OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 22, 2018

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: a,c

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.

Transcript

0:02:34 and Falls City Council for Monday, October 22nd.

0:02:38 It is five o'clock and confirm that we do have a quorum

0:02:40 and the council, all seven members are here this evening.

0:02:43 The first item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:02:46 For those of you wishing to join us, please rise.

0:03:11 Next on the agenda, we have Proclamation's

0:03:13 and this evening, we have a Proclamation

0:03:15 for Rotary International.

0:03:18 Whereas Rotary International founded on February 23rd,

0:03:21 1905 in Chicago, Illinois, is the world's first

0:03:25 and one of the largest nonprofit service organizations.

0:03:28 And whereas there are over 1.2 million rotary club members

0:03:32 comprised of professional and business leaders

0:03:34 in over 35,000 clubs in 200 countries and geographic areas.

0:03:39 And whereas the rotary motto's service above self

0:03:42 inspires members to provide humanitarian service,

0:03:45 encourage high ethical standards,

0:03:47 and promote goodwill and peace in the world.

0:03:50 And whereas rotary in 1985 launched polio plus

0:03:54 and spearhead of the Global Polio Eradication Initiative,

0:03:57 which today includes the World Health Organization,

0:04:00 US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, UNICEF,

0:04:03 and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation

0:04:06 to immunize the children of the world against polio.

0:04:09 And whereas polio cases have dropped by 99.9% since 1988,

0:04:14 and the world stands on the threshold

0:04:16 of eradicating the disease.

0:04:18 And whereas to date, rotary has contributed

0:04:20 more than $1.8 billion in countless volunteer

0:04:24 powers to the protection of more than two and a half billion children in 122 companies,

0:04:30 whereas Rotary is currently working to raise an additional $50 million per year, which would

0:04:35 be further leveraged for maximum impact by an additional $100 million annually from the

0:04:40 Villain-Linda Gates Foundation, whereas these efforts are providing much-needed operational

0:04:45 support, medical personnel, laboratory equipment, and educational materials for health workers

0:04:50 and parents.

0:04:51 Whereas in addition, Rotary has played a major role in decisions by donor governments to contribute more than $8 billion to the effort.

0:04:58 And whereas there are over 155 Rotary Club members in three clubs throughout this city sponsoring service projects to address such critical issues as poverty, health, hunger, illiteracy, and the environment in their local communities abroad.

0:05:14 Therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim October 24th as World Polio Day in Twin Falls, and encourage all citizens to join myself and Rotary International in the fight for a polio free world.

0:05:29 We have several members of those of multiple Rotary Clubs here in Twin Falls here this evening to accept this proclamation. If you want to please come forward, I'll meet you down there.

0:05:38 I know it's going to rain tonight, so do it tomorrow.

0:06:45 Or do it twice.

0:06:46 Yeah, or do it twice, do it tonight, do it tomorrow.

0:06:49 And then Wednesday evening at Anchor,

0:06:52 contribute to polio.

0:06:58 You tell all the Rotarians for all that you do in our community.

0:07:08 Rotarians can stay for the rest of the city council meeting.

0:07:12 They would say they would enjoy that, but the first one is,

0:07:17 is it the truth?

0:07:20 Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.

0:07:24 If there is anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council on an item that is not on the agenda this evening

0:07:31 Now is your opportunity to please come forward

0:07:33 Yes, sir, please introduce yourself

0:08:32 [Muted for privacy: street address]

0:08:40 [Muted for privacy: street address]

0:08:46 in that area. Massive facility going in next door to it approximately seven acres.

0:08:52 I understand the owner of the facility that needed this person,

0:09:33 an inexpensive thing to do, but that'll be sound way to this new facility.

0:09:52 The facility half the size of a football field.

0:10:02 Door all the run-off from this facility on the edge of a free-flowing

0:10:09 spring-fed stream or flow into that stream, yeah, but I assume that's coming.

0:10:16 The water table in this area is about 5' deep and they're already into the water from this huge facility.

0:10:26 It's all going to the city system on this 7-acre facility, which is supposed to be paved.

0:10:39 I went to regulations to report on a Iowa City regulations at all.

0:11:00 Pawn that I would assume is similar to other ponds in the city, which are not federally compliant.

0:11:13 at this time in speaking with various departments in the city I've discovered that the city is

0:11:18 trying to upgrade to the federal aid and standard and eliminate. This one also happens to fall

0:11:31 within less than 75 feet of a domestic well, services, six businesses or residences. And

0:11:38 also in very close proximity to a women's shelter, gap center, the urn sewer, the process

0:12:11 That's right now, I'm acquiring plans from itself so we can see why this mosquito pond is replacing what was done on the other, not only sound, albeit expensive, before they started.

0:12:27 And I had to slip this one in and mentally sound.

0:12:35 This facility is probably two to three times as being the other one.

0:12:39 It is designed mainly for outdoor storage of boats and RVs, which are going to have holding tanks and all kinds of things that could lead to fuel and sewage.

0:12:48 and sewage, which will all be flushed directly into this pond, called a mosquito pond.

0:12:57 And it puts the maintenance of that pond up to the city of Twin Falls, and they're right next to the mosquito abatement and fish in there, and we could take spare shit and not maintain mister.

0:14:00 I also understand that water resources in the DEQ pond system are impossible, oh, and discharge into the free flowing stream.

0:14:19 But that's something else that needs looked into.

0:14:22 I just wanted to bring this issue before the council, but I matter seriously.

0:15:05 To the council's attention, it sounds as if you've already contacted the city departments and there were of your concerns and looking into that, it will certainly be seconded by Nicky Consent Calendar 7-0.

0:16:22 You were here for the Voices Against Violence Candlelight Visual Special Event Application that was just approved as part of the Consent Calendar.

0:16:32 Welcome to Stick Around though.

0:16:34 Next on the agenda are items of consideration.

0:16:37 The first is request to approve the CH2M Jacobs

0:16:40 Yearly Contract Amendment.

0:16:42 We have Jason Brown, our environmental engineer,

0:16:45 welcome Jason.

0:16:50 Members, appreciate this opportunity to come before you.

0:16:54 We try to do this on a regular basis in this amendment

0:16:59 asking that the council approve the mayor decide

0:17:03 the council packet this year.

0:17:06 There was a during the budget process.

0:17:09 realized that the budget contract amount needed was a 2.75% increase. And that was due

0:17:19 mainly to the cost of chemicals in the contract or in the, that we use at the wastewater treatment

0:17:26 plant. So, Jacobs has a national contract with products have gone up and so the majority

0:17:36 of that increase in that contract. And so the, the contracted amount that Jacobs, the

0:17:48 contract with Jacob's would be $3,155,545 requests is that council approved that

0:17:58 so this the mayor can sign that up. Chris talking to the answer to that question. I'd probably I'd probably step into into something I don't know anything about so so there are two

0:18:40 different statutes that could be involved with this the the public bidding statute provides an exemption for done by

0:18:49 and professional services which this would be services the other one is

0:18:58 continuous is also accepted

0:19:05 talking to yes

0:20:44 thank you boy yes

0:20:48 since 7-0 and we have some folks from CH2M here so thank you, general work you do in the partnership

0:20:56 thanks for it's next on the agenda is a request to purchase a sludge truck chassis for wastewater treatment

0:21:06 plan using wastewater reserve funds and again we have

0:21:09 Thank you, Mayor, Council members.

0:21:15 So this, this particular one has a little bit of unique stories.

0:21:19 So we actually budgeted for a chassis in last year's budget,

0:21:24 and felt that it was on our part that we'd hold off on bidding

0:21:29 that until we kind of understood some of the year

0:21:31 of the operation, caused out the wastewater treatment plan.

0:21:34 Once it got closer to the end of the fiscal year,

0:21:37 we realized that we wouldn't have enough time

0:21:39 to properly bid and competitively bid that chassis.

0:21:44 And so tonight asking for the council

0:21:46 to approve city staff to advertise

0:21:51 and then sign a contract with the winning bidder

0:21:57 for a new truck chassis.

0:22:00 What this truck chassis helps us do

0:22:02 with the wastewater treatment plan

0:22:03 is remove biosolids from and do some land application

0:22:09 according to our biosolids permit

0:22:11 and we've been down one truck, and so this would help us get back to a more complete fleet

0:22:20 with finance and Lori Race at our Reserve Expense would be coming fun.

0:22:32 So we've talked to finance and had a conversation.

0:22:35 And so tonight asking you to allow staff to talk chassis.

0:22:43 And with that, I'll stand for any questions.

0:22:46 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:22:47 Jason, where are we then?

0:22:49 So it just over time trucks wear out and it just happened to be that this one wore out a little bit quicker.

0:22:57 Most of our fleet is approaching 20 years old.

0:23:00 And so with these types of load we typically run these twice a year really heavy.

0:23:06 So you land a ply, biosolids in the spring, and then you also do it right before the winter really sets in.

0:23:14 the winter isn't as heavy as the one in the spring and so what we're trying to

0:23:17 do is gear up for the spring because it's simple. Yeah so a lot of it was just

0:23:42 to help with that process and cutting down if you want me to come back I have

0:23:46 no problem coming back and presenting those to the council so this was just

0:23:51 hopefully to streamline a little bit of that process but it was just absolutely

0:23:58 I think extremely personally that's what we budgeted last year

0:24:22 So it was the same budgeted amount is what we what we had done last year

0:24:27 They could come in different we have some older

0:24:33 Chassis that will end up going through as a part of the bid as a salvage price

0:24:37 And so we're hoping that that helps us get a better price

0:24:40 That then the truck manufacturer can use those as salvage rebuild them on their side

0:24:45 And so that helps us turn down the cost but 130,000 truly was what we had put in the budget for this piece of equipment

0:24:54 Yeah, but there is a chance that the bids could be different

0:24:58 Struck chassis, I thought a reserve funds to pay for it and the ones are steamed brands that I'd like to see it come back as we went

0:25:26 You had to be actually awarded a second

0:25:31 Who is Paris?

0:25:52 Yes

0:25:53 Mr. Fareed?

0:25:54 Yes

0:25:55 Thank you very much, I'll leave the contracts with Amy and agenda is a request to approve

0:26:15 ordinance O 2018-19 for the purchase of purpose of annexing property located at 630 Hankham's

0:26:22 located at 630 Hankham's Road in south,

0:26:26 which Jonathan spent a lot of.

0:26:32 Steve O'Connor, city planner.

0:26:36 The games from here, city council members.

0:26:39 So this is a request to approve the ordinance

0:26:42 for the annexation of the 48 years off of Hinkham's Road

0:26:44 south.

0:26:46 It's a little bit of background on August 14th, 2018,

0:26:49 the Planning and Zoning Commission approved

0:26:50 or recommended approval of positive recommendation

0:26:53 for the annexation with the zoning designation of M2

0:26:56 on the property.

0:26:58 And then on September 10th, City Council approved the annexation with the zoning

0:27:02 designation of M2 for the property located at ZX30.

0:27:05 He can throw himself.

0:27:07 So in order for in order to enact this ordinance today, City Council would need

0:27:11 to suspend the rules and place it on third and final reading by motion and

0:27:15 majority consent.

0:27:17 A little bit of regulatory impact that this will have since the property was in

0:27:22 the area of impact and agriculture really used pretty much only titled hand

0:27:26 applied to this piece of property.

0:27:29 This annexation will change this

0:27:30 and bring this entire piece of property

0:27:32 under the full title of the city code.

0:27:38 Inclusion as directed by city council,

0:27:40 staff has prepared an ordinance

0:27:42 for the final annexation process.

0:28:09 Okay, boy, seconded by awesome place ordinance 2018-19

0:28:14 and third and final reading.

0:28:16 Only as they're in discussion.

0:28:23 Christopher Reed.

0:28:24 Yes.

0:28:27 Yes.

0:28:30 Duncan's.

0:28:31 Yes.

0:28:32 Great landing.

0:28:33 Yes.

0:28:33 I should pass this as 7-0.

0:28:36 Ordinance number 2018-1-2018

0:28:43 to the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho,

0:28:49 annexing certain real property below described,

0:28:52 providing the zoning classification therefore,

0:28:56 the necessary area of impact and zoning districts, map it.

0:29:05 A passage of 5-10 seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve

0:29:14 ordinance 2018-19, is there any discussion?

0:29:18 7-0.

0:29:38 Next on the agenda is a request to add subsection F to Twin Falls City Code 8-7-5 Airport Traffic and Parking Regulations.

0:29:48 We have Sean Stanley, our Code Enforcement Coordinator.

0:29:51 Three months ago, Mr. Cartman and his staff were in one city.

0:30:10 We said absolutely.

0:30:11 We're already set up to do it. Our software is set up just like it is for downtown.

0:30:18 Title 7 and so at subsection F which is consistent with the parking regulations, the parking fines for all the downtown parking lots, and throughout the city of Dune Falls, which would be more consistent.

0:31:08 agency versus a general citizen who's parking and legal agency. The car rental

0:32:17 agency would be liable for the ticket or the person who rented the car if they're

0:32:22 flying out of state. I would say the car long is their part there for less than

0:32:33 two hours they're fine for the city code. I'm not speaking from personal experience

0:32:39 but my understanding is that if the car rental agency gets a ticket they tend to

0:32:45 track down the consumer who had rented their car to get that money at some point

0:32:50 and it goes to the questions for Sean.

0:33:10 Sean, is it the possibility that the previous one

0:33:13 was more modeled after places of health

0:33:17 pay for parking in their airports?

0:33:19 I'm a gym, I might be able to,

0:33:21 or Mr. Carper, my belt is just there.

0:33:23 Because there you might,

0:33:26 it might be just worth it to take the ticket

0:33:28 to park in some place you shouldn't.

0:33:30 If it's just a normal parking fine,

0:33:32 but if you have stiffer families,

0:33:33 as I think of like Boise Airport,

0:33:35 where they're parking garages,

0:33:38 So much a day, and maybe it's just cheaper to pull in for your own overnight flight.

0:33:42 That's why it needs different penalties.

0:33:44 And on the previously, I'm not sure we don't, we don't, our parking is free, so obviously,

0:33:50 that doesn't make sense for us.

0:33:52 But, uh, I could feel that when Prankett was purely at oversight.

0:33:58 I think in the airport, section, and, so I think it was an oversight.

0:34:12 Billy goes to show, historically, we haven't written relations.

0:34:25 We don't see this desire that we have to certainly welcome them.

0:34:38 If you see historically that the cursor atmosphere down there,

0:34:56 which is trying to...

0:35:01 Chris talking about song time.

0:35:17 And so we're going to study ordinances by,

0:35:24 but it's also kind of the sensitive area.

0:35:28 We're going to 875, we're going to 2nd.

0:35:59 I've been 2nd by Chris Reed to add subsection F,

0:36:02 Twin Falls City Co.

0:36:09 I'm sorry, I didn't see that it was coordinates.

0:36:11 by Chris Reed to place ordinance 2018-21 on 3rd and final the rules is there any yes yes

0:36:56 yes yes passes 7-0 or it's 2018-21 an ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls

0:37:15 Idaho amending Twin Falls City Code 8-7-5 by adding a new subsection F providing penalties

0:37:23 for parking violations at Joslin Field Magic Valley Regional for Reed seconded by Greg

0:37:49 to approve Ordinance 2018-21 as their discussion.

0:37:54 Yes, Mr. 7-0.

0:38:10 Next on the agenda is a request to ratify these city manager and human resource directors

0:38:23 proposal to create a retention compensation program in Resource Director Grecian Scott.

0:38:31 August, I presented to you a focus area, eight things that we would do, boys and their

0:40:22 The last seven budget sessions and years, the council has remained steadfast in your commitment.

0:40:44 The state will increase our general salary table by 46% and the average employee wage by 0.6%.

0:41:02 In August, when salaries were released, several of our competitors of our salary table by 1%.

0:41:39 editors are moving their the situation. In addition to our efforts throughout the

0:42:02 salary table and compensation we recognize that one plan doesn't fit all.

0:42:06 With your support we created two parallel pay specifically targeted for

0:42:13 professionals in both the fire and the sworn police department. Each of those

0:42:20 table reward education, certification, and ten-year organization. Investments within

0:42:29 themselves in addition to that and facilities and goals and the council has embraced a set

0:43:01 of values, service, and grace.

0:43:17 I want to share with you a couple of stories tonight when we talk about this issue because

0:43:26 it's more than just dollars and cents, years when people have been with us.

0:43:34 So Deputy City Manager Pike and shared with you a story about a promotional process that

0:43:40 he was sitting on within the police department and that was made from a guest from an agency

0:43:50 When something like the line always come down, it follows as a gray fish and hole.

0:43:57 Excuse me, great insight to your people.

0:44:03 So the Twin Falls and Magic Valley is absolutely an area, opportunity for outside larger agencies

0:44:14 to come, try to attract estimates and individuals that we have in focus area aid.

0:45:01 It also aligns with the values that we've adopted as an organization.

0:45:07 It is a fair program that is sustainable financially.

0:45:11 Investing in employer message,

0:45:21 elevates the milestones that employees achieve through us.

0:45:30 And it fosters connection and teamwork,

0:45:34 bridging seasoned, experienced employees.

0:45:39 Maybe stay a little bit longer and share that knowledge

0:45:46 in the same philosophies that we're trying to instill.

0:46:03 So this is a district of things that you may notice.

0:46:11 Very first group, employees who have not yet completed

0:46:20 their first year of service,

0:46:21 up to four years of service with us.

0:46:24 And that's 100 employees.

0:46:27 The next group have just celebrated their fifth year anniversary through here and now that we have celebrated for years.

0:47:07 But when vacant positions have, let's say, three, there's an immediate, impasse sustained issues that can occur.

0:47:29 It can also lead to burnistration. I've got two examples that I want to share with you about what retention looks like for us

0:47:55 and how the impacts of department turnover ended us this summer, recognize some of those names, those celebration notices that came out.

0:48:11 One was an administrative assistant that left on May 31st, and we had two community service officers, three, so, process crime scenes.

0:48:25 We had two of those people. One went in June. We started the recruitment for those positions, gave us ramp up time, improvements, process, additional jobs.

0:48:57 The CSO 3 position, we assigned an employee from a previously held and had

0:49:10 cover the staffing position that we found ourselves in as a dispatcher that person

0:49:28 because of the shortage of people in the dispatch center.

0:49:32 So at this time, due to the circumstances of the process,

0:49:39 we're six months into the hiring process to fill these three FTAs.

0:49:50 is hired. The second FTE transfers in a week from today. In addition, I want to share with you

0:50:17 a public work story. Sean has actually heard this one. He separated from us in July through

0:50:30 the selection process. Two weeks ago, a process of that in the course of the back, Greg, of this

0:51:10 and my head said, I'm sorry to do this to you. I understand the stress of trying to fill positions.

0:51:23 he is a great applicant. He said he is. I can't stand to lose him. It's gonna hurt our organization.

0:51:30 He can't replace the knowledge he has. I said, so I share those stories with you to let you know

0:51:46 the retention and where there's not simply about doors, avatar spaces, trying to select different people.

0:51:57 This is a problem that we're seeing. Several places have standing interviews once a week

0:52:03 where they're asking people skills, and a match for suitability.

0:52:13 The stories that I've just shared with you are not the positions that require attending

0:52:17 and cannot positions that require they're not specialized training or certification.

0:52:24 We are jobs within our community that we have a rich employment base.

0:52:31 Of our place that I've showed you, it's a living problem for the organization.

0:52:43 Roughly we're hiding in just one place. The organization hires

0:53:01 As knowledge, workers to new hires, what you see on the chart is an inability for us to deliver service.

0:53:23 Next, six more that are considering within. It's the six and the next twelve that we might...

0:53:51 So, why this isn't just one department of service? I've included on this graph people,

0:54:18 those that are reasonably within two years of being able to take advantage of the program,

0:54:26 and those who might assign after ten year anniversary, three years.

0:54:46 So, building safety at work percent of that went out of 16, 40 percent of public safety,

0:55:12 which includes dispatch, fire ground police, 5 percent of administration, which includes

0:55:19 IT and finance, 6 out of 15 of the positions, 27 percent of public.

0:55:44 So this is who we're trying to organization, lead incentive to pass the point with test

0:55:59 and the Armed Services Re-enlistment Program.

0:56:28 So as people are service, even it's made up front, this is not a bonus.

0:56:50 Loan is this paid for performance.

0:56:52 This is a retention piece.

0:56:56 Beers of service.

0:57:01 And that's not just what they actually net.

0:57:09 It's the full growths.

0:57:11 Beers of service.

0:57:24 Five years and in five.

0:58:21 So, that's why some people may choose not.

0:58:24 Comments in the same amount.

0:59:11 Can I talk to you about what better dresser doing that we're seeing?

0:59:21 This is about stabilizing the current workforce.

0:59:23 Beers adjustments are something we are watching and analyzing very closely.

0:59:29 costs associated with this fiscal years serves. Historically the city is used

0:59:45 cash reserves to invest in assets, buildings, equipment, things that are one

0:59:51 time expenses. This base and always liver services without them,

1:00:17 and is investments in them. This is a way to secure that investment. For fiscal

1:00:34 years the city has placed on average 1.8 and the single largest source from

1:00:43 that has been salary savings, averaging $1.2 million, $2,000,000 salary savings, is because

1:00:59 of the examples, the two stories that I shared with you about how we're trying to fill positions.

1:01:07 salary savings occur when we have senior operator in the streets department retire at a grade

1:01:14 eight in the top of the pay scale, six entry level. salary savings occur vacant, posted through

1:01:31 new positions that were authorized in this fiscal year's budget. That's why some of those things occur.

1:01:40 We also budgeted a certain rate for positions to be hired at times. I want to stress data evings.

1:01:54 We budget it just doesn't always come to have to say it's just salary savings. Ants.

1:02:38 To dress as those people who are not as a and not as a bonus as you say, but really as a shared commitment,

1:03:54 consistent and quality services and addressing this challenging or second experience.

1:04:47 It's hard to specialty license or the jobs that we have to understand that we do make sure we stretch those dollars where we can.

1:06:55 Gretchen, you have a receiving tension.

1:07:17 They receive it. So it also saves some tax implications to the city depending on their choices as well.

1:07:25 So for example, employees can elect to choice fund.

1:07:32 What the Percy Choice Fund is to the audience? I know because I have a public employee.

1:07:42 So Percy Choice is the base plan of Percy as the peppermint system of Ida.

1:07:55 So by choice, the choice mirrored to the, so it's retirement savings.

1:08:06 The second option that they can do is they can elect.

1:08:14 A second choice would be they can, so if they are on the city's high deductible

1:08:20 bike of Social Security is not to withhold state and federal.

1:08:44 They're responsible for that.

1:08:45 The second one comes to mind, is there going to be anything tied to, let's say

1:08:53 they're evaluations or whether or not they're eligible or are we what are we looking at

1:08:59 against the second part of that one is if someone elects to do this for years and then we regrettably

1:09:05 because of performance or something we've done we have to fire them are they still required

1:09:11 to pay a back end of the same but is it my whatever's our option since hurting that?

1:09:16 So if they are on an under disciplinary action if there is a chance agreement it doesn't

1:09:43 chance agreements and disciplinary action. So the chances are that Chris and Susan, but obviously if we

1:10:27 accounts to see how much we are training certifications and the officers the training and the firemen the training

1:10:41 to get to levels that especially on wastewater and water we absolutely have to have people with those certifications

1:10:48 we don't have choice. What a system and the ones that we come in taking over we have to have those certifications

1:10:56 and it's scary to think that we can have a chance to lose some of these positions to other cities, other agencies, things.

1:11:12 The one I said especially like is I think this beer is a little bit not nearly as good as the one that the state has put in for teachers.

1:11:21 In our case, it would be helpful to lay retirement for a few years for somebody that we feel valuable and would like to keep for that time.

1:11:33 right now necessarily Boise in there this budget chose 25 shooting 25 additional officers

1:11:55 obviously the fishing home were the fishing home from the tireless 25 officers we trained them

1:12:03 they want to take them away I've seen an education for years ready and for a long time what's the

1:12:10 paying ground for teachers that Boise is like Boise paying more so they would let them get three

1:12:15 three to five years in radiant,

1:12:21 the close of the disbooped physical district.

1:12:25 Very much in favor of this,

1:12:26 I would certainly like our best brightest here.

1:12:33 If this helps us to do that,

1:12:35 all forward, especially if we look like we possibly do it.

1:12:40 Pointy, safe and see tear, at least close.

1:12:42 Maybe not the first year, but only it's a substance

1:12:45 when we're here in the sky listening in.

1:12:52 Thank you as well, and everyone else involved

1:12:55 in the Central Finance Department

1:12:57 in a big part to plan this as well, so thank you.

1:13:01 This is an item for the Council's decision this evening.

1:13:29 Yes, Mr. President.

1:13:45 Yes.

1:13:48 And next on the agenda we do have another opportunity for general public input for those wishing to address the Council and as your opportunity to please come forward.

1:14:02 forward and state your name and whether you're a property owner or a member.

1:14:16 Yeah, it works Twin Falls, Mr. Edwards, let me run through the procedures real quick before you interrupt me.

1:14:21 Three minutes to speak, make my comments concise. My name is Kerry Edwards. I'm here from Twin Falls.

1:14:27 Thank you. Welcome to you too. I agree that the employee retention is important, but at what cost

1:14:36 there's had hundreds have been in the business for years, just like you indicated Mr.

1:14:42 that you had known that people were always trying to steal a good teacher or a good administrator away.

1:14:51 This isn't going to stop that.

1:14:53 Merit-based payment is probably more effective than this.

1:14:59 The thing is approval process is 50% plus one, since when is it supposed to be a board decision?

1:15:08 isn't it? 50 plus one, that means just half of you plus one. I don't see that as being a majority

1:15:17 funds in the reserve accounts. Don't you think we ought to send some of that back to the public?

1:15:31 The other thing I'm seeing here is it says the largest source of the salary savings is because

1:15:37 we don't have people in those positions. So it's self-perpetuating. So we don't hire them.

1:15:44 get more money so you can get more money out to the people that are here working. Merit

1:15:50 basis is a better decision and this does not, retention in the military, there's a hammer

1:16:00 over your head, this is just okay, well if you don't pay it back, you're gonna take

1:16:05 it out of your purse, we're gonna take it out of your, are you guys gonna be chasing

1:16:11 those people down? It's easy to say yeah, I want to be in this program, sign me up.

1:16:19 Now how many positions do we have in the city that are unfulfilled, unfulfilled vacancies?

1:16:24 And what's the plan for the, how many do we going to have here talking about, okay, can

1:16:31 I expect offer more complex services if we cannot staff basic requirements resulting in

1:16:37 diminished levels of service?

1:16:40 I'm not requesting any complex services.

1:16:44 So why do we have to have more people to get, provide more complex services?

1:16:49 It's just a way for government to get bigger and grow and get bigger. And since when are we

1:16:58 going to take from reserve?

1:17:01 The 700 and what was it?

1:17:04 773 is in the tax supported funds. So you're taking tax supported funds of that

1:17:13 $86,000. That's just crazy. It's just unbelievable you guys are even contemplating this. I don't see that

1:17:22 I don't see the benefit in it other than keeping up. You'll never

1:17:27 be a better head with ourselves.

1:17:36 I'm going to be chasing this all the time, and it's not going to go away.

1:17:40 There's always going to be deficiency.

1:17:42 There's always going to be people that will jump ship for a better position, a better

1:17:46 look useless.

1:17:59 And I think it's a slap in the face of the citizens of Twin Falls.

1:18:18 Again, Mike Jones, resident of Twin Falls, I certainly didn't know about this retention

1:18:23 program when I came in here.

1:18:25 I learned a lot.

1:18:26 I was here.

1:18:27 But what I saw is ridiculous.

1:18:28 It's a salary increase that isn't a salary increase.

1:18:33 If you folks, being a businessman myself, 75 years old, I've seen a lot of this.

1:18:38 If you want to keep good people in this city, pay them good money and start with.

1:18:43 If you pay them away just competitive with Boise and Idaho Falls and Salt Lake City, even that's close, they're not going to go anywhere.

1:18:51 They're going to stay right here because that's why they're here.

1:18:54 And your retention program, really to me, with the little mollings I've gained over the short period of time, makes no sense at all.

1:19:02 How many people they're going to take to administer this, who's going to enforce it, what are you going to do when they move on, and they owe you $5,000 or $2,000?

1:19:10 Are you going to sue them? Is the city going to spend $10,000 in legal fees trying to collect it?

1:19:15 Any of them in the money out front, raise the salaries base, pay your people good money, they will not leave this community, it's a good community, it's a strong community, and you'll attract people, a lot more people.

1:19:29 with a solid-based pay to start with and you will buy these incentives and hangin' and care it out there.

1:19:35 All you're doing is creating a quite minor little cost money to collect.

1:19:39 If someone's getting an extra $2,500 for this three-month or three-year commitment,

1:19:45 and in two years somebody comes and offers him a $10,000 a year increase,

1:19:49 he's going to walk, but isn't going to make a darn bit of difference.

1:19:52 I think it's ridiculous in a waste of taxpayer money, but I appreciate your decision.

1:20:04 advisory board for the council thing from the city manager's office. Next on the

1:20:15 agenda we have a request to adjourn to executive session under Idaho code 74206 1A

1:20:22 to consider hiring a public officer employee, staff member or individual

1:20:27 agent wherein the respective qualities of individuals are to be evaluated in

1:20:32 order to fill a particular vacancy or need. This paragraph does not apply to

1:20:36 filling a vacancy in an elective office or deliberations about staffing

1:20:40 in general with the right spot.

1:20:57 So moved.

1:21:01 A Chris Reed to turn to executive session

1:21:05 has presented a screening discussion.

1:21:19 Yes.

1:21:23 As the seven is zero, the council meeting is following

1:21:29 executive session and with that, the meeting is adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 22, 2018. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:21:41.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    d85a0a26b33bccd48a7916f22b069aaf9d0c5f414f0f1dbb6fda524918db750b
  5. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 2 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    527b5ad2f946abed4618521b44327cb8a72009f198a723116b4cda6b6c88abb6

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file