City Council meeting
Monday, April 10, 2017
Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.
The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.
No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.
The audio for this recording isn't posted yet. It's being held back until a privacy review is finished. The transcript below is complete apart from marked passages.
Transcript
0:10:41 Good evening. I'd like to call to order the Football City Council meeting for Monday, April 10th.
0:10:45 The first item is the Pledge of Allegiance. So I'd like to invite our Boy Scouts.
0:10:50 I think maybe there were a couple of Cub Scouts thrown in there too to come forward and lead us in the pledge.
0:10:55 For those of you wishing to join us, please stand.
0:10:57 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
0:11:32 And before you boys all go sit down, if you would please swing by the microphone over here
0:11:36 at the podium, tell us who you are, which group you're with, and if you're here working on
0:11:40 one of your merit badges this evening, please, which one?
0:11:44 I'm Caleb Gorley, we're with Troop 4, and we're here to speak about the Refugee Center.
0:11:52 Okay, great, thank you.
0:11:56 I'm Ethan Sumson, and we're also here for the Refugee Center, so I'm working on my Eagle
0:12:03 Project to build a bike shed for the Refugee Center.
0:12:07 Thank you.
0:12:09 I'm Stephen Thusen, and we're here for the Refugee Center, and we're with Troop 4.
0:12:15 Thank you.
0:12:17 I'm Colby Goerley and I'm the troop four and we're here for the refugee center
0:12:21 I'm Kyler Western and I'm here with troop four for the refugees center
0:12:26 I'm Porter St. Clair and I'm here for the refugee center
0:12:31 I'm I'm Asher Gert from to four and I'm here for the refugee center
0:12:38 Like Crandall from troop four here for the refugee center
0:12:41 I'm holding the ward from troop four here for the referee. Yeah, refugee
0:12:48 I'm Logan Pittard
0:12:50 for here for the refugee center.
0:12:53 I'm from Peter's in here, I'm for the refugee center.
0:12:58 Great, thank you very much.
0:13:02 We'd like to call the meeting in order.
0:13:03 We do have a quorum of the council.
0:13:05 All seven members are here this evening.
0:13:07 Mr. Rothweiler, are there any amendments to the agenda
0:13:09 this evening?
0:13:10 Mr. Mayor, members of council,
0:13:11 there are no amendments this evening.
0:13:12 Thank you.
0:13:13 We have no proclamations this evening.
0:13:15 So next is general public input.
0:13:17 So if you would like to address the council
0:13:20 an item that is not on this evening's agenda and now is an opportunity to come forward
0:13:24 and speak about that. Otherwise, we will have an opportunity for public input following
0:13:29 the first item on the agenda which is the welcoming city presentation. So if there's
0:13:33 anyone wishing to address the council on an item, not on the agenda, you may please come
0:13:37 forward. Mr. Edwards, I would remind everyone for the public input session to please approach
0:13:46 the microphone and the podium. State your name and address and whether you're a resident
0:13:50 or property owner in the city, and then proceed with your input.
0:13:54 And we're going to limit that to three minutes per person this evening.
0:13:58 I'm just curious.
0:13:59 I live in Jerome.
0:14:01 I have property in Twin Falls.
0:14:03 And I'm here about the safe city proclamation.
0:14:07 With everybody having gone with a reasonable market.
0:14:13 The safe city proclamation is a proclamation that treats everybody equally
0:14:18 in the state, in the city, in the state, in the county, in our country.
0:14:24 I presented this to the City Council last Monday
0:14:26 and yet haven't heard anything about
0:14:30 whether or not they're receptive to this or not.
0:14:34 So what I'd like to do is I'd like y'all to read it.
0:14:37 And if you don't have one, I'd like to make sure you give one.
0:14:40 I don't wanna take the time to read it to each one of you,
0:14:43 but you can go back online and read the,
0:14:47 or view the video from previous City Council meeting.
0:14:50 It will be in there the presentation.
0:14:53 What I'm concerned about is that by putting people in different categories, instead of all
0:15:01 residents, citizens, what we're doing is we're setting aside precedent.
0:15:06 We're setting aside precedent that everybody has created equal and has equal rights.
0:15:11 Now, my concern was about the sanctuary city, and I know this is not termed the sanctuary city,
0:15:19 But it's surprising to me that we have a scout troop here that are in favor of the refugee
0:15:25 center, and I don't know that they know a whole lot about it.
0:15:29 So Mr. Edwards, if you want to speak about the welcoming resolution, that's on the agenda
0:15:33 coming up and you're welcome to speak on that.
0:15:35 So this is for items not on the agenda.
0:15:37 I'll do that also.
0:15:38 Thank you.
0:15:39 I would mention that the fact that when we talk about people coming here and impacting
0:15:47 the city, this proclamation is to highlight the fact that law enforcement has taken an oath,
0:15:56 all city officials have taken an oath to carry out the Constitution United States and the Constitution
0:16:03 of the State of Idaho as well as their oath of office which states that they will treat
0:16:11 everybody fairly and do their job the best of their abilities.
0:16:15 So I would just have you take a look at this, read it, if you have any questions you're welcome
0:16:21 to call me and talk to me about it.
0:16:24 I just want to know where the City Council stands.
0:16:28 Thank you.
0:16:29 And as I've shared last week, we're taking that under advisement and we will have some
0:16:33 discussion about that.
0:16:34 So probably not this evening.
0:16:36 I appreciate you having the patience to wait a week since you presented it to us.
0:16:40 Okay, I'm waiting.
0:16:41 And I just gave you the answer, sir.
0:16:45 I'm still waiting.
0:16:47 I've got 11, 10, 9.
0:16:50 All right, wonderful.
0:16:51 Thank you.
0:16:51 I'm still waiting.
0:16:52 Greg Lansing.
0:16:52 Well, I just wanted to comment.
0:16:54 The other resolution that's on here
0:16:56 has been working through the system for probably at least
0:17:00 a month, maybe longer before it came to this point.
0:17:04 So it does take time for it to get vetted and come back
0:17:07 to possibly if it even is allowed to come back to us.
0:17:11 It does take time.
0:17:12 A week's done about it.
0:17:15 OK.
0:17:16 And to clarify, we don't have an actual resolution
0:17:19 in front of us this evening, we have a presentation.
0:17:25 Is there anyone else wishing to address the council
0:17:27 on any items not on the agenda this evening?
0:17:32 Seeing no one, we will move on with the regular agenda.
0:17:35 The first item is the consent calendar.
0:17:37 Council wishes.
0:17:39 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:17:39 I move approval of the consent calendar.
0:17:41 Second.
0:17:43 The motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Ruth Pierce
0:17:45 to approve the consent calendar.
0:17:47 Is there any discussion?
0:17:50 Sharon, roll call, vote please.
0:17:52 Suzanne Hawkins.
0:17:53 Yes, Nikki Boyd.
0:17:55 Yes, Sean Berriger.
0:17:56 Yes.
0:17:57 Chris Talkington.
0:17:58 Yes.
0:17:59 Greg Lanthine.
0:18:00 Yes.
0:18:00 Christopher Reed.
0:18:01 Yes.
0:18:02 Ruth Pierce.
0:18:02 Yes.
0:18:03 Motion passes 7-0.
0:18:05 So I do see there was one person who had signed up
0:18:07 for the church in the park item that
0:18:10 was on the consent calendar.
0:18:11 So that's been taken care of now.
0:18:13 So if you don't want to stick around for the rest of the meeting,
0:18:16 you're welcome to sneak out.
0:18:21 So the first item on the agenda and our items
0:18:22 for consideration this evening
0:18:24 is presentation of a welcoming city resolution.
0:18:27 We have Dr. Mark Crandall, Dr. Crandall.
0:18:31 And I know you have a couple of the scouts
0:18:32 you'd like to introduce to join you as well.
0:18:37 Thank you for having us here.
0:18:39 We're grateful to be here.
0:18:40 And as you know, we are here in support of the CSI
0:18:42 Refugee Program and the welcoming city resolution.
0:18:45 We're going to take just a few minutes
0:18:46 to explain why we're here and what we're
0:18:49 asking the council to do.
0:18:50 I'm going to turn the time to our scouts, Ethan Sumson,
0:18:54 and Caleb Borlean.
0:18:58 When I was using the assumption I'm 14, I'm working on my Eagle project.
0:19:01 I'm a proud member of the Snake River Council, Troop 4.
0:19:06 I noticed right away that the refugee center needed a bike shed to safely store their
0:19:13 bikes and provide bikes for people who need it for transportation, to work or school or
0:19:19 whatever they need.
0:19:22 So that's what I would like to do.
0:19:29 So I'm Caleb Gorley, I'm 15, and I'm an Eagle Scout in troop 4.
0:19:35 I had the pleasure of working with the CSI Refugee Center last fall for my Eagle project.
0:19:40 When I was looking for something to do for my project, I noticed that they had no way
0:19:44 to practice for their Idaho drivers test.
0:19:48 So I contacted Goody Motor and arranged to have a car donated to them, to the center,
0:19:54 And then I took some of the Scout Troop over to Goody Motor and did a few hours of service.
0:20:01 And I just, I loved working with the refugee center and I loved the people there as well.
0:20:09 Well thanks, Caleb.
0:20:10 We have great scouts.
0:20:11 I think they're great examples to all of us.
0:20:15 To the first question of why we are here, why does this issue matter so much to us?
0:20:20 I think you need to know a little bit more about us and who we are.
0:20:23 As you know, Boy Scout Troops are sponsored by organizations, so each troop has a sponsoring
0:20:28 organization, usually a church congregation.
0:20:31 In this area, almost all of the scouts are organized and sponsored by LDS wards, just like
0:20:37 ours.
0:20:38 And if you're familiar with church history or the Mormon pioneers, you'll know why that
0:20:42 issue really hits home to us.
0:20:44 And so in the 1800s, the early church members in Joseph Smith were driven from state to state,
0:20:49 New York, to Ohio, to Missouri, to Illinois, trying to escape persecution.
0:20:55 In Illinois, he was killed by an angry mob, and then bring him young, took the rest of
0:20:59 the church, and left the United States trying to escape.
0:21:03 They went to Utah and settled Salt Lake City, which at the time was northern Mexico.
0:21:07 And so today, we call them Mormon pioneers, but they were American refugees in every sense
0:21:12 of the word.
0:21:13 And that is part of why that issue hits home, especially to us.
0:21:17 It's part of why we feel so strongly about helping refugees and preserving religious freedom for all and all religions
0:21:23 Now there's a lot of other reasons to support the refugee center and a welcoming resolution
0:21:28 There's a lot of other people involved that would love to see this pass
0:21:32 Including the city count including other cities for example the city council and Boise
0:21:37 Unanimously passed a welcome resolution just a few months ago the city council and Ketchum did the same
0:21:42 This symbolic gesture is what we are asking the city council to approve.
0:21:46 Our refugee center is one of only two centers in Idaho and their numbers are declining.
0:21:51 For example, about six months ago, we could expect 110,000 refugees coming into the United States now.
0:21:58 It's about 50,000. In Twin Falls, that number is also half of what it was.
0:22:02 One refugee center boyse closed their doors in February.
0:22:06 Our refugee center is an important part of our community.
0:22:08 of our community has been here for almost 30 years
0:22:11 and has provided through the United Nations
0:22:13 and official channels a new start
0:22:14 to thousands of families from all over the world.
0:22:17 Now, this statement is a symbolic statement.
0:22:20 It does not have a financial, fiscal impact.
0:22:22 It doesn't have a policy impact.
0:22:24 It might not improve or it might not increase
0:22:27 the numbers of refugees coming here.
0:22:29 I don't know if it'll change national policy.
0:22:31 I doubt that it will, but I can tell you,
0:22:34 it might change the people in this room tonight.
0:22:36 It might change some of the people in our city.
0:22:38 and I hope that it will send a strong message through the media that we support the center
0:22:42 and that we are a welcoming city.
0:22:45 I grew up in Twin Falls and I have always felt safe.
0:22:48 I have always felt welcome.
0:22:50 We want everyone to feel the same.
0:22:52 And I hope that our city council will pass the resolution reaffirming that Twin Falls
0:22:55 always has been a welcoming city and will continue to be so and that we value all of our residents
0:23:01 regardless of refugee status, immigration status or religion.
0:23:05 Thank you.
0:23:06 Thank you Dr. Trandall.
0:23:20 Thank you Dr. Trandall.
0:23:21 Thank you Ethan and Caleb.
0:23:22 Appreciate the presentation.
0:23:24 We have a number of folks who would like to provide some input on this issue this evening
0:23:29 as well.
0:23:30 I grabbed the first sign up sheet that was back there.
0:23:32 If you didn't sign the first one there is another sign up sheet.
0:23:35 If you're wishing to address the council you're welcome to, excuse me, to sign up there.
0:23:41 So we are going to ask folks to please keep their comments limited to three minutes.
0:23:45 Thank you sir.
0:23:47 Councilman Reed has a screen help put up here that will help you keep an eye on that time.
0:23:53 We'll just go through the list as folks have signed up here.
0:23:57 So first I have Ron James.
0:24:01 And again a reminder just to keep your comments in three minutes.
0:24:03 Please state your name and address for the record and whether you are a resident or
0:24:06 property owner in the City of Twin Falls before you begin.
0:24:08 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:24:09 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:24:11 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:24:13 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:24:20 a discomforting incident from Twin Falls' early history that I dug up while I was researching
0:24:28 years ago, researching Chinese immigrants who, along with other immigrants such as Herman
0:24:34 Stricker, Tom Bell, the Hansons, the Larsons, founded the Magic Valley.
0:24:41 This is from the April 14th, 1905 issue of the Twin Falls News, predecessor of the Times
0:24:48 News, and during the previous September 1904, a long Chinese man in search of new opportunities
0:24:56 disembarked from the stagecoach that had brought him to the recently established Twin Falls
0:25:01 from the railroad station of Shosham.
0:25:04 Now the Twin Falls News reported that the fact of his arrival soon became known and there
0:25:10 It was a hurry conference.
0:25:12 And within an hour of his arrival,
0:25:14 a group of local citizens approached the Chinese man,
0:25:17 took him to a restaurant, bought the best meal the town
0:25:21 afforded, and then offered the services of the local
0:25:23 liveryman who provided a team of horses and carriage
0:25:26 complete with driver.
0:25:28 Just as the Chinaman, I'm quoting now, and I want to
0:25:31 emphasize the term Chinaman is a racially derogatory,
0:25:35 it's a racist term, I'm quoting from the Twin Falls News now.
0:25:39 when I use that term.
0:25:40 As just as the Chinaman was beginning to think,
0:25:42 he had struck the greatest stamp of his life,
0:25:45 the locals informed him that they wanted to take a little ride,
0:25:48 wanted him to take a little ride with us.
0:25:51 So near sundown, the Twin Falls citizens escorted
0:25:54 the Chinese man down to the Blue Lakes Ferry.
0:25:57 The Chinese man was then taken as far as the middle
0:25:59 of the river, where the ferry was insecure for the night.
0:26:04 The times, the Twin Falls news then states,
0:26:07 As the weather was warm, the unwelcome visitor did not suffer
0:26:11 through having to sleep on the soft side of the plank.
0:26:15 In the morning, the Chinese man was allowed to land
0:26:17 on the north side, and they're commanded to hit the breeze
0:26:20 for Shoshone and tell other Chinese
0:26:22 that Twin Falls would not welcome them either.
0:26:24 Nine months later, on April 13th, 1905,
0:26:29 the City of Twin Falls was officially incorporated.
0:26:31 I gave you all coffees.
0:26:33 And then the next day that was reported, and then on page four was this article titled
0:26:41 Why No Chinaman Are Found in Twin Falls, containing the story I just recounted.
0:26:48 The article faithfully and unabashedly represents the prevailing sentiments of the Twin Falls
0:26:53 community toward non-whites of the time by stating, quote, the idea that Chinaman, or
0:26:58 a factor in civilization is not entertained here.
0:27:01 Twin Falls News, 1905.
0:27:04 So now the question before the council rhetorical question is,
0:27:08 which narrative does Twin Falls prefer to choose?
0:27:13 We have the narrative of a community that yesterday
0:27:15 in the Times News editorial, quote,
0:27:18 welcome people of all kinds for dreams come true,
0:27:22 also illustrated in the recent New York Times article.
0:27:26 Mr. James, your time is up, so if you could wrap up your thought, I appreciate it.
0:27:30 So, or the 1905 version in which Twin Falls is a place where the idea that Latter-day
0:27:35 Chinaman, today's refugees, Mexicans, Muslims are a factor in civilization is not entertained.
0:27:44 These recent attacks, well, these are skeletons and secrets, ratting around in our collective
0:27:50 historical cellar that need to be confronted and hopefully overcome.
0:27:54 One way would be for the City Council to proclaim Twin Falls a welcoming city.
0:27:59 Thank you.
0:28:00 Thank you Mr. James.
0:28:07 And while I certainly appreciate everyone trying to be supportive of those who are speaking,
0:28:11 if we could please hold the applause to get through the comments that would be appreciated.
0:28:17 So next I have Mark Crandall, so you already spoke.
0:28:21 Terry Edwards, did you wish to speak on this issue as well?
0:28:25 Well, if you have input on this item, I might suggest the
0:28:32 you present it now. If you don't have input on this item, then you're welcome to come up
0:28:37 later.
0:28:48 Terri Edwards Jerome Twin Falls. I might mention that it's kind of contradictory. The
0:28:55 first gentleman spoke and said how we're always a welcoming city and it sounds to me like
0:29:00 this story and finds out that we weren't. If I had a bowl of M&Ms and offered them to
0:29:08 to you and your children.
0:29:11 And then you found out that one of those M&Ms was poisoned,
0:29:17 and either one of your children or yourself may die.
0:29:21 Would you grab a handful?
0:29:23 I doubt it.
0:29:26 Also, I might mention that what we're
0:29:30 thinking about doing with this institution of refugees,
0:29:36 The refugees here, my parents are second generation, I'm third generation refugee, and
0:29:43 they've contributed to this city or the state, this country, but these refugees today aren't
0:29:52 refugees of today, the refugees of today are different.
0:29:56 And it's not because of their ethnicity, it's because of their culture.
0:30:00 They're from another country, they don't assimilate.
0:30:03 problem that we have with that is that they're above the law. As we can see by the cases that
0:30:09 have just been litigated, we have three sexual assault refugees that have admitted to it. And
0:30:19 you guys kind of ignored it for months on end. The other thing is that we have another
0:30:24 one that's pending trial. These people come, they're the poison pill. There might be only
0:30:30 one of them. The problem being is that we don't know who those are, those are, and I don't care
0:30:36 what it says in the documentation that ZZ puts out, they can't be vetted. So what we've got
0:30:42 here is people wandering around, we don't know when they're going to explode, and we know that
0:30:47 they're costing the city much for every one dollar that they earn or they pay in taxes, they
0:30:54 get four dollars in benefits. So where you guys going to come up with that money, if we extend
0:31:00 this to bigger numbers and thankfully there's only 38 have been here since
0:31:06 January 1st been admitted into Twin Falls which is incorrect on Mr. Crandall's
0:31:14 letter. It's 38 we've got had 38 since January 1st in the calendar here but not
0:31:22 in the fiscal year. Thank you. Rick Nair about. Rick Nair about the 195 River
0:31:40 for Vista Place, I am a property owner in Twin Falls.
0:31:45 So I am an employee of the Idaho Derryman's Association
0:31:48 and we are proud supporters of Immigration Reform
0:31:51 and that includes supporting the Refugee Resettlement Center.
0:31:54 That's something that I've spoke to this council
0:31:56 about before and we are supportive of this effort
0:32:01 and supportive of the resolution.
0:32:03 That would declare Twin Falls a welcoming city.
0:32:07 I wanted to spend the majority of my time today
0:32:09 talking about other leadership roles I have
0:32:11 this community and support from those organizations for this effort.
0:32:15 I am also President of the Rapid Soccer Association.
0:32:19 We are an athletic club of about 400 athletes ranging from 5 to 19.
0:32:25 We are supportive of this effort.
0:32:28 We have a number of immigrants and refugees that are part of our club.
0:32:31 They represent our parents of our athletes, our athletes themselves, our coaches, our
0:32:38 referees.
0:32:40 Our club would not be the same club without immigrants and refugees.
0:32:43 They make up a significant portion of our club, and they are very good members of our club.
0:32:50 We've tried to embrace being a welcoming club.
0:32:53 In the past, every year we host the soccer tournament.
0:32:56 If you come to our soccer tournament at Sunway Soccer Complex, you will see as you come into
0:33:01 the complex, it's lined with American flags.
0:33:05 In between those American flags, you will find flags of other nationalities.
0:33:09 Those are representative of our refugees in our community and members of our soccer club.
0:33:15 And we feel that's very important to show that support for those individuals.
0:33:20 Lastly, I want to address you all on something that's a little bit closer to home.
0:33:28 So I'm the father of a biracial family.
0:33:32 We've lived in Twin Falls for 15 years.
0:33:35 We've felt welcome all of those 15 years.
0:33:40 situation is perfect, you do have your awkward moments, but those are far outweighed by the
0:33:46 welcoming environment that Twin Falls and the surrounding communities provide. And I think
0:33:51 this resolution is important. If I look back and consider, based on the publicity that
0:33:57 this community has had the last year, would I make the same decision to move my family here
0:34:02 today as I did 15 years ago? And I was an outsider looking in, I'm not sure I have an
0:34:08 answer for you. So I think this resolution is important to be able to send that explicit
0:34:13 message that we are a welcoming community regardless of race, religion, or nationality. Thank you.
0:34:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:34:31 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:34:40 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:34:42 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:34:46 I want to start by addressing some of the remarks already
0:34:49 made, saying that refugees are not M&M's.
0:34:52 They're not pills.
0:34:52 They're human beings.
0:34:54 And refugees enrich our community.
0:34:56 My husband and I moved here to Twin Falls about three years ago.
0:34:59 And two, the reasons why we felt that Twin Falls was a place
0:35:02 we wanted to make our home was one,
0:35:04 because there was a college here, but two,
0:35:05 because of the refugee center.
0:35:07 And we wanted to move to a community that
0:35:09 had that kind of diversity.
0:35:12 I'm in English as a second language teacher.
0:35:13 I currently teach at the college.
0:35:15 But previously, I did teach some classes
0:35:17 at the refugee center.
0:35:19 And I love my work because I get to work with people
0:35:22 with immigrants, refugees or otherwise, who really understand
0:35:25 the opportunity they have.
0:35:27 They have experienced extreme hardships in their lives.
0:35:30 They've experienced extreme loss.
0:35:31 And they understand that if they come here, they get a chance.
0:35:35 And they work so hard.
0:35:37 And it's partly that work ethic that I think enriches our community.
0:35:42 I'm thinking of one student at the Refugee Center about a year ago that I was working
0:35:47 with who was working as a planter.
0:35:50 He was planting on farms.
0:35:52 I remember at one point they were planting carrots.
0:35:53 So he was working all day.
0:35:55 They started at dawn, he told me, and he was bending over and planting carrots in the sun
0:36:00 in the fields all day, and then he had my English class at night.
0:36:04 And he would come after spending the whole day in the fields working and come to English
0:36:08 class because he wanted to improve his English, because he wanted to be part of this community,
0:36:14 and he wanted to contribute to the community.
0:36:16 So the refugees are people that want to become a part of our community.
0:36:19 They're not people that set themselves apart.
0:36:22 They work hard and they bring wonderful diversity to our community.
0:36:25 And so those are some of the reasons why I am in support of this resolution.
0:36:30 Thank you.
0:36:31 Next, we have a bird gole.
0:36:46 Commercial property at 2140 Eldridge. I'm kind of a duck out of water tonight, but I thought I should come and talk to you folks about something about this welcoming committee.
0:36:55 We've always been a welcoming city. We don't have to have a title. Where are you guys at?
0:37:00 When you got to have a title, would you have a title? You always got the title. Governor, general, private, sergeant, whatever.
0:37:07 And I don't really think we need a title to have Twin Falls
0:37:12 a welcoming center.
0:37:13 If you want to go back in our history, we welcomed everybody.
0:37:17 Everybody that came here was welcome.
0:37:19 We're a different time now in America.
0:37:22 If things are different than America.
0:37:24 So I think we don't need to have a title.
0:37:28 We're just a lovely city.
0:37:30 We've got a lot of lovely people.
0:37:32 We've got a lot of neat things, including the colleges
0:37:35 Southern Idaho and our city I just think this is there is these these boy scouts
0:37:42 are on a mission they're doing their job I don't really think they know what
0:37:45 up what's going on in the world they can't know I don't know and I'm 77 years old
0:37:50 I know a 15 year old kid don't know nothing other than what he's told and so
0:37:57 I I just think why are they doing this is this for money hey guess what happens
0:38:02 If our government stops their refugees from coming in here, how much money is it going to cost our community?
0:38:08 They don't have a job. These people don't have a job. And these people here aren't treated bad that comes as refugees.
0:38:14 They got better than people work here. They make more money than people at work here every day.
0:38:19 We're a welcoming community. And I'm just concerned that once you put this title on there, it's for a long time, you guys.
0:38:28 So I would really consider not putting this title on our city. It's Twin Falls, Idaho
0:38:35 Not Twin Falls. I had a whole welcoming you you can welcome anybody and so I'm I'm just concerned
0:38:41 I realize that these refugees of here. There's all kinds of debate
0:38:47 So be it I can't I can't stop it
0:38:50 but just remember we've been a great city for many many years with our ups and downs and
0:38:56 And I know each and every one of you are wanting to do the right thing, but I think that you should probably
0:39:03 give this some real consideration and not try to make it up all the ones because you've got a group of people in here that
0:39:10 wants to have a title to our city. It's not going to help us a bit. Thank you.
0:39:17 Thank you.
0:39:19 Next we have Tris Woodhead.
0:39:22 I'm, can you hear that?
0:39:30 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:39:31 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:39:37 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:39:43 [Muted for privacy: home address]
0:39:45 I had a little Cambodian girl here in Twin.
0:39:48 She went to Yale and got straight A's, and she works for the State Department.
0:39:52 I had another child visit me.
0:39:54 She's not a child anymore.
0:39:56 I had her visit a couple of weeks ago, and she works on Wall Street.
0:40:00 And when she and her brother and sister came to twin, none of them could speak English at
0:40:06 all.
0:40:07 They just spoke Spanish.
0:40:08 And now she's working for a bank that makes sure that mortgages are given to people who
0:40:14 need mortgages.
0:40:17 I think that it's very important for us to set a good example for our children.
0:40:22 And we should set that example by welcoming people.
0:40:26 And if it's got a title, that's great, because I think most of the teachers in Twin would
0:40:31 be proud to be able to tell their classes that we are officially a welcoming city, and that
0:40:37 all people are equal.
0:40:39 So when I came to Twin from Southern California, my impression was most of the people in Twin
0:40:44 Falls were plump and white, and now the city has improved a great deal.
0:40:51 the more I look around and see different kinds of faces, the happier I am.
0:40:57 Thank you. Next we have David Woodhead.
0:41:06 David Woodhead, 251-5th Avenue East, footballs, and I co-own our house.
0:41:15 She's my wife, for those of you who don't know, come back to follow.
0:41:20 I just want to come tonight and give my support to this concept.
0:41:25 concept. Thank you, Boy Scouts, for doing this. It's hard to say no to Boy Scouts, so you probably have a good chance here.
0:41:34 I've been very happy to see the transformation that's happened to Twin Falls. I remember one time when Tris was teaching at
0:41:48 I got carted off to these carnivals from time to time.
0:41:53 And I happened to notice that all of a sudden,
0:41:57 it looked like the whole world was in Bickel School
0:42:00 because the refugee program had started.
0:42:03 And so we started to have people from Cambodia in particular.
0:42:07 In fact, that little girl that's no longer a little girl,
0:42:11 the one that went to Yale, that whole family became our best friends
0:42:15 our best friends pretty much and we watched them grow and prosper and twin falls and that's
0:42:22 been the case with pretty much all of the refugees that I've ever had any experience with them.
0:42:28 I've met several of them and just recently I've rented space in my other property in
0:42:33 Old Town to an Iraqi refugee who's going to open a mid-east restaurant and I'm very proud
0:42:38 of the fact that that's about to happen because I love that kind of food.
0:42:44 So, look forward to that and please call us a welcoming city.
0:42:49 Thank you, David.
0:42:54 And next I have Julie DeWolf.
0:42:56 Twin Falls County, I own several homes and properties in the area.
0:43:14 Thank you.
0:43:15 Mayor Baraker, Vice Mayor Hopkins, Councilman Lanting, Reid, Tockeington, Councilwoman Boyden-Piers.
0:43:25 that each of you have both sworn and signed your oath of office according to the U.S.
0:43:31 code, you are under obligation. According to Idaho State legislation, Title 74, if you're
0:43:46 familiar with that, is about transparent and ethical government. Ethical is relating to
0:43:50 moral principles. Moral principles are rules of conduct right or wrong. The policy and
0:43:57 the purpose is hereby declared that the position of the public official at all levels of government
0:44:03 is a public trust and the public interest, you are to protect the integrity of the government
0:44:08 throughout the state of Idaho, assure independence, impartiality and honesty, you are to inform
0:44:14 citizens of the existence of personal interests which may conflict with the interest between
0:44:20 the official public trust and private citizen, etc.
0:44:26 We go on in chapter 4, you are required a public official shall not take any official action
0:44:35 or make a formal decision or formal recommendation concerning any matter where he has a conflict
0:44:40 of interest and has failed to disclose such conflict as provided in this section.
0:44:47 If you're uncertain about what those conflicts of interest are, you may want to look up this
0:44:50 code before you take a vote.
0:44:53 If he is an elected public official of the County of Municipality, he shall disclose the
0:44:58 nature of the potential conflict of his interest prior to acting on the matter and shall be
0:45:03 subject to the rules of the body of which he or she is a member.
0:45:09 If he or she is appointed as a public official of the County of Municipality, he shall prepare
0:45:15 a written statement describing the matter required to be acted upon in the nature of the potential
0:45:19 conflict and shall deliver the statement to his appointing authority.
0:45:27 A conflict of interest means any official or any decision or recommendation by a person
0:45:32 acting in a capacity as a public official, the effect of which would be a private pecuniary
0:45:38 benefit to that person or a member of that household, or a business with which the person
0:45:43 or the member or the person's household is associated unless the pecuniary benefit arises
0:45:47 out of the following, an interest of the membership, etc., etc.
0:45:54 I'm letting you know, I'm aware of that code and I hope you are.
0:46:01 I'm going to encourage you to take it very seriously,
0:46:05 because we are going to hold you accountable.
0:46:08 We're going to hold you accountable
0:46:09 to the laws of Idaho.
0:46:12 So I'm giving you peaceful notification in a public way
0:46:15 that we will be investigating your situation specifically
0:46:20 as it relates to you and the public interest,
0:46:23 because your decision about a welcoming city
0:46:25 will have an effect on the people who don't messile here.
0:46:30 It is already affecting people.
0:46:32 as well if your time is up so if you could please wrap up your point I'd
0:46:34 appreciate it. You shall also receive a written letter from me as well and it
0:46:39 will include instructions as well as an overview of what I've just stated. Thank
0:46:42 you. Thank you. So that is all of the people who I have who signed up to speak
0:46:50 on this item. If there is anyone else wishing to address the council on this
0:46:55 item you can now please come forward. Yeah. Again if you would please state
0:47:00 your name and address and whether you are a property owner or resident in the city of
0:47:05 please limit your comments to three minutes.
0:47:08 Good evening.
0:47:10 Lea Bovian, I'm a resident, property owner, small business
0:47:15 owner, concerned citizen, school board trustee for the
0:47:21 best school district in the state of Idaho.
0:47:24 I am also a proud M&M and a former refugee that was
0:47:29 resettled here by the CSI refugee center.
0:47:32 I was very emotional as the line of our Boy Scouts was lined up here, these young 15,
0:47:41 14, 13-year-old young men who don't know better about the world and who might just be paid
0:47:48 to do this, right, kind of was implied.
0:47:51 But I was so proud and overwhelmed with the emotion to see leadership in our city begin
0:47:57 in their generation.
0:47:58 I think that gives a lot of hope to all of us living
0:48:01 in this country.
0:48:04 It also reminds me of a quote that,
0:48:09 and this I hope the young men take this away with them
0:48:11 and go further outside of just this cause,
0:48:14 but there is a huge difference between being elected
0:48:18 and getting things done, and these young men today
0:48:20 demonstrated that they are leading not only our community
0:48:24 to come out of the closet after 30 years of having a program
0:48:30 and people adopted into their community
0:48:32 to actually be proud of that and to be proud of that in a way
0:48:35 that it becomes a staple of this community in a very proud way
0:48:40 and not just something tucked away and invisible,
0:48:43 but they are also shaping their future,
0:48:47 the future they want their community to be
0:48:49 by influencing and playing a role in that decision.
0:48:52 So it makes me very proud to hear this conversation take place
0:48:56 here tonight.
0:48:57 I only wish that my grandparents were alive,
0:49:00 who also came to this country as refugees here
0:49:03 to Twin Falls and contributed.
0:49:06 I only wish they were alive to hear the community that adopted
0:49:09 them, be proud of it 15 years ago, 10 years ago,
0:49:14 25 years ago, 30 years ago, and that it was not just led
0:49:19 by boy scouts, but actually led by the many leaders
0:49:22 that have decided to bring us here.
0:49:26 Whether it's motivated by earning a project badge,
0:49:30 or whether it's motivated by saving an industry that
0:49:35 depends on refugees and immigrant workers,
0:49:38 I think that regardless of what is the motivation,
0:49:43 at the end of the day, I think that it
0:49:44 needs to be highlighted, that this city saves lives.
0:49:48 And I'm standing before you all today.
0:49:51 I only speak for myself when I say this,
0:49:53 but if it wasn't for the program at CSI,
0:49:57 I would not be alive.
0:49:58 My family would not be alive.
0:50:00 I've had that chance.
0:50:01 I could become silent about speaking on this subject,
0:50:04 but it's important that I speak on behalf of those people
0:50:07 that also are waiting and surviving
0:50:12 and then contributing to the communities
0:50:14 they're adopted to.
0:50:15 Thank you.
0:50:16 Thank you, Liam.
0:50:19 So I do have another sign up sheet here with a few other names.
0:50:22 I have Willie Bachma, and then I'll
0:50:27 get to the folks who didn't have a chance to sign up to.
0:50:35 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen.
0:50:36 I'm Willie Bachma, I'm a dairy farm owner south of Twin Falls.
0:50:40 My dairy is at 3374, North 3100 East.
0:50:44 The only dairy on Eastland Drive.
0:50:47 Anyways, my dairy and all the industries
0:50:50 that are affected by my dairy's output,
0:50:52 which produces enough milk to feed this entire city.
0:50:56 Every man, woman, and child in this town
0:50:58 can have milk products from my dairy every day
0:51:02 and it would fulfill your daily requirements
0:51:05 for dairy products.
0:51:07 Anyways, my dairy would not function
0:51:09 without immigrant labor for one thing.
0:51:12 And with the diversity of people that help this community,
0:51:16 the industries that are represented by farming in general
0:51:21 would not survive without refugee help and also I'm going to help.
0:51:25 So I'm in favor of this resolution and I would ask you to vote in favor of it too.
0:51:31 Thank you.
0:51:33 Thank you.
0:51:37 Next day I have Karen McCarthy.
0:51:38 Hi.
0:51:44 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:51:45 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:51:50 [Muted for privacy: street address]
0:51:54 The negative side, when I was moving to Twin Falls, Idaho, some people told me I think
0:51:59 thinking that I was white and plump and would fit in well,
0:52:02 that I would be comfortable it was mostly white,
0:52:07 there weren't many blacks and the Mexicans knew their place.
0:52:12 I got here, my parents came to visit
0:52:14 and being from a small town in Crawford'sville
0:52:17 that had the grand wizard of the KKK residing in it,
0:52:21 my father read our newspaper, The Times News,
0:52:24 and was astounded and said,
0:52:25 Karen, I thought journalism like this had gone away
0:52:28 in the 50s, I have read nothing like this,
0:52:31 where every single Hispanic person was defined
0:52:35 by where they came from, but not white people.
0:52:39 That's the bad news.
0:52:41 The wonderful news was, I think,
0:52:44 the very first house guests we had on arriving here
0:52:46 in the summer of 1985 were two Yugoslavian refugees
0:52:51 that my husband met at a music store,
0:52:53 and they all played music together,
0:52:55 and we could speak very little at all
0:52:57 and made symbols to each other like you want to come eat,
0:53:00 and they played together for hours,
0:53:03 and it was a friendship that lasted for years.
0:53:08 Delighted to have my daughters, my children,
0:53:11 whoops, sorry son,
0:53:13 my children grow up with refugees,
0:53:16 who, you know, as the different waves came through,
0:53:19 and I would say first it was Eastern Europeans,
0:53:21 And my daughter had close, close friends from that community.
0:53:26 And as it's progressed, those are the delightful news.
0:53:29 I'm a member of the Twin Falls United Methodist Church.
0:53:32 And in our basement, the Burundian African Church
0:53:35 holds their worship services.
0:53:38 We got involved with them.
0:53:40 I spent a summer helping learn English and the ABCs
0:53:45 with a group of them, got to know them.
0:53:48 a joyous time is to sneak into our church
0:53:52 when they are meeting and listen to their worship
0:53:56 and their music.
0:53:57 It is a delightful, wonderful experience.
0:54:00 And we've gotten to know them by sharing our facility
0:54:04 with them through the years.
0:54:06 I am a local attorney and I have had the joy
0:54:09 of getting to represent several refugee families
0:54:13 with some housing cases,
0:54:15 but also with guardianship cases.
0:54:17 And that's where you really find their stories representing
0:54:21 children who need guardianships from older relatives
0:54:26 because their family is dead or can't be found or are lost.
0:54:31 I have read the UN documents of all the background checks
0:54:36 that these children went through to get here
0:54:40 and the efforts made to try and find parents and locate them.
0:54:44 I have read the documents of their vetting.
0:54:47 It's been a privilege to meet them and the families who they have been here with.
0:54:52 And I'm delighted with this side of Twin Falls and I urge you to vote that we be a welcoming city.
0:54:58 Thank you.
0:54:59 Excuse me, next I have Stacey Hallmark.
0:55:17 Plus one.
0:55:18 My name is Stacey Hallmark and I live at 2434, 9.5, and I'm here to just show my support.
0:55:25 I grew up in the Magic Valley but lived in New York City for 12 years and recently moved back.
0:55:30 and race through children there.
0:55:33 And as you can imagine, there's such a diversity
0:55:36 of cultures and peoples and religions in New York City.
0:55:39 And I really, growing up, I didn't have that.
0:55:42 And I really loved living in that city
0:55:49 and experiencing the richness that can come.
0:55:52 And I know that there, I understand that people are afraid.
0:55:58 It's human nature to be afraid of things
0:56:00 we don't know or understand or things that are different.
0:56:03 And so I do understand that there is a fear among some here.
0:56:09 But I truly believe that if people could be exposed and get
0:56:12 to know and that there would be a greater understanding and friendship
0:56:18 and bond and love, and I would love for my kids to continue
0:56:22 to be raised in a community that has diversity.
0:56:26 And I know that there are lots of statistics I could share.
0:56:32 You know, that,
0:56:34 sorry, I believe that nobody's ever been killed by a terrorist attack, by a refugee in the United States.
0:56:44 And I know that we hear all this scary news in the world,
0:56:47 and there's always something happening and something going on.
0:56:50 But it happens even in these small, I guess it happens everywhere.
0:56:55 It's universal, unfortunately bad things happen sometimes, but I don't think we can live our lives in fear and I believe that Twin Falls would be well served to be a welcoming community to have that title and I would be proud of that.
0:57:10 Thank you.
0:57:11 Thank you.
0:57:15 All right, so again, I have hit the end of those who had signed up.
0:57:18 So if there are other folks who would wish to address the council, come on forward.
0:57:22 I'm on a Crandall 3102, Obama States and Twin Falls, I own property here.
0:57:28 I'm an obstetrician, a kind of college in the town. I came here in 1985.
0:57:32 During that time period, I delivered almost 6,000 babies here.
0:57:36 And many of those people have been refugees.
0:57:39 I think most of the refugees have come to our office for care, and I've met hundreds of them.
0:57:43 And I have not met one of the refugees that I thought was a bad person.
0:57:48 They were all good people, every one of them.
0:57:50 I didn't feel threatened by any one of them and now as time has gone on I've seen their
0:57:54 kids grow up and now they're coming and having babies with our office and many of them are
0:57:59 co-workers of my hospital, they're good productive citizens of our community and I just hope that
0:58:06 we can be supportive of them and show by supporting this resolution that we are good decent people
0:58:12 here in Twin Falls.
0:58:14 As these refugees have lived here they've become a part of us and I think they are a part of
0:58:17 us and I'm proud of that.
0:58:19 Thank you.
0:58:20 Thank you.
0:58:23 Did I grab silver?
0:58:38 For silver, I look at 1401 poplar and I do on property in this town.
0:58:46 A couple of years ago when this issue came to the front page, I have to tell you that
0:58:54 if we had 200 people sign up in support of the refugee center within about 36 hours.
0:59:02 So I do have a group called Betty Belly, refugee advocates, sorry about my voice, but
0:59:12 our community supports the refugee center.
0:59:14 I walked last summer and not done over 5,000 registered voters' doors last summer and fall.
0:59:24 And I'm at so many, they're not refugees anymore, they're citizens.
0:59:31 They are voters, and they are a big part of this community, and it was amazing to me that
0:59:41 so many were registered to vote, and if they were on my list, it means they are voters.
0:59:49 There are quite a few people in this town who are eligible to vote, but who don't take
0:59:54 advantage of that.
0:59:56 So we have people who come here, and we offer them hope and help from incredible, incredible
1:00:05 this background stories here.
1:00:08 This community supports the refugee center, those citizens support this city.
1:00:14 And I am proud to be one of supporters.
1:00:19 I must say that it is most of the faith communities in this community.
1:00:25 are big supporters and I appreciate so much what this troop is doing and I
1:00:31 encourage you to support their resolution. Thank you.
1:00:39 Is there anyone else who wishes to address the council? Yes, I'm the back.
1:00:45 Come on forward. My name is Anna Graf and I'm a resident of Twin Falls at 232
1:00:58 Locust Street North. I don't have much to say but I do want to come up and
1:01:04 And when my voice to this in support, I have a son on the single mom, and I look forward
1:01:10 to raising him in a community that is open and welcoming to other cultures, to other people.
1:01:18 He's going to get to grow up with access to a much richer culture than what I grew up
1:01:26 in, in the same area.
1:01:29 one of the ways that that happens is through this program and it's opening this
1:01:35 letting me speak yeah I'm going in all that to say I wanted to wait my voice
1:01:47 thank you thank you
1:01:55 anyone else who wishes to address the council on this issue yes kind of Jesse
1:02:01 Sorry.
1:02:07 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:02:08 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:02:15 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:02:18 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:02:21 I know I brought up this issue a couple of times before, but the housing that they're
1:02:24 living in is pretty terrible and nothing's really changing.
1:02:29 So I just encourage you, before you say anything about being a welcoming city, you check what
1:02:35 you're welcoming people too. Are you walking into a better life? Are you
1:02:37 walking into crummy apartments, resting water pipes, exposed electrical outlets
1:02:45 that can harm people, climbing them into these apartments down here? Like their
1:02:48 sardines really. And that's a big deal. So that's all. Thank you. Is there anyone
1:02:58 else who wishes to? Yes, sir. Hi, my name is Regan Larson. I am a resident of Twin
1:03:12 Falls and I'm with that scouting troop over there.
1:03:15 Now I am proud that I live in this city Twin Falls and I do believe that these refugees
1:03:25 are looking for a better place.
1:03:27 Yes, there may be that one M&M that is poison and does do all these bad different things,
1:03:34 but that's what you're going to get anywhere and we unfortunately have some of those people
1:03:40 Twin Falls. Now those people, when they're living in other countries and other places,
1:03:46 when your alarm clock is a bomb blowing up the house next to you, you know you want to
1:03:51 go to a better place. They're looking for a place to come and some of them do end up here
1:03:57 in Twin Falls. Now what these people are wanting to do is they want a better place where they
1:04:03 know that they will be safe from the chairs that they have back there. Yes, we will always
1:04:10 have those people who do have all these offenses, but they will be the ones that do have to
1:04:17 live with that and most often times they will end up going to jail and punishing and get
1:04:23 punished for their crimes.
1:04:26 Now I, like I said, am a boy scout and us boy scouts live by a certain law. A scout is
1:04:32 trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave,
1:04:38 and reverent. Now all of those things, they add up and what we feel about this, I'm here
1:04:44 supporting my fellow scouts, which both have VEGO projects associated with the refugee center.
1:04:52 What they are doing is they're trying to make Twin Falls a better place. And if we are
1:04:57 a place that does allow these refugees to come and come to a better place seeking freedom,
1:05:04 I would be very proud to tell everybody, if I do ever leave here, saying that I came from
1:05:09 a place that welcomed refugees and people who came here.
1:05:14 Now these people do have, they have bad pasts with Al Qaeda and ISIS and all these different
1:05:22 terrorists in their countries.
1:05:24 Coming here, these people, if we were to kick them out and not allow them, those nine
1:05:32 out of 10 people who are good, they came here seeking a better place to live.
1:05:38 And if they can't find anywhere, then we might as well just be as those other countries, not
1:05:44 letting them live there.
1:05:46 Because if they can't live here, then how will they know what good of a city in town we
1:05:51 are?
1:05:52 Now, this city's big brother, Boise, has unanimously passed this.
1:05:59 And so obviously they believe that there is going to be good coming from this.
1:06:05 Now I may be just a 15 year old kid who doesn't know anything but of the few things that I
1:06:12 do know I know that sometimes in class if one kid does something bad we all get punished
1:06:17 for it, no one likes that and that's just how these refugees are feeling and so I am
1:06:23 in support of allowing these people to have a better place than where they were.
1:06:29 Thank you.
1:06:30 Thank you, sir.
1:06:31 There's another.
1:06:37 Yes.
1:06:38 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:06:45 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:06:50 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:06:51 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:06:54 bit during my time there and I wasn't entirely sure if I was going to speak tonight or not,
1:07:00 But then it became clear from some of the previous speakers that I'm not much older than these
1:07:05 gentlemen and the scarves behind you.
1:07:07 I'm 23 years old.
1:07:08 It became very clear that we can't formulate good opinions because we haven't experienced
1:07:13 much and call it good old-fashioned millennial rebellion.
1:07:17 I decided that I'd come and share a few thoughts with you in response to that.
1:07:21 The first thing I want to talk about is something that the good doctor said in his opening and
1:07:24 that's something he said, maybe this won't influence national policy.
1:07:27 really want to stress something to this body and those that are listening in the
1:07:31 audience today. This town is doing something right, rural communities across
1:07:36 this country are disappearing and in mass droves young people my age are moving
1:07:41 inward to the city and that's something that is a national trend. But Twin Falls
1:07:46 isn't doing that. Twin Falls is doing something right and if you don't believe
1:07:50 me there's a tiny newspaper back east that decided to do a little story on us a
1:07:53 couple days ago. Actually they're not that small they have a daily readership of
1:07:56 somewhere in the tens of millions.
1:07:58 And they decided to come and talk about what we're doing right.
1:08:02 And so don't think that this small gesture doesn't have impact
1:08:07 beyond just the city limits of the city of Twin Falls.
1:08:10 And then kind of along that, we talked about the fact
1:08:12 that it's just a title.
1:08:13 What does title mean?
1:08:14 Title doesn't mean anything.
1:08:16 Well, that's also not entirely true.
1:08:19 I work a lot with the FFA organization.
1:08:23 They were just in Twin Falls.
1:08:25 They left last week.
1:08:25 their state convention was here on the CSI campus.
1:08:28 And I meet with a lot of Hispanic students,
1:08:29 and in one of my interactions they told me they're scared.
1:08:34 They're here on legal terms and legal status,
1:08:37 but they're scared because of the way
1:08:38 that the national media is portraying minorities
1:08:41 in this country.
1:08:42 And they say that it's not that I'm scared
1:08:47 because of my status, I'm just scared
1:08:49 about what other people think.
1:08:51 And so I guess all that just to reiterate,
1:08:54 Yes, it can't have an influence well beyond the borders of this city, and then on top of that.
1:09:00 Yeah, it might just be a title, and to most of us, title doesn't mean anything, but to some of us, that title can mean everything. Thank you.
1:09:14 Yes.
1:09:15 Lanny Whitney, I'm a resident of Kimberly.
1:09:26 One of my dearest friends moved here four years ago, actually a little over four years ago,
1:09:32 a refugee that came from Baghdad, Iraq, Iraq, she always corrects me.
1:09:38 And just commenting about the conditions that the refugees might come to here in Twin Falls,
1:09:46 this mother of four young, very young children and father came to Twin Falls
1:09:52 And one of the comments that she made was that they came from a city where bombings and shootings occurred daily.
1:10:02 And they would hear them throughout the day.
1:10:04 And her experience was one of sending her children out the door in the morning or her husband.
1:10:10 And really truthfully praying and hoping that she would see them at the end of the day.
1:10:17 day. And so to share what she expressed coming to Twin Falls of the safety that they felt
1:10:28 of not hearing shootings and bombings throughout the day is they felt a lot of gratitude for
1:10:35 that and they didn't feel hard done by or upset about their conditions. They were just
1:10:43 grateful for the couple of plastic chairs that were in the kitchen for a roof over their
1:10:48 heads and for silence of not being in the midst of a bombing city and chaos and shambles
1:10:57 of a city that is in constant warfare.
1:11:01 And so I think that that helps us with all the things that we have around us, that we
1:11:08 take for granted, we might get a little confused as to thinking what are they coming to, not
1:11:14 to say that I don't want to improve that because I work towards that with each of you trying
1:11:18 to improve what they come to, but I know that those efforts are being made on all fronts,
1:11:24 so I know that they're grateful to be here and I'm so glad that they're here too.
1:11:32 So, any one else?
1:11:33 Yes, sir, and in the front.
1:11:38 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:11:39 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:11:43 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:11:49 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:11:51 I had the privilege of living in Central Africa for a few years, and while I was over
1:11:55 there. If I could express to you how welcome and how I was received with open arms over
1:12:03 there regardless of my race or my nationality, I felt that I would be condemned if I didn't
1:12:11 get up here and speak for those people that I've met and speak for their generosity. And
1:12:17 I think us as twin members of the Twin Falls community should likewise take a look at ourselves
1:12:24 and think if roles were changed, would we not want someone or somewhere to feel welcome?
1:12:35 I know that there are much more yays than nays, and I just wanted to add my voice to that and
1:12:42 to let you know that I love these people and I'm willing to welcome them as best as I can
1:12:47 here in Twin Falls.
1:12:48 Thank you.
1:12:49 Thank you.
1:12:50 Anyone else?
1:12:54 Guess in the back.
1:13:11 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:13:12 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:13:21 [Muted for privacy: street address]
1:13:27 gassing and everything in Syria in the last week.
1:13:29 Your heart goes out to those people.
1:13:31 But I don't want Twin Falls to forget about the little five-year-old girl that was sexually
1:13:37 molested by three refugee boys.
1:13:40 She was innocent. She didn't do anything wrong. And yet she was assaulted by those boys.
1:13:48 And this community did not reach out to her. She should have gotten federal and state funds.
1:13:53 She never did. She never got counseling. Cares, I was here last week and heard Cares talk
1:13:58 about how important it was to counsel young children shortly after they were sexually abused.
1:14:05 She's never had counseling.
1:14:08 Several people came and asked the council to help them find a home for this family.
1:14:13 They still had to live next door to the boy, one of the boys who molested her, for months.
1:14:19 And finally, some citizens in the community reached out, got her home, got them a car, helped
1:14:25 them get established in the community.
1:14:27 And so while my heart goes out to those people too, my heart goes out to Jala.
1:14:33 had no counseling, she's had no support from the community at all. And when the council
1:14:39 was asked to help find them a place to live, never got a response from anybody. So my concern
1:14:46 is the fairness. You know, everybody reaches out to the refugee community and I'm not opposed
1:14:54 to them, but the treatment should be fair to the American citizens too, and I want everybody
1:14:58 to remember what happened to that little girl. Thank you.
1:15:01 May I?
1:15:03 Yes, Suzanne Hawkins.
1:15:05 I just want to go on the record with that.
1:15:08 I do want you to know that I did reach out to the family.
1:15:11 So to say that nobody on the council tried to help when they were looking for housing
1:15:14 or help is an unfair statement.
1:15:17 I know that Greg Lanting took money out of his pocket to help that family.
1:15:22 And this community set up with that GoFundMe page and did help.
1:15:27 And I understand there's a lot of legal what and things that we don't understand as council
1:15:32 members and it's out of our jurisdiction, but for you to say that none of us tried to help
1:15:36 is an unfair statement, and I just want to go on the record with that.
1:15:39 Okay.
1:15:40 So, I appreciate your comments.
1:15:47 We can't have a debate back and forth across the room, okay?
1:15:51 These issues have been shared clearly.
1:15:54 It's been communicated with the family.
1:15:56 Again, I appreciate your frustration and concern, and I thank you for sharing it with
1:16:01 us.
1:16:02 Is there anyone else here wishing to speak on the welcoming resolution?
1:16:07 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:16:16 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:16:20 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:16:23 [Muted for privacy: home address]
1:16:25 So I want to speak from just a little bit different angle.
1:16:29 I'm an American.
1:16:32 My parents immigrated from the Netherlands.
1:16:35 I'm the first generation born in the U.S., but forgive me.
1:16:46 I have spent time overseas, and I have been welcomed in every country that I've lived
1:16:54 in except for Honduras, and there they don't like or at that time they did not like me because
1:17:04 I was an American, an American. We tend to think that Americans are loved and welcomed
1:17:12 everywhere in the world. They're not. They are not. But I tell you, it was really strange
1:17:19 to go there and not be loved, not be welcomed simply for that reason. It was an American.
1:17:26 They were burning an American flag in the park, children threw rocks at me and then ran. Now,
1:17:33 I don't want anybody to come into Twin Falls
1:17:37 and feel that they're not welcome or that we don't like them
1:17:41 because of where they came from.
1:17:43 We are humans or people.
1:17:47 So I would say it doesn't even matter
1:17:49 if they're refugees, whatever they are.
1:17:52 Come to common ground, we are people, we are one.
1:17:56 So I would vote that we welcome people
1:17:59 that we proudly wear a title that says we are welcoming.
1:18:03 Thank you.
1:18:05 Thank you.
1:18:10 So anyone else in the audience wishing
1:18:12 to address the counts on this issue?
1:18:17 Yes?
1:18:26 Once again, like so many people here,
1:18:27 I wasn't planning on speaking, but I'm Bethany Rasmussen,
1:18:30 and I'm a resident of Tunes Falls.
1:18:32 So I was reading over your proclamation here, Mr. Mayor,
1:18:36 and I couldn't help but notice that there wasn't a lot
1:18:38 of information about this.
1:18:40 So which resolution are you reading?
1:18:42 this one. So that actually is one that was drafted by Mr. Edwards, not by that
1:18:48 council. Oh, okay. There was a spot here for you to sign in. So I'm sorry. That's
1:18:52 just a draft that was presented to us as another option that we might consider.
1:18:56 Oh, okay. Okay. There just wasn't a lot of information on it. And so I was
1:19:00 slightly confused how this was going to affect. I know that the troop leader
1:19:04 mentioned that it probably would not affect a lot of things, but as we know
1:19:08 So, all of us, whenever someone moves here, there is a lot of effect.
1:19:13 My mom moved here back about 30 years ago.
1:19:17 And since she has moved here, I was born in Twin Falls, but since she has moved here,
1:19:21 our population has moved from about 25,000 to now pushing 55,000.
1:19:26 So, for me, I also have family members who look different than I do.
1:19:31 I won't call them a different race, but we all share different characteristics.
1:19:36 And we have experienced the love of our community as well as the man who spoke earlier that he has a biracial family.
1:19:44 And I don't quite understand, I love being a welcoming city, we need to love people.
1:19:50 They are most important when everything else burns, people are going to last.
1:19:53 They're the ones that are going to last and be here permanently and what we need to fight for.
1:19:58 But I'm curious how stamping this on our city is really going to change people's minds.
1:20:04 on both sides of the issue.
1:20:06 So to me, I don't really understand
1:20:09 what this is going to change.
1:20:12 I think it's a good idea to strive for it,
1:20:15 to be a welcoming city, to love people,
1:20:18 and to understand that they do, they matter.
1:20:23 But I also have a hard time looking at what's
1:20:26 happened to, like, Jayla, and looking at that issue
1:20:30 and saying, OK, is every need being met.
1:20:34 The larger our city becomes, the harder it is for us
1:20:37 to take care of those individual cases.
1:20:40 And I want that.
1:20:42 I want that for everybody.
1:20:43 So when they come here, they are now someone
1:20:46 that me as a citizen.
1:20:47 I take responsibility for their safety,
1:20:49 their wellbeing as a taxpayer,
1:20:52 that's what that goes toward.
1:20:54 And I want them to be taken care of and loved
1:20:57 and appreciated.
1:20:59 I don't believe that we're not a welcoming city already.
1:21:04 And maybe I'm just kind of reiterating a lot of different ideas that people have already
1:21:08 said.
1:21:09 But to me, I want to be known as welcoming.
1:21:13 But my question is as well, if this goes a step further and we become more like a sanctuary
1:21:18 city, what will we attract?
1:21:21 That was my immediate thought.
1:21:22 I had no thought of refugees.
1:21:23 I had no thought of immigrants.
1:21:25 I had a thought of people coming here who have done crimes in other states and decided,
1:21:30 hey, we're going to go over here.
1:21:32 No matter if they look like me or not.
1:21:34 So anyway, those were just kind of my thoughts.
1:21:35 Thank you.
1:21:36 Thank you.
1:21:38 All right.
1:21:39 Last call for anyone else who wishes to address the council.
1:21:43 Otherwise, we'll turn it over to the council for discussion.
1:21:45 I don't see anyone else.
1:21:50 So, council, Chris talking.
1:21:51 I've been a good meeting tonight.
1:21:54 It shows the DNA at Twin Falls.
1:21:56 80% of you are on what I consider the right side, the light side.
1:22:02 We always give room and time for people to speak their opinion, no matter whether we agree
1:22:07 or disagree.
1:22:08 as part of the strength of local government and our democracy.
1:22:12 I keep hearing references to the Idaho Constitution.
1:22:16 I have to tell you I'm guided by the US Constitution.
1:22:19 All men are created equal.
1:22:21 That's my guiding dogma.
1:22:23 I've lived in a foreign country.
1:22:25 I have been welcomed when I didn't speak the language,
1:22:27 didn't look at them, looked at like them the same way.
1:22:32 I bring that value back to Twin Falls,
1:22:34 But I'd like to also mention that we have a bit of history
1:22:38 in Twin Falls that is a stigma, a dark point of our history.
1:22:43 At the beginning of World War II, we had a Japanese concentration camp.
1:22:49 There is a very polite language for it, but I had a secretary
1:22:52 as a child who was incarcerated there.
1:22:56 That is a blemish of Twin Falls will never be able to erase,
1:23:00 but for God's sakes we can at least learn a lesson not to judge people
1:23:04 by how they speak, how they look, but how they act and treat others.
1:23:09 You know, this town is 113 years old.
1:23:12 Twin Falls was formed in the basis of opportunity, open doors, hard work, looking each other
1:23:19 in the eye and speaking clearly and telling people what you thought and admitting mistakes.
1:23:27 The history of Twin Falls is based on these positive American values and I don't want
1:23:33 to recede back into the darkness of suspicion in paranoia.
1:23:40 The only time I've been paranoid is when I lived
1:23:42 in that foreign country and during the Cold War
1:23:45 and I had the Cuban government trying to kill me.
1:23:48 But we still spoke the same language
1:23:50 and I met Cubans afterwards
1:23:52 and some of them are almost friends now.
1:23:56 Even the people in this audience
1:23:57 that are speaking against a welcoming community,
1:24:01 I try to have dialogue with, usually not successfully,
1:24:05 but that's because I'm a left handed Irish,
1:24:07 and that's my fault.
1:24:09 I want you to know that Twin Falls wants
1:24:12 to be a welcoming community, but we
1:24:14 have to prove it.
1:24:15 And a resolution similar to the one the Boise passed,
1:24:19 I think, is the first step.
1:24:22 One other little addendum.
1:24:23 I keep hearing the people who don't want Twin Falls
1:24:27 to be a welcoming community complain
1:24:29 about those people stealing jobs. Twin Falls is above full employment. Anybody that wants
1:24:37 to have a job in Twin Falls can get a job. Don't ride that dog. Don't hunt. Okay? I'm
1:24:47 in favor of a welcoming community, but I see other counsel wanting to speak, and let's
1:24:52 just remember, four out of five people, more than 80 percent of the people representing
1:24:57 to unfalls DNA support a welcoming community.
1:25:01 Thank you.
1:25:02 Thank you.
1:25:03 Chris, Greg, Lansing.
1:25:07 I'd like Dr. Crandall, not only for his work with the scouts, I'm also an Eagle Scout
1:25:14 for all of those who are there.
1:25:16 I'm proud of that fact and some of your Eagle Scout projects seem to be well recognized
1:25:24 for the city as a whole.
1:25:27 I tended to do those for my sponsoring group as the Hollister Press Training Church, and
1:25:33 I did my projects for the church, so I wish I had expanded to the community as a whole.
1:25:40 I also would like to thank Dr. Crannell for being a leader in health care for this city.
1:25:46 He was my mother's part doctor, and I certainly appreciate his helping along that way.
1:25:56 I too am in favor of this resolution.
1:25:59 I believe that it will, as the one gentleman said,
1:26:03 who needs to get a job with broadcasting.
1:26:05 His voice was unbelievable.
1:26:07 Yes.
1:26:08 He has an excellent voice to talk about that.
1:26:12 It does mean things to certain people.
1:26:14 And if they feel welcome,
1:26:17 then that's enough for me right now.
1:26:21 And I'm gonna say this very clearly this time,
1:26:23 Because I said it one time before and the times just quoted me rather poorly.
1:26:30 We are all children of immigrants.
1:26:33 Last time they got it really messed up.
1:26:35 I'm not sure how.
1:26:36 I was like to see a few Dutch people show up because that's my background.
1:26:41 My grandparents came from the Netherlands to the United States and actually settled in
1:26:49 Amsterdam Idaho, which is supposed to be, don't know where it's at, it's between Hollister
1:26:52 and Rogerson out there, and they settled there because that way they could speak Dutch and
1:26:58 not have to, for most of the time, my oldest uncle actually went to school speaking no English,
1:27:06 and was learned how to speak English at school.
1:27:09 By the time my dad got there, who was the youngest child, he already knew because these
1:27:13 brothers and sisters all spoke English to him because they've learned in school.
1:27:19 I think it's important for the City of Twin Falls to support being a welcoming city and
1:27:25 I will gladly vote, yay, when that is presented to us.
1:27:31 Thank you, Greg.
1:27:32 Nicky Boy.
1:27:41 Diversity is really important and diversity comes in many forms.
1:27:45 And one of the things is when it comes to diversity, we are each responsible for educating
1:27:52 ourselves.
1:27:54 We are responsible for perhaps traveling, perhaps visiting.
1:27:59 I think somebody served a mission and went to another country.
1:28:03 It's very important for us to understand that we are very proud of America and it is a land
1:28:11 of opportunity.
1:28:13 It's not a guaranteed anything.
1:28:15 People that come here come here for a better chance at things.
1:28:20 There's no guaranteed outcome.
1:28:23 There's risk in life and sometimes when you go places it doesn't work out like in Honduras
1:28:28 That just didn't work out, but that didn't stop her from living a good productive life
1:28:33 I came from a big city and I I love big cities. I I still do but I chose Twin Falls
1:28:43 I
1:28:44 Chose Twin Falls and this is where I've raised my children and I believe that tonight you guys have
1:28:51 have demonstrated what a welcoming city this is. Everything from scouts to dairy farmers
1:29:02 to people who serve at their church. I've been a real estate agent for a long time and
1:29:09 I was blown away years ago by how many people drove through Twin Falls on the way to somewhere
1:29:17 else and stayed and thought when I, you know, retire, I'm coming here or we're thinking about
1:29:25 changing jobs, we want to look here.
1:29:27 I hear all the time, all the time and it amazes me how friendly everybody is to strangers here.
1:29:37 When I first came here, I found it very friendly but I didn't find it as welcoming because I
1:29:43 had different kind of license plates. And my neighbor simply said, change them over,
1:29:52 you know, get rid of those plates. But we all have experiences, but I believe that Twin
1:29:59 Falls is a welcoming city. It has always been a welcoming city. And we have always been
1:30:06 for all the citizens, any oath anybody has ever taken for the Constitution, for the state
1:30:13 of Idaho and it's for all citizens. Our police pledge to serve all the citizens. We are all
1:30:21 created equal under God. And when I read on here that, you know, we were referring to Boise
1:30:28 how they did this. And when it says, you know, the symbolic thing, it says that they want
1:30:36 So they want to be a welcoming city, but it's right here.
1:30:40 It is non-binding with no financial impact, but it's a powerful statement of support.
1:30:47 And I don't think I need a welcoming city put in writing.
1:30:53 I think we need citizens who, all of us, pony up, and we are welcoming citizens.
1:30:59 And we do the acts, we don't have something on a piece of paper because everything that
1:31:04 You see, the safe city, the welcoming city, all of this stuff, that's how we live.
1:31:11 That's how we do it here already and I'm very proud of that.
1:31:14 And I thank you all for demonstrating that to me tonight.
1:31:18 Thank you, Nikki.
1:31:20 Suzanne Hopkins.
1:31:21 Thank you.
1:31:24 I came tonight with a prepared speech.
1:31:27 I had worked through a number of issues because I feel that Twin Falls is a very welcoming community.
1:31:34 And I'm going off script now.
1:31:37 I thought this last Saturday I had the opportunity to give out awards to all the volunteers at the Senior Center for the last year.
1:31:47 Last year when Special Olympics decided they were going to host their state games in Twin Falls,
1:31:53 we had a volunteer for every athlete that showed up for those games.
1:31:59 They were blown away.
1:32:00 They have never seen anything like that in our state before.
1:32:04 If you look at our service clubs, if you look at our churches, you look at what Salvation Army does.
1:32:09 If you look at the Boy Scouts, if you look at all the committees and commissions that help the city of Twin Falls achieve its goals,
1:32:18 this community is a community that helps their neighbors like no other community in the world.
1:32:23 I've heard Red Cross say when there's a disaster in Twin Falls, they don't have to come because the neighbors take care of it before they get here.
1:32:30 And they don't find that anywhere else.
1:32:32 We're a unique blend of different personalities and people who come together.
1:32:38 We find solutions for our problems.
1:32:40 We welcome anyone into our community who wants to be a part of our community.
1:32:44 We help our neighbors and that has been demonstrated tonight over and over and over and over.
1:32:51 When I came in tonight, I didn't feel like I wanted to support this resolution.
1:32:55 I'll be honest.
1:32:56 I felt like it was written to be a bigger divisive tool in our community.
1:33:02 We have two very strong personalities and both sides of this issue have real concerns and they
1:33:10 have real positive points.
1:33:13 I would like to see us as a community, as a welcoming community who includes everyone,
1:33:18 come to the table together and maybe take this resolution and the safety resolution and find
1:33:25 common ground and come up with a resolution that is Twin Falls. It is not Boise, it is
1:33:31 not Ketchum, but it represents Twin Falls at its core. That it includes those who want
1:33:37 to see the vetting increased for refugees to help their security so they feel safe. They
1:33:43 have a right to feel safe. They live here too. But at the same time that when we have
1:33:47 refugees that we can truly help, that we reach out that hand as neighbors, as humans, and
1:33:53 help each other. And so when I vote on this resolution tonight, it is not what you're reading
1:34:01 in front of you, but I would like to encourage us as a council to create our own resolution
1:34:06 that represents Twin Falls for what we are and who we are and not copy what our neighbors
1:34:11 have done and find a common ground that welcomes our refugees and welcomes our legal immigrants
1:34:19 and at the same time welcomes those that were born here and are at the heart of this community
1:34:23 that keep it going and I don't want to, I guess I want to get off my soapbox but I want
1:34:30 to say thank you to everyone, everyone who spoke on both sides of this issue tonight.
1:34:35 You really made me look inside and do some soul searching on how I feel and what I can
1:34:40 and want to support in this community and it's because of every one of you that Twin Falls
1:34:45 is what Twin Falls is, a very welcoming place to all.
1:34:50 Thank you Suzanne. So I would echo just a couple of comments that I've heard from a few of the council members here
1:34:57 So in all of my experiences
1:35:00 Dealing with folks who were here visiting perhaps it was a company looking to possibly locate here
1:35:07 You know, I work at the Chamber of Commerce office. We see hundreds of visitors every day
1:35:14 Without exception the first thing I hear from them when I'm talking about their their interaction in the community is how
1:35:21 and how kind and how welcoming our community is.
1:35:25 And that's not just when falls, that's the entirety of the Magic Valley.
1:35:29 I do believe it is what makes us unique and special.
1:35:33 I think it is more important than our natural setting.
1:35:39 It's more important than the miracle of agriculture here.
1:35:42 It's more important than all those things. It's the people who live here.
1:35:46 Even in this room, I know, we all have differences.
1:35:50 We have concerns about politics.
1:35:55 We have concerns about how money gets spent or doesn't get spent.
1:35:58 But I don't think there is a one of us in this room that can't say, we want to be kind
1:36:03 and welcoming people.
1:36:06 And we've had our blemishes in history, and to Council on Talkington's point, I think we,
1:36:14 as leaders in this community and you as citizens in this community have an obligation to learn
1:36:19 from history and to try to correct those things that have not gone quite the way they should
1:36:25 have in the past.
1:36:28 But this needs to be more than just words on paper.
1:36:32 I am so immensely proud of these Boy Scouts who have come here this evening and some of
1:36:38 the other speakers referred to them, Liam in particular, talking about they're the leaders
1:36:43 of this issue. It's not the seven of us. This is coming from our community. This wasn't the seven of us,
1:36:50 two of us or one of us saying, here's my agenda, I'm going to ramrod down this community's throat,
1:36:56 which I have heard from many in this community over the last week. This is about young individuals
1:37:03 in our community taking their responsibility to embrace Twin Falls, to celebrate what it's about,
1:37:12 to make sure it's a better place for them in the future, and those others who live here.
1:37:17 And so I am in full support of taking the request, which is that Twin Falls should have some sort of welcoming resolution,
1:37:27 because you didn't bring a draft of one, per se. You brought some examples.
1:37:32 And I do think that we collectively should take some time to make sure that it is reflective of what we are now,
1:37:40 and also looking toward the future.
1:37:42 So I pulled up our strategic plan here,
1:37:46 while others were speaking.
1:37:49 And we have a focus area in our current city strategic plan.
1:37:54 Again, not written by the seven of us or the city staff,
1:37:57 this was written by the community
1:37:59 with input from the community.
1:38:02 And our focus area seven is about a responsible community.
1:38:05 And our vision is that the Twin Falls community
1:38:08 has retained its human face as it has grown over time.
1:38:11 New residents are welcomed and made
1:38:13 to feel part of the tightly knit community.
1:38:17 This was written three years ago.
1:38:21 This was well before the most recent
1:38:24 controversial conversation going on in our community.
1:38:28 To me, this references a 30 plus year old
1:38:32 refugee resettlement program.
1:38:34 It represents a history of immigration in our community
1:38:39 to take care of the needs of the land, it celebrates the western migration of after we were a state
1:38:48 and well before we were a state with the Mormon pioneers who came through. It's just who we are
1:38:54 and I made similar comments many, many months ago at the peak of this initial conversation,
1:39:01 in our community, and I'm thankful that we have been
1:39:08 through a very difficult time as a community,
1:39:11 but that we can have a civil conversation to talk about,
1:39:15 putting on paper what it is we are and what we want to be.
1:39:19 So again, I thank everyone for being here this evening
1:39:22 and being a part of this conversation,
1:39:24 and I would certainly entertain some direction
1:39:27 from the council.
1:39:28 Chris talking to you.
1:39:29 request that the Council direct the city manager, city staff, to provide a first
1:39:37 draft of a Twin Falls as a welcoming community with language that may be
1:39:45 modified as we jointly discuss it.
1:39:50 Second.
1:39:51 Motion by Kristina.
1:39:53 Seconded by Greg Lanting to direct city staff to give a first blush at this and to
1:39:59 have some further discussion as a council.
1:40:01 I would like to amend that motion to include that city staff reach out to some of the public
1:40:08 who spoke maybe tonight and if offered them a chance to buy email or however submit ideas
1:40:15 of things that they should think should be included or should not be included in this and
1:40:20 just kind of get a little more pulse from the community and make sure it's truly a community
1:40:24 document and not a city staff document.
1:40:31 second to that motion.
1:40:32 Second.
1:40:35 Motion by Suzanne Hockens and the by Chris Reed
1:40:37 to encourage staff to reach out to the community
1:40:40 and some who spoke this evening to do our best
1:40:42 to gather community sentiment here.
1:40:45 Chris Stockton.
1:40:46 Well, I just wonder Suzanne, we've had 24 speakers
1:40:49 here tonight, pro and con.
1:40:50 Don't you think this is a hearing the community?
1:40:54 I do think it's of the community,
1:40:56 but I think before we put pen to paper,
1:40:58 it's a good idea to maybe give them a chance
1:41:00 to submit what they presented tonight
1:41:04 so that staff doesn't have to go back
1:41:05 and listen to the recordings.
1:41:10 Any further discussion on the amendments?
1:41:15 Seeing none, Sharon, roll call vote, please.
1:41:18 This is on the amendment.
1:41:19 On the amendment, yes.
1:41:21 John Berger.
1:41:22 Yes.
1:41:24 Chris Hockington.
1:41:25 No.
1:41:26 Greg Lanting.
1:41:27 Yes.
1:41:29 Christopher Reed.
1:41:30 Yes.
1:41:31 Ruth Pierce.
1:41:32 Yes.
1:41:33 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:41:34 Yes.
1:41:35 Nikki Boyd.
1:41:36 Yes.
1:41:37 Motion passes 6-1.
1:41:38 So is there any discussion on the main motion as amended?
1:41:43 Chair in roll call vote please.
1:41:48 Dickey Boyd?
1:41:50 Yes.
1:41:51 Sean Bericher?
1:41:52 Yes.
1:41:53 Chris Tockington?
1:41:54 Yes.
1:41:55 Greg Lanting?
1:41:56 Yes.
1:41:57 Christopher Reed?
1:41:58 Yes.
1:41:59 Ruth Pierce?
1:42:00 Yes.
1:42:01 Suzanne Hawkins?
1:42:02 Yes.
1:42:03 Motion passes 7-0.
1:42:05 Once again, thanks to everyone for your input this evening.
1:42:08 So staff will begin working on a draft,
1:42:10 and this will certainly be noticed up on a future agenda
1:42:13 before the council takes the action.
1:42:15 We'll have some opportunity for conversation.
1:42:19 So with that, I'm gonna ask that we take
1:42:21 a six minute recess, and we will reconvene at 20.
1:42:26 Thank you.
1:42:27 So I'll reconvene the council meeting
1:42:29 for Monday, April 10th after a break.
1:42:33 The next item on the agenda is a request to reappoint.
1:42:35 Susan Petrizelli, Chad Debbie, and Gerald Martins,
1:42:38 as well as a point Ross Conlin,
1:42:40 to the Development Impact Fee Advisory Committee.
1:42:44 So Susan, Gerald, and Chad, or Susan and Gerald,
1:42:48 recently completed their first term, full term of three years,
1:42:52 and Chad completed a first partial term of one year
1:42:55 on the Development Impact Fee Advisory Committee.
1:42:58 All three of these members have had great attendance
1:43:00 and participate on the committee.
1:43:02 Recently, City staff published a vacancy for the committee,
1:43:05 but did not receive any applications.
1:43:08 The Council recently confirmed appointments
1:43:10 to the Planning and Zoning Commission,
1:43:12 and there were some well-qualified candidates
1:43:14 for the Planning and Zoning that were not able
1:43:16 to be appointed because we just had more applicants
1:43:19 than positions.
1:43:20 And so staff reached out to those applicants
1:43:23 who were not appointed to Planning and Zoning,
1:43:25 and one of them, Ross Conlin,
1:43:27 has expressed interest in this opportunity.
1:43:30 Councilman Tockenton, Chairman Brad Wills,
1:43:32 The city staff and myself recently interviewed Ross.
1:43:36 He spent 30 years previously, but the Pocatello and American Falls Police Department has a
1:43:40 great desire to serve the community.
1:43:43 And we felt he would be a great addition to this committee, offering a different point
1:43:46 of view on growth and development.
1:43:49 So it's important to point out that this particular commission or committee has some specific seats
1:43:55 that must be filled by various sectors, engineering, developers, so forth.
1:44:02 But it also includes at-large members, and that's a position that Ross would fill.
1:44:07 So he comes with no engineering or development background per se, but could really be kind
1:44:13 of a voice of the at-large community.
1:44:15 So I would request that we appoint him to appoint all of these folks, the reappointments
1:44:24 as well as Ross, to the development impact fee advisory committee.
1:44:27 Chris, talk to you.
1:44:28 I'd just like to make one additional comment to your relation to what went on.
1:44:33 Even as Mr. Ross Conlon has not been involved in development and
1:44:39 in public service through the police department, he does understand that the impact
1:44:45 the advisory committee is a function of a policy that has been approved by courts
1:44:52 out the state where the cost and growth can be assessed to future development and those
1:44:59 funds be applied toward four categories of police, fire, streets, and park improvement.
1:45:06 So there is no question as to whether this is, I guess the term is constitutionally upheld
1:45:12 in the state of Idaho.
1:45:14 And I would certainly think you'd be a good additional candidate for our group.
1:45:20 I'd like to make a motion if you're ready for that. I would move that we
1:45:25 reappoint Susan Petruzzelli, Chad Debbie, and Gerald Martins as well as appoint Ross
1:45:32 Conlon to the Development Impact Fee Advisory Committee. Second motion by
1:45:38 Ruth Pierce second by Chris Reed to approve the appointments request it is
1:45:43 there any discussion? Just one little point of clarification the vacant
1:45:50 position, and we forgot to help you out with this on your
1:45:54 report, Mayor, but the vacant position that's going to be
1:45:58 filled by Ross is a partial term. The other three are full
1:46:01 terms three years, and I think Ross is a two year term, I'm not
1:46:05 mistaken, it might be one, but it's a partial term. Okay,
1:46:09 thank you. Seeing no further discussion, Sharon, roll call
1:46:13 vote, please.
1:46:15 Chris Tockington. Yes, Greg Lanting. Yes, Christopher Reed.
1:46:20 Yes.
1:46:21 With Piers.
1:46:22 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:46:23 Yes.
1:46:24 Nicki Boyd.
1:46:25 Yes.
1:46:26 Sean Baraker.
1:46:27 Yes.
1:46:28 Motion passes 7-0.
1:46:29 Next is a request to adopt an ordinance for a zoning district change and zoning map amendment
1:46:33 for approximately 2.14 plus or minus acres from C1PUD to C1ZDA to develop a hotel and
1:46:41 accessory uses the maximum building height of 55 feet on property located east of 1788
1:46:48 to the street north and we have Mitch Humboldt.
1:46:51 I had pity on Renee and I let her go home early tonight.
1:46:57 I'm told I would go ahead and take this far.
1:47:00 If you'll recall back on January 9th, the city counts
1:47:02 that a public hearing on this request.
1:47:05 At the end of that public hearing approved, the request
1:47:07 and directed staff to prepare an ordinance.
1:47:09 There's been some time to get all those details straightened out
1:47:12 because there's a few conditions on that.
1:47:14 But in the end, we have the ordinance ready for your adoption tonight.
1:47:18 It is an ordinance, and so adoption and disordance will require the, if you want to do it tonight,
1:47:23 we'll require the suspension of the rules and all that jazz.
1:47:27 So if you have any questions, we can try to answer them for you, but otherwise it's pretty straightforward.
1:47:31 Adoption and ordinance.
1:47:34 Thank you, Mitch.
1:47:35 Questions for Mitch?
1:47:37 Council wishes.
1:47:39 Do we have an ordinance number?
1:47:41 It's ordinance number 2017-10.
1:47:49 I would move to place ordinance 2017-10 on third and final by
1:47:54 total only under suspension of the rules second motion by
1:47:59 Kristoff and second by Ruth Pierce to spend the rules in place
1:48:02 ordinance 2017-10 on third and final reading by title only
1:48:06 is there any discussion?
1:48:07 Chair and roll call vote please.
1:48:13 Greg Lanthine.
1:48:14 Yes.
1:48:15 Christopher Reed.
1:48:16 Yes.
1:48:17 Ruth Pierce.
1:48:18 Yes.
1:48:19 Suzanne Hopkins.
1:48:20 Yes.
1:48:21 Yes.
1:48:22 Sean Barriker.
1:48:23 Yes.
1:48:24 Chris talking.
1:48:25 Yes.
1:48:26 Motion passes.
1:48:27 720.
1:48:28 Sharon would you read the title please.
1:48:30 Ordinance number 2017-10.
1:48:32 And ordinance of the City Council of the City of Twin Falls, Idaho rezoning real property
1:48:39 below describe providing the zoning classification therefore and ordering the necessary amendments
1:48:46 to the area of impact and zoning districts map.
1:48:52 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:48:53 I move approval of Ordinance 2017-10.
1:48:57 Second.
1:48:58 Motion by Suzanne Hawkins, seconded by Nikki Boyd
1:49:01 to approve Ordinance 2017-10.
1:49:05 Is there any discussion?
1:49:08 Roll call, vote please, sharing.
1:49:10 Christopher Reed.
1:49:11 Yes.
1:49:12 Ruth Pierce.
1:49:12 Yes.
1:49:13 Suzanne Hawkins.
1:49:14 Yes.
1:49:15 Nikki Boyd.
1:49:16 Yes.
1:49:16 Sean Beriker.
1:49:17 Yes.
1:49:18 Chris Tockington.
1:49:19 Yes.
1:49:19 Greg Lanting.
1:49:20 Yes.
1:49:22 Motion passes.
1:49:23 7-0. Next we have a presentation on the Twin Falls Urban Renewal Agency Main
1:49:30 Avenue Redevelopment Project. We have Paul Johnson with CH2M. Welcome Paul.
1:49:36 Thank you Mr. Mayor and members of the council. I was asked again my name is Paul
1:49:45 Johnson and I'm the owners representative for the Urban Renewal Agency on the main
1:49:49 avenue project. We have I think an exciting update for you tonight I was asked to
1:49:54 to give the same update that we presented to the Urban Renewal Agency.
1:49:59 The bottom line is the project is just under budget and on schedule so far.
1:50:06 That's exciting.
1:50:07 All right.
1:50:08 Do I have three minutes?
1:50:09 Presentation complete.
1:50:10 I'll keep it very brief.
1:50:16 This picture on the cover of the monthly report is from the March 24th pre-bid conference.
1:50:23 There were one of three walkthroughs with large groups of contractors interested in bidding
1:50:27 the project.
1:50:28 Guho construction had arranged that.
1:50:32 Again, they are construction manager, general contractor managing the project.
1:50:42 This is a summary.
1:50:44 As we talked the last time, there was the landscape removal contract of $56,538, about $9,500 of
1:50:52 that is being turned back into the URA from savings on that landscape removal that took
1:50:57 Place in February.
1:50:59 Item two, we went to the URA board last week with a request
1:51:04 for the overall amendment for the guaranteed maximum price
1:51:07 on the project after assembling all the bids
1:51:11 from the various subcontractors.
1:51:14 Most of them from Twin Falls.
1:51:15 Most of the awards are going to Twin Falls subcontractors.
1:51:18 I think there's just one from away from the area,
1:51:21 all the rest are from Twin Falls.
1:51:23 That totaled $6,389,570.
1:51:30 So when we add the two together, the total GMP, shown in item three,
1:51:35 is $6,446,115.
1:51:40 And that is about $54,000 under our budget.
1:51:45 Tomorrow at the groundbreaking, at 12.30 PM at Columbia Bank, no doubt,
1:51:50 There will be representatives from the URA in the city talking about the value of the project.
1:51:55 We like to talk in engineering terms about cost to worth ratios or cost to value.
1:52:00 The value will be tremendous, obviously.
1:52:02 I don't want to steal anyone's thunder much greater than the $6.5 million price tag for the project.
1:52:09 My part, our part as a team was to bring the project in within the $6.5 million budget.
1:52:15 And we believe that we've done that.
1:52:17 The earlier estimates by Guho were 6,446,000 and by OTAC, the design firm, 6,493,000.
1:52:27 So we were within 4-1,000 of a percent of Guho's prediction and within three-quarters of 1% of
1:52:36 OTAC's prediction.
1:52:37 So those are really good numbers.
1:52:39 In addition to that, we've afforded some additional scope within the $6.5 million budget.
1:52:48 We have several fire hydrants that will be included on main avenue.
1:52:52 The others are on the seconds, but it will be a safer street in the future.
1:52:56 With new fire hydrants on main avenue, in addition to everything else with the streetscapes and
1:53:00 the brick sidewalks, we'll have cast aluminum white poles instead of the cheaper fiberglass
1:53:06 light poles.
1:53:07 So we were able to afford that within the budget.
1:53:10 And the storm drain system is upgraded, so it will handle more storm flows.
1:53:15 There are other projects downstream outside of the project area that will need to be improved
1:53:19 in the future, but Main Avenue will have a more comprehensive storm bearing system to
1:53:25 handle storm events.
1:53:26 So that's some additional good news afforded within the budget.
1:53:30 The rest of this is just how the GMP was assembled by Guho, and it all came in within the budget.
1:53:39 They have every intention of returning any savings back to the owner.
1:53:44 At the end of the project, there's a 5% contingency held within that $6.5 million.
1:53:50 If it's not tapped into, or if we take only a little bit, the rest of it will be made available for other URA projects.
1:54:01 Just a quick note on schedule.
1:54:03 I'm sorry, Suzanne Hopkins had a question.
1:54:06 Sorry.
1:54:07 Do you know how if you were able to find a way to incorporate flagpole holders in all of that as well?
1:54:13 We talked about that last time, but sure.
1:54:15 You might have an update on that just right after this point.
1:54:18 I won't get ahead of you.
1:54:19 Thank you.
1:54:20 So, we're right on schedule, ground breaking tomorrow at 1230 p.m. at Columbia Bank and
1:54:27 that will be right after the state of the city presentation that I understand is at 1130
1:54:31 a.m. at the Orpheum Theatre.
1:54:36 Construction will begin or actually demolition will begin in area one as you see from good
1:54:42 getting to Shoshone, and that will take place beginning April 17th.
1:54:47 So each block will take about two months to rebuild, and there will be an overlap of about
1:54:52 one month per block.
1:54:54 So we anticipate substantial completion of the project on October 31st, 2017, right on
1:55:01 schedule.
1:55:07 Now to the point about the flags.
1:55:10 Excuse me, Paul.
1:55:11 And all businesses and the respective blocks know when their time of maximum discomfort
1:55:17 going to be.
1:55:18 They've been generally informed and they will be informed specifically on a block-by-block
1:55:26 basis.
1:55:27 Rob Klanninger is the superintendent and he's already spending time with the businesses
1:55:31 on the first block to talk to each of the merchants so they understand what's coming
1:55:35 up with the sequencing of the project.
1:55:39 There will be a lot of disruption on a block-by-block basis, however the businesses will remain open.
1:55:45 The accesses will be both from the alley entrances
1:55:50 where the parking lots are mostly along the seconds.
1:55:54 And then also in front of the businesses
1:55:56 all through construction, we'll have compacted gravel
1:55:58 lanes leading to the front doors of each of the businesses.
1:56:02 So Rob will be working out the details
1:56:05 with each of the business owners
1:56:07 well in advance of construction
1:56:09 so they understand what's coming up.
1:56:11 I have a couple of other comments that I can see your question, Chris.
1:56:17 Zanna Hawkins?
1:56:18 Thank you.
1:56:19 Kind of a follow up to that.
1:56:21 Last week we heard from one of our business owners that so many construction vehicles are
1:56:26 parking in those back parking lots and near the alleys that it's basically closing the
1:56:31 alley entrances now and as we start working through this, that was a concern.
1:56:35 Do we have a plan for where construction workers can park and stay out of the way of
1:56:40 We do their vehicles that are there now are for probably the alleyway utility project, which is fairly limited in duration, just the utilities that are necessary to serve the remodeled city hall are being done now.
1:56:57 And then of course the city hall project itself, which is separate from the project that I'm talking about.
1:57:05 The Guho has arranged, we've leased space right nearby
1:57:09 for construction trailers and for the contractors to parks.
1:57:14 We will not be taking up any parking spaces for the public.
1:57:18 And if any of the construction crews violate that,
1:57:22 then they'll be reminded and asked to move their vehicles.
1:57:24 Guho will be right on top of that.
1:57:26 Thank you very much.
1:57:27 Ruth Bierst.
1:57:28 So, Chris, I wanted to mention that Nate discussed
1:57:32 that he actually personally visited every business on Main Street and talked to them about the
1:57:39 schedule. So there actually has been some reach out, but I know they're going to do some more.
1:57:44 And I think that first block is be kind of kick everything up and all the other blocks if they've
1:57:51 had their head in the sand they will no longer have their head in the sand. Yeah, a little bit overkill,
1:57:57 but we want to make sure.
1:58:01 Okay, with regard to the flag display tradition,
1:58:06 the Lions Club pictured here as Mr. Mervin Mueller
1:58:10 of the Monarch Twin Falls Lions Club.
1:58:13 They've had a tradition of displaying the flags
1:58:15 on eight holidays per year in front of participating businesses.
1:58:20 Those holidays have included Martin Luther King Day,
1:58:23 President's Day, Memorial Day, Flag Day on June 14th,
1:58:27 Independence Day, Labor Day, Columbus Day, and Veterans Day.
1:58:32 So businesses who wish to participate pay a nominal fee of $35 per year.
1:58:38 All of that money goes to the Lions Club and they give all of that money, 100% of it, to
1:58:44 provide eyeglasses to people who can't otherwise afford eyeglasses.
1:58:50 At our company CH2M, we think that's a very honorable program and a tradition that we'd
1:58:55 like to see continue. So I check with our office manager and we're willing to pay for
1:59:01 the sleeves that would go in the sidewalks to continue the tradition in front of the businesses.
1:59:08 This is one example in front of a business on main avenue. The flags, the poles are about
1:59:16 10 feet tall. It was a windy day so we have a great display of the flag and again the
1:59:24 Lions Club takes care of this not only for main avenue but for other areas of downtown.
1:59:30 And the Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts also continue the tradition around other areas of Twin Falls.
1:59:36 So the question right now is, it's a technical one of where will the sleeves go?
1:59:42 Because we have about 26 businesses who participate, dozens more who could, so do we put sleeves in front of every business?
1:59:49 we make it so that it's not a tripping hazard or unsightly in some way, so we're trying
1:59:54 to work those details out right now with the design team and the construction team.
1:59:59 And then at a meeting, a month from now, we'll present options for the URA Board's consideration,
2:00:06 and then if you like, I'll come back and give you their suggestion on how we can handle
2:00:11 that.
2:00:12 There's been a suggestion of having flags in limited areas, and businesses contribute
2:00:16 to that.
2:00:17 There's been a suggestion of only having flags in front of the participating businesses, and
2:00:23 there's also a suggestion that they be potentially in front of every business.
2:00:26 So we need to get that figured out because construction is starting later this month.
2:00:30 But what I'd like to request of City Council this evening, and
2:00:35 what we ask the URA Board is just for consensus that we should continue to pursue the technical
2:00:42 options so that we don't have to have lines club drilling holes and the sidewalks later
2:00:47 on we take care of it in advance.
2:00:49 So is this a tradition that you would like to see continue?
2:00:53 Thank you.
2:00:54 And I think it's very generous of you to offer the sleeves.
2:00:56 Thank you.
2:00:57 Thank you.
2:00:58 So I would take that as general consensus head nodding amongst the council.
2:01:02 How could you go against the Merck and the Germans?
2:01:05 Exactly.
2:01:06 If only you would have had a Boy Scout request.
2:01:11 Okay.
2:01:12 Thank you.
2:01:14 Next is a presentation on the revised enforcement response plan associated with the pretreatment
2:01:24 program that is to be submitted to the Environmental Protection Agency for review and approval.
2:01:28 We have Jason Brown.
2:01:29 Welcome to Jason.
2:01:30 Glad it's a glamorous title.
2:01:31 Mr. Mayor and Council members, appreciate the opportunity to speak with you tonight.
2:01:37 Before I get started, I'd been asked to talk about an award that the engineering group got
2:01:45 an engineering and excellent award for the Clickbar Pre-Treatment Facility. I was able to go accept
2:01:50 that today at the conference up in Boise on behalf of the URA and Twin Falls staff along
2:01:57 with our design firm for that. So that was an opportunity that was good to show our involvement
2:02:03 in a project with our community partners. So the enforcement response plan is the document
2:02:10 which helps us, guides us in enforcing the federal
2:02:15 and the city pretreatment standards here
2:02:18 with our industrial partners.
2:02:20 And so what the last time that we had actually revised
2:02:24 the ERP was about 20 years ago.
2:02:27 And so as things have changed
2:02:29 and through some conversation discussion
2:02:31 with the Environmental Protection Agency,
2:02:33 we've chosen to go through and revise this document.
2:02:36 It helps us and guides us in how we interact with our industrial partners here in town.
2:02:44 So it's a requirement of the pre-treatment standards as an accepted pre-treatment program
2:02:51 which the City of Twin Falls has.
2:02:53 We have to provide this document to the EPA for their review and approval of that.
2:02:59 So we're coming here to the Council tonight to present this, get any feedback and comments
2:03:04 from you with the final and then at a later date come back after the EPA has reviewed that
2:03:11 and get your approval for the overall program.
2:03:15 And so tonight I've asked CH2M, they're the under contract to operate our pretreatment facility
2:03:21 and they're really the ones that have put the effort into this document and the effort
2:03:26 into this presentation.
2:03:28 So I've asked our pretreatment coordinator Lance Nelson to come and present this to you
2:03:34 And then any questions will be answered by committee if needs be.
2:03:39 So I'll go ahead and turn the time over to Lance and we'll start with the presentation.
2:03:44 Thank you, Jason.
2:03:51 Good evening.
2:03:52 I'm Lance Nielsen.
2:03:53 Welcome.
2:03:54 With CH2M.
2:03:55 And we have a presentation with PowerPoint and hopefully it will work.
2:03:58 It just went to sleep.
2:04:27 Sorry.
2:04:29 I appreciate it.
2:04:34 It's my hot chocolate.
2:04:37 Oh, you just need to share.
2:04:42 Can you flip the switch?
2:04:58 There we go.
2:04:59 Thank you.
2:05:11 Tonight, we're going to talk about the enforcement response plan and the new surcharge program
2:05:15 that we hope to implement.
2:05:26 So what the enforcement plan is, like Jason mentioned, is just outlines what the pretreatment
2:05:31 personnel can do given a certain situation such as violations.
2:05:39 do we need it? It is required by the EPA. It falls under the Clean Water Act and 40 CFR
2:05:46 403. So this is our current enforcement response plan. Like Jason said, it hasn't been updated
2:05:57 since our last 20 years. This is the first revision of it. The issue that we have with
2:06:02 it now is that the wording of it is confusing and it doesn't allow for a lot of wiggle room
2:06:09 for us to work with our industries in the area.
2:06:17 So with our current enforcement response plan,
2:06:19 it has an enforcement guidance.
2:06:21 So when a violation occurs,
2:06:23 the industrial pretreatment coordinator is aware of it.
2:06:26 He or she is able to make or determine the action
2:06:32 that needs to happen with it.
2:06:34 If it can just happen with an informal notification,
2:06:38 they can just go ahead and do that and document it.
2:06:41 Other cases is that they have to compile that information
2:06:44 and then send enforcement action to the control authority, which in this case is the City of
2:06:51 Twin Falls.
2:06:52 Once the City of Twin Falls decides what they want to do, they implement the enforcement action.
2:07:02 So what we did, we took last, or the information from the last six years and compiled it into
2:07:06 this graph from October 2010 to September 2016.
2:07:11 We had 1,329 violations, both major and minor violations.
2:07:20 With this, this amount, 80% of them came from only two categories.
2:07:26 When the EPA sees this amount, they freak out a little bit.
2:07:30 Okay, what's wrong with windfallers, are they not caring or what's wrong?
2:07:35 So we are hoping to continue on or to improve the amount of violations.
2:07:46 that are reported and hopefully reduce the amount
2:07:49 with our new enforcement response plan and search
2:07:53 our program.
2:07:55 So the modifications that we are making to the enforcement plan?
2:08:00 So I'm going to interrupt you real quick,
2:08:01 because I'm just going to go back to the DOD
2:08:04 and the suspended solids.
2:08:06 Why is EPA so surprised when we do food processing?
2:08:10 Are they not a major contributor to the early area
2:08:13 of food processing plants?
2:08:15 I mean, are we that much of an anomaly in the enforcement?
2:08:19 Well, the reason that we are so high
2:08:21 is because how often we test, how often we sample.
2:08:24 Law of areas, they only sample one, two times a month,
2:08:29 or more in some cases.
2:08:31 OK.
2:08:33 That's the reason why we're so high,
2:08:35 even if we do have the food industry here.
2:08:39 Thank you.
2:08:44 So like I was saying, the modification we're making
2:08:46 is relating to the structure and duties.
2:08:49 Control Authority will still be able to review the samples, identify discharge violations.
2:08:58 They compile the enforcement actions and then send the notifications off to the industry
2:09:04 that has that violation.
2:09:06 We are hoping to improve communication with this new enforcement response plan to make
2:09:12 life better for City of Twin Falls and the industries themselves.
2:09:17 Once the control authority hears back from the industries, then they can decide do we need
2:09:22 to meet with them to decide the proper course of action, or are we okay?
2:09:29 Another one size done, we can review the history of the industry.
2:09:34 We know our industries pretty well here in Twin and how they operate and how willing they
2:09:38 are to change.
2:09:41 And then once we get a good baseline, we can decide what violations or what enforcement
2:09:47 action we need to take? Yes, Suzanne Hopkins. Sorry, before you get on, and I
2:09:57 apologize if I misunderstood or missed what you were saying, this is what we're
2:10:01 going to now, so what have we been doing before that's different than this, if these
2:10:06 are the changes? Sorry. No, that's perfectly fine. So what we currently do is we have a
2:10:13 major minor violation situation, and in our current realm we don't have a lot of
2:10:21 flexibility, and we haven't really specified exactly how we're going to handle some of
2:10:26 those issues and instances where a greater area, if that's the way I can put it.
2:10:33 And so what we've chosen to do is to classify them a little bit more distinctly, and so
2:10:42 that's what these levels have gone to.
2:10:44 So we want to make sure that we have much more front end communication with our industries
2:10:49 than what we've had in the past.
2:10:51 And so this allows us to be able to talk to them,
2:10:55 understand what the situations are,
2:10:59 what's happening in their facilities,
2:11:01 more so than what we have now.
2:11:03 It really, if you go over your permit limit now,
2:11:08 we really don't have a choice to work with you.
2:11:10 It is what it is.
2:11:12 And we're trying to get away from that at the EPA's request.
2:11:16 As you can see back to Councilman Tockington's comment before was we sample our industries
2:11:25 every day.
2:11:26 We have a huge understanding, a big understanding of what our industries do to our treatment facility
2:11:36 where other communities, they sample a little less frequently than we do and even oftentimes
2:11:42 the industries are required to sample themselves.
2:11:45 And so we understand, and it's inherent in our program, that we're probably going to have
2:11:50 more violations in our current program, and we're trying to get away from having to report
2:12:00 though the instances that we don't even see their minute blip in the radar.
2:12:08 And so that's really what we're trying to do.
2:12:10 And the EPA has encouraged us to go this way, that we are able to have a little bit more flexibility with our industries under the new program, where we don't have under the program.
2:12:23 Did that answer?
2:12:25 Yeah, I think so.
2:12:27 Okay.
2:12:29 Yep.
2:12:30 Uh oh.
2:12:31 Getting the big guns now.
2:12:33 Answer by committee.
2:12:35 Sean knows I won't let him go without speaking.
2:12:37 Thank you, Mayor Council, to be able to address this.
2:12:41 Kind of one of the things, hopefully that explains it a little bit different, is in the permits
2:12:46 that the industries have, they have limits for each item, so they have limits for B of
2:12:50 D, for TSS, for flow.
2:12:53 And in the old enforcement response plan, if they went over those, any amount, that caused
2:13:00 us to give them a notice of violation.
2:13:02 And that's going to be one of the big drastic changes in this, is that working with EPA and
2:13:06 re-looking at this, those are able to be changed to what is more of a surcharge instead
2:13:11 of a notice of violation, and that will actually bring that down.
2:13:15 And as they mentioned before, I think the difference is when you're sampling that many
2:13:19 times, it gives you that many more opportunities to have those kind of violations where they
2:13:24 can exceed it.
2:13:25 And there's some industries that have very, very small amounts that they can discharge,
2:13:29 say, 25 pounds a day.
2:13:31 So a tiny little bit that they may be over going down as violations that we're adding
2:13:36 towards this and causing that issue.
2:13:38 And so as we've been talking with the EPA and they have
2:13:42 given us kind of this guidance of here's an option
2:13:44 that you may look at.
2:13:46 I think that benefits the industries where it doesn't look
2:13:49 like black marks constantly, but it also gives another way
2:13:52 of still holding them to those limits that they have,
2:13:57 which is basically kind of a capacity of the treatment plan
2:14:00 so that they're just not going above that.
2:14:03 Does that make sense hopefully?
2:14:04 Okay.
2:14:05 That's why I brought them.
2:14:09 So we broke it down to three levels of notification.
2:14:17 So level one, it's kind of an area that will be mostly in.
2:14:21 It will just be a corrective notice, an informal notice.
2:14:25 Just, hey, an email saying you're over, limit what's going on, etc.
2:14:31 Level two is a little bit more severe than that.
2:14:34 We would put them into S and C or significant non-compliance status.
2:14:39 SNC status has its own federal requirements.
2:14:43 If an industry, for example, discharges something that passes through
2:14:47 the wastewater facility and into the environment,
2:14:55 then that would violate their permit, our permit,
2:14:59 and it would be bad all the way around it. So that would put them to an SNC status.
2:15:04 With that would increase fines and compliance schedule.
2:15:08 And then there's level three, which is the most severe of all three levels.
2:15:13 We never want to be in there, so they would result in termination,
2:15:19 service suspension, things of that nature.
2:15:26 Chris Reed.
2:15:27 So with the historical data that you currently have in place, where would most of those fall?
2:15:33 They would most of them would fall on the level one, or even before that just as Sean mentioned,
2:15:41 that they're just little blips that we don't even see them.
2:15:44 So they wouldn't even fall on one of these levels.
2:15:51 So the new enforcement response plan, the control authority
2:15:57 can identify and verify the non-compliance events,
2:16:01 evaluate for the significant non-compliance
2:16:04 as federal regulations demand, and then they can decide,
2:16:11 and then they send out the notice to the industries
2:16:13 and wait for a response back from them.
2:16:17 When with that, the control authority has an option
2:16:19 of either continuing on to escalated enforcement
2:16:23 or to decide not to further go after the enforcement action.
2:16:31 In all circumstances, documentation does happen.
2:16:38 So this slide goes in more detail of the last one,
2:16:43 just to iterate everything.
2:16:44 Again, compliance authority, we'll see it,
2:16:47 they'll send off the notification,
2:16:50 and then based on the reply,
2:16:52 they'll determine the correct enforcement's action.
2:16:59 So seeing how these three levels work,
2:17:03 this is a table taken from the actual document
2:17:05 of the enforcement response plan.
2:17:09 On the left is just the type of compliance,
2:17:13 and then middle is the specific nature of the violation
2:17:15 of what happens, and then the enforcement response,
2:17:18 what level it could correspond with.
2:17:25 So then we get into our new surcharge program
2:17:27 that we want to get into to help reduce
2:17:34 the amount of violations that we are getting.
2:17:37 So the surcharge program will have two limits.
2:17:39 A surcharge limit or threshold and a compliance limit.
2:17:43 So the surcharge threshold will be at a specific limit,
2:17:49 which is their permit times 1.4, their permit limit,
2:17:56 and then compliance is when they go over the 1.4 times
2:17:59 their permit.
2:18:00 So when they're going over, their permit plus 40% percent.
2:18:05 The surcharge will result in no violations
2:18:07 while the compliance limit does result in the violation.
2:18:18 So these are the rates that apply to the surcharge program.
2:18:23 The first column is just a simple one to 1.2 times their permit limit and 1.2, 1.4, their
2:18:30 surcharge limit for the next one and then their enforcement limit is when they go above
2:18:35 the compliance limit and each one of those has a corresponding rate that goes with it.
2:18:41 And then once they pass the 1.4 times the permit or the compliance limit, we are required
2:18:52 by federal regulations to implement administration fines.
2:18:58 So first day is 250, 500, second day, and so on and so forth until the fourth and so
2:19:06 on as a thousand.
2:19:08 And then also we talked about when they have consecutive days of surcharging, surcharging.
2:19:16 That should actually read four to five days, three to five.
2:19:20 But then it's fine as well.
2:19:21 And then when it's six or more consecutive days of surcharging, then they, it's a thousand
2:19:28 dollar fine.
2:19:29 Also, when there are six or more days,
2:19:32 they will be put into a significant non-compliance
2:19:35 because by then they know that they have a problem
2:19:38 and we can see it or feel it at the wastewater facility.
2:19:43 And did those fees go to the EPA or to?
2:19:48 No, those fees are put into,
2:19:51 I believe the general fund, is that correct, Lori?
2:19:54 Or wastewater?
2:19:55 In the wastewater fund.
2:19:56 So those are the funds that go to the city themselves or to ourselves, but it is required
2:20:04 by federal law that we actually have a graduating escalation of fines as well.
2:20:13 So that goes to the city.
2:20:15 Yeah, there's no appellate process on this.
2:20:19 So we, there is, and that was part of some of the front end communication.
2:20:25 If we've gotten to this point, we have some serious issues going on with the industries,
2:20:33 they're in a situation where they're violating constantly.
2:20:37 So the levels were really set up to help some of the front end communication and be able
2:20:42 to get out of this point.
2:20:45 And so that's where the communication part really comes in with the industries and working
2:20:51 with them, and we have, and you'll see from some examples later in the presentation, and
2:20:57 we have in the past, we've been able to work with our industries, and instead of us collecting
2:21:03 the money directly, we've asked them to put it back into their facility to help them resolve
2:21:10 the problem.
2:21:12 This is what we're trying to do is let them know, okay, we're following and implementing
2:21:16 the rules but if they're the way for us to help you not get to this point we're
2:21:21 willing able and wanting to do that so that's but yeah those those go to the
2:21:27 city thank you. Thanks Jason. So this graph is a comparison of the violations
2:21:35 that currently happen which are in purple and then the comparison of violations
2:21:40 that would have occurred if we would have had a surcharge program six years
2:21:45 ago, which is the grain. Comparing the two, there's a 60% reduction. This is a huge amount,
2:21:57 which makes everyone happy, makes us happy, makes the industries happy, because they don't
2:22:01 have to report their violations, and the EPA is happy in the end as well. So we have made
2:22:08 three different surcharge case studies to show you how this works. Out of the 13,000, or
2:22:19 of the roughly the 1,300 violations that did occur over the last six years, roughly 69%
2:22:28 of them fall into this example.
2:22:32 So this is just a minor permit exceedance.
2:22:36 They have a permit limit of 2,300.
2:22:38 They exceeded with the actual discharge of 29,000 roughly, or 2,900.
2:22:45 Under our current EAP enforcement response plan, it's about a $717 fine with a minor
2:22:51 violation. With our proposed surcharge it would be a $1,300 fine with no violation. The reason
2:23:00 for the increase in fines is one we are hoping to or excuse me we are encouraging our industries
2:23:06 to stick to the permits not to exceed them. Another one is when they discharge extra they
2:23:13 are taking an extra capacity at the facility so that could so that limits others as well.
2:23:24 This is a major permanent exceedance.
2:23:26 This occurred 30% of roughly 1,300 violations.
2:23:35 You can see the numbers again, 2,300 for a permit limit and almost a 4,000 for actual discharge.
2:23:41 This puts them over their compliance limit.
2:23:44 So it's roughly a $2,000 fine with a major violation.
2:23:48 Proposed surcharge is roughly 2,600 with a violation.
2:23:58 Bad days do happen.
2:23:59 Ooh, that's scary.
2:24:01 Don't worry, you happen out of the 1,300 violations
2:24:06 that we did see, this happened less than 1%.
2:24:10 So these are really, really rare locations.
2:24:15 So they violated all of their permits.
2:24:19 This would be a $28,000 fine under our current one
2:24:24 with the violation and proposed would be roughly a $79,000 fine
2:24:31 with a violation.
2:24:33 However, as Jason had mentioned earlier,
2:24:37 that sometimes we can talk to the industry themselves
2:24:40 and say, OK, you have this fine.
2:24:42 But what happened?
2:24:44 Did a machine break down or was there a lapse?
2:24:47 And so you can take part of the fine
2:24:50 and then put it into your own system,
2:24:54 trying to update certain machinery,
2:24:56 or training, or things of that nature.
2:25:01 Again, I just wanna express that this is a really rare occasion.
2:25:05 And if I can here as well, so we understand
2:25:09 that this, it's a large number,
2:25:12 but we also in this particular situation,
2:25:15 it's not an exact correlation to an event that happened
2:25:19 recently, but a very similar situation.
2:25:22 And we actually saw an impact down at the treatment plant
2:25:26 that really could have put us into a situation that
2:25:31 wasn't good for us.
2:25:32 We had a potential of seeing more TSS out of the back end
2:25:36 of our treatment plant.
2:25:38 With the upgrade to the treatment facility, the IFAST system
2:25:41 that we've done over the last couple years,
2:25:43 where we were able to manage this a little bit better.
2:25:47 And again, it is less than 1% and as Lance was saying,
2:25:51 We really, this one is not to go out and try to get money
2:25:56 from the industries.
2:25:58 These events really are caused by specific potential malfunctions
2:26:03 in industry pretreatment facilities or something
2:26:08 that happened inside the facility that then they could use
2:26:11 this money to go and fix.
2:26:13 And hopefully these events don't happen.
2:26:16 And so it is a scary number.
2:26:19 We had a lot of internal discussion about this number, but it is a situation and scenario
2:26:24 that can and has happened recently to us.
2:26:31 Chris Stockton.
2:26:32 Jason, this is a little bit off track.
2:26:33 We've been primarily addressing suspended solids and BOD, but with our settlement ponds,
2:26:40 which I think I'm correct, the primary purpose is to improve the water quality by further
2:26:45 a reminder removal of phosphorus before it percolates back into the water, through
2:26:50 the water table, into the snake. We have no process for receiving credits, out of boys,
2:26:58 anything positive for that. Is that my understanding? The EPA is so befuddled that they don't know
2:27:03 how to handle it.
2:27:05 It is the phosphorus issue is something that isn't in our current enforcement response
2:27:11 plan. The new enforcement response plan allows us to, if we get to that point with the EPA,
2:27:20 we actually have a meeting tomorrow with the EPA and the local water advisory group here
2:27:26 in town. Since some of our last meetings, there hasn't been a lot of updates. The EPA
2:27:31 wants to come back and present their presentation to a larger group of people. But under the
2:27:38 The current reality, there aren't opportunities for attaboys.
2:27:43 It looks like they're afraid to move out of their comfort zones, visiting for being a little
2:27:47 bit brushed on this, but they want to hold us accountable, rightfully so.
2:27:52 But our upgrade in our water system, we're providing almost tertiary quality water to
2:27:57 the Snake River.
2:27:59 The phosphorous is just another addition that through our innovation, our cost to the taxpayers,
2:28:06 providing additional water quality, it just seems that they are only interested in looking
2:28:14 at the negative.
2:28:16 And through our conversations with the EPA, we have tried to point out just that in the
2:28:22 sense of, hey, we have tried to implement newer technology, technology that helps us and the
2:28:30 water body itself, the Snake River, improve.
2:28:34 So that has been a sounding board for us from the city
2:28:39 and city staff in those conversations that we have tried.
2:28:43 And we are on the forefront, trying to move forward
2:28:46 for better water quality.
2:28:49 I appreciate that.
2:28:50 I'm sure I'd like to be kept in the loop
2:28:52 on how that discussion goes.
2:28:53 We'll have that conversation tomorrow
2:28:56 and then update as needed through that.
2:29:00 But and we feel that this program, it was time to look at the enforcement response plan
2:29:08 because time had changed.
2:29:09 The regulatory environment had changed in such a way that we want to continue to improve
2:29:16 our relationship with our industries, but also improve our water quality.
2:29:20 We have the benefit of having the upgrades to the treatment plan, our treatment plan.
2:29:25 We have some flexibility there and we really believe that this.
2:29:29 We're on the right path of what we're doing, and then also the EPA has really encouraged
2:29:35 us to look at changing our pretreatment program along this process.
2:29:43 The word violation obviously has a certain meaning in the environmental regulatory world
2:29:49 and any chance that we can get away from using that specific language we definitely are trying
2:29:57 to get there.
2:30:01 And I believe that is the end of the presentation.
2:30:05 So if there's any further comments or concerns or questions,
2:30:10 we would take those.
2:30:12 So a question I have is, so obviously you've
2:30:15 had these conversations with our industry partners.
2:30:18 We have.
2:30:19 And their understanding of the process.
2:30:25 Is supportive a good enough word?
2:30:27 They were.
2:30:27 Actually, they were very supportive of, let's see, two weeks
2:30:31 ago we had a meeting with roughly four of the industrial partners and then last week
2:30:37 on Wednesday we had the remaining remainder except for one was unable to attend.
2:30:42 We've sent the documentation to all of the industrial users.
2:30:46 There were good comments.
2:30:47 One of the eyebrows that was raised was on that last surcharging slide, obviously that
2:30:53 is, we are aware that that is a large sum of money and so we went back through our documentation
2:30:59 to look, is there an ability to be a little bit more flexible in those types of situations?
2:31:05 And so we looked back through the document and we believe that it gives us the flexibility
2:31:10 to work with the industries to not accept that money in-house, but also go back.
2:31:16 Use it to correct the problem.
2:31:18 Use to correct the problem.
2:31:19 And we've done that since I've been with the city, and I know we've done that before
2:31:23 I came to the city, and so this helps us document that process.
2:31:28 they were supportive because violations internally to them caused them some issues as well.
2:31:35 And so again that word of violation really holds a specific meaning inside the environmental
2:31:42 regulatory world.
2:31:44 So.
2:31:45 Thank you.
2:31:47 Any other comments or questions from the council?
2:31:53 I think we all have a very thorough understanding of all that.
2:31:57 That's never been.
2:31:59 Yeah, it, you know, these processes actually help you gain a lot more information and understand
2:32:05 the program a little bit more.
2:32:07 But so the next step for us really is to submit this for comments to the EPA.
2:32:13 They have the opportunity to then, you know, comment on that.
2:32:16 If we don't receive comments for 90 days from them, then by a lie, they've basically approved
2:32:23 the changes.
2:32:24 I imagine we'll have some comments and we'll go back and forth and then at a later date
2:32:30 come back and give an update and then an approval for that specific adoption of the new enforcement
2:32:37 response.
2:32:38 Great.
2:32:39 Thank you.
2:32:41 Thank you.
2:32:46 Next is a presentation of an update on the winter road damage and request to use street
2:32:52 reserves to repair a portion of the winter road damage.
2:32:55 We have John Caden, public work director.
2:32:58 Good evening.
2:32:59 Thank you, Mayor and Council, one second here.
2:33:32 Okay, thank you.
2:33:34 Tonight I asked the Street Superintendent,
2:33:37 the Street Supervisor to be here tonight.
2:33:39 Mark Thompson and the Street Supervisor
2:33:41 is gonna give the beginning part of this report.
2:33:44 And really our point tonight is to give you an update
2:33:46 on what the winner, we all know we had a tough winner
2:33:48 when giving an update on the toll that took on the roads
2:33:52 and what we plan to do with it.
2:33:53 So with that, I'll let Mark go ahead and get started.
2:34:00 Mr. Mayor, members of the council, I appreciate you giving us the opportunity to come before
2:34:05 you tonight.
2:34:06 My part of this power point is kind of just the first two bullets.
2:34:14 Most of you have been a pretty good understanding of our zone maintenance program.
2:34:21 So I'm going to give you just another brief overview and then just a little refresher
2:34:27 on the pavement condition index, which we call PCI.
2:34:31 And then an existing pavement condition survey that we took from Trampap in the fall of 2015.
2:34:45 So what is our zone maintenance?
2:34:47 Zone maintenance is a preventative maintenance program to focus on utility maintenance, pavement
2:34:52 preservation and accessibility.
2:34:55 It accounts for 40% of our annual budget between street sewer and water.
2:35:02 We have eight individual zones that we've broken the city up into that they encompass
2:35:10 78 lane miles and each year we focus all our efforts in that one zone and we may not
2:35:18 focus, the streets may not focus in one area, water may focus in another area.
2:35:26 We prefer to have water out in front of us because it's easier for them to get underground
2:35:32 utilities done before we come and then
2:35:34 save over the top of it.
2:35:36 So our zone maintenance goals, our
2:35:42 very top goal in our zone maintenance program
2:35:46 is to preserve our roadways and our infrastructure
2:35:50 to provide a safe accessible community for our citizens.
2:35:54 It allows the public works and engineering to collaborate
2:35:58 our projects and we can sequence the work
2:36:02 efficiently and we can coordinate the planning a little bit easier. We can perform the underground
2:36:12 maintenance prior to our surface repairs. We can do the proper surface treatment over
2:36:23 an entire zone. One of our other goals is to overlay one lane mile. Between overlays
2:36:31 and millinen lace. We try and replace one mile of sewer and water main and then we follow
2:36:39 in behind our seal coat with the sewer manhole rehabilitation which is most of you know Mr.
2:36:45 Manhole.
2:36:46 Mr. Manhole.
2:36:47 Mr. Manhole.
2:36:48 Yeah.
2:36:49 So, and then we try and after an overlay, we try and go back at least a year later and do
2:36:56 some type of surface treatment on that overlay.
2:37:01 This just kind of shows our zone 5 seal coat that we will be starting this summer.
2:37:12 And this shows the different surface treatments that we're going to be doing in different
2:37:16 areas.
2:37:17 It lists the chip seal, slurry seal, and bog seal.
2:37:25 And then when we talk about pavement condition index, it's a scale of 0 to 100.
2:37:31 Our brand new road is basically 100.
2:37:36 Anything once you start dropping off the scale, the lower the number goes, the less your pavement
2:37:42 is going to survive.
2:37:43 So anything below 20 is basically in very poor condition.
2:37:49 Zero is completely failed.
2:37:51 And all of these distresses are how we come up with pavement condition index.
2:38:00 Each different distress is measured and then a certain number is given to those and then
2:38:08 it takes an average of all those numbers, I was going to throw in the formula, but I
2:38:12 couldn't even understand the majority of it. The computer does the most of it. So all
2:38:19 these different distresses go into forming our pavement condition index. These are just
2:38:28 examples of some rutting. These are pretty high severity ruts. And if you look by his
2:38:34 right foot, you can also see where the pavement has actually started to shove into that other
2:38:39 wheel track. The picture on the right is what we don't want. We don't want
2:38:44 ruts filled with water. Eventually those are going to fail. This just shows some
2:38:51 different severities of block cracking. Block cracking is usually climate related.
2:38:56 On the left is some pretty high severity block cracking. The one on the
2:39:02 right is low to medium and when we do a pavement survey the if those lines don't
2:39:11 connect into blocks they have to be measured out individually so it's very
2:39:15 time-consuming when we do our surveys this one pretty much pretty easy one
2:39:25 figure out alligator cracking that's where your pothole is gonna be we've got a
2:39:29 few of those around town right now yeah that's a bad one so in the fall of
2:39:36 2015 we had a company named trans-map come in in two weeks they did
2:39:44 what we couldn't do in two years, they drove every city street and at the end of the, at
2:39:52 the end of their project they were able to give us a PCI number on every single street
2:39:57 in the city. So we can use this map now to help guide our surface treatments and where
2:40:06 we plan to do our work in the future. The picture on the left is from our Zone 2 fog
2:40:18 seal that particular street had a PCI number of 82 so we went with a lesser
2:40:26 treatment of pog seal pitcher on the right is from our zone three seal coat
2:40:31 which that piece of Washington had a PCI of 74 so we ended up doing a little
2:40:37 bit heavier treatment gone with the went with the seal coat this is where John
2:40:47 Thanks, Mark.
2:40:53 Just to add on to what Mark was talking about with the PCI, he can explain it in way better
2:41:01 detail because he's actually done it.
2:41:03 He actually gets out in the field and he's taken pavement condition measurements.
2:41:11 When he says measurements, he means that we actually go out and grab a sample, you count
2:41:15 the cracks, you measure the depth, you measure the width, all that.
2:41:18 you can imagine how long it takes.
2:41:20 You don't need to do 100% of the city.
2:41:22 You do need a representative sample,
2:41:24 but even doing a representative sample
2:41:25 takes a lot of effort.
2:41:27 And so when he said they drove it,
2:41:30 they used a LiDAR laser radar, a bunch of other stuff,
2:41:34 to drive it at the speed limit.
2:41:36 And they can pick up tens of thousands of data points
2:41:40 per second.
2:41:42 And the whole idea is to measure our existing life of pavement
2:41:47 existing life of pavement, which is what this slide's a little bit about.
2:41:55 So like Mark said, on the left hand side of this chart, we have pavement condition, 100
2:42:03 being brand new, zero being completely failed.
2:42:06 And then you got life in years, time, 0, 5, 10, 15, 20.
2:42:11 And this is specifically for asphalt pavement, which generally has a design life of 20 years.
2:42:18 And so I think I've showed this chart to you guys before, and none of you might be wondering
2:42:22 why am I showing you this?
2:42:24 I was teasing Mark.
2:42:26 I said this is probably the most important slide because I think it's what helped me convince
2:42:30 Lori to spend some money.
2:42:35 But really what we got going on here is this curve here describes the life.
2:42:43 If you don't do anything, any maintenance at all, this is what happens.
2:42:47 It'll just deteriorate over time.
2:42:49 And you can see that it holds its life pretty, pretty good.
2:42:52 And then it reaches what we call the critical PCI.
2:42:55 And it's the point of no return.
2:42:57 And right there, it turns into a general slope,
2:42:59 from a general slope into a steep cliff.
2:43:03 The whole idea is to, this was created
2:43:08 by the Army Corps of Engineers, the pavement preservation
2:43:11 philosophy.
2:43:12 And basically, for, I don't know how long, 50, 60 years,
2:43:16 The Army Corps of Engineers has basically revolutionized the pavement preservation program
2:43:23 through study.
2:43:24 It's all empirical.
2:43:25 You know, there's some theory, but a lot of it is tried and tested.
2:43:30 And basically what they've shown is that the smartest and best way to spend your money
2:43:37 is as shown.
2:43:39 As life starts to go away and you do a chip seal, let's say, or a fog seal or a slurry
2:43:46 seal.
2:43:47 You come to here and it's like a volleyball, you just got to keep the
2:43:53 volleyball up in the air so they explain it and basically the condition
2:43:56 improves from a seal coat, it deteriorates over time, you do another seal coat and
2:44:01 you can see it extends life. The thing is when you do surface treatment like
2:44:08 like fog, chip, slurry, if you want to do it before you hit your critical PCI.
2:44:18 Because here's the main reason.
2:44:21 For every dollar you spend up here, if you miss your critical PCI and you're down here,
2:44:27 you're starting to get into millen overlay or reconstruct, which can range anywhere from
2:44:33 $15 to 60, 60 times this amount here.
2:44:38 So we have, thanks to council's support,
2:44:43 what I would call a robust and good seal coat program,
2:44:49 going back to zone maintenance,
2:44:51 we're able to seal coat or provide a surface treatment,
2:44:54 I should say, for almost a hundred percent of every zone
2:44:57 as we go in.
2:44:58 So seal coat, I think we're pretty much there.
2:45:01 where we're lacking a little bit of fun,
2:45:04 but we've gotten better over time
2:45:05 as in the millen and light and reconstruct.
2:45:09 And now I can probably talk about what happened this winter.
2:45:12 First of all, actually, is there any questions
2:45:14 on this slide?
2:45:19 Exactly.
2:45:20 I don't see it prevented us worth a pound of cure.
2:45:23 Yes, yeah.
2:45:25 So I created, so every climate, every region,
2:45:31 is gonna have different experience.
2:45:33 This is our actual experience.
2:45:34 This is what we spent on our pavement rehabilitation.
2:45:38 So the first thing you see, I just
2:45:40 want to walk you through this chart.
2:45:41 So the first thing you see is fog seal, PCI condition.
2:45:44 So this is the pavement rehab type fog seal.
2:45:48 You're going to, it's pretty light, the stress.
2:45:51 It's fairly new pavement.
2:45:52 And what you're doing is you're rejuvenating the oil.
2:45:54 You're adding life to the oil.
2:45:56 And so your PCI scores will be pretty high.
2:45:59 You're going to add three to five years to that.
2:46:02 This is a unit cost.
2:46:03 And then I then I converted it to a life cycle cost and I converted it to one.
2:46:12 I'll just explain later.
2:46:13 So the next the next the theoretically though, John, every three to five years,
2:46:18 you could do that fog seal and bump it back up or another in that indefinitely.
2:46:24 Well, what happens actually, and it's not illustrating that picture very well,
2:46:27 is every time you bounce that volleyball up, it doesn't quite go as high.
2:46:31 Okay.
2:46:32 So it does, yeah, there's diminished return.
2:46:37 Okay, so the next level of slurry seal, again, you can see the PCI, you can go a little bit
2:46:41 worse roadway, you get a little bit more life.
2:46:45 Slurry seal is basically an oil with a small particle, like, what size are the particles
2:46:52 that you probably don't care?
2:46:57 small particles bigger than a molecule but smaller than a red box
2:47:04 so slurry is light though it's not the chip seal my point is it's not the chip
2:47:12 seal that that aggravates people you're gonna get five to eight years there's
2:47:17 enough cost chip seals a little bit more you get a decent amount of light out of
2:47:22 a chip seal. You can see, I want to spend a minute on this, we try not to put chip seal
2:47:31 just anywhere. We put it in arterios and collectors, places at high have higher, more robust traffic.
2:47:38 We try to avoid the bike lane. If a roadway has a bike lane on it, we either will leave
2:47:44 chip off or we'll maybe use a different surface treatment for the entire road. Harrison's
2:47:48 what I have in mind this past year.
2:47:51 And I just want to point out that you can see chip seal and slurry.
2:47:59 Why would we use chip over slurry?
2:48:02 It's because it's cost less.
2:48:03 You get more like that of it.
2:48:05 It is a better product.
2:48:07 It does cause complaints.
2:48:09 So there is a balance there.
2:48:10 So we're trying to balance that by not using it everywhere.
2:48:13 Overlay.
2:48:15 Overlay is when you, you know, we use that on mostly collectors
2:48:18 or greater, you're going to mill out some pavement and you're going to put back a couple
2:48:22 inches of plant mix. You get 10 to 15 years on that, that's probably 15 is pretty high,
2:48:31 it's probably 10 to 12. And I don't need to go through all these, but then reconstruct,
2:48:37 of course, you're going to have a really low PCI, you're going to get 20 years, extremely
2:48:41 expensive. And this last column is really the most important. So, VOG seal, you're going to
2:48:46 spend a dollar and here when we have to reconstruct, we're going to spend 34 times as much. So it's
2:48:53 really important for us to take care of our payment and keep investing it wisely and spend
2:49:02 it right here and let every dollar we can. Any questions on this?
2:49:06 Okay so now I'll just talk about what our experience was this winter and I know it's been a long
2:49:42 Council meeting. So I'll try to try to be brief here. What you see here is Mark
2:49:50 actually personally went out and he's inventory blowouts and so we've
2:49:56 experienced potholes which are going to be pretty small localized you know what
2:49:59 they are potholes and then these are not potholes these are bigger they're
2:50:04 blowouts we call them and basically what you got here is a freeze-thaw the
2:50:09 the process coming out of the ground.
2:50:10 In some cases, you saw the ground rise six to 12 inches
2:50:13 out of the ground, and the settles back down,
2:50:15 and there's absolutely nothing left of the pavement.
2:50:19 So there's over 40 locations that were significant blowouts.
2:50:33 You don't see, I don't think any potholes on here,
2:50:35 so this doesn't capture the whole picture,
2:50:37 but it captures parts that are the most significant damage.
2:50:43 So this year, Mark and Dane plan on dealing with the potholes within their existing budget.
2:50:50 And actually, some of these blowouts can be dealt with their existing budget.
2:50:56 But many of these can't be dealt with, and you see these long red lines,
2:51:01 these are larger construction projects, they're just total reconstructs.
2:51:05 Which leads us to our proposed project for this.
2:51:08 Yeah, that's an actual layout of those potholes that we kind of indicate we had
2:51:18 some designer construction deficiencies that have them loaded in that end of town
2:51:23 there northeast quadrant. Yeah, a lot of those are residential roads, some of them
2:51:34 are old county roads, so yeah, it was not surprised to see the failure. Okay, let me
2:51:42 back up before I get into projects, Dean's budget this year has been in fact, it is Ops
2:51:47 budget. And so this is a quick update. So he printed this update on March 7th and he's
2:51:54 showing how much he spent on overtime. So he budgets 18,000, he spent 15,600 as of March.
2:52:05 Snow ice control materials, only salt, liquid, de-icer. You can see he budgets 10, he spent
2:52:11 These are the big ones, there's other categories, but you can see he spent over half of his budget
2:52:19 by March.
2:52:20 Okay, so this project list is above and beyond those cones that you saw in that map, which I said, there's some on here, but some are not.
2:52:38 But these are the projects that we've gone through, and we've prioritized.
2:52:42 that we've gone through and we've prioritized.
2:52:44 It doesn't get every single, everything.
2:52:46 But the way I have these divided is the top one, two, three,
2:52:51 four are complete reconstructs.
2:52:55 The next grouping is a mill in inlay.
2:52:59 And I added a contingency to those for each of 15%.
2:53:07 And so the rebuild cost is $2 million.
2:53:10 The millenin inlay cost is $2.3 million, total $4.375 million.
2:53:18 I do need to talk to you about this workload.
2:53:20 This is a big workload, unanticipated workload,
2:53:24 contractors, all over the state are scrambling to do this.
2:53:28 There's a lot of Fs, you know.
2:53:31 First of all, if you guys approve the dollars to be funded,
2:53:36 we have to, in some cases, design the projects.
2:53:39 Some of them don't require very much design,
2:53:41 they just require a public bidding.
2:53:44 But there is a process where an engineer will be involved.
2:53:47 I have collaborated with engineering,
2:53:49 they're ready to support whatever we can get done this summer.
2:53:53 I won't be surprised if because of schedule, conflict,
2:53:59 or contractor availability that we don't get everything done
2:54:02 on this list.
2:54:03 But these are our priorities.
2:54:06 And there actually are two more projects.
2:54:09 I put on here, if you remember, last year, we came back and asked to mill it in the rest
2:54:13 of the falls from Washington to Lulex, and in order to do that, we needed to do the south
2:54:21 side of 88 ramps.
2:54:22 We just have to do that, so I plugged in with a number there.
2:54:27 As an example, each one of these projects is going to have an unknown.
2:54:32 That one, this falls down to 88 ramps, when we get out there and we start sizing the scope
2:54:37 of every single EDA ramp, it might include aprons,
2:54:41 it could include valley gutters, wherever best we,
2:54:45 you know, engineering uses their judgment.
2:54:46 If we can salvage a component, we will, it minimizes cost.
2:54:51 When it's not appropriate to salvage something,
2:54:53 that's already, you know, it's gone, we won't do it.
2:54:56 So I expect that there's going to be some unknowns
2:54:59 in each one of these categories.
2:55:01 That's why I've added 15% contingency.
2:55:05 John Suzanne, if Hawkins has a comment or question.
2:55:08 Hi, John.
2:55:09 So last year when we were talking about Frontier Road,
2:55:13 where it connects to Falls Avenue by the fire station,
2:55:17 I thought we learned that that road belongs to CSI and not
2:55:21 the city.
2:55:23 We have Frontier on here.
2:55:25 You see that?
2:55:25 It's a big number.
2:55:27 And I actually have, I'm glad you asked.
2:55:31 I actually have the maintenance agreement.
2:55:33 And it looks like we have maintenance.
2:55:35 But I do want to, before we spend 800,000,
2:55:38 I wanted that aspirates to give a formal opinion on that.
2:55:42 And he hasn't had a chance to do that yet.
2:55:44 OK.
2:55:48 Thank you.
2:55:51 It's a little one, but that's C3 parking lot.
2:55:53 Are you sure we have to put a penny into that dang thing?
2:55:57 We may be getting rid of that.
2:56:00 I see heads nodding.
2:56:01 OK.
2:56:02 It's ours and not the URAs.
2:56:04 I thought that belonged to the URA.
2:56:12 Jackie Sam, for maintenance purposes.
2:56:13 It's ours.
2:56:20 So the deferred projects on there?
2:56:23 Yeah.
2:56:24 Did you want to address those?
2:56:26 Sorry.
2:56:28 Yeah, OK.
2:56:28 Thank you.
2:56:30 Getting ahead of myself.
2:56:31 So on these deferred projects, we know we have an issue with Locust,
2:56:36 and we know we have issues with Major O'Nann Addison.
2:56:40 Because they either are arterials or behave like a major collector,
2:56:45 they're going to require a significant design right now.
2:56:49 Engineering Jackie has a contract.
2:56:51 It was in place before this winter
2:56:53 to do a material study of locusts, so we can size that job.
2:57:00 So what I wanted to point out here
2:57:01 is that all these projects we prioritize,
2:57:05 they don't get all of our backlog, obviously.
2:57:08 These are big projects that need to happen.
2:57:10 And we have problems on them right now.
2:57:12 So you're going to see some spot repairs on Madrona Addison
2:57:15 and Locust.
2:57:16 Dean's going to have to work his magic.
2:57:18 Dean and Mark are going to have to work his magic on those streets, meaning they're going
2:57:22 to have to zip and end when they have failures and just end them through it until we can one
2:57:28 find fun and then two get it designed.
2:57:37 Okay, so project requirements.
2:57:41 Obviously when it comes to reserves you can't, I mean there's no more, there's no more to,
2:57:45 I can't exceed budget in this, in this, for this project and I'm not worried about exceeding
2:57:53 I talk to you about unknowns, we have contingency, but also we're going to phase the projects
2:57:58 in a way that we spend, I mean we're going to construct as we go and if we get close to
2:58:04 the budget limit, we just stop letting contracts, so that is zero concern to me.
2:58:10 Again, we need to be mindful of pavement preservation philosophy, we need to invest correctly.
2:58:19 We'll be doing thorough preliminary engineering to identify it as many as unknowns as possible.
2:58:24 Again, we'll be constructing in phases and that's really it.
2:58:29 That's it.
2:58:33 You have any questions?
2:58:34 Sure, I left something out.
2:58:35 You want some money?
2:58:38 Oh, yeah.
2:58:40 I took these projects to Lori and Travis and we talked about what we can do with reserves.
2:59:16 And Lori has explained to me that if we have $488,000 set aside in the streets reserves
2:59:28 as three months operating, and then on top of that $488,000, we set aside $700,000 for
2:59:35 Canyon Springs Road Reconstruction next year, I need to talk to you more about that.
2:59:40 And then another million dollars for unknown emergencies.
2:59:45 And then if I take the remainder of reserves, which is about 4.4 million, that 4.4 could
2:59:55 be used to fund projects.
2:59:57 And if you saw, I sized it right up to almost 4.4, 4.375.
3:00:04 On Canyon Springs, the long-term planning group hasn't done the presentation yet, of course,
3:00:08 but we've been in conversation talking about the Canyon Springs roadway, the side slope,
3:00:15 and the trail. One of the casualties, if you will, will be, you know, is only so much
3:00:23 money and $700,000 is being set aside in Street Fund to reconstruct the roadway and a million
3:00:33 dollars is already being used from the wastewater bond. So 1.7 can be used for the road reconstruction
3:00:43 and this slope stabilization, but that's it.
3:00:48 So the trail would not be funded.
3:00:50 It was estimated to excess $4 million.
3:00:53 There's simply no funding unless we didn't do this.
3:01:04 So thanks for the reminder.
3:01:06 I guess what is the next?
3:01:09 Great landing.
3:01:10 Drums, then Lori,
3:01:14 well there's a lot of posturing in the legislature
3:01:16 this last year, thank you.
3:01:18 posturing this last year about additional funds.
3:01:22 I know that there's a possibility of receiving some funds
3:01:25 from if there's excess money,
3:01:28 but if he signs or allows them to come in to be the repeal
3:01:32 of the grocery tax, that will certainly cut into any excess
3:01:36 funding there might be, and there was another transportation
3:01:39 bill in there.
3:01:42 When would we receive those funds if we receive anything?
3:01:45 And what is your confidence level we're going to receive
3:01:47 I have. So I'm not going to give you my thoughts on it. I'm just going to kind of maybe lay out the timeline because I think that the process is yet to be defined by the legislature.
3:02:05 I think that if the governor obviously signs the grocery tax that additional surplus eliminator which would be then split between the cities and the state to fund road construction that amount of money becomes into question about how much of that surplus is available now.
3:02:23 available. Now, I believe that that program to go beyond just this fiscal year and there's
3:02:29 other future opportunities in the state continues to grow at a pretty strong pace.
3:02:36 There's the Garvey piece that the governor has yet to sign as well and that would not
3:02:42 necessarily improve any of these projects that you're looking at right here.
3:02:47 There's a third piece of legislation that the legislature passed, I believe, that had to do
3:02:52 with the emergency winter repair and that's a third bill that's outside of the process.
3:03:00 The legislature appropriated the money.
3:03:03 My understanding is the money is available now, but there is going to be a process and
3:03:11 they have to set up a committee that is composed of city representatives, county representatives,
3:03:16 going to be overseen by the state's Bureau of Disaster Services.
3:03:23 And there is some question about the declaration that was prepared by each county and whether
3:03:28 or not individuals are going to be eligible for moving forward.
3:03:36 So there may be an opportunity there.
3:03:38 What I would say is what John illustrated was about $4.3 million of critical need today.
3:03:46 In fact, if the city had additional reserves, you saw the deferred maintenance piece of upwards
3:03:52 of $12 million.
3:03:55 What's important about that deferred maintenance piece is it's not going to go away.
3:03:59 In fact, what's going to happen is it is going to get worse each year as it continues to sit
3:04:08 on maintain.
3:04:10 So if we receive additional funds from the legislature, we have the opportunities to
3:04:15 fill and plug in those opportunities. If not, we'll have to use cash as it comes in to be
3:04:22 able to fund projects and chip away at those pieces of deferred maintenance as we move forward.
3:04:31 Unfortunately, and I think that John and Mark did a great job. This winter really kind
3:04:37 of exposed our roads and our systems. And while we have a great system in place now and the
3:04:44 Council has really risen to the level of providing additional funding for road maintenance and building an eight-year program.
3:04:51 Part of this is the sins of our past, recognizing that maybe we as a community and
3:04:57 as an organization didn't invest in our roadways the way that we should, or
3:05:02 as we accepted additional roads from the county, those upgrades and processes didn't necessarily materialize.
3:05:09 So I think that you're going to see the other thing that John has shared with us and
3:05:14 are in members of the city staff is that this is just what you see today.
3:05:20 And the potential full impact of what a cause below the surface
3:05:26 may not be seen for even a few more years out.
3:05:31 I would just add to your question of prognosticating what the legislature did or didn't do.
3:05:37 So the bills still have to get signed or allowed to become law.
3:05:44 But secondly, we're not the only community in the state that dealt with this.
3:05:47 And so while it may be additional funds coming from the state,
3:05:52 how they're going to get carved up around the state, I know, has been a level of debate.
3:05:58 Discussion of perhaps it's a competitive grant process.
3:06:01 It's not just allocated on a formula basis.
3:06:04 And I think that as good as we've been about trying to keep up with maintenance lately,
3:06:10 I would suspect that some of our other cities in the state maybe have not been that and
3:06:15 probably have greater damage than we do.
3:06:19 Chris, talking to me.
3:06:22 Whenever I make a motion, I just don't say that we have any choice.
3:06:25 We barely have our head above water because of this bad winter.
3:06:28 Got that big deferred amount that we don't even know how it's going to be paid for.
3:06:33 I would so move the use of up to $4.4 million
3:06:37 in reserve funds for this year's road maintenance
3:06:42 reconstruction repair, as described.
3:06:46 So, by Chris talking to second, by great landing
3:06:50 to authorize the use of up to $4.4 million
3:06:55 of street reserve funds for the project's outline.
3:06:59 Is there a discussion?
3:07:03 I just want to say that John and certainly to your team,
3:07:06 I think that the work that you've done in trying to patch up the mess that's out there now is admirable,
3:07:13 but I appreciate that it's temporary.
3:07:16 I tend to drive locust a lot because it's a handy way to get from my office to downtown,
3:07:22 and that was certainly a challenge this winter.
3:07:25 And there are some fairly smooth spots now, but I don't suspect they're going to hold an ever-be-keeps driving on them.
3:07:33 So, again, I think you all did an admirable job of trying to keep up with the damage that we had,
3:07:38 and hopefully this can help fix some of those so that you're not playing patch up on more and more miles of road.
3:07:47 Thank you.
3:07:49 Is there any further discussion?
3:07:52 Sharon, roll call, please.
3:07:54 Ruth, Paris?
3:07:54 Yes.
3:07:56 Suzanne Hawkins?
3:07:57 Yes.
3:07:57 Nikki Boyd?
3:07:58 Yes.
3:07:59 Sean Beriker?
3:08:01 Yes.
3:08:02 Chris Tockington?
3:08:02 Yes.
3:08:03 Greg Lanting?
3:08:04 Yes.
3:08:05 Christopher Reed yes passes 7 to 0
3:08:09 Get the bits out now. Good luck
3:08:13 Can you kind of give us a periodic update on how the progress is going sure can yeah, thanks
3:08:20 And next is a request to approve the zone
3:08:23 7 waterline replacement project to
3:08:26 Mesquite Incorporated in the amount of 242
3:08:30 $500 and $5 John Kate
3:08:32 Thank you, maren council you've spent an awful lot of money tonight
3:08:36 So this one was planned.
3:08:39 So, uh...
3:08:42 So much to plan it.
3:08:44 If you remember, Mark Thompson was saying we're going to be in zone five.
3:08:48 He was talking about the surface treatment this year.
3:08:50 And so you're going to see, we're talking about zone seven today.
3:08:53 And that's because we're doing utility work in the area of
3:08:56 Filer Avenue from Medrona to sunrise.
3:09:00 We're going to be replacing a water line.
3:09:04 We probably bid this March, we had two bidders, the little bidders was key inked, they're a local contractor.
3:09:13 And just to keep counsel posted, I'm going to propose a change order for this contract.
3:09:21 Since you've approved the use of funds to replace winter damage, this project actually lands in one of the projects of Filer.
3:09:32 that's completely, you know, falling apart.
3:09:35 And so the asphalt paving portion of this would be,
3:09:41 of this project, 242,000 included a trench patch,
3:09:45 but instead of doing a trench patch,
3:09:46 we're going to repair like we should the whole lip
3:09:49 to lip the full width of the street.
3:09:52 So I need to, I'll talk to Chris, I need to award the contract
3:09:56 as it was bid in the amount of 242,000.
3:09:59 And before I were to authorize a change order
3:10:04 to change our work out, which is approximately $30,000,
3:10:09 if Council agrees.
3:10:11 So at this time, I just, I stamp request
3:10:13 and request Councils approval for this contract.
3:10:18 Any questions for John?
3:10:21 Suzanne Hawkins.
3:10:22 Not a question, but a motion if you're ready.
3:10:24 Sounds good.
3:10:25 I move that we approve the request to award the 2017 zone
3:10:30 7 bid to Ms. Geet, Incorporated for $242,505, and after the bid is accepted, then to go ahead with the change order as needed.
3:10:44 Second.
3:10:46 Motion by Suzanne Hocken, seconded by Ruth Pierce to approve the request as presented.
3:10:52 Is there any discussion?
3:10:56 Sharon, I'll call the vote, please.
3:10:58 Suzanne Hockens.
3:10:59 Yes.
3:11:00 Nicky Boyd.
3:11:01 Yes.
3:11:01 Sean Beriker.
3:11:02 Yes.
3:11:03 Chris Hockington. Yes. Greg Lanting. Yes. Christopher Reed. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 7-0. Thank you. Thank you, John.
3:11:14 Next another opportunity for public input. If there's anyone here from the public wishing to address the Council on any issues now is your opportunity to come forward.
3:11:24 Seeing no one. Items from the City Manager. Mr. Mayor, members, the Council will keep this brief. There are four quick items for your calendar. Number one, obviously, the state of the city begins at 1130.
3:11:38 30. After the presentation in a quick Q&A, there's an opportunity to grab lunch at one of the
3:11:47 participating restaurants, and then we will jump over to do the official ground breaking
3:11:53 with the Urban Renewal Agency. I believe that's starting at about one o'clock.
3:11:58 one so it would be it's a city then the ground breaking ground breaking yeah and
3:12:05 then one thing and then you can go enjoy lunch right on your own through the end
3:12:09 of April very good so this week Phil Cushlin's in town and he and I've been
3:12:16 going around and speaking with several of our partnering agencies and groups
3:12:20 about the strategic plan and update really really good conversations we hope
3:12:24 to present kind of a what we heard response from all the different groups that we're talking
3:12:31 about in May. We'll use that as a spring board to have a final strategic plan for the community's
3:12:39 review in the fall. But I just wanted to let you know we're progressing with that. This
3:12:45 week also on Thursday is the City County Meeting in Murtaugh. If you're going to that, please
3:12:52 I think contact the county to RSVP.
3:12:57 And then next Monday we're going to have an early start at 3.30.
3:13:00 We're asking you to come in so that we can then take a tour of the public safety complex as well as the City Hall project.
3:13:16 Just to carry on with the ceremonies, the airport terminal is nearly done, they're on the final punch list in that open house, the 10 o'clock, April 19th with City Council's
3:13:29 snake preview, most of an hour before 915. That's Tuesday I think isn't it? Pretty sure.
3:13:36 Yeah, and some good news. Yeah, we've had a hellacious winter, but we have had
3:13:44 180 additional diversion flights from the Sun Valley and every time one of those planes tips down the landing fees ring the till
3:13:52 He has a lot of good money
3:13:54 So you can either pray for more snow next winter or say we had our our good luck, but that is real good news
3:14:01 I will say one of the other bonuses of the winter weather is certainly the amount of traffic
3:14:10 we're seeing down at Shoshone Falls and it's certainly spreading around town.
3:14:13 We had a good weekend at the visitor center last weekend, but I know there are businesses
3:14:18 in town that seem pleased with the number of visitors coming to spend a little time in
3:14:22 my.
3:14:23 Greg Lane.
3:14:24 I'll just quickly add, my apologies, I won't be able to be at the airport dedication.
3:14:28 I will fly out that morning at 6.30, I'll be in the airport that day.
3:14:32 Yeah, I just will be leaving that day, so we've got to give up on it.
3:14:35 That's even better.
3:14:37 Anything else from Council?
3:14:40 That meeting is adjourned.
3:14:43 Why we'd never let go?
Download
- Transcript (text) 169 KB
- Captions (WebVTT) 227 KB
- Transcript (JSON) 310 KB
Chain of custody
- Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, April 10, 2017. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 03:14:45.
- Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
- As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
not recorded - Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
c10460c39535e9aa1dfd7aa1ecd75845947b8f7648fb03e1b9266a6dc5984834 - Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 34 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
81c3d5694f130236a754981406054646d47300c768b5ac07c1f9b1d1a2c273dd
The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file