City Council meeting
Monday, December 3, 2018
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Minutes on fileExecutive session: b,f
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Part 1 (from 0:00:00)
Part 2 (from 1:30:00)
Transcript
0:00:23 I would like to call the order of the meeting of the Twin Falls City Council for Monday, December 3rd and confirm that we do have a quorum in the Council here.
0:00:30 Six of the seven members are present this evening. Councilwoman Ruth Pierce is absent.
0:00:35 Next on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us please rise.
0:00:40 Clamation this evening, 2018 Veterans Suicide Awareness Month.
0:01:08 Whereas according to the most recent US Department of Veterans Affairs study,
0:01:13 approximately 20 veterans die by suicide every day in the United States, and whereas veterans face a
0:01:19 disproportionate risk of suicide when compared to the general population, and whereas the highest
0:01:25 risk for suicide is among younger veterans, especially those who served on the battlefields of Iraq
0:01:30 and Afghanistan, and whereas the risk of suicide can be reduced through awareness,
0:01:36 proper education, resources and treatment, and whereas suicide affects each and every one of us in some
0:01:42 way as it is up to us to help those we love by being good neighbors, good friends, and
0:01:47 good family members if there are ways to protect our veterans from such a tragic fate.
0:01:52 Now, therefore, I, Jean-Vereger, mayor of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho, be here by proclaimed
0:01:57 December 2018 Veterans Suicide Awareness Month in the City of Twin Falls and encourage all
0:02:03 residents to recognize how serious suicide is and the steps each of us can take to protect
0:02:09 those around us from such tragedy here this evening to accept the proclamation we
0:02:15 have state veteran service officer Bob Smith and
0:02:51 even right here in Twin Falls, being a former Marine, I don't like to lose anything and I do not
0:02:58 like to lose a single veteran. I can point to try to get this information out as much as we can
0:03:05 to our outlying areas. Sometimes when veterans return home, they seclude, they don't reach out,
0:03:12 family members don't know how to get the help they need to sit down across the desk face-to-face
0:03:23 and help identify the issues and get them to help in the treatment that they need.
0:03:27 There's a lot of statistics out there with the veteran suicide that we don't really
0:03:34 focusing on OIF and OEF, that transition back, state side presents a lot of different barriers
0:03:42 and obstacles.
0:03:43 It was kind of intriguing when Commissioner all got a hold of me today.
0:03:48 I just received an email from an outside source in the Boise area and asked do you
0:03:54 have literature anything for veterans suicide this month in your office as a matter of fact
0:04:00 we do. Whether it's a key chain, a refrigerator, a bag net, a crisis, a veteran crisis, hotline
0:04:07 cards, juicy hats, you know, it's in the office. When we happen to be co-located inside with
0:04:14 the Idaho Department of Labor on falls across from the college and I just happen to walk
0:04:19 up just to see if there was any literature there as well. Not even see any. The office
0:04:27 manager making fire. I said I'm gonna shoot an email off to scan Idaho, suicide
0:04:34 awareness month. I said let's get some more literature out there because not
0:04:40 just for the civilian population but the Department of Labor holiday season for
0:04:51 some people you know as an added stressor prevention you know you know your
0:05:03 support you know from the community as well. Several of you up this so I know the
0:05:14 City of Twin Falls and the County of New Year continued support. I would just, Mr. Mayor, members of the council, I would just add to that
0:05:33 County have made great strides, actually, within the last couple years we have
0:05:39 dedicated about 7 or 8,000 square feet in our facility for the Veterans Council. This is all the different organizations that serve our veterans, and it's a healthy place for them to come.
0:05:50 We also have made our Veterans Service Officer Haley Greenstra within the last year and a half.
0:06:13 It was a part-time position. Now it's a full-time position and she's there dedicated to help veterans through their benefit packages and all those other dynamics and if they have any needs and any resources for them.
0:06:26 So again Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, thank you for reading the information and your support of our here.
0:06:31 I would also like to ask for an observance of a moment of silence in memory of our 41st
0:06:46 President George H.W. Bush who passed away in recognition of the National Month of Morning
0:06:52 Agenda's an opportunity to address the Council on an item that's under the agenda this evening.
0:07:18 Now as your opportunity to please come forward.
0:07:20 Verger. Yes. Great glanting. Mr. Ferriid. Yes. Passes 6 to 0. I glanced down this. So if you were
0:08:16 here for a license for a taste of Thai with the trust agreement for golden
0:08:23 Eagle subdivision number one.
0:08:33 items of consideration the first is an action item to request to authorize the
0:08:40 mayor to sign the program agreement or for the children pedestrian safety
0:08:46 program 2019 application we have hearing steel engineering department.
0:08:53 Back to my mother request.
0:08:56 So tonight I'm here to request to authorize the mayor
0:08:59 to sign the program agreement for the Children
0:09:02 of Pedestrian Safety Program, 29th location.
0:09:05 This fund is a state surplus and limited program
0:09:09 that splits remaining funds into different grants
0:09:12 to help children's safety.
0:09:14 So we've gone through the process
0:09:16 and we've selected the following,
0:09:18 and I'll tell you a little more about it.
0:09:19 As you see on your map, there's two portions in blue
0:09:22 and yellow.
0:09:23 Washington Street is on your right and both in Robert Stewart Elementary
0:09:33 proposal for us in pieces of sidewalk that are missing to create a safe path
0:09:41 from Washington Street North all the way to the schools. This is a fantastic
0:09:47 program. Already in program on Washington Street North is a hot signal. It's gonna
0:09:52 be going in. There was a state surplud, sorry, a state safety grant that we won
0:09:58 waxed here in the staff report that we put together we had a mistake and we said
0:10:04 that this was a previous child safety that's incorrect so this the hot signal
0:10:11 is already a state as you can see this will connect all the way through provided
0:10:20 very safe place for the children to walk and get to school so the master
0:10:25 transportation plan calls this road out as a collector it was originally
0:10:29 platted as a residential status, we understand the trans-vide safety from one side to the
0:10:44 other. Staff doesn't foresee a huge increase in traffic along here, so this will tell about
0:10:59 five or six different curb ramps depending on the design that happens, along with 1,200
0:11:04 feet of sidewalk and it also will take care of some irrigation pipes that are in the way,
0:11:11 So we're requesting a grand total of 148,500 out
0:11:16 of the maximum grant that, so it's on max.
0:11:29 So tonight we just ask that Council
0:11:35 authorized the mayor to sign this program agreement,
0:11:39 the child safety program.
0:11:40 One more thing I wanna add before I end is
0:11:44 one of the aspects that we have to have
0:11:45 that would get grounders different letters of support.
0:11:48 So we already contacted both principals
0:11:50 for both schools and we have one of the letters
0:11:52 of support we've got one coming in
0:11:55 place the partner here but I also want to ask is there anybody that you can think of specifically
0:11:59 that went for this application. President's up for a letter because safety of their children
0:12:26 and other children as they're walking to school might ask if I go worse I have way more power than
0:12:37 way over. Sure that's a good session. Is that how it's? So it's already separated by pieces sidewalk
0:13:12 okay so it's just showing the difference to connect everything. So the 60-40 split is what the
0:13:43 state splits internally. The only cost that we would have.
0:13:57 I were to sign the program 10 second by Greg Lansing to sign the program in the safety
0:14:14 programs. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes.
0:14:29 As talking to yes. Yes.
0:14:31 And Sean Baraker. Yes.
0:14:32 A day is a request to approve between the city of Twin Falls and the Twin Falls Rural
0:14:44 Fire District from October 1st, 2018 to September 30, 2021.
0:15:05 Mr. Mayor, Council, thank you for the opportunity to you've received the packet and, um, to
0:15:12 just a little explanation.
0:15:14 I thought that we maybe had this completed already,
0:15:17 and there was a little bit of a mix up in staff
0:15:21 where we thought and how contracts needed to go forward.
0:15:24 So I apologize for that,
0:15:25 because I knew that this is an effort
0:15:31 to get everything back in order and do it properly.
0:15:34 And so, what you consider requesting approval
0:15:39 of the contract between the City of Twin Falls and the Hudson.
0:15:47 So I think you saw it in a couple of highlights of change
0:15:51 And if you ask a specific question,
0:15:53 so I'll be glad you have the biggest things.
0:15:59 Well, it's not the biggest, I guess we had an extension
0:16:02 from prior to my arrival here.
0:16:08 So the district was hoping that we get
0:16:10 a between three and five years.
0:16:14 And so with this contract, some of the other things
0:16:24 that we considered, and this was by our RCFO,
0:16:28 Lori Race, is that we changed the way we calculate.
0:16:33 We charge the district based on the MCI.
0:16:37 And as you can see, in 2018, the contract price
0:16:41 by using that MCI was $504,795.
0:16:45 You will also notice in the contract
0:16:47 where it talks about Pacific apparatus
0:16:50 that the fire district owns.
0:16:53 At this time, the district does not own any fire apparatus.
0:16:56 The city of Twin Falls owns all of the different pieces
0:17:00 of apparatus into the city.
0:17:05 We kept a consultation with our legal team.
0:17:09 We kept those terminology in there just in case in the future of some changes we still have.
0:17:17 So, besides the EMCI, also with the, that's pretty much the only difference from past contracts.
0:17:29 The questions I'd be otherwise.
0:17:34 Okay, Suzanne.
0:18:03 I'm seconded by Christopher Reed to present it.
0:18:09 Is there any?
0:18:16 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:18:20 Christopher Reed.
0:18:21 Yes.
0:18:22 Chris Tockington.
0:18:23 Yes.
0:18:24 John Merricker.
0:18:27 Yes.
0:18:29 Next on the agenda is a request to approve the use of contingency funds in the amount of $7,653.50
0:18:37 to be used to partner with Twin Falls County, Jerome County, to hire an EMS consultant firm
0:18:43 to evaluate opportunities for regional cooperation to include consideration of EMS system design
0:18:49 and operational changes. We again have less Ken Worthy, our fire chief.
0:18:53 Thank you Mr. Mayor again, thank you for the opportunity.
0:18:56 I just want to assure you that in the request that we're unfunded or unfunded, it just so happens it won't work out.
0:19:12 So it's not going to be. I'm here tonight to ask requests of your approval for contingency funds in the amount of 7,653 LMS systems and services.
0:19:52 I think that's the right move. Was the right move and I think that's the right move.
0:20:02 Based on the service delivery to the public.
0:20:05 nine months down and digging into this. I've seen some areas where I think you'll look at some things
0:20:21 and how we're doing the same time period over the last few months. Magic Valley paramedics,
0:20:28 an association with Twin Falls County, Dr. Crail from St. Luke's have all been working also on
0:20:36 their system because they have some issues just within their own system that they've had to possibly
0:20:43 look for some new efficiencies, ways of doing business. So with Twin Falls getting into the
0:20:56 that's been a help but we still have some areas we can we feel as a group
0:21:01 as if we partner together closely we can come up with more efficiencies not only
0:21:07 cost savings but also our resource deployment and also for ultimately the
0:21:14 key to our citizenry so so with that I've asked tonight as if we could have
0:21:22 their team here and actually we got all of them so it's gonna nice Patterson and
0:21:30 all so I'm gonna speak give you a little background then we're gonna have
0:21:46 He'll speak on specifics of the RFP.
0:22:05 He'll go through that, any questions that might help.
0:22:07 He'll do an overview and show you what these costs are.
0:22:10 And then he'll answer any questions you might have.
0:22:13 And we actually have a pleasure of having Dr. Crell here tonight as well.
0:22:17 Dr. Crell is not only the director for paramedics,
0:22:20 but he's also our overseer for our licensing to be able to be here as well.
0:22:28 as well, and he'll just say a few words, maybe not specifically to this, although he's more
0:22:33 than capable and willing to answer those questions, but I know he'd like to talk to you just a
0:22:37 little bit about EMF.
0:22:40 So I'll start here and do that, and then I would ask, you'll get information from all
0:22:46 three of you have specifics for me, you can certainly answer an answer, but besides asking
0:23:06 for this, you might ask why are we coming, realize number one that has a new fire chief,
0:23:17 Magic Valley was probably and was a fire team was going to be like act like what
0:23:24 the agenda did I have what no partnerships no communications or relationships
0:23:34 were as the budget process was going on. In Falls County and I believe both are
0:23:43 the same budgeting cycle we with us or not or how this was still since then we
0:23:57 have and I think it's that they came to me they ask if we'd be interested in
0:24:01 partner or is part of the city, but it's a large percentage of the service they provided
0:24:18 to the city.
0:24:19 So they were willing to kind of split those costs up between Jerome County, Twin Falls County
0:24:26 and the city.
0:24:27 So I think we're getting a study like this and actually you have a seat at the table.
0:24:37 Again, some of the things from the city's perspective that gets upstances.
0:25:04 I thought maybe I'd share a couple things that I've seen as far as from the city perspective
0:25:17 in some of the areas, because you might ask what are some of those holes, what are some of those things that I see as issues that we need to deal?
0:25:26 I'd say probably one of the biggest ones is communications.
0:25:29 Currently we have two concenters, and basically calls are being transferred to all goes off, our units respond,
0:25:43 He goes to circum all that data is being collected hard to specialists hang on the line and listen in to see what the call receiver
0:25:52 Her caller is saying but after that
0:25:56 Both units are responding independently within the city to call. They have a good mechanism units on the horizontal level to go
0:26:09 There's a problem and so radio systems
0:26:30 We need to have interoperability
0:26:38 Some of these incidents and currently that's like
0:26:49 One other thing that we're currently working on is EMT level training at our dispatch center.
0:26:56 In essence, what that is is to bring the level of our education to our dispatchers up to a level,
0:27:04 not comparable to an EMT, but to a medical level.
0:27:08 So as they're taking calls, they have some better understanding of what resource needs to go
0:27:14 and get better patient information to somebody who's, for example,
0:27:20 Our dispatchers are currently dealing with some issues with some delays, call transfers, that sort of thing.
0:28:14 We'd like to get that outside perspective to look at this idea by service, not only in the city of Twin Falls,
0:28:34 times if their ambulances are all out of service, and ones responding in tell service,
0:28:42 and respond, they are the only transportation vehicle to get somebody to the hospital.
0:28:50 We're working on that as well. But, until some of those things get bad.
0:28:56 And that was because they were, and so this point's doing it,
0:29:18 Mass and I know some of the things that we sent somebody out in a unit from all about some of these things instead of taking them.
0:29:53 Basically the time of dispatch into the front door of the Global Sense.
0:30:10 And I can certainly come back right now.
0:30:21 So I think there is a real opportunity here to develop a system.
0:32:03 You have the same way in grants, 7,000.
0:32:49 So you got the documents, the hat, kind of the items to consider the scope of work.
0:32:53 Do you guys have any questions on them?
0:33:14 also county residents and residents are getting duck and share even though that was considered
0:33:33 before because the city is by far our largest five percent of our calls are in the city's
0:33:46 city also having their own dispatch center their own cat system their own radio system
0:34:02 it adds up for considering this and i don't know that i have a lot to add to what these two
0:35:48 gentlemen have said that my title is i'm a medical director for but the emus system for the two counties
0:35:54 That's all the QRUs, and I like to say right now that I think, and one of the things that's sort of got me thinking about this, well, what is thinking about this is in fact he comes from a system with a tear response.
0:36:13 And I don't know if you really got that, but right now we send a name on screw to airfree porn.
0:36:17 Yeah, most are more expensive. They're very well across.
0:36:25 I'm going to say it's when we have an EMS system here.
0:36:30 Parts of it and we are two to two to three sources.
0:36:37 And this is done better care to the people they should save in the cost of the farming.
0:37:11 And one thing I was thinking about is because I think you have a pretty question, you know,
0:37:14 why these costs and so forth is that I anticipate that we're going to have a cost,
0:37:20 but part of a system thing I was saying lives in, part of a system,
0:37:29 we honestly can't survey in this because our stroke outcomes are established.
0:37:54 And so we are really great job on this in this spectrum,
0:37:58 but not so well as a lot of human system in the city.
0:38:01 in the city and the council for any of the presenters,
0:38:28 Aganton, seconded by great landing to our contingency funds
0:38:59 as presented, is there any further discussion?
0:39:01 That this is a great strengthening partnership that already exists,
0:39:11 but as all of the presenters pointed out,
0:39:15 to do what's best for the end user, which is our citizen
0:39:19 or the county citizen, or see the results and find some ways to improve those things.
0:39:36 Suzanne Hawkins, yes, great landing.
0:39:39 Mr. Fareed? Yes. Mr. Talkington? Yes. Next on the agenda is a request to approve changes to the municipal powers
0:39:57 outsourced grant or impug process. Any Thompson? No, just here. Thank you for the question of our municipal powers
0:40:24 house first, process. As you recall, as a true grant program, first, should we just? Is it the job of the seven of us to collect
0:42:20 individuals to donate shoes to support the senior center but that's our
0:42:43 building and we need to take care of our building and it doesn't need to be so
0:42:55 we still have person on staff in the police department so we're trying to
0:43:05 internally take on some of those tasks that I think recreation department does
0:43:14 such a great job of offering things to our children do we really need to take
0:43:18 taxpayer money to support other people's programs for the you know I just went
0:43:25 through this list one at a time that is so close to my heart, I love what they do, city service.
0:43:34 It's not wellers, but it's since jobs, but I've been support the organizations they choose,
0:43:51 and it's not our job to take tax money and fund direction.
0:43:56 I'm very much in favor of keeping the M.B. in program in some manner.
0:45:51 I liked Mandy's, changes to where we could put priorities, we had a story matrix, we could really look at each program
0:46:02 and set a priority one year over another year.
0:46:05 Back out on our back out of finding things that basically helped our most vulnerable populations.
0:46:16 That's who were support with this.
0:46:18 I mean, looking at most of them are rights to doctors' offices' rights to different things.
0:46:23 We have youth programs that are for, maybe can't be funded fully other ways.
0:46:31 There's far more programs for the elderly that we've found than just the senior center.
0:46:39 And so I would fully support keeping the MPa program and doing it with the program that
0:46:51 Mandy set out.
0:46:52 So it is a little more like a grant program and a little less, a little more objective.
0:46:56 It's always going to be some subjective.
0:46:58 There's just even any grant program is, but that's where I've come.
0:47:02 I would like to see us implement Mantis.
0:47:07 Formula that she's put forth to us and give it a try on here.
0:47:10 We've already got it in this year's budget.
0:47:12 Let's give it a run and see whether it works better for us.
0:47:16 Before we start taking money away or taking funds
0:47:20 away from some of the groups who use it many times as match
0:47:25 so they can get other money so they can operate their program.
0:47:29 And one, I don't think we've given them enough time to go out and find the other sources if they are available to
0:47:37 by dropping at the slate and ball game. So, I will definitely be staying in favor of the M-POG program
0:47:45 and I will be supportive of Mandy's changes.
0:47:48 I understand what maybe to an organization just because we felt like they came, they presented, we need to give them something.
0:48:21 thing. I think that the way is which is presented right now, all of the other, all
0:48:26 of the areas, the proposal, the one that I'm not a big fan of, is the MPOG
0:48:31 Commissing Your Center, Transportation, Victims, those are areas that I feel like
0:48:50 the city has ties to and that we need to help and we need support because
0:48:55 without them is a city we would struggle and our citizens would struggle so I don't
0:48:59 have a problem with it at all. I do think that the matrix, I think that
0:49:04 connecting into this strategic my eye for this you need to understand what
0:49:11 we're and then also having a specific dollar amount I hear it says limitation
0:49:18 of funds if we want to set that but I do think it's all or nothing and we say no
0:49:31 you're $6,000 well I don't know if you're gonna get a car with $6,000 so those types
0:49:36 of things is essential so those are the areas that I feel perfectly fine I
0:49:43 personally would rather get rid of the impart committee where that's just a
0:49:49 A couple of us.
0:49:51 No one has reviewed the applications prior to coming to the council, and it's going to
0:50:10 be very difficult to assign scoring of the matrix if you're going to be doing it.
0:50:20 So the matrix wouldn't be scored by us while we're sitting here listening.
0:50:23 That's what I thought maybe it's different.
0:50:26 Well, I mean, I think at, I love scores based on, and it just gives it, I guess, a little
0:51:16 bit of a start versus just.
0:51:21 It's the senior center which we do transform out of this process and give them their own.
0:51:51 So as a city we are stepping up to help with transportation needs.
0:52:22 So a couple of things just as a process.
0:52:26 One of the first is by legal does compliance powers that are created in advance at Ford
0:52:55 or City Attorney always reviewed the house to Stanford.
0:53:01 Staff in this case would serve as ex officio.
0:53:03 We did PISU one, it's connection to the strategic plan.
0:53:06 plan we would not. This is a council driven process and it remains a staff one.
0:55:31 It's very specific.
0:56:51 This is in seeing a set of about 50-50 right now because I too, as I've shared in the past,
0:57:04 Anne raises some good points and I appreciate the thoughtfulness that you put into.
0:57:09 What it is we're trying to, that said, stood this particular process that I have specific
0:57:27 programs to specific goals as opposed to broad. If it's in the code as something
0:57:33 a municipality could do then therefore you're eligible to get the dot stick of your money.
0:57:50 Understanding that that station still happens at the council.
0:57:53 Burries, but that so that it's not just a specific program tied to a specific goal
0:58:15 should already do that. You should have a member that says to do I don't see that
0:58:24 as a discussion of this process around to what is it that we need as the city
0:58:39 to prioritize a strategic goal, let's go find a partner and let's provide funding to assist
0:58:45 that partner. Personally, I think that's a better way to go about this because I think
0:58:51 it still preserves what some of the other council members have shared here. Process is
0:59:04 to say there's a need for rides to, for example, let's find that, you know, if that's a strategic
0:59:13 goal that we have and let's find a partner to do that and let's pay for it. Perhaps if
0:59:20 If we go through this process, if we give it another, as we're doing that, it's going
0:59:27 to line on the same time of year as long-term planning, starting and spusturing process and
0:59:33 us going through our process for the following year.
0:59:37 Maybe as we look at those applications, we say, gosh, you know, these three really stand
0:59:42 out and these are important.
0:59:44 So instead of doing it through this grant program, let's identify those as needs we need.
0:59:49 Be the same drum here, because I've been saying this, I think, for the last two years that we've
0:59:56 done this of if we think we need victim services from voices against violence
1:00:02 why don't we create a contract for the services we're going to get to pay for that
1:00:05 seniors need rights to healthcare services why don't we create a contract
1:00:12 with if we think we need recreation programs maybe we ought to look at
1:00:18 creating and funding those recreation programs within our recreation department
1:00:22 as opposed to finding the partner who's doing this particular process I think
1:00:30 We've sharpened it up that it can maybe help us get down a path.
1:00:35 I would certainly second that one if we would have put a maximum ward of 10,000.
1:01:19 We could have a starting point there.
1:01:23 Is that all right, Besser?
1:01:24 So, so how about let's do this?
1:01:26 What if we have the motion stand as approving this?
1:01:29 And, well, so now we second take this as well.
1:01:37 The motion would be of this entire proposal as presented.
1:01:43 to suggest is funds that have that discussion and then perhaps make
1:01:57 action to set that gap.
1:02:02 You made those finer points separately.
1:02:04 I'll set all of this tonight so that this process forward,
1:02:13 that was the reason for getting it on the address.
1:03:46 In the past, in 10,000 is a reasonable organization,
1:03:51 what these organizations have been receiving recently.
1:03:57 If you go back on that of the history of the MPOT program,
1:04:02 of these ads. Some of the applicants got larger sums. I think part of the reason that they're
1:04:13 to us, so there's just in general. I guess the idea for me of putting a cap could request
1:04:25 the way for you to preserve your interpretation is a partial funding they ask for a process.
1:05:04 If we do, it'll give them costs to think a little dollars, five hundred themizations,
1:05:51 ization in this association with their admission, but a project or a program, a thousand dollars.
1:06:22 for these in advance of the whole process, posed as this is how it's going to be.
1:07:34 So back to Suzanne's question earlier of, could we just have a motion on the proposal as it stands,
1:07:40 and then, Sarri, since we have a process here of what makes the most sense for people,
1:08:39 like vote on the motion as stated, and then if we want to have additional conversation on those other two items,
1:08:48 we can do that towards getting our consensus on that.
1:08:53 Nick, did you have something else?
1:08:55 I was just so proud I could actually get the light to come on.
1:08:58 Alright, so we have a motion by Chris talking to the 2nd of my great planting to a process as presented.
1:09:07 If the motion failed, does that mean we're since it's already in the budget,
1:09:46 we're going to be using last year's process?
1:09:48 So those of those who voted no one want to reconsider.
1:09:57 The processes that we've used in the past have no substantive changes.
1:11:20 There's another question then, which is do we want to consider?
1:11:31 who want to continue to bring those funds at all, which was not the question tonight, the
1:11:37 night was too approved. So, process here, so if we were to have an agenda process that's been
1:12:32 held for first, city attorney. By the side, three, so I think your question, services that do help
1:13:30 the city, we have a process in place if we were to vote no, those services can come to the city
1:13:37 and say, hey, we need help, or we would like to sign a contract, do we have that in place from
1:13:42 All of a sudden, meeting we say, we're done with this.
1:14:09 The history of the MPOG is such that,
1:14:12 but you don't work that you can ask for help.
1:14:18 Reconsidering at this point such that...
1:15:12 Are you sure?
1:15:35 I don't mean to be.
1:15:36 That's very fun.
1:15:37 I apologize.
1:15:38 Can I ask?
1:15:39 Can I ask?
1:16:01 Is it all the same thing?
1:16:02 Sixes?
1:16:03 Prove as is.
1:16:16 You pass as is.
1:16:30 You are substantive.
1:16:39 You have difference of opinion hacks and journeys as opposed to.
1:16:53 Voices are.
1:17:12 As an organization says that it's a one process.
1:17:48 It is something that I'm consider.
1:18:25 There is nothing that says that you have to this evening,
1:18:56 Pinterest, 6th.
1:19:14 So, Anna, I've assessed.
1:19:43 Is that a whole not as a scene?
1:21:24 I have some suggestions in here.
1:21:27 Can it simply say something like, does anybody think...
1:21:47 What is most a saying program, senior program,
1:22:29 I'm assuming, too.
1:22:50 Chris Reed, I would agree that when you fund it,
1:23:03 it's just, it's not a good process.
1:23:15 This is a great process. I think we need a vote.
1:23:36 So you're glancing already says.
1:24:04 Look at the scoring matrix, one of the suggestions on the scoring matrix was priority
1:24:38 and it was my intent that the council had to say,
1:24:43 serving out the recreation or youth park proposed is really like sorry if it came.
1:25:27 Process as soon as we can place a $1000.
1:26:36 Christopher Reed? Yes.
1:26:39 Sean Burger? Yes.
1:26:41 Yes.
1:26:42 Is that Hawkins?
1:26:43 Yes.
1:26:44 In grade 19.
1:26:45 Yes.
1:26:47 Passes 6-2.
1:26:48 Process.
1:26:56 Very yes vote here when I think when we have staff to do this much work on some, we need
1:27:12 the least the opportunity to see whether it works or not.
1:27:17 That's one point.
1:27:18 And number two, I've said this before, some point way in the past.
1:27:22 But ever once in a while when I'm up here I get a chance to vote with the law in mind
1:27:29 or the ordinance in mind or the what I think is right is in my mind and sometimes I get to vote my heart
1:27:35 I voted my heart this time. I think this is important to a lot of people in our community
1:27:41 I don't want to see it go go away without a lot of warning that it's going away
1:27:47 we could put that at the end as we start budget this year if we don't put the money in the budget
1:27:53 we start the budget very early they're gonna have a lot of warning that it's not there
1:27:57 So, that was the purpose for I prefer to do it in that matter, so I won't be voting yes.
1:28:20 Where's talking to it?
1:28:59 It's zero. This process we've learned in the last ten years.
1:29:08 Thank you.
1:29:09 Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.
1:29:21 Is there anyone who wishes to address the council? Advisory board with council.
1:29:30 Council.
1:29:38 Mavis, and the district reminder, as we shared last week,
1:29:43 organizationally, most of the city functions
1:29:46 will be closed with the exception of those
1:29:49 that are deep de-services for the city's annual December
1:29:59 request to adjourn to Executive Session under Idaho Code 74206-1E.
1:30:19 And so the evaluation dismissal or disciplining of already
1:30:22 here complaints were charged as brought against a public officer
1:30:25 employee, staff member, or individual agent
1:30:27 public school student, and Idaho Code 7426-1-F to communicate with legal counsel for the
1:30:35 public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation
1:30:41 or controversies not yet being litigated but humanly likely to be litigated.
1:30:45 The mere presence of legal counsel at an executive session does not satisfy this requirement.
1:30:50 No.
1:30:55 Wait a second.
1:30:56 If I use the Anakin's executive session as stated as their new discussion.
1:31:09 John Berger?
1:31:10 Yes.
1:31:17 Chris Dockey.
1:31:18 Yes.
1:31:19 Pass the 6-0 with that.
1:31:20 We are adjourned.
Download
- Transcript (text) 35 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 44 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 59 KB
- Audio, part 1 of 2 (M4A) 21.3 MB
- Audio, part 2 of 2 (M4A) 376 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, December 3, 2018. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:31:33.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
a966f16ed8a3019bba6fbfabc5ef3951583890d6b916aadd01772a84898a72f5 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 068f312b0ae5ad01d26c6557890a722576baf1a1f61a4fc67341fa689899d7ee
part02.m4a b4809a1f847a610ef1c3327049349f613e7bff7f75307f124e3ccf977de1979b - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
7dbaa284a37a1888fa06ffec750d2d57a8ee07f9212b3ee242a1a1f3d386d578
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file