OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, October 9, 2017

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Recording

Transcript

0:00:08 Good evening. I'd like to call to order the Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday, October 9th, and confirm that we do have a quorum of the Council.

0:00:16 Five of the seven members are here this evening. Councilman Reed and Councilman Lanting are both absent and excused this evening.

0:00:24 The next item on the agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. For those of you wishing to join us, please rise.

0:00:29 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:00:45 Mr. Rothwiler, do we have any amendments to our agenda this evening?

0:00:56 Oh, all right.

0:00:57 Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, there are no amendments to tonight's agenda.

0:01:01 we do want to notice that in the first agenda that we had published, we had listed two proclamations,

0:01:10 we had aired in putting them on this agenda. They'll actually be on next week's agenda.

0:01:16 Thank you. Next is an opportunity for general public input. So this is a chance

0:01:24 for folks to address the council on items that are not on the agenda this evening. And I do have

0:01:28 three people who have signed up to speak, two of you are in the general public input,

0:01:35 Mr. Killinger, you wanted to speak about the fire stations and so I'm going to hold off until

0:01:39 we get to that part of the agenda and give you an opportunity to speak there. So first,

0:01:44 under the general public input, I have Terry Edwards. So again, I'm going to ask this evening that

0:01:52 when you approach the microphone that you'd be recognized by the mayor, state your name,

0:01:56 and whether you're a resident or property owner in the City of Twin Falls.

0:01:59 And this evening we are going to limit the input to four minutes Vice Mayor Hawkins will be running a timer

0:02:07 and she'll have signs for you there. Welcome Mr. Edwards.

0:02:10 Good evening Council Mayor. My name is Terry Edwards. I'm a property owner in Twin Falls and I just have a kind of

0:02:22 of informational thing that I'd like to tell you about.

0:02:27 Mr. Tom DeWeese, a national sustainability expert,

0:02:31 will be speaking at the College of Southern Idaho

0:02:35 and the Heritage Center on October 17th,

0:02:37 beginning at 7 p.m., the meeting is open to the public.

0:02:43 This is a council's opportunity to get the latest

0:02:46 on sustainability and personal property rights.

0:02:49 And I have complimentary tickets

0:02:51 I'd like to give to you for that event.

0:02:54 And I understand there's two that are missing.

0:02:56 I'll give it to Sharon and she can get it

0:02:57 to those council members.

0:03:00 That's all I have.

0:03:00 Thank you.

0:03:01 Thank you, Mr. Edwards.

0:03:04 On the side of that.

0:03:06 17, I can accept.

0:03:08 Is that okay, I don't have that, Andy?

0:03:16 But you don't, you wouldn't do that.

0:03:17 Okay, thank you.

0:03:19 But it's just the discussion information on that for you.

0:03:32 Next on the agenda for the general public input,

0:03:35 the sign up sheet here is Lynn Langford. Welcome. My name is Lynn Langford. I'm a

0:03:45 property owner in Twin Falls City. I am here representing the Magic Valley Church

0:03:51 of Christ and the treasure for that organization as well as on the member of

0:03:55 the leadership group. I'm here asking for a two-part request. I provided you a

0:04:03 letter stating all this but first of all oftentimes we have visitors that come

0:04:08 through town to visit with us and a lot of those people are retired and they come in RVs.

0:04:15 And we'd like to request permission to have them be able to park in our parking lot overnight

0:04:21 before services or at the night after services before they move on in their trip wherever they're

0:04:27 going.

0:04:28 Recently we found out that that was a violation of Twin Falls City Code 10 day, 7 day, 16.

0:04:34 And so we'd like to get permission to be able to allow them to do that.

0:04:37 the letter I wrote of variants, I don't know if that's the right word, we'd like to have

0:04:41 permission to be able to do that, not have somebody get in trouble.

0:04:45 The second part is on occasion we have a need to have some people that travel around the

0:04:50 country site helping out small congregations such as ours called the Sojourners and that's

0:04:55 a group of retired folk and they travel around in their RVs and they come and use it for

0:04:59 a week or two weeks and stop and help us try and spread the word and contact and do other

0:05:04 things related to church activities, and oftentimes it's much easier if they can park at the parking

0:05:09 line.

0:05:10 We've looked this over, we have no problem with it, we have a small congregation, we have the

0:05:14 parking lines totally adequate to take care of the facility that we have, and we see no

0:05:19 problem with sewage, there's plenty of places where they can dump, we're not providing electrical

0:05:24 outlets, they take care of all that on their own.

0:05:28 But since we found out that there was a violation of 10, May, 7, May 16, we'd like to figure out

0:05:32 how to get that done so we can continue to operate the way we'd like to as a church in

0:05:38 this community.

0:05:39 And like I said, if I variance was the wrong word, I need permission to figure out how to

0:05:44 get around the ordinance that was passed if that's at all possible within the review of

0:05:50 the council.

0:05:51 Thank you.

0:05:52 If you have any questions on what I'd be asking.

0:05:54 All right.

0:05:55 Thank you, Mr. Langford.

0:05:56 Chris, talk.

0:05:57 Could you explain the difference or are you asking for up to two nights for one group

0:06:03 and up to two weeks for the sojourners?

0:06:06 Would you just request two weeks for all groups?

0:06:09 Well, the sojourners is a specific group that comes through, and when they come,

0:06:15 they're usually here for two weeks at a time.

0:06:17 And we'd like to be able to have them be able to stay in the parking lot.

0:06:22 That's a rare occasion, but it does happen.

0:06:25 on a kid, on a more frequent time, we have people that go to Arizona for the winter and

0:06:32 stuff, they drive through, and they'll stop the worship with us, and they're just here

0:06:36 for like a weekend as they're passing through.

0:06:39 And so in case I can get one, I won't want it.

0:06:41 I'd really like to have both, but I don't know if that depends on how you all look at

0:06:46 it.

0:06:47 Thank you.

0:06:48 Thank you.

0:06:50 So Mitch Humboldt, could you fill us in a little bit on the City Code and RB Campground

0:06:58 zoning stuff?

0:06:59 Yeah.

0:07:01 Please.

0:07:02 If I had forgotten my classes this morning.

0:07:09 So there's an opportunity in the code.

0:07:12 I would say that allows the planning and zoning administrator to deal with the second part

0:07:17 of the request, the sojourners.

0:07:21 You can approve a temporary RV park for some fixed period of time to kind of come and then

0:07:27 at a time it expires and they can go away.

0:07:31 So I think that's an opportunity that the code is provided in that same chapter 10, 7,

0:07:35 16 that he referenced.

0:07:37 That provision is in that section.

0:07:38 You just need to talk with them in this case Renee and she could deal with that.

0:07:45 The second one I was still trying to look up because that one's a little bit trickier

0:07:50 because that one could be like a, it's essentially like a land use on the property where any time,

0:07:57 any given weekend somebody might show up and it's not just for this fixed period of time.

0:08:03 So it kind of falls outside the bounds of the provision in 10, 7, 16 and it becomes a land use

0:08:08 issue per the code and I'm still trying to figure out if that's permissible by SUP or

0:08:16 and church is allowed by an SUP.

0:08:33 So essentially what you're talking about is creating an RV park.

0:08:36 So what 10, 7, 16 says, I'm going to paraphrase a little bit.

0:08:41 What that section says is you can't plug in and use an RV,

0:08:48 like sleeping quarters on a residential property,

0:08:52 unless that is in a designated RV park.

0:08:55 And then that's the gist of it.

0:08:57 And then there's a provision in the next sentence that says, but the administrator can approve

0:09:01 a temporary park for some given, like the time, up to six months is what it says.

0:09:09 So then you would basically need to establish it as an RV park in addition to establishing

0:09:13 it as a church.

0:09:14 So it's a church.

0:09:15 The church is allowed to use in the R4 zone.

0:09:18 I'm pretty sure this is a zone R4 if it's where I think it is.

0:09:23 And so the church is permitted to use there, but then you've got to go through the process

0:09:27 to figure out if we can allow an RV park there, that's just the way our code is

0:09:32 constructed right now. So there's a there's a process for the for the second

0:09:38 group, pretty easy, go talk to Renee, ask a, making a fish request and she can

0:09:43 improve that. The second one I'm still unsure how that works. I'm not sure

0:09:49 that there's a process really to allow an RV park into R4 zone, right? So Mr.

0:09:54 Langford, what I'm going to suggest is that you need to get in touch with our

0:09:57 planning and zoning department? Renee? Okay well we're we're just hearing on the

0:10:03 second part on the wanting the two weeks for the sojourners that is something that

0:10:09 you can discuss with our planning and zoning administrator and and that can be

0:10:14 reviewed and she has the authority to grant that permission with whatever

0:10:20 conditions many of you and if she isn't inclined to approve that her decisions

0:10:25 are appeal to the planning zoning commission. So the second part you can deal with with her.

0:10:30 The first part, we need to do a little bit more research into our code to understand that.

0:10:34 Because again, it's trying to treat your property like an RV park. Well, that's what it is.

0:10:41 It's the same as if, so for example, I run the visitor center and we have people come overnight

0:10:48 park in our parking lot. Well, that's camping. So camping is supposed to be done in an RV

0:10:53 Park and we have RV parks in town for that. So it's a similar type activity. So again,

0:10:59 we have to do a little bit of research on that. So we'll do that and someone from the

0:11:04 Planning and Zoning Department will get back to you. We have your contact information on

0:11:08 this letter here. Ruth, did you have an additional comment?

0:11:11 I just had a question, Mitch. If you see RVs parked at Fred Meyer, Walmart, some of those

0:11:19 other grocery stores or whatever, probably places. So how do they get by with that?

0:11:24 They don't. Oh, Shawn goes and talks to them too. And in fact Walmart is the

0:11:31 frequent stop of our code-and-version officers because it happens there all

0:11:35 the time. And Walmart has done everything they can to prevent that. They

0:11:38 have signs in the parking lot that say no overnight. They're really trying to

0:11:43 comply, but it's just people nationwide. Walmart's have they attract that use and

0:11:50 it's okay in a lot of places and so people driving through just sort of go

0:11:54 there and stop and don't realize that our rules are a little different than other

0:11:58 places rules and so it's kind of a weird thing with Walmart but Sean is all the time

0:12:04 going out to these places and and not just that he goes to individuals homes

0:12:07 oftentimes you'll see a neighbor who will call and say my neighbors got their

0:12:11 thing plugged in on the street. So he's this is one of the ones that he

0:12:16 enforces pretty regularly actually. Thank you, Mitch.

0:12:20 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:12:21 So when you were reading through it, you use the term plugged in, but we were

0:12:27 just told that they don't plug in when they're there, they just park there and

0:12:31 then leave the next day. So if they're not plugged in, does that change

0:12:35 the rules?

0:12:36 It would. So what it says specifically, I'll just read it to you in 10,

0:12:39 It says recreation of vehicles may be stored, maintained, loaded, or unloaded, but not occupied

0:12:49 otherwise or connected to sewer water or cable services except in approved RV parks on residential

0:12:56 lots.

0:12:57 So the occupied part of that.

0:12:59 So the occupied thing.

0:13:00 And then also connected, it references connected to.

0:13:03 Right.

0:13:04 I was just curious because he made the point of saying they're not connected to anything

0:13:07 there who are just sleeping and leaving so I didn't know if that mattered.

0:13:13 Nicky, did you have an additional comment on that?

0:13:15 I did not.

0:13:16 Krista, I'm very favorable of this request as opposed to the first part and I would suggest

0:13:21 that the council consider giving permission of the applicant, in those case, the Church of Christ

0:13:30 on Fire and Ewees, to allow the two nights for parking in the facility, subject to

0:13:38 subject to conditions that are already discussed until the city can come up with a defined statement of policy.

0:13:45 So I would prefer to wait until we have staff review the code and see if it's compliant or not,

0:13:53 because I don't know that we really should be changing land use items without background.

0:14:00 You're assuming.

0:14:01 Travis.

0:14:02 I'm saying get one made better for the bill until then.

0:14:05 Travis so one of the things that

0:14:08 Council could do this evening would be to instruct staff in for the preparation of a

0:14:15 ordinance to begin that process that

0:14:19 could narrowly

0:14:21 limit

0:14:22 the use of RV parking in certain areas

0:14:26 and

0:14:28 Then that would start that process because as you know that there are a couple of ways for ordinances to be created one

0:14:33 is to be initiated by staff, one is to be initiated by the council, and the third is

0:14:37 to be initiated by our citizens. And we can start that review. I think that Mitch's

0:14:43 cursory review illustrates that there is an option for the second, as it stands today.

0:14:51 The first, based upon our initial review, would require a code amendment to the process. And

0:14:59 staff would recommend a code amendment. It sounds arduous, and it may even sound bureaucratic,

0:15:05 but we don't believe that we should pick and choose what rules and laws we want to follow

0:15:09 because that becomes an incredibly slippery slope on which other rules may fall into that

0:15:15 same boat.

0:15:17 Susanne Hawkins.

0:15:18 I have a question for Lynn. Do you have a date when you expect your next overnight guest

0:15:24 to need your parking lot? How much time do we have to work with Dino? And I think we

0:15:43 We all understand that I'm just trying to get a feel for how urgent it is, you know, do

0:15:48 we have six weeks to work this through without causing you inconvenience?

0:15:52 Okay.

0:15:54 Okay.

0:15:55 Thank you.

0:15:57 So I think then probably if we address it with staff and start working on it now, would

0:16:02 that meet your request for tonight?

0:16:06 Okay.

0:16:07 Thank you very much.

0:16:13 Any other discussion on that from the council?

0:16:15 I just go on record as opposing that and allowing them and step to do it until we said

0:16:20 Did you want to make a motion or could you just want to make that you didn't actually make a motion?

0:16:25 So did you want that to be a motion that that was my request?

0:16:29 Okay, so there is sort of motion from Chris talking to always say that maybe sure and good

0:16:35 I would move to allow the the church of Christ at

0:16:39 2001 file aries to allow up to a two-night stay for their described

0:16:45 church overnight activities until the city presents an ordinance for the council's review.

0:16:59 It was a motion by Chris Stockington and I see no second for that motion so it dies for lack of a

0:17:05 second. Sorry Len. So I have no one else who has signed up to speak on the general public input.

0:17:15 Mr. Kalinger will get to you a little later on the agenda. Does anyone else who wishes to address the

0:17:19 the council this evening on an item not in the agenda.

0:17:24 Seeing none, we will move on to the consent calendar.

0:17:27 Council wishes.

0:17:30 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:17:31 And move approval of the consent calendar as printed.

0:17:34 Second.

0:17:35 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Ruth Pierce

0:17:38 to approve the consent calendar.

0:17:40 Is there any discussion?

0:17:43 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please.

0:18:02 Sean Beriker.

0:18:03 Yes.

0:18:06 Nikki Boyd.

0:18:07 Yes.

0:18:08 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:18:09 Yes.

0:18:10 Ruth Pierce.

0:18:11 Yes.

0:18:11 Chris talking to motion passes five to zero under items of consideration the

0:18:17 first is a request to approve a one-year extension on the governmental fire

0:18:21 service agreement to provide fire protection services to the Twin Falls

0:18:25 rural fire district and we have Lori race our chief financial officer welcome

0:18:29 Lori. Hey good evening so tonight you have before you a one-year governmental

0:18:35 fire service agreement and this agreement is for the city of Twin Falls fire

0:18:40 Department to provide fire protection service to the Twin Falls Rural Fire District.

0:18:45 The city has been providing this service since 1993. In the past we have simply

0:18:52 renewed the contract that was in place for a five-year period and this year after

0:18:58 discussion with the district on our own team we'd like to spend some time really

0:19:02 reviewing the details of that agreement and maybe beginning to work towards

0:19:07 updating some processes and the fees and other language in that document. So in

0:19:13 order to do that we're asking the term of this agreement be for one year beginning

0:19:18 October 1st 2017 and going through September 30th 2018. We plan to begin

0:19:26 working with the district on the new agreement towards the end of October. Our

0:19:31 city manager, our city attorney along with myself have reviewed the agreement

0:19:35 and the fire district passes well, they've run it past their legal counsel, and I'm recommending

0:19:41 that you approve that agreement and authorize the mayor to sign that, and with that I would

0:19:47 be happy to answer any questions.

0:19:50 Any questions?

0:19:51 Chris Stockton, move to approve the one-year extension of the governmental fire service

0:19:55 contract, the Twin Falls Rural Fire District.

0:19:58 Second.

0:19:59 Question by Chris Stockton and seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve the request as presented.

0:20:05 Is there any discussion?

0:20:07 Chair and we'll call vote, please.

0:20:12 Nikki Boyd?

0:20:13 Yes.

0:20:14 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:20:15 Yes.

0:20:16 Ruth Pierce?

0:20:17 Yes.

0:20:18 Chris Hockington?

0:20:19 Yes.

0:20:20 John Berriger?

0:20:22 Yes.

0:20:23 Motion passes five to zero.

0:20:29 Next item on the agenda is a request to approve the City of Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency, guaranteed

0:20:34 maximum price Hanson Street improvements to be performed by Star Corporation for a guaranteed

0:20:39 maximum price of $268,244.

0:20:44 Mr. Madam members, Council just should know that actually that was approved five or zero

0:20:53 just was a little delayed and come popping up on our screens here.

0:20:59 Mr. Madam members, the Council, good evening. What we have before you is the guaranteed maximum price for the Hanson Street improvements to move forward with that aspect of the project.

0:21:12 And I'm going to take you back a little bit in time, and that was when the city had entered

0:21:17 into an agreement with the Urban Renewal Agency to select a contractor to move forward with

0:21:24 the project for the downtown commons and the hands and street improvements.

0:21:30 And we had gone forward and consulted with Fred, so that we'd also created a scope of work with

0:21:37 Star Construction to be able to complete that work because we felt that while

0:21:42 Guho is doing a phenomenal job on the downtown improvements, we really believe

0:21:47 that that area needs to be controlled by a single contractor to make sure that

0:21:51 things were working and operating smoothly. And Star has done a great job on

0:21:55 the City Health Project and now they're getting ready to begin that next phase

0:22:00 of the project and you can see part of that project has already been approved

0:22:04 It was approved by the City Council, which was the curb and gutting that would curb the

0:22:09 gutter and sidewalk piece that would go up to the building from Hanson Street.

0:22:14 This next phase would actually be from that first price all the way down to the next curb

0:22:21 and gutting piece, curb and gutter piece, which also allows for the construction of the roadway.

0:22:26 At a maximum cost of $268,244.

0:22:32 a little bit of history on this project. You'll recall that we approved the first piece of

0:22:40 that bid and we weren't satisfied with the second. So we went back out. So this project

0:22:45 had, this part of the project has been bid twice. If it's approved tonight, we believe

0:22:52 that Star will begin construction one of the 16th next week, next Monday, with completion

0:22:58 of that project to occur about a month later on the 17th of November and then the rest

0:23:05 of the downtown's Commons project will be completed in the spring of 2018.

0:23:11 Michael Arrington was talking about this year and is available to answer any questions

0:23:16 that you might have associated with the project and staff would also stand for any questions

0:23:20 that you have.

0:23:21 Thank you Travis.

0:23:22 Chris talking to me.

0:23:23 Well, Travis, and I'm assuming that this suggested price,

0:23:27 fixed price at 268 is a result of independent evaluations

0:23:34 of the costing, the city's side looking at,

0:23:37 and making sure we're getting a fair deal,

0:23:40 and equitable deal, even though it's been bid

0:23:43 several times now.

0:23:44 It's been bid twice.

0:23:45 This is the second bid going forward.

0:23:47 We do believe that based upon our review

0:23:49 that it is a fair project.

0:23:51 While it's the urban renewal funds that are covering that project that was part of the agreement, we still have that fiduciary responsibility to make sure that those public funds are being invested in an appropriate manner.

0:24:03 We've looked at this bid and we believe that it is a fair bid and it's one that we would ask that the council approve this evening.

0:24:12 Thank you.

0:24:17 Are we ready for a motion?

0:24:19 I believe so.

0:24:20 I move that we approve the request for the city of Twin Falls, the URA, the gross maximum

0:24:26 price for the Hanson Street improvements to be performed by Star Corporation for a guaranteed

0:24:32 maximum price, not gross, guaranteed maximum price earlier.

0:24:39 Price of 268,244.

0:24:42 I'll second that.

0:24:44 by Nicky Boyd, seconded by Ruth Peac, Pierce.

0:24:47 Well, I'm not excited.

0:24:50 Sorry.

0:24:51 I can't stop.

0:24:52 I'm curious to approve the City of Twin Falls,

0:24:55 URA, GMP, Hanson Street improvements.

0:24:59 Chris, talk.

0:25:00 Is there a mic?

0:25:02 What happens if the weather turns cold,

0:25:04 you can't do any more asphalting or concrete

0:25:07 probably wouldn't be a problem?

0:25:10 I mean, is this an optimistic completion time in November?

0:25:15 the weather have to be perfect.

0:25:17 There's a lot of questions there, Mayor and Councilman.

0:25:23 It is optimistic, but realistic at the same time.

0:25:28 It does not have to be perfect weather in order for this

0:25:32 to work out, but it will need to, for things to fall into,

0:25:38 what is typically what it's often we're seeing,

0:25:41 paving what's happening almost until Thanksgiving.

0:25:45 and we're new for that to happen this year.

0:25:47 If something were to change,

0:25:48 we're all of a sudden to get more moisture

0:25:50 than we're used to,

0:25:52 then have an inability to drive those things out,

0:25:54 then we would be back with an alternate plan.

0:25:57 But at this point, we don't expect that.

0:26:01 So we're confident to move forward.

0:26:04 Thank you.

0:26:06 Any other discussion?

0:26:09 Sharon, we'll call the vote, please.

0:26:14 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:26:15 Yes.

0:26:16 Ruth Pierce.

0:26:17 Yes.

0:26:18 Chris Hockington.

0:26:19 Yes.

0:26:20 Yes, Nicky Boyd. Yes

0:26:22 Pass this time to zero

0:26:24 Thank You Travis and Michael

0:26:28 Next is a request to enter into an agreement for comprehensive

0:26:31 Architectural with pivot North architecture related to fire department stations remodel and build and we have Brian Pike our deputy city manager

0:26:43 Thank You, Mayor and members of council

0:26:46 Little bit nervous is everyone was kind of going around wondering if what what I might miss pronounce

0:26:54 There's some tricky stuff here, I was a little bit worried about that.

0:26:57 Probably before we get to the issue tonight, I want to go back just a little bit in history.

0:27:04 So back in May of 2017, the city published a request for qualifications for the fire station

0:27:09 build and remodel project.

0:27:11 So we put that out and we put it out with the intention of doing this project, a series

0:27:16 of project and phases.

0:27:18 If you remember from the RFQ, we were looking at the first phase being kind of a needs analysis

0:27:23 on our stations. This wasn't about station alignment as we discussed back in July, it

0:27:28 wasn't about station alignment, it was about whether what condition stations were in, what

0:27:32 the structures looked like and whether they needed, whether they were able to be remodeled,

0:27:38 whether they weren't able to remodeled. So in our RFQ we had a series of phases that

0:27:42 we outlined. On July 31st, actually we received a number of interest from firms, we took

0:27:49 I think we had 12 architectural firms that were interested.

0:27:52 We narrowed that down to three through a threat internal process

0:27:55 and then chose to the north.

0:27:57 And we presented that to you on July 31st of this year where we talked

0:28:01 about the reasons why we chose Pivot North.

0:28:04 And on that night, you asked staff to move forward and negotiate a contract

0:28:08 and the scope of work with Pivot North regarding the phasing of that project.

0:28:12 So tonight, we've done that.

0:28:14 We worked with Clint and his team at Pivot North and Clint is here

0:28:17 to help answer questions and to kind of talk a little bit about what that looks like.

0:28:22 So you have in front of you an agreement and I think it's probably worth mentioning tonight.

0:28:28 This is really, this project is really the needs analysis, this is the needs analysis phase

0:28:34 and the programming phase and is what we want to talk about tonight.

0:28:39 And each one of these phases is really built upon, you know, so we'll start with programming

0:28:45 and then we'll move through that design phase.

0:28:49 And we have the ability of just doing this step by step,

0:28:53 by step, and making sure that we do it well,

0:28:55 and that we do it to meet the needs of our community.

0:28:58 So tonight we're doing just that.

0:28:59 You have in front of you a contract,

0:29:01 Fritz and Travis have reviewed the contract.

0:29:04 We think the contract is fair.

0:29:06 I don't want to get too far ahead

0:29:07 because I want to talk a little bit about

0:29:09 what the scope of that contract looks like.

0:29:13 The contract amount is for $236,360, and it's important to recognize that that is not to

0:29:21 exceed.

0:29:22 And I think I'll talk a little bit about how he reached that figure and what that means.

0:29:25 It's kind of his best shot at what it would cost us to do this on an hourly basis.

0:29:31 We believe it could be done for probably less money than that.

0:29:34 Certainly not more, although that's a possibility, but it's his best shot at not to exceed $236,360.

0:29:41 $360. That money comes out of fire impact fees that we've collected to help

0:29:47 fund this project as we move forward and with that I think I'll turn it over to

0:29:51 Clint to talk a little bit about the programming phase. Welcome Clint. Thank

0:29:59 you Ryan. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, the office card, we have a little bit of

0:30:05 cold going on so just keep it over there. Yeah. So you have back in front of you I

0:30:13 I believe and have had an opportunity to read, most importantly the cover letter that it very

0:30:19 generally explains the scope of service.

0:30:22 The way we've approached this is with direction from the RFQ that was written by city staff.

0:30:29 So in that RFQ, as Brian mentioned, there's a request for services, meaning of needs analysis,

0:30:37 and then services based on each project as they fall out of that master plan.

0:30:43 So, what I've done tonight is built a service for that upfront master planning programming phase.

0:30:52 This is really no commitment to do anything with any of the fire stations.

0:30:56 It's simply the first step to master planning program for your facility.

0:31:02 So, out of this, you get a kit of parts per se that would tell you how to plan your fire stations into the future for now until 20 years.

0:31:13 So this is really a service that we've built to give you the best value and something that you can use well into the future

0:31:24 So what I'll do is just step through

0:31:34 That's really the meat potatoes

0:31:37 Scope of services we have contracts and management listed there

0:31:45 Those are more internal and administrative management, as you can see, is just a coordination

0:31:52 project, daily phone calls, email, stuff like that.

0:31:55 So we allow for that time within our service.

0:31:59 Where we'll spend most of our time is on items, your tasks, three through six, and it's the

0:32:07 easiest way for us to break down the work that will perform with you for the next few

0:32:14 months.

0:32:15 and I'll direct your attention to the schedule.

0:32:17 The schedule follows that as well.

0:32:20 Basically, the work would start right away

0:32:22 and go until next March when budgeting

0:32:25 for the next fiscal year begins.

0:32:27 So that's really how we've established the schedule.

0:32:35 So task number three, kickoff and tours.

0:32:38 One thing that we found very valuable

0:32:41 and we've done this, we did this with your city hall project,

0:32:44 your public safety, and then we've also done this.

0:32:47 public schools as well from time to time, but it's taking the executive

0:32:53 committee a program committee and seeing some other facilities, seeing what the

0:32:57 trends are in design, and how fire departments are using their facilities,

0:33:04 whether it's rural or city, and whether the remodels or new buildings, training

0:33:10 centers, or mixed-use type facilities, etc. So we feel that's a very valuable kickoff

0:33:17 starting up for the process, one of the most valuable in the whole process, what we're

0:33:25 proposing to do, our teammate is Rice Fergus Miller out of Seattle and they're a specialty

0:33:31 architecture firm, Dave Fergus, who's a part of their, he does purely fire stations around

0:33:37 the country, so he brings a lot of value and expertise specifically to this project type.

0:33:42 They've done, I think, a handful of recent remodels and new stations, and as well as a training facility.

0:33:51 So, it would be our efforts to try and go up and see all of us and bring back a perspective, a lesson learned from each of those types of facilities to use in your master plan for the next activity.

0:34:03 So, that's task number three.

0:34:12 Task number four would kind of go along at the same time.

0:34:17 Would be primarily Pivot North, my firm, and my staff.

0:34:22 The research and facility analysis, this is really where we come down to spend some time walking through all your facilities.

0:34:29 We have engineers, other companies that we've got are team.

0:34:33 They'll come down, look at mechanical systems, structural, electrical, all the other systems.

0:34:38 And then we'll develop a series of report cards for each building.

0:34:42 At the same time, we'll meet with local utility agencies, city staff, to start to understand

0:34:50 that if we were to remodel a building, what does that mean, program that was?

0:34:54 So all of that gets summarized in a report card assessment.

0:34:59 Tasked by this programming, this is probably the heaviest, most intensive.

0:35:09 That's where we'll, RFM will come down to the Twin Falls, we'll do a series of two-day workshops

0:35:15 where we'll interview and spend a lot of time with city staff.

0:35:19 We'll then work in the afternoons and meetings and then the next day to present what we worked on with an House of Swords World

0:35:29 Fire Station personnel can come, provide info and ask questions.

0:35:33 So we'll do that a couple of times during task five.

0:35:42 You'll also get a deliverable on the program guide.

0:35:45 So, for long-term planning areas such as the Bayes for apparatus, the Sleeping Quarters, things like that,

0:35:53 will develop components for the floor plan that you can use, whether you design a facility by 10 years or now,

0:36:00 or you use it on a station, a new station too, right now.

0:36:03 But it's kind of your kid of parts for a second.

0:36:06 And then finally, station five, or excuse me, task six, the concept design and budgeting.

0:36:18 What we'll do is we'll take the work done today, the programming, the building assessments and such,

0:36:23 and we'll transition those into a concept design, a very light, mass model concept material type,

0:36:33 renderings that will show you what these stations could look like.

0:36:37 There's a list of here stations one through five, it may be that we only need to do one or two of them,

0:36:43 it may be that we need to design more for all five.

0:36:46 That really, you know, previous steps in the process tell us what we need.

0:36:51 And I think that's important because that's how we've set up the contract as well.

0:36:58 For us, it's a little bit difficult without getting into the process to know what the fees are going to be in the time.

0:37:05 So the fees that we've included are a product of hours versus billing rates,

0:37:11 and we're basically guesstimating what our time efforts will be.

0:37:16 I like to use these as not to exceed, so I fully expect them to go over this, but again,

0:37:21 it's such a product of time.

0:37:27 So out of that deliverable for Task 6, you would have concept planning diagrams, floor

0:37:33 plans, site plans, and some very basic design elements for each of the stations.

0:37:39 I think it's important too.

0:37:41 We've included cost-consulted with our team, so they're a professional cost estimator.

0:37:46 They know the Twin Falls market, they're out of Salt Lake,

0:37:49 and we've used them before in the Valley.

0:37:52 We'd like to work with them so you can understand.

0:37:55 And once we get done with the master plan,

0:37:57 you can have an idea of costs associated.

0:38:00 And whether we've raised the projects out

0:38:03 for the next couple of years or 10 years or 15 years.

0:38:12 So that's really a summary of the service.

0:38:15 I'm happy to stand for any other questions

0:38:17 on schedule or anything else.

0:38:20 Chris, talking to you.

0:38:21 For those of us that are not familiar

0:38:23 with this type of planning, it seems like a lot of money

0:38:26 for planning for fire control in a growing town.

0:38:33 I mean, what is this really providing?

0:38:35 Hopefully a usable open the duck and follow the plan,

0:38:39 but what uniqueness am I overlooking?

0:38:44 Yeah, we built a fire station in the plant

0:38:46 and we put fire engines in it and it has to have

0:38:49 so much water pressure and they're manned

0:38:51 and they serve a certain community around it.

0:38:55 Why is there such high tech?

0:38:57 Well, I don't mean this in any unfriendly way,

0:39:00 but no, I understand.

0:39:02 I'll certainly give you my input perspective on it

0:39:05 from what I know.

0:39:07 I'd also ask Brian, I'm sure you've got as well.

0:39:15 You really have a series of challenges here

0:39:17 for a master plan.

0:39:19 It's more than just designing or developing

0:39:21 the program for one station.

0:39:23 you're really looking at five different stations,

0:39:25 and you're looking at a master plan for the next 10 to 20 years.

0:39:31 And so that's what this service revolves around.

0:39:33 It revolves around taking a deep look at each of your facilities.

0:39:38 So station one has its own difficulties and challenges

0:39:42 with being downtown, original station, operations effect

0:39:48 that facility.

0:39:49 Station two being a replacement that may have partners

0:39:54 which is St. Luke's, the college,

0:39:56 the micro station for police department,

0:39:59 such things like that, it's vastly different.

0:40:03 And then we look at station three,

0:40:04 which is an existing station, I believe, from seventies or so,

0:40:08 that's maybe we can modify that

0:40:11 and make it, you know, consistent with the service

0:40:15 you want to offer.

0:40:17 Station four is at the airport, the art station.

0:40:21 We don't anticipate a lot there but we'll study that

0:40:24 just to make sure I had the right service.

0:40:28 And then station five was just looking

0:40:29 to the future of a new site.

0:40:32 So you can see there's just a lot of complexity

0:40:35 in each station is a little bit different.

0:40:39 So that process, that number was a little bit more

0:40:44 than I liked to, but it's a product of the service

0:40:49 that basically RF and Mavicial has developed

0:40:53 and we've put time to that to get the most value out of it.

0:41:03 I think Clint's done an excellent job of covering that, but we're also looking at, you know,

0:41:09 these stations represent, to me, resources and assets within communities, within our community.

0:41:18 And that's been our approach here, whether we're looking at community space for future emergency operation planning,

0:41:25 whether we're looking at police substation to his

0:41:29 clenchared with you as a real possibility of providing

0:41:31 service and increasing service on the north end,

0:41:34 which we don't have the capacities of doing today

0:41:37 in regards to fire.

0:41:39 The other thing is that these stations are complex systems

0:41:43 and for those that sit on the selection committee,

0:41:48 we really got exposed to some interesting concepts about

0:41:52 infection prevention versus control

0:41:55 what systems have to look like, how you control contamination within those stations, and with

0:42:00 the added service of providing EMS to this community, those are all just interesting obstacles

0:42:08 that our stations have to be able to handle.

0:42:12 The other thing that when you look at this, probably the most important thing to me is

0:42:17 the programming stage of this.

0:42:20 Clint is proposing here really is the foundation for the stations as we move forward.

0:42:25 It is a considerable cost and I think it's a fair price and I know that Clint and his team

0:42:32 will do everything they can to save money where they can.

0:42:36 But the programming part of this is essential in getting it right.

0:42:39 We're putting stations in place that I hope are in place for 30 years.

0:42:43 It was funny, Jonathan brought over the plans for station 3 built in 1980.

0:42:47 And really, we haven't done anything with station three since 1980, so we're looking to the future, trying to have the foresight to have the systems in place that will keep these assets in our community.

0:43:00 Thank you, Brian.

0:43:04 Are you done, Clint?

0:43:06 So we did have Mr. Killinger who wanted to share a little bit of thought on this item, I think, before we move toward a vote on this.

0:43:16 this. So Mr. Killinger, if you'd like to step up and address us, you're welcome to take a few

0:43:23 minutes. I would appreciate it if you could keep those comments brief and to the point of this

0:43:29 discussion tonight for the architectural planning. I still do that. Thank you. I have a property owner.

0:43:37 I pay sales tax. I believe in fiscal responsibility or appreciated Chris talking to

0:43:45 concerned about the cost. For somebody that's 236,000 up to that amount for somebody to tell us what to do

0:43:54 is a lot of money. Don't we have brains here in Twin Falls? Don't we have a city engineer?

0:44:00 The wheel has already been invented. Play Chinese and Japanese. Go visit other fire stations.

0:44:14 They come over here to get our ideas to see what to manufacture. Go visit Boise,

0:44:20 I see, Pocatella, Idaho Falls, a lot of fire stations there, take a survey of what we're

0:44:26 deficient in here among our local firefighters, ask them what kind of problems they had in

0:44:33 these other towns.

0:44:36 Our city engineers should be able to face to forecast growth and plan for expansion.

0:44:43 We don't know how it's going to grow, but as it does grow, we can make the plans.

0:44:48 We can save a lot of dollars, we don't have to bill it today, as a need arises we can bill

0:44:56 as a need arises.

0:44:58 I think that's pretty well covered.

0:45:01 I encourage you to do it in-house, but our own city engineer and our own people.

0:45:09 If we think we have problems with our fire stations go visit others.

0:45:13 these fire stations and other towns, they already have a bluecrest, they have the engineering

0:45:19 stamp of approval, we can save a lot of money on finding something somewhere that was done

0:45:25 right. There's a lot of things we can do, again, investigate, see what we have here by

0:45:31 talking to our own people. Thank you. Oh, and save them a lot of money. That's what this

0:45:37 232,000 is a lot of money, even if they do up for 100,000.

0:45:43 There's still a lot of money.

0:45:46 Let's keep it here until it falls.

0:45:48 Thank you, Mr. Gellinger.

0:45:53 Council wishes.

0:45:54 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:45:57 So, a question again.

0:45:59 The funds to pay for this are coming out of impact fees.

0:46:02 Is that correct?

0:46:03 Can you speak to that and explain where that money comes from

0:46:06 and what makes it possible for us to do this?

0:46:09 The Master Impact Fee person.

0:46:14 So the state code allows the city to collect impact fees for several different types of

0:46:26 Expenses and Twin Falls we've adopted four different impact fees. We have parks

0:46:32 streets

0:46:33 Police and fire fires what we're talking about today. So every time somebody pulls a building permit

0:46:39 In town part of their permit fee we assess an impact fee collection and it's based on

0:46:45 New square footage or new residential homes. Every time there's a new home that comes in or somebody builds a new commercial facility.

0:46:52 There's a fee that's assessed and that fee is collected by the city and it goes into the bank.

0:46:58 We have a separate fund for each of those four impact fees separate from the general fund and every other fund.

0:47:05 They're just only for that specific purpose. So we collect money from new development only to go to the construction and design and development of

0:47:14 of in this case fire stations and actually I guess we could spend it on

0:47:19 Utah apparatus too so if we have some capital type improvement that's gonna

0:47:24 last us ten years then we can spend an impact fee on that and so we've been

0:47:29 collecting impact fees for fire department expenses since like August of

0:47:33 2009 we've got I can't remember the exact number off top I had over a million

0:47:39 dollars million to something like that in the bank right now that can only be

0:47:44 spent on impact on fire capital improvements. Design is certainly a phase of that property

0:47:52 acquisition would be a phase of that actual design, construction, those kind of things.

0:47:57 And so, like I said, we've got, I want to say, 1.1 million dollars in the bank enough

0:48:02 to cover the contract here. And then obviously the next phase will talk about construction

0:48:09 and that's sole purpose for that money.

0:48:13 It's not tax dollars.

0:48:15 It's not, well, it's earmarked for fire stations.

0:48:19 So.

0:48:21 Thank you, Mitch.

0:48:23 It's talking to you.

0:48:24 I think we're on the Council are all charged

0:48:26 with long range planning to make sure our community

0:48:29 is served at the growth that it's undergoing.

0:48:32 We would be sure it's cited to only look

0:48:34 at the five different areas described individually

0:48:37 without the interconnectedness to them

0:48:39 in this time of growth.

0:48:42 It's a complex issue and it's also one with a lot of money.

0:48:47 I think that we need to have the input

0:48:49 of the remaining two council people

0:48:51 before we make a decision on this.

0:48:53 And as such, I would move to table the proposal.

0:49:04 So we have a motion to table the proposal.

0:49:09 Is there a second for that motion?

0:49:15 Seeing none, that motion dies.

0:49:18 Nicky Boyne.

0:49:19 I did serve on that committee, and it was really enlightening when I toured a few years

0:49:28 ago when I toured all of our facilities, police, fire.

0:49:32 Fire was amazing to me.

0:49:35 I've said this before.

0:49:36 It was like going on a set for some movie that took place a way long time ago with what

0:49:43 was in there and what they had.

0:49:45 It was in mint condition.

0:49:47 Every bit of it.

0:49:48 is really impressive on how little they had to work with and how much they cared for.

0:49:53 And I really admire that.

0:49:55 And I think that's really great.

0:49:58 We also are growing and money, the people as Mitch just talked about, the impact fees

0:50:06 are specifically collected and put in an account that is for a specific thing.

0:50:14 One of the things we've run into here is that we know we're going to have to do something

0:50:21 in the future, but there isn't a plan or something to work with.

0:50:26 We can't wait until we have such a large, even if we just have a few more subdivisions, if those

0:50:33 people don't really have good fire service, that's on us.

0:50:40 and fire are both incredibly important and that's one of the things as a citizen you just

0:50:46 plain all expect that's not those are benefits those are you get those and and I think that

0:50:53 we need to be smart about what our options are and what we can do.

0:50:59 Another aspect that's coming down the pike that wasn't brought up is the fact that we

0:51:04 have female firefighters now we don't have any here we don't have any that I know of

0:51:10 that are wanting to be firefighters here,

0:51:12 but we do need to be able to address,

0:51:16 because we're looking at far into the future,

0:51:19 many years, that we need to have something for that.

0:51:23 We don't need a whole wing,

0:51:25 but we need to be able to accommodate the firefighters.

0:51:29 The other thing I hadn't really thought of

0:51:31 is what these firefighters walk in or touch.

0:51:37 When they come back to the firehouse,

0:51:39 They're, they're trumping around in boots that have goodness knows what all over them and they need to be contained and then they're, they were finding out that a lot of those things that they walked in, those things were being transported home on shoes or boots that small children and families and things.

0:51:57 And so there were a lot of things about firefighting I had never thought about and so I think if we're, if we're moving forward with how to build a firefighter home,

0:52:09 which is really what it is in a station that serves all of our citizens into the future.

0:52:14 We need to spend some time and really look at what is out there and what we can do that

0:52:20 serves our community and we need a plan and we need one now.

0:52:28 Thank you.

0:52:29 Any other discussion?

0:52:30 Council wishes.

0:52:31 Who's in Hawkeyes?

0:52:33 I'm ready to make a motion.

0:52:36 Alrighty.

0:52:37 Okay.

0:52:38 Sorry.

0:52:39 I'm slow here.

0:52:41 I would move that we authorized the mayor to sign the agreement, to enter into an agreement

0:52:48 for a comprehensive architectural study with Pivot North Architecture related to our fire

0:52:55 department stations, remodels, and possible new builds.

0:52:59 Second.

0:53:01 Motion by Susan, how can I second invite Nikki Boyd?

0:53:06 Is that figure in the contract?

0:53:08 It is.

0:53:09 Okay.

0:53:10 Thank you.

0:53:11 As long as it's in the contract, we don't need to amend the motion then Brian. You feel it's comfortable?

0:53:22 Any other discussions?

0:53:24 Sharon will call vote, please

0:53:31 Ruth Pierce. Yes. Chris Tockington. Yes

0:53:34 Sean Baraker. Yes, Nicky Boyd. Yes, Suzanne Hopkins. Yes

0:53:40 Passes 5 to 0. Thank you. Thank you

0:53:42 Next on the agenda is discuss and provide input on the greater Twin Falls Area

0:53:49 Transportation Committee priority list and we have our city engineer Jackie Fields.

0:53:53 Welcome Jackie. Thanks, Carter.

0:54:01 Thank you.

0:54:10 So the city is a member of the Greater Twin Falls Area Transportation Committee.

0:54:15 That's a regional group of all of the transportation entities on the south side of the Snake River in our area.

0:54:25 It includes fuel, fuel highway district, windfalls, windfalls highway district, several other communities.

0:54:37 That group needs to talk about facilitating traffic through the entire region.

0:54:47 They also work on a priority list which ITD uses to help them determine what projects they're going to program and their item.

0:54:57 So, in fine print, we have list, I'm sorry, I'm going to recognize that, on the first part

0:55:12 of the page are the state projects, those are the projects that ITE does with their five

0:55:20 or eight or whatever different types of funding buckets that they have for maintenance, capacity,

0:55:26 bridges and things like that.

0:55:28 And those are in our area, so the top says, stay projects, and that's kind of what those are.

0:55:35 Sometimes they interface with the communities.

0:55:38 And when they do, there will be a project on the opposite side

0:55:41 of the sheet for a local urban or local rural type of project.

0:55:50 So projects that ITD puts out on their planning horizon,

0:55:54 which is six years and more out there are called ITD Horizonless.

0:56:00 And our second avenue for improving six

0:56:05 in Minidoka and Washington Street South is on that horizon.

0:56:13 There's a local urban project category, and in our district,

0:56:17 we qualify, and we qualify with, but towns like Filer,

0:56:28 Buell, so on, are still small enough to be rural,

0:56:31 so they don't compete for those dollars of us.

0:56:36 On the local rural projects,

0:56:37 those are the smaller communities.

0:56:43 Local projects are on local streets only,

0:56:46 and so when I say how it comes through

0:56:48 and you do a joint project,

0:56:50 And you touch local streets and you work on the local streets.

0:56:53 We try to fund those out of local funds,

0:56:56 and the rest of it is out of state funds.

0:57:00 L-R-H-I-P is like a reconstruction money

0:57:04 for rural entities, signs that's also for rural entities.

0:57:09 So that's not us or urban transportation plans

0:57:13 are for rural entities.

0:57:14 That's not us, we're considered to be urban.

0:57:28 On our existing local urban projects list,

0:57:32 we have as our priority, Washington Street South 6-Minidoga Reconstruction.

0:57:40 And then there's also a project that was recommended out of the Southeast Twin Falls study that

0:57:48 was adopted to pass the project, to widen the intersection at Shoshone and 6.

0:57:56 That could be an intermediate step.

0:57:58 And then, City of Kimberly has a project, and then lastly on the list was a goal to widen

0:58:06 Pull Line from Bridgeview, more or less, to Torts Candle Ridge.

0:58:14 A bunch of that work has been done.

0:58:16 I needed logical, terminide, as just a project, and starting in the middle of the street somewhere

0:58:22 because it's narrow and going to another spot that doesn't appear to go anywhere was not

0:58:27 helpful.

0:58:28 the project limits included a destination which in this particular case was the

0:58:34 help way. So this evening so rarely have I been here to chat with the council about

0:58:45 what should be on this list and that has been because we have had Washington

0:58:51 Street North Phase 1 and 3 on that list forever and it took a huge amount of money

0:58:58 And then after the project was complete, we were not qualified to ask for anything for

0:59:04 several years because our allocation just didn't exist.

0:59:09 So last year or the year before, we started to try to make an effort.

0:59:15 This year I can't put forward a local urban project because LTCH is not accepting applications.

0:59:21 But I think that it's probably reasonable to try to keep our projects on the top of the local urban list.

0:59:29 And the question for me is, the question for me is twofold.

0:59:37 Do you know if you would like to see something else on the top of the list, let's talk about that.

0:59:43 And if you would like to see it, just like this, that's fine too.

0:59:51 Chris Targeting. One project that goes back a few years, in fact, shine on a tenet a couple meetings, and that's the

0:59:58 this functionality at these five points truck traffic coming to the intersection from the

1:00:04 east and having to go up Main Street to Murtaugh and then waddle left on Murtaugh and then waddle right on

1:00:14 to get to the businesses, didn't told that it's going to be very difficult, a lot of money,

1:00:23 and I still think it's a priority.

1:00:26 It messes up our road on Main Street where you do that left and sponges up the asphalt,

1:00:31 especially in hot weather, hit and peeps traffic.

1:00:34 There have been times where I've seen traffic back on behalf of Block waiting for an 18-wheeler

1:00:41 to try to reconnoiter that.

1:00:45 I think it's a priority for us to try to get that straight through traffic on, I guess

1:00:50 it would be Menadocu coming into that.

1:00:53 These five points and having some reconfiguration where the trucks can go straight through instead

1:00:58 of main and left and right.

1:01:05 You're following what I was saying on that track?

1:01:07 I think it's the last one on that track.

1:01:09 I believe so.

1:01:10 Very bottom.

1:01:14 Okay, so this is on the state highway side and I don't understand quite how Murtaugh

1:01:23 second half of the self cut on that one only but that's okay because it's a

1:01:27 start to have it on any list at all. So the Muerta second half of the self was to

1:01:32 conduct a traffic study and talk about installing the signal there. So that does

1:01:36 not accomplish the goal that you have you have articulated but it could be

1:01:43 helpful as a short-term maybe 20-year possibility. There are, there's another

1:01:52 project in here that could also fit that bill.

1:01:58 Again, a lot of it gets to the signaling of the East Five Points intersection doesn't have

1:02:03 much to do with Second Avenue.

1:02:05 Okay, so the whole Second Avenue, Washington, 6th and Minidocca Street project that's shown

1:02:13 as a tiger grant on the top of the state page with a coordinating local urban job attempts

1:02:18 to deal with an entire problem at East Five Points,

1:02:26 the turning movements through downtown

1:02:29 and try to facilitate truck traffic coming

1:02:33 from both directions at itself.

1:02:35 So that is shown as IDE's number one

1:02:40 on their horizon rank, which is how you enter the program.

1:02:44 They are encouraging us to go for a tiger rant

1:02:48 and I need to talk to them more about that.

1:02:52 And then we have a corresponding project that's ranked number one for that same position.

1:02:59 I see not funded on all of these.

1:03:02 Yes, you do.

1:03:03 So they are not currently in the program, but the start of the process is to get them ranked

1:03:10 on the priority list because then the chairman who happens to be Gerald Merton's rights lawyer

1:03:15 and says, this is a great project, it's number one on our transportation list.

1:03:20 And that helps me in their support for funding a capacity job.

1:03:31 Jackie, a comment I would make, and it's probably not necessarily for this priority list for the discussion tomorrow,

1:03:38 but I think maybe something to start thinking about.

1:03:40 As we continue to grow south, are there transportation issues that we might be running into, related to capacity, safety,

1:03:52 some of the hopscotching that we have of development, you know, leaves a half-mile and

1:03:58 we end up with these narrow and wide streets, maybe something to be thinking about of in

1:04:04 the future, how do we maybe try to pay attention to those on the front end, since our plan

1:04:14 of having development just build that as it goes works really well until someone skips

1:04:18 a quarter-mile.

1:04:24 So it's a really good comment, and it's an eternal dilemma for us to exact part of the

1:04:33 farm off of the farmer or ask for a developer to cooperate with somebody who's next to him

1:04:40 who has some issues to try to buy the land as a possibility to have the city construct

1:04:48 the road and in lieu of waiting as a part.

1:04:52 There are some possibilities there.

1:04:56 I just wrote out there that the least expensive alternative is the one we currently do, but

1:05:03 that doesn't necessarily reflect our priorities as of here.

1:05:12 Otherwise, I fully support the number one statuses of our projects that would like to

1:05:18 continue to have on the radar screen so that they can get done someday.

1:05:21 There's my two cents.

1:05:25 So that would also imply then that we want to pick the, we want to try to keep that on

1:05:31 the horizon.

1:05:32 And then, oh, I'm sorry for alerting out

1:05:36 before you acknowledge me, I didn't want anybody else to do that.

1:05:39 OK, so there are other jobs on the state list that affect us.

1:05:44 And there's an opportunity to seek a rank for those.

1:05:49 Blue Lakes spur, it would be a third line.

1:05:54 It would be an maintenance job probably for the state.

1:05:58 They have a huge problem because of the ADA ramps that

1:06:02 are along the way.

1:06:03 And they would ask us to participate in improving those ramps.

1:06:07 And we would have some right-of-way acquisition

1:06:10 due to get that done.

1:06:11 So there'll be a little bit of lead time

1:06:13 if we choose to prioritize that.

1:06:18 The blue lakes and bridge view signal is that's on US-93,

1:06:25 and it's on their summer, I notice.

1:06:27 I have a phone phone.

1:06:28 Yeah, it's been on past the handsome bridge.

1:06:33 I think that it's worthy to keep this up front

1:06:36 and have a conversation for the initial discussion

1:06:39 on whether or not that could work is stalling.

1:06:43 And I think that we have some,

1:06:46 it may end up becoming a bigger project.

1:06:49 The concerns with traffic backup on the state highway

1:06:51 across the bridge is legitimate,

1:06:53 and the impacts on the golf course road intersection,

1:06:56 those are legitimate concerns,

1:07:01 there's also something to be said

1:07:03 for having the timing through that area, the entire area,

1:07:07 be pretty difficult.

1:07:08 So that solution might be a little bigger than simply putting

1:07:11 a different head on that signal.

1:07:14 And I think that it's a worthwhile venture

1:07:16 for the council to keep that on the forefront

1:07:19 until we can see some recognized improvement

1:07:25 on Breschulu and Fillmore.

1:07:28 The US30 and Locust project, we've done that.

1:07:33 We just did it.

1:07:34 It was a small amount of money and my grant out there with Dean and the guys and they took

1:07:40 the U.S. 3300 East project is to construct, that's kind of like Champlain, that's the East

1:07:51 side of Chobani, that is a worthy left turn project and a report that was recommended for

1:08:12 adoption, you know a lot of data came out of that report and this was one of the project

1:08:16 project opportunities that came out of it.

1:08:18 And it was to install left-term based on highway

1:08:23 and put some flashing beacons on the side streets.

1:08:29 We could seek to enhance that by adding left-turns

1:08:33 on the inter-emption with the highway district

1:08:36 if we decided to do that.

1:08:37 But I think keeping that project on the priority

1:08:39 must be kind of nice.

1:08:41 It might not be our top priority.

1:08:43 It doesn't show up anywhere else for us at this point.

1:08:45 But that would be convenient for getting people

1:08:49 of the way, you know, and making traffic in that area

1:08:52 of smoke flow better.

1:08:58 The state also had, there's a nice little job,

1:09:12 right second from the bottom called Washington Street,

1:09:15 Highland Orchard, widened five lanes.

1:09:17 That's a huge project.

1:09:19 That sounds a huge project.

1:09:20 And it's becoming something that we're going to need

1:09:23 to consider as that side of town grows.

1:09:28 There's water there now, there's sewer there,

1:09:30 there are developments coming through,

1:09:32 And that is, that blue lakes are it,

1:09:36 for reasonably getting across to the other places

1:09:40 of employment that are on the north side,

1:09:42 as well as some of the schools.

1:09:44 At the very least, I'd like to suggest to the state

1:09:47 that we work on a left turn opportunity at park.

1:09:54 The backups there are pretty spectacular,

1:09:57 the near misses are pretty spectacular.

1:09:59 And you know, I'm not a person who really likes

1:10:01 to talk about near misses,

1:10:02 because they're not documented data, but I have been there.

1:10:05 And your opportunity to sail around the side

1:10:08 is obstructed by the telephone pole.

1:10:12 That's right at the edge of that property.

1:10:14 So sometimes it gets quite exciting.

1:10:17 At some point we'll start to see

1:10:20 some type of accident riding that hits the charts.

1:10:26 If the council had a preference to have any of these projects

1:10:31 at a higher priority, then I would appreciate the input.

1:10:37 And if you're fine with it, so what happens in the absence of a priority is that the state

1:10:44 seeks projects that fit funding categories and maximize the amount of benefit they can get

1:10:53 from their data-driven requirements and so on.

1:10:58 So we can use all of their criteria and their available funds and their funding costs.

1:11:06 Or we can inject in a G-H-shirt kind of if you push this one more farther to the top.

1:11:12 Personally, I would trust your expertise in understanding where there might be the most bang for our buck to get some of those projects done.

1:11:22 I know that's not where you came here to hear from us, but I trust that you're able to kind of come up with those opportunities.

1:11:33 Thanks, I appreciate that. That's actually really nice. And if anybody has anything out of their passion.

1:11:40 Well, I lit up the Christmas tree after or something.

1:11:43 You know, I appreciate the vote of confidence, but I certainly appreciate the input.

1:11:49 So, Suzanne Hawkins?

1:11:50 So, since we completed the Locust Street Project that's on there, if we take that off,

1:11:56 does that give us brownie points with them to get other things looked at in a better light?

1:12:02 They don't give us any paybacks on it, huh?

1:12:07 Okay, a desk.

1:12:08 Chris Stockington.

1:12:09 I would move to accept the presented priority list for the Twin Falls part of the Greater

1:12:17 Twin Falls Area Transportation Committee priority list.

1:12:21 Do we need a formal action on this tonight?

1:12:27 Would that be helpful for you?

1:12:29 for us to say or can't suggest the state's heart funding.

1:12:36 Second.

1:12:40 We have a motion by Chris Dagen and seconded by Mrs. Ann Hawkins too.

1:12:44 I guess follow your recommendation on the priority list as it was presented.

1:12:48 I do have a comment from Ruth.

1:12:50 So my question, Jackie, I know that Chris Reed is the liaison.

1:12:55 Did he give you any input?

1:12:58 Or did he say go?

1:12:59 not yet, but he has some additional opportunities and is laid down that the rest of the council

1:13:07 doesn't have.

1:13:08 Okay.

1:13:09 So, I guess I should tell you what I'm going to say then.

1:13:14 Okay.

1:13:15 I think that we should keep Bridgeview and Blue Lake signal up front.

1:13:20 I think that we should patiently wait a little bit longer for major widening on Washington

1:13:26 but ask for a study and a potential small project

1:13:32 to address the intersection of Washington Street,

1:13:34 South and Park.

1:13:39 And I think that we should advocate and support

1:13:42 for the left turn base on 3,300 Champlain,

1:13:45 even if we're not in a position

1:13:47 where we can do the widening on the 3,300 Champlain Park

1:13:51 just on the same target.

1:14:04 Great.

1:14:05 Any other discussion?

1:14:08 Sharon, roll call, vote please.

1:14:16 Chris Hockington.

1:14:17 Yes.

1:14:19 John Berriger.

1:14:20 Yes.

1:14:21 Nicky Boyd.

1:14:22 Yes.

1:14:23 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:14:24 Yes.

1:14:25 Great.

1:14:26 Yes.

1:14:27 She passes five to zero.

1:14:28 Thank you, Jackie, for your work on that.

1:14:30 Good luck at the meeting.

1:14:33 So at this point, a state will go through, they'll take input from all of the different transportation

1:14:39 groups, and then they'll develop their program and it comes out for public comments.

1:14:45 Thank you.

1:14:49 All right, next on the agenda is a brief discussion of the ICRIMP Region 2 Board of Trustees nomination.

1:14:56 So I failed to remember to mention this last week's I received a letter from the Idaho County's Risk Management Program or ICRIMP as a member of that organization, the city, is our right to participate in the ICRIMP Board of Trustees nomination and election process.

1:15:15 The incumbent trustee representative from our region, the region two cities, is currently

1:15:22 Mayor Brian Bladd from the city of Pocatello.

1:15:25 He does desire to run for another two-year term on the i-crim board, and if we do not propose

1:15:32 to nominate a candidate to challenge Mayor Bladd, we do not need to act further on this

1:15:38 item.

1:15:39 If someone wishes to be nominated to run for that election,

1:15:44 I need to know that and have to fill this format and send it back,

1:15:47 and then we'll have an election.

1:15:49 So is there anyone who has a burning desire to serve?

1:15:52 I should mention the Region 2 membership is this long west here.

1:15:56 It's not like four cities.

1:15:58 It's a pay-by-lives.

1:16:03 So if anyone from the council is interested in doing that,

1:16:06 How's your chance to chime in, otherwise, Suzanne Hawkins?

1:16:12 I was just going to say I've worked with Mayor Blatt on that, and he's done an excellent job recommending a representation.

1:16:18 I turn now, and I've got total confidence and his ability to do that for another two years.

1:16:27 So, seeing no one jumping at the bit to be added to the nomination forum, I am going to not do anything else,

1:16:35 anything else which will let I crimp know that we are just fine with that nomination.

1:16:40 Thank you.

1:16:43 And next, another opportunity for general public input, if there's anyone here from the

1:16:48 public who wishes to address the Council on an item that's not on the agenda this evening,

1:16:53 now is your chance.

1:16:56 Seeing no one, Ruth Pierce.

1:16:59 So I just want to remind everybody that next Monday the proclamation will be read for breast

1:17:04 cancer awareness, tough enough to wear pink.

1:17:08 Our police department is wearing pink and or purple, depending on whether it's cancer,

1:17:14 domestic violence, same with our fire department, that Friday night when the boys came with

1:17:20 CSI, they all have their pink shirts on.

1:17:23 So I encourage everybody on Monday to show up for pink and with pink and I guess the

1:17:30 20th is the quote, official date, okay, thank you.

1:17:35 I'd like to make people aware that in addition to the incredible amount of construction on

1:17:42 Main Street and City Hall and water projects, wastewater plants, the airport is undergoing

1:17:48 a major taxiway renovation and expansion project beginning about April to mid July.

1:17:56 Four million dollars will be expended.

1:17:57 This is mainly federal funds and boarding fees and it's going to really provide incredible

1:18:04 opportunity for new tenants and businesses at the airport and take us to the next level

1:18:11 of operation and who knows, someday we may even get another carrier. That's not a direct

1:18:17 part of this but is to facilitate everything from FedEx to the private users and is going

1:18:25 to change the, especially the south side, look at the airport quite substantially. So look

1:18:32 around and be moving a lot of dirt.

1:18:34 Thank you.

1:18:35 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:18:36 Two quick things.

1:18:37 First of all, just to remind everybody that tomorrow night and Thursday night from 7 to

1:18:41 9 is the fire prevention open houses at our fire station right down here on 2nd Avenue.

1:18:48 Make sure everybody in the community knows they're invited to come enjoy learning about

1:18:52 fire prevention.

1:18:54 And also tonight was youth council meeting right before city council.

1:18:58 They were able to elect their executive board, we're fully up and running.

1:19:03 I left them in Josh Palmer's capable hands as I came over here to finish up their agenda.

1:19:09 But we had a really large turnout again and we'll be meeting the second Monday in November

1:19:15 if there's anybody else who'd like to join us.

1:19:19 Thank you, Suzanne.

1:19:21 Travis.

1:19:22 Mr. Mayor and members of the Council, we do have a quick update but it will be provided

1:19:26 by Wendy Davis and John Polly in its regards to the pool and the bubble.

1:19:31 All right.

1:19:33 Good evening, Mayor and Council.

1:19:46 We just want to give you a little update on the most recent correspondence I got from

1:19:53 Horizon was that the shipment of the air handling unit would be on November 15th, which was later

1:20:02 than we were hoping and puts us into the middle of November for the install and final activation.

1:20:08 They're still aware of how important it is to us to try to get this thing up and going

1:20:15 as soon as possible and so I feel like at this point we have a, it will happen no later

1:20:22 than and there's still hope that it will happen sooner.

1:20:26 So we are planning now as though it happens at that late as possible time, meaning that

1:20:32 we would have it inflated by Wednesday, November 22nd, which is the Wednesday before Thanksgiving.

1:20:37 So John and I sat down and kind of went through trying to come up with a plan that would get

1:20:43 us through that point, accommodate the needs of the swim teams, and basically to use right

1:20:51 now a swim team and lap swim primarily.

1:20:56 And so trying to find a way to continue to capitalize on that use and make that available

1:21:01 but minimize the costs of just being open because right now people don't look outside

1:21:07 and get, oh, it's 48 degrees, let's go swimming.

1:21:10 So looking at changing the pool hours, Monday through Friday from 5.30 to 7.30 a.m. and then

1:21:16 closing until 11.30.

1:21:18 And then opening again from 11.30 to 1.30 to accommodate CSI, they've got some classes

1:21:24 going on over the lunch hour. John said that we started Sunday and yesterday and I guess

1:21:32 today is Monday. The swimming at noon was, it kind of compacted everybody into the noon

1:21:40 hour and they were actually doubled up in the lane so it was a good move because we just

1:21:44 kind of consolidated rather than spread them all out. So, 5.30 to 7.30, 11.30 to 1.30 and

1:21:50 than 3.45 to 8 p.m. Monday through Friday,

1:21:53 then opening from 11.30 to 1.30 on Saturday,

1:21:56 and then just closing on Sunday,

1:21:57 because Sunday is primarily open swim.

1:22:00 And then once we hit the end of the high school swim season,

1:22:03 which will be Friday, November 3rd, closing on Saturday,

1:22:07 the 4th until we get the bubble up.

1:22:11 Looking for some opportunities to utilize the lifeguards

1:22:13 as much as we can, John is going to reach out to the Marlins

1:22:18 and to the water polo group and see if they want

1:22:23 to come and practice, and then we could try

1:22:25 to kind of consolidate that into one time when we can do that.

1:22:29 We project that savings to be about $1,000 a week in staff

1:22:33 if we can reduce it down to those hours.

1:22:37 And then also we're going to extend all

1:22:41 of the pass holders one month.

1:22:43 So we'll suspend monthly for one month and not charge them.

1:22:47 And then all of the annual pass holders

1:22:49 will give them an extra month to make up for the fact

1:22:53 that it's not as usable right now as we like it to be.

1:22:57 And then I also reached out to the Y,

1:22:59 and they will honor the City Pool Passes

1:23:03 for the month of October to let people

1:23:06 come in and use that facility with our City Pool Pass.

1:23:10 Just give us another option for use.

1:23:16 Great, thank you Wendy and Joan for your work.

1:23:22 Okay, that's it, nothing else.

1:23:26 Alright, with that, the meeting is adjourned then.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, October 9, 2017. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:23:39.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    f8141ac9e2f1fd92ebb9d1101fd14d1df7b518f5f18daa7c4f44b26f7a2d86a4
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a dec3d3e5f101c92394cd85dd5a22b3ecbe731cc5b56a3e3cf50762efef5258c1
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    0853adbd11a6610e0d234a46487573c76a0cf99e1cc4f661bf07eb963ed93ba6

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file