City Council meeting
Monday, June 18, 2018
Regular meeting. Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
Agenda on filePacket on fileMinutes on fileExecutive session: a,b
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
Recording
Transcript
0:01:29 So Chris, I'm sorry, we have to go in order.
0:01:31 Chris Reed, and then a second to Chris.
0:02:18 Yes.
0:02:19 Christopher Reed.
0:02:20 Yes.
0:02:20 And Chris talking to.
0:02:23 At this time, I've been remarked out of the seven of us here,
0:02:31 and we run as a request to a Marie Seal project to 569 and 94 cents.
0:03:17 So members, I'll clever ink in the amount of $69 to yours.
0:03:32 Slerie's Seal project.
0:03:33 And where you can see the map of the areas where we plan on Slerie's Seal.
0:03:37 There was two bitters.
0:03:38 And there was slightly material, so we get off some time.
0:04:21 the story so it's it protects the rope paint and it doesn't get as minor as some of our terms.
0:06:01 The red one is on six. It's all zoned six and so that explained why some are four sets.
0:06:41 All seven? It's very sealed project. Nicky Boyd? Yes. Suzanne Hawkins? Yes. Greg Lanting? Yes. Ruth Pierce? Yes. Christopher Reed? Yes. Chris
0:07:01 This might look somewhat familiar to you several months ago, but the first phase of
0:07:36 this contract with this causes also organic. So this portion goes through and they identify
0:08:51 exact source. Once they have the process of a design, comments, or questions, services,
0:10:15 we can't avoid any documentation. Some of them do roads, some do bridges, some do sewer,
0:12:15 So at the very beginning of our process and our process window is about two years long.
0:13:32 That's how long we'll preserve that list.
0:13:34 Jackie and members of her team will send out and make a publication and say, and then we'll also do it direct.
0:14:42 A solicitation of request for qualifications to be submitted to us.
0:14:47 And I have an Introisrite Idaho Code that says that you can only use a qualifications-based
0:14:52 process when you are hiring an architect.
0:14:58 Land surveyors and engineers.
0:15:00 Those are the three that you use in the process.
0:15:05 The team then goes forward and they get all of the qualifications and they score and review
0:15:10 them independently as they compare their scores and they will compile that list and that list
0:15:16 is what they have the ability to draw is that
0:15:22 any multiplication-based process you would have to submit something.
0:15:28 The architecture or the engineer or the land's rare then enters into a
0:15:37 negotiation with our team after. And that's the piece that you have here
0:15:44 when I first read it, where I got lost was in the term construction.
0:15:48 Really what you hired tonight was an engineering firm.
0:15:53 The design or, as Troy said, when we ace that will be
0:16:09 does go into the lowest response, very similar to what you saw on the slurry seal tonight.
0:16:16 And once again, send out a list of people send out an advertisement with solicit firms
0:16:23 through a sealed bid process because of the dollar amount.
0:16:26 The sealed bid will be opened in a public place in lowest response of bid, and presented
0:16:33 to the city council for the construction of that assessment of responsiveness will be
0:16:38 done by the citizens of the rules of construction for a dozen in-
0:17:35 situation with a city in which we've hired an arbor land surveyor
0:17:41 so when we process that to look at this process or siege those are those
0:18:12 exact same processes that we have followed. A reference is there was also a
0:18:19 qualification to be processed because it's connected to an architect. So that's
0:18:23 where we heard the S&R and pivot north to the same process until we do this kind
0:18:38 of process all the time. We might have got a little bit confused in the
0:18:44 language in which we were using tonight so I know the notes reviewing the agenda
0:18:48 statement I've looked actually read the statements and what do we do we can
0:18:53 certainly have a staff work on that and then for mr. Talkington we will
0:18:57 certainly with friends to be able to that process
0:19:10 the city of Twin Falls 28 is so it's just joking with our CFO lorry race that
0:19:34 this begins her happiest time of the year this is just a brief pre at this point
0:19:54 this year because it is slightly different we had some other processes
0:19:59 And so one of the processes that we went through was really having a conversation about our
0:20:05 strategic plan policy that we there's a direct tie and tether to our strategic plan and we spent
0:20:16 a lot of time going through the last strategic plan a month and it was just a few months
0:20:21 ago in March that you approve that plan.
0:20:24 So as you approve that plan you really did help us set those initial priorities for this
0:20:30 and through some independent conversations we want to say what does that look like moving.
0:20:36 The long-term planning was a bit reef amazing work, but one of the things that we did rather
0:20:49 than making that says this is our plan and it almost became like a stand-alone plan versus
0:20:59 the city's core leaders that you have across the organization.
0:21:04 And collectively about 44 individuals spent about process help community because as you
0:21:14 all recall they're also engaged in jobs that we had as well.
0:21:20 So in those different groups you had members of our long-term planning group and our cities
0:21:25 management team process with our long-term planning
0:21:34 team because they are going to be
0:21:36 make parts of the presentation here to the city council.
0:21:42 So as I have the purview that I directly oversee,
0:21:45 Mitch has his, Brian has his, we're
0:21:47 going to have members of the long-term focus area
0:21:54 when the shifts that they came up with in this last process.
0:21:59 We're just trying to do some things a bit differently
0:22:01 so that, I recognize that a bunch of conversation
0:22:07 might be the happiest time of the year for some.
0:22:10 We might want to change it up a little bit
0:22:13 for some of the rest of us, but again, this kind of does begin
0:22:17 that formalized process as we're moving forward.
0:22:20 In the FY 2018 budget contained all of the projects
0:22:24 initiatives that are designed to enhance our citizens' quality
0:22:27 of life.
0:22:28 It is designed to further our strategic basic goals
0:22:34 and initiatives series of additional steps
0:22:42 to be able to advance our organization towards the type
0:22:45 of community that our citizens have said
0:22:48 they wanted to live in. I also say that right now it's very early. We are still in the process
0:22:57 of getting information and so there is nothing illustrated. So one of the things at this point
0:23:10 in time that we do not know is the property tax rate and as you look at the $7.43 you might say
0:23:17 that's a different number than last year which a process to recall is about $7.56
0:23:26 As we went through a taxable value of the city that number we received in 2008, we don't set a mill up.
0:23:49 We set a tax rate. Our role is to have a conversation about the number of dollars that we in office tax rate.
0:24:07 That tax rate is applied universally to all across the city of Twin Falls and all the other.
0:24:16 So we do have control over our spending and we do have control over our utility rates.
0:24:20 And then really quick as we like to share that first story, we're looking at slight adjustment
0:24:27 in water, wastewater, or sewer, and the sanitation funds.
0:24:33 And we'll spend time this evening, and those just to give you a time.
0:24:42 The overall budget is $3.2,000 less, or $4.36 million less than the budget that we presented
0:24:51 and was approved.
0:24:53 budget was $71 million. This budget does take the statutory allowance of 3% rate about $607,000
0:25:05 new property tax dollars. The total property tax dollars inside of the city of Twin Falls represents
0:25:11 about $21 million or slightly less than the new construction value is really similar to the prior
0:25:24 you can see that we see about $52 million.
0:25:27 A new construction value is $3, larger, but when you apply the prior year's tax rate,
0:25:37 we will actually collect about this budget does not require any of the use of the foregone
0:26:07 balance.
0:26:08 And so the entire foregone balance of $26,000 does have creases to 5%, sewer at 1.5% in sanitation.
0:27:20 So what we're hearing are some increases in the assessed values we're seeing that.
0:27:31 One of the things that I would share is the assessed value by itself does not, it's a
0:27:42 number, tax rate by itself.
0:27:47 It is a number, need the two numbers to be multiplied as, this is where basic math grows
0:28:04 faster than the numerator than the top number of tax rate will go down in versus
0:28:14 truth and so what we're looking at about a three percent increase taxes across
0:28:25 the city of Flint Falls reasonably certain based upon what we're hearing
0:28:30 we will see assessed by the city both of those numbers to determine also one
0:28:49 that is different is that this is one of the fears since 2007 that you do not
0:29:06 not seen adjustment in the 1007 was they
0:29:27 the 75,000 and then the index did index fell
0:29:50 to take some subsequent action to adjust that $1000 threshold
0:30:11 because a homeless exemption Idaho as you will call this
0:30:14 is 50% maximum, $1000 and the reason we don't know
0:30:33 what that number is is because there's still
0:30:35 the appeals process that the county is going forward with
0:30:37 so the county will process and you said,
0:30:41 you were surprised that it had occurred
0:30:47 states that believe it's 90 assessors must do an acceleration in the make sense
0:31:10 that if you fell below those market values outside of those statutory thresholds
0:31:15 that you would see a subsequent adjustment we receive state shared
0:31:26 revenues are just in most significant portions of the state shared revenue
0:31:34 formula which is the sales tax distribution the county distribution
0:31:38 gas tax distribution all of those one of the primary components is the total
0:31:44 tax value of a community. So one of the
0:31:51 can say is that we will see a total
0:31:57 taxable value of a community continues to
0:31:59 appreciate as we're seeing and the rest of
0:32:02 the state is not appreciating that same
0:32:04 rate we will see a larger share of those
0:32:06 revenues coming into the city of
0:32:08 Twinfall because what's important is
0:32:10 sales tax distribution is not based upon
0:32:12 point of sale. Point of sale is not a
0:32:15 piece or any portion of that
0:32:17 that 19, 60 when this was set up for 70, and much value.
0:32:51 And so bigger in the state, our citizens have a spending
0:33:20 probably happy to help them.
0:33:46 So the county won't, they will give us a preliminary number.
0:33:51 I just shared we got that in March.
0:33:56 And so when we start looking at that tax rate,
0:34:02 we can't tell you until what that looks like.
0:34:05 So this is like 13 cents per thousand dollars,
0:34:08 less than what we had approved the budget.
0:34:15 We have the state sales tax numbers in shared revenues in our budget right now.
0:34:24 The impact of an increased assessment won't be seen for our CFO who is fairly conservative
0:34:53 in revenue approaches to a projected revenue increase.
0:35:03 So things that we've always talked about inside of our organization is that public services
0:35:09 are provided by the men and work for the city of Twinfall.
0:35:14 In that process of providing market-based compensation adjustments and these adjustments
0:35:18 you'll see are less than what we've advocated in previous years. In previous years, we were
0:35:24 to 5% adjustment market stability across the organization. This is, instead of the organization,
0:36:14 are about 17.6 million, which is an increase of just less than 4.5, which is in line,
0:36:21 caused index in marginal investments, totaling 11.6 million roads and sidewalks,
0:36:32 improvements to our waterlities, irrigation stems, and the shot of some of those projects that we
0:36:42 And it also has us move forward with some performance.
0:36:53 So one of the things that I challenged our team
0:36:56 was to spend time looking at service delivery,
0:37:00 deploy those services in this type of market,
0:37:09 ending the size of our employee.
0:37:16 There are several areas that talk about
0:37:20 some of these employees.
0:37:22 You'll notice that historically,
0:37:25 and I provided this, this,
0:37:26 the employees to be very small.
0:37:36 This is probably things and change.
0:38:06 As you know, we started that transition
0:38:08 with the legal team and they started IS and some of the service that they were getting
0:38:40 was our internal force at three who cancelled the contract and so there is no net cost to the organization
0:38:52 but we believe that is going to be significant.
0:38:56 We're excited to be able to dispatchers.
0:39:03 As you recall, there was a point in time in our organization that we did an over-hier to see
0:39:11 So what we're doing is we look at what we always did over hires and funded hires with salary savings.
0:39:24 But as an organization who is seeing far and less eternal, those salary savings aren't always there.
0:39:32 So what we want to do is make sure resources are known as aquatics and lifeguards.
0:39:39 Those changes we used to in you contract place positions in house to ensure that we're in.
0:39:52 And this is also a cost savings for our organic comparison to the $2,000 total savings.
0:40:05 And one of the reasons that we have that savings is because of the things that we do next,
0:40:33 the process, and are recommended for funding.
0:40:44 One of them is a code enforcement administrative assistant.
0:40:47 The course of the last few years, in fact, I think the inception we had been such as Sean Stanley
0:40:55 John Stanley walking, please, not him. Yes, the Ministry of Assistance team would assist
0:41:03 with that workload. It's becoming more complex. And one of the things that we're seeing is
0:41:09 this is causing an overload in rectal causing and over-enforcement in the administrative
0:41:17 assistant. We're with public safety team. In addition to that, we provided animal and
0:41:34 also in addition to animal control, a sprinkling larger group and was assisted to try and also
0:41:50 to file the next position that passed the review of the team was a combination
0:42:03 fire and electrical inspector and I thought that this was a pretty ingenious
0:42:08 approach because I think that Jared would tell you that it was not at a place today
0:42:15 is that when up goes out and he's on there is a gay service that's being
0:42:31 with the state to be able to see that because of the Latour citizens and our
0:42:50 ability and so without being able to go through electrical inspections they're
0:42:55 at a standstill, and it stops. The other side is that fire and fire inspections are becoming
0:43:04 increasingly important, and so really less in settings for our citizens moving forward.
0:43:42 The next two positions really is part of the genius of when your teams get together, so
0:43:55 we had an initial conversation about the importance of sidewalks, and we challenged our team to
0:43:59 to take their budget and to reconsider some of those things.
0:44:02 And so really, Mark Thompson, and they
0:44:09 were looking at how much does it cost for a private firm
0:44:13 to lay.
0:44:17 And what is the availability of PDAF?
0:44:24 If you talk to people, it is the one area of our construction
0:44:37 area that has not yield since the recession.
0:44:44 There is a significant rising up.
0:44:50 So if anyone wants to go into the concrete business,
0:44:53 there's a ready and open market ready for you to go.
0:44:58 And so our team looked at the amount of money that they had budgeted, sidewalks and other
0:45:04 miscellaneous improvements and they had made air to in-round city facilities that were just
0:45:20 to take that same doll.
0:45:24 So they're estimating that they'll be able to lay price.
0:45:38 Folks have the ability to grow.
0:45:46 It's not seasonable too.
0:45:50 Our Tonsons going to come during the accessible community presentation really looks like, but
0:45:58 of this, those positions, their carve of existing
0:46:03 and appropriating resources that they were
0:46:05 on contracted side, and those,
0:46:08 either in the wastewater operators,
0:46:12 are really designed to assist and augment our teams,
0:46:15 and they would describe as kind of go things
0:46:27 that they do, get the services that fall neatly
0:46:31 with wheelhouses and the things that they're proficient at,
0:46:34 and then they want to make sure that the crews
0:46:37 are augmented to be able to perform a task.
0:46:40 So if you have a person gone or a person who's on vacation
0:46:43 or people who go to conferences, we're running short crews,
0:46:47 and so this would be role for a position
0:46:50 and always make sure that we have the three main crews
0:46:53 that we require, but those are the six new positions
0:46:59 that organization and these are the requests
0:47:04 that in the current placement of workplace,
0:47:40 any of you would say, I'm across your team,
0:48:02 essentially put on basket, they should accostivate you.
0:48:12 I've talked to Laura, if we are successful,
0:48:14 we do iterate at salary savings.
0:48:18 We have salary savings, and just like you saw
0:48:29 the previous slide where we found out we were successful last year and got the cops grants
0:48:51 and so those cops grants they rolled in because we were awarded them and then these were the
0:49:16 decisions that were not the decisions made by the team. They're going to continue to look at
0:49:26 other strategies and other opportunities but you can see that there are six positions here
0:49:31 that the team alike. There's absolutely no question that as we continue to have
0:49:42 of using the replacing on Taddeus's Sean and co-op.
0:50:06 They're all squinted, because I understand the patrol officer
0:50:17 was to kind of fill back in.
0:50:19 So one of the things that happened post-budget
0:50:22 was that Craig elected to absorb the South Hills Middle
0:50:27 School SRO.
0:50:40 These positions, just so you know when they were moved,
0:50:42 they were not removed by approach.
0:50:45 These were removed by department leader from consideration.
0:50:59 So like I said, it was a very unique process.
0:51:03 It was pretty dynamic, I think the people
0:51:05 tell you the first day was a little slow.
0:51:08 Second day, ball started rolling pretty fast.
0:51:10 And so here's the numbers that we know that are associated
0:51:20 with this budget in that side-by-side comparison that we
0:51:24 like to share.
0:51:26 Again, the $2,683 million number is $34,000 larger than if you
0:51:34 go back and wear a fiscal year because that number came
0:51:39 The council adopted, oh, that's, that's part of, that's the reason that the tax range room, before the budget is published, we'll have all this information and we will share with you, because they're subject to change throughout our entire process and sometimes they change.
0:52:08 This is a, uh, uh, illustration of the tax rates that we've issued inside of the City of Twin Falls, uh, since 2000, uh, that some of the property or some of the capital requests that we have is the performance management system that we had talked about.
0:52:59 about $1,000 in the area of information, technology, sand, and replace of parks and open space for parking and facility in the end of $1,000, of course, for property tax funds.
0:53:47 So, remember, under our current degree, of course, what has been said, like we have been sharing significantly less than $10,000, of course, because the support is operation very similar to the pool, so we're transferring $0.6, $36,000,000 for zone 7 maintenance.
0:54:45 and you approve zone 6, this is for the chip seal, the slurry seal and the fog seal treatments.
0:54:52 It also includes salenius projects and improvements in those areas as well.
0:54:58 The prices increase on the open part of our zones.
0:55:12 Then the sidewalk program, we're taking the $276,000 that I was sharing earlier.
0:55:19 So this is the 8-height-front zone, North College goes by Xavier.
0:55:41 And then so it connects to that's an 817 construction.
0:55:45 the construction construction out there, $600,000 for the Castlewood Pi Station and piping improvements.
0:56:22 The $750,000 for the design out of the South of El Ten, that's just to continue to take advantage of the water rights that we have.
0:57:15 $8,000 for the dock replacement. Any questions on those again?
0:57:31 Those are, I just picked some of the cool things or pages of highlights that I could have shared with you and as we go through that process.
0:57:39 I will certainly be much, so you have the Ramadi portion, this is on the old existing trip.
0:58:04 Again, so it's driven by the strategic plan.
0:58:16 It is roughly 4.38 million per cent or $3.3 million less than the prior limiting to the statutory market.
0:58:37 These are from that sheet, kind of just expanding it a little bit.
0:58:40 96 associated with the 40 cents associated, how many ones cents associated with the sanitation.
0:58:54 but there's some caveats. There'll be some opportunities for some decision-making on these.
0:59:02 Water fund is really connected to the bond governance, so that 5% is fixed.
0:59:14 But on the waste water side, there will be some decisions and we'll be spending some time talking about.
0:59:22 So right now, as we share during the last budgetary conversation,
0:59:27 this only applies to residential customers. So think only residential in this piece.
0:59:34 So we have roughly 10,052 residential customers on our system.
0:59:45 We have an 8,000 gallons of what that means is that as your water meter spins up to 8,000
0:59:54 gallons, we stop billing you for super, but it's not a flat of 8,000, right?
0:59:59 So if you only use 4,000, we only bill you for 4,000, and we will cap it if you use 12,000.
1:00:07 We're only building you for 8,000, and that makes incredible sense, and so as we're irrigating
1:00:19 and washing cars and watering flowers and flower pots, that's not going down to the sewer drain.
1:00:27 There are a couple of different things that we're looking to be able to more closely reflect
1:00:35 what is the true sewer consumption.
1:00:38 But in the month of November, James should have subsided for the year 15% of our total customers exceed.
1:00:52 And if we were to move that cap to reflect actual consumption in the non-irrigating months and then average that forward, the city would collect an additional $33,000.
1:01:12 One way to look at that $33,000 is that the individuals that are using the system are paying for the share of the system in which they're currently using crease the one request to win by creating the additional $33,000 on the residential side.
1:01:32 So I will be something for you to take a look at for something to consider.
1:01:41 The sanitation also invents the recycling, placed in here.
1:02:00 So if all things, you could see there's some pieces that are still very much in plain.
1:02:04 We'll define those as we go through the budgeting process, but you could see across the...
1:04:31 You had mentioned there toward the end that as we further discuss the sanitation rates,
1:04:38 that we may be looking at what costs might look like if we were to overcycling.
1:04:45 Yes.
1:04:46 I'm going to make sure I understood that correctly that looking at going back to how we were
1:04:52 doing it, what those costs might look like.
1:04:54 Yes, so our plan, and I guess I'll ask the council to see if staff is on the right page.
1:04:59 We will be presenting general options for our first option would be the status quo to do
1:05:07 it as we do right now.
1:05:12 The price per ton is greater than dollars per ton.
1:05:16 We send everything to the we're looking at option $200 a ton.
1:05:31 PSI will pay some portion.
1:05:33 It might be still locked at dollars, but if that grows to a higher ton, there's a cost
1:05:39 associated with that, and that's what this cost would look like, and raise, raise accordingly.
1:06:08 So the city of photo-contrary to what's absolutely important is to lay out those three options.
1:06:29 Travis, I like that idea.
1:06:30 I'd like to see some options given flux that we've been going through.
1:06:37 So, I appreciate that.
1:07:40 So, we will adopt our budget.
1:08:31 We will submit what's called an L2 form.
1:08:45 And that is what is used to collect.
1:08:49 The legislature will begin their conversations in January.
1:08:59 We'll pass a collection of laws.
1:09:00 And let's say one of those laws that they pass
1:09:02 is the elimination of a city's ability
1:09:05 to collect foregone balance.
1:09:09 There wouldn't be all state laws take effect.
Download
- Transcript (text) 26 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 33 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 44 KB
- Audio (M4A) 16.4 MB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 18, 2018. The recording started at 16:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:09:19.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
d37006cc1e93b6a5a181a63a9c9dc6b4b64a6b1875c93724b1478a0122fc7328 - Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
part01.m4a 76f721e04148f326459016404d690bed4e67474c94266159d5d8ca0802940040 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. SHA-256 of the posted text:
fefb01d7913b920116b71b76581085c468f96eb8c2b701a0471641295c6e86d8
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file