OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 7, 2021

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,c

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:03:53 We are still experiencing a little difficulty,

0:03:55 but we're gonna go ahead and get started.

0:03:59 So welcome to the June 7th meeting

0:04:02 of the Twin Paul City Council.

0:04:04 We're going to call the meeting to order

0:04:06 and confirm that we do have a quorum.

0:04:08 All seven members are present this evening.

0:04:11 At this time, if you would like to join us,

0:04:13 please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:04:39 Our acclamations this evening,

0:04:41 so we will move forward to the consent calendar.

0:04:45 And I see Christopher Reed.

0:04:47 to approve the consent calendar as published.

0:04:49 Second.

0:04:51 We have a motion from Christopher Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce

0:04:54 to approve the consent calendar as it was published.

0:04:59 Any questions from anyone?

0:05:01 The Nof80 roll call vote, please.

0:05:10 We keep away.

0:05:11 Yes.

0:05:12 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:05:13 Yes.

0:05:14 Frank Leifton.

0:05:14 Yes.

0:05:15 Good Pierce.

0:05:15 Yes.

0:05:16 Christopher Reed.

0:05:16 Yes.

0:05:17 Chris Crank Hawkins.

0:05:18 Mission passes seven to zero.

0:05:24 First item under items of consideration this evening

0:05:27 is a request to accept public right away,

0:05:29 and we have Troy Vtech, Troy.

0:05:33 He was trying to get away, and we caught him.

0:05:38 Almost got away, not quite.

0:05:45 Nice try, Troy, but we caught you.

0:05:49 So this is part of the agro from the plant.

0:05:53 They were a specific key right away.

0:05:55 It's part of their subdivision process.

0:05:57 There's an air on the boundary description,

0:06:00 and part of the plant.

0:06:01 So this is just fixing that air that

0:06:03 We're just our standard specifications for wins,

0:06:08 and we have to accept it.

0:06:27 For a motion.

0:06:27 And we accept requests to accept public right of way.

0:06:34 We accept that.

0:06:40 One second.

0:06:42 I have a motion from Hinky Boy, seconded by Christopher Reed,

0:06:45 to accept the public right of way as presented.

0:06:49 Amy will call vote please.

0:06:51 Hinky Boy?

0:06:52 Yes.

0:06:52 New Zand Hawkins?

0:06:53 Yes.

0:06:54 Frank Lanting?

0:06:55 Yes.

0:06:55 Bruce Pierce?

0:06:56 Yes.

0:06:57 Mr. Fareed?

0:06:58 Yes.

0:06:58 Frank Hawkins?

0:07:02 and Sean's America.

0:07:03 Yes.

0:07:04 Motion passes 7-0.

0:07:05 Next on our agenda is a request to apply for the Learning and Earning ARPA Grant from

0:07:13 the Idaho Commission for Libraries and we have Tara Barkley, our Director of the Library.

0:07:20 Good evening.

0:07:21 May I knock on the council members?

0:07:22 Thank you for your time.

0:07:23 Like I said in the packet, Idaho Commission for Libraries have received funding from the

0:07:31 American Rescue Recovery Act, and they are opening up for libraries in the State of Idaho

0:07:40 to apply for grants.

0:07:42 So we have two projects in mind.

0:07:43 One of them is to create space inside our building that allows people to virtually connect

0:07:50 in the event that they need to connect for meetings, for students that might need to

0:07:56 reach out to a teacher.

0:07:57 They would be semi-private rooms so that they would have that kind of closed

0:08:02 personal that they could

0:08:04 Talk without being within the open space of the library and then the second project itself would be on our vacant lot

0:08:12 On the east side of the library right behind our bookmobile garage

0:08:16 It's vacant right now. It's just grass

0:08:18 What we would do is we would extend our Wi-Fi out to reach that area and then also put concrete tables down concrete

0:08:25 just so that we make for sure the tables stay and they're easy to clean up in the

0:08:30 event of anything going on them. So those are the two projects I think in the

0:08:35 packet I estimated in about 26,000 as I'm learning more about this grant. It's a

0:08:40 very quick grant. We have to have the application in my June 15th as I'm

0:08:44 learning more. That is actually going to go down and so I'm estimating it's going

0:08:48 to be around 20,000 now. Any questions or comments for Tara?

0:08:55 This is just a request to second. We have a motion from Sean

0:09:25 Bericher, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the request for the library to

0:09:30 apply for the grant as presented. And we roll call vote please.

0:09:34 Suzanne Hawkins, yes Frank Lanting, yes. Ruth Pierce, yes. Christopher Reed, yes.

0:09:42 Frank Hawkins, yes. John Bericher, yes. And Nicky Boyd. Thank you. Next on our agenda is a

0:09:56 request to adopt ordinance 2021-011 for a comprehensive plan amendment to

0:10:03 modify the future land use map and we have Jonathan Smith of our planning and

0:10:08 zoning director. Mayor members of the council you read the number this was a

0:10:15 comprehensive plan amendment that kind of fixed the road commercial on the

0:10:19 north that took place. Papers upstairs I'm reading from my I took place in April

0:10:28 and from the planning and zoning Commission they said a positive

0:10:30 recommendation to the council on May 17th the council the ordinance has gone

0:10:39 through legal and now we're here in order to suspend to the rules third and final

0:10:45 I take that tonight.

0:10:56 I move that we suspend the rules and put ordinance 2021 dash 0 1 1 on third and

0:11:09 final by title only the motion from Christopher Reed seconded by great

0:11:19 landing to suspend the rules and place ordinance 2021 dash 11 on third and

0:11:25 final by title only although please

0:11:29 Yes, Mr. Fareed. Yes, Frank Hawkins. Yes.

0:11:36 Yes.

0:11:37 Yes.

0:11:38 Yes.

0:11:39 Yes.

0:11:41 Yes.

0:11:42 Yes.

0:11:43 Yes.

0:11:44 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:11:45 I had that ordinance up so I could read it.

0:11:48 Please hold on just a second.

0:11:51 Ordinance 2021 dash zero eleven.

0:11:57 an ordinance of the city council of the city of Twin Falls, Idaho,

0:12:01 bordering an amendment to the revised area of impact and comprehensive plan and use.

0:12:07 Mayor, I move we adopt ordinance 2021-11.

0:12:19 A motion from Ruth Pierce, seconded by Craig Hawkins to adopt ordinance 2021-011.

0:12:30 Amy Roll-Covall, Ruth Pierce.

0:12:33 Yes.

0:12:34 Mr. Perrine. Yes. Greg Hawkins. Yes. John Berger. Yes.

0:12:38 Nicky Boyd. Yes. Dan Hawkins. Yes. Greg Landy. Yes.

0:12:43 Well, should pass this 7-0. Thank you, Jonathan.

0:12:46 On our agenda is a discussion and we are going to talk about our budget for the 2021-2022 year

0:12:59 at the City Council Priorities and we have our City Manager, Travis Rothweiler.

0:13:04 Good evening Mayor City Council, thank you for the opportunity to present the third and final pre-budget workshop.

0:14:23 It's kind of like pre-season.

0:14:26 So we go through three pre-season games. We're in our last pre-season game and we'll start constructing the final parts of the budget.

0:14:35 We'll be able to start game time on the 12th of July. We'll run all the way through August.

0:14:41 And hopefully we'll have a budget that's ready to move forward.

0:14:47 What I will share is that things have changed since our last conversation.

0:14:50 And as you know, and we are having conversations, the legislature was still in session.

0:14:56 And then at the 11th hour of day 100 and whatever it was,

0:15:05 there was an omnibus tax bill that was introduced and it sailed through the session.

0:15:11 And that occurred between our second meeting and today.

0:15:17 And so we've spent some time trying

0:15:20 to understand the impacts of the legislation.

0:15:24 And we have then constructed a budget for that.

0:15:30 And so again tonight it is really we're

0:15:32 seeking your input and your direction on steps

0:15:34 that you would like for us to take because after this,

0:15:38 we are then going to begin the process

0:15:40 of publishing a budget that we will present to you in the community of July.

0:15:47 So as we have questions, we'll continue to move forward, and what's really, really interesting is the site all of the same.

0:15:55 What I will tell you is the numbers have changed significantly just in the few months that we have been doing this.

0:16:04 And so when you take a look at the size of the city of Twin Falls,

0:16:11 we've shared that it's just slightly below 5,000 people, but in past conversations as we

0:16:18 had shared with you that there are 81,700 vehicle trips that come into the City of Twin Falls

0:16:23 on a daily basis. And so we need to think about our community in terms of service population

0:16:29 and size. That the service population inside of the City of Twin Falls on any given day

0:16:35 the exceed 100,000 people. And the level of service that we are required to provide isn't

0:16:43 just to the 51,000 taxpayers. It is to the more than 100,000 people who we have watched

0:16:57 the median household income stay relatively constant. But yet, at that same point in time,

0:17:05 we've watched the median increase and we'll spend some time talking about that. So if you

0:17:14 look right here. It increased $50,000, increased $50,000. There are lots of factors that are

0:17:32 going into that. One of those factors are within our control. Army and home value is

0:17:43 still $100,000 less than the Idaho average. So as we talk about affordability of homes

0:17:54 Twin Falls, this conversation's occurring in other communities, especially fast dynamic

0:18:00 and growing communities, is much more significant and maybe in some cases much more as they

0:18:12 kind of watch that rapid escalation.

0:18:15 As you start trying to think about creating housing workforce, housing to Twin Falls metropolitan

0:18:28 statistical area on employment rate is 3.4 percent. 4% is what is considered to be

0:18:38 full employment. We shared this survey that we are finding that individuals are

0:18:51 moving to our area, right? We understand that we see that on a daily basis, but

0:18:56 understanding why they're moving, right? They're moving much less for new jobs,

0:19:00 which is important as we're trying to find workers not only in our own

0:19:05 organization but other organizations. Individuals as a result of COVID and businesses have learned

0:19:12 the ability to work remotely. Many companies are still working remotely and individuals have the

0:19:19 ability to truly choose where they want to live. So all the individuals that are coming into our

0:19:27 community are not necessarily adding to our labor supply and helping. In fact, here is the most recent

0:19:33 data that we have, state unemployment rate is at 3.1%, the Twin Falls Metropolitan

0:19:42 Statistic Area is at 3.4%, and the city of Twin Falls unemployment rate is 3.7%, what

0:19:49 does 3.7% mean? It means 881 people out of 24,109. If you look at all the help wanted

0:20:00 signs on blue legs, I'm entirely certain that number could diminish relatively quickly.

0:20:07 Again, you'll never see zero at the unemployment,

0:20:13 which makes full employment.

0:20:19 We're finding that people are moving and choosing to work,

0:20:23 or to move to places that are less in price,

0:20:27 and they try to find their moving to places

0:20:29 that are less dense, places that they're able to raise

0:20:34 their family, places that will allow them to continue to,

0:20:39 remotely, but a place that might be different for them too,

0:20:42 as they consider where they're going to raise,

0:20:44 family and we see that so anecdotally we've always said inside the city of

0:20:52 Twin Falls that we grow to more than a hundred thousand people every day and

0:20:55 then someone says we'll prove it and Jonathan's been love, help prove it, get it

0:21:04 so we have 81700 vehicle penetrations inside the community of Twin Falls every

0:21:12 single day and if you say just half those folks are coming and going right

0:21:16 and only 40,000 still nearly doubles our population.

0:21:23 We think that this is an incredibly conservative number

0:21:25 and this is where they're coming from.

0:21:27 We talked about housing.

0:21:36 These numbers are bolded for a reason,

0:21:38 because as we'll share, that is where tax value is determined

0:21:47 by the assessor's office.

0:21:49 On January 1st of every year, the assessor sets the value up.

0:21:54 So those are the two that we, those two values that we will use for the comparison moving forward, but just in one quarter.

0:22:06 The median home value has won from $250,171,000 in a single quarter.

0:22:21 We know that houses inside the city of Twin Falls have gone up 21.7% and that they're projecting that it will be eight and a half.

0:22:33 I will share with you that projections are often conservative, so I had an opportunity to have a

0:22:42 conversation with Zach with the Times News a little earlier today as we're talking about what are

0:22:47 the ramifications and of the property tax bill and what's going to occur and we pulled this up

0:22:56 from last year. And last year it actually said that our property values in Twin Falls are going

0:23:03 to decrease by half a percent. I would say that was a little off and I think it is a sign of when

0:23:16 you look at the value of an eight and a half percent increase and you start seeing and you hear the

0:23:25 continued pressures that we have and you know that the availability of labor in our community

0:23:33 is not expanding. You understand the material prices are skyrocketing. I believe it is safe to say

0:23:44 the need and have percent aid be conservative. So as we consider the price of a home, we need

0:23:57 to look at that from the availability to attract talent into our organization. The ability to

0:24:05 retain talent without our ability to keep and retain talent, especially for employees on the

0:24:13 front line, their ability to afford and to acquire a home, we are going to struggle offering

0:24:21 critical services to the members of our community. Everything that we do is

0:24:29 delivered and driven home by what you think about that just for a minute. Every

0:24:37 single service that we offer wires a person. You can't automate the fire response

0:24:48 that we had on Saturday night. It's forced, at least. When I think about science fiction

0:24:59 movies like Robocop, I'm not entirely certain I want to. You start thinking

0:25:06 about all of the men and women inside of our organization and the impacts of their

0:25:11 experience. So our budget is built around the preservation services in an era in

0:25:19 which revenues remain uncertain and the legislature continues to chisel away at

0:25:26 property taxes. So here's some strategies that we have in moving forward that we'd

0:25:32 like for you to consider, as we drive 22 fiscal.

0:25:40 So we want a sustainable, nimble budget.

0:25:44 There's a high degree of uncertainty

0:25:46 that still is out there.

0:25:49 Whether it be COVID-19, whether it be unemployment,

0:25:54 whether it be building materials,

0:25:55 whether it be scarcity of labor, whatever it may be,

0:26:01 operating and creating and leading an organization today

0:26:04 requires us to be dynamic, nimble and flexible.

0:26:08 and our budget needs to reflect that.

0:26:13 We need to be sensitive to our,

0:26:18 in a minute I'm gonna share with you

0:26:20 what the consumer price index looks like.

0:26:23 And we talked about the price of food.

0:26:26 During COVID-19, we saw significant increases

0:26:29 in the price of food, and we talked about that being

0:26:31 as a part of the supply chain.

0:26:35 The supply chain, from what I understand,

0:26:38 is virtually back in tact.

0:26:41 But the price of food continues to escalate.

0:26:48 The price of homes continues to grow.

0:26:52 And so we need to be sensitive that as we're building

0:26:54 Expending plans we want to understand how it's going to impact our citizens bottom line all of our expenditures to the strategic plan

0:27:05 And we're going to continue to build a performance measurement system that is able for us to better track to show our results

0:27:13 We're gonna balance available revenues and resources with our ability to expand and provide possible even more services

0:27:20 and I say more

0:27:22 Because as we crest of over 50,000 population, there are those host of new things and we are going to be responsible for.

0:27:30 And a growing community requires us to look at doing some more things as well.

0:27:34 I share it with the council in a past slide, ratios.

0:27:41 And if you have 77 form police officers that are on the street, you have a community of 50,000 population, you have a ratio of about 1.5 police officers per 1,000 served.

0:27:53 and Craig and all other law enforcement professionals would say that's a good

0:27:58 number. We don't really support ratios, we don't want to find everything by ratios

0:28:02 but that's a good number if you're going to live by ratios.

0:28:05 Population served inside the city of Twin Falls is more than that, it's double that.

0:28:10 More than a hundred thousand and seventy seven's weren't police officers in the

0:28:15 community over a hundred thousand not an event weekend is under one and under

0:28:21 one's not a good number and in order to fund the number of police officers that

0:28:26 we need in our community to be able to reach a ratio of one point officers per

0:28:33 population served of a hundred thousand requires us to find an additional $1.9

0:28:37 million. Actions of the legislature just took that away. So we will continue to

0:28:51 look at growth and there's a great conversation occurring that growth needs

0:28:54 to pay for growth. But what's occurring inside of Twin Falls and was causing a

0:29:01 demand on our services is not the growth of our own community. It is the growth of

0:29:06 region and regionally we need to find a way to continue to provide those services

0:29:12 because as we shared with you in the past half of the misdemeanor citations and

0:29:18 general citations that we issue are to individuals that do not live within the

0:29:23 city of Twin Falls. I think last year was 28% of the number of calls that we

0:29:30 respond to and likes all citizens not in Twin Falls. We don't think and choose who

0:29:36 we provide services to we do so when there's a need.

0:29:42 We also need to be able to have the resources

0:29:45 as a human organization to be able to continue

0:29:47 to provide those services.

0:29:51 We have some ideas when it comes to finding capital dollars

0:29:56 to be able to meet the requirements

0:29:59 that we have in our water system.

0:30:00 And we believe there's a dynamic opportunity for us

0:30:03 to find additional money without causing a net increase

0:30:09 increase to our ratepayers. We'll talk about that a little bit tonight. We want to continue

0:30:17 to strive to be the employer of choice. I don't want the ways who are just good enough.

0:30:26 Providing for the public safety, I want us to be able to open space, moving snow and patch air

0:30:44 creative, driven individuals that answer some really ton of our pursuit of being the employer

0:31:00 of choice. We need to position ourselves to ridiculously tough labor market. We talk about

0:31:11 our strategic plan and sometimes we gloss over it are at the heart of our

0:31:18 organization and we need to be mindful of that as we move forward. So here's the

0:31:26 numbers. What I want to do is exercise or say that these are incredibly

0:31:38 preliminary. We have a phenomenal relationship with our county assessor.

0:31:42 Mr. Will gives us the information before it is final which is incredibly

0:31:49 valuable for us to be able to have these conversations.

0:31:54 And his process is still ongoing. They still have the board of equalization, and they still have a whole series of other staffs

0:32:01 before these are going to be finalized numbers, and they're really good.

0:32:06 They're in the ballpark. They're not going to be perfect. We're going to expect some changes, but it gives us a really good starting place to start the dialogue.

0:32:14 And so we think, Mr. Will's for the effort that he goes through to get us the numbers early.

0:32:21 But you can see that the City of Twin Falls in total taxable value of the community

0:32:26 is growing by nearly 600, actually 6.7% lower than what it was last year.

0:32:42 We're projecting a potential decrease between 61 cents and 67 cents per thousand dollars of taxable value to the tax rate.

0:32:53 And we'll talk about those options in a minute, you're going to see why.

0:33:02 There are some things that we'll talk about that you will cause this number to grow.

0:33:06 But on the other side, there's still some uncertainty as to what that looks like.

0:33:11 We're not spending significant cash reserves as we did, like on the Hank and Throw project, $3 million in the last year.

0:33:21 So this is a graphical representation of the city of Twin Falls.

0:33:28 Total taxable value, corporation traded on Wall Street, and we doubled our corporate value in.

0:33:39 As your CEO, I think I'd like that bonus check. I'm just saying.

0:33:50 I can't take responsibility for that number, but really if you take a look at that, it increased by 17.36%.

0:33:58 As an interesting number, the total taxable value of the community increased by 17.36%

0:34:06 but we know residential properties increased by 25%.

0:34:11 What that tells me is residential properties are growing at a much faster rate than commercial

0:34:17 and industrial properties.

0:34:18 That's important to consider.

0:34:21 One of the courses in the last few fiscal years you can see that we've significantly

0:34:28 grown in the course of since 2019.

0:34:36 This excludes the urban and regional agency.

0:34:39 The Urban Renewal Agency adds an additional $654 million to the total value.

0:34:49 This is the new construction number.

0:34:52 So in that new construction number is $103 million of net value.

0:34:59 Now the real new construction number is $114 million.

0:35:05 But the Idaho legislature says we can claim 90% of that, but that 90% yields $103 million

0:35:11 of new construction, which is still the largest on record.

0:35:15 So even though it's discounted by an additional 10%,

0:35:19 it is the largest on record by 103,

0:35:22 and 103 new construction activity will result in $626,000

0:35:30 of new property tax revenue.

0:35:32 New construction last year was $80,576,000.

0:35:41 How we calculate new construction has profoundly changed

0:35:45 the revenues that come in,

0:35:47 and for here it's a decrease in about $156,000.

0:35:51 the old formula remained in effect where you take 114 million and you multiply it by the prior year tax

0:35:57 rate. In comparison to you take new construction, you discount it 10% and you multiply it by the

0:36:06 anticipated tax rate of that is actually 609 before you add new construction and that's how you get

0:36:13 into the mathematical product but still great opportunity for us to continue to move forward

0:36:20 We're seeing a healthy, expansive community, which is not what every city in our country can boast about.

0:36:29 So this is a graphical representation of what we see the anticipated tax rate being.

0:36:38 You can see that it has a general downward trend.

0:36:41 In 2017, the tax rate was $8.04 per thousand dollars of taxable value.

0:36:47 2022 is going to range between $6.16 and $6.22.

0:36:56 Either tax rate issued will be the lowest ever by the city of Twin Falls.

0:37:01 I shouldn't say ever because in 1842 it could have been something.

0:37:09 Let me say the most recent history.

0:37:20 I want you to remember I said that we're cutting overall spending.

0:37:25 This curve represents the cost of doing business for the City of Twin Falls.

0:37:32 So we focus on the municipal cost index, the municipal cost index.

0:37:36 He is an inflationary tool that helps take local government products, puts it in our own little basket,

0:37:45 and it says those products have increased blank over blank year over year.

0:37:52 increases in us in doing business for the City of Twin Falls and the materials that we

0:37:58 procure diesel as fault.

0:38:01 The cement when it's not rationed is of 7%.

0:38:09 The MCI has increased since 2012-2022%.

0:38:20 Because of the leadership team that we have inside the City of Twin Falls and you focus

0:38:23 on our operation and maintenance budgets, they haven't grown by 22%.

0:38:28 and maintaining quality people, the value of moving forward in one city is able to maximize resources,

0:38:37 that create true savings on the back end and is reflected over a period of time.

0:38:46 Saving 22% and maximizing those dollars, the real win for our community,

0:38:52 and the CPI over that same period of time year over year April to April has gone up 4.16%.

0:39:05 That's important to recognize that as members of our employee core are looking at providing for their families,

0:39:12 the very cost has gone up with property taxes.

0:39:28 This budget recommends taking the 3% statutory allowed decrease.

0:39:35 It also recommends taking the new construction and annexation rules that's permitted by code.

0:39:41 One of the things that the city council needs to consider and the variation in the tax rate

0:39:46 is to whether or not you want to initially include 1% of the city's foregone balance.

0:39:51 When we were having a conversation, there was the should the city take the foregone balance.

0:39:59 House Bill 329 restricted the amount that you can take.

0:40:04 1% revenue.

0:40:07 As long as your total revenues for that fiscal year fall under 8%.

0:40:12 If you take the 1% foregone balance, we are under the 8%.

0:40:17 and it's going to save interest over time by paying that off early.

0:41:12 Then we are suggesting that you incorporate two new rates, one in an $8.67 flat rate,

0:41:21 and then an $11.00 per gallon increase inside of our system,

0:41:30 and we can illustrate a little bit later,

0:41:33 reducing and eliminating the one rate and creating the other rate

0:41:38 The rate still provides a net reduction in overall water costs to our customers.

0:41:45 Provides a valuable revenue stream for us to be able to care for a water system.

0:41:52 Requires significant monies moving forward from dollars and sixty cents in an increase

0:42:05 of eleven per one thousand gallons is that just at what point time would the eleven cents

0:42:11 kick in for a thousand gallons or is it you get so many I have some examples okay all right.

0:42:21 I'll show you the examples when we get to where we show the residential numbers.

0:42:25 I think that might answer your question a little bit more clearly.

0:42:30 We are not increasing, we are not recommending any increase in the eye in the story.

0:42:34 And we are looking at a .68% increase in this annotation and recycling rate.

0:42:41 That's really a pass through by our service provider at PSI, recommending a 3% compensation adjustment.

0:42:53 We are recommending maintaining health insurance benefits at an increase of 9.4% to the city as well as to the employees.

0:43:01 So what's important to remember is that when we increase this, the city has a share and there's an employee share and as our rate goes out, so do the employees' rates.

0:43:15 One of the things that we've heard about and clear from our employees is they want

0:43:18 continued investment in training and education, so we've placed more money into training and

0:43:24 education.

0:43:25 We're adding additional positions that are going to help maximize everything moving forward.

0:43:31 A water rate operator, as well as a assistant public works director, to really focus on

0:43:38 the critical infrastructure components that we have, someone in the area of organizational

0:43:45 of development to do supervisor training

0:43:47 to help grow leaders within our own organization

0:43:51 so that we can become not so reliant on attraction

0:43:57 and more reliant on retention

0:44:02 and then taking advantage of a GIS tool

0:44:04 that is going to help us make better decisions

0:44:08 by incorporating better data.

0:44:13 One of the questions that I have for the council

0:44:15 and we ask this routinely is do you want

0:44:19 to take a look at your compensation.

0:44:22 And the reason we ask that every other year

0:44:24 is because that's when you can consider it.

0:44:27 Idaho Statues 203 says that you can change

0:44:34 your rate of compensation.

0:44:36 75 days before, any general's an election.

0:44:42 All that election's in November.

0:44:44 These are the years in which you consider that.

0:44:47 And then it does not go into effect

0:44:50 until the next council is seated.

0:44:53 So it goes into effect after January.

0:44:57 So the council conversation is timely for you

0:45:01 to direct staff on how you would like to move that forward.

0:45:06 Staff would recommend that we make sure

0:45:09 that we are offering competitive salaries moving forward.

0:45:13 And the last time the council salary was increased

0:45:17 was by ordinance on August 13th of 2007.

0:45:23 and it took place in January of 2008.

0:45:27 And I would say that probably the way in which

0:45:30 staff works in the council is slightly different

0:45:32 than the way it was in 2008.

0:45:35 So the three cents that you guys make per hour

0:45:38 might be something you want to evaluate.

0:45:43 And staff will be in a position that can help with that.

0:45:46 This is the entire, this is kind of a chart

0:45:50 that reflects the capital that we've invested in our community

0:45:54 ranging from water lines to sewer lines to parks, to playgrounds, to the whole process.

0:46:01 And here, it looks like we're spending $6 million less.

0:46:06 Well, there's some really big projects that aren't included.

0:46:09 One of them's $14 million for a fire station.

0:46:12 So we know that we're going to spend $14 million on fire station, but we're still waiting.

0:46:18 We're finalizing the design. We'll go out to bid towards shortly, either before or after the first of the year.

0:46:24 the first of the year, we'll have a better idea and we'll come to you with a budget amendment.

0:46:29 So now that there's going to be $14 million of growth in fire stations that we've allocated.

0:46:32 In addition to that, we would like the council to consider doing a buying and another fire apparatus.

0:46:42 So we have $375,000 of care's money, and then we would like to do that same lease agreement

0:46:50 that we had that we did with letter one.

0:46:52 So remember with letter one, it was a $1.5 million project.

0:46:56 We shared with the council we'd like for you to take out a lease purchase arrangement.

0:47:00 It may go for 10 years, but we shared that the first cash reserves payment that we would

0:47:05 do is we'd go pay off that debt.

0:47:07 We've paid off that debt.

0:47:08 So now we officially own the latter truck, but what this does is it provides us with some

0:47:13 financial flexibility because of the uncertainty.

0:47:17 We can extend that payment out over a period of time with the non-appropriations clauses

0:47:22 that are placed into it.

0:47:25 Because I know that the council is dead at first, we would pay that off with cash reserves

0:47:32 just as we did with the prior fire truck to ship those revenues and resources to be available.

0:47:37 But again, a really staggering number for me is the amount of money this council and past

0:47:46 councils have invested in our infrastructure.

0:47:52 As an organization, we've invested 138, that's from what that does is it sets a really solid platform for us to continue to build and expand upon.

0:48:10 Which is why when we start looking at the new water rate proposal, we believe that's only going to continue to help us move further.

0:48:17 I'm not going to go through all of these tonight, one by one, and painfully, but these

0:48:28 are just some of the projects that as we've gone through our balancing, these are the projects

0:48:37 that have fallen into what we would describe as a category A. These are the projects that

0:48:43 we would move forward for immediate funding upon approval budget in the next fiscal year.

0:48:54 We are also in the process of developing an entire series of category B projects.

0:49:00 I believe strongly in category B projects and for me it's very, very simple.

0:49:07 We've shared the robust building economy that we have.

0:49:11 We've shared with you that we've already met the budgetary needs for this current fiscal

0:49:18 year and the issuance of building permits.

0:49:20 But I can't tell you how long that's going to last.

0:49:24 And I don't want to artificially inflate that because when I do, I am going to have to intentionally

0:49:33 And so by being able to fund category B projects with revenues that are not built into our permanent revenue stream

0:49:46 It allows us to be much more stable and more deliberate in our actions

0:49:51 It allows us not to put our community on a roller coaster when it comes to financing.

0:49:56 It also allows projects to be released out of the gate as opposed to putting on holdbacks.

0:50:02 So we spent a little bit of time talking about the water payoff, and the reason we're able to pay off our snake dead early is because we've collected that additional premium.

0:50:32 We've banked that additional premium, and now we're in a position to be able to pay that off, and by paying it off early,

0:50:39 be able to save $578,000 of revenue.

0:50:44 So that completely goes away.

0:50:47 We think that just makes really, really good sense.

0:50:51 By having or blessing what we do, then we go from a 60-day notice period,

0:51:10 provide that in advance to the city council,

0:51:20 and have two more debts.

0:51:26 You can see what those debts look like as we...

0:51:32 So what do we want to do?

0:51:39 So the entire arsenic fee right now generates

0:51:44 about 2.3 million, and what we would like to do,

0:51:51 like to take a combination of flat and consumption rate,

0:51:58 like to incorporate that into our overall operating system.

0:52:04 So this orange area and everything

0:52:07 in above that orange area represents

0:52:11 all of the opportunity that we have, objects.

0:52:20 What we're proposing is a gradual increase

0:52:24 so that John and members of his team

0:52:26 can be successful in line maintenance,

0:52:30 so that they have the ability to capture

0:52:32 the additional funds, design work, be successful,

0:52:37 and then take and move those projects forward.

0:52:40 Over time, in a 15 year window,

0:52:45 this is just giving John a ramp,

0:52:48 gives them an opportunity to collect $15.2 million

0:52:53 funds be able to be applied for routine maintenance, line maintenance projects.

0:53:05 The additional cash reserves that we have in the bank allow us to consider a completion

0:53:11 of these significant projects moving forward.

0:53:21 It is pay as you go system and allows us to be able to complete and make improvements

0:53:31 to eat canyons springs, crossing 8, 8, 10,000,000,000

0:53:39 to allow for additional growth in that transmission line.

0:53:51 One of the things that as we move forward,

0:53:53 we're having a conversation about is making sure

0:53:56 that people of our organization have fulfilled,

0:54:01 be able to fill with the things in which they're doing.

0:54:06 I was left to have when I said that engineers are creative,

0:54:11 but engineers like to be able to eat, solve problems,

0:54:20 and administrators.

0:54:22 And when you think about just I will be the first

0:54:26 to tell you that I cannot tell you or begin to tell you

0:54:29 the complexities of designing a water tank,

0:54:32 consulting engine to design a water tank

0:54:47 that costs us 3.2 million, or a single project.

0:54:54 I'll imagine if you will, we brought some

0:54:58 of this work back in house.

0:55:01 How many more projects we're able to complete internally.

0:55:08 And at the same time, create an environment

0:55:10 where that members of our team can pick and design

0:55:19 and fulfill those projects that they're comfortable doing.

0:55:25 At the same time, save us, consider one money.

0:55:30 So this is the concept.

0:55:32 And we would like to move forward with this.

0:55:35 By moving forward with it, tonight,

0:55:36 getting the nod and the blessing to move forward

0:55:39 isn't the end of the conversation.

0:55:42 None of these are the end of the conversation.

0:55:44 It's just what we're putting at the starting line

0:55:46 of the conversation as we move forward.

0:55:50 So to Councilman Reed's question,

0:55:51 what does that look like?

0:55:53 So here's the flat rate,

0:55:55 and here's the consumption rate of an individual

0:55:58 that consumes 10,000 gallons of water.

0:56:01 You can see the rate as it is now,

0:56:04 and the new consumption rate.

0:56:06 If you take a look at it,

0:56:21 you can see that a person who uses 10,000 gallons of water

0:56:26 with save $1.27 a month,

0:56:29 under this new purple being slow, but you show the rate S is as 1173, but we're going

0:56:42 to drop that new flat rate was what did you say $8? It looks to me like you're showing

0:56:50 the new rate at 20.33, so it looks like you're adding the 8 to the 11.

0:56:56 We are adding the 8 to an 11 because there is an existing flat rate now, we're in utilities

0:57:03 and then we're decreasing this rate.

0:57:07 You often share more of the numbers

0:57:11 so in our water rate structure,

0:57:13 there's an initial flat rate, which is reflected here.

0:57:17 And that flat rate has nothing to do

0:57:19 with the arsenic rate now.

0:57:21 This is a regular mandatory.

0:57:22 The MAC mandatory arsenic rate is that rate here,

0:57:25 so the rate as is is $10.75, it moves to zero.

0:57:30 That's true.

0:57:40 So what does our average per month?

0:57:51 Let's give me a second, we'll get right there.

0:57:53 It looks like Brianna's jump bike ramp.

0:58:02 It's actually between that five and 10,000

0:58:04 run around 8,000.

0:58:06 We've got multiple examples that we could share with you.

0:58:09 I've actually pulled a sampling of about 10 different homes.

0:58:13 Mine included in some years.

0:58:15 So we have some examples that you can actually see in point,

0:58:19 but it's about 8,000.

0:58:20 8,000.

0:58:21 8,000.

0:58:22 Thank you.

0:58:23 Thank you.

0:58:24 Mine might be on the higher side, actually.

0:58:28 So our random sample included the council line.

0:58:30 Breanne is a bit just a few who just wanted to know.

0:58:34 Early random, right?

0:58:37 Try to say no questions, too.

0:58:38 So is that just on the residential rates?

0:58:42 And so it wouldn't be the industrial order.

0:58:44 So the industrial folks would see a slight increase,

0:58:47 as opposed to what we would see on the residential side.

0:58:50 I think that some of our larger users were just right,

0:58:54 had more slightly under $1,000 a month.

0:58:57 So when you think about the grand scheme of the water consumption, the water users and the projects,

0:59:03 that's saying that $1,000 isn't a month based upon usage, to a certain extent because the arsenic fee was $75 and $10.75.

0:59:23 What we wanted to do is we recognized that if you have an emergency shutdown, there's no water,

0:59:35 that type of capital project is going to affect everyone.

0:59:38 But when you're looking at upsizing lines and capacities,

0:59:42 so that you can use more, that's a consumption thing.

0:59:46 So that's why you see more of a blended rate here.

0:59:49 Then with the arsenic rate, the arsenic rate

0:59:51 was really about water quality.

0:59:54 That the first drop and the last drop

0:59:56 had to mean the arsenic standard.

0:59:58 Here, what we're looking at is when

1:00:00 you look at a 10 million gallon water tank,

1:00:02 air community benefit springs crossing.

1:00:19 I also like the, the chains.

1:00:22 I know you don't have mine because I live in a condo and we pay our eight units and my condo

1:00:28 Bentley paid $10.75. That's supposed to be to these individuals. I think this actually becomes a fairer thing for the many

1:00:38 multi-family units that I actually live in and I live in a condo that will be paying a little more for water as well as a flat rate.

1:00:48 So it's fair as the how people live in our community is changing to be honest with you

1:00:56 because each one of those four places has one tap, I'm sure, just like my condo building

1:01:00 has one tap, and so the fly rate doesn't necessarily equal being fair, but if I play

1:01:08 it a little bit more for the water than I became my favorite myself.

1:01:16 So then this new rate would be per person like Greg said, or would that rate just still

1:01:21 be that one rate to his whole building?

1:01:25 So we build based upon the water meter.

1:01:28 And so when you take a look at the water meter, it would still be two meters, but where it

1:01:36 does get to be slightly different is because there are more units using the water that

1:01:42 that's going to be better reflected in them.

1:01:45 Just a solid flat rate that's going to be reflective in an increased consumption.

1:01:49 Again, we're going to be able to pay off the interest, provide $570,000 of savings to all

1:02:11 of our ratepayers, residential customers across the board that we looked at.

1:02:16 Saw a rate reduction, but we also acknowledge commercial industrial customers.

1:02:22 The larger users, volumes of water, see modest increases.

1:02:26 And again, some of our largest users were right at or slightly less than $1,000.

1:02:34 Council directed capital is something that as we continue to forward

1:02:44 These are some of the projects that we've incorporated that we'd like for you to be considering there may be others

1:03:09 70

1:03:16 like we had done in the past, this was the first time we'd done it this way.

1:03:20 Yeah, I will tell you that there are quite a few needs that we're not able to meet and move forward to you as if the council says yes, you'd like consideration of the 1% foregone balance.

1:03:34 We would incorporate that into our budgets and move forward and continue to have conversations on how we would best allocate it to the base, but I would encourage the council to consider some of it for the areas of compensation for our employees.

1:03:52 But that's not something that we've put in this labor market and then also recognizing that

1:04:01 the price index is in excess F4, the way it needs cost.

1:04:12 Also, to markets there are areas that we are struggling and that we need to be able to

1:04:26 resource better.

1:04:27 I was thinking that CPI was what I was going to mention, was that my help was to keep up

1:04:42 that piece.

1:04:49 So then again, that 1070 is completely isolated, it's ready for the council to kind of move

1:04:54 some of those projects. So we usually we share this at the beginning but we want to save it to the end.

1:05:04 So again we we reflected how fast homes are growing into and false today but the taxable value of a home

1:05:15 is determined at a very specific point in time by Idaho Code to on January 1st what is the value of

1:05:20 that home. So we took those median values and we incorporated it into this model at the invaluable home.

1:05:33 You apply the two different homeowners exemptions.

1:05:37 Now for the home in fiscal year 21, it qualified for $100,000 homeowners exemption, or 50% whichever was less.

1:05:48 So in this case, the $100,000 cap was used and created a taxable value of this home of $118,000.

1:05:57 For fiscal year 22, the legislature increased that cap to $125,000.

1:06:04 So the taxable value of that home after the deduction of 125,000 became 128 tax rates, $8.63

1:06:19 that was assessed last year, 616 that does not include the 1% foregone or the 622 that

1:06:28 includes the 1% foregone. This right here is the impact of the citizen of the city of

1:06:37 If you take the 1% foregone balance, you would see that person is going to realize a savings,

1:06:48 a property taxes of $16.61, so make the numbers don't change at all.

1:06:55 They'll change, right? So this is just what kind of war we're in.

1:06:59 Someone who uses 18,000 gallons would see a reduction in their bill of $0.39 per month.

1:07:05 month. We have a hard cap on super at 12,000 gallons. They would not see any increase. If

1:07:15 there's annotation recycling, we'd go up 13 cents based on the pass-through for PSI. So

1:07:23 you're looking at a typical water customer that was received about 26 cent savings. It would be $1.64.

1:07:31 In $1.64, it doesn't sound like a lot, it's in an environment that we're experiencing a

1:07:43 7% increase in the cost of doing business.

1:07:46 That is a credit to the leadership team of the City of Twin Falls.

1:07:58 Dan, process.

1:07:59 There's the regular season calendar.

1:08:12 Questions?

1:08:22 This evening, thank you, Travis.

1:08:27 Very good presentation.

1:08:28 I guess we all have more homework to do.

1:08:32 We are Mitch.

1:08:33 Is Mitch going to present on?

1:08:37 is Michigan to present on this is pre-season and he got injured or he just had you know some stuff done oh

1:08:46 He'll be back. All right. I just want to make sure

1:08:50 He loves doing it

1:08:52 Well, I took it as you didn't want to hear from me

1:08:55 Great things that we're going to be able to do is we're going to replicate what we did in 2018

1:09:07 We've we've sent out the call. We've encouraged all members of our team to creatively showcase what they want to do

1:09:14 We've shared

1:09:17 You know, use videos, use pictures, explain share stories,

1:09:23 get that true on the ground,

1:09:25 impact from members of the team.

1:09:26 And so COVID didn't allow us to do that last year

1:09:29 because we weren't able to move people into our organization.

1:09:32 We're taking full advantage of where we stand

1:09:34 in the health members of the long-term plan

1:09:38 as well as other members.

1:09:40 Be making significant portions of these presentations.

1:09:44 Mitch and I will be just kind of serving

1:09:46 as the initial employees of the teams.

1:09:56 I'm gonna ask you to take our thanks back to your staff,

1:09:59 but I'm just gonna look around the audience

1:10:01 and say thank you.

1:10:02 I see a lot of smiling faces out there,

1:10:04 and I know that these are the folks

1:10:05 that have been putting in some hours.

1:10:08 So we appreciate all the work.

1:10:13 Right, he and moving forward,

1:10:14 now is an opportunity for anyone in the general public

1:10:18 who would like to discuss anything

1:10:20 with the Council that was not on this evening's agenda,

1:10:24 to three minutes to come visit with us.

1:10:26 Alright, seeing the one taking advantage of that, I'll turn it over to the council for advisory board reports.

1:10:34 Go ahead, Craig.

1:10:40 I thought the parade was really a lot of fun after the parade.

1:10:48 The parade calls so when I spoke there, I was, I've never been there. It was amazing.

1:11:04 It was really, really good.

1:11:09 We tried to disagree that the part I was supposed to raise was they'd set it up so that they don't even have to be open for you to make it a great experience for your family.

1:11:16 family if you want to take a group out there. They've got

1:11:20 civilians that are outside that are covered with seeding videos that play

1:11:25 and then lots of signage of the different things.

1:11:29 And then if they are open, if the interpretive center is open, it's even greater.

1:11:34 Knowledge value, the four things you can see on the inside there that

1:11:39 cover all kinds of immigration. Talk about the Chinese, the Kingdom,

1:11:43 Sell their gold, might have been in the Snake River as well as many other groups and information about them in the area.

1:11:51 So it's really a place you don't have to be the Snake Forest Grater.

1:11:55 So you can certainly take your family out there and have it be an experience.

1:12:00 And it's free.

1:12:01 And they've done a really nice job.

1:12:04 I will admit, I've been there, but I have not been there since the summer of 1965 or 4,

1:12:11 for whichever one the centennial celebration

1:12:14 because of the Falls County's centennial celebration

1:12:17 for becoming in territory was added at that site.

1:12:20 So it looks a lot better now than it did by then.

1:12:24 Good.

1:12:29 So really a committee.

1:12:31 But last Thursday night was the first city band concert

1:12:35 of the year.

1:12:36 And I have never seen so many folks out there

1:12:38 enjoying the music and the festivities.

1:12:41 This Thursday night against 730 at City Park.

1:12:44 I'd like to invite our community to come out and support our man.

1:12:47 It was really fun night, so and then I know we have next Monday night,

1:12:53 but just for the council members and staff that are attending

1:12:57 AIC conference next week at Boise, oh my goodness.

1:13:02 Typically, the association would host a dinner on Wednesday night,

1:13:06 which they're not doing any longer.

1:13:08 And we did not have any per diem put on our expenses for Wednesday night.

1:13:14 So I'm inviting everybody to a city mayor's dinner at the Cottonwood Grill at seven o'clock.

1:13:19 And we're just going to have some time to catch up and discuss what we're learning at the conference

1:13:24 and show our Twin Paul's pride that while we're together.

1:13:28 So we'll get the bill to Travis.

1:13:31 Isn't it nice of me to invite anything from city manager's office?

1:13:38 Two things.

1:13:39 So if Josh Barrett could come forward.

1:13:41 So I want to, again I shared with the council and who gets used to that as,

1:13:56 As a member of the city's executive leadership team, but I'm proud to introduce Josh Baird

1:14:00 as the next city engineer will continue to Josh. Josh is going to be in capacity. Josh, I think,

1:14:22 is an example of how organizationally to invest in the network site at what it's for us, and so

1:14:35 we put him on the spot for a minute, but Josh, there you go. Welcome, and congratulations. Yes?

1:14:42 Thank you. Thank you. I'm a next city engineer. I have very large shoes to fill. I asked Mark

1:14:49 a couple of days ago in their size 14.

1:14:52 I don't quite wear a size 14,

1:14:55 it's a big shoes I have to feel,

1:14:56 but I'm excited for the opportunity.

1:14:58 I'm thankful for the interests and confidence

1:15:01 that Travis and the rest of the video

1:15:03 put into me, I'm excited for a chance

1:15:06 to watch the series with Paul's crew

1:15:07 and I'll do my best to make a decision here, so.

1:15:11 Thank you.

1:15:12 We know you will.

1:15:13 We're happy to have you.

1:15:20 Let's have more.

1:15:24 No doubt it's good to kind of put members

1:15:25 of our leadership team on the spot just for a minute, right?

1:15:27 because it's an impromptu, because during the budget process.

1:15:30 You're gonna raise your hand, you're gonna have a question,

1:15:32 which is all need to be ready.

1:15:34 So it's welcome to preseason, Josh.

1:15:38 The second thing I have is we've been getting a lot of questions

1:15:41 at the city in terms of independence, de-celebration,

1:15:44 and what that looks like.

1:15:46 Yes, we're going to have fireworks.

1:15:47 They're going to be city sponsored entirely this year,

1:15:51 just as it were last year.

1:15:53 And it's going to be the same celebration that we've had

1:15:57 In years past, we're working in partnership

1:16:00 with the College of Southern Idaho.

1:16:04 My special event permit will be come next

1:16:09 for your consideration, but lots of individuals

1:16:11 have been calling asking, are we going to do something

1:16:13 this year, and we thought that we would officially announce

1:16:17 that and we'll continue to announce

1:16:19 that new re-opportunity, that's all I have.

1:16:22 Thank you.

1:16:27 So this evening, we do have a public hearing,

1:16:30 which we do not start before 6 p.m.,

1:16:33 and once again, we have been successful

1:16:35 not getting there before 6 p.m. This evening's public hearing is a request for

1:16:41 annexation and appropriate zoning district for property located at the

1:16:46 Harrison Street, Inclinton Drive intersection in care of Johnny Hanche on

1:16:51 behalf of eternal life Christian Center and I have visited with our legal team

1:16:57 this week and because Johnny is my relative and I am a church member at the

1:17:03 I am going to recuse myself and turn the remainder of the meeting over to our vice mayor.

1:17:10 So if you'll give us just a second, we'll have a few days to bear with me, Sean, I hope you have my back.

1:17:43 So I believe I need to read this, is that correct?

1:17:48 Planning and zoning, public hearing procedures, during public hearing portion of the meeting,

1:17:54 testimony will be taken from the public related to each item.

1:18:00 Please contact staff if you have any items not listed on the agenda.

1:18:05 The commission will follow these 9 steps for each request listed under public hearing portion of the agenda.

1:18:10 City staff will present the request and analysis.

1:18:14 The applicant will then present their request.

1:18:17 The commission will then ask questions of the applicant or staff.

1:18:21 After questions have been asked, the public hearing will then be opened.

1:18:26 During that time, anyone in attendance is given the opportunity to comment or ask questions

1:18:31 about the request being considered.

1:18:34 When the testimony, when giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address

1:18:40 and present your comments or concerns.

1:18:43 After giving testimony, please sign the public.

1:18:46 Sign in sheet located in the lobby with your name and address for the record.

1:18:50 After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer any questions, make a closing statement,

1:18:57 staff will then answer, clarify any comments as needed.

1:19:01 After the closing statements, the public hearing will be closed, no further testimony or comments from the applicant or audience will be allowed.

1:19:09 The commission will then have an open discussion and take action on the request.

1:19:16 Some of the actions are taken, some of the actions taken by the Commissioner final,

1:19:21 others are recommendations which are sent forward to the City Council which we are doing

1:19:26 for the Board of Commissioners for a final decision. Okay, that'd be good. Okay, so City staff, welcome.

1:19:38 Thank you. Council members, good evening. This is a request to annex approximately 12 acres

1:19:45 into the City limits with a zoning designation of R4. The subject property which you guys can

1:19:51 see on your screen is outlined in that red box, is located at the intersection of Harrison

1:20:00 Street and Clinton Street, which is south of us right now, it's just north of Orchard

1:20:05 Drive where there's a church right there. The property has historically been used for

1:20:11 agricultural purposes and is currently undeveloped. Surrounding properties are zoned our fort and

1:20:17 have existing residential and religious facilities. The applicant is requesting that the subject

1:20:22 property be annexed in the city for the purposes of having access to city utilities

1:20:27 for future subdivision development. Applicants also requesting that the zoning

1:20:31 site designation of an R4 with the annexation. The future land use map identifies as

1:20:38 area's town neighborhood and in the comprehensive plan it states that single

1:20:42 family dwellings, two plexes, triplexes and town home units are appropriate land

1:20:47 uses for the town neighborhood area, a staff believes that this the applicants

1:20:52 request isn't in compliance with the comprehensive plan and the P&Z

1:20:56 Commission forwarded a positive recommendation for a zoning designation of

1:21:00 R4 on April 27th, 2021. Staff did receive one public comment via email which was

1:21:07 forwarded to the city council. The city council has a task to decide whether the

1:21:12 subject property shall be annexed with the recommended zoning designation of R4.

1:21:18 Any questions that you guys have for staff?

1:21:21 Any questions at this point in time?

1:21:26 Thank you.

1:21:27 Moving on, the applicant, who's the applicant?

1:21:38 I don't see the engine, you two options.

1:21:50 We can't table the item for a future date.

1:21:53 They were certainly notified of this meeting

1:21:55 because they sent letters out for it.

1:21:57 Or most likely you'd want to hear

1:22:02 as they can't make a presentation.

1:22:06 I'm thinking Stephen was the one, are you the applicant?

1:22:09 And the applicant sure come up.

1:22:11 Stephen's the only one I don't know.

1:22:12 Thank you. Excellent.

1:22:14 Moving on.

1:22:19 Thank you.

1:22:20 is Johnny Hanshee, I owned the property to the north air of the church, we sold it since,

1:22:25 and I understand it's the development that's coming in to take pretty much it's out of my hands as

1:22:34 now he is, and so that's kind of where we're at. Is that close enough? Not as much as I can.

1:22:45 Okay, so any questions for council have some wishes as to what we want to do? Without the

1:23:05 to applicant here should we do the public hearing at least decide we do have to open the public hearing

1:23:15 yeah so any questions for staff at this point I'm doing something shot mr.

1:23:35 hanci signed the letter of intent so he's actually the deeded propaganda representative

1:23:41 the third intent does not actually transfer the 10 us history and she is the current deeded property

1:23:49 on her body has a letter intent to sell it as cited have a quite zoning so I realize tonight we're not

1:24:04 It's just a complex and a puzzle plexus.

1:24:22 Yeah, so, seeing family duplexes are outright permitted,

1:24:25 and triplexes and forplexes require special use permit.

1:24:28 Other questions? Okay, then I will open the public hearing.

1:24:44 Is there anybody here from the public that wishes to give testimony?

1:24:48 Please step up to the podium.

1:24:54 Oh, we do. Jason? This Jason? Okay, Jeff?

1:25:12 Oops, pardon me. Duplexes and triplexes.

1:25:20 And that area is in desperate need of rental property, and that's what this is going to be.

1:25:27 They are also finishing the property the roadway on Harrison to Richard for the city.

1:25:35 And having that taken care of as the city had requested.

1:25:39 So I also have Jason Somargo on the list.

1:25:49 Is he left?

1:25:54 I say, okay, thank anybody else from the public?

1:25:59 We did.

1:26:00 We see one comment via email that everybody thought.

1:26:03 I said, okay, with that, with no further testimony, the closing public, actually because they

1:26:20 said they're applicant.

1:26:22 If anybody wants to add anything, applicant is invited to answer any questions.

1:26:26 Any questions?

1:26:27 Staff?

1:26:28 No questions?

1:26:29 So I'll close the public hearing.

1:26:31 So no further comments will be allowed.

1:26:36 So now council discussion.

1:26:37 Wish to speak.

1:26:38 Motion?

1:26:39 Yes.

1:26:45 Okay.

1:26:48 Does your mic go?

1:26:49 It is.

1:26:51 Okay.

1:26:52 Thank you.

1:26:53 Thank you.

1:26:54 Great.

1:26:55 I was going to go ahead and make a motion.

1:26:59 If the vice mayor is ready.

1:27:02 Vice Mayor, I move that we approve the request for annexation and appropriate zoning district

1:27:10 for property located at Harrison Street and Clinton Drive intersection here of Johnny

1:27:15 Hancey on behalf of the Internal Life Christian Center, Incorporated.

1:27:18 Thank you, sir.

1:27:21 Second.

1:27:23 Thank you, Craig.

1:27:24 We move right, Greg Lanting and seconded by Craig Hawkins to approve the request for

1:27:30 annexation inappropriate zoning district for the property located at the Harrison

1:27:35 Street and Clinton drive intersection care of Johnny and she on behalf of the

1:27:40 eternal life Christian center

1:27:42 So any further discussion?

1:27:44 Well, I've had a question to clarify that the appropriate zoning is the recommended R4 from.

1:27:49 Yes, that was my attempt.

1:27:52 Thank you.

1:27:53 Thank you.

1:27:54 That was a second.

1:27:56 I'm like, like Craig said, I think I'm in favor of this.

1:27:58 I was, that was a good question.

1:28:00 Great question.

1:28:01 By Ashan.

1:28:02 We know that Valera tried places four places.

1:28:04 They will require study, require an issue B.

1:28:07 We still have an opportunity to take a look at the plan and see where they might be located

1:28:12 located in related relationships of these existing residential as we've been

1:28:17 trying to do so with that knowledge and well as in favor as well anybody else

1:28:25 wish to speak Amy Rokavo Mr. Perrit yes right cockens yes

1:28:40 on barracker yes Nicky Boyd yes right Lanti yes yes thank you the motion

1:28:49 carries six to zero. That's it for the evening. Thank you everyone. We're adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 7, 2021. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:29:09.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    a6fd0ec107c6e7e6cd74f06932932527b8fd3ef0a8d3cfc8681d0b3f02fed753
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 29af381ef408406409171a7f497b62c3ecaf05d68932aee0b3c2e5b5334fbcc1
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    d2d428eb7953a98554c0c6824b456ba23f47ae8c970cee7834718113a7a346ec

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file