City Council meeting
Monday, September 30, 2019
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: b,c,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:00 Good evening. I would like to call to order the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, September 30th and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council.
0:00:08 Present six of the seven members here this evening, Councilman, talking to music skews to tonight.
0:00:13 Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise.
0:00:17 And next on the agenda, we have no proclamations this evening. So next is an opportunity for general public input.
0:00:46 There's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening.
0:00:51 Now is your opportunity to please come forward the next item which is the consent calendar council wishes.
0:01:04 Chris Reed, the calendar is published.
0:01:10 Ruth Pierce.
0:01:11 Second.
0:01:11 Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar.
0:01:16 Is there any discussion?
0:01:17 Christopher Reed.
0:01:24 Yes.
0:01:25 Ruth Pierce.
0:01:26 Yes.
0:01:27 Greg Lanting.
0:01:28 Yes.
0:01:28 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:01:29 Yes.
0:01:30 Nicky Boyd? Yes. Sean Verger? Yes. Motion passes 6 to 0. So if you are here for
0:01:38 all license, the Walk for Wishes Special Event application, the October FAS Special Event application,
0:01:50 or the Southern Idaho Buddy Walk Special Event application, or the many park conditions in the Canyon Trail subdivision,
0:01:59 Those were all just approved. Next-under items of consideration, the first is a presentation
0:02:07 of the Rotary Club of Twin Falls Check Presentation for the Archway Project.
0:02:12 We have Mike Felton, the President of the Twin Falls Rotary Club, as well as other members of the Travis
0:02:40 Get the Mike Groven to say a few words first, and then we can go through the formalities.
0:02:47 Okay, we've really in support of the archway that's been proposed.
0:02:55 I wish we had enough money, we could just pay for it ourselves, but we're not quite there.
0:03:00 But we'd like to present community foundation with a check for $15,000.
0:03:08 Two checks, one you can cash, one you can cash.
0:03:20 Sounds good.
0:03:21 So feel free to turn however would be most appropriate for you to get some great pictures there.
0:03:27 Have the council come down and remember that the Rotary Club of Twin Falls, thank you so much for your generosity.
0:06:32 Your continued community support on this and many other projects and we appreciate the efforts.
0:06:39 So thank you.
0:06:40 On behalf of the Archway Committee, we really appreciate all the donations that we've received and thank you for stepping up and helping us to complete our project.
0:06:48 Next, on the agenda, this is an action item.
0:07:00 We have a request to appoint Eleanor Young, Debbie Dane, and Susie
0:07:04 Capularis to serve on the Board of Trustees of the Twin Falls Public Library.
0:07:08 We have Tara Hartley, our Director of the Twin Falls Public Library.
0:07:12 Let's see, liaison, in front of you today, three individuals that on behalf of the
0:07:32 Library Board of Trustees, I would put forward for a recommendation to become
0:07:36 future Trustees. Bear with me, this is a little different. We don't usually put
0:07:41 three names through at one time so I'm just going to go through and tell you what their terms look like. Eleanor Young will be the first one. She will be
0:07:50 filthy pieces. She resigned in June of this past year so her term will go from October 2019 until December of 2022. Debbie Dane, you're all very familiar with Debbie Dane because she's currently sitting on our library
0:08:10 Board of Trustees. She filled in this past year for a one-year term and we have
0:08:16 our current chair, John Van Englund. He will be resigning in December and so
0:08:22 Debbie has graciously agreed to say for yet one more year so her term would look
0:08:27 from January 2020 to December 2020 and then the last is to the
0:08:33 capillares and she will be going through her full five-year term and she would
0:08:38 becoming on in January 2020 and stayed in 2025.
0:08:45 We got to meet with all of them a couple weeks ago
0:08:48 and I strongly believe that each one
0:08:51 will bring a strong quality to the library board
0:08:54 of trustees and our library community.
0:08:57 And if you don't have any questions from me,
0:08:59 I will put it over to them.
0:09:11 Since LA asked me not to ask for a question,
0:09:13 I think we should have them all come up
0:09:14 and say a few words.
0:09:15 They're following the library rules of being very quiet, all right, so you have no questions.
0:09:30 Yes, I would like to make motion to appoint Eleanor Young, Debbie Dane, and Susie Capillares
0:09:36 to serve on their respective term, for their respective terms on the Board of Trustees
0:09:41 for the Twin Falls Public Library.
0:09:43 Susan, prepare a second by Susan Hawkins to approve the appointments of Eleanor Young,
0:09:55 Debbie Dane, and Susie Capillares for the terms as outlined.
0:11:03 here to learn more about the theory industry and they toured through around the Magic Valley.
0:11:07 We received really great feedback from those site selectors as a result of that tour
0:11:11 and some of the feedback was great for us to learn more about how they'd like to actually be marketed to.
0:11:15 And so one of those suggestions was directly marketing to them as individuals.
0:11:27 We started doing most of site selectors across the country
0:11:34 as well as doing direct mailers to them and I have some examples to share.
0:11:38 to share so you can kind of get a good idea but those letters that's coming around to you
0:11:56 are the ones that we first launched so in August and this one was featuring Twin Falls
0:12:02 so talked about the new Jibani Innovation Center, it talked about some of your available properties,
0:12:10 highlighted the site selector tour and gives them links to our website where they can learn
0:12:15 more about the community. We did another one in September and we'll be doing those also those
0:12:25 newsletters especially the first one you never know how those are going to turn out people are
0:12:29 We're actually going to open them,
0:12:30 it's going to end up in their junk mail,
0:12:32 or they're just going to delete them.
0:12:33 But we've had a really, really good open rate.
0:12:37 We had a 30% open rate for the very first one in August.
0:12:41 Industry average is 16%.
0:12:43 So 30% for the length 9%, industry average is 1.4%.
0:12:53 So we're really pleased with that.
0:12:54 I think that tells us that the information we're sending them
0:12:57 is relevant to them, and that they're interested
0:12:59 in learning more about Southern Idaho.
0:13:00 So we're really happy about them.
0:13:02 We also do a talent recruitment one.
0:13:04 We've been doing that one for about a year.
0:13:06 And those different topics of course, so those includes our 12 cool things, your videos,
0:13:13 I should watch them, we're actually telling people not to come, but you'll get on sites
0:13:20 throughout the region and we've had over 60,000 views of those videos since we've
0:13:24 lost them about a month ago, so we're pleased with that.
0:13:28 For go ice climbing, we're so shopping online, you look for a pair of shoes, and then you
0:13:56 go anywhere, you go on the internet, you see those shoes everywhere, similar to that.
0:14:01 So if someone's looking doing site selection searches or looking for dairy or things about
0:14:09 Idaho if they do those searches they're going to start being fed our ads and so
0:14:14 we've been doing that for the last several months and we've been really
0:14:17 seeing some good results from that. Specifically we've been targeting dairy
0:14:21 processors in the central California region so kind of our targeted market
0:14:25 for getting people to leave California and come to Idaho and use some of the
0:14:29 milk we have here so so far 2000 people have been reached with that and with it
0:14:33 being so specific in such a very constrained geographic region we've been
0:14:36 pretty pleased with that. And there's been 200 clicks to the website, so if you think about
0:14:41 how often you actually click on it as you see online, probably not very often. So for two
0:14:46 clicks directly to our ads about moving your business to Southern Idaho Crewman Campaign,
0:14:55 it adds to a similar message, but it's not moving here for your family or for jobs. A
0:15:05 website specifically to our Lifestyles page. The lawyers spending time, they're going to
0:15:11 additional pages, so going to our Lifestyles page and our jobs page. So we're seeing messages
0:15:16 having traction with those veterans who are getting out of videos, so I told you it's been shared about 60,000 times,
0:15:38 and shared over 600 times in the top locations viewing those videos for our talent recruitment.
0:15:43 Our California Oregon, Washington, Texas, Arizona, Colorado, so those are really our target demographic.
0:15:50 I think it western states for those talent relocation efforts.
0:15:56 Pushing those out, business recruitment efforts, supporting our communities and going to site selectors guild
0:16:02 and some of our other trade shows that are coming out.
0:16:05 So I know you've been doing some work, specifically with the veteran recruitment and some of those efforts.
0:16:25 Yeah, so it's been about a year. I've been going to my own home. I have a program called
0:16:31 its Transition Assistance Program. So as you're getting ready to leave the military, it's required to attend that class.
0:16:36 Jobs here in Southern Idaho. And when we're here at the types of companies that they encourage them to reach out to us
0:16:50 and live in the region in a number of the disreceived news. A whole bunch of different folks that can go in and
0:17:15 Each side class is one gentleman in the Department of Labor who's contracted through his time, no longer gets time, and so we're working with the base to make sure that we can still get on base and meet with those service members as they transition out.
0:17:30 That was news we just received recently, so we're still working to make sure we're connected with those veterans and we reached out to Senator Cravo's office to see if there's some wiggle room with those federal guidelines so we can still get on base.
0:17:41 on a piece. We still have a really good relationship with the folks on base at
0:17:45 a hodevision event to recruit veterans digitally and through those connections.
0:17:50 Welcome to your podcast. I've been listening to that. I keep getting caught up on
0:18:00 episodes because I wasn't listening to it. It's one of those things I think even those of us who have been around.
0:18:09 Thank you. I appreciate you mentioning that. Yes, so we have a podcast that we
0:18:12 launched this spring. We just finished season two, so there's 24 episodes and we
0:18:17 interview a different person from throughout the Magic Valley, so when it has an
0:18:20 interesting story. They may have lived here their whole lives or maybe moved here recently.
0:18:24 We have Olympic athletes on there, small business owners, veterans who have moved here and who
0:18:30 all love Idaho. That's also received really good feedback. It's been listened to those
0:18:38 which had more people to it as a pleasant surprise. So thank you for sharing that as well.
0:18:55 Next on the agenda, this is an action item. This is a request for approval and adoption
0:19:00 of the collective bargaining agreement between the City of Twin Falls and Twin Falls Fire
0:19:04 I have three firefighters, local 1556,
0:19:08 the Deputy City Mayor.
0:19:09 I have thoughts of my third,
0:19:11 last time, I'm working.
0:19:13 Welcome sir.
0:19:15 Mr. Mayor, Council members,
0:19:18 thanks for having us tonight.
0:19:19 Again, I'm third strength tonight.
0:19:21 HR is out of vacation and not here tonight
0:19:26 and then Brian is not here tonight either.
0:19:30 You've got me, so I was in the room, I did this,
0:19:34 so I hope they can answer any questions you have.
0:19:36 So I'm here to formally request the approval and adoption of the collective bargaining agreement
0:19:42 which are between the City of Twin Falls and the firefighters local 1556.
0:19:47 Before I get started and kind of run through this very quickly, make this fairly brief,
0:19:51 because I just wanted to touch a little bit on the relationship that we have with our local firefighters here in Twin Falls.
0:19:59 When I came from Washington State, being a very labor state compared to the state of Idaho,
0:20:06 I really got my eyes opened with the relationship that we have with our local compared to where
0:20:13 I came up with a great relationship with our who is the vice president of the local.
0:20:24 Josh may show up at some point.
0:20:26 He is on a fire currently, so he may show up too.
0:20:29 He's, I think it turned out to be no nothing major, so he can be rest assured.
0:20:34 But we do have Jerry, I'll give Jerry an opportunity to come up and speak as well.
0:20:39 But we have a great relationship with our local, far different from what I'm used to.
0:20:45 We communicate often, and we're surprised at what's going on with different issues in
0:20:51 the department.
0:20:52 And when I went to the negotiating table for the first time, and we all set in different
0:20:57 places compared to being on two different sides of the table, it was really awkward for me.
0:21:03 But it's been a great change, and I appreciate the relationship we have with our local.
0:21:09 So just going over recapping, you've got in your packet, really, there's really no substantial
0:21:16 changes per se, but I'll just run through these really quickly and if you have questions,
0:21:21 I'd be glad to answer any of those that you might have.
0:21:26 Section 23 is just a correction to our stations as far as the way it used to be prior to hiring
0:21:33 our new additional firefighters, it just gives some language to allow that to occur with
0:21:37 the new way that we're staffing.
0:21:40 And then the Section 30 is a residency requirement that now is kind of grandfathered and is no
0:21:47 longer needed to the degree that it used to be, so we took out some grandfathered dates.
0:21:53 Section 32 was really kind of focusing more on some of our focus in the fire service and
0:21:59 in the public safety sector with the PTSD that we're seeing in the fire and the law enforcement
0:22:08 community, and that we're seeing more and more PTSD suicides and some other things, and so
0:22:14 we added a section to our patient, he's a patient's stress questionnaire that our firefighters
0:22:21 will be taking annually as well, so we put that in the country.
0:22:26 And then the appendix A, which deals with our current pay table, and that was an increase
0:22:33 of 3%, which is the same as the rest of our city employee.
0:22:38 The other thing on item 5 of Appendix A was removal of the training officer that was in
0:22:44 there prior to hiring a full-time fire train officer which we will highlight next meeting.
0:22:51 This was a part-time position and so we did no longer need this and we also have a MOU
0:22:57 that we have built for the full-time training officer.
0:23:00 So this piece is now out of the contest.
0:23:04 is a longevity piece. Again, this is consistent with city policy, city handbook, and then we
0:23:15 are not only reflecting the pace, but also 10-year in the department. So just a little change we
0:23:22 had it before, but we tweaked that a little bit, working with the local to make that a little
0:23:28 different in the firefighter world especially longevity is kind of a big deal
0:23:35 and so we did some changes there minor changes and it's be under progressive
0:23:43 counseling basically takes the written reprimand when those occur out of the
0:23:50 process that has to go to the city manager if there's an appeal it basically
0:23:56 make it a progressive discipline or a progressive, not progressive, progressive
0:24:01 counseling piece instead of focus more on the discipline piece. And it also opens up
0:24:08 the ability if there is some disciplinary issues in the contract, if the city
0:24:15 manager is not available, that the deputy city manager can also handle that if he's not around.
0:24:19 So that's just cleaning up some language. That's pretty much it as far as the contract.
0:24:28 Again, it's pretty straightforward, and I have open for any questions that you might have, and then I'd like to offer
0:24:33 Terry Delman an opportunity to come up and speak to his questions for the Chief of the Council, the Steam City Staff, and General Public.
0:24:58 My name is Gerald Delman. I've had the pleasure of serving the city to involve us for ten years.
0:25:02 I'm the current Vice President of Local 1556, and we just want to express our gratitude for the support and
0:25:09 and love and affection we get from the Council, the City Staff, and the relationship again all completely second.
0:25:15 We have a great working relationship.
0:25:17 We all have an eye that is focused on serving the public, the people that really matter that we're serving.
0:25:24 I genuinely believe the product that we come up with conflict.
0:25:30 Sometimes we don't always agree. I think it's awesome.
0:25:33 We have great conversations and I think it's genuinely a better product than I could build on myself
0:25:38 or that anyone individually could build a true effort to have the product that we have.
0:25:48 It will serve not just the firefighters, but the city very well.
0:25:51 And I just want to say thank you for your support.
0:26:00 Otherwise, Mickey Boyd, seconded by Ruth Pierce to present it.
0:26:49 Christopher Reed, Greg Lanting.
0:26:53 Yes.
0:26:53 Mickey Boyd, yes.
0:26:55 Sean Berger, yes.
0:26:56 Suzanne Hawkins, yes.
0:26:57 Ruth Pierce.
0:26:58 Yes.
0:27:00 Passes 6 to 0, both for your input and for a seemingly smooth process
0:27:07 to, as you've said, come to, collectively,
0:27:10 They come next on the agenda isn't action item.
0:27:17 This is a consideration of the City of Twin Falls accepting the status to become a community
0:27:22 development block grant program recipient for the 2020 fiscal year or city manager Travis
0:27:28 Rothweiler as well as some guests who I will let him introduce.
0:27:33 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, this evening we have Doug Carlson who is of the CDPG based
0:27:44 Before I begin, I just for Carlson, for all the time that he has spent trying to get us educated, we have been, and questions, trying to develop an understanding for us as the City of Twin Falls.
0:28:17 You'll see that the letter that we have presented up on the screen.
0:28:21 I'd also like to thank Carlene Herring for being here as well, to also kind of assist
0:28:29 maybe how the current prime deal noticed tonight before I begin that tonight is labeled as an
0:28:36 action item should you choose to take an action. We're fully prepared to place this on next week's
0:28:42 agenda should you not be in a place to be able to like I said bring this essence and I will point
0:29:03 out that thanks to Dr. Carlson for his grace that he's accepted, we received
0:29:10 notification on the 16th of September that the City of Twin Falls as a result
0:29:17 of his population estimate exceeding 50,000 has had the opportunity to become
0:29:23 what is often referred to as an entitlement city or a city that would
0:29:27 receive a direct allocation to participate and an opportunity to
0:29:31 participate in the CDBG program. That estimated in Title I want to stress that that is an
0:29:45 estimated entitlement into the city. But like all grants, there are opportunities and there
0:29:53 are requirements based upon the city has had the opportunity and the course of many
0:30:23 recently we areas of economic system in the Logan very successful and the program is administered
0:30:35 for cities under 50,000 in population. It was for the creation often designed job create
0:31:11 and her team would assist the Department of Labor through
0:31:18 to check the bottom.
0:31:31 That option is still available, and you can see that that is
0:31:34 number two, kind of as the director pointed to his correspondence.
0:31:41 We can't the clause based upon that.
0:31:51 That was new information to me, and I think that was new information
0:31:54 to Carlene, because we always had the lead working in this world.
0:31:58 That once we crossed over that 50,000 threshold for these,
0:32:06 and that we would receive a direct appropriate apply
0:32:14 not warrant the assistance of job creation in Bodimodra, but there is also a whole host of other programs that fall under this category.
0:32:25 That is not currently just talking about through some of our research.
0:32:37 There are communities that do ADA's with this money, the city of Pocatella.
0:32:43 A significant lead paint based program in which they use these funds.
0:32:48 20% of those funds can be used, of these funds,
0:32:53 of the new basis can be used as associated in position
0:33:03 in clients and moving for inconsistent
0:33:06 with when to assist with that same imp costs.
0:33:23 So in this case, if the city were to receive $342,000,
0:33:29 the city would have the opportunity to take up to 20%,
0:33:33 or in this case, about $68,000 a year
0:33:37 and apply that to the administrative costs
0:33:40 designed to assist with compliance.
0:33:46 Part of this program, there are two elements
0:33:50 that I think that most importantly I want to bring to the first
0:33:55 is there is a time frame in which we have to respond for us
0:34:02 to be successful.
0:34:04 The first thing that we have $1,000 is determined
0:34:09 to build what's called a consolidation plan.
0:34:12 And in this plan, it drives how the city of Twin Falls
0:34:15 is tending based upon a series of programs and processes.
0:34:20 Members of our team have looked, and we believe that we might have some of the information contained in the forensic plan.
0:34:27 There is a certain process that we will use to achieve data.
0:34:35 Things move forward in the list of priorities that we will use.
0:34:45 The second, that's the opt-in. That's the number one option.
0:34:50 When I was speaking with the director prior to the meeting,
0:34:53 it opted in this year, and then opted out the next year.
0:34:57 And also is that every city that we're aware of,
0:35:04 especially in the state of Idaho,
0:35:06 when they've had the opportunity to opt in,
0:35:09 they've opted in, one has yet to opt out.
0:35:14 And so they're able to take these funds,
0:35:15 they're able to take these resources,
0:35:17 and they're able to apply them,
0:35:19 departments that are fully, if you have specific questions
0:35:36 about that, I'm going to refer you to Econ, certainly help.
0:35:46 But this is the beginning, that transitionary piece
0:35:50 that we've talked to the course of the last few years,
0:35:53 where the City of Twin Falls, when we crest over that 50,000 population mark, we placed
0:36:08 upon them.
0:36:10 And this is just one of those other opportunities that we have.
0:36:13 We spoke to you about process and we had stakeholders, years in advance of the requirement,
0:36:30 but we're trying to get ahead of the curve.
0:36:34 Internally, we as a team have talked about this opportunity and time-leaf is that if the
0:36:41 council believes it's appropriate to opt in, we would much rather opt in sooner than
0:36:46 we would later because of the other requirements that we know that are going to, after the
0:36:54 of the census in 2020 to kind of start checking some of these boxes off early nicely with some of the things that we're doing or maybe some of the other things that we've contemplated with the initial sidewalk like this only helps us achieve those things moving for all those costs would be the heaviest list left though is that consolidation plan.
0:37:45 That consolidation plan must be completed prior to the committee.
0:37:53 And there's, he might give them the under the council,
0:38:02 said yes, this is something that we want to move the cost of building that to assist us with moving.
0:38:16 Can't tell you the true cost of that plan.
0:38:18 They say that only organization, if they run similar to Public Works facility plans,
0:38:42 the comprehensive plan, those as it has been.
0:39:12 So with that, we answer the question again.
0:39:25 This is certainly something that we are friends.
0:39:36 and I would say that I miss anything of significance.
0:39:39 As I say, perhaps before we have a conversation amongst the council,
0:39:44 if there's anything that our guests would like to add,
0:39:48 words of wisdom as we embark on this new adventure.
0:39:53 Good evening, the council. My name is Doug Carlson.
0:39:57 I am the Community of Health. This isn't for getting this out right at one, so you're okay.
0:40:09 And so I have been administering the Block Grant Program for years in one capacity
0:40:17 We did give a two-week timeline to the city to respond to us, but we have some flexibility
0:40:40 in regards to that, because we know the decision making around this is important.
0:40:45 So it's not a hard deadline.
0:40:47 The reason we have the deadline, however, is that we want to determine who's in and who's
0:40:51 out for the program so that when we get a budget allocation from the Congress, communities
0:40:57 get what amounts of money.
0:41:01 So the timing is really for budget purposes, and it's not really a hard deadline to say
0:41:07 you know that.
0:41:09 The only other comment that I want to make sure I make about opting out is that yes it
0:41:14 is possible to opt in and opt out as an entitlement jurisdiction to CDB.
0:41:18 But it's not very cost effective.
0:41:20 I mean to go out of losing your administrative dollars one year and the next year is I mean
0:41:33 as possible, but I wouldn't recommend so would say.
0:41:37 And Travis is right, every city that's
0:41:39 opted into the CDBG programs, stayed in the precise,
0:41:47 it's noisy from it.
0:41:57 This is optional, literally in the sense
0:41:59 that if you don't opt into the program,
0:42:03 you're still eligible to apply for state CDBG funding,
0:42:06 just like you were in the past.
0:42:08 The State Department of Commerce basically,
0:42:10 in their administrative rules, says,
0:42:12 if you become a CDBG entitlement community,
0:42:14 you're not long, so, and that makes sense.
0:42:19 of course you're either going to be part of the same program.
0:42:23 So our catch is involved in this to some degree,
0:42:26 but it's really just a decision of whether or not
0:42:28 you feel that you're comfortable administering
0:42:30 the program, the administrative responsibilities
0:42:34 associated with the program,
0:42:35 especially preparing.
0:42:36 Then the question, of course, is whether or not
0:42:41 you have projects that meet the product,
0:42:46 and it's entirely your decision.
0:42:48 There's no requirement, just because you hit 50,000
0:42:50 in population, there's no requirement to take the grant.
0:42:54 It's literally a choice.
0:42:58 And it just disadvantages to both to consider it,
0:43:01 and I'm not, and so with that,
0:43:10 I also want to recognize who's already recognized before us to field off of the state of Idaho.
0:43:20 So, any questions for me?
0:43:22 How's Suzanne?
0:43:23 I'm more of a general start budgeting process and this was not budgeted for.
0:43:46 Sure, and say that we're not opting in in 2020, I should make it clear that we're talking about the federal government's 2020 fiscal year with respect to this resource.
0:43:56 So, our federal fiscal year starts tomorrow for 2020 and I think it's similar to the state of Idaho's fiscal year.
0:44:02 So it starts tomorrow and then in September, you can begin a program year for CDBG funding
0:44:10 anytime between the beginning of 2020 on January 1st and October 1st, I'm sorry, 20 for budgeting
0:44:21 purposes, even if you took the 2020 grant, you could fold it into your budget beginning late
0:44:27 summer. You can start your CDBG program year on which is basically a year behind, but we
0:44:37 have lots of jurisdictions who do that, including the city of Boise. Instead, the CDBG program
0:45:01 Travis Travis mentioned offers a wide range of eligible parks, infrastructure,
0:45:06 public works, public services. There's a wide range of eligible activities under
0:45:11 the CDBG. The state restricts those down to just a few for their funding because
0:45:17 they set their own priorities which they're allowed to do, their highest
0:45:21 priorities, job creation, disaster response or relief which they also do with
0:45:28 the world. The pro for you with it be that you can do some of the things that Travis
0:45:35 mentioned and then you have the range of other acts. So it frees up the use of those
0:45:40 money's for community development activities that you couldn't get money from the state
0:45:45 for.
0:45:46 Pawn is that, and I don't know if it's a con or not because it all depends upon whether a
0:45:51 jurisdiction wants to take the program out or not, but it is a federal grant program.
0:45:55 It does have requirements that have to be followed.
0:45:58 That's why the 20% of our administration is set aside.
0:46:02 A plan will have to be developed for funding that will have to review.
0:46:05 And as the agency, the grants, the program through my staff, and you would have a community
0:46:15 is not from my staff that worked directly with the city.
0:46:19 We will be looking at how you're using the funds
0:46:22 and how you're spending the dollars.
0:46:26 It's a federal program.
0:46:31 You want the state president to come?
0:46:34 The state pro is that you can typically
0:46:37 have an outside administrator like somebody
0:46:39 from the development agency, the manuscript for you.
0:46:43 It's typically targeted to a very narrow range of activities.
0:46:47 And then you can go ahead and do that project, perhaps
0:46:49 associated with some kind of expansion of a business.
0:46:52 What's the jobs are created or done?
0:46:55 It's fairly more straightforward.
0:46:58 Con is that that's kind of what you're limited to doing,
0:47:00 and then you compete against other jurisdictions.
0:47:04 Go to the governor's economic advisory council,
0:47:06 and basically have them make a decision
0:47:08 about whether the city of Twin Falls
0:47:10 gets a grant or whether some other city
0:47:11 within the local Instagram.
0:47:14 So it's competitive.
0:47:15 If the city is an entitlement community,
0:47:17 as long as the Congress appropriates money
0:47:19 for the CDBG program,
0:47:23 So you have always laws and authorities that are related to administrative requirements.
0:47:58 Travis would provide that information to the council if you have specific questions that you want to ask about that.
0:48:03 But would I consider it owner or surperts some? Well, we have those grants being managed throughout the state with pretty good success and not too much difficulty.
0:48:13 So I would say it's a learning process just like anything else.
0:48:17 So I can't come down, but I understand what you're saying, and yes, there are requirements.
0:48:26 That is a huge chunk out of this question is format.
0:48:50 Is this this entitlement? That's a set number.
0:48:57 The thing I'll say for Travis is that it's a cap.
0:49:26 So the $68,000 is the maximum amount you can spend on administration,
0:49:30 and it isn't necessarily you don't have to spend less.
0:49:34 the last of the CIF costs and process for load tens or some.
0:50:29 So they had to sift through 1400 applications
0:50:32 to determine who was some of Suzanne's questions.
0:50:53 It's important to recognize that we receive federal grants
0:50:56 now all over the place.
0:50:58 We receive lots of federal grants to associate with our airport.
0:51:01 We have received federal grants associated
0:51:02 with our COPS program, higher fighter grant program.
0:51:06 And so all of those requirements are.
0:51:12 So there's not this collection of new ownership things
0:51:16 that because you've accepted our money that as the director said there are very
0:51:28 specific requirements in reporting requirements associated with this grant
0:51:32 and Mandy as our grant manager is all his processes now for all of the federal grants
0:51:40 that she is overseeing and so while this is a new opportunity this report of
0:52:11 justice this would be a clarification. So last three CDBG grants that I'm
0:52:40 So over the course of the last two thousand eight years, eight years, so in eight years
0:52:55 we had a million and a half dollars, ten percent of that going to this, yes.
0:53:07 Could we anticipate roughly the same amount of money this three hundred and forty two thousand?
0:53:12 I mean does that number typically stay in the same range or does it swing wild?
0:53:21 Well, put it this way. My past says that over that eight year period you'd have, I mean, sorry, immediately.
0:53:42 The reality of it is, as populations in cities grow and other cities qualify for the block ground program, we have a little to thousand entitlement.
0:53:52 We ask them every year because cities grow. So, if you're doing the same amount of money, the city would get to play about the same amount of money, maybe plus or minus a couple hundred percent.
0:54:21 is significantly more was a significant boost in the Alec crisis than the city would be managing significantly.
0:54:33 On average, the block has been in existence since 1974, currently the funding light is
0:54:42 around three buildings. That is typically ramped, so your estimate is fairly accurate.
0:54:57 It will be somewhere within that, if it's safe.
0:55:03 That is so kind of historically, or at least in recent history, we've pursued those funds tied to a specific project.
0:55:20 Whereas, while those funds would likely still be tied to some specific project, we can sort of define that project as part of our process.
0:55:32 It sounds like the scope and operation.
0:55:38 So instead of waiting for the project and going and pursuing the funds, this is sort of, we have the funds available.
0:55:43 We can identify what the projects are going to be.
0:55:45 There's an administrative compulsion for Docker traps.
0:56:31 So what kind of, we've always been, budget season and things.
0:56:41 and then things we were all used to, we were about 48,000 bare baths in Seoul.
0:56:47 Where did the data come from that said we're an hour or 50?
0:56:50 I mean, I'm just curious.
0:56:53 And so those planning updates projected that the city had already reached the 15th threshold.
0:57:09 It wasn't really based on a Caroline, it's just a progression of looking at the census making that we got from that.
0:57:23 And it's a weird process, but it goes from the census to the office of management.
0:57:26 And the office of management budget says they qualify.
0:57:30 I've been saying here 50,000. I just say 50,000. The second question I would have is if the
0:57:48 There's a scary line in there. It says its president's budget does not have this money in it
0:57:54 But whether or not Congress does approve it or not still
0:57:59 Possibility money goes away
0:58:01 Say where into the years and two years now they choose to fund this
0:58:10 State money then go away as well
0:58:31 Since we've been pretty successful, if we do choose to opt-dances, we've been fairly successful.
0:58:38 Let's give the state a lot of cities to suppress.
0:58:45 We're going to be in front of us.
0:58:49 So Doug, I have a question for you.
0:59:03 And then a question for Trowis.
0:59:05 So as the 2020 Census is coming around and as you're identifying entitlement cities,
0:59:12 there's more being added to that pot.
0:59:16 Nobody's dropping off. Are there cities dropping off or if their population falls below and are went sure and title me or entitlement.
0:59:28 What's your entitlement? Your status is grandly. Like I said, you can always choose to say we don't want to be not efficient to go in and out.
0:59:43 Some estimate it out like the folks in the city of New York. So there are cases where communities have other reasons why.
1:00:15 So that's my question is as we're adding as you're adding you
1:00:29 eligible grantees, does our amount deeks the same?
1:00:34 You have cities dropping off because they've fallen below the 50,000
1:00:42 Not because they've fallen below 50,000. It's typically a budget issue.
1:00:46 Okay. You know it's not enough money for us to manage
1:00:50 for one reworks is that your allocation is driven by
1:00:57 higher of two amounts based on two four minutes. For some communities, particularly communities
1:01:10 communities that are more affluent. That formula hurts them and their allocation
1:01:14 drops down because this is a program that's targeted towards
1:01:17 what modern-income persons. They look at that as something that they choose not
1:01:22 to administer for one reason. Travis, I have a question for you. Kind of summarized it in your report.
1:01:35 Intention, I assume, is to make this a zero impact to our current budget.
1:01:42 it would be a self-sufficient grant out of the budget.
1:01:50 Process with the exception of what I shared for, and then like I said, our existing planning
1:02:16 in subsequent years into my skill sets necessary for this.
1:02:44 You also have some communities that have elected for that staff person during his team
1:03:35 towards a collection. For example, right now the City of Twin Falls commits,
1:04:00 has committed the last two fiscal year significant monies towards a sidewalk rehabilitation program.
1:04:05 $1,000 towards our sidewalk program here this on top if those were some of the projects itself while it may not be something that you may be something the projects in advance those
1:04:30 So Travis, so it's likely that in the 20%
1:04:37 available somebody to offset their does bring the potential of
1:04:58 $275 in difference of those if you were to conversations Carly was buying me and she's had those conversations as well so
1:05:17 kind of share the process so after we received the letter of September 16th
1:05:26 we had a series of questions what does it look like what are some of these
1:05:29 questions that you have several questions that you had asked as well and
1:05:33 we've ordered those out the council were to take the money things and the steps
1:05:47 that we would take in our very first recommendation process to hire us that
1:06:10 play surprised but I'm during on the site of caution because I believe the
1:06:19 $68,000 have set aside that we place in every if it's not something you'd want to
1:06:33 And you said, well, you know, let's budget for this next year, then we would have to allocate an amount.
1:06:47 Once that plan was constructed in the process of someone to, I think it's important to bring somebody,
1:07:58 this is something that you're interested in opting into because of the other environments that are going to be cresting over a very significant urn is also.
1:08:28 And as I shared with others, I have yet to find the magical hand necklace that says when you crest over 50,000 population,
1:08:36 These are all the things and all the requirements that are going to come to you.
1:08:40 If that exists, and someone would forward that to us, that would be a tremendous relief.
1:08:47 But that's so if in vision, that that would just answer that.
1:10:13 It's different in every cancer. I have to say, and I'll rejoice, but it raises, you know, kind of other places.
1:10:36 And that makes the program more administratively intense.
1:10:39 Focus the funding is less. That makes it a little easier.
1:10:48 So there's several ways to deal with.
1:10:54 In some communities, the block right person is a part time
1:10:57 person, not a full person.
1:11:00 So they didn't work half time either because of the limit
1:11:03 on the 20% that's allowed or their focus
1:11:06 and their work is entirely on the play takes.
1:11:09 I know if that's going to be the case, I've seen this happen.
1:11:15 We also have seen people split their time
1:11:17 between planning functions, other types
1:11:20 of grant management functions, and the block right.
1:11:23 Obviously, you'd have to say, OK,
1:11:29 so we have to set up a system to say this person is spending
1:11:32 This amount of time on CDBG and there's spending this amount of time.
1:11:40 We have seen that too, where the funding just supplements a full-time option is to contract it.
1:11:52 And that's the option of some of the City of Coeur d'Alene used to contract it for several years,
1:12:02 and the Pan-head Council.
1:12:04 They used to, as a person who was familiar with state block granted,
1:12:07 which is then the City of Coeur d'Alene, a person who works for a place in the future.
1:12:23 So there's several options.
1:12:26 We're getting set up, but we just voted on to understand the basics of this,
1:13:12 but I don't know that I have enough, so let's just jump.
1:13:17 and answers and more research and if that's okay, adjust this, but cost up front this year.
1:14:53 To be honest, we're going to be doing this. I mean, I need to be a look at the pros and the cons and, you know,
1:15:01 I certainly got it. It's not from Carly. I love the pushback. Carly lost. But anyway, the, I think we're just delaying things for a year,
1:15:12 that we're going to do anyway and we've digested by next week and we think it's best for to
1:15:18 involve them. Why wait a year, why wait? That's not fun, $342,000 or potential for the river.
1:15:26 If it's not funded, then it doesn't make any difference. It is funded. We used to pay
1:15:37 for them. Somebody stepping up and sitting here, here's a way to pay for them. Why would we
1:15:43 But I concur with Greg, I'm comfortable waiting another week, but I do not think we need to wait another year.
1:15:57 This is a great opportunity to potentially take care of some issues that are part of our strategic plan, comprehensive plan.
1:16:08 And I think it's not free money, but it really gives us some great opportunities over the next 12 months.
1:16:16 Again, we don't have it. That doesn't have to be in effect until October. One of next year if we do that,
1:16:23 so I think this is the time before we get too crazy busy on the MPO to to get started on this.
1:16:31 Ask is impossible to take the list of projects other entitlements cities are new wings of the state
1:17:00 or abroad scope. The second piece I would say on the process for finding a consultant to do a process to actually
1:17:40 It's going to take some level in this thing.
1:17:59 There is a considerable process that needs to be included, so a next summer, by review time, to get it out internally, where it's hard to do it.
1:18:14 We said that you can see I'm cutting as a significant, those are maybe some aggressive of the time you want to have this thing more successful.
1:19:41 I also would say that a decision not to pass it on any event next Monday out of fairness
1:20:07 to the director.
1:20:08 We said he's out there.
1:20:11 What is their allocation of the process to make a decision?
1:20:19 And if we're out this year and there's more time that needs to be made, staff is happy
1:20:24 to develop those lists and develop those processes to create a comfort level.
1:20:29 If you need that decision, cost of this little piece of that that is offset by the potential checks,
1:21:32 then send those statements, send them to me.
1:22:04 that response of a chance to review close-up business to already have received your quick
1:22:27 answer those and we need to have it by Thursday. It's Friday, some days is Thursday depending
1:22:36 of staffs. I know that's... Thank you so much for making sure you're in support of the
1:23:13 good air as well. Thank you to Carlin for being partners in all of this and historically.
1:23:34 Next on the agenda, this is an action item. This is a request to sign a contract with PMF
1:23:41 Incorporated for construction of Canyon Springs, Great Roadway,
1:23:46 and Troy Vitek, our Assistant City Engineer.
1:23:49 To members of the S
1:24:50 by state law. The way I say review, they see if they want to re-receive zero bins on new
1:25:12 bids. It's per 67. It allows us to do that. So we went out the project. They chew us a bit
1:25:50 only busy. He's given us a bit on the talk with our engineer. He came up with us some really good ideas.
1:25:59 The schedule was starting to get towards winners. So we need to go. So,
1:26:27 4% of documents essentially says this is exactly what we're doing. They'll release
1:26:43 and it's long to show them this fall and soon as they can actually get their executed
1:26:51 to that site so rocks can kind of business.
1:27:49 So what is, we had to stop traffic in order to drop rocks on the reserves from street foot.
1:28:32 Her CFO, she says there are comments or questions.
1:28:41 I was just going to make the general comment.
1:29:01 He did a great job of describing the history here, I think.
1:29:04 Best intentions from the front end of this project were wide community play instead of just so that it is
1:29:41 and to apologize Troy, set this for Knox, thank you,
1:29:49 I was gonna share the number, so $1,266,
1:29:57 requesting it to cost of $1,247,693 from reserves,
1:30:35 sorry I said that, but Susan Hawkins.
1:30:50 And it springs great roadway.
1:31:00 And by Susan Hawkins second by Christopher Reed
1:31:03 to approve sign the contract with PMF
1:31:07 Construction of Canadian Springs.
1:31:08 Recresented.
1:31:27 John Berger.
1:31:28 Yes.
1:31:29 Nikki Boyd.
1:31:30 Yes.
1:31:31 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:31:32 Yes.
1:31:33 Greg Lanting.
1:31:34 Yes.
1:31:35 Ruth Pierce.
1:31:37 Yes.
1:31:38 Christopher Reed.
1:31:40 Yes.
1:31:41 Motion passes 6-0.
1:31:42 Thank you, Troy.
1:31:43 Next on the agenda is another opportunity for general public input.
1:31:44 If there's anyone from the public who wishes to address the council, now is your opportunity
1:31:49 to please come forward.
1:31:52 Seeing no yet.
1:31:54 Vice report.
1:32:00 Travis, anything from the city manager's office?
Download
- Transcript (text) 48 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 61 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 80 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 530 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, September 30, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:32:11.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
8e3a6cf55c67b09bf8447f8f06c82a92009caed3293ac135ace82653287fe377 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a fd6b2f17448148ee86a004abaaf8e36eb255fb80ae7f4bab7dcf7e122a10895f
part02.m4a a2c166498a8472aab38acccc8b98bb6a99eb75c3a54164e6be3b3b9b836c0a38 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
1feafbf7778d92dce8d6057bbd76cfb0f57c933ed3c800406d3ea314df6bafac
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file