OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, August 19, 2019

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: c

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:06 Good evening. I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting from Monday August 19th and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council. All seven members

0:00:15 Are present this evening next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance for those of you wishing to join us. Please rise

0:00:20 We have no proclamations this evening next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input

0:00:47 There's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening

0:00:52 Now is your opportunity to please come for

0:00:54 I'm going to go to the podium if you would please state your name and whether you are

0:01:08 a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls, we are going to limit the input

0:01:12 to three minutes each this evening.

0:01:15 My name is Linda Gooden and I am a resident of Twin Falls.

0:01:19 Two weeks ago we had a meeting on putting forth a bill to stop abortion in Idaho.

0:01:27 And I've been thinking about that a lot.

0:01:30 and I happened to interview with a man named Jacob Buyon.

0:01:37 He's a man from South Africa

0:01:38 who's been exposing child sex trafficking.

0:01:41 Mr. Buyon's sister was kidnapped

0:01:43 by a child sex trafficker

0:01:45 and escaped after six years in his custody.

0:01:49 According to Mr. Buyon, sex trafficking of children

0:01:53 is rampant in this country.

0:01:55 The lifespan of these children is only seven years.

0:01:58 The U.S. has the youngest average age of sex-traffic children, average age of 12, which means there

0:02:06 are some who are much younger.

0:02:08 The U.S. leader in the world for sex trafficking is us.

0:02:12 The disgusting torture of children sweeps rewards of $200,000 to $250,000 for the perpetrator.

0:02:21 One percent of these crimes are reported, and that comes in at $300,000.

0:02:27 In Texas alone, 76,000 children are trafficked per day.

0:02:32 It's hard to believe that could happen in this country.

0:02:35 No one is immune.

0:02:37 Teachers, police, foster care is a big contributor

0:02:40 to this crime.

0:02:41 The average wide male earning 100,000 a year

0:02:44 eyes one child a week.

0:02:47 So what does this have to do with abortion?

0:02:49 Since 1973, the murder of innocent children

0:02:53 has reached an estimated 60,069,971 babies, 1.3 million per year in the U.S., 152 per hour,

0:03:04 3,657 per day. Mr. Puyan has stated, and I agree with him, that the practice of murdering

0:03:12 children for 46 years in this country has destroyed the value of human life. It's no longer shocking

0:03:19 that we kill these babies by the millions.

0:03:22 So if the murder of innocent helpless children

0:03:24 has no value, then why, what life is value?

0:03:29 The trafficking of our young children

0:03:32 is no problem because they too are of no value.

0:03:35 Immorality in this country has skyrocketed

0:03:38 since the sexual revolution with a rise in pornography,

0:03:42 rape, sex trafficking, abortion, on and on.

0:03:46 I have a friend who had a little great-grandson born in April, and he was born in 24 weeks, which doesn't even finish the first-time master.

0:03:56 He weighed one pound, 11 ounces, and he lost down to one pound, 8 ounces. He fit in their hand.

0:04:03 He was so tiny that everything was perfect. His hands, his fingers, his feet, his toes, his ears, his nose, he was perfect.

0:04:13 he's so tiny but perfect. And he let the nurses and the doctors know when he was not happy

0:04:22 with the poking and the prodding and the tubes that they were putting in him every day. He

0:04:26 squawked. Now very loud because he wasn't strong but he squawked. Now picture 24-month

0:04:32 baby torn to pieces in his mother's womb and pulled out one piece at a time to be sold

0:04:37 for scientific research. Don't believe that those little babies don't feel that excruciating

0:04:42 They do. It was said at the City Council meeting that this city might be sued by Planned Parenthood.

0:04:50 May I say that the Bible says it is a fair thing to fall into the hands of the living God.

0:04:56 I would like...

0:04:57 Now you have 15 seconds left.

0:04:59 I just want to tell you that the population of Idaho, Washington, Oregon,

0:05:04 Oregon, California, Utah, is 56,671,303.

0:05:12 The number of babies killed since 1973 is 60,69,971.

0:05:18 That's 349,3,498,666.

0:05:25 More murder babies than the whole population of these

0:05:28 states together.

0:05:30 Thank you.

0:05:31 Thank you.

0:05:33 Anyone else who wishes to address the council?

0:05:47 a business owner and I have some other business owners on Main Street with this.

0:05:51 We're just wanting, we're concerned with the new building that's proposed for the

0:05:56 project.

0:05:57 That is scheduled on the agenda for a public hearing at 6 p.m.

0:06:00 No earlier than 6 p.m.

0:06:01 So we actually can't take additional input on that at this time.

0:06:04 You're fine.

0:06:05 When I called they said I could come in under public input because they didn't tell me

0:06:09 what to say.

0:06:10 The specific to the new building on the request for additional height, yep, that's scheduled

0:06:14 on the agenda.

0:06:15 So, we'll get you there.

0:06:16 There anyone else who wishes to address the council

0:06:20 and item that's not on the agenda this evening?

0:06:36 I'm Mona Kay Blameyer's Weeks.

0:06:39 I spoke with you guys last week.

0:06:41 I'm a Twin Falls citizen.

0:06:42 And I know you guys all talked about the recycling center

0:06:45 last week, but I have a few other things

0:06:47 that I kind of wanted to touch on that maybe you guys hadn't

0:06:50 considered.

0:06:51 And I also brought a print out for you

0:06:52 that you can share with everybody.

0:06:55 The City of Portland Bureau of Planning and Sustainability

0:06:59 resource for thoughtful conception, recycling, composting, and garbage information.

0:07:04 Their goal is to reduce waste and increase the materials recovery rate of 90% from 2030.

0:07:09 Portlanders can help reach these goals by finding resources and staying informed to make

0:07:14 the best choices at their home.

0:07:16 They are struggling but are still working.

0:07:19 Most successful cities constantly run aggressive education programs.

0:07:23 What does our city do as far as the education to this city?

0:07:26 I know you guys said last week you're going to eliminate it down to what was it?

0:07:32 Yeah, cardboard, aluminum, tin. So what about all the newspapers? I mean, that's huge to our landfill.

0:07:40 Many of the manufacturing and cycling centers have a charge to pick up the cardboard bells,

0:07:46 cardboard not valuable and hard to get rid of currently.

0:07:49 Who are you guys using to take the cardboard? Are you using somebody local or is it outside of that?

0:07:55 Magic Balor recycling, newspaper, office paper, plastic number one and two.

0:08:00 Those are things that you guys are getting rid of and we use a ton of plastic bottles in this community.

0:08:05 Sorting costs is the same to the city even if they stop taking the other items.

0:08:09 What are they saving? Are they saving on the hall? How can they save on the hall with cardboard? It is bulky.

0:08:15 Garbage will still be the same because city is not running a good education program.

0:08:19 City can easily implement penalties if garbage is in the recyclables at any

0:08:24 house. You guys know it when they pick it up, they have cameras, you can see it being

0:08:28 dumped. Why can't we implement that? What did the city expect going forward

0:08:35 with the recycling when they're not imposing penalties to families that are

0:08:39 not recycling properly? What's your solution for that? And I know you can't

0:08:43 tell me that right now because you kind of voted on everything last week but I

0:08:46 And I wanted to give you some ideas of three different communities that is working great,

0:08:50 Boulder, Colorado, Wyoming, and again in Washington area.

0:08:55 And so inside here are some really neat websites that you guys took a look at to see amazing

0:09:00 recycling programs that are offered that maybe you guys haven't even considered.

0:09:04 And to answer one other thing, I don't understand how Burley can have an incinerator and you

0:09:10 can say it's too expensive.

0:09:13 Burley's a smaller community to the Twin Falls.

0:09:15 That's it, thanks guys.

0:09:17 Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council this evening?

0:09:26 Uh, the consent calendar and I would ask that item

0:09:36 I've D, which is the request to hold the Wings of Love World H-Jump Concert on September 14th, 2019 be

0:09:44 pulled off as a separate item, and I'm going to recuse myself on that since the event is being

0:09:49 posted at the visitor center, which I manage.

0:09:52 Mr. Reed, move that we approve the consent calendar without 5D.

0:09:59 Motion by Christopher Reed, seconded by Ritpiers to approve the consent calendar, except for item 5D is there.

0:10:09 Discussion?

0:10:10 Sean Berriger.

0:10:18 Yes.

0:10:19 Niki Boyd.

0:10:20 Yes.

0:10:21 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:10:22 Yes.

0:10:23 Great landing.

0:10:24 Ruth Pierce.

0:10:25 Yes.

0:10:26 Christopher Reed.

0:10:27 Yes.

0:10:29 Yes.

0:10:30 Motion passes.

0:10:31 the by Christopher Reed to approve the consent calendar.

0:10:51 Niki Boy, Suzanne Hawkins, Greg Lantee, Ruth Pierce, Christopher Reed, Chris Dockington, and Sean Barrieger.

0:11:00 Abstain, motion passes 6-0 with one abstention.

0:11:04 Next up the agenda is an action item.

0:11:10 This is a request for funding of a service club entrance sign into the community by Dennis Boyer, Optimus Club of Twin Falls.

0:11:17 I'm going to ask Vice Mayor Nikki Boyd to preside over this item as one of the clubs

0:11:23 is the Magic Valley Young Professionals, which is a committee of the Chamber, which I manage.

0:11:28 In Dennis.

0:11:31 Good afternoon, City Council.

0:11:35 My name is Dennis Boyer and I'm a member of the Twin Falls Optimists Club since 1982,

0:11:39 next year, right after I started with the City Bank in 81.

0:11:43 Anyway, but I'm representing other service clubs that I do have a lot in the audience here tonight.

0:11:48 tonight. We have the three main rotary clubs, the Blue Lakes Rotary Club, the

0:11:52 after hours Rotary Club and the main Rotary Club in noon. Also we have the Twin Falls

0:11:57 of October 45, more a lot of people know them as the Masons. We have the Twin Falls

0:12:02 Shrine Club, we have the Lions Club of Twin Falls, the Quantas Club of Twin Falls

0:12:06 and also as Sean mentioned the magical young professionals. So I like to have

0:12:10 whoever's a club member please stand up, just from the service clubs.

0:12:21 Currently two signs that are entrances, two of them, one on Addison West and one on

0:12:28 Kimberly Rodees. Can you show that up on the screen? Those two, but those two

0:12:37 signs have been out there 40 years. We have no idea. There's no record even with

0:12:43 the city planning zoning. No record with these signs went up. Also with

0:12:47 the idle transportation department. They had no records with these signs went up.

0:12:49 They just been up there forever. Also they used to be one at the visitor center

0:12:53 but I know during the remodeling that was a remove and never put back up.

0:12:57 If you remember those signs are not very nice looking.

0:13:02 They might say ugly. Anyway, so we've got

0:13:06 together approximately a little bit over a year ago. We started looking at designs,

0:13:10 what we can do, how many entrances we want to look at. So this group

0:13:14 of service clubs we decided that, yes, okay, this is the one on Addison Avenue.

0:13:18 As you see, it was hit one time years ago so that that top part

0:13:22 kind of bent anyway. If you can show the one that I found on Kimberly Road East next to the,

0:13:28 there we go, that's on Kimberly Road East, next to the cemetery, kind of the old cinemas anyway.

0:13:34 So you can kind of see those signs, you know, like I said, do not know when they were put up,

0:13:37 they just been put up there in clubs and throughout the years it kind of redid their

0:13:42 logos or put their new meeting place and time anyway. But anyway, we're meeting about what can we do?

0:13:48 So we decided we want to do four signs.

0:13:51 One was the new one out of the Visitor Center,

0:13:54 replaced this one on Kimberly Road,

0:13:55 and replaced the one on Addison Avenue West.

0:13:57 And also we looked at one on Washington Street South,

0:14:00 kind of across from the water tank out there.

0:14:02 So people coming in from the airport

0:14:03 are coming off Highway 74.

0:14:05 We can get both of them there.

0:14:07 So we've kind of let that couple of companies

0:14:10 that we could work with,

0:14:11 and we ended up working with Lydal Science

0:14:14 because they're a local company and professional company,

0:14:16 and we knew that they could do a good job.

0:14:18 So we worked with them, we finally got some prices, they did let you tell you, they did do a donation for us because they are a very

0:14:24 terrific minded also, it's probably a lot of their members of their company, our members of service clubs.

0:14:31 So then what we did, we decided that each club could commit up to about $2350, but that only would do three signs.

0:14:41 We definitely want to do the two replacements in the one at Visitor Center.

0:14:45 The one at the visitor center is a little cheaper compared to the other two or possible three

0:14:49 sciences because it's a different design. We want to kind of match with the existing

0:14:53 science that's currently out there at the visitor center. And I just want to kind of talk about,

0:15:00 I know that the city council is really, I want to make sure that a lot of the initiatives that

0:15:06 the city does are part of our strategic plan and kind of review on this strategic plan under

0:15:11 focus area number six of prosperous community. One of the initiatives talked

0:15:15 about using tourism as a tool for economic development and objective three

0:15:20 under that says the city will support community partners who host supporting

0:15:23 contests and other community events that promotes Twin Falls and I would

0:15:28 really believe that our service clubs promote Twin Falls. I can kind of go

0:15:33 over through some of the things we do. You know there's the big ice cream

0:15:36 Social Coats for Kids program. They provide eyeglasses for kids and adults. They put on the big Twin Falls beer fest that raised lots of money for other community activities.

0:15:47 One of the clubs for now flags out there on I think five separate days, Vietnam, Veterans Day Memorial Day, Flag Day, Fourth of July and Labor Day.

0:15:55 Also, these service clubs provide specialized pediatric care for no-costive families,

0:16:01 your fund runs, co-sponsor the Hershey Track Meet, to teen suicide awareness,

0:16:06 annual North-South High School All-Star Game, monthly trivia contest.

0:16:11 One of the clubs right now is Raisin Funds,

0:16:13 with a drink and found along our canyon and trail at the visitor center.

0:16:16 Also, the school supplies say Halloween events,

0:16:20 so you can kind of see where these service clubs do promote Twin Falls

0:16:24 and make our community better.

0:16:27 Part of the focus area is number seven on response level.

0:16:30 Response level, if I will, you can't speak today, right?

0:16:34 It's been a while since I've been up here, you know,

0:16:36 they've given us staff.

0:16:37 You might say it's another staff report.

0:16:38 Old habits die, you know, anyway.

0:16:41 Part of the 2030 vision is for the community

0:16:43 to be actively engaged in various public, private, civic,

0:16:47 arts, religious, and institutions serving the area

0:16:50 through volunteerism and involvement in the neighborhood

0:16:52 local community activities. That's what really service clubs is all about. And you might say a

0:16:57 couple of the big ones. When I was actually Director of Parks and Recreation, working with the Blue

0:17:02 Lakes Rotter Club, they developed the Blue Lakes Rotter Club part kind of back behind Work and

0:17:07 Trail Elementary School. They invested over $150,000 in cash and donations and labor and developing that

0:17:14 part. Also, I'm proud to say that Twin Falls Optics Club with numerous donors helped build the

0:17:20 Twin Falls Optumus Youth House for Kids at Asia to Fall Out of foster care and also we got some support from the city of Twin Falls.

0:17:26 The building specters were great to work with in that process going.

0:17:29 It was a long process but we got it done.

0:17:31 Also, you know, one way for service clubs to track new members, to have the information available in all sorts of media now.

0:17:39 There's no one way to advertise anymore.

0:17:41 And this one interest sign is just another way that we could do that.

0:17:45 So, myself representing this one follows up this club and the other eight service clubs

0:17:49 who are requesting to sit in to involves the fund $8,000 for the fourth sign that would

0:17:54 be out of the visitor, excuse me, that would be out by the water tank on Washington Street

0:17:59 south.

0:18:00 And I kind of talked about, you know, maybe because I know part of my own staff reports

0:18:04 about funding issues and where the funds come from.

0:18:07 I don't know, you know, I kind of threw out some ideas, you know, maybe there's some

0:18:10 money left over in contingent to see fine, any money left over from capital improvement

0:18:14 projects throughout the year or maybe with all that in-pog funding was used this year or not.

0:18:19 So that's my presentation. I don't know if I did I miss anything thing. I'm good? Oh, I'm sorry.

0:18:28 Yeah, there we go. All right. Thank you. Oh, okay. So these are the three signs we're looking at.

0:18:33 Can we road east as an avenue west? And this is the one that we're requesting the city of Twin Falls

0:18:39 to fund another one. How that? On Washington Street South. Can you show any app? This is the one who

0:18:45 would be out of visitors and as you can tell if you've been out there this will

0:18:48 kind of match the two other existing signs we have to thank you so I'm done

0:18:55 with my presentation I'm ready to have some questions so Dennis I think this

0:19:06 is a great idea being a Rotarian which I hope doesn't disqualify me from voting

0:19:13 because there's a couple of quanians on the council too so I actually look for

0:19:21 these signs when I visit other cities because I want to attend other rotary

0:19:25 meetings and the signs that we have right now are awful. I mean the locals

0:19:31 are anyway so I think this is a great idea. Travis the MPOG grant money is

0:19:38 actually for a 501c3 organization. Correct? There's a 501 any see anything.

0:19:47 see anything there anything of a nonprofit status is eligible to apply and

0:19:52 what do we have available in our impact grant

0:19:57 we have approximately $30,000 that was not expended in the shoes budget thank

0:20:02 you

0:20:07 I think these are rural bridge but I know communities are published

0:20:11 they sell publicity very healthy and shows the inclusiveness of bringing

0:20:17 people from different backgrounds and looking for common purposes within the organization.

0:20:22 I have a very real concern.

0:20:25 We're talking about the use of public money, public right away for a group.

0:20:31 It will one say three's and another five will one say's.

0:20:37 But what about tomorrow morning after reading the use of $8,000 for funds for the sign?

0:20:44 Friends on the upper of life say we've set the President using a specific number of organizations only.

0:21:06 Did this I'm assuming to replace the signs of the new ones that all the service clubs that are having to pay for their individual sites again to be added to that?

0:21:27 Yes, a lot of them, like I know the Optimus Club, the two existing ones we have out there are good sheep.

0:21:33 We have a third one in storage. And if some service clubs have to get a new one, they can work with some sign company.

0:21:38 and we'll have the same thing.

0:21:39 We'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll

0:21:42 have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the

0:21:45 same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing,

0:21:46 we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll

0:21:49 have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the

0:21:52 same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing,

0:21:54 we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll

0:21:55 have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the same thing, we'll have the

0:21:56 Well, we're working on with Vital Signs, they are starting to build up the service clubs

0:22:03 for half of the amount, and also they are working because all these services, all these signs

0:22:08 are at within the Idaho Transportation Department right away, because they're all along state highways

0:22:13 or in the visitor center, you know, that's Idaho Transportation Land.

0:22:16 So we're working on vital signs as applying for a permit through Idaho Transportation Department to

0:22:22 put these signs up.

0:22:24 assuming the price quoted that includes the installation and all the labor that goes in

0:22:29 with them.

0:22:30 And to let you know that, you know, it asked for $8,000, it's roughly the $7,900, all our

0:22:35 service clubs are kind of chipping an extra $100 front unforeseen thing, you know, and

0:22:41 all of a sudden they have to hit bedrock trying to get down there.

0:22:43 So I went ahead of an extra $100 for the city anyway, so it could be only $7,900.

0:22:51 and I do understand to count some and talking to his points, but I know that as Ruth stated,

0:22:57 when I travel and go into a new city or a new area, I too look not always to attend a meeting,

0:23:03 but to see what's there and what's thriving into me, it is a sign of an active and an involved

0:23:09 community which is a good thing to show and I do believe as you've brought forth it does

0:23:16 with our strategic.

0:23:25 was chipping in two thousand three hundred fifty dollars toward the size of

0:23:31 there's there's three signs and they each chip that much in that's roughly that

0:23:36 eight thousand dollars that's needed for those signs yeah two eight thousand dollar

0:23:40 signs and the other side of the visitors center I think 46 so on this one that's

0:23:45 on the screen there is room for four more clubs and so F P E O for instance

0:23:52 would like to be on that then they could purchase a sign and pay to have it installed on there.

0:23:58 Well also what we want to do is all service clubs are kind of signed in agreement together

0:24:03 and if some other service clubs because we contacted as far as we know we defined as what a service

0:24:09 club was we contacted a lot of them who signed in to drop out they couldn't afford it for one reason

0:24:16 or another and decided not to have up there so if some new service club wants to put a sign up there

0:24:20 They're gonna have to reimburse all the other clubs the fair share so they're not just gonna be able to get up on there

0:24:26 Just for doing a logo meeting play sign. They're gonna you might say subsidized rest of the club for their time

0:24:32 I mean other time up there

0:24:34 Cloughs to put that sign up. So it's not gonna be it. Maybe if someone wants to come on

0:24:39 They're instead of 2350. Maybe only like $2,200 or four signs

0:24:46 Or do the other signs have open spots? Yes, they do. They all have open spots, okay wishes

0:25:05 We allow up to $8,000 to the service club to place the sign on Washington Street South.

0:25:20 I'm just going to do it out of the impug funds.

0:25:29 I'll second that.

0:25:32 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:25:41 Yes.

0:25:42 Greg Lantee.

0:25:43 Yes.

0:25:44 Chris Pierce.

0:25:45 Yes.

0:25:46 Sir.

0:25:47 Sir.

0:25:48 Sir.

0:25:49 Sir.

0:25:50 Sir.

0:25:51 Sir.

0:25:52 Sir.

0:25:53 Sir.

0:25:54 Sir.

0:25:55 Sir.

0:25:56 Sir.

0:25:57 Sir.

0:25:58 Sir.

0:26:02 Sir.

0:26:03 Sir.

0:26:05 Sir.

0:26:06 Sir.

0:26:07 Sir.

0:26:09 Sir.

0:26:10 Sir.

0:26:11 Sir.

0:26:12 Sir.

0:26:16 Sir.

0:26:17 Sir.

0:26:18 Sir.

0:26:21 Sir.

0:26:22 Sir.

0:26:23 Sir.

0:26:24 Sir.

0:26:25 6f up. This is an action item. This is a request to use park impact fees to construct a canyon

0:26:33 trail extension across the Bruckenridge property. We have Mitch Humboldt, deputy city manager, and Wendy Davis our Parks and Recreation director.

0:26:40 Thank you. Sorry. I was moved in and wait until the end of the agenda. So this is awesome.

0:27:09 I'm excited to be here this evening to ask

0:27:11 to ask for funding for this part of the project.

0:27:14 This certainly is a culmination of an effort

0:27:17 that has been ongoing and has taken lots of community

0:27:24 partnerships and a lot of internal work together

0:27:27 to get to this place where we're ready

0:27:29 to move forward on this project.

0:27:31 I think this little connection that we're talking about

0:27:35 on this Breckenridge Extension,

0:27:37 gonna connect to the steps that have been there

0:27:39 for a long time with a lot of people peering over the fence

0:27:42 and just waiting for this to happen.

0:27:43 So this will allow, you can go now with this piece in

0:27:50 from Washington to show some falls

0:27:53 continuously on the Canyon Rim Trail

0:27:58 without having to do any of those little workarounds anymore.

0:28:01 So we got the one in a couple of years ago

0:28:03 by the Preserve section and now we'll have this one.

0:28:06 So this is pretty exciting.

0:28:08 I think, as you know, we've been working on this

0:28:11 to get ready to do it as part of the rock mitigation piece.

0:28:16 When they did that rock fall,

0:28:19 the rock mitigation part,

0:28:20 they put in a service road along that back end

0:28:23 on the north end of the property.

0:28:25 And so we have an excellent base to work with,

0:28:27 and now we just need to put in the asphalt

0:28:29 and put the trail in.

0:28:30 And we've talked about this on various lists

0:28:35 for funding, we've talked about it as foregone,

0:28:37 We've talked about it in the long-term planning process.

0:28:41 Now, I've been working on it.

0:28:43 And so tonight I have a request, but I

0:28:46 wanted to give Jamie a minute to talk about the piece

0:28:49 that they've come forward to do as well.

0:28:59 The director of MAFTEC, and Wendy said,

0:29:02 I'm just as excited, if not more,

0:29:06 to have a full connection from Washington,

0:29:09 Aloha E. T. Shoshan Paul, so I'm really excited to be a part of this project.

0:29:13 And thank you, everybody who's with the time and effort to also make this happen.

0:29:20 So, MavTech, combined with sponsorship from plant therapy, Chris Jones donated a chunk of the portion for the trail connection along with tech,

0:29:34 so we will complete the asphalt part of the project and the budget.

0:29:38 So the combination of both of us will make that part happen because MathTech is you guys may remember or know that we're in the business of building trails, right?

0:29:50 So that's what we will do all the asphalt of the trail building.

0:29:56 So we're just really excited to be a part of that and that's where our donation will come from.

0:30:06 Thank you, Jamie.

0:30:07 So, the project includes the asphalt, the fence on the new section, and then the connecting

0:30:17 piece that goes on the north side of the Brecken-Registates needs.

0:30:24 That's on the list of that.

0:30:29 It's magic.

0:30:30 So, it's the part that runs behind the condos right there.

0:30:34 needs some repair and some seal coating and so the idea is to do it all together and so

0:30:42 that's where the 65,000 comes from. So with map text generous donation of the 23 to help

0:30:48 get the asphalt in we need 42,000 to finish it and we're taking a look at the impact fees and we

0:30:59 have more than adequate funds in there and so tonight I'm requesting that we use 42,000 of

0:31:07 Mark Impact fees to complete this project.

0:31:10 Mr. Stockton, at the city of the US 42,000 at Park Impact fees to construct the King and

0:31:32 Rim Trail extension across the Breckner Ridge property as described.

0:31:36 Second.

0:31:37 Mr. Bank, Mr. Stockton, seconded by Nikki Boyd to prove the request to use $42,000 at Park

0:31:44 Impact fees for the construction as their discussions as it happens.

0:31:49 Thank you.

0:31:50 I just want to say thank you to you and MAFTEC for all that you do. I know the hours you put in and if you would pass along the things to blend therapy for us as well. I appreciate you.

0:32:02 Yes, this is a fantastic example of public-private partnership in the community and we certainly appreciate all that.

0:32:16 Thank you, Mayor. Yes, I'm very much excited about this as well. I first called it Council in January 2006.

0:32:23 I remember this was one of the items we looked at strongly because this was part of the piece that I felt we really need,

0:32:31 because it was right there close to connect that portion of the trail,

0:32:37 and I think this is a good use of the impact fees to do so.

0:32:42 And thank you so much to all the community partners as well as my F-TEC

0:32:46 that have helped us complete a world-class trail on our Canyon for people to enjoy a natural wonder that we have here in our city.

0:32:56 Thank you, Greg, it's there any further discussion?

0:33:08 Great landing.

0:33:09 Yes.

0:33:10 Great peers.

0:33:10 Yes.

0:33:11 Christopher Reed.

0:33:12 Yes.

0:33:12 Chris Talkington.

0:33:13 Yes.

0:33:14 John Berica.

0:33:14 Yes.

0:33:15 Thank you, boy.

0:33:16 Yes.

0:33:16 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:33:17 Yes.

0:33:18 I'm here this evening to request to use surplus state shared revenues to purchase a new chemical

0:34:09 controller for the city pool.

0:34:12 Our current controller is about 15 years old and is failing to properly maintain consistent

0:34:16 chlorine disinfection levels at the pool.

0:34:19 We have tried to fix the problem by adjusting the settings and using different chemical combinations

0:34:24 however we've been unsuccessful in that process.

0:34:27 This has led us to manually control the pool chlorine.

0:34:30 This requires constant testing and adjustment by staff throughout the day to maintain proper

0:34:35 chlorination levels.

0:34:37 and support are no longer available for this model of chemical controller.

0:34:41 In fact, the vendor that we use was surprised the thing was still working at all, so we

0:34:46 made it longer than they planned.

0:34:49 The best solution is to replace this unit with a new one.

0:34:52 The new controller will allow for the chlorine to be controlled automatically with minimal human intervention.

0:34:57 It will also allow us to have remote access to it so adjustments can make quickly and easily as well.

0:35:05 And with that remote access, we'll be able to get notifications if an error happens along the way, say head in the middle of the night.

0:35:12 We can get there and fix it right away and not be surprised the next morning when we open if we're something's wrong.

0:35:18 So that would be a definite perk for us there.

0:35:22 The quote we received to replace the chemical controller is $6,500.

0:35:26 The current city pool budget doesn't allow for the replacement of this unit.

0:35:30 So, the city is receiving higher than anticipated state sales tax revenue, and these surplus

0:35:36 funds would be used to purchase a new controller, so with that said, I'd be happy to take questions.

0:35:43 John, Greg, and you learned it.

0:35:51 There's a lot of money.

0:35:53 I'm getting over there.

0:35:54 I'll go ahead and make a motion.

0:35:55 I move that we grant the request to use $6,500 from what's going on here.

0:36:05 that we grant the request to use $6500 from what specific fund would tax surplus?

0:36:16 Yes, it's in the pool fund.

0:36:17 Pool fund, okay.

0:36:18 Alright.

0:36:19 Grant the request to use $6500 in surplus in the pool fund to purchase a replacement chemical

0:36:26 controller for the city pool.

0:36:28 Second.

0:36:30 I should buy a new keyboard, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the request as presented.

0:36:34 Is there any further discussion?

0:36:37 Raise Paris. Yes. Mr. Fareed. Yes. Mr. Stockington. Yes. Sean Baraker. Yes.

0:36:47 Nikki Boyd. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes. And Greg Leiting. Yes. Mr. Passes 7-0. Thank you.

0:36:53 Thank you. John. Next on the agenda is an action item. This is a request to support in investing city employees time to perform a thorough process review of City Code Title 3 business regulations.

0:37:11 We have Janie Higgins, a counting specialist.

0:37:13 Welcome Janie.

0:37:22 Thank you.

0:37:25 I'm here seeking your support in investing city employees time

0:37:29 to perform a thorough process review of City Code Title III,

0:37:33 which pertains to business regulations.

0:37:35 Over the past several months, we've

0:37:36 had costs referred to that City Code Title III

0:37:39 to seek guidance in responding to licensing and permitting

0:37:43 questions that are posed by citizens and by business owners.

0:37:47 We're also preparing to make several city clerk application

0:37:50 forms paperless through our laser fish forms program.

0:37:55 As we found, parts of the code haven't been updated in decades,

0:37:58 and we've sometimes found them difficult to interpret

0:38:01 or found them to be out of date.

0:38:04 Add clarity, where there are also some sections

0:38:07 that were implemented several decades ago,

0:38:11 longer be appropriate as they were originally written,

0:38:14 such as the chapter on card rooms,

0:38:17 or items that would like to expect references

0:38:22 to fee amounts out of the actors.

0:38:37 We would also like to consider changing the fee description from a license fee to a vacation fee.

0:38:42 There's on beer in much of the same sub-sections based on what type of area is a chapter on going out of business

0:38:57 and requiring a license as well as a $1,000 to cover dissatisfied customers.

0:39:02 And we question whether that is really something the city should be administering at this time.

0:39:06 A chapter just to solicitors which are door to door sales and move the transient merchants which are stationary sales

0:39:16 into their into the chapter on commercial bending request this evening

0:39:22 we will move forward in creating teams for reviewing each chapter of title three

0:39:26 input from all applicable departments as each chapter is reviewed we will return

0:39:32 to council to summarize our findings and propose changes if any that were the

0:39:38 course of the next few months and collecting fee once all chapters have

0:39:43 been reviewed and we've shared our proposal with the council there are

0:39:53 Some chapters that have already had the slate, such as the chapter on public downfalls, and we feel that re-killing the entire title and starting over will give the budget impact of the costs involved in publishing our summary of changes, and if approved, updating those sections of city code with sterling code of five.

0:40:21 I have a question, so be bringing these pieces back to the council, which of course gives

0:40:27 an opportunity for some public input, would there be any plans to do like specific open

0:40:32 houses or something like that for specific types of businesses?

0:40:37 That makes sense that you have kind of these more informal gatherings of, there's, you

0:40:43 know, transient vendors or, you know, food trucks?

0:40:48 That's something we could look at.

0:40:49 That's not something that we had thought.

0:40:50 I'm official to get input, but we're actually transacting that business in a setting that may feel more comfortable than showing up at accounts meeting and having to stand at a podium.

0:41:02 If there are ways to kind of carve out specific types of businesses.

0:41:07 Okay.

0:41:08 Is that how it comes?

0:41:09 Katie, thank you for your work and leadership on this. I know it's not an easy task, but I think it's definitely something it's time.

0:41:18 I was ready to make a motion, but I see other people are waiting in, so I will step back through.

0:41:24 I think we're starting to be inversion of time for this.

0:41:27 I hate to make it open and that some role-meaning committees can go on.

0:41:32 This is my first re-into this.

0:41:47 I'm not sure how much more time might be.

0:41:56 Realistically, we're probably looking at six to eight months on some of them.

0:41:59 There are some chapters that are not going to take that much time.

0:42:02 Or others if we do our true due diligence and we really invest the time.

0:42:16 So just to kind of add one of the conversations that's going to be included, this is the mobile food trucks.

0:42:29 And you'll recall some time ago we made some changes to the code in response to some community requests.

0:42:38 They've come back and they've really shared some of the changes that they believe that would be really beneficiary to not only their industry, but also to the community.

0:42:48 And so that would be one group that would certainly be incorporated into this process

0:42:54 to share their ideas that it's working well in other communities in Idaho and other places.

0:42:59 And then we would take a look at those ideas and see how we can incorporate some of their

0:43:03 thoughts into the Title III rewrite before we bring it back to you.

0:43:08 So when we plan on doing that where it is applicable, in some of these things it's not

0:43:12 applicable.

0:43:13 It's really more of an internal process driven thing in other places and to be greatly

0:43:16 impacts some of the business partners that we have and we certainly would have a sneaky

0:43:25 boy.

0:43:27 This is a question for Jonathan or maybe you can answer it so we're working on a rewrite

0:43:32 of Title 10, three, there are other titles in there that are meeting at the same time.

0:43:41 I'm doing some sections back that need to be addressed but I talked about Title 3 specifically

0:43:51 the food truck portion.

0:43:52 These convoluted people are having a difficult time getting through the process so I would

0:43:59 And we will be involved with that section specifically.

0:44:05 Going through the same process we are with Title 10,

0:44:07 getting input from the focus group types of people,

0:44:11 drafting something, getting more input,

0:44:13 taking the comment before it comes back to that.

0:44:19 And obviously it's a lot bigger, it's like 300 pages.

0:44:22 This is a little bit smaller, but there are sections

0:44:25 in Title 3 that I'm just saying don't,

0:44:29 that same type of thing, we can still do it.

0:44:41 There's an outcomes.

0:44:43 Thank you. I move that we approve the request to support investing city employees time to perform a thorough process review of CECO Title III.

0:44:54 In a second, the motion is seconded on the day of six month report that the city on progress or finalization.

0:45:20 A motion and a second on the original motion to approve the request is presented.

0:45:25 Another motion to amend the motion to have a six month reporting back to the council.

0:45:30 Is there a second for that?

0:45:39 All right, so we will take up the amendment first.

0:45:41 This is an amendment to place a six month report back to the council.

0:45:46 A deadline in the motion by Chris Stockton, second by Greg Lanting, is there a discussion?

0:45:51 Let's better tell it, staff, do their job at the process, be it a great job.

0:46:12 He was there for the discussion.

0:46:20 To answer that, Suzanne, to me that means that they're going to at least give something back to us within six months if they need more time, they'll ask for it then.

0:46:27 So, I'll be there.

0:46:28 Is there further discussion on the amendment?

0:46:39 Christopher Reed?

0:46:40 Yes.

0:46:41 Chris Tockington?

0:46:42 Yes.

0:46:43 Sean Berriger?

0:46:44 Yes.

0:46:45 6'5 to 2".

0:46:55 Now in the main motion which is to approve the request is presented with a 6 month reporting

0:47:01 back to the council included as their discussion on the main motion.

0:47:14 4, 6 months.

0:47:15 Whenever when in a reasonable time 6 to 8 and it's sooner on the first one we'll see you here.

0:47:40 The main motion we're going to vote on now is to approve the request as presented with the inclusion of a six month report back from the council.

0:47:47 Further discussion?

0:47:56 Chris Tockington?

0:47:57 Yes.

0:47:58 John Berriger?

0:47:59 Yes.

0:48:00 Nicky Boyd?

0:48:01 Yes.

0:48:02 Ed Hawkins?

0:48:03 Yes.

0:48:04 Rick Lanting?

0:48:05 Yes.

0:48:06 Yes.

0:48:07 Christopher Wieck?

0:48:08 Yes.

0:48:09 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:48:10 Have a great time.

0:48:14 Next on the agenda is an action item.

0:48:17 a discussion and possible action on a fire bond.

0:48:21 We have Travis Roth, my city manager,

0:48:23 and Brian Pike, deputy city manager.

0:48:32 Thank you, Merritt, members of the council.

0:48:34 As always, it's a pleasure to be here tonight.

0:48:37 And hopefully my PowerPoint worked better

0:48:39 than the last time I was here.

0:48:45 So I think tonight is a pretty straightforward conversation

0:48:49 with the council.

0:48:50 We talked a little bit about a month ago.

0:48:53 We came before you and we asked the council

0:48:56 consider placing a fire station bond on the November election. Tonight that's

0:49:02 changed just a little bit. Tonight we really want to gauge your support of proposing a

0:49:06 fire station bond in the upcoming election. You notice that I didn't put a

0:49:11 month on there so we're certainly not asking for November and I'll explain

0:49:15 why and I could put may up there but honestly I think that as we have a

0:49:21 further discussion tonight I think you'll understand a little bit of where we're

0:49:25 at. So really coming out of the May election, as we talked about last time, here's what

0:49:29 we know. And we're pretty confident in what we know in this particular set of facts. We

0:49:35 know that 12.8% of our registered voters participate in the election. We know that we came really

0:49:41 close to a super majority at 63.45% of the voters voting in favor. So certainly over

0:49:47 the majority had this been a simple majority would have been a spectacular victory. But

0:49:52 that super majority at that 66.67% we fell just a little bit short of and as we

0:49:59 talked about last time here's some things that were really not for sure

0:50:03 and I put lessons learned and I put some question works because we've had a lot

0:50:07 of community conversations and we've had a lot of input from people that we know

0:50:11 friends and some cases family and when we were before you last month this was our

0:50:17 best estimate on why we failed to have that super majority and we talked a little

0:50:21 about the total bond amount being too much for our community to improve. We talked a little

0:50:26 bit about the turnout and that tied back to where the voters were actually aware of the

0:50:33 election and a number of factors, which would make sense. And then we had some conflicts

0:50:38 with high school and things like that. But what we'd like tonight is really to consider

0:50:45 there, we believe there remains a series of questions that we need to answer before we

0:50:50 We can come back in front of the council and make a recommendation that we believe has

0:50:54 a strong chance of achieving the required super majority of support from our community.

0:51:02 We don't think or don't feel that we're in a position tonight to give you that solid

0:51:06 recommendation because we really need a little more time to find out why.

0:51:11 I think that's an important question.

0:51:13 I think it's a fair question to our community, especially moving forward.

0:51:17 This is an important issue, we believe it's a relevant issue, we've certainly demonstrated

0:51:22 the fact that we do have needs, and I think the community supports that need, but I'd

0:51:28 hate to be in this situation where we move forward not being fully aware of that picture,

0:51:33 the totality of that picture, and that not achieving the required super majority vote

0:51:39 in the next process, whether that's in May or in November, I'm not for sure, and that's

0:51:44 It's really why we want it just to step back and say we need a little more time to work

0:51:48 as a city staff to work with our partners, Fire Station Committee and others to determine

0:51:53 what we really need to do to achieve this.

0:51:56 Because we think ultimately once we have that information, then we can come back and

0:52:01 reengage, build upon the work that we've already done, we'll know what the specific

0:52:06 community concerns were and we'll know how to address them.

0:52:09 So we have options that we presented to you last month, we had three options.

0:52:13 those are best shot but you might come back to you in a month or two months from now with

0:52:19 some options that we haven't considered based on some of the input that would receive and

0:52:24 of course we would apply that to the process and then just continue to have that strong

0:52:29 community conversation.

0:52:30 So tonight we're just trying to get a gauge of how the council feels if tonight you would

0:52:37 say you know you would like to move forward with placing this issue on the November ballot

0:52:43 We have options that we could present very similar to what we did last month, but it would be our recommendation really to step back and make sure that we have a good feeling, not only just a feeling, but we know what the community is saying and how we can find an option that will work for them.

0:53:03 Chris Reed, concerns they have, those concerns, the committees there, it's done an amazing job, some success, recognizing that we might run into some issues with November and Chris talked about what Chris said, I think the investment, this has to pass next time, Andy's safety future grows, fever goes next May, I also put the strongly discouraged proposal, this place to cause, I could see some other alternatives that would be helpful, which this time will buy so.

0:54:31 more time makes sense. Susan Hawkins. I'm hoping that we can fire Chief for a few

0:54:40 minutes and just kind of get his thoughts and maybe a pulse on the fighters as

0:54:46 they're facing this issue and maybe how we can support them more as we work

0:54:51 through some of these issues. Absolutely. Thank you. Council, I have been in these

0:55:01 discussions as well as we've been talking about this and I think a lot of comments

0:55:07 that helps the memory breaks up and others is accurate.

0:55:16 Some of the feedback that I received

0:55:18 from some of my constituents was to do this very thing.

0:55:23 Spend some time on really understanding,

0:55:30 you have talked around things,

0:55:32 we've just point to a budget issue to do some survey work,

0:55:43 but fully understand what the citizen will support.

0:55:47 But to make sure that our firefighters know

0:55:56 that we're working hard for them too,

0:55:58 So to go along with that as well, I have been talking along the way, planning scene, community to keep this conversation going.

0:56:11 We don't want to lose them with men that our group has done.

0:56:15 And this is another way to do that as well with the short time frame that we have.

0:56:19 So well, obviously we would have liked to have fire stations started.

0:56:24 We would have liked to have the election pass and they also understand what the public said.

0:56:36 to make sure this task is done.

0:56:43 Yes, I think I'm in favor of taking a look as well, Brian.

0:56:55 As I've said before, I'd like to look at other options too,

0:56:58 that maybe we build one or two or something along that line

0:57:03 with the use of an override levy, because working out...

0:57:06 I've worked a lot of mod elections in my form of career of the schools

0:57:11 and different things.

0:57:12 You've got a super majority's hard,

0:57:15 and because there's about 20 to 25% of the electric are going to basically vote no no matter

0:57:22 what you bring before them, they just they don't feel like an afford it or they don't

0:57:25 like taxes so you've got a 10 or 10 or 10 to 20% window to to convince them because you've

0:57:33 got another I don't think I've ever voted no on a bottom election in my life not for anything

0:57:39 I've always voted yes and so you have people that are in that category you just have to

0:57:44 that in between or the ones that hold one one where the other

0:57:47 the ones you need to convince.

0:57:48 And I would still like to, like I mentioned,

0:57:51 that started to select it.

0:57:52 Make sure we have all the options on the table,

0:57:54 whether or not we could start out with an onal right levy

0:57:58 that on these 50% in two year when we can build one station

0:58:03 and then come back with a bond later

0:58:05 or something along that line, just kind of get things going.

0:58:08 Not saying that's the solution,

0:58:09 but I'd like to look at the information

0:58:12 to see how that would work.

0:58:13 So I'm in favor of taking a longer look, because I'm by Chris.

0:58:19 I think he's got to pass the next time, because once you see school ones,

0:58:23 then they go down there on our third or fourth,

0:58:25 and they just keep asking for lower amounts,

0:58:27 and they keep getting lower percentages.

0:58:29 So we need to get a nice step in the next time.

0:58:33 So thank you.

0:58:55 This can't be a hearing tonight, or was this general consensus from the council.

0:59:49 So this is just general consensus because the action would be to cause staff to go create an ordinance if you wanted to go

0:59:56 In November, but since that does not seem to be the consensus of the Council, no action is needed this evening.

1:00:06 Citizens Committee that worked on this so diligently, please stick with us and we'll be on these conversations.

1:00:27 We are at six o'clock, we do have a public hearing scheduled

1:00:30 to start no sooner than six o'clock.

1:00:32 We have one more action item on the main agenda

1:00:35 with the exception of the budget presentation.

1:00:37 I'm gonna rearrange that and do the budget presentation

1:00:39 after the hearing.

1:00:40 We are gonna take up this last item under items of consideration.

1:00:43 So this is an action item, this is a request

1:00:46 to propose a budget amendment to accept a grant

1:00:49 from the Twin Falls Rural Fire District

1:00:52 begin programming for a regional fire department

1:00:54 training facility.

1:00:55 and plus can we're the Art of Fire Chief,

1:01:04 I'm gonna give this to Mayor, Council.

1:01:06 Again, this kind of ties in nicely

1:01:08 with the last conversation.

1:01:10 And just to, I'll make this quick,

1:01:13 I think this is pretty straightforward as well,

1:01:16 just to give you a quick history, though.

1:01:17 We have been talking about a training facility,

1:01:20 not only here in the reports,

1:01:24 but also in the fire station bond process we just went through.

1:01:30 And one of the things,

1:01:32 I think it's currently one group of demoed houses,

1:01:38 tear down some buildings,

1:01:40 whatever academy, typically in the fire service,

1:01:45 you have some form of an academy

1:01:46 that you run firefighters through here in Twin

1:01:49 up until this last group that we just purchased.

1:01:52 We just hired, we made this last group,

1:01:57 we actually sent through a five-week academy,

1:02:00 and we used Boise's training facility to help.

1:02:07 The other thing that we typically do,

1:02:08 just so you know we do train,

1:02:11 but we're using private parking lots, businesses,

1:02:14 a service organization, like churches,

1:02:16 that's where I think we do our training.

1:02:18 So a need for a training facility,

1:02:20 as you're all aware, is something that we need.

1:02:23 And during the budget, or excuse me,

1:02:26 the fire station ballot process,

1:02:29 one of the gentlemen that I'll point out tonight,

1:02:32 Jim Olson is one of our commissioners

1:02:34 of the fire district is here tonight too,

1:02:36 so if you have any questions for him,

1:02:38 answer those has brought up on several occasions from the district's point of view is they're

1:02:46 really open to assisting with the training component of whatever the city of Twin Falls

1:02:53 Fire Department is in need of. And so with those conversations over the last year, I've

1:02:58 also done some additional conversations with some of our regional partners, other fire

1:03:02 chiefs in the area, talked to the college a little bit, it's a preliminary discussion

1:03:07 with some of our private business, and there's a real need out there for a regional type facility.

1:03:15 So again, through some of these conversations I've talked with City Management with Public Works John Caton,

1:03:22 quite a few months ago, hopefully still on board with us.

1:03:25 As we look towards where could we possibly build a facility for training in the future?

1:03:31 So, as we discuss this, and with the fire district, they're itching, I might just say,

1:03:39 to really move forward and try to move some kind of agenda forward to build a training

1:03:45 facility.

1:03:46 I won't say the amount, because they're kind of waiting to see the next step before they

1:03:50 say what that amount is, but I would just like to say it's a significant amount of funds

1:03:55 that they're willing to put up to support the building of a training facility, regional training

1:03:59 facility.

1:04:03 So tonight, the action item that I'm looking for is, or looking for a approval or a discussion,

1:04:09 for sure, is to accept a $20,000 grant from the fire district, and that $20,000 would

1:04:18 go forward in basically doing the programming piece, much like we did for the fire stations,

1:04:23 but on a training facility to look at and I'll pop up a sign here or the slide if you

1:04:29 you can see it, or the property on at 420 Victory Avenue, which is over by the Humane Society

1:04:36 between that and the golf course. This was in our fire station, programming study as well,

1:04:43 it was pointed out there, but this is just an overview again of that on the left was some

1:04:50 of our recruits during our training in Boise. So, with that, what I'm asking for tonight

1:04:56 for you to consider as accepting and ending the budget

1:04:59 to allow accepting acceptance of a grant for $20,000

1:05:04 to move forward with actually coming up

1:05:08 with what the programming of this piece of property

1:05:10 would look like.

1:05:12 So this would move us to the next step,

1:05:13 which would allow the district and the city

1:05:16 as we might move forward with kind of a sectional kind

1:05:22 of piece this kind of together with different components

1:05:25 that we could fund along the way over several years.

1:05:28 So this is process would do the programming and then we would have kind of a roadmap.

1:05:34 That's what I'm asking for.

1:05:37 I'm going to answer any questions.

1:05:38 I'm really excited to see this on the agenda.

1:05:45 I think this is fantastic because I have witnessed much of our very best work is when we do it in partnerships.

1:05:56 I just have one quick clarification, this is amending the budget fiscal year 19, the current

1:06:47 budget we're in so we will go through a formalized process to amend the budget

1:06:53 this will be included in that ordinance as well as the public hearing this is

1:06:58 acknowledgement that we will have to do that if you accept the grant thank you

1:07:02 comments Chris talking to most uh much of my month to accept the 20,000 was it

1:07:16 20,000 grand from the fall for a whole fire district to begin programming for

1:07:21 the regional fire department training facility and this current budget

1:07:26 fine this could be a question for Travis or for the city attorney so are we

1:07:39 actually proposing a budget amendment or is this really acceptance of the

1:07:42 grant and then the budget amendment will be mixing with the budget it's the

1:07:46 latter it is just the acceptance of the grant so the motion should need to accept

1:07:50 the grant as presented so we have a motion by Chris Stockton second by Chris

1:07:55 Street to accept the $20,000 grant from the Twin Falls Rural Fire District to begin programming

1:08:02 for a regional fire department training facility as their further discussion.

1:08:06 Great lighting.

1:08:08 Tim, thank you for your group to get us moving forward on this site.

1:08:13 I have a lot of relatives and some relatives in some of these other fire districts around

1:08:20 the Magic Valley that I was certainly excited to be part of this.

1:08:25 There's a well, so thank you for your group for the, for the, the grant for the discussion.

1:08:40 On Burger.

1:08:45 Yes.

1:08:46 Thank you, boy.

1:08:47 Yes.

1:08:48 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:08:49 Yes.

1:08:50 Great landing.

1:08:51 Yes.

1:08:52 Chris Pierce.

1:08:53 Yes.

1:08:54 Christopher Reed.

1:08:55 Yes.

1:08:56 Yes.

1:08:57 Yes.

1:08:58 I should pass the seven zero.

1:08:59 Thank you.

1:09:01 Thank you again, Jim.

1:09:02 All right.

1:09:03 So as I mentioned, we do have the budget presentation still.

1:09:04 I am going to delay that until after the public hearing.

1:09:06 public hearing, and we will move to the public hearing.

1:09:10 So this is an action item.

1:09:12 This is a request for additional height

1:09:15 to allow a 75 foot tall mixed use building

1:09:18 at property located at 160 main avenues south.

1:09:22 Carrot 160 LLC.

1:09:25 We have Rock, Cherry, our city planner.

1:09:27 I am going to review the planning and zoning

1:09:29 public hearing procedures as these are a bit more formalized

1:09:33 the public input session from earlier. The council is going to follow these steps for

1:09:40 the request this evening so the city staff will present the request and analysis. The

1:09:46 applicant will then present their request. The council will then ask questions of the

1:09:50 applicant or the staff. After those questions have been asked the public hearing will then

1:09:55 be opened and during that time anyone in attendance has given the opportunity to comment

1:10:00 or ask questions about the request being considered.

1:10:04 When giving testimony, please step up to the podium,

1:10:06 state your name and address, then present your comments or concerns.

1:10:10 After giving testimony, please be sure that you sign in on the public sign-in sheet

1:10:15 located in a lobby with your name and address for the official record.

1:10:20 After public comments are concluded, the applicant will be invited to answer

1:10:24 any questions and make a closing statement.

1:10:27 Staff will then answer or clarify any comments as needed.

1:10:31 After those closing statements, the public hearing will be closed.

1:10:34 No further testimony or comments from the applicant or the audience will be allowed in the council

1:10:38 and then have an open discussion and take action on the request.

1:10:44 So with that, we will have a Brock begin with the staff presentation.

1:10:50 Thank you Mr. Mayor. The City Council, what you have before you is a request for additional

1:10:56 high or a 75 foot mixed use building at 160 main avenue south. Our youth ranch building

1:11:05 just right near us. The building is within the CB district which has a maximum height limit

1:11:10 of 50 feet. However per city code applicants are able to ask city council if they are able

1:11:18 to go higher than the overall height which is currently mandated. It will be a 75 foot

1:11:29 building which will have six floors. The first two floors will be commercial. The first floor

1:11:37 will be retail services. The second floor will be offices and then the top four will end up

1:11:49 being residential apartments. Yeah, planning and zoning commission voted to

1:11:55 recommend this to you with a 6 to 6 to a 0 positive vote of recommendation. The

1:12:05 math has prepared the visuals for you to just give you an idea of what 75 feet

1:12:12 looks like. Currently the building there is 33 feet. The de-hall stands at 43 feet.

1:12:20 the allowed maximum height is 50 feet. And then what is being asked for the 75 feet is

1:12:27 pretty tall. To give greater context, we have created these visuals. Note these are approximate.

1:12:34 They are not 100% precise, but they give you an idea of what 75 feet looks like downtown.

1:12:42 Here is traveling westward along Hanson. And then we have traveling southward on

1:12:52 on Main Avenue East, and then we have traveling eastward along Handsome.

1:13:02 This building will be the tallest structure within this proximity, and we believe it may be the tallest building within the city of Twin Falls itself.

1:13:14 Staff recognizes that there will certainly be impacts surrounding such a tall building.

1:13:27 The impacts that we recognize is that it will dramatically change our downtown skyline.

1:13:33 It will be the tallest building within downtown and as I mentioned before the tallest building

1:13:37 within the city of Twin Falls.

1:13:39 Being that it is so tall it will end up creating shade, obviously.

1:13:44 However, the Parks and Recreation Master Plan says that shade is the number one amenity

1:13:50 sought by our citizens, which we think is a positive thing.

1:13:55 Also, we believe that there will be more pedestrian traffic, however due to our great renovations downtown as far as our sidewalks go, we believe that we have the appropriate pedestrian infrastructure to certainly help with all of the pedestrians that will be shuffling by to either shop or even perhaps live.

1:14:17 Also, there will be vehicular traffic within the area.

1:14:21 Staff has done a brief analysis of just the two and a half block area.

1:14:26 We believe that we do have parking that will be able to satisfy this building.

1:14:31 We believe we have approximately 1,600 public spaces available with around 400 private

1:14:38 spaces.

1:14:39 However, this is only after a brief analysis.

1:14:41 This isn't a firm analysis, which we could definitely do a greater look to what the parking

1:14:51 would end up needing to be.

1:14:55 If short, if council was to approve this, we would ask that it be subject to continue compliance

1:15:04 with all local, state, and federal code requirements and other standards as applicable.

1:15:11 be subject to continued compliance with the application materials and drawing submitted by

1:15:18 by the applicant and that it be subject to mechanical service or other structural

1:15:26 equipment extending no more than 10 feet above the height of a proposed structure.

1:15:34 And with that I open myself up for any questions however I would like to give the applicant an

1:15:39 an opportunity to present and then of the staff

1:15:49 we will be in your presentation.

1:16:00 Thank you.

1:16:01 I don't think I'll need that much time.

1:16:03 Mr. Mayor and members of the city council,

1:16:05 my name is Fran Florence.

1:16:07 I'm representing 160 LLC, the developers,

1:16:13 the proposed developers for this building.

1:16:18 The process that we've been going through

1:16:23 probably to revitalize downtown,

1:16:25 probably predates just about everybody on the council, and certainly everybody and staff.

1:16:33 The effort to revitalize downtown Twin Falls didn't start long after the Great Sucking

1:16:38 Sound occurred when the north room of town with the shopping out that direction started

1:16:47 to happen.

1:16:51 My involvement in this process of contemplating and planning started in the early 90s.

1:16:57 I became a volunteer on planning and zoning and participated in that process, and even

1:17:02 then we were talking about it, and since that time at least three comprehensive plans

1:17:07 have been ratified and agreed with public input that revitalization of downtown as one

1:17:19 of the very top priorities for the community.

1:17:23 the past handful of years. We've seen great movements towards that and again

1:17:28 through the public process of asking for and receiving opinions on our citizens

1:17:36 view towards downtown and the building we're standing in is the outcome of one of

1:17:41 these well the process that we've been going through and I commend the city and

1:17:47 their foresight in participating in this revitalization effort. Downtown Main Street

1:17:54 Revived is a strong commitment that happened with the help of urban renewal and

1:18:03 you know again vetted through the process, public process to engage citizen

1:18:10 comment and support and the last few years the plan or the request or the

1:18:18 desire for our community to see this downtown revitalization has been more

1:18:23 defined to include references to try to bring back some retail and references

1:18:30 with we need a place to work and more people working downtown and specifically

1:18:37 regarding residential. It's been on the top of the list through this process,

1:18:45 especially the last handful of years. This project is the first project that

1:18:53 from the ground up satisfies all three of those. It satisfies a place for more

1:18:58 retail. It satisfies a place for employment with the commercial levels

1:19:04 and it certainly satisfies our first foray into offering new residential component of

1:19:11 downtown. I think that the support for downtown housing and revitalization of downtown is without

1:19:22 question. Now having said that, I know we're in a new territory because we're talking about

1:19:30 taller buildings than we've had in the past and as part of the development team we respect

1:19:37 the concerns about the effect that that might have. Certainly it changes the skyline and for

1:19:45 our community that's been accustomed to the skyline and satisfied and supportive of our

1:19:53 historic buildings, I can understand how it can be difficult for some of those folks

1:20:00 to think that this is the right way forward. I had a couple of calls earlier this last

1:20:07 week, Ashley, and I recommended that people who have concern about that, I told them the

1:20:13 day and the time to be here because I think it's important that we hear again from our

1:20:17 citizens know that, and I know you know this, that when it's now here in our

1:20:24 face that we're looking at this, the people that have been participating all

1:20:29 along might not be the same people that are in the room tonight. There might be some

1:20:33 that have been, but I want you to be aware that there's a lot of folks out there

1:20:38 that are very supportive of this. I've heard about the parking and the concerns

1:20:43 about parking and well you know staff says well we know we've got a lot of

1:20:48 parking we were also concerned about that parking and we think it's important that

1:20:54 we continue to to look at this the parking needs of downtown and we're we're

1:21:00 pleased to know that urban renewal has committed some resources to add parking

1:21:08 structure that would complement this project and it may be that in the future

1:21:15 there are others who want to participate as well including the city. I think that

1:21:21 comes at a different time in discussion. I think that comes with some more study

1:21:26 on that. We certainly encourage that but tonight we're here to talk about

1:21:31 allowing 75 feet building height and that really should be the focus of what we're

1:21:39 doing. You know one final comment and I maybe this is corny and I talk about

1:21:44 people talk about history historic buildings and history and there's you

1:21:50 know there might be some people in the crowd that have more of a respect and

1:21:53 appreciation for history but on the fifth generation or I represent five

1:21:58 generations and the third generation resident. I have grandchildren that live here and you know I

1:22:05 think it's okay to to respect that history but I think it's so it's also okay to make some history

1:22:13 and without people coming for us making history and building downtown Twin Falls as it was

1:22:20 we wouldn't have anything to work with and I think it's okay to move forward and take these steps

1:22:24 and something that is well-measured, well-planned, and we can be proud of it.

1:22:29 So I'll be available for questions if there are any.

1:22:35 I guess right now if there are any questions for Mr. Florence or staff.

1:22:42 Let's take what this building is done.

1:22:57 That is a blocked out and it shows the representation of the mass

1:23:01 and some of the architectural elements that I anticipate will remain with the building.

1:23:05 But we aren't heavy into the final design of this until we know that we can go six stories.

1:23:15 My follow-up to that question is, it is six stories.

1:23:21 Is through mechanism and taking advantage of the opportunities zoning, does there need

1:23:30 to be four floors of residential living to make that all work?

1:23:35 Yes.

1:23:38 This is how it happens.

1:23:39 Thank you.

1:23:40 This is probably one for staff, but with this being our first building in the city of this

1:23:46 height, how does that affect our fire response and are we equipped well enough to take care

1:23:51 of that at this point in time?

1:23:53 Well, this is great because we do have our fire.

1:23:56 There he is.

1:23:58 I feel like we're in the spot all night.

1:24:03 I apologize for making you get up again.

1:24:06 Your council?

1:24:09 Yes.

1:24:11 So, one of the things that, first of all, we have a...

1:24:15 All we have a ladder truck that's on our feet tall, different systems to help, obviously,

1:24:42 it only what's required for building and scanning.

1:25:21 So at this point we will open up the opportunity for public testimony.

1:25:27 I do have several people who did sign in, have front and will certainly have an opportunity

1:25:32 for those of you who are unable to sign in.

1:25:34 Again, I would ask that you state your name and address for the record and please limit

1:25:41 your comments to three minutes.

1:25:42 minutes we will have a timer going for those. So to start off I have Kim Rice.

1:25:47 Kim Rice, 132 Main Street South, I'm a business owner. And there's several that came that didn't

1:26:05 sign up. Some had to leave, but we are worried about the parking and we'd like to see more

1:26:11 of what he talked about that, you know, they think that they can sustain it with the parking

1:26:16 that we can camp now. But right now we're kind of being suffocated out. We have a kickback.

1:26:22 who bought Wells Fargo, they're bleeding over into the public, taking up most of the road.

1:26:27 And from my understanding, they don't let anybody in the upstairs park in their specific lot.

1:26:33 I personally have elderly people, a lot of them walk just fine,

1:26:40 and I have quite a few that aren't going to walk, want to walk blocks to get to my office.

1:26:44 I love being in the downtown area, I don't want to have to move.

1:26:48 So, my suggestion is that, can we please look more into the parking before this is approved?

1:26:54 Because once that building's up, it's up, and they're going to put it up in the parking

1:26:59 wall manner anymore.

1:27:07 Uh, damper seat.

1:27:08 Yeah, I'm a resident of the walls, uh, Mr. McKitt, I guess that's why I said it on, we

1:27:36 decided to purchase this building.

1:27:44 And the reason we decided to purchase this building is exactly what's happening.

1:27:50 This is the unique opportunity for our community to end the city.

1:28:19 This building is a challenge.

1:28:20 It turns when the process continues.

1:28:39 While this is happening, we lose our funding.

1:28:54 It's an issue, and it will continue to be an issue, and it has to be.

1:29:06 This project needs to be underway this fall, that all of these families have been in doubt.

1:29:31 We're celebrating, and we're presently in.

1:29:40 We see a lot of stuff happening down here.

1:29:45 I saw the first urban rental project that about clicks is clicking out of your own.

1:30:01 Anyway, it ended up sucking, and I ended up sucking.

1:30:12 And it's coming back, and it's coming back because of what we're able to do with tax and common financing.

1:30:20 though I would really urge the city council may appreciate your time at Paul

1:30:54 Graf Twicoffee one for four main avenue sales I'm actually quite excited for

1:31:01 what's happening downtown quite excited for possibly of what this building could

1:31:07 do to downtown the benefits that it could be as was right said I was much

1:31:16 concerned about the parking especially in my location where it'll have a major

1:31:20 of that. I would just encourage City Council to aggressively pursue some kind of structure

1:31:28 to increase the parking concurrently with this project.

1:31:32 I was looking for a hiding behind that row of people back there.

1:31:49 Used to work at the Paris with Mr. Faulkner. So I've seen downtown change and grow and watch

1:32:11 what happened on the North Rim take away from the downtown and I'm seeing it revitalized

1:32:17 And my one concern I talked with Franny about was the parking.

1:32:24 I think everybody was talking about the parking because we dealt with parking at the Paris too.

1:32:30 And he mentioned building a parking facility which I think should go along with the building.

1:32:39 And when I was in Italy, they had all these beautiful buildings, but everybody lived up above.

1:32:49 Their businesses were below. I think that's a great concept. We even saw that in Germany.

1:32:55 And downtown needs to do something different.

1:32:59 And I talked to a friend about the height and some people had asked me about it.

1:33:07 And you know what, we're going to grow up and you go all over, I don't know if any of

1:33:13 you drive around, my husband doesn't do much so I drive him around because he wants to see

1:33:18 all the new things going on.

1:33:21 There's so many houses, we are growing in leaps and bounds.

1:33:26 And the downtown right now with this new building here is fantastic and I think it's going to

1:33:33 keep on going but I think there should be parking. That is a main thing and it would

1:33:40 be really nice for young and people that are wanting to put in new businesses to have

1:33:48 a place to live up above. It will be vital. I think you're going to have people coming

1:33:55 downtown. I see the malls dying and I think the downtown thing is like Sun Valley. People

1:34:05 want to be come downtown and have things that are new and interesting. We've got great little

1:34:13 places that are unique and that's what downtown is becoming. And I think Mr. Faulkner would be pretty

1:34:23 proud of it to see the changes and that he'd say raise that building. So thank you. So that is all

1:34:34 All the names I have on the list of those who signed up, but certainly will allow additional inputs, so if there's anyone else who wishes to address this issue, come on down and please state your name for the record, and then if you would, before you leave, sign up on the sheet outside, so we have it for the record line.

1:34:51 I'm going to ask you, sir, that this is our meeting that we're running on here at year.

1:35:03 As you're meeting, sir, please, please state your name for the record, as this is a public hearing.

1:35:10 If you have a public hearing, how's that?

1:35:13 I heard that.

1:35:14 Some people know me as a name.

1:35:16 That was accepted in the last year.

1:35:19 Go on.

1:35:21 Can you cord you?

1:35:22 I'm just hearing voice and concerns, and I get hostility everywhere I go, man.

1:35:26 I'm asking you to state your name for the record.

1:35:29 I did, instead of listening to some people know me as Nick.

1:35:32 Well, we're going to go ahead and take a quick recess here so I can consult with the city attorney on how we can go forward with this.

1:35:39 That's a bad idea. I wouldn't talk to Shane by any kind of might get a charge for taking a recess, sir.

1:35:44 I'd say I'd take a look at Shane's conduct and take a look at maybe what some of your guys' law books, policies, procedures they have.

1:35:56 I'd like to reconvene the City Council meeting from Monday, August 19th, is 644, which is the, for the additional height request.

1:36:18 I've gone through the list of those who have signed up to speak to this issue. Is there any other citizen who wishes to address the additional height item?

1:36:26 Yes, please come down. Again, please state your name for the record and we are limiting input to three minutes per speaker.

1:36:36 My name is Susan Hall, 227, made Avenue East.

1:36:43 At best, I think this plan is grandiose.

1:36:45 I think it's too tall for our skyline.

1:36:47 If you really, really, really, really,

1:36:49 once a 75-foot building, there's a lot of area in the old warehouse

1:36:54 district that's currently empty and abandoned.

1:36:56 It might fit in with the skyline better.

1:36:58 I worry a lot about them getting in the middle of this plan

1:37:03 and investors bailing.

1:37:04 I've seen it happen in Vegas and different places.

1:37:07 And then you have a skeleton of a building that stands for decades and not completed.

1:37:13 The parking is a real issue also, and where's the homeless guy gonna live this, living in front of him right now?

1:37:21 But yeah, I think, overall I think the building height.

1:37:25 I love looking out at my building and seeing the sky and seeing the clouds, seeing what the weather is.

1:37:32 I don't want to be looking into somebody's bedroom.

1:37:40 Anyone else wish to speak to this item?

1:37:43 Hi guys again, Mona, Kay, Blay, Myers, Weeks, Twin Falls City.

1:38:02 I have just a couple questions regarding the building and I don't know if anybody's addressed it.

1:38:07 The first part is, yeah, it's going to be 75 feet. The parking, everybody's pretty much made that a point.

1:38:13 What about the noise ordinance? You guys have businesses that are open past 10 p.m.

1:38:20 There's a lot of community events that take place down there.

1:38:23 How is that going to impact the people that are going to be living upstairs that?

1:38:27 How many calls are you guys going to get saying, shut it down. It's too loud.

1:38:31 So I think we need to consider that before you put somebody living upstairs.

1:38:35 When you guys have already opened up the downtown to live concerts in the summer, everybody loves those.

1:38:40 You have the ice skating park down there in the winter, and you also have the splash park.

1:38:46 Everybody likes that. So how's that going to fit with those residents?

1:38:49 I'm not concerned about the businesses and the offices because they close at a decent time.

1:38:54 be affected by how that loud noise that they are going to be by the parking and by that

1:39:00 loud noise.

1:39:01 Other part of it, I know that when you build that, it's kind of like when you buy property

1:39:07 and you know that you're buying that property by a dairy, two years later you're complaining

1:39:11 about that dairy and it's smell, you knew that when you bought it.

1:39:14 So if you guys build that big building and they start complaining about the noise that's

1:39:20 here first. How's that going to impact? Are you going to side with the

1:39:24 apartment people and limit our music that we have currently going on? Or are

1:39:29 you still going to support the downtown and the music and the fun and the activities

1:39:34 that go on after 10 p.m. Especially some of those businesses that have business

1:39:38 after 10 p.m. That's all. So sir, if you will, if you will follow the procedure

1:39:57 Which is the state your name?

1:39:59 Oh dick.

1:40:00 Uh, some people know who's listening.

1:40:02 And are you going to speak to this issue?

1:40:04 Say it once.

1:40:05 Are you going to speak to the height issue?

1:40:07 Oh absolutely.

1:40:08 Oh man.

1:40:09 Give me a moment.

1:40:10 I'm sorry.

1:40:11 I'll give you three minutes.

1:40:12 Thanks.

1:40:13 I appreciate it.

1:40:14 You guys are selling the building for a hundred bucks.

1:40:16 That accurate.

1:40:18 I mean, you guys can't respond.

1:40:19 If you have questions, I'll make those damn items.

1:40:20 I know.

1:40:21 I read the rules.

1:40:22 I have some sucks.

1:40:23 We're trying to get them put.

1:40:24 We need feedback though.

1:40:25 We're really thinking the right way.

1:40:26 But you guys sold a business for a dollar for the climbing gym. That's the name is great, right? We give them a deal

1:40:33 But they're not forthcoming with a lot of their information your proposal and they're gonna anticipate

1:40:41 X

1:40:42 This many visitors report Nick are you speaking to the height of this?

1:40:49 I know the names of that item before us. I'm just speaking to you sir, I'm speaking to you. I'm speaking to you with that gal

1:40:53 We give you a moment. No, I'm not gonna give you a moment because you're not speaking to this item. I'm speaking to that gal

1:40:58 what they all said please i'm speaking with you are you gonna side with this is a public hearing

1:41:04 yeah i'm trying to give a lot of the height of this building yeah you still have some sort of

1:41:13 to business owners they're investing in them i would just say if they're gonna propose something

1:41:21 to you and promise you guys a certain amount of visitors traffic i mean just make sure the

1:41:26 numbers are accurately forecasted i'm telling you guys if i like get your budget and look at

1:41:31 in the forecast, those numbers change all the time. You look at what the climbing gym

1:41:34 did for you guys. You guys put money into them and they built a tall building, right? It's

1:41:39 okay, it doesn't look bad, but you guys are going to allow these guys to build a taller

1:41:43 building and we're not going to get what we expected out of it. They're going to anticipate

1:41:47 an X amount of traffic to come, just like the climbing center expected, X amount of

1:41:52 visitors. At the end of the year, it was grossly off. They had 44,000 visitors they

1:41:57 They said on their website, and one year, if you divide that by 365, that's like over

1:42:03 100 visitors a day.

1:42:05 So I think you guys are just being played there, and just what do you mean with these

1:42:11 guys?

1:42:12 If you guys are going to build a 75-foot on infrastructure, we'll make sure it's worth

1:42:17 the public, and they know that you guys vetted them properly.

1:42:20 They didn't give you all's information that you made your decision on.

1:42:26 Thanks John.

1:42:27 Thank you.

1:42:28 Anyone else who wishes to speak to this item on the agenda this evening?

1:42:37 All right, so no one earned the time over to the applicant.

1:42:43 There were a couple of questions that actually I'm not confident that applicant can answer

1:42:47 perhaps these staff could speak to the, there were some questions about parking structure

1:42:54 and also potential conflicting uses in the area.

1:43:00 Further statement on the zoning perspective.

1:43:17 So this area of downtown including majority of Main Street does not have a parking requirement

1:43:23 that was removed back in or get the date.

1:43:27 It's either in the late 80s or early 90s.

1:43:29 So all the businesses between the seconds,

1:43:32 basically almost the entirety of Main Street

1:43:34 has no minimum parking requirement.

1:43:36 It means when you come to do a business

1:43:38 and you build a new building,

1:43:39 the city does not require you to build a parking lot.

1:43:42 There's multiple reasons to do that.

1:43:44 We can get into that if you have the discussion.

1:43:45 It's just part of the code.

1:43:49 A second, the parking garage that has been mentioned

1:43:52 is not something we can make a decision on today.

1:43:55 This item can't be tied to it because there's a special use permit requirement for any type of parking structure.

1:44:02 Not only do separate public hearing through the planning and zoning commission.

1:44:06 So a procedural standpoint, Nate has a couple of discuss.

1:44:14 Thank you.

1:44:21 The agency is currently the owner of this building.

1:44:27 It has been our intent to facilitate a housing development at this.

1:44:36 It is our opinion that a certain amount of congestion is good for down-to-tail places.

1:44:52 and restaurants and those other people that thrive on behalf.

1:44:55 And so we put out requests for proposals in E&L.

1:45:08 This was sort of the winning proposal.

1:45:11 The reason why we're disposing of it for below market value is because the return is about a $9 million investment.

1:45:19 So we need to dispose of any price if someone's willing to sign agreement that says they'll invest $8 million towards it.

1:45:30 And so we feel that that's sort of our return as an agency we're allowed to do.

1:45:39 We have not committed any as towards constructing our infrastructure.

1:45:44 We're doing right now is looking at working with the developer of that building on some cost sharing for a new structure.

1:45:53 Where those prices come in at is dependent on the agency you can trigger towards the structure.

1:46:00 If we do we also might consider building in some of the adjacent lots as well if we can build a sizable enough structure.

1:46:08 structure. Again, we would like to see some vibrancy and work lab that people will

1:46:16 better receive downtown. We're just going to see the height. I do not see that

1:46:21 or see any detriment to health safety or welfare of anyone without additional height.

1:46:25 If anybody is putting in a block that you should have our city manager the most,

1:46:30 so go ahead and see the problem with Twin Falls is growing. And this is sort of the

1:46:39 signal of where we're going to go and I think it's better to go exhaust

1:46:44 additional resources and those are dollars spent to get. I see several. I just

1:47:00 I just wanted to clarify before everyone starts asking questions that these questions are related to the request that is before us on the height of the building.

1:47:11 I hope this is concerned about the question dealing with so far into a pullout.

1:47:21 Do you have some kind of a guarantee or a bond to make sure that it's not a half built building?

1:47:26 We do. We have our contract stipulates that we will not dispose of the property, turn it over to them until we are confident this substantial completion will occur as we're maintaining ownership.

1:47:36 I think we're some of the other cities have run into, and you have a conflict of who owns it, and that's always where we've got...

1:47:47 No, he's the issue has nothing.

1:47:48 There's uses of this building and how to get this done.

1:48:27 Sorry, I'm sorry.

1:48:39 No, I'm sorry.

1:48:40 No, I'm sorry.

1:48:41 I'm sorry.

1:48:42 I moved ahead to the discussion.

1:48:43 I'm just trying to keep the process from pointing to her.

1:48:46 Sorry.

1:48:47 First, first, did you have a question?

1:48:48 So, four stories for living residential to get up to the 75-foot height.

1:48:56 How many units are proposed for those four stories?

1:49:00 There's still a design phase of approximately.

1:49:03 That's at this time. If you want to ask a question that Jonathan maybe you can answer.

1:49:14 There was a question about noise, special events that will be occurring in this space.

1:49:21 Can you speak to that process, please?

1:49:23 has been discussed in the past.

1:49:25 Twin Falls doesn't have like a decibel level,

1:49:27 no ways ordinance.

1:49:28 We have a disturbing piece.

1:49:30 There's also a state statute that goes with that as well.

1:49:32 So as far as a special event,

1:49:35 if the council approved that special event

1:49:37 to a certain time,

1:49:38 that would kind of allow that event

1:49:40 to take place in those areas

1:49:42 is something that the people that live there

1:49:45 have that discussion during a meeting

1:49:47 when you approve those events to voice their concern

1:49:51 in this public arena.

1:49:53 As far as who's there first,

1:49:55 It's one of those things if you buy or rent this place downtown across a very public area,

1:50:00 there would be some, you knew it before you moved in.

1:50:05 There's no actual code that would be enforced for a decibel level, in short.

1:50:11 So it's kind of one of those things, you know, what's going to happen when you move in there.

1:50:14 Any special events would come to you in this public realm for discussion

1:50:18 and they would have the opportunity just like every other special event that comes through.

1:50:22 Thank you, Jonathan. Any other questions for staff or close the public hearing?

1:50:34 No further testimony or comments from the applicant or the audience are going to be taken and we will turn this over to the council for discussion and action.

1:50:44 Thank you, boy.

1:50:46 Excuse me.

1:51:02 Are very interested in this.

1:51:18 Enjoy that aspect in this kind of situation.

1:51:33 I just remember to ask it of our legal counsel, so I will ask him the question at this time about future process.

1:52:04 So this is one item for I request, can you clarify, will there be other steps in development process through planning and zoning or city council or this particular project?

1:52:15 With regard to the park, you've been interested in there to be a special use.

1:52:22 But in terms of the job experience, obviously there will be building design plans, that process going through our building department.

1:52:32 And now with the rest of the subdivision, we would deal with preliminary plaid, plaid, those kinds of things. That's all.

1:52:38 Okay, I just want to clear that.

1:52:40 It was a mayor in 1983, and we may not be aware of this.

1:52:49 We had a form of business improvement district,

1:52:52 kind of the predecessor of urban renewal at that time.

1:52:56 Some of the city fathers who were older than me had plans for

1:53:01 down time falls and almost mimics what we're proposing this evening.

1:53:07 We were talking about a community that the city would not

1:53:16 of flights at five o'clock, the ancillary businesses

1:53:21 to support people for both Russian drying,

1:53:25 extending beyond traditional hours,

1:53:31 who was discussed as for additional parking.

1:53:35 We knew that was gonna be a problem given the,

1:53:38 like we've taken the initial first step

1:53:44 to revitalize Twin Falls, and we know

1:53:46 we're amongst the most energetic communities

1:53:51 held with somebody empty storefront buildings.

1:53:54 It will take time and I think if this variances a lot of the building were to be constructed and 40 people are just living down to sea.

1:54:08 The quality of what I see this very consistent to propose as many as 35, 37 years ago times are changing and it's taking a long time to catch up with 1983.

1:54:27 I think we're here, but just that we, in a motion,

1:54:33 only a additional height variance to a while,

1:54:37 the 75 foot tall mixed use building,

1:54:40 be located at 160 Main Avenue South,

1:54:44 by Chris Tockington, seconded by Greg Lanting

1:54:51 to approve the request for additional height,

1:54:54 as presented, when nations from the...

1:54:59 Like Chris, I've been here a long time.

1:55:10 I've been here in the city to have falls.

1:55:13 I remember coming to just, to have falls on Friday nights

1:55:16 and probably the late 50s when downtown was vibrant, the sucking that they're talking about,

1:55:23 where all the business is going up, blue legs hadn't occurred yet, and we probably have 10 times

1:55:31 the parking now that we had that, that we did when every business before front was full.

1:55:36 This was big parking lots behind used to have buildings on them in the 50s and early 60s,

1:55:41 But I think we can work out the parking issue, I really do.

1:55:44 Since I've been on County of Zoning starting in the late 90s and early 1980s and on council

1:55:53 since 2005, I've looked at enough studies about downtown, you know, I don't know how

1:56:00 much we've had, but I've read a bunch of them and they all said the same thing.

1:56:04 You've got to get people living downtown before you're going to totally revitalize your downtown.

1:56:10 and Urban or Noah has made amazing steps in our main street.

1:56:15 I'm so proud to be part of that,

1:56:18 although they are a separate organization.

1:56:21 We've certainly helped to encourage them along,

1:56:25 and it was some of these things.

1:56:27 And then the one question about the concert,

1:56:30 I came to almost all the winners and I conquered the given nine.

1:56:33 I don't think the nine is going to be a problem for people who have chosen to live downtown.

1:56:40 So I will be enthusiastically voting yes on this high

1:56:45 plantation and I will say yes and we will work on the park

1:56:49 parking we'll make sure that we're not

1:56:51 with just closed out of ten falls because they can't find

1:56:55 police to park downtown.

1:56:57 It's their name for the discussion.

1:57:02 Thank you, boy.

1:57:11 Yes.

1:57:12 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:57:13 Yes.

1:57:14 Greg Lanting.

1:57:15 Yes.

1:57:16 Where's Pierce?

1:57:17 Yes.

1:57:18 Which is for Reid?

1:57:19 Yes.

1:57:20 Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Agenda to item 6.

1:57:34 Just the presentation of these city managers recommended budget for this year 2020.

1:57:40 Followed by citizen input.

1:57:43 I have our city manager Travis, Travis Rothwiler. Travis.

1:57:49 I'm wondering if Brock ran a mouse.

1:57:57 On the other side of the table. Brock was being helpful.

1:58:04 On the other one it looks like.

1:58:14 Mr. Mayor, members, the council tonight is the last meeting that we will have as part

1:58:20 of the overall planning process and discussion of the budget.

1:58:25 Next week we are going to be hosting our official public hearing and in that public hearing we're

1:58:30 going to be asking you to consider the appropriation ordinance for the City of Twin Falls for

1:58:34 fiscal year 19 and 20.

1:58:37 So tonight we just have a quick overview of the budget share parts of that conversation

1:58:45 that we've been having really since about May, and very intensely since the first Monday

1:58:52 after the Independence Day holiday, Build-A-Shitway.

1:59:11 So which we have is the recommended budget, and as we've been sharing with you the entire

1:59:15 time, this is directly connected to our strategic plan.

1:59:18 And over the course of the last several weeks, we've engaged in the conversations over the

1:59:24 various focus areas that we have. The budget that we have is a sustainable course of action.

1:59:33 It is thoughtful and it is proactive. We also believe that it allows us to continue to maintain

1:59:41 a strong sense of quality service as well as it is physically sound and one that we believe

1:59:47 that will support the organization in the upcoming years. This is the primary focus areas of the

1:59:55 the city's strategic plan, you'll notice the internal organization is the central part of

2:00:01 that and we spent a lot of time talking about how our people really are the energy that caused

2:00:06 the strategic plan to be activated in public services to be realized.

2:00:14 So this budget here relies on the statutory 3% increase which will generate about $661,000

2:00:21 $1,000 in new property tax revenue, we're fortunate that the new construction that we realized is the largest that we have at nearly $75,000,000, it's $20,000,000 larger than what we realized last year, and that will generate approximately $560,000 of new monies, total property tax collections in this budget, about $23.26 million, and it does not use any of the city's $1.4 million of foregone balance, the council made the decision not to touch that.

2:00:50 that the budget that was presented to you did not incorporate it and so the

2:00:54 budget continues to move forward without it. It is too late to include it. The

2:00:59 statutory process is that you went through last year you create or excuse me

2:01:04 last week. It may seem like a year ago that last week you set the maximum spending

2:01:13 cap and the only action that we have this week and next week is to drive

2:01:18 spending downward. The rate increases are reflected there at 1% for water, 1% for

2:01:25 sanitation, and then, excuse me, sewer, and then we're still working on that

2:01:29 sanitation rate. Like we shared with you that the overall change is going to yield

2:01:34 about $90,000 in recycling savings. However, there's going to be a increase

2:01:41 with more stuff going to the landfill. So we asked to make there's about a

2:01:45 of $30,000, excuse me, $30,000 expense

2:01:49 and about a 60,000 net savings.

2:01:51 Members of our team met with PSI today.

2:01:55 We recognize that the education component

2:01:57 is one of the most important things

2:01:59 to make that successful.

2:02:00 And we talked about what the educational component

2:02:03 would look like moving forward.

2:02:04 And so Josh Palmer is working on that.

2:02:07 The first is going to be a collection of stickers

2:02:10 that we'll be placing on garbage cans

2:02:11 to make sure that everyone understands

2:02:13 what can go into the bed as a reminder.

2:02:16 And then they have intensive outreach of all forms of whether it be media, whether it be print and making sure that we're hitting various groups to continue to share what can be recycled, what can not be recycled.

2:02:30 We also pledge to continue to watch the market.

2:02:33 We recognize that it is continually evolving.

2:02:36 One day we may be able to reincorporate the items that have been excluded as a part of moving forward.

2:02:43 However, we also may be coming to the council and sharing the items that we're accepting

2:02:51 are no longer having as the markets continue to be involved, so our pledge as a staff is

2:02:57 to continue to report back on a periodic basis to make sure the council is on the informed

2:03:03 of the progress of our cycling program.

2:03:05 I have to interject with a question I've been asked to repeat it, but we are not yet.

2:03:12 Oh please start out requesting the three extra recycling at some time in the near future.

2:03:18 We are actually asking our citizens, so I've been asked the same question and what I've said is don't wait.

2:03:23 If you have the opportunity to be conscious and we're thinking about it and it's on the force of thought of people's mind,

2:03:31 We're asking them to make that change today.

2:03:35 What plastics in the garbage can, so in our house,

2:03:39 our family is avid recyclers, and it is paint my wife to take plastics,

2:03:45 and to have we removed them from our recycling bin that we have in our house

2:03:49 that goes to our recycling bin outside.

2:03:52 And I've been taking them and placing them into our garbage.

2:03:57 We would encourage all citizens to start that process now

2:04:01 because that really does become more of a habit.

2:04:04 And the sooner that we can get in front of that, the momentum that we've had regard from the news coverage and the social media and the various public posts and comments, we believe it's out there.

2:04:16 And so if citizens would recycle the cardboard, tin the aluminum, the steel cans, and then the mixed paper and the plastic separate that and place that into a garbage, we would be much further ahead in moving that forward.

2:04:30 So we're saying start now, please.

2:04:33 We believe, and we look back to Laurie Race, I think, the sanitation rate is down to about 3.5,

2:04:41 about 3.3% increase as opposed to the 4.9%. So that will be the modification in next week's tables

2:04:49 and grass will reflect what that is. So it is a decrease from the 90 cents that you'll see in a minute.

2:05:01 This is just a really quick snapshot on the city's total taxable value,

2:05:05 as comparison to the total budget into the two forms, both the tax-supported funds that we have,

2:05:12 which is a portion of our budget that gets some of its funding from property taxes,

2:05:16 and then non-tax-supported, which we operate through user fees, and each one of them stand alone.

2:05:22 Often we refer to those as enterprise funds, and they will stand alone,

2:05:26 and they will have to operate like a small self-supporting business.

2:05:31 You'll also notice that the tax rate is scheduled to decline by 29 cents per 1,000 value, and

2:05:39 the city's total taxable value in 2012 was $2.3, $1,000,000,000, interestingly, that's really

2:05:49 close to what the taxable value of the City of Twin Falls was in 2017 as well, and we'll

2:05:53 reflect that graph.

2:05:54 And so, over the course of just a two-year period, the City of Twin Falls has grown by

2:06:00 over half a billion.

2:06:01 So you can see that the city of Twin Falls in 2017 was 2.36 and now we're at 3.18 billion

2:06:11 dollars more than 800 billion dollars of growth in that period of time. Really, really significant

2:06:18 for our community. The 281,000, or excuse me, 281 met this year is on top of the 200, this

2:06:30 year we're tracking building construction and building activities and we believe that the

2:06:37 pace to see maybe not $75 million of new construction, but again continue new construction growth

2:06:44 into the future.

2:06:49 As a result of all of that growth, this is what has occurred with our housing, and so

2:06:55 we spent some time really talking about how the growth of the house, median house in Twin

2:07:00 Falls has increased from $118,000 in 2012 to nearly $205,000 today, median list price

2:07:12 on a house in Twin Falls is $140 a square foot and it's

2:07:17 I equate out to about $245,000 is the median less price for all properties inside the city

2:07:24 of Twin Falls.

2:07:25 To put that comparison to some of the Church of Alley cities is about $100,000 less for the

2:07:31 similar property in Twin Falls than it is in Canyon and Eight accounts.

2:07:37 This is a copy of our, this is a reflection of our tax rate.

2:07:40 Our tax rate is not in mill levy.

2:07:43 We often will hear the term mill levy, but in Idaho we don't operate in mills, most

2:07:48 states and cities operate in mills.

2:07:50 We operate on a very easy mathematical formula.

2:07:55 Total taxable spending divided by the total taxable value, capture a tax rate.

2:08:02 That tax rate in Idaho is required to be applied to all properties within the corporate

2:08:07 geographic area uniformly.

2:08:09 We do not have the ability to change or modify that been asked.

2:08:18 And we've been asked, how does property taxes compare with the major cities in Idaho, full

2:08:23 service cities?

2:08:25 Those that appear in blue are very similar to the city of Twin Falls, which they're full

2:08:30 service cities, and they also operate their own street department.

2:08:35 You'll notice that the city is a radiant and Boise

2:08:38 impure and a pink as well as a red color.

2:08:42 The pink represents just those cities tax rates

2:08:47 multiplied by their median values.

2:08:49 And then when you incorporate the eight

2:08:51 Accounting Highway District tax rate on top of that,

2:08:54 to try to create some type of apples to apples comparisons

2:08:58 you see with those cities stack out.

2:09:01 I had a really good conversation earlier today

2:09:04 about what about how do we compare to other cities

2:09:07 within the Magic Valley, and my responses were competitive,

2:09:10 but it's really hard, the smaller the community

2:09:13 that you look at to try to create

2:09:15 that apples to apples comparison.

2:09:17 So the city of Twin Falls is a full service city,

2:09:20 and in other cities, they may contract out,

2:09:22 like Burleigh does with its police department,

2:09:25 or what Jerome will do is have

2:09:27 an independent recreation district.

2:09:29 And so it's really hard to build

2:09:31 those apples to apples comparison

2:09:33 to determine is the level of service in our area comparable to the level of services in other areas.

2:09:40 Generally speaking, we would say that the City of Twin Falls is incredibly competitive and overall

2:09:46 constant living. You can see here, but also in all the communities that are surrounding.

2:09:51 But coming up with that empirical data to show that becomes very, very difficult because you have to know

2:09:56 how much to add to the different taxing entities moving forward. Yes?

2:10:02 And you would also have to because of some of the ones there are stink bills get that much harder so you'd have to compare their water sewer

2:10:10 Her every trace to get any kind of an apples and apples and

2:10:13 My sister pays like a hundred forty dollars. That's the minimum bill

2:10:17 She has for water sir. Her every good goes for every drop of water. It goes up from there

2:10:24 So what we like to do is we kind of we illustrate what the cost is

2:10:32 is to live if you are the average person.

2:10:36 And we have yet to find that average person where

2:10:39 all of these averages fit uniformly.

2:10:41 But if you were the average person who

2:10:42 consumed 18,000 gallons of water on a monthly basis,

2:10:47 then hit the sewer cap of 12,000 gallons.

2:10:51 And participated in the 95 gallon in the recycling program,

2:10:56 you would see that utility services inside the city of Twin

2:10:59 falls are going to increase by about $1.61 per month, and that includes the $0.90, but when

2:11:06 you reflect that out, it's probably going to be closer to that $1.30, $20 ranges when we're

2:11:11 estimating, but again, we'll show that next week.

2:11:16 The largest source of the increase, so a lot of the times we have shared with the council

2:11:21 in years past, especially when maybe that tax rate was trailing upward, don't focus on the

2:11:27 tax rate it doesn't tell the story right because it's a multiplier it's like saying

2:11:32 to to doesn't mean anything unless you multiply it against something so you can

2:11:38 see here a tax rate is going down but because of the rapid appreciation in the

2:11:42 taxable value of our homes you can see that even with the decline in the tax

2:11:47 rate we are anticipating an adjustment to those those property taxes and it is

2:11:54 It is a portion across all properties within the City of Twin Falls because again, it's

2:12:01 a simple mathematical form.

2:12:02 So this is where we're at.

2:12:08 It should say on Wednesday August 14th, you adopted the preliminary budget, but we'd

2:12:14 want to just block that from our memory, but it's so long as we don't make that same mistake

2:12:19 again.

2:12:20 Tonight is just really a review of all sections and staff is here to answer any questions

2:12:24 that you might have in preparation for the anticipated adoption of the budget next week.

2:12:30 Any questions for Travis Green's schedule and the next week for the budget,

2:12:59 but we have a long list of input through this process.

2:13:03 So if there's anyone who'd like to give input on the budget,

2:13:06 now is your opportunity.

2:13:07 And then we'll just give input on the budget three minutes,

2:13:21 who's speaking on regards to the equation he is?

2:13:38 Not milk, right?

2:13:39 To calculate the size of the body, right?

2:13:41 We use the county of the city manager, yes, that's awesome.

2:13:44 So we have the assessor, the county assessor.

2:13:48 So we've got nothing to do with that.

2:13:50 But you guys use another variable that says, you know,

2:13:53 based on the budget needs.

2:13:55 And so we can, we can do, we can obviously have some form of control.

2:14:02 Sorry, I'm good.

2:14:04 But he's stating that we have directly set.

2:14:10 Now I bought a house in 2008.

2:14:20 It's like $109,000.

2:14:22 And on the same, you know, almost, that's within your guys' group, protecting each other.

2:14:34 And this will help you guys out too. You guys want community involvement?

2:14:38 I'm up here trying to get involved.

2:14:40 You guys have these budgets that means the city needs.

2:14:49 Just because you guys live in close proximity to us,

2:14:52 then you guys already have these public inputs where you guys can't respond and get that.

2:14:59 These are your, or, like a judge would say.

2:15:05 And I thought that this was citizen-driven and some sorts of you guys are public officials.

2:15:14 You guys can clean up your reports a little bit better in this page.

2:15:25 Now how long? How many pages are report 260?

2:15:27 Four pages less.

2:15:35 Though it's either you guys have boiler plates like lawyers do.

2:15:38 You know, you just fill out the information, you increase what you need to do.

2:15:43 But I don't think you guys are taking that care.

2:15:46 When you're spending people's money, that doesn't belong to you.

2:15:49 And you guys are giving each other $100,000 for every $80,000 for your wellness program.

2:16:01 Sort of the dishuposition as public servants helping us better our lives.

2:16:09 better our lives. Freedom's not good things here. I still don't know. Am I the

2:16:24 police who would do impose your codes? I'm just going to say I don't. I'm going to

2:16:42 state this on the roof of this budget. I think you should another subcommittee with

2:16:50 citizens. I tried to join you guys, some committee for the private department

2:16:53 times up, but I tried to join the committee for the private department

2:16:57 up with the chief. It is like there's not anyone else who wishes to address the

2:17:14 budget that counts. Advisory report reports from the council. I haven't seen anything

2:17:27 from the same editor's office.

2:17:28 I'm just very, very happy to see the council

2:17:30 due to the hour we're going to say

2:17:32 that we can postpone the executive session

2:17:35 that we have on land acquisition

2:17:36 and we can do that at a later date.

2:17:38 It was anticipated that the event that the meeting

2:17:42 didn't go a significant time that we would

2:17:46 conversation, but we'll concentrate with facts.

2:17:54 The meeting is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 19, 2019. The recording started at 05:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:18:12.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    a34d0e0483e479d88572a0b58c456b8a6171abae31ba680567e7b9ce91b4534c
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 477db8168cf895f9a39e32a5e7619d159caf155aa4caa04ddd1ebd55fe29471d
    part02.m4a 63bd94ce1f9343401fcbf22f0c8e0aa2b8da44be02dbd248f062cba80320eda2
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    8071e8f9430f670b14d2444a5c5eb29813799fea1e8fd2723ef83254fc3cb659

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file