City Council meeting
Monday, October 14, 2019
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:06 call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday October 14th and confirm
0:00:12 that we do have a quorum of council hall 7 members are here this evening before I
0:00:15 move on with the agenda. As with sadness that I have some news to report that we
0:00:20 weren't today that our former fire chief Ron Clark passed away this afternoon on
0:00:27 was a year or 40 plus year employee of the city along the serving as city
0:00:32 employees in false history and retired here just a few years ago. Our thoughts are
0:00:39 certainly with this family today and I would ask for a moment of silence.
0:00:42 On the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. We do have a number of scouts here this evening who I've asked to come down and please lead us in the pledge for those of you wishing to join us please rise.
0:01:06 Put your seats if you wouldn't mind stepping up here to the podium at
0:01:48 microphone around for you to introduce yourself and tell us what's bad
0:01:54 working on this evening.
0:01:56 My name is Jacob Stomball and I'm working on my citizenship in the community badge.
0:02:03 Well my name is Hunter Thorton and I'm working on my citizenship in the community badge.
0:02:19 Our count is citizenship in the community.
0:02:27 I'm in a side and I'm working on my citizenship and community badge.
0:02:32 Welcome.
0:02:33 My name is Albert.
0:02:38 It's Maverick.
0:03:12 On the council meeting was just elected our public relations officer today.
0:03:22 Congratulations.
0:03:23 Thank you.
0:03:24 You all for being here and for leading us in the pledge this evening.
0:03:37 May I have to stand for the rest of the meeting to get yours and get the rest of your badge?
0:03:41 I'll be out one more in the back.
0:03:44 Sorry.
0:03:45 Okay.
0:03:46 Perfect.
0:03:47 Okay.
0:03:48 So thank you guys.
0:03:49 Welcome to BC.
0:03:50 I think it should be acknowledged.
0:03:51 The incredible amount of work is shown acknowledged by their mayor of bad sessions.
0:03:54 Congratulations.
0:03:55 Thanks for saying some. I was thinking is there a single batch left that they have in
0:04:01 her house? Yeah. I'm going to figure out. I don't think I had that way. Badges and that
0:04:06 was an eagle scallop throughout their life and still have a good deal. There are a lot
0:04:10 of city council meetings you can go to. Maybe you can get past credit for it now. Next on
0:04:17 the agenda we have proclamations. We have none this evening so next will be an opportunity
0:04:22 for general public input if there's anyone here wishes to address the council on
0:04:26 an issue that is not on the agenda this evening now is your opportunity to
0:04:29 please come forward council wishes chris talkington seconded by Ruth appears to
0:04:47 approve the consent calendar as printed as a discussion yes yes
0:05:06 yes yes yes yes yes so if you are here for the trust agreement for field
0:05:13 the Special Events application for Voices Against Violence, Candlelight, Visual, or the
0:05:21 Special Event application for the Trick-or-Treat on Main Street event, those were all just approved.
0:05:26 Next, on the Agenda, under Items of Consideration, the First as a Presentation, this is a presentation
0:05:41 of award and award to outgoing airport board member Brady Workman.
0:05:50 Aaron, City Council members, thank you.
0:05:53 It is with mixed emotions, certainly, to see somebody go that's been with you for six
0:05:58 This year's Brady Workman has been on the airport advisory board since about 2013.
0:06:03 He served two full terms and turned out, as we say, after two terms, that he's allowed.
0:06:10 Brady's a CPA here in the community, he has his company, Workman and Company, and they
0:06:15 always say it's good to have a CPA around, right, Rose?
0:06:22 He's been through projects.
0:06:23 He's been very, very helpful with the terminal remodel.
0:06:26 we looked through that several years back early in his term. The FedEx
0:06:31 development Brady was very instrumental as we took a close look at what was going on
0:06:36 there with that major company as well. And in the last few years the planning
0:06:40 with the Northeast development hangar, taxi area, taxi lane area, so he's been
0:06:43 those are just a few of the highlights, some of the things that we've been kicking
0:06:47 around over the last few years. So with that Brady, thank you for all your help over
0:06:51 the years and I know the mayor has got something for you that's plaque for you
0:07:09 here. As we have various members of our advisory boards and commission serve, we present these
0:07:20 certificates of appreciation of certain things for your service of your civic pride and duty
0:07:25 that you have given to Twin Falls. It's reminiscent of the ancient Athenians and the Athenian oath
0:07:30 that's on here and I think it really epitomizes the work that you and the many others we have
0:07:34 serve involved in.
0:07:50 Quick, I'd say it's been a great opportunity out there as Bill mentioned. In the past six
0:07:55 This year's there's been a lot of projects done, so it's been a lot of fun to be a part of that.
0:08:00 On the board, one thing that was sure to appreciate is the support of City Council on the capture center.
0:08:07 We feel the support that did that, so thank you.
0:08:15 That was a work by me. It was difficult. We're going to be such a straight-arrow shooter. We could head more around.
0:08:26 Alright, so next on the agenda, this is an action item. This is a request to reject all bids for the 2019 school sidewalk project.
0:08:34 We have hearing steel staff engineer.
0:08:36 Thank you, Mr. Mayor, Council members, before we started.
0:08:41 I just want to give you a brief history.
0:08:43 I used to be one of those scouts sitting back there.
0:08:46 I was back when I had hair.
0:08:48 So maybe someday you can be up here without hair presented.
0:08:51 So tonight I'm here for a warrant.
0:08:56 A request to reject bids for the 2019 school sidewalk forgone project.
0:09:01 During the bid process, we discovered that there were two irregularities.
0:09:05 the first one being that the apparent low bidder, the primary bidder, didn't follow bidding process
0:09:13 as outlined in the adage was. All the bids had to be submitted electronically through Quest CDN.
0:09:21 He didn't follow that process and by itself we thought, okay, maybe we can get over that one
0:09:25 because there's a clause in here that talks about may cause full rejection. Well, then we sat down
0:09:31 We're talking about a little more looking and it turns out that the second bidder also had the first bidder as a subconsultant
0:09:39 which I used to see as a small section in the talks about if you are a consultant who have interest in its grounds for rejection
0:09:49 or consulting with the City Engineer, Assistant City Engineer, City Legal Counsel.
0:09:55 The best thing to do to get rid of all the irregularities and start over again was to reject all bids.
0:10:01 And then, so I've asked that we reject these bids, clean up what was a Stanford question
0:10:38 to reject all its early-20s school sidewalk project is their discussion.
0:10:43 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:10:44 You're not to drag it out, but I'm assuming there's a number of P. This project wasn't
0:10:51 maybe you could just real briefly talk.
0:11:05 First specific project is on Grandview, north of Rock Creek, sidewalk from Rock Creek Elementary
0:11:12 School, nor this team subdivision is the first one.
0:11:16 The second one is on Harrison Street connecting sidewalk again to schools and so this was money
0:11:24 that council had set aside to put sidewalks in and so staff worked diligently to try to
0:11:29 get that done.
0:11:30 We just kind of ran to clear that up so there weren't any questions, there weren't any problems.
0:11:35 If this process, the fitting process and all that will be in there and Boise who runs a
0:12:30 program through them were sidewalks to schools and then in the weather we had applied for
0:12:35 that that is their entire purposes to help make safe sidewalks to schools
0:12:45 safe routes to school and actually if it doesn't include the child pedestrian
0:13:01 safety grant which was actually taking place right now on CASL between us
0:13:26 straight landing yes Ruth Beers yes Christopher Reeve yes Chris
0:13:31 talking to yes and John Verigar yes thank you thank you next on the agenda
0:13:41 That is an action item, this is a request to adopt Ordinance 2019-002 to approve a zoning
0:13:49 title amendment to repeal and replace City Code 10-11-19 floodplain regulations A-1-7-1
0:14:01 I brokered a deal since I was coming up twice, already with Brock and Troyed.
0:14:10 history of you have a good memory most of you do last March we actually heard this
0:14:14 before I'm not going to read the entire report in the end what happened was we
0:14:18 had a bit of a snaf with the publication with the newspaper and it didn't get
0:14:21 published state statute requires an ordinance to be published after the date
0:14:26 of decision by the council if like a certain amount of time we didn't get
0:14:31 that getting on the fringe with this one until we had a night where we had some
0:14:35 public hearings and some other items were free so we could bring this back
0:14:38 Essentially, we're just reaffirming the decision of that ordinance and then we will get kind of shows the votes from the previous ones
0:14:49 If you're just left go through the same process as before actually proven tonight would go through that third and final
0:14:56 I
0:14:57 suspension the room where you see exact same ordinance number as
0:15:24 To suspend the rules in place of ordinance 2019
0:15:32 Suzanne Hawkins yes great lighting yes
0:15:45 Yes. Mr. Fareed. Yes. Mr. Talking Ted. Yes. John Vericker. Yes. And Nicky Boy. Yes.
0:15:51 Which passes 7-0. The title, Ordinance number 2019-002. An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho.
0:16:02 Amending Twin Falls City Code by repealing and replacing Section 10-11-9. New Section.
0:16:10 providing for new requirements and definitions related to floodplain regulation.
0:16:16 Clarifying that that's the correct visit since 10-11.
0:16:27 So that's the title.
0:16:38 Suzanne Hawken, seconded by Nikki Boyd to ordinance 2019-002.
0:16:45 Is there any discussion?
0:16:53 Yes.
0:16:54 Mr. Fareed.
0:16:55 Yes.
0:16:56 Chris Tockington.
0:16:57 Yes.
0:16:58 John Barriker.
0:16:59 Nikki Boyd.
0:17:00 Yes.
0:17:05 New San Talkins.
0:17:08 Yes.
0:17:09 Seven-zero.
0:17:10 This is a request to adopt an ordinance to vacate right of way, and these men's located
0:17:15 within the Perrine Point subdivision, blocks five, six, seven, and eight, located at the
0:17:21 100 block of Falls Avenue West, and again, Jonathan Smith Love.
0:17:25 Members of the council, this item came before you previously, and we also went to the Planning
0:17:32 and Zoning Commission.
0:17:33 We've seen it a couple times, it's that northwest corner for the Perrine Point to have this project
0:17:39 to do some, for that to be accomplished,
0:17:43 they vacated the roadways, so they could place,
0:17:46 I have one large lot to place some housing units on.
0:17:50 This is the piece of hat.
0:17:53 I took to have some construction going water and sewer,
0:17:59 and when it went to the Planning and Zoning Commission
0:18:02 on Tuesday, March 26th, and it was unanimously approved,
0:18:07 or recommended approval on May 22nd,
0:18:09 the council heard it,
0:18:10 deliberated and approved the vacation,
0:18:14 and easement, we also heard it on August 5th,
0:18:18 on August 5th for the approval,
0:18:24 seen it multiple times.
0:18:26 He ordnance, and he plays on third and final as well.
0:18:33 Ordnance, no.
0:18:56 Yes, I move with ordinance number 2019-10
0:19:03 on third and final reading.
0:19:05 My title only, it says, man the rules.
0:19:13 Motion by reverse.
0:19:14 Second by Chris Tock, and two plays of ordnance,
0:19:16 2019-10 on third and final reading.
0:19:20 The under suspension of the rules,
0:19:22 is there any discussion?
0:19:31 Piers, Mr. Fareed, Mr. Stockington, Sean Berriger, Nicky Boyd,
0:19:37 Suzanne Hawkins, and Greg Lenting.
0:19:40 Yes, Piers, 7-0, I will read the title of Ordinance, an ordinance of the mayor and the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,
0:19:51 a cating right of way in the Eastman's, the real property described below, and providing for vesting up title to the Ordinance 2019-10.
0:20:08 Second.
0:20:09 Planning seconded by Christopher Reed to adopt ordinance 2019-10 is there to discussion.
0:20:20 Christopher Reed.
0:20:21 Chris Tockington.
0:20:22 Yes.
0:20:23 Don Bericher.
0:20:24 Yes.
0:20:25 Nikki Boyd.
0:20:26 Yes.
0:20:27 Zann Hawkins.
0:20:28 Yes.
0:20:29 Great.
0:20:30 Yes.
0:20:31 Yes.
0:20:36 Next on the agenda is an action item.
0:20:38 This is a request to repeal and replace city code 9-6-8.
0:20:44 Marking trucks trailers unused and in operative vehicles
0:20:48 We have Sean Stanley, our code enforcement officer, court mayor, or officer
0:20:52 Take you mayor of the city council, so this is the third opportunity to discuss parking trucks and trailers
0:21:02 Streets to understand, thanks to mr. No, the other city departments
0:21:16 I am in the police department, code enforcement
0:21:21 Now have a city code, the old city code, is much easier to comprehend
0:21:30 and it does allow for a couple of exceptions
0:21:35 that we're not in, those of, of which are the parking of recreational vehicles for no
0:21:43 longer 24 hours on a city street.
0:21:46 In the prior code, you depart on a city street unless you were actively loading or unloading
0:21:53 that recreational vehicle.
0:21:55 And then the other difference in the new code is if the person is engaged in an ongoing
0:22:03 lawful construction project, or such construction project is conducted under a ballot city.
0:22:09 The city of Twin Falls permit in such trailer or vehicles parked within 100 feet of such construction.
0:22:18 Both those items were practices that we did anyway, but this puts it in the code and just makes it easier for everybody to understand.
0:22:26 The council desires to adopt the ordinance's special motion to waive their role and place the ordinance on third and final reading by title only.
0:23:00 We did reach out back to that citizen after the last time we discussed this, that he was
0:24:17 aware of what caused you any grief and make sure that we're citizens of chances of citizen.
0:24:43 Well, this doesn't, as you did say, with Baylor's, could extend that to 48 hours.
0:25:26 Might be a little bit more beneficial to our citizens against, we don't want them to park
0:25:30 for two years.
0:25:31 I think the reason that we came up 24 hours to be consistent with the rest of our code,
0:25:48 I would say as someone who does an RV and pulls us across sidewalks, it outs, it scares out across sidewalks and it creates a whole other problem.
0:26:49 So just to remind the council and I think the conversation about the 24 hours, the council always has the ability to amend the ordinance if that's a direction that you would.
0:26:58 Third discussion.
0:27:16 2019-01-11.
0:27:18 Spend the rules, 2019-01-11.
0:27:39 On third and final reading, my title.
0:27:42 by Chris Tockington to suspend the rules and place ordinance 2019-011 on third and final
0:27:53 here? Yes. Nikki Boyd? Yes. Suzanne Ockett? No. Greg Lanthi? Yes. Chris Pierce? Yes. Christopher
0:28:09 Reid? No. Two passes. Ordinance number 2019-011 in the ordinance of the City Council of the
0:28:25 City of Twin Falls, Idaho, amending Twin Falls City Code by repealing and replacing Section
0:28:31 6-8, clarifying what constitutes a parking violation and providing for exemptions.
0:28:39 Provide Kristagen seconded by Ruth Pierce to adopt Ordinance 2019-011, is there any discussion?
0:29:09 Yes, yes.
0:29:17 Passes 6-1. Next on the agenda, in action item, this is a request to consider an act on a resolution declaring the city's intent to dispose of real property
0:29:38 and setting a date for a public hearing.
0:29:40 We have mentioned both deputies and even a few weeks ago
0:29:45 we talked about this property.
0:29:47 This is the little parking lot that
0:29:49 is just kind of north of our old council chambers.
0:29:53 And if you'll recall, we only have
0:29:55 share of that parking lot.
0:29:57 And so don't use it anymore.
0:30:00 And we decided that we auctioned.
0:30:03 So this resolution starts that process.
0:30:06 It does a couple of things.
0:30:07 It declares that it's access to our needs.
0:30:10 Declares are intended to dispose of it by auction.
0:30:13 and it sets a public hearing date of 2019, Tuesday night, by the way.
0:30:21 That's what this resolution does, it just sort of kicks off that process
0:30:31 so that we'll publish this 14 days ahead of that November 12 hearing
0:30:36 in the public hearing. We would decide, yes or no, we're going to auction.
0:31:04 We can set the minimum appraisal, we can sew currently.
0:31:19 I mentioned to you that we have a half share.
0:31:22 The other half share is a taxable entity, I guess.
0:31:28 And so their taxable value on the property is about 15.
0:31:33 Obviously our taxable value is zeroed out,
0:31:35 so we don't have any.
0:31:37 If you assume value standpoint,
0:31:54 that's what the assessor has placed on that appraisal
0:31:58 for one last time, I'm appraisal about a year ago.
0:32:02 Us is about 2000.
0:32:07 That decision will be at the next on the heaven,
0:32:12 and that we should get in appraisal.
0:32:24 Honestly, it's just a cost test.
0:32:32 So getting rid of the cost is a great value, I think.
0:32:41 A bitch, since we only own half of it,
0:32:44 And it's like half use of it.
0:32:47 How does that work when we're selling it,
0:32:48 when we move or buy it, we'll then have half use of it
0:32:51 with the other owner unless the other owner buys it.
0:32:55 We actually would work exactly the same way
0:32:57 it worked when we bought it.
0:32:59 We bought it from a person who had half interest in it.
0:33:03 So the other half interest is a parking lot.
0:33:06 That's what it is.
0:33:07 If you wanted to do something different,
0:33:10 the interests would have to align.
0:33:19 It'd process to try and get it so that they would own
0:33:22 a complete interest in it. That's actually what started me down this path, is they reached
0:33:26 out to us and Sean actually was having some issues with some parking jobs and issues.
0:33:36 We just said that if it's an auction it'll go to them. So whoever it is needs to understand
0:33:56 that they're only bidding on the houses. It's a half interest, so collectively we own the
0:34:08 whole thing. So we don't own the left and it's a resolution so there's no certain final
0:34:21 This resolution 2019-0012 to declare the city's intent to dispose of real property and set a date for the public hearing.
0:35:08 Vice-X-X, how can I second by Nikki Boyd to about this resolution 2019-02 setting in that city's intent to dispose of real property and setting a date for the discussion?
0:35:25 Who's an honkens? Yes. Are you planting? Yes. Who's peers? Yes. Mr. Fareed? Yes. Who's talking to? Yes. Yes. And Sean Berger. Yes. I should pass this over to Sarah.
0:36:03 And next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input if there's anyone here which is to address the council item that is not on the agenda and as your chance to please come forward.
0:36:12 as report reports, so obviously if there's a pollinator sign thing tomorrow noon, where's that located?
0:36:29 We're really going to sign this. We're going to be at the intersection of Fubbett, suggest parking.
0:36:50 I'm so excited. We have officers from both Twin Falls High School, which is a members officially, as of this year, middle fund raisers, their natures and...
0:37:33 Right, so we do have two public hearings scheduled this evening. Those are noticed to begin no earlier than 6pm, and since we're 20 minutes till...
0:38:04 We will stand in recess until 6 p.m. and then we will hold those public hearings.
0:38:09 It is now 6 o'clock and I would like to reconvene the City Council meeting for Monday, October 14th.
0:38:43 We have taken a recess at the end of our regular agenda. We're now prepared for our public hearings, which are scheduled for this evening.
0:38:50 I'm going to briefly review the planning and zoning public hearing procedures since these both are land use items.
0:38:57 So, the way the process will work is City staff will present the request and their analysis,
0:39:04 the applicant will then present their request.
0:39:06 The council will then ask questions of the applicant or staff.
0:39:10 After those questions have been asked, the public hearing will then be opened and during
0:39:13 that time, anyone in attendance has given the opportunity to comment or ask questions about
0:39:18 the request being considered.
0:39:20 When giving testimony, please step up to the podium, state your name and address, then
0:39:25 to present your comments or concerns.
0:39:27 After giving testimony, please be sure
0:39:29 that you sign the public sheet,
0:39:31 sign-in sheet located in the lobby
0:39:32 with your name and address for the record.
0:39:35 After public comments are concluded,
0:39:37 the applicant will be invited to answer any questions
0:39:40 and make a closing statement.
0:39:41 Staff will then answer or clarify any comments
0:39:43 as needed and after those closing statements,
0:39:46 the public hearing will be closed,
0:39:47 no further testimony or comments
0:39:49 from the applicant or the audience will be allowed.
0:39:52 The commission or the council will then have
0:39:54 and open discussion and take action on the request.
0:39:58 And items this evening are,
0:40:01 final actions by the council,
0:40:02 not items that would go then further
0:40:05 to the county commission as they are within the city.
0:40:14 A request for a zoning district change from R4 to C1
0:40:19 on property located at 890 Washington Street South.
0:40:22 We have Colby Ricks on behalf of Oasis
0:40:24 to stop and go LLC.
0:40:28 Looking at this evening and city staff,
0:40:30 Jonathan Spentlove here to give us the over.
0:40:37 Today, as described by Mayor, we have this rezone request
0:40:41 like the vicinity map discussing the rezone.
0:40:49 The portion here is the entire property owned
0:40:53 by the applicant.
0:40:54 You can see the orange piece is the R4,
0:40:57 which is a residential district.
0:40:59 The C1 is the commercial or C1 district property.
0:41:02 Their desire in their application is to expand
0:41:05 the use of this retail store gas station.
0:41:16 comprehensive plan has the area as mixed use that mixed use basically is that
0:41:22 intersection it's not defined as one specific spot on the south north side
0:41:27 just kind of encompasses all four corners of the intersection and then we
0:41:30 would be bringing rezones just as just like this for specific
0:41:34 it's a scrutiny or a bridge to reason the problem c1 is one of those that it's
0:41:45 into mixed use there is a mix of uses already at the corner a little bit of
0:41:49 The extended portion is where the Swenson's market is down here with some other types of retail city fire stations here.
0:41:57 Some residential on the across the street in the north and the southwest has one single shop with some other types of utility uses that are on the property.
0:42:07 So there's some, but it is on C1. Location is only for this one piece here. The applicant has provided a schematic of future potential.
0:42:25 This is not being decided tonight, this is just an information only as far as a background
0:42:31 to why their brain and the request is their goal, have a schematic, this would be a new
0:42:37 store next week to discuss the actual specifics of the site as a gas station is especially
0:42:49 used.
0:42:50 They can't ask for that special use until there's an action tonight or until this action is
0:42:54 taken through the process.
0:42:56 So this was purely just as far as the comprehensive plan that mixed use has, it allows for just
0:43:04 like it says, a mix of types of uses,
0:43:07 retail, mixes of retail, housing,
0:43:13 industrial's not really in it.
0:43:16 It calls for some of those types of things.
0:43:18 C1 does meet that.
0:43:20 Tonight's decision is based on the zone,
0:43:22 not the use they want to use,
0:43:23 although that's what they've said.
0:43:25 Really, we're just looking at,
0:43:26 does the C1 zone meet that comprehensive plan of mixed use?
0:43:32 I have to set that aside and say,
0:43:34 to C1 meet that mixed use.
0:43:38 Staff has determined that it does,
0:43:40 we've made those decisions in the past.
0:43:43 The C1 does meet that mixed use because it has a mix of those retail uses within this.
0:43:50 There are some things that usually come up as questions.
0:43:54 If the C1 zone is approved, there is a screening requirement between C1 properties and residential
0:44:00 properties.
0:44:01 There's also a setback requirement between those properties.
0:44:04 Those things are taken care of within the face code.
0:44:07 Any new building would need to be a setback from the property line a certain distance
0:44:11 if it's residential next door, in this case it is, as well as some other types of developments
0:44:16 have to occur as a C1 property questions we got, or we have received, is a state road,
0:44:26 so we have some limited input as to how that road looks and functions because of the state
0:44:31 is the one that is also part of the gate where the arterial, so there will be some landscaping
0:44:42 along the front if they redevelop as well as on the new property that's rezoned to C1.
0:44:47 History was on September 24th, the Planning and Zoning Commission voted 8 to 1 of the
0:44:56 rezone to this body types of decisions you can make. Yeah, there is some lighting provision
0:45:25 in code, but as it's a special use, the lighting is a topic for that specific type of use to
0:45:32 come into discussion during that public hearing for the land use itself as a convenience store.
0:45:37 We have some protection, but as a special use, the Planning and Zoning Commission has been given
0:45:42 even though this body to kind of address those impacts of that type of use.
0:45:47 As well, so I like testimony of this evening we will limit to three minutes per person
0:46:14 as they change this opportunity.
0:46:28 In this project, job of sending the project, there's not a lot more than the rezone goes.
0:46:48 Facility rezoning edge will use is permitted that there's a lot of things in this area that are,
0:47:18 this area as pumps.
0:47:29 I think some of the items that will, during the special use with sidewalks and with the landscaping
0:47:36 and the setbacks on the proctes will be
0:47:42 set back for the intersection of Washington,
0:47:46 which is very ill, it's a lot more safe.
0:47:53 When I was out posting the notices on this property,
0:47:57 when I pulled out, there was a
0:48:06 enable to see down orchard,
0:48:11 cars coming off of Washington,
0:48:13 under it's just not near as safe.
0:48:17 The approaches will be pushed back.
0:48:19 There's going to be obviously a lot more space
0:48:22 on the property to get those delivery trucks off of Orchard in Washington on council four.
0:49:22 Yes, the property that is to the west, everything up here.
0:49:37 That's just what this partial feel to it.
0:49:40 Alrighty.
0:49:41 Yeah, there's a memory surgery.
0:49:43 There was an historic occupation type.
0:49:47 Who's in how come this game is just really good at this?
0:50:15 I'm supportive.
0:51:07 I know it's signalized.
0:51:08 It would be a state, I think, owned by the state as Washington.
0:51:13 And if it were, we'd down the state.
0:51:15 on the signaling like the guts of the signal I'm not so sure if current state
0:51:28 infrastructure can say I don't believe a project for their north or their south
0:51:35 that the state has basically said they do not believe the Washington needs to be
0:51:40 widened and that portion for their south so they have not the rezone wouldn't say
0:52:02 the same thing probably with the signalized issue of rezoning it doesn't really
0:52:06 kick in the signal but the special you certainly could kick in is something
0:52:09 needed to be done it is happening darts it's a great idea I think I'm rezoning
0:52:55 is is perfect and it's kind of a dark place to stop if you're coming from the
0:53:01 airport anyway and I think having to let up more in concerned about the
0:53:08 neighbors but having to let up more so it's a safer place to go into if you need
0:53:13 to stop on that road so I think this is a great idea. Before planning and zoning
0:53:26 four years ago I think since I'm excited to see this go forward I think it's a great
0:53:35 for the south side of town.
0:53:37 I'm also in favor, and my reason to mean that the approaches are going to be moved back.
0:53:48 Anytime we get the approaches back farther away from those corners,
0:53:52 as I've been in there before, and the pumps, if you're second on land,
0:53:56 the pumps you're practically out in Orchard Street,
0:53:59 and so all of these changes I think will make it a much better
0:54:02 order and a much more attractive entrance to Twin Falls.
0:54:05 And with MSI's Nikki's point too, I think the ability to provide these goods and services
0:54:12 This is closer to neighborhoods so that we all have to jump in our view drive someplace else every time we want to.
0:54:18 It's something now for us to plan.
0:54:24 Request for a vote.
0:54:44 Zoning District change from R4 to C1.
0:54:47 On property located at 890 Washington Street, South.
0:54:51 On behalf of Oasis, stop and go LLC.
0:54:54 Or is there a second by Chris Talkington to approve the zoning district change from R4 to C1.
0:55:04 I have presented this area for discussion.
0:55:07 Special conditions that area that the C-1 are-
0:55:35 Washing be the state highway, the orchard is well-traveled around currently, so nothing jumps up at me.
0:55:42 Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Great planting? Yes.
0:55:52 Ruth Pierce? Yes. Christopher Reed? Yes. Chris Tockington? Yes.
0:55:55 John Berger? Yes. And Nicky Boy? Yes.
0:55:58 Pass at 7-0. On the agenda item, this is a request for a special use permit for additional height to allow a 75-foot-tall mixed use
0:56:15 building on property located at 160 Main Avenue South, Carab 160 LLC, with Staffordport as a
0:56:23 Brock Cherry City Planner. Thank you Mr. Mayor, City Councillors. Today I bring before you a familiar
0:56:30 application. It is something that we have previously August 19th of the scaring body,
0:56:53 however being that the aboutless project and to express their opinions. So a little reminder,
0:57:14 This is a request to go higher than 50 feet, which is currently mandated by the commercial business zone all the way to 75 feet.
0:57:26 The applicant is proposing a six foot tall mixed use building.
0:57:30 Six story, excuse me, six story tall.
0:57:34 Two stories will be commercial and office uses.
0:57:42 And then the remaining four will all be used for residential housing options there.
0:57:49 And it's different this time that staff wanted to answer was in the earlier presentations
0:57:59 for this project.
0:58:01 One issue that was common was do we have sufficient parking?
0:58:06 Staff took it upon ourselves to do a visual survey.
0:58:23 parking available, the proposed project, 77 spaces approximately available. Certainly
0:59:01 we noticed that other spaces in other parking areas are certainly used more than
0:59:09 others. However, never found a specific day or a specific time to really go over
0:59:17 50% of these. We believe that we do have sufficient parking that we'll be able to
0:59:23 satisfied the needs of a six-story building. Another item that I wanted to
0:59:31 note fairly closely is we did receive a letter from a concerned citizen on
0:59:37 September 20th in all in all. He is in favor with the building but he is concerned
0:59:42 about the North have a scroll to a slow guy right here. He's concerned if they
1:00:00 have a significant amount of windows or if they do certain things to the
1:00:04 exterior whether or not the neighbor will be able to build up their building
1:00:08 to a similar height or if this will limit them. So all he said that he's in favor. He was
1:00:17 just curious about those certain aspects and maybe those are items that the applicant can
1:00:23 speak to direct. It's pretty similar to what was presented before and I open myself for any
1:00:31 questions you may have and if not, I wouldn't myself offer any questions after the applicant's
1:00:37 presentation.
1:00:40 I'm talking to Percy, I'll hide the exception for this building, the 75.
1:00:47 For a 75, it is part of the condition of approval that we currently have, as a recommendation,
1:01:38 if this body chooses to approve this project, that it be approved as a such,
1:01:44 that they want 75 feet and then an additional 10 foot infrastructure that would be needed.
1:02:05 So Brock, I just want to clarify.
1:02:07 You said that there were 177 spaces available, but I think what you've shown here says there were 383.
1:02:16 The average was 177 used. Is that correct? I just want to make sure I understand.
1:02:25 Yes, that is correct. Okay, so there really are.
1:02:28 It's literally 383 spaces. Close to 400 spaces available.
1:02:32 I missed red. Thank you. Okay, Councillor. Thank you.
1:02:35 Thank you.
1:03:05 Those things.
1:03:24 Youth Ranch Building is only 33 feet fast, just right on top.
1:03:30 It's customary with buildings of this significant size.
1:03:34 And similar to what we've seen with hotels we've approved at this time.
1:03:42 Florence representing?
1:03:53 Yes, thank you.
1:03:57 My name is Fran Florence.
1:03:58 I'm representing 168, LLC.
1:04:01 This is the second time we've come before you, as was explained.
1:04:07 We received the call that proper notice hadn't been given, immediately disappointment and some finger pointing
1:04:21 Was it the county? Was it the city? Was it us?
1:04:24 But very early on we decided that we take full responsibility because as the applicant
1:04:31 It really does stop with us
1:04:34 And so for that I apologize that we're going through this process again
1:04:38 To note on the city council but to those
1:04:41 Maybe in the audience that didn't receive notice, it was never our intent to try to skirt the process, and in fact by the mistake that was made, we put the process a few months behind.
1:04:56 So when we spoke last time, I spoke last time, I really kind of gave a very brief history, very long period of time of history, a brief summary of long period of history that, you know, we started the process of trying to reinvigorate down the road.
1:05:18 a great downtown, maybe 40 years ago when there was a giant exodus of buildings and
1:05:25 businesses and the vibrancy that started going north towards a transportation
1:05:31 quarter. At that time it started with the same body that's here and others
1:05:36 that participated, not the same people, but the same body. And there's been efforts
1:05:42 over the years, significant efforts that have added some energy back and
1:05:48 some haven't, but there's been multiple studies and multiple citizen involvement and interaction
1:05:58 that keeps telling the story to us and to you. That the city does want vibrancy in downtown.
1:06:09 The city does generally want residential components and other components to come to downtown
1:06:18 and after so many years of working on this,
1:06:20 not everybody in the city, I'm assuming,
1:06:22 there's some people here that maybe aren't that enthused
1:06:24 about it, but I think overwhelmingly we've seen responses
1:06:27 from hundreds, if not thousands of citizens
1:06:29 that are supportive of our efforts to try
1:06:31 to revitalize downtown and I commend you and others
1:06:37 in the progress that's been made, especially recently.
1:06:42 This building is a testament, and so is Main Street,
1:06:44 and so is the other activity that we're seeing
1:06:46 on Main Street and other places.
1:06:48 Speaking as not just the representative here, but as also a business owner decided to join
1:06:57 the excitement downtown, we've made a significant investment and we're enjoying the vibrancy
1:07:02 and we look forward to, I think it's pretty clear what we're asking for.
1:07:11 It's exactly the same thing we were asking for before.
1:07:13 The only maybe caveat that's coming in is, and this is ironic, typically developers are
1:07:22 of saying, geez, we don't want to do any more than we absolutely have to as far as parking
1:07:26 goes and those kind of things, and staff is usually the one demanding that we do more.
1:07:32 And in this case, it's almost the opposite because staff is clearly noted.
1:07:37 There really isn't a parking issue at this point, and this doesn't cause a parking issue,
1:07:45 but I can tell you that's not the position of the developer on this, and certainly not
1:07:49 the position of the anchor tenant here. As a part of this package, we have to have some dedicated
1:07:55 parking for the anchor tenant. This is important to us. And the parking issue will come up in further
1:08:00 discussions, future discussions, but it will involve efforts from urban or old private sector,
1:08:07 and possibly even the city at some point. And I say possibly because it helps satisfy some of the issues that come up there too.
1:08:17 That will be worked through.
1:08:19 The project, as far as we're concerned, doesn't move ahead unless we solve that parking issue.
1:08:35 This letter, it's a good catch for the gentleman who wrote the letter.
1:08:40 I don't believe the gentleman who wrote the letter owns the property immediately, Jason.
1:08:44 But I think he's identified an issue that we are well aware of.
1:08:49 When you have zero lot lines, you have to construct in such a way that you don't allow fire to transfer between buildings.
1:08:58 And so when you're building a building that has residential or hotel or those kind of things, you have to accommodate the issue of how do you bring daylight into the building?
1:09:09 It's easy to put a firewall if you put a brick wall, but it just goes straight up.
1:09:12 And so while we don't have an agreement, we are in discussions about air rights next door, and if we aren't successful in that.
1:09:21 There are methods of construction and methods of design to create some daylight in the building
1:09:28 without superseding the family pourser and still comply with building permit.
1:09:43 We understand that, what the options are, and we're to address that.
1:09:49 But, Drily, he did point out that there has to be a method.
1:09:56 The building department would less move forward without addressing those issues one way or another.
1:10:09 I don't spend a lot of time on social media, surprise, but I am aware that there has been some, maybe more in
1:10:22 migration, in protest, on social media, and I just want to say that I do believe it's everybody's right and
1:10:31 everybody's responsibility to speak up at these, and I welcome the input even if it is positive, because ultimately we
1:10:38 a final decision that is the correct decision and I will stand ready to
1:10:44 answer any questions that you might have the result of any that doesn't. If I
1:11:03 if I could just speak I have the questions you know this is not a hearing to talk
1:11:08 about barking it's a hearing to talk about building hides and I agree with
1:11:12 that this is when you say that this won't go forward unless there's something
1:11:18 else contingent. It's not a contingency with City Council okay it's not a
1:11:25 It's the project NRA, when we started into this project.
1:11:32 Assurance was that we would figure out how to solve the parking issue.
1:11:37 So the statement where you said that possibly urban renewal, the city has made no commitment whatsoever.
1:11:47 Urban renewal, that was my concern.
1:11:49 I had opened the idea of buying these two together.
1:11:53 I have an issue.
1:11:54 Thank you for these are two separate issues.
1:11:56 Completely separate issues.
1:11:57 He hasn't come in and said you for clarifying that he's that's a very important issue
1:12:08 The subject property is in a parking overlay
1:12:30 What other point you know I went discouraged this body to lay any contingencies
1:12:46 Illustration up on top clearly the thing is illustrated and even behind that it shows a parking structure
1:12:54 That parking structure if it is there is built on property that is owned by the city the city
1:13:15 to be constructed on property by the city and that's I think the piece that
1:13:19 Florence is talking about and it's clearly illustrated here in the city has
1:13:27 not have shared with you in past meetings that this is a conversation that is not
1:13:36 going and the city has been asked to partner in some solution maybe that's
1:13:42 the solution maybe there's another solution should this process get approved
1:13:46 eight minutes per person please state your name and address where we have a
1:15:39 software development. It's okay to analyze some of the parts of this. It's specified that they do now.
1:18:52 So, my lifetime, I see a lot happening, discussion about that, so that just kind of dates things a little bit for those of you that I was sure a person.
1:19:49 Or exactly, well, it's time to quit talking. It's delicious to speak.
1:21:13 Just to speak for society walk into the splash park,
1:22:14 a clock tonight, the 30th shadowed clinic,
1:22:36 just it's an unstrusty.
1:22:39 I'm not opposed to the idea that the bills,
1:23:07 they're not showing the other buildings,
1:23:08 that one's a much better visual.
1:23:41 If you walk up to that's an imposing building.
1:23:43 In 75, they're from surrounding buildings,
1:23:50 now two or three blocks back into the old warehouse district,
1:23:53 it would fit in a little better.
1:23:54 It would still be taller, proportionally wise.
1:24:03 Anyone else who wishes to speak on this issue?
1:24:20 Some members, my name's Rudy Ash Bredner,
1:24:23 Presented 3259 Wood Ridge Drive.
1:24:26 I currently sit on Urban Renewal Agency,
1:24:28 and I think my voting record speaks for itself
1:24:32 with this building, this project.
1:24:35 We've gone through this a lot.
1:24:36 I'm not in capacity with the RA.
1:24:42 Generation, business owner, downtown.
1:24:49 History since the late 40s.
1:24:51 Father still owns building on that.
1:24:56 A 163th Avenue North, which is downtown,
1:24:59 and is not on Main Street.
1:25:01 And I speak to a citizen today.
1:25:04 I think this is incredible opportunity to win falls, but this is the right move, this multi-use building, is the right thing for downtown.
1:25:16 It lost metropolitan 50,000 plus in the next year, next two years, make adjustments for growth.
1:25:29 I think it's important to keep top of your radar as soon as I have the opportunity.
1:25:40 12 years go by and I move back to sit stagnant and succeed sustainably.
1:25:49 And I think this fits in with that plan.
1:25:52 What is the most important thing Twin Falls is facing right now?
1:25:55 This is something that will help us get to that point.
1:26:02 I'm downtown and as a community is thriving, let's continue that.
1:26:07 This is a town attraction.
1:26:10 It has some history in it.
1:27:11 You just stand there and you look up at some of the designs of the house as you're going down.
1:27:45 I mean, sorry, the businesses.
1:27:47 As you're going down Main Street, I think it's just really a city resident.
1:29:22 Originally, when I addressed this a few months ago, I was really against this building.
1:29:27 But Pat Lewis enlightened me over the weekend, and he gave me a lot of valuable information regarding the building.
1:29:33 Although the parking is still a concern for me, Pat has assured me on that, and I believe that in the end,
1:29:39 if the building's done the way he is hoping it to have done, as the superintendent, I think it's a great idea for Twin Falls City.
1:29:45 That's all I wanted to say. Thanks, Pat.
1:29:47 Now just listening to all of this and I don't really have input one way or another I think
1:30:12 wrote this always a positive thing, why is a person will consider as far as citizens as
1:30:24 businesses and I just really want to encourage you to do that.
1:30:28 My husband and I go to St. Louis every year.
1:30:37 We have seen we considered our citizen and what, when money is something, we can support
1:30:57 something like that.
1:30:59 terrible to have a beautiful building by years and so that's just you know look
1:31:14 at a lot of your big cities there's a lot of and consider the cause I want to
1:31:25 say if it's Gerald the end business owner down here down town the old Paris
1:31:59 building on main Avenue here and have spent a better part of that 10 years
1:32:03 vaccine renovating spaces in the bestrons here have spent a you know a
1:32:17 amount of time moved to software kind of city staff kind of if we stop this one
1:33:08 and then you'd have to stop them all, businesses.
1:33:39 Even though we've all spent a lot of money,
1:33:42 properties and businesses, we're still struggling.
1:33:53 Residents just from one bill, thanks to anyone else.
1:34:18 Ford Street, originally I was gonna say
1:34:22 a lot of things that have already been said,
1:34:23 but I kinda wanted to touch on the fact
1:34:25 that I actually am a new business owner in downtown
1:34:28 and I am in favor of urging you guys
1:34:31 to support the decision for the high variance
1:34:34 because exactly what Ken just said,
1:34:36 it's time for Twin Falls to start growing up.
1:34:37 If we don't grow up, we're going to grow out, and we're going to start taking over some precious agricultural land that I don't want to see go away.
1:34:44 But I also wanted to touch on a point that I just heard from a lady that's very concerned about what's going to happen with that building.
1:34:51 Can we fill it in the thing that I can attest to?
1:34:53 The people working on this project worked really closely with us on our project over at the Oak Sludge,
1:34:59 and I assure you that they've done their homework and that they are already filling that space before that building is built.
1:35:06 they've already got tenants coming in and they've been talking about this
1:35:10 project for a long time. These guys are not throwing around, the money they're
1:35:13 throwing around and putting in investing into involves if they don't already have a
1:35:16 plan to make it successful. So I just wanted to touch on that as if that's a new concern to anybody.
1:35:21 They followed through with every step they promised us when we committed
1:35:26 to joining the downtown renovation and plus they're still continuing to support
1:35:32 our business and I also just just end on that. I urge you to support this because I
1:35:36 I think the growth of downtown is huge, and there's a lot of business that is chose to come down here because of promises and commitments with the renovation of downtown.
1:35:44 And I think this is one more step in the progression of us being successful downtown.
1:35:48 Seeing that, I'm going to close the public and ask, so I did my best to jot names down.
1:36:04 But I would ask, as you're taking off tonight, if you did testify, please sign the sheet out there so that we have that for the record and the correct smelling of your name.
1:36:15 So with that, I just want to thank those who stood up and testified both positive and
1:36:33 negatively.
1:36:34 And it's refreshing to see people involved.
1:36:39 It's also refreshing to see young people actively involved, so I know it's been involved
1:36:47 in this process to try to re-engage the Council for discussion.
1:37:13 We're talking to a first seal request to 75-foot ask the VISTA for your subject to continue
1:38:30 compliance with all local state and federal code requirements to other standards as applicable
1:38:34 subject to continue compliance with the app materials and drugs and then if an
1:38:37 applicant service or other structural equipment extending. I also know that
1:39:15 this was a key compiberacy to the businesses as well as the residents so.
1:39:35 For last 20, well, I've been on claims only for eight years. I've been on council for 14 years,
1:40:11 so 22 years. We've been working on getting to and falls downtown revitalized and we've done more
1:40:17 the last two or three years, then we did that other 19 years combined.
1:40:22 And every study that I've ever been involved in is the same thing housing to downtown.
1:40:32 Well, this happens to do both jobs downtown and brings housing downtown.
1:40:42 They're less than your investment into some tax credit things throughout your program, but nobody still has to put their name on the line.
1:41:02 Somebody still has to have the vision to outstanding and Boise.
1:41:22 I can't wait for this building to be built so when I come down on Wednesday night music I've done a place to set in the shade.
1:41:35 Instead of setting the sun and sweating and trying to watch the music so all of those things are actually positive for me.
1:41:46 And I thank everyone involved in this project.
1:41:49 It's kind of hard for me to think of that but I have visited people.
1:41:55 Everyone involved in this project, and so it's kind of hard for me to think of that, but I have visited people.
1:42:43 Isan Hawkins.
1:42:44 I, too, am very smart for sale. It's not our choice. We don't.
1:43:16 His, this is in the warehouse district, I hope, is property owners.
1:43:57 The council, the special use permit, has presented them with.
1:44:08 Ruth Pierce. Yes.
1:44:18 Christopher Reed. Yes.
1:44:19 Chris Tocquington. Yes.
1:44:20 Sean Berriger. Yes.
1:44:21 Nicky Boyd. Yes.
1:44:23 Suzanne Hawkins. Yes.
1:44:24 And Greg Lainty. Yes.
1:44:26 We should pass this 7 to 0.
1:44:32 This evening, we had an exact concession that we do.
1:44:41 That was a lot of place in the agenda, so I'm going to have that.
Download
- Transcript (text) 52 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 67 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 89 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 3.5 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 14, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:45:00.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
86ec7ed94ef9a2634c25828b5312af4ee99afb4e8e85863e11262f79f399ce76 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a d92c93aa8bde9c65e9b535bc37e3d0f6c89f68805e7cb8d93ab8096ac6f00024
part02.m4a c174286cc25bbbbd043017f6e5c9957481cb827c02782cba76ec6f5e1e610f4b - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
d401394e8650f6eada8a8b2f6994da6fbc6bd69d836e053a2b28403f74d1126a
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file