that

0:36:38 restroom and so there will be some additional work that needs to be done

0:36:42 with that, trying to kind of time that with these other two projects. So right

0:36:47 now we're kind of thinking frontier and evil, Knievel would probably be our

0:36:51 next, next projects with the facility enhancement dollars. That's what's on the

0:36:58 docket at the moment. We did hear from a citizen asking about Harrison Park and

0:37:06 So that plan is that one that plan is being built right now

0:37:12 Okay, and I intend to reach out to her and ask her to help us with that plan

0:37:17 I've given her the timeline several times

0:37:20 But I think she just goes over there and gets frustrated

0:37:24 What's you to know?

0:37:25 What do you think on that? What is that like two years down the road or where we would what is it?

0:37:30 I look at the timeline. I think that

0:37:33 that plan is

0:37:36 on for right now. Remember, we pulled those out and we got those funded mid-year, so

0:37:44 Harrison was one of those, and so we're getting that process started on Harrison

0:37:49 right now. And then when we get the plan done, then it'll be kind of... Basically

0:37:56 what I'm seeing with these smaller parks is that they tend to be curved in

0:38:00 grass and amenities with no connections. So I know one of the things will probably

0:38:06 we'd be creating a structure of sidewalks to get to the different amenities in that

0:38:13 park besides just parking on the side of the road and walking through the grass.

0:38:17 I'm not sure what all Tammy has in mind and I'd like her to be involved in that

0:38:23 process and reach out to any other citizens that have any interest in that

0:38:27 park to see what else maybe we can do there that would better meet the needs in

0:38:32 that area. So, to park facility enhancements are things like playground equipment, restroom,

0:38:43 right. When we talk about enhancements, it would be either adding amenities to a park

0:38:50 or a major overhaul of something like leveling the cascade restroom and building a new one.

0:39:06 With understanding, some are in there because where you spend the money and when you spend

0:39:17 the money, have a list of the projects and when, you know, Harrison Park.

0:39:23 Yes, we do have, we do have a list of, so when we do three plan, we've been doing three

0:39:33 plans a year and obviously we can't keep up. We cannot do these major park construction

0:39:42 projects at three a year. And so what we started to do a couple years ago was back

0:39:48 we were working on some of the bigger ones.

0:39:50 So the first year I think we looked at doing Harmon in Frontier and I don't remember there was a third one.

0:39:57 And you know those were over $400,000 to $500,000 a piece probably in major projects.

0:40:04 So we started trying to do a bigger one and then adding a couple of the smaller parks like Sunrise and Harrison

0:40:10 so that those improvements could be done along with in a budget cycle with maybe a bigger project.

0:40:17 project, or maybe lumping several of those smaller ones together.

0:40:23 But I can get you a list of kind of what we've done so far.

0:40:27 We keep wanting to come and talk to you about the park plans and show you what they look

0:40:30 like.

0:40:31 And we can maybe do that and you can see which plans we're working on, which ones we've been

0:40:38 putting money toward and where we are as far as a calendar as to what's coming up next.

0:40:47 Would that be helpful?

0:40:48 That would be extremely helpful because understanding that you're in a situation where labor costs are going up, material costs are going up, and so utilizing up wisely, but understanding what next year, two years, three years, especially for parks where we have some older parks and some of the equipment there is a little bit older, would help, especially with the type of budgeting we have here, understanding where those lump sums could be spent.

0:41:13 We're here this evening, the airport under the prosperous community, and I just wanted

0:41:44 to maybe steal a minute to talk a little bit about air service before we get into talking

0:41:50 about our pleasure to request.

0:41:51 So from time to time, I'm an opportunist, and I'll try to throw you a little monthly

0:41:55 year over year to let you know how the recovery is going out there in Jaws and Fields.

0:42:00 So this is a July snapshot, a fairly complete month, I think there for 2019 as the green

0:42:07 line, but things would go go before the pandemic, July of 2020, a year ago, you could see we were

0:42:15 starting to get some summer activity, or anemic, certainly up by historical standards, but compared

0:42:21 to March when we were crawling around that zero number to 10 people a day, three days a week, I

0:42:28 think it got to be that bad. So, and then in yellow, you'll see this July that we just had,

0:42:37 So the good news here is that you can see our yellow, our current year, is up to sort of a historical average with 2019.

0:42:45 But really the wrinkle in this is we do have a fourth flight and in 2019 we had three flights to Salt Lake.

0:42:53 This year we still host three flights to Salt Lake on Delta, but we do have the United Flight.

0:43:00 So with that, really, the shirt on that is that United

0:43:05 Flight is selling very well.

0:43:06 Skywest is very happy with how that's selling.

0:43:10 However, the Delta flights, three flights a day, are not

0:43:13 quite up to speed.

0:43:14 It's going to take a little longer to recover.

0:43:17 I think we're off probably by 20% or so on in

0:43:20 payments with Delta on a daily month average.

0:43:24 So we certainly hope as they recover that we'll see the

0:43:27 yellow line even increase a little bit more.

0:43:29 So we'll have to stay tuned.

0:43:31 The council I got from Sky West went discussing Delta's

0:43:35 performance and their recovery were much like other markets

0:43:39 that feed into Salt Lake.

0:43:40 So they're not surprised to see our Delta numbers

0:43:43 at this level.

0:43:44 So that was good to hear that we're

0:43:46 in step with really the industry recovery

0:43:48 on the Delta side.

0:43:49 So any questions on this before I move on?

0:43:53 I just wanted to take a moment to give you a snapshot on this.

0:44:00 So the airport, as a piece of infrastructure,

0:44:05 really our small community out there,

0:44:07 we have many, many disciplines

0:44:09 in many various strategic goal areas

0:44:11 from accessible to safe and secure, responsible,

0:44:15 prosperous, we have goals within all of those areas,

0:44:18 for instance, accessible, is very much like our public works,

0:44:22 our maintenance, how we maintain the airport,

0:44:25 safety and security, we have public safety departments

0:44:29 out there that assist us as well as our operations department responsible.

0:44:35 We do master planning those types of things and prosperous.

0:44:37 We certainly hope to be platform for prosperity.

0:44:42 So tonight we'll look at just a few primary budgetary items that we wanted to look at

0:44:48 and those are in the safety security areas.

0:44:51 I've got two of my esteemed colleagues, Matt Barnes here and Ryan Johnson.

0:44:56 Matt is our operations supervisor for several years now.

0:45:00 Matt, one of the things that's really important about our safety and security side is that

0:45:06 we have partners in the FAA and the Department of Homeland Security and TSA that visit us,

0:45:13 inspect us regularly. We have one major inspection by the FAA every year. TSA seems to hang around

0:45:21 a lot, Ryan, and keep up with what we're doing. So we're closely regulated and it's critical

0:45:28 that we pass the muster in these areas and Easter gentlemen are a big part of us

0:45:33 maintaining our operating certificate being a safe secure and efficient airport

0:45:37 out there so so with that I'll introduce Matt Barnes to talk about one a couple of

0:45:43 our safety items in our next year's budget so I'll be talking to you guys about a

0:45:58 couple of the key capital requests for safety and the accessible community

0:46:05 goals that we have in this slide you'll notice that we've got a lot of this

0:46:11 really nice black pavement with sharp markings. This is kind of shows an

0:46:18 example of our ability to take advantage of some of those FAA funded

0:46:22 projects and you can see that they've got a lot of our painted asphalt markings

0:46:27 nice and dressed up in crisp. All total we have approximately 1,500 gallons

0:46:33 worth of painted asphalt markings at the airport. These markings are critical for

0:46:42 those FAA inspections that Bill mentioned. This is a big part of our inspection to

0:46:47 make sure that we're adhering to all the FAA standards as far as how they look,

0:46:51 their condition, their size, that kind of thing. For decades the airports partnered

0:46:58 with the Street Department to help make sure that we maintain these and like I

0:47:02 mentioned we also utilize FAA funded projects as much as possible. We're very

0:47:09 grateful for those partnerships and we do anticipate that the those partnerships

0:47:15 with the street department and the FAA will continue. However we are finding that

0:47:20 additional equipment to help make sure we do the daily maintenance and annual

0:47:25 maintenance on our markings to make sure that they pass FAA standards. So the photo

0:47:37 that you'll see on the left side of your screen is a picture of our current

0:47:42 equipment with a couple of our team members working on a runway marking the

0:47:48 right-hand side you'll see what the $33,500 request could purchase us. The

0:47:56 equipment's not a lot larger but you'll notice that the capacities are more than

0:48:00 double so it'll give us more capability to do more of these markings in-house and

0:48:07 and make sure that we adhere to the FAA standards.

0:48:15 This additional equipment with the street department and take advantage of every

0:48:21 FAA-funded project possible. Next, it is a $40,000 request

0:48:34 for these lighted runway closure markers. These are a critical piece of

0:48:39 safety for whenever we need to close down a runway

0:48:43 for things like maintenance, like painting it, or even if we have

0:48:47 an accident or incident where the runway is no longer usable to aircraft. The purpose

0:48:54 of these is to provide a visual cue to pilots. It's kind of that last line of defense to make

0:49:00 sure that they know that runway is not safe. In addition, we would continue to do what we

0:49:07 do now. We issue notice to airmen which go out nationally over a digital system that pilots

0:49:13 can look up to see what the condition of runways and the tax

0:49:17 ways are at the Twin Falls Airport.

0:49:20 We also communicate very carefully over two-way radio

0:49:23 with air traffic control.

0:49:24 So they'll help us make sure pilots

0:49:26 understand what's going on.

0:49:28 And then with this acquisition, we

0:49:30 could have that final visual cue that this runway's not safe.

0:49:37 They are portable.

0:49:38 They are completely collapsible, and they're

0:49:41 self-sustaining units, the 40,000 would get to.

0:49:50 That's the end of my portion of the presentation.

0:49:53 I'd be happy to answer any questions if you have any.

0:50:05 Brian Johnson, the Airport Operations and Security Coordinator

0:50:08 will be able to talk about security upgrades.

0:50:11 Thank you.

0:50:19 Councilor Johnson, the Operations and Security Coordinator.

0:50:25 Over the past year, I've been pretty closely with the city IT department

0:50:31 department, and we've been finding issues with our current access control system.

0:50:40 So, it is a cost of $65,000.

0:50:49 This will integrate the airport's security system with the current city system, and it

0:50:56 will give us new vehicle gate hardware, door hardware, place all existing cameras and add

0:51:08 additional cameras in high volume, high traffic areas to make it a little bit more secure.

0:51:16 And with the only insecurity, there's always adding regulations or adopting security reports,

0:51:29 and this would allow the airport in the future to easily adapt to any of those.

0:51:34 So I have a short video that we currently have and we would like to switch to all of these cameras.

0:51:47 This is a KC-135 aerial refueler that visits us once a week from Salt Lake City.

0:51:56 This next clip is, I'm sure you guys have heard of the corporate beach jet that was disabled on our runway.

0:52:11 way and this is a video of the incident with two flat main gear tires. That is what a blown

0:52:21 out tire on a airplane looks like. This fire department allowing us to get the inaugural

0:52:31 flight of Denver, Twin Falls Airport, the water gun salute. That is gonna be...

0:52:44 Like a Facebook page of social media like some of the other city departments.

0:52:56 Fourth with a lot of social media that is expected, I think, so at this time, yeah, we've not entered the social media realm.

0:53:17 We do have a website, we do market air service, and we're working closely with tourism, the chamber.

0:53:25 I fly at Twin Falls, and I believe some of the marketing going on may also have some social media components to it as well, so I spoke a little bit too soon.

0:53:36 So, in regards to air service, yes, we certainly have made some great strides, but just as an entity, as the airport, for a variety of things that may be happening out there we don't.

0:53:58 So you talk about the integration between Police Department, is this something that, because of this, our Police Department would be able to monitor this as well?

0:54:07 So the access control system for the city, it would be the same as city hall, fire department, police department.

0:54:17 So in any emergency situation, anybody with access to that would be able to access cameras from our control tower in the building.

0:54:29 So even city dispatch, if they had access to it, they would be able to see that as well.

0:54:35 So currently we don't have that.

0:54:37 Currently we do not, we are in a separate

0:54:39 Access Control System.

0:54:41 So let's look at us there.

0:54:42 That's wonderful.

0:55:17 At this point in the budget process,

0:55:19 I get to speak for the council.

0:55:21 We appreciate all of the videos and pictures very much.

0:55:24 That's it for focus areas one and six.

0:55:32 If you have any more questions for either of these two teams,

0:55:34 let us know, because I'm going to change the subject on you

0:55:37 if you don't pay.

0:55:40 So we got to this point in the presentation in the past,

0:55:44 We've started talking about what we haven't budgeted yet,

0:55:46 that's for you to give us some input on.

0:55:49 And so that's that $770,000 of council capital

0:55:52 that we've had for the last few years.

0:55:54 And last week we showed you a couple of,

0:55:57 I think in response to your question,

0:55:59 a few weeks ago, we put together three different slides

0:56:01 of what some of those options might be doing.

0:56:05 So I'll go through those again.

0:56:06 I know you had some questions last week

0:56:08 I'll try to maybe answer some of those.

0:56:11 The first page here is the category B capital request,

0:56:15 and I want to explain to you what that means.

0:56:17 That means that departments made a budget request

0:56:20 through the long-term planning committee.

0:56:22 Long-term planning committee included it

0:56:24 into the department's budget request

0:56:26 that the budget committee looked at,

0:56:29 balancing committee cut it.

0:56:31 Okay, so these have made it farther through the process

0:56:35 and they were cut at the last minute to balance the budget.

0:56:38 And that's what category B means.

0:56:40 So, these are those things in the budget that made it through all those other earlier processes

0:56:45 that were until that's kind of a list of, I don't necessarily need to go.

0:56:58 The second one, the term planning committee cuts.

0:57:01 So, these would be the request that made it to the long-term planning committee,

0:57:04 but didn't make it out of the long-term planning committee.

0:57:06 So, these are ones that projects in there last paid.

0:57:21 You just ask what are some other things that we can consider?

0:57:27 And these are to treat and sidewalk projects that you have in the last couple years.

0:57:35 So these are a few of those that were still kind of hanging out there.

0:57:39 You know, so there's a couple of benchmarks for prices, right?

0:57:43 So, I don't know, six months or so ago, Aaron Steele came and talked to you about our sidewalk master plan.

0:57:49 It's got like 25 different projects in that we've shown too.

0:57:54 There's a lot more to be concerned with.

0:57:59 We could certainly grab the price for that one.

0:58:00 The park improvements, this is the $300,000 that Wendy was talking about.

0:58:06 have a list of those park projects. What they're going to be able to fund with the $300,000.

0:58:12 So if you just had some money that you wanted to throw up toward that list,

0:58:15 you can find some of those prices. But as we don't know with them,

0:58:27 floral, I threw back up there just so you know these prices for floral are the

0:58:32 prices that we showed you last year when we decided not to fund it last year.

0:58:38 And so we haven't updated these prices. I know they're your old and I know they're not good anymore.

0:58:44 So if you have an interest in proceeding with something on Floral,

0:58:47 we'll have to go back and update the prices with some of those MCI increases.

0:58:55 These are going to be low. If you want to do something with Floral,

0:58:58 we'll have to come back and adjust those prices for you.

0:59:01 And so with that, believe I heard you have some questions about

0:59:07 specifically at BLEX-Chord-Work, right?

0:59:19 Open government.

0:59:21 And open government.

0:59:22 And open government.

0:59:23 Open government as well. I've started working with new teams.

0:59:25 So OpenGov is basically a permitting software.

0:59:32 And it's not really a software, it's a web-based thing, so we would just kind of sign up to use this web-based, so we just use Google Chrome, or a really soft runner, but it's this permitting technology that would help us better.

0:59:59 So that permits, permits, right away permits, planning and zoning applications for SUPs. It would basically be for the second floor of this building.

1:00:09 but not special events for that time.

1:00:12 Actually, I just had to take that back.

1:00:15 It could be those as well.

1:00:16 It would be basically, okay, let me limit it

1:00:19 to the city hall permitting, right?

1:00:20 So if you came in for a license for an alcohol business,

1:00:25 especially if you don't use it now,

1:00:28 because we don't use it now,

1:00:29 because we don't have to use laser fish now

1:00:31 for a lot of those processes.

1:00:34 It could be used for those as well.

1:00:36 And I remember any stuff we call you,

1:00:39 so also use it for code enforcement activities.

1:00:43 So it's basically a process that would sort of replace city works,

1:00:47 if hand a little bit more, the difference between this and city works would be trying

1:00:56 to figure out how to explain this.

1:00:57 It's easy to use their hand staff.

1:01:06 So easy to use for the customer that's coming in, but also really easy for the staff to set

1:01:14 up new processes.

1:01:15 So we've had city works now for city works going in years later, 12 years later, we still can't with city works.

1:01:38 The cities that are successful with city works have basically a full-time IT guy person.

1:01:44 And so we muddle through it with, so when you create a new permit process, like an SUP, right?

1:02:07 So none of our planning and zoning applications are going through city works right now.

1:02:11 We're going to create an SUP application process through city works.

1:02:14 It would take one of our staff, this other open-gov software, it's like the MS-DOS programming in, and so that's kind of the selfish reason why I think that would be really cool.

1:02:44 Other piece of it that's actually probably the more driving factor is the parentcy, then starts it released to the public because it's got all these kind of built-in sort of reporting tools.

1:02:58 Anybody can go and look at the website and figure out on the fly it updates every night, you know,

1:03:09 in the city where you go once a month and it takes us like seven days to get all that information out.

1:03:22 This is the parentcy stuff that's hit open gov. It's just kind of automatically updates those numbers every night.

1:03:31 And the next day you have it. So the open gov permitting is really started out as a transparency and a better communication tool.

1:03:43 And as we got into it, we found out that it also might cost it's up there $111,000 is a one-year cost.

1:03:56 That gives us some programming effort from the software provider to get our stuff up and going.

1:04:03 It gives us some education to teach us how to do some of these things ourselves.

1:04:08 That it gets us our first year of if we spend that $100.

1:04:16 Even in the coming years, we'll have continuing in all license fees, and that's what the little

1:04:21 district is.

1:04:22 It tends to be something like 37 or so, 40, so I just want to make sure, provide just a

1:04:34 little bit of a clear answer, so they're city works is used by multiple departments across

1:04:41 our organization, and there's two pieces.

1:04:44 One is going to be the permitting side, which is what Mitch is talking about.

1:04:49 John and the public works team use city works on that application and that's not going away

1:04:55 and this doesn't replace that. In fact, they've been incredibly successful with what they're doing on public works with lands developing their maintenance schedules and replacement schedules.

1:05:08 But it becomes probably that foundation of the GIS model that it doesn't go.

1:05:17 I know that we have a city works enterprise license, we're one of the original customers

1:05:24 into city works and because we may be using less of the city works program does not mean

1:05:32 that we will pay less for the city works software.

1:05:35 So there is no savings in the city works site per se by moving to this model because their

1:05:42 costs are largely built on population of the community, which is the driving, the costs

1:05:49 of this would be enhancement to those people who are doing permitting applications in the

1:05:55 organization, but it doesn't have or generate cost savings in other departments, and John

1:06:00 and his team will continue to utilize city works.

1:06:04 So the half, it's really two half city works is an asset management piece, and it's a licensing

1:06:09 permitting piece, and this would only replace the licensed permitting piece, and actually

1:06:13 like Travis said they're really quite happy and I should probably to be fair to

1:06:18 City Works. Placed with City Works is so much better when you're in place so it's

1:06:26 not by any means trash, right? It's a good program. It's way better what we had before from the permitting

1:06:32 side of it. There won't be a savings if we go with this from the City Works site.

1:06:37 Right. Sean Bericher? Yes, just a general comment I would make about that. First of all, thanks for clarifying what that was because I was the one who asked that question last week.

1:06:45 Do you see the value of the F side and also making it work?

1:06:54 We'll say as a user of some of the through laser fish,

1:07:03 like with special net applications,

1:07:05 has been converted to a more present,

1:07:10 we've made some pretty good net processes.

1:07:15 An application is extremely way easier than it used to be

1:07:18 being dead if there aren't.

1:07:26 I guess I would be supportive of this particular item

1:07:29 staying in the category price because that's sort of driven

1:07:36 It's easy to say, well, it makes it a little easier for folks to create in the forums, it makes it a little easier for the people using it.

1:07:50 It's still 150,000 the first year. What is the cost benefit of that?

1:08:01 Pour it out seven days earlier than aggressive about.

1:08:16 So the question I have mentioned, this software is, would it improve the time it takes to improve it?

1:08:25 Do you expect any improvement on that time?

1:08:30 I would say it's hard to measure that exactly, but I would say not directly, but it might improve vacation with the customer.

1:08:44 And what I mean by that is basically we'd have the ability for everything to be electronic applications.

1:08:56 We have some electronic applications and others that are not, and if you make a building permit application for the actual structure, right now that's got to come in and it's got to be input into the system.

1:09:10 It's not electronic mechanical electrical plumbing. Those are electronic. If you make one of those applications and you want to know where you're at the computer and it'll give you a real-time status, but for building permits you can.

1:09:25 So what happens is they pick up the phone and they call and the guy who's doing the plan review has to answer the phone and stop doing what he's doing to give you the update on your process.

1:09:37 Okay, it's asked him that was over in this person's desk and the benefit of opening up is you would notice emails say here at this stage, here at this stage.

1:09:54 When you want it to call for your inspection, you don't have to call anymore and leave a voicemail on the line.

1:10:01 You do it on the commuter schedule for tomorrow and stuff, so I think there'll be little pickups and inefficiency.

1:10:09 I don't believe it's going to be days off of your permit, or on this page, to get the UX corridor study.

1:10:33 So, UX corridor study would be currently working on with our general master transportation plan.

1:10:44 That's going to be a big city-wide focus on

1:10:46 Warner Streets to look and notice that this would be specifically a study

1:10:55 to improve capacity and crease weight.

1:10:59 And it's not just blue lakes, the study would look at the north-south corridors

1:11:06 that are near my blue lakes that could be improved.

1:11:09 For example, because we know that some of that traffic will move over to that road

1:11:23 like it does now on Locust on the other side if you do that.

1:11:26 So the study will give a lot more detail about that kind of thing.

1:11:29 It would give us some really good ammunition to go to, not a city road, to make some of these improvements.

1:11:43 It would also give us really good information for federal and state grants that might be used for some of those projects that come out of that study.

1:11:52 The hope there would be to do something pretty much north with a specific focus on projects could be done.

1:12:11 Another thing I'll tell you that this didn't make the budget request, which is from Planning

1:12:22 Committee, because we also included this in the upcoming Impact Fee program that you haven't

1:12:27 seen yet, but you know it's incoming.

1:12:29 In fact, tomorrow night at the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting the Planning and Zoning

1:12:33 Commission is going to have their hearing to make a recommendation to the City Council on

1:12:37 the Impact Fee program.

1:12:40 $100,000 is included in the Street Impact Fee program.

1:12:44 Right now, assuming that program gets approved, when it comes all the way through the process, there's a funding source that'll come with that.

1:12:52 So maybe this isn't the greatest place for a year 770, but it was one of those projects that was cut out.

1:12:58 If you don't fund it here, there will be an opportunity to fund it with the impact fees, some street impact fees, because it is definitely a growth-related improvements that can help.

1:13:07 That's kind of what that explained as well.

1:13:13 expenses later, cost savings for the taxpayers?

1:13:30 In a couple of steps. So the program that you're going to see following the recommendation from

1:13:37 Planning and Zoning Commission will include the $100,000 of the study. Now when you complete the study,

1:13:43 the study will identify maybe some projects, then we could amend the program to include funding for the projects.

1:13:51 Or, as for grant letees, or projects will be as the first step once we know those projects that we can find out using back fees potentially to fund some of the projects themselves.

1:14:05 But in what you'll see next month, that's not there yet, just the study would be there.

1:14:10 I believe there was a question last week about the digesters.

1:14:21 I need to answer yet, but maybe next week.

1:14:24 We're doing a little research on that one still.

1:14:27 I just wanted a question, so remind me when the hearing was here with the sidewalk master plan with those

1:14:39 projects prioritized

1:14:42 Like a one two three four five order. They all had there's like 25. I want to say projects in there

1:14:49 They all had kind of pros and cons

1:14:52 But they didn't like idea was specifically not to rank them

1:14:58 But rather if you find the opportunity

1:15:02 So if we found $100,000 one year, let's jump on that excellent one, $100,000 is not even

1:15:14 going to touch the Elizabeth one, right?

1:15:16 So it did give us good cost estimates and it did give us pros and cons of each project,

1:15:21 but it didn't rank coming in comparison to one another.

1:15:23 Do we know where we're at cost wise on the Wendell Street Project?

1:15:27 Do we maybe need to be looking at some of our funds to help complete one that we started last year?

1:15:33 I know that projects underway and don't hear us working on it, I'm not sure where he is at.

1:15:43 I'm not sure where I'm at, but I can now get to bring it back next week as well.

1:15:47 Actually anything sidewalk related would be important to me because that's kind of worth this $770,000 started

1:15:55 and what we were really focused on with it and just, you know, the question mark with sidewalk projects

1:16:02 that we should probably be

1:16:11 getting that information out of our system from past meetings is just a lot of these are little pieces that we could talk at.

1:16:22 I know one time we were talking about that piece along Falls Avenue just east of Blue Lakes and I think some of that got maybe,

1:16:32 but I know there were a lot of bits and pieces of things that maybe just a quick.

1:16:36 Some of those projects in the past ended up in the hills of the rock tree projects that we worked on.

1:17:00 Maybe it just kind of hey this is how we finished or this is where we ended up.

1:17:04 up and bring this up off the wall when we were talking about the planning and zoning issues

1:17:34 out off of Washington where that new housing corner is going in. On the east side of Washington

1:17:43 there are some apartments already in without sidewalk. I would just be curious how that

1:17:50 got developed with that sidewalks being put in there. Do we have some kind of an agreement?

1:18:06 There's something we gave some of those neighbors concerns about connectivity over there too.

1:18:14 I'm just throwing ideas of things we've talked about this year.

1:18:18 Good to listen, Steve.

1:18:33 And we also, so understanding, I appreciate that Marrow talking about sidewalks, but also

1:18:38 what do we have bandwidth to do next year?

1:18:42 Understanding that that takes, to finish these jobs, what can we actually spend money on income?

1:18:52 Listening to dentation on parks, and then seeing a couple of the park items here.

1:18:58 Yes, I'd love to get those done, but also at the same time, would they actually get done in that year?

1:19:04 Do we actually have the human capital to be able to do that?

1:19:10 That's, you know, there's a list of items that we would purchase, which hopefully we could get those.

1:19:17 And I mean, we understand what shipping is doing right now, but that's a little bit easier to go on and purchase that,

1:19:23 as opposed to, hey, we would like sidewalks done, but we can't get the material and we don't have to do it.

1:19:29 So, to that point, wait, if you remember a few months back, we improved some category beefers.

1:19:35 Yes, one of those projects was the pickleball.

1:19:37 That's the reason I would like to weigh those two things and spend their money wisely.

1:19:59 So these projects are easier to accomplish than others.

1:20:05 And that's what I'm kind of looking at.

1:20:07 I don't know how.

1:20:10 And then also sit walks around schools.

1:20:12 If like walks was the window project, it was the perfect example of the happens list.

1:20:22 So the project is that too.

1:20:29 Yes.

1:20:30 Those should be here.

1:20:34 Just one other thing, and like using the Evo Knevo as an example, depending on this timeframe

1:20:40 answer is whether that can be broken out into phases.

1:20:45 So maybe we put some money toward, I mean, we kind of did that last year where we faced

1:20:51 some things and if we could put doors drawing the plans or the phases are broken out so we

1:20:59 could get some of these things rolling whereas out potentially outside labor, not inside labor.

1:21:06 On the evil Knievel one, I'm glad you brought that up because it probably gives me an opportunity to talk a little.

1:21:12 In this current fiscal year, we've got some design money that we're spending right now.

1:21:19 An engineering firm, an access drive, and the parking lot.

1:21:23 Those improvements, and the access drive for that $800,000 estimate.

1:21:34 That $800,000 is not the same $800,000 as the projects that Wendy was just talking about when she was up here in her presentation.

1:21:42 That's literally the driveway in the parking lot.

1:21:46 And what she was talking about was other things like maybe a restaurant or a benches and those

1:21:52 other types of park development thing, and that's some of the projects that they're thinking

1:21:57 about doing, $100,000.

1:22:03 Which is, I think I talked to Lee today and I think he said it was like a 60% plan, right,

1:22:09 and $100,000 is a little bit.

1:22:11 And as they get more and more designed though, and so $3,000, this is something we agreed to spend money on next year.

1:22:33 Wendy's got one of those kind of thing, versus the sidewalk.

1:23:00 I've been designed yet at $650,000.

1:23:08 That would take some time to design that sidewalk for it to take some time there.

1:23:13 It hasn't been yet, but we have a preliminary.

1:23:42 I think this will be super quick.

1:23:44 So the question was kind of the digests and where we at.

1:24:32 $5,000 to inspect Digestor No. 1 and that Digestor No. 1 inspection also occur upon completion of the Digestor 2.

1:24:42 So we're still on track, I think. We're using our service for all of that.

1:24:48 New weeks, Troy should be coming to City Council.

1:24:53 Accommodation to Digestor No. 2. And so after that's all complete, we're guessing later in the fall when we begin early spring.

1:25:07 Digestor No. 1 inspection.

1:25:12 Any questions on any of these you have is understanding that taking some budget steps

1:25:34 tonight and we'll be taking some and old steps soon as staff is counsel

1:25:46 opposed to give out some more things for you to bring back for us next week.

1:25:53 So the $770,000 is in you tonight you have to adopt a preliminary budget

1:25:58 that's going to set your max spending and traps the talk a little bit

1:26:04 770s in that number so and actually the 770s in there

1:26:17 So if we go beyond that even if we adopt the budget

1:26:20 770s in there, so if we want to take a longer time figure out how to spin that we can do that if you want to say for example

1:26:27 Fund two point eight million dollars of floral Avenue

1:26:31 We need to add money to the preliminary budget that you're gonna prove tonight

1:26:35 Because that's not in there right now

1:26:36 Now, $7.70 is in there right now of kind of flexible money.

1:26:40 If you want to take reserves, it's from where?

1:26:44 And throw it in the budget to do.

1:26:46 Or even $800,000 for the evil thing,

1:26:49 because $7.70 isn't $800 either.

1:26:52 So we're needing another $30.

1:26:53 Let's add another $30 tonight in the very budget.

1:26:58 Any of those going beyond the $7.70.

1:27:03 But I think we're OK tonight.

1:27:06 And we can still talk about it specifically.

1:27:10 It's in a general kind of a line item.

1:27:12 When we adopt the final budget, actually this probably means the difference to me doing that.

1:27:19 Because we have to get our funds right too, so if some of these projects are street fund projects,

1:27:24 we're going to do that preliminary budget for the street fund as well.

1:27:27 So I'm going to stop now to real quick.

1:27:30 So actually what we're able to do is, we obviously want the council to be able to not only set the preliminary budget,

1:27:41 which is going to set the maximum, but also set the public hearing.

1:27:45 And then as you take those projects, the $770,000 is earmarked as capital.

1:27:54 Capital spend a whole series of different moves that if the council is not ready tonight,

1:28:02 I don't want the council to feel like they're pressured to take those steps where we could

1:28:08 do adjusting journal entries to be able to move it from one tax-supported fund to another

1:28:13 tax-supported fund with ease. It is all acceptable, which doesn't describe it by

1:28:29 fund. It describes it by... I think we just fit next week as the last bit of

1:28:56 information and within the next couple weeks we make our final decision. I'm

1:29:02 with you. We can be daydreaming. No, we want. We will never get this done.

1:29:07 Anything that's important to you that this isn't just some

1:29:10 I'm a Christmas tree list that got thrown in front of us.

1:29:14 It's been through a process, not only this year,

1:29:17 but some of these projects have been

1:29:19 linked through the process we have internally for.

1:29:24 And just, I would certainly sense that we all

1:29:40 tend to be a little focused on walks.

1:29:43 And those safety issues, I think that's

1:29:45 where we've been the last couple of years.

1:29:47 I would question, we actually accomplished.

1:30:03 So I'd like to see us do that sooner than later.

1:30:19 We should be able to make walks done then.

1:30:37 And I said, is there anything new to that update?

1:30:39 I know that's some update of next Monday and then the week conversation.

1:31:02 As a comment question, discussion this evening on the budget. Now is your opportunity to come forward? State your name and we'll give you two minutes.

1:31:56 When is this overlining of coming out of the social media as an extent, dimension or some type of collaboration between rising and new residents are coming here?

1:32:24 So we do have a number website. We have a lot of different departments that read their own, plus the city hall has their own.

1:32:41 I believe all of us have our information publicly accessible on the city's website.

1:32:47 And so we do.

1:32:51 Would there be like more opportunities to maybe massage some of those relationships so it's less of maybe residents doing certain more of a presentation, for example, videos on the local businesses here.

1:33:03 Don't we don't run businesses, we just run city services.

1:33:07 So that would be probably something done through the Chamber of Commerce.

1:33:11 If you're looking for those types of engagements, but everything we do is structured around parks and recreation, water, sewer, and those types of items.

1:33:20 Appreciate it.

1:33:21 If it actually has to add maybe a recommendation to touch base with Josh Palmer, who is there

1:33:26 with the information officer at the city, but Josh manages some of the city's platforms

1:33:32 and would have that connection to maybe outreach to some of those other organizations that

1:33:37 have organizations like Ashes available here at City Hall.

1:33:47 And you can sign up for email notifications.

1:33:52 There's a place to register and select the topics you'd like to see information on.

1:33:58 and when they go out you receive them. Good info.

1:34:03 You should think of life's streams as well if you can't make it in person.

1:34:08 I appreciate it. Just out of curiosity, what's the participation right on those life streams?

1:34:12 How many people do you guys? Is that like? Not much.

1:34:16 I guess that's kind of where my question is. It's actually pretty good.

1:34:20 Actually, you'd be surprised I think that over 100 or less.

1:34:24 I believe it is. In fact, I believe depending upon the time of the year and depending upon

1:34:28 the system that we have in place can describe a unique viewer.

1:34:38 It's someone that not only comes in but stays for a period of time and I want to believe

1:34:44 it's some period greater than ten minutes.

1:34:46 So they're just not clicking and clicking out.

1:34:48 Josh has all that data.

1:34:50 But the Census was actually pretty significant in my opinion.

1:34:54 There's far more people that are watching it online whether it be live or whether it be

1:34:59 which is the beauty but also recording it.

1:35:06 But Josh, you can get all that information for you.

1:35:08 He has all the analytics and we're happy to share that.

1:35:10 Thank you, guys.

1:35:11 Appreciate it.

1:35:23 Most item, request to adopt a resolution of the City Council

1:35:27 for the City of Twin Falls stating the intent to use the

1:35:31 foregone balance, levy, and authority in the fiscal year

1:35:35 budget to have our city manager Travis Rothweiler.

1:35:39 Madam Mayor, members of the City Council,

1:35:41 so this is where we start moving into the portions of the budgeting process

1:35:48 to really not only since or that several months before that we started engaging with the city council.

1:35:56 I've just the pre-season parts of the budget where we formed it to collect through a series of conversations

1:36:09 that was then placed into the budget and the back was the last of the focus area presentations.

1:36:28 And the first thing that we have is the passage of a resolution.

1:36:39 The resolution is in your packet in a little background.

1:36:43 House Bill 474 was passed by the Idaho legislature in

1:36:46 thousand and sixteen and at that point in time it's at forward a process that any

1:36:52 time a city wanted to incorporate the foregone ballot had to do so resolution

1:37:01 to the resolution Todd this past legislative session was limited to one

1:37:15 percent or three percent one percent of the foregone balance that could be used

1:37:19 used to be placed into the budget as ongoing revenue to assist with absorbing and that second

1:37:28 P. Inside of the budget, it is 1% for ongoing operating costs it is described in the budget

1:37:48 that amount is $251,803. And that is done in accordance with Idaho Code 63-802. Conclusion

1:38:00 Should the council adopt the resolution the city will still have a foregone balance of

1:38:08 $162,691 which is I believe still the largest in the Magic Valley and largest inside of the state of Idaho

1:38:16 So with that I'm happy to stand for any questions your resolution is in your packet

1:38:22 I do not have resolution number is 2021

1:38:28 Dash zero one one Travis

1:38:55 I'll second that motion from Sean Berriger, seconded by Ruth Pierce, to adopt resolution 2021-011.

1:39:05 Christopher Reed? Yes.

1:39:15 Ray Cockett? Yes.

1:39:16 Fun Berriger? Yes.

1:39:17 Nicky Boyd? Yes. Yes.

1:39:20 And Rick Perry? Yes.

1:39:22 Motion passes 6 to 1.

1:39:24 6 to 1, 6 to 0.

1:39:26 It's an origin, a adoption of the tentative budget for the City of Twin Falls.

1:39:39 So, what you're going to do this evening is you're going to, the next item is to adopt

1:39:46 the tentative budget for the City of Twin Falls for the fiscal year 2021-22, in the amount

1:39:54 of $69,464,041, and set August 23rd, 2021 at 6pm as the public hearing date.

1:40:11 Is it sense you remove this number?

1:40:26 This becomes the ceiling in which the city council can.

1:40:30 It does not set the budget.

1:40:34 It just means that you cannot crest over that a

1:40:38 Mountation and should the city council choose to

1:40:47 Additional adjustment.

1:40:48 Those adjustments can be made, but you cannot exceed that

1:40:53 Toast us.

1:41:13 Any questions or comments?

1:41:15 Everybody?

1:41:17 About this for a while.

1:41:18 a little bit for me. I move that we adopt the tentative budget for the city of

1:41:25 Twin Falls for the 2021-2022 fiscal year in the amount of 69,464,941

1:41:34 dollars and said August 23rd 2021 at 6 p.m. as the date and time for the public

1:41:41 hearing. We have a motion from Christopher Reed seconded by Craig Hawkins

1:41:48 to approve the adoption of the tentative budget as presented and set the time for the public hearing as also presented.

1:41:58 I just want to say before we take a vote on this, I know that staff has put in hours and hours of work,

1:42:07 and I know we belabor the fact that we've been processed for a few hours,

1:42:11 but we know where the brunt of has been spent.

1:42:15 Yes.

1:42:16 Thank you to everyone.

1:42:24 Yes.

1:42:30 Yes.

1:42:36 Thank you, and on our agenda is a chance for general public input, and this is an opportunity for anyone in the audience to address the council on any issues that were not on the seat means budget budget.

1:42:56 the advisory board report simultaneously.

1:43:25 It is a really, also, and so if you're in serving on that,

1:44:08 it is really good.

1:44:29 So I would say if anybody's looking to get involved.

1:44:34 We do break during the summer, and with school starting,

1:44:53 we're in full recruitment of Josh Palmer,

1:44:56 from staff is helping take the youth council this year,

1:45:01 and I just really throw a plug out there, folks,

1:45:05 that are considering running for city council this year

1:45:07 with Greg and I stepping down,

1:45:11 Great Leader, I'm told to pick up the ball to pace running.

1:45:18 We have a number of great kids coming back,

1:45:20 are energetic, they have my, so if somebody has,

1:45:28 if you are in eighth grade through 12th grade,

1:45:30 and right here in the overflow room,

1:45:46 and everybody's welcome to join,

1:46:04 this might take a few minutes,

1:46:06 we are going to take a five minute recess.

1:46:09 We'll be back at 6.50 to start the public word

1:46:51 to our public hearings this evening.

1:46:54 First item this evening is a request to allow

1:46:56 for additional building height for a new silo

1:46:59 property located at 236 Washington Street South and we have Elizabeth Hart

1:47:04 Senior City Planner this evening welcome members so as the mayor said this is a

1:47:12 request to allow to show building height because might be familiar with the

1:47:17 subject property as glampia nutritional system for their processing

1:47:22 that is south of downtown Washington South it's within the manufacturing

1:47:29 district that have two districts specifically and surrounding properties

1:47:33 so to the north and to the south but that two districts and then across the

1:47:37 street on the east side of Washington you have some residents. Our future land

1:47:43 use map shows us up to industrial and commercial. So within the district it

1:47:54 actually limits the building I-50 feet which is why the applicants here tonight

1:47:58 there's an exception in title 10, chapter 7 section 3 that allows the city council

1:48:03 a grant more height, a few different districts and then I'm two districts, one of those and

1:48:10 some background. So this isn't the first time they've come to the City Council to ask for additional

1:48:20 height back in 2014. They also came through asking for additional height for other silos

1:48:27 on the property so you can see in these photos that there's a total of six silos and the four

1:48:33 that are there. So you guys would approve though. Today's request is kind of similar to 2014,

1:48:51 existing on the right is what is proposing to increase the existing silo from 42 feet to 70 feet.

1:48:59 If you notice on these plans on the silo that they're proposing to increase was a 4 foot plus 46 feet

1:49:09 right now and so that would make the highest 74 feet so it's going from 46 actually 70 feet.

1:49:20 This is a better way to serve their needs for the facility and that would

1:49:26 staff doesn't see for C&E significant negative impacts on silos bars have back pretty far from

1:49:33 the lines as we don't have any commission to hold a public hearing on to a 4-0 phone

1:49:47 and not receive any public questions for me.

1:49:53 Since the request will have a chance to ask questions of applicant or staff,

1:50:25 after questions have been asked, the public hearing will be opened at that time anyone,

1:50:29 the opportunity to comment or ask questions, address, and then present your comments and concerns.

1:50:41 After giving testimony to the public sheet that's located in the waters for our permanent rec,

1:50:49 after public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions and

1:50:53 make a closing statement. Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.

1:50:59 After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed and no further testimony or comments

1:51:04 will be allowed. At that time, the council will have an open discussion and make a decision,

1:51:10 even if the action taken this evening is to bring it back on it.

1:51:14 Okay, sorry. History on that. The Sicilian staff, so basically,

1:51:47 Basically, the Twin Falls plant is about, 300,000 pounds of cheese daily, bringing about

1:52:00 3 million pounds of milk, we employ about 100 people, and also local contractors do work

1:52:05 for us also.

1:52:06 One of our storage silos you can, you know, over at needs to be replaced, and we're going

1:52:12 to basically like to extend it to help us in other areas and stuff.

1:52:16 As said, basically, December 2014, we come in front of the city council back at that time

1:52:22 to also have two silos, basically the same thing they were going to be, you know, they're

1:52:32 also four other silos in the same area, they're pretty close to the same height and stuff,

1:52:37 so.

1:52:38 E-points is basically, this will not increase the truck traffic in the area and stuff, basically

1:52:42 we're not going to run any more product, it's basically just going to have pretty much

1:52:45 help so we can be more efficient and get the trucks back on the road sooner and stuff like

1:52:49 that.

1:52:50 Going from a basically a 30,000 gallon silo to a 50,000 gallon silo, I think existing pad,

1:52:56 We're going to use the existing pad and have been certified by an engineering company that

1:53:00 can basically be suitable to handle the bigger, like this kind of like an existing picture

1:53:08 of the facility and stuff.

1:53:10 The silo is basically one of the smallest ones, basically they're kind of off to the right

1:53:15 slash.

1:53:16 Right by the Columbia silo and stuff, that's the one we're looking at in a Clish show.

1:53:23 That's what the existing silo is about.

1:53:25 The fourth foot pad is on about 46 feet and this is what the new silo and approximately

1:53:31 It's going to be a little bit, you know, a foot or so higher than the existing silos.

1:53:38 To the 74 feet.

1:53:57 For staff or Apple Open, the public hearing.

1:54:02 There's anyone in the audience who would like to comment or ask questions on this item.

1:54:06 Now it's your opportunity.

1:54:14 I would assume that those statements for discussion, deliberation or decision.

1:54:36 Just want to say it looks like it is an opener.

1:55:06 It's not going to, I don't, I certainly am in faith.

1:55:14 motion to the new silo on property located at 236 Washington Street South

1:55:29 Garabdick Pfizer on behalf of Glamby and new officials planning zoning in

1:55:37 20-0076 on July 13th 2021 planning and zoning commission recommended approval

1:55:44 this request by a vote of four vote. So your second the motion by Mr.

1:55:55 America to approve the request as presented this evening.

1:56:00 Right, Hawkins.

1:56:08 Yes.

1:56:09 John, America.

1:56:10 Yes.

1:56:12 Is that Hawkins?

1:56:13 Yes.

1:56:14 Yes.

1:56:15 Christopher Reed.

1:56:16 Yes.

1:56:17 Motion passes 6 to 0.

1:56:18 Thank you very much.

1:56:19 Thank you for being a great community.

1:56:23 Next is...

1:56:35 Not.

1:56:36 Hey, but I want to start out the conversation.

1:56:39 So Madam Mayor, members of the City Council, as you know, we have engaged and had conversations.

1:56:46 a whole host of different fees throughout the entire budgeting process, and in those

1:56:52 few conversations, uh, it, or as we would, we statutorily, the process, we published this

1:57:01 evening, the publication. It was brought to my attention that staff, um, did not have

1:57:15 all of the conversations that we, uh, could have, um, with all the members of our development

1:57:21 community and so what we're going to ask for you this evening is only to

1:57:25 approve and consider part of them so after it was brought to our attention we

1:57:29 can't unpublish so we can't unwind that clock but it is not the city council just

1:57:36 because the fees are published does not necessarily mean that you have to move

1:57:39 forward with it and so tonight we're gonna host a public hearing and everything is

1:57:45 there and should the council choose we have a alternative resolution that would

1:57:53 all engineering and planning zoning fees from consideration. Should that be the

1:57:59 case of the city council we would do is we would reverse of our development

1:58:04 community on the engineering and planning and zoning fees make sure that we have

1:58:09 good conversations gain better clarity and then we would present to you after

1:58:14 those conversations, staff's recommendation for those feet, they may not change at all.

1:58:19 They may come back significantly differently.

1:58:23 What's important is that that conversation takes place before we present those fees to you.

1:58:28 So with that, I want to touch that.

1:58:35 So pursuant to our codes section 63, 1311, the city must hold a public hearing prior to

1:58:50 proving a new fee or a fee increase in excess of 5%.

1:59:13 So this resolution 2021 dash zero 10 is a very,

1:59:20 it's a summer, or what it is,

1:59:22 is it shows the actual resolution for increased fees

1:59:25 and then behind it in the attachments

1:59:28 is the master fee schedule, what was published

1:59:30 in addition to the changes that we have made

1:59:32 since the last one.

1:59:34 So of importance is the second page,

1:59:37 but I wanted to focus in on a little bit,

1:59:40 is the ones that we published,

1:59:42 so this is a publication, it's too long,

1:59:45 because there are a lot of fees this time

1:59:47 that we've changed, updated,

1:59:49 and there should be somebody in the audience

1:59:53 that can help if you have any questions

1:59:54 on some of these that I cannot answer.

1:59:56 So what I do wanna talk about

1:59:58 is the highlighted ones or ones as Travis indicated

2:00:00 that we published, assuming that we would go forward with it,

2:00:04 but we are not going to at this point in time.

2:00:07 So, the only ones that I am referring to for tonight's resolution would be the ones that are not highlighted.

2:00:14 So, the water meter fee, this one, and I'll discuss, there's really not a whole lot.

2:00:20 I'll discuss the ones that are over 5% because that is the ones that the public hearing pertain to.

2:00:25 So, the water meter fee is literally just a pass through because our supplies on the Badger Model have increased.

2:00:31 So you'll see there's about a $22 difference, it says a 7% increase, but dollar-wise it's

2:00:37 not huge.

2:00:38 There are a couple of new fees that the planning, so there's one, two new fees that the planning

2:00:44 and zoning department have proposed that are not increases.

2:00:48 The certificate appropriateness for $100, the zoning verification letter, those are the

2:00:55 only two new fees that are not increases than what we currently have.

2:01:00 And the next section is probably the bulk of what I have as new fees.

2:01:06 So our pool has experienced quite a bit of upset over COVID, over shortages in labor,

2:01:14 supplies, chemicals, and so what they have done, and Wendy leave is still here.

2:01:20 What they have done is they've gone through and analyzed what their fees are, what their

2:01:23 costs are, and proposed new fees.

2:01:26 What you are seeing and what was published is their proposal.

2:01:30 Some of them look like big increases, 25%, but they're really minimal comparatively.

2:01:36 Some of them are a little bit higher.

2:01:38 So for instance, going $150 to $200, but this was all in your package.

2:01:43 These are pool fees that we are recommending.

2:01:46 A couple of smaller ones that I'll ask for questions.

2:01:51 So the skate rental, we decided to start, we may not do this again, but just in case

2:01:56 we want to, we want to get the fee on there.

2:01:58 We started ice skating over here in the comments.

2:02:01 So this is an actual rental of ice skates if somebody's citizens come in and bring their

2:02:05 own ice skates, then they wouldn't pay a fee, it's just to rent skates and the utility billing

2:02:11 ones are the ones that we've belabored quite a bit.

2:02:15 So of importance is this usage of the 2000 gallons, which most people use, so it's almost

2:02:21 a flat fee, goes from $11.73 to $20.33, that's the $8.60 increase, but what's not shown here

2:02:30 is the decrease in 10.75 for the arsenic fee.

2:02:34 So we have a, of what looks like a large increase,

2:02:39 but this is gonna actually be less to most of our,

2:02:42 most of our citizens.

2:02:44 So with that, is there any questions on any of the fees

2:02:48 that I, or maybe somebody can...

2:02:57 Or class, can you explain what that is?

2:03:00 I know I've had parents, whose kids,

2:03:04 safeguarding, when it comes to those fees,

2:03:07 They have to pay for the fee, economic situation we're in, and are we shooting ourselves in the foot while having kids pay for their own class.

2:03:17 And then...

2:03:30 As you know, John's not here, so I'll take my best stab at them.

2:03:33 So, those fees are set by the Red Cross.

2:03:36 And that's the training fee.

2:03:40 So, whether we're paying it or whether somebody else is paying it,

2:03:44 that fee needs to be on our schedule in order for that class to happen.

2:03:50 So that's not really about, um, I mean, anybody can lifeguard training class.

2:03:58 We didn't do much issue with it.

2:04:00 We were primarily training our staff, but it's driven by American red class.

2:04:06 I think it's important to remember.

2:04:20 So, Graham is administered, who is assessing and collecting the fee.

2:04:30 But also important to remember is just because we train lifeguards doesn't mean they come to workforce.

2:04:35 No necessary commitment. They're always going to be able to afford the city of Twin Falls.

2:04:46 They can choose employment everywhere else. They don't be conservative.

2:04:51 The schedule regardless if we say it's a passover or not,

2:05:00 then we don't put it on the schedule as if it's a different, if it's like the fire district fees.

2:05:05 Fire district has a legitimate pass for pass or fee that we collect on their behalf and then remit to them.

2:05:11 Anything else that is something that we charge is something that we do have to publish as our fee.

2:05:16 Do we know the last time those were in some of those fees were increased when they had swim lessons?

2:05:27 I think the last resolution was in 2018. It doesn't necessarily mean that all of these were increased at that time.

2:05:40 The last fee resolution we did for parks or for recreation and aquatics was in 2018.

2:05:48 I think we did a special resolution when we took the pool back from the walk to put all of our fees in place then

2:05:57 Yeah, because we had to go through that process

2:06:07 It's like I said there's um, there's multiple pages here

2:06:19 Yeah, the schedule being its entirety is the master citywide fee schedule and we're trying to keep making this as transparent as possible

2:06:28 also if you go down to words the end after it's in EPC order, you're gonna see the dates.

2:06:38 So starting here, there's master citywide fee schedule changes, so there are some changes.

2:06:48 We don't have to hold a public hearing on the ones that are less than 5%, but just for

2:06:53 transparency purposes and to have everything on one document, these are all the changes.

2:06:59 There's some description changes, there's some smaller fees, airport has some smaller

2:07:04 fee increases.

2:07:05 Again, these are not ones that we have to have a public hearing on, but those are in your

2:07:09 packet for you to look at.

2:07:11 Increases for the City of Twin Falls.

2:07:44 Any questions or any concerns before the Council?

2:07:50 We'll give you two minutes this evening if you'll just come forward and state your name.

2:07:54 My name is Brad Willes, Tutu to Tisha Schone Street West here in Twin Falls.

2:08:06 I just want to thank Travis as a developer community and the builder, you know, this was published last week, I'm going to see it in the page, Travis, and responsive, and so I appreciate the willingness to oppose the fee increases, you've done a really good job on the impact years ago and down, so this was just, I appreciate it, and we'll catch you off guard again.

2:09:25 It is entirely one to resolution.

2:09:32 Did resolution, at least not really an amendment,

2:09:38 but we just present resolution as presented this evening,

2:09:43 not the one differentist that we have to ask

2:09:54 illustrated on that.

2:10:09 These are included, also one thing I probably didn't state

2:10:12 is clearly.

2:10:13 This new fee of $900, that's not what it will be.

2:10:19 It's going to be commensurate with what

2:10:21 before with plat with plat

2:10:26 fees of $50 and plat per lot of $10 so

2:10:31 it's commensurate with what we normally

2:10:33 have so of the existing fees not the

2:10:36 increase from Sean Barrigar segment

2:10:58 Christopher Reed to adopt resolution 2021

2:11:02 dash 0 10 as presented this evening and

2:11:07 and not as was published.

2:11:15 We will call vote please.

2:11:20 Yes.

2:11:20 Thank you, Boyd.

2:11:22 Yes.

2:11:23 And yes.

2:11:24 Mr. Fareed.

2:11:25 Yes.

2:11:26 And Craig Honk.

2:11:27 Yes.

2:11:27 Motion passes six to zero.

2:11:30 Thank you very much.

2:11:32 At this evening, we have a request

2:11:34 to adjourn into executive session

2:11:37 under Idaho Code 74-2061B to consider the evaluation,

2:11:43 dismissal, or disciplining of, or to hear complaints

2:11:47 charges brought against a public officer, employees, staff member, or individual agent,

2:11:53 or public school student.

2:11:55 Second.

2:11:56 Second.

2:11:57 We have a motion from Nikki Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce, to adjourn into executive session.

2:12:05 Amy Roll, call vote please.

2:12:09 Nikki Boyd?

2:12:10 Yes.

2:12:11 Suzanne Hawkins?

2:12:12 Yes.

2:12:13 Ruth Pierce?

2:12:14 Yes.

2:12:15 Christopher Reed?

2:12:16 Yes.

2:12:17 Motion passes six to zero.

2:12:21 We will be adjourning into executive session.

2:12:24 We will not be making any decisions this evening

2:12:27 and we will not be reconvening this meeting.

2:12:29 So we're adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 9, 2021. The recording started at 16:59 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:12:36.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    96adf82e6cf672f7df87289bfa21a5a20f34f13e85b40c0319bc2f26aaff68c6
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a a4ffc6f440249f90b88254a834d15f7ee1463ef51cc5cfe898961a573152cc43
    part02.m4a f0fabc00ef017aac09e078e97b580876f9f26db58eb0bbac111ce3234e2a0c1f
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    7a9e7595baceaca42f36e89f79eefa541cc59fd1d225d58f1883e51fae4af1c7

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file