OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, August 6, 2018

Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: c,f

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:00:09 when fall city council for Monday August 6th and confirm that we do have a quorum of the council

0:00:14 as six members are present here in the council chambers and councilwoman Hawkins is joining us on

0:00:20 the telephones Suzanne are you there? I'm here Sean. Thank you. Next on the agenda is the Pledge of

0:00:29 Allegiance for those of you wishing to join us please rise. I have no proclamations this evening so

0:00:56 next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input. A couple of folks who have signed up

0:01:03 for items that are not on the agenda.

0:01:06 Mr. Edwards, you wanted to speak specifically on item 6B.

0:01:09 Is that correct?

0:01:10 We'll actually allow that to come out when we're dealing with that issue.

0:01:14 I would appreciate it if you haven't tied to the issue.

0:01:20 This is for items that aren't on the agenda for the public input.

0:01:23 So, just so you know, we're flip-flopping those two,

0:01:31 so we're going to actually talk about the budget first,

0:01:33 and then we will talk about the resolution

0:01:35 that will take the input before we vote.

0:01:37 So, that's when we'll address that.

0:01:39 I have Andrea Masilco,

0:01:42 Again, just a reminder of input, procedures, if you come down to the podium and be recognized by the mayor,

0:01:52 it's take your name and whether you're a resident or property owner in the city and then proceed with your input,

0:01:57 and we are going to go to three minutes per person this evening.

0:02:00 If that's up, welcome.

0:02:05 My name is Andrea Masoko, and I am a homeowner.

0:02:12 Homeowner, when it falls, to give a different perspective on the border situation.

0:02:18 I work for U.S. Customs for 17 years in the San Diego District.

0:02:22 My husband worked 33 years on the border in Texas and California in each of the border

0:02:28 agencies.

0:02:29 Title VIII USC 1325 of the US Nationality Act enacted in 1952, says that crossing into the

0:02:37 US without authorization is a misdemeanor offense if you are deported and are apprehended again

0:02:44 and be considered a felony.

0:02:46 Customs and Border Protection enforces the border.

0:02:49 The U.S. has a process for allowing entry into the U.S. legally.

0:02:54 It takes a long time, however that doesn't mean you should enter illegally.

0:02:58 The U.S. also has laws for processing asylum seekers who have a legitimate fear of returning to their home country due to persecution or war.

0:03:08 The majority of the children who were removed from the people who brought them to the U.S. have been returned to them.

0:03:14 The adults who actually broke the law by entering the U.S. illegally went through a vetting process

0:03:21 to ascertain that the children were indeed theirs or they were guardians. The U.S. does

0:03:26 not release children to people who cannot prove they are the parents or guardians. Many

0:03:32 young children have also been found wandering in the desert and were rescued by CBP. The

0:03:38 most recent was a two-year-old found the desert. Ice, which stands for Immigration and Customs

0:03:45 enforcement arrests people who are already in the U.S. illegally, at times. In fiscal

0:03:52 year 2017, ICE made 76,000 drug arrests, 48,000 arrests for assault, confiscated 11,000

0:04:02 weapons, arrested 5,000 people for sexual assault, 2,000 for kidnapping, and 1,800 for

0:04:09 homicide. Additionally, 1,000 children were rescued from child creditors. Remember, those

0:04:15 Those arrested were already in the US illegally.

0:04:18 And all people arrested at the border are from Central or South America.

0:04:23 Recently there have been people from China, Bangladesh, Somalia, Pakistan and other countries.

0:04:29 If they were eligible to apply for asylum, they could have done so.

0:04:33 It is not safe to allow anyone into the country if we don't know their background.

0:04:38 All other countries protect their borders and so should the US.

0:04:42 The southern border especially has been out of control for years. It can be very violent.

0:04:48 Border Patrol immigration and customs officers have been killed.

0:04:52 However, there are ways to make changes, continue building the wall, reinstate the guest worker program.

0:04:59 Shorten the time it takes to enter legally, but only Congress can change the laws.

0:05:05 Hey, next day I'm Jordan. Good afternoon, folks. My name is Jordan Thornquist.

0:05:30 I am a resident of Twin Falls.

0:05:34 I wanted to briefly touch on some points I heard in last week's City Council meeting,

0:05:38 which happened to be the first I attended.

0:05:40 I was fascinated by a couple of statements that I found odd, and they stuck in my brain

0:05:45 as the week went by.

0:05:46 To me, these statements implied that these weekly sessions of public input were an interruption

0:05:51 of a discussion of business, but they were a distraction with the real importance of

0:05:55 a City Council meeting was formed.

0:05:58 Some stated that these sessions should be held later in the City Council gathering.

0:06:01 There's going as far as to say that this form of public input was entirely inappropriate and should be removed.

0:06:06 I would like to quickly remind those in attendance today of the First Amendment, our right to free speech.

0:06:12 As a human being and an artist, I believe this right is inalienable and impossibly important.

0:06:18 This level of importance, I think, is reflected by the council's choice to place the free speech of its citizens first and foremost in these meetings.

0:06:27 I recommend that our right to ensure that we are heard and that our humanities above any form of business for bureaucracy is the declared foundation of the country we live in, and that seems feared then of placing humanity above bureaucracy.

0:06:40 I'd also like to briefly implore the city council to issue a statement regarding and condemning the treatment of the children that others have mentioned.

0:06:48 Confident that it will not only be a vital declaration of how we value humanity, but further a reinforcement of the value we already

0:06:54 Attempt to demonstrate we hold dear that every human being has a voice in my extension that every human being matters

0:07:00 And should be treated as if they did

0:07:02 Check to see if there are folks who have signed up on the second sheet up there

0:07:12 Unless that Richard Altham is Richard Altham, a resident of the two issues that we brought before you today concerning

0:08:18 resolution regarding family separation

0:08:20 and then also establishing a diverse City Council. I'm here to give my whole

0:08:25 hearted support. As I mentioned in previous presentations to you, it is of

0:08:30 vital importance that the City Council serve all members of the Twin Falls City

0:08:35 community, whether they are voting citizens or not. A significant portion of

0:08:40 our population doesn't have a voice and that goes on at the City level. While many

0:08:46 of the decisions that are made or not made have a profound impact on their

0:08:50 There are people that don't speak up or seek assistance from law enforcement or the medical community for fear that their existence here may be jeopardized.

0:08:59 It is time that as a city we rectify the situation.

0:09:03 A proposed resolution as a symbolic gesture could go a long way to all lay the fears that may exist in parts of our community.

0:09:12 With respect to an item regarding a proposed diversity council, this would be an excellent way for the city council to connect with a diverse and vibrant population.

0:09:22 and vibrant population that lives in our great city.

0:09:25 It will allow the city council to stay one step ahead

0:09:28 of any future activities or issues

0:09:30 and prevent it from being in a reactionary mode.

0:09:33 It can be a valuable tool of communication.

0:09:37 We are growing rapidly here in Twin Falls,

0:09:40 and it is our duty to ensure that no one is left behind in that growth.

0:09:47 Next I am.

0:09:48 It's going to talk a fancy words.

0:10:08 I don't have notes.

0:10:09 I'm not going to tell you about history

0:10:11 and I'm going to tell you about law,

0:10:12 But I do want to tell you this.

0:10:14 The Merci Palace growing with the Latino community, we are growing, we are not first-generation anymore.

0:10:21 We are second and third-generation.

0:10:23 Our vote is going to count this November, and we're going to be saying a lot, because we are pushing for the Latinos to be involved in it.

0:10:32 And we are asking you to represent us.

0:10:36 You are there because we are part of the community and we are not going anywhere.

0:10:42 are from my heart and what is happening in the borders, you should take notice of it because

0:10:48 those are children, not dogs, not cats, children, and you have to represent us.

0:10:56 That's what we're here for, so you can represent us because we are paying taxes, even the undocumented

0:11:03 pay taxes.

0:11:04 They pay for the social security and they do pay for it, isn't their checks, because they

0:11:10 get checks.

0:11:11 So don't forget that.

0:11:13 forget that I don't know if you're gonna get retirement I am I'm waiting for my

0:11:18 retirement and they're paying for my retirement and if you start taking all

0:11:22 the undocumented they are working in paying for retirement you're taking my

0:11:27 retirement so think about that I hope you can sleep my night because I'm not

0:11:32 rich like you and I'm not rich like the rich people I'm just another person

0:11:36 working making my living I took care of my three kids by myself I'm a single

0:11:41 I have my own business and I can say whatever I want because this is the United States, so thank you.

0:11:48 I want to take the opportunity to acknowledge and applaud the people who have come here for four weeks to talk in front of you.

0:12:16 I want to especially acknowledge the people from marginalized communities who have never come before the council

0:12:23 and who have felt intimidation to even come and speak to you about the reality that they face in their communities.

0:12:31 It takes great courage to speak up here. It takes especially great courage to speak in front of a council that dismisses your voice the first time you actually approach it.

0:12:42 So, I wanted to say that last week, people in the audience

0:12:50 stayed longer past public input and observed

0:12:54 you encourage and be enthusiastic and supportive

0:12:58 towards historic buildings, more so than I think you were

0:13:02 with people who have been historically marginalized,

0:13:05 oppressed, unrepresented, I would say exploited in this community

0:13:10 when they've approached you and instead of opening doors and building bridges they

0:13:14 were dismissed. Last year of air, if you recall, I stood up here with the Bosnian

0:13:20 community. I was honored when they approached me to work with them on the

0:13:25 symbolic resolution, proclamation, proclamation, thank you, to acknowledge

0:13:31 the separation of families, detention of families, and extreme genocide of their

0:13:37 people which this council not only unanimously condemned and recognized but also shed tears

0:13:46 and also held a moment of silence that was very beautiful to witness in this community

0:13:51 that's an adoptive community. Unfortunately, the largest and the longest oppressed community that

0:13:57 is the Hispanic community in Twin Falls in the Magic Valley could not have had that same reaction

0:14:03 from you. Last year, Mayor, I recall we were talking towards the end of that moment and

0:14:09 you stated that you would look into the Council would look into creating a diversity advisory

0:14:14 board or something like an advisory board representing the marginalized voices of Twin

0:14:19 Falls. I encourage you, I'd like to see that happen. It's been a year, there's not been

0:14:25 any talk action effort or reaching out to the communities to try to work on that. I

0:14:31 I would hope that this capacity of growth

0:14:33 that our community is experiencing

0:14:36 and with the diversity and the history of being

0:14:39 an adoptive community that we would also be

0:14:41 a responsible community and form a commission

0:14:45 that represents human beings.

0:14:47 We have them for parks, trail systems, buildings, dogs,

0:14:51 fences, signs, traffic, let's form a committee

0:14:55 or diversity advisory commission

0:14:58 to represent a significant portion of the community

0:15:01 you don't hear from and who does not have access to you.

0:15:05 It would be a mutual benefit.

0:15:07 Thank you.

0:15:08 Thank you.

0:15:10 Next, I have Ibn Florence.

0:15:29 Has not changed substantially since 1996

0:15:33 when President Bill Clinton signed

0:15:35 that he made further sweeping immigration losses.

0:15:52 This is in Gratruz organizations' immigration system,

0:16:05 regardless of their design, state, and local people's lives

0:16:11 and the federal derma show martin to all supporters who respond to the family separations with

0:16:18 well they broke the law so this is what they get

0:16:21 if tomorrow a civil war broke out here and you were forced to choose between staying

0:16:32 a scene certain death or leaving every due stay or go

0:16:43 and how would you feel after presenting yourself to border control they took your babies away from you

0:16:49 stop and actually think about the scenario

0:16:52 How would you fail?

0:16:53 And once they took your babies, how would you fail at the people from this new country?

0:16:58 Scufdae all said you deserved this because you took two steps across an international border

0:17:07 and said a silent proposition carefully because life has a way of treating us the very same

0:17:13 way that we treat others.

0:17:14 But let's work together.

0:17:15 My sister's response because I believe that most refugees, silent seekers, stateless persons

0:17:25 and other migrant populations should prefer to remain in force

0:17:32 to storm its responsibilities to be a leader in solving the crisis that lead

0:17:45 to a forced migration and desperate people seeking

0:17:48 portation and vampiration, solution for you, the council,

0:18:03 to consider now that you have some care with us because I'm out of

0:18:17 where I is resolution, but isolation for 38 seconds

0:21:12 if the floor is set and it says get together and we'll see.

0:21:45 That is all the folks I had who signed up to provide public input on items, not the agenda this evening.

0:21:56 Is there anyone else in the audience who would wish to address the council?

0:22:15 My name is Eshkul Adios. I'm a citizen of Twin Falls and a local business owner.

0:22:23 I'm going to keep it short. My mother was born in San Antonio Tejas.

0:22:29 My father was not. He was born in San Catecas, Mexico.

0:22:33 It took some time for him to become a citizen, and his path to naturalization wasn't without

0:22:40 its share of issues.

0:22:42 He dealt with a variety of challenges.

0:22:44 Some that included physical assault, a slew of derogatory insults, and rounds of deportation.

0:22:50 Despite all of this, he refused to give up for he had a family to support and a dream

0:22:56 to work hard towards.

0:22:57 I understand how you could view this as a waste of time and effort on your part as a city

0:23:03 Council, but I would like to invite you to please reconsider working on, with us the

0:23:10 citizens of Swin Falls on re-wording the resolution that we asked you to vote on or to come up

0:23:17 or to help us come up with some type of resolution that denounces the behavior that took place

0:23:21 on behalf of our government at the southern border of the United States.

0:23:25 I think it's imperative that we work on something which conveys the sentiment that we are both

0:23:30 a welcoming and appreciative community towards those who wish to contribute to our society

0:23:35 in a healthy and positive way, one that recognizes the hard work and genuine efforts of those

0:23:41 who are continually underserved, underrepresented, and often go unrecognized. It's silly because

0:23:47 I imagine how all of this came to be, because most of our ancestors couldn't have all come

0:23:53 over here on the Mayflower as if that journey was without its share of perils, but like broken

0:23:58 bodies that refuse to quit we're here and we will continue to push forward if you

0:24:04 would like my input on this or any other issue pertaining I would be happy to

0:24:09 discuss with you kindly thank you very much

0:24:40 that recently two months ago I found out the recycling bin.

0:24:44 Everything that I recycle for the city is going to the landfill.

0:24:48 We need to recycle it and get paid for it or do something to make it.

0:24:53 Not go to the landfill as I collect aluminum cans to make extra money.

0:24:58 So I recycle five times a week for ten hours a day

0:25:03 and we need to put something together where we can put this stuff

0:25:09 Not to the recyclables. That's all I got to say. Thanks for hearing me.

0:25:17 Thank you. Anyone else who wishes to address the council? Yes sir. A dark spot there.

0:25:32 My name is Scott Rekord. I'm a resident of Twin Falls. I know. A social justice warrior is a person who uses to fight for civil rights as an excuse to validate their sense of morals and

0:25:43 The behaviors of social justice warriors usually have a negative impact on the civil rights movement, turning away potential allies, and generally fueled the resurgence of bigotry.

0:25:55 The term is applied to bloggers, activists, and commentators who are prone to engage in a lengthy and hostile debate against others on a range of issues concerning social injustice,

0:26:07 justice, identity politics, and political correctness.

0:26:12 The social justice warrior is distinguished by the use of overzealous and self-righteous

0:26:16 rhetoric as well as appealing to the emotions over logic and reason.

0:26:22 There are elements and forces within our society and twin falls that want to take us further

0:26:27 away from our constitutional system, away from our founding principles, and away from

0:26:32 private property and capitalism.

0:26:35 Facebook post-compared decisions made by Twin Falls City Council to the Holocaust and the Genocide.

0:26:41 Another Facebook post-claims cruelty towards immigrants and refugees keep spreading like a cancer in America.

0:26:48 These forces and the resolutions they bring before us are that of what I call fake Americans,

0:26:55 that want illegal aliens to benefit from the laws that grant them asylum at the border,

0:27:01 but not the laws that allow them to seek asylum before entering illegally.

0:27:06 Our Constitution is not a fetish.

0:27:08 We welcome all peoples who wish to enter our nation legally.

0:27:12 The issue of children at the border is a device to tug at the feelings of well-meaning Americans

0:27:17 and seeks as its main goal to undermine our laws.

0:27:22 The resolution brought before this council previously seeks to validate the activities of law-breaking aliens.

0:27:29 But this is not really their point.

0:27:33 The resolution is a preliminary device that sees the breakdown of our will and as such

0:27:38 there will be more.

0:27:39 This will never stop until our walls are broken down and there is no longer in America.

0:27:45 What follows is anarchy.

0:27:48 Interestingly, too well in great cultures within our borders, you never actually hear

0:27:53 about East Indians in the Chinese, never seem to break our laws or cross our borders illegally.

0:27:59 vast majority of these peoples in the race into our society and we welcome them. Next

0:28:04 week I want to speak about white privilege, the week after I'll talk about social appropriation,

0:28:09 and then we can talk about racism because I'm not going away.

0:28:14 Thank you Mr. Wreckard. Does anyone else who wishes to address the council? A minute of

0:28:30 last week's meeting has councilmen talked about consent calendar, the exception of the

0:28:55 consent calendar with the exception of the minutes.

0:28:58 Is there any discussion?

0:28:59 At least several call.

0:29:20 Yeah.

0:29:23 It appears.

0:29:24 Yes.

0:29:25 Mr. Verriede.

0:29:26 Yes.

0:29:27 Yes.

0:29:30 Seven to zero.

0:29:31 Great.

0:29:46 Seconded by Chris Reed to approve minutes of last week's meeting.

0:29:50 Is there any discussion?

0:29:53 Yes.

0:29:54 Yes.

0:30:06 Yes.

0:30:09 Mr. Verriede.

0:30:10 Yes.

0:30:11 John Berger.

0:30:12 Yes.

0:30:15 As in 6-0 with more for special event applications for the amazing Grace Fellowship outdoor service,

0:30:28 high-rower recovery in motion, the annual beings and things tailgate to challenge those who are

0:30:34 all just approved. Under items of consideration, the first the Twin Falls Fire Department would

0:30:41 like to recognize the achievements of firefighters Dan Gould, Jared Sauer and Cody Lewin for having

0:30:47 successfully completed this year's Twin Falls Drivers Academy, the Firefighters Act Fleming

0:30:51 for completing his Twin Falls Fire Department Firefighter II certification and our Fire Chief

0:30:57 Les Kenworthy. Welcome Chief. Mr. Mayor, Council members. So I'm gonna, we're gonna present

0:31:05 two awards tonight, two different awards and when we do that, if I could ask Mr. Mayor

0:31:10 if he would come up when we do that piece. I just want to talk on a couple items here

0:31:14 to tell you a little bit about these two awards.

0:31:17 The first is a, we just recently completed

0:31:21 our annual Twin Falls Drivers Academy.

0:31:26 Drivers position in Twin Falls is something

0:31:28 that you can volunteer for.

0:31:30 It's something that is not required.

0:31:33 It's also a position that in the future,

0:31:35 if you want to achieve a permanent spot,

0:31:38 that's a promoted position.

0:31:40 So this year's process was approximately

0:31:42 about a four-month process.

0:31:44 It involves defensive driving,

0:31:47 global water supply, brush truck operations.

0:31:50 I shot up a few photos up there.

0:31:53 The pump panel up there,

0:31:54 where all the gentlemen are standing around the fire truck.

0:31:57 There's a lot of knowledge that has to go into knowing

0:32:00 how to operate that to get all those hosts

0:32:03 in operation and water supplies, et cetera.

0:32:07 Fire ground pumping, aircraft, rescue firefighting,

0:32:10 ladder truck operations as well. Process is about 100 hours to complete for each

0:32:15 student. It includes both practical and also classroom. It also involves a lot of

0:32:21 self-study off-duty, not to mention all the time that spent a lot of duty preparing for

0:32:26 that. This year, Driver's Academy has three students. Most of them are in

0:32:31 attendance tonight and they'll be receiving their awards. We do have one

0:32:35 of our firefighters not here tonight, so vacation. So with that, if I can have

0:32:40 these three gentlemen come down for the driver's academy. Second circuit

0:34:29 certification is for Zach Fleming. This is firefighter two. Firefighter two is

0:34:34 another level in the fire service that we achieve. It was fire two here at Twin

0:34:40 Falls. Firefighter one is usually conducted and completed within the first

0:34:45 year of employment. Firefighter two goes on several years depending on how that

0:34:50 individual chooses to do so. So Zach Fleming, he began his career with between

0:34:56 falls on May 13, 2013 as a rookie firefighter in his five years with the

0:35:00 department. Zach has met and exceeded the expectations put upon him. He attended

0:35:06 the tender attack portion of the drivers academy in 2015 and the pump ladder

0:35:10 truck operations in 2016. He excelled exceedingly well in both of these.

0:35:16 Zach's also been a critical part of the multi-special committees and processes we have in the Fire Department.

0:35:24 He's contributed to the betterment of our situational readiness and operational tactics.

0:35:30 Zach has recently wrapped up his Twin Falls Firefighter Level 2, which is why we are honoring him here today.

0:35:36 It consists of, again, about 250 hours of training. This is also, again, multiple as well as testing.

0:35:43 It includes EMT, Emergency Medical Technician, Building Construction, Hazardous Materials

0:35:50 Awareness and Operation Levels, Fire Determination and Cause, Vehicle Extrocation, Incident Command

0:35:59 System, and also 45 hours or more of self-study.

0:36:06 The achievement of this certification also requires multiple practical evaluations as

0:36:11 well as final written tests.

0:36:13 That's completing all of them with flying colors and we'd like to recognize him tonight, Zach, if you could come down.

0:36:19 Guys, we're all leaving. I have fundraising efforts on Friday for the Phil Pudu, Thousand and Change.

0:37:04 And I think you guys raised so, thank you for that hard work, 22.

0:37:08 So, the next two items on the agenda, we're actually going to flip flop.

0:37:16 We're going to have the presentation on the recommended budget for 2019 first,

0:37:21 and then we will take up the discussion of the potential for the resolution to use a portion of the foregone amount.

0:37:28 So we will have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler, who is back on the budget brigade for us.

0:37:35 So Mr. Mayor, before I begin, I want to congratulate not only the firefighters, but also the community

0:37:49 in raising money for muscular dystrophy.

0:37:52 It is obviously something that is pretty near and dear to my heart as members of our family

0:37:59 through those processes individually and what I will tell you is that it's through generous contributions

0:38:07 like in Twin Falls that one day there will be a cure.

0:38:11 We have a disease that will not rob them, not only of their sore firefighters,

0:38:23 for standing out on hot pavement and asking our citizens to contribute to a cure

0:38:32 a cure, but also to help to send individuals to camp and it's important I

0:38:37 think also to recognize if I could give a shameless promotional plug is that you

0:38:42 can donate to muscular dystrophy all year round, not just windfill curse. So if

0:38:50 you're interested please see me I'll be happy to help point you in those right

0:38:54 directions. So I'm back really like the process that we've started this year

0:39:07 because I think that it has given you an opportunity to hear from a diverse

0:39:12 collection of members of our team and it really was the process in which this

0:39:16 budget was constructed. We shared that this budget is submitted not only in

0:39:25 accordance with the GFOA best practices and standards but also in

0:39:31 accordance with state law and our budget if you've gone through it is

0:39:35 It's available on the city's website.

0:39:38 I would encourage citizens to read it if they have not engaged in the conversation just

0:39:43 as you have allowed.

0:39:45 But it really is much more than a series of spreadsheets.

0:39:48 It is a collection as our CFO likes to share of words and numbers and pictures that really

0:39:56 describe how this budget is connected to its strategic plan.

0:40:01 And as we've engaged in this conversation, we have gone through the budget.

0:40:07 was placed out for conversation. And over the course of the last few weeks that conversation

0:40:17 has evolved and we want to spend our time really focusing as you know the city council

0:40:26 in their conversation last week has requested that the staff include $770,000 of the current

0:40:38 $2.186 million into process, at least for a conversation starter.

0:40:48 And so what we wanted to do was to now begin to present,

0:40:52 that looks like as we move forward.

0:40:56 So you'll notice that in the past we shared that the budget was going to be

0:41:03 released from past years, even with the inclusion of the $770,000,

0:41:08 The budget measure that is before you now is $1,628,000 less than the current fiscal year budget that we are.

0:41:18 And as you increase the foregone balance of $770,000, which is property tax, it only makes sense that you're going to see an increase in property tax dollars associated with this budget.

0:41:32 Property taxes do not impact enterprise funds.

0:41:36 Remember, enterprise funds operate small,

0:41:39 like small, independent businesses,

0:41:41 and each one of those receives their funding

0:41:44 through user fees or dedicated revenues

0:41:47 for those very specific and independent purposes.

0:41:50 And so our enterprise funds remain unchanged

0:41:53 as they operate today, but as we'll go

0:41:55 through the conversation today.

0:41:57 Today is part of that conversation in which we want

0:41:59 to have a discussion about sewer caps

0:42:02 and recycling movement.

0:42:08 So this is the slide that we had presented

0:42:12 in terms of what would occur with the recommended budget.

0:42:16 And you'll notice that we also talk

0:42:18 about how the recommended budget and taxable value

0:42:25 of the community tax tax rate.

0:42:30 That tax rate, as we've shared, is a simple multiplier.

0:42:33 And it's important to understand how that multiplier

0:42:36 is leveraged against the individual properties

0:42:39 within the site of the City of Twin Falls.

0:42:41 as we've shared, this is what has occurred to property values inside of the City of Twin Falls

0:42:46 over the course of the last decade. What is important to recognize is also is that this is a snapshot.

0:42:53 This is something that is too as an illustrative purpose only. It is not

0:43:02 every single home inside of the City of Twin Falls and or is it indication of what was really

0:43:12 important is that while we are talking globally digital circumstances that may

0:43:22 vary significantly either positively or negatively from the discussions that we

0:43:28 have and so with that was we fair ourselves to what we look like inside of

0:43:38 the city of Twin Falls and this is a slide that we have shown previously and

0:43:42 you'll notice that inside of the city of Twin Falls when you apply the tax rate

0:43:47 for fiscal year 2018, and do you apply the median property value for 2017? This is the

0:43:56 tax residential. These all assume that they are on it illustrates where the city of Twin

0:44:17 Falls is moving forward. And what's important is this slide does not illustrate $770,000

0:44:31 inclusion of the foregone ballot in a second. So this is really that place to begin to look,

0:44:41 and this is where we start to include some new information based upon the conversations that we've

0:44:46 had up to this point. You'll notice that if we take a property that had a total value inside of

0:44:54 the city of Twin Falls, that was owner-occupy numbers that were provided to us by Zillow, and we

0:45:02 We say that that median old man's side of the city of Twin Falls is $163,000.

0:45:08 We apply at the tax rate of $7.43 per $1,000 of value.

0:45:14 You notice that there's a tax high in the city of Twin Ignizes that everything that we

0:45:23 share here is only the city of Twin Falls.

0:45:27 We focus on only the city of Twin Falls because we have absolutely no control over what any

0:45:32 of the other taxing entities do.

0:45:34 If there's a concern over what other taxing entities do, we encourage our citizens to also engage in those processes as they've engaged in ours.

0:45:42 So you'll notice that the recommended budget that came forward had a tax rate that did not include any of the four-gun balance of $7.33.

0:45:51 with the inclusion of $770,000 that tax rate grows to $7.60,

0:45:58 and you can see what that impact is on those individual properties.

0:46:04 And you'll notice that the impact tax rate has less to do with the increase in the

0:46:12 and the comparison to the increase in the assessed value.

0:46:18 I'm in joke because we did in both examples

0:46:20 of fiscal year 19, we $178,000 value of those.

0:46:28 And so it really is a focus on the multiplier.

0:46:33 It's based, like when you take a look

0:46:38 at what is that monthly burden and changes on water

0:46:42 and sewer remains the same.

0:46:44 And this is a real example on a median house.

0:46:47 You'll notice that their property,

0:46:49 their total monthly bill, if you will, to live inside of the city of Twin Falls compared

0:46:54 to fiscal year 2008, decreased by under $10 a month. It is a difference of $2 in comparison

0:47:04 to the budget that was proposed. So if I scroll back, we focus on a $7.60 or a $676

0:47:20 total city tax load. You'll notice that we don't necessarily change places yet that we still

0:47:33 fall below NAPPA. So $6 and $676 NAPPA which is just above Twin Falls is at 7. You'll notice

0:47:54 that while there is an increase our total positioning on this chart with the include does not illustrate

0:48:10 the tax rate, you'll notice that we called it $7.60.

0:48:18 Since we rounded the tax rate goes out, I believe it's $1.70.

0:48:48 And so then that site that is kind of that site by site compares,

0:48:52 and you'll notice, and I think that this really illustrates

0:48:56 that point where total taxable value in the total tax

0:49:03 collections drive the tax rate, because you'll

0:49:06 notice that from our first conversation, it was a slight change, but this budget is based

0:49:14 upon a total taxable value, 60, you'll notice that total expenditures goes up slightly, and

0:49:28 it's at $770,000 by comparison, and you'll notice that it is all in the tax collections

0:49:35 that drives that, and that's why that's reflected in the tax-supported funds and the impact to

0:49:40 the tax is illustrated in those three columns.

0:49:58 Illustrate, what's rate increase at the 770?

0:50:05 Recognizing that there are still several more opportunities

0:50:10 for the conversation, maximum.

0:50:32 It does not necessarily mean that it is final.

0:50:37 We have two more weave conversation.

0:50:40 As we shared with you last week,

0:50:42 after you've set the maximum, you can continue to work.

0:50:45 I wanted to illustrate the potential using 770 or no foregone or foregone increase to the

0:51:04 last discussion about this last week as we sort of settled in our checks and perhaps before

0:51:22 we would like to wait to hold conversation until you are the resolution in front of you.

0:51:39 So one of the things that we've really been illustrating and I think that the team coming

0:51:44 forward has helped of this budget is tied to the strategic plan and if you look throughout the

0:51:51 the entire budget. The things that we hope to accomplish by providing resources are described

0:51:58 in each one of the budget narratives of each one of the departments. This is something that

0:52:06 previously, and this is really how our organization drives through the accomplishments of the

0:52:15 mission that were validated by our citizens through our process. It really does drive our mission

0:52:23 and our guiding principles, and our financial decisions.

0:52:27 It really is the overarching policy document, or the City of Twin Falls.

0:52:32 And tonight, we're going to have last presentation focused areas,

0:52:41 and those are going to be responsible community.

0:52:45 Thompson is going to be areas that Gretchen Scott is going to be highlighting the areas that fall within the immunization.

0:52:59 Those presentations illustrate how those are tied in Gretchen's.

0:53:03 It's going to illustrate organization or for some more conversations over the past year.

0:53:38 You speak to today about Focus Area 7 of the Strategic Plan Responsible Community.

0:53:44 The 2030 vision of a responsible community in Twin Falls is that of a community that has retained its human face at its ground over time.

0:53:52 New residents are welcome and made to fill a part of the tightly knit community.

0:53:55 A vital aging population is an active segment of the population.

0:53:59 The community is actively engaged in the various public, private, civic, arts and religious institutions, serving the area through volunteerism and involvement in neighborhood and local government activities.

0:54:10 Furthermore, what I'm highlighting tonight is also that as a responsible community, the City of Twin Falls is responsible for the use of taxpayer dollars.

0:54:24 in addition also that we make sure that we levy fees within our enterprise funds that are

0:54:30 at an appropriate level for the services that we're offering. So within Focus Area 7

0:54:40 responsible community we have one capital highlight this year within the city manager's office.

0:54:46 If you recall past budget years the city manager's office very rarely has any expenditures within

0:54:51 capital. So this is something that actually has been in discussion for several years, and

0:54:59 it is called priority-based budgeting. The cost to the city for the first year would be

0:55:06 $50,000, and so I wanted to just give you a little highlight of what exactly priority-based

0:55:11 budgeting would mean for the city. What is it? Technically, it's software and analytical

0:55:19 tools, and those two things together are designed to assist in the use of data and evidence to

0:55:26 transparently improve the results for the citizens and the community. We would do that is by transforming

0:55:37 the budgeting process from a traditional method of line item budgeting to more of a project based

0:55:44 budgeting. Typically government budgets are set by revenues from taxes fees and other charges.

0:55:49 These limits are typically based on prior budget allocations, and they don't necessarily identify the services that are of the most importance to the community.

0:56:00 With priority-based budgeting, resources are allocated to advance identified objectives and priorities within the community, not only by the leaders of the community, but the community members themselves.

0:56:11 This is definitely a shift on how we have budgeted in the past.

0:56:15 It's taking a look at how much programs cost, the amount of resources required for each of

0:56:22 those programs from within the city, and the relevance of those programs to the community's

0:56:26 priorities that are made clear through the budgeting process.

0:56:30 So essentially what we are wanting to do with this new method of budgeting is to take the

0:56:36 priorities of the community, the priorities of the city, and the priorities of the council

0:56:40 and have those drive the budgeting process.

0:56:43 It will allow us to see how our spending is aligned

0:56:48 with having a safe community, a healthy, accessible,

0:56:51 responsible, and prosperous community.

0:56:54 Travis spoke earlier about the strategic plan

0:56:57 and how that's really the guiding document,

0:56:59 the guiding plan for the city.

0:57:01 It encompasses our comprehensive plan,

0:57:04 compasses our facility plans, but really that's

0:57:08 that overarching document that really should be guiding

0:57:11 all of our budgeting decisions.

0:57:14 But the past and how this has worked

0:57:19 is that as we make these recommendations

0:57:21 in long-term planning for the items that we need,

0:57:25 we then go back strategic plan.

0:57:33 It is driving allow us to identify the service areas

0:57:40 that are most important in the city.

0:57:42 I think there are times when we are doing things

0:57:47 that we think are of the utmost importance,

0:57:49 but maybe they don't matter to our community.

0:57:52 And this will open up the conversation

0:57:53 and our ability to have, I guess,

0:57:56 an open and honest conversation

0:57:57 about what we're doing and whether or not

0:57:59 we actually even need to be offering some of these services.

0:58:04 And work for some performance measurement within the city

0:58:11 by allowing us to look at outputs and outcomes.

0:58:16 We will be able to then type those expenditures

0:58:19 directly back to our budget

0:58:22 and hold ourselves accountable for the tax dollars

0:58:25 that we receive from the citizens of Twin Falls.

0:58:33 So shifting gears a little bit,

0:58:35 this is not necessarily a budget allocation,

0:58:40 but if you recall earlier on in the budgeting process,

0:58:44 we had a conversation,

0:58:45 and we've had many conversations

0:58:46 over the last few months about recycling,

0:58:48 and what some of our options

0:58:50 were before recycling moving forward.

0:58:53 So our finance team, Bill Baxter and PSI

0:58:58 have worked closely together to come up with what we see are really the three

0:59:02 options we have for recycling until it falls at this time. Bill did update me

0:59:08 just a few moments ago that as you recall we'd set a cap where we would be

0:59:14 recycling if it were at a hundred dollars per ton and we haven't seen

0:59:18 nothing but an increase in that that cost ever since we made that decision

0:59:22 It's actually fallen over the last month from $175 a ton to $160 a ton, so certainly moving

0:59:30 in the right direction, but we do have some ground to make up.

0:59:34 So just kind of keep that number in mind as we go through this conversation.

0:59:38 So currently, in current fiscal budget, our costs per household to PSI for recycling and

0:59:45 sanitation is $10.60 per household per month.

0:59:50 And in addition, you have the 53 cents that was levied to the work collecting for the landfill

0:59:56 that is helping to, well, would help to subsidize the recycling program.

1:00:06 So our options moving forward are to continue the service as currently provided.

1:00:12 We always have some sort of a percentage increase through with PSI each year.

1:00:17 They gave us a range, and so what we built into the current recommended budget was 2.9%,

1:00:22 would come out to $10.91 per household, those are costs that would go to PSI and

1:00:27 then you have the landfill fee. You need to keep an eye on the market and any time

1:00:36 that's threshold of $100 per tenant recycling would move cycling stream. Our

1:00:44 second option is to discontinue the recycling program altogether. This would

1:00:49 represent an 8.1% decrease or $9.74 per household to PSI. This would then

1:00:59 essentially mean that all of our trash goes to the landfill. There would no

1:01:06 longer be a different stream option of recycling. We'd retain the landfill fee

1:01:11 because obviously the fill versus some of it going into the recycling centers we

1:01:19 were going to increase or decrease and we would probably need to take a 6-12 month

1:01:26 time period to look at that and make sure that we have a understanding of where

1:01:32 those landfill fees would be without recycling. Then the last option is to

1:01:37 to collect the true cost of recycling from citizens.

1:01:42 This one, the number that PSI was able to help us come up with

1:01:46 would be a 7% increase to the recommended budget.

1:01:50 So that would mean that the average household,

1:01:53 each household would be charged $11.34 per household.

1:02:00 And that cost would, but we would be able to cover our costs

1:02:09 at the cross-ear market conversation.

1:02:17 I think earlier today about true cost of recycling, the citizens if we were to recycling at fixed months also on that one so there's there's some level of cost share between PSI and the city on recycling that threshold doesn't change right this would be his additional funds would be difference.

1:04:53 The total number of numbers of the budget if we were to set a maximum budget tonight, a few

1:05:43 I have to say, well, but it's going to the light three cents.

1:06:31 Thank you.

1:06:33 I agree with the others.

1:06:37 I believe that numbers three is the right option for us if there's time.

1:08:45 I've been watching, you know, different recycling projects in different cities.

1:08:51 And I think it's time for us to pick it back up and do what's right.

1:08:55 And I think the forty three cents is reasonable.

1:08:58 So, when we had our hearing or our discussion about that last time and conversations I've

1:09:15 had with citizens, they're not afraid to pay more in order to keep recycling.

1:09:22 They don't like the fact it's going to the landfill, in fact I hear about that often,

1:09:27 so I would be in favor of Option 3, personally.

1:09:31 I would say there is consensus that we have a sewer cap of 8,000 gallons.

1:10:09 That means that no matter how much a user sends down the drain, they're only charged for

1:10:17 8,000 gallons.

1:10:18 Now we don't measure wastewater discharge and so we have to make these assessments of

1:10:26 use based on the water that's coming in.

1:10:32 So what a finance team did was this,

1:10:36 or use in order to get an understanding,

1:10:40 users are actually using more 8,000 gallons.

1:10:46 So what Bill did was he took three measures,

1:10:51 I suppose I would give it the best way to describe it,

1:10:54 low months, which are months when water use is typically low

1:10:59 and it's not being affected by irrigation.

1:11:03 So those months would be March, April, May, October,

1:11:06 In November, households are using 8,000 gallons.

1:11:19 He also looked at the winter average.

1:11:22 As if you remember, in December, January and February,

1:11:24 we average use based on prior year consumption.

1:11:30 So for that measure, it was 695 households.

1:11:34 We're using to see why we decided to take

1:11:41 those high irrigation months of June, July, August,

1:11:44 and September into account, because clearly,

1:11:47 those numbers are affected by irrigation through

1:11:54 and not through a pressurization.

1:11:57 And so then you can look down and see that for the same time

1:12:03 periods and same categories, it redoed

1:12:08 as more than cut in half the number of users

1:12:10 that are exceeding what be exceeding the new proposed

1:12:14 cap of 12,000 gallons.

1:12:17 Significantly that winter average.

1:12:20 And just for, I think, this is still

1:12:25 got one that's using between 1,000 and 40,000 gallons,

1:12:30 which I do remind you, these are all residential numbers,

1:12:33 so there are 56 accounts that do use more

1:12:37 than 13,000 gallons of water each month.

1:12:41 So what we are giving you is information

1:12:45 in order to make a determination of whether or not

1:12:47 the city is ready to increase the wastewater sewer cap

1:12:52 for residential property owners,

1:12:54 or residential account holders from 8,000 gallons

1:12:56 to 12,000 gallons.

1:12:59 that is a more equitable collection of fees when you do that based on usage.

1:13:05 So for a family of 52 that usually uses considerably less than 8,000 gallons,

1:13:10 they're not necessarily subsidizing that neighbor with a larger family

1:13:15 or just a higher water usage.

1:13:19 It also improves our bond compliance when the revenue is based on usage.

1:13:27 And the other positive is that if you recall in our recommended budget, the rate increase

1:13:36 for waste water is 1.5%.

1:13:38 If we were to increase the cap to 12,000 gallons, that rate increase would drop to an additional

1:15:25 60 cents for that additional thousand.

1:15:27 60 cents that were going out?

1:15:29 60 cents.

1:15:30 We're talking about 60 cents every thousand.

1:15:31 Yes, I do think people should pay for a family of two, or to a family, I'm on the large

1:15:49 I'm okay with that, but at the same time I want to make sure citizens, it's not one of those increasing, it's manageable, 60 cents is manageable.

1:16:00 And if you were to be on that higher end say, well you're still getting capped at those individuals that are using less water, obviously not paying for the water because that's who are discharged because they're not discharging it.

1:17:02 And so the question of why we haven't done it in the past,

1:17:05 but I can tell you it I think it's probably twofold.

1:17:07 I think it's partly because of conservation

1:17:10 that we would like people to look at what they're utilizing

1:17:14 versus water.

1:17:15 And again, because we don't measure wastewater and sewer discharge,

1:17:18 we just have to go based on what they're consuming

1:17:21 in potable water.

1:17:22 But then also I think it is to make it be more users

1:17:27 because we have this historical data now.

1:17:29 We can tell you the course of many years.

1:17:40 So I think the idea just being, again,

1:17:43 is a responsible community that we ask that people

1:17:47 pay for the sort of discharge that they're producing

1:17:51 to a certain level in order to decrease the subsidy

1:17:58 that perhaps a smaller household would be producing

1:18:01 for those.

1:18:09 The conversation, this very conversation,

1:18:12 and foreshadowing that we had started our process

1:18:15 for you and one of the three sources.

1:18:21 We started working through this process

1:18:24 After the budget had went forward and materialized and so we said next year in the budget

1:18:30 We're going to be asking you to have a conversation about what that sewer camp is and what that means

1:18:36 Upon reflection. I think that Mandy's absolutely right. There was probably a point in time

1:18:42 1,000 gallons was a legitimate give crescent as a dental house holds that crest over that in December

1:19:01 There are 700

1:19:03 Bijals that had crested over that what we're trying to do and also in that process review is really exploring to make sure that

1:19:12 I think it's, it's, it's, it's stomachs a couple of years in the past, especially last year like Travis said, that we're going to take a look at it.

1:19:40 We had some good firm data, we have the firm data now that we have people that are obviously using over that amount.

1:19:49 We're sending more than 12,000, those kind of makes it a max of 240 cents.

1:19:56 Two to 140 cents, I think it's a, is a good starting place.

1:20:00 This to me is just the same as when we were working with smaller cans for people who don't use as much trash.

1:20:12 I mean, very if they're using less water and less wastewater.

1:20:16 Then why should they be sub-state somebody who's using a lot more water?

1:20:21 And if you look at that, still a lot of people use more.

1:20:25 So I think that amount is a good 12,000 is a good place to begin.

1:20:41 It actually gets a little reduction in there.

1:20:43 Is this going to affect the budget dollar amount or is this an internal change or shift for us?

1:20:57 We're able to decrease that spreadsheet. I could have shown you but you know

1:21:19 Lori has it all

1:21:39 The way you are showing up on my speaker request

1:21:47 A quick follow-up we were able to ascertain that if we go back to

1:21:56 Discussion?

1:21:57 The total sanitation budget would increase by $73,084, and the sanitation rate would increase

1:22:07 by 3.64%, so from 1779 to 1844, so first let me just say, the focus area aid is the organization

1:22:59 of the Travis' slide.

1:23:04 and that is the critical world-livering services.

1:23:17 So with that vision statement,

1:23:28 so focus area eight organization

1:23:34 that the city of Twin Falls strives

1:23:36 to carry out its mission with unquestioned,

1:23:38 intact, highest ethical standards.

1:23:43 In its role as stewards of the community assets,

1:23:46 it focuses on the proper use of available resources,

1:23:50 continually assessing programs and processes

1:23:52 to ensure maximum effectiveness

1:23:55 and pursuit of shared obligation for community liveabillant civic affairs.

1:24:06 The decision-making, the desired effectiveness, the elected later works in close partnership

1:24:14 with professionals carrying out clear policy directives.

1:24:20 High level of competency is provided compensated and respected.

1:24:27 Maximum effort is expended in ensuring that there are two state legislative points that

1:24:39 I have spoken to area and that I'm going to spend some time.

1:24:43 I'm kind of trying to paint a how to change organizational development and major objectives forward, objectives described.

1:25:11 Third thing is about taking care of our employees, protecting our resources.

1:25:17 And then the fourth one is about a directive that you the council issued to us in 2012, choice.

1:25:36 Sense the adoption values into our daily tasks and our decision making processes.

1:25:47 It's part of becoming a values-based organization is a organization by a group, a team, a employees

1:26:05 who went throughout and interviewed our organization and said, what's important to us, what do we

1:26:11 stand for, what do we try to encompass in our work, what do we do through a very long process,

1:26:20 Katie Touche, sends that time which makes sure that this was in front of us, truly some of

1:26:40 the deals.

1:26:41 The book is Area 8, and the vision statement says the city of Twin Falls strives to carry out its mission

1:26:52 with unquestioned integrity, highest ethical standards.

1:26:58 That's a really high bar. And it has to be approached deliberately.

1:27:03 It's not something that we can just do by accident, although sometimes really lucky people can.

1:27:08 But we're human, and we're going to make mistakes, we're going to fail.

1:27:12 purpose and intent of having a value-based organization, one with these five pillars to stand on, about how to achieve that vision statement.

1:27:24 How are we going to get there? They see that vision statement. The difference between rules-based organization, which we have historically been,

1:27:43 values-based organization, where we are trying to get to, is really about the way about our business.

1:27:53 So organization and compliance historically has sort of the floor, no this is where we're going to be, this is what we have to do.

1:28:06 This is the floor of our decision making. As we work towards using values, we understand there's a higher, we can make decisions based on the things that are important to us as an organization that we've articulated in those five values.

1:28:25 It helps us organization, but it takes time to roll separate people.

1:28:50 So, build difference of opinion on where everybody's supposed to be here at 8 o'clock, and somebody's late.

1:29:07 Or somebody has a different clock setting, and it's always 8 o'5, and that's 8 to them.

1:29:14 That separates people, is.

1:29:18 And we say to our partner, 5 minutes late, can't leave.

1:29:30 That means I'm late getting home. It means that I can't make daycare worker.

1:29:42 It's watching my kids that I got off my shift. I'm coming home to means I now have hold of her time

1:29:48 So the city's gonna pay me an extra word because I've been held on matters

1:29:58 As opposed to your five minutes late it drives home the importance of everybody working drives home the mission of what we're trying

1:30:06 So they tried to learn from the failures that we've made and the mistakes that we've made

1:30:18 We try to incorporate those lessons and we try to move forward by trusting people to make decisions within the framework

1:30:27 mission that we're set out to accomplish. Rules-based organization requires bureaucracy, who's

1:30:36 watching who is documenting what, and it breeds authoritarians. I know the rules best. I'm

1:30:42 the one. So, as we start moving ahead, I'm going to have some faults. But we're doing

1:30:52 our best to try to incorporate a value-based philosophy within our organization. Part of

1:30:59 doing that is about changing the resolution, trying to thread values throughout all parts

1:31:13 to the organizations, include them into job descriptions,

1:31:18 how we interview people for positions,

1:31:21 how we write disciplinary actions,

1:31:24 like the example that I just gave you

1:31:25 about being timelings of decision-making,

1:31:31 policies in our processes.

1:31:35 Accomplish some of those things

1:31:37 we have to look at the change to our resolution

1:31:40 was last updated in 2012,

1:31:44 and it doesn't incorporate the values-based model

1:31:46 that we're trying to move towards,

1:31:49 full-based, proposing that we move away

1:31:53 from a historical practice of adopting by resolution,

1:31:56 the standards that we have within our organization,

1:32:00 and instead move towards an employee hand-bug or choice.

1:32:08 Flexibility, responsive, when issues come up.

1:32:12 The current resolution lacks the Y,

1:32:18 which describes intent and provides basis

1:32:21 for interpretation,

1:32:23 when something doesn't exactly match and says it's current.

1:32:29 So supervisors are trying to figure value their appliance,

1:32:35 are they being consistent,

1:32:37 All they have is a pretty black policy, and our resolution current not timely, as I've said before.

1:32:50 And it's missing things that should be easy for employees to find, a definition of when shift differential applies.

1:32:58 It's not described.

1:33:00 How exempt people be in access and proxy cards.

1:33:11 Policies are for when you lose those, what they can be accessed for, who you should let borrow it.

1:33:17 Code for that is nobody.

1:33:23 Things that are needed in the resolution in policies, workplace violence policy.

1:33:31 The only thing in our resolution that addresses that critical topic in today's world is we

1:33:36 strive to provide a safe place for employees.

1:33:39 It's one sentence.

1:33:41 We've looked at developing things like a compassionate leave bank.

1:33:47 We've also talked about things like inclement weather policies when we have to shut down

1:33:51 for SHNO.

1:33:52 So, values, documents that help guide.

1:34:51 to say that they're interested.

1:35:10 I'll let the Chiefs address that function,

1:35:17 but I want to maybe kind of the conversation for you as well.

1:35:22 So we have a resolution in hand

1:35:31 what's also important to recognize

1:35:32 is the police department.

1:35:37 The department, for example,

1:35:38 is going to have a different grooming standard

1:35:39 when it comes to facial hair from what it used to

1:35:43 of how they seal their masks.

1:35:50 And so those are all embedded in what we would call SOPs,

1:35:55 or standard operating procedures.

1:35:57 So there are, you have the overarching employee who have SOP describe of maybe tech police officer to brandish their weapon.

1:36:16 What does that look like?

1:36:18 It's probably for the city manager, at least I'd say that that's not something that the city manager should do.

1:36:30 And so, recognize that there are different rules for different departments based upon what they do occasionally.

1:36:40 So then I'll have the chief talk about the value space.

1:36:46 If you have a mayor, council, um, as the city manager said at the Twin Falls Police firm,

1:36:56 we do have a policy manual within that manual, as the police court rulings come down, comes

1:37:19 out of our credit deck.

1:37:20 I have that authority as a police, it is value-driven though with policy, I would say

1:37:35 with the resolution, the city manager, you know, for example, in the pretension, and

1:37:59 and we have had a lot of employees, you know we have our no shave November, we

1:38:05 increased it to down December, well the the man I'd say the man and women but it

1:38:14 was mostly the man got to where they there's no reason safety reasons such as

1:38:25 in the fire department white men can't have facial hair and law enforcement

1:38:28 parational readiness, so we made a change in policy manual years within

1:38:37 I think something is sporting a beard over there that is allowed within reason.

1:38:43 The other thing that got questioned was was tattoos.

1:38:48 In today's day and age, body art is much more common.

1:38:52 Personally, I have zero tattoos, but we do some men and women.

1:38:57 Previously, we would show you it is very warm.

1:39:09 This last spring, we made a change to our tattoo policy.

1:39:17 Tattoos to be fit as long as they were,

1:39:21 met a racist to have some rules like that within our policy manual I had the

1:39:48 authority to make those changes so that that kind of goes back to our values. So

1:40:00 without saying the same thing the fire department is very similar we're

1:40:04 value-based as well we have an SOP policy we're actually looking at looking at

1:40:11 kind of dividing an SOP and what's called an SOG so standard operating

1:40:14 guidelines and standard operating procedures and procedures manual

1:40:20 We're not following here, I'm sure you've seen some of our individuals that have mustaches

1:40:30 that are further than their face, that is against the law, actually, so we're changing that.

1:40:39 But likewise, tattoos, same thing, that's in our grooming policy as well.

1:40:46 but likewise tattoos, same thing, that's in our grooming policy as well.

1:40:54 The last city that I worked for was actually had an employee handbook as well,

1:41:01 and obviously most of the agencies in the area I made came from also had handbooks,

1:41:06 and it did not, it helped me talk, so it worked quite well.

1:41:16 It's much less cumbersome, obviously, to be able to change things when we need to.

1:41:22 other things that we're currently looking at looking at as well as a gratuities

1:41:26 policy in this I guess it's somewhat more common to who it is to occur so we're

1:41:35 looking at from the city standpoint as well so does that answer your question

1:41:42 basis they're saying gosh these things are really need to have a serious

1:42:38 home home as we know what it is what they might it is our insurance company it is

1:42:45 County's first management program. So as we move into the next couple of the next

1:43:08 three segments I have specifically brought my team with me today Katie

1:43:13 Touche our wellness and safety coordinator Kristen Shuff our recruitment

1:43:18 coordinator today is her anniversary date and is finishing her first year of

1:43:24 employment with us. We get to keep her just in case you're wondering she's hired

1:43:37 31 people in her first year. Okay so on to organizational development. The

1:43:45 To focus area vision statement that I attribute to this, is it in pursuit of shared obligation

1:43:51 for community livability, opportunities are made available to citizens for direct involvement

1:43:56 in civic affairs and transparency in decision making, helping to move objectives forward

1:44:04 in transforming how HR does business is a large part of meeting organizational goals.

1:44:09 We've coordinated several pieces that I want to touch on here tonight.

1:44:16 A part of our armaments lead train of the last four years,

1:44:24 has been to develop facilitators for actions

1:44:30 with formal meetings, structured workshops,

1:44:37 brief service encounters, both out in the field and offices,

1:44:43 over email, letters and phone calls.

1:44:46 We getting the most that we service that we're delivering.

1:45:02 Facilitator training was conducted

1:45:04 to help us promote citizen involvement.

1:45:07 The goals were to identify the types of public meetings

1:45:10 and workshops that produce better results

1:45:12 depending on what we're trying to do,

1:45:15 how facilitators are able to draw out participation

1:45:19 from the people that are there as it

1:45:24 and to let their voice be part of the conversation.

1:45:28 It also included increasing productivity

1:45:30 so that you cover more material within times precious

1:45:35 through the work sessions that we did

1:45:42 through the strategic plan update,

1:45:44 through our planning and zoning meetings.

1:45:46 All of those are opportunities for us

1:45:48 to engage and really draw out.

1:45:52 Specifically, the training gave us tools

1:45:53 to use for group decision-making,

1:45:55 that are the best formats for out,

1:46:00 the results of those decisions,

1:46:02 and how we can increase the transparency

1:46:04 of how we do those.

1:46:14 They use those facilitators.

1:46:16 We have some supervisor training was conducted in February,

1:46:41 and it was a statement staff,

1:46:47 and it's folks that were trying to.

1:46:48 We revisited the expectations for supervisors,

1:46:53 talking specifically about how they are guiding

1:46:56 mentoring their employees. We provided a refresher for the major federal and

1:47:02 organizational guidelines that we have to comply with, a small opportunity. We

1:47:41 also have used the MBTI or the Myers-Briggs type indicator training to

1:47:46 accomplish a number of goals that we have organizationally. We utilize it at

1:47:50 the new employee orientation for our new employees. They set the foundation for

1:47:54 honest communication and good teamwork, but corresponding right versus somebody who

1:48:04 who wants to sit and talk, immediately set up conflict.

1:48:08 It's important that they recognize

1:48:09 what types have different preferences and why,

1:48:12 but the best way to navigate.

1:48:15 We've used more advanced tools to complete

1:48:17 that communication style inventories.

1:48:20 The MGTI step two to help build employee skill sets

1:48:23 relative to specific communication,

1:48:26 the knowledge the various styles that people have

1:48:28 for learning or perceptions on issues,

1:48:34 the information they trust, projects,

1:48:41 and are always right.

1:48:52 The last one that I wanted to talk about is laser fish deployment.

1:48:55 So, laser fish software is really advancing our capabilities.

1:49:01 In Kristen's evaluation this year I specifically apologized to her because I made her an IT really.

1:49:09 I made him push something out.

1:49:13 If it isn't perfect right now, you don't kick it out the door.

1:49:20 We need that. And so I apologized.

1:49:28 I laser fish deployment.

1:49:30 The five step process.

1:49:33 First you digitize the information.

1:49:36 So whatever you have in paper, you make it electronic, and then you organize that content into what it is really going to be used for,

1:49:44 make processes so that it's collecting the information that you need and routing it to the people that need it.

1:49:52 It streamlines processes by removing gaps for tests. It is process review.

1:50:11 To date, we've used it and transformed several of our own internal HR processes, like job

1:50:17 applications which are finally online.

1:50:19 The evaluations were in our second year and were in the health savings account and will

1:50:38 sign up this year.

1:50:40 Wellness reimbursements.

1:50:41 All of these processes previously were all paper.

1:50:48 We've seen major process change and gained inefficiency and we're only at step three.

1:50:56 Streamlined as much as we can, we're saving time of focus and provide better services

1:51:13 to the other departments they need as in order to complete their emissions.

1:51:17 Departments are picking up on that as well, about using it for the special event

1:51:23 application process, we're talking about using it in utility buildings, using it

1:51:28 we're talking about processes like all supervisors and all leaders

1:51:58 within our organization. We have introduced them to the concepts

1:52:02 of high performance organizations and the decision making

1:52:06 processes of looking at decisions through your values

1:52:10 as well as through your vision. We have a leadership philosophy that helps push

1:52:17 decision-making down within our organization and helps encourage people to

1:52:22 take initiative that aside with we're not sure if it's going to be the exact same

1:52:46 format or if we're going to try to use his time specifically our resources.

1:53:18 The focus area a vision statement the sense that I pulled out here is that a

1:53:24 high level of competency has provided from a lean and properly compensated and

1:53:28 or just a second, and in some cases, maybe to the detriment of my career challenge you

1:53:39 to think about the word lean. So, self-balance, stress, your personal development, things that

1:54:00 you volunteer for, patients that you accept, what's full-time, any calls,

1:54:29 apply to text messages, or emails, get into city business, it's not a part of your job,

1:54:40 your job and your personal time that you've set aside for yourself in a

1:54:45 decity time. Any of us talk about how busy we are, knowledge that as council

1:54:56 members are also extraordinarily busy to what's apart. I would say to you we're

1:55:13 busy. I even used it as I have conversations with employees and as I've

1:55:20 heard budget and department presentations to you I've heard employees tell you

1:55:25 we're busy and there's kind of a thing where people believe that they need to

1:55:30 justify tons of stats, differences about what they're doing year after year and they increase

1:55:38 to their workload that are as moved to small city and use an auto analogy we've moved from

1:55:52 second gear to fourth. We're not slowing down, we're continuing to grow, citizens expectations,

1:56:01 our visitors and our communities expectations have grown and we have to be responsive to those.

1:56:07 takes energy, takes commitment to accept what we're doing. We've had some growing

1:56:21 pains. We're working to meet the needs of employees and take care of them. So to

1:56:29 talk about those things, I want to talk about the bullets that are up on the slide ahead of you.

1:56:33 So the first one is health education 101. Health insurance feels more

1:56:39 complicated than ever. Employees are looking for the kinds of education that

1:56:44 helps them maximize and maintain the lifestyles. It's not enough to roll out

1:56:52 plan each September and say this is your benefits and expect that folks will

1:56:57 understand what's offered to them how to take advantage of it how to research the

1:57:03 resources that are included in it as an organization we spend 4.2 million

1:57:12 dollars designed to support the health and wellness of our employees includes

1:57:19 what the employees pay as well that's the price tag that goes out on an annual

1:57:23 budget. We spend a good onding to employees hoping to educate them and use,

1:57:35 buying a gym membership, fail to seek treatment, or if they delay treatment to

1:58:02 best heavily fit for our employees. And I think it's an important tool that we

1:58:06 continue to educate some of the things that we do. This past year St. Luke's

1:58:21 implemented a new rebuilding system. She also helped numerous employees that

1:58:47 were built for services that they obtained programs and ultimately some of

1:58:54 them received collection notices. So when you talk about things that are work-life

1:59:00 balance, imagine getting a collection notice that you lose with. Unfortunately,

1:59:15 each year we do have employees that are injured on the job of navigating the

1:59:20 worker's compensation system, is helping employees follow doctor's orders, because

1:59:26 our employees like to work hard and they show up to work hard. Doctors told

1:59:30 them to sit stationary, if that includes talking with supervisors and making sure

1:59:46 They know that even though your employee wants to do more, you need to rank.

1:59:50 We also have a number of them that are used that use those events moved

2:00:14 department we have about two employees a month that are on FMLA for one purpose or the other.

2:00:22 Those department workloads move to other employees.

2:00:25 The shift priorities may change. The priorities of the department may change.

2:00:30 Within the same work group say, I can pitch in and help out.

2:00:37 They support flow that changes the dynamic of the density,

2:00:53 We rail normal patterns of daily life, dimness at work, so things that we've helped in the

2:01:05 last two years decline in the health of a parent that they're now responsible to take

2:01:10 care of spouse.

2:01:15 We've helped transition and to fly, employees are looking for help, things like relationship

2:01:26 difficulties, actual stress, bankruptcy, or a divorce, or suddenly have to assistance

2:01:39 that they have when they rank up, nuisances like when your identity is stolen.

2:01:47 Those are all things that are happening to our employees that they're trying to balance

2:01:50 at the same time as do their jobs.

2:01:52 It's not unusual, all of us have the same things, but they are things that now people

2:01:57 are dealing with at work as well.

2:01:59 And we help employees find resources in all of those type of situations.

2:02:02 In the area of wellness, this past year and a half essentially, we've started offering

2:02:10 reimbursements for activities and classes that employees are participating in, but not

2:02:15 for stuff.

2:02:16 So, things like climbing, pens, visitations to Yellowstone, fishing licenses, hunting

2:02:26 things that people do to maintain active lifestyles, to pursue their passions, to remain engaged and

2:02:34 invigorated. We want to encourage employees by providing opportunities to learn about health and wellness, exercise and

2:02:42 invest in themselves. This last year we had our first city fair and 70 employees participated in the three-hour

2:02:50 event. They had the opportunity to visit with St. Luke's South Central Community Health and touch up

2:02:57 But it showed us smokers long right next to it, which was very educational.

2:03:04 Tried to learn experience a variety of different health topics through different resources.

2:03:15 We're conducting luncheon learns on topics like ergonomics, stroke awareness, and to go experience a new activity.

2:03:23 In addition, proving the city exercise room, which was in Fire Station 1 and now is in the old council chambers.

2:03:35 105 employees have signed up to utilize that facility, which is a third of our organization.

2:03:43 It's moved locations, we've added equipment, moved to facility, offers more space, improvements are scheduled for the cause of pretty small expenses.

2:04:00 Paint mirrors for the weight lifters of a small set of lockers, those kinds of things.

2:04:04 The last thing that I want to talk to the future trend is to decide what to do.

2:04:14 We're looking at utilizing a total reward strategy with three components.

2:04:18 attractive, responsible, and meaningful.

2:04:22 So, a true your market, is it externally competitive?

2:04:27 Is it something people are looking for that would attract people to our organization?

2:04:33 Responsible, know our impact, is it fair, and is it meaningful?

2:04:41 Will they utilize it? Is it what they want? Is it meaningful to them?

2:04:49 Some of the future trends in wellness, and taking care of our employees,

2:04:53 may be something like an onsite personal health coach.

2:04:58 maybe it's the opportunity to volunteer in service of an organization or a project that's

2:05:04 aligned with our values and our organizational goals. So the last one that I want to talk about

2:05:24 was the Council directive in 2012 to be the employer of choice. And you guys may not remember

2:05:30 this. The Council adopted a direction to become the employer of choice and in doing so approved

2:05:39 for the new compensation model and the salaries that started with at that point in 2012 our data

2:05:50 that I presented to you at that time and our research indicated that we were 20 percent behind

2:05:56 the salary market for experienced workers and that we were 6 percent behind the market for starting salaries.

2:06:04 We utilized only the people who are losing, so basically the Southern Idaho Treasure Valley

2:06:17 in eastern Idaho areas.

2:06:20 2015, fiscal year, we had made some headway,

2:06:23 but we still lagged the market by 9% for experienced workers.

2:06:28 And we had slipped even further to 13%

2:06:30 behind the market for entry level wages.

2:06:33 That's despite giving 3% salary adjustments every year.

2:06:37 So even though we were moving, competition

2:06:40 was moving faster than we were.

2:06:47 So you may recall that in June of 2016,

2:06:51 the council authorized a mid-year adjustment

2:06:53 to the salary table of 4%.

2:06:55 And it was just a salary adjustment,

2:06:57 but because of the compensation program we have in place,

2:07:00 people there were in targets, moved as well,

2:07:06 5% in October of 2016, and another 5% in October of 2017.

2:07:13 In addition, we made mid-year adjustments

2:07:16 to police and fire salaries in February of 2017,

2:07:21 substantial investment facilities, salaries.

2:07:28 As a result of those efforts,

2:07:29 We've just recently conducted a salary survey.

2:07:33 We requested an update to our data of 2018.

2:07:39 We are currently leading the market

2:07:41 and experienced workers by 2.25%.

2:07:44 Three level salaries are leading the market

2:07:48 by the same margin.

2:07:51 We've seen a number of requests for our salary data lately.

2:07:55 That's a sure sign that we've caused other agencies

2:07:57 to take notice of what we're doing.

2:08:00 Recent surveys from Moscow post falls, Idaho falls,

2:08:03 Pocatello, I'll indicate that we're situated well,

2:08:07 if responsive to what's going to occur in the labor market,

2:08:16 we're going to be watching it really closely.

2:08:18 2.6% unemployment demographic here in Magic Valley

2:08:25 is a much different available workforce

2:08:28 than a 2.6% unemployment.

2:08:34 We're small, we have new positions,

2:08:47 we have some folks in process,

2:08:52 don't hold up under the main processes

2:08:54 for some of the positions that we hold.

2:08:58 And so we do, and we see salaries as being in addition.

2:09:18 So the 225 employees that we were 15 years ago,

2:09:23 grown to 300, both has shown us.

2:09:28 We offer work for us as diverse and has different needs,

2:09:39 and this is extraordinarily individualized.

2:09:42 This past October, we offered two health insurance plans

2:09:46 in response to a survey asking our employees,

2:09:48 what do you want?

2:09:50 What benefits are most important to you?

2:09:53 They indicated that they wanted more selection.

2:09:55 We offered a dual plan this year, and as a result, a full third of our organization moved to the height of that large of a migration before.

2:10:13 We listened to them and they responded by PICS satisfaction, organization, and responsive to employees as a piece that I want to talk about.

2:11:07 In the question that we've been used as part of the recruiting strategy.

2:11:17 So it's no longer is the applicant a good fit for us, but are we also a good fit for them?

2:11:23 We're a fairly unique organization, organizational personality, organization, if you know my

2:11:39 pretty structured, but we also have some wild cards mixed in there.

2:11:48 It's important that we match skills and abilities, permits, as well as to the potential that

2:11:55 the applicant can bring, and we want to recognize that in organizational culture, it's not

2:12:04 important that our culture, values, and maybe they'll make contributions that improve.

2:12:15 We want to look at people that are in our processes with fresh eyes and suggestions, people that

2:12:21 are going to help us achieve the high performance goals that we've set for ourselves and to move

2:12:25 our organization into the future.

2:12:27 Just want to say, congratulations, that was a very, it was a great chance for you to wrap up all

2:12:55 things. So that really does kind of focus areas that we talked about over the course of the last several weeks.

2:13:16 Briefly kind of go through relates to the, this is a slide that we had shown, this is, that was there

2:13:33 conversation kind of set the stage to remind those. What is included in that

2:13:40 $770,000. And those are the projects that are illustrated in red and I think

2:13:48 that they're really categorized as accessible community focus area for

2:13:54 movements because they include sidewalks, they include ways to really it is furthering

2:14:01 the strategic objectives that you may illustrate some of those projects that

2:14:08 you challenge staff to come forward with. And so this really does

2:14:13 This constitute nearly the $770,000, which is Locust, on Eastland, it's the 3600 North,

2:14:27 Northside, near Skyline Mobile Park, sidewalking from the Harrison on the Westside and Orchard.

2:14:35 It's the grand view on the East side of the road, those price tags that were included in

2:14:43 those conversations.

2:14:44 At conversation, the Council had also discussed making that improvement iteration on the North

2:14:52 of the run and settlers for the pricing of AD7000 conversations that the council would

2:15:09 like to have, projects, other projects, like to say I'm with the sidewalk and prom addresses

2:15:30 and I'm not used to having this much growth post sidewalk and that's our projects that

2:16:00 were conversation in that 770 things when it comes to the foregone balance that internally

2:16:18 the decision may take the $770,000 on an annual basis and we're going to on your beneath

2:16:33 The City Council has the ability to have that conversation about that $770,000 foregone balance on your basis, so that it doesn't get necessarily lost in.

2:16:45 This is the list of projects that you would like to see accomplished this year.

2:16:54 The list is obviously going to change, and that $770,000 per percent is dedicated by the City Council for the first year, not to take it.

2:17:14 process to take it. All Jews still choose to take that 7-7-7-7-7. So you will be reflected in the

2:17:28 cap process. What we will do is we will...

2:17:32 The drow was high, I think I liked that approach. They noticed that there were in

2:18:01 falls and I don't falls and I had about 20% of the total foreground for the state.

2:18:06 I was talking to all the tax districts, counties, highway districts, the works and

2:18:12 I noticed I don't falls. I was choosing to use about a million of theirs,

2:18:17 I'm a little bit short of a million public safety, which is a little scary, because you know those folks need training, those folks need to increase salaries in the future, and take long outlines.

2:18:33 Our projects, projects, but I agree in the future, I was part of building that.

2:18:50 I mean most of that has been built, that foreground balance has been built since 2010, and we have to be able to save the taxpayers that amount of money.

2:19:03 money and we will still be saving them well over a million and half dollars are close to

2:19:07 a million and half dollars and so the past one time for more projects that we took some

2:19:19 for now.

2:19:20 So we're just going to briefly enterprise funds because those really do complete that

2:19:35 entire budget.

2:19:36 I'll notice that the enterprise funds when you take a look at that total $25 million cost

2:19:44 this is going to be how those funds at 46% to water, 10% to sanitation, 8% to wastewater

2:19:55 And then you'll see very specific projects in which we, areas that we collect a revenue

2:20:09 source that use that revenue source to offset their expenditures and then they tax dollars.

2:20:24 Our conversations, the water rate remains unchanged on the increase of 5%.

2:20:30 It illustrates an increase of that 18,000 gallons, which is the average.

2:20:34 So this is a bit different than that 12,000 gallon cap.

2:20:38 This is for actual water that you use, whether it be in your household or with practices.

2:20:51 It is that amount that is right across one of the things that we often get asked is we

2:20:57 say that it's a 5% increase and we reflect the average water user and is often a resident.

2:21:02 It's important to recognize that all of our rates are based upon the residential rate

2:21:07 in all of our industrial partners.

2:21:09 We also see that 5% increase as well.

2:21:12 Focus here is predominant the residential the wastewater fund and I think that you know going through her conversation

2:21:28 That 12,000 gallon cap does not necessarily increase the revenues that are going to be coming, but it

2:21:36 Percent you less than the 40 cents

2:21:56 Obviously the more y'all's and gallon cap the sanitation rate as we illustrated that would be an increase to the sanitation fund

2:22:23 $74,000 brings that up to a belief

2:22:29 360 is the percent increase that would force, so they're all on the thresholds that are described by ID.

2:22:45 So just ideas that we're going to ask you to adopt the preliminary budget, but we're not going to ask you to do that right now.

2:22:56 We're going to ask you not to action on item C.

2:23:02 Item C, after session about item B, have a resolution process for you guys to adopt,

2:23:23 and then we would have to set the budget based upon that conversation.

2:23:29 We have those numbers for you, assuming they don't change mid-stream in the conversation.

2:23:35 We may ask for a flight recess depending on just to make sure that we have the right to publish it

2:23:43 because what you will be doing tonight on this item will be setting maximum for the City of Twin Falls

2:23:54 and setting the public hearing date no sooner than 6 o'clock p.m.

2:23:59 August 20th, 2008.

2:24:08 So what we will do, because that changes, $69,707, that does include the foregone.

2:24:24 We will add the nearly $74,000 here, and we will give you the exact number if nothing changes.

2:24:31 That will be the maximum gap.

2:24:38 It does not mean that that is the budget.

2:24:41 There are still two more weeks of conversation, and there's a public hearing that will transpire

2:24:45 Two public hearings if you like to use the foregone balance as part of it a code requirements

2:24:58 So Lori race

2:25:15 I said that out in any but I asked Lisa if she would put that so house bill

2:25:28 474 was passed by the

2:25:31 2016 Idaho legislature and it says for the process to be followed when a city uses its foregone living authority

2:25:39 First, the Council must adopt a resolution stating it's intent to use the foregone-leaving

2:25:46 authority, the amount of foregone revenue to be included in the tax levy for that fiscal

2:25:52 year, and the purpose for which the foregone revenue will be used.

2:25:58 So the passage of this resolution this evening covers those requirements.

2:26:02 It declares the intent to levy $770,000 of foregone property tax for fiscal year 2019.

2:26:11 The specific purposes are $274,000 for sidewalk improvements, a 3,600 North North side near

2:26:22 Sky Lane Mobile Home Park and Harrison West Side and Orchard.

2:26:28 $180,000 for sidewalk improvements at Grandview Eastside North of Rock Creek Elementary School.

2:26:35 163,000 for Road Overlays in Stadium East of Washington.

2:26:41 3,000 for Road Overlays at Locust.

2:26:46 So, steps after this will be to publish and notice that we're going to be holding a hearing on the foregone blepee our fiscal year 2000.

2:27:04 My answer is does it mean you have a 770, just as stating your intent and purpose amount?

2:27:15 Questions for Lori Edwards, you want to comment on this item here?

2:27:26 Welcome to Thoughts on this item and several other things as it came up to today's meeting.

2:27:40 Tonight, Twin Falls has gone all touchy-feely.

2:27:45 Social justice, political correctness, values, conversations.

2:27:52 Rather than priority-based budgeting, how about zero-based budgeting?

2:27:57 Where every budget request must be justified from a zero basis

2:28:02 before being placed on the budget.

2:28:05 Numbers and statistics say anything to the statistics class, and I know you can do that.

2:28:14 Make those numbers say anything you want, apples to apples.

2:28:20 This is Twin Falls, not Boise, not Shoshone, not Idaho Falls, not Jerome,

2:28:26 I believe the city administrator in his first budget recommendation, recommended not using

2:28:34 the foregone balance.

2:28:35 I suggest the council not set a new precedent for the city by utilizing the foregone balance.

2:28:43 The city council will always find a project it likes and spend $1 on it.

2:28:52 It's just another way of getting into our pockets.

2:28:56 because it's legal doesn't mean you should do it or could do it or would do it. News

2:29:03 flash, when false is not recycling and has not for two or three months or so. I heard tonight

2:29:13 that people need to pay what they use, pay for what they use. I heard tonight that people

2:29:20 need to pay for what they use. How about industrial use? Do they pay for what they use? Why should

2:29:27 We as citizens subsidize industrial use of water and sewer.

2:29:34 And I know we're doing that.

2:29:39 We have the expense of the homeowner.

2:29:42 People need to pay what they use that should include industry.

2:29:47 $6.62.

2:29:52 53 cents a month increase.

2:29:56 73 cents a month increase.

2:29:58 60 cents per hundred gallons.

2:30:01 et cetera, et cetera, F% increase, $1.98, $1.96 per month increase.

2:30:11 It is all an increase to the homeowner benefits for the city staff, how about helping the homeowner

2:30:20 with physical responsibility, and I know you can justify it, because that's what you guys

2:30:25 are all about, keeping your tails out of a sling, so I would ask that you would also consider

2:30:34 for the people that have to pay this bill,

2:30:38 what might be minimal to you, it might be a lot to others.

2:30:42 And I know there's all kinds of programs in there

2:30:44 to help us out, but not everybody has a homeowner's exemption.

2:30:48 There's renters in this town that end up paying

2:30:51 that increase, whether we're not.

2:30:54 So I would ask that you'd be physically responsible.

2:31:30 006.

2:31:51 10 second, by any discussion.

2:32:16 that accessibility of access issues is a discussion in the past few weeks and

2:32:30 census on pockets yes yes mr. Farade yes Chris talking to John

2:34:11 Yes.

2:34:12 Nicky Boyd.

2:34:13 Passes 7 to 0.

2:34:32 Your maximum budget is presented there in 57.

2:34:44 Are there a second?

2:34:47 Or not.

2:34:49 Recycling.

2:34:58 That we set there, amount of 69,000,000,000.

2:35:07 Part of the $67.00 in due to date.

2:35:11 Yes.

2:35:12 The other, we already have the public hearing set for the, okay.

2:35:15 So, what we also said August 20th is the.

2:35:25 Second.

2:35:34 Entering second of members.

2:36:16 Yes, Christopher Reed. Yes. Chris Talkington. Yes. John

2:36:20 Vericorn. Yes. Mickey Boyd. Yes. Suzanne Hawkins. Yes.

2:36:25 Yes. So as you can see, rates that next week is going to be abbreviated

2:36:57 conversation of the budget and just it really is going forward staff will be

2:37:14 outside of what you made. Certainly we reserve the rise. They listen to those

2:37:31 But questions full to get with us between now will also be a valid projects questions things that you might have.

2:38:05 I was talking to my parents, I'm trying to get some knowledge of these third counts in the organization.

2:38:17 I might have ways past these six o'clock published time of the public hearing,

2:38:29 but request to consider adopting a resolution setting the new fee schedule for Jaslyn Field Magic Valley Regional Airport.

2:38:43 Information tonight, it is budget time and we've got a resolution before you that sets the airport rating fee schedule.

2:38:59 This is a public hearing, there are two particular fees that are bringing for us tonight, or landing fee, or out for us to be firefighting fee, 5% just slightly over.

2:39:12 So with the use of just the first year, landing fee, that was adopted, it was 2014, so it's been four years since we made an adjustment to that.

2:39:32 $1.39 per 1,000 pounds of maximum gross landing weight, proposing to raise that 8 cents or about 5.75% fees.

2:39:44 The greatest percentage of those are SkyWest, they're commercial air passenger service as well as Lord's general aviation aircraft.

2:39:51 They pay at end reader for spline service collects, that is as well.

2:39:55 So that is the first fee adjustment, that's being the aircraft rescued firefighting fee.

2:40:05 that's been in place for some time now back in about 2008. We were required to

2:40:10 provide standby firefighting services for all commercial service aircraft and

2:40:15 access of ten seats. That also last changed in 2014 so it's been about four

2:40:21 years there as well. Post rate is about 6% at $4.25 per operational hour to

2:40:30 So, it's something that the advisory board and I'm very closely over the spring and early

2:40:53 summer, we survey us of airports in our region and I think we're below us as far as these

2:41:00 fees are concerned. Seeing that, there's a new one that wishes to you, try to tune in

2:41:09 and please come forward.

2:41:10 concerned seeing increases that there's anyone who wishes to you.

2:41:27 Trapped for you to please come forward.

2:41:47 Bill, since we received a lot of my federal government,

2:41:51 I know some federal entities pay landing fees,

2:41:55 and some do not get you.

2:41:57 Tell us which pay, which don't, or maybe they don't all pay out.

2:42:05 The firefighting service that federal agency

2:42:07 does assist by paying landing fees.

2:42:09 Essentially they pay us.

2:42:11 It's really their vendors that fly the aircraft

2:42:14 that we're charging, but the BLM

2:42:16 does that administrative they reverse their vendors for landing fees so we've

2:42:21 sort of cut out that so essentially we're getting it from their vendors but

2:42:25 it's coming from the BLM if that makes sense right what about what about I often see

2:42:30 because you'd see it land from since I spent some time outside of the Gulf

2:42:35 forest you could see planes landing like to be military planes did they play

2:42:40 at landing fee or the Department of Defense we don't chase that landing

2:42:44 They come up from Hill, and we let our boys practice in gals, uh, as a aircraft, and, uh,

2:42:52 honestly tracking that through the Department of Defense may be more difficult than Chris

2:43:00 Talkington.

2:43:09 007.

2:43:10 10 second by an after-resolution, and 20-0-0-0-7 has presented us during a discussion.

2:43:40 Bericor?

2:43:43 Yes.

2:43:44 Suzanne Hawkins?

2:43:45 Yeah.

2:43:46 Tink?

2:43:47 Yes.

2:43:48 Ruth Pierce?

2:43:49 Yes.

2:43:50 Christopher Reed?

2:43:52 Yes.

2:43:53 to zero. That's the way an advisory board reports anything from the council.

2:44:16 Adams just enters a large ceremony at City Park.

2:44:33 The second reminder we received just some events for your calendar for this upcoming meeting.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, August 6, 2018. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:45:48.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    7fab4905497e7a813713af935dfc9d6740ae19650090be2d05369a49b3bcf583
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 580b65a96fd56e278b89039871e42152bdff7d65de2d187f4987966fb0df6f0d
    part02.m4a 013112d8b7d10dc1100952bc36cf80d65b4bc962eabca3e75ce7a1c0788e48f5
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    5b08740928563e9c65543a66f29e694b9ece6b6e7965594a00905f192a5ef6b3

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file