City Council meeting
Tuesday, November 12, 2019
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: a,b,c,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:13 Up Tuesday November 12th, 29th, we have six of the seven.
0:00:19 Sean is excused this evening.
0:00:22 For those who'd like to join us,
0:00:23 please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
0:00:52 It's this evening, so the agenda is general public.
0:00:57 There's anybody in the audience
0:00:59 who would like to come form,
0:01:01 state your name, consent, Kellen.
0:01:21 Gretchen Scott, I'm a resident of the City of Twin Falls.
0:01:24 We have a veteran's day tribute
0:01:28 that was produced in-house,
0:01:29 And I would like to introduce two of our employees
0:01:32 who put that together.
0:01:34 And we would like to play it for the audience
0:01:36 and for you this evening.
0:01:38 I'm sorry, we didn't practice this,
0:01:39 so I didn't know it was going to be me.
0:01:41 But right here now?
0:01:43 Yes, please.
0:01:44 Awesome.
0:01:44 OK.
0:01:45 So if Rachel Sparrow from Utility Billing
0:01:48 and Courtney Cunningham from the police department
0:01:50 will step forward, all this was created and how it originated,
0:02:03 is it up already?
0:02:19 As we go about, how many people had to face this?
0:02:30 That was a big thing for me this year.
0:02:35 I knew the list from last year, so I asked Katie for it ahead of time.
0:02:38 So I asked her ahead of time if she would help me before I even sent out the email to the Veterans.
0:02:45 They absolutely loved it.
0:02:53 Pictures, some of them I had to put it together, exist together for me.
0:03:02 The ones that she struggled at wasn't because I didn't want to send a picture in.
0:03:13 I couldn't find a picture of myself in the uniform.
0:03:18 And so I finally found one that's somewhat embarrassing.
0:03:22 And when you see the third, you'll probably see why.
0:03:24 I was in the National Guard summer camp in the days
0:03:29 when you could have your hair a little longer.
0:03:32 And you could put it up underneath the wig.
0:03:36 And I was young with it.
0:03:39 And I didn't have the wig on, but I
0:03:42 was seeing a doctor for a source road.
0:03:45 And the dust never makes something.
0:03:47 Time to take a picture of me as the doctor is
0:03:51 We can say I'm going to eat my throat with hair sticking out the back
0:03:54 That's the only one I can find if I could have found a better one
0:03:59 I wouldn't have prepared him again because I wonder how I was saying they hadn't invented
0:04:09 You had air, Greg? Is that what you're saying? You had air?
0:04:13 Yeah, okay. Okay. IT has saved us. They've brought it up. Do we have sound with it too?
0:04:21 Listen, everyone, my suit, dressed up, pose yourself
0:05:04 When I hit down to possibility
0:05:25 Yeah, I'm real good pressure
0:05:29 Being all that I can be
0:05:31 I can't call it sick on Monday
0:05:34 When the weekend, I just broke straight through the holiday
0:05:40 That I stand, ready, I'm standing
0:05:52 Damn true
0:05:53 But it was affirming the city and the council's commitment to uphold Ysera, our militaries, and our employee soldiers who are out there.
0:09:26 You have made that commitment to support them.
0:09:29 We appreciate you taking the time to allow us to acknowledge our employees that have worked so hard to truly recognize their service.
0:09:37 And we stand with all of them and really appreciate everything that they do as well as what you do. Thank you.
0:09:44 Thank you so much. What an honor to get to watch that as I grew up also. I'm so glad. Thank you so much for putting that together
0:09:53 Wow entrance
0:09:56 Everybody who has served is our consent
0:10:36 Yes, Christopher Reed
0:10:39 Passes six to zero items of consideration is a presentation the council audience members and citizens who are watching
0:11:09 We're watching, well, as we're streaming in here
0:11:12 in the chambers tonight, I want to thank you
0:11:15 for the opportunity to take a few minutes
0:11:17 to continue to recognize some of our outstanding employees.
0:11:22 Tonight, the police department would like to honor
0:11:25 some employees for their achievements
0:11:27 in receiving some post certifications.
0:11:29 Following that, we will be presenting two promotions.
0:11:33 There's only two of our members to the rank
0:11:36 of Lieutenant Hicks, Captain Barnard,
0:11:40 the tenant Wilson come down to start the presentations and vice mayor Boyd if
0:11:44 you'd come down to join us please. Vice mayor City Council we've received their
0:12:46 basic post certifications and our first officer is Cody Cunningham and Cody was
0:12:53 hired by the TFPD on November 13th of 2018 as a full-time police officer Cody
0:13:00 was born and raised in Twin Falls and graduated from Canyon Ridge High School
0:13:04 Upon graduation, Cody enlisted in the United States Marine Corps and served from August 2014 to August of 2018.
0:13:14 If you remember the photos that we show, Cody looked like the seven-year-old Marine.
0:13:20 Currently pursuing a Bachelor's of Science degree in Psychology, Cody graduated from the Post Basic Academy Session number 194 in April of 2019.
0:13:33 It is with great pleasure that we present Cody with the basic certification from the
0:13:38 Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.
0:13:56 Jacob Lee, Jacob was hired by the TFPD on October 29 of 2018 as a full-time police officer.
0:14:05 Jacob was born in Twin Falls.
0:14:07 He grew up in Meridian and graduated from Rocky Mountain High School.
0:14:11 He went on to continue his education at the College of Southern Idaho and the College
0:14:16 of Western Idaho and detained an associate's degree in liberal arts. He's continuing his
0:14:22 education with the goal of completing his bachelor's degree in criminal justice. Jacob graduated
0:14:28 from Post Basic Academy Session number 194 in April of 2019. It is with great pleasure that
0:14:36 we present Jacob with the basic certification from the Idaho Peace Officer Standards and
0:14:42 Training Council. Jonathan Show, Jonathan was hired by the TFPD on October 29, 2018 as a
0:15:10 full-time police officer. Jonathan was born in Twin Falls and attended and graduated from
0:15:15 Jerome High School. Prior to his employment with our department, he worked as a physical
0:15:21 therapy aide. Jonathan graduated from Post Basic Academy Session number 194 in April of
0:15:28 2019. It is with great pleasure that we present Jonathan with the basic
0:15:33 certification from the Idaho Peace Officer, Standards and Training Council.
0:15:38 Curtis Wheeler, this was hired by the TFPT as a full-time police officer. Curtis was born in California,
0:16:23 graduation enlisted in the Marine Band four years with the second battalion,
0:16:36 seventh Marine Regiment based in 2020. Curtis graduated from Post Basic Academy
0:16:43 session number 194 with great pleasure that we present Curtis with the basic
0:16:51 certification from the Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.
0:16:56 Three officers will receive their intermediate certificate. We'll start with
0:17:35 Shana Peterson. John was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on June 13th 2016
0:17:43 as a full-time police officer. John was born in Twin Falls. She was raised in
0:17:48 and graduated from Jerome High School.
0:17:51 She attended the College of Southern Idaho
0:17:53 and graduated in December of 2007
0:17:56 with an associate's degree in pre-law.
0:17:59 In January of 2009,
0:18:01 Shawna joined the United States Naval Reserve.
0:18:04 She's currently a master of head arms
0:18:06 and a Petty Officer Second Class.
0:18:09 Shawna went on to further education
0:18:11 by attending Boise State University,
0:18:13 and in May of 2013,
0:18:14 she attained a bachelor's degree in criminal justice
0:18:17 with a minor in psychology.
0:18:19 Shawna graduated from the Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Basic Patrol Academy
0:18:24 Session 187 in November 2016. She was awarded her post basic certification in May of 2017.
0:18:32 It is with great pleasure that we present Shawna with the intermediate certification from the
0:18:38 State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council. Next is Officer Candice Camone.
0:19:01 Candice was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on June 13, 2016, as a full-time police officer.
0:19:07 Candice was born and raised in Winamoc, Nevada.
0:19:11 After graduating in high school in 2012, she moved to Twin Falls and attended the College of Southern Idaho.
0:19:16 While attending college, she worked two jobs and did an internship at the Public Defender's Office
0:19:23 in an effort to get more well-rounded outlook of law enforcement and law enforcement career that she wanted to pursue.
0:19:30 Candice graduated from CSI in 2014 with an associate's degree in criminal justice and successfully completed the CSI law enforcement program.
0:19:38 Prior to her employment with the Twin Falls Police Department, Candice was a police officer with the Mountain Home Police Department from May 2015 to June 2016.
0:19:47 Candice currently serves as a post-certified instructor and field training officer, honor guard member, and a hotel liaison officer.
0:19:57 Candice was awarded her basic certification in December of 2017.
0:20:03 I'm sorry, in December of 17, 2015.
0:20:05 It is with great pleasure that we present Candice with the intermediate certification
0:20:10 from the State of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.
0:20:14 This is Officer Tracy Thompson.
0:20:33 Tracy was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department, March 20, 2017
0:20:38 as a full-time police officer.
0:20:40 Tracy was born and raised in Jerome Idaho
0:20:43 graduated from Jerome High School. All still in high school, Tracy enlisted in the Army
0:20:49 Reserves and attended basic and advanced training at Fort Wood, Missouri. Upon returning to from
0:20:58 training, Tracy attended the College of Southern Idaho as a music major. And shortly thereafter,
0:21:03 switched over to the Idaho Army National Guard Army Band, based out of Gallman Field.
0:21:08 Tracy eventually obtained his bachelor's degree in criminal justice and most recently
0:21:13 attained his master's degree in management and leadership from the Western
0:21:17 Governor's University this fall, prior to being employed by our agency Tracey
0:21:22 worked for the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office as a detention deputy for
0:21:25 four years. Tracey successfully completed, I'd hope these officer standards in
0:21:31 training Academy in June 2017. He received his post basic certification
0:21:37 November 2nd 2017 and it is with great pleasure that we present Tracey
0:21:42 with the intermediate certification from the state of Idaho
0:21:45 Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.
0:22:05 Madam Vice Mayor, if I could invite you
0:22:07 to the city council to come down and congratulate
0:22:10 these fine officers on these achievements.
0:22:13 Also be nice or done if we could have them
0:22:15 point out the family members they have here.
0:23:12 Officers, as you heard the request from Councilman Lanting,
0:23:15 which was a very good request.
0:23:16 If you could just come forward to the microphone
0:23:19 and introduce the family members that you have,
0:23:22 family is so important in policing.
0:23:24 And we have many of our family members here in the audience, so we're going to start right with you.
0:23:29 Thanks, Chief.
0:23:31 As you guys saw earlier, this also works for my mother and my wife, Sarah, and my two sons, Chandler, Ash, and my daughter.
0:24:42 Thank you, ladies and gentlemen.
0:24:51 Also, I did promise Officer Wheeler's son that we do this quickly, so I think they're going to ice cream or something afterwards.
0:24:58 And right Curtis is still the way one of theirs.
0:25:03 The next step is one that I'm very honored to present.
0:25:09 I have been here just shy of four years,
0:25:12 and the promotional process in any policing organization
0:25:17 is always very competitive,
0:25:20 and we have many very deserving members
0:25:24 of the Twin Falls Police Department
0:25:26 for all different ranks that we currently have.
0:25:30 If you remember back to the last budget process,
0:25:34 we upgraded two of our Staff Sergeant ranks
0:25:37 to the rank of Lieutenant.
0:25:40 doing so. We didn't change the standards for the rank of lieutenant. We just
0:25:45 positioned. So after a process we have selected two very deserving men to be
0:25:55 promoted to the rank of lieutenant in the Twin Falls Police Department. And as you
0:26:00 saw these other officers achieving their post certifications, I would tell you
0:26:05 that these two men were both very instrumental in all of those officers
0:26:10 success at the police department whether it be in training them in the police academy
0:26:16 or training them as they have come on to the department and I look forward to working
0:26:21 with these two men for many years to come as we continue to increase our piece within
0:26:30 the Twin Falls Police Department. So if I could have Lieutenant Chuck Garner and Lieutenant
0:26:36 Brent Wright, come down here please, as well as Captain's Anthony Barnhart and Captain Matthew Hicks and Vice Mayor if you join us again please.
0:26:46 So I'm going to start with Chuck Garner as he is immediately to my left.
0:26:59 Chuck was hired by the Twin Falls Police Department on June 2, 1997 as a full-time police officer.
0:27:06 During his career with the Police Department, he has served as a patrol officer,
0:27:11 An Archotic Detective for three years, a field training officer for four years, and a member
0:27:17 of the Special Weapons and Tactics Team for 12 years.
0:27:20 Chuck was promoted to the position of Sergeant in the Patrol Division of May of 2006.
0:27:26 In June of 2011, he was promoted to Staff Sergeant and has served in that capacity in
0:27:30 the Patrol Division and the Administrative Services Division.
0:27:35 Chuck currently supervises the Criminal Investigations Division.
0:27:39 graduated the Post Academy as a self-sponsored student in March of 1997.
0:27:44 Prior to attending Post, he served in the United States Army for five years.
0:27:49 Chuck was awarded his basic certification in June of 1998, his intermediate in February
0:27:55 of 2004, his supervisory certification in March of 2007, and his advanced certification
0:28:02 in December of 2015 by the Peace Officer Standards and Training Council.
0:28:07 and just I know the council is aware, but
0:28:10 just everybody's aware, post or peace officer,
0:28:13 standards of trade council is our,
0:28:15 is our regulatory arm under the state of Idaho.
0:28:20 We are licensed or certified by that.
0:28:22 As you can see, Lieutenant Garner has gone through
0:28:25 many of those certifications,
0:28:27 in fact I believe every possible certification
0:28:29 that he was eligible for.
0:28:31 After undergoing this promotional process,
0:28:34 Chuck was selected for the position of Lieutenant,
0:28:36 And he started to sue me these duties on Sunday, November 10th, 2019.
0:28:42 Now, check before we get to the formal stuff.
0:28:46 I know you also have many family members here in the audience.
0:28:49 If you would please take a moment to advise mayor, members of the council, thank you.
0:28:55 My father, Sergeant for his class, retired Bobby Garner, standing right there.
0:29:00 And I think maybe the coolest thing about today is that for the last 46 years he's
0:29:04 outranked me. My wife of 28 years, Sarah, is sitting right there. My son, Josh, and I
0:29:23 have a daughter Kelly, that's a teacher. She can be here. I was hired by the Twin Falls
0:29:39 Police Department on April 15, 2002, as a full-time police officer. He began his law enforcement
0:29:45 career in December of 1997 as a detention officer with the Mini-Catchit Criminal Justice
0:29:50 Center. He then worked as a police officer with the Kimberly Hanson Police Department from
0:29:54 August of 1998 until April of 2002.
0:29:58 He attended the College of Southern Idaho Law Enforcement
0:30:00 Program and received a certificate of completion
0:30:02 in July of 1998.
0:30:05 During his career with our department,
0:30:07 we're in a surge as a star or strategic traffic accident
0:30:10 reduction member, field training officer, SWAT team member,
0:30:15 SWAT team leader, and narcotics detective.
0:30:19 Whereas currently the field commander of the SWAT team
0:30:21 and a post-certified instructor in several disciplines,
0:30:25 such as firearms, active shooter, firearm simulator,
0:30:28 and a general topics instructor.
0:30:30 He was promoted to sergeant in June 26th, 2011.
0:30:34 In that capacity, he supervised the patrol division,
0:30:37 the juvenile crime unit, and the criminal investigations
0:30:39 division.
0:30:40 He was promoted to staff sergeant on September 4th, 2016.
0:30:44 And in that capacity, he has worked
0:30:46 with the Office of Professional Standards.
0:30:48 Ryan was awarded his basic certificate in June of 99,
0:30:51 Intermediate in May of 2004 is Advanced Certificate in October of 2007, and is a
0:30:58 Supervisory Certificate in June of 2012 by the State of Idaho Peace Officer
0:31:03 Standards and Training Council. As mentioned earlier, after this process,
0:31:07 Brent was selected to promote the position of Lieutenant Effective Sunday,
0:31:11 November 10th. Brent, if you'd introduce your family.
0:31:14 Members Council, thank you again. I have lots of family here, lots of people here.
0:31:49 So now, if I could ask Mrs. Garner and Mrs. Wright to come down here and have a presentation.
0:31:57 The bars. Those of you that may not be aware of the lieutenant rank is signified by one single bar.
0:32:06 We're on each of the levels of the color and we have asked their wives to pin their bars on to come and assist me.
0:33:39 The police thing there, Kurt, do the tats, thank you.
0:36:53 And as you can see, the family of law enforcement
0:36:56 goes near and wide as we were able to have a couple
0:36:59 of our brothers from the Twin Falls County Sheriff's Office
0:37:02 join us in quite honestly when Captain Bishop,
0:37:04 I saw him in line, I wasn't brave enough to tell him
0:37:06 he couldn't come through so well.
0:37:08 We love the guys who let him through,
0:37:11 but even if we didn't, we'd let him through.
0:37:13 None of Vice Mayor, members of council,
0:37:15 thank you so much for allowing us this opportunity.
0:37:18 Thank you. It is a privilege and an honor for us to get to participate in this.
0:37:22 We are so proud of all of you. Thank you very much. A chance to gather out, wait just a minute.
0:37:42 You guys didn't come to stay for the whole meeting, did you?
0:37:45 Of course.
0:37:49 Gretchen.
0:38:52 May I ask you to close doors?
0:38:56 Thank you.
0:38:58 Parks in lieu of contribution for El Malogro Phase 1.
0:39:39 That's correct. Thank you, Madam Vice Mayor, members of the Council.
0:39:42 This evening before you have normally
0:39:45 parsley blues go straight to the consent calendar
0:39:48 we don't do an incineration for an action
0:39:53 this is a bit of a unique circumstance
0:39:55 for El Milagro, the Workforce Housing Project
0:39:59 that's going on down south, south Washington
0:40:03 essentially what's going on here
0:40:05 let me pull up the master development plan
0:40:08 you'd seen this once before with the zoning development agreement
0:40:11 that took place a little over a year ago
0:40:15 I think planning to build this out in phases
0:40:19 to help mitigate the effects that this will happen on current residents so they don't have
0:40:24 to displace anyone. They can build a phase, move to the new phase. Due to financing reasons
0:40:34 for the project, they need to de-plat out each phase or at least this first phase they need to.
0:40:41 When planning happens, you require a Parks and Blue, a Parks dedication. That is why this is
0:40:50 before you today is because they need to plot and there's obviously a
0:40:57 circumstances here and the fact that there's already a development right on
0:41:02 the property there's individuals already living on the property and the first
0:41:06 phase will not increase any sort of strain on the current system like a park
0:41:12 system that we have and so for that reason Kent has requested a no cash
0:41:20 contribution for phase one which is slated for 60 units and as I said that
0:41:27 those 60 units will not put any more strain on the current park system and the
0:41:37 parks department got together and we decided that coming forward for a decision
0:41:42 from a body to to move this process forward to get that decision to take that
0:41:46 no cash for 22nd the Parks and Recreation Commission convene the special meeting
0:41:58 that is all I really have if they have any specific questions I can certainly
0:42:12 answer them. If there's anything that I cannot answer, I believe there's a representative
0:42:17 in the Tito, correct? Yep, he is in the audience to answer any specific
0:42:22 questions. So currently there's a number of residents that live on the
0:43:15 property, there's a number of units. That exact number, I'm not super, I know it's
0:43:19 somewhere upwards of 110, 120 units currently, and so they have a development
0:43:25 right currently for 100 plus units. Our parks in Lue generally works as a number of units.
0:43:32 It's an algorithm based off the number of residential units. So what they're proposing
0:43:38 here is to build phase one 60 units. And it's not actually new housing that they're creating
0:43:43 because what's going to happen is so they don't displace any current residents. They
0:43:47 want to build 60 units, move 60 families, and or 60 individuals that live on the property
0:43:53 into these new 60 units, and then demolish those units that are currently there, and so
0:44:02 again it's not adding that current strain, and so the no cash contribution is because
0:44:08 there's really no additional cause for it, there's no additional need for it. This is,
0:44:14 has been proposed in four different phases, three residential development phases, and then
0:44:19 one with a commercial component. Hevelock data is once they reach the phase in which
0:44:28 There is an additional strain on the current park system that I believe be in phase four.
0:44:35 We will revisit what is required and what, and so that'll happen either phase two and or on phase four.
0:44:50 Possibly in phase three. They have the commercial component listening to phase three and then the third residential phase in phase four.
0:44:58 Demolishing something now to put up these first 16 homes, or is it going on empty space?
0:45:05 It's going on empty space with the exception of the head start, so I can
0:45:11 orient you a little bit. So currently the head start is approximately here and
0:45:16 there's some buildings that and so this first phase is this area right here.
0:45:23 There are no residential units there. Okay all the residential units are
0:45:28 generally focused in this area. Okay and so they want to they want to
0:45:34 build these out and then move the residents from this area into these homes
0:45:39 and then I believe to demolish those units up there for further development.
0:45:45 Yes. If it's 60 homes to the problem. I'm gonna defer that question to Jonathan and
0:46:06 Ornich. But any kind of future development has to look like what's on your screen.
0:46:18 It's further complicated when removing from park dedication to impact fees.
0:46:30 When I say complicated, it's a lot cleaner for us if we were already in that system with this, because then they just pay them as we serve Mitch as any.
0:46:50 If there's some way Shane may be legal for sure, in process, we enforce.
0:48:34 We have some of that comfortable situation for sure.
0:48:47 With some language like that, that would allow us in the future.
0:48:58 If it came up, that's the condition.
0:49:31 If that was the condition that went back to that, once it's vacated, it's a complicated situation.
0:51:11 I was impressed because it was such a good example of masks.
0:51:30 If you hear at one point, it's all this, whether on P&Z.
0:51:45 That's the point.
0:53:02 We also come here, we move on to phase two.
0:53:06 That's exactly what it is.
0:53:08 It's just a safe guard and protection in place and so I get solved.
0:53:21 We don't see how we can, I see it as a net.
0:54:11 Motion two, phase one is completed.
0:54:19 That house is there being on cue, need to be removed.
0:54:25 I would clarify that it's 60 units of current structures,
0:54:38 just to clarify that, because yes, it's 60 units that are being built in Phase 1.
0:54:42 Yes, that would be fine.
0:54:43 Okay, so first, and so everybody under what is, so it's request approval.
0:54:59 Mission of 60 units in Phase 1.
0:55:13 I'd like to say the term in place then.
0:56:36 For me, yes.
0:56:37 Chris Tockington, Nikki Boygs, and Suzanne Tockington.
0:56:40 It's in the City of Twin Point, construction of the Archway with two message boards.
0:56:59 For $636, and our guests.
0:57:06 Several years ago, the City Council requested that a citizen advisory committee be created
0:57:21 to fundraise in and got to...
0:58:42 So today we have before you...
0:58:43 I've just had a question, 3.24, less 22, about 48.24 is the amount, right?
0:59:41 22,000 on top of that is on top of that, that's my question, thank you.
0:59:52 Vice Mayor, I move that we approve the...
0:59:55 to approve the contract agreement between line of signs and city to unfals for construction
0:59:59 of the archway with two messy boards for its own cost of $34,636.
1:00:23 So we've called donations to catworks, a request you permission to add park to the list of address changes.
1:01:29 Thanks, line of signs from an individual who said that they were on park view.
1:01:43 The dispatcher was unable to vent, so as you see all the addresses that are in green.
1:02:15 So, yeah, this has posed a problem for those people
1:02:23 who bid businesses on that street.
1:02:39 One of them has Parkview Loop as their address on dresses
1:03:30 within the circle that touch.
1:03:54 There's only two businesses on the loop.
1:04:27 So the homes are the addresses to the addresses.
1:04:37 One, zero, Park, multi-change, but that except for a second.
1:05:32 Yes.
1:05:34 So six to zero, put City Park restroom.
1:06:26 As you may recall, in 2018, the project
1:06:33 to replace the city park restaurants as a capital improvement project.
1:06:38 And then as we went through the design process between the historic preservation commission
1:06:46 and trying to meet those requirements and other things,
1:06:50 we also had some other partners step in and step out.
1:06:54 As we went through the process, we did not get the project very good
1:06:59 to go to bed prior to the end of the fiscal year.
1:07:03 So we turned out those bunnies back into cash reserves,
1:07:07 which might as the design fees.
1:07:10 Then as we finished everything up,
1:07:14 it came time to take it to bed this summer,
1:07:16 and we were advised not to do it.
1:07:18 It was a bad time.
1:07:20 Beds were coming in really high,
1:07:22 and so we decided to wait.
1:07:24 I am being advised at this point
1:07:26 that things have kind of settled down,
1:07:28 And it's a good time to take it back to bed.
1:07:31 I have my resident experts with me this evening.
1:07:35 I'm going to have Colby talk to you just a little bit
1:07:37 about the bid schedule.
1:07:40 There's a decision that needs to be made.
1:07:43 So the request is to take it back to bed.
1:07:47 I have an engineer's estimate for it,
1:07:49 but I'm not requesting funds right now.
1:07:51 I just want to take it to bed so we
1:07:53 can bring that back and talk about it,
1:07:55 depending on how it comes in.
1:07:57 And then there's a little bit that we need to discuss
1:07:59 about the schedule.
1:08:02 The better four or five month project
1:08:04 and if we take it to bid right now,
1:08:06 if we want it done before the events start,
1:08:09 you have May and June,
1:08:11 we'll have to do winter construction.
1:08:13 If we want to wait,
1:08:16 then we may not be done before the end of June.
1:08:18 So I think Colby can address any of those questions,
1:08:22 but I guess I kind of need to go to bid
1:08:25 and what would you want that schedule to look like?
1:08:28 I'm going to start if I start to misspeak myself, but we open them at like six o'clock in the morning.
1:08:54 They're locked around ten. And only during, then we shut them down in October for the winter.
1:09:05 So we advised not to bid this past summer just because every project we were bid a class week
1:09:29 I would say if we were dis and start try to start construction in January or please
1:10:15 So as to the existing restaurant facility
1:11:11 Question so yes, we do rely on western days to add extra restrooms
1:12:01 What would we what would you propose we the city do for use of the park time?
1:12:09 The same restrooms are open back up after winter
1:12:13 till the event, and does that's May?
1:12:20 Thank you for just doing a place.
1:12:24 Turn pretty restrooms out, dinner.
1:12:26 So we need to make sure that's what we would do.
1:12:28 That's what we would do.
1:12:29 Include that in our cost-decimate construction workers
1:13:05 who normally would use the park
1:13:07 that the restrooms are going to be clubbed.
1:13:14 Some provision, not necessarily in the contract,
1:13:17 but in the budget.
1:13:18 Travis?
1:13:19 Yes, so this is something that would fall outside of the project's scope and it's something that would fall under the operational costs associated with the apartment and those restroom space conversations with us.
1:13:41 This is kind of which is there something that I just don't want any surprises. Is it something that's dancing with the government?
1:14:48 I was talking about trying to get started and it was available to December that make a difference between December and January.
1:15:14 I'm just talking to the contractors that I know there.
1:15:18 That's when they did December and January is when they started lining up next year's work.
1:15:23 And so I want to be in the front of that queue.
1:15:26 So basically we want to get the kids out.
1:15:53 The kids out there too have a due date of...
1:15:58 Yes.
1:16:03 Would give us a little bit of time for contracts together
1:16:07 It's to the council, what it is.
1:16:43 Chris talking to?
1:16:44 Yes.
1:16:45 Keep quiet.
1:16:46 Yes.
1:16:47 Great glanting.
1:16:48 Yes.
1:16:49 Yes.
1:16:50 Christopher Reap.
1:16:58 Yes.
1:16:59 Item is a request to adopt an ordinance for zoning district change from R4 to C1.
1:17:06 Conting street south.
1:17:07 May I have Jonathan?
1:17:08 Thank you, Vice Mayor.
1:17:13 I have the council.
1:17:15 This is a quick item.
1:17:16 890 South was the Oasis and they came through a few months ago, went through the process.
1:17:22 the process of the funding and zoning and city council to rezone the process.
1:17:33 Those meetings had a recommendation from the Planning and Zoning Commission and the
1:17:37 positive council voted ordinance ordinance vice-versa move that we place
1:18:37 orders 2019-12 on third and final by the use of suspension of the rules
1:18:44 that are rezoning certain or running zoning classification.
1:20:08 Suzanne Hawkins yes Greg Lanting yes yes yes Mr. Fareed yes Mr. Docking yes
1:20:15 and Mickey Boy.
1:20:16 Yes, it's 6-0.
1:20:19 We should leave.
1:20:47 We should leave.
1:21:06 We're watching for the youth launching off and would also like to say that I'm giving
1:21:51 service since 6-65 to 8.
1:22:25 You can see the current purpose of this easement or vacation is to be lost.
1:23:34 There are, we did receive a decision of this and if there is any easements or any utilities
1:23:47 within the east request and all present did forward a pummendation as received.
1:24:09 request does not contradict any elements or chapters of the 2016 comprehensive plan so we've deemed
1:24:15 it plans and so in conclusion should the council approve the request as presented staff recommends
1:24:22 approval be subject to the following condition one subject to continued compliance with all
1:24:26 local state and federal code requirements and or other standards as applicable their statement
1:24:35 And it's door one.
1:24:48 So, request and analysis.
1:25:03 Present there, request questions and then or staff.
1:25:09 If your questions have or ask questions, request being considered.
1:25:20 Give me a testimony, please step up to the lectern, place your name and add an estate, your name and address.
1:25:27 Your concerns.
1:25:30 After giving testimony, please sign the public sign-in sheet located in the many questions and may staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.
1:25:47 and the closing statements the public hearing will be closed.
1:25:59 Council in this case will then have an open discussion
1:26:02 and take action on the request.
1:26:05 So the classroom with the 8th representing the iteration point,
1:26:21 LLC, sorry.
1:26:24 As Steve said, this is part of what this is at,
1:26:42 the Anasag and the site plan for another office building
1:26:54 in Nittis lot and also plan to go and be placing
1:27:27 our stormwater facility.
1:27:31 That is no longer new much that we approve the vacation of 3,359, 3,350,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000
1:29:34 to 6-0 is the request to dispose of real property.
1:29:46 A few weeks ago I talked to you about setting the date for this public hearing today,
1:30:04 and this is the public hearing that's required for the disposition of property
1:30:10 that's owned by the city of real property that's owned by the city.
1:30:17 A few weeks ago we adopted a resolution we declared our intent to go through this process
1:30:21 or intent to dispose of it by this opportunity.
1:30:56 Afterwards I do want to talk to you again,
1:31:00 If the decision is to go ahead and submit this for public auction, then we need a conversation about
1:31:07 price. We want to set a minimum price. We don't have to, but we can't bring first and then we'll okay. So there's a process
1:31:52 That was one of the steps
1:31:55 the statute regarding city's sale of property allows the city council to
1:32:01 Well, we have to do it by auction unless we have like a trade or something like that, which we don't for this one
1:32:06 And since it's by auction
1:32:09 we can if we would like to set a minimum kind of a base auction price.
1:32:14 We won't accept bids for less than next dollars.
1:32:18 We've done it both ways in the past.
1:32:20 We have set minimums and we haven't set minimums.
1:32:23 The most recent one, if I remember about a year ago actually right now,
1:32:26 was we went through this process to sell the hands of billing.
1:32:29 In that case, we did set a minimum.
1:32:31 In the auction process, there was no bidders for that price.
1:32:37 And we ended up doing this either one.
1:32:50 If we want to set a minimum base price,
1:32:52 we need to have some sort of reason for that.
1:32:56 In a appraisal done, cost a couple thousand dollars
1:32:59 to get in the appraisal done a year ago.
1:33:01 We'd done a appraisal for the Hanson Building.
1:33:04 There's a $2,000 cost to the appraisal
1:33:06 that we've done the proceeds for the sale
1:33:09 of the Hanson Building, which on this,
1:33:17 and then we have a half share ownership in this property.
1:33:20 That means there's another party out there
1:33:22 that has the other half share property tax records.
1:33:26 We obviously show up as a big fat zero
1:33:28 because we're not taxable.
1:33:30 The other, the other party taxable value on the property is just over $15,000, this, this taxable value.
1:33:41 And so if we can assume that that's half the value of the property, then maybe the full value of the property is $32,000, $30,000, $30,000, $300,000, or something like that.
1:33:49 Our half share of that, that's a pretty fair, you know, assessment of, of market value, market value doesn't always equal taxable value, but they should be close.
1:34:01 And so we could do that, or we don't have to do.
1:34:06 And that's really discretion, it's the decision body here.
1:34:11 So I'd just like to throw that out there.
1:34:14 I can answer questions if you want.
1:34:15 You can discuss it if you want.
1:34:17 And at the end of this, we need a motion to send an adoption
1:34:40 specific to $15,191 up in this after work.
1:34:47 I think that's probably,
1:35:21 look, this kind of, since we own a half,
1:35:23 I fear, well, the only half bidder is probably the other half.
1:35:28 Then I think, well, you know, so they might, if we don't put a minimum, they might just put a hundred dollars and see if it goes through, but then again, they don't want somebody else to be the other half, I'm assuming they all themselves, so I'm going to go with Chris, and I think I would believe them.
1:35:43 I will actually make a motion that says that we approve the disposal of a property located three on three, fourth avenue east, my public auction, with a minimum bid of $15,000.
1:35:54 That's 15. That has to go by public auction. We don't have to set a minimum. Yes.
1:37:06 Deaf session, section 74-206. We consider hiring officer employees, staff members.
1:37:51 It's about staffing me under the same not satisfying. This required.
1:38:51 Christopher Reed. Ruth Pierce? Yes.
1:39:02 Yes.
1:39:08 Yes.
1:39:09 Yes.
Download
- Transcript (text) 39 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 51 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 69 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.2 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 2.2 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Tuesday, November 12, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:39:29.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
3e0e633ff7650548908ae3775996df205fd198441afac49e72f4c0a015ddb194 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 3be42767c7de06945b09232562fa62075149019d27db599b81f33e196739f359
part02.m4a 74704750a79858d05c44fe93b59b3a418c148ca8ac1001d7a88d64c554d6c1ce - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
4a581fc388066b5629dc8591519fc94d92d80064a1057d14551f3601d9f382f8
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file