OversightArchive
Twin Falls, Idaho

City Council meeting

Monday, March 13, 2017

Listen, read the transcript, and link to any moment. Every timestamp is time into the recording.

The transcript is machine-made and not checked word for word. Names, numbers and quiet speakers are the most likely to be wrong. The one exception is the Pledge of Allegiance: a room reciting together is hard for the machine to hear, so the pledge is shown in its standard wording. The recording is the record: listen before you quote. Home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses that speakers give are muted in the audio and marked in the text. The audio is a smaller copy made by software from the video the agency posted, so it loads quickly; nothing is cut apart from the muted passages. The agency's own posting is the original, and each recording below links to it where we have its address.

No finding or timeline entry cites this meeting. It's here so the whole record can be searched and checked, including anything that could explain or change a finding.

Part 1 (from 0:00:00)

Part 2 (from 1:30:00)

Transcript

0:14:38 Good evening and welcome to the March 13th 2017 Twin Falls City Council meeting.

0:14:52 It is five o'clock and we are going to start with the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:14:56 If you'd like to join us please rise.

0:14:58 I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:15:14 Thank you. So with calling the meeting to order, I would like to confirm that we do have a quorum tonight.

0:15:28 There are six of the council members here and our mayor is with us via telephone tonight.

0:15:33 tonight. Can you hear us, Sean? Okay, we're going to have them turn up your volume a little bit. Hang on just a sec.

0:15:39 Okay, Sean, try again. No, hang on. We're working on it. Sean, can you go ahead and try calling back in and I'm going to keep moving with the meeting for a moment.

0:16:10 Thank you. I don't. Yeah. Okay, there we go. We're good. Thank you. All right. Travis, do we have any amendments to the agenda tonight?

0:16:24 Madam Vice Mayor, there are no amendments this evening.

0:16:26 Okay, and we have no proclamations this evening as well.

0:16:30 So at this time we'd like to open up our meeting for public input.

0:16:34 If there's anyone who would like to address the city council on any issue that is not on tonight's agenda, now's your chance.

0:16:41 When you come up please just introduce yourself and we ask you to be respectful of our time constraints.

0:16:48 Funny you should say that.

0:16:49 My name's Terry Edwards.

0:16:50 I'm from Twin Falls.

0:16:52 And my concern is last week there was a gal that came up

0:16:56 and spoke about her situation with the Canyon Trail.

0:17:01 There was no time constraint.

0:17:03 She spoke for 25 minutes at least.

0:17:06 There was no timer.

0:17:07 You didn't time it.

0:17:09 Nobody timed it.

0:17:10 She didn't sign in and request permission

0:17:12 to speak and make a presentation before the board.

0:17:15 She came under the public input session.

0:17:18 We've been here and we've been denied time to speak.

0:17:21 And we were also asked for the fact that if we wanted

0:17:25 to do a presentation, we had to submit all kinds of paperwork,

0:17:28 get it approved by the city or the city

0:17:32 and before we could present anything.

0:17:35 I don't think she presented any paperwork to the city

0:17:37 and she was allowed to do that,

0:17:40 which I think it's a great thing and it's a concern.

0:17:43 but so is everybody else's concern.

0:17:46 So I'm just saying you need to be fair across the board

0:17:48 and that was not fair.

0:17:50 I appreciate your comment

0:17:51 and we will take that under consideration.

0:17:54 Is there anyone else from the public

0:17:56 who would like to address the council tonight?

0:18:00 See no one, we will move forward with our agenda.

0:18:04 The first item tonight is our consent calendar.

0:18:06 Council wishes.

0:18:08 I would move that we approve the consent calendar.

0:18:13 Second now.

0:18:14 We have a motion from Ruth Pierce,

0:18:16 Seconded by Chris Tockington to approve the consent calendar.

0:18:20 Is there any discussion?

0:18:23 Seeing none, roll call vote, please, Sharon.

0:18:25 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:18:27 Yes.

0:18:27 Nikki Boyd.

0:18:28 Yes.

0:18:29 Sean Berriger.

0:18:30 Yes.

0:18:32 Chris Tockington.

0:18:33 Yes.

0:18:33 Greg Lanting.

0:18:35 Yes.

0:18:35 Christopher Reed.

0:18:36 Yes.

0:18:37 Ruth Pierce.

0:18:37 Yes.

0:18:38 Motion passes seven to zero.

0:18:42 And moving on to the items for consideration.

0:18:45 The first item we have is a request from the Salvation Army,

0:18:48 Twin Falls Corps, to waive all building permit fees

0:18:51 associated with replacing the failed HVAC system.

0:18:56 And we have Jared Bodie from the city.

0:18:58 And I believe we're going to have-

0:19:04 Mr. Capullera.

0:19:05 Mr. Capullera, speak to us on behalf

0:19:06 of the Salvation Army, is that correct?

0:19:08 Yeah, Lieutenant Troico could make it so he sent John.

0:19:10 So I'll just have him come up, make his presentation,

0:19:13 and then I'll be here for any questions.

0:19:14 Thank you.

0:19:19 I'd mayor and council.

0:19:21 I'm John Capillares, a member of the Twin Falls Salvation

0:19:23 Army Advisory Board.

0:19:25 Lieutenant Cook was out of town tonight

0:19:27 and gave me the honor of advocating for the cause.

0:19:33 The historic building on 4th Street

0:19:35 is in dire need of renovation.

0:19:38 And the immediate need is for two HVAC units.

0:19:42 The two units, Heat and Cool, the Chapel, and gymnasium.

0:19:45 Many of the programs used those rooms.

0:19:47 And there was a generous donation of $6,000,

0:19:51 but it's going to cost $10,000 total to purchase and install them.

0:19:55 The Salvation Army does so much good for our community.

0:19:58 In the immediate future, we have many costs

0:20:01 associated with renovating the building

0:20:04 to accommodate the expansion of social services.

0:20:08 We'll also begin a capital campaign this spring.

0:20:13 If the city would waive the permit fees,

0:20:16 you will be contributing to the common good of Twin Falls.

0:20:19 The motto of the Salvation Army is doing the most good,

0:20:22 and they have been at it for a long time.

0:20:25 Almost almost 100 years ago, the leading citizens of Twin Falls

0:20:30 asked the Salvation Army to come to Twin Falls.

0:20:33 And right now we have some great leadership

0:20:38 at the Twin Falls Salvation Army who have an ambitious vision,

0:20:42 And they want to help others while managing their resources well.

0:20:47 And I humbly beg that the City Council

0:20:50 waive the building permit fee for the new HVAC units.

0:20:53 Thank you.

0:20:55 Thank you.

0:20:56 Ruth and Nick, you both went in at the same time,

0:20:58 so I'll start on this side.

0:21:01 Go ahead, Nick.

0:21:02 I was going to say this is kind of super easy and the salvation

0:21:07 arm.

0:21:07 They do the really hard work.

0:21:10 They do.

0:21:11 And they do it on the shoestring.

0:21:12 And they've been doing it on a shoestring forever.

0:21:15 They can make more good out of a quarter

0:21:18 than anybody I've seen.

0:21:19 So I would like to make a motion unless there's discussion.

0:21:22 Did you have discussion?

0:21:23 Oh, I wanted to say is for the public,

0:21:25 it's only $265.34.

0:21:28 So to me, this is pretty much a no-brainer.

0:21:30 So if you make the motion, I'll second it.

0:21:34 Go ahead.

0:21:35 Oh, I thought Chris was waiting to speak.

0:21:37 No.

0:21:39 I move that.

0:21:40 We honor, accept the request, grant the request for the Salvation Army to involve court,

0:21:45 waive all building permit fees associated with replacing the failed HVAC system.

0:21:51 Second.

0:21:53 We have a motion and a second to honor the request from the Salvation Army to waive the building permit fees.

0:22:00 Is there anyone else on the council that would like to weigh in?

0:22:05 Seeing no one, roll call vote, Sharon?

0:22:07 Nicky Boyd?

0:22:08 Yes.

0:22:08 Sean Beriker?

0:22:10 Yes.

0:22:11 Chris Tockington.

0:22:12 Yes.

0:22:13 Greg Lanting.

0:22:14 Yes.

0:22:15 Christopher Reed.

0:22:15 Yes.

0:22:16 Ruth Pierce.

0:22:17 Yes.

0:22:18 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:22:19 Yes.

0:22:20 Motion passes 7 to 0.

0:22:23 Thank you, John.

0:22:24 And I'm sorry I drew a blank there.

0:22:25 It was just, you know, one of those moments.

0:22:30 Next on our agenda, we have a presentation

0:22:32 from Scott Hunsaker and Laurie Race

0:22:35 with the City of Twin Falls 2016 audited financial statements.

0:22:41 Go, Laurie.

0:22:41 All right.

0:22:42 Well, good evening.

0:22:44 Tonight, Scott Hunsaker for a Mulkey Hunsaker

0:22:46 and company is here to present the audited financial statements

0:22:50 for the fiscal year ended 2016.

0:22:54 And you all should have received an electronic copy.

0:22:56 We wanted to make sure you have that in your hand

0:22:58 so you could review it and have any questions ready.

0:23:01 And so with that, I'll turn it over to Scott.

0:23:04 We've all memorized it.

0:23:05 I've been.

0:23:06 Well, it's good to be with you again tonight, and if you memorize it, I'm impressed.

0:23:19 I was just telling Brandon it continues to grow.

0:23:22 It's just over 120 pages now with regulations and things that continues to increase in size.

0:23:30 But like I said, it's good to be with you.

0:23:33 If you have represents a significant amount of work for the city, the staff and everybody

0:23:39 to get these documents prepared and ready to go, and the audit went very well.

0:23:45 That's what I'm here to report on.

0:23:46 We can talk about some highlights if you'd like, but really the audit went very well this

0:23:51 year again.

0:23:53 I just want to draw your attention to a couple of things.

0:23:57 the award that the city received that's presented as part of this document, this distinguished

0:24:04 budget presentation from the GFOA, that's a really significant thing and very ambitious

0:24:10 project that the city took on to present that.

0:24:16 There's an amazing amount of detailed review that goes into that and getting that award,

0:24:24 So they should be congratulated and recognized for that.

0:24:28 That's a significant thing.

0:24:30 Just after that award is our audit report and it's an unqualified opinion.

0:24:36 We didn't see anything that would change that unqualified opinion.

0:24:41 And so it's a clean report, which is another way of putting that, dated February 24 of 2017.

0:24:52 And like I said, nothing was an issue.

0:24:55 We review the internal controls as we're auditing to make sure that the procedures are followed

0:25:00 that have been put in place and review checks and disbursements and everything seemed to

0:25:08 be handled appropriately.

0:25:12 Another nice thing about your financial statements is the MDNA that just follows the report and

0:25:17 And that is a very concise way to read through the financial statement, summarizes the data

0:25:24 in a way that's easy to read and understand, and kind of gives a projection of the future.

0:25:30 So I would encourage you to at least browse through that section the risk gets kind of down

0:25:36 in the details of what these financial statements are.

0:25:41 The audit process, just real quick, we assess the risk of the city of misstatements in the

0:25:48 city when we start the audit and then we adjust our audits according to those risks and then

0:25:57 follow that procedure through.

0:26:00 Most of your balance sheet is tied out to financial state or to balance balances in the bank and

0:26:07 things like that and then we do select checks and things like that that would go

0:26:12 on to the income statement and the city's financial statements and processes are

0:26:18 really exemplary in how it's handled. So we really don't have any issues to report

0:26:25 to you other than it's handled really very well and like I said the audit went

0:26:29 well we do issue a report on the internal controls at the end of the document which

0:26:35 is required for the government and that's an unqualified opinion as well. Any any questions

0:26:44 you may have about the audit process or the audit. Chris Daukington. Well I do read these.

0:26:50 I find them interesting reading and I have been doing this for so many years I always

0:26:55 learned something new but because 47% of our budget comes from property taxes I think a lot

0:27:01 of people out there that have very peak interest

0:27:04 in public expenditures at all time.

0:27:07 And on page 117, speaking of the internal controls,

0:27:12 I'm quoting now, it's on the first paragraph,

0:27:17 the end of the first paragraph on page 117.

0:27:20 We do not express an opinion on the effectiveness

0:27:23 of Twin Falls City's internal control, the compliance.

0:27:28 compliance. So you're not contradicting what you just said, but I think you need a further

0:27:34 explanation because most businesses I work with, we do have internal controls. Is it just

0:27:40 that you're coming in for a spot check? You can't validate the effectiveness of those?

0:27:46 Or does it mean we have a total lack of internal control?

0:27:49 No, no. What it's saying is there's nothing that rises to the level that a material weakness

0:27:55 for a significant deficiency of what we selected and the samples that we selected.

0:27:59 Now, we don't go through and test every transaction to test those internal controls, but the samples

0:28:06 that we selected passed and didn't have any issue.

0:28:09 So we can't give an opinion on every transaction, but those that we do select and the balances

0:28:16 that we select to test in detail.

0:28:17 So there is a random verification of that?

0:28:20 Absolutely.

0:28:21 The thousands of thousands of transactions we selected a sample statistic.

0:28:24 Scott, I will sleep well better tonight.

0:28:28 Great-lantine.

0:28:29 Scott, I think I know what you mean,

0:28:30 but that's one of the certain.

0:28:32 You keep saying unqualified, and it makes it sound like,

0:28:35 I think you mean that there's no problem,

0:28:39 but it's not like you're not qualified to give them a ticket.

0:28:41 It's counterintuitive.

0:28:43 Unqualified opinion is a clean opinion,

0:28:45 and that's what you use normally.

0:28:48 That's what I assume, but.

0:28:49 Accountants, we just like to use strings.

0:28:50 But it kind of sounds like, and I'm worried,

0:28:52 since we do broadcast everyone,

0:28:54 that it sounds like you weren't qualified to give an opinion.

0:28:56 If we were to qualify the opinion, that means there would be items

0:28:59 that we have to live in.

0:29:01 Kind of backwards.

0:29:02 It is.

0:29:03 That's a challenge.

0:29:07 Sean, I just wanted to check with you.

0:29:08 Do you have any comments?

0:29:12 I would just echo the comments that have already been made,

0:29:14 how much we appreciate the efforts of the auditors

0:29:18 and certainly our financial team for plan work that they do

0:29:21 and keeping good track of the public's money.

0:29:25 Thank you.

0:29:27 Ruth Pearson, then we'll go to Travis.

0:29:29 OK, Laurie, I just want to tell you, give you a shout-out

0:29:34 that we so appreciate you and the tough love you have

0:29:39 over your department.

0:29:41 I've talked with other city people

0:29:44 that have experienced not-so-pretty stuff,

0:29:47 and it just makes me want to thank you every day.

0:29:50 So appreciate you and your staff.

0:29:57 So, Madam Vice Mayor, members of the City Council,

0:29:59 there's a couple of things that I not only want to echo,

0:30:02 but maybe stress in terms of what Scott had shared

0:30:06 this evening, so one of the things that he shared

0:30:08 was the GFOA notification.

0:30:12 And what's important to recognize about that

0:30:14 is the City of Twin Falls is one of three cities

0:30:17 in the state of Idaho to have received bolt designations,

0:30:20 not only for our budget, but also for our comprehensive

0:30:24 annual financial report and being one of three out of 206 cities inside of the state of Idaho

0:30:32 to have received that, I think really talks about Lori, Brent, Shane, and all the members

0:30:37 of the finance team and the hard work that they go forward in the care.

0:30:43 I think the most important way to look at the audit is it is a report card.

0:30:49 So when we go through the budgeting process, the budget is our best financial plan moving

0:30:55 forward.

0:30:56 And we try to remove lots of unknowns.

0:30:58 We try to make reasonable assumptions for a whole host of variables.

0:31:05 The audit is a reflection on how closely we follow that plan, how closely we follow the

0:31:11 rules and the regulations that are attached to us spending money.

0:31:16 And when you receive the unqualified opinion and then you hear the high remarks, I think

0:31:20 that that is just for their testament of the team that Lori is leading and the work that

0:31:27 they're doing to really make sure that the city's fiduciary responsibility is held into

0:31:33 the highest of light.

0:31:34 So really compliments to Lori and her team for all the work that they do.

0:31:39 Thank you.

0:31:40 I just want to take a minute and echo that as well.

0:31:41 Thank you for your time, Scott.

0:31:43 We appreciate your efforts in helping us through it and to Lori and Brent and Shane and everybody

0:31:48 in that department.

0:31:50 Thank you again for all of your hard work all year long.

0:31:56 So I know that we spent just a little bit of time this evening, but I think it's also

0:32:02 important that the audit will be available if it's not already.

0:32:07 It's in the agenda packets, but it's also will be made available separate and distinct

0:32:12 online. As part of our effort to be transparent, the citizens have complete access to that audit.

0:32:18 They can review that. Members of the city's team are happy to answer questions about that

0:32:23 audit process of what individuals may have and will continue to further that role of being

0:32:30 fiduciary and stewards of the public money.

0:32:33 Thank you, Travis. All right. Next on our agenda is a presentation from Paul Johnson with an

0:32:42 update on our main avenue project.

0:32:46 Welcome, Paul.

0:32:55 Thank you, Madam Chair, Mayor and members of the Council.

0:32:59 I'm Paul Johnson with CH2M, the owner's representative on the main avenue project on behalf of the Urban Renewal Agency of Twin Falls.

0:33:09 And I'm pleased to provide this project update for you.

0:33:12 It's the same update that I provided earlier today to the Urban Renewal District Board meeting.

0:33:19 Starting off, the photograph in the upper left and upper right is from February 16th in this

0:33:26 room where we had another project advisory committee meeting with the merchants of Twin

0:33:31 Falls, approximately 15 to 20 attended.

0:33:35 It was just kind of a heads up meeting to remind them of the planned landscape removal

0:33:39 project that took place February 17th through the 20th.

0:33:45 I believe successfully.

0:33:46 So I'll have more comments on that later.

0:33:49 Well actually in the lower left and lower right you see two other photographs of the landscape

0:33:56 removal along the five blocks of Main Avenue which kicked off on February 17th.

0:34:02 In the lower right, Rob Kloninger is the superintendent with Guho on the left side and to the right

0:34:08 is Randy Stedom from Four Seasons Tree Service.

0:34:12 First season's tree service of Jerome did a marvelous job, I think, in removing the landscaping

0:34:17 with minimal disruption, they got it done one day early.

0:34:21 We had planned on four days over President's Day weekend, and they got it done and cleaned

0:34:25 up in three days.

0:34:26 So, we're planning to commend them on a job well done, and we're hopeful that the city

0:34:32 and the public in general are pleased with the progress and anxious for the project to

0:34:36 come, which I'll talk about next.

0:34:46 As you may know, the project construction will be administered by Guho Corporation and

0:34:53 they've done quite a few of these projects, streetscape, urban renewal projects.

0:35:00 They headed up the landscape removal from February 17th through the 20th and in honor

0:35:06 of the City Council's request and the desires of the urban renewal agency, we all paid attention

0:35:12 to recycling the wood products from the trees that were removed along Main Avenue.

0:35:17 About 50% of the wood chips were taken to the city parks and recreation yard for reuse

0:35:23 as landscape mulch.

0:35:25 Logs from about 20 trees were given to a number of businesses along Main Avenue for repurposing

0:35:32 needs including Paul Graf who is the owner of Twin Beans Coffee.

0:35:37 I looked in the coffee shop and I enjoy going in there and there's a pile of logs right

0:35:41 in the business, so clearly he has some plan for use of those logs.

0:35:47 And also a local woodworker, Mr. Mark McClellan, who served our country and is a disabled veteran,

0:35:55 he received wood from about eight trees to make archery bows, and he sent a nice email

0:36:03 to Guho thanking them for providing that wood to him, and that's quoted there.

0:36:09 He said that it would have been difficult for him to acquire that wood on his own, and he's

0:36:14 very appreciative of the efforts of the team.

0:36:16 So, we're hopeful that you're pleased with that effort as well, and the trees served the

0:36:22 public well for many years, and now it's time for a refresh, and the project will get going

0:36:27 here very soon.

0:36:36 Regarding the financials on the landscape removal project, there were a couple of things

0:36:42 packaged into a $56,000 initial price, including the landscape removal, which was a subset of

0:36:50 that, plus an environmental review for the Crowley basement, plus traffic control and

0:36:56 administration. But Guho has passed along a savings of about $9,200 back to the URA because

0:37:04 we were able to do the job in three days instead of four. So rather than pocketing that

0:37:09 as profit, that's going right back to the urban renewal agency for use on the streetscape

0:37:13 project. So we're all very appreciative of that. I think that's one of the advantages

0:37:18 of this particular CMGC contracting process for that dynamic can take place in the best

0:37:24 interest of the owner. This is just a recap of the bidding schedule. We have, the project

0:37:38 is being bid right now, Gu Ho will manage a number of subcontractors on the project.

0:37:46 About 59 to 60 or so contractors have received the plans and they're putting together bids

0:37:55 for various things including paving and the underground work, the utility work, the storm

0:38:00 drainage only and irrigation and some electrical, not the alleyway utilities work, but just what's

0:38:07 in main avenue. And the street lights and so forth. So the project is being bid now. We

0:38:16 will have two pre-bid conferences tomorrow on March 14th. So we expect quite a few companies

0:38:23 to show up who are interested in bidding the project. Bids will be received on March 22nd

0:38:29 and then we'll have about a week to review the bids and assemble the guaranteed maximum

0:38:34 price led by Guho and then that will be presented to the Urban Renewal Agency at a special board

0:38:40 meeting on April 3rd.

0:38:42 And then we should be good to go on the project after that with construction beginning around

0:38:49 the third week in April, the first block that will receive the demolition is from Gooding

0:38:55 to Shoshone, so that will probably take place beginning around the third week in April.

0:39:01 And the project is still expected to be completed substantially complete by October 31, 2017,

0:39:09 so right on time with completion.

0:39:11 We've taken a little bit more time in ensuring quality in the bid documents before we release

0:39:22 the plans to the bidders, as I'm sure everyone can appreciate if there are errors or inconsistencies

0:39:28 in the documents that results in extra cost and sometimes delays.

0:39:33 So Guho has been very good about building this project in their heads and making sure

0:39:40 that everything is very clear in the documents and proposing a number of cost-saving ideas

0:39:47 that once it's bid, that savings will go right to the Urban Renewal Agency.

0:39:52 One example of that is combining the electrical and the irrigation in one common trench rather

0:39:58 than digging two trenches.

0:39:59 So the bidders see that and comply with that and submit competitive pricing and then the

0:40:05 urban renewal agency sees that savings.

0:40:07 I won't read through all of these items but there are a number of elements there that we

0:40:11 think have been improvements to the drawings as a result of taking a few extra weeks in

0:40:17 carefully reviewing the documents.

0:40:20 Can I interrupt you for a question?

0:40:22 Yes please.

0:40:23 Chris Talkington.

0:40:24 Hi Paul.

0:40:25 point about the sharing the trench for electrical and irrigation takes me back to my cable days

0:40:31 when we were under advisement that don't put electrical and water in the same trench.

0:40:36 It must be separated from some 18 inches or something to pass the code or the safety codes

0:40:43 or explain that.

0:40:44 How you?

0:40:45 Yes, there will be the required separation per code and the irrigation helps in that it's

0:40:51 It's not a domestic water supply, it's actually a separate system just for watering the landscaping

0:40:58 along Main Avenue and the hanging flower baskets and so forth.

0:41:02 I was still electric, although electricity and water don't mix, but there's a separation

0:41:07 that.

0:41:08 Exactly.

0:41:09 Yeah, I mean, it would still be in proximity to one another, even if the trenches were offset

0:41:14 a little bit, they'll do over each other with the required depth of cover per code so that

0:41:20 It's not running immediately together, thank you.

0:41:25 The illustration at the top of this page with the blue highlighting illustrates the, just

0:41:31 one page from the plan, one detail, and the blue highlighting is Google's effort at coordinating

0:41:36 the work on Hanson Avenue North with Storm Drain Coordination, obviously next to City

0:41:42 Hall, Hanson Avenue going to the north to 2nd Avenue will be taken care of by Star Corporation,

0:41:50 who's going to be managing the commons construction

0:41:54 and Hanson North, but there is storm drainage connection work

0:41:57 that has to be carefully coordinated

0:41:59 with the main avenue project.

0:42:01 And Guho did a very good job of going through those details

0:42:05 and helping to define the scope of work for their work

0:42:10 and where it interfaces with STARS work.

0:42:12 And they did this in many cases throughout all of the documents.

0:42:15 I've really never seen as good of quality control as this

0:42:20 construction management firm in helping to clarify to the design firm what the questions

0:42:26 are rather than just submitting a lot of writing. They took time to illustrate the comments on

0:42:31 the drawings and we literally had hundreds of comments that in my opinion all of those

0:42:37 are requests for clarification averted and potential for extra cost averted. So again

0:42:43 I think the several weeks of additional time in reviewing the documents once they were completed

0:42:48 was time well spent. Another topic that we're currently working on is the desire that was

0:42:58 expressed by the Lions Club to be able to display flags at various holidays throughout

0:43:06 the year and that was not incorporated into the design but we're working on doing that.

0:43:12 So rather than complain about it, Guho sketched out a detail and sent it in for as a suggestion,

0:43:22 I'm not saying that that will be the final detail, but they do have experience with mounting

0:43:30 flags with their work at the Veterans Cemetery and so forth.

0:43:35 So we will work with a representative from the Lions Club and the Merchants to find out

0:43:40 whether the flags can be attached to the building or whether it needs to be in the streetscape

0:43:45 area, the brick furnishing zone or somewhere else and then come up with a detail that will

0:43:51 be workable and make sure that that's included in the bid documents.

0:43:58 Just one other quick example here, this detail deals with the irrigation controller that will

0:44:05 need to go at the location in the commons where the building will be built by Star for

0:44:12 housing storage and the mechanical area for the splash park and the restroom building.

0:44:19 So we will need to install that controller prior to that building being built and this

0:44:24 just illustrates how that can be done with a temporary condition.

0:44:28 So we're trying not to overlook any important details that could result in extra cost if

0:44:32 we just, you know, if we just skip that issue.

0:44:35 So again, Guho is very thorough as were the other representatives including the city and

0:44:42 engineers from our company as well and clarifying things in the documents before it bids.

0:44:53 the design progress. Again, the final design was submitted at the end of February. It's

0:44:58 now out for bid. We're still working on a few final details with filling in the

0:45:04 Crowley basement which is underneath main avenue in front of the former Moose Hill

0:45:09 tenant space and also the Twin Beans coffee space. So a week from Wednesday

0:45:16 there'll be an environmental survey to make sure we don't have any asbestos or

0:45:20 other issues in that working area and to check a few conditions for the existing structure

0:45:27 prior to infilling that section of the basement.

0:45:35 Just a comment on the budget.

0:45:37 As I reported to the urban renewal agency, we do have six and a half million dollars budgeted

0:45:42 for the project and two independent estimates and then a cross check of those estimates all

0:45:47 indicating that we should have bids within that range.

0:45:51 If the bids come in lower, then we propose to have money for contingency to replace some

0:45:57 other critical broken up sidewalks adjacent to the project within the Area 4.1 of the

0:46:04 Urban Renewal Agency.

0:46:05 May I answer any questions?

0:46:10 Ruth Pierce.

0:46:11 I just wanted to reiterate that we came under budget by 16%, almost 10,000, and one day quicker

0:46:22 and I was downtown the whole weekend, it was happening, and it was cleaned up and with the exception of kind of being in shock because you can see down Main Street and notice there's some facades that need some work.

0:46:37 It was a very quick moving project and it was excellent.

0:46:43 Thank you.

0:46:44 Sean, do you have anything?

0:46:49 I do not have anything specific, but it's not already been said.

0:46:55 Thank you.

0:46:56 Thank you.

0:46:57 Thank you very much.

0:46:59 Appreciate the update tonight.

0:47:01 We'll be looking forward to the next one.

0:47:09 The next item on our agenda is a request to award the 2017 downtown utility upgrade project

0:47:16 to extreme excavation.

0:47:18 Is it the next one?

0:47:20 Rob Bowlby?

0:47:21 Oh, I skipped.

0:47:22 I apologize.

0:47:23 I didn't mean to miss you, Rob.

0:47:25 Everything's all running together.

0:47:27 No, Rob's afterwards.

0:47:28 Am I okay?

0:47:29 Am I okay?

0:47:30 You're all right.

0:47:31 I'm all right.

0:47:32 So, shoot.

0:47:33 That invites me.

0:47:34 Before you go to that one, it might be a perfect segue to kind of jump in real quick.

0:47:36 So, one of the things that Paul talked about was the going through that bid process.

0:47:42 And so far, Guho has received interest from 46 different bidders on the project, 31 of

0:47:49 which are located inside of the Magic Valley.

0:47:52 So this is a really good project, a really good local project.

0:47:56 We hope that obviously what the most competitive bit, but if local firms can secure some of

0:48:02 these jobs by being competitive, that just further adds value not only to the project,

0:48:07 but to the community.

0:48:08 I think I'll just go ahead and from the Twin Falls Community Foundation, you have through

0:48:13 the month of March, I believe, if you want to order a brick with your name on it to go

0:48:18 in the Commons area.

0:48:20 I believe March 31 is when they're going to stop selling those bricks.

0:48:24 $100 each and the Twin Falls Community Foundation has their website and you can look them up there

0:48:29 and get the bricks online real easy. So just throw that out there too. Okay moving on now we are going

0:48:36 to move on to the request for the downtown utility upgrade project to extreme excavation. At this

0:48:44 point I am going to recuse myself because extreme excavation is one of my company's clients and I'm

0:48:50 I'm going to turn the meeting over to Greg Lanting.

0:49:00 Thank you, Vice Mayor.

0:49:02 Next item agenda is the awarding of a contract

0:49:05 for downtown utility upgrades to extreme incubation

0:49:08 of Jesse Sherman.

0:49:10 Staff Engineer is gonna be covering this for us.

0:49:30 Hello, City Council members.

0:49:32 I'm Jesse Sherman.

0:49:32 I'm a Staff Engineer with the Engineering Department.

0:49:38 This project basically consists of water and storming.

0:49:42 lines that are in this area. If you notice the new city hall in the

0:49:50 Commons, it's right behind that area. On February 16, 2017, we opened up

0:50:01 some, we opened up the bids for downtown utility upgrades project.

0:50:08 One bid was received from extreme excavation for the total amount of $1,000,

0:50:15 $218.56. JUB engineers, the design engineers, confirm that extreme

0:50:23 excavation has provided all the necessary bit documents and other requirements

0:50:27 necessary to perform the work within the attached letter. The engineers

0:50:33 estimate was 13% below the bit from extreme excavation. What I've found with

0:50:41 my conversations with my fellow engineers is that the bidding environment

0:50:45 is very competitive at this time in Twin Falls.

0:50:49 And other projects in the area are attempting

0:50:52 to schedule around this work.

0:50:55 And so there could be repercussions

0:51:02 if we do re-bid the work.

0:51:05 Project cost could actually go up.

0:51:10 We also had an additive bid item that

0:51:12 was included separate from the base bid

0:51:14 for the lighting improvements.

0:51:17 The cost of the lighting improvements was approximately $90,000 considering the bid is

0:51:23 modestly over the engineer's estimate and there is a backlog of work and wastewater collection.

0:51:30 It's prudent to admit this alternative.

0:51:34 To be responsible considering the older infrastructure, we would like to include the cost of unforeseen

0:51:39 events on the project. A 25% contingency would help us with any of these unforeseen events.

0:51:50 Ultimately, the downtown merchants would appreciate a fast, responsible decision to lessen the impact

0:51:59 of business and help this project avoid construction activities in the front and the back of the

0:52:06 The city or engineer would approve or deny contingency requests or change orders.

0:52:14 Is there any questions I can answer about the project?

0:52:22 You're starting to, I don't, don't figure how this is 13% below the engineer's

0:52:31 estimate.

0:52:32 If you take a million, 10,000, divide by 88.5 or where did I miss that?

0:52:40 Well, I think he said it differently than we have to use it.

0:52:43 I think he said the engineer's estimate was 13% lower than the actual bid.

0:52:48 Yeah, but it is, it's lower.

0:52:51 So in other words, the bid is 13% higher.

0:52:54 Yeah, I don't get 13% by dividing those two figures.

0:52:59 More like 20% in your mind or?

0:53:01 Looks like considerably higher.

0:53:03 So what am I missing?

0:53:05 Okay, well, it looks like it's,

0:53:10 What, 11% is that what you get, Ruth?

0:53:13 What is it, 1010?

0:53:15 1010 218 divided by 88505.

0:53:22 What are you other way around?

0:53:23 That's right, that's right.

0:53:25 88 what?

0:53:26 88505.

0:53:28 Or than that, 88.

0:53:34 That's the 85.

0:53:35 What was the...

0:53:36 No, excuse me.

0:53:37 I'm dealing with the wrong figure then.

0:53:40 So, there we go.

0:53:41 882, what 3, 1, yeah.

0:53:43 Well, I'm going to turn it on my calculator

0:53:45 I'm going to leave it to rear to the front of obviously.

0:53:54 14 and a half.

0:53:56 OK.

0:53:57 So forget what I said in our room.

0:54:02 Chris Reed.

0:54:04 Did we just have one business come back to us?

0:54:08 One bid?

0:54:09 One bid?

0:54:10 I just had one bid, and I kind of think

0:54:13 it's because of the bid environment

0:54:15 and the busyness of our contractors in the areas.

0:54:24 We had seven prime contractors.

0:54:27 I think it's mentioned at least seven prime contractors look at the bedside and consider bedding the project.

0:54:34 One bit.

0:54:37 Did they say why?

0:54:38 They didn't bid?

0:54:42 So I think that Jesse talked about that.

0:54:44 Part of it is a really, really competitive bid environment.

0:54:50 The second is the alleyway work is known to be a very difficult project.

0:54:56 businesses that are going to stay operational, they're going to stay moving forward, it's

0:55:02 going to be still open. And then the other side of the coin is that that is a very, very

0:55:08 narrow area with lots of, whether it be power, electrical, gas, now sewer, and water lines

0:55:17 all crammed into a very, very defined corridor. So the work becomes very, very complex. So

0:55:24 There's probably those two reasons when you start looking at the complexity of the work

0:55:29 and then the amount of work that is available for individuals to consider throughout the Magic

0:55:35 Valley.

0:55:37 Chris, I don't like that variance between the actual and the estimate, but if we were to

0:55:43 delight as bidding to what we think is past the prime part of the season, that's going

0:55:47 to have a ripple effect on the entire project, isn't it?

0:55:52 With no guarantee that we wouldn't turn out to be the same or worse.

0:55:57 kind of limiting our options.

0:56:04 Any other comments? Any other questions?

0:56:09 Any, any, any, any way you want to make it a motion?

0:56:14 Yeah, I would so move that we award the 2017

0:56:18 downtown utility upgrade project

0:56:22 in the bid amount of a million 10,218.50

0:56:26 to extreme excavation ink. Second.

0:56:31 They're allowing a 25% contingency amount as well.

0:56:35 Yeah, yeah, all right.

0:56:40 Any discussion?

0:56:43 Seeing none.

0:56:44 Roll call vote.

0:56:45 Sean Bericher.

0:56:47 Yeah.

0:56:48 Chris Hockington.

0:56:49 Yes.

0:56:50 Greg Lanting.

0:56:51 Yes.

0:56:52 Christopher Reed.

0:56:53 Yes.

0:56:54 Ruth Pierce.

0:56:55 Yes.

0:56:56 Suzanne Hawkins.

0:56:57 Upstanding.

0:56:58 Oh, I'm saying that's right.

0:56:59 Nicky Boyd.

0:57:00 Yes.

0:57:01 A motion passes six to zero.

0:57:04 And this is a way better book than I had when I was married.

0:57:09 Wow, this is nice.

0:57:11 We're spoiled right here.

0:57:14 Yeah.

0:57:15 Let's just need more help.

0:57:18 Thank you, Greg.

0:57:20 Okay.

0:57:24 Now we'll move on to the presentation on the Backflow Device Program from Rob Bowling.

0:57:31 We like Backflow Devices.

0:57:36 And Rob, before you leave tonight, could you change your clock for us?

0:57:41 This don't even be Dennis Bauer, boy, boy, your responsibility.

0:57:47 Move on down to the next two tallest people of the year, you're Bill Baxter.

0:57:53 Good evening, Council.

0:58:17 We appreciate your time this evening.

0:58:20 We discussed this year's back vote program and we're going to be going with it.

0:58:25 And for the new council people, I thought I'd kind of just go kind of through where the

0:58:36 backflow is, what the program consists of, so you guys kind of know what's going on.

0:58:43 So what is the backflow assembly, the assembly's designed for to prevent back pressure or back

0:58:50 life niche of any fluid or substance into our potable water system. I protected from that.

0:58:57 There's three types of backflow devices, a pressure vacuum breaker, double check, and

0:59:04 a reduced pressure, pressure vacuum, that sort of pressure vacuum breaker looks like.

0:59:12 They're mostly for long sprinkling systems, that type of application. A double check assembly

0:59:20 can be put in the ground.

0:59:23 Most people would have devices on their lawn

0:59:26 sprinkling systems.

0:59:28 The majority of them are these.

0:59:30 And they're good for back pressure or back siphonage.

0:59:35 And then the reduced pressure assembly,

0:59:37 they're more for the high hazard areas

0:59:41 with industrial chemical fertilizers, that kind of stuff,

0:59:46 if there's any cross connections on those.

0:59:50 So that's kind of an overview of the assemblies.

0:59:54 Who regulates this?

0:59:55 EPA says the guidelines that we have to follow

0:59:57 and can direct DEQ and they govern us.

1:00:04 It's under the IDAPA section

1:00:07 in the Idaho drinking water code.

1:00:11 Section 552-06 covers those rules

1:00:15 and then we also have our own city code.

1:00:18 And that's under Title VII, chapter 9.

1:00:21 And that covers the rules that Council has said to govern us.

1:00:29 So our program at a Gute Glance, we have been with this.

1:00:34 Back close, it's not a new thing.

1:00:37 It's been around for a while.

1:00:40 I think in 1992 issues when they started really looking at it

1:00:47 requiring devices. In 2003, around somewhere around there, we tried to get our program going,

1:00:58 and we decided that we'd do the commercial stuff, but we didn't really enforce the rules

1:01:08 on the long-streaming system. That kind of goes against the rules set by DEQ and EPA.

1:01:16 Can't just you can't do one without the other

1:01:20 Yeah, protect if there's a cross connection. You have to protect it. So

1:01:26 Over that 10-year period we were trying to figure out how we were gonna do our program

1:01:32 We've never had a program

1:01:35 We had the best ordinance in the books, but we didn't enforce our own ordinance

1:01:40 We had a lot of cities come to us and say

1:01:43 Can we use your ordinance, but then they found out well and not

1:01:47 We were kind of behind a lot of the other cities, but it's something we're working

1:01:57 at.

1:01:58 So, DQ, when we had our sanitary survey in 2013, I believe it was found that we were

1:02:06 out of compliance.

1:02:08 So in 2014, we came and asked, you know, first staff and council to get behind us and

1:02:16 a get our program going. We knew that we needed more testers in that. The landscape

1:02:23 and companies kind of just sat back because of prior experience without we

1:02:29 were running our program. They didn't want to spend a lot of money and get people

1:02:33 certified because it does cost money and the tests for kids cost money. So they

1:02:37 kind of just for sitting back and watching.

1:02:42 We gathered in 2014, we went out and we had our meter readers, utility crews, and the

1:02:54 landscapers and everybody told them, hey, we've got to get this program going, can you

1:02:59 help us?

1:03:00 So they started gathering locations of devices and our meter readers were a real big help

1:03:07 to us because their reading meter is usually the back foot device is right by the meter.

1:03:12 So we kind of schooled them on what to look for and they went out and gathered a whole

1:03:19 bunch and helped us attend to them in that area.

1:03:24 Through this process people would call and say, well, who do we get to test it or what

1:03:31 are we supposed to do?

1:03:33 So we worked with the people, it's a program in progress.

1:03:37 I worked with them, told them, you know, get a whole of the testers and put out a lot of

1:03:42 people who didn't know what they were looking for or anything.

1:03:45 So we started doing some education in the media stuff, did some commercials and stuff,

1:03:52 the houses and that kind of stuff, because we were lacking on education on the public

1:03:58 and that was our fault.

1:03:59 So we've done a whole lot more education in the last two, three years and I think it's

1:04:05 helped a whole lot. Also with that, we've hosted three back well certification classes at the Water

1:04:13 Department building. We had certified testers come in and they put on the class and that is

1:04:20 really well. Now that people know we're serious about it and we have to get it done, they're

1:04:25 willing to put the time and resources into it. So in 1415 I think we prior to that we had 11

1:04:35 on our list and we added 22 more in 1415,

1:04:40 but we still knew we needed more testers to get the city done

1:04:45 at a timely matter.

1:04:47 In 2016, we sent out 500 little, over 5,000 letters

1:04:54 requiring that people needed to get it done out of those.

1:04:58 We had a little over 5,000 complied.

1:05:02 And then we still, last year, the testers were inundated because we had not, this was kind

1:05:13 of new.

1:05:14 Now we were enforcing it.

1:05:15 A lot of people didn't even have devices on their screen from systems.

1:05:18 Or if they did, they were so outdated that they needed to be replaced.

1:05:22 So it was a pretty good-sized load on the testers again.

1:05:25 Last year, out of those, we had over 700 that either didn't get them tested in time before

1:05:31 tested in time before the sprinkler systems got shut off where they needed

1:05:35 replaced and then there are a few that told us they're just not going to do it.

1:05:41 So we still know that we need a few more testers. After we had our class this

1:05:50 spring there's I think 33 over 33 companies now that are on our list and out

1:05:58 of those companies. A lot of them have four or five testers now in their company. So I believe

1:06:04 we'll have well over 50 testers this year to be able to handle this. We plan on holding

1:06:12 more training and repair classes is a big deal now with all the new testers out there

1:06:20 knowing how to repair these devices and stuff so that they don't have, you know, disjank them

1:06:25 out, but you can repair them and these devices will last quite a while if you know how to repair them.

1:06:30 So we're going to look at and make sure we're doing due diligence on that

1:06:35 and get them testers trained up to where they can repair devices.

1:06:39 Because it's a cost, you can repair a device three or four times versus buying a new one.

1:06:47 So we're going to make sure we're doing that.

1:06:50 We held a meeting at the end of February this year with all the testers, and we got together.

1:06:58 We let them know what we're expecting them.

1:07:01 There's a code of conduct that the testers have to follow now, and we're going to make

1:07:05 sure that they're following that and testing these devices properly and doing the right.

1:07:12 We've had some problems in the past with testers, turn on the test reports that you

1:07:16 can't hardly read.

1:07:17 They just scribble something here or there, not following the rules.

1:07:23 So those testers that don't follow the rules, we're going to reserve the right to remove those

1:07:30 people from our list.

1:07:31 It's a license, you should do a good job right.

1:07:33 If you want to be on our test list, we expect that.

1:07:38 So we'll continue to educate the public through media.

1:07:41 We'll keep doing that.

1:07:43 I think that's helped a lot.

1:07:45 You can always be information off of our city website under the water department, the back

1:07:51 of the ordinance.

1:07:52 DEQ has a ton of information on the website.

1:07:56 And then any more, Google is an amazing thing, anything Google doesn't or anything.

1:08:02 You can find out just about anything you want about it.

1:08:05 So we'll keep up those efforts.

1:08:07 Our customers will always continue to work with them if they're trying to make an honest

1:08:14 effort to get it done and we'll work with them.

1:08:19 We are this year, we're going to send out some letters for those 700, over 700 that haven't

1:08:25 had them tested and let them know.

1:08:27 We're going to give them three months to the end of June to either let us know that they're

1:08:32 in the process of giving it tested or get it tested by them before they roll.

1:08:40 under the, again, to get their water shut off.

1:08:43 It's something that we don't have to do, but.

1:08:46 I'm not answering.

1:08:47 City and Meridian, they shut.

1:08:50 I talked to Dennis, the water superintendent there,

1:08:53 and they shut over 200 people off every year

1:08:56 for failure to comply.

1:08:57 And he said it's just something every year,

1:09:00 you're gonna have some people who just don't wanna, you know,

1:09:04 you don't pay your water bill, you do your water shut off,

1:09:06 and you don't get your back to the test and you don't.

1:09:09 So, but as long as they're trying, we're going to work with them and give it an honest effort.

1:09:15 But our goal, you know, in the end is to be able to have these devices tested when the water gets turned on.

1:09:21 And I think we'll get there, but it's going to take a few years.

1:09:24 Because when you turn the water on, that's when you want to make sure the device is working properly.

1:09:29 So, we're working on it and I think we'll get there.

1:09:35 It's just a work in progress.

1:09:37 Mike Brown and Stephen Lapper, they're here for DEQ if you guys have any questions for them also.

1:09:43 We have lights on. Are you ready? Chris Tockington.

1:09:47 I'm a couple of queries. First of all, very thorough report.

1:09:50 With the number of testers we have that provides a check and bounce for people to do some

1:09:56 competitive pricing if they have a equipment that needs to be installed or retroed.

1:10:02 Have we had a couple of informal complaints about what was considered as price-gatching?

1:10:10 Have you substantiated any of that or is that pretty self-regulatory by virtue of...

1:10:16 I think it's going to really self-regulate itself now because there's a lot more testers now that are available.

1:10:24 And some of these guys price themselves up there because they really don't want to do it.

1:10:31 So we always encourage people,

1:10:33 call around on the list, call four or five people.

1:10:36 And I know it was hard when we didn't have

1:10:39 quite as many testers, but we're gonna keep an eye on that.

1:10:44 I think having more testers now is really gonna help

1:10:47 kind of regulate that out.

1:10:49 But thank you, my next query is off track on this,

1:10:52 but what are the normal water year?

1:10:57 I'm wondering have we had any,

1:10:59 Any problem with our south side wells and having that water table from the south move in that's affected our nitrate levels?

1:11:11 No, we're so far so good. What happens there is if people's wells aren't sealed correctly, water will infiltrate down into the well seal.

1:11:23 Luckily the rules are rules we seal our wells quite a bit deeper than

1:11:33 I guess I'm speaking more about a city up water table

1:11:38 Ag well the water table migrating our way have

1:11:43 And we do sample we have sample wells out around the

1:11:47 sugar factory

1:11:49 by the airport the old

1:11:53 I don't think we've pulled those samples yet.

1:11:55 And not just say you test like twice a month or something.

1:11:58 For certain things you do.

1:12:00 Okay.

1:12:00 For bacteria and omega-like kind of stuff.

1:12:04 Thank you.

1:12:05 Chris Reed.

1:12:07 So quick question for you.

1:12:08 So I was one of the individuals last year that got a letter

1:12:11 with all of the companies listed on there.

1:12:14 Do we go back every year and make sure that all the companies

1:12:16 are actually doing it because when we made some calls,

1:12:21 Some of them said, no, we don't do that.

1:12:23 So just checking with them, making sure with 32 companies,

1:12:27 making sure all of them are actually doing that.

1:12:30 Yeah, this year we were updating the list every year.

1:12:35 We also make sure that they have all the credentials.

1:12:39 They have to have their testing unit tested annually

1:12:44 to make sure that it's calibrated correctly

1:12:46 and then that they have their license obviously.

1:12:51 Perfect.

1:12:51 And that kind of stuff when we keep that all on file.

1:12:53 OK.

1:12:54 So yeah, I know last year there was a few people on there

1:12:58 that were showing that there were so many people calling

1:13:01 that they finally just didn't know what to do

1:13:03 and any more this year.

1:13:04 It took about three months for us.

1:13:06 Yeah.

1:13:06 Oh, yeah.

1:13:07 So yeah.

1:13:08 Well, we're hoping it goes a lot better this year.

1:13:12 Ruth Pierce.

1:13:12 So Rob, is that an annual test for homeowners?

1:13:16 Yes.

1:13:17 Okay, so those of us that tested last year are going to might as well get your ducks in a row this year, got it.

1:13:24 Every year annual test and basically the reason behind that is because the device gets shut off and the seals and gaskets in those.

1:13:34 When you turn the water off they dry out and again calcium and stuff builds up in there.

1:13:40 And so then when you start it up the next year,

1:13:42 they want to make sure that everything's moving

1:13:44 and working properly in there.

1:13:48 Great landing.

1:13:50 I'm just a reminder to people, the people

1:13:52 that are on pressurized irrigation do not need to do this,

1:13:55 correct?

1:13:55 No.

1:13:56 No.

1:13:56 The people that are on the pressurized irrigation,

1:13:58 that's a whole different system.

1:14:00 That's non-potable water, irrigation water,

1:14:03 coming out of the irrigation canals.

1:14:06 Now people cross-connecting, we do see that every once

1:14:09 in a while and that's a big no-no. They'll want to have city water, they're on

1:14:16 pressurized irrigation and they will actually, some landscape companies for a

1:14:21 while, we're going out and tying into our city water system on the backside. So

1:14:26 like on water earlier? Yeah, yeah. And that's where Eagle and Meridian ended up

1:14:32 with people sick. Lots of people sick that one time was people going on

1:14:37 and cross command on between the two systems.

1:14:40 Yeah, if you have PI water, you're not allowed

1:14:42 to use city water.

1:14:44 And my last one was kind of the same theme

1:14:47 with some of the others about getting it done.

1:14:49 My father got a letter last year,

1:14:51 and his system was not repairable.

1:14:56 There was actually one place from a 50-nair,

1:14:58 the 50s are housed from somewhere,

1:14:59 but not replaceable and not repairable,

1:15:03 and it ended up costing me about $600.

1:15:06 but it had to wait quite a while to get somebody there

1:15:08 to actually do it.

1:15:09 And so they were glad to see there's more testers.

1:15:12 Plus that was a little different

1:15:13 because he had an installation necessary as well.

1:15:16 It was just a test.

1:15:17 And that's why we say, if people are giving an honest effort

1:15:22 to apply, we will work with them.

1:15:24 It's the ones that just are adamant that they're not

1:15:27 going to do it.

1:15:29 These guys back here are going to be coming and looking at me.

1:15:32 It was one of those ones where they came by and said,

1:15:35 It needs to be replaced, but then it was like two months before they get back to replace it, so yeah

1:15:40 Yeah, and there was quite a bit of it and that's why we we didn't go out and

1:15:45 You know we shut people up because we knew you know and we knew we needed more testers and

1:15:53 So we went out and held a couple more classes

1:15:56 So hopefully with those extra testers

1:16:00 The landscape companies now know that hey we're gonna

1:16:04 make everybody complies so hopefully do their new day launch in and get it done.

1:16:09 Thank you for the report Rob. Thank you. Sean did you need to weigh in on

1:16:14 anything? Nope. Okay. Rob thank you very much for the presentation tonight.

1:16:23 Good information and we'll be looking forward to hearing how it turns out at

1:16:28 the other end of the season.

1:16:31 All right.

1:16:32 Thank you very much.

1:16:34 Okay.

1:16:35 Next we have a request from Sharon Bryan to adopt a resolution to destroy any semi-permanent

1:16:43 or temporary records and to notify the Idaho State Historical Society before destruction

1:16:50 of the records.

1:16:52 Welcome Sharon.

1:16:53 Vice mayor and council, Sharon Bryan, deputy city clerk for Twin Falls.

1:17:01 This is kind of a routine housekeeping resolution that we do every year.

1:17:07 This year we're kind of doing it now because the police station is trying to move all the

1:17:15 records and so they would like to get rid of as many as they can so they don't have to

1:17:22 move them.

1:17:24 And so Idaho State Code 50-907 requires us to, that the record, semi-permanent and temporary

1:17:36 records, be done by resolution.

1:17:41 And so I'm asking that you approve the resolution.

1:17:46 It will be resolution 2017-4.

1:17:49 Does anyone have any questions for Sharon?

1:17:55 Chris Tockington.

1:17:56 If not, I would move passage of resolution in 2017-14, but for a second.

1:18:06 We have a motion from Chris Tockington, seconded by Nikki Boyd to approve the request to destroy

1:18:14 the records and notify the state historical society.

1:18:18 And that's resolution 2017-4.

1:18:20 Is there any comments from the council?

1:18:25 Seeing none, roll call vote please.

1:18:27 Yes.

1:18:28 Greg Lanting.

1:18:29 Yes.

1:18:30 Christopher Reed.

1:18:31 Yes.

1:18:32 Ruth Pierce.

1:18:33 Yes.

1:18:34 Suzanne Hawkins.

1:18:35 Yes.

1:18:36 Nikki Boyd.

1:18:37 Yes.

1:18:38 Sean Berrigger.

1:18:39 Yes.

1:18:40 Motion passes.

1:18:41 Seven to zero.

1:18:42 Thank you, Sharon.

1:18:47 And next we have a request to use $652,000 of cash reserves from the Capital Fund and Impact

1:18:55 fee reserves to purchase furniture, fixtures and equipment and an electronic system for

1:19:01 the City Hall and public safety campus projects and a security fence for the public safety

1:19:08 campus.

1:19:09 And we have Travis Rothweiler.

1:19:10 Thank you.

1:19:11 Madam Vice Mayor, members of the City Council, thanks for the opportunity to make this request

1:19:15 to you this evening.

1:19:16 So the reason for the request is because we're ahead of schedule.

1:19:21 And when we had built our original plan in moving forward, we had taken the estimated

1:19:26 costs of the project and we broke them succinctly into two fiscal years.

1:19:31 We said that we're going to use $600,000 and as you recall, when we went through the budgeting

1:19:35 process, we allocated $600,000 because at that point that was based upon the calendar moving

1:19:41 forward.

1:19:42 Well, lo and behold, when you go through the CMGC process and you have a fixed amount of

1:19:48 time, materials, and opportunity.

1:19:52 They have found opportunities to get ahead of that schedule.

1:19:55 And right now, they're about a month ahead

1:19:57 of the original anticipated schedule, which causes us

1:20:00 to have to accelerate our acquisition process.

1:20:04 And that is why we're asking for a slight deviation

1:20:08 from the original plan.

1:20:09 In both cases, we had intended to use

1:20:12 the sources of funds that had been outlined below.

1:20:17 kind of dovetailing on a couple of things number one

1:20:20 in the audit that was presented this evening as you look at that you'll notice

1:20:24 that

1:20:24 the city of twin falls will be sweeping about one point one million dollars of

1:20:29 of cash from the general fund into the capital improvement fund

1:20:34 as a result of tonight's actions we have a fiscal policy

1:20:38 uh... inside of the city that says all of our tax-supported funds and there are

1:20:41 several but the big three are going to be the general fund street fund and the

1:20:45 airport fund, we will take three months of operating revenue of the total cost of those

1:20:52 funds and we will lock those away. And we act like those do not exist and we treat those

1:21:00 for us to be able to cash flow and to be able to provide some level of certainty in a fairly

1:21:05 uncertain economic world as we can see how volatile it is. And right now things are looking

1:21:11 very good. We hope that continues well into the future. So that three months is locked

1:21:19 away and then what we have are a series of dollars that could be available for at the Council's

1:21:25 discretion for projects. And inside of the Capital Improvement Fund, again, we're taking

1:21:32 $1.1 million because we would sweep that per fiscal policy that would go into the Capital

1:21:37 improvement fund and the capital improvement fund has about 16,877,000

1:21:43 dollars of total funds in there and after we restrict the monies for all of the

1:21:48 projects we still have a balance of 8,717,000 dollars that could be available for

1:21:54 projects and again that is net after we have removed the three months in each

1:22:00 one of those funds moving forward. There's $721,537 of impact fees that have

1:22:09 been collected and impact fees that have been designed for these very

1:22:13 specific purposes as we move forward. So in total, the total FFME budget right

1:22:19 now with some contingency and I wanted to say with some contingency because the

1:22:25 The construction schedule is a bit ahead of our design schedule of the FFNE piece.

1:22:32 And as you know, one of the things that's going to be very, very different about this

1:22:36 city hall is it is an open office concept.

1:22:39 And so we are recycling and moving as many desk systems and furniture systems as we possibly

1:22:44 can into the building.

1:22:46 But when we're going into an entirely new concept that is much more open, much more collaborative,

1:22:50 We have found that the systems that we have will not necessarily work in that environment.

1:22:56 Systems that are generally constructed for that entire purpose.

1:23:00 So in total we're looking at $450,000 for the furnishings in all three buildings.

1:23:06 And know that I'm talking about all three buildings.

1:23:09 It's the Police Admin Building, it's the Operations Building that will house the Dispatch Center,

1:23:15 and then it is the City Hall Complex that will also hold everything that is currently

1:23:20 operating in the Hanson building. You will move the council chambers over to that

1:23:25 building and then everything that's working out of our temporary facility

1:23:28 located on Main Street now. Four hundred thousand dollars for all of the

1:23:33 electrical systems associated with all three buildings. That's going to be

1:23:37 switches and screens and monitors and recording systems not only for the

1:23:42 council chambers but other facilities. It's a two hundred thousand dollars for

1:23:47 security fence at the new public safety complex. As we had shared in that project, we had received

1:23:53 that one bid and that one bid wasn't necessarily competitive and so we wanted to go back through

1:23:58 that process. Because of the acceleration in the schedules, we wanted to come and ask once

1:24:02 and we intend to fully bid. That, we believe, is a very high estimate, but we wanted to make

1:24:07 sure that we had enough money to be able to go through that process. $115,369 for high-density

1:24:15 roller scourge for both records and evidence. One of the things that we had talked about

1:24:20 was we would include that in next year's $600,000 allocation and really as we were looking for

1:24:26 that in hindsight was a bit short-sighted on our part. So in evidence there's about 15,000

1:24:38 and cataloged units of evidence.

1:24:41 Any time that is moved outside into a new location,

1:24:45 you have to count it.

1:24:46 But you don't count it just once.

1:24:48 You count it when you move it, and then you take it,

1:24:52 and you count it that it made sure it reached

1:24:54 the temporary facility.

1:24:57 You count it when it's going to leave the facility,

1:24:59 and you count it again when it's moving into it.

1:25:01 So really, those 15,000 pieces of evidence

1:25:04 would be counted a total of an excesses four times each.

1:25:08 And so it was really not efficient or effective in use of our staff time.

1:25:12 And then the same with the records and the storage.

1:25:14 Like Sharon said, what we're trying to do is we're following the Idaho Code and

1:25:18 we're reducing the number of records that we have to move on to the new building.

1:25:23 If anybody's interested in looking at that, or the resolution, excuse me,

1:25:28 details that entire list and we can show that it's time cards and

1:25:31 really non-sensitive information.

1:25:35 And the next piece is 86,000 for dispatch work stations that weren't included in the CMGC

1:25:42 because we really wanted a very specialized piece of equipment, so that is included in

1:25:47 that process.

1:25:48 Again, the total project here that we're looking for because we have $600,000 allocated is $652,000

1:25:55 of cash reserves to be able to move forward.

1:25:58 That would lessen the amount of cash reserves that we would shift this year from rather

1:26:02 would be $1.1 million to the net difference of roughly about $500,000 is what we would shift

1:26:10 into cash reserves this year as opposed to transferring the entire balance should the council

1:26:15 be interested and approve of this. With that, I'm happy to stand for any questions that you

1:26:21 might have.

1:26:22 Chris, I did a good sales job. I have one question though. The original, there are the

1:26:31 9.9 million that were budgeting for the place complex and City Hall.

1:26:36 Does that include the $652,000?

1:26:39 It did not.

1:26:39 So when we were looking, so the CMGC is strictly associated with the construction of the building.

1:26:46 So everything that you've seen, and we've talked about is for the construction of the building.

1:26:51 It did not include all of the FFNE pieces that we needed.

1:26:55 Some of those are included.

1:26:56 So for example, chairs in the council chambers, those are included.

1:27:01 Diocese is included, but they're very technical and specific systems that were not included in that construction piece

1:27:06 And I've seemed a little short-sighted for us not to include some amount for furnishings. Yeah, so

1:27:13 The reason we intentionally excluded them from the CMGC is because we didn't want to pay additional funds on top of those things

1:27:20 And so our team is working specifically to design the furniture. We're not going through star

1:27:25 Kathy and her team is doing all the installation and the procurement of the electrical stuff

1:27:29 And so we're using our teams where we can to avoid paying a profit margin of 3% 3.5% on those items that we felt that we could move forward on our own.

1:27:39 Thank you. Is there any other comments from the council?

1:27:44 Suzanne?

1:27:45 Yes, Sean.

1:27:46 So first of all, I just want to say great news to hear that we are ahead of schedule on this project.

1:27:52 this project and I think that it's prudent for us to take care of these current

1:27:59 and current equipment needs. So again, this money wasn't included in the

1:28:05 construction management contract however we've been discussing this since the

1:28:10 beginning of the project as well, correct? Yes, as you recall we included so you had

1:28:15 the CMGC process and then when we went through the budgeting process you'll

1:28:19 notice that there's $600,000 this year and we had a conversation about a like

1:28:24 amount in the following year and that $600,000 appears as a capital line item. I

1:28:28 believe it's under the City Council. It's either under the City Council

1:28:34 Capital allocation or it's under the City Manager's allocation and was

1:28:38 specifically reserved for FFNE for this project. Thank you Sean. Anything else?

1:28:45 Hearing nothing. Great landing. Nice mayor. If you're ready for

1:28:52 motion. I'm ready to do one. I'm ready. Okay. I move that we approve the use of

1:28:58 $650,000 of cake reserves from the capital fund and the impact fee reserves to

1:29:04 purchase furniture, fixtures and equipment and electronic items or excuse me systems

1:29:10 for the City Hall Public Safety Campus project and a security fence for the

1:29:15 public safety campus.

1:29:17 Second. We have a motion from Greg Lantine seconded by Ruth Pierce. Is there any other comment from the council?

1:29:25 See no one Sharon will call vote, please Greg Lanting. Yes, Christopher Reed. Yes, Ruth Pierce

1:29:34 Yes, Suzanne Hawkins. Yes, Nikki Boyd. Yes, Sean Berriger

1:29:39 Yeah

1:29:40 Chris Hockington. Yes

1:29:43 Motion passes seven to zero. Thank you. Thank you Travis

1:29:46 With that, we are to our next opportunity for public input.

1:29:54 If there is anyone in the audience who would like to address the council tonight, this is your last chance.

1:29:59 See no one.

1:30:03 Mitch Travis, is there anything from the city manager's office tonight?

1:30:07 Madam Vice Mayor, just a couple of quick items.

1:30:09 Number one, there will not be a meeting next week.

1:30:12 We will go to our normal schedule beginning on the 27th.

1:30:15 We anticipate a meeting beginning at 5 o'clock.

1:30:21 So this is a pretty hectic week for the folks in the police department.

1:30:26 They're experiencing the same level of happiness that all of us experience when we move.

1:30:33 And so they're in the process of moving from the current building and they're slowly starting

1:30:42 to deploy into the new building.

1:30:48 There's a couple of important things.

1:30:49 So the first is that if you look at the exterior,

1:30:52 it's not done yet.

1:30:54 And that was really a large part of because of a pretty

1:30:59 crazy winter.

1:31:01 The outside of the building is going to go forward

1:31:04 with obviously a freshening of the paint

1:31:06 that was included into the project.

1:31:08 We're looking at removing some of those glass panels where

1:31:12 the gas has escaped, and then we're also going to be doing landscaping, and so you'll see

1:31:17 all of that completed in about April.

1:31:20 But to stay on that schedule, the PD is moving out of the building this week.

1:31:25 We hope next week it will be a functional operating building, and then they will begin,

1:31:32 Star will begin the work on the operational building, and then we anticipate that's about

1:31:38 a five month project.

1:31:39 And so that building is currently on that schedule moving forward.

1:31:44 When it is complete and we recognize that April 15th, after was the date for the tours,

1:31:50 we're going to certainly, we encourage you to walk through it now, but we'll have an official guided tour with the members of the city council.

1:31:57 What's important is when we occupy the building, the building does go under lockdown.

1:32:05 And so it will not be accessible to the general public

1:32:08 in all areas, we wanted to make sure that it was secure.

1:32:11 We do have very sensitive information that is in there

1:32:14 and we have a duty to protect that information.

1:32:17 And so we will provide tours to the council,

1:32:21 but there will be under a guided process.

1:32:23 So if you have a chance,

1:32:25 I know that Chief Kingsbury is really excited

1:32:27 about the project, please connect with him this week.

1:32:31 If you have a few minutes and we can walk you

1:32:33 through that building or we'll have to wait

1:32:34 if we can go for a larger group.

1:32:40 The next thing I have is just kind of put on your calendar

1:32:44 and I'll ask Sean to clarify the exact date.

1:32:47 But the second, I believe it's the 10th, Sean.

1:32:52 Is it the 10th or the 11th?

1:32:54 Is going to be the state of the city?

1:32:56 Yes.

1:32:57 It is April 11th.

1:33:00 The 11th, the Tuesday is going to be the state

1:33:02 of the city address.

1:33:04 We're starting to get the word in that process out.

1:33:08 So mark it on your calendars now, it's a Tuesday.

1:33:11 We're going to return downtown.

1:33:13 We're still kind of working on that format,

1:33:15 but it will be part of an official groundbreaking

1:33:18 in conjunction with the urban renewal as we kick off

1:33:21 the project moving forward.

1:33:23 And then in addition to that, we're

1:33:25 hoping to coordinate tours of the new city hall complex

1:33:29 to show the status, because as you will call,

1:33:32 One year from our previous day of the city, we had begun construction and so we want to get those tours and and have that follow-up.

1:33:39 And hopefully next year, we'll be able to have another state of the city inside of brand new city council chambers.

1:33:48 Great. Thank you. Anything from the city council? Ruth Pierce.

1:33:53 I just wanted to talk about a couple of commissions that I'm liaison for Winnes Historic Preservation.

1:34:00 And we are burdogging the operation facelift this year.

1:34:06 And we've decided there's going to be a scavenger hunt downtown, which will make it kind of fun.

1:34:12 It'll be good for all ages, but also that's May as Idaho Historic Preservation Month.

1:34:20 months, so we're having a day, which I believe is May 11th, not positive.

1:34:25 But in conjunction with that, this operation faced lift, we decided to focus on the alleys

1:34:31 this year.

1:34:33 So because Main Street is going to be pretty busy and people are going to be using the back

1:34:39 of the alley entrances, we thought we could help by cleaning that up.

1:34:44 So we have some CSI kids that have volunteered, so I think it's going to be a really good project.

1:34:51 The second one is the Archway Committee, the signage arch across between City Park and

1:34:58 the Courthouse.

1:34:59 We're to the point where you probably saw the drawing in the paper.

1:35:04 We're waiting to get a final cost and then the committee will be working on fundraising,

1:35:12 But I think the committee has come into the city the third.

1:35:17 Yeah, so that'll be in front of us to make some decisions.

1:35:23 Thank you Ruth, anyone else?

1:35:26 I'm going to weigh in real quick with the report from our youth council then.

1:35:29 This year our youth council's initiative has been healthy in motion with other kids.

1:35:36 And so they are launching their first ever city hula hoop contest.

1:35:41 So they have worked with the school district and the competition this year will be for fourth

1:35:46 and fifth graders and the initial round will happen in the schools and they will have a

1:35:52 winner, a boy and a girl from each school and those winners are going to compete in

1:35:57 a final face off I believe at the visitor center parking lot in the end of May and we will have

1:36:02 a city champion hula hoop contest.

1:36:05 So the youth have been out and there's local businesses that have been donating prizes

1:36:09 for the winners and I think it's going to be kind of a fun adventure so you'd for

1:36:13 bitty might want to get their hula hoops out and start practicing so you can come

1:36:16 hula hoop with us. It's going to be a good one but if yet if you if you have

1:36:21 children in fourth and fifth grade in the Twin Falls School District be watching

1:36:25 for the flyers coming home. All right see you nothing else we do have on our

1:36:33 agenda tonight to adjourn into executive session, and it is 74-206-1B to consider the evaluation

1:36:44 dismissal or disciplining of or to hear complaints or charges brought against a public officer,

1:36:50 employee, staff member, or individual agent or a public school student, and category C

1:36:57 to acquire an interest in grill property which is not owned by a public agency.

1:37:03 And before we take a motion, I would like to make sure everyone knows that we will not be

1:37:08 making any decisions in an executive session and we will not be coming back out here in

1:37:13 this meeting tonight.

1:37:14 So when we adjourn, that will be the end for this part of the meeting.

1:37:20 And with that, I will stand for a motion.

1:37:23 Ruth Pierce.

1:37:24 I move we move adjourn this meeting and move into executive session second we

1:37:31 you have to list the number do you need her to read the yes please under 74-2061

1:37:41 B and C B and C the second celery yes okay we have a motion from Ruth Pierce

1:37:49 seconded by Chris Reed to adjourn into executive session seeing no counsel

1:37:57 lights on, Sharon roll call vote, Christopher Reed, Ruth Pierce, Suzanne Hawkins, Nikki Boy,

1:38:05 Sean Bericher, Chris Tockington, Greg Lanting, motion passes 7-0 and with that will conclude

1:38:15 this part of the meeting.

1:38:17 Thank you for coming.

Chain of custody

  1. Recorded. At the open meeting of the City Council on Monday, March 13, 2017. The recording started at 17:00 by the recorder's clock and runs 01:38:26.
  2. Obtained. Posted publicly by the City of Twin Falls. The copy here has the same SHA-256 fingerprint as the City's posted file. Request filed 2026-09; the City's response: Denied (response not in folder) (request log).
  3. As received. SHA-256 of the video file exactly as received:
    not recorded
  4. Audio track. Taken from that video and kept unaltered. SHA-256:
    dccb2218af7b30c29aa0e26340308e492165af68747721bff80018051c6bdc7b
  5. Listening copy. Made from the audio track for playing on the web: aac 32k mono 22050Hz, levelled, parts of 90 min. SHA-256 of each file:
    part01.m4a 5d85cf5c5c2deaab6153f58d125af44c1a5a4b816fa9a6689e52c4e4151bf591
    part02.m4a 5e4991a396e412b84824aeae9fd6df7d5e3023d87698934cd9bcb071a557ab4f
  6. Transcript. Machine transcript of the audio track, made with faster-whisper base.en on 2026-11-10. Not edited, except that 0 passages with private details are marked instead of shown. The Pledge of Allegiance is shown in its standard wording. SHA-256 of the posted text:
    48f724b828032fc31ea3879d9a1d2dd9b7c786fb11c84b92fb02b571fbc5a274

The original video and audio track are kept unaltered. Anyone holding the City's copy can check it against the "as received" fingerprint. Chain of custody for every meeting (CSV) · How to verify a file