OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, June 12, 2017

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:02:47 Sharon, are you all ready to roll? Good evening. I'd like to call to order the

0:02:55 Twin Falls City Council meeting for Monday June 12th. Would you have a quorum

0:02:59 of the council? All seven members are here this evening. The next item on the

0:03:03 agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance and I would like to invite the members of the

0:03:06 Civil Air Patrol to come forward and lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. For

0:03:09 those of you wishing to join us, please rise.

0:03:10 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:03:39 And if you all wouldn't mind just stepping to the podium there and introduce yourselves, all of you, go around the other side of the podium there.

0:03:50 That'll be awkward you'll face us instead of the audience.

0:03:54 Well, right.

0:03:55 Thank you, Mayor Beringer.

0:03:56 I'm Gila Nedwards.

0:03:57 I'm the current commander of the Civil Air Patrol at Jocelyn Field.

0:04:01 Welcome.

0:04:02 Thank you.

0:04:04 My name is Lieutenant Loehr.

0:04:05 I'm the Deputy Commander for the cadet program.

0:04:07 I'm in charge of running all aspects of keeping them in line stuff.

0:04:11 Great.

0:04:12 Thank you.

0:04:13 Hi, I'm senior Airmen Bill Himmer.

0:04:17 I'm one of the cadets.

0:04:19 Welcome.

0:04:20 Pull it down.

0:04:25 You can pull it right down to you.

0:04:26 I'm Tyrell, and I'm a senior member, I can't remember what I am, but I'm a cadet of this

0:04:37 all good for you. I'm a cadet at the Twin Falls Civil War Patrol.

0:04:42 Great, thank you, welcome to all of you, thanks for being here this evening. Mr. Rothweller,

0:04:51 do we have any amendments to the agenda this evening?

0:04:58 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, there are no changes to the agenda that was published

0:05:02 just for the note for the record. We do have two public hearings, public hearing B and public

0:05:09 hearing C. We're both withdrawn by the applicant and rescheduled for the evening of June 19th.

0:05:18 Those public hearings will be held at 6 o'clock, no sooner than 6 o'clock depending upon that

0:05:23 agenda.

0:05:24 Other than that, Mr. Mayor, members of the Council, there are no changes to the agenda.

0:05:27 Thank you, Travis.

0:05:29 Next on the agenda are proclamations, and we do have a proclamation this evening for General

0:05:33 Aviation Appreciation Month, whereas the City of Twin Falls and the State of Idaho has a significant

0:05:39 interest in the continued vitality of general aviation, aircraft manufacturing, aviation

0:05:45 educational institutions, aviation organizations, and community airports, and whereas general

0:05:51 aviation and the Magic Valley Regional Airport have an immense economic impact on Twin Falls,

0:05:56 and whereas according to the PricewaterhouseCoopers study, contribution of general aviation to

0:06:01 the U.S. economy, general aviation in Idaho contributes over $1.1 billion to the state's

0:06:07 total economic output. And whereas the Idaho Transportation Department Division of Aeronautics

0:06:13 reports that Idaho has 117 public use general aviation airports, according to FAA data,

0:06:20 these airports serve 4,834 pilots and 2,966 active general aviation aircraft. And whereas

0:06:29 according to the Price Waterhouse Cooper's study, general aviation supports 7,900 jobs

0:06:37 in Idaho, resulting in 342 million dollars in labor income.

0:06:42 And whereas general aviation not only supports Idaho's economy, it improves overall quality

0:06:47 of life by supporting emergency medical and healthcare services, law enforcement, firefighting

0:06:52 and disaster relief, and by transporting business travelers to their destinations quickly and

0:06:57 safely.

0:06:59 And whereas the nation's aviation infrastructure represents an important public benefit and

0:07:03 congressional oversight should be in place to ensure stable funding of this system.

0:07:07 Now therefore, I, Sean Berriger, Mayor of the City of Twin Falls, do hereby proclaim General

0:07:11 Aviation, a vital strategic resource to the City of Twin Falls, and declare June as General

0:07:18 Aviation Appreciation Month in the City of Twin Falls.

0:07:20 We have our Airport Manager, Bill Carberry here to accept.

0:07:23 Thank you, Mayor.

0:07:24 I've invited Galen Edwards to come and receive this.

0:07:28 Galen and the Civil Air Patrol have a very active squad out there, and there are a lot

0:07:33 of cadets.

0:07:34 He may just like to take just a very brief moment to describe his organization and the things

0:07:39 they do.

0:07:40 The Civil Air Patrol is of course a national organization where a total volunteer force,

0:07:55 we are part of the total force of the Air Force and the official auxiliary of the United States Air Force.

0:08:04 Locally or statewide there's about 450 members.

0:08:08 Hopefully we have 39 members that we meet on a weekly basis at the Johnson Field.

0:08:18 25 of those are cadets, which is one of our programs we shine in.

0:08:23 We incorporate core values in our youth in order to prepare them for our future leaders,

0:08:30 especially in aerospace and through the STEM programs, science, technology, engineering,

0:08:35 and mathematics.

0:08:37 core values of course, for we instill in them is integrity, volunteer service, excellence,

0:08:44 and respect.

0:08:46 And those are built into all of our activities and all of our lesson plans that we do.

0:08:50 They are our future leaders.

0:08:52 We have to be prepared and prepare them for such and invest in our future through them.

0:09:03 So on behalf of Civil Air Patrol, I acknowledge the receipt of the proclamation and our continued

0:09:09 effort to promote general aviation through both our search and rescue efforts from the

0:09:14 air and also through the cadet program. Thank you, sir.

0:09:17 Thank you. Chris Tockington.

0:09:23 As long as we're talking airports, I'd like to update the public and the council on our

0:09:27 terminal project. Thanks to the excellent management of our engine hired engineers and

0:09:33 our airport manager, Bill Carberry, that $3.9 million project is in his final weeks. I think

0:09:42 Early July we're talking about the final punch card change orders to be completed.

0:09:50 But I'd like to compliment the project because $3.9 million project with about $50,000 and change

0:09:57 orders were coming within $4,000, actually, so I think that's highly competent and professional

0:10:05 and reflects well in our airport city and county operations.

0:10:10 So, talk about that.

0:10:12 Thank you, Chris.

0:10:15 Next on the agenda is an opportunity for general public input.

0:10:18 If there's anyone here from the public

0:10:19 who wishes to address the council on an issue

0:10:21 that is not on this evening's agenda,

0:10:23 now's your opportunity to please come forward.

0:10:25 If you would please state your name

0:10:28 and whether you're a resident

0:10:29 or a property owner in the city of Twin Falls.

0:10:31 We are, I am.

0:10:32 Okay.

0:10:33 On Bridge Street, I be prying road.

0:10:35 My name is Marvin Barnes.

0:10:36 Welcome.

0:10:37 I am a member of the Young and Heart Group

0:10:38 out at the Twin Falls Reform Church.

0:10:40 And this Saturday, you the council and all the members of the people here in Twin and the

0:10:46 county will find all the first responders in one location.

0:10:50 If you haven't heard about it between 10 and 2 Saturday morning, 20 units from the city

0:10:55 of Twin, the county of Twin, and the surrounding area is filer bringing in people.

0:11:01 And the first responders are coming out to, excuse me, show off, which is, we need to

0:11:07 have them.

0:11:08 public doesn't know. I retired from the Air Force and the public doesn't fully understand

0:11:11 everything. It goes on from our police and our fire names and all these. So it's an opportunity

0:11:16 to come out and see them, greet them, shake their hands. We understand we're having the

0:11:20 dogs are showing up, the drones, the SWAT team, the bomb squad. They're cutting a car in half

0:11:28 and we've got a nice little quarter of hot dog for anybody who wants to show up. It's tended

0:11:32 to on Saturday morning and I've got packets, I'll leave with the clerk for you. It's great,

0:11:36 You go see flyers around, but it's just a chance for us to thank those first responders.

0:11:41 Us older types, kind of know we're going to see these things.

0:11:44 I'm necessarily shaking their hands saying thanks, but just to Mayor and Council.

0:11:48 Come out and join us and have fun with us.

0:11:50 Great.

0:11:51 Where is it located?

0:11:52 Twin Falls, where is the hospital?

0:11:54 Twin Falls, where is the hospital?

0:11:55 Twin Falls, where is the hospital?

0:11:56 The hospital is in part of your ambulance circle.

0:11:58 Excellent.

0:11:59 Thank you, Mr. Barnes.

0:12:00 No worries.

0:12:01 Appreciate the information.

0:12:02 Is there anyone else from the public wishing to address the council this evening?

0:12:09 Seeing no one, we will move on to the consent calendar on the agenda council.

0:12:15 I'd like to move that we accept the consent calendar.

0:12:19 Second.

0:12:21 Motion by Nikki Boyd.

0:12:23 Seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the consent calendar.

0:12:26 I'm sorry, Susanne, I saw your light there.

0:12:28 I was just going to make a motion, but they're headed me.

0:12:30 And I'm trying to find the right place on my papers here to write these things down.

0:12:37 I think you boy Ruth Pierce.

0:12:39 Is there any discussion on the consent calendar?

0:12:44 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call though please.

0:12:46 Sean Beriker?

0:12:50 Yes.

0:12:51 I think you boy?

0:12:52 Yes.

0:12:53 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:12:54 Yes.

0:12:55 Greg Lanting?

0:12:56 Yes.

0:12:57 Ruth Pierce?

0:12:58 Yes.

0:12:59 Christopher Reed?

0:13:00 Yes.

0:13:01 Chris Tockington?

0:13:02 Yes.

0:13:03 Motion passes.

0:13:04 Seven to zero.

0:13:05 Greg Lanting.

0:13:06 How are we going to have Robin looking at this

0:13:08 and it looks to be a little different spot

0:13:10 than we've had in the past, at least the addresses on here.

0:13:13 We're probably, can I say Robin, boy,

0:13:15 I'm going to rob a dog.

0:13:16 Grab and dovry.

0:13:17 Yeah, so.

0:13:18 Where is it going to be located this year?

0:13:20 No.

0:13:21 In the parking lot behind Rudy's and Save More Drug.

0:13:24 All right.

0:13:24 OK.

0:13:25 So this is the Twin Falls Tonight concert series.

0:13:27 So with the main avenue project underway,

0:13:29 they'll be relocating to the parking lot behind Rudy's

0:13:34 temporarily as this kicks off on July 5th, so that was one of the items we approved this

0:13:38 evening.

0:13:39 Yeah, thank you, Robert.

0:13:42 I also want to take the opportunity to invite Tom, Mike Sell, would you like to come up and

0:13:47 give us the brief details on the annual Vietnam War Veterans Commemoration event?

0:13:52 No, I wouldn't.

0:13:53 But here I am.

0:13:54 There you are.

0:13:55 Good evening, my name is Tom, Mike Sell, I am a Twin Falls City resident, former sitter

0:14:02 up there.

0:14:04 This is our third annual Vietnam War Veterans Welcome Home celebration.

0:14:09 As many of you up there remember the Vietnam War and the lack of attention our veterans

0:14:16 got when they returned as compared to what they are now.

0:14:20 So there's a movement throughout the country to welcome them home and thank them for their

0:14:23 service and remind the rest of our community that they're no different than any other soldier

0:14:28 at any other time or any other war conflict and that's what we're doing is thanking them

0:14:33 and helping them find services and other needs that they may have as veterans if they've

0:14:39 been overlooked or have a look for themselves.

0:14:43 Great.

0:14:44 Thank you, Tom.

0:14:45 So that's on Saturday.

0:14:46 We're on the 15th, Saturday.

0:14:48 At Harman Park.

0:14:49 At Harman Park.

0:14:50 And three lengths for everybody that comes, veteran service is available for veterans.

0:14:56 And since right now, a whole lot of Vietnam veterans ride bikes, there'd be a lot of bikers

0:15:02 there.

0:15:03 to ride through town. We're expecting a couple hundred riders this year. Thank you.

0:15:08 Great. Thank you, Tom. And I'll also throw a little plug in for one of the other events

0:15:13 that we just approved on the consent calendar. So the annual 4th of July celebration this

0:15:17 year will be having a community breakfast to be held at the Twin Falls City Park from

0:15:21 8 until 10 that morning. And then the annual fireworks display will take place in the evening

0:15:27 at the College of Southern Idaho, starting at 8 and concluding as soon as it gets dark

0:15:33 and the fireworks are done. There's those plugs. Next, under items for consideration,

0:15:41 the first is a request to approve the food concession and commercial display application

0:15:46 for the hot dog carts to be located at 203 Fifth Avenue South on the sidewalk. And we have Sharon

0:15:52 Brian, our deputy city clerk, to present that. Okay, I'm Sharon Brian, the deputy city clerk.

0:16:08 We are requesting a food concession and commercial display application for the hot dog car to be

0:16:14 located at 203-5th Avenue South on the sidewalk there and in order for the hot dog car to set

0:16:24 up on public sidewalk, they need the consent of the adjacent property owner, which is Red's

0:16:31 Trading Post and they have gotten that consent and then they also need the city council's

0:16:38 consent.

0:16:40 We haven't had to do this before, but not too long ago, we updated the code and we just

0:16:50 missed that the council needs to approve any food concession or commercial display that

0:16:59 is set up or that is using public right-of-way, so the ice cream trucks and anything that's

0:17:06 going to be on a sidewalk. We'll need to come before council. This time we put it as an item

0:17:14 for consideration and after this I think we'll just put it on the consent calendar if that's

0:17:19 okay with you. So tonight I'm asking for approval of the HUTDA card. Staff recommends approval.

0:17:31 They've met all the code requirements, and so this is the last piece that they need to

0:17:38 meet in order to do that.

0:17:40 Thank you, Sharon.

0:17:43 Ruth Pierce.

0:17:44 I would make a motion if we're ready unless anybody has any questions.

0:17:48 I think we may have a couple questions.

0:17:51 Okay.

0:17:52 Sharon, I'm not quite sure of the implications of this for requiring the permit.

0:17:57 Does this mean that Ketchum Burrito has tables and chairs out and the former

0:18:06 Crawley's coffee shop that sporadically but repeatedly has?

0:18:11 No, they are not mobile or they're kind of and they're in the downtown area and I'm

0:18:17 gonna have it kind of talk about this.

0:18:21 This request is only for the mobile the mobile stains so brick and mortar

0:18:29 businesses don't have to do this, but one thing you will probably be seeing here in the very

0:18:33 near future would be a way to authorize a change to our code to better control those types of

0:18:41 situations now that we have the main street probably coming through. It's always just been

0:18:46 one of those things that we just kind of knew was happening, but didn't really do much about it.

0:18:50 We need to now that we're setting up the sidewalk for those things. We need to primarily have a code

0:18:56 amendment. So more of a time of that. So this is this what you're looking at

0:19:02 tonight is these guys get an annual permit to set up in the right-of-way. This is

0:19:07 different from the ones that set up on private property. Those ones are all

0:19:10 handled at the staff level and and we just do that you know under here about

0:19:15 them probably but when they're using the right-of-way the streets or the sidewalks

0:19:18 they got to come through and get the council authorization before we give

0:19:23 from their permit, and it's an annual thing,

0:19:25 so if this guy's successful, he'll be back every year,

0:19:28 hopefully, and then the others that have been coming,

0:19:31 we'll start bringing them through as well,

0:19:33 and we can send calendar.

0:19:35 Thank you.

0:19:35 We do want to bring forward an amendment that deals

0:19:37 with tables in front of restaurants

0:19:41 that are brick and mortar type restaurants,

0:19:43 and that'll become in here pretty soon.

0:19:47 Thank you, Mitch.

0:19:48 Chris Reed.

0:19:49 So this is for a specific location.

0:19:51 What about those vendors that are moving around?

0:19:53 Do they need to come back if they're going to be moving locations for a new address?

0:19:58 If they're going to a different address?

0:19:59 Yes.

0:20:00 Yes.

0:20:01 Whether they're on private property or they're on public right away, if they want to move

0:20:06 to a different location, they would have to bring us a site map and staff would have to

0:20:13 approve that as well as if they're on public property, then yes, they would have to get

0:20:20 council approval.

0:20:21 So looking at this, the code here, public streets are part of it, or sidewalks, and you mentioned

0:20:28 the ice cream truck.

0:20:29 So this ice cream truck that drives around making noise, you know, all hours a day.

0:20:33 Yeah, the ice cream trucks, they don't part, I mean they park just long enough to sell ice

0:20:40 cream and then they're gone.

0:20:41 Okay.

0:20:42 But they would have to get, every year when they apply, they would have to come in and get

0:20:46 Council approval because they are selling on right of way but they wouldn't use

0:20:51 to have a slight map because they're always on the go. Okay. Makes sense.

0:20:55 The addition that I would share would be they need to tell us what they're doing

0:21:01 when they apply. This particular one is saying we want to set up here in the

0:21:06 application and so we're proving that application. If these guys decide that

0:21:10 they're going somewhere else we probably need to amend that application. The

0:21:14 It's also going to prove that.

0:21:23 And we'll approve what the application is.

0:21:26 So if it's a mobile thing like an ice cream truck, you'll know that when you approve it and you'll approve it.

0:21:31 And then the following year they'll come in for renewal and we'll just do it every time.

0:21:36 In a specific case like this, if they want to go somewhere else,

0:21:40 they'll probably need to amend their application and come back for a new approval.

0:21:45 But hopefully we get that all squared away before we need to come into cancel,

0:21:50 so that you know what you're approving,

0:21:52 and they know what they're asking for,

0:21:54 and we all move out of here, and then let's go.

0:21:57 Perfect. Thank you.

0:21:59 Susan Hawkins.

0:22:01 Couple quick questions.

0:22:02 So what is the cost of a permit to do something like this?

0:22:05 And if they do need to amend it, is there a cost for that?

0:22:09 It's $100 a year for the permit, and then they

0:22:13 have to have current insurance.

0:22:16 And no, if they amend it like, say, if this location,

0:22:22 she's not getting any business, so she

0:22:24 wants to move to a different location,

0:22:26 all she needs to do is come back to me and tell me

0:22:30 where she wants to locate.

0:22:32 And if it's on right of way, public right of way,

0:22:35 then she'll be coming back to council.

0:22:38 If she decides to set up on private property,

0:22:40 she will not have to come back to council.

0:22:43 She will just have to get a staff approval.

0:22:46 So, and just because we're on this,

0:22:48 this is probably more from it again,

0:22:49 but we went through the big mobile vendor amendments.

0:22:55 It's been over a year now.

0:22:57 Do we have any feedback on that and how that's working

0:23:00 and where we're at on that whole process?

0:23:03 I think they like that about coming only once a year.

0:23:08 I haven't heard anything about the fees.

0:23:11 It is the requirements for this,

0:23:16 but I think they have a problem with when they're just starting up

0:23:21 and they're having to pay for somebody to take care of their trash

0:23:26 and their grease and things like that.

0:23:28 They kind of grumble about that.

0:23:31 I know that between Jonathan and I, we can spend a good day on trying to get, go through

0:23:40 this application, get with them, review up and get it to the point that they can go ahead

0:23:48 and get their license.

0:23:50 But, you know, that's what we do in our job is to make sure that they follow the code and

0:24:02 get it going.

0:24:03 But it is very time consuming.

0:24:05 Thank you.

0:24:06 Appreciate the information.

0:24:10 Any other questions?

0:24:11 Ruth, is your light on just to make the motion?

0:24:13 Yes, sir.

0:24:14 Okay.

0:24:15 So I would just add one comment.

0:24:16 I do think we're seeing a growing number of food truck type operations in the community.

0:24:25 I might suggest that as we're thinking about amendments to the code for sidewalk dining,

0:24:32 as we're having more requests maybe for public right-of-way, we have the food truck component

0:24:36 that deals with commercial private property, but I know other communities, particularly Boise,

0:24:42 a lot of food trucks that operate kind of in the parking stalls in certain areas of Boise

0:24:49 that maybe we should be taking a more comprehensive look of what does this look like in the future

0:24:54 and are other maybe some experiences from other cities of what they're seeing because it does seem

0:25:00 to be a growing trend that has taken off a bit here rather than trying to deal with these kind

0:25:05 of piecemeal as they come through maybe we look at a more global way of that. There's my two cents.

0:25:14 I am ready to make a motion to approve the request to approve the food concession and commercial display application for the hot dog cart to be located at 203 5th Avenue South on the sidewalk.

0:25:33 Second.

0:25:34 Motion by Ruth Piers, seconded by Suzanne Hawkins to approve the application for the Hot Dog

0:25:39 Cart as presented.

0:25:40 Is there any discussion?

0:25:41 Chair in roll call vote please.

0:25:45 Niki Boyd?

0:25:46 Yes.

0:25:47 Suzanne Hawkins?

0:25:48 Yes.

0:25:49 Greg Lanting?

0:25:50 Yes.

0:25:51 Ruth Piers?

0:25:52 Yes.

0:25:53 Christopher Reed?

0:25:54 Yes.

0:25:55 Chris Hockington?

0:25:56 Yes.

0:25:57 Sean Berriger?

0:25:58 Yes.

0:25:59 Motion passes.

0:26:00 Seven to zero.

0:26:02 Next in the agenda is a presentation on the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency main

0:26:06 Avenue redevelopment project and we have Paul Johnson with CH2M. Welcome Paul.

0:26:12 Thank you Mr. Mayor and members of the Council. This is just a quick

0:26:29 informative update on the progress of the main Avenue project. The same report

0:26:35 that was presented to the Urban Renewal Agency Board earlier today. In the photo

0:26:41 Also in the upper left we had a site visit by Niko Vanderhorst from Otak.

0:26:45 They're coming out twice per month to work with Guho and the team to make sure that all

0:26:50 of the technical details are fully addressed and submittals are reviewed and all questions

0:26:56 are answered.

0:26:57 Jesse Schurman of the city in the middle and then myself on the right.

0:27:02 In the upper right corner you'll see the sidewalk that is going in place between Gooding and

0:27:07 in Shoshone, along the festival street,

0:27:11 that's about a 19 foot wide concrete section,

0:27:13 and already there are tables and dining

0:27:16 in front of those restaurants,

0:27:18 so it's exciting to see that coming back in place.

0:27:20 You'll see brick pavers here very soon,

0:27:22 and asphalt paving within two weeks on that block.

0:27:26 And lower left, just down the street a little further,

0:27:29 continuing with some of the sidewalk demolition.

0:27:32 Again, Guho is doing a great job

0:27:33 of keeping the pedestrian access to those areas

0:27:37 during construction, they've kept about a five foot sidewalk section and then when that needs

0:27:41 to come out they immediately come back in with compacted gravel to make sure there's full access

0:27:47 in front of all of the businesses. And of course there is the entrance system, there are the entrance

0:27:52 system of the business from the backside as well in the parking areas. In the lower right, you see a

0:27:58 photograph of the light pole base and electrical going in to some of the creative thinking that Guho

0:28:05 offered earlier in the project and collaborated with the design team was to make sure that

0:28:10 those bases are no deeper than five feet. The original design showed seven feet deep and

0:28:15 we would have had to have OSHA required shoring and so forth to protect the workers from potential

0:28:22 cave-ins so we value engineered that and came up with a five foot deep foundation that was

0:28:28 suitable for the design team and a lot safer for the workers in working on the project.

0:28:32 So those are just a few examples of photos of what's going on.

0:28:36 The majority of the work is ongoing between Fairfield and Gooding and Gooding to Shoshone.

0:28:42 The Gooding to Shoshone section should be complete by mid-July.

0:28:47 That's a few weeks later than we originally forecast. Sorry about that.

0:28:50 But a little bit of weather and so forth and all of the submittals and technical clarifications on that first block are just taking a little more time.

0:28:58 But Guho is speeding up on the second block, which is Fairfield to Gooding, and we plan

0:29:06 to have the project completed, substantially complete as promised, by October 31st, 2017.

0:29:12 So they're making up time as they go.

0:29:15 Already today they were starting on the basement demolition in front of the Crowley Properties

0:29:23 twin beans and the former Moose Hill property, so that will be in filled within the next

0:29:28 few weeks and ready for that street to begin as the third block that will begin in the mid-July

0:29:35 timeframe.

0:29:44 On July 2nd, we had a meeting with several of the merchants who were the expressed legitimate

0:29:50 concerns about some of the signage and the parking availability, and we think we had

0:29:56 a good discussion with them and agreed to improve our processes by providing weekly reports

0:30:02 to the merchants. The City Council should also be copying on those on the URA board. I think

0:30:08 that's an improvement just to let them know week by week was coming up so they can anticipate

0:30:13 the work on their block whether it be storm drainage or underground electrical or sidewalk

0:30:19 demolition or new pavement. So Guho's doing a great job and in turn the City is working

0:30:25 to make sure that more of the parking areas are filled with visitors and customers to downtown

0:30:33 versus, say, business people, certainly not contractors from our project, who are doing

0:30:38 a good job of managing that to make sure that the workers are parking in designated areas

0:30:44 only, well away from the businesses.

0:30:48 So there are a couple of other projects going on downtown, and I know that Travis and Josh

0:30:53 Jesse are all working on making sure those parking areas stay open for the general public.

0:30:59 I wanted to make sure that if you have any detailed questions about construction, I'll answer the general ones,

0:31:07 but Anthony Guho is here from the construction management company, Anthony.

0:31:12 If you raise your hand, and then Rob Kloninger, who's here on a daily basis, the project superintendent,

0:31:17 keeping checking in with everyone and making sure that their questions are answered.

0:31:22 So we're at a very difficult point in the project right now with the first two blocks

0:31:28 underway and until just recently all people saw were demolition but now they're seeing

0:31:33 the build back with new sidewalks, new curb and gutter.

0:31:37 The new concrete pavers as you see here will be going in very soon on that first block.

0:31:42 So it's coming together.

0:31:43 It's very exciting and we're on schedule and on budget.

0:31:49 and I'll pause for any questions.

0:31:52 Thank you, Paul, Chris, talking to you.

0:31:54 Well, I walked the project again today,

0:31:55 and I'm really impressed with that wide sidewalk.

0:31:58 That is gonna be such an uptick

0:32:00 for the appearance of downtown.

0:32:03 I'm not sure if you or the contractors

0:32:05 could reply to this or wish to,

0:32:07 but I have a source that is confirmed

0:32:11 what I found from another source

0:32:12 at the end of a little bit of a labor problem,

0:32:15 getting qualified labor, and that may be

0:32:18 causing the project to drag.

0:32:20 You want to confirm that or respond to it?

0:32:24 Anthony, could you address that, please?

0:32:27 And even if that's the case, you're still sticking

0:32:30 with roughly the October 31 in project.

0:32:34 Correct.

0:32:34 So it's not delaying us directly statewide.

0:32:38 There's nation-wide.

0:32:39 There's a shortage in labor in the construction industry.

0:32:43 And so it eliminates some of the possibilities

0:32:47 with working double ships, triple ships, and whatnot.

0:32:50 So that came up in our business meeting.

0:32:52 We had a couple of weeks ago, but overall,

0:32:55 we're stacked up well with all the subcontractors

0:32:57 we have and plugging through it.

0:33:01 That's what our wand is.

0:33:05 Any other questions or comments for Paul?

0:33:10 Well, thank you for the work that you're doing.

0:33:12 And thanks to the crews that are down there working

0:33:14 at many all hours of the day, I've

0:33:17 been down there a few times over the weekend

0:33:19 and seeing a lot of work going on.

0:33:21 So exciting to see some construction coming back,

0:33:24 and hopefully that will continue to encourage folks

0:33:27 to go down and support those local businesses

0:33:29 and be a part of this great project.

0:33:32 Thank you.

0:33:35 Next is a presentation about the city's progress

0:33:37 on the fiscal year 2017-2018 budget preparation,

0:33:42 as well as an opportunity for city council input.

0:33:44 We have our city manager, Travis Rothweiler.

0:33:45 Welcome, Travis.

0:34:07 Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the council.

0:34:09 So this is, I believe our third conversation

0:34:12 that we've had regarding the construction of the FY18 budget.

0:34:19 And we are going to continue these conversations.

0:34:21 So tonight's purpose is to give what I would call a very brief

0:34:26 preview in terms of where we're at.

0:34:29 And there may be still a lot of questions,

0:34:31 but we'll talk about the sequencing of information

0:34:33 and how that comes into the city and how as we continue

0:34:36 to evolve this budget from now until the time

0:34:39 that we asked you to adopt it on the 28th of August,

0:34:43 how more information will come in

0:34:45 based upon the statutory guidelines.

0:34:48 But really, what we're trying to do in every single budget

0:34:51 is to go forward and create a budget that is sustainable

0:34:56 and that it also allows us to deliver excellence

0:34:58 in public service.

0:34:59 And so what you see is creating sustained excellence

0:35:02 through our process.

0:35:04 And our philosophy of creating the fiscal year 18 budget

0:35:08 is really the same philosophy that we've incorporated

0:35:11 every single year that we started this process.

0:35:14 And as you recall, when we started

0:35:16 the new more dynamic process, we really

0:35:18 wanted to go down to the very basics as, why do we budget?

0:35:21 The very first thing is that we want to make sure

0:35:23 that we're providing high quality government services

0:35:26 to the citizens and that we're honoring and meeting

0:35:28 their expectations.

0:35:31 That we as an organization are constantly

0:35:33 challenging how we deliver goods and services

0:35:36 and that we want to find new ways of exploring that service delivery method,

0:35:40 and we're going to incorporate process review,

0:35:43 going to incorporate technology.

0:35:45 It's the technology that's dancing your slides.

0:35:48 It is.

0:35:50 It is not even on a time.

0:35:53 But that is one way to get through this presentation really fast.

0:35:56 Yeah, I need to add your presentations.

0:35:58 And maybe that's a little Freudian because there's a certain basketball game on it.

0:36:03 And a certain player by the name of Kevin Durant might be playing tonight, and I might have been interested in that, so we'll go.

0:36:10 The other thing is we want to make sure that we are being good stewards of the city's resources, that we recognize that we have a fiduciary responsibility, that the money that comes in, that we then turn into government services, is not money that is ours.

0:36:29 In fact, we're very, very different than a private institution in which we're not looking

0:36:35 at profit more.

0:36:36 What we're trying to do is to make sure that we're offering the highest level of services

0:36:40 to our citizens at the greatest rate of return for their investment.

0:36:46 And we really look at our citizens as our shareholders in our corporation.

0:36:51 The next thing is that we want to make sure that this budget honors the employees that

0:36:57 work tirelessly through this process.

0:37:00 So all of everything that we do inside of our budget is driven by the City's Strategic

0:37:06 Plan.

0:37:07 The Strategic Plan was created in 2012, and this will be this last budget in which we're

0:37:13 using the current version of the City's Strategic Plan to really guide that 2030 vision.

0:37:19 As you know, we are in a series of conversations with our stakeholders as well as the community

0:37:26 And the community engagement piece will occur in July,

0:37:29 as we've had a whole series of conversations,

0:37:32 to really redefine that vision

0:37:34 that we're trying to create around

0:37:36 those eight primary focus areas within our communities.

0:37:40 We believe those conversations of the past

0:37:42 and the conversations of the future

0:37:43 really strengthen our organization

0:37:45 and help set the vision of what we're trying to achieve.

0:37:49 Last year, we kind of changed this a little bit.

0:37:52 You'll recall that all, we looked at all eight focus areas

0:37:55 as being equal, and as we're having the conversation,

0:37:59 we recognize that not one of the other seven service deliveries

0:38:04 or visions could be realized if we didn't have

0:38:06 a quality, competent, strong employee staff

0:38:10 that's working tirelessly on the front lines

0:38:12 to deliver that service.

0:38:14 So really everything for our success

0:38:16 and to realize our vision, it is driven

0:38:19 by the quality employees that we have within our organization.

0:38:23 So one of the things that we wanna do tonight

0:38:25 is to take a look back at the current budget tonight.

0:38:28 We'll get this published, but if you really wanted to,

0:38:30 we put a lot of information on a single page,

0:38:32 and so we'll read through what that is.

0:38:34 This is an eyesight test.

0:38:36 Yeah.

0:38:37 OK.

0:38:38 So the first thing to recognize is that our budget that we

0:38:41 had the Council adopt and approve

0:38:44 was based upon a community total taxable value of $2,392,000,

0:38:52 the total tax-supported enterprise budget

0:38:54 for the City of Twin Falls, the net budget last year

0:38:57 was $60,958,000.

0:39:00 And we utilized the statutory increase of 3%

0:39:04 and the new growth formula.

0:39:06 That is what is provided to local governments

0:39:08 in Idaho codes to be able to move forward.

0:39:10 And we had the new construction value of $67.124 million

0:39:14 that represented the new growth that occurred moving forward.

0:39:18 That, in its totality, created a tax rate of $8.03

0:39:23 for $1,000 of taxable value and it produced $19.276 million in total property tax revenue.

0:39:33 When you break that down to the average resident inside of the City of Twin Falls, that represents

0:39:38 about $572 on the average owner occupied home inside of the City of Twin Falls.

0:39:45 And every year we do our comparison and we say, how does the City of Twin Falls stack

0:39:49 up against our competition and as we illustrate every single year we are incredibly competitive.

0:39:55 Now you cannot look at a tax rate only because when you look at a tax rate the tax rate is

0:40:01 a simple multiplier by taking a look at the total government spending and the community's

0:40:05 total taxable value and then that multiplier is multiplied against every single property

0:40:11 inside of our community. And so by comparing tax rate to tax rate does not illustrate the

0:40:19 tax burden that is experienced in those individual communities because you really need to look

0:40:25 at a tax rate as a simple multiplier. If you look at the tax rate as a mill levy, you're

0:40:30 looking at it wrong because inside of the state of Idaho we do not assess mills like you'll

0:40:35 see in other communities where the mill has an assigned value.

0:40:41 And then last year, in this current fiscal year, we take a look at those averages, and

0:40:46 it's $48.94 for 18,000 gallons of water, and we base that upon the average resident's water

0:40:56 consumption within our community.

0:40:58 a sewer rate at the 8,000 gallon cap of $25.97, and then the sanitation and curates side was

0:41:06 like a link of $16.90. So that's the current budget that we have. It's the cost and the impact

0:41:14 to the citizens and kind of the quick facts that we have. You'll notice that as we look

0:41:21 at this budget, it is slightly different.

0:41:25 So we won't have the community's total taxable value until about August.

0:41:31 And we're starting this conversation very, very early, and we won't be able to accurately

0:41:37 predict what the tax rate associated with this budget will be.

0:41:42 So one of the conversations that is probably occurring, not only within this room, but also

0:41:48 in other places of the community, is what is occurring

0:41:53 when they got their mailed their tax assessments.

0:41:56 And we've answered a few phone calls

0:41:58 and we've seen lots of increases

0:41:59 in the terms of tax assessments.

0:42:02 But what's important to remember is that tax assessment

0:42:05 is not an indicator of what is going to occur

0:42:09 with your property taxes.

0:42:10 In fact, that is just one very small piece

0:42:14 of the overall process.

0:42:16 So recognize that the tax rate is the multiplier and annually a local government can only collect

0:42:22 3% more property taxes than what it did the prior year.

0:42:28 So if your property tax value increased by 15%, that should be looked at in a sense is a good thing

0:42:36 because it is very very closely indexed to the marketability or the saleability of your home

0:42:42 and that's in accordance with Idaho Code.

0:42:44 that your real property that you have inside of the City of Twin Falls is

0:42:48 growing and that hasn't always been the case as we will recall when it's

0:42:53 occurred in 2009, 2010, 2011 where we actually saw depreciation of property in

0:43:00 fact very very significant depreciations. What we're looking at is that

0:43:05 appreciation is occurring and that we will probably see a tax rate that will be

0:43:12 similar, or will cause a similar tax burden to what we've seen in the past, because of

0:43:19 that statutory cap of a 3% increase should local government elect to take that.

0:43:26 The other important thing to recognize is the homeowners exemption has also increased

0:43:30 from about $94,000 to $100,000 by movement, by creation of new law by the Idaho legislature.

0:43:40 In the past, the homeowners exemption for occupied homes was indexed.

0:43:47 The legislature has now made the decision to remove that from indexing and to return to

0:43:52 more of a static number of the way that they were in the past.

0:43:57 So the total budget, estimated budget, and I say estimated because I'm coming to you

0:44:01 with a budget that's not balanced yet.

0:44:04 We still have a month.

0:44:06 So we're still working, but we want to make sure that continuing throughout this process

0:44:10 we're capturing council input.

0:44:13 We don't want to have a balanced budget tonight,

0:44:16 and then try to find ways to incorporate

0:44:19 the council thoughts and ideas.

0:44:20 We want to make sure that that is included

0:44:23 in the overall process.

0:44:25 We want to make sure that we heard you the first time

0:44:27 when we engaged you, and then we want to make sure

0:44:29 that those important items that you're going to discuss

0:44:31 are included inside of this budget,

0:44:34 because we are statutorily obligated

0:44:36 to present to you a balanced budget,

0:44:38 and we will do that, and we'll show the calendar

0:44:40 when we expect that to occur.

0:44:43 So right now we're looking at a total budget

0:44:44 of about $66 million total tax-reported funding

0:44:48 of about 39,397,000 dollars in enterprise funding.

0:44:54 Those parts of our organization

0:44:58 that operate small independent businesses

0:45:00 are Water Fund, our sewer fund.

0:45:01 Those free, they're driven by fees

0:45:03 in which those fees help those funds operate.

0:45:07 those areas total 26,605,000 dollars.

0:45:13 It does utilize the 3% of new construction statutory increases

0:45:17 as the past budgets.

0:45:19 Our new construction number this year

0:45:21 is down 28% from the last number.

0:45:23 And that should be something that's going,

0:45:25 why is that down?

0:45:27 Every building permit that you look at is up.

0:45:30 Every single construction report that I send you is up.

0:45:34 How can our new construction be down 28%?

0:45:38 And what's important is there is a leg time

0:45:41 from the time in which we issue the permit

0:45:43 and the time in which the project is owner occupied.

0:45:47 So until the property is occupied

0:45:50 and the owner has taken possession,

0:45:53 it does not fall onto the tax rules.

0:45:55 And so when we received this, we were shocked

0:45:58 because we're anticipating a new construction role

0:46:00 very similar to what we had.

0:46:02 Lori and members of her team reached out to our friends and partners at the county to ask

0:46:07 why because it is the county who assesses all of our property.

0:46:10 And they shared that about 60 to 70 homes in about a $200,000 taxable value range came

0:46:17 onto the rolls after the first of the year.

0:46:20 So what's important to recognize is the property taxes that we pay are based upon a calendar

0:46:25 year and we're operating on a fiscal year.

0:46:27 So sometimes there is a bit of a lifetime between those, and so what we're seeing in

0:46:34 the first new construction number is slightly less, about 28% of what we had anticipated.

0:46:42 What does that translate into dollars?

0:46:44 It was about $153,000 less revenue than what we were looking at.

0:46:52 So when the long-term planning committee was here and they were making their recommendations,

0:46:57 were using a new construction number that was slightly larger. We're anticipating right

0:47:02 now total property tax collections of $20,251,000 and we can't project a tax rate at this time.

0:47:12 So remember a tax rate is that multiplier where you have government spending divided

0:47:18 by the community's total taxable value and if you look at the first bullet we will not

0:47:22 have that until August of 2017 and in the past we've tried to project that and we've

0:47:29 put you on a roller coaster of it and even after we've gotten the first response and then

0:47:34 a second response and a third response we have now decided that we are going to have

0:47:40 a conversation not necessarily about what is that tax rate but we're going to have an

0:47:44 intentional conversation about what does that mean in terms of our ability to offer services

0:47:49 and the services that you want to move forward.

0:47:52 Because if we waited until we had the tax rate,

0:47:54 we really shouldn't begin this conversation

0:47:56 until the second week of August.

0:47:58 And we don't believe having just two weeks

0:48:00 to have a conversation about a $66 million budget is appropriate

0:48:05 and doesn't honor our fiduciary responsibility to the citizens.

0:48:10 We're looking at about a functional rate increase

0:48:13 of 1.95% to the water rate.

0:48:17 And we say functional because the arsenic rate kind of plays with what that rate looks like until the consumption rate of our bill

0:48:25 Will actually go up about two and a half percent, but when you incorporate the flat arsenic fee

0:48:30 The effective net rate increase to our water customers is about 1.95 percent

0:48:36 The sewer rate is about a 5% increase based upon

0:48:39 2,000 gallons per month now one of the things that we're going to spend some time exploring is that

0:48:45 that eight, excuse me, about 8,000 gallons a month, not 2,000 gallons a month.

0:48:50 We want to spend some time looking at that 8,000 gallon cap because we believe that is

0:48:57 not an accurate reflection of the amount of sewer that is consumed by our residential

0:49:04 properties.

0:49:05 And we had this conversation with you last year.

0:49:08 We believe there's about 30 to 35% of our total customers that exceed that 8,000 gallons

0:49:15 cap, and which that means is that when you cut that off, those who are below that cap

0:49:20 are actually paying more per unit in comparison to raising that cap.

0:49:25 So we're looking at some different options, and one of the things that we're looking

0:49:28 at is more of a seasonal option, where we take a look at the true water consumption

0:49:36 in the month of November, December, January, and February.

0:49:40 months where we're not typically irrigating. And that bill over the course of those four

0:49:46 months is averaged and then you apply that to the summer months in which irrigation is

0:49:51 occurring. The other thing that we could look at doing is we could raise that cap and we

0:49:56 felt that if we raise that cap there's probably some outliers that were never going to be able

0:50:01 to truly effectively hit. And so you may raise that up to say 10, 12,000 gallons but what

0:50:10 impacts in the summer is that some people still utilize potable water for

0:50:17 irrigation. They don't send it down the drain and that would artificially raise

0:50:21 their sewer bills which would not be fair to them. So we're looking at some

0:50:25 different options but again based upon 8,000 gallon cap the sewer rate would be

0:50:32 be about a 5% increase to $27.27 per month based upon that level of consumption.

0:50:42 The recycling rate would go up about 2.5% to $17.31 per month.

0:50:49 That's kind of the focus of the budget that we're looking at now.

0:50:56 The rate increases allow us to honor and meet our bond covenants that we have established.

0:51:01 And that's one of the driving factors, especially in the sewer fund.

0:51:05 It also allows us to continue to move forward on those capital initiatives that we've sent.

0:51:12 Any questions on this piece of it, so far?

0:51:15 Just answer that.

0:51:17 At 5% is necessary to fulfill the profiling for our bond for the wastewater.

0:51:24 Yeah, for that and to do the capital items of the count that we talk about in terms of the area.

0:51:30 When we do the zone maintenance.

0:51:32 Those are the two pieces that are really driving that piece of budget.

0:51:42 So the two areas that we really want to spend some time focusing tonight on are the positions

0:51:47 that are included in the budget.

0:51:49 We want to spend some time walking through that.

0:51:51 We also want to talk about the salaries, the benefits, those types of things.

0:51:55 And then we also want to spend some time talking about the capital.

0:51:58 We want the capital projects that are included so far for your consideration.

0:52:05 and then to make sure that we're answering those questions

0:52:07 to be able to move forward.

0:52:08 So this really is an excerpt out of the focus area eight

0:52:11 that's described in the strategic plan.

0:52:14 One of the things that we talk about

0:52:16 is being a lean and properly funded staff,

0:52:19 but one of the things is that you can become too lean.

0:52:22 As an organization, you become so lean

0:52:25 that you actually have diminishing returns

0:52:29 in the areas of efficiency.

0:52:30 So one of the things that we've done in this budget

0:52:32 to really spend some time looking at what do we need to be able to do, and whether the

0:52:38 total number of positions that we want to add and need to add, but what can we sustain?

0:52:44 Because the one thing that we don't want to do is add so many positions into our budget

0:52:50 that we can't suss forward to them as we continue to try to be competitive in our areas of compensation.

0:52:57 So it's that balancing act of making sure that we have enough boots on the ground and

0:53:01 we have the long-term ability to be able to afford them.

0:53:07 So what we're looking at this year is a three and a half

0:53:09 percent adjustment for all of our employees based upon our

0:53:13 performance system that we have.

0:53:16 And then we have the compression ratio adjustments that are

0:53:20 inside of our table, and that allows for us to ensure that

0:53:24 our positions remain competitive.

0:53:27 We've apt and shared, especially when we went through

0:53:30 the mid-year adjustment site, it is important that we are

0:53:32 moving that table and we don't fall into the sins of the past where we didn't move that

0:53:38 for nine years and our tables became less and less competitive and we found that we were

0:53:44 hemorrhaging staff. One of the key areas that we're able to say now is that we are fully

0:53:49 staffed in several of the key areas. I knock on wood because it's always kind of a tenuous

0:53:56 place to be. Health insurance increases are at 7.9 percent and that will be shared

0:54:04 in that co-sharing process that we typically have with our employees. And then this budget

0:54:12 tentatively adds 8.13 FTEs at a total cost of $382,000. We want to spend some time talking

0:54:19 about that. But I want to go back up to the compensation piece just for a minute. So one

0:54:24 One of the, and that's the global hots if you will, I want you to think about that is the

0:54:28 amount of money that we're placing because we're in the process of building two new salary plans.

0:54:33 We shared that with you during the mid-year adjustments.

0:54:36 One is for the police department, the others for the fire department.

0:54:39 So what we've done is we've reserved funding to make sure that we can start the process

0:54:47 of creating more and better defined pay plans for the police and fire department that are

0:54:53 more accustomed to those areas. Now, we will not be able to achieve the optimum place in

0:55:02 a single fiscal year. It has taken us years to be able to fall into this hole, and it's

0:55:07 going to take us a few years to be able to reach out and create the plan that is of, I

0:55:14 guess, a preferred plan of our different groups. But what we're doing is we are taking some

0:55:20 significant steps each year. We did that with the mid-year adjustments and this is

0:55:24 again another significant step that I think illustrates our commitment to our

0:55:28 employees. I want to spend some time talking about the number of employees

0:55:32 because if I look at 8.13 I still shudder. That's a lot of bodies and it's like

0:55:39 oh if I were sitting in your position you might be saying I thought you said it

0:55:44 was sustainable but it really there are some really interesting things that

0:55:50 that are occurring in this budget,

0:55:52 we're gonna go through these one by one.

0:55:55 So one of the things that we have is an agreement

0:55:59 with Wonderlichen Wakefield for the delivery

0:56:04 of city attorney and prosecution services.

0:56:08 And in that agreement, it contemplated

0:56:11 when we first created it that the prosecution services

0:56:17 offered by the firm will cease to exist

0:56:20 on October 1st of 2008, or the beginning of fiscal year 19.

0:56:25 And we've had conversations with Fritz,

0:56:27 and we've asked if Jackie would be willing to stand and continue.

0:56:31 He's not going to laugh.

0:56:32 But he gave us that belly laugh that really says,

0:56:34 no, not going to happen at all.

0:56:36 And so we worked with Fritz to be able to, and with Shane

0:56:40 Dope, to build a plan that allows for a transition.

0:56:44 And it calls for a paralegal.

0:56:47 And we would look at hiring that paralegal in January.

0:56:50 That's why it's 0.75.

0:56:52 And then we would hire the attorney

0:56:55 at six months into the fiscal year.

0:56:57 And so what you see with those positions

0:56:59 is about a cost of about $83,000.

0:57:02 And there's a slight bump.

0:57:04 But we've already negotiated what it looks like

0:57:07 if the city takes over all the prosecution services.

0:57:10 And those two positions are nearly and completely covered

0:57:14 in fiscal year 19 with the savings of the contract.

0:57:17 So those two positions, while you will see an increase

0:57:20 in cost, that cost recedes in fiscal year 19.

0:57:26 So it's a single-year bump.

0:57:27 And what this allows us to do is to create more of a smooth

0:57:30 transition in bringing in attorneys and being

0:57:35 able to move forward.

0:57:36 And I'm going to look over to Fritz,

0:57:37 and you'll probably give you another nod,

0:57:39 that if Jackie could leave a little bit earlier than

0:57:42 October, that might make her happy.

0:57:47 So what we're trying to do is really kind of balance

0:57:51 what that looks like, because one of the things

0:57:53 when you look at the manpower piece,

0:57:56 our police department is going to continue,

0:57:59 and our code enforcement team are going to continue

0:58:00 to write citations, and they're going

0:58:02 to continue to need to go to courts,

0:58:04 and so we want to make sure that we're

0:58:05 building those bridges and those gaps.

0:58:07 We'll also say that we're going to be investigating

0:58:11 the level of workload in the prosecution services,

0:58:14 and we're also looking at what's occurring

0:58:16 at the state code to see if is that an area

0:58:20 that we need to continue to look for additional help

0:58:22 as we continue to move forward,

0:58:24 but that's out in the future.

0:58:26 One of the things that we're looking at

0:58:28 is enhancing our code enforcement services

0:58:32 and creating a much more robust program

0:58:34 than what we have right now.

0:58:36 And Sean Stanley does an absolute job,

0:58:39 and we believe that he's the right leader

0:58:41 for this job.

0:58:42 And so what do we do with all good leaders in our organization?

0:58:44 We're going to get more to do.

0:58:46 We're looking at also incorporating animal control

0:58:51 underneath code enforcement, because what we're looking at

0:58:54 is a larger quality of life and nuisance piece

0:58:58 that we believe the Shawn and his team can execute.

0:59:01 So as we're building the new building

0:59:03 and building the new structure, we

0:59:04 are moving them into the new public safety complex.

0:59:07 and they'll operate out of the operations building.

0:59:11 Right now, under the code enforcement piece,

0:59:14 all of the administrative help is split

0:59:16 across the three folks that are in the Hanson building.

0:59:19 And so having a team in the Hanson building

0:59:23 and then having you operate out of another facility,

0:59:26 we questioned whether or not that was going to be something

0:59:29 that was going to allow Sean to be successful

0:59:32 in accepting additional roles.

0:59:33 And the other thing is we wanted to have a primary point

0:59:36 of contact that was able to share and exchange information.

0:59:39 And so as we add more to the quality of life piece,

0:59:43 we felt that we needed to give Sean the tools to be able to move

0:59:47 that forward so that he could be successful and our citizen

0:59:54 could receive consistent information.

0:59:58 We're looking at adding funding, not necessarily

1:00:02 a new police officer, but we're looking

1:00:04 adding and absorbing the funding associated with us receiving the COPS grant. So as you recall we'll

1:00:10 receive the COPS grant in the beginning of this fiscal year and in accordance with that we are

1:00:16 responsible to own the salary of one officer each year for that grant. So COPS grants are absolutely

1:00:23 wonderful because they allow us to build our staff and then slowly absorb those costs and so this is

1:00:30 is the first year associated with this cop's grant that we'll absorb that in. So it's not

1:00:35 really, we're not adding a police officer. And so that 8.13 is really 7.13 potentially

1:00:43 new bodies. But when you look at the funding needed, it is that body is needed. So then you

1:00:49 look at 8.38 of custodial and staff moving forward. And one of the 2.8, right? Because

1:00:56 I mean, we have none at 2.38 and what we're doing with the 2.38 is the 0.38 is out at the airport

1:01:05 and it increases the two-thirds time staff member to full time to take on the responsibility of the

1:01:15 larger terminal building the restrooms that are in beyond the security and that in that place.

1:01:21 And then we took a look at what was needed for the new city hall and the public safety.

1:01:26 And we looked at the contracts that we're already offering, that we pay individual firms

1:01:33 to come in.

1:01:34 And this is really, really close there.

1:01:37 Most of the costs are offset with the savings because we will discontinue the contractual

1:01:42 services that we have.

1:01:44 And rather than having just a few hours of custodial staff and individuals to help maintain

1:01:49 our new facilities, we will have a team of individuals that are dedicated to that.

1:01:53 We believe that the quality will certainly rise and will also have more hours available

1:01:58 to assist us in really maintaining those new structures.

1:02:04 We're looking at adding two additional dispatchers and these are two positions, really the last

1:02:11 two positions that when we started our reductions of force associated with the recession, all

1:02:18 All of those positions have essentially been restored except for two dispatcher positions.

1:02:23 And one of the things that we have found, in fact if you would look at all of those positions

1:02:28 aside for the deputy prosecuting attorney and parent legal, which I would describe as contractual

1:02:34 obligations, the city members of the city's executive team probably looked at the dispatcher

1:02:42 positions as the single most important need because of the level of work, the call volume

1:02:48 that's coming into our call center, and the ability just to offer that frontline service

1:02:53 to our citizens when they're in their largest and most important need, and those dispatchers

1:02:59 are in that as a significant priority for us.

1:03:05 And then you'll see a half-time for Human Resource Department Benefits Coordinator.

1:03:10 And there's a caveat.

1:03:11 It's a half-time.

1:03:12 So one of the things that we want to do is a lot of the things that we're trying to do

1:03:16 in the area of one city focus largely in the area of human resource, the department.

1:03:24 And there's a lot of things that are still in process, so Gretchen is still establishing

1:03:30 her team, she is going out, and she is hiring an individual to really fill the position

1:03:35 that she vacated when she was promoted.

1:03:38 And there's some question as to whether or not that position is going to be needed, but

1:03:44 we didn't, because of how significant it is to our advancing of one city and how it really

1:03:50 connects to our employees, and our employees are really driving our process.

1:03:56 We've allocated half the funding needed for the position, but prior to it being filled,

1:04:04 we want to spend some time with process review.

1:04:06 We want to make sure that the department is fully staffed, and so that position may not

1:04:12 be funded, and it may not go forward if Gretchen and her team are able to deliver, but we

1:04:19 didn't also want to be so short-sighted that we weren't able to accomplish the critical

1:04:23 missions associated with One City if we, by not funding the position.

1:04:30 So that's kind of an explanation of those positions.

1:04:32 And it at least softens it, but still it's

1:04:37 a significant number of new bodies that

1:04:40 are added into the budget.

1:04:44 And then there are a whole bunch of positions

1:04:46 that weren't included.

1:04:48 Inside of the budget, you look at a traffic tech.

1:04:52 One of the things that we're going to do with that

1:04:53 is very similar to the deputy prosecutor

1:04:58 And the paralegal is going to allow for an over higher

1:05:01 in the advance in the event that there is a retirement.

1:05:04 And then that will recede back to one position.

1:05:08 We're looking at hiring a street operator

1:05:10 and we're going to offset some of that associated cost

1:05:14 with seasonal health.

1:05:16 But right now we feel that we're going to still continue

1:05:18 with that part time and that seasonal help

1:05:20 to be able to staff those roles.

1:05:24 We're going to be looking at the part department structure

1:05:27 And rather than adding another operator, we really kind of want to look at that structure

1:05:31 first before we add additional positions.

1:05:34 We think that there are some realignment of resources inside of the parks and recreation

1:05:41 department that we might be able to create greater efficiencies and might also help with

1:05:47 some coordination and some boots on the ground.

1:05:51 In terms of a half-time electrical inspector, that is one that I really believe that we

1:05:56 we need to watch. Over the course of the last three months, we've seen an increase in the

1:06:02 number of electrical permits. But when we've had the conversation, there is some question

1:06:10 as to whether or not it rises up to that position entirely on its own if there's some other things

1:06:16 that we will be able to do. So the electrical inspector is one that we're certainly going

1:06:20 to be keeping our eye on as we move forward. And again, this budget is in that state of develop

1:06:27 and so we'll continue to take a look at what that looks like.

1:06:31 There was a request for a Assistant Public Works Director

1:06:35 that would help us really take a look at different workloads.

1:06:39 We've removed that for the time being. That one was going to be split between

1:06:43 the Water Fund, the Sewer Fund, and the Street Fund.

1:06:47 That's three different funding sources. That is one that we'll certainly keep our eye on on looking.

1:06:51 The Fire Inspector for the time being is

1:06:55 not included into the budget.

1:06:57 We've asked again for a process review

1:07:00 when having a conversation.

1:07:02 Three firefighters who are actually in long-term planning

1:07:06 piece were suggested in 19.

1:07:09 Tim included them in the 18-budget,

1:07:11 and we've pushed them out to the 19-budget for consideration

1:07:15 at that point in time.

1:07:17 And then a new school resource officer

1:07:21 was requested as part of the process.

1:07:23 As you open up the new middle school,

1:07:25 we're going to absorb that with the existing staff.

1:07:29 One of the things that we're looking at also

1:07:31 with our friends at the school district,

1:07:32 and we've already set up the meeting,

1:07:34 is how school resource officers are funded,

1:07:37 and the process of the program.

1:07:40 We're operating after an older model,

1:07:43 and when a time at school was nine months,

1:07:47 now school is like 10 and a half months,

1:07:51 And the how the costs are shared between the two organizations we believe needs to be reviewed.

1:08:00 And so we're going to spend some time reviewing it.

1:08:03 The school operates on an entirely different fiscal year.

1:08:06 Their fiscal year begins on July 1st and we start our budget process in earnest in May and June and their budgets are set.

1:08:15 We made a commitment to continue under the existing agreement

1:08:18 and fairness with our partners at the school district,

1:08:21 and then we will continue to develop a new model

1:08:24 that will present not only to the city council,

1:08:26 but also to the school board to review

1:08:29 and what that looks like in the future

1:08:32 will be negotiated between us and the school.

1:08:35 The total cost of these positions was $719,000.

1:08:40 So you can see that those are, that's a cost

1:08:44 in terms of sustainability that we're concerned about being able to move forward long term.

1:08:51 What I will say is that I think a great case was made by every single one of the department

1:08:59 leaders on why this budget or why they should be included into the budget.

1:09:05 And these are not wants.

1:09:08 They really aren't wants.

1:09:13 But I think that one of the things that maybe our mistakes of the past is that we've been

1:09:18 too lean and maybe in our process of trying to also over time overcome the mistakes that

1:09:26 we've made associated with our salary table, we need to slowly build in the help that we

1:09:34 need to be able to move forward.

1:09:38 Twin Falls is often thought of a community of 48,000 people if you look at the census,

1:09:44 that every single day our citizens are delivering services to a community of nearly 80,000 people.

1:09:50 We have lots of guests from the outline areas that come into our community every single day

1:09:56 to take advantage of services that are provided within the City of Twin Falls that are paid

1:10:02 for by the citizens of the City of Twin Falls.

1:10:05 We have an obligation to provide that level of services to not only our citizens but to

1:10:10 all visitors.

1:10:13 that we are not going to pass these costs on, and we're not going to offer those services

1:10:18 isn't an appropriate response, and so we need to make sure that we are assembling the teams

1:10:24 to be able to meet a growing community. And as Twin Falls is growing slightly less than

1:10:29 2%, what's important to recognize is so is every community around us, and as they continue

1:10:36 to grow in their populations and the unincorporated areas continue to grow, that only creates

1:10:42 larger impact. Again, and we will we will look at this, but in the past as we've

1:10:51 illustrated approximately one half of all the infractions and misdemeanors that are

1:10:56 issued by our police department are to individuals who do not have addresses

1:11:02 or within the side of the city of Twin Falls and in excess of 25% of all the

1:11:09 automobile responses that we respond to are from individuals that are also not

1:11:14 So those are the positions and I'm happy to answer any questions and provide additional

1:11:22 clarity for the ones that we've included and for the ones that we haven't.

1:11:26 Ruth Pierce.

1:11:27 Excuse me.

1:11:29 What would you estimate the percent of benefits is on the wages for the city or Lori or Gretchen

1:11:44 or somebody?

1:11:45 So I'm going to just make a general statement and then they can certainly come up and the

1:11:51 percent of benefit is kind of tough because we budget for example for full family insurance

1:12:00 coverage and obviously at about eighty nine hundred dollars per family unit that cost as

1:12:08 a percent is going to be much larger to those men and women on the front lines as opposed

1:12:14 to those members of the organization

1:12:16 who might be in more of a department head level position.

1:12:20 But typically it's about 45%.

1:12:23 Well, in terms of because you have to look at

1:12:27 the mandate of Percy, you look at the health insurance programs

1:12:30 that we offer on the average, it's about 45%

1:12:34 uniformly for the organization.

1:12:36 Thank you.

1:12:37 Those costs include the fully burdened costs.

1:12:40 We don't look at just the cost of the position.

1:12:42 we look at the fully burdened cost to be able to look for.

1:12:47 Chris talking to me.

1:12:47 I want to be able to explain this to the public.

1:12:50 Three and a half percent bump for all employees.

1:12:54 Certainly, current cost of living.

1:12:57 But as are we call, we got ourselves

1:13:00 into a migration of employees for better playing and paying

1:13:05 slots around the state.

1:13:07 So this three and a half is to kind of build up a defense

1:13:10 and an assurance that they're valued,

1:13:14 and we want to keep them here.

1:13:16 So a lot of the organizations that we're talking to

1:13:18 are offering about a 3% adjustment.

1:13:21 And so one of the things that we look at

1:13:23 is what are the competition, and what are the offering,

1:13:27 and what does that look like?

1:13:29 What's also important to recognize,

1:13:30 and I think that you said it well,

1:13:32 is we're not necessarily entirely competitive.

1:13:36 And then what we do is very, very different.

1:13:39 And when I said we are competitive, let me

1:13:41 receive that.

1:13:41 We are competitive.

1:13:43 We're not at par.

1:13:44 And there may be a time that we're never quite at par.

1:13:47 But what's really interesting, in fact, Gretchen went to a human

1:13:52 resource group in Boise.

1:13:54 And they all kind of share what they're doing.

1:13:57 And she read the report.

1:13:58 And my response was, they're all a bunch of liars.

1:14:02 And we proved that to be true, because then I texted some of

1:14:06 my city manager friends and said, what are you guys doing?

1:14:08 And their numbers were very different than what their HR professionals were saying that

1:14:12 they were doing, but there could be an explanation.

1:14:15 So one of the things that does not occur inside of the City of Twin Falls is we do not offer

1:14:19 a cost of living adjustment.

1:14:23 Most organizations will offer a COLA and then they will offer a performance improvement on

1:14:31 top of that and when they talk about the raises that they're giving, they're only talking

1:14:38 about the performance piece, not the COLA, because in their eyes, they will say that they're

1:14:44 keeping the buying power of their employees at the same level.

1:14:52 And this year, the consumer price index is about 2% I believe, and what most organizations

1:15:00 would do is they would offer a 2% COLA, and that would just be considered, and then they

1:15:04 would offer a performance raise on top of that.

1:15:08 We do inside of the city of Twin Falls as we look at a performance-based adjustment and

1:15:12 then we move the table to ensure that we're being competitive based upon particular 10-year

1:15:19 slots.

1:15:20 We don't just slide it associated with cost of living adjustments.

1:15:24 Greg Lanting?

1:15:25 I think you answered most of the Travis Sarah one of my thoughts where I was going to bring

1:15:30 up to ask you what are others doing and because we're going to stay competitive, which we want

1:15:36 to stay competitive. I think, well, with money we spent on training for people and

1:15:41 then let somebody steal them away. That's just money lost without a doubt. So we will

1:15:47 will we get more detailed information on what some of the other cities might be

1:15:51 looking at as we go along or is that just impossible to do? We will certainly

1:15:57 continue to ask and next week is the Association of Idaho Cities Conference

1:16:01 and I would encourage you to ask and it might be really fun to come back and

1:16:05 share stories about what people say that they're going to do, because one of the

1:16:09 things is everybody is in that same boat, and everybody wants to be incredibly

1:16:15 competitive, and everybody wants to know what someone else is doing so that they

1:16:19 have that equal opportunity to retain that valuable employee that's a part of

1:16:23 their team. So we will certainly continue to ask and engage our peers. When you're

1:16:28 up at AIC, we would encourage you to maybe engage the elected officials to see

1:16:34 what's kind of on the table, and it might be fun to kind of compare stories in terms of

1:16:38 what the different cities are looking at moving forward.

1:16:41 In the areas of police and fire, many of those organizations negotiate longer term agreements

1:16:49 than what, and they put in a percent salary.

1:16:53 So for example, we know the NAPPA Police Department is about a one and a half percent

1:16:57 adjustment for their employees in this upcoming year.

1:17:02 When we built our salary tables, we know that we were behind NAPA when we did the mid-year

1:17:09 adjustments, but closing that gap.

1:17:11 This allows us to make up more ground, but we still won't be at that on par level.

1:17:16 The same is true inside of fire departments.

1:17:19 There's also lots of other different pays that are offered.

1:17:22 So pay is not as simple as how we make it.

1:17:26 There's lots of different specialty pay.

1:17:30 There's longevity pay that is certainly much more robust than what we offer inside of the

1:17:37 City of Twin Falls, and that is often not described during a budget process.

1:17:42 Those are just policies and processes that organizations are allowed to move forward.

1:17:47 We don't necessarily believe in our organization that that's honoring your fiduciary responsibility

1:17:52 because we throw out there exactly what those raises are going to be.

1:17:56 So when you compare ours, you kind of what you see is what you get with other organizations,

1:18:01 you kind of have to dig a little bit deeper to see what that is.

1:18:05 Susan Hockett.

1:18:06 Thank you.

1:18:07 So just an estimate, do you have a dollar figure to attach to that 3.5% for all employees?

1:18:16 And I know that the table move doesn't affect everybody, but a rough estimate on the dollar

1:18:21 figure on the table slide as well?

1:18:25 We do have that.

1:18:26 Maybe just not with us

1:18:29 Yeah, so the total cost is about a million three hundred seventy six thousand these two moves

1:18:46 Across the organization

1:18:48 Thank you, and that includes the mid-year table adjustment

1:19:00 So what's important is when we did the mid-year table for police and fire?

1:19:03 We have to absorb that into this year

1:19:07 And just an FYI if we're asking questions at AIC maybe be careful and hold our cars a little close to our chest

1:19:15 Right? I think it's important. Well, so we're televising and we publish it. And it's going

1:19:24 to be published in the newspaper. So you can keep secrets, but you're just going to be

1:19:29 banking that they're not reading. Maybe you have the conversations with the folks in North

1:19:36 Idaho who don't know. So those are the positions. The 7.9% represents an increase of about 30%

1:19:49 And that's right now renewing the plan as it is, we've spent a lot of time at the executive

1:19:58 team level looking at different plans, from plan options understanding how do we create

1:20:03 a more sustainable health plan moving forward and we plan on exploring that.

1:20:11 But the funding is intact.

1:20:14 But that ultimate and delivery looks like has to be decided by August and we'll be communicating

1:20:19 that throughout the budget process not only with the Council but also with our employees.

1:20:23 We're looking at going to offering the traditional plan that we have now.

1:20:28 But potentially looking at a higher deductible plan attached to a health savings account and

1:20:35 there's been some interest associated with that from members of our team.

1:20:43 Any more questions on the positions that are included in the budget and the positions that

1:20:46 are not included?

1:20:52 So we're going to go through a couple of different things.

1:20:54 One of the things that we're going to talk about

1:20:56 is generally capital, but what you can see is we're doing

1:21:00 park master plan improvements.

1:21:02 We're taking over a pool.

1:21:03 We have improvements that we have to make in a golf course.

1:21:06 We need to make sure we're rotating our fleet

1:21:08 and our vehicle, our equipment, our machineries

1:21:10 to ensure that we continue to be competitive and also deliver

1:21:15 services, because having good equipment

1:21:18 is a retention factor.

1:21:19 And that's important for us to recognize

1:21:21 that providing the tools for our team to be effective

1:21:25 is not only important to that service delivery

1:21:28 for efficiency, but it also helps with the retention fees.

1:21:31 Inside of our organization, we call those hygiene factors.

1:21:35 When you take a look at the new city hall,

1:21:37 you take a look at the public safety complex,

1:21:39 you look at moving forward with the RFQ and the fire stations.

1:21:43 Creating quality spaces for our men and women

1:21:45 to deliver their services is a secondary

1:21:49 behind compensation, important factor in employee retention.

1:21:53 It also helps into the deliverable services to our citizens.

1:21:56 And so it's an important process.

1:21:59 We're also making improvements to our water

1:22:01 and waste water in our transportation systems.

1:22:03 We've started to make good progress on those systems,

1:22:05 and we want to make sure that we're continuing

1:22:07 to maintain those.

1:22:09 And we also want to become more efficient and more effective.

1:22:13 So what I'm going to have Mitch do is kind of put on the screen.

1:22:26 So we're going to kind of go through the highlight

1:22:29 of the different things that are included here.

1:22:34 It was a lot easier just to bounce off of the sheet

1:22:37 and then we'll email the sheet so that you have it.

1:22:39 Because what we wanted to do was illustrate kind

1:22:42 of what's included in the chat.

1:22:44 If you could turn up this bank of lights right here,

1:22:48 that might help remove some of it.

1:22:58 Why don't you just include me, Tchaikovsky.

1:23:02 Thank you.

1:23:03 That's good.

1:23:16 So inside of the Finance Department, we're looking at a piece of equipment that is going

1:23:22 to be tethered to employee ID cards, and Laura can certainly explain it for a better night

1:23:27 because her team has been working on this for the last two years.

1:23:30 But it's an electronic time card piece.

1:23:34 Right now, all of our time cards are done on an Excel sheet, and then they'll print it

1:23:40 off and they're given to Becky and at three hundred employees Becky has to

1:23:44 manually enter a whole bunch of things and it's not really efficient it's not

1:23:48 effective and as we continue to grow one of the things that we started seeing

1:23:54 is the potential for greater human error and one of the things you don't want to

1:23:59 do consistently is screw up some of the paycheck. Members of our team seem to take

1:24:06 that relatively personal and I think that's understandable. So what we do is this is going

1:24:11 to really help in efficiency, it's going to help in scheduling, it's going to have a whole series

1:24:15 of different models that's going to help them move that forward. We're looking at replacing the

1:24:20 mail machine. That mail machine is used by all departments and so it's about a $12,000 cost but

1:24:25 we still send mail. We send lots of mail because we're required to and that machine is

1:24:30 really on its last leg and so it's important for us to be able to replace that.

1:24:37 It's that time to do the citizen survey every even year we go forward with the

1:24:42 citizen survey and so after the election in February we will move forward with that.

1:24:48 The other thing that we're looking at is performance measurement. One of the

1:24:52 things that we don't do well in our organization is to be able to measure our

1:24:57 performance and benchmark it against our peers. We can do some anecdotal evidence, but one of

1:25:01 the things that we want to do is measure those vital few things inside of our organization.

1:25:06 We've tried this in the past. We've tried to do it on our own, and we weren't necessarily

1:25:11 successful, so we have some funding for individuals to help us through that process. We believe

1:25:16 the efficiencies that we will gain will pay for themselves for that contract. That contract

1:25:21 is $50,000. We talked about the paralegal and the setup associated with that and the administration

1:25:30 and setup is for the code enforcement. The survey is for additional opportunities and equipment

1:25:37 for the economic development department. What is the new position? And that's an HR until

1:25:54 under that new position. That won't be expended if we don't get the new position. We're looking

1:26:04 At a significant expenditure of our radio systems,

1:26:11 we're going to be using E911 funding

1:26:13 associated with our systems.

1:26:16 Kathy and members of our team,

1:26:18 also with police and fire, have been looking at our radios.

1:26:21 And we want to make sure that we are providing

1:26:23 the best equipment to our team.

1:26:26 It's not good when members of our public safety

1:26:29 and public works teams cannot communicate back.

1:26:32 And so we want to make sure that we're working through that vehicles you'll

1:26:38 notice that there's a lot of vehicles inside of the police department but not

1:26:44 only are they replacements to rotate our fleet but they're also because as we add

1:26:48 more employees we share vehicles inside of the police department and so we also

1:26:52 have to add vehicles as we move forward. We're upgrading some vehicles you'll

1:27:03 and notice that there's a, you have the entire list in here,

1:27:07 so when we give you this list,

1:27:09 you'll see what has been removed,

1:27:10 we're just kind of going through this right now.

1:27:14 But some of these things are no longer included

1:27:16 in this process.

1:27:18 Like for example, the generator in station number three,

1:27:22 as you're at fire station number three,

1:27:23 one of the things that you're aware of is we've solicited

1:27:27 the services of an architectural firm

1:27:29 to assist us with some remodel.

1:27:32 We have removed that generator,

1:27:33 We believe that there might be a generator in the hands and building that can get us through.

1:27:38 And then as we look and progress towards the modeling of our fire stations, a new generator

1:27:43 would be included in that process.

1:27:48 The surface pros are for the lab.

1:27:51 And then if you scroll down just a little bit, sorry, the other down.

1:28:00 These become the parks and recreation so you can see the skate bark extension, new employee

1:28:05 trucks. One of the things that's listed in there is the resurface of the first Presbyterian

1:28:10 church gym floor and I've removed that. You have Harman Park signage, baseball equipment.

1:28:20 You'll see the new restroom at City Park. We've also, one of the things that we've done

1:28:27 is you'll recall that the pickle ballers came in and had a conversation and the staff

1:28:32 had placed in some money for pickle ball, but it wasn't the number one priority by the

1:28:37 members of the team. All but one member of the Parks and Rec team has listed that as a

1:28:43 number two priority. We're just finishing the first six courts of our pickleball and

1:28:49 we want to see if those six courts and what that does for the demand before we spend an

1:28:58 additional $172,000. Moving forward with pickleball, so what we did was we took that money and then

1:29:05 And we added to it and we said,

1:29:06 Wendy, we believe that there are lots of park improvements

1:29:09 that need to occur in accordance with the park master plan.

1:29:13 We're not just going to remove the $172,000

1:29:16 for the Pickle Wall course,

1:29:17 but we're going to reallocate it.

1:29:19 And we wanna make sure that we're moving forward

1:29:21 with all of those park improvements

1:29:23 that are spelled out in the master plan moving.

1:29:27 We're doing some work on the ban shell.

1:29:29 We have some, we describe it as unknown improvements

1:29:32 at Sunway Park, but we've allocated money

1:29:35 so that as we go through the master planning process

1:29:37 of Sunway Park, we have funding to be able to make

1:29:41 continued improvements.

1:29:42 We talk about widening sidewalks, radio replacement,

1:29:47 irrigation systems, and those type of things.

1:29:53 What's interesting is the Gulf Fund and the Pool Fund

1:29:56 are two funds that really rely upon the general fund

1:30:00 to be able to support their operations.

1:30:03 We are making improvements to both of those areas.

1:30:07 There's an aerator, I believe, that's included in the Gulf Fund and other equipment to ensure

1:30:11 that the Gulf course is able to function.

1:30:14 And then there are also some baseline level improvements.

1:30:19 Potentially in the pool, we're looking at current revenue right now and how things are

1:30:24 materializing and whether or not we can advance them this year.

1:30:28 We think that there's a good case that we'll be able to do that.

1:30:31 We have funding for our fireworks.

1:30:34 That is a static $8,000 that we move forward, not only a part of the funding here, but also

1:30:42 permits that we have received.

1:30:44 And then we also have a public art funding multiplier is a percent of this total budget

1:30:51 that we have.

1:30:52 You'll notice that we're moving forward with seal quotes and sweepers really kind of moving

1:31:01 through on the public works piece.

1:31:04 One of the things that we've done this year,

1:31:06 and it really came out of a conversation

1:31:08 with the larger department head group,

1:31:09 is we've moved some of the expenses

1:31:12 by being able to rebuild equipment,

1:31:14 and then we've taken some additional funding

1:31:17 and placed that into the overlay program.

1:31:21 So while the seal coat program is one

1:31:24 that we believe is beginning to be able to be

1:31:26 right sized for the different areas,

1:31:29 as we've shared with the council,

1:31:30 We know that our transportation system is going to require additional roadway overlays,

1:31:37 and as John has shared in his past presentation, that is the next focus area to ensure that

1:31:42 we have a quality transportation system.

1:31:45 We just received word, not good news, but we're going to certainly do some more investigating

1:31:50 that none of the projects that John placed forward, members of this team worked, were funded by

1:31:58 the state from that emergency funding. It's always interesting when politics and funding collide,

1:32:09 and so we're going to do some exploratory work. John is going to submit again, he's been really doing

1:32:16 some great work and investigative work and reaching out to folks in terms of what can we do to improve

1:32:22 our applications. The next round I believe is due very soon, and John intends to meet that deadline,

1:32:28 And then there's also get up their deadline that we can be able to massage those applications

1:32:32 that continue to go forward.

1:32:33 But the first response wasn't necessarily one that made us happy, but hopefully we can learn

1:32:38 from that and maybe receive some funding.

1:32:41 You'll notice that we have some additional funding for ADA and those ADA requests, LED lights,

1:32:48 and then those bottom ones are associated with the airport where we're assisting in looking

1:32:54 of the terminal flooring in the existing section of the airport, not the new section,

1:32:58 but we've got this great new addition.

1:33:00 And so now we're going to look at the other sections.

1:33:04 We always believe it's important to maintain that asset, and one of the assets is the restaurant.

1:33:09 And so we take that same philosophy that we want to have a marketable golf course,

1:33:13 we want to have a marketable pool, we want to have a marketable restaurant.

1:33:16 And so we continue to make those investments and then some equipment to tires.

1:33:22 And those are going to be the really the things that are delivered through taxes.

1:33:28 There's an entire laundry list and complement of projects that are specifically dedicated

1:33:33 with airport resources that are for taxiway and runway and our vehicles and those type of

1:33:40 things.

1:33:41 As we get those allocations specifically for the airport, those are also included in the

1:33:48 rules.

1:33:49 Any questions on the cap?

1:33:54 Chris talking.

1:33:55 This is the right place, but I'm every year concerned that how our GIS system plan is going.

1:34:06 Is that another part down here you're going to cover?

1:34:09 So in our GIS system, one of the things that's important is to be able to get the information

1:34:13 and so we have tremble units that are going to assist the members of our team.

1:34:18 Be able to get the information from the field to be able to incorporate that in.

1:34:22 The Fire Department, the Police Department, Brian, several individuals are looking at many

1:34:28 different types of systems.

1:34:30 One of the things that I've asked for is to have a single platform that can be tethered

1:34:36 through SQL servers or now I'm speaking way outside of my knowledge, but I want to have

1:34:40 a single base map that all data and all information can be flung into and it can be freely exchanged

1:34:47 between all parts of our organization.

1:34:50 Kathy knows that charge of members of our team

1:34:52 understand that charge and they're gonna be working

1:34:55 towards that end.

1:34:56 I believe that they're going to continue

1:34:57 to be utilizing city works to be able to make those advances.

1:35:02 But I really believe it starts with that base map

1:35:04 and that base information that we have

1:35:06 and we'll have those tools be able to continue to get more data.

1:35:08 I thought last year we did agreed upon a plan.

1:35:11 Are we still trying to invent our system?

1:35:14 I guess my ultimate question is what's our vision

1:35:18 when this can be completed.

1:35:22 So we are using the Esri software for our mapping system,

1:35:26 which is a base mapping system.

1:35:30 And we have the parcel data set.

1:35:34 So we're getting the parcel data from the county

1:35:36 and we update the records regularly.

1:35:39 And then we created a parcel fabric,

1:35:41 which basically gives the footprint of the city.

1:35:45 And the addresses are all updated,

1:35:48 We have some control point areas that are a little out of whack right by the canyons.

1:35:53 We're working on those areas to get that little section of the canyon exact,

1:35:58 but we're having some difficulties because of all the duplexes.

1:36:01 It's safe to say we're several years away from the completion of that.

1:36:05 No, I don't think we're several years away. We're moving quite quickly.

1:36:09 In fact, we have Robin working on it full-time, and then we have an intern

1:36:15 who's actually helping us right now to Kennedy. He's doing a lot of work and

1:36:19 getting some features out there. I think you'd be surprised at how far along we

1:36:24 actually are, but it's all compiled together yet. So we have different

1:36:29 little pieces and once we compile it all together so that as Travis said that

1:36:33 you could put in one address and see all the different pieces together and we're

1:36:37 working on that piece of it with Frontier right now. So I think within a

1:36:43 Here you'll see some amazing wonderful things.

1:36:53 One of the things that we didn't describe in here

1:36:55 are the water and sewer improvements.

1:36:57 But again, it's PI stations are included.

1:37:01 Funding to replace water lines and sewer lines

1:37:03 associated with zone maintenance.

1:37:06 An entire exhaustive list of both those independent funds

1:37:09 that have been included as well.

1:37:12 They attempt to begin to knock off and chew off

1:37:17 some of those larger improvements that are articulated in the facility plans.

1:37:22 But I think it's important to recognize that those facility plans call for some very significant

1:37:28 and robust improvements in the near term.

1:37:32 We're still working through processes to understand funding and funding opportunities to be able

1:37:36 to achieve those.

1:37:38 So we'll continue to work through those means to be able to do that.

1:37:41 But right now, this budget, not only in the water and the sewer, but it continues to maybe

1:37:46 chip away, but it certainly doesn't meet all of the needs moving forward, as capital as

1:37:55 well as employees.

1:37:59 One of the things I wanted to spend some time talking about is the foregone balance.

1:38:04 This budget does not incorporate any of the foregone balance.

1:38:09 In fact, you'll see that the number grew a little bit by about $40-ish-1,000, and that

1:38:19 That was because we received information from the county

1:38:22 well after our budget was adopted that properties

1:38:24 have been annexed into the city.

1:38:26 And we didn't get to include those on the new construction

1:38:31 and annexation report because we weren't aware

1:38:34 that they were included.

1:38:37 Because they weren't on that initial report.

1:38:39 And so as a result of not taking that,

1:38:41 we increased the foregone balance by $37,034.

1:38:46 So one of the things that we put together

1:38:49 was how much foregone balance, or how much has not

1:38:53 been collected on an annual basis.

1:38:55 And so what it illustrates is the amount in each one

1:38:58 of those years, and then what it illustrates

1:39:01 is the cumulative impact of that decision.

1:39:08 And so the cumulative impact is $2,186,000.

1:39:18 But that's not the total impact since 2010,

1:39:22 and I won't spend a little bit of time talking.

1:39:24 That's the annualized impact.

1:39:27 So what is foregone balance?

1:39:30 The foregone balance occurs when the city does,

1:39:33 or any local entity, elects not to take the statutory increase.

1:39:38 And if you take a look at the city's foregone balance,

1:39:40 it's one of the largest inside of the state,

1:39:43 and it's certainly the largest inside of the Magic Valley.

1:39:46 and that opportunity to include that moving forward

1:39:52 is given to us by the Idaho legislature.

1:39:55 So as a Dillon state in which the legislature shares

1:40:07 and provides the authorities that we have

1:40:10 as opposed to a home rule

1:40:12 where those authorities are derived locally,

1:40:15 The legislature sets the playing field for us to be able to operate, and your opportunity

1:40:21 to take a look at that foregone balance is really dependent as to whether or not that code still

1:40:26 exists with the Idaho legislature.

1:40:28 And over the course of the last couple of years, there have been a couple of chips at

1:40:32 that, and when the Idaho legislature says that you can no longer include the foregone

1:40:37 balance in your projects, that money is no longer available to you.

1:40:44 When is that going to happen?

1:40:46 We don't know.

1:40:48 But if it happens in the next legislative session, it's important to recognize that all

1:40:53 state laws, if they don't have an emergency provision, are effective on the 1st of July

1:40:58 at the beginning of the state's fiscal year, which is prior to you adopting your next budget.

1:41:04 And so if in the next upcoming legislative session, the Idaho legislature were to say

1:41:09 cities can no longer have the opportunities or counties, it implies to all local government

1:41:13 to cities have the opportunity to go after a foregone balance, that right to go back and

1:41:19 do so will have been exhausted.

1:41:22 Now there's a benefit, there's a benefit to our residents and that means that if you look

1:41:29 at the $2.186 million and if we were to collect that, if you take the average across our home

1:41:37 owners, that saves them about 11% a year in property taxes.

1:41:41 So on the average home, you know, you're looking at probably somewhere around $55 a year savings

1:41:51 that would have otherwise been collected.

1:41:53 So that's the impact.

1:41:55 Now we could go back and share what the actual impact is on all of those properties, but just

1:42:01 globally it's about 11.3% savings in property taxes without that amount included.

1:42:09 that like all decisions, there's an opportunity cost.

1:42:12 That opportunity cost in its entire aggregate totals $13,279,000.

1:42:21 And you're asking, but Travis, it's only $2.16 million.

1:42:26 And this is tough to illustrate, but what happens is, this is an illustration of how

1:42:32 property taxes occur in the state of Idaho.

1:42:37 So you can see in the first year in 2010, there's $539,000

1:42:42 a foregone or monies that was not collected.

1:42:45 So that adds to the foregone balance.

1:42:49 But had you collected it, you would

1:42:51 have had a larger 3% cap that you could have operated with.

1:42:57 Because what Idaho Code says is you

1:43:00 are entitled to collect 3% more revenue

1:43:03 than you did the prior year.

1:43:05 And so it's based upon your base amount assessed.

1:43:08 And so each year that we did not take the maximum,

1:43:12 the amount that we could have also levied in the 3% decreased.

1:43:17 And you can see that that 3% over the course of time

1:43:21 is not only 16,192 in fiscal year 11,

1:43:26 but it's an additional 30,012, 45,013, 47,014.

1:43:35 all the way down. So if you added in, had we not had any foregone balance, the City of

1:43:42 Twin Falls would be able to collect $2,509,000 more dollars in property taxes this year by

1:43:51 statute than what you could under the current. And the total cost of that decision is illustrated

1:44:00 at the bottom at $539,902 growing all the way $2,509,000 for a total cost, a $13,279,000.

1:44:21 And that's just since 2018.

1:44:23 Greg Lanting.

1:44:27 And then you look at what John presented his budget for the roads and we're about 12 million

1:44:32 dollars behind.

1:44:33 And I think about it doesn't.

1:44:38 Well, and we talk about lots of different improvements.

1:44:43 We talk about lots of different needs.

1:44:48 And what I've shared is our budget that we've created as a team moving forward covers the

1:44:55 baseline levels of needs and does continue to chip away at some of the

1:45:00 things for us to continue to advance our community. We're trying to build more

1:45:05 trails. We're trying to create and complete parks. We're trying to make sure

1:45:10 that we have a competitive program, that we're replacing roads, that we're making

1:45:14 sure that we don't have deferred infrastructure, and you'll never be able

1:45:19 to collect $13 million. Okay, that's the opportunity cost. That's the lost

1:45:24 opportunity of the decision that we have made and really I take responsibility for

1:45:29 that because it's my budget that I have set forward. But at some point we feel

1:45:37 it's important to share that next year that number grows, that next year that

1:45:44 number may be getting close to about $2.7 million of money not realized in its

1:45:52 actual budget. So I share that knowing for you to know that we didn't include it, but oftentimes

1:46:04 we talk about what we're not doing. We illustrated capital projects, we illustrated personnel.

1:46:10 I certainly would not advocate by any stretch that you take a lot of this money here and

1:46:21 apply it to personnel because one of the concerns that they have organization is making sure

1:46:26 that our employee levels are sustainable into the future.

1:46:30 But I will also say that at some point in time,

1:46:33 we have to continue to add personnel in places

1:46:36 that we haven't typically added personnel

1:46:39 because of the demand that is being placed upon our organization

1:46:42 and as we continue to grow as a community.

1:46:45 And it's an incredible balancing act

1:46:47 and we wanted to share this with you on the front end.

1:46:51 Chris talked.

1:46:52 I think the foregone balance is one of the strongest sales tools we have to show the city

1:46:59 government work at the local level.

1:47:01 We are demonstrating to these annual budgets that we're not taking every tax dollar we can.

1:47:07 And outside of the unusual year that we've had with our roads, I agree with on that, Greg.

1:47:13 Outside of that, we are demonstrating to the public that we are approval and responsible.

1:47:20 rather than being looked at in that terms from the state legislature, they are

1:47:24 turning unity even to saying we're taking it away from you at some time in the future

1:47:29 and I have no doubt that they will be able to accomplish that. I look at this as a

1:47:34 flag of pride that the city can raise to say we're not spending everything we

1:47:40 could. That's a plus to me sure.

1:47:54 They turn very slow, unfortunately.

1:48:00 It's one of those things you label it, opportunity lost, but going back to what Chris said, you

1:48:06 can also label it what has been saved, what taxpayers have not had to pay into this.

1:48:12 And so I understand from the city's point of view, where that's coming from, but from

1:48:17 the taxpayer point of view, that's 13.2, almost $13.3 million that is in their pocket.

1:48:26 And not in the city and so again, I know that that's a spin on it, but as a taxpayer

1:48:33 Also, I look at that and think that's one of the reasons I chose to in falls to live here

1:48:38 So I appreciate that and understanding from the city's point of view

1:48:43 We do need to work on some things we need to improve some things

1:48:47 But that's that that's as a taxpayer something I look at and I appreciate Greg Lanting

1:48:54 Off to the side of things.

1:49:00 As I drive down my street every day, headed north from, yeah, north from

1:49:09 Haberne to Glenwood Shopping Center in the last 180 feet are gone. Completely gone.

1:49:19 I mean, you dodge around multiple holes in the road just to finish getting there.

1:49:26 And I think if John and his team had another million dollars a year to work on, we'd have a lot fewer of those.

1:49:35 And I would like to at least see that we see a budget that has it in there.

1:49:41 That doesn't mean we need to choose to do it.

1:49:44 But a million dollars of that 2.5 million dollars.

1:49:48 Because I've been on here and it's way more than 13 million.

1:49:53 There was a, there was a foregone balance when I got on the council in 2005, okay?

1:49:59 And like we've talked about, and there's that old adage about you can starve the horse and starve the horse and starve the horse and

1:50:06 make sure you save money, but when the horse dies, what did he save?

1:50:11 And I think it's time that we at least take a look at taking some of that money and not like Travis said, not for salaries,

1:50:21 Take it for infrastructure because that's where we're behind and that whole 12 million dollars didn't come from this winter

1:50:28 That whole that was probably a dollar's of backlog that John is talking about we have been building that up over the last 10 years

1:50:35 At least by the fact that we haven't we haven't funded our roads our streets

1:50:44 Completely okay, we've done a brilliant job of trying to add it add to that budget

1:50:48 budget, but we got so far behind in the late 2000s and then when the recession hit, we

1:50:55 bought a budget, got leveled. I think it's time we start taking a look at it, and I don't

1:51:02 want to take the whole two and a half million. I'm certainly not going to throw that on the

1:51:05 backs of the taxpayers at this time. But I think as our community grows, we have to

1:51:13 be realistic here. We're never going to get a local option tax through the current

1:51:16 legislature and that'd be one way to fix this where we have those 40,000 people

1:51:20 are coming to town, help us pay for it. That's not gonna happen but we do have a

1:51:26 very large industrial portion of our city. A lot of them are on the tax rolls

1:51:32 especially the commercial areas are on the tax rolls and to service that as well

1:51:39 as our residents we have to start looking at because that's a million dollars this

1:51:45 year if we decided to use it but that's also a million dollars next year that

1:51:50 John would have an opportunity in his work his teams would have an opportunity to

1:51:53 work with that I think about that every time I drive down the Elm Street and I

1:51:58 know John Elm Street was on John's list as possible getting repaired but I don't

1:52:04 think it's high on this list okay because he had a lot of arterials and Elm

1:52:08 Street's definitely not a noterial but it's going away and it's going away

1:52:13 quickly and a pretty very quick time spent we need to replace all the way

1:52:18 from haber to to filer that whole street needs to be replaced and that

1:52:25 million dollars isn't even going to cover it and so I'm thinking a different

1:52:29 act I think our infrastructure in our commerce needs to have our roads into

1:52:34 position that we can be competitive on that level as well so Travis I would I

1:52:42 I would suggest that as we, as you start to put together the hard numbers of the budget,

1:52:50 looking at what that impact would be, if I know in the past we've done it's kind of

1:52:54 the cost of each one, each percent, up to 3 percent of what that valuation is, looking

1:53:01 at some options with foregone, if you were to take it all, if you were to take a piece

1:53:05 of it, to identify opportunities that we're not taking to keep a balanced budget within

1:53:13 in what we have now, but to look at that.

1:53:16 I do worry of the legislature's potential direction

1:53:23 to just have it go away.

1:53:27 I mean, I guess that makes our decision a lot easier

1:53:29 if they take it away, because now you don't have

1:53:31 the opportunity anymore, but to Greg's point,

1:53:34 I mean, there are certainly a list of needs

1:53:39 that we continue to kick the can on in the community,

1:53:41 in the city, but I think it's worth at least looking at that option.

1:53:46 That's a good decision.

1:53:55 Well, that was incredibly clear.

1:54:00 We will certainly, what we will do is we will spend some time looking at how not only the

1:54:13 impacts, so the challenge with the impacts is you're going to ask what is the impact

1:54:18 on the individual and we're not going to be able to tell you that because we don't get

1:54:23 the property tax information until we are, you know, a couple of months into this process.

1:54:29 Now, one of the things that we know is that when you hear that the property values inside

1:54:35 of the city of Twin Falls increase, I'm just guessing, right, you know, significantly, I

1:54:42 think is one way to describe it.

1:54:44 That doesn't necessarily mean the tax burdens are increasing that same level of significance.

1:54:51 Without having a good understanding of what is occurring on those individual levels and

1:54:56 the total taxable value of the community, it's going to be hard for us to share what is that

1:55:03 individual impact.

1:55:04 But what we can do is we can probably spend some time understanding the needs of, if that

1:55:13 money were available what would those highest priorities be and it almost

1:55:18 include that as an appendices into the budget with an amendment item that if

1:55:22 you wanted to have it for inclusion it could certainly be there. Does that work?

1:55:27 Yeah I like the idea of prioritizing. So we will spend some time and what I

1:55:35 heard was a million or did I hear the whole? I'd like to see the impact of the

1:55:42 the whole thing and in pieces, so maybe it's just putting it you know for every

1:55:48 half million dollars it's X. So again this is the very very first conversation

1:56:02 you can see as we will continue to move forward our next conversation is going

1:56:06 to occur on July 10th in which we will go through a detailed account of all the

1:56:11 budget items in all of the sections, and then each week through the entire

1:56:16 through the entire summer, all the way until August 28th, we will be having a

1:56:23 conversation about the different focus areas of our budget as it connected to our

1:56:27 strategic plan and the impacts associated with that. There's two

1:56:31 important dates. One is you will be asked on August 14th to adopt the

1:56:38 preliminary budget of the City Council, that is where you will set that maximum spending amount, and then you will

1:56:47 have the opportunity to

1:56:49 make reductions in spending at that point. You won't have the ability to add above that maximum cap that you set with a

1:56:56 preliminary budget. And then on August 28th, we will ask for you to adopt the

1:57:03 final budget. That gives us as a team about a week and a half to complete

1:57:09 all the necessary paperwork to meet our statutory deadlines in getting that to the county, and

1:57:16 also to make sure that that's done, eyes are dotted, tees are crossed prior to people, you

1:57:23 know, leaving for the Labor Day holiday.

1:57:28 That is our process and any questions that you might have.

1:57:31 Michael, plan.

1:57:35 Thank you, Travis.

1:57:36 Thank you.

1:57:37 Thank you.

1:57:38 Thank you for reporting.

1:57:48 Next is another opportunity for general public input.

1:57:51 If there's anyone here from the public who wishes to address the council,

1:57:54 now it's your opportunity to come forward seeing now.

1:57:59 When do we have any advisory board reports from the council?

1:58:05 Travis, any announcements from you?

1:58:07 Just a reminder that we'll be meeting early next week.

1:58:09 I believe the time is 3.30.

1:58:11 we're going to be touring the new city hall building.

1:58:22 All right, next, only a smidge behind schedule

1:58:27 is a public hearing.

1:58:28 So we have a public hearing to consider a request

1:58:31 to exchange city on property for the purpose

1:58:33 of constructing an extension to the Canyon Room Trail.

1:58:35 And we have Mitch Humble, deputy city manager.

1:58:50 So, as we've talked about this before,

1:58:57 So I'll try to be brief as we're running along.

1:59:04 The map that I have pictured up here is our new Canyon Trail that, if you all remember,

1:59:09 we had a nice groundbreaking ceremony for you just a couple of weeks ago.

1:59:12 So we're well underway now. Right over here is the jump site on the far, I guess, top right of the picture.

1:59:19 And then at the far bottom left of the picture we have that curve where Eastland turns into Poline.

1:59:24 and so the heavy dark line is our trail as we kind of run through it. Now these

1:59:30 blue parcels that I wanted to talk about these are the two on the two on the right

1:59:35 here that we have completed now trade agreements for the mayor and I were at

1:59:41 the title company about a week ago when we signed documents and those are all

1:59:45 done. The third one I want to talk about is is part of our hearing tonight.

1:59:51 Another property owner has come forward and worked to deal with Gary

1:59:56 store to where they can purchase some property that'll help us straighten out

2:00:00 trail. Let me show you this and zoom in on the on the trail in that blue area and

2:00:11 the current plan would be to kind of follow and then a hard 90 and then another

2:00:15 hard 90 and the proposal would be to trade this property that we currently

2:00:21 for a like width property that follows this dash light that then eliminates two

2:00:28 hard 90 degree turns and eliminates about 300 feet of trail. That 300 feet is

2:00:36 something like $95 a foot, $100 a foot, so it's about savings of maybe $30,000

2:00:45 And that's proposed trade number one.

2:00:49 Over here, the corner is the second, and it's just kind of off the map here, you just barely

2:00:58 miss it.

2:00:59 But the current trail that goes through the pillar falls properly, it comes straight down

2:01:04 and intersects with pull line just right off the map.

2:01:07 This project will stop us about right here.

2:01:10 That's what we need to do is make that last connection, and it's about a 300 or so, maybe

2:01:15 350 foot gap that we need to make that connection for.

2:01:18 And there was a piece of property that we didn't have

2:01:20 the ability to get across.

2:01:22 And that map.

2:01:29 And so that current trail alignment is going to come

2:01:31 follow this red line and sort of stop right here.

2:01:34 There's a triangle right in here that we recently acquired

2:01:37 from the highway district that now allows us to come down

2:01:40 to the corner across the road and then get up to about this

2:01:44 point.

2:01:45 And now we need to get here to this trail.

2:01:48 So we have this short little gap right through here.

2:01:51 And that property owner right here

2:01:56 is willing to potentially work a trade with us

2:01:59 for this property over here in red that we own.

2:02:06 And we have owned for probably 10 years now.

2:02:08 And I think that was probably acquired.

2:02:10 This is a little before I got here when we acquired that.

2:02:13 But I want to say that Dennis's plans,

2:02:15 at least when me and I were talking about this,

2:02:17 was that maybe that could be a little parking lot for six or seven cars that might someday

2:02:23 access this future trail.

2:02:27 Part of our acquisition property down here was a three acre park that will hold a lot more

2:02:31 than six or seven cars and be a great trailhead and with that coming soon, I think the need

2:02:38 for this to be a small little parking lot is the trailhead is probably less needed down.

2:02:44 So that ends up being about 6,000 square feet.

2:02:48 The back half of it, you can see cracks in the rocks.

2:02:51 It's not really usable.

2:02:53 No one.

2:02:54 Really, we have about 3 or so 1,000 square feet

2:02:57 of usable property there.

2:02:59 And the idea would be to trade that for about 3 or so 1,000

2:03:03 square feet of property that gets us around the curve.

2:03:05 And so that's the second proposed trade

2:03:09 that we want to talk about today.

2:03:11 Both of these will make the gap in the trail from here,

2:03:16 over to the jump site.

2:03:17 That's the total of about 7,800 linear feet of trail.

2:03:23 And as I said, a couple of weeks ago,

2:03:25 it would be a shame to build 77 under the trail

2:03:28 and stop 300 feet short of the goal.

2:03:30 And so staff recommends that we move forward

2:03:34 with these two trades.

2:03:36 If you have any questions, I can try

2:03:38 to answer them for you.

2:03:39 The primary purpose tonight is to open a public hearing

2:03:42 and allow the public to speak on this.

2:03:44 And then afterwards we would ask your simple majority vote

2:03:47 for approval.

2:03:48 So if you have any questions, I can give that now.

2:03:51 Any questions for Mitch?

2:03:53 Seeing none, we will open the public input portion

2:04:00 of the public hearing.

2:04:00 This is your opportunity to share your two cents

2:04:04 on this proposal.

2:04:05 You're welcome to come forward.

2:04:10 Seeing no one, we will close the public input portion

2:04:13 of the public hearing and turn it over to council

2:04:15 for direction, Chris talking.

2:04:16 I would move that we approve the request

2:04:18 to exchange city property for purpose construction extension

2:04:23 of the Canyon Rail trim as described.

2:04:25 Second.

2:04:27 Motion by Chris talking, 10 seconded by Nikki Boyd

2:04:30 to approve the requested the exchange as presented.

2:04:36 Exchanges, I guess it's two of them, correct?

2:04:38 Exchanges.

2:04:40 Is there any discussion?

2:04:43 Chair and roll call vote please.

2:04:51 Suzanne Hawkins.

2:04:52 Yes.

2:04:53 Greg Lanting.

2:04:54 Yes.

2:04:55 Ruth Piers.

2:04:56 Yes.

2:04:57 Christopher Reed.

2:04:58 Yes.

2:04:59 Chris Talkington.

2:05:00 Yes.

2:05:01 Sean Verigar.

2:05:02 Yes.

2:05:03 Nikki Boyd.

2:05:04 Yes.

2:05:05 Motion passes 7 to 0.

2:05:08 Thank you, Mitch.

2:05:10 The next two items have been were withdrawn.

2:05:12 So we are to adjournment to an executive session under Idaho Code 7420618

2:05:19 to consider hiring a public officer, employee, staff member,

2:05:22 or individual agent, where in the respective qualities

2:05:25 of individuals are to be evaluated in order

2:05:27 to fill a particular vacancy or need.

2:05:30 This paragraph does not apply to filling a vacancy

2:05:32 in an elective office or deliberations

2:05:34 about staffing needs in general.

2:05:36 Greg Lanting.

2:05:37 So moved.

2:05:38 Second.

2:05:40 Motion by Greg Lanting, seconded by Christopher Reed

2:05:43 to adjourn into executive session.

2:05:45 Is there any discussion?

2:05:47 Sharon Roll, call vote.

2:06:02 Greg Lanting.

2:06:03 Yes.

2:06:04 Ruth Hairs.

2:06:05 Yes.

2:06:06 Christopher Reed.

2:06:07 Yes.

2:06:08 Chris Tocking.

2:06:09 Yes.

2:06:10 Sean Berriger.

2:06:11 Yes.

2:06:12 Nicki Boyd.

2:06:13 Yes.

2:06:14 Suzanne Hocken.

2:06:15 Yes.

2:06:16 Motion passes seven to zero.

2:06:17 We will not be making any decisions during the executive session nor will we be reconvening following

2:06:22 the executive session.

2:06:23 And with that we are adjourned.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, June 12, 2017. The recording started at 16:58 by the recorder's clock and runs 02:06:32.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    641fb12724994516d1b711a79a7c2d2c0075cff16449fcaa1889d59dde726073
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 3d01d6c45850600e9c038c9de30cb949934aa80faa8e0321d64290e68aea800b
    part02.m4a d9844e9609a6cf99821c6913b85ed0408c452fac442f94688b9054c5b431ff97
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    fddd9470039bb9bbaec979f3340b0910738d555372720e7832ce959e0705ac34

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file