OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Tuesday, May 28, 2019

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on file

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:00:07 Good evening. I would like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Tuesday, May 28th at 5 o'clock and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council.

0:00:15 Six of the seven members are here this evening. Councilman Lanting is excused.

0:00:20 The next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wish to join us, please rise.

0:00:25 Proclamations this evening. So next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.

0:00:53 There's anyone from the public who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening now

0:00:58 Is your opportunity to please come forward?

0:01:00 Seeing no one, we will move down to the consent calendar

0:01:10 and solutions

0:01:11 Mr. Reid move to approve the consent calendar a keyboard a motion to accept the consent calendar by Christopher Reid seconded

0:01:22 By the keyboard is there any discussion

0:01:27 Please.

0:01:33 Keyboy?

0:01:34 Yes.

0:01:35 Is that Hawkins?

0:01:36 Yes.

0:01:37 Who's Pairs?

0:01:38 Yes.

0:01:39 Mr. Fareed?

0:01:40 Yes.

0:01:41 Who's talking to?

0:01:42 Yes.

0:01:44 Trim passes 6-0.

0:01:45 Next under items of consideration, the first is an action item.

0:01:48 This is a request to reappoint Gabe Austin and appoint Amanda Nussbaum and Kirk Melton

0:01:53 to the Parks and Recreation Commission.

0:01:56 Please, I have to get to my paperwork here.

0:02:02 So, the Parks and Recreation Commission terms were completed as of March of 2019.

0:02:07 I gave Austin a greet to serve a second term on the commission.

0:02:10 Aaron Camacho and Cindy Collins completed their terms.

0:02:14 So, we had openings that were advertised.

0:02:16 We had 10 applications that we received.

0:02:19 An interview committee consisting of myself, I swear, Boyd and Parks and Recreation Commission,

0:02:25 Commissioner Brian Rice and Parks and Recreation Director Wendy Davis met and

0:02:31 interviewed all ten applicants that could be selected Kirk Melton and Amanda

0:02:35 Nussbaum to fill those two vacancies background checks have been conducted and

0:02:39 no concerns were identified. So the approval process is that there shall be

0:02:45 nine voting members of the Parks and Recreation Commission to be appointed by

0:02:48 the mayor and confirmed by the City Council. So I would ask for confirmation of

0:02:55 of the appointments of those three folks, Gabe Austin,

0:02:59 Commander Nussbaum and Kirk Melton

0:03:00 to the Farks and Recreation Commission, Hickey Boy.

0:03:04 I move that we grant the request to reappaint

0:03:06 a reappoint Gabe Osteen and appoint Amanda Nussbaum

0:03:09 and Kirk Melton to the Parks and Recreation Commission.

0:03:14 Second.

0:03:16 Motion by Hickey Boy, seconded by Ruth Pierce

0:03:19 to approve the appointments.

0:03:21 Are there any discussion, Chris Stockington?

0:03:23 I understand one of the 10 out because I had a degree

0:03:26 from Parks and Recreation and Parks and Recreation.

0:03:31 We did have one applicant that had a degree

0:03:34 in some Parks and Recreation Management,

0:03:36 but was not currently practicing that in her profession.

0:03:42 Yes, we actually had of the 10 applicants

0:03:45 with their very well qualified and passionate

0:03:48 and community engaged people.

0:03:50 It was a very difficult decision to keep.

0:04:04 Boyd?

0:04:05 Yes.

0:04:06 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:04:07 Ruth Pears?

0:04:08 Yes.

0:04:09 Mr. Fareed?

0:04:10 Yes.

0:04:11 As talking to?

0:04:11 Yes, excuse me, motion passes 6 to 0.

0:04:15 Next on the agenda is an action item.

0:04:21 We have Daniel Mooney, partner with Mooney.

0:04:24 We lend attorneys to make a presentation regarding cities

0:04:27 and counties that are pursuing a national lawsuit

0:04:30 against opioid manufacturers and distributors.

0:04:33 Pull up their presentation and be ready to roll.

0:04:38 Unless they have expertise in small community air service grants.

0:04:49 Touch the base versus push up.

0:05:17 Oh, there we go.

0:05:18 Great.

0:05:19 Thank you.

0:05:20 Thank you all for hosting us here today.

0:05:24 My name is Daniel Mooney.

0:05:25 I'm a partner with Mooney Wheeland Law Firm based in Boise and we make our living representing

0:05:30 businesses and government entities in commercial disputes.

0:05:35 This is to my right, Seth Meyer of the firm, Keller Linkner.

0:05:40 He's based in Chicago and his firm has extensive experience managing complex cleanness litigation.

0:05:47 Our firms have formed a team to seek relief for Idaho cities and counties from the staggering

0:05:59 public cost and I'm sure you all felt of the opioid crisis currently affecting our communities

0:06:05 and our country.

0:06:08 We currently represent other Idaho local governments including the City of Boise, Bennett County

0:06:14 and the city of Pocatello, and we'd be glad to provide the same service to the city of Twin Falls.

0:06:23 Mounting into salts on these massive and well-funded opioid manufacturers and distributors who are

0:06:29 largely to blame for this crisis might seem like a daunting task, particularly for a city,

0:06:36 cities across the state who have to already stretch resources. As an important issue, as this is,

0:06:42 I know you have a lot of other front burner issues on your plate, and pursuing a major

0:06:50 lawsuit is probably not one of them.

0:06:53 And that's where we think we can help.

0:06:56 We'd like to tell you today about a strategy that we think makes sense for cities like

0:07:00 Twin Falls, cities of all sizes, and makes us litigation accessible.

0:07:05 Just a little more about our team.

0:07:08 I'll let Seth tell you a little bit about his firm, Keller Lankner, first.

0:07:13 Sure, the Council members, thank you very much for having us here today.

0:07:19 I, as Daniel, introduced, come from the law from Keller Lankner in Chicago.

0:07:25 We are based in Chicago with offices in Washington and New York, and have a variety of different

0:07:32 experience, predominantly before our current firm on the defense sites that we like to

0:07:37 I think that we have significant experience, even representing pharmaceutical companies,

0:07:43 so we've got significant experience for what to predict here, and we've got a number of

0:07:49 different valuable mass towards experience in comparable ideation.

0:07:54 We believe that we present a national reach and the opportunity to deliver a significant

0:08:00 relief as possible for the city.

0:08:03 On our firm, Mooney Whelan rounds out the team with high-level local litigation, experiencing

0:08:08 credentials.

0:08:09 Our attorneys come from NATO's Supreme Court clerkships, prominent Idaho law firms in the

0:08:14 Attorney General's office.

0:08:15 So I think together we can guide our clients through this complex litigation, including interfacing

0:08:23 directly with these major players.

0:08:26 And I think we can carve out a meaningful stake in any settlement or award for cities like

0:08:32 So, just a little overview of the epidemic that we're currently seeing, you know, this

0:08:43 is, opioid abuse has truly become a significant problem.

0:08:48 I think everyone's heard about it in the news, and I bet some of you have at least been

0:08:55 indirectly touched by it.

0:08:57 Growing up in Pocatello, I know a handful of my local peers have struggled with addiction

0:09:02 and it even lost their lives to it.

0:09:05 You can see from this graphic how the problem has worsened

0:09:08 in recent years with opioid addiction,

0:09:11 opioid overdose rates exponentially rising

0:09:14 over the last decade.

0:09:16 And this chart shows the rise of not only synthetic

0:09:19 prescription opioid deaths, but also heroin overdose deaths,

0:09:24 which are largely driven by the manufactured drugs.

0:09:28 That's because opioid users largely

0:09:31 turned to or often turned to street drugs, like heroin, even meth sometimes, even though

0:09:38 that seems a little bit paradoxical, when they can no longer afford to get access to opioids.

0:09:45 As you can see, there have been 183,000 reported opioid deaths during this period with 145

0:09:55 people dying every day.

0:09:57 It's been estimated that the overall economic cost of opioid abuse in the country has risen

0:10:04 to 78.4 billion dollars per year, and that's a conservative number by some people's estimation.

0:10:14 And a lot of that staggering cost has been borne by municipalities and counties just

0:10:20 like Twin Falls, and in 2016 alone, in Idaho, 119, Idaho, and died from opioid abuse.

0:10:29 There's a picture of how this has affected Idaho specifically, and you can see the number

0:10:36 of deaths has fully doubled between 2012 and 2016.

0:10:46 The why is this happening?

0:10:48 Well, the raw data alone paints a pretty compelling picture, and it points the finger directly

0:10:54 at these largest opioid manufacturers and distributors peddling these pills to basically

0:11:03 wildly disproportionate amounts of these drugs are being dumped into communities in Idaho

0:11:09 and across the country that just can't be safely absorbed.

0:11:14 In 2015, there were 68 opioid prescriptions written per 100 Idahoans.

0:11:20 2017, 650,000 grams were distributed in Idaho, and I think this is the most shocking figure

0:11:28 is 2.5 million lethal doses of hydrocodone alone were distributed in Idaho in 2017.

0:11:40 That's enough to kill every person in the state, and then some, and you can see from

0:11:45 this map, you can see Twin Falls County down there has been hit particularly hard by the

0:11:51 opioid flood, it's got one of the highest proportions of opioid prescriptions among

0:11:55 counties in the state for this period. And these massive amounts of legal drugs

0:12:02 have contributed to the the illegal drug trade and I think that's compounded by

0:12:06 Twin Falls County being smack dab on the Idaho Utah border. So Twin Falls is

0:12:14 obviously not immune from this. In fact, it's smack dab in the center of the crisis

0:12:18 as it's affecting the state and the steep lines you saw in the graphs before,

0:12:24 they're not a coincidence. I mean these are direct effects of these major drug

0:12:29 manufacturers and distributors dumping these massive amounts of these pills into

0:12:35 our communities. So what does this cost? I mean this is a breakdown and again I

0:12:44 think a lot of people would say these figures are conservative. These are some

0:12:50 public costs that have resulted from the opioid crisis and these are costs that we

0:12:55 think cities like Twin Falls can and should fight to recover. First, there's

0:13:01 lost productivity which includes things like government employee, perhaps

0:13:04 it's heism and employee assistance programs for addicts. Those items cost

0:13:10 the country an estimated $42 billion in 2016 alone. Other costs include rising

0:13:16 health insurance costs caused by more opioid prescriptions, the cost of addiction treatment

0:13:21 for addicts themselves and their children, and the administrative burden of processing

0:13:25 opioid related claims that's an estimated $26.1 billion.

0:13:31 Also, a significant criminal justice costs increase for policing and adjudicating opioid

0:13:37 related crimes and incarcerating opioid offenders, not to mention ongoing public treatment and

0:13:42 rehabilitation for these offenders.

0:13:45 There we have another $7.6 billion dollars.

0:13:49 Finally, we've got another $2.8 billion dollars

0:13:52 for substance abuse treatment and social programs.

0:13:56 That includes homelessness programs, foster care,

0:14:00 blight abatement, things like that.

0:14:03 And again, these are very conservative figures,

0:14:08 conservative estimates, some of it estimated

0:14:11 that the true cause of the epidemic

0:14:12 could be as much as a $500 billion.

0:14:21 As I said, the raw data alone points

0:14:23 that the opioid industry is the culprit.

0:14:26 Behind these losses and the direct evidence

0:14:29 we've seen to date confirms this.

0:14:31 The manufacturers of these drugs

0:14:33 used false and misleading advertising

0:14:35 and marketing materials and even influenced medical literature.

0:14:39 They made up pseudo-science concepts.

0:14:42 It's a good convinced doctors pharmacists in the public

0:14:45 that opioids are not likely to cause addiction.

0:14:47 And in fact, if a patient's exhibiting symptoms of addiction,

0:14:52 that just means they need more opioids.

0:14:54 That's what the medical literature that was tampered with said.

0:14:59 And so this conduct misled not only patients, the public,

0:15:08 but also physicians and train pharmacists.

0:15:12 And I think the most commonly overlooked

0:15:15 but equally culpable player in this effort

0:15:20 were the distributors.

0:15:21 They, by a law, they had to keep track of how much

0:15:24 and where they were distributing these drugs

0:15:26 and continue to dump just unabsorable amounts

0:15:30 into these communities.

0:15:34 So as a result of all of this and the costs

0:15:40 that it's imposing upon communities like Twin Falls,

0:15:44 The opioid industry makes $10 billion a year selling these drugs.

0:15:54 So what do we do about it?

0:15:57 We'd like to see municipalities of all sizes stand up to the drug industry and get the relief

0:16:02 they deserve and that includes Twin Falls.

0:16:05 And fortunately, there's a path to recovery that doesn't require Twin Falls to go it alone

0:16:11 and to sue these major companies by themselves.

0:16:15 Over, it's actually 1,600 cities and counties now are pursuing a law

0:16:21 sitting as the major manufacturers and distributors in Ohio referred to as the

0:16:26 multi-district litigation or the MDL for short. And in this litigation, these plaintiffs

0:16:31 were able to tag along with three bellwether plaintiffs with all cases being

0:16:35 managed and resolved by a single judge. So it's like a class action, but it's not

0:16:39 actually a class action. It strikes the same efficiencies. This means that these

0:16:47 bell-weather plaintiffs, just like the class plaintiffs, the named plaintiffs in a

0:16:52 class action, likely will do the heavy lifting of proving liability and

0:16:58 establishing the types of damages and other relief to be awarded across the

0:17:03 board. So these cases will likely determine how other most other public

0:17:08 entity cases are resolved which eases the litigation burden on smaller

0:17:13 municipalities like Twin Falls to recover similar damages and other relief

0:17:17 based on the formula that's set by these bellwether plaintiffs. What do we think

0:17:27 will happen in the MDL? There's no guarantees obviously but of the common

0:17:31 belief which we believe and others believe is that the MDL will culminate

0:17:37 in a global settlement under which all of the cities and counties which are

0:17:43 in the litigation can apply for financial relief.

0:17:46 And those discussions have already begun.

0:17:49 The MDL judge has been extremely active in encouraging

0:17:52 the parties to reach a settlement that meaningfully addresses

0:17:55 the problems across the country and the pressures on.

0:17:59 And it's appropriate that we're talking about this today

0:18:01 as the first trial, a state court lawsuit brought

0:18:04 by the state of Oklahoma.

0:18:06 You may have seen it in the news today.

0:18:09 just kicked off today, opening arguments were heard,

0:18:14 so we're opening statements.

0:18:17 The first Bellweather trial in the MDL

0:18:19 is also set for October 21st,

0:18:21 which in the litigation world makes it right around the corner

0:18:24 as well.

0:18:26 Other recent developments have also made us think

0:18:30 that the settlement talks will accelerate, in this case,

0:18:34 to the major manufacturer defendants

0:18:36 Purdue pharma and insists of publicly announced their intention to explore bankruptcy and

0:18:43 Purdue and the Oklahoma case also reached a major settlement.

0:18:49 And recently, executives of incis were criminally convicted of racketeering for misleading insurers

0:18:58 about their products and bribing physicians to write more prescriptions.

0:19:02 So all of these developments made signal a tipping point, we think, for the major defendants

0:19:08 in this litigation, so we're encouraging parties to get involved as soon as possible so they

0:19:12 can have a seat at the table with those negotiations heated up.

0:19:16 We're just a little bit about participating in the MDL and how that works on the ground.

0:19:26 We'd file a lawsuit in Idaho's federal district court.

0:19:30 We'd tag it as a tag-along action that would be sucked up into the MDL.

0:19:36 That would be against the largest opioid manufacturers and distributors.

0:19:41 The ones that we think are most likely to result in a recovery for the City of Twin Falls.

0:19:47 I think we provided a copy of what we filed for the City of Boise to Bear Beargar.

0:19:55 Twin Falls as complaint would generally track those bases for relief.

0:20:00 The Muni wheeling would work with the city directly to prepare that complaint and file

0:20:07 it and then we'd also work with the city to prepare initial discovery disclosures in the

0:20:11 form of a plane of fact sheet.

0:20:14 This is high level information about the city.

0:20:17 It's not extremely detailed.

0:20:18 It's not extremely time consuming.

0:20:20 It's a list of its departments.

0:20:22 The services it provides.

0:20:25 level information that will be exchanged among the

0:20:33 plainness and the other defendants.

0:20:36 Then Keller Lincoln would take over largely after that,

0:20:40 and would guide the city through the MDL and the anticipated

0:20:43 settlement negotiations.

0:20:49 One of the most common concerns we hear from cities and

0:20:53 counties, particularly smaller cities and counties,

0:20:56 and we are representing smaller cities than to

0:20:59 falls in this effort is, you know, how much is this going to take us, how much work are

0:21:05 we going to have to devote to this because I know you have to stretch resources as it is.

0:21:10 The short answer is we'll do as much work as it takes to make this accessible for you.

0:21:17 We will prepare that complaint, we'll draft the court pleading and documents, we'll work

0:21:22 directly with your department heads.

0:21:23 So your city attorney, for example, doesn't have to compile all that information, and will

0:21:31 guide the city through the process.

0:21:37 The other concern we hear is obviously what is this cost and the bottom line is the city

0:21:42 won't pay anything out of pocket to participate.

0:21:47 Keller-Lankner and another associated firm in Washington, D.C., they provide all the litigation

0:21:52 resources, including core costs, expert witness fees, and vendor fees. They even pay my fees

0:21:58 on an hourly basis, so I have every incentive to take most of the weight off of the city

0:22:02 shoulders, and put it on mine to keep this case moving forward. If the city recovers,

0:22:08 the law firms will retain a negotiated percentage plus litigation costs, the city will keep the

0:22:13 rest. If the city recovers nothing, the city won't pay a dime.

0:22:19 Got a question at the the last presentation. Is there is there any chance of the city getting countersuit?

0:22:26 We think that the likelihood of that is very very very remote and all of this is laid out in detail and the

0:22:37 Engagement letter that we provided to the mayor and I believe that mr. No, PES has reviewed

0:22:43 We'd be proud to represent your city and what we think is a worthy effort

0:22:47 And I think we are well suited to give you the best chance of recovery that you can

0:22:52 And we'll take all the questions that you have at this point.

0:22:57 Thank you, are there questions?

0:23:02 Chris talking tomorrow.

0:23:03 Would like Shane's input, do you see a new downside to the city joining this MDL?

0:23:15 At this point, I don't, based on what we've seen here, but I do have a few more emails out to other cities that are participating right now.

0:23:23 The feedback I'm getting is similar to what's being said here, and that is, it's a scenario where if the law firm wins,

0:23:30 that the argument goes to the city, otherwise there's no cost to the city.

0:23:35 The same question came out, could we be a prostitute or a countersuit?

0:23:39 And it's so remotely low that the people I've spoken to have said

0:23:46 that they can't conceive of a way or mechanism by which that would happen,

0:23:50 but they weren't willing to say no, that's absolutely not going to happen.

0:23:54 I mean, just to corroborate on that last point, at this point in the litigation,

0:23:59 because the majority of cases have survived motion to dismiss.

0:24:03 This is by no means a frivolous lawsuit.

0:24:05 This has been vindicated in courts across the country,

0:24:07 including in the MDL where we'd be filing the action.

0:24:10 And so the basis for a potential countersuit would be,

0:24:13 I mean, extraordinarily far-fetched,

0:24:15 I think by all accounts.

0:24:19 Because I'm not gonna.

0:24:21 Thank you.

0:24:22 So this is totally out of my realm of expertise.

0:24:26 Personally, I don't like lawsuits.

0:24:28 I don't believe that's the way you solve problems

0:24:30 this world. I would have a hard time putting a dollar figure on what I think

0:24:36 our city's been harmed to know what's fair and then I have a hard time personally

0:24:40 knowing who is truly to blame. Our federal government has investigated these

0:24:45 drugs and said that they are safe so these companies have worked within the

0:24:50 guidelines and that there's costs on both sides of this but I really

0:24:59 struggle with getting involved in the lawsuit that I don't know or sure that

0:25:04 It's our fight, necessarily, and that we're going after the right people.

0:25:10 I don't want to hurt patients who need medication that might not be able to get them on the other side,

0:25:17 and I don't know enough about all the facts to understand how that all works.

0:25:22 Absolutely, and I think that's a perfectly reasonable physician, and obviously getting involved in litigation,

0:25:32 especially at the municipal level, is something that requires all due consideration.

0:25:38 I think, you know, just to respond while these companies saw FDA approval, the marketing

0:25:46 that they engaged in, both before 2007 and I'll indicate why 2007 is an important time period

0:25:54 and subsequently is contrary to what was approved by the federal and what gives rise to the lawsuit

0:26:00 here, so for all who are not aware, in 2007, Purdue Pharma, who's one of the

0:26:07 tip of the sphere in terms of producing OxyContin, which is one of the most

0:26:13 overused of these particular medications, entered into an agreement with the federal

0:26:18 government in several states, acknowledging that it had misleadingly marketed

0:26:24 is it's drugs appropriate for indications that are far beyond the initial approval.

0:26:31 So while these drugs, these drugs were only approved for use on a very acute basis or post-surgically.

0:26:38 It was promoting use directly to physicians in an extraordinarily active way for long-term use

0:26:46 and with no ceiling dose recognizing the extraordinarily high risk of addiction.

0:26:51 That is something that was not approved by the, so while it's drug may have been legally

0:26:58 out there on the market, what it was promoting was certainly not that case.

0:27:03 You know, beyond that, totally understand, again, if the narrative were, as you presented,

0:27:11 and that's, you know, a company producing a lawful substance and sort of putting it out

0:27:15 into the market, and, you know, putting his hands back, I completely understand, I think,

0:27:20 what we've seen from discovery from the federal government's investigation from state government

0:27:26 investigations and currently from the lawsuit that's come out in discovery is that this

0:27:31 narrative and what's going on in causing this opioid crisis has been anything but.

0:27:37 And just to go back to the incis criminal convictions, there were executives that were

0:27:44 criminally convicted in addition of racketeering and bribing physicians to over prescribe these

0:27:51 medication. So there is some fairly glaring, glaringly culpable conduct that we've seen.

0:27:58 And finally, just in terms of beyond the culpability factor, these are costs that have been born,

0:28:05 these are costs that are either going to be ultimately born by cities and counties through the programs

0:28:10 and the various expenditures that they've needed as a result of the epidemic to spend that money on.

0:28:17 And as we see these are these are profits that have ultimately been

0:28:22 borne by these companies both manufacturers and distributors to the

0:28:25 tune of hundreds of billions of dollars and so it's really a question no matter

0:28:29 what you view about the appropriateness of litigation of who's going to

0:28:34 ultimately bear those costs and whether or not it's appropriate for taxpayers

0:28:40 and cities and counties to bear those costs.

0:28:44 So a couple of questions, one for you guys, and then one for Shane.

0:28:48 Where is the Idaho State Attorney General on this?

0:28:52 Typically a lawsuit like this, the states get together as opposed to doing it at a city and county level.

0:28:59 Why is it not being approached that way?

0:29:02 So I can tell you my law from also represents the state of Arizona, and I think so I can give you a little bit of the background on

0:29:10 the extent to which states are pursuing litigation,

0:29:13 the extent to which cities and counties

0:29:14 are pursuing litigation.

0:29:17 Tobacco being the Hallmark lawsuit,

0:29:20 where the states pursued the lawsuit exclusively

0:29:23 and encouraged the cities and counties

0:29:25 to stay to the sidelines, I think resulted by many accounts.

0:29:29 And that's not every state, but in many,

0:29:31 it felt most states to the disservice of cities and counties.

0:29:36 And by that, I mean, when the states ultimately pursued the lawsuit,

0:29:41 they pursued the recovery on behalf of their state.

0:29:44 They took in the money.

0:29:45 They were able to shape the injunctive relief.

0:29:46 And the cities and counties sat by the sidelines.

0:29:49 I think what that meant was, once the money came in,

0:29:51 at least in certain states, the state

0:29:54 elected to do with it what it would.

0:29:56 And so that may not be appropriating that money

0:29:59 to where it's needed or where money associated with dealing

0:30:03 with, at that point, tobacco was most acutely felt.

0:30:07 And for example, if it was, you know, tax cuts

0:30:09 are paying down the debt or highways or things like that,

0:30:13 this was just revenue for the state that they used.

0:30:16 And I think the reason you see cities and counties

0:30:19 getting involved in the mass that they are

0:30:21 with several thousand currently signed on

0:30:23 with independent lawsuits is to ensure

0:30:25 that they're able to directly recover proportionately

0:30:28 to their loss.

0:30:30 And, you know, I think that is learned experience

0:30:32 from other situations, and why this is a bit different.

0:30:36 Shane, I cramp, have you contacted I cramp

0:30:40 and had any conversations about this?

0:30:43 I have to be interested to know.

0:30:48 I'll follow up with this.

0:30:49 Yes, please, thank you.

0:30:52 And the only other thing I'll say to that point is

0:30:55 liability, whether it's at the state or local level,

0:30:59 is going to be apportioned directly proportionately

0:31:03 to the injury felt by those places,

0:31:06 whether it's via settlement or via an ultimate verdict.

0:31:09 And so the city pursuing an action on its own,

0:31:13 or the state pursuing an action on its own,

0:31:14 neither forecloses the other from happening.

0:31:16 It's just a more direct path to recovery for both frankly.

0:31:21 I was talking to, I guess I'm really shocked to think

0:31:24 that we're gonna put our head in the center, pretend

0:31:26 that we don't have a drug problem in this community,

0:31:29 starting with the map that our guests showed

0:31:32 Twin Falls County in Cash Accounting,

0:31:35 back to back one of the higher abusers of opiates in the state 13 years I spent

0:31:42 with juvenile adjudication. I know well over a dozen of my juveniles died of

0:31:48 direct drug related offenses or associations. The thing with drugs you

0:31:55 don't often know when you see a robbery a break in shooting the

0:32:02 attachments to that, but I can tell you the majority of time drugs are almost to think that

0:32:10 certain socioeconomic groups are immune from this is ridiculous, and I think to the research

0:32:18 and for us not to join in this MDL action, I think would be remiss in our response.

0:32:26 I'm with you all the way.

0:32:29 I will say I did listen to a fair amount of news coverage day from the Oklahoma cases

0:32:36 that had its opening statements.

0:32:38 So since I had initially been reached out to a month or so ago,

0:32:43 when you're back to the US information,

0:32:45 I've shared that information with Travis's office

0:32:48 and certainly machined to take a look at, you know,

0:32:51 what are the mechanics behind this, really,

0:32:53 from the logistics perspective, an extent

0:32:58 that I think the court system to make decisions about things

0:33:03 is not necessarily the way to go about things.

0:33:06 Unfortunately, I think in our society these days,

0:33:08 that's about the branch of government

0:33:10 that's capable of doing some of these things

0:33:11 because we don't seem to have action at the legislative level or even administratively sometimes.

0:33:16 So, I think it's pioneering ground necessarily for us to get engaged in this,

0:33:23 that there certainly are practices that have gone around opioids,

0:33:31 and similar to cigarettes, tobacco is a legal product, it was legal.

0:33:35 The lawsuit wasn't about whether it was legal or not,

0:33:38 it was about the practices that were used to market it to people

0:33:41 and basically a addiction and then the implications of that afterwards.

0:33:47 So, city functions or healthcare functions or others have certainly been impacted by the

0:33:56 disabilities and the practices of how they've been coded.

0:34:00 So, I would certainly be supportive of moving forward with the limited action on our part

0:34:07 here initially.

0:34:08 It sounds like it would be a resolution that would need to come back, a resolution that

0:34:14 would come back to the Council for consideration of bringing to sign on to functional information

0:34:25 about the city by a shared with Shane and Travis to make sure this wasn't a

0:34:30 burden some you know we're not detailing the last five years of police arrests

0:34:35 and which ones involved these types of things I think it's an opportunity for

0:34:42 us to look out for our community to try to recover costs for the impact that

0:34:47 we've had and hopefully to hold some folks to account to help prevent these

0:34:52 things in the future. Mr. Mayor just one additional point I think is something that

0:34:58 is often overlooked. This is not just about money. By any stretch of the imagination,

0:35:02 obviously we're pursuing monetary relief and ensuring that the funds are appropriate in

0:35:08 a way that the city can make up for some of the damage and in a prospective way, address

0:35:15 the issues of addiction going forward because this is not a problem that we're going to

0:35:19 be able to solve overnight. However, part of our pitch and part of why we're encouraging

0:35:25 in the city to get involved is injunctive relief is to make a difference in terms of how these

0:35:29 drugs are marketed going forward to ensure that this problem does not continue and to

0:35:34 ensure that, as we said, individuals are able to obtain this medication for its lawful purpose,

0:35:40 but the companies that produce and distribute these drugs should not be able to promote them

0:35:46 in a misleading way. And that relief, I think, is just as significant, if not more so than

0:35:51 any financial relief we'd be able to obtain.

0:35:53 Susan Hawkins.

0:35:55 Thank you for that last statement.

0:35:57 That helped clear up a lot in my mind.

0:36:02 So, action this evening would be to vote to direct staff to bring back an appropriate resolution this evening.

0:36:15 That would just, to that point, it wouldn't be that you would be joining the MDL this evening.

0:36:26 It would be that you would be more with the resolution for consideration.

0:36:32 Chris Stockton, yes, I would move that we direct the city staff to, uh, counts with the resolution to join the MDL litigation.

0:36:44 Second.

0:36:45 Motion by Chris Stockton, second by Ruth Pierce, two direct staff to bring forward a resolution that would allow consideration of joining the MDL.

0:36:55 Is it possible to make sure that Shane has a chance to finish the research he's been doing on and present that to us prior to the resolution, maybe on the same night?

0:37:04 so that we just get confirmation that he's had a chance to finish his research.

0:37:09 I believe Shane would be able to do that.

0:37:11 He's been doing some of that research in the interim areas.

0:37:14 We've had this schedule, so I think that would be absolutely...

0:37:17 Thank you.

0:37:19 Also during that time, would you be able to give us some of the information that you've found, some of the lives?

0:37:24 Back and forward, then, other information that was emailed to me.

0:37:27 I hadn't shared that, bro. Okay.

0:37:28 I'd be able to cancel until we had this day.

0:37:30 I do have the draft resolution and some of the background information.

0:37:34 Absolutely, and we're happy to answer any other questions by email or by phone as he yes go about this

0:37:46 Great peers yes Christopher Reed yes, Chris Tofkington. Yes, John Verigar. Yes, and Nicky Boyd. Yes

0:38:04 Anyone say thank you so much for the presentation

0:38:15 Thanks for your time. Next on the agenda, we have an action item. This is a request to accept grant funding from the Idaho Office of Emergency Management to produce a new hazardous materials detection device.

0:38:32 We have Mitchell Brooks, Fire Department, and Ryan Powell with the Police Department.

0:38:38 They just sit in the back.

0:38:43 I think it's a rank thing.

0:38:44 I think I'm going to get it to do this.

0:38:46 Welcome to the Good Evening Mayor and Council.

0:38:50 Fire Department, as you probably will know, we have a hazmat team that consists of 12 technicians.

0:38:56 And we also work real close with our bomb squad.

0:38:59 One of the things that we've found, we're lacking in is detection equipment.

0:39:04 We have all the fancy drones and suits, robots,

0:39:09 breathing apparatus, but we really don't have a good way to detect unknown substances.

0:39:15 That's why we're here tonight. We currently

0:39:19 respond to several hazmat incidents within the city.

0:39:23 Our detection methods right now are very archaic.

0:39:26 If you could picture your dad's or your grandpa's tackle box,

0:39:31 that's what ours looks like except there's chemicals in it.

0:39:34 And what we have to do is actually physically get the material, compare the chemicals that

0:39:40 we know they are, do the substance, and try to figure out what it is.

0:39:46 It's not very accurate.

0:39:49 This is very time consuming and obviously resource intensive.

0:39:54 As many of you know, we had an incident recently at Senator Wish's office, an envelope with

0:40:00 an unknown substance we thought was unknown inside of it.

0:40:04 We spent seven and a half hours on, and it also required us to reach out to our partners

0:40:10 in Boise and the Region 4 hazmat team to come in and help us out because we weren't able

0:40:14 to go in there and figure out what it was.

0:40:18 We had another simple spill on Pull Line that took approximately nine hours.

0:40:23 Turned out to be a sugar substance that was not hazardous.

0:40:28 We looked at these things more evaluating what there's got to be better with.

0:40:33 So I think we've found a detection device that's going to help us out.

0:40:38 This one's called the Resolve Ramen Handheld Identifier.

0:40:42 It detects unknown liquids and solids, explosives, narcotics, it reads through opaque containers

0:40:50 like a gas jug of 55-gallon drums, glassware envelopes.

0:40:56 So we don't even have to physically touch the product to be able to identify this piece

0:41:04 of equipment is expensive.

0:41:06 around $60,000. So Ryan Howe and I have been trying to find funding sources and we reached

0:41:13 out to our close partner Jackie Fry with the Twin Falls Office of Emergency Management and

0:41:18 she was able to secure $40,000 in grant money towards the project. I'd like to publicly thank

0:41:25 her for her work. The Twin Falls Bond Squad is going to allocate $10,000 from grant money

0:41:32 they have already received towards it, which leaves $10,000.

0:41:37 The police and fire operations will take care of.

0:41:42 So we feel both the Twin Falls Fire Department and Police

0:41:45 Department will certainly benefit from this piece of equipment.

0:41:48 It will allow us to operate safer out the field.

0:41:52 It will allow us to come up with better operational plans.

0:41:58 And it will make us rely on our partners outside the city as

0:42:04 often.

0:42:06 Tonight we're looking for the council's approval

0:42:08 to utilize the 40,000 in grant money

0:42:11 from the Twin Falls office of emergency management

0:42:13 towards the purchase of this equipment.

0:42:16 I would entertain any question.

0:42:20 Can you actually try to have a question?

0:42:22 So the action plan is to accept the grant funds.

0:42:25 We don't have to authorize the reallocation

0:42:28 of the operational funds within the two departments.

0:42:32 Please do both.

0:42:33 Do both.

0:42:40 So I guess the question comes to mind is,

0:42:42 has enough history and backing that you know from other jurisdictions that

0:42:46 can get advertised. Yes, I am warranted. Yes. One of our members actually had the

0:42:55 opportunity to use one of these in Aniston, Alabama during week-long training.

0:43:01 We've done a lot of research on different pieces of equipment similar to

0:43:05 this. This one actually we like because it laser on it isn't very hot so it

0:43:12 It won't actually set off an explosive on accident, so we've done a lot of research.

0:43:17 We feel like this piece of equipment is the one that we'd like to purchase, and I mean,

0:43:22 it's been used in other terms.

0:43:24 It is.

0:43:25 Yes.

0:43:26 Hey, take the thumbs up.

0:43:27 Yes.

0:43:30 And it's a question.

0:43:34 I noticed reading through the material that the output is USB 2.0, which is semi-old in

0:43:39 computer world.

0:43:40 And so that was kind of a concern why it was still 2.0 and not up to 3.0 or new standard.

0:43:45 You have any?

0:43:48 My understanding is this unit is upgradable.

0:43:51 So throughout the years, we'll be able to upgrade the database

0:43:54 as well as the hardware itself itself.

0:43:59 And kudos for all the teamwork on this.

0:44:00 It's really impressive to see and everybody come together

0:44:03 and find a solution that we can share and make work for the city

0:44:06 as a whole team instead of just department-wide.

0:44:09 So thank you for that.

0:44:12 Very sweet.

0:44:13 Getting through this it talks a little about how easy it is

0:44:15 to use.

0:44:16 Is there any training?

0:44:17 There is training.

0:44:18 OK.

0:44:19 The general company will prefer the salesperson has agreed to come in and train the bulk departments.

0:44:26 Perfect. Comments? I too would like to echo thanks to Jackie and work that you do in partnership with our organization.

0:44:38 We certainly appreciate that. Yes. Only if you're going to say nice things.

0:44:49 Fire yourself for the record.

0:45:01 My name is Jackie Fry. I'm the coordinator for Twin Falls County Office of Emergency Management.

0:45:06 And I would like to address Suzanne's question and actually a little history.

0:45:11 Amber used to be our Magic Valley Emergency Response Team, which was critical for response

0:45:17 with fire departments or the first responding agencies during that incident.

0:45:22 And when they disbanded in around 2014, it was a tremendous disadvantage to our entire

0:45:28 region.

0:45:30 The reason they were formed, and I was originally on the committee was because it would cut the

0:45:35 time for response during an incident and it would help maintain life safety.

0:45:40 The piece of equipment that the teams would like will help them support regional response

0:45:47 and will help them support with MOU, other departments with a piece of technology that

0:45:53 can help again enhance that response time and also save lives.

0:45:59 So I really feel that's important for all of you to understand.

0:46:02 projects that I do I really look at doing regional projects so that there is a

0:46:08 combined teamwork effort on any kind of response during an incident or disaster

0:46:13 in our county and city and the eight cities that I'm over so I definitely

0:46:17 appreciate your time and your support in this project. There's no further

0:46:25 discussion we would entertain a motion that would accept the use of the grant

0:46:30 funds and reallocate the operational funds and vote the fire on police

0:46:36 Department to purchase this equipment. Suzanne Hawkins is so moved.

0:46:39 Oh, she buys Suzanne Hawkins. Seconded by Chris Reed. Further discussion. It's a

0:47:03 40,000 in grant funding. Another 10 from already received grant funding. And the allocation of

0:47:09 $5,000 each in the further discussion. Mr. Fereid. Yes. Miss Tockington. Yes.

0:47:27 John Farrier? Yes. Thank you, Boyd. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. And Ruth Pierce? Yes.

0:47:33 Motion passes 6-0. Thank you. Thank you. And next on the agenda is an action item. This is a request to award a bid and contract to item home materials and construction to construct an FAA-funded hanger, taxi lane, phase 1 extension at Magic Valley Regional Airport, for $621,473. We have Bill Carberry, our airport manager.

0:48:00 Thank you, Mayor. Good evening, Council. I'd like to just utilize a picture to kind of take us back.

0:48:08 The airport board was involved probably 2016-2017 in developing a Northeast planning projects to look at, ultimately, a build-out of some more taxi lanes and for hanger development.

0:48:24 In large part due to FedEx developing there, we wanted to start to take a look at this area out there in the northeast of the airport.

0:48:33 What we've done is gone with the FAA to look at phase one portion, and that would be the construction of this brown taxi lane right here.

0:48:42 Phase two would create a connectivity to the main taxi lane. We'll have circulation back in here through this way.

0:48:51 We just have this one way in now.

0:48:53 So getting with the FAA, we've planned this project

0:48:56 to do this phase one right here.

0:48:59 We hope to have phase two shortly,

0:49:01 and then we'll work the other phases in as funding allows.

0:49:06 So earlier in April, we went to bid

0:49:10 for that piece of taxilane.

0:49:13 It's about somewhere around 1,000 feet long

0:49:16 to enable more hanger development there.

0:49:19 We received one bid from Idaho materials and construction for $621,473.

0:49:28 This was slightly above the engineer's estimate.

0:49:30 About 3%.

0:49:31 The engineer's estimate was $603,686.

0:49:37 When you receive one bid, the FAA requires you to do a cost analysis

0:49:42 for a recentableness of cost.

0:49:44 JUB Engineering has done that.

0:49:47 Kent Atkins is in the audience tonight.

0:49:50 He provided that to the FAA.

0:49:51 They were satisfied that costs were in line

0:49:55 with standard unit costs and things

0:49:58 with this type of construction.

0:49:59 So we're very pleased that Idaho Materials

0:50:02 and Construction has found us as a niche for some

0:50:05 of these really smaller jobs in the construction world.

0:50:07 And we're certainly pleased to have a local firm helping us

0:50:10 out here.

0:50:11 So with that, I'm taking the engineers recommendation and I echo that and I would recommend the Council accept the bid award for the

0:50:22 how to materials and construction bid in contract for the amount of six hundred twenty one thousand four hundred and seventy three dollars.

0:50:30 We have been answering any questions right now.

0:50:32 Thank you Bill, Chris Stockington.

0:50:35 Any question?

0:50:39 With the solo crew, construction.

0:50:44 With the FAA funded taxi and hanger taxi lane.

0:50:48 Phase 1 extension, a magic rally,

0:50:50 reached a smaller report in the amount of $621,473.

0:50:55 Nicky Boyd?

0:50:56 Second.

0:50:57 I'm going to make Chris Stockington seconded by Nicky Boyd to

0:51:00 award the bid as presented.

0:51:02 Is there any further discussion?

0:51:03 Chris Talkington?

0:51:08 Yes.

0:51:09 On Burger, Nicky Boyd, yes, Suzanne Hawkins, yes, Ruth Pierce, yes, Christopher Reed, yes,

0:51:16 I should pass this 60-0. Next on the agenda is an action item. This is a request to utilize

0:51:23 airport reserve funds for a $7,500 contract with six-old consulting to develop a U.S. Department

0:51:30 of Transportation Small Community Air Service Grant proposal and again Bill Carver.

0:51:36 Thank you, Mayor.

0:51:37 Let me see if I can get you the right view here.

0:51:40 And would you be able to help me out with the PowerPoint here a little bit.

0:51:45 Out of myself, I've got a few slides together.

0:51:51 Yeah, I'd like to just move through a kind of a brief presentation before the discussion

0:51:56 and questions about this grant.

0:51:59 So I just want to mark it back to the strategic plan as we often do when we come and visit

0:52:08 with you.

0:52:09 And the strategic plan includes the following objective in there.

0:52:12 it says the city will develop strategies to expand passenger air service through frequencies

0:52:17 and destinations. I want to talk about that one of those strategies here tonight, but first

0:52:25 I thought I'd just go back to really some basic fundamentals of our air service market.

0:52:32 This is what they call a catchment area. It's where our air service customers originate.

0:52:38 Typically, it's about a 50-mile ring from the Twin Falls airport. It includes all these zip

0:52:44 codes up there, but essentially the six or eight county magic valley area from

0:52:48 Gooding to Minicazia up to Lincoln County. It's just shown and down to the

0:52:53 Nevada and the Utah border. Occasionally it'll spill Elko. We'll see some people,

0:52:57 things like that, that will visit with us. So this is where most of them are coming

0:53:03 from. This next slide talks about where they go to to originate their air

0:53:09 service. So this is the the airports that compete with us for our customer base and you

0:53:17 can see Twin Falls retains one of four people that wakes up in the morning and gets on an

0:53:22 airplane from our area. You can see that we were right about the same ratio as Salt Lake

0:53:28 City and those two combined will use the Boise airport. And this is understandable. Folks

0:53:38 look for more options, I often look for better prices, the drives to these two airports in

0:53:44 the western United States would be considered reasonable drives, and it's really a dynamic

0:53:48 that we've had in our air service market for a long time.

0:53:55 This next heat map, if you will, really talks about folks from our market, where they go,

0:54:03 regardless of which airport they use, and you can see the larger dots represent more activity.

0:54:09 And Twin Falls, you can't see my white prom, first of all, just won't use that.

0:54:18 Maybe I can use this laser pointer.

0:54:22 So, Twin Falls Point being here, and Salt Lake here, you know, it's certainly no surprise

0:54:29 that a lot of folks travel in the West and the Rocky Mountain area.

0:54:33 But take note how many people go East.

0:54:37 It'd be interesting to kind of think about how they do get there.

0:54:40 Salt Lake, they use the Boise airport. Often these are not one-stop connections.

0:54:47 They would need to go through, let's say Delta, they go up to Minneapolis. They

0:54:52 may go over to Detroit to connect to some smaller places. Certainly Delta goes

0:54:57 down to Atlanta to take a look at the East and Seaboard in the Southeast. Some

0:55:02 folks may travel from Boise to Denver, maybe onto Chicago, and then picking up

0:55:09 some destinations. So it's interesting where people go and just take note of just

0:55:15 how many people do go to the eastern United States from from our market area.

0:55:19 Next slide just talks a little bit about our growth. To a false market this is

0:55:28 total passages and planning and de-planning. You can see there's been a

0:55:32 significant jump over the last four years there between 2014 and 2018. I

0:55:37 think really it's telling of a lot of markets around our country have had

0:55:41 a very brisk economy, but with Delta providing that third jet a few years ago, 150 seats

0:55:49 a day, we're normally seeing a daily load of 130 to 140 passengers, under 45 passengers

0:55:55 of the 150 seats, so we're really seeing quite a bit of activity out there at the airport.

0:56:04 That's just about a rule every other year, so I bring an air service team with me to visit

0:56:08 with SkyWest, and Sean Barrick is always very good

0:56:12 about coming with me.

0:56:13 Dan Homestead, who's here tonight.

0:56:15 Nate Murray joined me this past April.

0:56:17 We all went down there to talk to SkyWest

0:56:19 as we do about every other year.

0:56:21 Just to sort of talk about our market,

0:56:24 what types of opportunities might we see in the future.

0:56:27 And we also are able to provide some color about our market.

0:56:29 They know a lot about the numbers, how people buy,

0:56:32 what prices they buy, where they go.

0:56:34 But it's nice to tell them about a lot of the business

0:56:37 expansion we've had in diversity in our economy and investments in schools and

0:56:42 retail and medical and all of those things that have been happening so I

0:56:46 appreciate when I'm able to bring a group of folks to help me do those kinds

0:56:50 of things so this April as we do normally about every other year we've

0:56:55 visited with them and this is sort of a summary of the discussion that we had

0:56:59 with SkyWest so they certainly recognize that our market has been growing

0:57:04 significantly, they read the headlines, they were able to see the data, and they

0:57:08 acknowledged that. One of the things they did about a year ago is they put a

0:57:12 fourth flight in to Salt Lake, so we had four Delta flights to Salt Lake. It did okay,

0:57:19 but it didn't do really well, and they felt that it was sort of getting tapped

0:57:24 out. Salt Lake, as I'll show you in the next slide, is a very good

0:57:29 air transportation hub, but it mainly serves the Rocky Mountain in the west coast.

0:57:33 And they felt their demand for those areas was satisfied with the three flights.

0:57:39 But they were very curious about potentially adding a Denver route to assist us with the

0:57:44 East Coast.

0:57:45 And then we went on to talk about the small community air service development grants that

0:57:49 have been around since 2001.

0:57:52 We were a recipient of a grant back in 2012 when we expanded our brazilia fleet to four

0:57:57 flights for about a year, which really helped us keep up our numbers at the airport and

0:58:03 Ultimately we transitioned to jets, so we've had successful experience with grants.

0:58:08 We've worked closely with Sky West on a grant in the past, and they expressed some interest

0:58:14 in potentially working with us again with one of those grants.

0:58:20 Like to just illustrate a little bit about Salt Lake Hub, which is featured here in that red circle.

0:58:25 And you can see as you look at these destinations that Salt Lake serves,

0:58:32 You get a great clustering in the Rocky Mountain West and the West Coast, and you get some of

0:58:37 the usual players, the bigger markets to the East, but you can almost just see the concentration

0:58:43 just sort of slacks off here, which really, the illustration is indicative of Salt Lake

0:58:49 being a very good Rocky Mountain and West Coast hub.

0:58:55 Taking a look at the Denver connections here and don't let those lines bother you too much,

0:59:00 but looking at the red dots, I just thought off by just trying to compare the two, the

0:59:05 to airports and these are all airlines.

0:59:07 I mean, there are others, but Delta is basically

0:59:09 a fortress hub in Salt Lake and Denver is a big hub

0:59:14 for United, but there's more activity in Denver.

0:59:18 This map illustrates United's domestic routes,

0:59:21 and you can see in the east, there's a lot more going on

0:59:27 to some of these smaller cities, these Midwest cities,

0:59:30 more happening down here in Texas,

0:59:33 money happening in Florida, and then the urban corridor in the north east is certainly represented.

0:59:41 So you can see that Denver does offer quite a bit a new way of options.

0:59:46 Skywest felt this would be a good opportunity to try to bring those people off the highway

0:59:52 as I illustrated earlier. Most people drive to another airport for service, and often it's

0:59:57 a two-stop to get to their destination. So this would bring one stop through Denver to a lot

1:00:03 that are going east, so they're very curious about this opportunity.

1:00:07 So just to sort of outline a little bit about the grant project proposal that is being discussed,

1:00:15 and we have an aiming point at this point in time for requesting a grant of about $900,000.

1:00:22 That grant would be used for a revenue guarantee contract with SkyWest for United to Denver.

1:00:29 We have to have a very robust marketing program to create awareness of the new route to new

1:00:35 route and to also offer some assistance with startup costs such as IT infrastructure at

1:00:41 the station and some other other things along those lines.

1:00:45 So this is where money would hope to be used to sort of kickstart the program, if you will,

1:00:51 have paid some risk as they initiate service to the community as well.

1:01:00 So when the U.S. Department of Transportation, who is behind the grant, looks at criteria and

1:01:06 priorities when judging where they should award grants.

1:01:11 Certainly the small communities is what they focus on and we certainly feel the bill there.

1:01:16 Number one, we've got higher than average air affairs, access to the transportation system

1:01:21 is limited.

1:01:22 They also look for, and they've always have, is a community that establishes some sort of

1:01:28 public-private partnership to facilitate the service, and that, in large part, is support

1:01:35 letters certainly helpful, and I think that was cited in our 2012 grant as being one of

1:01:40 the things that really stood out as just how much support we had, but also cost participation,

1:01:46 some matching funds, some contributions from the local business community, local governments

1:01:52 to match a portion of that grant amount.

1:01:59 A little bit more on the partnership here.

1:02:02 Excuse me, local government, business,

1:02:05 or the areas they're looking for.

1:02:08 And typically, there's no stated amount of grants match

1:02:12 with when you look at the order from the DOT

1:02:14 and they announce this.

1:02:15 But certainly, there is history that shows

1:02:19 those that receive grants or those that participate

1:02:22 in contributions in some match dollars

1:02:25 to match the grant.

1:02:27 So typically somewhere in that 12, 15% range

1:02:31 would be a significant number, I think, to reach for.

1:02:35 And this is something you would need to really discuss

1:02:37 tonight, there's opportunity in next month.

1:02:41 These grants are due July 15th.

1:02:43 So there's a little bit of time.

1:02:44 And I know there's certainly discussions

1:02:46 in the business community about potentially developing

1:02:50 some match dollars here for this.

1:02:52 And perhaps a discussion can be had here.

1:02:54 the county and other places in the coming short weeks that we have.

1:03:02 So in conclusion, I feel this is an excellent strategy, the Small Community Development Grant,

1:03:08 programs an excellent strategy to help us attain some of our strategic goals and improving

1:03:14 air service out there.

1:03:15 And I would recommend the Council approve the utilization of $7,500 from Airport Reserves

1:03:21 to fund the contract with our air service consultant.

1:03:24 We've been utilizing 6L consulting to develop the grant proposal.

1:03:29 I'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.

1:03:32 Thank you very much.

1:03:36 I will speak just briefly with my other hat as well as the chamber executive.

1:03:41 The chamber helped to work with the business community in 2012 when we had the last grant here in brain together.

1:03:49 That private partner to help bolster those match funds for life a better term really to drive a robust marketing program

1:03:58 because at the end of the day the service is successful and it's used.

1:04:02 The whole here is not to have revenue guarantee checks to line its to

1:04:07 whether the service is will utilized and so the Chamber Board has discussed this

1:04:13 and there is a commitment to getting stepped forward in bridging those partnerships as needed.

1:04:20 Having also, while the grant application is due, those commitments need to be made on the front end with the grant application.

1:04:30 My view process at the federal level months out for even the potential announcement of a service and then kind of mamming that up.

1:04:40 So, I think this is an excellent service that well received and a new destination and a new carrier that could-

1:04:54 I would just say that this is a really good opportunity, and it's always good when there's some companies.

1:05:15 out the best in folks.

1:05:16 I'm glad to.

1:05:21 I think one of the interesting twists on this one as well, while there are certain late

1:05:25 pent-up airlines at the end of the day have been dealt with and united.

1:05:30 It is a common carrier who provides that short haul service for both of them, West and SkyWest.

1:05:35 Now it's a pretty plus year partner and they have their own entity as a business are a

1:05:43 pretty significant contributor to our local economy.

1:05:46 It's encouraging to see them being willing to partner and really find some unique ways

1:05:51 The customer is here at the passengers, we're just talking to them.

1:05:55 Request to utilize airport reserve funds for a $7,500 contact with SIXEL Consulting to

1:06:15 develop a US DOT small community air service grant proposal.

1:06:21 And if you could wait a second, I was talking to approve the use of airport reserve funds

1:06:29 for the $7500 contract with SIXEL Consulting for the grant proposal development, is there

1:06:34 for your discussion on that?

1:06:42 is talking to yes is that

1:06:46 yes Ruth Pierce yes Christopher Reed yes

1:06:50 since six to zero but maybe just to have a

1:06:56 brief discussion here so the last grant

1:06:59 that they'll pursued was five hundred

1:07:02 thousand the target on this one is nine

1:07:05 hundred thousand which I will say as generous

1:07:14 and supportive as the business community will

1:07:16 be higher fifteen percent from the private

1:07:20 business sector maybe a bit of proposal is

1:07:27 fine tuned and before it's due

1:07:29 And before it's due, I suspect they'll

1:07:32 would like some discussion about whether the council,

1:07:36 non-airport funds, may be something

1:07:38 we've been contributing or pledging, I guess,

1:07:42 toward the habit decision on that today,

1:07:49 but probably good to start having that come.

1:07:51 Happen seeing how many we reached out

1:08:00 to those other cities, those other counties,

1:08:04 early to county gooding.

1:08:09 Asher County, I mean, they're benefiting

1:08:11 just as much as the folks here,

1:08:13 and instead of putting it on the backs of the people

1:08:15 who just live here, reaching out and sharing it.

1:08:18 It's a regional airport, and the region should look at this as well.

1:08:22 I think they're going to, but we're fighting them the opportunity to help.

1:08:27 I will say the last go round to business plus, and the way those funds are...

1:08:54 July 15th is the deadline, so we certainly hope to have things collected by the end of June.

1:09:17 Get that in. Thank you very much.

1:09:21 Next is another opportunity for general public input.

1:09:28 If there's anyone from the public who wishes to address the council, now's your opportunity to please come forward.

1:09:33 being no one advisory board report, item that's not really an advisory board, but something

1:09:44 I wanted to share, so there was some discussion online today in Round Town on the radio this

1:09:51 morning related to the lack of United States flags being displayed yesterday from a more

1:09:57 L.A. particularly on Main Avenue. Many of those concerns were being directed to the city of

1:10:03 Twin Falls, which actually has no direct involvement in the flag display program.

1:10:07 That's why I did want to provide just a couple of background details and information that I've gathered to help clarify the situation.

1:10:14 So the flag display program is actually managed by two local organizations, the Boy Scouts,

1:10:19 a place of about 200 flags that individual businesses in Twin Falls, north of Addison Avenue.

1:10:25 Even on our compliance club, places 240 flags that individual businesses in Twin Falls south of Addison Avenue.

1:10:33 As individual businesses pay a small annual fee to have the flag placed and removed on

1:10:37 the holidays, and that fee helps to support donations to those two groups for the other

1:10:42 civic work that they do in the community.

1:10:44 It speaks to a representative of the Monarch Lions Club today, and he shared that the club

1:10:49 did not place the flags yesterday due to the persistent rain we were experiencing.

1:10:54 The flags that they have are stored in boxes, and they cannot be stored when wet, as a volunteer

1:10:59 club with no facility of their own, the Lions do not have a place to drag those flags out

1:11:04 in the display.

1:11:08 He did say that they do plan to have the flags out for Flag Day coming up in June and the 4th

1:11:13 of July and so on throughout the year.

1:11:15 They just did not have a way to deal with the rain yesterday.

1:11:18 It asked if his club could use additional volunteers to assist with this program, and he said that

1:11:23 they could, as their club members, have dwindled over the years, that they've had offers from

1:11:28 individuals and other clubs in the past, but since the flag placement is on holidays,

1:11:33 people tend to be unavailable when they are actually needed.

1:11:36 With that said, I told them I would do what I could to encourage folks to volunteer to

1:11:40 assist them.

1:11:41 So if you, as an individual or know of a group who would want to help in the future, you're

1:11:46 welcome to get in touch with me and I'll get you connected with the folks at the Monarch

1:11:50 Club.

1:11:51 I also suppose some volunteerism or donation did figure out a way to have them dry the flags

1:11:56 after they get what would be. I appreciate it as well. I do want to say that personally I really

1:12:01 believe that the effort of these community organizations as volunteers is the right way

1:12:06 to handle the flag displays as opposed to considering it yet another function of local government.

1:12:12 It's worked well for years, truthfully probably for decades. I believe it will continue to work

1:12:17 well as a community-based civic activity encouraging personal engagement. I do hope that individuals

1:12:24 and groups will consider stepping up to volunteer their time in town to continue this great display

1:12:29 of patriotism when falls and potentially provide the opportunity to even expand it in the future.

1:12:35 I would also add that of course none of this activity restricts your own individual ability,

1:12:40 either at your home or your business to purchase your own flag and put it up and take it down on

1:12:45 holidays yourself. So I just wanted to clarify some of the background I was able to receive on

1:12:51 on that, it did take off a little bit, like,

1:12:53 while firing on social media this morning.

1:12:55 So, that was the background, I was able to gather,

1:12:57 I just wanted to share that with them.

1:13:00 Anything else from the council?

1:13:02 Yes, is that?

1:13:03 All right, the council members might not be aware

1:13:08 that for the past few weeks,

1:13:10 I've been doing the Bill Cully show on Monday mornings

1:13:13 of 8 a.m., and I'm having a change to my schedule,

1:13:16 and I'm not going to be able to do that as frequently.

1:13:18 And he would really like to keep a Monday morning,

1:13:21 just city council talk,

1:13:23 over what's on our agenda for that night, very basic, normally 20 minutes, and I'm hoping

1:13:29 some of you might be able to volunteer to help fill in some of those time slots for

1:13:33 him.

1:13:34 And if you want to, I don't know if we want to coordinate it through some day at city

1:13:38 staff and schedule it, or if you want to deal with Bill directly, I don't care, I just

1:13:43 think that it's a good service to the community to know what we're going to talk about on

1:13:47 Monday nights.

1:13:50 I certainly would throughout a rotation and then folks that didn't want to participate didn't and it just needs to be coordinated by someone when someone's not going to show up and I would recommend that be directly with Bill and not suggest a route and dates and then if we want to first trade on those or if you don't want to be a part of it then we can go.

1:14:20 We had a wrap up to Memorial Day in a retirement home.

1:14:32 Our chief was one of the participants along with the sheriff,

1:14:35 and there were about 50 veterans, I think, in attendance.

1:14:38 Some going through back to the tail end of World War II is highly meaningful.

1:14:43 We all ate so much in sacrifice.

1:14:54 The guys were biting their lip, bringing back a lot of memories,

1:14:59 but thanks, chief, for your participation.

1:15:02 The second thing I'd like to talk about, just a second,

1:15:05 does reflect on last week's fire bond election,

1:15:09 fire bond issue, that we had 12% turnout,

1:15:14 88% of the public eligible to vote chose to set out

1:15:19 the action on the public safety issue,

1:15:21 the vote failed by 77 votes.

1:15:25 But despite that, there's an incredible amount

1:15:27 of good activity by the fire personnel

1:15:30 and a number of citizens dispelling, dispensing information, answering questions, everything

1:15:36 from public presentations, the fire stations to door to dooring. This is democracy in action.

1:15:42 I was not happy, obviously, as many of us were speaking only as an individual that it did not.

1:15:51 The consequences for the public viewing and listening. The city staff right now is working on proposals

1:15:57 that they'll bring to us that we're sure with the public of course of our future

1:16:02 course of actions for this vital public safety action requirement of updating

1:16:07 our fire stations. It is safe to say though that the continuum growth of the

1:16:12 city response times of our fire engines are going to be pushed and it's

1:16:19 possible that those expense those response times are going to voiden

1:16:24 and the increase in that means the potential for your personal insurance property, uh,

1:16:30 rates on your home to go up.

1:16:32 It also means that we probably without knowing what the city staff are recommending

1:16:37 that we'll be doing whatever renovations, updates to the fire safety,

1:16:43 falls over a longer period than the short and long issue would be providing,

1:16:50 and that's going to drive the cost up over what it would have had the bond issue passed.

1:16:57 on the list that's democracy speaking will plow forward on the thing and thank you for the

1:17:04 1,000, excuse me, 2,405 people that did vote in the guest's end of the nose.

1:17:12 Me too.

1:17:13 Welcome to Council.

1:17:17 Travis from the City Manager's Office.

1:17:20 And Mr. Mayor, just two quick things I'll build on to Councilman Tuckington was sharing.

1:17:27 We are in the process of evaluating different options like I shared with you in May.

1:17:31 We are going to be meeting with our consultants on the 11th of June to map out a series of options on council folks that you saw as well as the architect individuals.

1:17:46 We plan on coming on the 17th series of proposals and options and possibilities of opportunities as well as consequences.

1:17:58 from that menu choice and we'll have the council hopefully select the ones that you'd like

1:18:05 best for us to continue to explore further and we are obviously lots of different paths lots of different

1:18:12 outcomes nothing has been decided it is still an issue that staff will continue to work to address

1:18:24 the second is that next week we will start early we'll start at four o'clock for an M-POC

1:18:30 conversation but make sure that until the community knows that that will be

1:18:37 earlier start than the typical five o'clock start conversation then follow

1:18:44 it up with a series of proclamations normal business and the possibility of

1:18:50 two executive sessions.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Tuesday, May 28, 2019. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:19:04.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    60805776944449c921d3721afc08f0e78d3f35b237799fbbcfb26ac4fd247c4b
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 3868171f8052f2f481671ac93b45c20f14ae9f98a894a27fa8e0e84ca2b65365
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    6b052602c31a2d274c895b5eaea45951289a48f78655924e91808d265cf712c7

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file