City Council meeting
Monday, December 23, 2019
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,c,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:00:06 Good evening, I would like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, December 23rd, and confirm that we do have a quorum of the Council here, six of the seven members are present this evening.
0:00:16 Vice Mayor Boyd is excused tonight.
0:00:20 Next in the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you who joined us, please rise.
0:00:24 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:00:40 Next on the agenda are proclamations of which we have none this evening, so next will be an opportunity for general public input.
0:00:51 If there's anyone here from the public who would like to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening, now is your opportunity to please come forward.
0:00:59 Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar.
0:01:08 Council wishes.
0:01:12 Move to approve the consent calendar.
0:01:14 Second.
0:01:16 Motion by Chris Reed.
0:01:17 Seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar.
0:01:20 Is there any discussion?
0:01:21 Amy, roll call.
0:01:24 Please.
0:01:25 Senator Eager.
0:01:29 Yes.
0:01:30 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:01:31 Yes.
0:01:32 Great.
0:01:33 Glanting.
0:01:34 Yes.
0:01:35 Yes.
0:01:36 Christopher Reed.
0:01:37 Yes.
0:01:38 Motion passes six to zero.
0:01:39 here for the alcohol licenses for Oasis, Stop and Go, or Oki, Tepanyaki, and Sushi, or
0:01:47 the Suntaris of Division paperwork, or the Morning Sun Subdivision paperwork that was all
0:01:53 just approved. You're welcome to stick around for the rest of the next on the agenda. Under
0:02:00 items of consideration, the first is a request to approve. This is an action item. This is
0:02:05 a request to approve the CH2M Jacobs yearly contract amendment. We have Jason Brown, Environmental
0:02:11 Thank you, Mayor. Members of the Council appreciate this opportunity to speak for you
0:02:21 tonight. As the agenda item noted, this is our annual update to our contract for the operations
0:02:30 of the wastewater treatment plant. And so as we went through the budgeting process, worked
0:02:36 with Jacobs this year, the budget of contract at price was $3,104,329 to operate the wastewater
0:02:46 treatment plan.
0:02:47 So the request denied is for the Council to approve this amendment with the updated
0:02:54 numbers for the operation of the wastewater treatment plan, and I will stand for any
0:02:59 questions.
0:03:01 Thank you Jason. Are there any questions? I just reaffirmed that say annual contract.
0:03:06 Correct. Susan Hawkins.
0:03:10 Just for the public's benefit, I do want to make sure that everyone is aware with that contract.
0:03:15 If there is any excess funds that have been paid, it is reimbursed to the city at the end of the year.
0:03:20 Correct. That is correct. Yes. So we, if they're not spent for the operation portion that is not spent for,
0:03:28 that will be returned, rebated to the city.
0:03:32 Any other comments or questions, Chris Stockington?
0:03:37 Ready to move to approve the request of CH2M on Jacob's Yearly Contract.
0:03:43 Yep, for the stated amount.
0:03:45 Second.
0:03:46 Motion by Chris Stockington.
0:03:48 Second by Christopher Reed to approve the CH2M on Jacob's Yearly Contract.
0:03:53 Amendment as presented is their discussion.
0:03:55 Give me a roll call vote, please.
0:03:59 Suzanne Hawkins?
0:04:00 Yes.
0:04:01 Greg Leinting?
0:04:02 Yes.
0:04:03 Christopher Reed?
0:04:04 Yes.
0:04:05 Yes.
0:04:06 Yes.
0:04:07 Motion passes 6-0.
0:04:08 Thank you.
0:04:09 I'll leave the document over here with perfect.
0:04:11 Thank you, Jason.
0:04:12 Thanks to the team from H2M Jacobs.
0:04:14 We appreciate the partnership that we have with you.
0:04:19 Next on the agenda is an action item.
0:04:25 This is a request to approve the application for Project Safe Neighborhoods Grant.
0:04:29 We have Mandy Thompson grant and Community Relations Manager for the city.
0:04:34 Welcome, Mandy.
0:04:35 Thank you.
0:04:36 Good evening.
0:04:37 be very quick. I'm here tonight to request Council's approval to apply for a grant called Project
0:04:43 Safe Neighborhoods. This is in cooperation with the Bureau of Justice Assistance, which
0:04:50 is a division of the Department of Justice. Essentially, it's part of a task force and
0:04:57 an effort to decrease gun violence nationwide, but specifically in Idaho, by assisting in
0:05:05 the strengthening and creation of a integrated
0:05:08 ballistics information network.
0:05:10 Essentially, it'll be a database that the police department
0:05:13 can enter ballistics information on shell casings
0:05:18 and allow for that it's a social database
0:05:21 that's shared nationwide in order to create links
0:05:25 between various crimes.
0:05:26 So I have Sergeant Kevin Loose here to answer any questions
0:05:29 that you may have, but this is fairly straightforward.
0:05:32 your requirements match, but local match by the city.
0:05:36 And it will allow for the purchase of some equipment
0:05:40 in order for them to start entering information
0:05:45 into the database.
0:05:46 Can you hand me anything to add, sir?
0:05:59 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:06:01 We can't let you off that easy.
0:06:04 So what is your vision with this database?
0:06:07 What is it going to accomplish to help you that we're not
0:06:10 doing already?
0:06:11 So, Neiman is what is referred to National Integrated Ballistic Information Network as a program, put on by the ATF.
0:06:17 So, really is what it does is it takes up the fingerprint of a shell casing, so where the strike hits on the bullet as well as the ejection allows us to mark your unique to the gun.
0:06:28 us to put it into national database. Often in the criminal world, guns travel. We've
0:06:33 had cases here locally where we've had multiple guns stolen. They're being recovered in California
0:06:38 in Nevada. More vice versa. We'll come up this way. A lot of times firearms are used as
0:06:42 currency in the legal drug business. It allows us to track firearms. So if we had somebody committing
0:06:47 crimes in California, that gun changes hands. And we had a crime here involving a firearm,
0:06:53 allows us to put the dots together so maybe you have a cold case drive by
0:06:58 shooting would be an example and you had a shell casing up in the Boise area
0:07:03 suddenly they might have more information allows us to put a case
0:07:06 together here locally and close about.
0:07:08 Great, thank you.
0:07:09 Ruth Pierce.
0:07:10 I'm just ready to make a motion if we're good.
0:07:13 I believe so.
0:07:14 I move we approve the application project safe neighborhoods grant.
0:07:19 Thank you.
0:07:20 Motion by Ruth Pierce, seconded by Greg Lanting to approve the application for the Project
0:07:26 and Safe Neighborhoods grant.
0:07:27 Is there any further discussion?
0:07:32 Give me a roll call vote please.
0:07:34 Greg Lanting?
0:07:35 Yes.
0:07:36 Ruth Pierce?
0:07:37 Yes.
0:07:38 Mr. Fareed?
0:07:39 Yes.
0:07:40 Yes.
0:07:41 Yes.
0:07:42 Yes.
0:07:43 Motion passes 6-0.
0:07:44 Thank you.
0:07:45 Next on the agenda is an action item.
0:07:49 This is an authorizing resolution for the Department of Environmental Quality Drinking
0:07:54 Water Planning Grant, and again, Mandy Thompson.
0:07:58 Good evening, again.
0:08:00 So this is just a formality.
0:08:04 During the 2000 or fiscal year 2020 budgeting process, we budgeted for a water facility
0:08:13 plan update.
0:08:14 However, halfway through that process, we found out that we had been allocated some funding
0:08:18 through DEQ to help offset the cost of that planned update.
0:08:24 Now we were placed on the list and now we're going through the formality of putting our
0:08:29 application into DEQ and then we will be awarded $45,000 to go against the cost of that grant
0:08:41 which are estimated at just under $170,000.
0:08:46 So this resolution that we're asking you to authorize tonight just gives, it just authorizes
0:08:51 three individuals within the city, the city engineer Mark Holson and John Keaton with the
0:08:57 public works and also rebouling our water superintendent.
0:09:00 It just allows them to sign all of the documents related to the grant so that we don't have
0:09:05 to be coming to the council and to the mayor every time something needs to be signed.
0:09:10 Great.
0:09:12 Any questions for Randy and Susan Hawkins?
0:09:19 I move that we authorize the resolution for Department of Environment, Quality, Drinking
0:09:25 Water, Planning, Gramps.
0:09:27 Second.
0:09:28 I was just...
0:09:30 Oh.
0:09:31 Well, I'm just seconding.
0:09:32 The motion by Suzanne Hawkins second by Ruth Pierce to approve the authorizing resolution.
0:09:38 Will this be...
0:09:39 Will this have a resolution number or is it just the document that's in the...
0:09:43 It'll have a number.
0:09:45 Okay.
0:09:46 2019-016.
0:09:47 I made my motion to include the number.
0:09:51 I made my motion to include the number.
0:09:53 I second that amendment.
0:09:55 Perfect.
0:09:56 So we have a motion and a second to approve
0:09:58 the authorizing resolution.
0:09:59 Is there any discussion?
0:10:03 Roll call, please.
0:10:05 Ruth Pierce.
0:10:05 Yes.
0:10:06 Mr. Fareed.
0:10:07 Yes.
0:10:08 Chris Talkington.
0:10:09 Yes.
0:10:09 John Baraker.
0:10:10 Yes.
0:10:11 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:10:12 Yes.
0:10:13 Great landing.
0:10:14 Yes.
0:10:15 Motion passes six to zero.
0:10:18 Thank you.
0:10:19 Thank you.
0:10:20 Thursday after signing all this.
0:10:23 Next on the agenda is an action item.
0:10:25 This is authorization to sign and submit a letter supporting the continued operation
0:10:30 of the refugee resettlement program operating in Twin Falls in accordance with President
0:10:34 Donald J. Trump's executive order, number 13888, and we have our city manager, Travis
0:10:40 Rothweiler.
0:10:41 Take us off.
0:10:42 Yes, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, good evening, and thank you for the opportunity
0:10:46 to present the letter that has been drafted for signature.
0:10:50 You'll notice on the signature line, it has the mayor and my signature to be submitted.
0:10:58 We can talk about that as we can go through this process.
0:11:01 So on September 26, as the mayor had discussed, President Don J. Trump issued Executive Order
0:11:08 13888, and in that it established a process for local entities to become engaged into
0:11:17 refugee resettlement conversation. And it asks not only local government, but also state governments
0:11:26 to take a positive action to say that they have the abilities within their communities for the
0:11:32 continued support of the refugee centers that have been in existence within their communities.
0:11:37 As you know, our refugee center has been in operation for the better part of three decades.
0:11:42 And we have members of the refugee community that have come into Twin Falls, and they've
0:11:48 made positive differences into our organization as well as our community.
0:11:54 The City of Twin Falls is like many other organizations in which we are blessed to have
0:11:59 members whose families have gone through the refugee program who are part of our employee
0:12:04 family, serving this great community.
0:12:09 executive order specifically states that you must submit a letter to continue to
0:12:16 opt into the program. And the letter isn't something that we would submit. It is
0:12:22 actually submitted by the refugee center as a part of their continued grant
0:12:29 process. And so what we have are a series of letters because while this has come
0:12:37 in September, the rules still seem to be a little ambiguous as to the appropriate steps
0:12:43 as to who should be submitting that letter.
0:12:45 So what we're doing is we're leading and we're taking the opportunity to cover all of
0:12:50 our bases.
0:12:51 So in there, we're asking you to sign or for the signature of two letters.
0:12:56 The first is directly to Governor Brad Little in which we say that we talk about the requirements
0:13:04 of the executive order.
0:13:07 We talk about how the City of Twin Falls created a welcoming
0:13:11 resolution in a neighborhood community in 2017.
0:13:17 And we also talk about how this is an important part for the 2020
0:13:21 grant application process.
0:13:24 Those letters are included in your packet,
0:13:27 and they've been online for review.
0:13:29 The second letter is identical.
0:13:32 However, we are sending that one to the Twin Falls County Board of Commissioners, because
0:13:37 there is some language that would lead us to believe that the city may not have an active
0:13:42 role, but it really is the county's role as defined by the executive order when they define
0:13:47 local government, that they may be indeed the local government that is required to take
0:13:53 action.
0:13:54 And so in the event that that is the case, we have our letter should be viewed as encouraging
0:14:01 the county commissioners to take an official step and the steps necessary to
0:14:05 be able to secure and submit the grant funding that comes through the refugee
0:14:12 center for the support of refugees. So with that I'm happy to stand for any
0:14:16 questions that you might have. Thank you Travis. Are there any questions for the
0:14:21 council? I would like to reaffirm that this doesn't have any financial responsibility
0:14:28 from the City of Maryland, in possession of our will or the majority of them.
0:14:35 That is correct.
0:14:36 So the City of Twin Falls does not provide any financial aid or benefit or allocation to
0:14:41 the refugee center.
0:14:42 This letter does not contemplate that we would in the future either.
0:14:46 What it merely states is that we continue to support the operations and the missions
0:14:51 of the refugee center locally.
0:14:54 Susan Hawkins.
0:14:55 Thank you.
0:14:56 a question just more of a ought to share. So whereas I know not everyone in our community
0:15:03 is in favor of a refugee center, I think it has been overwhelmingly evident that the majority
0:15:08 of our citizens are very supportive of the refugee center. And I think they do an excellent
0:15:14 work with what they have. I think it's wonderful that we finally have a chance to have a voice
0:15:19 in the project with that and it not just be CSI but to strengthen our relationship with
0:15:25 CSI and work as team members and so with that I'm definitely in favor of submitting
0:15:31 both of these letters. Thank you Suzanne. I would add too and as we've been
0:15:38 contemplating this for the last couple of months trying to understand the
0:15:42 provisions of the executive order the executive order itself as you know is
0:15:46 pretty sparse in detail and as the Department of State and the Department
0:15:51 of Health and Human Services at the national level are really dealing with
0:15:54 the logistics, and I do think this is an opportunity to strengthen the partnerships that we already
0:16:00 have, not only with CSI, but I think with other government entities who have some connectivity
0:16:06 with not only the refugee resettlement program, but certainly in serving those citizens as
0:16:11 they are part of our shared constituency.
0:16:14 So I too am pleased that we can be down a pathway here to lend our support to those other entities
0:16:22 who as we say our understanding is they're the ones who will be submitting that.
0:16:27 This same process is being contemplated in other communities and I know that also I have
0:16:33 the refugee resettlement programs and I should note that I think there was an article in the
0:16:36 paper this morning, 30 some governors across the country have submitted for this and dozens
0:16:43 of cities and counties and local communities.
0:16:46 Again, I think that the folks who come through this program,
0:16:50 once they're here, are part of our community.
0:16:53 And so I think the program is capable of providing that support to them,
0:16:57 and we should be supportive of it as well.
0:16:59 Chris Stockington.
0:17:01 Well, this is my last meeting with the council.
0:17:04 I don't have any questions.
0:17:06 The state, more than totally supportive of this necessary measure.
0:17:13 Aside from the full-blooded Native Americans, everyone in this room is a product of refugees coming to this country.
0:17:21 We have, at times, had better success incorporating people at different backgrounds than others.
0:17:30 But I tell you, the reason that strikes me personally so intransigent and not thinking we must do this measure tonight
0:17:41 is Twin Falls does not have a pristine clean background.
0:17:46 It's well noted in the news that we have had active engagements of the Ku Klux Klan in Twin Falls in the 20s.
0:17:55 We have had the imprisonment of the Japanese DSA in World War II,
0:18:01 and there have been threats and starts and stops and backward motions at times
0:18:08 of whether we really want to have an open community.
0:18:11 I'm proud, I'm proud, I'm damn proud of this community, how it is opening its doors and becoming an expression of what's right with, I don't know what's right with America this last ten years especially.
0:18:26 I know a number of you in the audience want to voice your opinion of the refugees, pro or con, and I'm welcome anybody to speak on both sides, not like the here arrest, no way we should not have.
0:18:41 should not have refugees, but God bless us all.
0:18:46 We're all part of the same blood.
0:18:50 My days as an anthropology student,
0:18:52 I learned very quickly that you go back 27 generations
0:18:58 and we're all related to one another
0:19:01 as the special tonight council.
0:19:03 Thank you, Chris.
0:19:04 Now that I have no opinion.
0:19:05 Okay.
0:19:08 For the record, you still have one more meeting
0:19:09 on the council.
0:19:10 So I might want to show up on January 6th.
0:19:13 Yes, I'm also
0:19:16 I'm also
0:19:19 I'm also favor this, I think I've stated multiple times
0:19:23 I'm a second generation on my father's side
0:19:27 who are immigrants from the Netherlands
0:19:30 and when my
0:19:31 aunt's and uncle's went to school, I couldn't speak English
0:19:34 I couldn't speak English, wasn't quite there
0:19:36 at the Amsterdam I'd hold between here and jackpot
0:19:39 But I think we could certainly point as Travis did our own city family with a number of refugees who service and service well.
0:19:50 I remember when my mother was in the hospital before she passed away, her head nurse was up there on the floor.
0:19:59 It was a rescue team as a child so they fit into our fabric through our community and helped us become not only a more diverse community
0:20:08 but also a stronger community, so I'll definitely be favored this.
0:20:12 Thank you, Greg. Anything else from the Council?
0:20:21 Council wishes on the after letters that were included in the packet discussion.
0:20:26 I think this will be your last one. Well, I'll just hope we can hear from the public,
0:20:33 but if that's not appropriate, thank you very much. I would
0:20:37 load record and ask the Council to approve the trust agreement.
0:20:43 Excuse me, that's the wrong thing with you.
0:20:46 It's time to throw me out of here.
0:20:49 To sign it, submit the letter supporting the continued operation of the refugee resettlement program,
0:21:02 operating in Twin Falls in accordance with President Donald Trump's executive order, number 138888.
0:21:09 Second.
0:21:10 Motion by Chris talking about Ruth Pierce to authorize the signing and submitting of the letters
0:21:17 Letters and support the refugee resettlement program that were included in the packet further discussion
0:21:26 Chris Reap yes, yes, yes, I think you all for attending this evening and understanding that as Suzanne mentioned
0:21:56 I think we all heard some input from folks in the community leading up to this and really
0:22:01 to have this be a discussion of the council and the hood forward so thank you.
0:22:05 Next on the agenda is an action item. This is a request to consider a resolution that outlines
0:22:10 the process to elect a mayor and appoint a vice mayor of our city attorney Shane.
0:22:15 Nope. Thank you Mr. Mayor, members of council. As you know we just had an election related
0:22:22 to the city council and with that we have the opportunity to select a mayor and vice
0:22:26 in the past the process is kind of gone back and forth and this resolution is
0:22:33 an effort to just make that more uniform so I'll stand for questions if you have
0:22:40 any questions about the resolution itself but in essence it follows the
0:22:43 process that was followed last time that a mayor and vice mayor were selected
0:22:47 Thank You Shane so maybe for the public's benefit I'll just clarify so in the in
0:22:59 the city of Twin Falls, we have a manager council form of government, so as one of three cities
0:23:04 night out that has a city manager who functions to operate the day-to-day operations of the
0:23:09 city, the mayor is elected by the council not by the general electorate, and so every two
0:23:17 years following a city council election, we have the process to elect a mayor and a shame
0:23:24 defined that isn't defined. So again the resolution that's drafted in our packet
0:23:30 basically puts on paper the process that we followed two years ago in the election
0:23:37 of the mayor and we can certainly go through that in more detail if that
0:23:41 would be beneficial for folks. Suzanne Hawkins.
0:23:44 How was this ready to make a motion when we get there?
0:23:46 I was going to say since we didn't have this officially last time are you a
0:23:49 of the biblical mayor that says we did that this process so that you fight. I'm going to say that
0:23:55 the advice of our previous city attorney was that every one of the mayors was duly elected. We just
0:24:02 tended to have a different election process every time we did that over the course of history. So
0:24:08 this would be just trying to clarify that process more clearly. Chris Talkington
0:24:14 Jane, under Article Section 1 of Item D,
0:24:19 it mentions the nominee who receives the most votes to be elected as mayor.
0:24:24 Why does that not say majority vote?
0:24:28 It says most votes to distinguish between the fact that there doesn't have to be a majority of the council.
0:24:33 It's in essence a plurality or the most votes.
0:24:36 For instance, if one individual gets three votes, one gets two, one gets one,
0:24:40 the person with three votes would become the mayor.
0:24:43 But it doesn't follow the same thought process as the resolutions and ordinances are a very specified majority.
0:24:52 That's correct. Thank you.
0:24:54 Anything that clarification is that it is an actual election, not a motion voting on a single motion, it's an election.
0:25:02 So for example, this last time we had one council member in absent at that meeting,
0:25:10 people who ran, so the load was three to two to one, so nobody had a majority of the council
0:25:16 because that would have taken forth. Then there is a provision in here that should there be a tie
0:25:26 for that, that those tied candidates would be considered again and you vote again until such
0:25:34 time as someone had a plurality. So what is the resolution number please?
0:25:44 It is 2019-017.
0:25:52 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:25:53 Bear, I move that we approve the request and give resolution 2019-017 our approval.
0:26:02 How's that for a word you get funny?
0:26:05 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Greg Lanting to adopt resolution 2019-017 as presented.
0:26:14 present to this there any discussion.
0:26:18 Amy Roll call vote please.
0:26:21 Chris Dockington.
0:26:22 Yes.
0:26:23 John Bericher.
0:26:24 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:26:25 Yes.
0:26:26 Greg Lanting.
0:26:27 Yes.
0:26:28 Chris Furie.
0:26:29 Yes.
0:26:30 Ossia Passes 6-0.
0:26:32 Next on the agenda we do have another opportunity for general public input if there's anyone who has an issue to address with the council and ask your chance to please come forward.
0:26:45 Seeing.
0:26:46 Oh.
0:26:54 Mr.
0:26:55 Claus.
0:26:57 You please stay your name for the record.
0:27:01 My name is Santa Claus, and I do not own property in this area.
0:27:07 I am from the North Pole.
0:27:09 However, given my travel throughout the world,
0:27:12 I have noticed over the years that the Twin Falls
0:27:16 Refugee Resettlement Program is a resounding success,
0:27:20 more so than anywhere in the world that I've ever been.
0:27:23 And so I've come tonight to thank you, personally,
0:27:27 from my heart for the great job that you're doing.
0:27:30 I have family and friends who live here
0:27:32 and who are members of your community.
0:27:35 They love it here, and I love coming and visiting them.
0:27:38 And so thank you for the continuing good work
0:27:43 that you're doing for all of the residents
0:27:46 of this wonderful place.
0:27:48 Thank you.
0:27:49 Thank you.
0:27:51 Merry Christmas.
0:27:52 and Mary Christmas to you.
0:27:54 Anyone else who wishes to address the council, that's true.
0:28:12 Seeing none, any advisory board reports from the council?
0:28:17 Travis announcements from the City Manager's office.
0:28:23 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, the city offices will be closed tomorrow, Christmas Eve and the 25th on Christmas Day,
0:28:36 So that members of our employee family can spend time with their loved ones.
0:28:41 We will reopen again on the 26th.
0:28:45 We will be in operation again next weekend or next week and then closed again on January 1st.
0:28:52 Our next meeting will not be until January 6th.
0:28:56 Then at that meeting, we will follow the process of the resolution that was just outlined in the selection of a mayor
0:29:05 Mayor and Vice Mayor for the City of Twin Falls.
0:29:10 Thank Travis.
0:29:13 We have no public hearing scheduled this evening,
0:29:15 so next we do have a request to adjourn
0:29:18 to Executive Session under Idaho Code 742061C
0:29:23 to acquire an interest in real property
0:29:24 not owned by a public agency in 742061F
0:29:29 to communicate with legal counsel for the public agency
0:29:32 to discuss the legal ramifications of
0:29:34 and legal options for pending litigation
0:29:37 or controversies not yet being litigated,
0:29:39 but imminently likely to be litigated
0:29:41 the mere presence of legal counsel
0:29:43 at an executive session does not satisfy
0:29:45 this requirement.
0:29:46 Great landing.
0:29:47 Merrimo, we move at the executive session
0:29:50 to consider items under 742061CNF.
0:29:55 Second.
0:29:56 Motion by great landing, second by Chris Reed
0:29:58 to adjourn to executive session as stated.
0:30:01 Is there any discussion?
0:30:04 Amy Roll, call vote please.
0:30:07 Sean Berriger, Suzanne Hawkins, Greg Lenting, Ruth Pierce, Christopher Reed, and Chris
0:30:14 Dauquington.
0:30:15 Motion passes 6-0.
0:30:16 I just let everyone know we will not be reconvening the meeting following the executive session
0:30:22 nor will we be making any decisions in the executive session.
0:30:26 With that, happy holidays to everyone this week and the meeting is adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 29 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 38 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 52 KB
- Audio (M4A) 7.2 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 23, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 00:30:34.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
cfddfd182c72a2686bad498376766e6f9529cfad2b1540270b25bda330473ba4 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a c7e0d760b02886bb6239bd1c40b5e3fb6c9ba7aa5463997d4bf41d9c02fa2788 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
61b790652bbf6bdb1c7e8fd8e342b8d50c024d93f4a072cb261a986cdaa0a958
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file